The Michael Knowles Show - YES or NO | Real Answers and Real Drinks with FREEDOMTOONS

Episode Date: July 24, 2021

Seamus Coughlin of FREEDOMTOONS sits down with Michael Knowles to see how well they think they know each other. They must choose "Yes" or "No" when it comes to aliens, The Pope, and if all parties inv...olved in Porn should be arrested. Check it out! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:01 It's 10 o'clock in the morning. My friend Seamus Coglin from Freedom Tunes is here. He doesn't have a lot of time. Everybody's busy. So I said, I need Seamus to be able to play the game here at Daily Wire Studios. We're not changing the rules. He's going to have a big pint of Guinness. I'm going to have my standard martini.
Starting point is 00:00:31 Yeah, I hadn't anticipated throwing back at 10 in the morning. You know the benefit of that, though, is it gets the shakes to go away. Yeah, exactly. It's a nice way to open the eyes. up. Honestly, I was trying to hide my embarrassment here. This is any other Wednesday for me, brother. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:00:46 I'm glad that I can enter into you. Exactly. I'm like, I'm going to bring him to my turf and I'm going to beat him there. Now, you're familiar with the rules of the game. Yes. So, there's very simple. We're going to read the prompt. We'll go back and forth. And you have to answer how you think the other person. Yes. What answer?
Starting point is 00:01:02 Okay. Should we get started? Yeah, absolutely. Should we have a little toast just to kick it off at, you know. Pour some out for the hall. Five o'clock somewhere. Can I pour some out? Yeah, just right on this, especially since the PA. I'll be good at the PA.
Starting point is 00:01:17 I'll be good at the PA. I don't want to make the PA's life more difficult. I was actually going to pour it out for them. I was hoping they could laugh it up. Yeah, that's their pay. Soccer sucks. I'm assuming you have to use. So I'm going to give the kind of standard answer.
Starting point is 00:01:34 The only reason that I even hesitated is because you're a Catholic man. Yeah. The Catholics tend to favor poverty ball I've noticed around the world. I've heard this. Yes, but I'm glad, you know. I'm an American. You're an American. So we answered yes, so we drink. Is that correct? You drink if you get it wrong or right or kind of whatever. Okay, cool. Mm-hmm. Yeah, my kind of game. Wow. Okay, so now you read the prompt. All right. The Michael Knowles show is at best, the third best show at the Daily Wire. Oh, wow. You know, I'm actually...
Starting point is 00:02:08 So I'm answering yours, yes. I was going to... You know, I mean, because I have due humility. You're a humble human being. I'm a humble man. That's what I was thinking. As a Catholic, you brought my last answer to my faith. I'm bringing yours to your faith.
Starting point is 00:02:24 Now I think you're wrong. You think I got this wrong about you? No, no, you're correct. I'm right about... I think you have the best show at the daily wire. Oh, thank you. I appreciate it. This was a gimmee, though, because I was thinking, I was like, okay, third best. So now you're telling me...
Starting point is 00:02:38 that a devout Catholic named a practicing Catholic. I always prefer that term because I'm going to keep on practice until I get it right. Well, and also, what does devout mean? What does it mean? That's not a technical term. Practicing Catholic actually means something. It's not a subjective grounded in reality. Yes. There are requirements you have to fulfill. It's like there's no way you've got Claven. He's an Anglican. Exactly. Exactly. Thank you. You got Ben. I'm beginning to think he's not a Catholic. Yeah, I'm pretty sure. Okay. So then it's just, I'm competing against Walsh. But that still puts me in the top three. Yeah, exactly. I mean, only one of the other podcasters here submits
Starting point is 00:03:12 to Rome, so I've got to pick you. So I'm going to take a drink? Sure. Why not? Yeah. It's 10 in the morning. That's the game. Okay. Comic book fans have a deep understanding of culture. This is I'm answering for you?
Starting point is 00:03:30 Yeah. Do we do it at the same time? Comic book fans have a... You mean generally? I'm going to assume some of Generally, okay. As a whole. You were correct. Okay, that's how you feel.
Starting point is 00:03:49 To be honest, I haven't really given that question much thought, so I don't have an answer. But I thought no would be an unpopular response, so that's the one I gave you. Try to get you in trouble here. Because I guess comic book, I hate the comic book movies. I can't watch them. With the exception of, like, Logan, which is not a comic book movie, it's a Western. What about the Dark Night? Or The Dark Night is another one, right?
Starting point is 00:04:08 It's like not really a comic book movie. I hate the movies. guess in the pop culture, the comic book fans are much more culture than I am, because I don't know anything about it. But generally, there is more to life than like invincible people smashing buildings. There actually is more. Yes. You can. Here's the thing. Actually, my answer probably would be yes so that my friend Eric July wouldn't come in here and smack me. There you go. You were wrong, which means I have to drink. Yes. And I have to drink. And you have to drink. All right, there we go. Eat this game. It's horrible.
Starting point is 00:04:42 All right. This next one is mine. This is you. Okay. Cartoons are the lowest form of art. So you have to answer for me. I have to answer for you. And of course, I know what your answer is, Knowz.
Starting point is 00:04:56 I know. I'm trying to figure out your humility here. You know, you might, but I'm going to say no. Here's the thing, Nol's, humility is knowing your place and taking it. Not necessarily denigrating what you do. It's not a humiliation. Exactly. And it's obvious, look, I can't.
Starting point is 00:05:14 I don't put cartoons on a very high level in terms of the hierarchy of art, but based on some of the liturgical art that I have seen, like bad liturgical art, abstract modernist art that's trying to pass itself off as Catholic is probably the lowest form of art. You know, compared to, first of all, cartoons can be very, very beautifully artistic. I'm not saying that yours are. I'm just saying, you know, that they can be. Yes. Compared to other forms of art, let's say slam poetry, then the... Which is how we met. At the slam. Yeah, we were giving a slam poem on how we're spiritual but not religious. We both had the exact same topic. It was really great.
Starting point is 00:05:56 It's like, why don't people get that? Why don't people understand that I'm unique and quirky? Yeah, that's the thing. It's like, why don't they understand I'm really interested in me? Maybe not in God, but you know, in me. In me. I'm very fascinating. Yeah, my favorite response to that is you have to be more specific because the devil's
Starting point is 00:06:10 spirit, boom. Owned. Yeah, mic drop. I owned that person who isn't here, who was just sincere about their beliefs and then got dumped on it. Now I'm feeling bad. It's like how to own every freshman philosophy major with facts and logic. Oh, man, I'm almost starting to feel bad. We should be more.
Starting point is 00:06:27 We should be more kind. Charitable? Yeah, we should have a drink. Yeah, that'll help me. Given the mass movement of voters from blue states to red states, traditionally Republican voting states, will soon flip for Democrats. All at once?
Starting point is 00:06:44 Yeah. You are right. Yeah. I think they will soon flip to Democrats. Yeah. Was I right? I'm not exactly. So this is another one where I wouldn't say that I'm on the fence here entirely.
Starting point is 00:06:57 I lean towards yes, but I have some hope that there could be a significant backlash. So you're saying, okay, yeah, okay, that's fair enough. Because here's my, I don't think that the people, People moving to Tennessee with the Daily Wire are going to flip this state. No? Blue. No. I mean, they're all conservative, mostly conservatives.
Starting point is 00:07:18 I would hope so. You would hope so. You know, some were ecumenal. Yeah, we're very open. We're just, if anyone's watching from the NLRB, we are not discriminating against people. I don't know. When I was in the waiting room, people were, like, walking up to me and whispering their left-wing opinions into my ear.
Starting point is 00:07:32 They were like, don't tell Noles. I poisoned Noles is drink. Exactly. I was like, sweet. I'll make sure we, I was like, I'll encourage him to drink regardless of what the answer is. It takes that in. here you are. You've walked right into my trap. But do you see the problem here is even if all the conservatives move to these states, frankly, daily wire is going to make Nashville more red than it was.
Starting point is 00:07:50 There's just the fact of urbanization. As cities grow, things get more dim. Yeah. That's just what happens. I've said this. This is sort of a line I've taken about progressivism. It's basically just a label that we've given to social decay. And unless our country embraces Christ and starts living the natural law, even without embracing Christ in its supernatural sense, then we're going to continue to fall apart. And so it seems, from my perspective, we'll keep going to the left, and a lot of these red states will flip blue. But part of the reason I was hesitant to give myself a specific answer is because I'm wary
Starting point is 00:08:22 of making predictions, because any prediction I would have made five years ago would have turned out to be completely wrong. It's been an insane couple of years. True. But, Seamus, hold on. Are you telling me that what people do in their totally private personal lives might have some effect on the public? Yes.
Starting point is 00:08:37 Hold on. I know it's going to blow your mind. It's insane. Are you saying we live in, like, a country and a society? I think that when you live with people, sometimes things that people do affect you. What? Yeah. Isn't that crazy? I'm going to have to think about it. Yeah, I know. I'm sorry. I hope I haven't shocked you too much. Is this mine? Is it my turn? Like degenerates who drink at 10 in the morning? Destroy everything in their private life. Oh, we have to. Yeah, we need a daily buyer. We need to make this video. This is horrible. libertarians are the best hope for bringing liberals to a less radical, more conservative political belief system. Well, let's answer this one. I was trying to think of the other side of the argument, but no, it's just, it's not. I was thinking of moving a T.S. just to embarrass you. Yeah, no, there's absolutely no way.
Starting point is 00:09:23 We have to be honest about what we believe. I don't like this idea that there's a more pragmatic approach, and you want to bring people to something close to the truth or closer to the truth, but not quite there, just have them stay because that's the best they can handle. again, I believe leftism is fundamentally just social decay embodied, but we have to have respect for individual human beings and say, if I'm going to engage with you in dialogue to try to persuade you of something, clearly I have faith in the idea that you can recognize the truth. So why would I only try to bring you halfway? That's stupid. And not just halfway. Also, halfway is the wrong way of looking. It's either true or it's not true. So why would I try to lead you to untruth to make you a little bit less terrible than you are right now? And in some ways,
Starting point is 00:10:03 by the way, the left has, I'm not saying they're more correct, they have better intuitions than some of the lalbertarian types. I hesitate even to call them libertarian. You know, this idea of just do whatever you want sexually and bomb the Middle East. I mean, I think that is kind of what it comes down to, you know, abortion or birth control or whatever. The fact is the left, I think, understands something like free speech better than the libertarians do. I think that can be the case. Part of my thing with libertarianism here is that it would be obviously significant improvement from my perspective if a lot of these left-wing people became libertarians. They wouldn't be as a power obsessed. They wouldn't be trying to silence us quite as often. And I know some libertarians who really
Starting point is 00:10:45 are crazy consistent and even though I don't agree with them anymore, I admire their consistency. And I think they have a good take on things every now and again. Just like the madman in the asylum who says he's Henry VIII. You say, I admire his consistency. Yeah. Well, no, but there are also some libertarians who I think do a fantastic job speaking about the disaster that the United States' foreign policy has been over the past several decades. Like, they're fantastic on that. And over the past several years, the Republican Party has adopted the worst parts of libertarianism in basically none of the good stuff. So they've adopted all of the social libertarianism, but they don't critique American foreign policy the way they should. They don't really care that much about
Starting point is 00:11:22 the Federal Reserve as a banking system or the fact that we're essentially a command economy and everything's been centralized. It's just, I'm fiscally conservative and so. socially liberal, which is this really melt-toast, not even quite libertarian position. Yeah, right. No, that's, it's actually why, I mean, I knock the libertarians a lot, but I'm not really knocking Ron Paul. Yes, exactly. I will also criticize Ron Paul for specific reasons, but that's actually not the phenomenon that we're really talking about here. Yeah, and it just doesn't, it doesn't work. I think that the left recognizes, the radical left even recognizes that there is such a thing as like an aim of society.
Starting point is 00:12:00 They recognize that individuals have something to do with one another when we are living in society. They recognize that not only is it legitimate to legislate morality, but you necessarily legislate morality. All laws do that. And they recognize that all speech regimes have limits and standards and taboos, and they're basically trying to pervert it to their own ends. I can talk to that guy. It's kind of like the ardent atheist. Right? I can kind of talk to the ardent atheist because he's thinking about religion.
Starting point is 00:12:32 Yes. Instead of the milk-toast guy who's just like, eh, whatever. Yeah, or the person who was raised religious. You know, I went to 12 years of Catholic school. Oh, yeah. I'm basically, yeah, I'm the Pope now because I went to 12 years of Catholic school. Yeah, so there are a lot of people who have stepped out of their faith or don't take it very seriously, but don't really identify as atheistic or non-religious,
Starting point is 00:12:50 and it's more difficult to have a conversation with them because they haven't staked out a position. So I agree with you on that. All right. in a world where I am single This is about you? This is about you So you're interpreting it to yourself Okay
Starting point is 00:13:03 I'm answering for you answering for me That's what's happening here? What's like, yeah, what's the name of the guy on first base Is what I want to know. Okay, yes, yeah, who? That's what I'm asking. Yeah, who's on first? Uh-huh, yes.
Starting point is 00:13:13 Let's put these back to the middle. I think you need a drink. I need a drink to understand this question. I'm very confused. So, okay, I'm going to make this statement and you're going to answer the way that you think that I would answer that statement for me,
Starting point is 00:13:26 and I will answer the way that I think you would answer that statement for you. In a world where I am single, if a female fan asked me out through a super chat or a mailbag question, I would consider the invitation. Would Knowles consider the invitation? Let me think about this. Hmm. Okay.
Starting point is 00:13:48 Of course. Yeah. And I'm not saying it's a prudent thing. Yeah. I'm not saying we would end up together. I'm just saying you're a guy. You're single. I am. Ladies, if you're watching, you want a super chat in.
Starting point is 00:14:06 You're there. It's just a descriptive statement. You would have to consider the intention. Yeah, of course. Of course. I guess when I was struggling to answer the question, I was more thinking, is Noel's a long distance guy? But then again, maybe the woman is in his town. Yeah, I know, I have been. I've done long distance.
Starting point is 00:14:22 I've done close distance. Now my wife and I were even considering moving into the same house. That's fantastic. Good for you. That would be a really big... You should probably talk about that with the spiritual director first. You should. A big step. It was like a huge step. All right. Here we go. Kamala Harris is worse than Joe Biden. Okay.
Starting point is 00:14:43 Kamala Harris is worse than Joe Biden. I'm actually going to need to think for a second about my own answer. Why not? First of all, did I get it right? Yeah, I think so. It's complicated, but yes. I, the reason I answered is the reason I would assume you would answer no to the question, which is basically that we have seen Joe Biden acting politically with a high degree of executive power. He was the vice president for years. And so we know what the failures of the Obama administration were. And we also know that Kamala Harris has a slimy character and has done some really awful things. But for every horrible thing she's done, Joe Biden has also done many horrible things. Plus, he pretty much came close to destroying America under the Obama administration. he's worse. And he's more effective. He's a more, you know, Kamala Harris. Would you say so? Yeah, because she's very unlikable. You don't like her laugh?
Starting point is 00:15:40 What? It doesn't, you don't hear that? You know, like, oh, Kamala. If she wants to win in her own right, she needs to ditch the cauldron and the broomstick, I think. I mean, it's really not attractive. She was one of, if not the first person out in the 2016 Democrat primaries. That's fair. They don't like it, right? Good point. But old Uncle Joe, who wakes up in the morning, licks his finger, puts it in the wind and says, which way is politics blowing today? Okay, I'll agree with that.
Starting point is 00:16:03 He is a snake, that guy. I mean, he, and it's even particularly insidious for a couple mackerel snapping papists, such as, you and eight. Because he's really so scandalous in the way that he's transforming people's understanding of Catholicism. Well, I've heard he's devout, though. He's devout.
Starting point is 00:16:21 Yeah, I've heard him described as about. Maybe not practicing, but devout. Well, it's funny because we were touching on this earlier. In order to be a practicing Catholic, there are a certain set of standards you actually have to meet. So you have to fulfill the six precepts of the church. You have to get full assent to Catholic teaching. You have to abide by the Ten Commandments
Starting point is 00:16:36 and attempt to repair your life when you violate one of them. Joe Biden very explicitly does not give full assent to Catholic teaching. And yet he's described as a practicing Catholic, and he's referred to as one by left-wing media as if they're not contradicting the facts because they actually think it's just a subjective label of identification. No, but shame. Yes. They went to 12 years of Catholic school.
Starting point is 00:16:59 They went to fucking Catholic school, exactly. They're basically the prefect for the congregation. Yeah, exactly. What am I thinking? Due to the current state of policing in America, abolishing the police is a discussion that should be had. I'm trying to think if there's like a trick to this question. Yeah. I know.
Starting point is 00:17:15 I know that you really want to abolish. Yeah, I do. Yeah. Yes, I guess it's a yes. Do you know why this is a confusing question? I know exactly. It's a confusing question for me as well. Part of the reason is because the police are sort of,
Starting point is 00:17:28 of equally enforcing the law, but then as it happens, conservatives are selectively prosecuted after the police arrest them. So they're not really helping the people who have been standing up for them. The police are, because of bad DAs, many of whom were installed by radical leftists. I know you're not allowed to call out people like George Soros. Who? It's a heinous. I don't know that name.
Starting point is 00:17:51 I've never heard that name. Where are you talking about? They are in many ways the enforcement wing of the liberal establishment. And so did we get it right? I mean, like, I would still, I still come down on the side of, the left is using Abolish the Police. Like, I think I would still say no in the sense that the left is infiltrating the police, just like they're infiltrating the intelligence community and the military with all these woke commercials. Exactly. We want to hollow it out from within, so we take over all the institutions.
Starting point is 00:18:20 Would you, did I get it right or no? And I'm not actually sure that they want to hollow out the police force. I just think they want to use the police force for their own goals because all they care about is power. have actual principles. So when you look at how militarized the police have come over the past several decades and the fact that the Department of Education and Department of Fish and Wildlife have SWAT teams. I don't think that anyone on the left would really in the long run walk any of those back if they could use it to advance their own agenda. Yeah, that's right. And so I'm not even entirely convinced that they wanted to fund the police. No, no. They want a robust police force made up of
Starting point is 00:18:52 people who agree with them or who are coward into going along with their intelligence. Absolutely. And are capable of doing social work, ideally. Yeah. Yeah, right. And social workers. Yeah, exactly. Social workers. Okay. I think we're both going to have to drink on that way. I think we are. I don't even know who was right and wrong, but we certainly have to drink. We both have to drink. I remember these rules. I watched the episode with Walsh. This is what happened. All right. I think you're up. Doodling a three-dimensional cube is more impressive than writing a blank book.
Starting point is 00:19:28 I'm answering for you, and you're answering for me. building a three-dimensional cube is more impressive than writing a blank book. You flatter yourself. No, no, you're actually correct. Thank you. Yes, you're correct. You're a man of discernment and taste. Of course.
Starting point is 00:19:45 Yeah, exactly. Well, and part of the reason I have sympathy for this. When I'm making cartoons, it's much easier to animate something short, but you don't get ideas for short cartoons quite as often. It's actually more difficult to write something really short. So it stands the reason that it's extremely difficult to write the shortest possible thing, which is nothing. No, in all honesty, it's a really funny idea to write this book where you say reasons to vote for Democrats. Stop it. Go on. And there's nothing in it. I know. So that's a funny idea that came to you. And that's not as straightforward or entertaining an idea is just drawing a
Starting point is 00:20:15 cube. So I actually think it requires more creative intelligence. Thank you very much. You're totally right on this, too, though. I mean, we all know brevity is the soul of wit. Yes. But... So then stop. This is just stop talking. But I want to explain... You know, I mean, look, you're a comedian. You're a comedian. Cartoonist, a cartoonist and a comedy writer. So you know that the funniest thing is to explain a joke. Yes, it's hilarious. There's nothing funny. Yeah, exactly. It's like an improv. I try to do it as often as I possibly can. When you improvise, you always want to say no, but. No, but. No, but. Maybe. And then explain why the thing the last guy said was funny.
Starting point is 00:20:47 Yes. Yes. It's really well. Now, I am. Okay. Okay, brother. Again, as to an Irishman. Is the, I don't even want to hear this in the town right now. This is, this is a microaggression. of macroaggression. A Guinness to an Irishman is the equivalent of a pumpkin spice latte to a white girl. Without question. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:21:11 Do you know what? I think that's kind of a degrading way of putting it. Do you know the only difference is a Guinness is less caloric? Yeah, that's awesome. Everyone thinks a Guinness is a very caloric drink. It's not. It's got the same calories as like a bud light. No, there is a difference. What's a difference? I don't drink my pumpkin spice latte is at 10 a.m.
Starting point is 00:21:27 Michael. All right. It's a very good point. All right, here we go. The host of the Michael Knowles show does a better impression of Dr. Fauci than Tim Poole. I'm answering for you. Yeah, I actually, I don't know that I've heard Tim's impression.
Starting point is 00:21:45 Are you kidding me? Did you not see my, I did a cartoon where Tim voices Fauci? Oh, really? Had you seen, so here's the thing. You said you haven't seen it, so maybe I'm going here, but had you see it, you'd absolutely be here. I'm sorry. No offense to your Fauci impression.
Starting point is 00:21:59 You think Tim does a better Fauci than me? Yeah, he does. The droplets, Andrew. The droplets are going to get all over your grandmother. When I do my Fauci, my Dr. Fauci, his sort of he goes up and down like this, you sheep. Yes. When I'm doing Dr. Fauci, I'm actually doing an impression of a Jewish woman that I know from Queens. Seriously, I am.
Starting point is 00:22:25 But it sounds to me, there's a similar kind of joke about it. What does Tim get that I don't get? Oh, man. Where do I begin? Yeah, I know. I mean, we could be here for hours. Well, when I was recording with him, I'll be honest. And part, maybe it's difficult for me to discern because I have never been in studio with you while you have recorded Dr. Fauci for a cartoon about Dr. Fauci.
Starting point is 00:22:50 But Tim knocked out of the park, man. And we have behind-the-scenes footage uploaded to my Patreon. If people want to support at patreon.com slash freedom tunes, a little plug. But he crushed it. And people listening had no idea it was Tim. They're like, oh, wow, Tim did that Dr. Fauci? He crushed it. He's actually really good in this acting.
Starting point is 00:23:06 I'm sorry, you know that, and I thought you knew that because I thought you watched my videos, but I'm not. You just invite me over for drinks at 10 in the morning and don't watch my cartoons. That's okay. I'm going to see Tim tonight, and I want to battle. Have a Fauci off. On a show. Yeah, it'll be. Everyone loses in that game, I think.
Starting point is 00:23:25 Okay, I'm up. I've seen Tim Poole without a Beanie. so we're answering for the other person. Has Null seen Tim Poole without a bean? I'm actually going to say, I mean, you're, you know, you're tighter with the guy than I am. But I still, he's pretty protective with the Beanie thing. He wears that beanie all the time. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:23:45 Was I right? We're pretty good friends. Oh, wow. Oh, my gosh. I've seen him without the beanie. Does he have, is there like a second head under there? What is? I cannot confirm or deny that there is a second head under Tim Poole's hat.
Starting point is 00:23:57 Well, maybe I'll try later on tonight. It's a gigantic exposed brain. It's just like that cartoon. It's just the meeting, you know? Okay. I'll take a drink because I got it wrong. Take a little sip. Once the left's boogeyman of white supremacy exhausts itself,
Starting point is 00:24:14 the church will become the left's primary focus of blame and animosity. I mean, it already is. Yeah, exactly. Well, that's why I answered no, because it already is. Oh, okay. That's fair enough. Yeah. It always, I mean, the church, by which I mean the Catholic Church, of course.
Starting point is 00:24:30 Is always the object of the left's. Always. Always. I mean, I talk about this quite a lot when people try to say that Catholics can support leftism or agree with it or that they're somehow fellow travelers on issues of helping the poor. The left came to exist during the French Revolution. This is where we get the term, and their entire purpose was to counter the Catholic Church in its interests. Was to chop off the heads of priests. And it's not as if they started being.
Starting point is 00:24:54 nice to Catholics in the 20th century. I mean, leftism has always been aggressively anti-logos. It's also worth pointing out. Because they hate God. Because they, yeah, right, they hate God. And they hate those of us made in the image of God, namely people. Yes, exactly. They're entirely misanthropic. Yes. But we have to remember, you think of Pope Leo the 13th, when we hear the Catholic Church is actually very pro-socialism. No. Leo the 13th, he said, socialists are a pest, a plague. a wicked confederacy that seeks to steal the very gospel itself. You heard the same thing from Blessed Pius the 9th, St. Pius the 10th, Pius the 11th, Pius the 12th,
Starting point is 00:25:32 even John the 20th, St. John the 23rd, who was actually sort of a liberal pope. He was a church liberal, for sure. He was a church liberal. He said no Catholic could subscribe even to a moderate form of socialism. Yes, and this is something I was talking about. I did Matt Frad's show yesterday, and we got a super chat. Would you rather live in an economically left-wing society, but with cultural conservatism where people are virtuous, or a liberal open economy where people are completely degenerate. And my answer was, I just have to reject the framing.
Starting point is 00:26:04 Obviously, I'd rather live in a virtuous society, but the headship of the father in the household is almost entirely contingent upon property rights. It just doesn't happen in your society. The father has to provide for the family. He has to be free to do so. Yeah. If he isn't, if the government is providing for the family for him, it undermines the entire structure. So you cannot have a socially conservative.
Starting point is 00:26:20 And that is most embodied when you have a complete command. economy where workers own the means of production, then dad has no property provided with the family for. It's up to somebody else's whim. Some bureaucrat thousands of miles away is making the decisions for the family rather than the father, how to allocate resources. But even though we know that as Catholics, we cannot embrace a full on total seizure of the means of production because it's beneath the dignity of man to not own property. It's not as if once you're not at that position, things are great for families. It's just the closer you get to it, the worst everything is. Yeah. I I'm so glad you're, because there are some people today, I think, who are reacting against
Starting point is 00:26:58 this kind of insane, very, what would you call it, neo-conservative or libertarian or something, idea that of the radical individual autonomy that were all free-floating atoms. And they're reacting against that and they're saying, socialism, sign me up. That ain't it, chief. That ain't it either, actually. And it's for precisely the reason you've described. the relationship between these economic matters and our social, cultural matters of virtue, you can't just separate them. You can't just compartmentalize. And they kind of all speak to the same
Starting point is 00:27:31 thing. Yeah, no. So what is the answer? Is the answer, the D word? Distributism? Oh, no. I see, I'm still a market guy. Yes. I'm still a market guy entirely. I don't know. I mean, I'm open-minded. I'd like to learn more about distributivism. A lot of people who I respect by to it. So I'm sure even if I don't end up agreeing with it, there's got to be some merit there, something to take away, but I am a free market guy. For those who aren't the macros... Those who are not like the crazy sort of totally in the weeds Catholics out there. Distributism is this economic idea that was advanced, really in the early 20th century,
Starting point is 00:28:07 advice. It was thought to come from Catholic social teaching, and it's a little hard to pin down exactly, you know, what it is, but it would be a sort of alternative to what we would call capitalism or to socialism. But you're saying, give me some markets. Yeah, so I believe in the market economy, and I understand that there can be a time and place for regulation. So F.A. Hayek put the Austrian school on the map, and he believed in antitrust laws. I believe the Austrian School of Economics provides a beautiful descriptive model of how economies work, even though I don't, even though I don't necessarily agree with all of the prescriptive claims. I'm not completely libertarian on economic issues. Of course, sometimes there's a role for the government to step in. But I would
Starting point is 00:28:45 say that if you look at an economy, even if as a Catholic you're looking at the economy and saying X, Y, and Z about capitalism absolutely has to be regulated as a matter of faith. If you can pick out some specific non-negotiables from Catholic teaching with respect to what economic regulations should be, it doesn't get you to this hardline distributiveist position. You can just have a sort of modified capitalism at worst if you do have to change the system all that much. Plus, we have Pope St. John Paul the Great, who says in Chintessimus honors that free markets are the most efficient way to allocate resources in an economy.
Starting point is 00:29:18 Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Coming back from Ray Room Navarum. Yeah. Have we... Is the entire audience Catholic by this point? They better be. If they haven't converted now, if they haven't converted,
Starting point is 00:29:28 seeing us drink at 10 of the morning. I know. We're being good examples of virtue. First of all, please don't drink at 10 in the morning at home if you don't have a reason to. Don't do it on five hours of sleep. I'm on five hours of sleep here. Oh, you've got five hours?
Starting point is 00:29:40 Are you bragging? Are you bragging by how much sleep you guys? Is this, are we doing the college thing where we brag about how to sleep? We don't have to one up each other. I got three hours. All right, Noles. Oh, okay. This is actually an important, an important question.
Starting point is 00:29:53 In America, the Italians have historically been more persecuted than the Irish. It's not even close. It's not even. Wow, I agree. That's big of you. Oh, wait. No. No.
Starting point is 00:30:09 Yeah. Oh, yeah. You believe the Italians were more persecuted? There's no. question. Largest mass lynching in American history. Was it of the Irish? Here's the thing, though. There are a lot of parts of Irish history that we don't discuss because it's not considered politically
Starting point is 00:30:23 correct because only certain groups are allowed to have victim status. So when you look at indentured service, in fact that most indentured servants were Irish, they were often treated worse than slaves because you had to buy a new slave if they died. If an indentured servant died, you just didn't have to pay them. You're good, yep. That's a fair point. I actually, I don't look at, I have a quarter Irish to me. I don't, I have a little more
Starting point is 00:30:43 the Swarthy side. The Italians, because when they came... I'm glad there's something good in this cocktail. In this human cocktail. Something that works. When the Italians came here, there was some question parts of the country. Are they white or are they black? One simply does not, you know... Same with the Irish.
Starting point is 00:31:00 Not exactly white or black, but Irish were... The Irish were not considered white. Yeah, they were... Yeah. I mean, I remember once I was talking to my English grandfather and my Irish grandmother. And my grandfather was very into ancestry and genealogy. And he discovered there were actually some Irish in his line, too. Thank goodness. Some the Nolzes went over to Ireland.
Starting point is 00:31:22 And my grandmother said, see, I told you, I knew there were some Irish there. And my grandfather, I believe the line was, someone had to tame the savages. Oh, my gosh. Okay. Well, first of all, he's absolutely wrong. But now I understand where you get your brains. I don't believe you were up. Yes.
Starting point is 00:31:42 It's just good you have some Irish DNA You know, there's something My life has been shaped by the immense amount of Catholic guilt I feel on a daily basis, clearly You'd be a much better person, Michael. I'm just, I'm born down. The thing about shame, just a plug for shame at the moment
Starting point is 00:32:01 because, you know, shame is very unpopular now. You know, you can fat shame or slut shame or shame shame, shame, shame is shame. Shame is shame. Every day this is. constantly. The thing about shame is, it's usually right. Usually, it's kind of on to something. You know, it's called your moral conscience. You don't want to hate yourself. You want to have an appropriate love of yourself. You know, you can't love your neighbor. You're made in God's image and likeness.
Starting point is 00:32:29 There's something worthy of love there. So there's something worthy of love. You ought to know, like when you do something wrong, you should, you'll know that and you should just, instead of embracing it and being like really happy about it and like dancing around for it, you should maybe repent of that feel kind of bad. What was the line? I think it was from Niebuhr who said that today religion is a God without wrath, leading a people without sin into a kingdom without judgment through the ministrations of a Christ without a cross.
Starting point is 00:32:55 Oh, man, that is beautiful. And it's true. I'll say this. I would define shame in guilt differently, though I agree with you that as a social mechanism. Shame is absolutely indispensable. So shame is when your primary concern is what other people think of you. So guilt is actually better.
Starting point is 00:33:10 Yeah, yeah. Because guilt is your own conscience bothering you. You coming to terms with that and ideally rectifying your life. Shame's a little bit different. But, of course, guilt has gotten this really bad rap. There's this idea of Catholic guilt and how horrible is it. First of all, there are some things you should feel guilty about. Would you rather have to deal with a person who feels too guilty or not guilty enough?
Starting point is 00:33:31 It's an easy question to answer. You have to moderate too. I'm not saying the answer is to feel too guilty. But what our culture considers too guilty is unbelievable. It's like, feeling bad about anything you do ever, no matter how horrible it was. It's like, you're being too hard on your stuff. Come on. You deserve it.
Starting point is 00:33:49 Yes, yes. It's like, I deserve to burn in hell forever. And I accept Jesus Christ so that won't happen. Seriously. Yes, I know. We've all sinned. We've all sinned. And we deserve to go to hell.
Starting point is 00:33:58 And like, here, God has given me an incredible life. So the answer isn't necessarily shame. It's gratitude. Yeah. But we should feel guilt when we've done wrong. I'm glad you're making the sort of public distinction here with shame versus guilt. guilt because the thing about shame is all cultures shame. It's like just how all cultures have stagos and taboo is all cultures will shame. The question is what are you being shamed for?
Starting point is 00:34:21 Bingo. We should be shamed for drinking a 10 in the morning. But we would be celebrated for that. We would be shamed for, I don't know, like diligently doing our work if we were to ever do that. Like pray, if either of us ever could do that. I mean like, but no, it's doing something very solid and worthwhile, praying outside of an abortion clinic trying to convince women to choose life. You'd be shamed for that, absolutely. Yeah, of course. And so they understand it's a social mechanism. They just don't want it directed towards behaviors that they consider to be positive or more cynically, behaviors which they know are going to destroy society so they can reconstruct something new. Yeah. All right. All right. Enough shame. Enough shame. Okay. So this, listen to the entire prompt for you react in any way.
Starting point is 00:35:07 Excuse me. Am I accused of being emotion? This is very, this is important. This could end the whole thing. Okay, all right. Some people with information that could lead to the arrest of Hillary Clinton were most likely indirectly or directly killed by Hillary Clinton. Due to YouTube rules, you have to make your guess, but do not verbally confirm if the other person guessed correctly. Give only an ambiguous nonverbal confirmation. so I'll read that prompt again.
Starting point is 00:35:43 Some people with information that could lead to the arrest of Hillary Clinton were most likely, indirectly or directly killed by Hillary Clinton wearing a mustache at the Manhattan Correctional Facility. Now, I would never say anything that could get anyone demonetized. How do we say this without saying it? I'm not going to say anything. I'm not going to say anything. I just, I just.
Starting point is 00:36:14 and then I'm the guard. I'm the cell guard. I think we answered the question. Yeah, I think we deserve a drink for that one. I think we deserve that too. Pour one out, man. Pour one out for that guy. Oh.
Starting point is 00:36:31 No, I think I'll just drink that. I think I'll say it for myself a little more wasted on him. Ben Shapiro is the only host at the Daily Wire who deserves to have a freedom of a sketch. Hmm. Hmm. Well, I mean, the answer for you is apparently just descriptive. Oh, okay. I just am saying I've looked. No, I don't know. I've looked at. Noles, you voiced characters. I've put you in cartoons.
Starting point is 00:36:58 I literally put you in a cartoon reference about the question we just answered. You were in a cartoon about the gentleman who we were just discussing. You're right. Oh, that global sex trafficker who committed suicide before he could tell us which of the most powerful humans on the planet were pedophiles. If you ask me, the whole thing is pretty suspicious. If you're some kind of crazy conspiracy theorist, that is. But I guess it wasn't about you. Oh, I'm sorry, Michael. Is that not good enough? Was spending hours of my time animating your face not enough for you?
Starting point is 00:37:30 Did it have to be all about you, Knowles? Unbelievable. Take a drink. I'll take a drink. You're being shamed. I should. I should be shamed. This is the last one.
Starting point is 00:37:39 Is this the last question? This is my question. Okay. No, no, it's not. This is the second question. Oh. Beautiful. Okay, well, I guess I have the answer for you on this.
Starting point is 00:37:51 Drawing cartoons is a great way to meet single Catholic women. I'm going to have to. I thought you were smarter than that, Knowles. I thought you're still single. I am. Right. Depends on the day the week. Yeah, exactly, exactly.
Starting point is 00:38:07 Look, Knowles, right, right now currently I am single. That is correct. Incidentally, I am single. I'm making cartoons on the internet. You know, it's a great way for Catholic girls to know who you are. And who does, look at it, who does every girl want to date? An animator, man, it's a whole thing. Ask any girl, who's your dream guy?
Starting point is 00:38:25 Walt Disney. No, I know. 10 out of 10 times. Even when girls are in, you know, they're in elementary school and they're saying, you know, who do you want to be with? Who do you want to be with? Bro. I can't tell you how jealous the football stars.
Starting point is 00:38:36 They always worry, yeah, when you were just giving them swirlies. You were like, yeah, take that, Chad. Doesn't you want to do a motion tween, bro. Yeah, yeah. Well, you know, another great way to meet single Catholic women. Show up on the Michael Mall Show. Oh, yeah. Ladies.
Starting point is 00:38:51 You're going to make me blush, Noles. You're making me blush right now. Because you're Irish. You've got that fair skin. It's true. I'm not going to be insulted. Reasons to vote for Democrats. A comprehensive guide is more informative than speechless,
Starting point is 00:39:06 controlling words and controlling minds. I'm answering for you. I suppose so. Hmm. I'm going to say no, too. it may be more profound. It may be pithier. It may contain more wisdom.
Starting point is 00:39:29 Of course. But there's just more stuff in the other book. Yeah, exactly. There's literally just more information. I've said it once and I've said it again. I don't think you have to read the book, but Knowles would appreciate it if you bought it. Yes, that's the main thing.
Starting point is 00:39:42 I really don't. As long as you buy it. I said this to a friend of mine. A friend of mine had bought multiple copies actually. for you know, for relatives and things. I said, but, you know, I just haven't had time to read it. You know, like, in fact, you don't even have to have to read every copy. You don't even have to read one of the copies.
Starting point is 00:40:00 Just, you gave me the money. You know what I really, it's not even the money. Because, you know, the way, I'm sure. No, the way, the way. The money has nothing to do with it. The way publishing works, you get in advance. And then the publishers always just, like, make up a bunch of accounting. And then you never get any money afterward.
Starting point is 00:40:16 But maybe you get, like, a little touch, a little, a little taste. But you know what I really. really want. I actually, seriously, more than the money. I want people to think you're cool when they read this book. I want them to think I'm a cool guy. And I want the New York Times editors. Oh. I want them to sit down at their little meeting. I don't know what they, what they usually meet for. They talk about, you know, how Trump is leading an insurrection. I talk about this. And I want them in the midst of this to say Michael Knowles' book about Us Libs has to be on the live. That's what I want. That's all I want. That's pretty good. Out of this.
Starting point is 00:40:51 And that's so he wants to make the New York Times bestseller list has nothing to do with wanting money. No, I never, I never, no money at all me, no money. He doesn't even like money. No, money is the root of all. Actually, money is not the root of all evil. Love of money is not the love of money. We should not be attached to anything, but our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ. And to that I will drink. Cheers. Weren't we finishing? I thought we were finishing. I thought that was the thing. We finished the game. All right. Well, now I'm just embarrassed. Now I just look like a hoodlum. absolute degenerate. It's 10 of the morning, Michael. What are we doing?

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.