The McShay Show - Senior Bowl Primer: Finding QB3, Ranking Position Players in Mobile, and an Unforgettable Tim Tebow Story
Episode Date: January 23, 2025Welcome back to ‘The McShay Show’! Todd and Steve open by sharing some of their favorite Senior Bowl memories, including Todd’s experience covering Tim Tebow and the 2010 draft. Then, the guys d...iscuss this year’s quarterback group and predict which signal-caller will get drafted after Cam Ward and Shedeur Sanders. To close, they draft the top players at each position in Mobile. (0:00) Welcome to The McShay Show! (2:12) It's OFFICIALLY Draft Season! (6:22) The State of the 2025 QB Draft Class (17:00) Evaluating the #1 Draft Pick Odds (17:37) Titans: “We won’t pass on a generational talent with the first pick in the NFL Draft.” (23:52) Who is QB3? (28:05) Todd's Tebow Draft Story (40:22) Who is QB3? (49:02) Senior Bowl Positional Rankings Draft (50:43) Senior Bowl Draft: Top 4 QB's (54:37) Senior Bowl Draft: Top 4 WR's (1:02:18) Senior Bowl Draft: Top 6 RB's (1:11:37) Senior Bowl Draft: Top 6 DL (1:20:14) Scouting Mobile's Food Scene (1:24:29) Coming up on The McShay Show The Ringer is committed to responsible gaming. Please visit www.rg-help.com to learn more about the resources and helplines available. Host: Todd McShay Guests: Steve Muench Producers: Tucker Tashjian, Mark Panik, Conor Nevins, and Daniel Comer Social: Eduardo Ocampo Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
It's the McShea show presented by Fandul.
You thought December was the most wonderful time of the year?
Well, you're wrong.
The NFL playoffs are just about here,
and there's no better time to bet with America's number one sportsbook.
Bet on new and fun markets like to catch a pass same game parlay's,
highest scoring game across the Sunday slate,
offensive touchdowns in the next drive, and so much more.
The app is safe, secure, and easy to use.
And when you win, you'll get paid instantly.
Plus, get exclusive offers all playoffs long.
So download the app today and bet the playoffs with Fandual,
an official sportsbook partner of the NFL.
The ringer is committed to responsible gaming.
Please visit RG-Help.com to learn more about the resources and help lines available
and listen to the end of the episode for additional details.
It must be 21 and older and present in select states.
Gambling problem?
Call 1-800 gambler or visit RG-HELP.
dot com.
It's finally here.
It's officially NFL draft season
at the McShea Show headquarters.
Let's kick things off properly today,
Medge.
What do you say?
I'm not going to panic this year,
McShay.
Just kidding.
I'm already panicking.
Yeah, I mean, that's right on brand.
Listen, is Cam Ward now
the clear leader in the clubhouse as QB1
in the NFL draft?
Band duel is going to kind of give us some insight on that.
Plus, will the senior bowl become a QB3
sweepstakes of sorts?
We'll explain.
And then finally, we're going to go through the Senior Bowl roster and use today to draft the top prospects in Mobile at the strongest position.
The college football season is in the books.
It's conference championship week in the NFL and just 91 days until the NFL draft.
Ment's you good?
I'm good, man.
Tickle me those sweet beats, would you tuck?
Jim Nagy always says the draft begins in Mobile, right?
Yeah.
The draft starts today for us.
Let's not, I mean, let's not kid ourselves.
I know that makes you nervous.
I know there's only 91 days left.
But the college football season's over.
It was an awesome season.
12 team playoff.
First time running through.
We've got changes to make moving forward, no question,
but an unbelievable experience.
And it was the start of this show for us,
the McShea show and really got us kicked off.
Great appetizer into our entree, right?
I mean, this is our bread and butter, if you will.
And we appreciate.
everyone being with us through the bumps the bruises the highs and the lows all of our live shows the
community we're building um it's been a fun ride but now it's time to honestly it's time to get serious
and we're putting together our draft boards we're going over our rankings we're watching tape
sitting here with the clicker going back and forth watching tape on all these players next up in line
is the senior ball mention i and a crew from from the ringer we're all flying down on sunday we're
going to be there Monday. We've got way-ins. We're going to do a lot of interviews on Monday.
Please join us next week. It's kind of like today's the unofficial kickoff for us. We're going to
preview everything and kind of get things rolling. But we kick into high gear next week, too,
with the Senior Bowl, we're going to be there all week long. But Tuesday, Wednesday,
Thursday, we're going to have shows following each day of practice. The practices are the best
match. I mean, take people through it real quickly. From the one-on-ones, the one's,
seven-on-sevons, the team groups, like how important that process is.
It starts with, I mean, for me, being the former offensive line,
and it's the one-on-ones with the defensive line, which is an outstanding group this year.
The one-on-ones with the defensive line and the offensive line,
just getting to see them go best against the best, who competes,
who has a good rep, who has a bad rep, it bounces back.
You see things like, you want to see how guys hold up in pass protection if they're a running
back, or maybe they didn't catch the ball a lot in college.
You'll see them go one-on-one against linebackers.
both pass protection and in the receiving drills the seven on seven stuff is great
quarterbacks you know can quickly get labeled as check down charlie's if they're taking everything
that's easy and just trying to get through the drill or they being more aggressive and pushing
the ball down field a little bit and it's three days of that i'm just guys competing against each other
the game's great it's it's awesome at the end but it's really those drills of seeing the best
against the best going at it being competitive that's the reason you want to go down there
And you mentioned the trenches being kind of the strongest group,
and it really is looking at this roster.
I looked yesterday, Ments, you ready for this?
On the American and national defensive lines, right, for the Senior Bowl,
the two rosters, I had four first round draft pick,
potential players in the first round, and 12 on day two.
That's 16 guys that could hear their name called in the first three rounds of the draft.
So that's going to be fun to watch.
And let's not forget to, and I think a good portion of what we'll do.
Yeah, we'll interview some coaches.
Like, this is never going to be a big interview.
Bring someone on for a half hour and, you know,
talk about how important this offseason is.
Like, I don't want to do that.
I always fast forward when I'm listening to a podcast.
I always change the channel if I'm watching.
You know, like I do.
I'm just going to be honest.
Right, right.
If we're going to bring someone on, there's going to be a reason.
It's going to be something that we've seen that they're doing,
that we're intrigued by that we specifically want to talk to them about.
And probably only like a couple player interviews,
typically maybe some quarterbacks.
that I think are most intriguing just to get to know them a little bit.
But what I find fascinating is always so valuable to me.
And this is our opportunity for the first time ever that I've had it in like 25 years of doing,
of doing television, radio, print, media for the NFL draft where we can like really get
into the conversations and not obviously, you know, expose anyone we're talking to.
But what are the conversations going on with general managers,
scouts, coaches that we're having with them, that they're having within their organizations.
I think that's going to be a fascinating part of what we do.
The top two quarterbacks are not going to be at the draft, right?
And it feels like every time we come on the show, there's more news, there's some kind of update.
I do think it's important.
Let's start things off today as now the college football season is over.
All the bowl games are done.
The college football playoff is over.
And kind of a state of the union, if you will, at the quarterback position.
and at the top of the draft.
I think it's fascinating.
And again, neither of the top quarterbacks.
We're talking about Shador Sanders from Colorado and Miami's Cam Ward will be at the
Senior Bowl.
I should note, Shadur Sanders is going to the East West Shrine game, which is taking
place this week.
He's not going to be participating.
He was there basically is a deal made with the East West Shrine game to help get a lot of
their late round free agent prospects from Colorado to be a part of that.
bowl and give him an opportunity. And I applaud him for that. Like, there's no problem in that.
He's, he's helping his teammates out who have helped him out through the course of his career.
But I want to, in a little bit, get to the QB3 discussion and how I think Mobile and the senior
bowl specifically is going to absolutely play a role. And we've seen it in the past,
is going to play a role in which quarterback is drafted third overall in terms of the quarterback
position in the 2025 draft.
But right now, did you see this on Fandual, Munch?
No, I'm not watching it.
Sponsors at Fandual, they keep, you know, they keep updating.
And I talk to our guys.
I talked to, you know, Tucker and Connor and Dan.
We're going to create like a stock market where we track it over the court.
Because I think it's fascinating.
I love that.
Really in the last like three years, it has legitimately become something that not just us in the media, track,
but like I'm literally having conversations with General Manifax.
managers who are like, hey, why is it on Fanduel that all of a sudden, Jane Daniels and
Caleb Williams are like neck and neck for the number one overall? What are you hearing?
It's like a jump starter to these conversations, right? And Fandual isn't like, they have information.
And so there's a reason why, okay? And so I find it fascinating. If we can put up this,
this graphic we have. Take a look at this is the odds to be the number one overall pick in the
2025 draft. Okay. Shador Sanders a while ago, and again, well, by next week, we'll start
creating a stock market where we contract this. But I find it fascinating that when Tennessee got that
number one overall pick and all the buzz about that organization favoring Cam Ward over Shador
Sanders, when that came in, Cam Ward went to the top of the odds and replaced Shador Sanders.
Okay. So that's the first part. The second part that I find fascinating, let's keep this up.
The second part I find fascinating is that we've already had a change in leadership in Tennessee and in the front office.
Ran Carthon was sent packing, you know?
And so why has that not changed even with new leadership?
And the third part that I find fascinating, you look at these numbers, it's Cam Ward number one, number one overall, the top odds, I should say, plus 105.
if you're not watching on YouTube, I'll keep you up to date.
It's Cam Ward at plus 105.
So he's got the top odds, highest odds.
Travis Hunter at plus 155.
So he's more heavily favored to be the number one overall pick
than Shador Sanders, who's at, listen to this number,
Munch, plus 360.
That's a high number.
And then beyond that, like they're huge drop in numbers,
but I do think it's interesting just to see the information fan duels getting in terms of guys
and where they may slot in the draft because obviously, you know,
I don't think Will Campbell, the guard tackle from LSU,
is going to wind up being the first overall pick.
But the fact that he's sixth in the odds here behind Cam Ward, Travis Hunter, Shador, Sanders,
then Abdul Carter at number four, Teteroa McMillan at number five,
and then Will Campbell at six, ahead of Kelvin,
Banks, the tackle from Texas.
Very interesting to me.
Mason Graham is up where he belongs at number seven behind Will Campbell.
Jackson Dart.
That's a great way to transition.
Jackson Dart, Kelvin Banks, Jr., Quinn Ewers, way off.
Will Johnson, I wish you could short some of these.
Will Johnson, Michael Williams, Jalen Milrow, James Pierce, Nick Skorton,
Defensive End from A&M, Luther Burden, Wide Receiver.
from Missouri and Ashton Jinty, the running back from Boise State,
round off the group of players that were involved in this,
in these odds, in these odds from Fandoul to be the number one overall pick.
What do you think they know?
Do they know that Tennessee favors Ward,
or do they know that Dion's not letting his kid go to Tennessee?
That's interesting.
There's two ways to look at that, right?
Yeah.
And I actually, when I was putting this together,
I wanted to ask you kind of that question.
Even if it's not,
even if it's not Coach Prime saying to Tennessee,
I haven't heard,
I've heard a couple places.
I have not heard Tennessee being one of them.
Have you?
No, I've not.
I've not heard that team.
I heard some rumblings about Cleveland, right?
I'm trying to think there were a couple other places,
and we're going to get Coach Prime on between now and the draft,
and we can go through all of this with him.
but but I do wonder too
I think there's two parts of this
when you're evaluating like what you're getting okay
the first part to me if you're favoring Cam Ward over Shador
Shador is the best passer in this class
best pure passer his instincts as a passer not in the pocket
his instincts as a passer when the initial play breaks down
and he's scanning the field his ability to throw with timing
trajectory layer the ball
ball placement, touch, all of those things are what makes him a potential good starting quarterback
in the NFL. Now, does he have elite arm strike? No, it's good. It's not elite. Does he have elite
mobility? Absolutely not. It's actually, when he takes off to run, he's not overly mobile,
which is surprising is Coach Prime and son. But what he has is an ability to locate and throw the
ball more effectively than any quarterback in his class. On the flip side,
Cam Ward is not as developed in terms of progression reads, seeing the whole field.
He's not as consistent with his ball placement.
A lot more frozen ropes on throws that could use a little bit of finesse behind them, those sorts of things.
But he's got a stronger arm.
He's more mobile.
Not elite mobility, but more mobile than Shador.
And he kind of creates more with the arm angles and the ability to break some tackles and different things.
that. So from a physical tool standpoint, I think the team that is that winds up, if a team winds up
taking Cam Ward over Shador, it's the traits to develop. Both players, I'll say this,
let's just get this out of the way. Both players are absolute dogs. Competitive nature,
their will to win, showing up in big moments, like toughness, taking hits, bouncing back.
Like both players are equal in terms of some of the intangibles you look at.
I have heard that Cam Ward's kind of legendary in terms of leadership demanding from teammates.
You're getting someone who's going to come in and kind of have that veteran approach already.
And so while Shador is great in that department, I think Cam's like a weirdly high level.
Okay.
So that can all factor in.
But then I also wonder, too, if you're sitting there in a front office, does it factor in it all?
And I'll ask you this question.
Do you think it will factor in it all?
How much of the circus are we getting with Shador?
And to no fault of his own, but all everything that comes with in terms of like the media attention, the commercials, coach prime, kind of the outside noise that can come with that.
Not dissimilar from Tim Tebow, right?
I mean, there were some places that when Tim Tebow didn't work out in Denver,
and he was trying to find somewhere else to go.
Remember, they had like a press conference about a backup quarterback coming
to play for the New York Jets.
And like it was a media frenzy.
He was a backup.
You know, like, so I wonder how much that factors in.
It has to.
I mean, when you're picking potentially your franchise quarterback,
you're making that kind of an investment with potentially
an early first round pick.
We'll see how this unfolds.
But I think realistically, it's probably going to be an early first round pick.
You better factor in everything.
You better know what you're getting and you better be ready for it.
I will say the flip side of that is, and we've mentioned this before,
is that sure has shown that he can handle the circus, that he can be, you know,
kind of the eye of the storm when things are crazy and there's a lot of press and
there's a lot of attention on a Colorado team that, you know, probably wasn't going to get
a lot of attention other than the fact that Coach Prime is the coach and he's the quarterback.
and obviously Travis Hunter, but, you know, got a lot of attention.
And he handled it well.
So I think you look at that if you're a big market team and saying,
this kid's kind of ready.
He's tailor-made for this high-pressure situation
because of some of the stuff he's already been in.
But yeah, you bet.
I mean, you have to factor in everything.
That's why reports are, that's why interviews are so important.
That's why medical is so important.
That's why doing all your background checks.
Just sitting down with a player.
And do you, is there a good vibe for lack of a better way of saying it?
Are you guys on the same page?
Do you feel good about, you know, spending all of the hours that you're going to need to spend
to be successful with this human being?
And do you feel like you can win?
Because that's, it's important.
All of that is important.
We put so much emphasis on the tape, and I think that's the correct way to evaluate players.
But this is a, it is a wide and a broad process that you have to put a lot of different
resources and instincts into.
It's going to be fascinating.
It really is.
and we look at the top of the draft, Tennessee picking at one, Cleveland at two,
giants at three.
All need quarterbacks.
Check, check, check.
If you're watching on YouTube, you can see the graphic that we've built.
Patriots at four and Jaguars at five, not in the quarterback market.
But right after that, Raiders at six, jets at seven, and then down in number nine,
the Saints.
All those teams, right, six out of the top ten, need a quarterback.
There's only two.
And if we're being brutally honest, jumping off point is what?
quarter QB four, five last year, if you're putting these guys in the 2024 draft class.
So changed. And I thought it was interesting too.
Tennessee's was it the president that came out of the organization? I don't have the name in
front of me in the press conference. Right. And said they're already looking to trade back or
we're entertaining. It pretty much put out the four sales sign. Yes, but also stated that we're
we're not going to be in the business, something along the lines.
I'm paraphrasing.
We're not in the business of passing on a generational talent.
So immediately, I saw Schefter, pooh, but, but, but, they're not, you know, read between the tea leaves.
I see it differently.
Face value, it's, hey, Travis Hunter is a generational talent.
We're not going to pass on that.
I've been in this game too long, and Schefter has too, but Schefter's just kind of reporting the news.
It's our job to then, okay, let's read between the lines here.
to me, in a class that doesn't have a quarterback like we had last year with Caleb Williams,
Jaden Daniels, Drake May, even maybe depending on how you viewed it, J.J. McCarthy, Michael Penix,
Bo Nicks, okay? In a class that doesn't have that quarterback. And what you and I have just recently
talked about, building organizations, right, the Detroit Lions, the Baltimore Ravens, San Francisco 49ers,
Like building from the trenches out, getting it right.
So when you get your quarterback, you plug it in, that's the way to go.
That's how the consistently good, the consistent playoff, even the Seattle Seahawks back in the day, right?
Consistently good.
They got Russell Wilson, plugged him in, but they had everything kind of sorted out for that moment.
I look at that and I read it between the lines of come and get them.
Ah, come and get them.
Right.
Because we're going to take him.
We're going to take him.
And maybe we're talking about Abdul Carter, but I think most people would say,
generational talent is something that you haven't seen in a generation.
There's only one player in this class that is a generational talent by those standards.
That's Travis Hunter.
Have we in our generation seen a player, both sides, that many snaps,
that effective as a receiver and a cornerback.
That's a generational talent.
I think Abdul Carter is phenomenal.
But Micah Parsons,
has been in my generation.
Agreed.
Do you know what I mean?
I do.
So I think that that was,
we're open for business.
If you don't want to come up and get them,
we're going to take it.
Because there's,
yeah,
there are some teams that want a quarterback,
but it's a rare year
where there may be a bigger market
for a team to say,
Travis Hunter's different,
special, best thing in this class.
let's give away a little bit to go get them.
I don't know.
That's how I read it.
You take Travis Hunter with the first overall pick in this class?
No.
Yeah.
I think I take Abdul Carter.
If I'm not taking a quarter,
if I'm not sold on the quarterbacks,
I'm taking Abdul Carter because of everything we've talked about.
And I don't want to get into another 20-minute rant about it.
I basically just summed it up the trenches.
Let's build the trenches, pass rushers,
let's make sure we're protecting your quarterback.
Let's get dudes up.
front, both sides of the ball. And I would take Abdul-Carter. And you never go broke getting a
profit in the draft. And you know Abdul-Carter is going to be a profit. He's going to better your
football team in probably the second most important area on your roster. Right. And so you're not
going to trade up to get him at pick one. You're not going to give up another asset or another couple
assets to go up and get him. I agree. I love you. I think we're going to see a lot of teams that want to
trade down this year because this class is loaded with depth. There's a lot of good players in this
draft. There's not a lot of elite players. Okay. I agree. So that part's all fascinating to me.
It really is. And we went a little longer on it than I wanted, but it's like this is the most
important part, the top of the draft, the quarterbacks and who else could be there and the messaging
coming out of Tennessee and teams like Cleveland and the Giants sitting behind me, they're like,
all right, well, maybe they will pass on the quarterbacks. Maybe we'll have our choice.
Or maybe our guy will fall to us, you know?
But, I mean, we've seen it before.
This, the top two quarterbacks in this class are better than the Kenny Pickett year.
I get it.
They are.
But it's more similar to that year where we saw, we were wondering, like,
is Pickett going to go way earlier than he should?
Is Malik Willis going to be a first round pick?
Yeah.
You know, all those guys.
So I, I, when it's all said and done, if the first two players taken in this draft,
are Travis Hunter and or Travis Hunter and Abdul Carter in either, either way, one or one, two,
respectively.
It won't shock me.
Nope.
And that means the Giants would be on the board at three and have a quarterback that they want.
So it's all going to be fascinating to see how it plays out.
And you know the Patriots sitting at four would have, listen, the Patriots at four,
it can work out one of two ways.
You either want both the quarterbacks to go, right?
you want both the quarterbacks to go so that you can get your guy,
either Travis Hunter or Abdul Carter at four,
or you want at least one of the quarterbacks to fall to four
so that the teams behind you that we just touched on,
Vegas at six, Jets at seven, New Orleans at nine,
one of those teams would be more likely to move up to four to go get a quarterback
than they would pay that exorbitant price in draft capital
to move up to number one or two.
Okay.
And that would allow the Patriots to move back.
Get pretty much pretty close to the same value in player at six or seven or nine.
If Hunter and Abdul,
if Hunter and Abdul Carter are gone,
you're desperate to move out of number four,
is my opinion,
if you're New England because you don't need a quarterback.
So give me more picks.
We're building this roster.
We want to take advantage of the depth this year
and also try to get a first round or at least a second round pick next year.
So that's how I kind of view things as we stand right now.
Who is QB3, though?
I see that smile.
I'm smiling too.
Let me go through a little history for you, okay?
I'm going to read off a bunch of names.
Okay.
The similarity, the tie that binds with all of these names,
they were not QB1.
Only one of them went on to be QB1,
but none of them were QB1 going into,
the senior bowl and the rest of them didn't even wind up being drafted as QB1, but they all
significant, I don't want to say significant, they all improve their draft stock with the way
things went at the senior ball, okay? Jordan Love, eventually the Packers draft pick in the
first round, Justin Herbert, Charger's first round, Jalen Hertz, actually improved his draft stock.
We were talking third round. He wound up going early second to the Eagles.
or second to the Eagles.
I don't know the exact pick.
Daniel Jones,
like one of the just butcher jobs of all time,
drafting him as high as they did.
Don't hold that.
Don't be afraid of it.
I never will.
Josh Allen,
Baker Mayfield is the exception.
He wound up being QB1 in that loaded class of talent coming out, right?
But he wasn't going into that weekend.
That was unthinkable.
Like two weeks before the draft,
that it was shocking that there was kind of rumblings, right?
Dak Prescott, Russell Wilson, Kirk Cousins, Andy Dalton, and Tim Tebow.
That's why when we start to look at this year's quarterback class, right?
And we've got two quarterbacks that aren't going to be playing in All-Star games,
even though Shador is going to be at the East West Shrine game,
but he's not expected to participate at all.
And we start to look at the fan dual numbers, right?
And I don't think for a half a second, not even a second, a half a second,
that Jackson Dart's going to be the first overall pick
or Jalen Milrow is going to be the first overall pick.
But I do look at those two and say,
we got an interesting battle for QB3.
And some people might say, Will Howard, I'm not there yet.
I recognize the growth in his game.
We talked about it in our reaction show,
our live reaction show to the college football national championship game.
But I think Jackson, Dart, and Jalen Milrow have phenomenal, unique
opportunities in Mobile.
And I think this is, and the reason it's critical is because they're working with NFL
coaches, they're in NFL meeting rooms, they're throwing NFL balls, they're working
against competition in NFL schemes to show things that they didn't show at Alabama and
Ole Miss respectively, right?
I'll never forget the Tim Tebow year.
Me neither.
I mean, that was a circus.
That was a guy who transcended sports.
It wasn't, you know, you get people down there who are Florida or Alabama fans
and they come in to see watch their players.
And you get the big stars that are just college football fans want to come and see that.
Tim Tebow was a rock star.
Tim Tebow was the Beatles in Mobile that week.
I mean, we used to, you would take off his helmet after every rep.
There was people just taking pictures.
It was just, it was a circus.
It was actually, it made it tougher to highlight other players that week.
which was frustrating, but it was, you know, that's not Tim Tebow's fault,
but it was an absolute circus that week.
So a little bit behind the scenes on this, right?
Kuiper never leaves the Kuiper compound.
That was the whole deal.
Like, and I joked about it for years, still due to this day.
Kuiper's like, nah, I'm good.
I'm not going to the Combine.
We got him to the Combine one year.
He's like, yeah, no, that was so much fun.
I love this.
We should do it next year.
Fast forward nine months later, we start talking about the Combine with the ESPN executives.
And he's like, no, I'm out.
I'm not going.
So, so I'm at that point in my career, what was that, the 2010 draft, 2011, somewhere in that range, maybe 2013, but yeah, 2013 maybe.
I'm, I'm kind of early in the TV thing and I'm just kind of, I'm grinding my way up, right?
And so all of a sudden, we're down to Mobile.
We've been, I've been going to Mobile, the Senior Bowl, since I was a senior in college.
When we were at Richmond, I went to the Senior Bowl and I went to the Combine.
Gary Horton, you know, flew me down and just kind of got as an intern, right?
So I'd been going for 99, you know, 13, 14 years already.
But this time, it was like, holy shit.
What is it?
They said, so ESPN sends down the college game day bus, Curtis, our driver, remember?
We would go between practices and sit in the bus.
Like, we're game, you know, where the game day stuff, eight screens in the backdrop,
camera set up in their little studio.
And now, like, what we used to do TV-wise before Tebow was at the Senior Bowl was,
day of practice done, Todd, come on, 90 seconds, instant analysis.
They'd send a producer down who would also run the camera, bare bones.
I'd do 90 seconds on a quick summary.
Here's how the top two quarterbacks played and one guy who's rising, right?
And they'd ship it off to Sport Center.
They'd run that same clip on like five different shows.
Now all of a sudden, I'm in production meetings, like the Wednesday before with like top executives.
They're like, we're sending the game day bus.
We've got five camera members, camera crew people going down.
We've got producers, directors, and executive.
Like, I was like, wait, what?
And so we get down there and it's an absolute circus.
It's always like, Mobile's the best.
It can never leave Mobile, Alabama.
They embrace this game.
It is their, like, it's their baby.
And it's what makes the whole situation special.
But we get down there.
And mind you, Mel's never disliked a quarter.
quarterback, okay? That's part of his secret sauce. And we'll have Mel on a couple of times lead up to the draft.
And I don't shy away from anything with Mel, as everyone already knows. But Mel has never hated a
quarterback. Mel likes some more and pushes them, but he's never been like, no, I don't think that's
going to work out. So I got Kuiper back in Maryland from at home in the Kuiper compound doing
bits with me. He's watching some things on TV and not even getting like full access.
of practices. I've done all the tape from the season. I'm at the practices and I'm watching these
things and you know my stance like, no, I don't see it. I don't see it. Like I love Tim and I said it
a hundred times that year. Tim Tebow's the greatest college football player at the time I'd ever seen.
Leadership, the toughness, the winning. Like he's he embodies everything you want. I couldn't have,
I just absolutely love Tim Tebow.
my mom and my sister hated me for my stance on it it got really bad because i was going on these
clips and being like how was tim tibo practice today but you know like it's all this media hyping
we've got all these executives and the game day bus and all this stuff has like has the NFL world
and media is there like it dropped in in mobile alabama and they come to me on camera and i'm like
yeah he's very inconsistent with his accuracy i don't see an NFL passer
he doesn't have anticipation as a passer.
His releases is,
and I don't think his brand of football is going to work in the NFL.
And then I got Kuiper responding and saying,
you know, I love his competitiveness and he's a winner,
but he's not saying he loves him.
He's just, he's playing the good cop for my bad cop.
And that's when it all starts.
I became the Howard Stern of the NFL draft.
And so it was like the hardest few months of
my professional career, just in the backdrop, personally, it was difficult, man.
I'm not joking.
It was hard.
You didn't work with Urban Meyer until years later, right?
I can tell that.
I can tell that story too in a minute.
But what I endured was hard.
I'm a young guy in this profession.
I have not made my way.
I'm not, no, people weren't mad, mensch.
They were enraged, like scary.
I get done with that week at the.
senior bowl of all the negative talk and trying you know me out good and bad competitors he's a winner he's
all these things but i mentioned maybe he should move to tight end which he eventually kind of tried
right yeah um but all and then all the negatives so i come back from the senior bowl and like the
how i mentioned Howard stern because Howard stern always says like the people who love me listen for
remember that movie right yeah people who love me watch listen for like 53 minutes or whatever that or
seven 17 minutes the people who hate
me watch for two hours.
Right.
That's what that was like this negative positive thing that was happening in my career.
People hated me.
I was public enemy number one nationally and like worldwide.
But real quickly, you know who didn't, do you know who didn't hate you?
A lot of the scouts, a lot of the front office guys who are walking by giving me a little.
I became a mouthpiece for them like enough's enough.
Enough's enough.
Like there's a ton of really great football players here and pro prospects.
What are we doing?
Who deserve attention and only one player is getting attention.
So we had that.
But I get home, Munch, back in Boston, and I have letters.
And this is like the anthrax time.
I've got letters coming in in the mail.
I don't know if I've ever told you this.
Letters coming in hate mail.
I don't know how people got my address.
That's fun.
And I'm opening up.
One of them was a three-page letter from a pastor,
from a Baptist church who was really mad at me.
And was the quote I'll never forget was I'm praying for your hatred.
And so like I go through all of that.
And meanwhile, like people want me on all these shows.
So it's like good for the career.
But personally, I'm struggling.
My mom's calling me pissed off.
She's religious.
My sister, they're religious, very religious.
And they're upset with me.
You know, so I'm going through all that.
And so now I got the pro day in Gainesville.
And remember that class was loaded.
That was Urban's gem.
You know, Joe, Joe Hayden, all the past, like, it was, it was a loaded class.
And so I'm down there.
I'm excited, you know, at the pro day in Gainesville to watch all these players and do it.
But I also know what I'm walking into.
And Tebow's there with his brother, right?
And his brother's got to start a production company to kind of document all this stuff.
And, and so now I'm going in the bowels of the, I'm there talking about Tebow and his workout and how he's throwing.
and it's not all positive again.
And when that's all done,
and I'm doing Sports Center hits and all NFL live,
all those shows,
then when it's done,
Tebow's brother brings me into like the bowels of the swamp
into one of the locker rooms and wants to interview me.
So that was uncomfortable.
I'm walking out of the swamp.
I'm walking out of what is Ben Griffith Stadium, right?
And Mrs. Tebow pulls me aside.
Oh, tough one, right?
And it's like, listen, sweetest woman I've ever met, you ever met in like a short span of time.
You know, like, yeah.
Could could not, as you would imagine, Tim Tebow's mom, beautiful, wonderful woman, like just salt of the earth.
She pulled me as such.
She's like, listen, I know you're going through a lot with, you know, with Tim and the backlash.
And I just wanted you to know that I'm praying for you.
And quite honestly, thank you.
you've provided my son with motivation, you know, so it's a good thing.
And so now I'm like, oh, gosh.
And my mom's mad.
My sister's mad.
Tim Tebow's mom's not mad.
She's praying for me.
Like, it was hard.
It was hard.
Right?
Yeah.
There's a real human element.
There was a real human element to all of this.
Yes.
And so that draft goes through.
He gets drafted in the first round.
Josh McDaniels falls in love with him.
I'm blown away.
Maybe I don't know what I'm doing.
Maybe I'm wrong.
Josh McDaniel, look at the success he had with Tom Brady and New England.
Like, maybe I'm wrong.
And then he goes and wins a playoff game against the Steelers, right?
But then the rest is history and I can live on the evaluation.
But then fast forward, right?
And you just mentioned Urban.
I wasn't going to bring this up.
I'll just give you a quick story.
We can dive more into it later.
Urban takes a year off after Florida, right, before going to Ohio State comes to works at ESPN.
I've been doing, I've been doing all these game day hits and traveling around.
The executives call me and say, hey, listen, we know you have a good relationship with Urban.
We want him to do a weekly hit for game day.
And we, like a feature.
And so we're going to fly you down to Gainesville.
And I was like, I don't want it like to kind of host this.
Anyway, they talked me into it.
It's the right thing for the company.
I'm a company guy.
So I'm going down there every Tuesday.
Get down there Tuesday night.
Stay to hotel.
Get there Wednesday morning.
And we would tape something all throughout the day.
We'd watch tape and hang out.
I played football with his son.
like became closer.
But the first time I walk in to the house,
like this is how naive and stupid I am sometimes, right?
I pull into the gated community where Billy Donovan, Urban Meyer,
like they all live in a beautiful, very nice community,
need the code, text my producer.
And I'm like, what's the code to get in?
He's like, whatever it is, 319, 4.4.
So punch in that number.
Gates open.
I'm driving in.
It's literally not until I can still picture to this day.
I'm pulling up houses on the left.
I see like a production thing.
It's definitely ESPN.
It's definitely the house number.
Here we go.
Going over the little bump to go down the driveway to park my rental car.
And not until I got over that bump did it hit me.
Oh, shit.
Oh, shit.
Urban's family is like family with Tim.
Right.
Yeah.
And I'm like, this might be uncomfortable.
How did that not process in the week leading up to this thing?
So now I'm kind of like, and it's like 97 degrees in early September and Gainesville.
And so I'm starting to sweat.
And so I walked to the front door and I'm like, and door opens up.
It's Shelly.
Shelly Meyer.
And she said, she doesn't let me in.
She shuts the door behind her and says, we're going to have to talk this thing out.
And I was like, I was like, yes, Mrs. Meyer.
And I'm still like younger.
I'm like, and so she lays into me.
You got it wrong with him.
I can't believe he's, he's like a son to me.
He's one of the greatest human beings and you've sat there for four months.
And I just, I don't know if I can ever forgive you, but I'm a, you know, God fearing and Christian.
I will forgive you, but it's hard.
And I just wanted to get, you know, I wanted that.
I wanted us to have this.
So she finally after for her, yep, oh, absolutely, it was great, giving it to me,
lets me in the door and we proceed. And by the way, Shelly and I are great now. I went down and
when they were Jacksonville, sat in the box with her and daughters and, and Tim Tebow and I are
great now. We worked together for years. It was awkward at first. Tim and I are good. And he understands
the job I was doing. We've, we've come to a respectable place. But anyway, I don't know how I got
on that tangent. But from that point on, the senior bowl elevated absolutely my career,
but it became much more of a national big picture thing. And it also, and it wasn't because
of Tim Tebow and all of that, but it was a good example of how a good week in Mobile and being
around coaches and the interview process and what goes on behind the scenes. And that's why I say
it's so important when we talk to coaches and scouts about the stories going on. How are they
in the room.
How are they with their leadership behind the scenes?
There's so much that can come from that.
So in the longest detour of all time,
let's get back to, I know.
But I do feel like I, you know,
we're 41 minutes into this thing now.
We haven't even gotten like the second thing I wanted to talk about.
And you take the floor because I can't,
I haven't shut up yet.
QB3, the opportunity that these guys have.
And I say specifically Jalen Milrow and specifically,
Jackson Dart. What are you looking for from them? How do you think this will play out throughout
the week? What comes to mind when you think of those guys with QB3? And is there anybody else in
QB3? Sorry, anybody else at QB3 that is in competition that is chosen or cannot in Quinn Ewer's
case because of injury needs to recover understandably that's not going to be there that
maybe it will hurt them or maybe by not participating the other two guys will
kind of expose some things.
I think that to knock this out real quick, because I want to get back
in the senior bowl guys. I want to focus on them.
Yeah.
Quinn Ewers, I think his stock is the lowest it's going to be in the process right now.
I think this is where he's going to start climbing back.
I still think he has a potential to be the quarterback three in this draft.
I feel like a lot of people are writing Quinn Ewers off.
I feel like he should have gone back to school.
That doesn't mean those, that doesn't mean that he can't be quarterback three in this
class.
It's not a great class.
As far as the guys going down to Mobile, I think,
the darts in the pole position to be that quarterback three guy. I mean, I just love his game.
He had 52 touchdowns compared to 11 interceptions. This guy's way more mobile than I think people are.
38 starts. I love the way he distributes the ball. I love the way he makes touch throws.
I just think he's in a real good spot to shine down there. I think Jalen Milrow has the most,
this is the most important week for anyone going in there because I have some of three turns about how
Mill Road finished the year.
But the talent is there.
There's absolutely no, you know, there's no mistaking the fact that this kid has the tools
to be a great quarterback.
And he has the leadership skills and all of that stuff.
Don't get me wrong.
The intangibles all seem to be great.
So he just had the last six, five or six games of the season were brutal.
I think he had three touchdown passes.
Two of them were against Mercer.
He threw five picks.
The Oklahoma game is a nightmare.
It's an absolute nightmare.
He was inconsistent.
You look at that the first half of the Georgia game.
I think it's made him a lot of money.
There's a reason people talk about it.
It was an amazing performance for that half.
I haven't seen a lot of that.
I haven't seen any of that since then.
I haven't seen it consistently over the course of his career.
But this is a kid who could go down to Mobile
and just wow people with the way he interviews.
Wow, people with the way he spends it.
He could have a great week.
And all of a sudden you're saying,
oh things just didn't work out in Alabama you know like Saban left and it was a different thing and he
didn't have the weapons that some other guys have had that you start justifying it you start rationalized
we've seen that before and for that reason I think that milro has a chance to be quarterback three coming out
but to me it's dart isn't pole position the tough part about mobile is you can't have this
expectation that just a few weeks ago that Jalen Milrow is is going to improve his footwork
his timing is a passer, his ball placement on anticipation throws all of that.
You can't, it's just, it's unrealistic, right?
But you can, here's what I like to do when I go down to Mobile with the quarterbacks,
especially.
Picture it as a blank canvas.
You haven't seen any tape before, okay?
Erase it, just temporarily erase it from your mind and see, okay, they're all in new systems.
They all have wide receivers.
They're not familiar.
with. They are all working with a new football. They're all dealing with new rules. They're all going
through this grind with the media interviews and bouncing from here to there, interviews at night
with NFL teams, all that stuff. They're all going through this grind together. So it's like,
it's a fair platform across the board because they're all having to do it. And they're all having to
make that same transition. How show me what you have that I can work with if I'm a quarterback coach,
offensive coordinator, head coach.
This is the blank canvas.
Show me what you have to work with.
And we know what he has mobility-wise.
There's like, don't need to see him so much as tuck the ball and run for three yards.
We know what he has.
Show me how quick you are in your drops when put in a position.
Show me how you're picking up from day.
And I love this too.
From day one to day two to day three, are you progressing?
Okay.
Right.
Show me, and this is critical.
We'll talk about it during the week.
week and I don't want to bog down this show right now, but like for quarterbacks, the red zone,
typically on like Thursdays, they do a lot of red zone. Tight spaces, tough decisions, where's your
ball placement? Are you, are you putting it high, you know, is a ball floating in the middle
and putting yourself in a position of risk, which he has done in terms of a turnover in the red
zone, which is like a mortal sin? Or are you, are you driving the ball low and making sure your
receiver is the only, the only one who can get it? Are you protecting the football? Are you making
quick decision? Because in the red zone, everything speeds up and it's confined. So throughout the week,
I want to see those sorts of things. We know he's got the huge arm. We know he throws a great deep ball,
but how is he without, you know, seven on sevens, without the defense, like, do you have what it takes?
Are you showing me promise that there is that?
that there if if myself and my staff can unlock it so that to me is going to be the most intriguing thing
for both of the quarterbacks but especially with jalen i also like to see how they are around these guys
and and and justin herbert i remember when we went down there he was coming out of Oregon there were kind
of some he's kind of a he's kind of a quiet guy he's kind of a different guy he gets down to
mobile people just gravitated to him the player's gravitated and he became you know he wasn't what you
think of as a typical alpha in terms of loud and brash and all that, he was the alpha there
in that quarterback class.
He was.
Guys just were attracted to him.
And it's easy when you go to school and you're a four star or you're the quarterback and you're
kind of the ordained leader and people are going to just gravitate towards you because the schools
put you in that position.
When you show up in Mobile for a week and these are all really good players, sometimes great
players, can you within the first, you know, practice get these.
guys to buy into what you're doing? Can you get them to come along and really kind of follow you?
And I thought Herbert did a great job of that. I always like to keep an eye on that with the
quarterbacks to see who are these guys gravitating towards this quarterback.
The McShea Show is brought to you by Fanduel. There's nothing like the NFL playoffs. It's one
big game after another. And you know what? Big games deserve bigger payouts. That's why Fandual
is giving all customers a same game parlay profit boost every game day during the NFL
playoffs. It doesn't matter if you're new to Fanduel or already have an account. You'll score a
bigger payout if your SGP hits. I just hit on a two-leg same game parlay in the college football
national championship. Oh, the feeling when you see your account jump like that, it's gold. So let's
keep it rolling this week. I'm going to go the AFC championship game, same game parlay. Hear me out on
this. Josh Allen under 284.5 yards. That's rushing and passing combined.
Under 284.5, I just think Steve Spagnola, he's going to have a plan.
They're going to limit Josh Allen.
This is going to be a great game.
But I think Josh Allen's going to be a little bit more limited than what we're used to seeing.
Then on the flip side, let's take the over on Patty Mahomes, one and a half touchdown passes in this game.
I do think they're going to have to win through the air in this one.
I think Mahomes is going to spread the ball out to his different receivers.
I think Mahomes over 1.5.
So let's combine those and hit on this SGP.
So don't watch from the sidelines.
Visit fandul.com slash mickshay to get in on the action.
That's fendul.com slash mickshay to get a same game parlay profit boost every game day during the NFL playoffs.
Make every moment more with Fandul, an official sportsbook partner of the NFL.
Must be 21 and older and present in select states or 18 plus and present in D.C.
Opt-in required.
Minimum three-leg parlay required.
Bonus issued as non-witrowerable profit.
boost tokens. Restrictions apply, including any token expiration and max wager amount.
See terms at sportsbook.Fandul.com. Gambling problem, call 1-800 gambler or visit
RG-hap.com.
A lot of other positions of strength. And I didn't want to do on this show where we sit down,
let's go through the best players. Let's go through each position. I want to do something fun
that makes it interesting, but also provides like a really good jumping off point to the senior
Bowl, but not just the Senior Bowl to the draft in and of itself.
So I want to go through a few positions.
Let's do it with quarterback real quickly.
Yep.
But then let's branch out.
I want to do wide receivers, which is not a great group in as a whole and reflected kind
of at the senior bowl.
But the running back position, which typically has been not a great group at the senior
bowl and kind of hit and miss from draft to draft, but this is arguably the best running back
class in terms of depth of talent we've ever seen since we've been doing it at least and and it's it's
also reflected in the senior bowl roster and then the defensive line that i mentioned 12 day two guys
four first round prospects like we i want to so i want to do a we'll call it draft them i don't know
we don't have any we don't have to be like cute and have all sorts of um you know graphics and fun
stuff and music but i do want to do a quick draft them let's just rip through this
And give our audience a feel of like who are the top guys, who do we like going in?
And then I want to revisit it in 13, 14 days after we're done with the Senior Bowl,
after we've been down there, after we've come back and watch the game,
after we've studied the tape and kind of revisit and take a look.
All right, what changed, right?
What changed?
So here we go, quarterbacks.
I'm going to give you the first pick of these quarterbacks.
I think I know where you're going to go.
But if we're going to draft the top four quarterbacks from the Senior Bowl roster
that includes Jackson Dart, Jalen Milro, Jalen Milro,
Riley Leonard, Seth Hennigan,
Dylan Gabriel, Will Howard.
So the Louisville quarterback's name, last name's change?
Tyler Shuck.
Tyler Shuck.
And then we also have a Canadian quarterback who we're literally just a couple hours ago.
We realized it is on there, but he's certainly not going to make their top four.
So of those quarterbacks, you get the first pick from the Senior Bowl quarterbacks.
Who are you taking?
I'm taking dart for all the reasons I just mentioned.
I mean, 38 starts.
Again, the touchdown interception ratio is good.
I know people are concerned about the system.
We won't know until we find out more and see how he does down there.
So yeah, for all those reasons.
And again, beat Georgia and he had some tough games.
Florida was tough, but he beat Georgia in South Carolina this year,
beat LSU last year.
He's played in a lot of big games, experienced guy.
That's going dart first.
And I'll go Milrow.
It's kind of, you know, we just discussed a whole lot on that.
So Milrow would be the number two for obvious reasons.
reasons. Number three is where it gets interesting. Who are you taking there?
I'll take it Howard. Here's my concern, okay? His completion percentage jumped about 10 points this
year. Is it the system? Is it is the supporting cast? Is it all those things that have made
him drop or is he getting better? He had some inconsistent games. It's kind of a theme. He had
some inconsistent games early in season. And then I thought he had a really magical playoff run.
So is he peaking at the right time? Is he got the right players around him? Tell me a
quarterback that's not better in the right system with the right players around you know that's that's just
you know i think sometimes we over overthink that a little bit i just think i would go howard third
i think you look at the frame you look at the mobility the way he played in the playoff i know he missed
a couple throws but he was accurate he spread the ball around i loved his decision making in the championship
game i went howard i'm going dylan gabriel number four you might be a surprise some people would
say well why not riley leon national championship game the run he had
really intriguing size, mobility, right?
Intangibles, all those things.
I just think as a passer and a processor,
Dylan Gabriel, who's undersized,
who doesn't have that prototypical frame.
I'm just intrigued by him.
I'm just as excited to be honest with you to watch Dylan Gabriel
coming off the season he had and the improvements he's made at every stop
from UCF to open.
Oklahoma to Oregon.
And you called him the Terminator, right?
Like almost like he has, like the numbers are flashing in front of his eyes.
And just the way he.
And yeah, did he finish with his best performances in the college football playoff?
No.
He didn't.
So I want to see how is he rebounding from that.
But more importantly, how is it translating with NFL offenses, new receivers,
all those things here in this environment?
So Dylan Gabriel would be my fourth.
If he's 6-2-2-20, is he in the quarterback one mix?
I think so.
Yeah, maybe.
Yeah, I think he is.
I mean, that's the kind of player he is.
It's the, it's the.
And I don't even think it's like if his traits, it's kind of like Madden, right?
Like my son's always, you know, did you know he's a 93 or dad, you think he's so good?
Matthew Stafford's only like an 84.
And I'm like, okay, but like that doesn't rule the world.
Right.
You know, a madden rating.
But it's almost like if we could.
And I, and I watched the kids.
here like they create players right and they and they bump each each you know accuracy you can bump
it up a little bit if you do these certain things and if you could just kind of bump up a couple of
his physical traits that's what I'm saying a little stronger arm a little bit a little bit bigger right
like I think yeah I think he has a lot of the the things that you look for um so I'm fascinated
to see that all right those are the quarterbacks we've exhausted it wide receivers let's only do
the top four. Let's just get it kind of our,
you know, dip our toes in this just a little bit.
Top four receivers. If you were to draft right now,
where would you go at number one?
It's, it's tough.
And I think I have a couple of curveballs, but I'll go Utah statewide receiver
Jalen Royals, who missed, I think, five games this year with a foot injury.
So I'm glad he's going to be down there. That's going to be great.
Oh, we played seven games.
average to 119.1 yards per game before he hurt his foot.
He is, I love him after the catch.
Makes guys miss.
He's quick.
He's got great contact balance.
He's not overly big at 6 foot 205, but he can be a number two at that size.
Makes contested catches.
I just think when you look at overall his body of work and his talent,
I think he's probably the best one down there.
I don't totally disagree, but the fascinating part to me is there's a bunch of guys competing.
for that for like and and i do think there will be movement i i just love going down to mobile
and knowing that there's a cluster right none of these guys are first rounders but there's a whole
bunch of guys on day two that includes the two iowa state guys jaden higgins and jalen noel
it includes jalen royals it includes alec um a manor which by the way i guess apparently everyone's
been pronouncing his name wrong and we just looked up like the way he pronounced it's elech is his first
name. We all know that. I've heard I-O-M-or,
I've heard also a-minor, but we just listened to him
actually pronounce his own name, which is kind of a helpful tool. And it's
Ah, Manor. It's Ah Manor. Okay. So Elik Ah-Mannor. And then
Tess Johnson's another one from Oregon. So all of those guys are kind of
in a competition and in a cluster and have a great
opportunity here in Mobile to separate themselves, right?
like Jaden Reed was an awesome example a couple years ago from Michigan State, what he did.
And he wound up being an earlier second round pick.
People were saying like third or fourth, I fell in love with him.
He was clearly the best receiver there.
And it's translated to the NFL.
And the thing in the return game that we saw that week, how naturally was catching it,
how quick he was, that is played out in the NFL as well.
With that as a backdrop,
You've got Royals first.
I'm going to go with Ah Manor as number two.
I think he's going to have a big week.
You got to remember, this is a guy who's not had a quarterback,
has not had protection in the offensive line for his quarterback,
which limits the amount of opportunities you're going to get down the field and all that stuff.
But what I've seen from this guy, 6-2-10,
he's not the fastest, but he's not slow.
Like he kind of sneaks up on you down the field,
tracks the ball extremely well, excellent hands,
sneaky vertical, as I said, contested catches, really solid route runner, physical.
And in that offense, with that quarterback situation this past year, it had 63 catches, 830 yards, 13 yards per catch, 6 touchdown.
So I want to see him here, again, equal platform, equal opportunity, a chance with the same quarterbacks throwing to all these receivers to just showcase what he can do.
I don't hate it.
This catch against Syracuse was unbelievable.
one-ended catch.
I will say that I had him number five,
which I think is interesting.
Of the guys.
I've ranked them when I went through.
I like him.
Where are you taking three?
I am going with the guy you didn't even mention,
Illinois wide receiver, Pat Bryant.
I haven't done his tape yet.
I'm just going to be honest.
Yeah, that's fine.
He is, you can't, listen,
we should all be honest about that.
There are so many players we got into,
and that's why I'm panicking if you caught the opening.
You know, you want to make sure you got enough tape on everyone.
He's the only player.
I got this off his website, so I hope it's true,
but it's the only player off the Illinois website.
Only player in the nation with three game-winning touchdowns
in the final two minutes or overtime this year,
which I think is interesting.
Kind of gives you an idea that he shows up in big moments.
Yeah.
Average 18.2 yards per catch this year.
I love the track and adjust.
He is, for a guy who's six-foot-three,
his ability to contort his body,
to make back-shoulder catches,
to adjust to that deep ball,
take the top off the cover.
I think that's really his his superpower, if you're going to talk about what these guys are elite at in terms of their, what jumps out in terms of their skill set. That's what it is for Pap Ryan for me.
I think maybe people are sleeping on him. I think he could have a big week and be the guy that comes out of there of like, I liked Pap Ryan, but I didn't realize he was that good.
Number four is a struggle for me. I can't un-I can't unthink the conversation I had with a scout about a smaller receivers scare me and then start to think about all this.
smaller receivers, right?
Mm-hmm.
And Tess Johnson, like, he is a stick of dynamite, but what happens when you press
them?
What happens when physical DBSs?
Durability has been, you know, he's been in and out of games.
Toughness, though, we saw in the college football playoff against Ohio State.
Everyone was getting knocked out of that game.
He got knocked out and came back in.
But I worry about that with Tess, and I want to watch him this week, you know, getting
off the line.
He's so quick and all those things.
So I'm going to go in a different direction.
I'm going to go with Jalen Noel.
Interesting.
But I fully recognize that Higgins is kind of considered Jaden Higgins,
the other receiver, 6-4-215, is considered the better prospect.
Only two drops all season, excellent hands, polished.
But I'm, I guess more so than anything,
I'm just intrigued to see Jalen Noel with his speed and what he can do.
He's more out of the slot, but half as many of his snaps came out wide.
He can move him around the field.
He had 1194 this year, average 15 yards per catch, 80 catches, eight touchdowns.
One out of every 10 catches was a touchdown.
He runs deeper routes and gets open vertical.
That's what I see.
That translates to the NFL, 12, 15, 17-yard routes.
he runs those and runs them well.
So I want to see him this week.
And I fully recognize that he wouldn't be on most boards,
the fourth receiver of this group.
But I think he's got a chance to elevate himself this week.
I love him.
I had him up there, too.
I mean, he's built like a running back,
and he kind of plays like a running back in terms of his.
He's listed at 5-11-200.
And his toughness over the middle,
the way he returns, Ponce,
how he is after the catch.
And he can separate.
He's got a lot of juice, man.
I'm interested to see how he runs because I don't watch his tape.
I'm like, he's explosive.
So I like him.
I did go with Higgins.
I had Higgins ranked higher than him, so I'll take Higgins here because he's the bigger body guy.
And that's what scared me off of Tess, too.
You know how much I love Tess.
I think he's so good and so explosive, but that smaller receiver and how it translates.
I think he's listed at 165.
It's going to be a big way in for him.
Let's see what he comes in at.
Put some nickels in his pockets.
Right.
So Higgins for the same reasons you talked about.
Smooth, catches the ball well.
He could take the top off the coverage.
You really like that Nichols in the pockets comments.
I just like how the reason I'm smiling is I like how we're so,
we're so used to each other's shit, you just ignored it.
You just totally ignored it.
Like, yeah, whatever.
So many tricks.
Running back.
It's loaded running back.
Let's move on.
Loaded running back group.
Let's keep it rolling.
Man, there is you talk about clusters.
it's a cluster bleep and running back.
Like there's so many dudes, right?
Let me just rip off some of the top names.
I'm not going to go through all of them,
but there's a lot of guys that are in that day two range, right?
And I'm not going by how the rankings are.
I'm going by how they're listed in this roster I'm looking at.
And a couple of guys that I've already featured is that's my guy.
Breschard Smith is one of them from SMU,
undersized former receiver.
Jarkwez Hunter's another, that's my guy.
Auburn. Then Trevor E.T.N. from Georgia. Devin Neal from Kansas. R.J. Harvey, UCF. That's all on one roster.
The other roster. Ollie Gordon, the second coming into the year was considered by a lot of people,
RB2 or RB3. Okay. Then Kelle Mullings, Monster Year for Michigan,
former linebacker. Damien Martinez, huge year at Miami. A lot of scouts are really high on him
and hoping that we don't kind of blow up that spot. So with that is the backdrop.
I'll give you the number one overall pick here for the Senior Bowl running backs.
Where would you go?
RJ Harvey from UCF.
I had not watched a lot of his tape before this.
Man, he is fun to watch.
Yes, yes, he is.
He had 131.4 rushing yards for game this year, 20, 22 touchdowns, production's all there.
20 catches, which is good enough for me.
I feel like he catches the ball fairly well.
But first thing that jumped out to me, I was like, patient with great feet and burst.
I mean, he is an instinctive runner.
He can get in and out of gaps.
he can make guys miss in tight spaces,
and then when he turns it on, he turns it on.
But what I, and I think that's probably his best trait,
but what I love about him is he's 5'9, 208 pounds,
and he runs angry.
He's got that compact build where he's stronger than he is big.
He's not that big 220 guy,
but he runs angry.
And the way he finishes runs,
I mean, he can just run over guys when he gets into space.
I was super impressed with what I saw on tape.
Yeah, I don't disagree.
He would have been my number one too.
But again, there's not a big gap here, man.
Just a reminder, too.
We're talking all the Senior Bowl stuff right now.
We're going to be there all week long, taping some interviews on Monday.
We've got the way-ins, get prepared, Tuesday practices, Wednesday practices,
Thursday practices.
As those wrap up, we'll go back to the convention center.
I've never had a radio row spot there before.
Kind of awkward sitting there doing a show with all these people walking by and bap-p-p-p-pah.
But I've done way more awkward before.
And I just told you the Tim Tebow situation,
is the peak of awkward.
So I think we can handle it.
But please join us.
Like if we're going to cover this top to bottom and not only just the senior
bowl prospects,
but also like how it how it plays into the bigger picture of what's going on.
So we'll have shows Tuesday,
Wednesday and Thursday next week.
Okay.
And so just,
you know,
keep checking in.
And also we've got a whole crew coming down.
Like the ringer's behind us, man.
Truly.
Like we've got,
we've got producers coming now.
We've got camera people and production group.
We've got people helping up the interviews.
We've got folks helping with the social media with our presence there.
We're going to be on YouTube from what I understand that TikTok is still in existence for now.
So let's rock and roll with it.
Our TikTok handle is The McShay show.
So go find us on TikTok.
Also, what is it, McShay 13, my Instagram.
Your Twitter is the longest Twitter handle of all time.
At Scouts Inc. Mench, it's M-U-E-N-C-H.
I'm at McShay-13.
So we're going to have all sorts of unique fun content throughout the week.
Behind the scenes, stupid stuff, I'm sure.
Mench eating food and spilling it in the passenger seat of my rental car, all that fun stuff.
All right.
So number two, you got R.J. Harvey at Running Back.
I'm going to go Damien Martinez.
Oh.
Come on, man.
Nope.
My guy.
Go ahead.
Oh, okay, good.
I thought you were going to.
No.
Again, there's not a lot of separation here.
I can't wait to see him.
I want to see catching the football.
He runs hard.
He hits the whole hard.
He makes, yes.
I love the fact he played in the bowl game as a running back and wanted to get.
I think he got over 1,000 yards, whatever it was, but like just wanted it.
So I just, I love dudes like that.
Everyone I've talked to in the league, it's kind of like, shh.
You know, don't bring him up.
I think a good value.
So I'm going to go with Damien Martinez, too.
Who do you get a three?
Trevor Etienne.
I know he didn't have a big year.
I mean, he ended up being the second leading rusher.
He's banged up, you know, the Florida transfer.
And I just, the talent.
When I see him on tape, I just like the talent.
I think he's smooth when he gets downhill.
He's one of those guys that, and I love this about backs,
he doesn't have to waste a lot of motion to make people miss or to get into a different.
He's almost always moving forward when he's changing positions.
And I love that about him.
He's got a really good feel for cut back.
lanes, not as productive as some of these guys, not as big as some of these guys.
I just want to watch the tape.
I like the talent.
My Instagram is T. McShay 13, by the way.
So that's how good I am with this stuff.
I don't disagree.
I like that pick there.
But again, I don't see much separation from him.
And I go down.
This one's hard.
The number four back.
We'll go six deep on running backs.
There's just too many guys.
This one's hard for me, Mench, because I really want to.
to take. I'm going to go
Kelle Mullins.
Really?
I'm going to, yeah.
Because I want to see
him catching the ball in the passing
game a little bit more, okay?
I think he has an opportunity to help
continue to rise up boards.
He obviously had a huge year,
former linebacker, physical, tough guy.
The fact that he's that productive and savvy
as a running back, you know, limited
experience speaks a lot
to him. So I think
Mullings can have a big week,
but there's some other guys right behind them.
Go ahead.
Interesting.
I'm going to go with Olly Gordon.
That's like God bless your heart.
No, listen, I love them.
I just think that there's other guys I like a little bit more.
Go ahead.
And he's great.
He's a monster games.
Oklahoma State running back,
Holly Gordon the second.
I know it was a down year,
but this dude,
let's just remember.
You know,
and this is,
I love to talk about GM scouts about this too,
where they'll say,
hey, man,
I know he didn't have a great year.
You remember what he did in 2023 when things were right.
And Ollie Gordon, he ran for 1,732 yards two years ago.
He had 39 catches that same year.
I love the way.
The Derek Stingley effect?
Yes.
Great example, right?
Right.
I love the way he catches the ball.
I love big backs.
He's 225 pounds.
We'll see what he weighs in at.
But this is that 225.
Looks every bit of it on tape.
Runs hard.
He can pick up yards after contact.
I think he's got good feet for his size.
Again, the production in the passing game.
And like you mentioned, this guy was in the RB2 mix coming into the year.
And I'm not sure.
I mean, I don't think he's in that mix anymore.
Don't get me wrong.
He's dropped.
There's no question.
But how far?
At what point do we start to reevaluate and say we may be pushing him too far down the board based on a down year?
I think he's a guy that could have a big week.
I'm going to surprise you a little bit here and maybe even myself.
I'm going to go Devin Neal next up.
I love Breschard Smith, and I really, really, really liked Jarquez Hunter.
Yep.
But there's something about Neil's run style.
I started watching tape, like, I don't know, four or five weeks ago on some of these running backs.
And Neil was one of them.
And just watching his cutting ability, his instincts, his patience, there's something to his game that translates to the NFL.
And I'm excited to see him in.
The Colorado game was phenomenal.
I actually went back and watched.
that tape after to watch him and then a couple of guys on the defensive side for Colorado.
Yeah.
So I'm going to go kneel there.
That's a great group.
Yeah, that's six guys.
And yeah, go ahead.
No, I was going to say, I like Hunter.
You don't.
That's six, but who are you taking next?
I think Hunter's in the mix, too, over Brashad Smith, who I love too.
But for me, Hunter, the contact balanced, hurtling defenders, running through
tacklers, bouncing off tacklers.
And he's one of those guys that I'm interested to see.
I wouldn't be surprised if he had an average 10-yard split
and then ran well top speed because he just accelerates.
The way he accelerates is smooth and he's building speed.
He was in the mix to be in my top group.
And then you throw you throw Breschart Smith into that, right?
Right.
We're talking like seven or eight guys and like the...
It's just a deep group.
Probably third, fourth round range in a deep group that may have been earlier
in other years. Okay. Last one, I want to wrap up on this. Defensive linemen.
My goodness, is this class loaded?
Yep.
What are these guys? I think they're going to play, too. That's what I love about defensive
linemen, especially, I'm just going to say it. Dudes on the defensive front that play
in USC was also this way in years past when they had those awesome defensive lines and
linebackers. I remember like Cushing, Mauluga, like those dudes,
showed up and it was like, yeah, they're going to play like Monday or Tuesday practice and be,
you know, they get like a mysterious ankle or like a hammy, got tight. And they would be there
all week grinding. And there's something about it's not just SEC, but like south, like down
south defensive linemen, like the defensive front seven guys, they just love to compete. And I
freaking love that about them. And I'm sure everyone's going to yell at me. You love the SEC.
It's not that, man. I look at this.
list and I started questioning like are they really going to show up are they really going to play like
is is is Mike green I think will because it's great opportunity from marshal and he's got to showcase
that but I look at like nick scorton from texas a and m Walter nolan olmiss um shimar stuart a and m
Kyle canard jared jared ivy just the way these dudes are wired I think we're going to have an
absolute dogfight like war on our hands
throughout the whole week.
And if you're an offensive lineman for these two teams,
like an Emery Jones from LSU,
Jared Wilson from Georgia,
you know,
some like Membo from Missouri,
like it's my boy Josh Connerly,
you know,
from Oregon.
Buckle up that trinkled up that.
Ariade, Urshare,
your boy from Minnesota,
like, get ready.
Get ready.
It's going to be like street fights out there.
All right.
That is the backdrop.
Who are you taking first?
Samar Stewart from Texas,
and him.
Yeah, he's just, six, six, two 90 is an edge.
And you worry about those guys just being,
oh, he's high caught and he's going to be able to get under pads.
And is he quick?
He's so explosive.
Like, my first notes were explosive power,
explosive power, explosive power,
just runs through offensive tackles.
He's one of those guys that can just knock an offensive tackle
on his ass on his way to the quarterback,
sets the edge against.
the run. You know he played
521 snaps this past season.
371 were outside
the tackle at that size.
Right. So it shows
that, but I was just, it shows
that, but it also, like, I
truly believe the versatility that he can bring is a
three technique, a five technique,
a seven, you know, like,
that versatility is, is awfully
intriguing, you know? Yeah, I, I think he's
a defensive end and a four man.
like a base four man front or a four man heavy front but he can play anywhere i he's he's awesome i'm gonna
go mike green your boy oh i mean you jumped me well i gave you the first pick um you had an opportunity
you could have taken him but he's interesting man six four 2448 pounds he's it he's an outside
linebacker in a three four base all day long for for me and i know that
know, like, it's not even about, like, position fits and schemes and all that.
Fine, play him, fine, play him as a, is a four-three, you know, right, defensive end.
But 700 of, he played 719 snaps last year, which, like, an absolute dog.
How many snaps that is?
It's 719.
Nearly 700 of those were outside the tackle, too.
He's, he's like a wide nine, seven, like, he'd get them outside, let him.
250, maybe.
Well, I watch him, man, like,
you've got to have counter moves you got to do you've got to like he's going to have to continue
to get stronger and all that but the short area power he has in his hands combined with that
first step quickness and the short area twitch and what do i mean by that like you rushing the passer
is we've talked about it it's like being a burglar trying to sneak through a tiny crack and like
always being on the move so that no one can ever quite get their hands on you right his about
with that short area of quickness and the snap in his hands,
it's tackles have a damn hard time actually like getting him and locking him now, right?
And he's slippery, but it's also like with every movement, the outside end moves,
the, you know, the punching inside and then working out back,
the club to rip, all those things that he does.
He's just, and his body control.
And people always like, body control I get with a receiver and adjust.
Body control with a defensive, with an edge rusher.
is about the ability when you are engaged in rushing half a man,
because you're trying to work that outside tackle or sometimes,
I mean, outside shoulder or inside shoulder of an offensive tackle as an edge rusher.
And you want to do that because, again, the kryptonite is a tackle being able to square up,
as you know, as an offensive lineman by trade, an offensive lineman where he can get his base
underneath them, square up, and then control.
Because let's face it, I'm bigger than you, dude.
meet me in what we used to call a phone booth,
meet me in a tight alley,
and I'm going to win this thing.
But my job as a 248-pound pass rusher
is to never give you my full body, right?
Right.
So it's working the one half of the offensive tackle,
working the outside shoulder, the inside shoulder,
and then being able to redirect,
and then when you do kind of get stuck,
because there's always that moment of truth as a pass rusher,
and the NFL, at least.
Sometimes in college you see them run around,
run the circle around.
run the loop.
But in the NFL, there's always that moment of truth where I'm kind of right here,
and it's whether it's given up leverage with your shoulder, whether it's a quick swipe,
whether it's a rip or, you know, like there's that moment of truth where you are engaged
with half a man and you're trying to bend that edge.
The great ones have the body control and the ability to continue their legs moving and
driving around like they're like a race car turning an edge right and i see some of that in mike
green and that's why i'm excited to watch him down here i'll say this i love me's bendy explosive
but how do you how do you pass by old miss defensive tackle walter nolan i get into you go ahead
thanks man when i watched the thing that jumped out to me when i watched his tape was he is a game
record when you try to block him with one man and sometimes two men just ain't enough he he's
He's one of those guys that's quick enough to split double teams,
and he's strong enough to fight off of them.
I look at that that defensive line was obviously loaded this year,
and he was the best player on it.
Again, I mean, I don't know what else to say.
The guy can absolutely take over a game and be a game record when he's right.
My notes are so disruptive.
Excellent production for inside defensive linemen.
Excellent.
He's 14-5 tackles for loss or something like that?
Yep.
You're six and a half sacks.
14 tackles for loss.
48 total tackles.
I think he's a really disruptive pass rusher.
I think he will continue to improve.
Classic three technique for me in between the guard and the,
the guard and the tackle, work that get penetrate, get up the,
get up field, disrupt.
Really disruptive pass rusher, but an excellent run defender.
Yeah.
I think just because he's so disruptive.
And speaking of excellent run defenders,
my fourth pick of this group would be Nick Scorton, A&M.
Still developing.
I get it. He's still developing.
But he is a power-based player, and that translates to the NFL.
37 tackles, 14 tackles for loss.
Only five sacks this year. I get it. He still got work to do.
But he had 10 sacks the previous year at Purdue.
Yeah. People forget he was a Purdue transfer.
Had 10 sacks a year before.
And he dropped a fair amount of Purdue, too.
Yeah. So I'm just intrigued to see.
I mean, all four of those guys with good weeks,
at the senior bowl will lock down spots in the first round. You know, it's, it's opportunity.
It's, it's an opportunity for those four guys. And we didn't even get to the 12 guys that are,
that are day two prospects. So right. Yeah. I'm fired up, man. You know what I'm also fired up
about? And you know it like more so than probably any here we go that we do. Yep.
You know, you know, we're going to dinner, right? And we're going to multiple places.
There are multiple places.
We will document it all.
So don't fear if you're not, if you're not noble South, like, we'll, and,
and you can sling it.
And you get good, like real southern good food.
And there's a bunch of places now.
Wasn't always a case.
Mobile used to be like, Carrabas.
Carrabahs on our airport Boulevard.
I'm not joking.
Carrabahs in the airport.
Canara for lunch.
Carrabahs at, uh, and by the way, that the one in Mobile might be the best carrabas in the country.
we love you there but like not a chain we right all of a sudden with it i don't know last like seven
eight years like the the the food got better the restaurant game up you know the south in general
i have an obsession with this is the south in general has found its sweet spot in the last like
ten years do you remember southern flare go ahead sorry do you remember the italian place with
the chalkboard menu we got to find that place again
had all the wines out front and then the chalkboard menu always a green flag man a chalkboard
menu is a I think that was over the bridge though it might have been I think it was that's when
we were staying over with the ravens at um one of the rest of the hotels right over the bridge
like not quite like daphne area fair before fair hope um but yeah we'll we will we'll we're there
Sunday night, Monday night, Tuesday night, Wednesday night.
I fly back Thursday.
Friday.
Thursday night morning.
Friday.
So you get an extra, you're always dangerous that Mench night when you build it in.
Don't you dare.
Don't you dare pretend like you don't know what I'm talking about.
I have no idea what you're talking about.
Mench, Mench has always because of it's midnight and then have to get up to New Hampshire.
Yeah.
No, I know.
That's part of it.
It's part of it.
But Munch likes to build in that last like McShay's out of town.
Oh, I can breathe.
McShay's going.
on. And then you always wind up, and you don't get into trouble, but like, you always find some stuff going on on that final night.
So, so that's four, four or five nights, depending on which one you're talking about to find excellent cuisine.
But Noble South is our spot. I love that place. No, I mean, we are going to, we are going to, I got a reservation.
Marissa brought us a reservation to contact the people there. They're excited to have us down. We've already given some love. We're going to have, we got a reservation. I think seven of us.
us everyone coming down in this group we're gonna we're gonna all go um i won't mention the night because
i'll just keep it keep it that way that all the mensch groupies are going to wind up showing up here we
go um but i like that menu it's that noble what do you do you remember any like what do you
want specifically i don't even have it's so funny because i don't get i usually don't get these
things but the what's it the foie gras yes that's a thing that like first of all i love deviled
eggs they do deviled eggs i will their devil dags it's so like people like oh devil dags no no devil
eggs uh i want to try their pork belly which i have not tried before but looks amazing and then all
the supper stuff is always so good and i've done shrimp and grits uh i've done all kinds of different
things there but i always end up getting their wagu steak which is always cooked perfectly
loved sides everything red snapper's good too man i know we're to lose in a half of our audience right now
we've never had anything bad i don't think
The shrimp and grits.
Oh.
Yeah, the patte.
Like, you were the first one to put me on to that.
I was like, what is this?
It is so good.
What I love about it, it's like, it's a lot of the fine cuisine you get in all over the country, you know, really high-end places.
But like, there's always that like little southern flaring, like the cavitelli pasta, right?
If I get that in Boston, I'm getting cabotelli pasta.
Right.
And maybe like, you know, there's a cavitelli with lobster or something.
But they have the jumbo lump crab with preserved lemon, gala, I,
apple like i want to try i don't remember the pepper jelly do you remember that i don't remember
that's a blue cheese moose on toast oh no no we did get that that was awesome did we yeah we got that
one time the foie gras it's it's the chicken liver moose it comes in like a little jar right or something
yeah something uh all right so we're going to be there um we're fired up we appreciate everyone
listen just another reminder first of all thank you for everyone joining us being a part of this thing
little engine they could.
We're just building this thing.
It's like I feel like it's like I said the other night.
Like batter up.
Here we go.
We're ready.
This is our time.
The draft is here.
Starts with the senior bowl as Nagy will tell you on every tweet.
Starts in Mobile.
And it does.
And the process kind of kicks off right now.
And we're going to be there.
Shows on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday.
We will deep dive into all of this.
We will talk big picture draft.
We'll have some pertinent interviews when it makes sense.
with guys that have stuff to share.
We'll chop them up and edit them when we can
and make them get you the best stuff that we're getting.
And we'll also have a lot of conversations
about the conversations we're having with people in the league.
So just a lot of information coming out that week
and you got to be a part of it.
Like if you're into the draft and you want to know the teams drafting at the top
or you just love the draft like we do,
you've got to be a part of this week.
And we're going to need feedback.
We're going to need interaction.
We're going to make this special.
It's going to be the most special tripmensch we've ever had to Mobile.
promise you that it's going to be awesome and make sure you're following us mench is at at um scouts inc mench
right yep at scouts inc mench on twitter i'm mickshay 13 um our our t t t t t t t t t t
stupid stuff. I'm going to get mensed dancing. Follow us on the McShay show and TikTok,
YouTube channel, Instagram. I just found out I'm T. McShay 13. So follow along. Be a part of it.
We appreciate you being a part of it. Like, subscribe, do all the things that we need,
that we truly need in order to continue to grow this the way we want to grow it. So we will be
back on Tuesday. Have an awesome weekend, everyone. Get ready because we're taking off running on
on Tuesday with Mobile and the Senior Bowl.
But until then, we appreciate you.
Talk to you soon.
Must be 21 plus and present in select states for Kansas in affiliation with Kansas Star Casino
or 18 plus and present in D.C.
Gambling problem?
Call 1-800 gambler or visit RG-Help.com.
Call 1-888-78-7-777-7-7 or visit ccpg.org slash chat in Connecticut.
or visit MD gambling help.org in Maryland.
Hope is here.
Visit gambling helplinema.m.m.a.org or call 1-800-327-50-50 for 24-7 support in Massachusetts.
Or call 1877-8-Hope NY or text Hope NY in New York.
