The Philip DeFranco Show - PDS 1.10 This Pokimane Hasan Piker Situation Will Get Worse, NFT Gaming Backlash, & Today's News

Episode Date: January 10, 2022

Start your free trial today: http://www.Squarespace.com/Phil & enter offer code “Phil” to get 10% off your first purchase!  More PDS: https://youtu.be/zbZaq9WhBSw TEXT ME! [phone] Get More Phil: https://linktr.ee/PhilipDeFranco -- 00:00 - Reality Star Sells Farts as NFTs 00:48 - Pilot Saved After Crashing Onto Train Tracks 01:38 - Canadian Influencers Face Backlash Maskless, In-Flight Party 03:53 - Twitch Creators Wonder if DMCA is the Downfall of TV Meta Trend 06:23 - Sponsor 07:08 - School Closures Top Record Highs, But Many Remain Open 09:17 - Noncitizens Get Right to Vote in NYC 10:40 - Gaming Companies Ponder if NFTs Are Essential to Their Future -- ✩ TODAY’S STORIES ✩ Reality Star Sells Farts as NFTs: https://www.insider.com/reality-star-made-200k-fart-jars-selling-them-as-nfts-2022-1 Pilot Saved After Crashing Onto Train Tracks: https://abc7.com/pacoima-plane-down-crash-metrolink-train-video-of-pilot-being-saved/11447057/ Canadian Influencers Face Backlash Maskless, In-Flight Party: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-59917300 Twitch Creators Wonder if DMCA is the Downfall of TV Meta Trend: https://www.sportskeeda.com/esports/the-entire-gordon-ramsay-twitch-drama-involving-hasanabi-xqc-explained School Closures Top Record Highs, But Many Remain Open: https://roguerocket.com/2022/01/10/school-closures-record-highs/  Noncitizens Get Right to Vote in NYC: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/09/nyregion/noncitizens-nyc-voting-rights.html Gaming Companies Ponder if NFTs Are Essential to Their Future: https://www.gamespot.com/articles/square-enix-ceos-new-years-letter-discusses-nfts-metaverse-blockchain-and-more/1100-6499258/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2022/01/sega-considering-what-will-be-accepted-by-the-users-in-gaming-nfts/ ✩ STORIES NOT IN TODAY’S SHOW ✩ Charli D’Amelio Tops Highest-Paid TikTokers List: https://roguerocket.com/2022/01/10/charli-damelio-tops-highest-paid-tiktokers-list/ ——————————     Executive Producer: Amanda Morones Produced by: Cory Ray  Edited by: James Girardier, Julie Goldberg, Maxwell Enright Art Department: Brian Borst, William Crespo Writing/Research: Philip DeFranco, Brian Espinoza, Maddie Crichton, Lili Stenn, Neena Pesqueda Production Team: Zack Taylor, Emma Leid ———————————— #DeFranco #HasanAbi #Pokimane ———————————— Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

You, right now, look me in the eyes and answer the question, what happened while I was gone? I leave for a month, I take a break from looking at the news, and then I get ready for today's show. I look on the internet, and what's the first story I see? A reality star from 90 Day Fiancé started selling her farts in mason jars for $500 a pop, then $1,000 a pop. Ended up making $200,000 before she says she was hospitalized

because she was eating so poorly to make those farts, and so now she's selling those farts in a Mason jar as NFTs. That is possibly the most 2022 story I've ever heard. I think it sets the tone for the year. And so on that happy note, it brings me joy to say, sup you beautiful bastards. Welcome back to the first Philip DeFranco show of 2022.

Do me a favor if you would, let's start off on a good note, hit that like button, make sure you're subscribed and let's just jump into it. You know, the first thing that we're gonna talk about today, it's one of the craziest things I've seen in a while, which given the state of the world is kind of wild, but here we go. Story is out of Los Angeles, California, where you have these hero police officers

saving a pilot from this horrifying accident. So let's walk through it together. You have this pilot flying a plane, luckily no other passengers on board. He has to make an emergency landing. But the authorities saying that the plane lost power and ultimately he crashed, but he didn't just crash. He crashed onto a set of train tracks near Whiteman airport.

Officers at a nearby LAPD station then rushed to the scene within minutes. And then we see this footage from the ground showing the officers trying to pull the pilot out. Right to seconds after they drag him to safety, we hear the train's horn blast right before it rips through the empty plane. Thankfully, there were no other injuries reported

on the ground. The pilot was taken to a local trauma center, was in stable condition. And understandably so, people have been calling these four officers who responded heroes. And yeah, that seems like the word to describe it. That's insane. And then let's talk about this fucking video.

This is one of several videos that have gone viral over the past week showing maskless people partying on a flight from Canada to Cancun, Mexico for a six night stay. It might be a little bit different than a flight you've taken recently. We're seeing dancing, yelling, passing around bottles of alcohol,

even vaping in the cabin. This blows up people going, okay, what? I need to know more. As it turns out, this was a privately chartered plane from Montreal filled with Canadian social media stars, reality TV personalities, among other people. The trip was reportedly organized by the invite only group 111 Private Club.

With these videos going viral, you had a lot of people pissed off in the public. In fact, the public backlash became so bad that we even saw Prime Minister Justin Trudeau say this. I think like all Canadians who've seen those videos, I'm extremely frustrated. We know how hard people have worked to keep themselves safe, to limit their family gatherings at Christmas time, to wear masks, to get vaccinated, to do all the right things.

And it's a slap in the face to see people putting themselves, putting their fellow citizens, putting airline workers at risk by being completely irresponsible. And so as a result of their behavior, Sunwing Airlines, which flew the group on December 30th, canceled their return flight, saying, our decision to cancel the return flight was based on the group's refusal to accept all terms and our security team's assessment that noncompliance

would be likely based on their previous disruptive onboard behavior. But it ended up not just being then. We saw other Canadian airlines like Air Transat and Air Canada announcing that they too denied return flights for several passengers in the group. And as of last Friday, you had Canada's health minister saying that only about 27 of the 130 passengers were back home. And of those back in Canada, reportedly they took four different flights to get there. They were tested upon arrival at the border. They were asked for proof of vaccination and quarantine plans.

Also turns out it's not over. The country's transportation authority saying they're investigating the incident, saying that the passengers could face $5,000 fines for violating masking requirements. This will also be interesting to watch because we've also seen at least one passenger test positive for COVID who's a teen who won a trip

in an Instagram contest. But they're claiming that not everyone was engaging in reckless behavior on the flight, which is also something the club's founder James William Awad also said on Twitter But I'm also saying I've significantly learned that I'm still learning from this experience But also trying to downplay the chaos that was captured on video. Then is the Twitchpocalypse here? That is a question that a lot of people are asking following this latest controversy and debate that's happening over Twitch and of all things Masterchef and Avatar the Last Airbender. And that because a number of major creators

on that platform have just been watching and reacting to TV shows with one of the most popular being MasterChef. With Gordon Ramsay himself even having a quick back and forth on Twitter with XQC, one of the streamers who's a major part of this meta. Well, many saw this reaction and were hopeful that it could open a door for maybe Gordon Ramsay

and streamers to collaborate together. With other creators and viewers going, okay, one, how is this even legal? And two, this new attention is just going to get everything shut down. With some creators asking, are these like public domain shows or something? Do larger companies just not care about folks

restreaming their stuff? Twitch DJ Weed, who's actually head of the Twitch community production saying it's absolutely not okay. Just like it has never been okay to stream music. This is just as DMCA-able as anything else. Hard to say why streamers have not been targeted, but just like music, it's probably just a matter of time. With that in, this is not an official Twitch take,

just my own. But also with that, you had major streamers chiming in about how people are getting away with this, including people who have been streaming MasterChef, like Ahsan Piker, tweeting, "'Everything is fair use if the copyright holder "'doesn't care about pursuing a DMCA claim. "'Be smart, don't watch entire movies, Viacom, Disney shit,

"'or new episodes, and stop snitching.'" With him adding, and he is right here, that technically video games should fall under that, but the companies don't care or actually see benefits if creators stream their games. But then, funny enough, not long after tweeting that, he got a DMCA hit of his own for watching MasterChef. This also after one of the largest streamers on the platform,

Pokimane, was banned for watching Avatar, the last airbender on stream. Though they're taking it in stride saying, I'm not surprised and I don't think this is unfair. In my opinion, it was inevitable that publishers would take action on me or someone else during this React meta. But also with that, she ended up receiving

a fair amount of backlash. With that criticism boiling down to the fact that many saw this as an example of a creator doing something that benefits them, even though overall it's bad for the community and smaller creators. They get a temporary ban for two days. They come back to usually bigger views than normal.

Y'all, as far as my reaction to this news, it's the first one of the year, prepare yourselves. I just wanna say, don't be stupid, stupid. I'm not hyped and excited about a DMCA claim or Pokimane or any specific creator getting suspended. But as large creators like Moist Critical have already publicly said, it's just common sense that you can't stream

a full TV series, anime, movie franchise on Twitch. No studio will ever say, yeah, if you buy our Blu-ray, you can stream it to 40,000 people who have it. And it's not just this random, it only affects you, harmless thing for these big creators to be doing this. When there's something like an adpocalypse that we've seen different versions of here on YouTube, it doesn't really affect the big channels

because we have the ability to move and figure out solutions, it hurts the little guy. But with that said, that's a story, my personal opinion, and I wanna pass the question off to you. What are your thoughts here? But from that, I wanna take a second to thank the sponsor of today's show, Squarespace. I've been partnering with Squarespace for years now. And I have to say,

if you're getting your business off the ground or creating a place to share your homemade goods, new favorite hobby, your current obsession, or even a personal blog to get all those thoughts out of your head, no matter what you are doing, Squarespace is there to help. It's so easy. There's nothing to install, patch, or upgrade ever.

And creating a beautiful website with Squarespace's all-in-one platform has never been so simple. It's extremely intuitive and easy to use. With their mobile optimized websites, your content automatically adjusts so your content looks great on any device. Plus, with Squarespace, you get access to all their marketing tools and analytics

and their award-winning customer care team via email or live chat 24 seven. So if you wanna check it out, see why so many others love it, see if it is perfect for you, start your free trial today over squarespace.com slash phil. And when you realize you love it, make sure you enter an offer code phil to get 10% off your first purchase.

And then there is a massive fight happening right now with teachers and students fighting back against schools staying open as Omicron surges. COVID cases in the US are topping new record highs as are school closures. According to Burbue, a data firm that tracks school closures, at least 5,409 public schools had canceled class or moved to remote learning by the end of last week,

which has tripled the number we saw in December. But notably, that is still just a fraction of the nation's 130,000 schools, and many of the biggest school districts in the country are still insisting that students come into the classroom. Los Angeles, which is home to the second biggest district, is requiring that students at least test negative before they return to school this week.

But in the biggest district, New York City, classes have already resumed following winter break. And although the city has said that it will double random tests and send home more kids, students were not required to provide negative results. Meanwhile, teachers in other major districts have protested the local government's decision to stay open with one of the most closely watched battles

being out of Chicago. There, students have now missed four consecutive days of school due to a feud happening between Chicago teachers and Mayor Lori Lightfoot. Last week, the teachers union there voted to return to remote learning in defiance of a citywide order mandating that they teach in person

with them citing inadequate COVID-19 protections. But you had Mayor Lightfoot claiming, "'No, the conditions are fine. "'The students are safe despite record surges.'" Instead, opting to cancel classes altogether while this fight plays out. And honestly, who knows when this is gonna end? Yesterday, you had the union saying

they were still far apart from making any kind of agreement with public school officials after Lightfoot rejected their demands. Lightfoot for her part has said that she remains hopeful that a deal could be reached, but she also stirred up the union by accusing teachers of staging an illegal walkout and claiming that they abandoned their posts

and they abandoned kids and their families. But also important to note that it's not just Chicago teachers, you have teachers in other school districts also beginning to draw their tactics from Chicago. Friday you had teachers in Oakland, California staging a sick out, closing 12 schools, serving thousands of students. You know, with this story,

I wanna pass the question off to you because many of you are on the ground going through this, either yourself or your family is. As a parent myself, I'm just kind of lost and exhausted with this. I've had, you know, I'm coming up almost on the two year anniversary of this hide and seek game that I've been playing with COVID.

Because you know, this morning, when I sent my kids off to school, I'm like, is this the dumbest fucking thing that I'm doing right now? Like it feels like everything that we've done over the last two years is trying to pick like the less shitty of the two incredibly shitty options. Yeah, that's why, especially with this story, I would really love to know your thoughts on this.

And then should non-citizens be allowed to vote? That question is in the air right now because New York city just expanded that right to more than 800,000 people. With that coming after legislation passed by the city council took effect yesterday, giving legal immigrants who are not US citizens the ability to vote in key city races.

And while New York City is not the first city to take such a step, it is the largest to give these rights to non-citizen immigrants. And so what this looks like in practice, non-citizens will be able to register to vote a year from now if they've lived in the city for at least 30 days and are green card holders, DACA recipients, or given work authorization.

And if the law remains in place, those individuals will be able to vote starting in 2023 for primary and general elections for citywide and local races like that of the mayor, council members and borough presidents. But that is also a big if, because legal experts believe that this new policy will be contested in court. And in fact, the Republican National Committee

has already said that it will challenge this matter, arguing that it violates the state's constitution and election laws. What I'll say with this is while yes, this is not going to impact a federal election, this is still very big locally. New York City has nearly 7 million voting age adults, and what we're talking about here is giving the right

to vote to 800,000 of them that previously could not vote. That's like one in nine. And while yes, this is a New York story, I mean, depending on what happens here with the law being contested, does it stand? Does it fall? It is very possible that if this stands, we will see this spread to other states. But we've also seen some states, including Alabama,

Arizona, Colorado, and Florida adopting new rules that will stop any attempts to pass laws like this one. But all that said, it brings us back to the main question of the story. Should non-citizens be allowed to vote? I'd love to know your thoughts. And then is it a cash grab? Is it good or disastrous?

And what I'm talking about is gaming and NFTs. Right since December, gaming communities and companies have been grappling with this issue after Ubisoft introduced NFTs to their games. Their platform called Quartz allows players to buy in-game cosmetic items for the game Ghost Recon Breakpoint as NFTs. It follows NFTs digits and the whole like appeal of these

is supposed to be that the NFTs number will be on the item itself and the item will remember all of its previous owners. Those items can be sold on third-party platforms with Ubisoft being able to take a small cut. However, the entire concept drew backlash from the gaming community with many viewing it as just a stupid cash grab.

And of note here, so far, it does appear to be a failure with early reports indicating that only around 15 items were actually sold on third-party platforms. But despite this initial backlash that we've seen, other companies have announced that they plan to move forward with NFTs as well. EA has been on the NFT bandwagon for a while with its CEO saying back in November

that NFTs and blockchain tech are the future of our industry. That sentiment also repeated by Square Enix's president over the new year with him writing in a letter, I see 2021 not only as Metaverse year one, but also as NFTs year one, given that it was a year in which NFTs were met with a great deal of enthusiasm by a rapidly expanding user base?

With them going on to detail how the company is excited by the prospect of blockchain-based games and how the tech might be used to allow gamers to more actively contribute to games. But not every company is on board. Sega cited fan backlash to gaming NFTs in their recent decision to be far more skeptical about implementing the tech,

although they didn't rule it out completely. But all of that involves companies, companies that would very likely make a lot of money. So what are the players think? Why would NFTs be attractive to players and why do players have an issue with them? Right, some of the criticisms we've seen are kind of the same criticisms that we've seen

with most blockchain tech. Critics saying that even the most environmentally friendly NFTs are still massive power hogs, they get worse as they scale up. But for the sake of today's story, setting that aside, right, we need to talk about the more specific problems that gamers have. With many saying that they have trouble

with seeing how these new NFTs in gaming would actually maintain their value. Saying that usually NFTs rely on artificial scarcity and speculative markets for JPEGs and other easily copyable file types. Some also pushing back saying we don't need NFTs to make a marketplace for in-game items. For example, Valve's Dota 2 and CSGO

both have in-game cosmetic items that can be sold for real cash between players. With the main difference being that if it was an NFT you could sell it on a third party marketplace, but also people saying, you know, why would I? Though you also have some supporters saying there is a collectible aspect to this. Yes, with the artificial scarcity, but also let's say if you're a big Dota 2 or League of Legends fan and player, maybe you're watching the international or worlds, kind of like how you have people in the real world buying an actual sports jersey that was worn by one of the players, it might be possible to buy the actual skin

used by a pro player during the finals of one of those events. I do want to interject, not me personally, I think in general, it's kind of stupid. Because my personal opinion, and maybe this is short-sighted, like we'll see in five to 10 years, like many others, I have huge doubts about how this could actually be implemented. A lot of the way that this has been talked about

are NFTs being used by companies to justify selling even more expensive skins and capitalizing on recurring revenue. Or because some of this way that this has been talked about are NFTs being used by companies just by selling even more expensive skins and capitalizing on recurring revenue. Because some of this stuff that's being imagined or proposed like for example, Mike Shinoda from Lincoln Park, he seems like a pretty massive supporter of the technology and he had a thread defending their use in games writing. Imagine taking your favorite skin from Valorant

and using it in Fortnite and not paying extra because you own it. Then using it in COD, Minecraft, even Twitter, Instagram, so many possibilities, no? But I mean, I look at that and I think, okay, that would require all those gaming companies who directly compete with one another to not only decide, yes, we're going to work together,

but also implement that same skin across multiple engines and platforms. And I don't know, once again, could be short-sighted, but I just, I can't imagine a world where, even if it was implemented properly for a consumer, that it wasn't a shit show. Like take Fortnite, for example, they sell a ton of skins that you can use in that game.

Most of the skins limited as far as when you can buy them, right, there are time limits, certain availability. But imagine for all of these skins to have third-party value, you'd probably only want a limited number of those skins available to users. So all of a sudden, like a clothing drop or a sneakers app drop,

you gotta deal with a ton of scalpers probably raising the price on you. But yeah, with all of that, to bring it back around, whether you're a skeptic, a casual, or you're super in love with NFTs, what are your thoughts on gaming and NFTs? Is it the future? Is it the future you're excited for?

Or is this a stupid, stupid cash grab? But yeah, ultimately that is where that story ends. Today's show ends. Thank you all for being a part of the first show back into 2022. And a quick reminder, if you're subscribed, go ahead and check your bell. Make sure that it is set to all notifications

because I'm gonna be posting a lot more than just the four videos a week, including there might even be a morning video tomorrow, but no matter what you decide to do, I just wanna close by saying, my name's Philip DeFranco, you've just been filled in, I love yo faces and I'll see you tomorrow.