The Megyn Kelly Show - Emotional Camp Mystic Hearing, Nuns Sue NY Over LGBTQ Mandate, DOJ Probes NFL Deals: AM Update 4/16

Episode Date: April 16, 2026

A Texas judge orders Camp Mystic’s flood-ravaged property preserved as emotional testimony raises new questions about the camp’s response to the disaster. Catholic nuns sue New York, arguing a new LGBTQ mandate forces them to violate their faith or face fines, shutdown, and possible jail time - their attorney L Martin Nussbaum weigh in. The DOJ probes the NFL’s media deals as critics warn fans are being priced out by a growing web of streaming paywalls. Australian police open an investigation into Katy Perry after actress Ruby Rose accuses the pop star of a 2010 sexual assault.     SimpliSafe: Visit https://simplisafe.com/MEGYN to claim 50% off any new system!   PureTalk: Save on wireless with PureTalk visit https://PureTalk.com/MEGYNKELLY Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Good morning, everyone. I'm Emily Dershinsky, host of After Party and the Megyn Kelly wrap-up show on SiriusXM Channel 111. It's Thursday, April 16th, 2026, and this is your AM update. You failed her. Did you not list her Eastland? I wish we had more information. An emotional hearing in Texas over Camp Mystic, the site of last year's deadly flood, leaving 27 campers and counselors dead. The sanctions for violating this law create an existence. threat to the sisters and their apostolism. A group of Catholic nuns taking on the state of New York or an LGBTQ law that would force them to adopt patients' pronouns, undergo sensitivity training, and more at their palliative care center, or face possible jail time.

The DOJ investigates the NFL as more games move behind paywalls, forcing customers to pay even higher prices. And Australian police investigating pop star games. Katie Perry over allegations that she sexually assaulted actress Ruby Rose. All that and more coming up in just a moment on your AM update. Traditional home security companies can make the whole process a headache. They can make it expensive. There's monthly fees and long contracts to lock you in for years. It's like, oh my, what am I like getting a mortgage or just a security system? And a lot of these systems require a technician to come, install everything. It can get overly complicated and daunting and you don't

want it. But let me tell you about a different kind of company. It's called Simply Safe. They make protecting your home straightforward, and the system is designed to cover everything that matters. What stands out about Simply Safe is that it's not just one device. It's a complete security system. And it's all backed by SimplySafe's 24-7 professional monitoring agents who are ready to respond and dispatch emergency help if something happens.

Over 5 million people trust Simply Safe every day. U.S. News and World Report ranks them the best home security system of 2026. How about that? Number one, consider experiencing peace of mind with SimplySafe. And this exclusive discount, right now, you can get 50% off your new system. 50% off the new system just by visiting simplysafe.com slash Megan. That's half off at S-I-M-P-L-I-Safe.com slash Megan. There is no safe like Simply Safe. Check it out. An emotional hearing wrapping up in Austin, Texas, centering on the future of Camp

Mystic, a private Christian girl's summer camp in the Texas Hill country, after a catastrophic flood killed 27 campers and counselors, plus a co-owner there last summer. The three-day evidentiary hearing stemming from a wrongful death lawsuit filed by the family of eight-year-old Cecilia Seale Stewart, the only camper whose body has not been recovered. Seale's family asking a judge to block the camp from rebuilding or reopening, arguing that key things, arguing that key physical evidence, including cabins, floodwater markings, and communication systems must be preserved as the case moves forward. Camp Mystic is planning to reopen in less than two months at a separate higher elevation campground, with more than 800 girls set to attend. The hearing focusing

on what happened in the early morning hours of July 4, 2025, when intense overnight rainfall caused the Guadalupe River to rise rapidly, sending floodwaters through the camp. testimony this week laying out the camp's emergency response or lack thereof. Camp director Edward Eastland, son of co-owner Richard Dick Eastland, disputing claims the camp lacked an evacuation plan required under state law, but telling the court he was unable to locate or produce that plan. Eastland testifying he and other staff were signed up for emergency alert systems, but did not see warnings issued by the National Weather Service and Texas emergency officials. Eastland also testifying that staff members did not use loudspeakers to tell campers to

evacuate their cabins to higher ground. The call to evacuate not coming until about 3 a.m. Well after the flooding had begun. On Tuesday, Eastland questioned about what more he could have done to save the campers. You failed her. Did you not, Mr. Eastland? I wish we had more information. All the information was there for your entire family to see and utilize if y'all had just stayed awake and looked. Did you want a trooper to come knock on your door and tell you to do your job? No, sir. What should the state have done?

Should they have showed up and said, wake up, go save these kids? I think it should have been a more urgent alert. Yesterday afternoon, Judge Maya Garra Gamble, issuing a new order keeping the property available to law enforcement for investigation, blocking the flood-damaged sites use as a camp, and ordering the structures remain unaltered, per the local Fox affiliate. Camp Mystic currently facing five separate lawsuits, the first one tentatively set to begin May 27. A group of Catholic nuns who run a palliative care home in Hawthor, New York, dedicated to caring for poor cancer patients in their final days free of charge, now suing the state of New York

over its LGBTQ long-term care facility residence Bill of Rights. The Dominican Sisters of Hawthorne operating Rosary Hill home for more than a century, a 42-bed facility where they say they provide care to all patients without discrimination, and regardless of race, religion, sex, or background. The law, signed by Democratic Governor Kathy Hochle in 2023, and taking effect in 2024, prohibits long-term care facilities from discriminating based on sexual orientation, gender identity, or expression, or HIV status.

The sisters say that the mandate requires them to assign rooms based on gender identity rather than biological sex, allow access to bathrooms based on gender identity, use patients' preferred pronouns, and require staff to undergo training aligned with the state's standards. The law also protects what it describes as a residence right to associate with others, including, quote, consensual expressions of intimacy or sexual relations, unless restrictions are applied equally to all residents. Failure to comply could result in fines, loss of licensing, and even jail time. Earlier this month, the Dominican Sisters filing a federal lawsuit, arguing the law violates their First Amendment rights to religious freedom and free speech.

as well as equal protection under the 14th Amendment. The state declining to comment on the pending litigation, but releasing a statement indicating it is, quote, committed to filing state law, which provides nursing home residents certain rights protecting against discrimination, including, but not limited to, gender identity or expression. We spoke with Attorney L. Martin Nussbaum, who is representing the sisters. He tells us the sisters first sought an exemption before filing

suit? We wrote a five-page letter to the New York Department of Health. We explained who the sisters were, what their Catholic values were. We explained what the New York mandates required them to do, that that was squarely contrary to their Catholic values. We pointed out to them that they've given a religious exemption already to the Christian scientists and requested it as required by the federal constitution, both the free speech clause and the free exercise clause. And we heard nothing, no response. We gave that, we asked him to respond in 15 days. We gave them three weeks before we filed and then we proceeded with filing the lawsuit. And we've not heard a peep from them since. Nasbaum says the state's decision to grant an exemption to

Christian scientists, while denying one to the sisters, only strengthens their case. We have nothing against the Christian Science Church of Christ's scientists, but for the to give an exemption to that group means, one, they recognize that there's serious moral issues around this mandate, and that they can accommodate those religious, conscientious objection by the Christian scientists. And the fact that they would not do that for similar Catholic groups, which have even more nursing homes and long-term care facilities, it's wrong and it's contrary to the Constitution of the United States.

describing the legal arguments underlying the sister's case. When the state discriminates in favor of Christian scientists and against Catholics, that would squarely violate the equal protection clause. This mandate also requires certain types of speech by the sisters. They have to train their employees, including their own nuns, in gender ideology. They have to use certain speech that's false regarding pronouns. They can't have a compelling interest to impose this mandate on the Catholics when they don't impose it on the Christian scientists. And most importantly, how the sisters do their ministry, they have a sacred calling to serve the indigent who are dying of cancer.

And that's ministry for them. It's the healing ministry of Christ. And the government can't get in the business of dictating how nuns engage in society. such a ministry. Nussbaum says the law presents catastrophic consequences for the sisters if they do not violate their sincerely held religious beliefs. The sanctions per violating this law create an existential threat to the sisters and their apostolate, which is called Rosary Hill Home. The government has the choice of imposing fines up to $5,000 per violation. They can revoke the licenses of the staff, including the nuns who work and people would lose their ability to make a living,

and they can revoke the license of the Rosary Hill home itself, which would stupidly shut down this ministry that's been doing this good work for 125 years. They could even send some of the leaders of the group to prison for up to one year. It's breathtaking. Coming up, the DOJ probing the NNFRABing. as its multi-billion-dollar media machine faces widespread scrutiny over rising costs to watch the games. And Katie Perry, under investigation in Australia, after actress Ruby Rose, claims she was sexually assaulted by the pop star.

You've been hearing me talk about Pure Talk a lot lately. Well, Pure Talk is veteran-led, so helping veterans is their North Star, first of all. They've donated over half a million dollars to America's warrior partnership, a fantastic organization that's on the front lines of preventing veteran suicide. And Pure Talks creating American jobs with a U.S. only workforce. Yes, it'd be a lot cheaper to send jobs overseas like other companies do, but they are committed to delivering the best experience possible for their customers. Pure Talk service? They give you the same towers, same network, same 5G coverage as one of the big guys,

but for a fraction of the price. Pure Talk supports veterans every single day and creates American jobs. If you want to give it a shot, dial pound 250 and say, Megan Kelly, to switch at Pure Talk. That's pound 250 and then just say Megan Kelly to switch to Peer Talk, America's Wireless Company, Pure Talk. Check it out. FCC chair Brendan Carr weighing in on a new DOJ investigation into the NFL over concerns the league's media deals may be driving up costs for fans in limiting competition. Here's Card Tuesday on CNBC. I think long term there's been a great partnership between broadcasters and sports league. It's helped them to grow their fan base.

And that experience has become frustrating for lots of Americans over the years. They feel like they're paying more out of pocket. They're having to sign up for different streaming services. There's been reports that DOJ is looking at this from an antitrust perspective. There is a sports broadcasting act, which gives NFL and others a unique antitrust exemption. There's a question of whether are they extending beyond the scope of that antitrust exemption? if they move too many games behind a paywall. The DOJ investigation first reported last week by the Wall Street Journal,

the exact scope of the probe currently unclear. The legal basis of the issue is the Sports Broadcasting Act of 1961, which allows the NFL to combine the TV rights from all 32 teams and negotiate as one seller, something most competing businesses are barred from doing under antitrust law. That law written in an era when fans could watch games for free on broadcast television. Today's media landscape looking much different

and its effect on NFL broadcasting, raising concern among consumers, regulators, and some lawmakers. The NFL now offering exclusive game packages to streaming giants like Amazon, Netflix, and Peacock, on top of its traditional broadcast deals. As a result, dedicated football fans now need multiple streaming subscriptions to watch all games,

running about $1,000 per season, according to Republican Senator Mike Lee of Utah, all while the media corporations stand to make a fortune. The agreements between the NFL and streamers, including Disney, Paramount, Fox Corporation, NBC Universal, NFL network, Amazon, Google, and Netflix, are expected to rake in more than $100 billion in sports rights fees under their current contracts, according to the New York Post. The NFL pushing back on criticism, calling its distribution model, quote, the most fan and broadcaster friendly in the entire sports and entertainment industry,

stating that over 87% of games air for free on broadcast, quote, including 100% of games in the markets of the competing teams. Legal scholar Jonathan Turley responding in a thread on X, quote, If you need any more proof of the NFL's contempt for its fans, it can be found in its antitrust statement. Roger Goodell and the NFL are about as popular as gum disease with fans. They fleece fans continually as they make record profits. Australian police now reportedly investigating pop star Katie Perry over sexual assault allegations

made by actress Ruby Rose. The Orange is the new black actress earlier this week posting on the social media platform threads, quote, spice market nightclub in Melbourne. Rose later elaborating on the alleged incident in a series of reply posts, quote, I was only in my early 20s, I'm now 40, it has taken almost two decades to say this publicly. Rose alleging that in 2010, at the now closed nightclub, Perry forced her private parts onto Rose's face without consent, causing Rose to vomit. A former manager of the club telling Rolling Stone both women who arrived and left the club together that night, quote,

way too much to drink, but he was not aware of any assault that night. The Melbourne sexual offenses and child abuse investigation team confirming Wednesday that an investigation into a historical incident is now underway, but declining further comment. Perry, denying the allegations through a spokesperson, quote, the allegations are not only categorically false, they are dangerous, reckless lies. Ms. Rose has a well-documented history of making serious public allegations on social media against various individuals, claims that have repeatedly been denied by those named. Rose has previously made a range of allegations on social media, including claims of rape by unnamed individuals and workplace misconduct tied to her time on the show Batwoman, all of which

have been denied. That'll do it for your AM update. I'm Emily Jashinsky, host of After Party. Catch the Megan Kelly Show live on Sirius XM's The Megan Kelly Channel 11 at noon east on YouTube.com Kelly and all podcast platforms.