The Peter Zeihan Podcast Series - America’s Changing Republican Party || Peter Zeihan

Episode Date: July 18, 2024

The Republican Party is undergoing some evolutions at the moment, moving away from many of its traditional stances. This is part of a broader cycle in which American political parties shift and realign every few decades. Full Newsletter: https://mailchi.mp/zeihan/americas-changing-republican-party

Hey, everybody, Peter Zion here coming to you from Colorado. It is the 17th of July, and it is the last day of the Republican National Convention, which I've been watching pretty closely because the Republican Party is in flux. For those of you've been watching me for a while, you know that I've been saying for a couple years, several years now, that we're in the late party structure for what is called the sixth party structure. Basically, every generation or two American politics goes into a period of flux where the factions that make up our parties move around. And for the last few years, we've been in that process. It's happening for both of the parties, but the Republicans are further along, so it's been the one I've been following most closely. Donald Trump is obviously part of this process and has been speeding it along. And now with the convention, we're starting to get a pretty good idea of what the next possible iteration of the Republicans are. Quick review.

So most people associate the Republicans with the degree of social conservatism, international involvement, a relatively hawkish position. on foreign affairs, especially military affairs, and a fairly pro-business outlook for businesses of all size. Every plank of that is now being challenged and rewritten by Team Trump as American Society, demographics, trade, technology, and everything else is evolving. It makes sense. Whether or not this new structure that's evolving is the one that is going to stick remains to be seen, but we now are a pretty good idea of what the Trump Republican Party would be. Three big changes.

The first one is a little bit of a surprise, a softer position on some social conservative issues like gays and abortion. Basically, the Trump Party is now saying that these are issues that should be decided by the states rather than the national level. And there's a lot of hardcore conservative, social conservatives are really pretty unhappy with that. But Donald Trump is betting that his cult of personality like hold over the Republican Party is going to be sufficient that no one can outflank him. And considering that he sailed to the nomination, without even showing up at any of the primaries, that's probably a safe bet, at least for this election cycle.

The second one, of course, is something that's near and dear to my heart, and it's a shift from international involvement to isolationism. The idea that the problems over there are problems over there, we should just stick over here, but still arm ourselves to the teeth. We saw a lot of this in Trump's first term, where you might talk tough on countries with Russia and China, but really, on every major issue, whether it's trade or security, basically just let them do whatever they want. If it couldn't be negotiated and stuck to in a single afternoon of talks, he really wasn't interested.

We saw that, of course, with Ukraine, and we've also seen it with trade policy with China, where we got this phase one trade deal, but then Trump couldn't bother to enforce it. So the Chinese basically just walked all over the United States as regards trade. Things like that are definitely being codified into the Republican Party's new platform. And then the third one has to do with business versus labor for the past several decades. really going back to the 1930s, the Republican Party is always sided with the business community over labor. But one of the highlight speakers of the convention this time was none other than the representative of the Teamsters Union, which is probably the most militant and throwback of America's unions. And he talked about the Chamber of Commerce basically being a welfare club for businesses.

And this is something that was on the stage of the Republican National Convention. I mean, for a while there, I was wondering if I was watching the right convention. These are issues that are usually trumpeted by not just the Democrats, but the really leftist group of Democrats, like, say, the squad. And now it's becoming core of the Republican Party platform. In essence, we are entering a golden age for organized labor in the United States. The United States is in the process of doubling the size of its industrial plant. Most of those jobs are blue collar, and so they're very amenable to be organized into a, labor unions. The Teamsters, of course, are all for that. And what the Trump Republican Party

seems to be doing is basically ditching the entire business community and going whole hog towards organized labor. And among the new things that are in the Republican Party's platform are basically starting to challenge things like right-to-work laws in places like the American South and Texas that prevent or at least dissuade unions from forming in the first place. It's now the official Republican Party platform that that's a bad idea. Now, will this new trifecta stick? It's way too soon to tell.

And the old Reaganite and Lincolnian Republicans are not dead yet. There were some hilarious moments on stage from my point of view. Ron DeSantis, who ran for president, of course, Governor of Florida. He was just angry. And it was pretty obvious.

But I would say that the highlight here for awkwardness goes to Nikki Haley, who came in second in the primaries against Donald Trump. still lost, of course. She came on stage to endorse Trump, and not only was she booed when she showed up, but her endorsement speech was really awkward. It was kind of like a woman being asked to toast her ex-husband who had an affair with the secretary and was now married her. It was that level of awkwardness. Anyway, Nikki Haley has already joined a think tank to reimagine what the next

version of conservatism looks like in the United States now that the old Republican party is truly and well dead. And Mike Pence has formed a think tank to do the same thing. Now, I'm not suggesting that one of these three visions, Pence or Haley or Trump, is the one that's ultimately going to stick. But I'm just highlighting that right now for this election cycle, we have a very different Republican platform and a very different Republican party. Everything is still in flux. This is not the final form. We won't get that probably until the next presidential cycle. And there's a lot of folks who have irons in the fire to try to figure out what that is going to be.