The Pomp Podcast - Kevin Kelly, Co-Founder of Delphi Digital: Crypto and The U.S. Pension Crisis

Episode Date: September 18, 2019

Kevin Kelly is the co-founder of Delphi Digital. In this conversation, Kevin and Anthony Pompliano discuss the macro economy, whether he thinks a recession is coming, where people should be watching o...ut for, the current pension crisis in the United States, dethroning the King Dollar, where DeFi plays into all of this, and whether an ETF is on the horizon or not. You can find additional resources and information here as well as Delphi's Weekly Market Commentary. BLOCKFI-----BlockFi allows you to keep your crypto, put it up as collateral, and receive a USD loan funded directly to your bank account. They do loans ranging from $2,000 to $10,000,000, and they're perfect for helping you reach your financial goals of all sizes. Visit BlockFi.com/Pomp to learn more about putting your crypto to work without having to sell it. CRYPTO.COM-----Crypto.com is a pioneering payment and cryptocurrency platform that seeks to accelerate the world's transition to cryptocurrency. With the vision of "cryptocurrency in every wallet", the Crypto.com App offers a full range of financial products with competitive pricing, well designed UX and high security. It is the best place to buy, sell and pay with crypto. COINMINE-----The Coinmine One is like an Xbox that turns your electricity into Bitcoin. You just plug it in, connect to wifi, and tap on the crypto you want. It’s so easy anyone can do it. Everything is controlled from the Coinmine mobile app and the Coinmine keeps getting better with over the air updates that add new coins, features and services to your Coinmine.  Visit coinmine.com/pomp to get a Coinmine and earn crypto for powering a new world.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 What's up, everyone? This is Anthony Pompliano. Most of you know me as Pomp. You're listening to Off The Chain, simply the best podcast in crypto. Let's kick this thing off. Kevin Kelly is the co-founder of Delphi Digital. In this conversation, we touch on the macro economy, whether he thinks a recession is coming, where people should be watching out for, the current pension crisis in the United States, dethroning the king dollar, where DeFi plays into all of this and whether an ETF is on the horizon or not. I really enjoyed this conversation and I hope you do as well. Want to know who has the best URL? Crypto.com. That's right. Crypto.com. They're a crypto platform with one goal. Mother f***ing mass adoption.
Starting point is 00:00:49 That's why we're all here. We're trying to get crypto in every wallet. Crypto.com is helping people do that through buying, earning, lending, and card payment. Everything you could want at crypto.com. Go help your boy out. Tell him Pomp sent you. Download the app or visit crypto.com. Pomp's got you always. Ever wanted to get into mining and didn't know how? Don't worry, your boy Pomp's got you. Everybody got some electricity and Wi-Fi. All you got to do is go to coinmine.com. You buy a CoinMine. It's like an Xbox or a PlayStation that helps you turn your electricity into bitcoin that's right you purchase it it shows up at your doorstep you pull it out of the box you plug it in connect to your wi-fi five minutes or less you're mining bitcoin all
Starting point is 00:01:34 you have to do is control it from the mobile app they provide and then you receive over-the-air updates that add new coins and new features on a consistent basis kind of like how tesla does over-the-air updates and updates the car software just you're updating your coin mine consumer mining made easy. That's right. Go to coinmine.com, tell them Pomp sent you, and thank me later. As many of you know, crypto investors store their digital assets on exchanges or in cold storage for long-term safekeeping. However, this strategy doesn't help them grow their investment holdings or build overall wealth. With the new BlockFi interest account, users can now securely store their Bitcoin or Ether at BlockFi and receive 6% annual interest paid monthly in cryptocurrency.
Starting point is 00:02:16 6% is an absurdly high rate. It's the best rate in the industry. I highly suggest you go check out BlockFi.com slash Pomp. Again, that's BlockFi.com slash Pomp to sign up and start earning crypto today. Anthony Pompliano is a partner at Morgan Creek Digital. All opinions expressed by Pomp or his guests on this podcast are solely their opinions and do not reflect the opinions of Morgan Creek Digital or Morgan Creek Capital Management. You should not treat any opinion expressed by Pomp as a specific inducement to make a particular investment or follow a particular strategy, but only as an expression of his opinion. This podcast is for informational purposes only. All right, guys. Bang, bang. I've got Kevin here. We've got the live stream going
Starting point is 00:03:01 as well. So we've got a whole bunch of stuff to tackle. Thanks so much for doing this. Yeah, thanks for having me. All right. Let's go through background first, and then we'll get into all the fun stuff. Yeah, no, for sure. So I started my career, I studied finance economics in undergrad, started my career at Bloomberg, knew I wanted to be in the market, specifically the equity markets in some capacity. Coming out of school, wasn't exactly sure where. So I started at Bloomberg as an equity fundamental analyst, later moved over to their independent research arm called Bloomberg Intelligence, which essentially is kind of similar to sell side research, equity research. And I was doing equity strategy there. So, basically what that means was, from a top-down perspective, more of kind of a macro strategist looking at global equity market trends and how the macro economy can affect those and trying to forecast where we thought the markets were going to go, kind of at a high level. And so, my path to Bitcoin, I'd say, was decently similar to a lot of other people, especially those who've come from the traditional finance world. First, actually heard about it or saw it in 2013. Like some people, I mean, I personally completely dismissed it, to be totally honest with you.
Starting point is 00:04:09 I thought it was fake internet money. It was breaking above, I think it was $1,000 at that point in 2013 when I first came across it. And I completely dismissed it, did none of my own due diligence, none of my own homework, and just kind of listened to what some of the financial pundits said, and then kind of came back around to it in 2016, really early 2017. What fascinated me at first was just that this thing was still around, right? That people were still talking about it. people were becoming increasingly more bullish on it and what its potential long-term valuation
Starting point is 00:04:37 proposition was. And so that's when I really started to kind of do my own homework and figure out exactly what this was. And that, I guess you could say, is the moment when I fell on the proverbial crypto rabbit hole. And it's kind of been off of the races ever since, to be honest. So you were not working at a crypto company when you came across crypto? No. What was the... You were at Bloomberg, right? Yes. Yes, I was. What was the general sentiment inside of Bloomberg in, what, 2016?
Starting point is 00:05:01 Yeah. So 2016, it was still, I mean, largely kind of flying under the radar. It really didn't get on, I guess you'd say, the radar of a lot of our strategists or research analysts until 2017, when you really started to see that run up. So probably summer of 2017, a few of my partners now at Delphi and I were actually trading some of this stuff, starting to actually invest capital into it. Again, continuing to get further and further down the rabbit hole of these different protocols and tokens and structures and things of that nature. And it was kind of funny that the run-up was, I mean, a lot of fun, obviously, for anybody who was a part of it. But it was interesting because we actually had a lot of our kind of like senior analysts that would look over at our desks. And, you know, we wouldn't be trading all day. But, you know, obviously, there were certain points where, you know, Bitcoin would fluctuate, you know, 10%, 15% in a single day. And I remember one time the S&P was down, I think, probably, you know, 1.5%, 150 bps.
Starting point is 00:05:56 And my job as an equity strategist is basically to figure out, A, why that's happening. and if we think that trend will persist. And I remember just thinking in my head, you know, I was almost becoming jaded to traditional market volatility because you'd see something like Bitcoin or some of these other altcoins that were, you know, ripping sometimes 60%, 70%, 100% a day. So it was a really interesting kind of dynamic. But when I left to start a crypto company, a research company with my partners,
Starting point is 00:06:20 the response was largely positive, I would say. It was positive in that we were going out to do our own thing. we were kind of, you know, being entrepreneurial. The flip side of that was anybody who was kind of in the traditional markets or had been there for years was basically like, you know, what the hell are you guys doing? You're basically betting your careers and your life on something that is extremely speculative and, again, still largely had the connotation of being, you know, fake internet, you know, magic money. For sure. So, you left to start Delphi Digital, which I sit on the board of directors of. Maybe give us a little update on what Delphi is and what the offerings
Starting point is 00:06:59 are. Yeah, no, for sure. So we're basically an independent research firm focused on the crypto and digital asset markets. On one side, we've got our research arm, which includes two subscription products, one for more institutional clients, high net worth individuals, starting to see some actual traditional institutions coming in and demanding research on this space, or at least trying to understand how they can get exposure to it. We also have a retail product that's a little bit more of a watered down version of our institutional product, but that includes weekly market commentary, thematic insights. So basically what we do is we're just an independent research arm. We're not attached to any asset manager, and we're basically trying to put out the most
Starting point is 00:07:36 objective research as we can on this space in terms of how to start to think about these things, how to value them. It's still obviously very, very early days and still very nascent market. So we actually love that aspect because we're able to, A, help kind of pioneer some of these valuation techniques, but also there's a lot of really good information and people that we've been able to connect with that are doing some really, really interesting things in terms of the valuation side of this. And we also incorporate a lot of, which I'm sure we'll get into in this conversation, a lot of the kind of global macro landscape and backdrop into our outlook for specifically Bitcoin, but crypto at large. Because as you know, I've been pounding the
Starting point is 00:08:14 table on this for a while, but I think you definitely have to have an understanding, at least a basic understanding of kind of where the macro landscape is taking us in order to have a real kind of idea of what the valuation potential of Bitcoin and crypto can be. So let's start with the macro economy. Just give us an overview of where you think we are across different markets. Yeah, so I mean, it's really interesting when you look out. On the surface, things don't appear to be that bad, right? You've got stock markets that are pretty much within striking distance of all-time highs.
Starting point is 00:08:47 Where it starts to get really kind of dicey is when you look beneath the surface and you see, you know, a slowing or deteriorating global growth outlook. And a lot of that's driven by, you know, trade wars and this kind of move more towards protectionism, especially with the debates going on with the U.S. and China. You've got now 17 plus trillion dollars in negative yielding debt, which, again, if you were, you know, even 10 years ago, but 50 years ago, I mean, that's just unimaginable to a lot of people. So we can talk about kind of how we got there and what the outlook is for that part of the market. And you've just had this kind of gradual shift out the risk curve for a lot of people, right, because you're no longer getting that type of yield or potential return or return potential from some of these asset classes. So where I think we're going to start to get pretty dicey and you're starting to see this show up in monetary policy, the European Central Bank this week, the ECB coming out, not only cutting their deposit rate by 10 basis points,
Starting point is 00:09:39 but the big kind of bazooka that they had that they were debuting was that they're going to revamp quantitative easing, right? So, essentially, that money printing process and trying to stimulate an economy that is simply just struggling, struggling to get growth, struggling to get inflation off the ground. The FOMC meeting next week for the Fed is the September meeting, and they're largely expected to kind of follow the same central bank race to the bottom in terms of more rate cuts, potentially restarting an asset purchase program. And so, again, a lot of this plays into our long-term valuation proposition for Bitcoin, because if you have this broad-based currency devaluation, you have to understand what it gets devalued against, right? And that's going to be these kind of real hard, you know, scarce assets. And obviously, Bitcoin, you know, fits right into that narrative. For sure. So, let's start on the macro economy.
Starting point is 00:10:31 You said a bunch of stuff there, but one of the things that I think is top of mind is this idea of quantitative easing becoming, you know, kind of the new normal, if you will. describe what quantitative easing is and then what the impact it has on both the legacy assets and then something like Bitcoin. Yeah. So quantitative easing essentially is basically central banks are now, when I say asset purchases, they're basically buying government bonds in Europe and Japan as well. Also buying corporate bonds. Japan's actually getting into the equity ETF market or has been in the equity ETF market. So basically what they're trying to do, long story short, is asset purchases to stimulate growth, right, kind of pump money into the economy. Hopefully that gets into the consumer's hands.
Starting point is 00:11:12 If it gets in the consumer's hands, that kind of wealth effect will translate into more domestic spending, faster growth, inflation will pick up, things of that nature. What's difficult is that that monetary policy can work when there's kind of pent-up demand for private borrowing, where I think we're kind of getting to the point where monetary policy is starting to push on a string and wish it won't be as effective is because, you know, you have to rewind and say, we are a debt-based economy, right? That's one of the realities that we live in. And so, when times are good, that's not necessarily a bad thing, right? That's not necessarily a bad thing, depending on what you use it for. And so, when times are good,
Starting point is 00:11:53 companies are borrowing, people are borrowing, and they're putting that towards, you know, productive assets or productive investments. That's how, you know, you can really spur economic growth, and the cycle kind of repeats, right? Where I think we start to get to the point where monetary policy becomes less effective is now you've had corporate companies go on a huge debt binge the last 10 years. Capital has been largely pretty cheap and easy to come by. And so if the demand for debt is no longer there, right, or is suppressed, cutting interest rates won't necessarily matter nearly as much, right? Because if you're a small business and you're saying, I don't need to take on any more debt. I'm good for now. If I cut rates from, let's say,
Starting point is 00:12:32 2% to 1%, it doesn't really necessarily matter because you're not in the capacity. You're not looking to add on to that debt or that exposure. So, what's tough is your monetary policy is probably going to be less effective. So, that means that the conventional ways in which central banks are trying to stimulate economies will probably get more and more into the unconventional realm, right, with more asset purchases, expanding the mandates for the assets that they can purchase. I mean, Japan, as I mentioned, is a really good example where they own something like 70% of the domestic ETF market, which is absolutely eye-opening. And when you think about how they unwind that balance sheet, right, how they actually sell those assets, if times and
Starting point is 00:13:11 growth does improve, I mean, there's no real easy way to do that. But long story short, how that has an effect on asset prices is a lot of that money from quantitative easing throughout this cycle ended up staying or getting trapped in the financial system, right? So it wasn't necessarily like the Fed or the ECB or anybody was pumping money into the system and it was going directly into consumers' hands, which we would consider something called like helicopter money, which is now a new proposal that's going to be on the table, I think, you know, in this next kind of easing cycle, because you want to be able to directly influence, right, the consumer's behavior and literally putting money in somebody's pocket is probably one of the best ways to do that.
Starting point is 00:13:46 it certainly has inflationary effects and potential. But now this whole kind of shift towards more dovish monetary policies is definitely one that we think is going to continue. And it's one of the reasons why you've seen not only Bitcoin run up this year, but also gold. There's a lot of similarities between the short-term drivers of gold and Bitcoin as well. For sure. So, one of the things that is definitely true is as economies start to struggle or enter these recessive periods, central banks have two tools. They can drop interest rates or they can print more money. Usually, they do both, or at least lately. I think that we're starting to see that that is the plan here as well.
Starting point is 00:14:27 But that leads to this third idea, right, which is the modern monetary theory, which you alluded to a little bit with kind of this helicopter money. Maybe explain what modern monetary theory is and kind of how that fits into the equation. Yeah. So, at a basic level, and I'll get into why, I think it actually does have a lot of merit, at least in the short term, but over the long term, I think can potentially run into some issues. And basically, what it says is that the government can essentially print as much money as it wants because it pays back its debts in that currency, right? So, hypothetically, we have $22-plus trillion in national debt here in the U.S. What's to stop the U.S. government from coming out and basically just printing that money and repaying those debts, right? And that's a very, very kind of watered down, simplified version of it, where I think that theory has a little bit of merit in the short term, because that's kind of essentially what we're starting to do, too, right? You see the fiscal deficit continues to increase.
Starting point is 00:15:22 The budget deficit continues to increase. You've got these fiscal stimulus plans with corporate tax cuts and no real way to kind of finance those. So these deficits in this national debt continues to grow. And it can continue to grow almost indefinitely because the U.S. is the U.S. dollar is a global reserve currency. There's a lot of benefits that come with doing that. We can basically finance our expenditure indefinitely. But where I think that does eventually hit a crossroads is that a lot of our debt is also internationally financed, which means that there's a lot of foreign holders of U.S. treasuries, for example.
Starting point is 00:15:59 And so, as soon as, and you're starting to actually see this play out with China and Russia and the, you had Mark Carney, for example, the BOE, Bank of England president, coming out in one of his recent speeches talking about the potential for, you know, not a Libra currency, but a Libra-like currency, right, that's more of kind of a non-sovereign, you know, digital currency for the world. This move away from the U.S. dollar, if that trend continues and people lose confidence in the fact that the U.S. can repay that debt, that's where I think we run into issues with this whole MMT theory, because we are dependent on foreign buyers of treasuries to help us. The demand for that debt is extremely dependent on some of these foreign buyers. If they lose confidence that we can repay this, or they lose confidence in the dollar as a reserve currency, then everything starts to shift. You'll have financing costs in the U.S. will increase, yields will increase.
Starting point is 00:16:54 And so if the dollar loses that global reserve currency status, that's where I think MMT really kind of starts to run into some troubles there. But again, that's just because we're still heavily dependent on the foreign perspective of U.S. debt and U.S. treasuries. For sure. So, one of the things that, to me, a lot of this is predicated on is there being some sort of recession or drawdown in the economy from growth, GDP, etc. What are you looking at from a data point standpoint that could be kind of the alert system, right, or kind of give us an early warning sign that a recession was coming? And then where do you personally think we are in terms of a potential recession occurring? Yeah, no, great question. So, one of the... All I do is great questions on this podcast.
Starting point is 00:17:46 Just set people up. No, one of the things that not only I look at, but a lot of the market looks at is the yield curves, right? So, you had a U.S. yield curve inversion, basically meaning that short-term yields or yields on shorter-term debt were above yields on longer-term debt. And the reason why people look at that as a potential indicator for a future recession is that if you think about how integral, you know, today's banking system is and the process of a bank connecting, you know, borrowers and savers and essentially being able to the spread between, you know, long rates and short rates is what, you know, where a lot of banks make some of their profits. And so the incentive to lend, right, is all well and good until you have an inversion, right, where you're actually, you know, that spread turns negative for you. as a bank. So, lending becomes, you're less incentivized to lend. And so, what's interesting, kind of tying this back to quantitative easing too, is that at the end of the day, a lot of the monetary policies are also indirect, right? So, they're not directly stimulating the economy,
Starting point is 00:18:46 they're indirectly doing it largely through the banking system. And you can lead a horse to water, but you can't necessarily make it drink, right? So, you can lead banks to all these conditions that make it profitable for them to lend, but at the end of the day, they don't necessarily have to lend if they don't want to. With a yield curve inversion, and again, you having this flip in rates, that also makes or disincentivizes them to lend as well, which easily can start to funnel into the real economy, right? Because again, we're very, very debt driven. So if you have the credit cycle start to tighten up, if credit becomes harder to get, if capital becomes harder to get, it can really start to slow or accelerate that slowdown in economic growth. And that's one
Starting point is 00:19:23 of the key indicators that a lot of people look for. There's a number of other ones like the US PMI, ISM. It's usually a pretty decent leading indicator because that looks at manufacturing growth and the expectations as well for what some of these manufacturers are expecting in terms of whether the economy is going to be contracting or expanding. And so those are probably two of the big ones that I look at. But there's a number of indicators. And I've got a chart book that when we release this podcast, we can send out as well with some of this stuff and some of these other indicators that we watch. But there's a lot of things. I mean, the credit cycle is extremely important. But again, it's also looking at kind of consumer sentiment. Right now, the U.S. economy
Starting point is 00:20:03 looks pretty good relative to the rest of the world, but it's largely driven by the consumer, right? So, if you have any kind of sell-off in the market or loss in consumer confidence, that certainly could kind of accelerate the timeline for a U.S. recession, which, again, will bleed into the global economy. So in terms of timeline, I mean, I don't think we get a recession here in the next, let's say, three to four quarters, but I definitely think in that 18 to 24-month window, that's where I would put my bets that we'll certainly see some type of recession. Got it.
Starting point is 00:20:38 And so when that recessive period hits, obviously, the central banks have their tools that they'll use to try to combat it and keep prices stabilized, if not continue to increase. But we don't give investment advice here. But maybe just mention some of the assets that you would keep an eye out in terms of as we enter into that recessive period, they would benefit from cutting interest rates, printing money, and maybe even some MMT going on. Yeah, so when you have interest rates cut and you have these kind of stimulative measures taken by central banks, a lot of risk assets actually tend to benefit, right? So this is kind of a little bit more outside of the recessionary period or just immediately following the recessionary period. If you think about stocks in 2008, 2009, you know, beginning of March 2009 was actually the best time to buy stocks. That's literally when they bottomed.
Starting point is 00:21:26 Hindsight being 2020, I mean, obviously, you know, it was very, very tough to predict that that was the bottom for the market. And if you actually look at headlines on the day that the market bottomed, they're pretty hilarious because, you know, again, a lot of people were coming out and a lot of the financial headlines were saying that, like, this was just the start, right? Like, everything, the world was at that point pretty much looking like it was coming to an end. And so, the best time to buy is usually when things are out of favor or when everyone hates a certain asset class. When you get into recessionary periods, it's tough to say that in a recessionary period, risk assets usually sell off more than your safe havens like your bonds or even your gold. Because investors want to try and preserve as much wealth as they can. So, you're going to flood into things like U.S. treasuries. You're going to flood into potentially safe haven assets like gold.
Starting point is 00:22:12 So those tend to outperform. But in absolute terms, a lot of assets in general lose a significant amount of their value because correlations kind of rise to one when everyone's panic selling. And so this also kind of bleeds into, you know, we talk about Bitcoin and what its potential performance could be in the next recession, right? Or if you do see kind of a market panic and sell-off, you know, I think it really depends, again, when that happens, obviously, because the macro narrative for Bitcoin has gotten a lot stronger, you know,
Starting point is 00:22:40 even in the last six months, which is pretty incredible to see because you don't have a lot of conversations that you're having, you know, with different macro strategies coming in and basically making the point or the use case or the long-term value proposition for something like Bitcoin, right? But if investors continue to see this as more of a risk asset, right? Because it is still a very kind of unproven, as incredible of an innovation as it is, it's still very unproven, right? It doesn't have a long track record, certainly nothing compared to something like gold. Its volatility is still very high, which we can get into, but I don't view that necessarily as a bad thing. You have to expect that with such a smaller market compared to something like gold,
Starting point is 00:23:16 which is extremely liquid. But I think long story short, Bitcoin probably takes a bit of a hit heading into the next market panic or when the next market panic happens. And you see panic selling and you get into this recessionary time. But at the same time, and you've seen this in gold historically as well, where people are trying to sell the most liquid assets they have. They're basically selling out of just about anything, right? So gold initially can take a hit and then longer term, you know, outperform some of these risk assets as that safe haven. I think you'll see something similar with Bitcoin. But what's, again, really fascinating to me and Doss is there is no historical precedent for this, right? So Bitcoin could absolutely rip up, you know,
Starting point is 00:23:56 the next time you see a huge market panic and huge market sell just because of its, you know, uncorrelated nature, but you could also see correlations rise with risk assets like we've seen, you know, in Q4 2018 was a great example where, you know, the market, you know, stock market fell off a cliff and Bitcoin and the crypto market also, you know, kind of followed suit as well. So, you know, I think it's tough to say which way that's going to go, but there's certainly arguments for both sides of the coin, so to speak. No pun intended. Yeah. So one of the things that people are definitely, especially in the Bitcoin community, talking about is this idea that Bitcoin could rise to be the global reserve currency. It could dethrone the dollar. I think that there's
Starting point is 00:24:38 other countries around the world, Russia, China, et cetera, who have openly come out and been combative towards the U.S. dollar system. They've said it's too expensive. It causes too many issues. There's too much risk involved from a macroeconomic and also from a national security standpoint for them. What are your thoughts around the dollar being the global reserve currency, the ability for somebody, either another country or a decentralized currency, to kind of dethrone it? And what's the impact to that global economy if that was to happen? Yeah. So, I think it's important to kind of put in perspective why the dollar today serves as the global reserve currency, right? One of the more heavily cited reasons and one of the more
Starting point is 00:25:16 obvious reasons is because it is, by and large, the most heavily used kind of transactional currency. A lot of the commodity markets are priced in U.S. dollars. Even more developing countries that are exchanging goods and services oftentimes will actually exchange those in dollars themselves because, again, those economies and those local currencies experience a lot of uncertainty, a lot of volatility. The dollar is heavily used in global commerce. The other reason why I think it's going to be longer to dethrone the dollar, it's going to take a little bit longer than most people think is because the network effect that, bring this back to the treasury market, the network effect that U.S. treasuries have as a global reserve asset. So when you think
Starting point is 00:25:59 about global reserves and FX reserves for these central banks, it's not literally like they're holding just, let's call it hundreds of billions of dollars in cash and U.S. dollars just sitting in a vault. They actually hold U.S. treasuries and things they can earn some type of yield on, or at least some type of yield up until 12 months ago. And so, I think the network effect of the U.S. Treasury market, because it is one of the most liquid markets on the planet, is going to keep the U.S. dollar at least in reserve currency status for the foreseeable future, because what is going to be your replacement, right?
Starting point is 00:26:33 Bitcoin, again, long-term, we think could certainly challenge it as an alternative global digital reserve asset, for sure. But I think the path to, you know, we'll say we'll call it adoption there or the path to central banks actually, you know, allocating or starting to accumulate this, I think is going to be a lot longer. Because, again, what is going to replace, you know, U.S. Treasuries or the dollar as a global reserve asset when you have structural issues going on with, let's say, the euro? You have Brexit with the pound. You've got the Chinese yuan that's starting to become more and more of a dominant player in the global FX markets. But at the same time, there's a lot of risk there and there's a lot of tension there, obviously, with the U.S.-China trade tensions and this move more towards protectionism. So I think longer term, potentially, you could actually get something that's more like what Mark Carney proposed, like a Libra-type non-sovereign currency that a lot of these countries move more towards initially. Bitcoin long term, again, you know, certainly has that value proposition to be an alternative global reserve asset.
Starting point is 00:27:37 But, you know, the dollars, I guess you could say network effect, so to speak, is kind of ironic because we're talking about something that, you know, Bitcoin's network effect is obviously a huge reason for its value proposition long term. The dollar is a very, very kind of similar in that sense where everybody holds treasuries. All these central banks hold treasuries because it's the most liquid, and the liquidity comes from most of them holding U.S. treasuries and being able to sell or buy when economic crisis potentially happens, or they're trying to basically prop up some of their local currencies. So, network effects can kind of go both ways. It's pretty interesting, at least from my side of the table, when you think about it from that perspective. So, part of this is definitely that there are traditional fiat currencies. then there is Bitcoin as a decentralized or non-sovereign currency. Is there a hybrid between the two, right? Do we see some of these countries who say, look, I understand that digital
Starting point is 00:28:34 currencies are going to be a thing. I see the value proposition for the end user. I have a monetary policy that I want to continue to pursue and implement on the world or at least on my country. I'm actually going to issue a central bank digital currency or a digital currency that taking my monetary policy and combining it with the technology. And that's my kind of foray into this future world where I can disrupt myself from a technology standpoint, but keep the same monetary policy intact. Yeah, so I think where it becomes tough to make that argument is when you think about just monetary policy, right, from an individual country standpoint, and even the I mean, the euro, right, the ECB, you know, overseas, it's not just, you know, one country that's that's
Starting point is 00:29:16 subject to the ECB's monetary policy. It's a large portion of Europe. I think where it gets pretty tough to have some type of hybrid is because you're almost surrendering your independent or your objectivity, more so independence for your country's monetary policy if you go into some type of hybrid structure. I do think there will be a place for, and I continue to use Libra because it's the easiest example. It's one that's actually been proposed, but a kind of non-sovereign collection of different fiat currencies, mainly the stable ones like the euro, the dollar. I think there will be some type of hybrid digital currency that plays out, whether it's Facebook's Libra or whether it's something else that comes to market.
Starting point is 00:29:57 I definitely think there's a lot of potential for that. And central bank digital currencies in general, I think that's just the way in which these markets are going to move. They're still going to be denominated in fiat, right? So creating China's central bank digital currency, If you create a digital version of the yuan, which largely a lot of fiat money today is digital anyway, there's a lot of potential efficiencies that could be realized. There's a lot of questions about surveillance as well. But at the end of the day, it's still subject to that monetary policy of whatever the country is that's issuing it, right? So I think you're going to see a broad-based move to central bank digital currencies. But I don't necessarily think that they'll forfeit their independence for their monetary policies through some type of hybrid structure, because, again, that's kind of how monetary policy has developed over time is to be not only independent but flexible enough so that when something happens, whether times are good or times are bad, monetary policy can adjust.
Starting point is 00:30:53 And you've seen a lot of problems even in Europe with the countries that use the euro because, you know, the ECB basically has to take into account all these different countries, right, that have different current economic situations going on, right? Some are operating in surpluses, some are in deficits, some are really struggling to, you know, get economic growth going, some are probably a little bit better off. So you have to kind of balance those. And you've seen a number of different examples where even something like a euro has proved the use case potentially for, you know, more independent country dependent monetary policies. So I think a hybrid structure would be certainly interesting, something to look into, but I don't think it would necessarily take off. For sure. And then you mentioned Libra a couple of times. Obviously, that is, I'll put it in the bucket of another type of hybrid where you don't have sovereign nations backing it. You instead have corporations. Those corporations have geographic diversity and they try to come together and create a global currency to compete with sovereign currencies and then also with Bitcoin. Maybe talk a little bit about how you and the team at Delphi have thought about this and kind of where your thoughts are today in terms of their ability to launch this and actually get adoption. Yeah, I think it's kind of interesting, too. If anybody else came out and Facebook's name was not attached with Libra, I think the conversation would honestly be drastically different. The fact that it was under the Facebook name, obviously they've incurred a ton of scrutiny over the last few years with data privacy issues and all of that.
Starting point is 00:32:24 I think just by nature, they kind of put themselves in a hole by having it attached to Facebook. But the idea of Libra, which, again, if you go through and you read that white paper, there's really only a handful of currencies that are out there that meet the criteria that they've laid out. It has to be an extremely liquid. It has to be part of countries that are developed and relatively stable. So you're not going to see a ton of emerging market currencies get put in there. So when you think about, again, the reserve assets or the reserve currencies of the world today, the dollar, euro, the yen, specifically the dollar as well,
Starting point is 00:32:56 One of the other criteria was that in order for the Libra Association, which, again, if you're a token holder in the Libra Association, you've actually got rights to the interest on these reserve assets. Tying it back to negative yielding debt, I mean, the U.S. dollar is one of the only currencies or deposits where you would actually put a lot of those reserve assets because you've got negative yields elsewhere in Europe and certainly in Japan as well. So I think that type of structure is certainly very interesting. It's also interesting that U.S. regulators have kind of been on the forefront of the scrutiny behind Libra when, if we're talking about the threat to the dollar as a global reserve currency, Libra is actually one of the things that potentially could help it because, again, it is probably the most attractive reserve asset to put into that basket just based on the different incentives that have been built into Libra. But I certainly think that whether it's Facebook or somebody else, that type of structure will get done. I think it won't really hit mainstream adoption until you have some type of central bank involvement, as potentially unfortunate as that is. I don't think governments are going to really surrender their ability to try and at least attempt to control monetary policy and attempt to control their currencies to somebody like a Facebook or Libra. I don't think it certainly serves as a huge threat to fiat currencies because, again, it's literally made up of them.
Starting point is 00:34:21 But I do think that how that plays into Bitcoin, too, with Libra and Calibra, the wallet itself, if you're actually able to use something like Libra and then transact or hold digital assets like Bitcoin, I definitely think it could accelerate the adoption of this space and the usage of crypto assets and digital assets in general. But I don't think necessarily that, again, Libra, the way in which it's been designed, I don't necessarily think that it'll get off the ground without some type of regulator stepping in and really kind of, I don't want to say hold-handing, or hand-holding, but having some type of influence on its launch and kind of how it gets to market. For sure. And so if Libra is probably not a great competitor, the central bank digital currencies are OK. Bitcoin obviously is a very, very strong competitor. And you've got the fiat currencies.
Starting point is 00:35:14 At what point does the Federal Reserve and central banks just say, look, we have to hedge. And so let's go buy Bitcoin and put it on our balance sheets. Is there specific moments or data points and inflection points that you're like, look, these are the things that I would watch out for for that to happen? Or do you think it's some much more of like a policy decision and it's less affected by data or things that are happening in the global economy? Yeah, it's a great question. And it's there's no real. All I do is great. Yeah, I guess I'm giving you props for those.
Starting point is 00:35:44 Want to know who has the best URL? Crypto.com. That's right. Crypto.com. They're a crypto platform with one goal. Mother mass adoption. That's why we're all here. We're trying to get crypto in every wallet.
Starting point is 00:35:58 Crypto.com is helping people do that Through buying, earning, lending, and card payment Everything you could want at Crypto.com Go help your boy out Tell him Pomp sent you Download the app or visit Crypto.com Pomp's got you, always Ever wanted to get into mining and didn't know how?
Starting point is 00:36:16 Don't worry, your boy Pomp's got you Everybody got some electricity and Wi-Fi All you gotta do is go to CoinMine.com You buy a CoinMine It's like an Xbox or a PlayStation that helps you turn your electricity into Bitcoin. That's right. You purchase it.
Starting point is 00:36:31 It shows up at your doorstep. You pull it out of the box. You plug it in, connect to your Wi-Fi. Five minutes or less, you're mining Bitcoin. All you have to do is control it from the mobile app they provide, and then you receive over-the-air updates that add new coins and new features on a consistent basis. Kind of like how Tesla does over-the-air updates
Starting point is 00:36:50 and updates the car software. Just you're updating your coin mine. Consumer mining made easy. That's right. Go to CoinMind.com, tell them Pomp sent you, and thank me later. One more word from our sponsor, BlockFi. Their new interest account allows you to securely deposit your Bitcoin or Ether at BlockFi and receive 6% annual interest paid monthly in cryptocurrency. This rate actually compounds, so you receive a 6.2% APY,
Starting point is 00:37:17 which is very attractive given the alternatives. So you can actually take your Bitcoin, you can deposit it with BlockFi, and get paid an interest rate of 6% in return. Go check out BlockFi.com slash Pomp. Again, BlockFi.com slash Pomp to sign up and start earning interest on your crypto today. If Libra is probably not a great competitor, the central bank digital currencies are okay.
Starting point is 00:37:43 Bitcoin obviously is a very, very strong competitor. And you've got the fiat currencies. At what point does the Federal Reserve and central banks just say, look, we have to hedge. And so let's go buy Bitcoin and put it on our balance sheets. Is there specific moments or data points and inflection points that you're like, look, these are the things that I would watch out for for that to happen? Or do you think it's some much more of like a policy decision and it's less affected by data or things that are happening in the global economy? Yeah, it's a great question.
Starting point is 00:38:10 And it's there's no real. All I do is great. Yeah, I guess I'm giving you props for those. It's I'll put it this way. It's an interesting question, right? Because I don't think there's any real timeline on saying, you know, 12 months from now, for example, could central banks come out and buy Bitcoin? I think it really depends on, again, if you think about what reserve assets and the purpose
Starting point is 00:38:28 that they serve, right, especially for central banks, basically having the liquidity to be able to get in and out of these things, right? It's one of the reasons why gold is still, you know, a significant portion of global reserve assets, right? And if you look at the trends in gold demand, right, and gold's ripped up this year, a lot of that, too, is central banks continuing to purchase and buy and accumulate more gold. The liquidity of the gold market is not quite that of U.S. Treasuries, but it's certainly extremely high compared to some other liquid alternatives. So, I think Bitcoin has to have
Starting point is 00:39:00 the liquidity to be able to support something like central banks getting into this, accumulating some, and then being able to actually offload that if they need to, and be able to get into that in a relatively easy way without a ton of slippage. I think liquidity has to develop for Bitcoin, which again, if we continue on this route of not only this was obviously a largely retail driven, you know, phenomena, but now getting more institutions involved, the liquidity can certainly develop for it. But I don't think you kind of get to that point where central banks take it seriously or potentially consider it as a reserve asset, at least in a large enough quantity to move the needle until they have, you know, until the market has that liquidity
Starting point is 00:39:36 to be able to support, you know, how they actually interact or use, you know, reserve assets. For sure. And then you mentioned the idea or the difference between the institutions versus retail and then obviously central banks. One of the things that a lot of people are looking for in the Bitcoin industry is the ETF. So there's tons and tons of talk about the ETF. There's been a number of proposals or applications. There's two still being considered, both Bitwise and then the VanEck ETF applications. What's the thoughts there in terms of how viable are those?
Starting point is 00:40:09 what's the likelihood that they get passed, and would it have a major impact on price and adoption of Bitcoin? Yeah. So, I think longer term, and by longer term, I mean, let's call it three to five years, I definitely think you're going to have some form of a Bitcoin ETF approved. Whether that happens in the next six months or not is obviously definitely up for debate. I think there's still some things that regulators are concerned about, especially the SEC in terms of potential price manipulation on these spot exchanges. I do think, and this is one of the things that we're digging into now and the potential effects of something like back coming into the market, where again, you're not as reliant on these spot exchanges for the actual
Starting point is 00:40:51 Bitcoin price quotes. If you could tie an ETF to that type of pricing source, I definitely think they could potentially accelerate the potential approval of a Bitcoin-backed ETF. But in terms of what it'll do to the market, I mean, again, this kind of gets outside of the, you know, obviously not your keys, not your Bitcoin argument. And it's not us saying that, you know, that's the best way for people to get exposure to it. But again, if you're just thinking about this from a pure kind of investment or investable asset class, if you look what happened with gold, right, with the first kind of exchange traded products and arrival of ETFs in the early 2000s, part of the reason why gold really ripped throughout, you know, the early 2000s and
Starting point is 00:41:30 really into the late 2000s, up until about 2010, 2011, was, one, because the dollar was getting a bit weaker, but at the same time, the accessibility for investors to get into these products. So now you could actually trade or invest in a gold-backed ETF, and it was much easier than actually going out and either buying physical bullion or locking up on some of these maybe closed-end funds. The just increase in accessibility in these products that were brought to market market for both retail and institutional investors was part of the catalyst that led to the explosion in gold's price right from the early 2000s onward.
Starting point is 00:42:09 And what's interesting today is that if you look at these investment vehicles, and this kind of gets into the argument of Bitcoin versus gold, there was a period in the early to mid-summer where Bitcoin and gold had a very, very high correlation with one another, right? And everyone's kind of like, this is it. This is the moment. Bitcoin's now proving its safe haven kind of store of value argument. it's trading in line with gold, which again has centuries and centuries of history to back it in
Starting point is 00:42:35 terms of its safe haven asset classification, then that correlation kind of broke down a bit. And when you think about it just from the incremental buyer perspective, there aren't nearly as many ways for people to actually buy Bitcoin in some type of ETF or investment vehicle as there are with gold, right? So you wouldn't necessarily expect them to trade in line with one another nowadays, because again, the markets are very different in terms of their size of liquidity, but also who that incremental buyer is and the accessibility to something like Bitcoin versus the accessibility to gold. So long term certainly can lead to an explosion in adoption and at least people getting exposure to it, which would then feed into Bitcoin's price
Starting point is 00:43:12 and value potential. But I think in terms of timeline, I don't think we necessarily get one maybe in the next six months or so, but definitely longer term, three to five years. I think that's certainly going to be a vehicle for people to be able to invest in, not only from the institutional standpoint, but financial advisors and people that are trying to put money into 401ks and things of that nature. Got it. So I want to switch gears for a second and talk a little bit about the pension crisis going on, specifically in the US. A lot of people probably are not aware that majority of the pension funds in the country are underfunded. Maybe just talk a little bit about what's going on there and how some of the crypto and Bitcoin could potentially be a solution.
Starting point is 00:43:54 Yeah, you want to talk about the potential risk that's just kind of hiding blatantly in the shadows. And it sounds kind of contradictory, but the size of, to your point, the size of the underfunded pension problem continues to only really get worse. You've seen a little bit of improvement here in the last few quarters. But what's really interesting is that the way in which pension funds work, too, when we talk about underfunded, it's basically what their assets are. I think about kind of the investments that they have, right, the assets they have in their books versus longer term what they're supposed to pay out or they're liable to pay out to their former employees as they start collecting pensions, that underfundedness, right? So comparing your liabilities to what your assets actually are, what's really, really difficult is that you have these underfunded pensions and the problem is becoming worse at the same time when, again, you have stock market. You have the stock market within striking distance of an all-time high.
Starting point is 00:44:45 One of the best 10 years for risk assets that we've seen, again, in decades. So, when times are technically good, if you still have this underfunded pension problem, what gets really scary is what happens when times turn? What happens when you get a drastic sell-off in bonds, which potentially leads to a repricing in stocks and risk assets? And let's say the stock market loses 20%, 25%, 30% of its value. Now that funded ratio gets even worse, right? And where I think this, again, kind of potentially leads into this larger global macro backdrop is in the economic growth and kind of who your incremental buyer is and consumer spending
Starting point is 00:45:24 and all of this. The more and more people that retire, demographics are obviously moving against us. If pension funds either go under or have to be bailed out or simply just cut the benefits they promised people, well, now that leads to less spending, right? Less spending in the economy. more people trying to save, and that, again, can have these kind of vicious circle effects that can really, really lead to some pretty significant drawdowns, not only, again, in risk assets, but in the global economy at large.
Starting point is 00:45:53 So that's one of the kind of underlying risks that's a lot longer term, because I don't think there's going to be a domino that falls that necessarily upends the entire global economy because of this. But especially here in the U.S., I mean, it's a huge problem, and it's one of the reasons why we're talking to some of these more conservative institutions. Again, we'll never say to sell everything and put all your eggs in the crypto or Bitcoin basket. But when you think about the asymmetric return opportunity of something like Bitcoin compared to the outlook for traditional asset classes,
Starting point is 00:46:23 that asymmetric opportunity becomes extremely compelling when you finally can convince people that the next 10 years are probably not going to be nearly as lucrative as the last 10. Yeah. And part of it, I guess, too, is, you know, Mark Yusko and I talk about this a lot in that a lot of times people make investment decisions based on the performance of the asset for the last 10 years. They don't look out and say, well, what is it going to do for the next 10 years? And so that's one really, really important thing. And the second thing is the correlation is really important, right?
Starting point is 00:46:56 And so just modern portfolio theory, if you add together a ton of assets that are non-correlated, you actually end up reducing your risk. Can you talk a little bit about how Bitcoin fits into that modern portfolio theory and then the outlook for various asset classes moving forward for the next 10 years? No, so spot on. I mean, if you look at an uncorrelated asset, because again, when you have fluctuations in stocks and bonds, and this year, actually, there's been a higher correlation between the two. Usually, you have bonds trading inverse with stocks because, again, one's looked at more as kind of a safe haven asset or a flight to safety asset when things go wrong in risk assets like stocks. You've seen that correlation trend positive this year. But to your point, the uncorrelated nature of Bitcoin actually allows you to reduce the overall portfolio risk itself, right? So the uncorrelated non-sovereign asset is certainly probably one of the strongest arguments for including it in a portfolio today.
Starting point is 00:47:50 Again, just based on that asymmetric return profile and the fact that there are certain periods where historically, if you look over long time periods, Bitcoin largely uncorrelated to any asset, whether it's stocks, bonds, even gold or other commodities. But it also has times in which, over the short term, it trades at a high correlation with stocks, for example, on that Q4 2018 sell-off. Then, beginning to middle of this summer, it traded much more in line with gold, while stocks were selling off and at a negative correlation to stocks. So, the fact that it is and is proving itself to be a largely uncorrelated asset certainly makes a strong argument for portfolio inclusion. In terms of the outlook for traditional asset classes now, and we've got data to support this. when you look at the next 10 years, just to make it easy, if you look at U.S. 10-year treasury yields, the fact that that is sub-2% or below 2% right now, that's one of the best predictors of what your longer-term returns, that 10-year return, will be on that asset. Let's say you're
Starting point is 00:48:48 getting, we'll call it 2%, maybe 3% on treasuries over the next 10 years. You look at stocks, which there are certainly pockets of the market that are still, I would argue, a bit undervalued. But by and large, especially when you look at price-to-sales ratios, a large part of the stock market is overvalued. Valuations are a very, very poor timing mechanism, right? So, people have been arguing the S&P was overvalued for the last five years now. If you sat out of this market, obviously, you've been kicking yourself because it's pretty much, I mean, not in a straight line, but pretty much gone up and to the right. they what valuations when i say valuations they think like price to earnings ratios things of that nature what they are really good are longer term return predictors right so if you look at
Starting point is 00:49:30 and you just look at the inverse correlation between um or i should say the inverse relationship between high equity valuations and then the subsequent 10-year returns on the s&p 500 looking back over um you know about a century they move very very closely with one another so when you have valuations that are at these levels, the expected return over the next 10 years is much lower than if you were buying it, you know, let's say bottom of 2009, when pretty much everything was, you know, fire sale and on sale. Those are typically the best times to buy because everything looks cheap, right? A lot of things today look expensive. So if you put this all together and you say, okay, I'm not really getting, if you're a pension fund, you're trying to get, let's call
Starting point is 00:50:06 it 70% a year, where are you actually going to get that return from, right? You're not going to get it, obviously, in government bonds. You're probably not going to get it in stocks, especially like U.S. large caps, which have absolutely crushed. So, the argument to put in something like a Bitcoin, which really does have that return potential at a very small allocation, really, if you can convince more institutional investors or high net worth individuals of that kind of outlook for traditional asset classes, that argument for portfolio inclusion becomes a lot easier. For sure. And I guess from that also, there's the qualitative argument of, hey, Bitcoin is a better piece of technology is going to be adopted, you know, all of that.
Starting point is 00:50:47 But then there's the quantitative argument, which we're talking about, which is non-correlated asymmetric asset. And for me, what I found is that the qualitative argument is very easy to debate for institutional investors, but the quantitative one is much, much more difficult to debate, and they actually are more receptive to. Yeah. And again, I think in order to understand that long-term value proposition of, and it's not to dismiss the technology, right?
Starting point is 00:51:10 technology is an absolute incredible innovation. But when you think about specifically Bitcoin as this long-term, non-sovereign, digital gold, store of value alternative, that value proposition is really going to be driven by a lot of the other things that are happening in the macro backdrop around it. And that's why we think that right now the macro backdrop is primed for the next 10 years for Bitcoin to really be one of the best performing asset classes is because that backdrop is primed for it to do that. Nothing operates in isolation like we talked about, not only uncorrelated returns, but there are a lot of, if you think about the psychology of investing, depending on how stocks and bonds in your overall portfolio trades, you might be more inclined to buy a
Starting point is 00:51:56 certain asset versus others. Again, coming back to when you look at the outlook the next 10 years for your portfolio, you're trying to find the assets that will at least help you preserve that wealth, but also obviously grow that. It's one of the reasons why you continue to see growth assets and you're seeing these multi-billion dollar IPOs with multi-billion dollar losses. You're seeing people get pushed further and further out the risk curve and trying to find these growth assets. Another reason why growth has outperformed value for much of the last decade is people are getting pushed further and further out the risk curve trying to find these assets that, again, will give them that value appreciation and they're willing to pay higher
Starting point is 00:52:34 of multiples for, right? Which is the definition of kind of what a growth asset would be. So, you know, I definitely think it's a very interesting dynamic. The technology, to your point, you can argue back and forth. And again, is there a, you're going to hate me for this, is there a non-zero chance that this all doesn't work and Bitcoin goes to zero? Yes, right? There's a non-zero chance. You have to, and you have to be upfront about that and you have to understand that. But at the same time, I think the, to your point, the quantitative or monetary argument for including someone like Bitcoin, especially when you're talking to people who are kind of more versed in traditional investing, is a very, very difficult argument to make unless they kind of tie
Starting point is 00:53:11 it back to the uncertainties around the technology. Other tokens, obviously, we could spend all day talking about Bitcoin. Anything else that you're paying attention to, interested in, or think others should be paying attention to? Yeah, I would say, I mean, just at kind of a high level, I mean, at Delphi, we cover a number of different, you know, tokens, projects, a lot of valuation work on some of these still, obviously, as I mentioned, very early days. But some of the things that we're obviously looking at, you know, smart contract platforms, the leader being Ethereum, a lot of obviously really incredible innovation going on there. where we've had conversations with some people that have some pretty significant influence in that community about what some of our longer-term concerns are, but also we've learned a ton from a lot of the developer community there.
Starting point is 00:54:03 So looking at just smart contract platforms in general, how those wars are kind of going to start to play out. Gaming, I think, is also a really, really interesting area where it's still, I think, too early to figure out exactly what's going to drive the most value or which project today potentially could drive the most value. But it is one of those kind of industries that we're looking at that we think, you know, the economics behind issuing a token certainly could make sense. And then the security token market, which is still very immature. We've talked about this a bit, too.
Starting point is 00:54:32 But things like, you know, tokenizing assets, I think that's certainly you're going to have this whole move towards digitizing or tokenizing different assets and different asset classes. I think that'll also make, you know, the portfolio management aspect a whole lot easier. And that's a longer term trend. But also, you know, some really interesting structures like tokenizing athletes or kind of tokenizing teams and things of that nature. I think what this has done, at least for us or at least, you know, for me, I won't speak for the other guys, is it makes you kind of question what different incentive systems can be designed to try and push, you know, a community in a decentralized way towards a certain, I'll call it end goal for lack of a better term. But what's really cool is that this whole industry is moving towards really interesting token economic designs, questioning ways in which traditional companies operate. Are there ways in which you can actually make it so that all the stakeholders in a system, so not just shareholders, but the community, the users, the customers, the employees, how can you design these types of systems that everyone benefits? I think that's one of the really cool aspects of crypto in the entire community.
Starting point is 00:55:43 is that by and large, yes, there's a lot of polarization that goes on, especially if you're in kind of the Bitcoin versus Ethereum camp. But at the same time, there's a lot of people that are out there that continue to just kind of push the bill, continue to innovate, and continue to put out some really great content and question, you know, what today's crypto economic landscape looks like, what different token structures could be. And, you know, that's certainly one of the reasons why, you know,
Starting point is 00:56:08 we've not only gotten into this industry, but plan on staying in this industry for a long time, is just the innovation and the, I would say, the level of talent and intellect is pretty incredible. You mentioned Ethereum. What's the take on the DeFi or decentralized finance and what's going on there? It's starting to get, I think, a lot more attention. I don't know if anything's kind of really broken out in terms of compared to traditional finance, but maybe just give a little bit of the thoughts from you and Delphi on DeFi.
Starting point is 00:56:38 Yeah. No, DeFi, one of the most, you know, one of the more definitely innovative, we'll call it, industries being built on, you know, Ethereum and some other platforms or protocols as well. What I think, you know, longer term, I think there's certainly things that need to not only just be addressed, but as you kind of get into a more, really try to compete with more traditional finance. One of the tough things right now is that if you're getting into DeFi or you're planning on locking up, let's say, ETH to get DAI to be able to use, DAI being a U.S. dollar kind of stable coin, it takes money to do those types of things now today. Which, again, if you're trying to really create an open financial system, we also have to lower not only the barriers to entry, but also the ways in which, I guess you'd say the capital cost that it takes or the capital requirements to get into some type of decentralized finance world. So, the over-collateralization, again, basically means that it takes money to make money
Starting point is 00:57:32 or it takes money to actually be able to interact with some of these protocols. It's certainly a really great testing ground, and there's still a lot of innovation that goes on every single day. I mean, we've got two of our partners out at Ethereal speaking in Tel Aviv this weekend, and their entire presentation was on DeFi, right? And so we'll put that on our site where people can reach out to us to get the slide deck for that. So there's a ton of innovation there. I think longer term, there's going to be some questions about, you know, how do you actually shift some of the maybe underwriting risk or some of the due diligence on things like if you're thinking about, you know, mortgages or more complex kind of loan structures.
Starting point is 00:58:08 But by and large, I mean, DeFi itself is certainly a huge movement, not something we see, you know, regressing or moving backwards. and people, again, continue to innovate and push that market forward. So, we're really excited to see what the next iteration of that is. For sure. For those that are just joining now, maybe just give us an overview of Delphi and what you guys are doing there and kind of the type of customers that you guys have with the various offerings. Yeah. So, we are an independent research firm focused on crypto and digital assets.
Starting point is 00:58:40 We've got two research subscriptions. One's more so for, we call it the institutional product, more so for institutional investors, high-end worth individuals, kind of more sophisticated investor class. And then we've got a slightly watered-down version that we call our insights product, more so for your retail customer. And that's weekly market commentary, thematic insights. We've got a number of free reports right on our website if you go to delphidigital.io. If you do slash Bitcoin, that's our state of Bitcoin report that we put out that needs
Starting point is 00:59:11 to be updated at this point because it was back in December of 2018. But we've got some pretty interesting analysis there on different things, not only just the state of Bitcoin, but UTXO analysis, kind of the process that we used to put out that bottom call back in December 2018. We've also got a consulting arm, so we work with a number of different, largely, funds that are trying to get in this space, understand what the potential investment use case could be, where they could actually deploy capital. We've also worked with some project teams just picking our brains about token economic
Starting point is 00:59:40 structures and things of that nature. So, really, again, just kind of an independent research firm trying to put as much credible information as we can. That's also extremely vetted, thought through, and hopefully pushes the community forward. All right. Time for the rapid-fire questions. I'm fearful of doing this with him because I know he's got questions waiting for me at the end. What's the most important company in crypto? Ooh, most important company in crypto.
Starting point is 01:00:06 So, I'll stick with the kind of investing thesis. I think backed, at least right now. I think the potential, if that gets off the ground, gets up and running, and actually becomes successful, I think could certainly move the needle in terms of institutional adoption for sure. Them and, I'm going to add a second one just because we can, Fidelity. I think everything Fidelity is doing in terms of custody. Again, we've been waiting a long time for a trusted custody provider to come into the ecosystem. Not to say that there aren't a ton of great custody solutions that already existed.
Starting point is 01:00:42 But again, if you're thinking about institutions and people putting real, real capital to work in this space, they needed some type of state street or fidelity to really come in, and a name brand that they trusted. So I'd say between those two, I definitely think that they're going to be some of the more important companies, for sure. What's the one regulation you would change or improve if you could? Accredited investor rules, I think. I could probably talk all day about this. More so from the fact that I think that the arbitrary limitations on people to, again, if you're worth a million or you have an income of $200,000 a year, I think it's for two or
Starting point is 01:01:24 three consecutive years, whatever it may be, the fact that that's kind of the standard for your, let's call it your investing intelligence level to be able to get into some of these riskier asset classes like private equity, like venture capital. I just think those are arbitrary, and I think it should be moved more towards you either have that system in place, then you add on the people that are really interested
Starting point is 01:01:45 and committed to learning about the risks and opportunities within just investing in different asset classes, having some type of, whether it's test or kind of comprehensive course that people can go through that kind of stamps them as an accredited investor, even if they don't have the capital requirements to meet those rules. What is your most controversial thought in Bitcoin or crypto? Most controversial thought in crypto or Bitcoin?
Starting point is 01:02:17 I'll say, I don't know if this is necessarily the most controversial, But one of the ones is I think that in order for Bitcoin to do what we all think it can do and will do, I think it has to obviously accrue a ton of value in the trillions or several trillions of dollars. And so when it comes to these kind of medium exchange and all the things being built on top of Bitcoin, lightning, obviously extremely important for the long-term kind of adoption and reducing the barriers to entry and the friction between transacting and interacting with Bitcoin. But I'm not nearly as concerned about, you know, the medium of exchange type metrics to value something like this. It's much more, you know, the store of value narrative has to come first in order for it to ever become, you know, a global currency or global medium of exchange. You simply have to get, you know, Bitcoin from where it is today to, you know, the multiple trillions of dollars in terms of worth or market value. Because then you'll have, you know, suppressed volatility, more institutions obviously being in the market that'll help. And it can actually become that trusted global medium of exchange, whereas today, again, I'm just not nearly as concerned with that as I am about the long-term value proposition the store of value provides.
Starting point is 01:03:32 Most important book you've ever read? Most important book I've ever read? So, back in 7th grade, this is a real throwback. I'll throw a second book that I read recently that's much more applicable to crypto, blockchain, and investing. I read this book, Trans All Saga, back in seventh grade, and I have no idea why, but it was like pivotal in just the way in which I've, I don't know, kind of approached life. That sounds kind of very, very high level and theoretical, but it was really interesting, kind of about the different parallel worlds. One of those books you kind of get entrenched in. I'll never forget, I read that probably three or four times throughout middle school and high school just because I kept going back to it because it was that good.
Starting point is 01:04:10 And the one that I would say is much more applicable to today and actually goes back to our conversation about central bank digital currencies and things of that nature. This guy, Eric Townsend, who is a macro hedge fund manager, also runs Macro Voices podcast. He came out of the book because he has a background also in computer science. I think a little bit mild cryptography, but you'll have to check me on that. But he came out of the book called Beyond Blockchain. and it was like the death of the dollar and the rise of digital currencies. And I don't agree with everything that he has in that book, especially some of his longer-term takes on Bitcoin.
Starting point is 01:04:48 But his argument, again, for the dollar, dethroning the dollar as a global reserve currency, as well as what the rise of a digital currency world would look like, I think are really, really interesting. He's one of the guys I'm going to suggest you try and get on this at some point, because I think he's got some really interesting takes. But yeah, that would probably be one of the more interesting ones I've read recently that certainly had me questioning different perspectives. Aliens, real, not real?
Starting point is 01:05:14 News was coming at some point. I would say aliens, depending on how you want to define them. I think extraterrestrial life, to some degree, yes. Can we prove that? Which is tough, right? You can't empirically prove that, so it's tough for me to say that they absolutely exist. But at the same time, I think it's really hard to imagine, I mean, if you try and imagine how big the universe is, that the odds that they're out there has got to be at least, again, it's non-zero.
Starting point is 01:05:42 There's a non-zero chance that they exist. And, I mean, that's good enough for me. I'm just a math guy, man. I'm just a math guy. They're definitely real. I just need data to support it. That's all it is. That's all it is.
Starting point is 01:05:53 The probability is above zero. That's for sure. I'll give you that. The comment section lights up when I ask about aliens. Yeah, right. I don't know if that's good or bad. All right. What one question do you have for me to wrap this up?
Starting point is 01:06:07 I'm going to hit you with two. The second one is going to be much more important. The first one is, obviously, you've created an incredible brand for yourself. You're constantly traveling. It's hilarious. You're sending us things at 3.30 in the morning. Just so happens you're in Tokyo, and we thought you were still sitting here in Midtown. How do you find balance, just in general balance, between what you're doing, the work you're doing, and the rest of, I won't say necessarily a social life, but just having balance, you know being able to eat enough sleep eating correctly like those types of things obviously
Starting point is 01:06:39 are extremely important how do you you know find balance in your life yeah it's a great question um i'm laughing because uh that's probably the question i get the most often um really i'll not on the podcast but just a lot of people ask and they don't want others to know that they're asking but they ask um one thing that i will so i'll give an example so today is uh sunday um i got to the office at 8 a.m. and I recorded five episodes for the second podcast that I started called Letters from Wall Street. So it's five annual letters to shareholders from CEOs of Fortune 500 companies. And then I've recorded two other podcast episodes for Off the Chain, and this is the third one. And I think a lot of people would be like, wow, why are you going into
Starting point is 01:07:32 the office on a Sunday and doing all this work, etc. And what they don't realize is like, I'm having fun, I'm enjoying it, right. And what I mean by that is, I would read those annual letters anyways. So I created a way for me to read them and share them with people because it's something I enjoy doing, like, it's almost like, quote, unquote, downtime for me. And then in terms of the podcast episodes, like, I think I found a potential investment opportunity earlier today, Right. And so it's it's a great way for me to meet people. It's a great way for me to just continue to build a network and understand how different people are thinking about the industry, et cetera. So I think that, you know, there's some people who look at it like it's work.
Starting point is 01:08:14 Some people like myself who just look at it as more as enjoyable. I frankly, I look forward to doing this. So that definitely helps when it comes to sleeping and eating. I used to be a like four to six hour sleeper. Um, I am now much more of a seven to eight hour sleeper. Um, and, uh, my girlfriend Polina, um, really has, has pushed me on that. And, uh, I'm at the point where like, I can definitely tell if I didn't get enough sleep. Um, and so once you get to that point, you realize like how important sleep is. Uh, so I just become much more efficient with my time. Um, and, uh, and then something that
Starting point is 01:08:51 a lot of people actually don't know about me, I don't think I've ever even talked about on the podcast is that I'm super interested in like longevity. And so part of longevity is what you eat and what you put into your body. And so I probably know too much about that stuff. And so it just comes down to, you know, eating and drinking the things that are generally good for you. I'm not perfect, like I had a can of Coke earlier, right? It's not going to kill me, but it's probably not the healthiest thing. And so it's more all about just moderation when it comes to eating and making sure that you're eating. And then from a sleep perspective, it's prioritization, right? If I said to you, what's the most important thing you do all day? If one of the top three
Starting point is 01:09:33 things is getting eight hours of sleep, then you'll prioritize it and you'll get eight hours of sleep. And so I think that's just the way to look at it is you kind of do the things that are important to you. And so if being healthy is important, then you've got to prioritize it and make it one of those things. Yeah. No, I'm totally spot on. I mean, it's funny you say that. When we first started Delphi, too, I was very much in that four to six hour sleep camp. And I mean, honestly, in a pretty short period of time, it's not very sustainable, right? So you find yourself, it's noon and you're exhausted and you're, you know, potentially making bad decisions or whatever, or what have you. And speaking of healthy, my second question, which
Starting point is 01:10:10 is arguably more curious to hear about, if you had to give up Bitcoin or McDonald's for the rest of your life which would you choose and why man so my my somebody here my one crutch or weakness is uh i just love mcdonald's man i love mcchicken sandwich with some fries and a mcflurry i don't know why people can hate on it they can tell me it's unhealthy but it hasn't killed me yet um yeah yeah just moderation i don't eat it all the time uh actually sunday nights, I usually take Polina to McDonald's in Times Square for a little date, which I think is more enjoyable for me than her, but that's okay. And so I would definitely give up the McDonald's though. I truly, you know, look, it sounds almost ridiculous to say this because I think a lot of
Starting point is 01:11:01 people don't understand how much I mean it, but to me, Bitcoin can have a bigger impact on changing the wealth inequality gap than all philanthropy combined, right? And the reason why I say that is it fixes the one structural issue, which is inflation, that causes for this drastic wealth divide to occur. And so for me, it's a thing where it has nothing to do with my personal financial gain. It has nothing to do with what we're able to do from an investing standpoint, et cetera, I just wake up every day and I'm super excited and frankly kind of run to work to work on this stuff because I say to myself, you know, look in the United States, 50% of people can't come up with $400 for an emergency, you know, bill.
Starting point is 01:11:52 And so if you've got something that could potentially save or help, you know, over 150 million people by simply changing the structural design of money, the thing that we all interact with. It's pretty incredible and frankly, pretty lucky to be able to work on something like that. And so, you know, I love McDonald's. I love those McChickens and McFlurries, but Bitcoin would definitely be staying and McDonald's would be hitting the road. Just kiss that McDonald's sponsorship goodbye, man. There it went. Absolutely. All right, man. Listen, I really appreciate you doing this. Where can people find more about Delphi and sign up if they're interested in any of their reports? Yeah. So, no, I appreciate you having me. This has been
Starting point is 01:12:31 awesome. So you can find us at DelphiDigital.io. You can find, we also have a Twitter, Delphi underscore digital. You can find me at Kevin underscore Kelly underscore Roman numeral two, Kevin Kelly the second, not Kevin Kelly Jr. for no reason, no reason at all. And you can follow all of our partners are on Twitter, LinkedIn, you know, things of that nature. So I'd say if anyone's curious about our research or just wants to, you know, have a conversation about crypto, feel free to reach out to us. Shoot us an email, drop us a DM on Twitter, whatever. Maybe we're always looking to engage with people in the community. Absolutely. Thanks so much. Hey, everyone. Pop here. If you like this episode of Off The Chain and want to help us take crypto
Starting point is 01:13:13 to the top of the Apple, Spotify, and other podcast charts, please do us a favor and rate, review, and subscribe. To review, simply go to the Off The Chain homepage, scroll down until you see the five blank stars. Taking 15 seconds to fill those stars in and leave a quick review goes a long way in helping us take the entire crypto ecosystem to the top of the charts. I appreciate you listening and see you next time on off the chain.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.