The Reel Rejects - STRANGER THINGS Season 4 Episode 5 REVIEW!!!
Episode Date: August 30, 2025DR. BRENNER RETURNS For The Nina Project!! Stranger Things Full Episode Reaction Watch Along: / thereelrejects Get your New Customer offer + 3-month Unlimited wireless plan for just 15 bu...cks a month at https://www.mintmobile.com/REJECTS With Stranger Things 5 on the way this winter, it's time for Tara & Andrew to continue their marathon with their Stranger Things Season 4x5 Reaction, Recap & Breakdown! Stranger Things Reaction, Recap, Commentary, Analysis, & Spoiler Review! After the chilling events of Stranger Things Season 4, Episode 4, Tara Erickson & Andrew Gordon (CinePals) continue their journey into the Hawkins nightmare with Episode 5: The Nina Project. This episode follows Eleven (Millie Bobby Brown – Enola Holmes, Godzilla vs. Kong) as she enters Dr. Brenner’s (Matthew Modine – Full Metal Jacket, The Dark Knight Rises) “Nina Project” lab in Nevada to regain her powers with the help of Dr. Owens (Paul Reiser – Aliens, Whiplash). Meanwhile, Mike Wheeler (Finn Wolfhard – It, Ghostbusters: Afterlife), Will Byers (Noah Schnapp – Abe), Jonathan Byers (Charlie Heaton – The New Mutants), and Argyle (Eduardo Franco – Booksmart) uncover clues about Nina after the shocking desert escape. Back in Hawkins, Nancy Wheeler (Natalia Dyer – Velvet Buzzsaw), Steve Harrington (Joe Keery – Free Guy), Robin Buckley (Maya Hawke – Do Revenge), Max Mayfield (Sadie Sink – The Whale), Dustin Henderson (Gaten Matarazzo – Honor Society), and Lucas Sinclair (Caleb McLaughlin – Concrete Cowboy) explore Victor Creel’s (Robert Englund – A Nightmare on Elm Street) house, piecing together Vecna’s deadly curse. With multiple storylines converging and Eleven confronting her past, this episode is full of suspense, eerie revelations, and major hints about Vecna’s origin. Popular moments include Eleven’s training inside the Nina tank, the desert burial scene, and the Hawkins crew’s chilling discovery inside the Creel House. Follow Andrew Gordon on Socials: YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@MovieSource Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/agor711/?hl=en Twitter: https://twitter.com/Agor711 Follow Tara Erickson: Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@TaraErickson Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/taraerickson/ Twitter: https://twitter.com/thetaraerickson Intense Suspense by Audionautix is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... Support The Channel By Getting Some REEL REJECTS Apparel! https://www.rejectnationshop.com/ Follow Us On Socials: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/reelrejects/ Tik-Tok: https://www.tiktok.com/@reelrejects?lang=en Twitter: https://x.com/reelrejects Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheReelRejects/ Music Used In Ad: Hat the Jazz by Twin Musicom is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Happy Alley by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... POWERED BY @GFUEL Visit https://gfuel.ly/3wD5Ygo and use code REJECTNATION for 20% off select tubs!! Head Editor: https://www.instagram.com/praperhq/?hl=en Co-Editor: Greg Alba Co-Editor: John Humphrey Music In Video: Airport Lounge - Disco Ultralounge by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Ask Us A QUESTION On CAMEO: https://www.cameo.com/thereelrejects Follow TheReelRejects On FACEBOOK, TWITTER, & INSTAGRAM: FB: https://www.facebook.com/TheReelRejects/ INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/reelrejects/ TWITTER: https://twitter.com/thereelrejects Follow GREG ON INSTAGRAM & TWITTER: INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/thegregalba/ TWITTER: https://twitter.com/thegregalba Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Ontario, the wait is over.
The gold standard of online casinos has arrived.
Golden Nugget Online Casino is live.
Bringing Vegas-style excitement and a world-class gaming experience right to your fingertips.
Whether you're a seasoned player or just starting.
Signing up is fast and simple.
And in just a few clicks, you can have access to our exclusive library of the best slots and top-tier table games.
Make the most of your downtime with unbeatable promotions and jackpots that can turn any mundane moment into a golden
opportunity at Golden Nugget Online Casino. Take a spin on the slots, challenge yourself at the
tables, or join a live dealer game to feel the thrill of real-time action, all from the comfort
of your own devices. Why settle for less when you can go for the gold at Golden Nugget
Online Casino. Gambling problem call connects Ontario 1866531-260. 19 and over. Physically present
in Ontario. Eligibility restrictions apply. See Golden Nuggett Casino.com for details. Please play responsibly.
This episode is brought to you by Defender.
With a towing capacity of 3,500 kilograms and a weighting depth of 900 millimeters,
the Defender 110 pushes what's possible.
Learn more at landrover.ca.
When you're with Amex Platum,
you get access to exclusive dining experiences and an annual travel credit.
So the best tapas in town might be in a new town altogether.
That's the powerful backing of Amex.
Terms and conditions apply.
Learn more at amex.ca.
slash yamex.
This video is sponsored by MintMobil.
More on them very soon.
Three, two, one.
five we're on the roll we just got done watching stranger things episode five good old time
if you're at least anything to us on apple or spot five please give us five star rating do all
the youtube things like comment subscribe ring the bell ring the bell um yeah so that you're
notified when we drop other videos we're going to get right into our
patreon special thanks to the fine folks over at prepper for reading down these highlights we appreciate
it.
Yeah.
Prepper used the best.
They also edit my stuff on my channel.
Go check that out if you haven't already.
Oh, yeah.
Also, I forgot to tell you guys.
My podcast just dropped like last week when I had COVID.
It's called the RagePod.
So if you can go listen to that on Apple or Spotify, that would really help us out.
Leave the comment, rate it five stars.
Yeah, it's a fun one.
Go check it out.
The Rage Pod.
All right.
Theo says, what did you guys think of Dr. Martin Brenner,
aka Papa coming back,
do you think he's actually going to help 11
or does he have an ulterior motive?
Also, what do you think about the way
they incorporated Young 11 in the flashbacks?
I personally love the cinematography
and transitions in those.
So, as you all know, as we were reacting in real time,
I thought at first it was like PTSD trauma
visualization and I thought he wasn't really there,
but I definitely, I love Matthew Modin.
He's a phenomenal actor,
so I'm glad that he's back on the show.
It's so hard.
And again, the writers do such an incredible job of always being unpredictable and throwing curveballs whenever they do.
I think Owens has, like, he has 11's, you know, he doesn't have ulterior motives.
And he has her, you know, her, how am I trying to articulate this?
Best interest at heart.
Thank you.
He has her best interest at heart.
So when it comes to Dr. Brenner, I think it's a combination of the two.
think he does want her to have her powers back and does care about her but he does it in
his own way and i think he does have ulterior motives too so again i think there's a fine line
there between the two again we shall see in regards to what you said about how the incorporation
of young eleven and the flashbacks and how they filmed it and the transitions i thought it was
done incredibly i loved how they did it just a little nip pick i thought some of the this is
just me because I have a very big pet peeve with, was it de-aging. Sometimes I think it looks like
really good. Oh, no, I think that was a real, it was a real, uh, girl or boy. I don't think they
de-aged it. Oh, they did. Okay. I thought it was. I think it was like a look-alike young kid.
Oh, okay. I thought they were de-aging that was C. Well, you guys can let us know. Yeah, let us know
because I didn't think the de-aging was fantastic. But having said that I was so emotionally pulled in
and like feeling it that it wasn't like, uh, it didn't bother
me like a ton, just more the visual
of it. But I love that
what was happening in the scene. And like, again,
how she was tapping into her trauma to try
and get her powers back was
very visceral and the emotional
complexity of what was happening.
But what about you? Yeah.
I think that Papa is
obviously power hungry. We realize
that in watching this whole entire
series. So there's no doubt
in my mind that there would be some
sort of ulterior motive
for him to get his like full
power back especially like after surviving right he's got to be even more power hungry than ever but
there is a part that even when we're watching the flashback he's like he's like they think that you're
weak because he knows what her button is to push her that far to get her to a place where she can
use her powers which is nice to see so it's like he knows how to push her he may be pushing her a little
too far, but we'll see. I'm not sure what power he would
gain other than if 11 trusts him now
and still calls him freaking Papa, right? That's a plus for him, but
we'll see what happens to the end. I don't really know where his place is in the story
except just to help 11. And with the young 11
stuff, I actually really did love the cinematography and the way they edit
it, the cuts. They placed 11 at really the right
framing in the camera.
that she was probably sitting down
so that when the
little one, which I do think is
like just another human who doesn't
look exactly like Millie Bobby Brown,
but looks a lot like her.
Yeah. And then they can
interstitially like cut in between,
which I loved. I thought it was great.
Yeah, I did know that they used a younger actress
to play that part, but I just,
I thought they maybe CGI'd and DHed over the face.
Maybe they did. That's what I thought.
But again, it was really good.
Yeah.
All right, from Jessica Houser, thank you for being a royal regic for asking the question.
We appreciate it.
The satanic panic was a period of intense fear and suspicion in the 1980s and early 1990s,
characterized by widespread accusations of satanic ritual abuse,
particularly of children, despite a lack of credible evidence.
Belief in the existence of satanic cults led to investigations into seemingly innocuous symbols,
music like heavy metal and games like Dungeons and Dragons
as evidence of satanic influence.
Jason is obviously convinced Hellfire is a satanic cult.
Do you see a way for him to let go of that and help the group
or do you believe he will continue to incite fear and anger in the community all season?
I love your connection of Gaston and Jason Tara, extremely accurate.
I agree with that.
Oh, that you love it.
Oh, do you want to start on this one?
the satanic panic thing is like it's wild because it like what you're saying
Jessica as you're saying is characterized by widespread accusations of satanic ritual abuse
particularly of children which reminds me of like wigi boards and sure dungeons and dragons
but I don't I feel like it what we didn't know in the 80s is what we didn't know right
that like dungeons and dragons is a game although it's new and it seems spooky
it's like things that you don't understand
you're going to like think negatively of
so I feel like there is a way
for him to sort of let it go
but I don't think he will
what I do think he'll continue to do is insight
like fear and anger
but here's what we did just get to see
what I was thinking when when
you know his friend goes up and
I'm like oh great Jason
seeing it. It's not freaking Eddie. Eddie's in the
freaking water. His friend is being ripped apart by
sci-fi unknown. So we would hope that Jason
is a good enough guy. We have seen the good side of him
a little bit of it. And it's understandable his guest
on side because he really just think a person had to have done
that to Chrissy. So we'll have to see. But I feel
like he may calm down now because I think that he might
be a reasonable human being. Well,
have to see you make a very good point i also need to look up myself on youtube just like more about
like this whole thing you're talking about too because i remember we got that question earlier on
the season i didn't i think to terris point you would think a reasonable person would see what
happened and go okay eddie is not doing this supernatural stuff eddie's innocent he didn't he didn't
uh you know he didn't uh take out chrissey rather so in my mind though i think what's and again
And usually I'm wrong on the predictions anyways.
For the most part, sometimes I get it right.
I think what's going to happen is what Jason just witnessed there in the water,
I think he's going to think that because Eddie was within five to ten feet of the incident,
some kind of satanic ritual.
It's still happening around him.
He was near Chrissy when it happened.
He was near this incident when it happened.
So it's all connected to Eddie somehow.
So he's not going to stop blaming Eddie and he's still going to keep ramping up the Gaston type of fear towards
Eddie and the Hellfire Club.
So I do not see that stopping in any way,
shape, or form. I hope Tara is right.
I hope I'm wrong. And I hope he sees
the light of day and he's able to calm himself.
But when we were in a fit of rage, and also
when you're near the person you are blaming and
another incident happens, I just do not
see logic having
its way. Yeah, we shall
see, baby.
Jess Delange, I know we
talked a lot in other reaction Q&As
about the team ups like Dustin and Steve,
iconic, Stephen Robin, Joyce and
hop but did you ever see a team up like joyson murray being so epic they're like chalk and cheese
but i love their banter and how they compliment each other in these crazy situations who's
your favorite new team up of the season so far i knew that i've said this at nauseam but i mean the
duffer brothers and the entire writing team they just deserve so much credit for all these different
types of units and duos that they come up with they're they're so good i don't know how they
decide to come up with all right we came up with we came up with
Dustin and Steve in this one.
We're going to come up with this one, but I agree.
I think it might actually be, I'm not to try to be boring, but it might actually be
Joyce and Murray.
I've really enjoyed, like, they are so polar opposite.
And I think those are some of my favorite types of team ups is the polar opposite ones.
Like, Murray is, he's like a very bit, he's very cynical and a conspiracy theorist type of guy,
at least that's how he was when we met him originally.
And Joyce, she's just a happy, well, I mean,
very paranoid, obviously, with what's happened with Will over the first two seasons, understandably so.
But very, like, when we met her, just a very happy-go mom at, you know, working type of mother in that sense.
And it's like they couldn't be more opposite, but their interactions are golden.
I love their dialogue and how they operate with each other and how they react to each other.
It's just perfect.
And the chemistry between Winona Ryder, and I'm so sorry, I don't know the actor's name who plays Murray, is so damn.
good honestly like the casting in this show is perfect uh i can't think of one casting that i do not
love but i that and i would say to uh robin and uh nancy i love that those two teaming up as well
yeah that's what i was going to talk about is like i i was going to say what she forgot in
there is the the robin and nancy but i did talk about that in the last episode i also talked about
joyce and murray because that was new newly they were together and they were together and
just landed at Uri's and then they were they were passed out whatever so i'm glad that they made
it they knocked him out um and i'm glad that it was finally now recognized by steve the team up
between nancy and robin that he's like well i'm glad you guys are friends now you know um and that
it all happened in front of robin steve they're all there going like it's platonic with a capital
p and he's like you know we're not dating like she's not my i mean
I would, but like, but he still didn't spill her secret, which he could have because Nancy is
right there and you know he still loves her.
We can tell in that look that like she still is going to have feelings for him.
He's an attractive guy and she has not seen Jonathan in such a long time and she's been
in such close proximity with Steve and he's been really helping, right?
He's like at the core of this group right now.
And it was really sweet when he said like, baby we all get to hang out and Jonathan like when
he comes back what it like that was just an awesome like place to put that conversation in there
to where they can all banter back and forth and it's like very clear Steve is not dating Robin
they are platonic friends with a capital P and now we sort of get uh the vibe back you know with
nancy and Steve but um I do think that Nancy and Robin's relationship has been the most fun
for me lately in the new team ups it's awesome
Yeah.
All right, from Just Delange.
No, I just read that one.
Oh, you just read that one.
I'm so sorry.
My bad.
From Moni.
A Reject Nation.
You know it doesn't belong
in your epic summer
moving into fall plans?
Getting burned by your old wireless bill.
While you're planning barbecues,
beach days, and, you know, long weekends.
Your phone bill should be the last thing holding you back.
That's why the Alba Residence has done it.
They've made the switch.
You've heard of them before.
Mintem Mobile.
Today's spot.
It actually happened.
With Mint, we still get the coverage and speed we're used to.
Same phone, same numbers, same contacts, but for way less money.
And as someone who often gets like decision weight fatigue,
I am surprised about how simple the switch actually was.
All of MinMobil's plans come with high speed data,
unlimited talk and text,
delivered on the nation's largest 5G network.
And for a limited time, new customers can get three months of unlimited premium wireless service
for just $15 a month.
Your friends are sweating over overcharges and surprising fees.
Losers.
They're not losers.
They just haven't been informed yet about the great MIMMobil.
Anyway, you'll be chilling, literally, and financially.
We now use MimMobile, and you should too.
It's helped us ditch overpriced wireless and save real money without sacrifice and quality.
My God, those are my love language.
This year, skip breaking a sweat and breaking the bank.
Get this new customer offer on your three-month unlimited wireless plan for just 15 bucks a month
that mintmobile.com slash
rejects. That's mintmobile.com
slash rejects. I believe it's, I'm finally
able to say it. I've been wanting to work with him for so long.
So I definitely know I have to say this.
Up front payment of $45 required equivalent to $15 a month.
Limited time. New customer offer for first three months.
Only speeds may slow above 35 gigabytes on a limited plan.
Taxes of fees. ExtraC. Mint Mobile for
for preserving quality, but saving us money.
Uh, episode.
Uh, hi, Terran Andrew.
Hello.
I'm loving these stranger things reactions.
And I am so glad you two were, uh, the,
the picks to do this.
serious. Thank you. Appreciate that. We are too because we love it. How are you feeling about the
development of Steve and Nancy's juice as Tara would say, by the way, we need a shirt of that
over the course of the show and the slow burn rekindling of their relationship so far. I'm
curious to see how it will play into the Nancy Jonathan dynamic as it's been established that
they're on different wavelengths and haven't been honest with each other about how they feel regarding
their futures. Steve and Nancy as a duo quickly became a highlight of this season for me
and I'm excited for you both to see what's in store for them.
I mean, you were just kind of talking about that, right?
I was. Yeah, I kind of just covered that.
But I also am curious to see how it's going to play into the Nancy Jonathan dynamic
because I get what you're saying that it's like they're on different wavelengths.
And like I said, Jonathan has really changed a lot with Argyle where it's like he's not this like go getter that was working at the newspaper.
his life has changed in a way
that I'm not sure would fit
Nancy's lifestyle at this point
and so I'm a little bit nervous
about it but they're still giving
us little clues like in the last episode
Jonathan looked at a picture
of him and Nancy and was
like this this fond nostalgic
smile that like obviously
still loves her still cares for her
but man oh man we
we really feel that chemistry through the screen
with Nancy and Steve so it's
they're toying with it here. The juices are
flowing. They're really going. Yeah, I do love the chemistry between Nancy and Steve for sure.
And I will say for Jonathan, we did touch a lot upon it about, you know, about smoking the
grass now that he's friends with Argyll. I think a big part of it too is he's had so much weight
on his shoulders. He's the man of the family. You know, he doesn't have his father's not there
to support them. And he's the man of the house, rather. And, you know, that's a lot of responsibility
for a young man.
So, like, to be able to just chill and calm down.
And also, he's away from his girlfriend now, long-distance relationship.
I can understand the urge to want to just, I don't know, I'm just going to chill and smoke.
Like, I can understand why he's going through that phase right now.
But in this episode, when shit got real again, Jonathan was like, he, like, did what he needed to do.
Like, he was keeping everything calm like he always does and was the go-getter you were talking about.
And I appreciate that.
When Jonathan needs to be responsible or do his thing, he,
is the man. I love Jonathan so much.
So that is going to
create, and as much as I love Steve
and Nancy, and it looks like
we're possibly hanging that way, it seems
like we're heading for a love triangle here.
And, you know, love triangles
can be very nasty, and they can also be
very fascinating when it comes to a writing perspective
in an audience because we love all three of these
characters. So it's like, what do we
do here? And, you know,
I'm curious to see what's going to happen.
We shall see.
Dee, the Shadow. So sorry about the small mishap last week where I misremembered when Will grabbed his painting. No Problemo.
This episode we get to see Nancy and Robin continue to work together. What are your thoughts in the fact that Robin seems to be the first friend that Nancy has been starting to make, because a woman since Barb has passed.
Maybe that's one of the reasons she seemed a bit cold to Robin to begin with. What are your thoughts on this new duo?
I thought she was cold. That's a great point. I didn't even think about that after Barb, but that makes total sense.
and also too, I thought she was being cold to Robin because she was into Steve
and she thought that her and Steve kind of had a thing going,
didn't realize that they were platonic with a capital P.
But, I mean, thoughts about the duo, I love them.
They work so well with each other.
I think my favorite moment with them,
besides how they were bickering with each other when she did think that her instead,
that Robin and Steve were a little bit into each other,
my favorite moment has to be when they were getting their way into the place to see Victor Creel.
and they were improvising on the spot
and Robin did her thing
but I love the way they compliment and work together
their interactions are so good
but that is such a great point
you make about how she'd be afraid to have
another female friend after Barb
I mean there's some serious
PTSD when it comes to that and I didn't even
think about that so really good point
what about you? Yeah I think it's probably linked to both
probably a little bit of the hesitation with Barb
and then
the feelings that she's
still is lingering with Steve a little bit.
But what I really loved in this episode is that when they team up, Nancy goes
Robin and she just, she knows right away.
She doesn't even say like with me.
She just goes Robin and they go upstairs.
And then Steve is left with Dustin.
And then they have that argument like, oh, so I'm boring you now, which is very, very funny.
They find really great ways in the writing to add comedy and some levity to all the series.
and, like, the horror of it.
And I think that's what makes this just such a standout phenomenal show.
Well, said.
You have to have levity in horror, I think.
It helps break the tension a little bit.
Yeah.
And I think I've already talked about, like, the duo a bunch in the last question.
So I'm definitely loving it.
All right.
Last question from Jay Rushden.
What up, Jay?
From Tara and Andrew, Kate Bush and Stan Bush are not related.
Both feature number one songs in 1986, oddly.
I think Stan Bush. I love Stan Bush, actually.
Does this remind you more of X-Men with Papa and mentor-like role?
So we are off to find Susie. Weird.
Question, what reject would you go on a road trip with?
Huh.
I don't know who I would do that with because they would probably get so sick of annoyed with me
that they would say, I don't ever want to work with you again.
Who would I go on a road trip with?
I mean, I'm basically on a road trip every day with Aaron.
Flip with them, right?
a year now I technically did go on a road trip with Greg and John when Greg got married a couple
years ago right so there you go there so probably Greg and John right because they're your best
buddies here kind of yeah we're all so I feel like we're all so close we could all just
go on a whole like our road trip together but what about you yeah I was going to say like the
thing with them going off to find Susie we do have to remember
She was the one that I believe did the grades stuff.
Remember when she hacked into the Hawkins School System?
That's why we're going to Susie.
It's not just because that one time with the radio
where they sing the never-ending story song,
which was great, which feels like a lifetime ago.
She is the only hacker that we know.
So I think it's really fun that they're bringing her back in that way
when we haven't really seen her in a minute.
So I am excited
Although I do think it's weird
But not really
Because they are all aware
Of who fix those grades
That was Susie
And on the road trip
I feel like I don't know
We would just
We would all go
You know what I would do
I'd be like I'll follow you guys
In my car
And we'll hang out when we stop
It's got to be Roxy
The She Jex
Yeah
It most likely
definitely most likely would be
because at least we like the same music
my thing with like road trips
is if it's like completely
different music then I'm like oh god
you know and then I would
cat sit for you
yeah because I love your cat
they're adorable
they're so cute they really are
they're the best
um well we love
this journey
this season's incredible I'm obsessed
with this show but this season
is absolutely incredible and I can't wait to see what happens with just in general the backstory of bechna what happens with hopper
after with the touchdown now and also we didn't even mention mike and will uh looks like will is in love with mike possibly
it looked like there was a hint of that so i'm very curious that there are so many things that are
have to happen here in the next four episodes or so because like he was saying it in subtext about like
you know you're worried about like how someone's going to think about the truth or some of that so I'm like okay and then he had that poster that he made for for Mike and then so it seems that he's in love with him which I think is adorable but I'm curious how Mike's going to react to that because he's also in well he said I care for 11 but like he still love he probably still loves right so again possible another love triangle there we'll see there's just trying love triangles all over the place everywhere yeah but we love this show we love that you guys are
joining us and sending us questions can't wait to watch the next one with you guys keep all the
comments and the likes going we super appreciate you and we will see you on the next one want to know
what life on the tennis tour is really like we're here to give you all of the deeds from our most
chaotic travel days to our late night laughs we're pulling back the curtain on the stories you've
never heard this is the players box hosted by me madame
and Keys, Jessica Baguola, Jenny Brady, and Desiree Kravchek. We're taking our conversation
out of the group chat and into the podcast so you can have an all-access pass. We'll talk
breaking tennis news, behind the scenes, our hot takes, and everything you don't see. We'll even
let you sit in our players box with us by answering your real-time questions right on the podcast.
So listen now to the players box on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcast, and watch us
on YouTube.
Thank you.