The McShay Show - Demond Williams Jr. vs. Drew Mestemaker: Who’s the Better NFL Prospect?

Episode Date: July 16, 2026

Welcome back to The McShay Show! Today, the guys are concluding their Building the Board series with Washington QB Demond Williams Jr. and Oklahoma State QB Drew Mestemaker. (00:00) Welcome to The McShay Show! (01:37) Building the Board: Demond Williams Jr. vs. Drew Mestemaker (03:21) Takeaways from the tape (04:34) Demond Williams Jr.'s biggest strengths (16:15) Drew Mestemaker's biggest strengths (23:07) Offseason development needs (31:32) How will their game translate to the NFL? (39:53) Head-to-head grades Make your rise with the MVP Bundle. Available now. The Ringer is committed to responsible gaming. Please visit https://fanduel.com/playwithaplan to learn more about the resources and helplines. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Part seven of our seven part series is here. It's building the board, the 2027 quarterback class. And today we've got an interesting one. Demand Williams Jr. from Washington versus Drew Mesta Maker, transfer from North Texas to Oklahoma State. And there's just 287 days. I had to look down on my notes to make sure 287 days until the NFL draft. You good, Mitch?

I'm great, man. All my favorite beat, tuck. This episode is presented. by EA Sports College Football 27, where you can engineer your team the way you want. And if you want the full football experience, try the MVP bundle. I'm already getting pressure from the boys in this house.

We got to get it. We got to get it, right? Well, I'm going to cave. You get College Football 27, Madden NFL 27, plus deluxe edition rewards in both games to help you go from campus legend to NFL superstar. Make your rise with the MVP bundle available now. Conditions and restrictions apply.

C.EA.com slash games slash EA dash sports dash college dash football slash college dash football dash 27 slash game dash disclaimers for details. We tried to pair up all these quarterbacks and have some kind of link, right? It was like Arch versus Dante, QB1, QB2, who's going to be QB1 in the very beginning? It was saying versus Carr. blue blood programs, red shirt sophomores last year, second year starters.

We did seller Sorsby, very similar type of quarterback prospect in terms of mobility, still raw, developing. Throughout it, there's been kind of a tie that binds. I can't find one with Mestamaker and DeMond Williams. Wait, I was like, how did you do it this time? How do you link these two? No, you didn't even try it.

I mean, Mestamaker is transferring from North Texas to Oklahoma State. It was a redshirt sophomore last year, similar to Carr and saying. But it's a transfer opportunity that he earned through a sensational season at North Texas. He's a bigger pocket passer. We'll get into all the nuances of his game. And then you get DeMond Williams, who's been in Washington for a few years and has continued to develop.

And he's mobile and he's undersized. And he's all the things that you would expect from an explosive dual. threat quarterback, right? But they happen to be their last two remaining in terms of quarterbacks. This makes 14 now, Munch. And we'll get into the grades at the end, see if we have any surprises, where these two will wind up on our board of 14 quarterbacks that we're doing in this building the board. This series has been awesome, man.

It's been fun. So let's just dive right in, right? Yeah, let's go. This episode is brought to you by Accenture. When your advertising operations fall out of sync, everything else follows. Spotify and Accenture are working together to reinvent the rhythm of ad sales, using automation, analytics, and smarter workflows to simplify campaign delivery and access better data across the business.

The result? Less time spent on operations, more time connecting brands with the moments and fandoms that matter most. Learn more at Accenture.com slash Spotify. I ask you this question every time we start, and I'm going to do it again for the seventh straight time. You got done with Mestemaker, you got done with Williams. What was your biggest takeaway? It is, we're this deep in the series,

and they are very different players, so I had a hard time coming up with a big picture one. I'm going to focus on DeMond Williams, Jr., and kind of give away some stuff here, but this is what I'm going to go with. DeMond Williams, Jr., to me, is a classic example of a quarterback who I love watching play, at the college level, but I'm not sure how this translates the NFL.

I'm different than you, man. Really? Good. That's great. My biggest takeaway is if there's a heat map, if there's a heat map for all these quarterbacks, it's a lot more red and it's hotter than I thought. I had an expectation that I was going to be similar to you when I went and popped in the tape. We've both watched them on TV. We've both prepared for different games.

We've studied enough. to understand who he is. But when I sat down and watched his tape, after watching 12 other quarterbacks, I've got him in a different place than I expected. So let's just dive in a way. I do, man. I do.

I can't wait. Strengths. Take it wherever you want. I mean, he's an unbelievable runner. I think he's electric with, I mean, with his ability to extend plays. He's twitchy. He's a former championship,

four by 100 high school sprinter. You see that on tape. he can he's not only is he had a naturally talented runner in terms of the quickness speed ability to make people miss he's instinctive i like how he hugs his blocks on design quarterback runs and then again extends plays really well and make some highlight real type plays when he has to go off schedule and make an off platform throw so it's the mobility to me yeah for demand let's just give let's give a little background right five five 10 and a half is what was measured by scouts in the spring. 195 pounds. Looking at a Manning Passing Academy,

I would say probably he's over 200, but we'll see. But he's in that range, right? I've got him listed at 4-6, like, get out of here, these conservative 40 times. No, yeah. I mean, since they've all been conservative, huh?

Oh, my gosh. He's a flat-out burner. And compared to Mesta Maker, who's a 4-8, like, it's just, no, he's in the, I'll be surprised. if he ever runs a 40, if he's not in the 4-4 range of things. I said a few years for Williams Jr. at Washington, this would be his third year, making it a few years.

Shows up in 2024 as a true freshman. Wines up playing in a few games. He's a four-star recruit coming out of Arizona. He actually played it in all 13 games in 2024 as a true freshman. Started two of them, completed 78 percent, showed a lot of promise. It's 944 passing yards. Just one interception compared to eight touchdowns. And then took over as the full-time starter this past season, right?

Started all 13 games, over 3,000 passing yards, 25 touchdowns, just eight picks. Also ran for 6-11 and six scores. So that's kind of the backdrop on Williams. Okay. Here's what the mobility is obvious. I equated it to, I'm equated. as we're in the process of building. I'm equating his athletic traits as essential.

Focusing, and I know everyone gets so pissed off when you say, oh, he's a wide receiver. I'm not saying he's a quarterback. And if you hear me out on all of this, like I'm hiring. I will say the same thing, by the way. Let's not get this twisted. Oh, by, like, he is an absolute, I'm saying when he takes off running or he's scrambling,

I view him almost as like a slot receiver that caught the ball in a little bit of space. I agree. I would say more of running back, but same thing. Not like this 4-3 guy on the outside, but he's a 4-4-speed runner, electrifying, you know, like the elusiveness, the sharp cuts, just a feel as an open field runner. He has a great feel, okay? There were a couple times I thought to myself, is he going to be able to turn the corner here, and the next thing you know, he's sprinting down to his island. got this gear, man. Yeah.

So there's that. But here's as a passer why I was like, huh, there's a little more here than I expected. Quick trigger, a lot of energy on the intermediate throws. Yes, there are throws that he makes that are off target and they're not where they need to be. But then I kind of studied, and it's, there's not. it's on the run and I think things are happening too fast. Feeder here. And I think that's a byproduct of some of the throws. And the Maryland tape was his worst tape that I watched, surprisingly. I actually liked his Ohio State tape, even though they scored, it was 24-6 of the final. He drove

them down the field. He did some really impressive things against it. Better than I expected, yeah. Way better than I expected. They just, they didn't convert drives, okay? The Washington State tape for me was like if I'm a scout and I'm walking in the GM's office and he's like, give me one tape because you're pounding the table for this guy. Give me the one tape. That's his best of tape is Washington State. Like just the running abilities on full display. I thought his ball placement was impressive, intermediate, over the middle, some outside the number stuff.

But I think he's a little bit late sometimes in the timing with the deep ball. But he actually throws a really good deep ball from, I mean, I just, like I appreciated where some of the placement was on the deep ball. I think as a first year starter last year and a guy who's 5, 10 and a half, who's known for his mobility and it's featured heavily, I saw a lot of promise in the way he throws the football. And I want to remind people. Here we go. I want to remind people of what Jalen Hertz was as a passer in his first year as a starter. I want to remind people of what Lamar Jackson was in his first year as a starter, throwing the football. So I'm not saying he's going to be one of those guys, but I saw more strengths in his game as a passer.

Like compact balls out hitting some spots and then the escapeability extending plays I don't know. Here's my thing with some of these quarterbacks. And this is the tricky part, Mitch, because we lived in a society, a scouting society for so long. We both graduated University of Richmond in 1999. Don't tell people that, dude.

Fine. We both got into this thing in the early 2000s, right? I was actually starting with Gary Horton in 98, going into 99, in an internship out in Arizona. If people don't know this, McShay was like Harry Potter, there are these stairs at University of Richmond

in these apartments that have a closet underneath the stairs and people would be partying and McShay would be in the closet watching tape like just a maniac. By senior year. I told Matt Davis and Baker and I forget who my other roommate was at that year. Winnington, Jim, Ryan. Wilmo. No.

Wilmo. Wilmo, Adam Williamowski, who's just up here. His son is looking at Ivy. Ivy League schools. I don't know how that man could produce an Ivy League, but I'm here for it. He must have a brilliant wife. Anyway, long, short, yes, I used to

in my senior year, I got this opportunity to help write some articles of sporting news, and I was watching tape in a closet in the university apartments at Richmond. But my point in all of this is it was all pocket passing. It was, the mobility wasn't a factor. It was about mechanics,

reads, progressions, all those things, right? And now I'm watching these quarterbacks in such a different light. And I told you, Mahomes was the first guy where it's like, give me the results, give me the special traits. And we can develop that because Josh Allen wasn't Josh Allen at Wyoming. He had the best arm maybe that I've ever seen. Marcus Russell was up there and we saw what that did. But you combine his mobility and his arm, but he was like broadside of the barn missing sometimes,

you know, throwing, trying to hit water off the boat sometimes, but developed. I'm obviously exaggerating, but there were some, there was a real of really bad. It was a concern. It was a legitimate concern. It was a concern, but still loved his traits, but it was still kind of stuck in the accuracy and progressions and mental makeup make the quarterback. And if you don't excel in those two areas, you're not going to be Brady, you're not going to be Manning, you're not going to be Breeze, you know?

And so the transition started with like Mahomes and Josh Allen. And I always mentioned Jalen Hertz because I didn't see it with Jalen at Alabama. And I saw a little bit more at Oklahoma and to see where he is. But it also takes good circumstances. Mahomes had him, had the year with Alex Smith, had Andy Reid, was a different human being, and especially a different quarter, not human being. He was a different quarterback mentally than he was, his second year in the NFL than he was coming out of Texas Tech. Josh Allen and Brian Dable and they kind of, the mobility

early on and had some struggles but worked through it. Jalen Hertz, grinding, like notorious for it. And yeah, everyone wants to point to all the things with the Eagles and there's frustration every year and all that. But Jalen Hertz was like showing up with the briefcase every morning. like there's legendary stories about when he's getting to the facility, when he's leaving. So like it takes circumstances and it takes special work ethic, which is like a commitment to this game that is like beyond OCD. It's obsessive. Yes.

And so we've got a bunch of months now to drill into who's DeMond Williams. That's going to be a big part of this. I swear. We have more common ground here than you think. Yeah. And I want to get Jed Fish on. And I want to get some of these coaches on to talk about the human being and what they see. And yes, I know they're all going to be.

Well, he's the best. He's first in, last out, all that. But you can tell sometimes the difference in some of the specific things they say. And it's like the BS reader and all that. So I'm not ruling this cat out because I saw more in his passing skills. And we've talked about some of these mobile quarterbacks from Sellers, Lenore Sellers, to South Carolina, Archmanning, Texas. Nico I. Maliava, UCLA.

Soresby, call it Texas Tech, call it Cincinnati. Can't play this season. Who am I missing? I feel like I'm missing one more. But there's a bunch of mobile quarterbacks that we've discussed. And you can make an argument. He's the most explosive, dynamic runner of all of them. You can't coach that.

you could make the argument i wouldn't i wouldn't be i would be on the other side of that argument for you rank them for me mobility i think the guy you're most afraid of sellers is is is by far the scariest guy i think that arch isn't as twitchy but the straight line speed it'd be interesting to see those guys in the race demand's mobility when you combine all those traits is is ahead of arch for me okay that's i that argument i'm more comfortable with i just seller I can't get there with you. Okay. So he's the second, even if we agreed.

He is definitely up there. He is definitely up. The reason I ask you this is because I think this comes into, when you have a quarterback to size, you're going to compare him to other quarterbacks that are similar frames, right? Do you think, let's go here. Do you think he's as dangerous to runner,

as athletic, as explosive, as Kyler Murray was at Oklahoma? He's twitchier. I think he's twitchier. More side to side, choose kind of a deal is what you're saying. Yep. Yep.

Yep. I think Kyler is faster on a straight line. I agree. And quicker, but yes. All right. So let's get to Drew Mestemaker, who's kind of been lost in the shovel. What strengths for him?

Former, you know, walk on, gets a starting job in North Texas. I really thought this kid showed a great grasp of the offense and was more developed as a quarterback and understanding concepts and how to attack coverage than I expected.

Now, look, the inexperience still shows at times there's certain rotations he didn't read well. He threw in a coverage a couple of times. I'm not saying it was perfect, but he could get to his backside read. He knew where he wanted to go with the ball. There were times it certainly looked like to me he was setting protections and making changes at the line.

This guy's brain is pretty developed, I think for a first year starter. And I think if I wanted to be obvious, I could talk about the arm strength. I think he's got a live arm. But I think to me, what really stood out that I wasn't really expecting was how smart he is.

Yeah, he has a really good control. And he, I was just looking up the name. Yeah, he was stuck behind other talented quarterbacks, apparently, backed up Braden Buchanan and Deuce Adams at the position at Austin's, Vandergrift High School.

Yeah. And so he kind of like barely played quarterback before. Yeah. It's a wild story. It's a great story. It's a great story. He made one start, this is Mestemaker, one start, five appearances in 2024,

his red shirt year, and then he started all 14 this past year. He completed 69% of his passes, almost 4,400 yards, 34 touchdowns, nine picks. Yeah, he won the Bullsworth Trophy AAC offensive player of the year and then goes and transfers to Oklahoma State, right, with coach. Yeah, that's a big deal, by the way. Do you want to get into the head coach at this point or should we wait a second? Sure, sure.

Head coach Eric Morris, who comes over with him from North Texas, has been at Texas Tech. He's been at Washington. So he's worked with Mateer and Cammore at Washington. He worked with the Holmes and Mayfield, Baker. Mayfield at Texas Tech. This guy's been with some big time. I will check.

I did not. I don't think he was at SMU. He was not. Okay. All right. He was not. So he was incarnate Ward with Ward, went to Washington with Ward. Mateer was, did not play that year, but he, he recruited him and had him on that roster

for a year. And then at Texas Tech, he was, you know, he got to work with Mahomes and Mayfield. So this is a dude that knows how to identify talent a quarterback, how to develop talent a quarterback. So, you know, it'll be interesting to see what kind of progress he can get in a year two out of this kid. Going against better talent, but I would argue this is not the big town of the SEC, and he's going to have better talent at receivers. Some of the receivers at North Texas, I was, you know, they weren't the, this wasn't the best roster. Let's just say that.

Yeah, agreed. I mean, it's a shotgun-based offense. a lot of, you know, after the snap, a lot of four receiver, whether it's four receivers look, but a lot of four routes going out. His strength is sitting back in the pocket as a tall six three to six three in a quarter, 215 pound quarterback is pre-snap reads, kind of figuring out the leverage of defensive backs, reading the coverage, pre-post, finding the right receiver,

seeing the whole field, all of it, progression. and then hitting the, and making the right decision, ball out pretty accurate passer, right? Led the FBS in passing yards per game and passing yards per attempt, by the way. They relied on them. And like you said, like for a guy who didn't play a ton in high school and played limited as a red shirt freshman, to come in and have that command. And he can kind of snap. He doesn't have an elite arm.

I like his arm, but it's not elite, yeah. It's a two. You know, one is exceptional on our grading scale. Five is marginal. Three is right in the middle. It's a two. It's good, right? And I like it.

And I like the way he can kind of like sometimes the defender's hanging on him or he doesn't have his feet problem. He can kind of just flick it and get the ball there. Yes. So those things are all good. I'm really excited to see him, like you said, in a similar system, new weapons. but also new level of competition. It's not like we're not saying Big Ten or SEC,

but definitely a step up, right? Yeah, that taller pocket passer, not a statue. We'll get into some of the weakness and all. Not a statue, competitive mobility. Think about all the things we said about Drew Aller and his mobility. He, like, he kind of not the fastest, not the twitchiest, all those things, but, like, there were times where you need a first down, and he kind of felt it, and he's got good, like, coordination and balance.

But I think he's a little, he's got a little bit more juice than Alar. I mean, I know. Yeah, he's a, oh, yeah, he's a straight line guy, but every time he ran, I was like, where did that come from? Right, right? Yeah, like, why are we not doing that occasionally? I'm not saying that's going to be the strength of this game. It's never going to be the strength.

But when he, I, in my notes, this guy's, I thought he was a statue. I thought he was a pocket passer, just strictly a pocket passer. And then he would, then all of a sudden out of nowhere he takes off. And I'm like, oh, he moves way better than I anticipated. Yeah. But way better than I thought. Same. In writing the preseason report that we're basically our foundation that we'll continue to build on.

The preseason preseason report, I was explaining to people all the things he wasn't from a mobility standpoint. And then he kept making me go back to my notes and kind of, and that's why I started with the, he's not a statue. because if you read my notes in kind of the early parts of it, I was like pocket passer, not the most agile, you know, but then I started seeing more and more on tape where he was effective when the opportunity presented itself, right? So again, very different quarterbacks. You get to Mon.

It couldn't be more different. And everything's like, and Messerschmaker's back there like four receiver sets, back in the backfield, pre-snap decisions, balls snap shotgun let's make a good read come to one to two maybe three balls out occasionally takes off and runs and gets a first down because he's kind of competitive coordinated he's athletic but he's not this burner and he's not the things that make them on so intriguing right the hulu original series furious is coming to disney plus starring emmy rossum furious follows fbi agent alice black on the

hunt for a mysterious and calculating serial killer Both walk their own paths toward justice, and as their lives start to intertwine, the line between right and wrong begins to blur. Don't miss the three-episode premiere of the Hulu original series Furious on July 27th, only on Hulu on Disney Plus. Hey, y'all, it's Kelly Clarkson with Wayfair. Ever order furniture online and wonder, what if? Like, what if it doesn't hold up?

That sofa was four days old. You should have ordered from Wayfair. With Wayfair, there's no what-if. Just style you love and quality you can trust. Visit Wayfair.ca. Fair, every style, every home. Right. Weaknesses, whether it's Demand or Mestemaker.

Take it wherever you want. Let's go with Mestamaker, because I'm just thinking about it now, and you kind of hinted at it already. He's not an escape artist. I do think he does a decent job of navigating the pocket. I think he can move around a little bit and buy some time. The problem is there's that aspect of it, and then what happens next? I think his decision-making and his accuracy really start to erode when you get him to move his feet a little bit. think that's a problem for him.

So that would be the number one thing that stuck out to me. And also, even though he doesn't have an elite arm, we do have a little bit of another power pitcher who needs to develop a change-up situation here where some of the trajectory and the arc on some of these passes, I want to see a little better. Yeah. I second everything you're saying. In addition to if he's going to be this guy, I got to see a big step.

want to remind people he's just a red shirt junior my guess is he's got two years at oklahoma state and i think that that will be best for i agree with that right considering how little he like i talked about the national list the blesto list the preseason rankings this year they were much more aggressive in terms of including guys like a jeremiah smith or quarterbacks but it would be third year playing right third year like after two years of eligibility they're willing to kind of expand the field, which in my, I don't know, 26 years of getting my hands on national list, blessed all this, it was always like, these guys are the true seniors, the ones who would grow the senior bowl.

Well, the whole thing's changed. Senior Bowl takes underclassmen. And we're NIL and Transfer Portal and all those things. So they've wisely expanded the field. But Julian saying, as a redshirt sophomore last year and first year starter, C.J. Carr is a redshirt sophomore, first year starter, and Mestamaker, same deal. red shirt sophomore first year starter last year none of those those three names appear on on those lists okay um and i think rightfully so smart so so i say all that because if he's going to be this guy

which he is i want to see i want to see the advancement because now he's going into a second year as a starter, right? Didn't play a lot of ball in the past, but now it's time to the old rinse, refine, repeat. He's so good at making reads and so good at controlling the offense and doing those things, now he's got to take it to a graduate level. Because I can't have those two

interceptions, what was the South Florida game, 501 first quarter is an example, didn't see the linebacker. Yeah. And I got, I got to believe, with a little bit more experience, you know, a bad one. Yeah. And then there was another one later. there's second interception in that game.

It was a little bit about, he was kind of throat pressure coming. I'm trying to remember it back. Pressure coming. A little bit more of a placement issue than a decision issue as we're getting to, I think. Yeah, but there also was a robber, like a safety right behind,

trying to fit it between two defenders. The ball placement was a little off. Probably didn't see that safety behind as well. So just let's advance, let's be great, not good. Let's be great with Reed's decision. although, you know what I mean? Because he's going to have to be. To be, yes.

If this skill set's going to work in the NFL as a starter or a capable backup that can come in and win some games, right? We've been doing like how does it translate? I think we kind of covered that. Well, no, sorry. We didn't have weaknesses. Give me your weaknesses of Lamon Williams. Yeah. What am I doing?

I want to say this. I want to. Because he has no weaknesses in my eyes. He's perfect. A liar. You have to pick apart anything you've ever evaluated. There's always a flaw, man. I want to echo some of the things you said really quickly.

I think what DeMont Williams Jr. hits his back foot and he throws over the middle and the ball is out on time and rhythm. I saw some really nice stuff on throwing over the middle of the field. I also thought on some of these throws where you're anticipating some of these deep crossers to clear zone looks and the receivers running away from him. He made a couple nice touch throws from within the pocket. that were really encouraging. I thought that was the most fascinating thing you said is that you saw some things in the pocket that were encouraging. And maybe this is just a different kind of,

I mean, this has popped up before with some of these quarterbacks, most obviously Sam Levitt. I'm encouraged by that stuff. I don't see enough of it. I don't, and I feel like I've seen this movie before where we have a dynamic, smaller quarterback who you just love what he does at the college level and make some of these throws that you,

you just are like, well, here's five throws, mensch. Here's five throws. Look at what he can do. And it's not really about what you can do. It's about what you do consistently. Now, if he's able to do that and take the next step, I'm going to be excited about anyone else as DeMond Williams Jr. But at this point, I'm seeing there's too much of the, of the,

I need to, I need chaos. I need to extend plays. I am going to take off and run if my first read isn't there. all of those things jump out to me as concerning of this hasn't actually translated that well as the NFL. I mean, Johnny Mansell was awesome to watch at Texas A&M. Kyler Murray was awesome to watch at Oklahoma. And the very key thing about both those guys

that I think is interesting again about what you brought up is we do have some time to get into DeMont Williams Jr.'s character Because I think both of those players, I mean, one more so than the other, obviously, but have had questions about whether or not not they were willing to put in the time to what it takes to be truly great. And maybe that's what DeMont Williams Jr. has that will get him over the hump and get him there because he does do some really nice things from the pocket.

I understand that. It's not consistent enough for me. There's too many misses. There's too many times where he wants to take off and run. I don't, that's my biggest concern is like, how does this, how does it translate? We saw it so differently, man. I know. Maybe I had a lower bar coming.

Like, I'm watching that Washington State game and he's, he's like, Yeah, he'll run if he needs to, but he's hanging in there and he's going through his reeds. He's doing it quickly. There's a tempo to what he's doing, and he's hitting spots. And then Ohio State, I'm expecting this is going to be a disaster. This defense, I have a crystal ball, right? I have hindsight in my favor, and I know 24 to 6 is the final. And he's hanging in there and he's making throws and the protection's not great.

and I don't like there's there's like the deep outthrow that he's making there there's crossers there's down the middle of the field there's left rail shots I just I saw it different I was so encouraged I hear you now the Maryland tape was like uh the organ tape wasn't great either I mean yeah but but he hung and I watched that and it was like but he hung in there and he did some things in that oh he's so tough dude I didn't know about Yeah. And Mansell had substance abuse issues and was disappearing at the Manning Passing Academy, wasn't showing up to meetings, the NFL, all this stuff.

Yeah, that's, yeah. And Kyler with the video games and the commitment and the contract, like. But that's why it's interesting. We got time to get into this kid. And there's no reason to believe he won't be an absolute workaholic. I'm not commenting in all about. about what it is. But like until we have that full picture,

until I see him do some things more consistently. And again, this is you are, I'm surprised because if you had asked us before this process where each one of us stood, I would be more of a guy who would be more of a, not benefit of the doubt, I guess that's not the right way of saying.

Projecting, you're seeing where this player's gone and I feel like you're making expectations about where they're going to go next. Whereas I'm more of a guy like, I haven't seen it yet. I need to see more. Maybe it's,

I mean, that's fair. I think the thing that I keep, I'm not beating around the bush. The thing I keep starting to reference, or I keep referencing. And let's just, let's, let's drill into it for a second. For so long, I was so obsessed with the mechanics of and all the things that the NFL films guy would come up, guys would come up to Bristol. And I can tell where the ball's going to go by where his foot, where his footwork is and all that stuff, right? I used to call him the NFL films biker gang. And it was proven and it was effective.

And then I talked about Mahomes and Josh Allen and Hertz and Lamar and all those guys, right? The thing that's different now, and I don't think I've finished and I want to make sure the thing that's different now is I'm obsessed with I can't coach that. It's a fucking unique trait. It is something I can't coach. It is something special. It is dynamic. It scares me on defense. It breaks down my coverages.

It breaks down my, my, my, my, my, my, my, my, my, my, my pass rush. I've got to have lanes. I've got to now rush properly. I've got to do it with discipline. I've got to have eyes forward. I can't turn in man to man. This quarterback that keeps coming out of these kinds of quarterbacks and we're talking about like five of them and potentially in this class with the amaliava and sellers and

and Sorsby and arch, all these guys we keep talking about and demand them. looking at, we just said he's second most in term, maybe second best, most dynamic athlete. And yes, he's 5, 10 and a half. I get it. I don't know. So you've got that. And then I see someone who's with Jed Fish. Like, I know Jed.

I've hung out a lot with Jed. I've talked to, like, he's been around a lot of really good quarterbacks and has developed him. And I'm watching what he's learning from Jed in just, you know, a short, like, probably year and a half. It'll be two, two plus years by the time. he takes the field. I see advancement in his game and I see a skill set that, like, right now in the NFL, it seems like it can work. And so I just don't want to help this cat out.

You think he has, you, you think he's elite. You think there's things that you have that you can. I don't, I don't know, man. Like, I get that he's, he's really athletic. I don't think he's historically an elite guy. And I just think it's a dangerous game you're playing. I really do. And I think who were the successful quarterbacks in this league?

I mean, you right now, there are guys like, you know, Lamar Jackson, which is funny because the ESPN rankings of Lamar Jackson, by the way, he's now the 39th best player in the league. I think that's crazy. But we'll get into that another time. That being said, there are guys that are elite that, you know, I would love to have a quarterback. But Sam Darnold just won the Super Bowl. I mean, the best quarterback in history in, he wasn't that long ago was Tom Brady. And there are guys like Jalen Hertz who's on a Super Bowl. Patrick Mahomes.

What is Patrick Mahomes? You can't coach. He's magic. You can't coach magic, but there's no like, you can't coach. It's not mobility. It's his instinct and ability to throw. That's not a physical trait, though.

That's not a physical trait. His arm is exceptional. And the way he can throw from different angles, yes. Exceptional. But I watched him throw, I watched him throw a ball. submarines 60 yards in the air and hit a perfect spot at Texas.

I don't. I'm not arguing. I'm not going to, I'm not going to sit here. He's so fucking gifted. It's like absurd and it's just come. And even though he's not fast and twitchy, is there more instinctive, effective? Like there are very, let me put it this way. Who is more talent?

Who has more natural talent in terms of being an athletic, strong, all of those things? Anthony Richardson or Patrick Mahomes? Of course, Anthony. Anthony Richardson. So what are we doing? If you want, like, true serum, what scares me the most is the size.

Because for every Russell Wilson, there's a bunch of these cats that don't work. And yes, I'm going to give him a grade in a minute and you're going to see like, oh,

he's still reasonable. Like, I'm not, I'm not elevating him up. That's like the funniest part about this. He's going to be. Dante one, Sellers, two,

Dumon, Williams, three. I'm reasonable. But I want the, audience to understand he's not just this running dual threat guy who's really cute in college. See, we're not that far off on him. And NFL teams, like, you look at these preseason grades that I'm referencing and talking

to different scouts and GMs and asking them for what their rankings are with positions. We try to do the way too early mock and try to kind of get more of a feel of what NFL teams before they get heavy in their process this fall, how they view them. like, DeMond's name's on all those lists. Demand's name is higher. Like, let's look at, like, we got, we got, we got, more in arch. We got Sellers Levitt, Sorsby, I Amaliava, and Williams, ahead of Champa. I'm not saying these are right, right?

Yeah, and I spend all year long saying, but I'm just, I'm just saying, like, I'm not alone in thinking, oh, you're not on Ireland. This guy's different from the other guys. I do want to say that, like, the mechanics, like, I see. I've talked about everyone now. It's, it's, think about the golf swing versus the baseball swing, right? The golf swing is compact.

You're all here. It's there. It's down. And you're not bringing, like when you go back with the club, you're not, you're not bringing that knee in like a baseball where you're like sliding back.

But at the end of the day, the whole, the whole power base element is become the same. We've talked a lot about it this, this off season. I think it's important to talk about these things. before we get in the season like i'm going to the m2 qb camp i'm going to arch to the manning passing academy i'm talking to all like the the um the qb country coaches and mobile like i'm i'm

getting access to on purpose because the quarterback position is being coached the same almost everywhere which is so different than what it used to be and so i'm watching deman and i'm then i'm watching a thousand 1400 campers being coached the same thing at manning passing academy from all all over the country. And I'm watching M2QB when I go on Saturdays. And by the way, they've got, they've got like Bork and Vargas guys who are going D1, like Virginia Tech and wherever Vargas is going to be the,

the best player of any position ever to come out of the state of Massachusetts. Got offers everywhere. He's that good at St. John's Prep, okay? Working there. They're all doing the same stuff, right? And it's like this balance and it's shooting the hip. and the release looks more three quarters than ever before. It used to be.

Yes. And now it's here because the hip is driving it. The arm is just an extension of it. And it's, right? Yep. And you're finishing here like and then almost pulling the string back. I'm watching him and I'm seeing like when he's missing sometimes, it's the lean, right?

Instead of here. it's the lean left longer stride and I should mention the stride is as barely a stride right it's kind of this short power base arm and and now I'm watching him he's kind of long striding on some of his misses and leaning and what does that do to your arm balls ball's going to go high right right so it's correctable stuff is my and I know that's long-winded and explanation but I think it's important to kind of fill people in on where the quarterback position is. And for Demand, I think, like, some of the misses are just correctable things. And then the other misses, a lot of them are, he's going 100 miles an hour.

He's avoiding pressure. His offensive line isn't great. He's running and he's, like, literally sprinting north and just throwing, and he rushes himself. So I'm fired up to see after another offseason, and he's been through his first year as a starter, is there advancement in those areas? And if there are, I'm going to be a backer. Let's put it that way.

What did you give him for a grade? I want to know now. Now I need to know, like, you say you're going to be a backer. Where did you put? Just give me his grade. 89. This is the biggest, this is by far the biggest cap we're going to have. I gave him an 89.

And I want to remind people, let's just go through it real quick. I got these notes somewhere. Dante is about a 94 or 95. He's number one. Sellers is a 93, 94. He's number two. I've got Levin is a 93. is the number three quarterback.

You've got them about four spots down. We both have Carr and Arch in like the 92 range, right? Mensa's and 91. We both have Nico and Chambliss in right around the 90 range. That gives us seven quarterbacks. Then I've got this pocket or cluster or grouping, bunch, whatever you want to call it, tier of 8889's with Sayan from Ohio State, Julian Sayan, Brennan,

in Soresby and Dimon Williams in there. And I would go saying Sorsby Williams if you're asking me to rank him, which I knew you were going to, so I'll just get out ahead of it. And that's ahead of currently Miava. But I told you, I think Miava can make a huge leap this year. And I've got Miava at like an 87 right behind him. Meteer, like call it a 79, call it an 80. But again, I don't know where we are with him.

encouraged by the mechanics I'm seeing. He's restructured his throwing. He's doing a lot more of the stuff I just explained. And the arm angle is kind of is changed to relieve some of the stress that he, he was an armed thrower that somehow found away, like up in the air, twisting all this stuff to generate torque. But he was putting a lot of pressure on his body and it was leading to inconsistency with placement. If those mechanics that we saw at the Manning Passing Academy play out, and he's the best version of himself, I think his grade could absolutely rise. But that would be ahead of Myava, Mateer, Mesta Maker.

We'll get to Hoover on Monday. Josh Hoover. Where do you have him? I gave him a 70. Oh, God. I think he's, I just don't think, I don't see elite in anything. I think he's a really good athlete.

I don't think he's as good as Kyler Murray was as an athlete. Now, remember Johnny Mansell, we felt the same way about Johnny Mansell. Can we just talk about that? Like, we felt like he was going to, the idea that he was going to go that early was Manistos. I don't think the NFL is really going to look at a 510, 10, 195 pound quarterback who isn't

polished enough at this point as a pocket. I actually think 70 is, is that, is, I mean, is fair. And I understand what the National Scout, that's an eye opening grade for me for the National Scout to give him that high of a grade. Oh, I don't, I don't care about that. I'm just saying, but it's just something that popped out to me when you look at the list. just don't, I don't know what the, what's the pathway here? Who were the 510, 10, 195 pound quarterbacks in the NFL have done really well.

And again, we could talk about the traits and about how you, things that you can't coach. But I would go back to, okay, we've seen players with traits that are elite. And why did they fail and why did they succeed? Who were the guys succeeded? Who are the guys that failed? And DeMont Williams, like, do we think he's that good of a pocket passer that he's going to be able to overcome his lack of size? I don't know, man.

Like, I just don't, I just, I'm not comfortable with the path. I'm not comfortable with the frame. How big is Bryce Young? Bryce. I'll pull it up right now. And I'm not comparing their passing ability demands currently to Bryce Young's.

But I am saying part of what made Bryce Young so intriguing with some of the magic and his ability to create. Obviously, I'm not comparing these two because people are going to go crazy on that. I'm just saying, 5-10 and an eighth, 204 pounds. Right.

And roughly the same size. And I think Williams is more dynamic athletically. I think DeMond might maybe has a little more, no, DeMont has a little bit more juice in his arm. He's nowhere near the pastor that Rice. No, I understand. I'm just saying it like, it can work. And it typically can work with guys who are more.

explosive as a runner. Kyler had like, I get that Kyler's career as the number one overall pick is not what you want. But Kyler also, like there was always something with the video games,

commitment, working contract, and Arizona news flash for you. They're picking in the top five every fucking year, man. It's not like, it feels like it, or top 10 or like,

they haven't exactly supported him brilliantly. Okay? I'm just saying, I'm not really, I'm not really ready to call Bryce Young. the success story that maybe you are either, just to say that too. No, but in 89 grade is this, yeah, but what number pick was he for Carolina? I'm just saying in 89 grade, I'm giving him somewhere, maybe he's a late first,

but I'm giving him a grade that's equivalent to a second round, much more importantly with our grading. It's about a backup quarterback that you think can develop because there's some stuff there that is highly intriguing that if we can get the best version of him and he keeps developing, maybe he could be a starter in the league. That's what you draft an 89 grade for. I gave 89 grades to Drew Breeze would have been the equivalent. Drew Breeze was like our first year.

I don't know what grade. It was higher than where he was taken. Derek Carr was in that range. Like, you know what I mean? Jackson Dart was, what, a 91? So, like, I don't know. I'm just saying, I'm giving him an 89, knowing full well,

there has to be improvement, and I want to see the progression here, but he's more gifted and has more to offer the NFL than I even was close to expecting when I really dug into his tape. What about Matt's the thing? Go ahead.

Yeah, we'll move on. We'll move on. Rune for the kid, because I love watching the play. But I just can't go there in terms of a grade. I didn't think there was a world in which we would spend a summer where I was kinder and saw more This is so off script for me. It's so off script.

Your grades are sweetheart grades in the summer, and then you become miserable bench and get depressed. They're all going to be, all the guards are top 50 picks, just so you know. All right, quickly. What a mess to make your grade? I gave him an 82. I really like him, man.

I know. I'm really high on his ability to, I think he's got a strong arm. 82 is, I mean, middle of day two, but there are things that I'm really excited about watching him do. I think he's got a quarterback coach who's going to develop him. So, like, I have him in the back. He's not the top 10 of these quarterbacks.

I mean, he didn't crack the top 10, so let's not get carried away. But in the middle of the second round, you're taking a kid who's, you know, 6, 3, 2, 15, he's got a strong arm who makes good decisions. That's what I'm looking for there. I'm looking for a guy who I think could come in and be a great backup. And like you said, maybe start. I feel more comfortable about that.

I'm not taking a flyer. I just, I don't know. I'm very comfortable with taking that kid in the middle of day two. I appreciate everyone who's watching on Netflix, both mentioned. I do appreciate it. Thank you so much for watching on Spotify. Thanks for listening on Apple, if that's where you're doing, or anywhere else you get your podcast.

We will be back on Monday. Okay. We're going to do a special EA Sports Driven Dynasty show. on Josh Hoover and Indiana, and it's going to be fascinating. I'm fired up for it. Then we're going to take a little bit of a break because I need some time away from Steve, and I think Steve could use some time away from me. I don't know what you mean.

We're going on a retreat together, it sounds like. I think our wives are working on that. We might meet up in Montana for a couple of days. And then I'm going to be out in L.A. for a couple days for some meetings. I may be looking for a new co-host. That's tough. No, I'm joking. That's mean.

No, it's absolutely, it's the opposite of that. But then we're going to be back. We're going to be back after, like, I don't know, it's probably like 12 days or so we're not going to have a show. We're back on Monday. And then it's like, you know, after that, it's like two weeks combined. So, and then we've got a lot of exciting stuff coming up. We might have some exciting stuff to talk about for this fall.

We might have all that. So I just wanted to prep everyone before I tell MENCH migrate on Mestemaker. and say five stars and just get out of here. I gave him a 60. A 60? To the kid who led, okay. You know what? All right.

The kid who led the FBS and passing yards per game. Okay. Five stars. See you on Monday. Thanks, man. Must be 21 plus and present in select states for Kansas in affiliation with Kansas Star Casino or 18 plus and present in D.C., Kentucky or Wyoming. gambling problem. Call 1-800 gambler or 1-800-Gambler or 1-800-m-800-7-7-77 or visit ccpG.org

slash chat in Connecticut or visit MDGamblinghelp.org in Maryland. Hope is here. Visit Gambling helplinema.m.m.m.org or call 1-800-327-50-50 for 24-7 support in Massachusetts. 1877 8-8-8-Hope-N-Y or text Hope-N-Y in New York. For Louisiana, call 1877-7-770-8-67.