The Reel Rejects - Extended Version: Well...Just Watched SHELBY OAKS!! Out Of Theater Reaction & Review! (Chris Stuckmann Movie)
Episode Date: October 14, 2025BEYOND FEST PREMIERE OUT OF THE THEATRE REVIEW!! Shelby Oaks Movie Review - Veteran YouTube movie critic Chris Stuckmann makes his feature directorial debut with a psychological found-footage horror e...pic!! Save & Invest In Your Future Today, visit: https://www.acorns.com/rejects Shelby Oaks marks YouTuber-turned-filmmaker Chris Stuckmann’s bold leap from film critic to feature director. Shelby Oaks (2024) is a supernatural horror mystery built around the disappearance of a paranormal investigation team and the dark secrets hidden in the abandoned town that bears their name. The film follows Mia (Camille Sullivan – Hunter Hunter, The Man in the High Castle), haunted by the disappearance of her sister Riley (Sarah Durn – Interview with the Vampire), as she searches for answers years later, retracing Riley’s last known steps with the Paranormal Paranoids team. Along the way, cryptic found-footage tapes, chilling revelations, and supernatural forces threaten to tear the boundary between life and death. The ensemble cast also includes Brendan Sexton III (Welcome to the Dollhouse, Maniac) as Robert, Mia’s husband; Michael Beach (ER, Waiting to Exhale) as Detective Burke; Keith David (They Live, The Thing) as Morton Jacobson; along with Robin Bartlett (Inside Llewyn Davis, Shutter Island), Charlie Talbert (American Pie, The Faculty), and others in supporting roles. Some of the most talked-about moments include the reveal of the second “lost tape” that was never found by police, the atmosphere-rich found footage sequences that echo Blair Witch and Sinister vibes, and the film’s twisty third act that leans heavily into supernatural horror tropes. Did the film leave us STUCKMANIZED??? Listen to Greg's out-of-theatre review to find out! Intense Suspense by Audionautix is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... Support The Channel By Getting Some REEL REJECTS Apparel! https://www.rejectnationshop.com/ Follow Us On Socials: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/reelrejects/ Tik-Tok: https://www.tiktok.com/@reelrejects?lang=en Twitter: https://x.com/reelrejects Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheReelRejects/ Music Used In Ad: Hat the Jazz by Twin Musicom is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Happy Alley by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... POWERED BY @GFUEL Visit https://gfuel.ly/3wD5Ygo and use code REJECTNATION for 20% off select tubs!! Head Editor: https://www.instagram.com/praperhq/?hl=en Co-Editor: Greg Alba Co-Editor: John Humphrey Music In Video: Airport Lounge - Disco Ultralounge by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Ask Us A QUESTION On CAMEO: https://www.cameo.com/thereelrejects Follow TheReelRejects On FACEBOOK, TWITTER, & INSTAGRAM: FB: https://www.facebook.com/TheReelRejects/ INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/reelrejects/ TWITTER: https://twitter.com/thereelrejects Follow GREG ON INSTAGRAM & TWITTER: INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/thegregalba/ TWITTER: https://twitter.com/thegregalba Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Ontario, the wait is over.
The gold standard of online casinos has arrived.
Golden Nugget Online Casino is live.
Bringing Vegas-style excitement and a world-class gaming experience right to your fingertips.
Whether you're a seasoned player or just starting, signing up is fast and simple.
And in just a few clicks, you can have access to our exclusive library of the best slots and top-tier table games.
Make the most of your downtime with unbeatable promotions and jackpots that can turn any mundane moment into a golden,
opportunity at Golden Nugget Online Casino. Take a spin on the slots, challenge yourself at the
tables, or join a live dealer game to feel the thrill of real-time action, all from the comfort
of your own devices. Why settle for less when you can go for the gold at Golden Nugget
Online Casino. Gambling problem call connects Ontario 1866531-260. 19 and over, physically present
in Ontario. Eligibility restrictions apply. See Golden Nuggett Casino.com for details. Please play responsibly.
Rejignation. I'm in a Ross parking lot right now to save money on very overpriced parking.
Anyway, I just got out of watching the highly anticipated, especially in our YouTube space,
Chris Stockman's new movie Shelby Oaks. In case you guys haven't seen the trailer,
here's the basic setup. Shelby Oaks. There's this character named Mia. She's played by Camille Sullivan,
and she's this woman who's searching for answers about her sister Riley, who vanished years ago,
along with their paranormal investigator group, they're called the paranormal paranoids.
And as Mia digs into this old footage and these forgotten leads, she's drawn back
to this eerie town of Shelby Oaks, where the line between imagination and something darker grows
increasingly more blurred. Now, before I down to my thoughts and feelings, I want to be totally
upfront about a couple of things. First, I was one of the many people who contributed to
the Kickstarter that helped get this movie made, so I've been anticipating this film for
quite some time. Second, I did have the fortunate opportunity to sit down with Chris himself
for this very long, in-depth conversation about life, filmmaking, the journey's obstacles,
of being a YouTuber making that leap into feature directing. And at one point, we even talked about
his philosophy of not reviewing movies he doesn't like. I should have told him that if I don't like
this movie, I'll have to be honest. Even though I've got to have that privilege with him, you're still
going to get my real thoughts. That said, if there is any layer of bias here, here's what I think it would
be. Doing all that research before speaking with Chris, it did give me a deeper sense of what this
movie is about and why he made it. That pre-understanding, I would say definitely enhance the experience
for me. And be aware that it's his first feature as a writer-director did shape how I watched it,
but even with all that, I feel like I'd be walking out with practically the same opinion either
way, honestly. The first thing I want to get major props to is the ambition and execution, though,
of the writing and the directing. This film pulls off this fascinating blend. That's part found
footage, part-traditional horror, or part-traditional filmmaking, I should say. And that marriage is not
easy. The tones of those two sub-genres are so different. If the transitions aren't handled well,
it could feel like tonal whiplash. But Chris and his team, they managed to make it.
work and honestly the first time the film shifts gears you could feel the whole audience react it
was kind of a badass moment actually a lot of the found footage in true crime documentary segments
they felt so raw and natural that i assume they must have been improvised and cleaned up in the
edit come to find out turns out all of that was scripted that shocked me when i found that out later
because i think it speaks to the naturalism of both the writing and the performances that ability to
make scripted material feel messy i mean that in a complimentary way feel messy and authentic
is one of the hardest things to pull off in horror.
Visually, this movie has this heavy, dreadful atmosphere, yet there's a very engaging pace
to it.
Like, it gets going into the ride pretty quick.
There's a real style behind the lens, but it never tips over into showy for the sake of being
showy.
It walks that line where it looks polished and often way more expensive than its actual
budget, but still retains that grit.
The practical effects are, they're genuinely unsettling, and when paired with the visual
effects. You get moments that really crawl under your skin. And something I didn't expect to say,
Chris and his team created a world. I literally had to Google afterwards whether Shelby Oaks is a
real place in Ohio. I didn't even bother to think that. That's how convincing this movie is
at selling its own mythology. It taps into that urban legend energy where you start wondering
if this history is something based on an already existing something or another. I can't
find the word for some reason, but that world building is horror done right. And this film
rests heavily on Camille Sullivan as Mia. She absolutely delivers. She's a woman who sacrificed so
much of her own well-being in pursuit of her sister. The way Camille plays her is layered. Sometimes
it's desperate. Sometimes it's reckless. Sometimes it's heartbreakingly strong. Early on, though,
I did catch myself questioning her choices in that horror movie way of like,
is she being stupid right now? Is she desperate? Is it both? You know, those moments for horror
protagonists go off alone, and you're like, come on. Come on. But the movie earns those
choices by showing how isolated she is. No one supports her. No one believes her. So she has no
choice but to confront this darkness herself. And that flips a lot of horror cliches on their
head. Friends, family, I wasn't raised what you would call financially literate. At the young
age, we did lose her house. I have what you might call money trauma, I guess. So when it came to
running a business here, I take that very serious. And I know how to run this business. But when it
comes to investing outside of that, I've always felt scared. And that's why Acorns has been
absolutely amazing. For you guys who don't know what Acorns is, it's a financial wellness app
that helps you invest for your future, save for tomorrow, and spend smarter today all in one
place. Favorite part, you really don't need to be like a finance whiz. I use words like
whiz now. With just your spare change, Acorns automatically invest into an expert built portfolio,
and they even have a checking account that invests as you spend. And an emergency fund that
that grows your money over time. Before we signed up with them, I remember distinctly.
One of our hosts, Roxy Stryor, tell me once how her investment in Acorns once really helped
get her out of a very bad financial spot. And that, of course, stuck with me, so I went on the
journey with them, and it is nice opening up that app. And I really love that you don't need
like a big chunk of change. You could start with such a small amount. First month, I started like
with $20. Now I go with $100 because fortunate enough, we can. So Reject Nation, you can sign up now
at acorns.com slash real rejects and acorns will boost your new account with a five dollars bonus
investment because we're talking about money i do have to say pay not client endorsement tier two
compensation provided investing involves risk acorn advisors at lcc cc registered investment advisor view
you're just atacorn slash rejects thank you again acorns for being
gaslit or dismissed as crazy mea gets agency she's afraid yes but she knows she has to move forward
alone that makes her a protagonist who actually root for and she when she's terrified
it feels so damn real those moments of fear help sell the scares tenfold i also want to shout
out sarah durn as riley even though she only pops in intermittently those moments have to land
hard and they do riley's journey is told in this non-traditional way but sarah nails every single
beat she's in i feel like this movie does balance character-driven dread with moments of genuine terror
terror and when it does aim for scares it delivers there were sequences where the entire theater
went silent and then you'd hear that ripple of nervous laughter moving across the crowd,
that kind of nervous laughter you only get in a horror movie.
That's like a great communal horror movie experience.
I got genuinely scared a few times.
There are twists and turns that kept me on edge.
One twist in particular absolutely shook me.
I didn't see it coming at all and it's a kind of reveal I'll never forget.
It was the first thing I was talking with people about after the credits rolled.
The music and sound design is great.
The score.
It deserves serious praise.
It's unnerving, creative.
and it feels like a legit horror score is considered the budget sometimes you expect that but it's not it's not just like stock sounds it's not just like stock sounds pasted over scenes it's prepared for that smart sound design and you've got tension that lingers i always look out for sound design and indie horror because it's usually like the first thing that feels amateur but here it's sharp calculated and chris knows when to let the silence do the work although within the silence it was just like one beat that i thought was a little bit repetitive it sometimes with mea when she's like alone and something scary is happening is a lot of
of that like, she's like, you can't see my face, but it's like, like, she's scared, and then she's
this very slow turn to see what's behind her. I felt like it was a little bit of a too much
of a repeat beat, but even though it was repetitive, still kind of got me every time. Anyway,
all in all, Shelby Oaks, it did pretty much give me exactly what I showed up for. It's fun,
it's creepy. It dips into that elevated horror territory without ever drowning itself and
self-serious. It's smart, but it's not pretentious. It's stylish, but never masturbatory. However,
If I have one big critique, it's most noticeable shortcomings for me about in the last 10 to 15 minutes.
Personally, I do think this movie could have used an extra 10 to 20.
That finale has some awesome stuff, but in its final moments, a few things felt a little bit rushed, almost B movie, and how quickly they were handled.
Like, it's still entertaining, but I think a longer version could have made those beats hit a lot harder.
It's tough to explain without spoiling, but for me, the last stretch didn't land as powerfully as the rest of the film.
I heard someone say, especially about something else, that it felt tacked on.
I wouldn't say that.
Like, the choices definitely feel intentional.
Like, that was always a part of the story.
So it definitely wraps up the story.
But I did feel like we needed to live in some other stuff more, allow more breath.
But I really can't talk about it.
But when you see it, you know, maybe we can argue about it.
And in all, honestly, it's a small gripe in the bigger picture.
The journey itself is strong.
Again, it's creepy, scary, atmospheric.
It's ambitious.
It made me tense.
It made me nervous, laugh nervously with the crowd.
It shocked me at times.
and it impressed me on a very on a craft level and for a debut feature it's really impressive so yeah
i enjoyed the hell out of this movie kudos to chris in a weird way i feel really proud of him and
i recommend you go watch shelby oakes leave a like on this video get rejectedized and it only works
with stuckman's words can stucmanize him he's got a thing all right yeah this video's done