The Viall Files - E1003 Ask Nick - Cheating in an Open Relationship

Episode Date: September 22, 2025

Our first caller is struggling to move forward after her parent said the thing she feared the most. Our second caller doesn’t know if she made the right decision breaking up her engagement over a prenup. And, our third caller polyamorous friend is having a baby.   “You can’t save people who don’t want to be saved." Listen to Humble Brag with Cynthia Bailey and Crystal Kung Minkoff every Monday. Available wherever you get your podcasts and YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@humblebragpod  https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/humble-brag-with-crystal-and-cynthia/id1774286896 https://open.spotify.com/show/4NWA8LBk15l2u5tNQqDcOO?si=c03a23d537f94735   Start your 7 Day Free Trial of Viall Files + here: https://viallfiles.supportingcast.fm/  Please make sure to subscribe so you don’t miss an episode and as always send in your relationship questions to [e-mail] to be a part of our Monday episodes.  We’ve partnered with Mint Mobile to open a hot takes hotline to hear your scorching hot opinions! Give us your hot takes, thoughts and theories and we’ll read and react to the best ones on an upcoming Reality Recap episode! All you have to do is call 1-855-MINT-TLK or, if you prefer the numbers, that’s 855-646-8855 and leave us a message. To Order Nick’s Book Go To: https://www.viallfiles.com  If you would like to get some texting advice, send an email to [e-mail] with “Texting Office Hours” in the subject line!  To advertise on this podcast please email: [e-mail] or go to: https://advertising.libsyn.com/theviallfiles    THANK YOU TO OUR SPONSORS:  Constant Contact - Get a FREE thirty-day trial when you go to https://constantcontact.com  Better Help - Talk it out, with BetterHelp. Our listeners get 10% off their first month at https://betterhelp.com/viall  Tonal - Right now, Tonal is offering our listeners $200 off your Tonal purchase with promo code VIALL at https://tonal.com   SKIMS - Shop our favorite bras and underwear at https://SKIMS.com  Sundays For Dogs - Get 40% off your first order of Sundays. Go to https://sundaysfordogs.com/viall  or use code Viall at checkout.   Timestamps: (00:00) - Intro (01:48) - Caller One (46:21) - Caller Two (1:53:49) - Caller Three   Episode Socials: @viallfiles @nickviall @justinkaphillips @the_mare_bare @dereklanerussell  

Grab a coffee and discover Vegas-level excitement with Bed-MGM Casino. Now introducing our hottest exclusive, Friends, The One with Multi-Drop. Your favorite television show is being reimagined in your new favorite casino game, featuring iconic images from the show. Spin our new exclusive because we are not on a break. Play Friends, The One with Multidrop exclusively at BedmGM Casino. Want even more options? Pull up a seat and check out a wide variety of table games from Blackjack to play.

poker, or head over to the arcade for nostalgic casino thrills. Download the BetMGM Ontario app today. You don't want to miss out. 19 plus to wager. Ontario only, please play responsibly. If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, please contact ConEx Ontario at 1-866-531-260 to speak to an advisor free of charge. BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with Eye Gaming, Ontario.

Constant contact empowers, small business owners, entrepreneurs, and creators to grow with confidence by making marketing simple, effective, and accessible. No expertise is required. They're all in one platform gives you the tools, guidance, and automation. You need to connect with the right people at the right time so you can focus on running your business while they help you thrive. If you are a business owner and you are looking to grow your business and let's be honest, who isn't looking to grow, everyone will tell you it comes down to saying the right thing at the right time to the right people, but how do you know what's right? Well, luckily, Constant Contact is here to help. Constant Contact's award-winning marketing platform is here to make marketing way easier and

way more effective for small businesses like yours. The best part, you don't need to know anything about marketing. Your struggle with expensive, slow, and measurable marketing is over. With their all-in-one platform, you can create and manage attention-grabbing campaigns in just a few clicks. Email, text, social media events, landing pages, you name it. It's all in one place. No more juggling dozens of different tools. Constant Context AI content generator helps you turn a rough idea into a ready-to-go message faster than ever. With hundreds of customizable templates, it's easy to make something that looks and reads like your brand. You also get automated sending, real-time reporting, and tools that actually help drive sales. So you're not just marketing your business, you're growing it. Pricing is transparent

and based on your contact list, so you're only paying for what you need. No surprises. And with a 97% email deliverability rate, your messages land far from spam. And if you ever get stuck, friendly phone support is included with every plan. That's why over a half a million small businesses trust constant contacts to stay connected, top of mind, and ahead of the competition. Get a free 30-day trial when you go to constantcontacts.com. Try constant contact free for 30 days at constantcontact.com. That's constant contact.com. how's it going good i am katherine i'm 31 and i'm wondering how do i move forward with a parent when they say the thing you fear most what's the thing you fear most um yeah she essentially

insinuated that i'm not a fit mother okay uh so your fear is not being a fit mother yes Why? Absolutely. And from where we sit today, certainly it's every parent's fear, right? You want to be a great parent. Forgetting about what anyone says about you, or including your internal, those thoughts that, you know, those dark thoughts that go on in our head, do you feel like you're a good mother? Um, yes.

Yeah. Um, but. The hesitation that I'm hearing from you is that, again, the doubts because you're worried because of what people think about you? Or is there a specific reason that's something that's going on in your life or in your world that makes you question and has that hesitation come in? Yeah, I'm dealing with just overcoming a lot of childhood trauma and everything like that. And I've noticed that I just, I get overstimulated easily by them. And I worry that I'm not going about it the right way, that I'm falling short and I'm not showing up how I should.

Wouldn't you mean by overstimulated? Can you describe an example for me of a situation with your kids where something happens, you emotionally react? And then after the situation calms down, you reflect back and doubt. your actions as a mother. Yeah. Just, I mean, it can be as simple as if both of the kids have been having a rough day all day and they're crying. I might have to take a step away from them. And it's instances like that where my mother implies that that's where I'm falling short. And when you say a step away, like, are you like taking off for a month or are you like going in your room for 10 minutes and crying?

yeah i'm going into my room or the bathroom for 10 minutes and crying and she says that i shouldn't have to cry okay well good for sure uh are you a single mother do you have a partner involved in in this equation yeah i have a wonderful husband he's very supportive great uh how old do your kids one and two they're 11 months apart okay well that's that's a lot for anyone to handle um yeah yeah that's a lot um and then day to day are you like are you a stay-at-home mom and husband's working? Are you also working in this equation? Like, what's, what's day-to-day look like for you? Yeah, I'm a stay-at-home mother. My husband is working. Okay. And then how does your mom have insight into these moments? So just like a little background.

We've never been that close. It hasn't been until recent years. It's just always felt very tumultuous. but now we're really close or we were and she took my kids home over the 4th of July to Minnesota I don't live there and it just erupted I guess it was just too much for her and why did she take your kids home in Minnesota like how did that go down yeah yeah so she just she wanted she's always dreamt of like taking the kids for a week home to Minnesota and showing them all of the fun things on all of her acres and everything. And she kind of wanted to give us a break. We've had some household things.

We've had to take care of and haven't been able to with them. And so she took them for the Fourth of July and my husband and I were going to go up and meet her. And that just is really when it all just unleashed. I thought all of the progress we had made, yeah, just fell apart. And she had a lot. Yeah. No, she had finished that thought? She just had a lot of opinions to say, and it got really dark, really quick.

Talk to me about your relationship with your mom and the childhood trauma that you... She just was never emotionally there for me. If I was crying, she would tell me to toughen up. And I understand that that's a very, you know, common thing for parents, but I feel like I just needed more emotional. support. And it was always just her being so hard-headed and telling me to just toughen up and grow up. Anything else? Or is that just the basic theme of the disconnect between you and your mom? It was, I mean, my therapist uses the words emotionally abusive, but I feel like that is a hard term to use. But yeah, she was just pretty mean. Kind of brought me down a lot.

Okay. Like belittled you and name calls you? Okay. Yeah, yeah. Like what? Like, what's the harsh memory of? I mean, I always heard the term, I love you, but I don't like you. It was always how I wasn't meeting her standards, how I wasn't good enough. Even when I graduated basic training, that wasn't good enough. It's just, I'm never good enough.

Basic training for, you were in the military? Yeah, yeah, I was in the Air Force. I can't help, but what, did you join the Air Force to prove something to Mom? Yeah. Yeah, actually, because she never thought I could do anything. And it's hard when you have a parent that thinks that. And then my biological father left me. So it's just kind of, I've always felt like I'm not good enough.

And she kind of confirms that narrative I have in my head. And then I guess I'm curious, how did you reconcile with mom? You implied that like you guys mended some fences and it sounded like things were on the up and up in the past few years. How did that happen? Yeah, I got pregnant, and I would say that's definitely what brought us closer. And then with the birth of my children, you know, you just, you really need your parents in that time. And so we grew really, really close.

I mean, we got to a point where we were talking every day, FaceTiming every night, as she could see my children. And yeah, it was a great relationship, I thought. I thought we'd move past everything. I'm not in a position to say whether your mom's emotionally abusive or not, not a therapist. but she sounds like a bully and there's only one way to deal with bullies and that is to stand up to them. It sounds like you've spent most of your childhood and even your adult life trying to prove something to your mom to try to get her to see you differently or finally accept you for who you are and validate you in ways that you probably always wish and every kid deserves to be validated by

their parents, but unfortunately your mom is a bully and she seems to only know how to parent in one way and that is to bully thinking that like tough love is the only way to communicate. I'm a big believer in tough love, you know, like I'm definitely, I think there is a time and a place to toughen up. All our feelings are valid, but we can't let our feelings dictate, you know, how we interact in every situation. That being said, like there's also a time for empathy and love and, and validation. And, you know, the I, I love you, but I don't like you from a parent to a child. This seems like just a horrific thing to say. But yeah, your mom is a bully. And I guess I would love for you to figure out, instead of trying to finally get mom to see you, how you hope she would see

you, I guess I would love for you to accept that she is a bully. And there's only so much you can, You know, like, you can do all the therapy possible. We could talk every day. But you and I talking is never going to change your mom. And you working on yourself is never going to change your mom. So it really comes down to how are you going to change how you interact with mom? Not to get mom to change, but just so that you have the peace of mind and the confidence to know to stop letting this bully, regardless of the fact that she is your mom, dictate how.

how you feel and destroy yourself confidence and affect you, you know, as a mother, right? Like, you have this very gentle demeanor about you, not sure how you are as a mother, but I'd be willing to bet if anything, you're probably the exact opposite of your mom when it comes to your kids. You know, it's kind of like, you know, when a parent is a, let's say, an alcoholic or something, like usually goes one of two ways. Either that child might develop some problems of substance abuse as well, or they have this kind of very rigid hard line, I saw my mom or dad destroy our family with alcohol and I'm never going to touch the stuff type of thing. And I feel like you're giving me the energy that you're more the latter

when it comes to how you want to be with your children. On the flip side, to your point, like there is a time and a place for tough love, and I want you to be able to find the balance that your mom was never able to find. You know, like being overly empathetic and afraid to like at the right i mean your kids are so young at the right now you just want to love them but at some at some point your kid's going to be old enough where instead of a gentle a gentle hug they might need a a gentle push and i i want you to be able to like know the difference in it right now you are questioning yourself constantly because of this emotional bowling that your mom has done listen i haven't observed you as a parent nanny and i are just doing our best too i'm sure you're

an amazing mother. You know, so much about being a great parent is the desire to be a great parent. All the talk about like narcissists these days and like I, the joke or is like if you've ever wondered to yourself, am I a narcissist? Then you're definitely not a narcissist because like you have the capacity to look in the mirror reflect and ask yourself all these moments where I have put myself first or I've been a little selfish or demonstrated a narcissistic. trait, does that make me a narcissist, but that reflection is literally what a narcissist is incapable of doing. In the same vein, the fact that, like, you had, like, I doubt very much that your mom's ever looked in the mirror or asked anyone if she is a good mother. Yeah, I would

agree with that. The fact that you have speaks volume about your capabilities as a mother and your intentions to be a mother. I mean, yeah, maybe it's different times. I don't know. You know, like, you're right. Like 50 years ago, is just a different world and, you know, whatever. But like, your desire to be the mother that you want to be is going to make you a great mother. And I think you just have to know, you know, you have to know that, right? Short of like saying that to yourself and be like, well, I want to be a great mother. So I'm going to be a great mother. And, like, kind of have this kind of almost delusion about how you are. But I'm not sensing that from you. Thank you for saying that. Oh, no problem. How is your relationship with your husband? husband? It's good. It's really good. That's great. I want that to be your priority. I mean, I would love, listen, it's very easy for me and I'm very privileged to have the parents I have. So I understand that it's very easy for me to say, like, your relationship with your mother is just

not that important compared to some of your other relationships, being one, your relationship with your husband, you know, most important, your relationship with your kids. Now, your relationship with kids, you know, they're so young that, like, it's not as fragile as, say, a husband and wife, you know, even the best relationships are fragile in the sense that, like, it doesn't take much to have two people being disconnected in life, right? And so I use the word fragile because, like, I think healthy relationships and marriages, you know, there's a lot of things working against us in today's society in terms of, you know, staying together, being together, being on the same page, working as a team, supporting each other, validating each other, picking each other up when

you're feeling down, pushing each other to rise, you know, when maybe we're not feeling and being our best selves. We don't have a lot of support from society in that space. And that's why I use the word fragile, not necessarily because your individual relationship is fragile. I'm guessing you're spending a lot of time in therapy, as we're talking now, focusing on your relationship with your mom. Yeah, that's the primary topic of conversation lately. Well, let me ask this. When you're in therapy, what is the goal when it comes to the conversations you're having about your mom? Like, what are you trying to figure out? I honestly, I'm just trying to get that narrative out of my head. I feel like when I think negatively about myself or my actions, which is often it's in like her

tone of voice or it's things she said to me in the past. And so I'm trying to, you know, to honestly just move on. Okay. It's been the hardest part, though. What's the hardest part about that? And just struggling with accepting her for who she is and our relationship for what it is and what it will be. The fact that it's never going to change. Did you feel better about yourself when you had less of a relationship with mom?

Yeah. Yeah. And when mom popped back into your life, did you guys kind of almost? slip into some of the same toxic patterns that you guys had when prior to you disconnecting from mom? Yeah. Yeah, I feel like I always try to please her and forget about what pleases me. Yeah.

What does your husband think about all this? Well, she's been nasty to him too in the past. So he hates how her actions impact me because, you know, I'm still crying about it. And this happened almost two months ago. And his parents, are they in the picture? Yes, yeah, and they're incredible. It's awesome. Yeah, so I'm very fortunate in that.

Again, I say this as someone who comes from a great relationship with my parents, but I just, I think I would love for you to figure out a way to take control of your relationship with your mom. And I think it first starts with accepting who your mom is. I think the challenge sometimes when it comes to these relationships is that, like, you can only do so much in a romantic relationship if there's, you know, let's say you or your husband were at odds or whatever. And your husband's like, I don't want to do couples therapy. And you're like, okay, well, I'm going to go do therapy. Like, there's only so much you can do in therapy when it comes to your relationship with your husband, right? If assuming he doesn't want to participate in therapy. There's only so much you can do. your individual therapy when it comes to your relationship with your mom. I'm glad that your goal is to just almost to like move on from the impact your mom has your life, but you're trying to do that while still having a relationship with mom without standing up to mom. I guess my question for you is I wrote a letter to my mother and I haven't heard anything back and it was just apologizing. You apologize your mom. Yeah, because I feel like there are areas in which I could be

better. So listen, again, your mom's a bully, and bullies respond to weakness. And your mom doesn't see an apology as ownership of your actions. Like some people might see an apology as strength, right? Like, I think being vulnerable takes a lot of confidence in a world where we're so fixated on being right, I do think it takes a lot of guts in a lot of situations to say, I'm sorry, I was wrong. But your mom isn't one of those people. She's a bully. And so your letter saying, I'm sorry, was her feeling right. And you were never going to get the response that you wanted. I hate to say it. I hate that you wrote her a letter. I don't even care what it said, because I think she just, she's going to weaponize it against you.

And her not responding is a manipulation tactic by her. And again, I think she just sees an apology is weakness. Yeah. I think honestly, the only way. And what I want for you, and I don't know, again, I'm not there, I want you to stop caring about what mom thinks. You know, I want you to start looking at what you have done, surround yourself with the people who love you the most. You know, see you for, starting with your husband. Do you have

siblings? Yes, I do. I have a younger brother. What's your relationship with him? Close. What's his relationship with mom? He sees her for who she is. Okay. So lean on those relationships. You know what I'm saying? Like, you are now an adult. And while it's sad and unfortunate you have the relationship with your mom, you are lucky enough to have a positive relationship with your brother, and now you two have each other to lean on. I'm not saying you should get together and talk shit about mom, but you now know what it's like to be the child of your mother. No one can relate to your brother more than you and vice versa when it comes to the emotional impact your mom's had on your life. So I hope, if nothing else, you,

go out of your way to validate your brother, to let him know various reasons how you believe in him or why you're proud of him or why you think he's done some great things to offer him grace and things like that. You guys have each other. I would rather have you invest energy in your relationship with your brother than with your mother. I think right now the energy you're investing in mom is mostly wasted. And I don't think she is seeing it as a second chance. I really, you know, I think, and if we want to offer your mom grace, I'm sure she had an even shittier childhood and she has passed down this generational trauma down to you,

but it can stop with you. And you can offer your mom grace and love in the sense that, like, you can forgive her for her faults. You can still love her and hope for the best of her. but that it doesn't require you having a relationship with her. And if that changes, I think the onus needs to come from her. I really think you, you know, instead of trying to figure out how to appease mom or writing her a letter and apologizing to her.

And again, I say I come from a place of privilege when it comes to this because like I have this from my parents. And the only way your mom's going to change is if she wakes up and changes. And it's going to start by you setting some very clear boundaries. when it comes to your mom and communicating those expectations. And you can communicate those expectations by not by just cutting her off. Or you could just say, hey, like, there's a new sheriff in town, so to speak. And if you want access to me or my children, here's how it's going to work.

And your husband has every right to also communicate that. And if your mom wants to react in the manner in which she has reacted, which is with vitriol and hurt words and nastiness, let her. You can cut her off. You know, she doesn't live with you. You can, you know, you can stop this woman from having access to you. You know, the challenge you have is like you still, you become this like 12 year old girl when your mom speaks to you. Yeah. And while not rational, there's a part of you that doesn't even comprehend your ability to say, I don't need to hear this from this woman, you know, she doesn't have the right to speak to me this way. You know, there's a party

that still, well, she's my mom. What am I supposed to do? Yeah, exactly. And I do feel this immense amount of guilt about keeping my children from her. Right now, your kids are two and one, all right? They're not, they don't remember anything. Yeah. Right. You know, most kids aren't lucky enough to even know who their grandchildren parents are. That's not going to, like, your, your children's childhoods and happiness in futures will not be based on their relationship with their grandparents. Like there are some very unfortunate family dynamics out there where some amazing grandparents

have stepped up and saved the day because mom and dad were not either present or maybe drug addict, you know, who knows. So shout out to all those amazing grandparents out there, but you're their parent, you're the mom, they have a dad, they don't need grandma. know and right now grandma isn't offering anything positive more than anything the age in which your children are old enough to remember and listen and respond i wouldn't let your kids anywhere near

this woman because she is toxic and she is going to pass down that same emotional if you want to call it abuse to your kids if nothing else she is going to talk shit about you to your own children She talks shit about me to my friends So I guess I don't know why I went Assume she went to it to my children And if I were you I mean, that would piss me off You need to start getting mad at mom, not sad

I think it just feels like To another individual Why was I not enough? I think that's where you have to It's not about you, you know Yeah, that is true That's the hard part, you know In these moments

There's a lot of things that go out in our lives where something happens to us. We are at the receiving end. Like, we want something. We don't get the thing that we want. It's outside of our control. We feel very helpless. But the reality, and this is not going to necessarily make you feel better, but it's out of

side of your control. You know, it's not about you. It has nothing to do with you. It has everything to do with your mom. And it has probably a lot to do with her mom and how she was raised. And she is a broken bird. And again, you can have grace for her and, and pity your mom and feel sorry for her that she is this broken person that has a bad

relationship with her daughter, her son, her son-in-law, that like a lot of people look at her with disdain and sadness because she is not a great parent, you know, because she's done maybe arguably more damage than good. And that's a hard pill to swallow if someone were to say this to the woman, but that is a reality. So if you're going to feel anything for your mom, I would feel pity and sadness. Yeah. And certainly you have the right to be angry. And yeah, I get it. Like, it's not fair. It is not fair. It's not fair that you don't get to have the relationship that you want with your mom. Yeah. You have to put a stop to this because your mom's not going to. Okay. And if that means cutting mom off because she's not going to listen, then so be it.

The next step is saying, mom, like, listen, like, I'm not hearing it anymore. You know, when you talk to your mom, I want you to say, I don't care what you say about me. I know who I am and I know I'm a good mom. I'm not a perfect mom. And I'm not going to get into why because it could be a lot of things that she didn't do. But like, what I'm not going to do is make my children feel the way you've made your kids feel. And I'm not going to let you talk shit about me and my husband. I'm not going to let you treat my husband with the disrespect that you often do or the way you treated me.

and if you're not going to work on yourself and fix yourself, then you're not going to have a relationship with me or your grandchildren. And there's just honestly no discussion about it. You can talk your shit to my friends. You can scream. You can do whatever. But like you have no power here, Mom. Yeah.

You know. So I shouldn't reach out again? I wouldn't. No. Okay. Okay. If I were you. Yeah.

I would mentally just. And honestly, I wouldn't take her calls. Ooh. Okay. I mean, you know, yeah, yeah, no, you're right. You're right. If this was like, how would I, how would I handle this if it's the same situation? I would call up your mom. Yeah. If this was Natalie's mom. And I would tell her exactly how things are going to be going forward. And I would say, listen, you know, you might not think it's my place. I honestly don't really care. I'm making this call for my family. I don't appreciate how you've treated me. I don't appreciate how you treated my wife, your daughter. uh here's how things are going to be going forward if you want a relationship with me or your daughter and your grandchildren you're going to have to treat us all very differently we will no longer ever be allowing your our kids to like i know you needed a break i think it's kind of crazy that you let your your

your two year old and one year old go to grandma's house alone with that woman you know um and i'm sure there's a part of you that was hoping that like well if i let mom do this You know, it's like, again, that was the child in you saying, well, I'm going to let her do this and she will reward me for it. I feel like you, you sending your kids there giving your mom her wish of like, I've always dreamed of having my kids up at the house and showing him around was a way to, well, if I let them do that, then mom will reward me somehow with the love I've never received. That's exactly it. Yeah. That's exactly it. And it obviously didn't work, you know. No, no, not at all. If anything, it. Made things worse. Yeah. One thing I want you to take away from this call is you have all the power in this situation. And so far, you haven't, you are acting as if your mom still has all the power. The parent-child relationship is very difficult to break, right?

Because 18 years of your life, which is your 31, 31? Yes. So, right, like less, more than half your life, your mom had literally all the power. You had no rights as a child, right? You were legally had to listen to your mom. you know yeah and so that's that's hard to break right that's you know um but you have you have to remind yourself i have the power now i do not need to listen to this woman i do not need to put up with how she makes me feel she does not deserve access to my children forget it except call

her grandchildren i don't give a fuck you know they're your kids they're your husband's kids and she has everyone in the world, whether it's your parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles, they all have to earn the right to be in your kid's life. And if they, you know, and no, don't use, and I'm not saying this to like use your kids as a way to weaponize, you know, like your relationships with other people, but if in any way you don't feel like a relationship with the outside world for your kids is healthy for you, your family, you do not have to appease those people. And I just want you to see that this is your family. And what really matters more than anything is your relationship with your husband and your

relationship with your kids. And right now, thankfully, your kids are too young to process any of this, remember any of this. So you still have some time for you and your husband, the change the dynamic of your relationship with your mom so that, like, they don't experience this tension. Your kids aren't even old enough to, they're not going to remember this visit at grandma's house. You know what I'm saying? They will never know. Yeah. Right?

Yeah. So let's fast forward three years. You know, let's say that, you know, your oldest goes to preschool or, you know, kindergarten and, you know, she makes friends. And all of a sudden, someone's like, oh, my grandma's coming over and her grand, and their grandparents are wonderful. And she comes to mom. She's like, where's our grandma or whatever? Or your mom. I mean, again, you have time to figure out that.

You can say, you know, you can talk. I don't know. You have time to figure out what you say to your kids. But you can come up with something that makes sense and is okay. And again, you're very, like, I want you to focus on what you do have, which is a positive relationship with your in-laws. But just, again, know that like your in-laws and your mom are just, they don't really matter when it comes to your children's life and their story and their childhood and whether it's happy or sad, because they have you. I have to remember that I'm struggling with that part, that I'm enough. Yeah, I mean, it's hard because, again, the emotional damage your mom has done.

But I want your, I want you to listen to your husband when he compliments you. I want you to say that, you have to say this to yourself, right? Because you have this internal monologue that started from your mom. And you kind of have to train yourself. You went to the army. and you did something you served your country and that takes a ton of guts and that's an honorable thing and I need you to compliment yourself about that honorable thing you did I want you to be proud of what you did I don't who gives a shit what your mom thinks of it did your mom was your mom

in the army no no she wasn't do you think she didn't have the guts or the capability of doing that no yeah definitely not and I want you to recognize that like yeah yeah I definitely don't give myself enough credit, and that's something I need to work on. My husband says that all the time. So work on it, you know, and the energy you are like that, stop writing letters to mom. Like, you write a letter to yourself, you know, literally. Yeah. I mean, that'd probably be a good practice, you know, just what are you proud of?

Write it down. Read it. Have it, like I have a note, you know, keep it between a journal, you know. Yeah. Yeah, that's a really good idea, actually. never thought about doing that. And I want you to, I want that to be, that's the ruminating I want you to do and not why, you know, it's just like, you are old enough and capable of enough.

While I know it's like easy to kind of slip back into that child, to objectively have an almost out-of-body experience to know that you are enough. Whether you feel it or not right now, that, that's a work in progress, right? But objectively, you know the things that you've accomplished and you know that like you could have ended up like your mom, but you didn't. Yeah, that's my biggest goal is to not end up like her. But you haven't. Right? Like you're already, you've already done that. Yeah. I guess where I get concerned is like when I do have these moments where I'm overstimulated, I get worried like, is this like my mother? Am I on the track to become like my mother? Well, I don't, I mean,

I did you ever see your mom go in a room and cry no no she would just let it build up you do you do that no okay so then you're not like your mom listen it's okay to have a moment of weakness it's okay to yeah be overwhelmed i mean you have two kids under the age of two that's a lot you know most of the day your husband's at work working hard for the family and you're left alone with the kids it's a lot for any parent hell i mean we have one kid and it's just me and Natalie and her mom you know it's a lot for both of us you know because your kids are at the age where you can't keep your eyes off of them so it's like you just never have a moment for yourself you know and when your husband gets home from work he's tired from a long day of work

you know and you're both kind of probably fighting for that like just like it's give me 10 minutes you know who like I cherish 10 minutes of silence I love my wife I love my daughter my whole life is centered around them we spend all of our time time together. I love every second of it. But like I'm an introvert who like needs like I also like benefit from isolation in alone time and I like I feel comfortable in my thoughts and in my head. And I have less of that these days. So when I have five minutes like I cherish it. Exactly. And you're allowed to cherish that. That doesn't make you a bad mom. That makes you a human being, you know, like you need to have your things that help you regulate. You know, you're not a

machine you are allowed to have those moments instead of seeing it as weakness just like you are you are regulating your emotions thank you for phrasing it like that i really appreciate it no problem i mean one thing growing up i you know i was very lucky i never saw my parents fight i certainly had a front seat at some um family traumas my mom had with her mom and her siblings and yada yada yada but my parents did their kids the benefit of whatever fights they had or disagree They did it behind closed doors. They didn't show their kids that because it, you know, and I, I didn't have to see a lot of that stuff that, quite honestly, your kids don't need to see. So the fact that you do take a moment and go in your room, your mom would probably do the opposite.

She would cry in front of her kids and then, like, weaponize that and to make them feel guilty about it and, like, almost, like, blame their kids for how they made mom feel. Yes, exactly. You don't do that. that's that's you that's you that's you thinking of your kids that's you being an amazing mother that's that's you being selfless you know and even when you are having this breakdown and feel like you are still thinking of your kids first yeah you're right you are right so yeah you just a lot of this stuff i just want i want you to i want you're wasting too much energy on this woman yeah i am i am and i you know you have all the power

Number one. I do not this. It's sad. It's sad. You want a relationship with your mom, of course. And that's sad. And you can mourn that. But it's her choice. And sadly, not having a relationship with mom is better than having a relationship with mom. And you have the power to dictate those terms. And I want you to realize that. Okay. Yeah. And if in the moment you don't have the strength, the strength, to stand up to your mom. I bet you your husband does. So let him. Okay. I thought that maybe that was too much. No. You guys are a team. Be a team. Yeah. You know. Yeah. Let each other, you know, step up for each other when the other feels like they lack the strength to do that. You know, that's the whole, what's the, that's the point of being married and having a partnership is that you guys can help you fight each other's battles. I guess I felt like it was my family, therefore I should deal with it.

This is your family. And by your family, I mean your kids, your husband. Like you need to change the way you, like your family is that, right? The moment you get married and have kids, like it's not like my family is my wife and my kids. And yes, of course, like I love my siblings and my parents and I take care of my parents. I'm proud of that. And I, again, I'm very lucky to have the relationship I have with my parents. But, like, they're not my top priority anymore.

Yeah. They're not even close. And I'm very lucky to, like, have the, you know, and I get that from my parents, that, that logic, you know. They both had their, you know, they, I think they overall had, like, generally positive relationships with their parents, all things considered the times and things like that. But my parents taught me that, right? it's just like their family was the family they created. And if you wanted to be a part of that family,

you had to play by their rules. Okay. I like that. I like that. And if your mom wants access to your family, she has to play by her rules, and you don't have to bend, you don't have to negotiate,

you don't have to compromise. You don't even have to be fair, but you're going to be fair because you're a fair person and you want a relationship with mom. And if your mom were to rectify things, you would, I'm sure, offer her grace. Yeah. I think right now your mom needs to, like, be put in a corner, so to speak.

And I think she needs a wake-up call that, like, there's a new sheriff in town. Because, again, your mom is a bully. And the only way to respond to bullies is to kind of meet them at their level. And I'm not saying you should be deliberately mean to mom, but I think you guys need to stand up to your mom. Enough is enough. We're putting a stop to this. You're a bully.

You're no longer going to bully us. Talk your shit, do what you want, but you have no power here anymore, Mom. And I think she needs to hear something like that. You will not see us or your children if you choose to treat us this way. If you choose to communicate to us and belittle us and make us feel bad, we don't need to, whether what you think of us as parents is irrelevant and we don't care. And I want your mom to hear from your husband and eventually you, when you're capable of saying it, is I don't need your approval on me as a parent.

I know I'm a good mom. I'm not going to say, you know, you don't need to say the hurtful thing. You don't need to belittle her as a parent. You just need to stand up to her in a way that she would never imagine hearing that. Yeah. And whatever energy you're wasting your mom, I want you to give it to your brother. I want you to give it to your husband. I want you to give it to your kids.

Stop wasting it on this woman. Okay. It's going to take some work, that's for sure, but I'm definitely, I'm definitely going to try. It's not worth the energy or honestly just the tears anymore. I know it's going to take work, but give yourself some more credit. It's not as impossible as it feels right now. Yeah. It's just not.

Your mom has no power. There's nothing she can do. The moment you simply just decide, you know what I'm saying? There's no legal system. there's no like approval process there's no committee that's going to you have you don't have to convince anyone but yourself i can i can do this i can do this there you that's the energy i want i can do this i i'm a good mom not i not i'm you know those those self-limiting beliefs i want you know they're going to pop in your head but i want you to recognize them and then i want you to get

rid of them okay yeah i can do that and when you go to an i'm not a therapist whatever but when you go to therapy, I would love for you to focus your conversation and energy on how you feel about yourself. I don't, I want you to focus less on talking about mom. And I want it to be about you, your belief in yourself as a mom, how do you prioritize your relationship with your husband, um, how do you still take advantage of the fact that despite your childhood with your mom, you have a good, solid relationship with your brother? And how do you guys give each, that's you know what I'm saying like you're both probably still trying to figure out how to get mom to love you and that might not ever happen but you guys have each other so be there for each other send I'm proud

of you you're I don't know what's going on in your brother's life but whatever's going on in his life I validate him give him the love that he's not you know the same love that I'm sure you know what your brother needs in terms of validation because it's probably all the things that you want from mom so give them that be there for each other i'll definitely do that you're right i i don't think we pour into each other nearly enough well i hope this is helpful it was it was very helpful thank you well you have a great rest of your day nick thank you so much for you as well and that would love an update from you you know in a month or two i'd love to to hear that you've been able to kind of change how you've channeled your energy when it comes to this relationship um

give your husband permission to have your back and trust his instincts when it comes to allowing him to stand up to anyone he needs to stand up for the sake of your family and you. I'll definitely do that. I held him back on that because I thought it was too much. But there is no such thing when it comes to you guys prioritizing, protecting your family. And your family is just that, you two and your kids. That is true.

And everyone else is this lucky to have a seat at the table that they are not entitled to. Okay. you're right you're right all right okay well thank you so much take care you too all right bye bye this is an ad by better help we are talking about therapy all the time on this show how it's helped me how it's helped natalie how it's helped us and therapy is just a great way to just let things go you know get things off your chest we know how difficult and how intimidating therapy can be certainly there's a cost associated with it it can be difficult to enough therapist, that's right for you. And sometimes it just feels like we don't have any time

in our day to add one more thing to our schedule. But with BetterHelp, they're helping alleviate all those pain points. It's incredibly convenient. You can literally do it as long as you have a phone or a tab. And then we certainly know everyone in the world spends a lot of time on their phone. So spend it with a therapist to get some of those things that are stressing you out off your chest. Also, my favorite thing about BetterHelp, since they're working with over 30,000 therapist. They're making it easier for all of their customers to find a therapist that they connect with. You can switch a therapist every time until you feel like you have someone that really gets you, that really understands you and really helps you. So much about therapy is,

you know, making sure that you feel like there is progress being made. And BetterHelp is helping you do that. These therapists are clinically trained in all kinds of expertise. So depending on what type of therapy you're looking for, Better Help has you covered. They've been helping people match with their perfect therapist for over 10 years now and have a 4.9 rating from 1.7 million client session reviews. So what are you waiting for? Stop procrastinating. And if you have ever considered therapy, if you're feeling a little stressed out, if work is getting you down, if you just find yourself ruminating over and over, let BetterHelp help help you improve your mental health. As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental

help professionals with a diverse variety of expertise. Talk it out with BetterHelp. Our listeners get 10% off their first month at BetterHelp.com slash V-I-A-L. That's BetterHelp, H-E-LP.com slash V-I-A-L. When life gets busy, workouts are often the first thing to go. With Tonal, you can make sure you're checking workout off your to-do list with their smart and compact strength training system right in your home 24-7. Tonal provides the convenience of a full gym and the guidance of a personal trainer anytime at home with one sleek system. It's designed to reduce your mental load. Tonal is the ultimate. strength training system helping you focus less on workout planning and more on getting results.

That was the thing that I always struggled with about going to the gym is that I was like, I don't know if I'm doing this right. Like is my form right? Is my form wrong? Should I be lifting this much? I don't know what I'm doing. I need some motivation. And Tonel gives you all of that in the comfort of your own home. There's no more second guessing your form. Tonel gives you real time coaching cues to dial in your form and help you lift safely and effectively. After a quick assessment, total sets the optimal weight for every move and adjust in one pound increments as you get stronger. so you're always challenged. Right now, Tonal is offering our listeners $200 off your tonal purchase with promo code V-I-A-L. That's tonal.com. Use promo code V-I-A-A-L for $200 off your purchase. That's

tonal.com promo code V-I-A-L for $200 off. How's it going? Good. My name is Jessica. I'm 32 years old and did I make the right decision in breaking up my engagement over a pre-knit? Okay. Interesting. Tell me about your engagement, your relationship. Okay. So two years ago, we met in the wild. We met on a like a single trip to Lake Powell, if you've ever heard of it. It's a big place where people go to hang out and boat on the weekend, be on the water. Sure. That kind of a thing.

And we met and it was very much like organic. It was like your dream meet you. We had like, yeah, a fun time anyways. And then pretty immediately after he like asked me out. We started dating right away. We basically became boyfriend and girlfriend after two weeks of meeting. Like, it was very much like matching each other's energy and everything was good from there. So I really, like, appreciated the way it started.

But then going into it, we ended up, you know, dating for two years later. We got engaged at, it was a year and a half. We got engaged after dating. Okay. And then it was basically, I knew the whole time, like, date one even that he wanted a pre-up. Why do you know that? He had told me in the date. Is he well off financially?

You know, he does do well. Like he's a dentist. I'll say that. So he does well. But it wasn't like, you know, and this is like finding out over two years of dating. Like it didn't seem like he necessarily had all these like hidden accounts. He had a lot of money or like he didn't own his own practice. So it wasn't like he had some equity in the company. Like he had bought in a house. So he had equity in a house. But as far as I knew there was nothing like beyond your regular like I own a home. And like I have my investment accounts, like nothing beyond those normal things. Does that make sense? Yeah. I just had a curiosity when you first started dating, how did it come up then he wanted a pre-up? Was it like, did date one, just so you know if we ever get married, I'm going to want a pre-up? Yeah, because the way that our like everything happened, it just moved really quick. We started having those serious conversations quick like it was off the bat, like, you know, what did you want your family to look like and how, you know, it was very much like it just everything clicked where we are almost already talking about those marriage conversations early on. Like he even like told me he's like

it felt different. Like you, dating you is different. Like it was very much like we thought it was the end game. Like kind of when everybody says you know, you know, that's kind of how it felt early on. And then pre-nup aside, how is your relationship? Well, that's where like it kind of like, you know, when you ask like, okay, did the pre-up backup who the guy actually was? I mean, I could say yes now. And ultimately, when it came down to like the reason I broke up the engagement, it was singular to the pre-nup because the way I was kind of looking at it was that everybody, you know. Let's just table that for a second. I just want to hear about the relationship.

Like you're, I don't know what your pet peeves and non-negotiables are, pre-nup aside. But I'm curious like how he made you feel on a day-to-day basis, you know, was he a partner in the truest sense where he was he someone you could go to for emotional support did you guys you know run ideas by each other did you feel like he you were someone in his life whose opinion he respected uh etc like what whatever the you know the day to day did you have fun together make each other laugh you know like where did you feel like you guys were a team i mean i did Like especially early on, like, you know, that first year, I think I was definitely like bought in. And I think that I, I really like loved him. I was, you know, obsessed with him. Like I put him on a pedestal of like this, um, everything that I wanted. And, um, I actually think that was probably part of the problem because I knew like the things that he wanted as far as like marriage goes. But when it got closer to actually like getting married and finding out like what. a marriage felt like or what a marriage meant to him. And again, that kind of revolves about

around the pre-up a little bit because that to me was like how he felt about marriage. What do you mean by that? Like just when the pre-nup actually came to light of what was in it, it was like it was almost like he didn't, you know, he wanted to make sure that he always had an out, which to me, that's kind of what. How so? What do you mean by that? Like the pre-nup essentially was like, you know, a regular pre-up is like, what I knew about it was what's yours is yours, mine is mine, right? That's how we kind of all think of a normal pre-up. Sure.

I guess that's the starting point, but yeah. Yeah. So with this, though, it was very much like, what yours is yours, mine is mine. But then also, like if I buy, let's say if I buy a practice in the marriage, that's also mine. Like, that's not ours. And like if I want to keep my investment account. So like my 401K or whatever else I have going on, those remain mine even after marriage.

and like he kind of wanted to like bar me from every like investment that he was making prior to or after marriage and to me like that's where when you ask if he is a good partner I was like well that's not like a partnership to me if I'm not involved in those things are like I mean essentially I would be involved in those things because like that's what a marriage is but even though I was involved I was probably never going to get the benefits of any of those things gotcha and there was no discussion about like what would be the two of yours I tried to have those conversations, but it just like, I don't know. It was all based on like, what ifs because to me it was like, okay, what if you buy a practice?

Like, what if that's successful or not? I mean, who's going to know if that's going to be even a successful business venture? Like, it could be unsuccessful. And then now I'm trapped with you in like an unsuccessful business venture essentially. Well, in that case, his pre-nub would benefit you because if he was an unsuccessful businessman, a lot of doctors are good doctors, terrible at business. And let's say he took on a lot of debt and woke up one day and realized, you know, then you would have benefited from the fact that he was like, this is mine and not yours. And it'd be great. That's all your debt, not mine. Yeah. Well,

and that's kind of like what leads into like the relationship ultimately ended because I just didn't see the partnership under the marriage. But that's where even for the future, I think pre-ups are something that are largely not talked about. And I'm like, I actually tend to maybe date more affluent men or like, that's been my history. And so I'm wondering going forward, like, I don't know what I should look for. Like, I just feel like this conversation is not had. Like, women keep this so private. And I'm like, how common is it to run into these things and like, you know, should I have signed the pre-up? Because ultimately it protected me from a bad businessman. You know what I mean? and so.

Yeah, potentially. Listen, I'm not a lawyer. Yeah. But I can tell you that, like, especially in 2025, marriage is a contract.

It is. And every person who gets married has a pre-nub. And that pre-nub, if they don't do a pre-nub, is decided by the state that you live in. Yeah. Or get divorced in. And so if you reside in,

you know, California and then get divorced, you will have to follow California's state law in terms of, what they decide in terms of, and I think like California is a no-fault state. I think Wisconsin's the same. And like California and Wisconsin, ironically, with two places that I'm associated with are it's a 50-50 state and no matter what, who cheats on who, what goes down, blah, blah, blah, like it's 50-50 assets. Like that's those laws. Every other state has different laws. But whether you realize it or not,

or anyone listening, you have a pre-num, right? It's a contract. And you have to follow those contracts Unless the two of you as a couple say, well, I'm not going to let the state decide our future if things don't work out the way we hope. We're going to decide. And maybe our first conversation, our first difficult conversation is a couple that intends to get married is to sit down and hash out what we think we're going to want if things don't work out the way we want. So this idea that some people have out there, I would. would never sign a pre-nub if I get married is delusional because you are literally signing a pre-nub the moment you sign a marriage license. And in fact, it's actually idiotic when you think about it that way to sign something that either of you had no say on. You just accepted whatever

the laws are in the state in which you reside if you get divorced. Again, I'm not a lawyer. I'm pretty sure I'm right about this. But yeah, you are accepting the law. laws of whatever state you're in if you don't have your own pre-up. Now, getting into the weeds of what he wanted versus what you wanted, like, yeah, you might sit down with them with the best intentions and say, you know, all right, let's take control of our future. This is like not a fun conversation. I don't want to sit there and start thinking about what we're going to do if we don't work out before we even started marriage. But like, listen, life is not a fairy tale. It's not a fantasy. You can't predict the future. And like, it's this, a married couple. It's not going to be the

last tough conversation people have. So you just got to figure it out, right? And if he's like, if he's just like, well, this is what I want and I don't really care what you want and this isn't a negotiation, this is my way or the highway, well, that, that's certainly like a data point that might make you second guess your decision to marrying that person because, again, it's a marriage as a partnership and therefore conversations about finances and a pre-nub should be a partnership. You should both have, you know, like you were required to have separate legal representation. Did you ever hire a lawyer? I did.

So I totally agree with you. And I actually, that's where I got to the point where I felt like after talking to a lawyer and everything where like it just wasn't coming down to what was fair. Because the other part about the partnership is he wanted me to actually be like his ideal of a family was like for me to be a stay at home mom. and like that's what he was like he kind of like maybe wanted a bigger family he was very traditional so that was kind of in my head i couldn't wrap my head around like how am i supposed to give you all this like financial security for yourself but then in me being a stay-at-home mom

yeah that's insane yeah so like how like that's like where i'm like how am i supposed to sign a pre-up and this is maybe a lot of women deal with it's like how am i supposed to sign a pre-up with somebody that like is potential like I have kids and now I have to be a stay at home mom like how do people ever work that out or like how does a stay at home mom ever go into signing a pre-nup essentially like is well I mean there's a pre-nub and then there's things like child support there's spousal support you know so you can still have a pre-nub also like contracts can be deemed inequitable or unfair so to speak when I'm hearing from you like you know if you're husband were able to negotiate with you and saying, all right, I want you to be a stay-at-home mom.

My money is my money. Your money that you're not going to be making is your money. And then if we get divorced, I don't owe you any spousal support. A good chance that if you guys got divorced, you could then sue your husband and get your pre-nub thrown out. Because a lot of judges out there would say, this is a bullshit contract. It's not inequitable. And I don't know who your lawyer was at the time, but I don't feel like you had good

representation. No, there's going, no guarantees. His lawyer might be, he's like, hey, she signed a deal, she signed a deal. Yeah. Well, and that was my worry. It was like, I kind of knew that, like, yeah, you can actually put anything down in a pre-up, but that doesn't mean it's going to hold up in law, right? Correct. I wouldn't let that be your plan. That's not a good plan to have, but like, that still might, that still might be what happens. But you're right. I mean, if he was expecting you not to work and have a career and be the mother of your kids, while you stay home and raise your children with him while he was able to make money for himself and then to decide how he gets to share that with his wife and his children and you have no say over it

and then at the risk of things not working out and he could leave you and you have given up quality years of your life and earning potential and things like that and leave you because that's kind of how it used to be right back in the day when traditionally it was only the man who worked and the wife would stay home and take care of the kids. If he left her high and dry, she'd be fucked. You know, it's 2025. It's different now. A lot of women are working. A lot of women are the breadwinners of the family and things like that. You know, I think a lot of marriage laws are outdated and archaic and like don't represent like the state of relationships in 2025. That aside, your husband being the traditional, more conservative man that sounds like he was,

he wanted a very traditional situation, which is, in a lot of ways, bullshit, and unfair to the women in their lives. So my general takeaway is, I think pre-nubs are a smart thing for a lot of couples. And like I said, you're signing a pre-nub anyways. So most of the time in most, I think in most marriages, people are meeting at a similar time in their life and they're earning, you know, like it's almost silly to sign like a pre-nub because it's like, I have some debt and I have some money you have some debt and you have some money and like what why are we wasting more money on hiring lawyers to say your bullshit is your bullshit and my bullshit is my bullshit it's like great and and most of things that you'll be fighting over is what you guys earn as a team as a couple and that will

be the both of yours but if he is not going to recognize the role that you're going to play as the mother of his children and the support that you're going to give him while you take care of his children and he is not going to be willing to share what he does, that's, yeah, that's bullshit. Yeah. Now, I mean, like, I think there's nuances

into, like, if he were to buy a business and, like, I'm sure he's a very pragmatic guy and I'm sure he's thinking, well, what if you screw me over? Everyone when they get into a marriage and sign a pre-nub is always thinking, well, what if you fuck me over, you know? Yeah. No one's thinking I'm going to fuck you over.

Most people are not like, all right, there's a good chance I'm not going to be faithful in five years. And if I turn into a piece of shit, I need to make sure that I don't also like lose my ass in this marriage. Very few people. I mean, if that's the case, that's not a very good person. But everyone is like, what if you fuck me over? And I definitely think that was like his approach.

Like I think he's known people growing up where it's like they did get. it screwed over in a divorce and it wasn't their fault and like here they are like their wives are taking half of everything they own when they're the ones that cheated on them and it just seems like a really messed up system and so that's where I was like very okay with the pre-up I just had a hard time understanding like how do you make it fair when like you know for the woman like there's always a chance of like I might have to leave my job because we're having kids or whatever it is like it's like especially if the man earns more than you or if he out earns you like there comes a time where it doesn't even make sense for me to work because it's like we're now paying

more for our kids time and energy to be taken care of that like my job even makes the money for and it's like I do well enough but that was my thing it's like you want me to give up my job where I can take care of myself to take care of children where now I'm also signing a pre-nup where I might get screwed over and it's like how does like I just don't know how you like get around that whole pre-up conversation when it's like the... Well, you don't get around it. You can't get around it. You have to get through it.

And so is that just my answer? Because we couldn't get through the conversation. But there is plenty of healthy ways to get through a pre-up where... Well, I guess my question, back to the pre-nub, did it really come down to him saying, it's my way or the highway? And you get absolutely nothing if we get divorced, even if you quit your job and raise our children 10 years from now. And 10 years from now, if I start a business three years from now and spend seven

years investing in our family and we have three kids and you don't work for seven years, you get absolutely nothing. And by nothing, I don't mean necessarily a percentage of the business, but how are you going to be taking care of? And how are you going to be compensated for the time that you invested in his career and your family? Well, and that's where it kind of got messy because there's no way to like equitably figure that out like dollar to dollar, right? You just kind of like. Yeah, but some things are in good faith. I think good lawyers can work that out. You guys have to be willing to be fair. You know, it's not about holding a hard line. You're right. Like, how do you negotiate a percentage of a business that doesn't exist? Yeah. And I think that's where it came down

to for me where, like, I was just like, I can't, there's no actually fair. Fair doesn't exactly exist. I don't think it's ever at the end of the day. I could be completely fair for either of us in a divorce. But like, it just felt like there was no winning for me because it was like, you know, we were trying to negotiate alimony at that point, which it's like, you can't really negotiate alimony. But at the same time, if I'm signing something on paper, he could just take longer to pay me anything because I signed my name on paper. So it was like, you know, he's like, well, I'll take care of you for this many years. Because the state that we live in, I don't think it's a 50-50. I think it's actually like more than 50-50 state. So they're a little bit more

towards like, you know, the amount of years you've been married, I think are the amount of years that you maybe can be taken care of over a certain threshold. Yeah. If that makes sense. And so for him, it felt like a bigger risk. So he was trying to negotiate it down from that like 100% to like maybe like 30% of that we're married that I get taken care of or whatever and trying to put this all

in a pre-up because his worry was that like he didn't want it to be in a situation where it's like now we are divorced. He's taking care of me. And I'm now being lazy and not going out to find another job because I'm just being taking care of and like living off the system. if you will. What if you have four kids and he's too busy to be the primary caretaker? And so you're divorced. You have even two kids. His position was he thought he could be the primary caretaker and that's what he was willing to take on if that was necessary. How does he know that?

I don't think he did. And that's where it was like it became a situation where there was like too many conditions. Like how do you solve for every single one of them? Yeah. Listen, I mean, Let me ask you this. Do you feel like you negotiated in good faith? Or do you feel like there was a part of you that was kind of more like, you know what, I just don't even want to have this conversation. I kind of think it's bullshit that we're even discussing a pre-nub. And were you finding ways to say no to certain things that he wanted because the principle of it? Or do you feel like it was more him saying, this is my way or the highway and you were trying to negotiate in good faith. But what he was asking for was just at the end of the day, your lawyer was advising you to be like, I wouldn't sign this.

Yeah, it was kind of the second. Like, I think there was a part of me, like, kind of both, but more on the second side of things where I was just like, I, I'm trying to do everything I can to like make this work. And like everything you're saying is like you want to make it work too. but then when we actually get into those conversations, it's almost like maybe at the end of the day, you're just too scared and that's why you have to have this contract. And ultimately, that's what the contract came down to. Because I think everybody, like, has this idea of a pre-up that it's like,

it's unromantic and that people are doing it that can't commit. And like, that's what it's saying. And it takes the romance out of everything. But in his case, and maybe I don't think that has to be the case, right? But in his case, it actually felt like he kind of like in his deepest core, he couldn't commit. And that's why the pre-nup, was there almost. And that's why he wouldn't negotiate with me. Well, I don't know if I

necessarily agree with that. Am I just, you know, you reading into something? I mean, I don't know. Do you even love them? I mean, I definitely did. What do you mean, did? I mean, a decision to not move forward based of a pre-nub. When did you guys break up? We broke up in June. Okay. Yeah. I mean, if I were completely in love of someone wanted to marry them and a pre-nub blew it up because we were too stubborn. It would be hard for me to, like, romantically move on that fast. I mean, if, if, if you don't think you love him anymore, then maybe that's your answer. I mean, who cares about the preem? Well, I mean, I don't think I've, like, moved on necessarily. Have you guys talked? We talked after the breakup. We talked for a little bit. And then, um,

we decided to, like, not talk for a time, which is an undefined time. But do you feel like, how did, I mean, he hasn't fought for you or you guys haven't fought for you? Or are you guys haven't fought for each other? No, there's been none of that. And what do you think he would do if you called him up and said, I really miss you? And I hate, like, the fact that, like, we said we wanted to spend the rest of our lives together, it just, it seems crazy that it's come to this. Yeah.

I mean, right now it seems like he wouldn't want that. I mean, only because I haven't heard from him. I guess I don't know because I haven't taken that action. But I just assume if I haven't heard from you that that's your decision. I don't know. Is he a stubborn person? Yeah. I mean, what do you think his version of the story is? Well, so that's where, like, when we, when I broke up with him, he came back and he was actually like, I feel like I did this wrong. Like, I feel like the pre-up ruined everything. And if we should, we could take it away. And then everything, like, he's like, I see that all the issues started happening with us when the pre-nep was like more involved and when we were talking about it. And he's like, if we take the pre-nip away. So he was kind of like going. after things like very like desperately like, well, let's just take the pre-nup away all together. What'd you say?

Well, that's when I was like, I don't, I think in my head, I was like, I don't really believe you. Like, I've thought this for two years. Thought what for two years? About the pre-nup. Like, I've known the pre-nup was going to be here for two years because then I start thinking like, I'm like, see, that's where I'm not following you, right? Again, when you get into the actual nitty-gritty of the pre-nub, I hear you that some of the

things that you're communicating seem unreasonable from his end. And you both should be able to negotiate in good faith. And if your lawyer is like, listen, do what you want, but I wouldn't sign this. This is not a fair deal. And you are really screwing yourself over if you sign this. You are, you are not protected with this pre-nub. So if you want to marry for love and nothing else, but this is crazy, then like, yeah, like, that would have been foolish for you. correct that being said like the idea of a pre-nub the pre-nub that you knew he was going to ask for on your second date when eventually he you got married that that idea of the pre-nub that annoyed you like that that part i don't get because again that is like whether you have that conversation

or not everyone signs a marriage contract a marriage license right and so knowing he he said that on the first date and knowing that it was going to be something whenever he proposed to you and before you got married that he was going to say, all right, well, there's no good time to bring this up. So like, let's just get through it. But like now it's time to have that pre-nub conversation because like, yeah, I love you and I'm planning on having the best life with you possible. But like, I can't decide five years from now whether you're going to wake up and choose me, you know, I want to buy a practice and build my own practice. And if, you know, if you do the unthinkable to me, I want to feel protected. You know, you know, like he had a right

to do that. And that shouldn't have been something that really bothered you, I, is in my opinion. You know, again, it's not fun. Like, you know, it's, it's not fun. You know, like the first thing you don't want to do is talk about what happens. But it is the reality. Like, I don't think people in 2025 should get married without realizing that you can choose to leave me. Yeah. And I, and that's where I think it came down to ultimately was like where he maybe saw our lives going because it wasn't about like being protected because like I want to protect myself too and like I'm equally invested into that.

But it was more about like, you know, when I thought about like if I have kids and like the minute kids enter into the conversation, you're just like, I don't know. and especially if, like, I'm the one that's going to have to be the stay-at-home mom in the situation, or if, like, my job is on the line because it makes more sense for our situation, then at that point, I didn't know how to reconcile it anymore. What is your lawyer advise? I mean, she, we kind of played with all these things where it's like he would pay me like an allowance, essentially, or like even pay me to be a stay-at-home mom in a way,

if he's not sharing any equity with me, right? Yeah, I mean, that's correct. You know, and listen, I can see a world where he's just like, you know, like, I can't predict the future of my business and I don't want a divorce to blow up my entire business, which can happen if the business isn't protected. And if he wants to protect his business, which I totally get, then yes. He, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, and, he should pay, you should be earning money. You know, you know, you're going to have separate account. counts. If he wants to keep it completely separate, then that's his choice, right? Then, yeah, that would be a reasonable solution. So my lawyer's fix to that was like, basically, he has to pay you a salary for being a mom, essentially. And then he also has to provide you child care. So two scenarios. If you're a mom, he pays you to be a mom. If you stay working, he has to promise you contractually,

like part of the pre-up, that you will have full-time child care so that you don't have to sacrifice your job. And you said no to that? And he said no. Well, he said no to the child care one. As far as like, well, that was the confusing part too because he was like, well, do I have to pay for that? And in my mind, I'm like, I don't know, maybe we could have shared like the percentage of

the child care based on our incomes. And that would have been the fix to that. But as far as like the salary goes, it was like, if he pays me, my salary, now so that I'm not losing equity, right? And maybe that increases over time because like as maybe I would get promotions over time or as his business grows over time, he could pay me more. That was the part that kind of broke because he was like, I don't know that I can even afford to pay you your salary. I mean, couldn't you guys negotiate to like renegotiate in a certain period of time? We maybe. I think I tried that at one point. But ultimately, again, like that was like too scary for

him because he was like, I don't know if I can afford to do that. Because his goal was like, he's like, I just don't, I want to make sure that when we get a divorce, I'm at the same. When or if? Right. He's like, I want to make sure that I'm just like at the same place that I was. Like, I don't want to have to like have to sell my house or like do all those things. I mean, listen, the reality is a divorce is a very painful and costly experience and there's no way to avoid that. Yeah. The best you can do with a pre-nub is. to try to mitigate some of the unfairness of a potential divorce. And the goal should be if you guys enter into a pre-nob,

like, what do they say about any negotiation? Any successful negotiation, both people feel like they had to give up more than they really wanted, right? So both the, no one should feel like they won. If one person's like, whew, great, then that was not a very good starting point to a marriage. So you, you know, and I doubt you guys did, but someone should have, I wish someone would have said to both you, for this to be successful, you're both going to have to feel like you guys conceded something. And there is zero way for you guys to 100% guarantee that if you get divorced, it's not going to affect you guys financially. And there's not going to be consequences and pain points to this divorce. like that's impossible and the only way to make it possible for one of you is for the other person to be completely fucked over yes and that would have been me in this case as far as I saw it um but he saw it a different way you know like I it is I'm getting the sense that you guys

never really sat down as a couple to try to like to recognize what I just said and to acknowledge that like we're going to both have to make some considerations and if the goal is for us as individuals to guarantee that if I get divorced, I have really no concerns, then that's not realistic. And you're both going to have to make some kind of concessions. It doesn't sound like you guys had that conversation as a couple. And I think we did in a shallow sense,

but not in the deeper sense of like. it needs to be in a direct sense it needs to like those words need to be spoken to each other and you got to like look in each other in the eye and recognize that while simultaneously reassuring each other it's like hey I know this is messy and I know this is not fun but I really love you and let's fossil like take a moment to talk about like all the things that we're going to do to protect this relationship like I want to wake up up and choose you every day. I want to be your partner. In this process of this negotiation, what you guys showed a glimpse of is how you guys would be in this divorce, which is both kind of

really stubborn and only thinking of yourselves. Yeah. And I think, like I said, I think I was just at the end of everything, I think I was just put, I felt like I was like pushed into a corner where like I had tried to come up with the ways that we could make it fair as we could. And like every idea that I came up with was just not compatible with his ideas. And eventually I just kind of like was like, okay, like I am out of ideas. And like we can't seem to compromise on this. And like maybe that's just the answer over this particular pre-up and marriage that like, we're just not compromising sadly like because i mean you broke up with him so sadly you he's probably

feeling validated that he drew the line that he did yeah maybe but i at the same time i'm feeling validated that i also drew the line probably yeah because again like what you guys gave a glimpses as to how you guys would be in a divorce which is like uncompromising yeah and only worrying about yourselves and I guess my ultimate question going forward to is like I feel like I'm not this isn't my last time I'm going to maybe run into a pre-up but is it just like I just am like where do I don't feel like I hear enough about how it actually like works out for people and how they functionally have those conversations like it just seems like nobody talks about this kind of thing yeah no it's it's tough and I don't have all the answers I think you guys didn't talk enough about what concessions

you were both willing to make. Yeah. I honestly wish more people would come on your podcast and tell everybody how they made it work because that would be helpful for all of us. Well, I can tell you, like they make it work because instead of worrying about what I want this and I need this, I need to make sure I'm protected about this,

you guys didn't talk about what you were willing to give up. And he made the mistake of trying to guarantee himself that, you know, is like, well, I can't afford, how does he know what he can and can't afford? you know um how do you know what you're gonna want or need you know and like you guys went too far it sounds like in trying to guarantee yourselves um absolute security when that was never going to happen yeah you know your goal should have been protecting each other from allowing future both of you from fucking the other person over

Yeah. And that should have been the baseline. And the baseline wasn't you guys not fucking each other over. The baseline for both of you was guaranteeing yourself that you were going to be in the best possible situation even if you got divorced. And that was definitely what it turned into. I mean, I even, I will say, like, to give myself some credit, because, like, I own a home and I even had, like, in his buying a practice. type of conversations. I was like, well, I would love to be able to sell my home and put that money towards like helping you grow your business. But I would never do that because you don't want me to be a part of it. So like I would never sacrifice something like that for you because you don't want me to be a part of it. And what was his response to that? To him, it was just like, well, yeah, like clearly we can't do that because then. Yeah, basically like I'm not asking for that. I mean, listen, for a guy, listen, I get.

his point of view on the business standpoint, right? Because like he doesn't know, the business doesn't even exist yet. And even if it did, like, it's one thing to talk about money and how much I might owe you and I would owe you a percentage of how much I'm, you know, because you're right, it's hard to come with a dollar amount because like $10,000 a month could be nothing to him by the time you get divorced and it could be everything to him. You know, so it probably should have been a percentage based off of like, you know, again, I'm not a lawyer, so there's a lot of things I might not be considering, but he was trying to protect his business from basically going belly up because his life left him for another man. Yeah. You know? No, and true. I think that's ultimately it just came down

to, like, I just don't think we could compromise, which honestly validates me because there's always the question of like, oh, well, if you could go back and do it over, or if you could have fixed it or whatever and I feel like I'm like I don't know that we could have like I don't think our relationship like if he would come back into the picture let's say or I would reach out to him like I don't it didn't seem like it was ever going to go down the path of making it work just like summing this all up and talking through it I'm just well it's not maybe that's your answer I mean but but I guess I want to say it's like I didn't I didn't ever have the belief that preempts wouldn't work I went into this knowing that they

they were a thing that people did and they were okay and they there's some statistics statistics that they actually like saved marriages yeah but I'm also just like my own experience was like man how do people make this work because it seems like the conversation is always just about like who's going to be okay and it's the other you know at that point when you're having that conversation it's like well whoever's on you know like I want to be okay and then they're on the other side of the table being like well I want to be okay well that's again the problem I think you guys both made you should have been thinking about him and he should have been thinking about you yeah and assuming you don't get back together with

this guy and you meet someone else and hopefully you're in a position to want a pre-nob or he presents a pre-nob I hope that next time you're I want to protect myself from getting fucked over but I also want to make sure that I'm being fair to you with the understanding that if we get divorced, it's going to fucking suck for both of us, both emotionally and financially. And there is no way to avoid that, even with a pre-nob. And so I want to make sure that if I were you in this situation, I would, you know, you should have both wanted to sign the pre-nub if you were the other person. And that was, it doesn't sound like in either of your thought processes. Yeah. I mean, I think there's some nuance to that.

I'm sure there is. Yeah. But I mean, ultimately, we'll just say that, I mean, yeah, we're just two people that couldn't compromise. Because it sounds like from what you're telling me that it's like it should be a healthy conversation. And a lot of couples make it that way. And it's available to couples to make it that way. But we were just. Well, it comes down to who the individuals are.

that relationship. Yeah, of course it's possible and it's not fun ever and there's always a little bit of ickiness to it, but it needs to be in good faith. You both should try to want to get through it and you both should be willing to concede things that. Yeah. You know, it's like, okay, I guess we get divorce. I guess I'll have to do that, but. And ultimately, I mean, I guess I had the feeling that he wasn't doing it in good faith because it just seemed very selfish to me. And I like without even knowing how he thought my side was or how he thought I was coming across. The fact that you don't know that answer I think is telling that I don't know the answer about how he was thinking about me. Yeah. I mean, you guys. Yeah. And I and I don't like I don't when I was fighting back with him. I don't know if he was

like thinking of me of like just trying to do what I could or protect myself or if he was thinking of like me being like also a selfish person and like wanting to screw him over i don't i actually don't know who he saw me as in those conversations i think that's something you should consider yeah because that was your responsibility to ask and and it was his responsibility if he can't answer that question for you then that's something he was responsible for yeah so um but ultimately i don't know that we'll ever return to that conversation necessarily but um Well, you broke up with him. So my guess is, and again, like, he could always fight for you and you could always fight for him.

And maybe, again, like I said before, maybe that's your answer. Because, like, hey, if you're, I mean, you know, if it's after two months, you're saying I was in love with them. I don't know. If you're not in love of them anymore, then maybe there's something deeper going on. And if you're not sure, then maybe that's your answer. If you're just being stubborn and you're sitting on your couch waiting for him to, like, fight for you, while he's sitting there waiting for the same thing, then, you know, like, in some ways, makes me sad for both of you.

That would be sad if that was the case. And, you know, like, listen, like, there's a lot of stubborn people out there. And someone's got to make the first move. And if I were you, I wouldn't, and again, how you, you got to figure out how you feel about them. But if you, if there's a party that still loves them and still thinks that, like, boy he's a great man and like I loved our relationship prena beside I loved our relationship and I loved him you guys have a lot of things unsaid and unresolved and unfigured out and that makes

me sad for the both of you and it's interesting you say that because like I don't know maybe in my head it wasn't as much of a mystery like to me I'm like well the fact that he needed to protect himself so hard was like this answer that he like couldn't commit truly um well the more in these negotiations the problem is the more you guys dig your heels into your point of view the more you get afraid that the person is going to you know fulfill your worst enemy like you both dug and you both did that to each other you both played into your each other's fears by digging your heels in and not saying oh time out hold on i don't you know like i just what is our goal here yeah and you guys didn't have that conversation it makes me sad yeah and maybe it is that sad

I don't know. And these are maybe questions I don't have, but I think I ultimately made my choice. And, you know, I'm, I'm moving forward with it. But I did. Yeah, I guess I thought the conversation was like, I don't know. I think they, we did leave some stuff unresolved, I guess is what I'm saying. But ultimately, I'm like, I just, that's where I'm like these pre-up conversations. I just, I don't. I was just maybe looking for it. advice on how I should handle them in the future, too. Yeah, I mean, my short, my short answer is put yourself in their shoes and both be willing to do that and not try to win the negotiation. Yeah. And I think my perception of, it was like, you know, because he had that, that condition, our entire relationship, I always felt like I was fighting against it. and like without going into like all of the other nuances about a relationship because obviously

that ultimately like says who the person is you're marrying right not necessarily the pre-nup but well that part i guess i'm not really following or agree with you this like the fact that he always knew he wanted it i don't that just means he's probably a maybe a slightly more pragmatic person than you are and always had a dream of having his own practice and knowing that he wanted to get married someday. Maybe he got advice from an uncle or a mentor who told him, like, you're going to want this and here's why and blah, blah, blah. And maybe as a young man, he didn't articulate it the best possible way. But the fact that he always wanted one, you've brought that up several times. And it sounds like for whatever reason, you've always seen that as a strike against him. And that I don't get.

I don't think so. I think for me, it was just like, I was fine with it the whole time. time. I think to me, I felt like the trial pre-up for him. Like, I'm like the first one he tried it with. And it's like, you know, maybe it was like a fail with me. Like he did it the wrong way. And like, it's honestly a learning experience for him going forward into the next one and like figuring it out to do it better because like I wasn't against the pre-up. I just wasn't like I didn't actually know the conditions until like we were engaged. And so, um, I, you know, it's a negotiate. It's The shitty part is it's a negotiation and you, it's a weird feeling to feel like you're negotiating in the manner, you know. So I like I guess what I'm saying is like I didn't get into the

details of like everything that was involved in our relationship, but I just was more like very interested in like how do people have these conversations and like how did we have it? Yeah, listen, these are tough situations. My humble opinion is that every couple should, I think to your point, there probably are studies, I see why there are, I'm not shocked to hear you mentioned that there are studies out there that suggest that couples who successfully navigate a pre-nob, maybe have a slightly higher marriage rate. One, because again, every marriage essentially is a pre-nub. And two, more than anything, it's a, it's their first test on being able to work through

and compromise on sensitive and difficult topics. And forgetting about how anyone other couple navigates this, right? All you can do is ask yourself, what could I have done differently or better? And how could have I empathized with his point of view more? Now, maybe you did everything you could, and it was all his fault, and he was just like a rigid prick. And you realize that this is a guy who didn't really want a wife or a partner. he just wanted someone to raise his kids so he can make his money. If that's how you felt, then maybe you're much better off.

But these are very difficult and very hard conversations to have with someone that can reveal the stubbornness of both people. And if you are not putting yourself in their shoes and asking yourself and being able to relate to their concerns and being willing to like, you know, then that's, that's a data point and something to learn from. Yeah. And I mean, again, I think if I really explain the whole story in detail, I feel like I really tried to like understand it from his angle. Like me even like saying like, hey, I'm willing to put equity into your business to help you out. Or like, I really did want to be his partner.

I just don't think that he maybe it was capable. of being mine or maybe that was just like too much of a fear for him and and i totally get i totally get all that and i i get all of the fears around this and i and i that's why i think prenups are great i think my struggle with this particular situation was just like maybe there wasn't a fair for our situation um maybe we were just too incompatible to find a fair for i don't know and maybe it was just like ultimately it was the good thing that broke up the relationship because that was was just it wasn't good. And so because we couldn't get through that conversation, it meant that we weren't going to get through the marriage. It's possible. Yeah. Only you two know.

Yeah. And I think that's how I took it at the end of the day. And that's why I broke up with him was because that's what I, that was the decision I had kind of come up to. And of course, you go back and forth from that. And you're like, did I make the right choice? But, and that's why, you know, with the pre-in question, I'm like, did I make the right choice to blow up my engagement? over a pre-up, but for me, I'm like the fact that we couldn't come to a compromise after, you know, as two years of knowing about a pre-up and then six months of talking about the details of that and then not making it work, to me, that just was the answer. I am curious, other than offering, putting up your house for a piece of his business,

what other compromises do you feel like you made in this negotiation? I mean, I think I offer, you know, because I was like, well, to me, I was like, okay, you want you maybe have the ideal to have like a stay at home mom. And to me, I'm like, well, you know, you want me to have maybe more kids than like, basically what I was saying is like, well, I could keep working. And then I could be like the career girl. You could be the career guy. And then I don't have to worry about relying on you. You don't have to worry about me relying on you. But then to me, that just means we can't have as big of a family as you might like to try for because the chances of that may be happening. What if you want in terms of family

size? I mean, for me, I think I was very much like I want what works for us. Like, you know, if you're so, if you're so insecure about like your life and like being me, being dependent on you, to me, it's like, well, in my mind, the more kids I have, the more likely I'm going to have to be a stay at home mom. And then I will rely on you. Does that make sense? Yeah. Yeah. So my fix to that was like, why don't we both work and then you don't have to worry about my dependency as much. So you guys were already negotiating whether you would work or not work 10 years from now or five years from now? Yeah.

Yeah. It sounds like you guys gotten too much into the weeds, in my opinion. Well, and that's where it's like hard because it's like a pre-nup, that's where it's like it's either so conditional and you have all these details or it's really kind of like what's yours is yours, mine, and then you go forward. I don't know. And that's where it got really complicated because it's. It's like the more conditional you make it, the more complicated it gets in like the detailing

of like, okay, well, how much time and how much money and blah, blah, blah. To me, it's like my very humble opinion, I would, I think prenubs can be really smart things for both people to do. But yes, when you start trying to predict the future and address every possible outcome and possibility, that's impossible. and therefore it's ever going to, it's going to be impossible for both people to land on a solution because you're arguing about things you know nothing about. And so your goal is to make the other person feel generally safe and reduce the risk of the other

person being fucked over or screwed over. Your goal should have been, if we get divorce and he has a practice, I don't want that business to have to crumble. That honestly should have been really your only concern. Yeah. His concern should have been if we get divorced, I don't want her to, especially if she, you know, I don't know if she's going to work. I don't know if she's not going to work. I don't want her to be like left high and dry, especially if she's the mother of my children

who is incapable because, you know, maybe 10 years later she's given up on her career and her dream and she's, you know, it's 10 years of career building and, you know, it's 10 years of career building and yada yada yada and she's going to be you know starting from scratch and that's going to be very difficult for her and if that is the case i want to make sure she is taken care of and that she can have a a good quality of life yeah and that should have been both of your goals and neither of you seem to have the goal of making sure the other person was okay you both had the goal of making sure that you were okay and i it sounds like to me that's the mistake you both made well except for the thing with like if he had the practice and he was making the money then

it sounds like he was on the side of like more likely he would have been okay where if i was on the side of like well i haven't been working it's been 10 years and i don't have anything to fall back well okay if yeah okay in the sense that you know if you were getting nothing you know but again like you should have been fairly compensated you know yeah well and that's i think the part that we broke The part we couldn't figure out was how to equitize my side of things, which is like, how do you amount that into some sum of like you've been out of the workforce for 10 years? What's your potential of getting back into the workforce? Those things was what that was the problem we couldn't solve like, sure, sure, his side.

He owns a practice maybe or he doesn't own a practice. He's just working regularly, regular salary. He has that side figured out of what he's going to do. For me, it was like what, how can we, we sum up all everything that I. missing and put that into like how are we going to make that fair so that was the part that broke i think in my mind because again if he's keeping everything great but like how do we sum up everything that i'm missing in that sense and neither of you were going to should have been keeping everything so to speak right yeah and i think that's where you guys were negotiating

hypotheticals right and that's where i'm glad you because that's where i came down to too i was like there's just like no way to figure out a future that like doesn't exist and I just feel felt like I was with a person that like couldn't get out of the way of like trying to figure out all those details for something that like it honestly would have been easier if it was somebody that like had already like built up that business and like that was definitely would have been easier yeah it would have been easier but I think because it was like all hypotheticals of what our future might look like that's what was just like impossible for me to know how to help make that fair even, especially if he's sitting on this seat of like, no, my future

will look like this, but who knows? And then I'm trying to like match that future. Anyways, so that's where I think in the future, maybe it would just be easier with somebody who already, they have a pre-up because it already is like, they're trying to protect that thing. Sure, but yeah, you don't know who you're going to fall in love with. So. No. But I guess I don't know. I feel like you've maybe just validated. me in my decision that we were two people that weren't going to figure it out. I don't know. Yeah, I mean, yeah, it's the fact that you're not, you don't seem all that heartbroken anymore is my big takeaway. I think maybe I'm being more pragmatic about it now.

Like I was, I was pretty heartbroken about it. I just think to me, it's like, I don't know that I have a choice, but to move, not like he's come back into the picture anyways, right? But like, To me, I'm like, I don't have a choice to be in that situation. Like, I just felt like it was like, you were either going to be like miserable being married because you had this pre-up looming over your head that you didn't know if you were ever going to be okay or, you know, you go back out there. That's the thing. Again, no pre-nub is successful.

If one person feels like after they sign it, they have less clarity than more clarity. And that should have bothered both of you. And that's how I would have felt if I signed it. So to me, I'm just, like, sitting in a place now where it's like, I honestly have more answers now than I did signing a pre-nup marrying him in a way. I guess I'm just wondering, like, why after you got, you broke up with him and he was like, I fucked up and blah, blah, blah. And to me, that sounds like a guy who had the best intentions, but just maybe handled it poorly because he's never done this before and didn't know how to do it. And, and. Yeah.

My read is you both made a lot of mistakes. in this negotiation um and i yeah i agree but i at the same time like i very much still feel like he is not in a place for negotiating further like so either like maybe he feels i'm that way but the way i see it now out of like i don't know i don't get the sense that he's open to more negotiation so that's why i'm i mean that's why we're not negotiating is like i don't think that he's and whether i am or not i don't i don't get the impression that he is well i I guess it's more to like, do we, I don't know, it's like, do we love each other? I mean, I don't like. Yeah. You know, I have a lot of, I have a lot of love for him for sure. But I think the whole

end of everything and how it happened opened my eyes to, and I can't say I don't love him. Like, I definitely love him and I have love for him for sure. I just, you know, I all at the same time, I just don't think we were going to come to, I just didn't see a way to compromise. Okay. Well, I'm sorry. It has. happened it sucks yeah but i did like i did want to like yeah and it and that was the confusing thing it was like it was in about the pre-nep i was really just kind of shocked when we got into the conversations i was like is this the way it goes every time because like i thought that it would have i thought it was going to be better than it was like i thought i was being this like progressive millennial

about the whole thing and then it just like blew up in my face and i was like oh like is this how it is every time. But I really don't want it to be that way. Yeah. I mean, I hear you. It's hard, again, I wasn't there. You know, I wasn't part of the negotiation. So from what I'm hearing, I think, again, you both made mistakes. So if assuming you don't get back to go out this guy, I would focus on trying to figure out the mistakes you made. I'm hearing a little bit of resistance from you from being willing to do that. And, and I get it because right now it's still pretty raw and you know that you made a very difficult decision and you don't want to second guess your decision if I'm you I'm this the type of person who this would be a moment to take

my ego out of it take my pro out of it ask myself did I do everything I could because these relationships are hard to find and if I'm willing to walk away I wouldn't want to be left with any regrets if you as long as you have no regrets then move forward and and and just accept that like maybe this was a blessing in disguise, but what could I have done differently to make him feel, to, you guys triggered each other. You guys played into your fears.

You guys started like becoming the person. You started seeing what the other person would look like in divorce proceedings. And that's never fun. There wasn't like, it doesn't sound like there was a constant reminder of how you guys wanted to be as a couple, as a marriage, how you guys wanted to be as a team, how you guys wanted to support each other.

If I'm you next time you have these conversations, you need to have as many of those conversations while having those. Because like the whole idea of a pre-nub and those negation is to focus on disconnect. And you guys weren't doing enough connecting during these very difficult conversations. Yeah. And again, not being able to go back and rehab those, at least the way that they did, you know, and I wish I knew if we were just like, I wish I knew the answer if we were just two incompatible people or if we didn't do it the right way, you know, and I, I feel confident saying you guys didn't do it the right way. It still means that you might not be compatible, but only hearing your side, I'm pretty sure you guys could have done it a lot better than you did.

Yeah. And that makes me sad for both of you. I actually would hope that that's the case too, because I hope that like the whole relationship was real and that it meant something and that it was like- Who gives a shit what your relationship meant if you don't end up together? Who cares? I mean, like, listen, if you're, if you guys don't end up together, all you can do is learn from the experience and hope that like there's no meaning behind it. Like I don't like, no offense to all my exes. It didn't mean anything other than what I learned from it. Like our love or how strong it was or wasn't is, it doesn't mean anything.

It's stupid, you know, I learned a lot from those experiences. I am grateful for those lessons in the roles those women played in my lives. And they're great people, and I'm glad that they're happy, but I don't know anything about their lives. They're literally meaningless to me other than the lessons I've learned. So it doesn't matter what it meant. You know, all that matters is if you learned something. Well, and I think I learned a lot, for sure.

Okay. I'd be willing to learn more. I am always only to learn more but yeah I just well I think I don't know I don't know if I got exactly the answer I came in it all got what was what were you hoping to get out of this um I don't know it kind of suck because when I I you know it's a bit a little bit past as far as when the situation was happening like we've got past like we're actually broken up now but uh so I you know it's a little different than when the situation or when the question was posed. What's the harm in reaching out to him? I got the

impression he didn't want that. I'm like I'm not by any means like waiting for him to reach out. Like that's not really like the point. I guess it's like my point was just maybe figuring it out like how could we have done this better. It's not like waiting for him to come around and like do it better. Like what's the harm and just like meeting up with them and just seeing how you guys feel about each other? There's probably no harm. Maybe it's worth a shot. I don't know. Maybe. But yeah, I don't know. I guess that the forward is a mystery. I would leave you with this.

I've said this a million times. I would ask yourself, do I want to be right or do I want to be happy? And again, I think you want to feel good about your decision. It was a difficult decision. I get it. But like I feel like your energy is more in the wanting to be right rather than wanting to be happy right now. And I would right now focus on your happiness and being willing to acknowledge that maybe

you were wrong about a couple of things. There's no harm in it. There's no harm. There's no harm in being wrong. Yeah. All right. Well, sorry you're going through this. It definitely sucks.

I appreciate the call. Give him a call. I don't know. I'd rather you just be a feel, I want you to feel good about this decision. Truly feel good. I don't want you to convince yourself that you made the right call.

And I feel like you're doing a lot of that right now. Well, that's, I don't know. I don't know that that's how I meant to come across. but if that's, it's an interesting takeaway that I did come across that way, but I don't know. That's how I meant it. I think I was just. It really doesn't matter what I think. You know what I'm saying?

So I just, I want, I want you to be happy. I want you to be happy. I think I wanted to come to this discussion of like, you know, pre-ups were a very like new thing to me. And I'm like more of just like, how do people get through these things? Because I don't think it's the last time I'm going to face it, which is fine. And I want to face it again. Yeah. I just want to face it again with the right person.

compromise understanding empathy putting yourself in their shoes and going into those negotiations with upfront expectations and saying hey we're going about to do this you know i heard a story and i'll leave you with this and we got to go but like i'm a big football fan right there's a very intimate relationship often between coach and quarterback argue the two most important people on a football team and the San Francisco 49ers quarterback is a man named Brock Purdy, who's very good, but like, you know, a lot of discourse about how good he can be or is or blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And he's had a lot of success recently in his rookie contract, and he was entering in his negotiations for his next big contract, right?

Lots of money on the line when it comes to quarterbacks. Teams like huge commitments, you know, hundreds of millions of dollars are on the line. and the San Francisco 49ers coach brought in the quarterback and said before these negotiations start between our front office and your agents and your team

I want you to know that you're my guy I believe in you and we're going to do great things together because when negotiations start your team is going to say a bunch of shit about the 49ers and our front office is going to nitpick

about what you're not good at and why you don't deserve the money your team is asking for and it might get messy and I want you to hear it from me that like we're in this together and I love you and blah blah blah blah blah blah and that was something that I think was really cool to hear and really smart and I don't know how often that happens and if you're asking for like what's one bit of advice to next time this happens is I don't think you two had that conversation I don't think you two sat down and looked each other in the eye and said, okay, we're about to start this very thing. But like, I love you and I want to be with you and I want a family with you

and I want to build something special together and I want to be a team. And you guys both said that to each other. And like, we're going to about to have some difficult conversations and we're going to do it the right way by getting lawyers who are going to represent us as individuals and have our individual best interests in mind. But like, I want us to hear it from each other that we're a team. And you guys didn't do that. and you should have. Yeah. Those conversations definitely weren't had under that light. Whether or not

we tried, they did not go that way. And that's, I think, something you both need to own. It's not any other person's fault. Well, here I'm owning it. I don't know if he is, but I am. Well, you know, maybe he, how does he know that? Yeah, I don't know. And that's why I'm just wondering if maybe a call. The worst thing you can happen is you could say, I don't want to hear a few, fuck you. you know, you could, and then that would just validate your decision, but... Well, if I ever do a call, I'll follow up and let you know. I appreciate it. All right. We'll take care. Okay. Thank you. All right. Bye-bye. Bye.

But one thing I know you're probably forgetting to do, it is to clean out your underwear drawer. I know they are probably crusty, dusty, musty all up in there and you need to replenish them with skims. Because before skims, underwear was always an afterthought for me. I would focus more on what I was wearing on the outside and think that a new dress or a new jacket would make me feel my best. But skims has made me realize that the bra and panting I put on in the morning is actually what defines whether I'll be feeling amazing in my clothes. If you want to feel like a new woman, it's time to get some skim's underwear. And it also makes me feel confident. It makes me feel sexy.

I don't feel like I need to have like this lace and this and that and this extravagant, like, Intimance line. I just need the fits everybody dipped front thong from Skims. And I feel my absolute sexiest. They also have an amazing Fits Everybody T-shirt brawl that feels like you're wearing nothing, but gives you the support that you would want. It's truly become one of my everyday essentials. And if you want to replenish your everyday essentials, shop my favorite bras and underwear at skims.

com after you place your order. Be sure to let them know. We sent you select podcasts in the survey and be sure to select our show in the drop-dom. that follows. Well, dog parents out there, you know how much we love our dogs, Jeff and Steve, and if you love your dogs as much as we love ours, you know you want to feed them good, healthy food because that improves their quality of life. And that's why we trust Sundays for dogs. Sundays for Dogs is fresh dog food made from a short list of human grade ingredients. It was co-founded by Dr. Tori Waxman, a practicing veterinarian who tests and formulates every version of each

recipe. Sundays contains 100% natural meat and superfoods in zero synthetic nutrients and artificial ingredients. Dog parents report noticeable health improvements in their pups, including soft fur, fresher breath, better poops, and even more energy after switching to Sunday dogs. Also, it ships right to your door. It's incredibly convenient. It does not require refrigeration or preparation because of their air drying process. So that makes it incredibly convenient to receive store. It's not heavy. It doesn't require a freezer or refrigeration. We love that. Cancel or pause your subscription at any time with their 100% satisfaction guarantee. Every order ships right to your door.

So you don't have to worry about running to the grocery store, and you can always make sure you have the dog food that's great for your pets on hand. So if you haven't switched to Sundays yet, what are you waiting for? Your dogs will be thrilled and happy and feel better for it. Get 40% off your first order of Sundays. Go to Sundays for Dogs.com slash V-I-A-L-L or use code V-I-A-L at checkout. How's it going? Hi, Nick.

My name is Kelly. I'm 32, and my polyamorous friend is having. a baby and I'm wondering if I need to talk to her about her husband. Why would you need to talk to her about her husband? So in the past, I have like sort of removed myself from the polyamory aspect. Like it's not my lifestyle and so I don't pretend to understand it or we've had lots of conversations about it. She's really open about talking about it. But he has just crossed a ton of boundaries that they've set in the past many years. Like literally since they've been together, he's kind of always been crossing boundaries with her um what boundaries are you referring to like

how he is with other women and his faithfulness or flirting etc etc yeah so like when they were not polyamorous he cheated on her and she found out like not because he was forthcoming um and then when they decided to be polyamorous they have these boundaries that are like if you're uncomfortable with someone that I'm talking to or do they have an open relationship or they're polyamorous? They're polyamorous. And what's the definition of polyamorous? Do you know?

Yeah. So like they are married, so they're each other's like primary partner, but they're both allowed to like date, have long-term relationships, like emotional connection, sex, everything with other people as well. And they all-

How was that different than an open relationship? I thought polyamorous was like a, like a throppel or three people or I guess I don't know if I can explain Open versus Polly to me Polly is like so there's something that they want to do that's called kitchen table Polly

where they can like all have dinner with themselves and their partners at a dinner table and they're all sort of like a family. Let me Google it. Okay. I'm honestly curious. It doesn't sound like either of us really know. Polyamers describes

the practice of having or desiring to have multiple romantic or loving relationships simultaneously with the informed consent of all partners. Sounds like an open relationship. Okay. Anyways, so she's pregnant with his kid. Yeah. Are we sure about that? I mean, I don't think there's like a paternity test, but...

Is it impossible that it's not? It's not impossible. I guess I sort of am like under the assumption that she took some precautions. while they were trying, um, but I haven't like directly asked. Why do you know stuff about him that she wouldn't? What do you mean? Well, you're asking, I'm wondering if I should talk to her about her husband and his actions. And so that's implying that like you know something or saw something that she's not aware of. Oh, no, no, no. So not exactly. So more I'm like generally I stay out of their relationship. I've heard these things through the great vine that she has that she knows. So like she knows. She knows. She knows.

he cheated. She knows that he has crossed boundaries and their relationship. They're always quote unquote working on something. Like she'll explicitly ask him like, hey, this person that you're talking to gives me anxiety makes me uncomfortable. I don't want you to pursue them. And he'll be like, yeah, yeah, totally. And then turn around and like sleep with them. And then she finds out about it because she like sees his texts. And so like to me, that's like betrayal of trust. Like whether or not. So even though they have a paliomer, he's not up front. It sounds like it's an ex-he cheated on her, and I don't know how they addressed that, but somehow he was able to, does she want to be in, does she sleep with other men? Does she take advantage of their relationship?

She does. So, like, she had a long-term boyfriend for a little bit while they, like a two-year relationship with a guy that ended amicably last year and then she'll date people. I mean, my impression is kind of that if her husband was like, hey, actually, like, let's close the relationship. for a little bit, let's be monogamous, that she would be like, okay, like, I don't think she's the driver of it. And so while she is now pregnant, he is out there just. Yeah, so he has a girlfriend. He has a long term girlfriend that he's had for like three years. And my friend knows this girlfriend. They get along. She has asked, my friend has asked her husband, like, hey, can you not see her as much? I'm feeling like I need a lot of support right now. Like she did not feel well in her

first trimester, et cetera. And he was like, yeah, yeah, totally. And then lies to her being like, oh, I forgot. I made plans with her tonight. I don't want to bail on her last minute. So I'm going to go basically lying that he has peeled back anytime with her. And I guess it's just like he's really manipulative. Like he's really able to make my friend feel like her feelings are not valid, that she needs to work on something in order to like be okay with the situation. So what are you debating to do? I just think that it's crazy. Like I have a daughter postpartum was really hard for me. Being pregnant was really hard for me. I have a crazy supportive partner and it was still so hard. So I'm like very alarmed that he's acting like this when she's carrying his

baby for all we know but like you know assuming that she's carrying his baby like if you can't be honest and supportive and curb your behavior for the betterment of the mother of your child like i feel like it's like loki a loss cause yeah but she's not asking right i'm assuming she's not and part of the issue is that some of this i've heard from other friends so like she tells me kind of sometimes in these big terms like you know things were kind of rough like a few weeks ago but we're really working on it now and like I'm feeling better. But it just like keeps happening and I just feel like he's proven to her time and time again like that he can't keep a boundary, like he can't honor a boundary that she's set.

Yeah. I mean, you're in a tough spot. I recognize and totally get why you want to be a protective friend in there for your friend. But it's only so much you can do. I think the most you can do is validate her feelings when she asks. You can check in. And that's a very fine line between checking in and being. nosy. When she does ask you questions, I think it's definitely okay to like validate her, you know,

like if he has the ability to manipulate her or make her second guess herself or gaslight her in any way, certainly as a friend when she asks, you can reaffirm any doubt in terms of like what she is entitled to ask for and be by her side. But I think it's a little risky. and honestly really not your place to like call her up, sit her down, and say, I think your husband's up to know. Like you could be just causing more stress for her in a time where you don't want to be causing any stress while she has this baby. Yeah.

And especially while she's pregnant, I don't think this is the time to make her question whether she should reconsider being married to this guy or things like that. Again, if she comes to you and says, I need your help. and I want to ask your advice by all means I'd be very careful about the whole like well I heard from other people type of thing it's never received well

and it just makes that person feel like people are talking behind their back right yeah I would ask questions like are you getting the emotional support you need from him yeah you know this is a really important time you should make sure that you're getting that from him and you have every right to like ask for more, you know, and things like that. It sounds like your friend again, like got convinced to

being, you know, but she had a boyfriend. I don't know. Maybe it's working for her. Yeah. I don't know how people in open relationships who have children together make that work. I mean, seems a lot easier for people who don't want to have kids. I can wrap my head around people having open relationships, the polyamorous, where it's like this aunt, I have a boyfriend. Yeah. And a wife seems, I don't know, seems like way too much work for me. Yeah, I agree. Teach their own. They're also like kind of almost like over-therapized in a way.

Like they're always an individual therapy. They're always in couples therapy. And like, and it's almost like to the point that. And I'm like a therapy person. Like I've been in therapy for years. Me and my husband are in couples therapy. Like, but it's like he's now utilizing these like therapy phrases to like, like he calls lying psychological splitting which like I mean yeah I don't know but again like

you're you know that's you're you're crossing a line of involving yourself yeah and their relationship and you might be right but like it's it's you know also it could be a friend who's just chosen a very different path for the type of relationship she's willing to have versus you I'm guessing you have no interest or don't even get someone who's in a polyamorous relationship. So there's maybe some level of disconnect that you have. Yeah. In the past, I think I've been very like, I don't really get it. So I'm not going to pass any judgment.

Like, you know, I can't even really understand this like extremely gray area blurred line situation. Like whatever. But it's like, I think that like the pregnancy thing has really pushed me to be. like super protective because I feel very protective of like new moms I get that but people instead of nitpicking and poking holes in her relationship and and potentially causing her to question her husband just be there as a friend check in on her ask how she's doing if you're worried that she's not getting emotional support offer emotional support and there again there's a line between offering some emotional port and like being nosy and inserting your opinion where it might not be needed or asked

for. If someone's not being seen, you see them. It's not saying, hey, you should be with someone who sees you. You know, like she's an adult. She's in therapy. She's in individual therapy and couples therapy. Maybe they have a bad therapist. I don't know. But like if you're worried about her check in on her see how she's doing make yourself available to her validate her feelings if she is feeling uh if she's like i don't know maybe maybe i'm crazy maybe i'm asking for too much you know then you can step in and say of course you're not asking for too much you're pregnant like you can't ask for too much right you know um you have every right to feel this way what can i do for you how can i help you if she brings up her husband to you then

certainly that gives you a little bit of wiggle room to maybe like ask more questions but like now like I said now is not the time to stick your nose in her relationship and start like and you know using her being pregnant as a way to finally be honest with how you really feel about her decisions in her relationship yeah and like when she's like has all this going on and then I hear about it for other people just like pretend I don't know that and have my on track with her like what are you hearing from other people like the whole like you hearing it from like we have kind of a friend group that's like emotionally close but not always like physically close so we're all like sometimes we're talking to like one-on-one

people and then you know you talk to another friend in the group and they've heard from this person like that they're not doing well or whatever so like I was hearing that her anxiety was like flaring up in the first trimester because she was asking him to like prioritize her and he wasn't doing it and meanwhile he had told my husband at like an event like oh i'm just spending all my time like just really caring for her and doting on her and so like it just like is so frustrating to hear him say that and then her have a completely different story for another friend yeah i i just think you know friend groups are great to have have but when it's this becomes the rumor mill it's never good yeah and also like unless are any other

people in this fan group polyamorous no so you know it's already you know there there are already by default going to be the most titillating and most like talked about couple because of their choice to have the most unconventional type of relationship so yeah i'm not saying he's a great guy or or or or you're not wrong i just it just sounds a lot like gossip yeah i guess like just like I don't feel like it's gossip because oh it literally is gossip okay she's not coming to you yeah I guess I feel like the purpose of gossip is like an interesting story whereas like I was kind of given this information with the like from a friend who doesn't have a child being like are you worried about this

because you have a child and you know what this is like sure but again you're also you're not in a polyamorous relationship and it's like again you you might you might be right but well-intention gossip is still gossip but again if you want to be a friend you can be a friend you if you want to step up in a time of need for your friend you can do that you can check in with her how you doing thinking about you today anything I can do do you want to talk you know you can make yourself available to her without being no without you know trying to be like well you know you know how's randy doing is he still like hanging out with his girlfriend you know like that don't do that you know yeah if she wants to offer

that information great i am like texting her and voice noting her and like she's responding and yeah it's just like yeah i guess it's just like it's just like it really freaked me out i guess that like she kind of gives me like this rosier story and then I mean maybe she's happy I don't know like maybe she is friends with this girl and I don't know maybe oh I don't you know I don't know I don't I don't know either clearly I mean listen it doesn't sound like anyone in this friend group would do what she's willing to do and so because of that you all are judging her a little bit yeah that's probably true. I guess like when I was thinking about it and I was like if you kind of strip out the like Polly part of it like he's still prioritizing seeing another person over her, which like

if my husband was like having to spend a lot of time with this friend, even if it wasn't like emotional or sexual or whatever, I would just be like, why is there a person that you want to spend more time with than me? Like that. I mean, you wouldn't want to be in a polyamist. relationship. You and I are aligned. I get it. We wouldn't do what your friend's doing. And I agree with you that, I mean, he doesn't sound like the best guy. And it kind of sounds like he's kind of convinced her to be in a polyamous relationship as a way to like sleep with other women guilt free. But like, I don't know your friend. And that's that's a snap judgment. I'm basing off a very limited information. And again, like, your friend is not a child who is incapable of making decisions for

herself and you can't save people who don't want to be saved and you can't help people who aren't asking for your help. All you can do is create a safe space for your friend that if in need, she feels comfortable enough to go to you. And the way to do that is to make sure that you don't feel like you will judge her if she does come to you. Yeah. That's all you can do. Yeah. Yeah. I guess like I'm normally a person who, like, really does not think it's your place to tell somebody what you think about their partner. Like, they've chosen that partner and they see something you don't. And I just, like, felt this, like, intense, like, protect yourself, protect the baby, like.

Now, I get it. I get it. I get it. I don't know. Is this the time? Is this the time to say something? But, yeah, I guess there's not really ever a time. Well, again, the fact that she is pregnant, you.

causing your friend a lot of stress would be the literal opposite of protecting that baby right yeah and like i wouldn't be like hey i need to talk to i heard a bunch of stuff i just like how would you do it i mean like i'm going to see her for the first time in a while this weekend and like how's it going has everything with your husband um which i would ask like any pregnant friend um try your best to be a normal friend um without being nosy and just ask how she's doing yeah and don't assume that she is lying to you or painting a different picture you know just see how she's doing if she's like i don't know just just a little you know i'm a little stressful why are you stressed what anything i can help out with anything you want to talk about you know i'm here just whatever i love i love you no matter

what and I just want you to my I'm you know I'm your friend and I you know if there's anything I can do or you know even if it's just a talk I just want you know I love you no matter what and I'm here for you and and all I want is your happiness and I just you know I'm so happy that you're going to be a mom and I can't wait to share motherhood and that experience with you and trade stories and I love you that's all you can say if she opens up to you'd be like oh my god I'm glad you asked so just you know and just unload on her that's not it's not a green light for you to stress her out. It's just you can ask more questions

because she's, you know, don't assume you know the answer. Just be more curious. If she says she's great, believe her. Okay. That's hard to do, but I get it. I get it. We don't know what it's like to be in that relationship. We can only make assumptions.

Yeah. And since it's something neither of us would do, it's almost impossible not to judge. I judge people all the time. And I usually think I'm right, but it doesn't mean I am. Yeah, yeah. And even if I am right,

it's not like, it's not my life. Yeah. It's like hard to watch her like be betrayed repeatedly and not. How do you, you're assuming she's being betrayed. I mean, she describes it that way. Like. Still, currently?

Yeah. Like if he sleeps with someone that she's asked him not to pursue, like she sees that as a betrayal and that's still going on and she's opened that up opened up to you like she's like my husband keeps sleeping with someone else that despite our polyamorous relationship I'm not comfortable with yeah like she's told me that in the past in the past or recently not recently because he's had the same girlfriend and now it's what I'm saying you can't like you know can't use something that happened two years ago what's the situation now him continuing to prioritize this other girlfriend while his like wife is pregnant with their child

is when she's asked him please prioritize me to me is like in the same bucket as like I'm asking you to do something for me in our relationship yeah I mean you can ask like how's that going is do you feel like he's doing that I mean that would be the I would say that's the extent of how nosy you should get without her opening up to you first yeah I understand you have the best intentions and you might not be wrong but like I it's just there's you want to be careful not to convince yourself that you need to play hero here I know and I normally don't I normally don't I really don't like I normally am very like live and let live and I just like I feel like because I feel so activated by this it's making me well that's like something you got to recognize that you are

activated because you're a mother and you have these very maternal instincts and you're very protective and you couldn't imagine your husband doing to you what you think is going on in that relationship but like that still doesn't give you permission to assume you know exactly what's going on again all you can do is check in have a relationship with your friend and the closer you two are the more she'll open up to you do i have to like be nice to her husband well it'd be weird for you to just be mean to him to her face i know i'm just like it's like frustrating and me to think to like almost let him get away with all this shit but yeah i hear what you're saying that would not be helpful to her so don't take that on yeah yeah all you can do is give her this

help her have strength when she needs to find strength and i know that she does have that like she is such a strong person i think that's why it's hard to watch this because i'm like so just keep validating yeah you know keep being there by her side and let her know you're care for her and you're always you know no matter you need them by your side i got your back Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Okay. That makes sense.

Yeah, there's a reason why, and I'm not saying this guy is, but like in your, what was meant, you know, gaslighting and blah, blah, blah, but in the, in the most basic, you know, original sense of the word gaslighting, part of the gaslighting playbook and equation is the person gaslighting their victims, uh, isolates their victim from friends and families so that no one can say, this, this reality that this person's painting isn't true. Mm-hmm. Which is why, like, the fact that you can be by her side can say, I have your back no matter what, and you have a relationship with her and you talked her on a regular basis is definitely a sign that, like, he is not to the extent that trying to manipulate, you know, like he might be doing things you don't agree with, but he's certainly not afraid of you having a relationship with her. And she clearly is maintaining friendships with a bunch of people who don't subscribe to their, lifestyle right and I think that is definitely a positive sign in terms of her not necessarily being a victim of this guy yeah that's fair that is a good point all right be a supportive friend stay in your lane okay got it oh hopefully this is helpful yeah thank you no it was clarifying because I was like you're gonna you're gonna have a hard time with as I can tell so you're gonna have to try not to like I've convinced you I've basically feel like I've I've

I've put you on pause, but you're going to want to convince yourself I'm wrong. Well, I think that like the point you're making about her not causing her extra stress is like that will be my North Star kind of like, you know, in the past like honestly, before she got pregnant when she was trying to get pregnant, my other friends were talking to me being like, I'm really worried about them getting pregnant. And I was like she chose him. You know, this is like. a next step for them like it i don't know maybe it'll be great and she's going to be an amazing mom so like and i was i was more like you know they chose each other they're doing it they're doing the stuff that people do um and i think i can go back to that and just be like i think also i feel so strongly since you know like being becoming a mom it's like so transformative and roxher world in good and bad ways that I like literally my only goal in life is to like support my other friends who are becoming moms now like I mean I like work and stuff but in my personal life like that's

like what I care about and so when I just hear that she's not being supported it just like makes me so mad but I think so just try to step up as much as you can to give her whatever support you think she's lacking I know you you can't obviously replace whatever support she is required by him but you can provide something else. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Okay.

Cool. All right. Take care. I appreciate the call. Mm-hmm. Bye. Bye. Bye.