The Reel Rejects - THE NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS (1993) MOVIE REVIEW
Episode Date: October 27, 2025THIS IS HALLOWEEN, THIS IS HALLOWEEN!! The Nightmare Before Christmas Reaction Watch Along: / thereelrejects Receive your New Customer offer + 3-month Unlimited wireless plan for just 15... bucks a month at https://www.mintmobile.com/REJECTS Grab The New TARAfier Tee & Halloween Sweater: https://www.rejectnationshop.com/ With Halloween drawing near, Aaron & Johnald give their The Nightmare Before Christmas Movie Commentary Reaction, Recap, Breakdown, & Spoiler Review! Aaron Alexander & John Humphrey react to The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993), the iconic stop-motion musical fantasy directed by Henry Selick (Coraline, James and the Giant Peach) and based on the original story and characters created by Tim Burton (Edward Scissorhands, Beetlejuice). Produced by Danny Elfman and Caroline Thompson, this beloved cult classic bridges the worlds of Halloween and Christmas in one unforgettable tale. The film follows Jack Skellington (voiced by Chris Sarandon – Fright Night, The Princess Bride, with singing voice by Danny Elfman – Oingo Boingo, The Simpsons) as the Pumpkin King of Halloween Town who grows bored with his spooky routine and stumbles upon the magic of Christmas Town. His attempt to take over Santa’s holiday leads to chaos, self-discovery, and some of the most imaginative animation ever created. The cast also features Catherine O’Hara (Home Alone, Schitt’s Creek) as Sally, the ragdoll with a heart of gold; William Hickey (Prizzi’s Honor, The Jerky Boys) as Dr. Finkelstein; Glenn Shadix (Beetlejuice, Demolition Man) as Mayor of Halloween Town; and Ken Page (Dreamgirls, Cats) as the jazzy villain Oogie Boogie. Iconic and highly searched moments include Jack’s haunting “What’s This?” sequence, the kidnapping of Santa Claus, Oogie Boogie’s musical showdown, and Sally’s bittersweet “Sally’s Song.” With its handcrafted stop-motion visuals, Elfman’s timeless music, and a perfect blend of eerie and heartfelt, The Nightmare Before Christmas remains one of the most enduring animated films ever made — a masterpiece that captures both the spirit of Halloween and the joy of Christmas. Follow Aaron On Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/therealaaronalexander/?hl=en Intense Suspense by Audionautix is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... Support The Channel By Getting Some REEL REJECTS Apparel! https://www.rejectnationshop.com/ Follow Us On Socials: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/reelrejects/ Tik-Tok: https://www.tiktok.com/@reelrejects?lang=en Twitter: https://x.com/reelrejects Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheReelRejects/ Music Used In Ad: Hat the Jazz by Twin Musicom is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Happy Alley by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... POWERED BY @GFUEL Visit https://gfuel.ly/3wD5Ygo and use code REJECTNATION for 20% off select tubs!! Head Editor: https://www.instagram.com/praperhq/?hl=en Co-Editor: Greg Alba Co-Editor: John Humphrey Music In Video: Airport Lounge - Disco Ultralounge by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Ask Us A QUESTION On CAMEO: https://www.cameo.com/thereelrejects Follow TheReelRejects On FACEBOOK, TWITTER, & INSTAGRAM: FB: https://www.facebook.com/TheReelRejects/ INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/reelrejects/ TWITTER: https://twitter.com/thereelrejects Follow GREG ON INSTAGRAM & TWITTER: INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/thegregalba/ TWITTER: https://twitter.com/thegregalba Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Hi, I'm Gene Chatsky, long time Today Show financial editor, author of Women with Money and host
of the Her Money podcast. If you are 10 years or less from retirement and you're unsure if you're on
track, well, you're not alone. But you don't have to guess anymore. Finance Fix is my six-week class
that helps you find your retirement number, build a plan, and feel more confident about your future.
For a limited time, get 25% off with code take charge at financefix.com.
That's fix with two X's.
This video is sponsored by MintMobil.
More on them very soon.
Very excited to hop into this commentary.
I hope we do a good job and flip a A.
Let's make some Christmas.
Oh, and Caroline Thompson.
Didn't she write the script for
Friggin Adam's family?
I don't know.
Her name is on more stuff
than you would think from around this time
that was all sort of like spooky skewing it
but she might have written on Casper to
Pete Kozachik.
Excellent cinematography and like two,
it really makes you wonder about what the actual scale
was because I think I often
just imagine stop motion characters
being really small but they must be like
actually a pretty decent scale.
Pretty decent sizable. Yeah,
Because you have to get the camera in there really close and everything.
And I imagine that like there's already crazy math that you have to do with any lens when you're shooting on like 16 millimeter versus 35 millimeter.
But like I imagine if you're shooting subjects that are like much smaller than normal, you probably have to take into take other things into consideration.
Yeah.
Yeah.
This is just such a, you know, it's evident why this is an enduring classic.
But each time and this time especially, just so a lovely to see the marriage of different is.
to bring such a wonderfully realized world to life with two very distinct Halloween Christmas aesthetics.
But also, yeah, just like the density of great songs, there's not a lot of fat in there.
And there are certain songs that, yeah, aren't as like, you know, iconic or the first ones that you think of.
But even those ones, you know, serve either a, you know, narrative and thematic purpose and or, you know, just fill in another.
layer of sound and and you know like emotive sound um oh and there we go we got the the voices of
the uh singing voices here uh or the cast sung by so danny elfman uh was uh jack and then chris rand
did the speaking role and then sally was katherine hara william hickie i'm sure is like a that guy
glen shattacks i think was in beetle juice if i'm not wrong paul rubens was locked so you got
Pee-wee, Catherine O'Hara, and Danny Elfman doing the other two kids.
Oogie Boogie was Ken Page.
And then Ed Ivory, I'm sure, is also somebody.
Oh, that cop.
That's, you know what?
I wonder if there's any trivia about that or anything like that or if there were other.
They're not even credited, are there?
No, unless there are additional voices.
Because, too, one of the fun things about the credit, like, I grew up in a credit staying family.
So, you know, but one of the cool things about credits and animated movies that I have
learned over time and here as well is just the way they break that stuff up because sometimes
because oftentimes they'll have like the character animation credited and the voices credited
and sometimes they'll do the credits by sets of characters or just like instead of like the
normal live action like here's the cast and then the next department and the next department
like the the mixture of where voices and performers with animators goes is can be different
um but yeah from like the big band stuff and like the jazzy stuff to the
the more sort of like theatrical, you know, and I don't know, almost like circus or organ
grindery kind of stuff.
Like just so many like great little lovely sounds.
And yeah, just a story about, I don't know, learning how to give yourself the proper
amount of a break from your every day, but also learning how to like not lose yourself
in the pursuit of, you know, breathing some new vigor into your life's work, I guess.
you know when it comes to credits do you like when they have like a little something on the side to like keep you there and do you prefer that do you think that takes away from what the credits are actually doing or and is there like a unique credit movie credit that you like I mean like I don't complain I don't have any sort of beef with that you know I don't think that we should have to like trick people into sitting through credits but like you know if you want to show bloopers or something like that or additional scenes I think I
think that's fun um you know it's like i understand fully inc i am not sitting here absorbing everyone's
name and a lot of the times it's most exciting for people who are actually working on this movie
to behold the credits and see their actual name or someone you know um but you know yeah i i can't
easily appreciate when there's stuff alongside them i often like in especially animated movies
when they put little things happening there's like cute little characters walking by the screen
are like oh here's a little scene in one corner you know here so if you are
sitting here and you are watching the credits there's like oh here's a neat little treat
you know rather than it being like here's something else to watch entirely while you're not
paying attention at all to this no i love uh the naked gun credits because they have like little
fake names in there and like here's a brownie recipe or or you know some kind of weird play on words
yeah yeah which i always loved as a kid i think the most unique weapon i mean the most unique one was
weapons that we saw it was like a little triangle the way it was coming up yeah that was
really a cool
design for that. I like when people get
creative with the credits. You know, it's an art
form into itself. Until
AI starts doing that entirely,
some people make those.
But yeah, any
just stray thoughts? You know, obviously
we've been sitting here, we've been discussing
the movie. So most of this is
concluded, but you know, in a few
just closing thoughts of review
or anything you're compelled to talk about.
Yeah, I thought it was really fun. It was
great getting to see this classic, a
movie. I think that they do a really good job of, you know, showcasing a lot of character,
a lot of detail and a lot of heart. And movie that's a lot shorter than what people
probably think it is in its memories. Yeah. Because yeah, you think it's like, oh,
this movie night before, night before Christmas. But it's only like maybe like an hour, 10,
hour 12, something like that. So yeah, it's a quickie. But yeah, thoroughly enjoyed it.
And I will be watching it for years to come. And hopefully you guys watch it and watch
our reaction or our commentary
of it because we had a lot of
I had a lot of fun. Yeah this is a blast
and it's fun to get to share
it. It's fun to get to dive in
in a way where the point is to like kind of
now you can observe everything
and kind of the point is to you know
find those things but
yeah it is interesting that this
does feel you ever think about the time when you're
a kid so much but like I am
frequently marveled and one of the fun
things about doing like the animated DC movies
different though they may be from this
is that there is a lot you can do.
This is a nice reminder of like,
oh, in an hour and 10 or 15 minutes,
you can do a lot.
For sure.
Depending on what it is and how you're doing it.
And this, yeah, you know, you have, it's weird.
When you're sitting and you're watching it,
you're like, oh, I guess there isn't that.
I had both feelings at different times
because there were times where I would be like,
oh, yeah, I guess this is a pretty compact and straight story.
And then there were other times where I'd be like,
oh, I forgot about this, you know.
And it feels substantial.
It doesn't feel too long or too short.
And it has just the right amount of grip on its fantasy and how lush it wants to be.
It's like there's a ton of really great, you know, texture in the environments, in the natural stuff, in the, like, bricklaying and covalstones and the wrought iron and the shapes of the buildings.
But, you know, you'll have a lot of very simple, just like the gray, sort of grayscale gradient sky in the backdrop.
Like, they know where to be simple and where to be very ornate.
and the way they embody Christmas and the warmth of Christmas
is really potent, but it doesn't take over the movie so much that it clashes
and the blend of Christmas and Halloween is really effective.
I've been hearing about Mint Mobile ads for years.
At a certain point, I realized I was the only one in America
not saving money with Ryan Reynolds.
Full FOMO, my friends were bragging about paying only like 15 bucks a month
while my old wireless company was charging me enough funds
to fund my own independent movie, so I finally said it.
Yes to saying no. No contracts, no hidden fees, no nonsense. Midmobiles entire thing is simple. Premium wireless starts at just $15 a month. You get unlimited talk, text, high speed data, all on the nation's largest 5G network. You can keep your phone, keep your number, and switch instantly using ESIM. Not only did I switch, I stayed because I was getting the same coverage I had before, but now for a fraction of the price. Did the math can have hundreds of dollars a year back in my pocket, back in your pocket. You're
you can do it too. That's vacations, PS5 games, or your entire streaming services bills paid
for the whole year. So stop letting big wireless drain your bill every month. This is literally
your sign to switch. Go to mintmobile.com slash rejects. That's mimmobile.com slash rejects.
Link in the description box and pin comment. And because we're talking about finances,
I should say. Off from payment of $45 required. Equip into $15 a month. Limit time new customer offer
for first three months only. Speed may slow about 35 gigabytes on unlimited plan taxes,
and extra see mobile for details. Thanks, Minmobile for converting me.
and yeah like you know it's it's got such a fun array and medley of different yeah classic spooky
characters uniquely burton-esque characters everything has some level of flourish on it and uh and yeah
like jack and sally it is fascinating because you there's so much of a you know iconic couple
of characters who you associate with being you know in love of some kind yeah and i totally
always forget that yeah
they spend so much time not
communicating properly and she's just
trying to get his attention and just trying to warn him
and she loves him so much
but you know he's got the
world on his mind and you know the future
of Halloween and now Christmas. Dreams and
ambitions. Yeah and it's
fascinating because I never would have thought
about that. I'm like you are dating like the king
of Halloween or you do you are in love
with this guy and you know he knows
your dad who's you know the Frankenstein
of the town
You know, and these little things of like the mayor, who's an elected official, clearly, as he says.
And it's just like, it's stuff that you don't have to think about.
And it's not important.
It's not plow holes.
It's not any of that.
But it is like fun to be like, oh, interesting.
Like, this is for her.
She's at home, you know, she's just out here trying to live.
He's out here with all these grand aspirations.
And he loses himself.
He loses sight of himself.
He loses, you know, grip on just his world and his, you know, place in it.
it and yeah she tries to you know keep him from falling down you know a bad rabbit hole and then
you know he has his brush with that and then he finds his way back and comes back more energized
for next Halloween you know back in his lane now that he tried something different and yeah
maybe it didn't go right and maybe he went too hard at it but you know he's back and it seems
like now they can finally kind of recalibrate and and actually be together yeah sometimes you
gotta fail to realize what's you have right in front of you yeah i think it's important lesson to at least
you know even if it didn't work out he saw it through and gained inspiration from seeing it through
but yeah the fact that most of the movie is not even with them together really it's not like that last
song yeah he was a line right before that last song i'm like man so many iconic things like i was that's
that one song like we can live like jack and sally then oh yeah like way too song yeah man
is it is it don't waste your time is that song yeah yeah yeah i was like they're barely together
in this yeah yeah well you know it's a beautiful song at the end and it leaves you off yeah you're
they're gonna go live spookily ever after or whatever but uh but this movie has like it has all the
fun and and variety and and sort of gleeful spookiness uh and it's a little bit gallows and it's a little bit
macabre. It feels very much like Halloween and the Christmas things feel very appropriately
Christmassy, but I also love that there are just a lot of these very meditative, airy moments
where you can feel the chill in the air. Like when they're on the snow-covered hillside at the end
and the little icicles hanging down and you see the little footprints in the snow, like you really
feel that stuff. Yeah. Or like when he falls off, when he hits the pole and he falls in that deep
jack-shaped like snow, just like, you know, depression in the snow. Like, you just feel
that or the you know fog in the air or the you know smell of leaves on the wind yeah no it's
very atmospheric in that way and you can yeah you you really get it and a couple of the fact that
you know it's pretty cold in the studio so it makes it makes it feel more alive that too um oh my god
yeah and really well constructed songs a lot of really interesting part like that yeah some good
great stuff for like one singer or two and then some really great ensemble pieces and yeah just
stuff that's like really perfectly macabre and perfectly heartfelt in its own way or perfectly
soulful in its own way oogie boogie all that stuff that stuff was great and two like he lives i think
it's also kind of nice that this is from a time when like things had a little bit more edge even if they
were kid accessible because like he lives in a gambling den essentially you know he's probably got in a
harder version of this movie there's there's probably a brothel here you know and uh and yeah like even though
he's of Halloween town it nicely separates him out as like this is a guy who's taking a little too far
you don't want to hang out with him I wonder if in just my own head cannon here because obviously
Halloween town all the spooky things if like what's the holiday and cocoa like is that
a different door dia de los mortos yeah I wonder actually because they're so did I imagine if you
climb the Halloween tree there's another door or something because it's
town over in that same door if you pan if you if you if you yeah dolly the camera a little over to the
right there's another tree right next to it that has like a big sugar skull on the doors something
like that because yeah it's like they're so close and the the skeletons hanging off the tree
do have like if you gave them some ornate like flower designing and pinstriping they would
look like you know the dia de los mortos like skeleton imagery you're used to seeing so it's like
it's got to be like just down the just down the road they're both
Disney. They're both in the Disney house.
Yeah.
Funny.
And, yeah, all the stuff that harkens to, like, you know, ink drawings and Edward
Gorey and everything.
And, uh, and yeah, just like props to the voice performers, both, especially Jacks.
I think, you know, Danny Elfman is who the people think of most.
But like the Chris Sarandon's performance of the character in dialogue really marries
well with that.
And it's all tied together in the animation.
Catherine O'Hara is amazing.
The rest of the, we're going to have to go find out who some of the incidentals are.
but yeah like such a great voice cast a lot of cool marriage of effects and yeah like uh it's got just
the right amount of like just fun stuff in it that it's perfect for any holiday you know watch
around Halloween to Christmas and anywhere between but also yeah it's got just enough extra sort
of like pathos and an actual story about it an actual little you know fable happening that uh yeah
like leaves an impact like not only is it beautiful and impressive and fun and spooky and it's got
great music that sounds really good but it's also yeah like just really well attuned to being
exactly what it wants to be no more no less yeah and what that is is a lot of things so you know
so it is an embarrassment of riches but yeah this is super beautiful yeah i'm happy we watched it
it's a lot of fun yeah absolutely well gang leave us your thoughts on a nightmare before christmas
thank you for joining us for this little uh reaction commentary we rewatch yakin at you thing and uh yeah
hopefully catch you for something else pretty cool pretty soon and uh yeah this is a joy be well and
uh you know stay spooky and get ready for christmas soon uh everybody scream
