The Reel Rejects - BRIDGERTON 1x5 REVIEW – SIMON’S CONFESSION MELTED OUR HEARTS! – FIRST TIME WATCHING
Episode Date: February 5, 2026DAPHNE & THE DUKE TO BE WED!! With the first part of Bridgerton Season 4 streaming on Netflix now, John & Greg continue Lady Whistledown's scandal sheet! Download PrizePicks today at https://www....prizepicks.onelink.me/LME... & use code REJECTS to get $50 instantly when you play $5! BRIDGERTON 1x4 Reaction Highlights: • BRIDGERTON S1 EPISODE 4 REACTION – ONE KIS... BRIDGERTON 1x3 Reaction Highlights: • BRIDGERTON SEASON 1 EPISODES 1 & 2 REACTIO... BRIDGERTON 1x1 & 1x2 Reaction: • BRIDGERTON SEASON 1 EPISODES 1 & 2 REACTIO... Gift Someone (Or Yourself) An RR Tee! https://shorturl.at/hekk2 Greg Alba & John Humphrey react to Season 1, Episode 5 of Netflix’s Bridgerton, titled “The Duke and I,” a pivotal chapter that dramatically reshapes the series’ central romance. Following the scandalous duel, the episode shifts into married life for Daphne and Simon—revealing that love, intimacy, and power are far more complicated behind closed doors. Phoebe Dynevor (Younger, Fair Play) portrays Daphne Bridgerton as she navigates the realities of becoming Duchess of Hastings, discovering both passion and painful misunderstandings within her marriage. Regé-Jean Page (For the People, Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves) gives a layered performance as Simon Basset, whose unresolved trauma and refusal to confront his vow about having children leads to one of the season’s most talked-about and controversial storylines. The episode features standout moments including the lavish wedding ceremony, the emotionally charged honeymoon scenes, and the tense confrontation that exposes the cracks in their seemingly perfect union. Elsewhere, the wider ton continues to churn with intrigue as Lady Danbury (Adjoa Andoh – Doctor Who, Invictus) offers sharp counsel, Queen Charlotte (Golda Rosheuvel – Lady Macbeth, Dune: Prophecy) grows increasingly obsessed with unmasking Lady Whistledown, and Penelope Featherington (Nicola Coughlan – Derry Girls, Big Mood) quietly observes from the sidelines. “The Duke and I” marks a major tonal shift for Bridgerton, trading courtship fantasy for emotional fallout and setting the stage for the conflicts to come. Intense Suspense by Audionautix is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... Support The Channel By Getting Some REEL REJECTS Apparel! https://www.rejectnationshop.com/ Follow Us On Socials: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/reelrejects/ Tik-Tok: https://www.tiktok.com/@reelrejects?lang=en Twitter: https://x.com/reelrejects Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheReelRejects/ Music Used In Ad: Hat the Jazz by Twin Musicom is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Happy Alley by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... POWERED BY @GFUEL Visit https://gfuel.ly/3wD5Ygo and use code REJECTNATION for 20% off select tubs!! Head Editor: https://www.instagram.com/praperhq/?hl=en Co-Editor: Greg Alba Co-Editor: John Humphrey Music In Video: Airport Lounge - Disco Ultralounge by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Ask Us A QUESTION On CAMEO: https://www.cameo.com/thereelrejects Follow TheReelRejects On FACEBOOK, TWITTER, & INSTAGRAM: FB: https://www.facebook.com/TheReelRejects/ INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/reelrejects/ TWITTER: https://twitter.com/thereelrejects Follow GREG ON INSTAGRAM & TWITTER: INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/thegregalba/ TWITTER: https://twitter.com/thegregalba Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
This January on Paramount Plus, it began on the shores of New Jersey.
Now, a new pack emerges in the Great White North.
Canada Shore, new original series, now streaming on Paramount Plus.
I was guilty of multiple skin care crimes.
Two counts of sleeping and makeup.
One count of using disposable wipes.
I knew my routine had to change.
So I switched to Garnier-Missler water.
It gently cleanses, perfectly remorse.
removes makeup and provides 24-hour hydration.
Clear away the evidence with the number one Missler Water worldwide by Garnier.
Local news is in decline across Canada, and this is bad news for all of us.
With less local news, noise, rumors, and misinformation fill the void, and it gets harder to
separate truth from fiction.
That's why CBC News is putting more journalists in more places across Canada,
reporting on the ground from where you live, telling the stories that matter to all of us.
Because local news is big news.
Choose news, not noise.
CBC News.
This week's videos are sponsored by Pricepix,
the easy-to-use fantasy sports betting app.
More on them in just a bit.
No, you're the smart one between you and the other, John.
Let's do this, guys.
Guys, that was a really good episode.
They got married, they lost.
She lost her Virginia.
opportunity.
It's true.
He banged the like
150th chick
he's ever banged.
Yeah, man.
He got to, you know, really
demonstrate his expertise.
Yeah.
Here's what I want to say, guys.
Yo.
So many of you guys
have been joining our page for you on page.
Become royal rejects.
Thank you.
To those have been supporting us.
Thank you very much.
Let's forget the full reaction.
Watch.
Long will be syncing with your own copy.
Rogerton. He also get some teas at Regenation Shop.com.
Hey.
Just that one. Just only this one.
And that one.
And Prepper. Thanks for a damn. These highlights.
Blame them for why you can't see any sex on screen. It's not my fault there.
They made the laws on YouTube.
Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. So much happened here. But here's what I know.
Team Penelope.
Team Penelope. That's all I'm thinking about.
That's what I care about.
Penelope.
Yeah.
Just feel so sorry
for her, man.
I know.
They're not actually
going to get married,
are they?
Let's lay it on this prediction.
I think they're going to be
on the brink of it
and then Marina's guy
is going to actually show up.
He's got to show up.
But do we want it to be
where he's like, oh, fine,
you're not going to choose me
and then do we want Penelope
to be second choice?
No.
Right.
We don't want that.
Penelope is number one all the way.
Yeah.
More than Simon.
She should marry the prince.
She should marry Simon.
She should marry Simon.
How old is Penelope right now?
I don't.
Doesn't matter.
Let her let her get married.
The actress is definitely to tell her to marry.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
I see so.
Why not?
Most heartbreaking fart.
Start him off as soon as you can.
She's trying to be cordial.
Only a tad manipulative.
But she's also trying to be very cordial and do it in the best way possible.
Either way, Colin is getting yanked around.
There's a lot of things that might have.
be about with that situation.
Yeah, I like the way she played that, that whole thing of like, you shouldn't entrap this guy
and you know that there's a personal aspect of, of course, like, I have a crush on him,
and I don't want you to do this, but like when you're young and you're like kind of flushed
with emotion, you recognize a situation, and you're like trying to tap into purely the logic
of it, even though you have a personal investment that you're grappling with.
Yeah.
It was nice little new ones.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I feel bad for them.
But he's got to come back.
They're playing up that tension.
I hope so.
Yeah.
yeah i i 100% understand the circumstances for marina and it's tough too because of all the lie the deceit uh but yeah i want
you know penelope has such a pure heart you want to see that heart fulfilled and also you want their
friendship to be okay she and marina they look out for each other now they're at odds it's sad i like when
they also took with the queen how they actually made her a real human being this time as opposed to just a
person who is up and looking down on people and bored you actually got to take a moment to give
her a true vulnerable moment yeah that was a sad that was a sad moment really makes you care about her
recontexture it makes the scenes following that scene when you're with her feel different that's like
if you're removing that one scene with the king you could still had all those scenes but they would
play totally different to the viewer if we didn't have the other scene of the king you know every other
scene now feels like she must be so relieved
to be out and dealing with other people's
nonsense while she has this like
gravely difficult
situation going on.
Yeah. And she's already in a
very blessed but also contentious position
in society and yada yada yada
and yeah I also
just was very charmed the way that
scene toward the later part
of the episode where she's overhearing
Eloise and Lady Danbury
and then she's like
okay so what's your theory about why lady
And I don't know, I feel like because we have both clocked the two of them as potentials,
as it's just like a fun cheeky, like, oh, okay, Danbury's right here.
They framed the queen very conspicuously to be like eavesdropping on them.
So then you're like, oh, shit is great.
Maybe right.
And then the whole thing is like Eloy's like, no, I think it's Danbury.
And so like they're having fun with that.
It still could be Danbury.
It still could be damn.
I feel like Danbury is a great guess.
It still could be.
Because she's connected and she's affluent.
She's out here.
but she's not like all eyes on me at all times, you know,
whereas the queen is a kind of conspicuous at all times.
Danbury's also someone who seems to have her...
She seems to be into knowing, like, every family.
Yeah, and there's something about that actress.
The way she speaks is reminiscent of the Julie Andrews' narrations anyway.
So, I feel like there's, yeah, there's some clues there you could extrapolate.
I don't know
Or it's the king and he's faking this day
Yeah, that'd be cool
I remember the whole time
I know she's dead
We're good
We're good
I was messing with you
I just had to stay in character
Yeah throw you off the set in here
I'm actually gonna pass my whistle down page
On to you
You can write it now
I know how much you love a good story
That would be crazy
Yeah
Well the big one
Simon
Alvin the theater
are all sleeping with death.
Oh, bridge monks.
No, yeah, they got married finally.
There's so much non-communication between the two of them.
Like any good marriage.
Two people who seem to want each other so badly
and yet are like, I think you hate me
and I don't feel good when I'm around you
because we're both pent up and we don't know how to talk to each other.
And so I just feel awful,
even though we both want the same thing
and can't quite get to the page where we both understand that.
It's a good, like, drawing out of this tension.
What the hell would happen over the next?
There's like three episodes left.
I felt like that was the culmination of the relationship.
Now, well, we just watched him in, like, a domestically violent marriage.
Like, where's the drama that's going to happen from their marriage now?
It's all then leaving this.
I guess, like, part of my...
I guess if I'm guessing, my theory would be that the marriage...
Let's use the metaphor of a flight.
the marriage having the ceremony
you know setting off
toward you know your new home
that's like the plane is just taken off
so I feel like maybe
the greater end game of this season will be like
oh what's the turbulence before
they finally reach like a cruising altitude
of some kind you know in the
plane of the metaphor
it's like oh maybe we got to do another
couple of things before we're like
settled into our married life
well yeah because the whole part of them
was the love what now
it's going to be a lot of politics they probably have to contend with.
Yeah, now it's going to be like, well, we got the love, but everything else is a mess.
Yeah, they'd have to deal.
Like how his friend's wife was saying, you know, you have to understand, like, the negotiations where
what she was saying, like, it's not that I wouldn't possibly know what to predict or what could
become of it, but I imagine there could be a lot of using and requesting expectations that fall
upon them in a situation like this.
You have to be social figures in some way.
shape or form. I do like the inverse
of the
very concept that it was
feeling like it was all transactional
and them not really understanding
until after they were married that they actually
both wanted each other. They actually were
not really lying like the ruse was still
upright even to the marriage point
where they both didn't, it just couldn't
deal with, they were both like trapping each other.
They were both trying to make it. She was
trying to make it happen because she actually did
love him and even though
there always seemed to be some justification
to rush it, which sometimes
the justifications were valid.
Like, oh, I can't be seen as this person
who was in the garden and the scandals that would
arise, all those things.
Oh, also, yeah, the other part about
their marriage is that he can't have children. He's just choosing
not to. Yeah, that's right. There's the trauma there.
Unless he figured
out the old-timey vasectomy.
Yeah. Yeah, this is just a matter of will.
Yeah, yeah.
So I, I really, I like the,
I like the inverse of it, because most stories would obviously have
them realize that love and then fall in love and then get married versus doing it this way.
It all played out in ways that were unexpected, right down to them like when the proposal
happens to them getting married at all.
It was all very unexpected.
So there was something very humorous in the fact that at the end with all the avoidance
that that's the last thing either one of them wanted and they kept avoiding because
they assumed that's what the other one wanted.
You know, it's nice.
It's real.
Yeah, absolutely.
Real shit.
Yeah.
Feels like an honest miscommunication.
Yeah.
Like my wife's been avoiding me for the last 10 years since our marriage.
It's been really funny, you know.
But I know.
She just really wants to talk to me.
Because we're both just like neither of us.
I know you don't want this, even though I do.
Yeah.
She just keeps asking for that check every month.
I'm like, I know what you're really saying.
This is your way of communicating with me.
Yes, yeah.
So just keep that check coming.
Yeah.
She's sweet.
Good communication.
That's her.
I really love her.
She loves me.
We're still waiting for our consummation wedding night.
I'll come.
We did the ceremony.
We still haven't gone to the hotel yet, though.
It would come.
Don't worry, guys.
Yeah, yeah, you'll get there.
Next season.
I hear terror screaming in the other room.
Oh, yeah.
What do they watch?
Oh, yeah, they're watching 50 first dates.
Watching 50 first shades of grades.
That Walrus joke, really getting in her.
Of gray.
You have questions on this?
I think we must have questions on this, right?
That's two.
Oh, and our boy, our boy is unlocking his latent
uh,
queerness. He's getting down with it. He's getting down with
everyone. He's going to be pansexual
bridge or he's going to bone that guy is boning that guy's
wife. He's going to bone everybody
at the party and then someone's going to paint it and then
it's going to get it out and become a scandal
because people will see the painting.
They'll be like, oh no, it's
whatever year this is and we don't
support that. But we should,
but we don't. All right, John,
take it away, please.
Yo.
All right, rejects. The big game is almost
here. And for us, surreal rejects the Super Bowl is practically a holiday. You heard that right. Every year, we've got the game on the TV, friends around, and we're locked in. Because, you know, we've got all those trailers that we've got to cover. But we're also watching the game. But we're also watching the game, but we're also watching me, not a hardcore sports expert. So it's great for newbies like myself. But it's also great for people who are aware of sports app. And it's the easiest way to make watching the game even more fun, especially if you're like me, not a hardcore sports expert. So it's great for newbies like myself. But it's also great for people who are aware of sports, probably even.
better. Now, me wife, she loves fantasy sports apps. She plays a lot with her friends,
some prize picks is great. Me, on the other hand, I'm not some stats wizard. The price picks makes
it ridiculously easy for me to jump in and act like I know what I'm doing. You open the app,
pick a sport, choose players, and decide if they'll get more or less on their projected stats. No
drafts, no season-long commitments, just making lineups for the game. I also love the community
features. You can share lineups, follow winners, or copy lineups with one click. And with a
early payouts if your player starts hot you can cash out early so if you're already watching the big game with us you can make it even better download the price picks app today and use code rejects to get $50 in lineups after you play your first $5 lineup that's code rejects to get $50 on lineups after you play your first $5 lineup prize fix it's good to be right care bear thank you for chiming in dearest g and j you both seem discouraged
not to know this historical era.
I was pissed to myself.
Intelligence is not based in knowledge,
but rather curiosity.
I beg to differ.
You two leaving your comfort zone
shows true intelligence.
Thank you.
Actually, this is a very lovely comment.
Because I rather supportive comments.
I really do it.
This is the antithesis of everyone on YouTube.
This is a very nuanced company.
Why are you watching more?
I shows the American education system in this country.
Yeah.
How do you not know everything about everything
If you're going to have a camera pointed at you,
this is already not a one-to-one depiction of the history anyway.
But anyhow, what about question?
What about bridge makes you curious?
And yes.
Well, how about I connects from one section to another?
The upside down is a bridge.
And you can just walk or drive across it.
What is it a bridge to?
You know, sometimes islands, they can connect.
Like so much in New York.
Where does it go?
Yes, this is the same King George's Hamilton.
oh snap no the one in hamilton's saying way more he didn't wrap though that's true
that's true jonathan groff should be in here if he was playing the king you know what about
bridgerton makes you curious what do you mean well it seems like it's rooted in some type of
historical accuracy and it's such a look at a different type of society that i will never ever know
and there's so many rules of how to live in society
and growing up at a time when everything's about freedom
and the more time goes on like be yourself
at least this is the parts of circles I'm surrounded by
and so to see something like this where you're born into money
you're born into a very specific class of the world
and where what is the intense drama
is something can seem kind of frivolous
in the end yet so much of this is embedded in some of the biggest highest stakes that control the
world you know like i there's a lot of things to be fascinated by to it and and because it seems
rooted in an accuracy makes me curious to know what it it's like when you watch a true story
of something or something based on a true story and you want to know like what what happened here
what was what was what really happened who's this based on what uh just something like that so
yeah i'm very very curious by it i feel like i'm like i'm learning something while being
entertained you know yeah absolutely i mean stuff like this peaks my
curiosity in those ways where
partly in a show
like this in a scenario like this you wonder
what the things
are that are like surprisingly
true what things have been adjusted
because this is not a one to one
to how the history would have been
especially in terms of just like the
kind of you know the diversity
of people you're seeing on screen but yeah
this stuff
while you were talking
I got distracted because I started
listening to you and I forgot
it's like i had a thing in mind and then i was like drawn back into you know it's like when you receive a question
you're like we both need an answer to this question but then i was also like listening so then i you know
like momentarily lost sorry no it's not your fault i think it's no no no no i think it's funny i'm not
blaming you i think it's funny uh i don't know what i was i was noticing that there was a trivia on our side but i was like
this isn't for Richardson.
I need to adjust this.
This is for what Tara and Roxy are shooting.
So I didn't have moved this on the document for them.
No, what I remember now.
Stuff like this makes me very curious because I know that there is a certain amount of
modern sensibility and there's a certain amount of liberty that's being taken with
the time and place.
And so, yeah, it makes me curious about going back to brush up the well-known stuff about
just like, oh, how does society function at this moment of time, all these different
like titles, what do they mean?
But moreover, I think stuff like this is fun because it, you know, stuff from this era, I think often to the lay person appears as very sort of, again, everything is very proper and, you know, regimented and society has all these cotillions and structures and pageantry, you know, pageant elements.
And here is depicting both versions where it's like the surface level versions.
that we're used to, but like the actual, I don't know, humanity underneath or the way in which, like,
a show like this is full of characters being like, yeah, we all know how society works, but like,
it's just the two of us right now.
Okay, we can be like a little more real.
And so, like, that behind the curtain of the facade of the time is like largely what makes me
curious.
And even your, you know, a little tidbit about like 1800s opera houses being known as high class
brothels essentially.
It's like stuff like that is interesting because it's.
It's the real stuff that's happening underneath all the veneer.
And I think shows like this are fun because while there is a certain amount of height and pulp,
you're also getting the taste of something that you know actually must have been there
that so much of the stuff from the time is trying to pretend like wasn't.
Yeah.
You know, I concur.
Sand rack.
Unless, the first time.
How was you both, Bridgerton's handling of Daphne and Simon's first time?
Oh, interesting question.
How does this compare to recent shows you both have watched with explicit-ish intimacy scenes?
And given that we're only halfway through the season, what do you anticipate for Daphne and Simon's relationship now?
Well, we already kind of talked about the latter part.
It only gets better.
Oh, in terms of that scene?
I think it was handled properly for the kind of genre this one is.
This is a period piece, romantic drama, you know, so they, they're not going to do it like fucking.
You know, like a rivalry or something.
Like, it's going to be.
It has to be a, it had that right mix that had that, like, elegance to it.
Even down to like the scene where, what's that Bridgetton, Benedict?
The artist one.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Anyway, artist Bridgetter.
One is not Colin Anthony.
Uh, when he goes down, it's ABC.
It's something with a B.
Right.
yeah that's that she's down
made that she's at louise it's a bcd
um i think it's benedict
um yeah
there is a benedict and it must be
yeah because collins the one with
marina and den pen triangle
yeah yeah i just know there's an alphabet
to it so um
benedict so yeah like even right down to that
even though there's like an orgy of things
happening there's something that feels
a little polished about what we're watching
it doesn't feel like that's probably
rough in
dirty as it is there
and this had to
have that blend of
it's her first time and
so it has to feel like
a little bit like
a fantasy is being lived out but it also
has to feel a little bit passionate and rough
but it can't feel too
glossy like you're watching some weird
80s movie with silhouettes or shit
you know it had to be
I thought they actually you know
something I didn't even bother to think about but now that you ask
the question like yeah there would probably have to
thought put into how do we want to execute
this scene and I think they
hit the right mark for
how you want to capture that
particular first time
they're intimate together. Yeah absolutely
because there's so many you know in the pageantry of
society there's so many things that are
like subconsciously trying to play
on you know
human instinct and arousal and stuff
but yeah the way they zoomed in on that scene
and really took their time
and made it sensual
was nice because this
show is as when I came in
I didn't have quite a
calibration on like what to expect the level of romance
and sexuality to be and like half my brain was sort of like
oh I some some accounts of this had me expecting
much more skin you know and much more sort of sexual
situations happening I feel like we will get there
based off of how some of these scenes have been playing
I guess yeah like I don't think so I feel like we will
Well, because we've had a couple of scenes that have, like, pretty extensive nudity, but there's, like, so in four or five episodes now, much fewer and further.
But there will only been, like, a couple.
And so I guess I was like, oh, I thought there might be more of this.
And so, and that's not a good or bad thing.
I'm just, like, in leading up to the consummation moment in the inn, I thought they did a cool job of that because, you know, it's like there's pretty graphic nudity in the, you know, art house.
And even when we see Anthony and Sienna early on, you know, that's kind of, you know, like, wow, you know, especially for the time, you're not used to seeing that much.
And the scene between Simon and Daphne, I thought was lovely because, A, they really accentuated just the general sort of, you know, we're feeling each other out instinctually and we're stepping closer to each other and we're finally freed up to do this thing that normally under circumstances we're not supposed to even think about or entertain.
Sure.
They captured, yeah, that sort of rush of anticipation, the nerves, especially from Daphne that are sort of percolating underneath all that.
And yeah, it's just like when they're undressing each other, like, you know, for this time and place, that's a pretty significant thing because everyone is very, you know, dapped up and wearing many, many layers and all sorts of things.
So like seeing your partner just fully exposed is a whole thing.
And then, you know, you get the skin, but it's super tasteful largely.
so it's it allows you i feel like in a non like lurid way to be like yes the the freeing of inhibition the
skin and all that but it's also very much in the faces it's also very much in the emotion it's also very
much in the bond the way they communicated it visually so i thought it did the thing in the right
temper kind of way enough yeah dude those are all beautiful points john thank you thank you
laud me for my intellect i do
I really do.
Thank you.
Thank you very much.
I'll be here all week.
And then the last question of the day.
Jay Rushden, which reject...
Sorry, guys.
There's just something really wrong.
My neck and shoulders right now.
Which reject would be a good servant of royalty there?
Dude, I think there's only one choice.
Andrew?
Is Andrew.
Yeah.
Andrew would be the best butler of all time.
He would be on top of everything.
He would have every T dotted and I crossed.
He would be.
And then you flip him.
Yeah, he would take every job no matter how minute very seriously.
And he'd do it with pride.
You'd forget I'd steal.
Yes.
Coy would talk about the problems.
Could he assist them in that.
Coy would be too fixated on how he's above having to do this.
Roxy would question every time
Roxy would
Yeah
Aaron would fall asleep
And then Tara would just be doing her own thing
Tara would be like too excited
Get ahead of herself to other people's jobs
Tara's on the
team but people are just like
I don't know she just does whatever
She decides to do and we do whatever else is around that
Yeah
Anyway guys
This is a really fun episode
This is a great one
Yeah dude we did it
under solid episode of television.
We got busy.
Looking forward to getting more time
so we could do these two at a time.
But right now, this is a good time.
Thank you so much.
Reggiton.
We'll see you soon.
