The Vergecast - Smart sleep is worth the cost

Episode Date: November 12, 2024

On today's show: sleep gadgets, AI DJs, and sneaky TVs. Victoria Song joins the show to talk about her experiences with the Eight Sleep mattress pad, the Oura Ring 4, and other sleep gadgets. Can you really measure your way to a better night of sleep? After that, Allison Johnson gives us her take on Spotify's AI DJ, and we wonder exactly how an AI tool is supposed to help us find and listen to music. Finally, Nilay Patel comes on to answer a question from the Vergecast Hotline about the Samsung Frame TVs — and how to figure out whether you need a TV at all. Further reading: Eight Sleep Pod 4 Ultra review: for sale, good night’s sleep, just $4,700 Ozlo Sleepbuds hands-on: resurrected and I’ve slept so good Oura Ring 4 review: still on top — for now Spotify’s AI is no match for a real DJ Samsung’s Frame TV is finally getting the knockoffs it deserves Email us at [e-mail] or call us at 866-VERGE11, we love hearing from you. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Welcome to the Vergecast, the flagship podcast of quantified REM cycles. I'm your friend David Pierce, and I am playing Batman Arkham Shadow on the Quest 3. I tend to always have one game that I like to play on the quest, usually for just like 15 or 20 minutes at a time, in between meetings or at night, just to kind of move around. I like this better than, you know, sitting on the couch playing video games, even though, frankly, I do a lot of that too. This at least kind of gets the blood going in a way that,

that I really like. For a long time, it was super hot VR. Then it was super natural when I was feeling like exercisey. Then there was a tennis simulator that I got strangely into, but I kept hitting the ceiling trying to do serves. So that didn't last. And now I'm playing Arkham Shadow. I have loved all of the Arkham games over the years. They're like the perfect mix for me of lots to do, but pretty straightforward. And they don't require me to just wander aimlessly for hours. Very much my kind of game. By the way, there's a decent chance to, you've heard ads for this game on this podcast. I've gotten some complaints from people who were like too many meta ads in a row,

and I can only assume there for Arkham Shadow. So trust me, this is not one of those ads. I'm happy to tell you all of the things I hate about both this game and the Quest in general. But this game's pretty great. I'm having a nice time. Anyway, that is not what we're here to talk about today. We are here to do two things on the show. First, we're going to talk to V's song about kind of a year of experiments

in quantified sleep that she's been doing. She's tried some gadgets. She's tried some more expensive gadgets. She's tried some really expensive gadgets. And we're going to talk about whether any of them are actually worth it and have made her sleep better. Then we're going to talk to Allison Johnson about the AI DJ on Spotify. And what it means to have a computer decide what is good and what you should listen to.

She wrote a really great piece about it. I have some thoughts. I actually disagree with her in some ways. So we're going to get into it. We also have a question from the hotline to do. lots of fun stuff coming up on this episode. But first, we'll get to that, but I have to go beat up some bad guys on the streets of Gotham.

This is the Verge Gas. We'll be right back. Support for the show comes from Retool. Too many companies run critical operations on duct taped spreadsheets, Slack workflows, and whatever else they could cobble together. Not because they want to, but because building internal tools means weeks of waiting on someone else's backlog. That's where Retool comes in.

Build custom internal tools just by your own. describing what you need. Prompt something like, build me a revenue dashboard on our Salesforce data, and Retool actually builds it on your company's data in your cloud with enterprise security built in. Go to retool.com slash Verchcast. We all need to retool how we build software. Welcome back. So we talk a lot on this show about the idea of tracking yourself and using wearables to get data about your biometrics and the whole idea of the quantum. self, which to be honest, is a phrase that I really hate, but it just means tracking something in order to be able to do it better. The thing we don't talk about as much with that, I think,

is sleep. We talk a lot about exercise. We talk some about food and things like that, and all that stuff is good. But I think if you wanted to make everyone's lives better immediately, getting everybody better sleep would be the way. So V-Song on our team has been testing a bunch of sleep-related gadgets. She's actually been doing this for a long time, both as part of testing lots of wearables, but also just because like the rest of us, she'd like to get more sleep. So I figured now would be a super fun time to have her on the show and talk through all of this. She's tried some cheap stuff. She's tried some absurdly expensive stuff. And we're going to see if any of it is actually worth the money and actually helps you sleep. Fiesong, hello. Hello. Okay, so a few weeks ago,

You were here on the show, and I said something about how I think sleep tracking is stupid. I don't think I said those exact words, but I said something like those exact words. And I would say a surprising number of people have had feelings at me about that feeling and have told me that I'm wrong. And it turns out that you, without even telling me at that moment when you could have told me, have been doing all kinds of interesting sleep tracking research over the last several months. So I want to talk about it. And I want to talk especially about the thing that you tried to do where you tried to convince people that it's not insane to spend many thousands of dollars on your bed. But before we get to all of that, I want to talk about sleep maxing because you brought up in one of your recent stories this thing that I find really fascinating, which is that sleep tracking has become the thing in a way that I can't remember this sort of quantified self trend being made. mainstream quite like this, maybe ever, or at least since the like, get 10,000 steps craze

sort of took over everybody. Like, sleep is, it's such a thing. It's having such a moment. And I'm curious what you make of that. Like, why do you think sleep has gone viral in the way that it has? So I think that we all feel a lot of existential dread. And there are so many things that are externally out of our control. At the same time, like, you have a lot of really health conscious people at this point in time. I attribute that in like my little bubble to like all of these devices that Apple, Samsung, Google say will save your life. And, you know, these are things you can buy in large control. Sleep. You know, talk to any doctor. They're going to tell you get a good night's worth of sleep. Sleep, eat nutrient dense foods, exercise. Every single health professional is going to tell you that if you can master these three things, your life will be better. Like they, And I think that message really does kind of just solidify when you hit your 30s and things start creaking and you have disposable income. And you just realize, oh, man, like sleep actually is pretty important. These doctors, they're actually not lying. If my sleep is bad, I feel bad. If my sleep is good, I feel good. So it's a very easy way to just dramatically improve the things that you can. control, like your anxiety will go down if you sleep well. Your health will improve if you sleep well. It'll be easier for you to lose weight if you sleep well. It'll be easier for you to build muscle

if you sleep well. It'll be easier for you to just do literally anything and have better mental health if you sleep well. So I think that's kind of where this intensity around sleep maxing comes from. And, you know, like, what is sleep maxing? Sleep maxing is literally just buying several products to try and hack your sleep. So it's like really a convergence of late stage capitalism and existential dread shaking hands like that meme in your TikTok shop to tell you like if you just do this one thing, you might sleep a little bit better and feel better while you deal with a bunch of other crap. And so I think that's honestly where it comes from. And they're not wrong is the thing I'm going to say. Well, and I think it's true. I mean, it strikes me as you explain

those three things that eat better, exercise more, and sleep more, essentially. Sleep better is by far the least costly of those three things. Like, eating better is hard. Like, all the tasty foods are bad for you. It's just a fact of the universe. It's hard. It's a thing I struggle with the most. It's more expensive. It's more complicated. Like, it's very hard to eat well. It's also hard to exercise a lot. It just requires a lot of commitment and dedication and the opportunity cost is high because I could be sitting on my couch watching television and I'm not. Also, it's painful. Yeah, it sucks. It's painful.

Yeah. And kudos to you who you get up and do it anyway. Sleep has, in theory, none of those costs. Like if I can, I'm going to lie in bed for eight hours at night. If I can make those eight hours more efficient, that is all upside. Right? Like, it's the only one of those three that if getting better sleep has zero downsides. It's also enjoyable.

Getting a good night's sleep is really great. It is the most enjoyable of these three things that you can fix your life. It would be one thing if, like, the activity of going to sleep really sucked. But, like, going to sleep is great. It's so good. It's not, like, exercise that way where you feel really good at the end, but not during. Sleep is just awesome the whole time. It's just great.

The whole, like, whenever you see someone going to bed and they're sleeping, And so they're always like sleeping with a little smile on their face, a sleeping babies, good vibes. And like, you look at insomniacs, they have bags under their eyes. They generally don't look good. So like just culturally speaking, sleep is by far the easiest thing you can do. And it's, you know, in terms of like effort put in to results immediately seen, you will immediately feel the effects of good sleep, whereas you will not immediately feel the effects of sticking to a nutritious diet or exercising over. a long period of time. Like those things are all like, I, you know you should do them. They're going to suck while you do them and you have to have delayed gratification. There's none of that complicatedness with sleep. Sleep, instant gratification. Yeah. It'll feel good literally in hours and you won't have to do anything at all. It's pretty great. Yeah. So it seems like in that vein of trying to do better with sleep, A, there's a lot of snake oil. I mostly don't want to talk about the snake oil, but I think by and large, if you see a thing on TikTok in the TikTok shop, you should assume it's nonsense.

I think that's true of everything, definitely including sleep maxing. Mouth tape, I legitimately, that makes me angry mouth tape. Yeah. But yeah. Yeah, we're just going to leave that aside. But it seems to me there are sort of two separate things that the tech industry has to figure out here. One is how to successfully tell how you're sleeping, right? And the sleep tracking thing has been happening for forever.

The reason we were talking about this a few weeks ago, so we were talking about the aura ring. Like, the idea of using some device or another to track your sleep goes back a long ways. So I would assume we're pretty good at that now. Are we pretty good at that now? We are okay at that now. So what we are really good at is telling when you go to sleep and when you wake up. The sleep stages. So, like, the REM sleep, the deep sleep, the light sleep, dubious.

Okay. And that stuff is really important. That stuff is important if you want to get more granular or if you're having sleep problems and you're trying to self, like, figure out, like, what's going on. You know, so ORA, they put a lot of research into it. But even there, only like our algorithm is like, I think it's 70 to 80 percent in agreement with the gold standard, which is polysumography. And that's when you go into a little clinic and they put stuff on you and you sleep there

for a night and the scientists watch you and measure your brain waves. So that's the clinical gold standard. And most consumer grade sleep trackers that are out there on the market, we're at best, we're getting around 70% to 80% in that range. So, you know, like, so we're much better than we used to be. But in the grand scheme of things, you do have to really take it as a very unsatisfying, oh, this is my baseline. I probably will know when I have a craft. Happy night of sleep. Yeah. Right. But you can, from that baseline view trance, like, oh, you have a lot of breathing disturbances. Maybe you have sleep apnea and you should go to a doctor and maybe get a CPAP and see how that improves your sleep quality. So, like, that's kind of the real thought process behind sleep tracking as well as, like, another really valuable thing is having a sleep routine. So something that a sleep tracker can do. is help you build that sleep routine by going, you regularly go to sleep at this time and wake up at this time.

Good job, buddy. You are super consistent with that. Or, you know, if you're just really having crappy sleep and you see that you wake up a ton of times in the night and you go, aha, that is the 3 a.m. cat is angry at standard time and that kibble is not coming at the time that they are used to. So they screamed and woke me up. Like you can view patterns and trends kind of easily in that way.

It just, it's not super automatic. right? Because you have to tag like angry cat. Like some of my sleep tracking devices that's literally got an angry cat tag. And I can tell you, they wake me up quite frequently because they're angry. But I don't need a sleep tracker for that because obviously the cat is hitting me in the face and whatnot. Well, so that's been the challenge with me with sleep tracking for forever, right? Which is I think the idea that it tells you when you went to bed and when you woke up is nothing. Like I know that. I don't, it's, it's like, it's like if the only thing a fitness tracker could tell me was that I went for a walk. Like, I don't need that. That's, that's not helpful. But I will say, to the credit of these vices, I think the thing you just said about these kind of macro trends that it can give back to you.

One thing that happened to me very recently was, uh, my wife and I got a sleep number bed a few years ago. Uh, we went from trying to perpetually compromise on firmness to just being like, we need a bed with two different firmnesses. So we got a sleep number bed. It's fine. We got like the cheapest, crappiest one. It's fine, but it does the thing we needed to do. And it gives me like a sleep score every morning. And I think the sleep score is mostly meaningless, generally speaking.

But one thing it did for me over time was it said, hey, David, just FYI, your sleep scores tend to be the best when you go to bed about 11 and you wake up about 6.30. And it was just like that, just that one thing was like, okay, this seven and a half hour window of sleep seems to be what you. you need in order to be successful. And that was so, it was one of those things I, like, never really paid attention to, but was so helpful that, like, A, that's about the amount of sleep I need to be a successful functioning adult. But also, this window actually kind of works was very helpful. And I'm like, that alone is like, okay, we've now, you've done something for me that I would not have done on my own. Yeah, that's, that's honestly, the thing about self-quantification is that

it takes a really long time to tell you something useful. And sometimes the stuff that it points out to you is going to be super obvious to everyone else, but to yourself, you're like, oh, I never really thought about that. Oh, I never really paid attention to that. So on the surface, it's all really dumb. But one thing that they show time and time again is that logging these things will make you more aware of them. So, like, I personally hate calorie tracking. I hate logging food.

I also have learned a lot about logging my food over time. Like I'm just like, oh, I was extremely protein deficient. I thought I was getting enough protein. No, I wasn't. Oh, I tend to like stress eat. Oh, wow. Like when you have to log all the things that you're stress eating, you will be more aware of those habits.

So that's primarily the benefit of sleep tracking, even if on the surface you look at it and you're just like, well, duh. Like, yeah. I had one the other night where my sleep score was 14. because I went to bed and I got up at 2 o'clock with a toddler who didn't want to go back to sleep and I spent the whole rest of the night in his room

and it's like, yeah, thanks, bed. I got a notification that I got a 14. Like, that's how, thank you. Great, cool, helpful. Which brings me to the second thing that I think is complicated and interesting in this space right now is step one is like figure out how you're doing, right?

And step two is make it better. And I think the challenge with a lot of these devices all these wearables, and this is the thing we've talked about many times, is the so what, the like, what do I do about this thing? Right? And like, you've seen this on the Apple Watch where it'll, like, prompt you to go for a walk at the end of the night to hit your goals. And sometimes that's good. And sometimes I'm like, shut up.

I don't want to go for a 61-minute walk at 10 a 10 a game to hit my goals. Yeah, like, I'm good. Thank you, Apple. But I think the trick with sleep is figuring out how to make things better. And I think this is what brings us to V's adventures in $5,000 mattresses. Let's just explain this thing to me that you've been sleeping on for the last few months. I've been sleeping on the 8th sleep pod four ultra. I have previously tested the 8 sleep pod two pro cover. And basically this is a smart mattress cover.

It's not even the mattress. The mattress is my mattress that I spent a good amount of money on. because I really do think you should invest in sleep. Clearly. A good couch and a good mattress are like the two grown-up purchases, I think are worth all of the outrageous amounts of dollars you will spend on them. I personally spent seven years in Japan sleeping on a really cheap futon, and I actually got several musculoskeletal, like, pain to the point where my doctor sat me down in Japan

and in Japanese was just like, ah, Victoria's son, you need to buy an actual mattress. So, you know, that was a huge life lessons for me. So take this into context that when I was saying, you know, I was willing to test and seriously consider a $4,700 mattress for not mattress, but mattress cover. Right. Not even a mattress. Not even a mattress. A cover with a base at the bottom. So the base will elevate. So you can use that manually and be like, hey, I feel like being. comfy while I read, and so it'll elevate you in that way. But the more like sleep maxing bits of it is that there is like a special position where it slightly elevates your feet for sleep position.

And supposedly the AI in this thing will adjust the position of the bed while you're sleeping to minimize snoring. I have woken up while it's been moving the bed to make my spouse stop snoring. I was just about to say, who's the snorer in the bed? It's not me. I have quantifiable proof. in our marriage that I am not the one snoring. So, ha-ha. So, you know, this can be great fodder or not in your marriage to be like, I am not the snorer. You, sir, are the snorer.

But, you know, I have actually woken up while this bed has been adjusting and watched as they're snoring dramatically lessened and just like in a sleep-addled state going like, oh, you mean, I don't have to like smack you and be like, wake up, you're snoring. It's woken me up. I can just go like, oh, this is a fever dream going back to sleep and whatnot. So that is one thing that it does. But the thing that they're most famous for doing, I certainly buried this lead, is that it addresses the temperature. Right.

So there's tubing inside of this smart mattress and water runs through it from this hub. And I am perpetually cold. So I like to crank it up and it's warm and it's toasty and I fall asleep so quickly. Normally I like tossing and turning. Wait, all right, let's just confession time here on the Vergecast. Left to your own devices, what's the thermostat at when you're sleeping? Warm. Like, in the winter, minimum 75.

Wow. I need to be toasty. I need to be warm. I need a heavy blanket year round. Like, I get cold so easily. And if I'm cold, I don't fall asleep. So I need to be toasty. I'm the opposite. I used to get in trouble when I was a kid because I would sleep with a window open in like the dead of winter. Because for me it's like cold face giant blanket. That's that's the life. That's where I want to be. But then getting out of bed is awful. These like the worst. No. No, I don't I don't mess around with cold stuff. I like to be warm, toasty, snug as a bug in the fetal position. That's me. My spouse, however, like this summer, like I think the max cold.

setting you can go on this bed is negative 10, and they were just like, negative 10. I want to sleep on a slab of ice. I'm living this penguin life. And honestly, they can do that on their side of the bed. I can be in toasty heaven, and they can be in ice cold hell. And we can both be super happy about that. But there's something interesting in that, though, because I think on the one hand, we have lots of science at this point about like optimal temperatures for getting good sleep. And things you mentioned, like the position your body should be at to not snore. So I can imagine in some world that like what this mattress pad ought to do for you is optimize all of it automatically and be like, no, trust me. I know what is required to get. Oh, it does do that. Okay. Because I was going to say, giving you a lot of buttons and knobs might actually not be helpful,

but it will attempt to solve these problems for you. Okay. Yeah, no, it has this AI feature which is locked behind a subscription, which is why everyone's like, are you crazy? And yes, actually. To be fair, I do think. a subscription mattress is just in principle, ridiculous. Even though I sort of understand why it exists, in principle, it's ridiculous.

In principle, subscribing to your mattress is ludicrous. And I think I wrote that in my review. It is absolutely bad shit insane ludicrous. But you're not even subscribing to the mattress. You're subscribing to the mattress cover. So it's absolutely bonkers. Honky tonk insane. But at the same time, I cannot lie.

I have been sleeping so well. Even when external circumstances in this world are crazy, I sleep like a baby. So if you have that mode on it, it will attempt to balance all the temperature and space and adjustments of the positioning. It'll try to just do all that for you. It does all of that for you. And then when you look it up in the app in the morning, it's so proud. It's like autopilot made four adjustments last night to help you sleep longer. So like I look at it and it's like these micro adjustments to temperature.

So I need to be very toasty to fall asleep, but to stay asleep, I apparently need to sleep cooler. So it'll do that. It'll adjust during the middle of the night to the temperature to help me stay asleep. And the longer you test this stuff, the better it gets. And to the point where I'm just like, oh, my God, like all my other corroborating sleep tracker data has basically said my sleep has been spectacular for the last six months. and I'm putting on muscle. I am losing fat at the same time. It's just, it's, I wake up, like, I wake up at 4.30 a.m. now feeling completely rested because I go to bed at, like, an insane grandpa time, like 9.30, 9.30 or whatever. And I'm out here. I just pop out of bed in the mornings a lot of times just like, hi, I'm super rested. Time to go on a run. Which I never thought was possible for me. It's, yeah, I. Like I have a history of insomnia. I don't fall asleep easily.

I previously in the past, and I have the data to back it up, I have had really crappy sleep scores. So it's just wild to see that and to feel the improvement in my life. And then think, this is $4,799. It comes with a $300 per year subscription or something along those lines. So really testing this, my whole thing. has just been like, how much is a good night's sleep worth? How much is the best night's sleep worth to me? Well, so let's actually separate those questions, right?

Because I think if you look at the eight sleep thing as kind of the very end of a spectrum, right, which is like it is doing the most and it is charging the most. It's actually doing the middle. Sleep number has like $10,000 beds. So this being, they do. So this being modular and fitting on your existence. mattress is actually kind of like mid-high spectrum. It's not the craziest end of the spectrum.

All right. So we'll put that at like a seven out of ten. Sleep number, I can't even fathom with, I don't want to know because I can't afford it and I don't want to know. But I'm curious, like, I remember, I don't even know if these are still really a thing, but there was this run of like sleep tracking apps and there were the gadgets that would sit on your bedside table that would try to do this. And have we gotten anywhere with those? Like, can these approximate some of the stuff you're talking about?

Some of them can. Like, I actually really liked the Amazon Halo rise, which is rare for me, because all of the Amazon Halo products I hated with like a burning passion. You and everybody else. It turns out. Me and every. That was not special. That was not a hot tank. But I liked this bedside lamp that gently woke you up with light because that's actually quite effective. I've tested a bunch of these. It's really effective to wake up with light. So smart lights really great if you hate. alarms. They just come on. You wake up kind of naturally because that's just how circadian rhythms and your brain works. I actually like that. It's sleep tracking. My cat got in the way. So I got a lot of really inaccurate results. So when you have these non-invasive, non-invasive in the sense that they're not on your body in any way, on the nightstand, they can be very hit or miss. They can be great if you sleep alone, don't have pets, don't have a bed partner. That can be cool, I guess.

But, you know, there's an option. It's there. I've tested the Withing Sleep, which is like a little mattress that you stick under your mattress. So it's like a little pad that you stick under your mattress. Oh, right? It looks like a little heating pad kind of deal, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Yeah. Super affordable. I think that's a really great budget option if you want to track your sleep. But you are like, these people are crazy. I am not spending thousands of dollars on this mattress that does all of these things, which is totally valid. I think you are probably fiscally very responsible if that's your reaction. But every morning you wake up feeling a little smug about your decisions. I feel so good waking up on this mattress.

Let me tell you. I hate that. Nobody hates this more than me. I hate this the most for me personally. I think this goes on the list of like never try the really expensive thing because once you know you can't go back. You can't go back. It's the recommendation I always give with headphones. Like, if you don't want to buy a really nice pair of headphones, don't ever try a really nice pair of headphones.

Because it will ruin everything else for you. And I feel like this is the same thing. You can't miss what you don't know. 100%. That's 100% it. There's, yeah. So there are cheaper versions of those things. I actually think the smart home is really great if you want to just hack it and have stuff that is multifunctional.

Because the other problem with a lot of the stuff is, very one, one dimensional, one function. It does one thing. Smart lights, you can program them. So you can wake up naturally that way. That's great. It can really help with you setting a routine. Smart thermostat. It is not going to stop your marital problems and fights over what temperature of the thermostat is, but you can schedule it. So, you know, that can help create a much more inviting sleep environment for you. So those are all. more affordable hacks that have multifunctional purposes that I personally have used and found to be good. Does it beat this expensive bed? No, no, it does not. But at the same time, it is really about what is it worse to you?

And how good do you want to feel after your night of sleep? Totally. And, you know, I have sleep problems. So it means a lot to me. But if you're someone who sleeps, like the dead on the crappiest IKEA mattress, you don't need this stuff. You're good. You're Gucci. Like, so it is I definitely understand the criticism and I'm just sitting there alongside you, nodding

my head and going, yes, yes, you are completely correct. I agree with you 100%. At the same time, though, if you're listening to this and you are desperately looking for a reason to buy this, here it is. This is not like buying a really fancy pair of running shoes.

you might never have or like overinvesting and workout equipment that you're never going to use. This will work. This is like you just put this on your bed and it will start doing things. In the same way that sleep has that it's happening anyway, like adding something like this into the repertoire just helps. It's just, it's just going to help. This is why like I want the version of this that is like 60% is good and 20% of the price because it's like that's the one that it's like just give me the math.

magic pillow and everything will be fine. You know what I mean? Like that's the dream. Oh, speaking of magic pillows, many, many, many years ago, I tested a smart pillow, which was the most insane thing because it had a speaker inside of the pillow. So it would track your sleeping and you're snoring because there's a microphone in there. And then it would wake you up to your music inside the pillow. It was one of the most ridiculous pieces of sleep deck I've ever tested. But yeah, another thing I tested was the Oslo Sleep Buds. Oh, yeah, I was going to ask you about that. Which is the Bose sleep buds resurrected.

They had a lot of people who are fans of those. And it's really great if you have a noisy environment because that's the one thing that this bed can't solve, right? It can't solve if you live in a city and your neighbor upstairs loves to practice salsa at 3 a.m. in the morning. Or in my case, if Hackensack loves to send garbage trucks outside of your house at exactly 5 a.m. And you're just like, oh, I'm awake now. Having these buds in your ear, it can muffle a lot of the noise. So I used to be a religious user of that. My spouse is a religious user of not the Bose ones because those, once again, very expensive.

Or the Oslo ones are expensive. But he has the cheaper Anchor Soundcore, which allows them to play their true crime podcast, which why you want to go to bed listening to murder is a thing I don't necessarily understand. But it works for them. So they do that. They love it. It falls out of their ear, which we don't love. But the Bose design is very good for side sleepers. I don't feel this comfort. They don't fall out of my ear. Pretty great. Those will apparently come with sleep tracking sometime in 2025. So, yeah, we're out here. We're sleep maxing. We're just sleep maxing and just trying to figure it out. The earbuds are one that I have always felt like could be more than they are. So I'm actually encouraged to hear that they're going to do some sleep tracking stuff with it. Because one thing you and I have heard a lot of over the years is people saying like the ears are a really interesting place to do wearables stuff. And especially if you're going to start to think about like how do I, you know, gently help you go to sleep and gently help you wake up.

Like that's a thing you can do with a thing in your ears. Like I don't know if it can help you not snore or fix the temperature. Probably not. But there's like little things that if you're just doing like a tracker, you probably can't do. But if you have this device that is just going to sit in your ears all night, it feels like there's more you could do. So maybe there's maybe there is a roadmap of interesting stuff to come there. Especially for like helping you fall asleep because I think that's something that a lot of people have issues with is just falling asleep, figuring out ways to fall asleep. So staying asleep, it's a valuable thing.

because I have tried the smart alarm clocks. I've tried the hatch restore. That TikTok made me try it. It's on my nightstand. And that, you know, just having a sleep partner doesn't really work out well for me. Like the light, great. Love that waking up.

How does it feel to know that you and my one-year-old son have the same alarm clock? Is that good? Is that cool? He loves it. Works great for him. He sleeps like a baby. So honestly,

Honestly, I'm trying to live that life. So it makes me feel great. That's good. All right, before I let you go, any other sleep gadgets on your mind? Anything else you've been looking at or trying or hoping to try? Honestly, I'm just going to reiterate one last time that you should invest in your sleep in whatever way

and don't cheap out on it. sometimes the right decision is to buy a $5,000 mattress cover. Sometimes that is the right decision. This is where we were going to land because the Verges' editorial policies dictate that you don't get to keep this thing. At some point, this beautiful device that has changed your life is going to leave your house. What happens then? Can you go back? I'm going to buy it. But it's either going to be a long-term sleep testing control device so that I can test.

it for sleep trackers. Right. For journalism. For journalism. For journalism purposes. Or, you know, you just have to buy the thing because I can't go back. And, you know, like, if it was just a simple matter of also returning it and knowing that that's what it was going to be, that'd be cool. But because this has my biological material on it, they will not necessarily return it. They will destroy it. And then that just feels like e-waste. So I'll figure out a way. I'll figure out financing. I will do long-term test tracking. But this is one of the things where, yeah, I'm just going to have to buy it, honestly, if it comes down to it. And that's just, it has a huge impact of my life. My sleep quality is so much better. You can think I'm crazy. All you like, I'll figure it out. I'll figure it out. My husband does not agree with me, but I'll figure it. So. That's their problem, not yours. That's their problem.

Not mine. I will be figuring this out. And I will be paying an absurd subscription. That's how they get you. Don't test it unless you're willing to buy it, people. I'm not proud of my life choices, but they are mine. These are the things we do for our audience, V. We spend outrageous amounts of money on beautiful nights of sleep.

You know, I'm winning. So there you go. All right, V, thank you as always. Thanks for having me. All right, we've got to take a break, and then we're going to come back, and we're going to talk about music. We'll be right back. Support for this show comes from Shopify. Every thriving, successful business has to start somewhere.

A good place to start is a relatively simple question. What if, given the right tools, I really put my all into this. One tool that can help grow your sprouting business to new heights is Shopify. Millions of businesses around the world rely on Shopify for e-commerce. They offer a host of helpful tools you can take. advantage of from payment processing to analytics to website design. Their design studio includes hundreds of templates to help you create the exact website you've been envisioning for your business. If you're wondering, what if I need help, then no worries because you're never left to fend

for yourself. Shopify's award-winning customer support is available 24-7. It's time to turn those what-ifs into a thriving business with Shopify today. Sign up for your $1 per month trial today at Shopify. dot com slash vergecast. Go to Shopify. com slash vergecast. That's Shopify. com slash vergecast. All right, we're back.

If you use Spotify, I'm sure you know the DJ feature. You click on it, it has this AI-generated voice that greets you, and then it plays you music. And that's the idea. It is supposed to be a sort of constantly updated, AI-c curated playlist of music. that you'd like. I love this feature.

I listen to it all the time. I think the voice bit is kind of weird, but I think the idea that I can just sit down and essentially press play and have something play music for me that I'm going to like is very powerful. Alison Johnson on our team feels slightly differently. She has also been testing AI, DJ stuff, has a lot of thoughts,

and I figured we just need to hash this out. I'm also working on a big story about what the best music app is because I'm sort of over Spotify and trying to find something else and finding something else is a challenge. So I'm hoping Allison can help me talk through this one piece of it and try to make sense of things. Let's just get into it. Allison, hello. Hello. I should tell everybody that I'm interrupting a day off for you to do this. So I and everyone listening owe you a great debt of gratitude. I'm happy to be here. I get to talk to another adult before a little bit before I go to the Children's Museum.

So I'm happy to, I'm happy to do it. So real quick, I want to talk about AI DJs, but first I want to know kind of your theory of the case about Spotify's AI DJ in particular. This is very clearly a thing you've been thinking about a lot. And there's a lot of interesting context, but you've come to a conclusion about these things, and I want to know what that is. Yeah. So Spotify, like every other tech company with an app,

has been shoving AI into everything over the past year. And the one that caught my eye recently is this AI DJ, which is not actually new. It's been around like a year, but it just kind of popped up in my feed. And I was like, sure, I'll try this weird thing. And right out of the gate, it's just so strange because it talks to you. It goes, hey, Allison, blah, blah.

They kind of launch into like DJ Spears. about what they're going to play. And then, you know, it gets into the music. And not surprisingly in any way, it's all stuff that I really like because what company has more data about what music I like to listen to than Spotify. Yeah. I was just kind of like, what is this? And I listened to it. I like kept with it for a day and like off and on throughout a week just to be like, what is it?

is going on here. But you don't like that. You just described such a good thing. This is why I think this is so interesting and why I want to talk about it. What you just said, I'm just going to say it back to you, is you clicked on a thing that greeted you by name and then played a bunch of music in a row that you really like. And this feels like a problem. Terrible.

Yeah. No. So here's the thing. Kind of the flip side is that we have a local radio station in Seattle. K-E-X-P that I've listened to forever since before I moved to Seattle. And it's just kind of like a daily habit. It's on in the background all the time. It's on in the car.

And I don't know if it's a Seattle thing or a me thing or what it is, but the osmosis of like you get, you have these like parisocial relationships with the DJs that kind of start you like have your favorite DJs. And then the weird thing in Seattle is like, be out on the bike path and I'll see Kevin Cole going the other direction after his show. I'm like, oh, they're real humans. They're out here. Just like we are. And I feel like in Seattle, like a very musicy town, that counts as like an actual celebrity setting. Like that's legit. Oh, for sure. Yeah.

The whole rest of my bike ride. I was like, oh my God, Kevin Cole was going to be on the way. So that's kind of like the background where I maybe I bring a little more skepticism to it where I'm like, you know, to me, a radio DJ is like a real person and I have favorite radio DJs. And yeah, hearing this, which is just an imitation of that, just like maybe I was just not going to like it right out of the gate. But that's my bias I brought to it, I guess. So this is part of why I wanted to talk about this, because I think trying to figure out what feels wrong about the AI DJ actually feels like a really useful sort of metaphor for all of AI. And I think this is a lot of what you were getting at in this piece.

And I think why it struck me too, there's this question of, okay, is it a bad thing that it is pretty much exclusively playing music? I definitely for sure am going to like. Like for me, I was listening to my DJ all morning. And I mean, it is just down the middle David Bate, right? One of it was like there was this guy I found who was doing like punk rock covers of old songs on TikTok. And then I listened to a bunch of his stuff on Spotify. And it was just like, what if we just played mine of his songs in a row?

I was like, great. I'm in. Let's do it. Yeah. Let's go. And then there was a bunch of like synthy 80s pop music, which Spotify, like you said, has immense. knowledge of the fact that that is music I am always going to like. And so it was like a no-skips playlist for an hour and a half. And I got to the end and I was like, did I get anything out of any

of that? Like, could I tell you what songs it played? It was just sort of music. So there's the question of like, is that the right thing? And then there's the question of like, is this, is this product even a good idea? And that goes back to the like, it's a person, quote, unquote, talking to you, quote, unquote, as it goes. And there is this thing. about this thing is obviously trying to seem like a person. And I think one of the things we're seeing about AI a lot is AI that is trying to seem like a person. And I think in some ways this is just the most sort of nakedly straightforward version of that. And it rubs me the wrong way too.

And I can't figure out if it's just because it's not very good or if it's because it's the wrong idea. Yeah. And it's, I mean, it's pretty convincing. Like, it just sounds like a person talking to you. And I think, like, to me, it just feels like this is not somewhere I need AI. Like, I'm good with Spotify putting together a playlist for me. You know, I use the playlist feature, the AI playlist feature, quite a bit where I'm like, I want to hear upbeat jazz. There can't be any lyrics because I'm writing a blog, you know, and like.

it spits out a playlist and it's great. Which is also AI, by the way. Yeah, yeah. It's a different flavor of it. That is still very much AI. And I'm totally good with that. I'm like, do not try to insert a human into this interaction. You know, it's a very like transactional, like, this is fine.

So that's where I think I'm just weirded out by the DJs. Like, we have human DJs. We have people. If you want to listen to the radio, you can do that. Like, who is asking for this? I put it in the box of who was asking for this. No, I think that's totally right. And I think I made a lot of fun of Apple Music when Apple Music came out and they had, you know, beats one and all of these celebrity-driven radio stations, essentially.

And my theory then was like, who wants this? Right? Like, I have a library full of infinite music. Why am I going to spend two hours a week listening to like whatever John Mayer feels like playing? I was wrong about that for, I think, exactly the reason you're describing that there is a lot of time that I just want what I want, right? Which is like a giant library full of music and I'm going to go in and I'm going to be like, I would like to listen to the wicked soundtrack, please. Yeah. Go listen to the Wicked soundtrack. Great. That is better than the radio. And then there's all the way on the other side, there is the like, just expand my brain a little bit. Right?

And I think that AI is not doing successfully at all. Yeah. And this goes back to the like, is it right to just play me songs that I like a bunch of times in a row? I think that that is such an easy win if your goal is to just get people to keep listening. but it doesn't feel good. Like in a way that, like, you talked about, you know, some of the stuff you've gotten from KexP as like meaningful stuff and you, like, remember the experience

and it feels cool and you feel like part of the community. I don't think it's possible to get any of that from this AI stuff. Yeah, that's exactly it. And the metaphor I've landed on is, like, listening to KXP is sort of like a well-rounded meal. Like, there's stuff I really like, there's stuff I'm sort of into. There's stuff I just straight up do not like.

But it feels like a balanced experience. And the AI DJ is just straight up feeding me like all this stuff I like. I'm like, I love M&Ms. I don't want to eat M&Ms all day long, you know? Like you get a stomachache eventually. And that's just kind of how it feels to me. And there is like, yeah, it just hits different. There's like, I hear tears for fears come on in the grocery store, and I'm like, well, they know that women in her late 30s is probably shopping is going to love this.

And they're right. But then my, you know, favorite DJ plays it on K-AXP because she really loves it. I'm like, oh, this is, it just, it's more meaningful, I think. Yeah. The one part of it I have trouble with is the, is it good? to play me stuff that I hate side of things, right? Because I think, and you made this case a little bit in your piece, and I think it's been a thing for you of, like,

the percentage of things that I hear from these DJs or whatever that I actively don't like is good and important. And there's part of me that sort of intellectually understands that, but then part of me that's like, well, A, that's the time when I turn off the radio, right? Yeah. Or B, what if it just only played? things that I liked. And then I'm back to the AI DJ thing that it's like, again, you can see how you get there, right? It's like if we just keep playing songs that you like, you won't turn

the thing off. And so what responsibility does it have to just inject randomness into your life even on the grand likelihood that you're going to hate it? And in a weird way, I feel like this is something we're not dealing with at all in the rest of AI. But it's the kind of question we're going to to have all the time when we get to things like all of these sort of information retrieval services and the way that we think about generating images and text. Like, should it write you a bad email one out of ten times just to like keep you on your toes? I don't know. Yeah.

Yeah. There's a weird like personalization echo chamber I think that you can get into. And it's, I don't know, maybe like there's times when I'm like, yeah, I want to be in the echo chamber of music I like. I don't feel like, you know, eating my vegetables today. I just want to hear the stuff I like. But I think it's like, that's probably different for every person. And I think there's a different limit of like, when do I feel like, okay, I should probably listen to something else and like get something else mixed in here.

And then, I don't know, then when I go back to listening to washed out or whatever I'm doing, It's like, it sounds great. I'm like, yeah, I love this. Yeah, I like the M&M's analogy a lot, right? It's like it's good to have comfort food. Yeah, yeah. But if you only eat comfort food, like comfort food, like comfort food is comfort food because you don't eat it all the time. That is kind of the point.

Right, exactly. Yeah. Do you think that's something AI can get better at? Like, is there someone at Spotify who can tweak that algorithm to make that work? I think it, I mean, it probably could. But, you know, someone commented. on the article, and it really resonated with me that when a human plays something that you don't like, they like it. Like, they have a reason for playing it. And you kind of like weigh it differently

in your head. And you kind of give it a chance, maybe more than if this robot, like, I'm, like, more offended when the robot plays something I don't like. I'm like, excuse me? Where did you come up with this? That's so true. Yeah. And there's a sense of, like you the robot should know. Yeah, yeah. Like you, you, you dumb ass Spotify DJ. You know everything about what I like. Why are you playing me? Yeah, get out of here with this. It tried to do that. There was, I turned it on the other day and it was like, here are some songs that are shaping rock music right now. And I was like, absolutely not. I'm good. Just play the stuff I want to hear. Yeah. It is, I don't know. Again, I keep coming back to.

this question of like, can we, can better AI get closer to these things? I think I'm just so stuck on this question of like, what is necessary for humans to do? And I think the point our commenter is making about having someone say that they like this to you is really powerful. I mean, we talk to people all the time about like recommendation systems and like we think about this like buying guides and all this stuff, right? Like someone you trust liking something. is an incredibly good predictor of whether you're going to like that thing because you're more likely to like that thing because you like the person who recommended it. Like there is some wild human nature thing inside of that that I think you just can't replicate with a computer.

And it's true of like the Netflix algorithm and everything else, right? Even if it puts the perfect thing at the top, I'm still probably more likely to like the thing that you told me to watch than the thing that Netflix told me to watch. Even if statistically Netflix is right. You know what I mean? Yeah. And so I wonder to some extent if it's a matter of Spotify and everyone else doing this kind of thing just totally barking up the wrong tree.

Or if it's like maybe if the voice was 10% more convincing, I wouldn't even know. And it would start to feel like a person. I feel like there's a, you feel the intention behind it a little bit. Like when I hear something on the radio, it's maybe something I don't like. Like there's a person playing it. It's their job to curate music and they like it. The intention behind the Spotify AI DJ is a little murkier where it's like, I think you just want me to keep using Spotify, you know? Or it's like, I just can't shake that feeling of like, this is a robot.

It's a convincing robot. you are basically like the voice of, I don't know, a corporate entity. Like that's not at the front of my mind when I'm listening to it. But I think it's somewhere in the back where I'm sort of like, I don't quite trust the intentions. Like when it's trying to introduce me to whatever's coming next in rock music, I'm like, well, are they sponsored? Or are they just like, did a human pick these? Like, I just don't know where it's coming from. It feels, yeah, it feels murkier, I think.

Yeah, and then ironically, I think there are probably similar questions worth asking about a lot of radio DJs. True. But it feels different even when it's not, right? And I think that thing is really important. And, like, for Spotify, I think if you rewind a bunch of years, Spotify and everybody else always talked about, we need the sort of human computer combo to do this stuff really well. And I think my experience, at least, was there was a long time where Spotify's curated playlists were where I did the vast majority of my listening. Oh, yeah. And it was a mix of like, you know, rap caviar was like the biggest playlist on planet Earth.

And it was a person. They had a ton of machine help. They get all kinds of listening data. They get all kinds of like, you know, quantitative and qualitative data about the songs themselves. But ultimately, they're putting the thing together. And I feel like Spotify probably most of all, but to some extent, kind of all of these media services of any kind have just leaned further and further and further into the machine. And maybe the right answer is just like a human face on the machine. Right.

The cynical answer is they hire a DJ to just say the words to you instead of a machine saying the words to you. But it does feel like that combination. is being lost. And I think part of the reason I wanted to talk to you about this is I'm curious about your own music habits because I was thinking about my own

after reading your story and I spend a shocking amount of my time in the daily mixes that Spotify does. It has like six of them. One of mine is always country. One of mine is always like movie soundtracks which is awesome because that's why I wasn't

taking very work all day. Like it rips. It's great. But I spend a lot of time in those and that's AI. There's no person involved in that. That is the computer curating music for me, but that's not, like, I get to the end of those playlist and I couldn't

tell you anything about them. They're just kind of the noise I have on during the day. Yeah. And reading your article, I was like, oh, I need to go back to listening to the radio in the car just as like a new kind of sensory experience for music. Because I know all, all music is background noise to me now in a way that I kind of hate. And I think Spotify has done that to me. Yeah. Yeah, Yeah, it's funny because, like, I feel like that's a big reason why we all signed up for Spotify was like, whoa, the algorithm is really good, and you're going to find stuff that you actually like. And that was, like, kind of a groundbreaking concept at the time. And I do find a lot of music I like through recommended stuff on Spotify. But yeah, it is a different, like, you do get into. the too many M&M's situation, or at least I do pretty quickly, because I will just happily keep listening to my, yeah, 80s-inspired synth pop bands. And then, yeah, it feels good to like, there's a couple of DJs I like a lot on KXP. I think one of the things they do is play the

songs that I didn't realize I wanted to hear, and they feel kind of out of left field. And there's like, love the Spotify algorithm for what it does. But then I do want, it's like gratifying when I hear something. I'm like, I had no idea that I needed to hear Stevie Wonder, like, as much as I did. And you hear it on the radio. I was like, that was perfect. I feel like it just, it just comes down to feeling like there is something there with AI and Spotify's had a lot of success with it. I think they're kind of leaning into that is getting to a point of like, well, yeah, the AI was good, but I didn't want to like talk to the AI. Like it wasn't the AI that I was here for.

I was here because the AI was helping me get to good music that I like. it's not the entity I want to be interacting with. And it's like such a cringy moment right now where everybody's like, you know, you log on Instagram. It's like, do you want to interact with AI? Right. No. I want to see what my friends are doing.

I know. I have come to the point where I'm like, I think we need to get to the point where we think of AI, like we think of, you know, TCPIP, like crucial infrastructure to how all of this And if it works correctly, you should never, ever for one second have to think about it. Right? Yeah. I don't spend time thinking about packet loss on the internet anymore because it works now. Yeah.

But that's not the point of any of it. All of it enables other stuff. And I think right now we are at a moment where AI is like the main character and what what it should be is like the camera. You know what I mean? Yeah, exactly. I don't know. It's a bad metaphor.

But I'm totally with you. So now that you've been messing with this way of music consumption, what do you feel like is the right answer? How are you going to do your own music to make sure you're getting the right kind of diet? I feel like I have a pretty, I mean, our use case is kind of weird in that like, I can't listen to songs with lyrics during the day. Fair. And when I'm writing. Movie soundtracks. It's the only way.

Movie soundtracks is good. I like that. The Pirates of the Caribbean soundtrack for like five years was all I wrote to. Oh, my gosh. If everything I start writing sounds like super epic and like you'll know I've been putting on the Pirates of the Caribbean. Cannot recommend it enough. Yeah. Yeah.

So I have like kind of my genre for when I'm writing and working during the day. I think probably in there there there's even a little room to experiment. Like I've listened to the same like coffee table jazz playlist probably a hundred times. But then yeah, it's like when the working day is over, I kind of like, like, I like having KXP on while I'm doing the dishes and while I'm in the car picking on my kid. And yeah, it doesn't feel it's like I don't need everything to be a banger. I don't know. Like maybe in different situations, I'm a little more like, okay, I want to listen to whatever it is right now.

But sort of feels like a nice way to unplug from the day and hear a person, hear some probably a lot of songs I'll like. Yeah, I think there's something to the kind of unoptimizedness of that that is really, I don't know, encouraging and compelling in a way that listening to a playlist of things that are sort of ruthlessly constructed for your oral pleasure is like, eh, you get to the point where you're like, okay, these are great songs and I'm kind of over it. Yeah. But then the like the peaks and valleys of like, oh my God, I love that. song versus what is this trash that they're playing for me for the next three minutes. It is. It's just so hard to replicate. And I think we're going to see a lot of companies and products try to emulate that. I'm not sure it's possible. I just don't know if you can do that

with computers in a way that people doing people things is going to keep working like that. So should everyone listen to KExP? Like is the move here find your own local radio station or just get into KexP and it'll solve all your problems? I think it is. KXP is streaming worldwide online. I am not a paid spokesperson for KXP. I just don't really like it. But yeah, no, that was the really amazing thing about this comments on this article or people trying me in like, yeah, I have this station and, you know, shout out to the station in Milwaukee or wherever you are. And they're out there. It was really gratifying to hear that. People have their favorite. indie radio stations in in our super optimized, super Spotify time. So that was great to hear.

Yeah. I will say the one other thing I would add in terms of like places to go for this kind of thing is YouTube is a surprisingly rich place for people basically just doing radio. Yeah. Like I think a lot of people know Lofi Girl and stuff like that, which is a thing I really like for sort of the,

the right vibe but new music. I use it sort of as a mood setting thing, which I'm very happy to outsource. Like, I don't need to know what the songs are called. I just want, I trust them to sort of make me feel the way that I'm looking for. But there are also lots of people out there doing really interesting mixes of like different kinds of genres and doing all kinds of really long radio DJ sets essentially.

And there's tons of great radio to do there. But I also would encourage people to go. poke around on the sort of endlessly streaming YouTube stations. Yeah. Because there's some very cool stuff out there. Yeah. Awesome. I think we all need a little more of the weird random discovery in our lives.

It's good. Eat your vegetables. Don't eat Eminem's all day. As much as I hate to say at John Mayer's Apple Music Radio Station is very good. It's very good. It's like I like John Mayer a lot against my will. But here we are. This is just what happened.

He's a good musician. He's like, undeniable. However you feel about him, yeah. Yeah, exactly. This is where I've landed. All right, give us a music recommendation, then I'm going to let you leave. While we're telling people to listen, what should everybody go listen to? Oh, gosh. I just heard, oh, Sudan archives. I saw her at a festival. I hear her on KXB all the time. She's a Cincinnati girl like I am. Check her out. I love everything she's doing. Love that. I have been listening to Casey Musgraves nonstop for like two weeks,

so it's probably good for me to go and branch on. Yeah. This will be good. Switch it up. Alison, go have fun at the Children's Museum. Thank you as always. Thanks. All right, we've got to take one more break,

and then we're going to come back and take a question from the Vergecast hotline. We'll be right back. Support for the show comes from Upwork. The days of doing it all, all by yourself, are over. There's no romance and burning out while you're trying to scale. Instead, you can check out Upwork. Upwork helps grow your business by giving you fast access to specialize talent across more than 125 categories, so you can fill skill gaps, launch projects faster, and scale without committing to full-time headcount. And finding the right talent is easy.

You can browse profiles, review past work, and get help scoping the role so you can get started quickly. Seriously, you could connect with the right freelancer in just a few hours, especially. especially when you sign up with Business Plus. Their AI powered shortlisting pairs you with the top 1% of talent and under six hours. No endless search you're required. You can visit Upwork.com right now to post your job for free. That's Upwork.com to connect with top talent ready to help your business grow. That's UPWRK.com.

Upwork.com. All right, we're back. Let's get to the hotline. As always, the number is 866 Verge 1-1-1. The email is Vergecast at theverge.com. We love all of your questions, and we try to answer at least one on the show every week. Thank you to everybody who has reached out

with thoughts about how we should be covering politics and the next Trump administration and just the next four years of life in America. We have a lot to think about. It's been really great to hear your thoughts on what you do and don't want us to talk about and do and don't care about yourselves and how we as the verge can make this stuff make sense

both kind of in our world, but in a broader world. Thank you to everybody who's reached out. But this week, we do not have a question about that. We have a question about one of the true central tenants of the Vergecast, and that is the Fram TV. Let's hear it. This is Pete from North Carolina.

I need some advice on the Framed TV. I'm probably not a normal TV buyer in that I'm almost 40, and I've never bought a TV. The only reason I'm in the market now is that we had some inclement weather out here recently, and our old TV that was going on like 20 years old, I got a piece of a window through it. So what I'm looking at is the only place in our house for a TV is the main room up on the mantel place. It's pretty central, and I hate the idea of having a big, empty black void staring at the room,

especially with our little kids because they're just going to demand that some sort of cartoon is played on it. It's also, well, used to be next to a big window that is getting repaired. And so it gets a lot of light. And between that, it kind of seemed like the frame TV, or something like it would be a good fit so that it's not getting too much glare, and when it's off, it's not just begging for something to be turned on. So that being said, I see 50, 55-inch TVs on Best Buy for like $200 to $300 while the frame TV is over $1,000.

Can I justify paying not much for something that hopefully will look nice? Is that a good tradeoff? Is the frame TV actually what I want in the middle of my main room that I'm going to be looking at all the time? I would love any advice you can give me. Thanks. Bye. When someone asks the question, is the frame TV actually what I want? There is only one person to bring in. And it's Neela Patel. Hi, Nilai. I'm just going to answer that question with a statement, which is that Hollywood is doomed. embedded in that question. If you listen to it carefully

is the complete destruction of the film and TV industry as we know it. Same more. Pete, you don't want a TV. You're 40 years old. You've gone your entire life without purchasing a TV

and I'm, yours got broken and you're like, I should have a TV in this space because you think you need a TV. And maybe you watch it sometimes. And you don't want your kids to watch cartoons on a TV. So you're going to buy something else out of obligation to cultural norms,

and you're actively looking to spend money on a TV whose picture quality sucks to prioritize how it looks when it's turned off. It is just a little, it's a little hop from there to not having a TV. I don't know how more clearly I can say this. Hollywood is doomed. People don't want to watch the TVs.

They want to watch TikTok. I mean, it is, it is, true in a way that I had never really thought about until you said that that you are just assumed to have a television. Like, we watch a lot of HGTV in our house, and one of the things that drives me the most crazy is whenever they stage the houses at the end, they're always beautiful and perfect and well set up. And you always sit there and go, well, where's the TV going to go? They're going to have to flip all this round because they're going to have a TV because you have to have a TV. The fact that people will spend money, I will answer the actual question with the frame TV, but I'm just embed. embedded in this question, in this thought process, is the end of the assumption that everyone's

going to watch TV. And once you break that assumption, everything goes to hell. The description is kind of, I have a space on a wall where I'm supposed to put a TV, not I want a TV. That is kind of the premise of this question. You're right. Yeah. Put a hang up a picture. But what if you bought a $1,000 TV that let you hang up all the pictures? Right. Can I just you in that? Maybe that's what you want. And you should spend the money on that. right but if what you want is to sometimes watch tv you should spend $200 on a 55-inch TV and put it on a roller stand and roll it into the garage and then roll it back out when you want to watch TV like and you will quickly find that maybe you never wanted to watch TV at all and I just as a person who has

giant expensive TVs and wants to watch movies on them I every single day think boy, this TV is off most of the time. Like, we don't have it on all the time. I have friends and family that keep their TVs on 24-7. Fine. That's another way to go. But it doesn't sound like that's what Pete wants to do. No. The reason I'm always ranting and raving about the frame TV is that the TV of it is pretty compromised.

Right? It's a very old panel. It doesn't have local dimming backlight. It's not Samsung's latest LCD tech. It doesn't have Dolby Vision, which is a Samsung choice. It runs Tyson. Like, I'm just sorry. Yeah.

Right? Like, it's all this stuff. But it has the matte finish and it has the art store and you can put a frame on it and you can hang it on the wall. And people prioritize how it looks way over the picture quality or how the TV of it works. And that's fine. I'm just saying it's just a short hop to the next thing. So Pete, what I recommend is you really feel like you need to have a matte finish TV showing a picture. There are now much cheap.

deeper rifts on a frame TV from a bunch of companies. TCL has one. Highsense has one. Everyone knows this is the market. I think the prices will come down. The frame TV itself is whatever. Like the art store, sometimes has done a great job with the art store.

They have spent a lot of time and energy making the deals and getting the licenses and da-da-da-da-da. But are you going to pay $50 a month for the art store? If you're not, then you should just get another matte finish TV that can be framed, of which now there are several and put up a picture of your family or something. Yeah. Ironically, Pete, I think, is coming into this thinking he's kind of like really trying to decide

which is the best TV to buy, which would make him Neli people. He's actually my people. He's like, I don't care about my TV. I just need to have one, right? Like, I think if you're starting from a 20-year-old TV, frankly, the frame TV is probably going to look great. The 20-year-old panel you had on your wall,

it's probably a big upgrade to even the frame TV. But I do think you're right, Clearly, the goal is not I want the best television, is it the frame TV? Like, I don't think anyone is arguing that it's that. And that's not what Pete wants either. Yeah, if you want to spend $1,000 on a TV at Solicrate, you should buy a 55-inch OLED. Right. But I think if the question is, like, how do I solve this specific problem that I have?

It seems like the cheapest riff on the frame TV is probably what you're after. Or get, what's that Samsung's easel TV? Oh, these are all expensive. Oh, yeah. Get that LG suitcase TV. I'm not kidding. You don't want a TV. That might be the solve.

I might be the TV that goes in a suitcase and put it on the kitchen table once a month when you want to watch a movie. Like, yeah. There are just many, many more ways to solve the problem of sometimes we all want to sit around the screen. Get a projector and hang up a bed sheet. I had the projector thought, but I think the place it sits in Pete's house where it's like a space that gets a lot of light and is kind of screwy, that might be, that might undo the projector. But I think the TV you can put away theory here in some way is actually maybe the solution. Yeah, I looked it up. I'd forgotten what it's called.

It's the LG Stand By Me Go. It's a 27-inch TV. It's in a, you know, it's one of those like James Bond metal briefcases. It's expensive. It lists it over a thousand. I bet on Black Friday it gets really cheap. Buy a smart monitor. I have a 40-inch Samsung's smart.

mark monitor that I bought for $300, throw that in a closet. Like, I'm just saying there are many, many more ways to solve this problem or by a cheap frame TV. But I just, every time I get this question out, I hear from people who are like, I want a TV that looks good when it's off.

And I'm constantly coming back to, it is just a tiny jump to I don't need this at all. Right. Yeah, I mean, it makes you think, do you remember that CES a few years ago where LG had that rollable TV that you, like, pulled up out of a case. Like, that's the kind of thing we all need.

It's like, I just, I want to be able to hide that behind a bunch of books and then pull it out, unroll it, and watch a movie, and then put it away. And I think, like, that's this sort of thing that would be great. And I think the thing about Pete's question I keep thinking about is, is if I put this TV here, my kids will want something on it. And like, I'm sure you feel that, but like, oh, God, do I feel that? I would love to be able to. I hide the remote now, because if he can't find the remote, I'm like, oh, I'm like, oh, sorry, I can't find the remote. But he just points at the TV, which is at his eye level and is like, put it on.

And it would be, it's like, there is more and more appeal to putting the TV away than ever for me. It's all, it's all fun and games and they get iPads. That problem instantly resolves the second the iPad or the Chromebook is delivered, right? For better and for worse. Even things that I've tried to turn into like, this is a TV thing, the era's tour. We're going to watch this on the TV. She instantly figured out how to get it on Disney Plus, right? Like, everything moved.

Yesterday I walked into our kitchen and she was listening to music on her iPad speakers in a house where she is surrounded by speakers can just speak into the void to ask a music service to start playing and knows how to use Airplay. I've taught my six-year-old how to use Airplay. Still listening to music on her iPad speakers. What are we going to do about this? I bought a whole Sonos system and my wife listens to podcasts out of the. speaker on her phone. And it will never, ever stop making me crazy. Mine as well. I'm just saying, Pete, buy what you, buy what fits your budget, buy most people just prioritize size. All TVs are right. I'm going to call up Casey Newton here. Casey asked me on TV to buy, and I told him,

and then he bought a frame TV, and I said, how's the picture? And he was like, it's so bright. And that was the end of that conversation. Yeah. And that's, that's fine. Casey is also my people when it comes to TVs. We're talking about this in early November. So we're just a few days away from Black Friday. So the frame TV will go on huge sale. Always does. Last year's frame TV, which is fine.

Samsung spends no money developing these. It's the same TV every year and they just collect huge margins on them. Last year's frame TV will go on even deeper sale. And then you've got the new class of competitors, right? You've got the High Sense Canvas TV, the TCL NXT Frame TV, the next frame TV. Amazon has the fire TV Omni, which has adaptive brightness and art. There's just a lot of these and they're all going to go on sale on Black Friday. And it's worth just looking at them and thinking, will this solve my problem of it's there? That's the problem you're trying to solve.

Yeah, I just looked it up by the way, the 55 inch Omni TV currently on sale for $369. Like this is a cheaper problem to solve than a $1,000 frame TV. However, you choose. to solve it, you can do it for less than a $1,000 frame TV. I feel pretty good about that. And I'm 100% confident that they'll be even cheaper on Black Friday. Yeah, there we go. That's just the way it goes. Awesome. All right, I hope this helps. Pete, let us know what you end up doing and send us pictures of your setup. I'm very curious. Neely, thank you as always. You're dead to me.

All right, that is it for the Vergecast today. Thank you to everyone who came on the show, and thank you, as always, for listening. There's lots more on everything we talked about at theverge.com, V's review of the eight sleep thing is great. Allison's story about AI DJs, all of our many, many, too many, frankly, stories about frame TVs, all of it on the website. I'll put some links to the show notes, but as always, read theverge.com. It's good website. I like it. And as always, if you have thoughts, questions, feelings, or other televisions that you'd like to spend too much money on, you can always email us at vergecast at theverse.com. Or, like I said, call the hotline. 866, Verge11, we love hearing from you.

The Slack room that all the questions get pumped into is bumping, my friends. It's great times in there. Thank you to everybody who calls, and thank you to everybody who emails. This show is produced by Liam James, Willpore, and Eric Gomez. Vergecast is a Verge production and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Nielai and I will be back on Friday to talk about all the AI news, some more Mac stuff, just a whole lot going on right now. We'll see you then.

Rock and roll.