The Reel Rejects - ALL STAR SUPERMAN (2011) IS PEAK SUPERMAN!! MOVIE REVIEW!! First Time Watching!
Episode Date: June 9, 2025ONE OF THE MAJOR INSPIRATIONS FOR JAMES GUNN'S SUPERMAN!! All Star Superman Full Reaction Watch Along: / thereelrejects Save & Invest In Your Future Today, visit: https://www.acorns.com/r...ejects With the DCU's flagship Superman film A MONTH AWAY, Coy & John continue their road to Metropolis with their All Star Superman Reaction, Recap, Commentary, Analysis, & Spoiler Review!! Join Coy Jandreau & John Humphrey as they celebrate the Man of Steel in All Star Superman (2011), the acclaimed DC animated adaptation of Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely’s beloved comic. When Superman (voiced by James Denton of Desperate Housewives and Good Christian Belles) absorbs a lethal overdose of solar radiation saving a U.S. space mission, he learns he has only days left to live—but not before completing twelve “super” tasks for humanity. Alongside Clark Kent’s heartfelt romance with Lois Lane (Christina Hendricks, Mad Men, Drive), we see Lex Luthor (Anthony LaPaglia, Without a Trace, Frasier) unleash a diabolical plot to capture the bottled city of Kandor, and Perry White (Edward Asner, The Mary Tyler Moore Show, Up) struggle to keep the Daily Planet printing under cosmic threat. Standout moments include Superman’s solar recharge chamber scenes, his bittersweet gift of temporary powers to Jimmy Olsen (Matthew Gray Gubler, Criminal Minds), and the climactic showdown where the dying hero still finds hope in saving the world. Nasthalthia (Linda Cardellini, Freaks and Geeks, Avengers: Endgame) offers alien perspective, Ma Kent (Frances Conroy, Six Feet Under, American Horror Story) grounds him in heart, and Steve Lombard (Kevin Michael Richardson, The Simpsons, Black Lightning) supplies brash newsroom flair. Don’t miss Coy & John’s breakdown of every iconic beat—from Superman racing the sun across the sky to the emotional farewell that cements his legacy as the ultimate hero! Follow Coy Jandreau: Tik Tok: https://www.tiktok.com/@coyjandreau?l... Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/coyjandreau/?hl=en Twitter: https://twitter.com/CoyJandreau YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCwYH2szDTuU9ImFZ9gBRH8w Intense Suspense by Audionautix is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... Support The Channel By Getting Some REEL REJECTS Apparel! https://www.rejectnationshop.com/ Follow Us On Socials: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/reelrejects/ Tik-Tok: https://www.tiktok.com/@reelrejects?lang=en Twitter: https://x.com/reelrejects Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheReelRejects/ Music Used In Ad: Hat the Jazz by Twin Musicom is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Happy Alley by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... POWERED BY @GFUEL Visit https://gfuel.ly/3wD5Ygo and use code REJECTNATION for 20% off select tubs!! Head Editor: https://www.instagram.com/praperhq/?hl=en Co-Editor: Greg Alba Co-Editor: John Humphrey Music In Video: Airport Lounge - Disco Ultralounge by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Ask Us A QUESTION On CAMEO: https://www.cameo.com/thereelrejects Follow TheReelRejects On FACEBOOK, TWITTER, & INSTAGRAM: FB: https://www.facebook.com/TheReelRejects/ INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/reelrejects/ TWITTER: https://twitter.com/thereelrejects Follow GREG ON INSTAGRAM & TWITTER: INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/thegregalba/ TWITTER: https://twitter.com/thegregalba Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
There is the cold
habitual
And it is the
cold of
the cold
at his
summit
Cozlight
T'envee
a friday
celebrate
in a fashion
responsible
you have
to have
the age
legal
for consuming
the alcohol
This week's
video is
sponsored by
Acorns
the money app
that makes
it simple
and cheap
to make
small yet
significant
investments
Without
further ado
let's watch
one of the
classics
that inspired
totally certain movie coming out
July 11th let's watch all-star
Superman
if you are just joining us
we just experienced
all-star Superman
in animation for the very
first time I would like to
thank the fine folks at
Prepper for making this possible for
getting this on the YouTube's
we very much appreciate them
as I said at the top head I'm to Patreon if you watch
think, but also check out
Rejectnationshop.com for some sweet
sweet threads. You too can
have wardrobe changes like Superman.
We got some Patreon questions. We do
in fact, Coytoos.
We'll start with those and then review this
masterpiece. All righty. So
starting off with Dauphmer.
Thank you for stoking
the fires of conversation
for All-Star Superman. Hello,
John and Coy. Glad to see
you both enjoying more DC
content. I was wondering, for both
you what makes Superman a compelling character
what aspects of him would you like to see
more on the big screen? Things like
him being a journalist, farmer, or
father are aspects of him I've
enjoyed seeing in shows like Smallville or Superman
and Lois and in this movie we get
to see him use more of his intellect which I enjoy
because Superman is a highly intelligent character
which doesn't get highlighted much
I think that's a solid point
in fact what was I guess
partly revelatory for me
because especially watching this now I'm like I definitely
but I didn't reread going
into this partly because I was like I'll reread after and before the James Gunn movie
you know just to so I don't so I can go into this as fresh as possible and you know a lot of
my memory is just like clear on gone so like one of the loveliest things about this is that
yeah like partway and I was I started to realize like oh this is a bunch of scenes with
characters for the most part and then we have like a couple of very physical threats but
they're more like interludes it's not really like a Superman story that's like heavily
predicated on like there's a big physical fight we need to go take care of that's ongoing throughout
the whole movie it's yeah more about the stakes of he's got he doesn't have much time and there are a
bunch of sort of competing factors at play you know in the jeopardy of you know earth at the moment
and so yeah i really liked this story's emphasis on superman both as cal and clark as a character
as a person and like the fact that he knows he's dying changes the demeanor in the way he interacts
with Lois, with Lex, with everybody. Yeah, I mean, to briefly touch on one of my favorite parts
about this story is that it feels like an old golden age serial. Like it feels very before
comics were what they are today format wise. But as far as Superman, I have said it before,
but I think it's very pertinent to this question. I think I like Superman more and more.
every year I grew up.
Like when I was a kid, I liked the edgy characters.
I actually, to be fair, when I started liking comics, I liked Superman.
I mean, I liked Spider-Man.
I liked Batman.
Those were my big three.
And like Batman was just always cool.
X-Men were always different.
Spider-Man was always funny.
Like the fundamentals of those things when you're like three, those were really foundational.
Superman, I had phases of liking because of like what he represented.
But it wasn't until I was in my 20s that I went from.
oh, I like Superman as, like, I appreciate him, but I don't identify with him.
And then, like, in my late 20s, I started liking him and identifying with him.
And now every year, I find the goodness isn't old fashioned.
So as much as I like him having an intellect, as much as I like him having any number of those, you know, things that add up to who Clark Kent and Superman is, for me, it's just the anchor of, it's not old fashioned to be good.
for the sake of good. It's not boring to seek the best. And I think that is something that as the world
gets darker, the brightness of Superman is more important. So as I get more frustrated with the world
and more plugged into the world and more cynical, it keeps me tethered into the optimism I try to
keep. Because I'm an optimist and that's harder and harder. And so Superman is that to me. So it's not about
anything he does it's about who he is yeah yeah absolutely and i mean i feel like what i find compelling
about a superman so i think that's a really cool point and i think i would agree because yeah it's like
when you're a young person you're coming of age and stuff you know uh you you get enamored by the cool
flashy things and yeah i always find part of what is most charming and most affecting about
superman stories that i've been exposed to is yeah is i feel like i don't know the more the more we
watch these the more i sort of feel as though
there is there's the difference between marvel and dc of you're looking up versus looking down but like superman in so many ways kind of represents a sort of parker luckish thing to me where it's like it's just a guy doing his best to be in as many places as he can and he's trying to protect all the people who are important to him and you can't do all of those things so you have to choose wisely and you have to you know choose goodness even when you have every excuse not to um and to see him in this movie in a in a
in a sort of state of, not resign, but just like acceptance of mortality is interesting
because it gives him a different vibe than I'm used to.
And I, yeah, I get the people often cite the sort of like, oh, Boy Scout character is kind
of boring, but I feel like when Superman's stories for me are really firing, it's like,
no, like, I don't know, it's a very relatable motivation to want to look out for people and
do the right thing and to rise to the occasion again in a world that is providing you with
every excuse to not reach for those heights sure and so yeah like it i get the inspiration factor of like
damn you know as as fanciful and science fiction as these stories can be like yeah this is the everyday
struggle of like life is hard enough and it's enough coordination and even without superpowers sometimes
it just feels like you're hearing and seeing everything and you can't block it all out and you can't
create clarity in order to just achieve either your own goals or you know help the people around you
thrive or at least, you know, not be subject to tyranny or harm or whatever it is. And,
and, yeah, like, I can get down with a very physical Superman story that has a lot of action.
But I really do love a take that, yeah, like, allows the character, the person and the dual
nature of the guy to shine. And, too, when you get to, yeah, kind of relish in the contrast
between Clark and Superman. Yeah, I hope I didn't lose the plot of this question. But, I mean,
I like seeing the human aspect.
I like any Superman story that doesn't seem like
it's trying to rush past all the character elements
to get to some punching.
Yeah, agree.
So yeah, like, and two, one, where especially when he's up
against Lex and especially in this story, like,
yeah, this wasn't, there was a lot of like fun in games
in a way and a lot of like random annoyance.
You know, Samson and Atlas show up to just kind of like be a nuisance.
I like that it feel like issues.
It felt so serialized.
And they did, I was really worried about how.
how they'd translate.
I was really afraid
that a narrative film
would try to make
that story a three-act structure
and that wouldn't work.
Yeah, and like, too,
I think the human characters
around him help.
It's like whenever he's with Maun Paw Kent,
there's that wholesome quality
and there's also that sort of bird,
like whenever I often find
in those scenes,
you come in touch with the wholesome
and also the burden
of choosing better
and living up to ideals
and morals and standards and whatnot.
And then when you're like,
with a lowest type of character you're with more of the edge you know you're you're with somebody
who is a little bit more cunning and who maybe you know not always doing everything by the book but
someone who still has that sort of good nature at heart like yeah i think a good superman story
is often elevated character wise superman as a character's flavored by his core people and also yeah
by the ideals and by the intellect and whatnot.
Next cue is from Joseph Brown for John and Coy.
What are your favorite?
This will be a coy question.
What are your favorite Grant Morrison comics?
And which one do you hope most will be adapted into animation?
I think Grant Morrison is one of the all-time greats.
I think he's an absolute genius.
He's doing, and this is a big deal.
Are you ready?
I'm hanging on the edge of my
Marvel and DC haven't
in 20 years
Grant Morrison
is writing
Are you ready
Deadpool versus Batman
Whoa
It's gonna be insane
That is the comic book
I'm so excited
For the now
I'm so excited
Graham Morrison
He wrote new X-Men
Which is one of my favorite
runs of all time
He wrote one of my favorite
singular volumes of comics ever
If I was to
to give anyone
10 comic
books to show the array of major comics.
One of them would be Grant Morrison's Animal Man.
Grant Morrison's Animal Man rocked me so much as a teen.
And then I didn't touch it for like 10 years because I just loved it.
And I didn't want to, I read a lot of comics.
I don't need to reread the ones.
But then I was in my 20s, like 28.
And I was like, you know, it's time.
And I reread Animal Man.
I was like, it's better.
Animal Man's so good.
And it's a character that shouldn't work.
And the way the metanus works is so genius.
it's a comic that I can't wait to
to show my unborn children
like I can't wait to be like
this is what comics can be
so that's a big one for me
I'm just I'm a big Grant Morrison
fan in general but all-star Superman
I didn't use to like nearly as much
as I like now when it first came out
I didn't have a connection to Superman in the same way
like I was talking about so this has become one
but Animal Man
always I've always loved Animal Man his take
and his new X-Men is pretty special
Did he do the New 52 Animal Man
that was one of them when they did the new 52 for whatever
reason. I remember specifically hearing people say
that Animal Man was a particularly good
title out of that. I don't think he did the new
52. His one was when
there was the thing called the British invasion, when
Alan Moore, Grant Morrison, a bunch of the Brits.
His Animal Man was from like the late 70s
and it was so good. Okay.
It was like when Al Moore was doing V
and that like
Watchman era. Okay. And that Animal Man
like was a Golden Age hero that he modernized
then that actually is even more applicable now.
Fun. Highly recommend it.
I didn't actually realize that I would
have an answer for this. But actually,
now that I, in the back of my
mind, I was like, hang on a minute.
I got one. Hang on. I got a Graham Morrison. I know
a fave of mine, I think,
has the name
thoroughly attached, and I have just
looked it up to verify. And yes, in fact,
if you've been watching these recent
iterations of our DC anime, you've probably
heard me mention, Arkham Asylum.
Correct. Serious House on Serious Earth.
I promise to read more comics,
so I'm not as much of a broken record.
But that's a great comp. I adore that book, though.
I love that book from memory.
Yeah, the way that story is told and unfolds,
but also the artwork that goes along with it.
It was one of those books.
I remember picking up from the library ages ago,
and Greg and I would go on like little pilgrimages to the library
to like grab a new comic or whatever,
and that's where I read a lot of stuff.
And that book recontextualized to me
what comic book artwork and storytelling could be,
and it's one I often think about whenever it was like,
whoa, what would you want to see adapted?
And I'm like, that one.
And to come to find, like, one thing I would love to do if given the time and more succinct version of having an attention span is to, like, you know, soak in authors, you know, like read a handful of ones by this guy or that guy or whoever.
Yeah.
And, you know, really sort of drink those in.
But that would be mine for sure.
Because, again, if you could transcribe that art style along with what that story is, I would be on cloud 10.
He came to one of my birthdays once and I lost my mind, Grandma, so.
showed up at I had a crazy crazy birthday that was like a ball like we had a gala ball
and Grant Morrison came and I didn't know how to react and I happened to be on a stripper
pole spinning at the time and so I just kept like dancing in the stripper pole while being
like how was Grant Morrison here and then we had a really amazing long conversation about X-Men
and the importance of like the voices for each it was like the coolest birthday present
hell yeah it was so special that is that I don't know how you could ever have another birthday
well that's it I got Jim Starlin and one birthday party too Jim
Starlin giving me a Thanos wishing me happy birthday
in pencil. Drawing happy birthday
from Thanos is a... Can't be that mad. Pretty
crazy. I've had some good birthdays with comic legends.
I'm also excited just on the heels of this
to go look at my shelf now
and go like, oh, that was Graham Orrin's
too. He's a genius, you know, like, I'm sure I've read
more than just that. Also, we've got
comics guy just responding to this comment.
I figure I'll work you in here too.
I always wanted to see an animated series
based on W.E.3.
Do we know what this is, Koi?
I think...
I think the crew
that animated scavengers reign
would match Quietly's style
well. Also, his Animal Man run
would be wild to see animated
but that would have to be a series since
the movie wouldn't even scratch the surface.
I have never read this, but it looks awesome.
It's Graham Orson and Frank quietly doing animal
stuff for Vertigo.
Cool. So is it We3, I guess?
Yeah. You just showed
me a new comic. Good sir. Thank you.
Thank you. Comics guy.
Animal. Lively named. Living up
your living up to your name. That is cool
comics guy. Heck yeah
and I believe our
last one for today
is from
sci-fi extremist. I've seen your
name pop it up a few times in these Q&As. Thank you so much
for John and Coy. Knowing that James,
knowing that Jimmy Guns has
stated All-Star Superman
is an influence on his Superman. Do you think there will be
any specific moments in the movie where we will be
the Leo meme pointing at the screen
other than the robots?
of course, or do you think that the influence on the movie is more in tone and character than
actual scenes taken from the book? I think it'll be more tone and character, but I do think
he will also give us some little things. I, as of filming this, I have not seen Superman, so I'm not,
this is a guess. I would assume he'd have the sun eater in there. I think we'll get, James Gunn seems
the type to add a crazy creature that's getting like, you know, throw sun smelt, like that felt
so James Gunn. Yeah. So I think that, um, I assume
we'll get some of the imagery
that are like the comic covers
and if not the story elements
but like reframed in a way
like there are some moments in this
that I was like oh that's the cover
I think he'll play around with that
I don't think we'll see like Lois in a suit
and like I don't think we'll get
you know a dying Superman but I do think
the creatures and
the actual fortress of solitude
I think we'll see some elements that Frank
quietly added like the Titanic
I was going to see a Titanic I think is the big question
That is the question.
New one more?
I was making sure we don't have it anymore.
Okay, great.
Oh, that was three.
That was the third.
Yeah.
Our goal was three.
Well, let's talk about this movie real quick for we wrap out of here.
I did not have high expectations.
I'm not going to lie to you.
I was really worried about all-star Superman because it is so, by its nature, not linear.
It is so, like, the story connects, but it connects so tenuously.
And then it has a resolution, but it's not a traditional three-ext.
it's not a traditional graphic novel it's not a traditional
story it is like those old comics
where it's like this adventure this adventure
oh we found a way to make it relate but with an intent
like those did not have much
goo glue or goo together but this was like a
perfect middle ground between modern comics and like
old 40s comics and so I was really worried when you
animate that what's that feel like um and
admittedly I didn't want to reread this before
the Superman movie because I I will already
Leo point, but I also don't want to be
doing a thing where I'm
thinking, oh, that's
missing or, oh, I'm looking for that.
And I think some of the rumors
when there's talks of a movie,
it sucks, because then you go, oh, I wish that rumor was
true or I wish that was a rumor wasn't true.
So I was afraid to reread the comic that I know
is tonally based. But
seeing this animated movie without having read the comic
in so long was really cool because I did get
to have some surprises. Like, I forgot about paranoid
Lois Lane writing an article. And like,
then the fun little, like,
how long has that been on that mind's eye
was really cool and different.
And there were a couple little extra elements
I had missed, so this was a lot of fun.
Reject Nation, I don't know about you,
but money used to intimidate me.
It definitely still intimidates me.
Growing up, I'm sure you guys are the same thing too.
Got to start investing early. It'll pay off
in the future. But no one actually taught me
how. And by the time I realized I needed
to start, I already felt like I was behind.
And that's why I'm really grateful for today's sponsor,
this company. I've already been using them
since before we ever partner with them.
Acorns!
Acorns is a financial wellness app that makes it easy to start saving and investing for your future.
You don't need to be rich.
Definitely don't.
Acorns lets it get started with the money you have right now.
Even if all you've got is spare change.
You don't need to be an expert.
Acorns recommends a diverse portfolio that I'll help you weather all the ups and downs of the market.
And yes, to this day, I still use them.
Watch that Mighty Oak grow.
That's what I love about it.
It automates everything.
Sometimes I forget that I'm still invested in Acorns.
But I love is how it automates everything.
Sometimes I actually forget that I still have the acorn thing going.
And it's always nice to check up on it and be like, ah, money oaks aren't growing.
I don't have to think about it.
Just link a card.
And it starts putting my spare change to work.
One of our team members here even use acorns to help them get out of a financial emergency.
I mean, I heard that that really hit home.
So you can sign up now and join the over 14 million customers.
We've already saved and invested over $25 billion with acorns.
So you can head acorns.com slash rejects or doubt.
We'll be apt to get started.
Because we're dealing with finances.
It's important that I say,
pay no client endorsement.
Compensation provides incentive to positively promote Acorn.
Tier 1 compensation provided.
Investing involves risk.
Acorns, advisor, LLC, and SEC registered investment advisor.
View, important, disclosure is acorns.com slash reex.
Thank you, Acorns, for sponsoring this video and for up in the bank account look
a little bit better.
Yeah, man.
Like, again, this seems like such a seminal Superman's story and anything, it's weird.
These DC, I think movies we've commented a lot on being very conscientious in how they blend
together in such a short amount of time,
a lot of different elements that, you know, make up,
what I'm trying to say?
They're good at typically making a story feel well-rounded
in not a ton of time in a format you know
is drawing from a vast source material.
And so, yeah, coming back into this after so long
was fun because, like, I didn't really,
my recollection was foggy enough that I was like,
I'm not really sure what kind of story to expect.
And part of me expected something that was like more classic in a way.
So it was cool to be then thrown into this like, oh, damn, Samson and Atlas are here.
And now we're competing for Lois's affections.
And now Lois has powers for a day.
And now Lex is over here plotting.
And he's got this niece chick around.
And then we've got a big sun monster.
And like, it's really cool because it, in a way, and a lot of, we've watched a lot of these now.
So like the shared intersection that these worlds often.
amount to is well ingrained, but something like this I thought actually had like a higher
degree of that than I'm even used to seeing in some of these. I feel like a lot of these animated
movies, you know, pick a few things to focus on and you kind of focus on that, whereas this
did feel like one big story, but amalgamated, yeah, out of episodes rather than one act,
a second act, and the third act. And so I really liked the sort of journey of this and the
flavors of this and yeah the way it felt like following a guy on his last days as he both does
what his duty instructs you know with the time he has left but also as he tries to make good on
just some life moments and things like that so yeah having him and lois bonding on his terms and
having it be that yeah he reveals his super identity here and you know there's a bit of a debate
about that but you know ultimately it gives way to you know this really lovely day that they get
to share together and then you get this you know battle of wits between him and lex and all the
other competing factors like yeah it was it was fun because i felt like i was sort of whisked off
on a ride and after a certain amount of time i was sort of like i don't i don't know exactly where
this is going to go and who am i where am i yeah and it's adapted out of a book that i imagine
had things trimmed and and consolidated and you know adjusted i got a lot of the juice though um
but yeah it felt nicely rounded and i liked the tone
of this like this had a unique
again given that it is such
a particular and well
recognized story it did feel
like it had its own kind of tone
amid the array
of Superman flavors that we've seen
in our animated journey up till now I found myself
in the tone you're speaking of like in a sense
of wonder which I don't always feel
like you know it's fun to watch these and it's exciting
and it's action packed and like the writing's good
and zippy like all the things you want out of a comic
but with this one I had a sense of like
awe and wonder and that was really
cool because that's the character. So I found myself
like forgetting to react verbally
because I was just like, whoa. Like it was really
cool to have that scope. And one of my favorite things
in the comic is, man, this is like, there's no way
to say this without just saying it. I enjoy
mushrooms. And I really enjoy
There's so many ways to cook them. Guys, you can do
shataki. That's right. You can have that umami
flavor. That's right. So I
enjoy a nice
you know, uh,
a vegetable. And I
found that so does
Grant Morrison and that shows in his
epiphany of Lex Luthor.
And so I
as someone who
it's all connected, as someone who has
had that moment and has someone who
has someone who's seen those
those, you know, you said even fractals
that I love the idea of like equating
gravity to anyway, as someone
who has had the moment of connectivity
and universality
that gave me benevolence, I
credit those by the way for a lot of
my optimism. I'm not kidding. So to have Alex Luther in the comic have that. It really was cool to see
with a performance because I've only read that. So you're directing it in your head. You're acting
those dialogue out, but it's still reading. So it was really fun when I was reading that,
you know, in my youth and being like he he and then like when I had that moment for myself being
like, oh, like the comic. And then to see it here like performed, I was like, this is nice. So
that that was cool. I, you know, I can only hope Nicholas gets to have his moment in Superman.
eight. That's a question, I guess, is do you think
he will get powered up in the text
of James Gunn's Superman movie? Not powered, I think
there'll be some mech. I think
you know, there'll be some... Lex-Mex.
But I think we'll get there, like,
down the journey. I wouldn't want that to happen so early.
Yeah. But yeah, I mean, this is one of my
favorites, I think, of the animated. Yeah,
this is really striking and it's one that I'm actually
not that I don't want
to go back and re-watch the other ones, but this is one
where part of my brain goes like, I kind of
put this on again and like re-observe
it. I want to watch the new
movie and then read this comic and then watch it again. I want to go in the order that I'm not
going to be waiting for beats because I hadn't read this in so long. This got to be fresh.
And I know James Gunn isn't going to adapt to this directly. It's tone. So then after the two
adaptations, I want to read it again. Yeah. I think that would be a good idea. In fact,
that sounds like a perfect way to do it. You see this version of it. Then you go watch Superman and
then you return to the source. Yeah. And then go back and see how this direct adaptation works. And
then we'll do a live stream. Yeah. Plus just so much.
funny fun. What was Jimmy doing in the dress? Unrevealed.
It's for us to. I was going to say, does the comic book make it clear?
That's actually a beat I didn't remember, which is funny because it's a whole issue about
it's a striking image, but now I'm like, I like that my brain was like, I think that
means I must have been like, Jimmy Hydrinks, because he like turns into a turtle and stuff.
Like Jimmy's like a crazy character. Superman's pal Jimmy Olson by Matt Fraction is one of the
greatest modern comics period for like this kind of tone and insanity.
and that felt like a beat where it was like you've finished a Jimmy Olson issue and then you're
catching up on Superman already in progress so they don't explain it because that's its own
adventure you don't know what I mean sure so I really like the beat not knowing so this is a
Jimmy Olson centric comic book where like Superman is off to the side dude Matt for action
wrote an insane 12 issue maxi series of Jimmy Olson just like going nuts it's insane I'm so
excited I will say too I do appreciate I think one thing people are are getting at when they
dog on Superman maybe is in a roundabout way like this has a sort of space opera kind of
quality about it even though it's mostly relegated to earth you still have like yeah these like
larger than life characters passing by and like some characters are here from different points
in time and it's like very sci-fi and timey-wimey and i feel like that's a in conversation i just
get this gist that that's an element of superman that people probably over
look in favor of pointing to
he's saving cats from trees.
He's an insane sci-fi character.
And that's a thing I think is really
as much as people look at James Gunn's
upcoming Superman and go, it's going to be too much.
I'm like, I'm actually kind of excited to see
in a day and age
where so many things have been brought down to Earth
and I like stuff
about Man of Steel certainly, but you know,
that's much more trying to be like
grounded in Earth physics
and Earth vibes and all that
all that dark night shit that we have to do
now. And the Superman, you know, as again, space opera, big sort of crazy sci-fi thing, I think is actually
a vibe I'm excited to see embodied more on screen. And I have this hope in the back of my mind. I think
we did like a massive overcorrection from Joel Schumacher days. And I feel like a little bit of
that wildness and that sort of whimsy could be a benefit. I do. I feel and honestly, I agree. I think
we did Schumacher over correct to gritty
and I love dark and gritty I like
grounded heroes more like I'm a street
level hero guy but not every
character is made for that so I think right now
what DCU is doing is it's kind of like swinging
the pendulum the other way and I don't think they're going to
swing as high as we went
high of not doing nipples yeah
we're not doing super nests but
if the highest darkest grittiest is like up here
I don't think we're going to go as high in the
absurdist but I think going in that direction
of sci-fi grandiose is
needed to keep things fresh and finally
I guess, just to cap us off.
Abienstein Arts asks,
has a little coda here.
What power makes this Superman special to y'all?
Mine personally is that he's not affected by kryptonite
because in the comics he's overly exposed
to the sun rays.
Yeah, which they do here in a fun way.
I think
I always really liked
and I liked it again and how they did it here.
Like the three times power
also meant three times empathy,
three times intelligence, three times.
I like that it is.
that it isn't just a power set that gets upped because Superman's ability to process data
is also heightened because he's Superman, but then that's also heightened because he's
overpowered. So I liked the processing of like what that would be for all things. Yeah. That's a
great answer. I don't think I could answer better. I think the only thing I'll throw in is I just
loved the acknowledgement here of the brief interrogation of like, wait a minute, but how are you
Superman when you were helping out Clark
in court or whatever? I was like, I had Batman.
Well, how are you Superman here? I had a robot.
So, like, I don't know, being...
I think that's an element that doesn't...
It's an element of fun. It's weird. Like, I feel like
those elements of fun can be off and overlooked in
Superman stuff, and I'm like that. It just
reminded me of something else
to appreciate about the joy
of beholding the more whimsical
aspects of a character like this.
And too, just, yeah, his conscientiousness.
It's not really like in his
characterization, but the way like, yeah,
Yeah, he's showing Lois his, like, confiscation-gated room of weapons and, you know, thinks to bring the gravity gun because the gravity is going to accelerate the time thing.
Like, his intellect really stood out here.
Yeah. And, uh, two, I really liked his super thoughtfulness in making her like, I love that reversal of like, oh, my God, his secret torture lab.
And then it turns out I'm just making you a nice gift.
Paranoid gas is caused the super suit. Yeah, I loved all that.
Yeah. So, like, I'm used to seeing the tender side through Clark. So it was cool to see the tender side through.
Superman. Yeah, and check off
Gravity Gun. That was
all the fun, really enjoyed All-Star
Superman. Please let us know in the comments
below what you think. I love the question
of what we think we might see incorporated into the
Superman film. I definitely threw
mine in there. I'd love to read yours below. So what do you
think we might see? This is not going to be
adapted, but totally, and certain
elements that might get the Leo point. I'd love to see
your Leo point ideas in the comments below.
As always, we're going to be doing more of these. So let
us know in the comments what other things you want
us to watch in the DC animated pantheon.
Love reading them. Love acting on them.
Also press like. Also, thank Prepper
for keeping us possible
on the YouTube. And thanks to all
our patrons. We'll see you guys very soon. For more,
by all. Superman!