The Pomp Podcast - #1349 Adam Sullivan | Core Scientific CEO on Bitcoin Halving & Mining Industry
Episode Date: April 24, 2024Adam Sullivan is the CEO at Core Scientific, one of the largest bitcoin miners in North America. In this conversation, we talk about building Core Scientific, public company impact, bitcoin halving, b...itcoin ETFs, future of bitcoin miners, consolidation in the industry, metrics to evaluate a business, and future plans for Core Scientific. ======================= Buy and sell cryptocurrency in a tax-advantaged crypto IRA with iTrustCapital. Enjoy 24/7 access, lowest fees in the industry, and tax benefits for your retirement. Open an account today at www.itrustcapital.com ======================= Core Scientific (NASDAQ: CORZ) is one of the largest public Bitcoin miners and hosting solutions providers for Bitcoin mining in North America. To learn more about Core Scientific, please visit: www.corescientific.com ======================= Pomp writes a daily letter to over 265,000+ investors about business, technology, and finance. He breaks down complex topics into easy-to-understand language while sharing opinions on various aspects of each industry. You can subscribe at https://pomp.substack.com/ ======================= View 10k+ open startup jobs: https://dreamstartupjob.com/ Enroll in my Crypto Academy: https://www.thecryptoacademy.io/
Transcript
Discussion (0)
What's up everyone? This is Anthony Pompliano. Many of you know me as Pomp. You're listening
to the Pomp Podcast, which is my effort to find the most interesting people in the world
and sit with them for hours while I ask questions in an effort to learn. So it would mean the
world to me if you would subscribe to the show on your favorite audio platform, watch
episodes on YouTube, and tell your friends and family about the podcast. My goal is to
help millions learn from the world's most interesting people. So let's get into today's
episode. Today's episode is with Adam Sullivan. He is the CEO of Core Scientific, one of the
largest Bitcoin miners in North America. Adam and I talk about how Core Scientific has built
their business, merging from bankruptcy, what it's like to be a public company again, what
has changed since they're back in the public markets. We also discuss how he thinks about
the Bitcoin halving. Is it a positive or a negative development for their company and
other miners? How these miners are using debt for financing and how they think of the tradeoff
between equity financing at the same time. Then we get into things like why Bitcoin miners have
a bright future, how there will be consolidation in the industry. What are some of the metrics that
Adam looks at when he's evaluating a Bitcoin mining business and whether he thinks that it's
a good business or not? And then what is the plan for between now and 2028, where Core Scientific
wants to continue to grow to keep their position as one of the largest miners in the world?
This conversation is packed with insights. Adam does a great job and I learned a ton.
So I am excited to show you my conversation with Adam Sullivan.
Anthony Pompliano runs Pomp Investments.
All views of him and the guests on his podcast are solely their opinions and do not reflect
the opinions of Pomp Investments.
You should not treat any opinion expressed by Pomp or his guests as a specific inducement
to make a particular investment or follow a particular strategy, but only as an expression
of his personal opinion.
This podcast is for informational purposes only.
Today's episode is brought to you by iTrust Capital.
Are you buying crypto on an exchange because you're excited about the bull run?
Well, I hope you're reporting your crypto gains to the IRS because they want you to pay your taxes.
That's right. When you buy and sell crypto on an exchange, you need to pay the government taxes when you make profits.
That sounds pretty taxing.
There's another way you can buy and sell crypto without worrying about taxes.
At iTrust Capital, you can buy and sell crypto inside of a tax-advantaged crypto IRA.
Crypto IRAs are retirement accounts that work similarly to an exchange, but with tax benefits.
Let me give you an example.
If you can buy and sell crypto on an exchange and you make a $20,000 profit, you have to pay the government taxes.
However, if you do the same thing in your Roth IRA and you make a $20,000 profit, you don't need to pay any taxes.
That's right.
You get to keep all the profits and not have to pay taxes because it's in a tax-advantaged account.
So opening a tax advantage IRA at iTrust Capital only takes a few minutes.
You have 24-7 access to the markets with some of the lowest fees in the industry.
The bull run has begun and people are starting to see their accounts go up.
So start taking advantage of tax benefits with an IRA at iTrust Capital.
You can start maximizing your crypto investment today.
Go to itrustcapital.com.
That's itrustcapital.com.
Today's episode is brought to you by Core Scientific.
They are one of the largest public Bitcoin mining companies and hosting solutions in North America.
They specialize in transforming energy into high-value compute with exceptional efficiency at scale
and recently announced a contract with CoreWeave, a leader in AI cloud compute,
to provide up to 16 megawatts of data center capacity.
With a substantial fleet of their own miners, Core Scientific not only earns Bitcoin for their own account,
but also provides hosting services for large-scale Bitcoin mining customers
Operating out of seven data centers in Georgia, Kentucky, North Carolina, North Dakota, and Texas.
You can learn more about Core Scientific by visiting corescientific.com.
That's corescientific.com.
Go check them out today.
All right, guys.
Bang, bang.
I've got Adam here with me.
Adam, I thought a great place to start this conversation is the Bitcoin miners obviously like when Bitcoin's price goes up.
We've seen Bitcoin go very high.
It hit new all-time high.
But it happened before the halving.
And the Bitcoin halving, I think a lot of people question, is this good or bad for the miners?
So how do you think about these two kind of inputs into the next, call it, six months or so?
We have a high Bitcoin price before the halving, and then we have the halving coming.
And so how are you guys thinking about your business today?
Yeah, I think one of the big questions is, is the ETF, the mechanism for Bitcoin to go even more parabolic post-halving in a way where it's allowing more institutional investors, more retail investors access to the market?
If that's the case, then we might see a much different bull run than we've even seen in the
past where we actually see it go higher than we expected. But the Bitcoin run up prior to the
halving is actually creating a very interesting situation post-halving where a lot of the machines
on the network today are still going to be profitable post-halving. That's much different
than 2020, much different than 2016. And so as we look forward post-halving, we're looking at a
point where a lot of miners are going to be marginally profitable, and they're going to
going to stay online for kind of three to six months. So I think we're going to see a much
more drawn out process. And instead of seeing what we saw in 2022, where we saw a much more
sped up process in terms of crypto mining or Bitcoin mining companies and having failures,
you know, that's going to take a little bit longer and we might not actually see it until 2025.
And are there things that would affect how you view this, whether it is regulatory,
like kind of external shock uh could there be um other etfs that are approved that like draw
institutional attention away does the etf open up the floodgates for institutional capital
to kind of plow into mining and so you have more competition like how are you just thinking about
like other things that could happen in the industry outside of just this having moment
yeah i think right now what we're seeing is just the fact that more institutional investors are
looking at bitcoin miners because of the etf that's a trend that we've seen really since
starting in december where more institutional investors recognized the etf was coming
and we're trying to find other ways to play the etf launch you know bitcoin miners represent a
leveraged way to play on bitcoin because you're investing in a bitcoin miner in order to get a
multiple on the us dollars that you're investing in a miner versus just buying bitcoin and so
that's really one catalyst is i think institutional investors actually could present
uh kind of the next bull cycle for bitcoin miners whereas retail has generally driven that in the
past and the only institutional whole leadership you see really amongst bitcoin miners today is
mostly passive funds i think you're going to see a lot more large active funds taking positions
especially as these institutions get a lot smarter on our economics really for the first time those
are the questions we're getting from institutional investors explain your economics explain your
power costs explain your minor fleet explain your facilities explain your advantage we never heard
that before how does the evaluation change in conversations as they're having it with you like
if they know where your wallets are they should be able to see how many bitcoin that you're actually
mining uh if they know how you're treating that if you're selling it all if you're keeping it all
um do they have like more insight into what the revenue in a quarter is going to be for a
bitcoin miner that maybe they would say you know in a facebook or an amazon or anywhere else well
we're incredibly transparent on this point so we actually post our daily bitcoins mind every single
day. We like the fact that people can understand how our business is performing and they can judge
us in real time. They can also see the effects of weather events and when we have to curtail.
And so all of those factors, I think, are really good for institutional investors who are seeking
greater transparency. Initially, this was driven towards giving the masses access to more
information about the company. But now it's institutional investors that are saying,
yeah, if you're not doing that, it's a problem because we want to know how you're doing.
Other companies have similar type, I would say, information out in the market, whether because
they're running their own pool. But it's very difficult to know what some of the other miners
are mining on any given day. And as you're talking to these institutions, what are they
looking to do? Are they interested in investing with debt? Are they interested at just buying
the stock and kind of equity capital? And then how do you guys on the flip side of that think
about equity and debt to help fuel the business? Yeah. So today we have about $600 million in debt
and we have a number of different instruments that are all publicly traded. And so we have
a wider range of institutional conversations than I would say most miners in this space have.
We have convertible notes, we have term loans, and we have also we have warrants on the equity
side as well as our common equity. And so we have about six publicly traded instruments. And so
institutional investors find that fascinating. They love the fact that they can be trading
different instruments in a Bitcoin mining company. As we're thinking about going forward,
I would say over the long term, having about one turn of debt in this type of industry,
it's probably the right thing in a non-volatile environment. Because then if you get into a
downside scenario, let's say you're two turns or two and a half turns in a deep downturn.
But then in a bull case, you're at a half turn. I think there is a place for leverage in this
industry. The industry has historically been funded through equity. We've seen some players
take on debt. Minor equipment debt was definitely a pretty dangerous instrument for companies to
take on. I would say short-term amortizing debt in this industry, that's a dangerous place to be
because you have very short-dated fixed US dollar payments, and you're mining a volatile
commodity. And so it can create cash flow scenarios that are very tight. And so for us,
we're in a very good situation. Our debt's mostly four and five-year debt. And we have a lot of
optionality in the capital structure. I think that's really key. Convertible notes are really
interesting for miners. You're seeing it being used heavily by micro strategy. Obviously,
if Bitcoin outperforms, you have a chance to de-lever. And that's a great place to be.
And when you think about the strategy around, do you hold the Bitcoin or do you sell the Bitcoin?
You're mentioning like you're mining Bitcoin.
You're telling everyone, here's how much Bitcoin that we've mined.
But then you've got this like volatile commodity, as you call it.
You have fixed cash payments, both in debt and expenses.
And so what is the strategy?
Like, do you try to time the market?
Do you hedge?
Do you sell immediately?
What are you thinking?
Yeah.
I mean, for us right now, we are currently selling our Bitcoin on a daily basis.
What we're really focused on is operating extraordinarily profitably.
We're the best Bitcoin miner out there from a number of different angles,
and we're one of the largest Bitcoin miners as well.
We actually led a number of Bitcoin's mines since 2021. We're leading again in 2024.
So for us, we're really focused on driving additional growth into the company.
Other companies have really focused on diluting shareholders to pay for cost of revenue,
to pay for their OPEX so that they could put Bitcoin on balance sheet. Essentially,
that's shareholders buying Bitcoin at a massive premium. You could say that's a similar situation
with people buying MicroStrategy, but that you're buying into a leveraged portfolio of Bitcoin
in the MicroStrategy situation. For miners, you're just funding operating expenses so that
the miners can hold Bitcoin. For us, if we're going to continue to grow this business, we have
a massive growth portfolio of facilities ahead of us, of partially developed infrastructure,
and we have a lot of ambitions.
And if we want to achieve those ambitions,
we just can't be sitting on a significant amount of Bitcoin
because there's an opportunity cost to that
and it's going to come at the expense of our shareholders.
Now, what is the counter argument that most resonates with you?
Is it just like, hey, if Bitcoin goes up, then we're giving up upside.
But really, as a public company and as a fiduciary,
you're trying to manage the downside and kind of the Bitcoin volatility?
Absolutely managing the downside.
This business is about time and market.
If it's a mining company, you're playing for the three months a year, four months a year
where Bitcoin price outpaces hashrate growth.
So that's when mining economics expand rapidly and you have to be alive for those types of
bull market cycles because that's when you're making significant outsized returns.
So really that's our focus right now.
And the other part is we have better margins than all of our competitors at scale and many
the companies that are operating smaller as well so for us we're experiencing a much larger upside
going forward as bitcoin price expands than our competitors so from our perspective we don't need
to put bitcoin on balance sheet to experience the upside of a bitcoin full market what what drives
the kind of better margins for you guys lower power costs and better operations so you know
for us it's having the best hash rate utilization or one of the best hash rate utilizations in the
industry so that requires significant operating experience our team's run by mostly x traditional
data center folks so they know what it means to actually have very high uptime uh the other part
is software you know we had to build our own software stack we were the first institutional
miner in north america first one to 100 first one to 500 first one to 700 megawatts we had to solve
a lot of problems before people knew that they were problems and so for us it was build software
that makes our machines more efficient build software that allows our machines to run longer
all of those things contribute to a much higher hash rate utilization than others
and then talk a little bit about uh or um grew very quickly went to bankruptcy because that
emerged as a public company again and i think a lot of folks uh know only one part of the story
they know the fast growth they don't even know about the bankruptcy uh they know about the
bankruptcy but they don't know about the before and after so like just kind of like walk us
through how did the company grow so quickly uh and then why did it go into bankruptcy and is that
actually a risk for some of the other miners that they need to try to avoid yeah let's go back to
2021 big you know every public mining company was raising a specific amount of capital and the
market was rewarding aggressive growth we achieved the most aggressive growth strategy in the
industry we built the largest infrastructure footprint uh and really the best designs in
the industry which are allowing us to achieve these high hash rate utilizations now we went
public in january of 2022 uh we already had a significant debt load on on the company and so
as we went through 2022 network after it was increasing bitcoin price was decreasing and we
had the war in ukraine which jacked up power prices due to the natural gas spike and so all
of those things contributed to negative levered free cash flow which is essentially your free
cash flow after you pay for that and so we went we filed for chapter 11 december of 2022
In 2023, we went through a 13-month process starting in December, ending in January of 2024.
I joined the company actually in the middle of the Chapter 11 process, so in April of 2023.
And we were able to eliminate over $400 million in debt.
The main part of it was we were actually able to extend the maturities and include optionality in the capital structure.
So I talked about that earlier.
Optionality in a capital structure is incredibly important.
So for us, if our stock performs well, we have a warrant that is a cash exercise warrant that
brings in $670 million into the business, which more than double covers our non-convertible debt.
And then our convertible debt has a mandatory conversion feature. So between those two
instruments, we can be debt-free. And so that's really a highlight of going through that process
was just actually making the structure of our debt proper for a Bitcoin mining business.
because there is a structure that works and it includes long maturities and it includes
optionality in the capital structure and talk a little bit as to like you're coming in how much
of the team turns over in that situation both executive team and then also kind of you know
the employee base and like how do you change the business is it all just literally like
financial engineering and balance sheet and debt and kind of the things people would assume are
happening at bankruptcy? Or are there also things that either culturally or kind of with the
employee base that you've got to do to really make sure you're in a good position to come out
of a bankruptcy? Yeah, bankruptcies can be extraordinarily challenging for companies.
I would say when I joined the company, we had the best operations team in the industry.
Obviously, you need to have the best construction, operations, software team to actually build
all of that infrastructure at scale and build it that quickly. So I came in to a,
I would say, the most talented team in our industry. And so it was really about shifting
the focus of that team, really from hyper-aggressive growth to let's focus on drilling
into efficiency and making our operations the best they can possibly be. Because we knew we
were going to be on the playing field at some point in the near future. It ended up taking
another seven months to get back on the playing field of being a public company again. But it's
really about that shift in focus. But absolutely, there's challenges going through a Chapter 11
process. It's challenges with managing talent, challenges with, I would say, retaining top
performers. Luckily, everyone understood where we were taking this company. And when you have
a vision for the business, and you're executing on it, people want to be there. People want to
be a part of a huge success story. And we offer that, of course, scientific. We are a huge success
story here, having the most successful Chapter 11 process in terms of equity recovery. And then also,
So we maintained the largest Bitcoin mining company in 2023 from Bitcoin's mine perspective.
At a time when we had both hands tied behind our back and everyone thought we were a punching bag.
Turns out, you know, we came out, we're fighting even harder in 2024.
We're still mining more Bitcoins than everyone else.
And what are some of the challenges that you all look moving forward in terms of you have this halving event?
There's obviously like always the capital markets, but it almost feels like maybe the last two years were headwinds.
and now you guys are starting to get some tailwinds um what are the obstacles left or
what are the friction points that you you know you guys walk into the office every day say hey
we got to solve these things or put ourselves in a good position yeah so we announced a deal
with core we've actually on con or on an hpc deal you know that's something that we're trying to
solve over the course of 2024. so we've identified over 300 megawatts in our existing portfolio that
could be converted so you talk about the next big challenge you know that's the next big challenge
in our in our company right now and it's not a challenge as much as it's a massive opportunity
and everyone's really excited about executing on it and so i would say having is definitely
a challenge from the bitcoin mining side i think that presents an opportunity for us to buy a lot
of machines post having you know there's going to be a lot of challenged mining companies out there
you know going back to an earlier point 2024 is going to be a challenging year for a number of
miners who are only marginally profitable and they're gonna have to find ways to raise capital
the smaller they are the more challenges they're going to have in raising capital
and so for us it's the opportunity to refresh more machines post-having that's a huge upside
for us as a business and then part two is the opportunity to go execute on over 300 megawatts
of conversion of existing facilities into more traditional computing and when those pieces of
hardware are coming to market it seems like every like two years maybe you know three years um
i think miners have gotten their heads around you know how often they need to uh kind of update the
hardware but now there's companies like uh arodine and a few others that uh allow for either more
granular controls or you know different types of um clocking and like all these like very intricate
things how much of the focus here is like we gotta get cheap power we gotta be good at operating we
gotta have the latest version of the hardware versus there's like a technical component of
if we really optimize our software we can eke out extra profit and it's almost like a tech company
that's building infrastructure versus it's an infrastructure company that has some technology
how do you view it yeah i mean for us we had to solve a lot of issues that other folks didn't
know they had to solve and so we built software to manage that not only keeping the machines up
longer and more efficiently but also figuring out ways to overclock machines during the night time
or underclock machines when mining economics demand that to generate greater profitability.
We built all that stuff ourselves. And so when we evaluate new machines,
we always come at it from the eye of, are we paying for the value that we've already created?
I think what's interesting is 2025 is the year of democratizing hashrate. And what I mean by that is
there are a number of manufacturers coming to market. They're going to start mass producing
at the end of 2024 in 2025 they'll start hitting their stride in terms of being able to build
a large number of machines and they're going to change their pricing model from what we've
seen in the past and so what we've seen in the past is roi pricing essentially pricing machines
on a return on investment from about 12 to 14 months depending on what your economics are
and that's what we saw in 2021 we saw pricing go up to 80 a terahash now going forward that's
going to be much more challenging to raise prices that high when there are a number of manufacturers
who are going to price it on a cost plus model essentially a cost or a cost added to the
manufacturing cost and so that's really going to change the outlook in 2025 for capex for mining
companies and also who we're going to be buying from where the machines are going to be sourced
from and so i think that's a huge you know i would call it the major theme of 2025 versus how much
which hash rate is going to be on the network, because all of that's going to be determined by
market economics. The Bitcoin network is self-healing and it always has been, and that's
never going to go away. So that's going to make 2025 a really interesting year.
And as we're watching core built, what is like the long-term vision here? I see a lot of miners
now talking about artificial intelligence. I see all these different kind of shiny things that
people could go do. How do you all think about the business over the next, call it five to 10
years, maybe two to three Bitcoin halving cycles? Yeah. I mean, right now we're hyper-focused on
2028. The good part is we have the most nimble infrastructure in the industry. We built it,
our facilities like a traditional data center. And so we have a much easier time actually making
conversions. We also looked at a lot of our facilities from the perspective of being data
centers when they were initially purchased and so for us it's about having nimble infrastructure
the ability to execute on the highest opportunity the highest value of compute we possibly can
and do that over the next three years so that we're prepared for 2028 and so that we can solidify
how much or i should say we want to solidify that each of our facilities for bitcoin mining are
going to be profitable at the next having which is something that a lot of folks can't say today
you know we're seeing a lot of deals get done from for facilities that have very high power prices so
that companies that have over committed on machines can just bring machines online you know that's not
our game you know we're at our core we are a digital infrastructure company that attacks new
and emerging forms of compute so that's what we're targeting in 2028 have a healthy mix of hpc bitcoin
mining, and whatever other types of compute are going to emerge over the course of the next few
years, which we have an outstanding design team. We have an outstanding construction team. We have
an outstanding operations team. So from our perspective, we kind of tick all the boxes for
the major companies, whether it's GPU as a service, whether it's traditional AI companies,
all of those companies know that they can rely on us to provide them the best infrastructure
they can possibly access. Now, I've seen you comment about picking up cheap hardware from
other companies that struggle post-halving. Is this a industry where even with you focused on
2028, like the big guys get bigger as mining gets harder and the halvings occur? And so there's kind
of like consolidation that occurs over time? Yeah, I would say there's definitely going to
consolidation in terms of hash rate consolidation smaller miners are going to have a much harder time
refreshing machines going forward they haven't really started that flywheel of just being able
to constantly refresh machines and infrastructure that they've already built you know we're at that
point today and so if you take our existing facility you can essentially think about all
right if we're operating you know about 18.9 xash today if we convert all of our machines
to the newest generation machine, we could almost double that number.
And so that's what we're starting to see is really just that exponential growth of hash rate.
And that's okay, because as efficiency gets better for each of the machine,
that means the break even hash price lowers for each new generation of machine, which means you
can generate the same amount of gross profit, even at a lower hash price on a newer and more
efficient machine and so you're absolutely right we're going to see a lot of i would call it hash
rate consolidation amongst a few of the top players but we represent such a small portion
of the overall network all public bitcoin miners today are only about 20 percent of the network
so there's still a massive amount of decentralization going on all over the world
one of the data points that i saw online uh when i was kind of looking at a bunch of the miners that
that i found really interesting is um there was a chart and you all had more hash rate than marathon
or i'm sorry they uh marathon had more hash rate than you but you all had more bitcoin produced in
february than them and it comes down to this idea of minor utilization and i'm not picking on
marathon or you know anything but just like explain minor utilization and like how that
ends up impacting the business? And how volatile is that number for each company over time?
Yeah. So we actually post a good chart in our earnings deck. So it's half rate utilization
is the metric that a lot of people have become focused on. So that means for every exahash we
are running, for Core Scientific, we're generating about 10 more Bitcoin per energized exahash than
our competitors. Now, some of our competitors have actually, I would say, gamed their numbers
little bit by not actually telling the market how many machines they have running so they
have a lot of machines on the ground they hot swap them for us we tell the market exactly how many
machines we own and our hatch rate utilization still beats out all of our skilled competitors
and so from our perspective it's a you know it's a huge metric that we we really hang our hat on
because we don't have to have as much xash online as some of our competitors and we can still mine
more bitcoin than them goes down to a really talented operations team really talented software
team. And so that's definitely a metric that is in focus right now. You see it on Twitter
constantly, right? I don't know if you've seen it, but I would say the retail crowd
has really started to focus on this metric because it's about long-term longevity of
our business. Like if you can actually get better hash rate utilization than a competitor,
that means you're generating a better return on your machines.
And as we start to watch you guys expand, site selection obviously becomes a pretty
important detail. What goes into that?
You know, right now, we have 372 megawatts of partially developed infrastructure at two
of our sites.
So that, I would say, is less of a focus right now.
But we are continuously running searches for new sites, really on the cost of power side.
That's probably the biggest focus.
And finding areas that can provide lower power costs in exchange for intermittency.
So what I mean by that is essentially exchanging uptime for a lower power cost.
There's an efficient frontier of where you want to fall on that curve, but you're generally
willing to accept lower downtime or lower uptime in certain situations for lower power
costs.
And so we're constantly valuing those both domestically and internationally right now,
because the next generation of our facilities are going to be more focused on lights out
facilities.
A lot of people don't talk about those, but essentially run them like where the data center
industry is moving, which is have less people involved, have less people touching them,
because usually you get better uptime out of your machines. And we can solve a lot of the issues
through our software stack. So that's what we're focused on in the future. It's building out
facilities in very low-cost power centers that are essentially lights out. They need people to
only go to those facilities once or twice a week to maybe exchange out some machines.
But we already have those processes nailed down. Centralized repair centers,
We have an amazing parts inventory or centralized parts inventory warehouse.
We have all these systems already in place to manage this.
And so for us, that's the future, right?
It's smaller sites that are focused on lights out, grabbing better margins.
Because if you have lower power costs and you have lower facility level operating costs,
you're going to have a better margin profile.
And we can already manage a large number of facilities.
We have some facilities today easily blow that number out to 25, 50 facilities when you have no problem managing it.
But that's really where the industry is going to start moving to.
It's going to start moving away from some of these mega sites and start moving towards some of these smaller, more modular sites that provide a lot more optionality.
But you need to have the right operations team.
You need to have the right software stack.
Otherwise, you're going to really struggle to manage that infrastructure.
sure. And as you kind of view Bitcoin's price going up, what would change your guys' mind on
not selling the Bitcoin? Yeah, so right now, we're contractually obligated, according to our
debt covenants, or certain debt covenants, to sell our Bitcoin. Now, Bitcoin really begins to
perform well, and we're able to start paying down some of that debt. That will provide an
opportunity for us to be much more opportunistic. I would say holding Bitcoin on balance sheet
will require, I would say, a more liquid hedging market for Bitcoin and Bitcoin mining more
directly. Once that occurs, Bitcoin is going to be a much more viable commodity to hold in your
balance sheet or on your balance sheet. Because soon you're going to be running this very similar
to a trading desk where you're going to be trading like a traditional commodities company would.
And so that's definitely a place where you're actually going to start having Bitcoin on balance
sheet against some of your hedge positions. But right now, it's like we walked into 2023
expecting to mine between $13,000 and $14,000 Bitcoin. That's a massive amount of Bitcoin
exposure to have. And really, I would say the accounting change that we've seen for
if Bitcoin price increases, you can put that on your income statement.
Some of that is just noise. And a lot of investors already recognize that.
So I would say our focus, continue to execute on growth, continue to have the right mix
of cash on balance sheet versus paying down debt, and continue to grow the company.
And so Bitcoin on balance sheet is great for some companies who have large hodls.
And I would say we would start holding Bitcoin on balance sheet after we start to clear some
of that debt and utilize it for hedging purposes.
And what are the things that maybe the average investor who's looking at these mining companies
What are the things that they usually don't ask you or the things that they don't care about that you're like, as a person who thinks about capital allocation, these are the things when I look at a miner that I really, really pay attention to that maybe should be more important.
Yeah, I mean, we talked about hash rate utilization, but that's kind of coming in vogue now.
I would say it's really all in cost of power and what's the flexibility in the power rates.
you know, everyone puts their headline number in their decks. What's the power rate that you
were charged? That's not standardized today. I think in the future, companies are going to
have to present a standardized metric for presenting price of Bitcoin. And then I think
the next part is really related to what does your infrastructure look like? Because a lot of people
who've built infrastructure in the past haven't been performing proper maintenance on their
facilities. It's been a big focus of us is actually ensuring that these facilities can
operate for tens of years. And so we've been performing significant maintenance over time.
So we never incur these major outages. That's a huge risk. You're seeing it today with some of
the other large mining companies. Facilities go out and their Bitcoin production is low for
sometimes months at a time because they can't get the facility operational again. That's a place
a lot of investors haven't focused on in the past, but they absolutely need to because
infrastructure is a high capex item. And so if you're not maintaining that infrastructure,
it can present massive risks just a few years down the road after you've completed it.
Got it. And then lastly, like you joined during the bankruptcy, you're out of the bankruptcy.
What's been the biggest surprise as CEO of a company that's kind of gone through this
wild ride and now has the tailwind rather than the headwind?
I would say it's the investor base. People stuck with us through the Chapter 11 process.
Obviously, a lot of people were upset by it. But we came out a stronger company. I think a
lot of people recognize that we got the best equity recovery for equity investors in history,
in terms of percent of the company received. And so I would say we have a lot of loyal fans
out there. And I'm very thankful for all of them because they supported us in our darkest times,
and others supporting us as we've reemerged. And we've continued to absolutely pound the table
with all of our competitors and being the biggest mining company, even as we weren't able to grow
through our Chapter 11 process. So I think a lot of people recognize that and they've stayed loyal
to us. And I think that's been the biggest surprise for me. A lot of friendly notes from a
lot of investors out there, which I really appreciate. That's okay. They eventually all
all come around, right? No, they are friendly. That's what I'm saying. Yeah. Yeah. That'd be
just fine. Awesome. Where can we send people to find you on the internet or find out more about
Core? Yeah. On Twitter, underscore Adam, underscore Sullivan1, at Core, underscore Scientific.
Those are probably the two best places to find us is on Twitter. It's where we're the most active.
Awesome. Adam, thank you so much for doing this. And I also appreciate you coming
to our recent Bitcoin Investor Day.
People really, really enjoyed your comments.
And I think that the halving specifically
has some folks questioning,
is this positive or negative?
And to hear your enthusiasm
is I think somewhat calming to them.
So I appreciate your insights.
I think people really learn a lot from this.
We'll definitely do it again in the future.
Yeah, and I'll give a quick pitch
for the Bitcoin Investor Day.
Amazing conference.
The enthusiasm was flowing out of the facility.
It's an absolutely amazing event.
There's a lot of people there, a lot of really important people there, too.
So it's great to be able just to rub shoulders
to some of those folks walking up throughout the conference.
So great event.
I did not compensate you to say that, but I appreciate it very much.
All right. We'll do it again in the future.
Sounds great. Appreciate it.
