The Majority Report with Sam Seder - 3616 - Trump Revels in War Crimes; Israel Ethnically Cleanses Lebanon in Darkness w/ Zahra Hankir

Episode Date: April 6, 2026

Welcome back to The Majority Report   On today's program:   Donald Trump spent his Easter Sunday posting threats of war crimes on Iran and mocking Islam.   Trump once again claims that he is very close to announcing a deal with Iran in an attempt to juice the markets.   Senate candidate in Maine, Graham Platner says he absolutely supports Bernie Sanders proposal to end military aid to Israel. Platner went even further in saying that Israel is exterminating people and it would take an immense amount of work to repair the relationship.   Zahra Hankir, Lebanese author and journalist joins Emma for a conversation about her recent piece in Columbia Journalism Review: "Who is Left to Cover Lebanon?" For more from Zahra check out her book Eyeliner: A Cultural History   In the Fun Half:   On Pod Save America, Cory Booker cannot bring himself to admit that Benjamin Netanyahu is a war criminal. Booker goes on to say that he had no idea who Hasan Piker was until a couple days ago despite condemning him.   Trump admits to Trey Yingst that the U.S. has sent weapons to Iranian dissenters through the Kurds.   Laura Loomer tweets at Marco Rubio to deport Trita Parsi.   Stephen Crowder and Dave Rubin share their idiotic thoughts on the war in Iran.   all that and more   Preorder Molly Crabapple's book: Here Where We Live is Our Country.   To connect and organize with your local ICE rapid response team visit ICERRT.com The Congress switchboard number is [phone]. You can use this number to connect with either the U.S. Senate or the House of Representatives. Follow us on TikTok here: https://www.tiktok.com/@majorityreportfm Check us out on Twitch here: https://www.twitch.tv/themajorityreport Find our Rumble stream here: https://rumble.com/user/majorityreport Check out our alt YouTube channel here: https://www.youtube.com/majorityreportlive Gift a Majority Report subscription here: https://fans.fm/majority/gift Subscribe to the AMQuickie newsletter here: https://am-quickie.ghost.io/ Join the Majority Report Discord! https://majoritydiscord.com/ Get all your MR merch at our store: https://shop.majorityreportradio.com/ Get the free Majority Report App!: https://majority.fm/app Go to https://JustCoffee.coop and use coupon code majority to get 10% off your purchase Check out today's sponsors: COZY EARTH: Go to cozyearth.com/MAJORITYREPORT for an exclusive deal only available April 6th - April 12th! SELECT QUOTE:  Get the right life insurance for you and save more than fifty percent on term life insurance at SelectQuote.com/MAJORITY SUNSET LAKE: Use coupon code "Left Is Best" (all one word) for 20% off of your entire order at SunsetLakeCBD.com  Follow the Majority Report crew on Twitter: @SamSeder @EmmaVigeland @MattLech On Instagram: @MrBryanVokey Check out Matt's show, Left Reckoning, on YouTube, and subscribe on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/leftreckoning Check out Matt Binder's YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/mattbinder Subscribe to Brandon's show The Discourse on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/ExpandTheDiscourse Check out Ava Raiza's music here! https://avaraiza.bandcamp.com

You are listening to a free version of the Majority Report. Support this show at join the Majority Report.com and get an extra hour of content daily. The Majority Report with Sam Cedar. It is Monday. April 6th, 20206. My name is Emma Vigeland, in for Sam Cedar, and this is the five-time award-winning majority report. We are broadcasting live steps from the industrially ravaged Gowanus Canal in the heartland of America, downtown Brooklyn, USA. On the program today, Zara Hankir, Lebanese author and journalist, will be with us to talk about her recent piece in the Columbia Journalism Review entitled Who is Left to Cover Lebanon.

Also on the program, over Easter weekend, Trump threatened to commit more war crimes in Iran via truth social, as Iran rejects calls for a temporary ceasefire and wants a more permanent one. U.S. Israeli strikes pummeled civilian infrastructure and universities, including one in Tehran over the weekend. Nearly 2,000 people have been killed in Iran. if not more. Trump also claimed he armed protesters and Kurds in Iran, which you are not supposed to say out loud. The second U.S. airmen shot down, has reportedly been rescued,

and Polly Market apologizes for letting users bet on whether or not those airmen will live. Yeah, they're so sorry. Yes. You can bet on the length of the Palestinian people, in genocide though, right? Wasn't that? Or it was the ceasefire stuff? But when there's a U.S. air person

involved, everyone's very outreach. I'm in there so sorry in the Yero, you can sign up today. The White House is censoring satellite imagery from the Iran War according to the firm Planet Labs. A federal judge in Boston puts a halt to Trump's lawsuit against Blue State universities

trying to access their data to prove they're not considering race in admissions. The NYPD announces New York City has had the fewest murders and shooting incidents in the first quarter of a year ever. Turns out socialists keep you safe too. Israeli airstrikes in Lebanon killed dozens over the weekend and at least four in Gaza City. The family of a three-year-old separated from their child by ice, alleged that the girl had suffered sexual abuse at the foster home where she was placed.

And lastly, thinking of our California friends, the first major wildfires raged this year as signs of one of the strongest El Nino's in decades emerge. All this and more on today's majority report. Welcome to the show, everybody. it is Monday. I will be with you all week. Sam is off for spring break. Hello, Matt. Hello, Brian. We've got a bunch of great shows for you this week. I hope everybody had a nice Easter. Nicer than Donald Trump. Well, I shouldn't say that because we don't know. Trump could have been spending the Easter weekend contemplating his deeply held Christian values, the Christian themes of Easter the resurrection of Christ that's me

kind of like how I was president three times the what this weekend is supposed to represent in terms of salvation and humanity and kindness to others just kidding he relished in threats

of war crimes against the people of Iran last week he had said that we were going to send Iran back to the Stone Age. And I saw John Gans point out on Twitter that bombing them into the Stone Age was a phrase that you can trace back to Curtis LeMayhe when he was referring to North Vietnam. LeMay. Sorry, LeMay. Sorry. LeMay. Who is LeMayie? I've never heard LeMayie. Is that a play? It's a Yankee. God damn it.

The baseball season. There we go. Curtis LeMay. had said, referring to North Vietnam, bombed them into the Stone Age. This was the guy that was, yeah, exactly. That was really, really pro using nukes on Japan, and then went on to run with George Wallace as a segregationist. So if we want to talk about this administration as a bunch of Klansmen, once again, we're not far off here.

We're not far off. So Trump threatened to target their civilian infrastructure, water plants, power plants. He's threatening to steal their oil. All of this, of course, is a violation of the Geneva Conventions, the UN Charter, what have you. Here is his insane truth social decree from Easter. Tuesday will be power plant day and bridge day all wrapped up in one in Iran. There will be nothing like it. open the fucking straight, you crazy bastards.

Or you'll be living in hell. Just watch. Praise be to Allah, President Donald J. Trump. There was some chuckling on the internet about how Zoran Mamdani had a Easter message that invoked Christ in this kind of humane way, right after Passover, where he'd done the same, speaking about Judaism. and you have Trump on the other side of things, basically doing a tongue-in-cheek Islamophobia to justify war crimes against an entire people. Today was supposed to be the end of the 10-day deadline that Trump gave for Iran to reopen the Strait of Hormuz.

And he doesn't seem to understand that, even though we are losing right now, that using kind of rapist bully language in this way is not going to give Iran what it needs to stop kind of decimating the Western economy and hurting Trump politically on this because they're going to want to have some sort of dignified response. And Trump is using a bunch of vulgar language

and mocking their religion in the process. So that's why we were always concerned about the escalation here. Iran needs to establish deterrence, and that means inflicting real pain on this belligerent actor. The belligerent actor needs to look like the winner with the offensive war that he started. And so both sides are incentivized to escalate because of Trump's particular political proclivities.

But Iran literally needs to do this because of their own sovereignty and survival. And Robert Pape has a piece in the New York Times, who we've had on the show before, and I know he's been making the rounds and some of these other progressive shows talking about how Iran has been strengthening its position geopolitically and can be a real power now

due to what Trump has done, especially because it seems almost inevitable that they're going to charge tolls through the Strait of Moose at this point. Yeah, and that piece he says that controlling the strait is more powerful than any nuke that Israel, the U.S. could have. Decimated.

And, I mean, that's a big, part of what the United States has provided to the world has been like, we will be the weaponry that secures the global supply lines. And this has done the exact opposite. This has done the exact opposite. And it has just made it more obvious that Iran can do so if they please. As I mentioned, the U.S. has already been committing war crimes and overnight the U.S. and Israel hit what I saw was described as the equivalent of Iran's MIT, Shariq. University in Tehran.

Israel's president, Katz, also confirmed that Israel bombed one of Iran's largest petrochemical plants, which is an attack on their energy infrastructure, but I believe Qatar also relies on it fairly heavily. But here is Trey Yinks of Fox News, speaking about his conversation with Trump. In this interview, Yinks reveals that... Trump had admitted that they armed the Kurds and protesters in Iran. It's unclear what the timeline is. I don't want to play that clip.

This is just, that's a separate part of this. But this is what is so psychotic about all of this. Is that Trump, we just read that truth social. He is, you know, coming up with some sort of, I don't know, timeline for war crimes where he says what we're going to do. on Tuesday we'll do power plant day and bridge day all wrapped in one. So he's already said what his intentions are, but he's once again terrified about the markets.

So what does he do? Oh, let's pretend that negotiations are happening, and they're happening very strongly. Good morning. I just spoke with President Trump for 15 minutes. He gave me some new details on the negotiations behind the scenes with the Iranians, and what's going to happen if Iran does not make a good faith deal? The president tells me if they don't make a deal and fast, I'm considering blowing everything up and taking over the oil.

The president went on to say you're going to see bridges and power plants dropping all over their country. Now, I asked him about the possibility of an agreement with the Iranians. He says those who are negotiating on behalf of Iran have been granted amnesty at this time so they can continue the talks. And the president tells me he thinks he'll be able to get a deal by tomorrow. He says, I think there's a good chance tomorrow. They're negotiating now. All of this following the president's post on true social, where he talked about these negotiations with the Iranians. We'll pull this up.

He says, quote, Tuesday will be power plant day and bridge day, all wrapped up in one in Iran. There will be nothing like... Yeah, so there you go. That's all that is. This is less of a war and more of a terrorism spree by our government in Israel. And, like, the idea that, like, phase, we immediately, like, not even boots on the ground, of course, because there's no appetite to fight a war and send our best, our youngest, our young people to die for, like, Israeli belligerence. So we've just moved right to war crimes. We're just going to do war crimes from afar.

And guess who's going to benefit is our missile companies who also get to pay for our campaigns for our Congress people. What a great country we have. Yeah. Why do people hate America so much? Because of the French fries and the freedom and all of that. Let's play six here. Trump this morning at the Easter egg hunt, once again, contemplating the spiritual nature of this holiday, saying here that he really just wants the oil if it was up to him. and doesn't, in my view, sound like an agreement on a ceasefire is imminent.

Because as I mentioned, Iran has basically rejected calls for any temporary ceasefire, which I completely understand from their position. They say only a permanent one will be what they agree to. And they also have the understanding that these negotiations are not in good faith. And they have not been. It's like Israelis call it for a temporary ceasefire because the IDF wanted to do raves for a couple months before they go back to slaughtering people. What's happening with that ceasefire in Lebanon, huh?

Oh, they're annexing the territory and bombing the hell out of the whole country, killing hundreds and hundreds, including bombing Beirut. And they're continued to bomb Gaza almost every day since this so-called ceasefire was in place. Why would anybody trust a U.S. or Israeli ceasefire? But here's Trump just this morning. We killed Soleimani.

Without Salimani, if they had Soleimani, would be a whole different thing. maybe would still be winning but it would have been harder because we are obliterating that country and i hate to do it but we're oblitering and they just don't want to say uncle they don't want to cry as the expression goes uncle but they will and if they're No bridges. They'll have no power plants. They'll have no anything. I won't go further because there are other things that are worse than those two.

What about schools? Well, the thing, if I had my choice, what would I like to do? Take the oil. Because it's there for the taking. There's not a thing they can do about it. Rapist again. Unfortunately, the American people would like to see us come home. If we're up to me, I'd take the oil.

I'd keep the oil. I would make plenty of money. And I'd also take care of the people. That is a lot of That is horrible They've killed 45,000 people As a month in Africa 45,000 protests

That is 45,000 protesters Where is that data coming from? So we're going to kill more people Just to add to the total It's totally psychotic And then also suggest that we've armed The protesters thereby giving that state

More of a justification for mowing them down if they want to. Exactly. We have a little time. Let's do this, let's do 10 here, just to give people a bit of some more positivity. So news broke yesterday that Graham Platner's opponent in the primary, the governor, Janet Mills, it has dropped out of the April 11th debate that she is supposed to be having with Graham, and then the other kind of much smaller candidates in the Democratic primary, which is really fascinating because we've seen that Platner has been trouncing her in polls.

He does better against Susan Collins in the hypothetical matchup than Janet Mills does. Mills has kind of reluctantly jumped into the race because Chuck Schumer was like, can we just we need a body like we've been doing the past many sites. against Susan Collins, just anybody that D.C. can throw in there and end up losing to this incredibly weak candidate. But she's 78 years old. She's saying that she would only serve one term. Just trust me. Where have we heard that before? Genocide, Joe. But even doing that so you don't get to accrue any seniority as being in a Senate, which is like kind of the point of being a senator. So actually that's not good. Like it's one thing. to say I'll run for one term and step aside for democracy because you're not trying to get on committees as the president of the United States. It's a great point. It would be much better for the people of Maine to have somebody who could be more longer

tenured and move up in committees. Exactly. I mean, look at how it's benefited the people of Vermont with Bernie Sanders who normally would have been, oh, seen as this crazy lefty who should not be a part of the people. part of senatorial committees. He's moved up. He, uh, in a variety of, of different committees, including veterans affairs and others. Um, and so, and health and human services, I believe, or maybe that's the, the administrative,

that maybe that's the name for it in the cabinet. But regardless, uh, it would be much better for the people of Maine for Platner to be there longer to accrue actual power. Uh, and that I think is part of what is so threatening about his candidacy in addition to just his ideology. And you can see why Plattenor is doing so well. He's doing town halls across the state. He's showing up. And then you have answers like this. I'm not sure if I've seen a better answer on the future of America's relationship with Israel and the aid to Israel from anybody who could serve in federal office, besides perhaps Rashida Talib and Ilhan Omar or something,

than this statement here by Grand Platner, because he looks beyond just the immediate cutting off of aid. But what does our relationship with Israel look like in the future? Here is Plattner's answer at this town hall from over the weekend. Not a single taxpayer dollar should be spent on arming and defending a country that commits a genocide. I would absolutely support Senator Sanders bill to restrict military aid. But I'll be entirely honest, looking down the road, this is a nation that right now is exterminating people. It is going to be very difficult for me to ever be able to look at them again and see someone that we should be working with closely.

An immense amount of work is going to have to be done, in my opinion, to fix that relationship. Because what I am witnessing now is the height of horror. and the fact that it is being done by bombs that are built in this country and paid for with our tax dollars is utterly unconscionable, and it needs to end. It's a vision for the day after. We've been speaking about that a lot. It's a little bit. We'll play probably in the fun half, Corey Booker's interview on Pod Save America, where his way to get out of his steadfast support for the genocidal government of Israel is to just call Netanyahu a bad guy. He won't even call him a war criminal. He's more of a, let me pick up this cross and drag it down the street. That's his way of getting out of everything.

Well, because, I mean, that's how he's going to end all human suffering on the planet Earth is like a Christ-like figure, right? That's what we need more of. We need more people who feel like it's their sole mission to save humanity and don't have any connection to some sort of broader political movement. Where has that steered us wrong before? But this is just like why Plattenor's the real deal, why that oppo didn't stick to him, why he's still one of the best Senate candidates in terms of like political ideology from a left-wing perspective that we've seen in my lifetime. I mean, this Iron Dome thing, and I'm very happy that AOC chose to lead on that last week and this statement. But the idea that this is controversial, because let's see what this isn't like. even saying Israel can't buy the weapons from America

missile makers themselves. This is about should we fund them to do so. We absolutely should not fund them to do so. And now once we get that further rolling and that litmus test which is one that we should apply to a country due to genocide, the question should be should we allow them to even buy any sort of weapons from our bomb makers themselves? And I would say not until you stop invading your neighbors and, you know, restricting aid. We should, we have an incredible amount of leverage, even after this shift away from funding Iron Dome, which, again, is disgusting that we would be giving taxpayer money to this country to buy our own missiles so that it can continue being belligerent towards its neighbors.

We shouldn't be allowing this country to have any weapons at all. Yeah, I saw that Hassan made this point that AOC's statement is now going to be the new kind of litmus test for this issue and to pay attention to who has shifted in the wake of her statement. Because there are a lot of politicians who look to see what she's going to do before they decide to have the kind of moral courage on this front. Grand Platner is not one of those people. Platner has been consistent on this issue from the beginning, and he's very consistent in this answer. What does this relationship look like in the future? I still want a more comprehensive answer from some other federal elected officials about what it means for Israel to be an exclusionary ethno state. Do Palestinians have the right to return? How do we create a situation where the walls of apartheid are removed, where there is, racial and ethnic integration into Israel and where the descendants of the Nakba of 1948,

those who were ethnically cleansed from that land, are able to return, are able to get some sort of form of reparations, and are able to live on the land that is rightfully theirs. I'm not somebody that believes that we're going to be able to kick out Israelis from Israel. Of course not. There has to be some sort of outside pressure that comes in. ensures that there can be racial and ethnic integration and a sharing of the land. Because right now, in Gaza, Israel's already taken 53% of the land and they shoot anybody that comes on the side of the strip that they've already annexed it functionally. And in the north, they are creating yet another, what do you know, buffer zone, which is just terminology that means they're going to seize land.

And they're already talking about Turkey. Right. I mean, it's like something like, what, 10% of Lebanon's land they've already stolen in the past few months? You think they're going to stop? They're bombing Beirut at this moment. And we're going to be talking to our next guest about that very topic. Because Lebanon is, there's not enough media coverage about what's happening there. But first, a word from our sponsors here.

What does it feel like to be cared for in the quiet moment? no one sees. This Mother's Day, Cozy Earth creates comfort designed for the rhythm women live every day. From the softness that greets her in the morning to the comfort that helps her unwind at night, thoughtful by nature and gentle in every detail. It's a small way to give back to the person who gives so much. This week, Cozy Earth is offering a Bogo deal. That's buy one, get one. There we go. Bogo. Cozy Earth is offering an authentic nod to moms, highlighting softness, quality, and comfort that supports mother's figures through their busy days and quiet moments, offering a small piece of everyday luxury that cares back.

What would it feel like to give comfort on Mother's Day instead of just saying thank you for so many little moments? Well, Cozy Earth pajamas bring intentional softness to the everyday spaces moms live in most. This Mother's Day, Cozy Earth offers a gentle reminder that the comfort she gives can be hers too. Last Mother's Day, this was my gift to my mom. I've also given these Cozy Earth pajamas as a Christmas gift for my mother-in-law. And I gotta say, it was a big hit overall, both ways, huge, huge fans of Cozy Earth. Right now, Cozy Earth is offering a B-O-G-O-Pajama deal.

Only this week, Bogo, buy one, get one. deal this week. And let me tell me about these pajamas. A classic cozy earth favorite and the sleepwear upgrade that you will love slipping into night after night. I have a pair of these. They're lightweight yet cozy. I got them in red.

I usually can only sleep in one particular outfit, but this is an exception for me because of how lightweight they are. I'm usually a big t-shirt and shorts lady. But with this pajama set, I can actually fall asleep in it, which is amazing because usually I'm pretty particular. about that kind of thing. They're designed to drape beautifully and sleep cooler than cotton

that keeps your temperature just right without overheating. Thoughtful, comfortable, and easy to love. Perfect for gifting someone special and treating yourself to better rest. And Cozy Earth's purchases are risk-free with their 100-night sleep trial. Try them out.

If you don't love them, return them hassle-free. There's a 10-year warranty because once you feel this level of comfort, you will want it to last a decade. Thanks to Cozy Earth for sponsoring this episode. these viral PJs are so good they sold out during the holidays and now they're back with an exclusive deal only available April 6th to April 12th. Head to CozyEarth.com today and use my code Majority Report, one word, to get these PJs for you and someone you love. That's Code Majority Report to get these PJs for you and a loved one.

And if you get a post-purch survey, be sure to mention you heard about Cozy Earth right here because Home starts with Mom. Link down below in the video and episode descriptions and at Majority. majority.fm. And lastly, right now and for a while, we've been experiencing some crazy economic uncertainty thanks to technology, the politics we talk about on this show, the market. Many of us are probably underinsured overpaying and underprotected, especially if your policy is through your job. One way to protect your future is through life insurance with select quote.

For over 40 years, select quote has been the most. trust one of the most trusted brokers in insurance, helping more than two million Americans secure over $700 billion in coverage. Their mission is simple, to find you the right insurance policy for your unique needs. They shop, you save. Unlike the other one-size-fits-all-life insurance companies, select, quotes, license agents work for you. In as little as 15 minutes, they'll compare policies from top-rated carriers

to find you the best fit, and they work for you for free. Head to select quote.com slash majority and a licensed insurance agent will call you right away with the right policy for your life and your budget. No medical exam, no problem. They'll partner with providers and offer same-day coverage up to $2 million without needing to visit your doctor. Have high blood pressure, diabetes or heart disease, well, SelectQuote has partners with policies designed for many pre-existing health conditions so you can get the protection you deserve. Life insurance is never cheaper than it is today. Select quote. Bay Shop, you save.

Get the right life insurance for you for less and save more than 50% at selectquote. com slash majority. Save more than 50% on term life insurance at selectquote. com slash majority today to get started. That's selectquote. Dot com slash majority. Link down below in the video and episode descriptions and at majority. Dot FM.

Quick break. And when we come back, we will be joined by our guests. here we go. Zara Hanqir. We are back and we are joined now by Zara Hankir, Lebanese author and journalist, here to discuss her recent piece in Columbia Journalism Review entitled What is Left to Cover Lebanon? Sorry, who is left to cover Lebanon? Apologies. Zara, thanks so much for coming on the show today.

Thanks so much for having me, Emma. Of course. So over the weekend, Israel continued to bomb Lebanon all over, particularly in the South, but also including Beirut. In the South, they are demolishing villages, residential homes, seizing territory, and yet there has been basically little to no media coverage of these crimes. If you could just reflect on the past many weeks of ethnic cleansing, really, in Lebanon, that's been under kind of the shroud of secrecy, darkness, lack of coverage, etc. Yeah, absolutely. First, I really want to acknowledge that there is coverage happening.

There are people on the ground doing the work. I think the question is who is doing the work and what sort of resources and backing do they have and also the framing of the reporting that is coming out of the country. So there has been a retreat in foreign correspondence across the region, not limited to Lebanon, But my belief is, and based off of the interviews I've done with journalists on the ground in Lebanon, that has had an immediate impact on the discourse and on the coverage. Often because the people who are there on the ground are facing tremendous pressures and they are operating under great danger, and they are trying to keep Lebanon in the news,

and often there are Lebanese or regional background. They don't have the same support as others. They're often treated with almost skepticism. because of their background and yet they are doing that work. As we know, journalists are also being targeted by Israel. There have been at least 11 journalists killed in Lebanon since October 20, 23. Three journalists were killed on March 28. They were targeted and Israel admitted to targeting that vehicle,

which was clearly marked as press. So what we're seeing is coverage of that, but in my opinion, not with the importance and prominence that that story warrants. And I could say the same about other stories that are happening in Lebanon right now. I do feel like there should be more coverage of those stories, more attention to the stories, and treating Lebanon as a sort of a war, devastating war and a form of ethnic cleansing, as you say, in its own right. Israel's using things like white phosphorus in southern Lebanon. That's a war crime.

It's also amazing to see how in the West at the very least the press is covering this, as if this isn't a continuous violation of the ceasefire that was supposed to be agreed upon. This is the same thing that's been happening in Gaza, but with Lebanon, it's almost treated as a kind of foregone conclusion. Of course they're going to violate some sort of ceasefire agreement. Sure. And I think what's really important here is the early days of the war, right? March 2 when there was a firing from Hezbollah into Israel, it was kind of framed as this is the sole reason. But obviously there is a whole background there. You know, the ceasefire had been violated over 10,000 times.

There were stories, in fact, one from CNN, saying that Israel had already been preparing for an invasion of some kind as early as January. And then also that this is a form of retaliation, of course, to the assassination of Khomeini. But it is not a simple tip for tat, is what I'm trying to say, right? And that contextualizing is very important. And also the internal dynamics in Lebanon, the politics, the sort of the sectarian, nature of the divisions. All of this is important because Israel is fanning the flames of some of those sectarian divisions. And I think that's also a really important point. Could you expand on that point? Because my understanding is that Shia Muslims in Lebanon have been

targeted in particular. And right now that many, many Shia civilians are the ones that are most susceptible right now to displacement. And of course, this connects to Hezbollah and to Iran. But what is the history of Shia Muslims in Lebanon? And why have they been the focus of Israel's bloody campaign? Yeah, I mean, these targeted areas in the South and also in the Dahlia in Beirut are viewed as predominantly Shia. And they are predominantly Shia areas, right? So the issue here is this framing of being synonymous, the Shia population being synonymous with Hezbollah, right?

The displaced population of Lebanon is predominantly Shia. They have had to move to other areas in Lebanon. It is also impacting the war is also impacting other communities. But this community itself is often portrayed as having an immediate sympathy to Hezbollah. Oftentimes there is, but it's that idea of trying to. kind of, you know, frame them as being somehow deserving of this displacement because of their background and because they, you know, may support Hezbollah. So I think that that's really important. It's also important to say that Hezbollah is far more than just a political party.

It offers social services to this community. It operates, you know, medical services. It, it operates health services. It really does provide to this community in a way that perhaps that community had been ignored by the Lebanese government historically for many decades. So I think that that's also important. But really what we want to keep in mind is that these communities are, they're not, it's not synonymous with Hezbollah, though it's often viewed as such. This is a community that is facing great, great humanitarian crisis in the current moment. Then I guess let's get into the history a little bit.

Your piece talks about how Beirut used to be this kind of vibrant center for journalists. in the Middle East, even going back to say like the 1940s. You can hear it in movies or, you know, like the Beirut office and now it's being pummeled by Israel. And it's in conjunction with the hollowing out of newsrooms in the West where they used to have kind of some of these foreign correspondence bureaus that might be stationed in Beirut for example. Now, if they have stations in the Middle East, so it's in Tel Aviv, most likely, and they have to deal with Israeli military sensors, for example. So this is very true, especially during the Lebanese Civil War, which was from 1975 to 1990, Beirut was really a hub for war reporting. There were many foreign correspondents on the ground. There were many freelancers on the ground.

A lot of them operated from this hotel that I mentioned called the Commodore Hotel. It was a hotbed for reporters. And what I try to argue in the piece is that Lebanon in a way taught the industry how to do war reporting well, right? How to have stringers, fixers, translators, how to help with logistics, how to navigate military checkpoints, how to move around cities with strategic reporting. So this is something that I know because I feel like that moment in time, even though it had its own problems, of course, there has been this diminishing in investment and resources when it comes to the story of Lebanon, right? And it's gone from being this great story where everybody would convene and they would have that on the ground correspondence that

lasted for years on end rather than a parachuting in of a journalist who may not have the same familiarity with the story. And I do, again, want to acknowledge that that system had its own problems and it was often quite extractive of local talent. and local expertise and local journalists. However, you also had great journalists like Anthony Shadidh, who worked, operated within that model, but did so with great care for the story and sensitivity for the story because he really learned the region, he learned the language,

he learned how to navigate and how to have these sources with sensitivity, how to develop sources with sensitivity. So that is something that I'm pointing to as there has been a shift in a retreat and investment, and perhaps we need to reconsider that because of how it has impacted the story and because of the strain placed on Lebanese journalists who are trying to fill in the gap. And where do you see this kind of shift away from this reporting, Beirut being so central to Middle Eastern reporting happening? What historical events can you draw to to show how this decline began?

It's quite important, I think, to know that Lebanon has its own economic crisis. and there was a convergence or a confluence of factors in 2019 and 2020 that led to a deepening of the retreat of foreign correspondents that was not fully a function of the broader retreat that had been happening across the region from the 2000s and 2010s and that was because of this economic crisis. It was essentially an economic free fall. There was an attempt by the Lebanese to have an uprising against. against the government, against government corruption. And then you had the Beirut port explosion, which was hugely devastating to both the Lebanese, the population and the economy. So this actually deepened the retreat, and you found that many foreign correspondents or bureaus

were either shifting to other locations or diminishing their presence. And the status of some of these Lebanese journalists, You open your piece with a story about Fatima, if you don't mind saying her last name. Thank you. Who was killed by a precision guided missiles along with her colleagues just a few weeks ago. Israel then, of course, claimed that she worked for Hezbollah, as did they say her colleagues. Tell that story.

Yeah, absolutely. So it was three journalists, Fatima Stoony and her brother, and then Ali Shia. who was a reporter for Al-Mahar, Fatima and her brother worked for Al-Mayadine, which is a editorially aligned with Hezbollah, and Al-Manar, as we know, is also affiliated with Hezbollah. Now, what Israel said was that Ali Shai, worked for Hezbollah, did not mention Fatima and her brother. However, it did so without evidence, and this is part of a broader pattern of the targeting

of journalists in Gaza, where they would say that these journalists, were affiliated with Hamas or worked for Hamas, but didn't have evidence. And this is backed by the Committee to Protect Journalists who have said that this is a pattern of targeting without producing evidence. And this is something that the entire industry should be condemning loud and clear without, you know, any hesitations to do so. And this is, I think, an extension, as I said, of what has started in Gaza. And essentially, Israel has been using the same playbook that they use.

in Gaza in Lebanon and they are saying this outright. So this is not something that we have to infer. They are saying this outright in their own statements. So, you know, journalists or civilians does not matter who they work for. And we should all stand together in condemning this kind of a targeting. And there was a story from a few weeks ago about, or week or two ago, where it appeared like the Israeli government photoshopped in a journalist that they had killed in Lebanon in Hezbollah fatigues.

That was a totally different story for them to justify their killing of this journalist, right? Again, that is a fabrication evidence that clearly goes to show that they are trying to justify these killings with falsities. And again, I think it's important to remind your listeners that this is the deadliest period on record for journalists because of Israel's targeted killing of journalists in Gaza and Lebanon, and this is according to the committee to protect journalists. I wanted to zoom out for a little bit to just speak about the differences in kind of western coverage of the Middle East, what you're observing as somebody who is Lebanese, who covers this, and what we see coming out of other outlets that are in the region.

What have been some of the more striking discrepancies in the understanding that's pushed in the West versus what the reporting is uncovering in the region itself? Yeah, and I think some of this has to do with, again, the depletion of resources, right? And I think that a lot of the coverage, especially in the early days of the war, when Lebanon was pulled in, essentially was framed as a form of spillover. it was again framed as like Hezbollah being synonymous with Lebanon. And some of this sort of the Lebanon being in the shadow of the Iran war, I think, is part and parcel of that depletion of resources. Because you see that it's impacted really the understanding. And we're kind of looking at it from like Washington rather than looking at it from on the ground in Lebanon where we have a deep understanding of the humanitarian situation there, the politics there, the intricacies of Lebanon. Lebanon is a highly complex country to cover. I do want to say that. It's

filled with nuance and people do try to do a good job with the resources that they have. But the idea is that because of that depletion, oftentimes the narrative is kind of reduced to, you know, foreign policy talking points. In the early days especially, it was very much about sort of Trump's ambitions, Netanyahu's ambitions, energy, oil and so on. And then you had this situation brewing on the ground where you have this displacement of hundreds of thousands and eventually over a million Lebanese, right? And instead of having that immediate focus on the humanitarian situation and the plight of Lebanese people on the ground, you're getting that sort of shadowing of the Iran war, right? So this to me is it should be almost inverse, like the immediate story should be the focus on

the humanitarian situation whilst providing that context, additional context. And again, I do recognize the complexity of the story for sure and that many people are doing, are trying to make sense of it with the resources they have. Is that because it's a more useful, well, at least from the in the way that things are framed in the West, denying really Lebanese sovereignty and speaking about Hezbollah purely as this terrorist group without the context of that it kind of fills the gaps of the failure of the Lebanese state to provide social services. and does have connections to Iran, but is a more complex kind of part of the social fabric of the society there,

is that because it benefits the notion that, you know, Lebanese territory is really up for grabs. There's no state here. And everything that comes out of Lebanon in terms of resistance is really just another Iranian proxy. Yeah, I mean, I do really want to acknowledge a few things here. So some of that historical background on the failure of the Lebanese state is entirely true. I think what happened over the years was that Hezbollah gained more and more traction

and became far more powerful within Lebanon than was comfortable for or acceptable to the Lebanese state, especially in the current moment. There had been an effort by the Lebanese government by Nawaf Salam to disarm Hezbollah so that Lebanon, the Lebanese army could stand up and say this is a sovereign nation, right? and that the army should be the only group to have weapons. So that effort is there, and that is part of the deepening of the schism within Lebanese society. I think it does play into this idea of Lebanon being kind of a failed state, right? There's a lot of chaos there.

It's hard to make sense of it. So perhaps reducing it to this kind of a simplified discourse is easier for people to understand from afar. Now, I really want to point to the idea of deepening sectarian tensions as being incredible. important in the current moment, especially amongst the displaced. There are communities in Lebanon that are hesitant to host the displaced because of the fanning of sectarian tensions, in part also by Israel. You know, there's Israeli officials that actually had said, you know, to Christian communities, for example, do not host or hide Lebanese or Drew. So this is very important. It's something that should be taken into consideration in the border discourse. But I do think to speak to your point,

there is this idea of, you know, this is a chaotic place and a failed state, and that it's kind of, Mohamed Bezzi, who is a journalism professor at NYU, said, you know, it's kind of easier for Western media to fit Lebanon into an established narrative rather than to complicate it with some of these nuances. That part about how there is this pressure on Lebanese Christians, don't hide Shia, don't, don't hide your mom. Muslim neighbors. What does this sound like?

I mean, what does this sound like? This is obviously a targeted ethnic cleansing campaign, and it fits into the sectarian tensions that you're talking about that have been stoked for so many years. Can you give some context on that with Drew's populations as well and how the West and Israel have fan those flames? Yeah, I mean, historically, there has been alignment between the Christian community and Israel and the Druze communities. Well, there are Druze, as we know, in Israel, there's the complicating factor of the Golan Heights and so on. So I think what is happening is there is an exploitation of those ties, right?

The connecting of those dots, that's being exploited in the current moment to aid or fulfill the Israeli agenda. the invasion again of Lebanon up until the Latani, the destruction of the villages, all of this combines to form an incredibly explosive situation for the Lebanese. And I think that we are one of the most detrimental points in Lebanese history because of the confluence of these factors. The Lebanese civil war was incredibly violent. There was an invasion by Israel in 1982. Again, sectarian divisions were fanned and exploited at that time as well.

And that was an incredibly violent time in Lebanon. So, yeah, it's looking pretty dire. We'll wrap shortly, but just a few more questions for you. I know that the humanitarian situation that you mention is deeply horrifying. You have hundreds of thousands of people who have been displaced. What is the status of those displaced people and what are you hearing about the destabilization that that has created. Yeah, I mean, it's over a million, so that would be about 20% of the entire population,

amongst them are migrant workers, Syrian refugees who've been uprooted more than once, more than twice. The death toll is over 1,000, 1,300, and of course there have been over 100 children killed. And with the displacement, I mean, you have shelters at full capacity. You have people who are trying to find a place to stay. but people are very hesitant to host them because of those warnings from Israel, as I said. And you also have a deep concern at the behavior of the Lebanese government in some places. The army retreated from some of those villages in the south, leaving the people who were still there in an incredibly precarious position.

And then you have the destruction of infrastructure as well, ridges, roads, electricity facilities, farmland, olive groves, the use of white phosphorus. So in general, the humanitarian situation is worsening by the day. And the sectarian tensions are obviously just an additional destructive and concerning factor. And when you mentioned Syria, it's just so important to point out how even when you hear regime change or that being the stated goal when Israel says it out loud or the U.S. does, it's also quite beneficial. to their aims for states to fail because it weakens the resistance. It allows for more military incursions and the seizure of territory. I mean, how many countries, how much territory that is in Israel's are they going to conduct military operations in by the end of the first half of Trump's term?

I mean, they've really expanded significantly. and the violence in the West Bank is escalating as well. So it's just as the democracy is preached as the ethic, this is quite literally an assault on the ability for kind of democratic self-actualization on many of these states, Lebanon included. Yeah, yeah. I think the situation in Lebanon is highly, complex because, like I say, the Lebanese state is actually trying to disarm Hezbollah.

And I think that we will continue to see that tension and how that manifest. I think that there are efforts for Lebanon to normalize with Israel. And, you know, of course, this is something that the Lebanese population, the majority of them do not want, although some do want, because they are so fed up of war. And, yeah, so it's kind of complex. just to know that these divisions aren't there and they're very real. Well, Zara Hankir, her latest piece in the Columbia Journalism Review is entitled

Who is Left to Cover Lebanon? I encourage everybody to check it out. Thanks so much for your time today. I really appreciate it. Thank you so much, Emma. Of course. With that, folks, we're going to wrap up the first hour of this program, head into the fun half.

I'm pretty sure we'll take calls today if we can get the computer working, which is not always easy. So as a reminder, this show relies on your support. Join the Majority Report.com. Become a member. You can IAM the show, all that good stuff. Check out our merch store, shop.m.majority ReportRadio.com. Got some great stuff there.

Matt, what's happening with Left Reckoning and the Jacobin Show? Yeah. Check out as a new Jackabin Show. Andres Pagliorini on Lula. But I also wanted to do sort of like a reverse promotion. Stop listening to the bulwark if you're in our audience. Just listen to us or find another leftist show to fill in that gap. You should not listen to those freaks.

I know there's a lot of people that like to be sort of even-handed. And indeed, I saw there's a new piece by Mona Sharon by the bulwark about how it's not worth it to win if you have to win the way of accepting people like Hassan Piker in your fold. Mona Sharon is a national review writer who, like, several years ago was talking about how Elizabeth Warren is a big liar, which, I mean, have some issues with this Warren, but not the same ones that Mona Sharon has. And also that you should stop. It's a big circus around Brick Kavanaugh and the left should be ashamed of themselves. Like, these are, these are bad people. Like, and so I just want to say that. Unsubscribe to the bulwark. I mean, we like Will Summer. I like Will Summer. And I appreciate putting him up because I would say I like some people at the bulwark,

but I wouldn't want you to think I meant Tim Miller. So I do want to say Will Sumner explicitly. Yeah. I can't believe that they've decided that it's part of their kind of holy duty to borrow from the weekend to go after Hassan. Let's go. Let's get it. I said at the start of this that whenever people pick this kind of fight, jumping with both feet and start swinging

because it is a fight we need to have. We should have had it a while ago. We should have had it in 2024 when Sarah Longwell was not, she didn't pitch the idea that you should run with the same. It was just a huge part of her campaign. And by the way, she was the one invited by Kamla Harris to moderate it.

Get these idiots out of the Democratic Party. If they have such a big constituency, go bring it to their fucking Republicans. A little preview of, that's left reckoning tomorrow. The left reckoning tomorrow. Maybe we'll touch on that tomorrow as well. We'll give left reckoning the head start there.

But that was some infuriating discourse that I got a glimpse of over the weekend. Lunatics. People are lunatics with too much money. All right, folks. I'm going to head into the fun half. See you there. Okay, Emma, please. Well, I just, I feel that my voice is sorely lacking in the majority report.

Wait, look, Samma's unpopular. I do deserve a vacation at Disney World. So, ladies and gentlemen, it is a lot. It is my pleasure to welcome Emma to the show. It is Thursday. Yeah, I think you need to take over Sam, but... That's good. Sir, I'm gonna, I'm gonna pause you right there.

Wait, what? You can't encourage Emma to live like this. And I'll tell you why. So it was offered a twerk, sushi, and poker with the boys. Twerk? Sushi and poker with the boys. Who was offered a tour? Yeah.

Sushi and poker with the boys. What? Twere? Suci and poker. Sushi and poker with the boys. He was offered a... That's what we call it. What you did to Tim Poole was mean.

Free speech. Look at how sad he's become now. You shouldn't even talk about it because I think you're responsible. I probably am in a certain way, but let's get to the meltdown here. Dwerp? Ugh. Sushi and poker with the boys. Oh my God.

Wow. Sushi. I'm sorry. I'm losing my fucking mind. Someone's offered a twirp. Sushi and poker sushi and this thing. I think the U.S. should be providing me with a wife and kids. But we're talking about.

not a fun job. It's a real thing. Willie Walker. That's a real thing. That's a real thing. Actually, not just in the game. Period.