The Prof G Pod with Scott Galloway - Office Hours: The Cyberattack on UnitedHealth, Investing in Music Royalties, and Scott’s Tips for Giving a Compelling Presentation
Episode Date: March 20, 2024Scott gives his thoughts on the recent ransomware attack causing chaos in the healthcare industry. He then discusses JKBX, a startup aiming to “democratize” music investing and whether it is a goo...d new investment vehicle. He wraps up with advice on how to deliver compelling presentations. Music: https://www.davidcuttermusic.com / @dcuttermusic Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Support for this show comes from Constant Contact.
If you struggle just to get your customers to notice you,
Constant Contact has what you need to grab their attention.
Constant Contact's award-winning marketing platform
offers all the automation, integration, and reporting tools
that get your marketing running seamlessly,
all backed by their expert live customer support.
It's time to get going and growing with Constant Contact today.
Ready, set, grow.
Go to ConstantContact.ca and start your free trial today.
Go to ConstantContact.ca for your free trial.
ConstantContact.ca
Support for PropG comes from NerdWallet. Starting your slash learn more to over 400 credit cards.
Head over to nerdwallet.com forward slash learn more to find smarter credit cards, savings accounts, mortgage rates, and more.
NerdWallet. Finance smarter.
NerdWallet Compare Incorporated.
NMLS 1617539. Welcome to the Property Pod's Office Hours. This is the part of the show where we answer
your questions about business, big tech, entrepreneurship, and whatever else is on
your mind. If you'd like to submit a question, please email a voice recording to officehours
at propertymedia.com. Again, that's officehoursaproptomedia.com. First question. Hey, Scott, first-time caller here. I'd love your
analysis on the Change Healthcare, UnitedHealthcare IT hack and the ransomware. I don't hear anybody
talking about this. I work in healthcare. Over 50% of claims pass through Change Health Care, and we haven't been able to bill for two weeks. This is going to be a large issue with no date and site for a lot of providers and hospitals not knowing when they are going to get paid.
Would love your analysis. Thanks for all. I don't see these questions because I want to be
raw and authentic. And the downside is sometimes I don't have the domain expertise and don't have
time to do the homework. And this is one of those instances where I feel I feel naked or maybe that's
the remnants of the ketamine speaking. Anyways, I'm grateful for your question. So, look, this is, so what is a war? A war is a shooting match, right? Ukraine and Russia are in a war. They've committed, you know, they've declared war on each other and there are Russians shooting. The Houthis are firing missiles at U.S. ships or Western ships,
trying to wreak havoc, send the price of oil up, generally just fuck with the West. And it looks
like they're getting a lot of funding and armaments from Iran. That's a proxy war.
To a certain extent, until we entered the war, Vietnam was a proxy war, right? It's large nations
don't want to get involved, engage in a direct shooting match because it can escalate. So what
they do is they have proxy wars and they fund one side or the other, which is kind of, it takes their finger away from
the button a little bit, if you will. The proxy wars being fought all over the world right now
are essentially the biggest proxy war being fought between, I don't know, our adversaries and us
right now are cyber attacks. And some of it is just pure criminality. A group of people in
wherever, I won't name, you know, in an African or Eastern European country, maybe even some folks
domestically, see an opportunity to shut down. And this is happening to a couple of friends of mine,
the IT of a business, and they call them and say, transfer $78,000 in Bitcoin and we'll unlock it.
And what happens is a lot of these companies just go ahead and do it because, and they don't report it because they just want to get their business back online. It's pure blackmail. It's pure extortion. But we absolutely need to beef up our security apparatus and put in place not only defensive measures, but counter offensive measures. What do I mean by that? We need to increase the compensation of our government officials such that we attract more young and technologically literate people.
We do have the best cyber defense and cyber offense in the world, but I would imagine we
still need more and more funding. Because what I'd like to see is more investigative or forensics
that identify who are the nations and bad actors doing this. And then I think we should just turn
around and kick them very hard in the nuts and do the same thing and start fucking with their
government institutions, turning off the lights, just really wreaking havoc and basically have a
disproportionate response every time they do this to us. I think right now the incentives are so
great. America is so rich that these nations have a group of entrepreneurial, technologically
literate criminal gangs that see opportunity to shut down an institution or
exploit it or blackmail it. And their government either turns a blind eye or is actually, in fact,
sponsoring it. By the way, something I'm very excited about, and I will make a more formal
announcement, and this is huge virtue signaling. I am funding a program at UC Berkeley and UCLA
around vocational programming. And one of those programs will be a one or two-year certification
in cybersecurity. I think there's an enormous number of young people, specifically
young men who are not cut out for traditional four-year BA liberal arts degree, but are smart,
are aggressive, are ambitious, want to be good citizens, want to pay taxes, want to build a
middle-class life, have kids, buy a home, et cetera. And there's a ton of vocational training
that they would benefit from, whether it's nursing, specialty home, et cetera. And there's a ton of vocational training that they would benefit
from, whether it's nursing, specialty construction, or cybersecurity. Anyways, enough about me. Isn't
that great the way I turned it back to me? Totally appreciate the question. I think this is a huge
problem. Wired Magazine reported that someone paid $22 million in Bitcoin to the ransomware
group thought to be responsible for the attack. If this was really a payment to fix part of the
breach, it's a huge gain for the hackers and again, creates the incentive, the wrong incentives.
As experts say, in 2023, the FBI documented 249 ransomware instruments targeting healthcare and
public health entities, up 68% in 21. So we're going to need more of this. Again,
CBOB, we need a new algebra of deterrence. Thanks so much for the thoughtful question.
Sorry for the word salad.
Next question, question number two.
Hi, Professor Galloway.
Bradley from New York here.
I recently heard about this website called Jukebox,
which allows people to buy shares in songs
and earn a proportion of the royalties
from this fractional ownership.
Do you think that this is a good new investment vehicle?
Thank you for being a role model and inspiration. Can't wait to hear your thoughts. Thanks, Bradley from New York. Although
I get the sense you're from somewhere else and that you're just living in New York. Anyways,
back to your music platform. So fractional ownership, this company, JQBX, pronounced jukebox,
is aiming to democratize music investing. It launched a platform that lets people invest in
song royalties. Think of it as stock shares from artists including Beyonce and Taylor Swift.
Jukebox just recently launched with SEC approval. A June filing with the SEC shows that since
January 2023, Jukebox has raised $16.1 million. So in terms of revenue, they enable the rights
holders to issue and sell royalty-backed
securities, meaning they earn from transaction execution. For example, investors can buy shares
in Beyonce's Halo for $6.78 each and receive quarterly distribution fees from various
music revenue sources. So what kind of yield are you getting on these shares? According to Jukebox,
the annual yield is around 3% to 4%, with potential for the underlying terminal value
to go up, right? Liquidity and future plans. Currently, jukebox doesn't support trading of
shares, meaning investors can buy but not sell their shares. That sucks. But they plan to enable
trading and expect to follow after overcoming a regulatory challenge. That probably means they
need to become a broker-dealer. The historical context, the concept of converting music rights into cash flows
or financial assets isn't new.
In 1997,
David Bowie became
the first musician
to securitize his song royalties,
who raised $55 million
through the sale
of what became known
as Bowie Bonds.
So essentially,
securitizing future cash flows.
If you win the lottery,
you don't get a lump sum payment.
They pay you,
I don't know,
whatever,
you say you win the lottery
of $3 million,
they pay you $100,000 over 30 years.
You can securitize that. If you get a settlement claim where they're obligated to pay you over 10 years, a certain amount per month, you can go to a company that will securitize it in exchange for you handing over those payments.
They give you one lump sum payment.
So this is the same thing.
You have a
royalty stream and you're essentially buying a bond. I mean, a lot of these big music companies,
their primary asset is not the individuals who can go out and find artists, not even the current
artists who are making them a shit ton of money, but their music library that spends off royalty
payments. And as interest rates go down, that means that the yield or the value of these things go up. So if you can get 10%
in the market and fairly secure bonds, that means that you should expect about $10 for $100, right?
So if a royalty catalog is producing $10 a year and royalty is from Beyonce and Beck and whoever
else and Tom Petty, oh my God, he'd produce so much more than that. By the way, I was asked last
night in this quiz show at South by Southwest, what is something you do when you're alone and and whoever else and Tom Petty. Oh my God, he produced so much more than that. By the way, I was asked last night
in this quiz show at South by Southwest,
what is something you do when you're alone
and no one's watching?
And I said, well, one, I like to take edibles,
drink and write.
And also I like to turn on Tom Petty
in my earphones really loud
when everyone's asleep at two in the morning
and dance around.
It is not pretty.
If someone looked into my living room
at two in the morning,
they see a guy with no music
on in jeans without a shirt on dancing around. But just know it's not as weird as it sounds
because I'm listening to Tom Petty. Anyway, not what you ask. As interest rates go down,
the value of these catalogs go up because your ability to get cash flow from other things,
you get less cash flow because the interest rate or the yield on bonds goes down, which means that any cash flow is worth more.
The multiple goes up. So the idea of securitizing or chopping up, finally chopping up assets that
democratize the opportunity to own them, it's a good idea. You need liquidity. You need kind of
an active trading market. And what happens is these things oftentimes, it's not about the
underlying assets.
Sometimes they just turn into pure vehicles for speculation. I think there'll be some of this.
I'm not entirely sure it's going to take off. What I would say is, if you love music
and you find it fascinating, take a small percentage of your portfolio,
you know, enough money such that if the Beyonce share goes up fivefold, it might mean something
to you. But not so much money that if it goes to zero and Beyonce share goes up fivefold, it might mean something to you.
But not so much money that if it goes to zero and you can't sell these things and become debt equity, that it would have any impact on your life.
Take just a small, just a dabble, just a skosh of your capital and do this if you're interested.
But to me, this feels like a niche market that may or may not live up to its potential. Sorry for kind of the word salad and not a very definitive answer here,
but it's definitely cool.
I'm going to check it out.
Thank you for the question.
We have one quick break
before our final question.
Stay with us.
Welcome back.
Question number three.
Hi, Scott.
It's Lance here.
A big fan of all your podcasts
and the thought leadership you bring to the business world.
Like you, I'm also presenting at the upcoming Financial Grand Forum in May.
My session tackles the complex and impactful topic of the ethical, legal, and strategic risk of AI in banking.
As I prepare to deliver this message, I'm particularly impressed by your consistent ability to convey complex information in an engaging and impactful way.
This resonates strongly with my approach to crafting my presentation.
My question for you is, what are your top tips for presenting complex and potentially controversial topics in a way that is both informative and engaging for the audience?
Thank you for your time and consideration, Scott.
I look forward to potentially connecting at the forum and learning more from your keynote address.
See you in Vegas. Lance.
Lance from Undisclosed. By the way, that's my favorite place to hang out. Undisclosed.
Okay, so how do you convey or articulate or present around controversial or complex topics?
Okay, so complexity, trying to get it distilled.
One, analogies, you know, fit it into a story.
So when I talk about the anti-competitive
or monopoly practices of the app store, right?
They charge a 30% tax on apps or revenues that apps get
if they're in the app store.
The analogy I use is credit card companies. And what if Visa went into the business of retail and the retailers they owned didn't have
to pay 30% transaction fees? Those retailers would be monopolies or other retailers wouldn't
be able to compete with them. That's an analogy or a story that helps understand, or maybe not,
but I think helps people understand how Apple is, in fact, engaging monopoly behavior. In terms of presenting a controversial topic, you want to, data is just
sort of says, all right, I don't like this guy's opinions. I don't like him. But if you present
data, it just is what it is. There is a certain truth and charts, visualizations, super, super
important. Also, just some of the softer stuff.
I think it's fine to have humility here.
And that is to say that I predicted this.
I oftentimes say, will say, I predicted this.
This is what I saw.
And I got it wrong.
Because just to acknowledge that you're wrong and bring some humility, people empathize with you.
And then the most effective one is something that's difficult to force.
But if you're blessed with it, it just softens the
beach, and that is humor. Jon Stewart can say very, very controversial things and is incredibly
powerful. Before you say something provocative or aggressive or a bit controversial,
anything around humor, it just kind of opens people's minds to listening to you and being
thoughtful. I describe
it as the Navy or artillery softening the beach before you invade it with a viewpoint. So let's
review. Analogies, storytelling, data, visuals, graphics, all get the message across. And then
on the softer stuff, having some humility, admit that you might be wrong or you've gotten wrong before and softening the beach with humor. So I will see you in Las Vegas. The dog loves to
roll in Vegas. I put on a kilt. I give myself a thousand dollars, actually ten thousand dollars,
but I've become very self-conscious about my wealth recently. I go down, I gamble like
fucking crazy. I drink a shit ton and I lose it all.
But for me, it's not gambling, it's consumption.
I don't expect to make any money.
I expect to lose it all.
It doesn't matter to me.
And I have a fantastic time.
I think Vegas is the most singular city in the world.
Also singular in the sense that for 48 hours,
it's the best place in the world.
And by hour 49, it becomes the worst place in the world. But anyways, I will see you at the conference and good luck with the presentation.
Let me know how it goes, Lance. That's all for this episode. Again, if you'd like to submit a
question, please email a voice recording to officehoursofpropertymedia.com.