The Rest Is Classified - 35. ⁠CIA Mind Control: The New Frontier (Ep 1)

Episode Date: April 6, 2025

What if the government knew how to control your mind? Could a secret program unlock the secrets of the human psyche? And how far would the CIA go to win the Cold War? In the shadowy world of espionag...e, the line between science and sinister experiments blurs. As the Cold War gripped the globe, the CIA embarked on a desperate quest to weaponise the mind. Unwitting Americans became guinea pigs in a series of covert experiments, pushing the boundaries of ethics and legality. Listen as Gordon and David delve into the shocking truth behind MKUltra, the CIA's mind control program, and the chilling story of Sidney Gottlieb, the man at its centre. ------------------- Order a signed edition of David's latest book, The Seventh Floor, via this link. ------------------- Get our exclusive NordVPN deal here ➼ www.nordvpn.com/restisclassified It’s risk-free with Nord’s 30-day money-back guarantee! Email: classified@goalhanger.com Twitter: @triclassified Assistant Producer: Becki Hills Producer: Callum Hill Senior Producer: Dom Johnson Exec Producer: Tony Pastor Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 By 2050, new cancer cases are projected to rise by 77%. It's why the Princess Margaret is reigniting our commitment to transform cancer outcomes in a quest we call Carry the Fire. But we can't achieve this alone. We need your help. Together, let's carry the fire for a world free from the fear of cancer and give every cancer patient brighter tomorrows. Donate to the Princess Margaret Cancer Foundation at carrythefire.ca Okay, flights on air Canada. How about Prague?
Starting point is 00:00:32 Ooh, Paris. Those gardens. Gardens. Amsterdam. Tulip Festival. I see your festival and raise you a carnival in Venice. Or Bermuda has Carnaval. Ooh, colorful. You want colorful. Thailand. Lantern Festival. Boom.
Starting point is 00:00:49 Book it. Um, how did we get to Thailand from Prague? Oh, right. Prague. Oh, boy. Choose from a world of destinations, if you can. Air Canada. Nice travels.
Starting point is 00:01:00 It's like you've been on something already. 70 micrograms of LSD, man. Gordon, you just look like a purple, fuzzy-shaped being It's like you've been on something already. 70 micrograms of LSD, man. Gordon, you just look like a purple, fuzzy-shaped being that I'm communing with. People who only listen to this rather watch it might think that's what I actually look like. Anyway, that's normal. You look fuzzier than normal, Gordon.
Starting point is 00:01:20 Okay, great. We might call it in in its new form, brain warfare. The target of this warfare is the minds of men on a collective and on an individual basis. Its aim is to condition the mind so that it no longer reacts on a free will or rational basis, but a response to impulses implanted from outside. The human mind is the most delicate of instruments. It's so finely adjusted, so susceptible to the impact of outside influences that it is proving malleable in the hands of sinister men. The Soviets are now using brain perversion as one of their main weapons in prosecuting the Cold War. Some of these techniques are so subtle and so abhorrent to our way of life that we have recoiled from facing up to them.
Starting point is 00:02:11 We in the West are somewhat handicapped in brain warfare. We have no human guinea pigs to try these extraordinary techniques. Well, welcome to The Rest Is Classified. I'm Gordon Carrera. And I'm David McCloskey. And that was Friend of the Pods CIA director Alan Dulles giving a talk which he makes public in April 1953 on the stakes of brain warfare and mind control as seen from the early days of the Cold War and that's gonna be our subject of this series isn't it David the sprawling world of CIA mind control
Starting point is 00:02:47 programs under the rather wonderful code name MKUltra, in which the CIA, I'm shocked to say, conducted experiments on unwitting Americans to see if there was a way of doing what Alan Dulles was suggesting the Soviets were doing, which was manipulating that malleable human mind. That's right, Gordon. We are starting a new series on MKUltra and the CIA's search in the early days of the Cold War for sort of a pathway into the human psyche to see if it could be controlled, if it could be manipulated, if it could be changed.
Starting point is 00:03:29 And Gordon, we are going to tell this story through the life and times of a very extraordinary chemist named Sidney Gottlieb, who was the bureaucratic manager and mastermind of MKUltra, this kind of really sprawling series of projects and experiments and funding for mind control work throughout much of the 1950s. Including, it has to be said, early use of LSD and psychotropic drugs, which are going to do strange things to the human brain and which we're going to be learning about. I haven't quite appreciated the full role of a CIA and hippie culture of the 1960s that emerges, but I think we'll
Starting point is 00:04:16 be looking at that. And it is also a subject which has got resonances in popular culture because it comes through in all kinds of famous movies, whether it's the Manchurian candidate or the Ipkress files here in the UK. But also it kind of resonates through to the modern day, doesn't it? In terms of this idea that the brain and the human mind is actually the focus of cognitive warfare, of trying to control and manipulate it. And we should say that Gordon and I, in preparation for this episode, have sampled all manner of substances in order to just get the first-hand research spot on. Are you currently microdosing? Are you, are you, because I'm not, just in case.
Starting point is 00:04:54 If at any point Gordon just sort of trails off, you know why. Or myself, I should say. So just, just be on the lookout for that. So I mean, this is a story, it really does have everything, right Gordon, as you went through that list. I mean, we have a massive, really abusive government power, trampling of constitutional rights, CIA dirty tricks in its early years. We have a chapter of a story that continues today in the search for mastery
Starting point is 00:05:20 of the cognitive battlefield, brain warfare, as Alan Dulles says. And we have this, I think, really fascinating perspective on the CIA as kind of the first cartel to bring LSD into the United States. Really like patient zero for LSD and LSD culture in the 60s in the states is the central intelligence agency. But to sort of bound all of this stuff, we're going to, as we said, talk about it LSD culture in the 60s in the States is the Central Intelligence Agency. But to sort of bound all of this stuff, we're going to, as we said, talk about it through the life and times of Sid Gottlieb. So maybe we start with him and his life.
Starting point is 00:05:55 You describe him as a bureaucratic manager. I don't think that does justice to the character of Sidney Gottlieb, who is straight out of a fictional novel, I think. Throughout this series, I'm going to refer to Sid Gottlieb in the most anodyne bureaucratic terms possible despite all of the insane adventures that he will have. So Gordon, you will continue to call me out and try to make him seem more colorful. So two books, I think just right up front are important to mention on Gottlieb and are really critical to the story we're going to tell. One of them is Stephen Kinzer's book,
Starting point is 00:06:26 Poisoner in Chief, great title, and the other is John Lyle's book, which is actually coming out here in just a few months, called Project Mind Control. Both deal with Gottlieb and his work on MKUltra. Both are exceptional reads. Gottlieb, young Gottlieb, Gordon. He grows up in the Bronx. He is born to Hungarian Jewish immigrants who left in the early 20th century. I have to say, Gotlieb was born in 1918. His parents are in the garment business. They own a sweatshop in New York.
Starting point is 00:06:56 He's the youngest of four kids, and he grows up in a really bustling Jewish neighborhood where many of the families are practicing. Many of them are first generation immigrants to the United States. Everybody knows everybody. And I think you could say the American dream here in this context is real, right? They are, and Gottlieb is, and this will be a theme through the story, a very patriotic person, someone who kind of, I think, sees America patriotic person, someone who kind of, I think, sees America as a country that brought in, his parents gave him a home. It's going to kind of filter through so much of the story we're going to talk about. Now, there are a couple bits of his childhood that I think do bear mention for this story. So Gottlieb was born with clubbed feet, and for most of his childhood, he really
Starting point is 00:07:42 can't walk. His mom carries him everywhere. He actually walks for the first time kind of on his own, but with braces when he's around 12 years old after he's had several operations. And he's gonna have a kind of lifelong limp that's associated with that club foot. He's gonna wear prosthetic shoes for the entirety of his life.
Starting point is 00:08:02 He's also got a stutter that a lot of the time is manageable, but when he's stressed becomes very pronounced. So he's harassed at school for the obvious reasons. And I've not able to find a picture of young Gottlieb, right? Like a childhood picture of the man. Don't know what he looks like, but he's got this stutter and this limp that I think really shaped so much of his early years. I'm channeling Peter Sellers as Dr.
Starting point is 00:08:30 Strange Love though, in my image of him, but that may be unfair, but given there's no other pictorial, you know, reference point, that's what I've got. We have, we have our first evidence of Gordon's acid trip here. His LSD is feeding him wild images of young Sid Gottlieb. But Gottlieb is very strong-willed. I think he's very smart. He perseveres through this. He reminds me a bit of the long shadow of Klaus Fuchs over our podcast.
Starting point is 00:08:55 He reminds me a little bit of Klaus Fuchs, right? In that Fuchs was sickly, anemic as a kid, but he ended up having this very sort of strong-willed spirit. And I think you see that with Gottlieb. One of the things that I find interesting though is he's quite left-wing, isn't he, as a young man? So for all that kind of patriotic side and loving America, he's not some kind of right-wing traditional uber-patriot capitalist guy, is he?
Starting point is 00:09:19 No, I mean, he will join the Young People's Socialist League. He'll later on tell people pretty openly that he was a socialist in his youth. I mean, he's growing up in the 20s and 30s. That's not uncommon. He's never a member of the Communist Party or anything like that, but he's a young sort of socialist. And he goes to City College in New York, known as Harvard of the Proletariat, studies German physics.
Starting point is 00:09:44 He takes speech courses to work on his stutter. He's very interested in agricultural biology, kind of unclear exactly why, but the field fascinates him from a young age. And he writes to someone, and this name will be important later, named Ira Baldwin at the University of Wisconsin, who's really kind of a mountain in the field.
Starting point is 00:10:02 And he gets admitted to UW, the University of Wisconsin, and Baldwin starts to take Gottlieb under his wing. He ends up majoring in chemistry, his senior thesis, by the way Gordon was entitled, studies on ascorbic acid in cowpeas. So CIA man all over him from an early age. He's moved by conditions he had seen in those sweatshops, so as we said, he's kind of got the socialist left leaning bent to him. And on Baldwin's recommendation Gottlieb is admitted to graduate school in California, where in 1943 he's going to earn a doctorate in biochemistry. And in California, Gottlieb's life is changed forever in a couple of ways. The first one is that he meets the woman who will become his wife,
Starting point is 00:10:46 named Margaret Moore. She's the daughter of a Presbyterian missionary to India. She's studying to be a preschool teacher. You'd think they don't seem to have a lot in common, and yet, they're both, I think, and again, this is going to be a theme of Gotlieb's entire life. They're very spiritually restless. So Gotlieb has become life, they're very spiritually restless. So Gottlieb has become estranged from his parents' Judaism, and Margaret, his soon-to-be
Starting point is 00:11:12 wife, has parted ways with her father's and her family's Christianity. And in both of them, you see this kind of very early desire for understanding this kind of quest for an almost mystical understanding of the universe and ourselves beyond the bounds of what you'd call maybe ordinary religion. Which sounds very California, which is where he is. It's the 40s, so the war is going on, but he's not directly involved in it at that point. Well, and this is the other, I think, major kind of factor that starts to shape him in this time. So he marries Margaret when he's 24.
Starting point is 00:11:55 And while they're in California, Gordon, he's rejected by the draft, right? It's 1943, 1944. He's denied entrance into the military because of his limp due to his club foot. But he really wants to find a way to serve. Again, he's a patriot. And you think about the psychology of someone who wanted to join, but basically sat on the sidelines
Starting point is 00:12:21 while the United States fought the Second World War. So he's deeply motivated to do something, but he's not able to. And then in the fall of 43, they move, the couple moves, they're married now, Tacoma Park, Maryland, which is a DC suburb. He's researching soil for the Department of Agriculture. Later, he gets transferred to the FDA, the Food and Drug Administration. He's developing tests to measure the presence of drugs in the human body, starting to get a little bit bored.
Starting point is 00:12:48 In 48, he gets a new job at the National Research Council. He's studying plant diseases and fungicides, changes jobs again, becomes a research associate at the University of Maryland. He's studying the metabolism of fungi. So you've got this guy who's smart. He's a wanderlust. His wife is also a wanderlust. I think he gets bored easily.
Starting point is 00:13:14 It's fair to say you can see by kind of his movement through these jobs in these early years, and he and his wife start this very almost kind of proto hippie lifestyle in this era. So they, they find a rustic cabin near Vienna, Virginia, out on 15 acres. And it's almost impossible to imagine this now with the sort of sprawl outside of DC, but this was a time when Vienna, Virginia was like in the woods. They got no electricity. They move in. They have four kids.
Starting point is 00:13:42 They settle into this family life. Gottlieb spends a lot of time with his family, seems to have really good relationships with his kids, even as adults, he milks the goats that they keep. They're keeping kind of a mini farm out on this compound. And he's really got kind of no clear path out of this mid-level research on pharmaceuticals and agricultural chemicals. So again, he's bored, he wants to do something else.
Starting point is 00:14:03 And he'll recall in this period of kind of the late 40s that his old mentor from Wisconsin, Ira Baldwin, had guided other students in the program into this exciting and pretty secretive work during the war. But Gottlieb had been too young to participate in it when he was at Wisconsin. So what was Baldwin doing? To answer that question, we kind of need to take a quick trip into Nazi Germany
Starting point is 00:14:32 and Imperial Japan of the war to find out because Baldwin is working essentially on the response to the German and Japanese bio warfare programs, toxin programs, these two countries, Germany and Japan, during the war had accumulated massive stores of information on both poisons and mind control, which are going to be two areas of Gottlieb's interest and fascination for the rest of his life. And I guess the key point is that both Japan and Nazi Germany had done some pretty dark
Starting point is 00:15:10 things by taking advantage of prisoners to conduct experiments on real people. I mean, we know obviously some of the Nazi stuff is pretty well known, but Japan as well, they'd really been experimenting with what you can do to people under extreme conditions, including the human mind, including with toxins. And I guess the US and the UK had learned about it by the end of the war by this period. That's right. So in the camps in Nazi Germany, for example, they'd fed mescaline and other psychoactive drugs to concentration camp inmates, did experiments aimed at finding ways you could control the human mind or shatter the psyche.
Starting point is 00:15:51 That kind of experimentation, as you mentioned, you can't do that in theory. You have to actually do it on people. It's very dark. But there were senior Nazi scientists who, after the the war knew more than almost anybody about these experiments and sort of the possibilities and limits of controlling the human mind. And it's a similar story in Japan. A lot of experiments had been conducted in occupied Manchuria by a group called UNED 731. I mean, it's a really sort of profoundly disturbing log of experiments that are conducted. But at the end of the war, Ira Baldwin, this old mentor, Sid Gottlieb, had kind of led the US answer to Germany and Japan's bio-war programs.
Starting point is 00:16:38 Now, chemical warfare, which had caused maybe a million casualties during the First World War, was already very well known and studied, but biological warfare, which had been banned by the Geneva protocols in the 20s, was something very new. And Baldwin had led the work during the war on whether a country could build at an industrial scale, a massive quantity of deadly germs or toxins. And he's established what's later going to become the headquarters of the army's biological warfare labs at Dietrich Field in Maryland. Later, this will become Camp Dietrich.
Starting point is 00:17:12 And scientists there have produced an industrial quantity of sort of anthrax spores, they bred mosquitoes infected with yellow fever and Gordon, this is for you, they've even developed a pigeon bomb, a bird whose feathers were sort of infected with toxic spores. And for those listening to the pod who are not aware, Gordon is a pigeon fanatic and lover of those noble birds. And so I'm going to let him address this. I wasn't aware of the toxic pigeon.
Starting point is 00:17:43 Cause I knew that they tried to train pigeons to be guided missiles during the Second World War but the toxic spore laden pigeon is just another sign of how badly treated these birds are and it's disappointing that's all I say that that was happening in the US. It is. This is this is one of many times in these episodes where Gordon Carrera is going to be very disappointed with what's going on. So maybe there with the toxic pigeon, let's maybe take a break at Camp Dietrich with this sense of what's been going on during the war. When we come back, we'll look at the start of the Cold War and how the newly formed CIA
Starting point is 00:18:19 gets into the business of mind control. Hello, I'm William Durrimple. And I'm Anita Arnand and we are the hosts of Empire also from Goalhanger. And we're here to tell you about our recent mini-series that we've just done on the troubles. In it, we try to get to the very heart of the violent conflict in Northern Ireland that lasted from the 1960s all the way up to 1998. It's something that we both lived through and remember from our childhoods, but younger listeners may not know anything about it. And it's the time when there was division
Starting point is 00:18:56 along religious and political lines, neighbours turned against each other, residential city streets became battlegrounds, thousands were killed, and the IRA bombed London. It seemed as if an end was out of reach, but in 1998, a peace process finally brought those 30 years of violence to an end. But the memory of the troubles is still present, not only within Northern Irish communities who experienced it, but in international relations and political approaches to peace. And new audiences are starting to understand this national trauma through films like Belfast and kneecap and TV shows like Derry Girls. In fact, our guest on the mini-series is Patrick Radden-Keefe. Now, he's the author
Starting point is 00:19:41 of the non-fiction book that inspired the hit TV drama, Say Nothing. It's one of my favorite books. It's I think the kind of inco blood for our generation, extraordinary work of non-fiction. To hear the full series, just search Empire wherever you get your podcasts. Welcome back. So we're looking at the CIA and mind control. We've learned a bit about Sid Gottlieb and we've learned a bit about what happened during the Second World War and the kind of early days of thinking about experimenting on people. But now David, we're into the start of the Cold War, where the focus really on trying to manipulate people's
Starting point is 00:20:24 minds in particular comes into being, doesn't it? Well, it is in this early period of the Cold War that the CIA starts to think it actually has practical intelligence to suggest that the Soviet Union or kind of a communist front more generally is making significant advances on mind control techniques. And there are a number of incidents in the late 40s that seem to add credence to this picture. And one of the most important is that in February of 1949,
Starting point is 00:20:57 the Roman Catholic prelate of Hungary kind of appears at a show trial and confesses to some wild charges, things like having attempted to overthrow the government, steal the royal crown, reestablish the Austro-Hungarian Empire, really nutty stuff. Apparently, he didn't even recognize his own mother. CIA officers watching this trial had
Starting point is 00:21:19 focused on the way this guy had behaved. He confessed to the crime, he obviously hadn't committed these crimes. He's totally disoriented. He's speaking in kind of a flat monotone. And it conjures up images for a lot of these CIA guys of Stalin's show trials a decade before where you had defendants that behaved in insane ways who admitted to crimes or confessed crimes
Starting point is 00:21:47 that they hadn't actually committed. And the CIA starts to think, well, have these people been drugged or hypnotized? And you go back to the kind of late 19th century, it was Russians who had pioneered this field of behavioral conditioning. Pavlov's dog. Yeah, salivating at the sound of the bell. And surely the CIA thinks the Russians have made some recent advances. And this is a pattern, isn't it?
Starting point is 00:22:13 And it's a really interesting pattern in the early Cold War where each side thinks the other side is doing it, whether it's mind control or something else, and therefore we better do it. And I think each side thinks the other has got this kind of possible new technology and therefore they have to push ahead in order to find it. And mind control definitely is one where the CIA does seem to be convinced that the communists have mastered it somehow because it's the only way in their mind they can explain some of these strange goings on.
Starting point is 00:22:41 It's playground logic but I guess you'd say it's playground logic because it's deeply embedded in us as humans from a very early age that if you think somebody else might be doing something, even if you cannot fully prove it, oftentimes the safest course of action would be need to get something going to counter this. Now, I would say in the early years of the Korean War, the intensity of the CIA's fears ratchets up even further because you have captured American POWs who will testify that the US had used bio weapons and German-infected insect bombs. Now, none of that's true, but the CIA wonders essentially the same question that they had with the Roman Catholics or a prelate in Hungary or the show trials, which is why are people confessing to things that they haven't committed? Now, we're looking at this from the lens of 2025 and decades having passed and we're no longer in kind of the absolute hot house of the early Cold War years,
Starting point is 00:23:46 but no evidence of any of these kind of more elaborate mind control techniques ever emerged. I mean, it's kind of run-of-the-mill stuff, traditional forms of torture and coercion that elicited these confessions. But what's so interesting is there's some captured Americans who decide they want to stay in North Korea, and the only explanation is that they've been brainwashed. It's a really interesting feature that people seem to struggle to believe that people can have changed their views or come to a different set of views unless they were somehow manipulated into do it by some kind of secret program. And that seems to be a theme
Starting point is 00:24:25 which is here. It gets into that slightly paranoid early Cold War period where you're gonna get kind of red scares, a fear that the Soviets are also ahead, they you know they get the bomb in 1949 they're moving ahead scientifically. So there's a kind of paranoia which you also see don't you in this talk about aliens and UFO films are also coming out this time where people's minds are being taken over and they look like ordinary Americans but actually they've been taken over by aliens and again it's the idea that people can be brainwashed and taken over and that seems to be the only way they can explain some of these things
Starting point is 00:25:00 like they're seeing in North Korea when as you said actually the evidence is these are just people who may be broken down by the pressure of detention often or that they've come to sometimes these beliefs genuinely. George Blake famously is a British intelligence officer who gets captured in Korea and ends up later being discovered to be a communist. Everyone says well he must have been brainwashed when he was captured in Korea and actually the evidence is he just genuinely ideologically became a communist, but people found it easier to explain it by brainwashing. It does become a catch-all, I think. And it is almost impossible, I think, to overstate the paranoia that was felt in particular inside
Starting point is 00:25:39 institutions such as the CIA in these early years of the Cold War. I mean, again, listeners in 2025 sort of look back on this and almost laugh and say, how did you come to these conclusions? But what we're describing here, these were not fringe ideas, right? During the early years of the Cold War, this was the base assessment of the CIA and its leadership that the Soviets, Communists more broadly, were absolutely working on and developing very powerful mind control techniques.
Starting point is 00:26:12 And this is where we talked before the break about Camp Dietrich, this kind of bio warfare lab. After the Second World War ends, now the US up until 1949 has a nuclear monopoly. And so Dietrich is kind of a little bit on the outs here out of favor because American policymakers sort of look at bio warfare and say well we have nukes why would we need any of this? And what's very interesting is that this this kind of fear of Soviet mind control starts to give the crew at Camp Dietrich a new mission and a special operations division is set up to establish really a study of the coercive use of drugs.
Starting point is 00:26:48 You know, could you control someone's mind? Could you establish a pathway into someone's mind with drugs? And a senior official at Camp Dietrich is going to write a very influential report in the late 40s, which concludes, I'll read it. I am convinced that it is possible by means of the techniques of psychochemical warfare to conquer an enemy without wholesale killing of his people and the mass destruction of his property. Now, that report is read by the head of the CIA at the time, who then goes to President Truman to authorize drug research and give that job to the CIA. And Truman agrees. And we should say the CIA and Truman agrees.
Starting point is 00:27:25 And we should say the CIA has just been established hasn't it and I mean as we've talked about in some of our previous episodes in some of our original episodes it's quite a piratical organisation this time. It's pretty freewheeling, there's not much in terms of kind of legal or other controls of what it's doing, not much oversight. It's kind of given a blank check where it means it's kind of unleashed into areas which are perhaps, you know, surprising now looking back. It's two years old in 1949 and sort of behaves that way in many respects. A toddler. The legal and oversight environment is nothing like what we have today.
Starting point is 00:28:01 And the Central Intelligence Agency Act of 1949, the CIA is established in 47, but this act sort of establishes more of the legislative basis for the agency, that gave the CIA the ability to spend un-vouchered funds and freed it from disclosing to Congress who its employees were and what they did. So the CIA is operating kind of on an island of its own and has now in the midst of this incredible almost panic about Soviet intentions, communist intentions, not only just with mind control but more broadly. Mao has won the Chinese Civil War, you know, in the early 50s North Korea invades South Korea, there's the Red Scare in the states and kind of this rise of McCarthyism and its panic about communists
Starting point is 00:28:45 at all levels of government. And in the middle of this, you give this very, as you said, Gordon, piratical organization the mission to go out and really chart the nexus of mind control and covert operations. But I think you can see, and again, bring this to Gottlieb for a second. One of the themes about Sid Gottlieb that is just a feature of his entire life is he is insatiably curious.
Starting point is 00:29:14 And I do think if you're giving somebody like that the mission to go out and understand sort of the promise and perils of mind control and how you might apply that into this kind of brand new world of clandestine operations in the early Cold War. What patriotic American wouldn't stand up and join that mission? It depends on what you end up doing, David. I think that's, as we'll discover, it gets a little bit darker than just simply patriotic Americans doing their, doing their duty, because the CIA, I guess, is looking for, when we talk about mind control, it's often more about truth serums, isn't it? It's about trying to understand how to break people down so that they will talk to you
Starting point is 00:29:56 and either give you the truth or understand what the other side might be doing to try and brainwash people. That seems to be the focus of some of these original programs that the CIA is working on, isn't it? The original goal is very much to aid in interrogations, I think we could say. And they're blending the polygraph, drugs, and hypnotism for use on prisoners in interrogations to extract information from unwilling subjects, to study how you might prevent that extraction from occurring on your
Starting point is 00:30:31 own people, and really elusively, but you know, for people like Gottlieb, this is kind of the holy grail, is could we control somebody's actions? Is there a way for us to control the behavior of an individual who does not want to be controlled? There is a lot of focus in these early years on hypnosis. The CIA actually found a stage hypnotist in New York who would often have sex with otherwise unwilling women after placing them in a hypnotic trance. Or at least this is what he claimed to the CIA. And the CIA officers don't do that. Clear in saying that, but they do bring these techniques back to the CIA.
Starting point is 00:31:09 They try to hypnotize their secretaries and do things like convince them they're on a beach vacation in Florida. And there's very mixed results in these hypnotic experiments at CIA. No one is actually quite sure if it's working or if the secretaries are sort of humoring them. But there is kind of this dip into this world of could we get somebody who might have access to an office or access to secrets or access to a safe? Could you hypnotize them and get them to go and collect the secrets for you? Or could you hypnotize someone to go and kill a foreign leader of a pro-communist country
Starting point is 00:31:46 or something like that, right? These would be the kind of use cases, I think, in Gottlieb's mind and in the CIA's mind in those early years. Yeah, which of course the hypnotizing to kill a foreign leader becomes, and we'll look at fiction at a later point, but you know, the Manchurian candidate is the famous notion that you could perhaps train people to be hypnotized and then signaled by something and then carry out some dastardly act. So again, you have this kind of overlap between fact and fiction, which we'll see again and again in this. And so there seems to be a lot of experimentation at this
Starting point is 00:32:18 early days in the fifties on, on that specifically in trying to work out how to do it. Well, and Alan Dulles, whose quote you read at the beginning of this episode, he is brought back to the CIA in early 1951. At that time, he's not yet the director, but he's going to manage the agency's covert operations. And he'll note, and he kind of said this or alluded to it in the quote, Gordon, is that the problem that the CIA has is that,
Starting point is 00:32:46 well, we can't do a lot of this research in the United States. We cannot or shouldn't be doing a lot of this research on Americans. And so the locusts will kind of shift outside of the states or move outside of the states. There's a detention center in West Germany called Camp King that the CIA will send teams to. It becomes kind of a test site for conducting mind control experiments on defectors or captured prisoners. It's kind of a CIA black site, you might say.
Starting point is 00:33:17 It's kind of the spacious and elegant villa, but in the basement is this complex of bricked in store rooms. It's overseen or managed by CIA officers and a staff doctor named Doc Fisher, who's a German physician who had been former Surgeon General of the Nazi Army and a man who had overseen some of those experiments we talked about at concentration camps. He'd been captured by the Red Army, then taken a professorship in East Germany before he snuck over the border into West Germany and he's running with the sort of help of the CIA, this broader network of prisons in the country where they're doing these kind of bluebird experiments to understand basically what could we get a prisoner to tell us if they don't want to talk. Yeah, part of that system of using Nazi scientists, which they used in all kinds of areas as well. And similar things, I think, in Japan as well, where they're running these experiments.
Starting point is 00:34:09 So these are largely outside of the US, though, rather than inside of the US at this point. That's right. And I mean, they're doing things like they're subjecting prisoners to hypnosis. They're doing this also, you mentioned, outside the states, they're doing this also in Japan, doing some of these experiments on captured North Korean soldiers, you know, using hypnosis, electroshock, and the goal being to kind of induce violent reactions, put people to sleep, wake them up to see if they can coerce them into providing information that they
Starting point is 00:34:38 shouldn't. And if all of this sounds sort of chaotic and disorganized, it's because it is. And one of the major problems that Dulles and the CIA have in these years of working on Bluebird is that they don't really have the scientific expertise necessary to answer any of the questions that they really want to answer. Which is where someone like Sid Gottlieb might come in, I guess, at this point. Someone who is a chemist and a scientist, and as we said, very curious by his background. That's right. So Sid Gottlieb applies for a job to the CIA, because as we mentioned earlier, he wants to serve. He missed the war, I think, in his view, he's got this very interesting profile for the CIA.
Starting point is 00:35:26 He's a chemist, right? He's a scientist. And he's got connections to Ira Baldwin, who helped set up Camp Dietrich. So Gottlieb applies for a job at the CIA. He enters on duty on July 13th of 1951 and thus begins, as Stephen Ginzer says in his book, Poisoner in Chief, the beginning of a career at the bizarre intersection of extreme science and covert action.
Starting point is 00:35:51 And Gottlieb, when he joins, it kind of seems like he was signing up for a new adventure. You know, again, we have this kind of wanderlust spirit, right? So Gottlieb knows they needed a chemist, but that's about it. And he said he didn't understand anything else they needed. He would try it for six months and see how it went. And what quickly ends up happening is that he gets thrust into the kind of technical services staff, which at the time at the CIA is very small.
Starting point is 00:36:20 It's probably a few dozen people. And this Bluebird project that the TSS staff is involved in is very sprawling, but it's disorganized and lacking complete focus. And Gottlieb is joining in the early years of the Korean War, where as we mentioned, the fear of communist brainwashing, in particular, coming out of the Korean War, is hitting a fever pitch. I mean, there's a New Republic headline from this era, communist brainwashing. Are we prepared? And you get references to some of these prisoners essentially having been fed or given psychoactive drugs to get them to say anti-American things or to lie
Starting point is 00:37:03 about their experiences. So Gottlieb's entering the CIA in the middle of that fever. Because no one could understand why anyone would say anything anti-American. No one can understand. No one could understand it unless you've been fed psychotropic drugs. I guess that's the thinking at the time, isn't it? That's right. It does 70 plus years later seem borderline insane.
Starting point is 00:37:23 But many of the things that we're going to talk about in these episodes will sound insane, are insane, and at the time very, very smart people thought they were absolutely 100% necessary to do, we should say. So Gottlieb joins the CIA in a newly formed chemical division, which is a great title. The chemical division inside the technical services staff is what he joins. And Gottlieb, we should say, is joining a CIA that in that era was pale, male, and Yale, for the most part. And Gottlieb is a fish out of water, right?
Starting point is 00:37:59 We'd argue that he's pale and male, but he's definitely not Yale. And he's Jewish, which is a bit out of step for the kind of patricians of the CIA in that era. He's not Ivy league educated. He went to city college and then he went to the university of Wisconsin. So he's kind of this outsider on the inside. And I mean, even things like he's living out in that cabin, right? In Vienna, Virginia, he's growing much of his own food and then like bringing it in for lunches.
Starting point is 00:38:24 So, you know, he's living out in that cabin right in Vienna, Virginia He's growing much of his own food and then like bringing it in for lunches So it does sort of beg this question of why in the world? Alan Dulles picks Gottlieb and One theory which I think is plausible is that Dulles when this is true also had a club foot Which I did not know about Alan Dulles he had one operation to fix it, but both Dulles, and this is true, also had a club foot, which I did not know about Alan Dulles. He had one operation to fix it, but both Dulles and Gottlieb wore prosthetic shoes for most of their lives.
Starting point is 00:38:53 There would have been like a little bit of a limp. They probably never talked about this, I'm gonna guess. I bet there were not many club foot support groups at CIA at the time, but it becomes a kind of, potentially a bond between the two of them. It's an interesting question, I suppose, because it's hard to understand otherwise, isn't it? How got Lieb fit in that world?
Starting point is 00:39:11 Yeah, but inside the chemical division at that point, there are a very small handful of people, right? So he's clearly an expert, right? Kinzer wrote in his book, over the next decade, they would stumble together through undiscovered frontiers. So the two of them, I think do hit it off and Dulles is going to become a patron of Gottlieb's and promoter of Gottlieb's work for the remainder of Sid Gottlieb's career. Now in this period, Bluebird becomes Artichoke. Now that takes on a new, a new code name.
Starting point is 00:39:48 Supposedly Artichokes were Dulles' favorite vegetable. There's also a theory that it was named for a murderous New York gangster known as the Artichoke King. It also could have been. Really? Yes, really. But it was changed because at this stage the CIA was letting the military in on Bluebird and the Navy already had a project Bluebird going,
Starting point is 00:40:10 so they changed the name. Now, for reasons that we'll come to later, but will undoubtedly be obvious to many listeners right now, is that little is known about the operations and experiments carried out under Artichoke. Mysteriously, not many documents have survived, But the goals of this project are very, very similar. And Gottlieb will later say Artichoke was really all about how would we interrogate someone who's hostile and wants to withhold information? How to break them? How do you break somebody, right? I mean, it's really brutal stuff. The directives to the Artichoke teams are, you know, they're carrying out these
Starting point is 00:40:44 interrogations in safe houses. This could be again in Germany or Japan. It could be prisoners. It could be defectors. And they had to have bathroom facilities because occasionally the artichoke techniques produce nausea, vomiting, or other conditions, which, quote, made bathroom facilities essential. And the scope is again very broad. They're looking at new chemicals and drugs.
Starting point is 00:41:06 How do you deliver them? Things like the effects of like high and low pressure on humans, effective sound vibrations, ultra high frequency. They're also looking at things like bacteria, fungi, poisons, plant cultures that can produce high fevers, electroshock hypnosis, whether electronically induced sleep could be used as a means for gaining control of an individual. The agency drew the line though, Gordon, you'll be pleased to know at lobotomies as a measure
Starting point is 00:41:34 for use in operations. They've drawn the line somewhere. The rest of it, it does sound like torture though, basically. Yeah, I mean, it's basically medical torture. That's what we're talking about. And by the 1950s, we have artichoke teams that are out in West Germany and France and Japan and South Korea. Sometimes they would be sent out at the request of a CIA station, a local station to deal with a prisoner. At others, they might want to test a new technique or chemical and kind of put out a call if
Starting point is 00:41:59 there were available subjects. And then sometimes, I mean, quite darkly in coded language, there would be messages in these cables about whether body disposal would be required. So you kind of see this connection right off the bat, before we even get into the much more sprawling world of MKUltra, that this nexus of kind of mind control and drugs in particular, but also all other manner of kind of coercive techniques, it's really dark stuff really quickly. And there with Sydney Gottlieb now inside the CIA at Langley, let's stop and then next time we'll look at how this world shifts into the realm of drugs and particularly LSD and its role in trying to control the human mind.
Starting point is 00:42:53 We'll see you next time. We'll see you next time.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.