This Podcast Will Kill You - Ep 156 Retinoids Part 1: How it started…

Episode Date: November 5, 2024

That little bottle of retinol serum sitting on your bathroom counter - what do you know about its history? This week, we’re digging deep into the man behind the medicine, renowned dermatologist Dr. Albert Kligman, and the unethical research he conducted at Holmesburg Prison in the mid-20th century. Kligman’s research program at Holmesburg spanned decades, involved dozens of experiments (including tretinoin) and thousands of individuals, received ample funding from public universities and many pharmaceutical companies, and was generally praised until it all came crashing down in the early 1970s. But, as we’ll discover, the unethical behavior persisted even after the program’s closure as Kligman fought to get tretinoin to market. The murky history of retinoids might be a bit too long to include on the label, but this episode forces us to consider the human cost of a household product and the importance of acknowledging that history. Support this podcast by shopping our latest sponsor deals and promotions at this link: https://bit.ly/3WwtIAu    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

This is exactly right. There are already enough things charging your card every month. Dinner should not be one of them, which is exactly why Blue Apron is now subscription-free. You heard that right, Blue Apron no longer requires a subscription. You can order meals when you want them and skip when you don't without adding another recurring charge. Blue Apron meals are designed by chefs and arrive with pre-portioned ingredients, so there's no meal planning and no extra grocery trip. Order now at Blue Apron.com. Get 50% off your first two orders plus free shipping with code this podcast 50.

Terms and conditions apply. Visit blue apron.com slash terms for more information. Indeed sponsor jobs gets you quality candidates when you need them most. Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Less stress. Less time. More results. When you need the right person to cut through the chaos, this is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.

And listeners of this show will get a 75. $5. Sponsored Job credit to help get your job the premium status it deserves at Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need to hire? This is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs. On eBay, every find has a story. Like if you're looking for a vintage ban tea. Not just a tea, the band tea. You wore it everywhere until your BFF stole it. Now you're on eBay. And there it is. same tea from the same tour. The things you love have a way of finding their way back to you, especially on eBay. Where else can you find that mint trading card you searched everywhere for? Or your first car, the one you wished you never sold. It has to be eBay. Shop eBay for millions of

finds, each with a story. eBay, things people love. In 1970 and 1971, I participated in three different types of tests. Two of them, nicknamed the patch tests by inmates, dealt with the experimentation of new products not yet released to the general public. The first patch test was one that tested lotions, creams, skin moisturizers, and suntan products. The procedure for these tests was as follows. A grid, made from thick strips of white hospital tape was fixed to the upper portion of an inmate's back shoulders. The grid consisted of about 20 squares. In each of these squares, a dab of lotion was applied, and the inmate's back was exposed to different temperatures from a sunlamp. The exposure to the sunlamp lasted anywhere

from 15 to 30 minutes, after which each square was inspected for degree of blistering or other adverse reactions. The grid was then covered with a large solid piece of tape to prevent tampering by the inmate, and the inmate was returned to his cell. This test lasted about 30 days, and once a day, the inmate was called back over to the lab and exposed to the sunlamp. After about five days of the sunlamp, there were sections of the skin that were burnt a deep brown, and the skin started to peel, itch, and blister. If a certain square became too damaged, it was covered over with a permanent piece of tape, and the test continued on the grid. That sounds awful, Erin. Yeah, it really, it really really really,

is. And so that was from William Rob, who was at one point in Holmesburg Prison and participated in these experiments that will make up a big focus of today's episode. And that ultimately was from a book titled Acres of Skin by Alan Hornblum. Hi, I'm Aaron Welsh. And I'm Aaron Olman Updike. And this is, this podcast will kill you. And today's episode, we are covering one half of a big story, all about retinids. Yeah. You know, sometimes with the topics that we choose, you never know where you're going to end up and what the story is going to be. Yeah, and this was certainly the case for retinoids. And, you know, we decided to do this because we were just like, what's the deal with retinodes? Yeah. And looking into the history of things like retinae,

I found a darker story than I anticipated. And the story itself, both like the origin of retinae and the marketing of retinids in general, that is one half of this big story. But I also wanted to tell the story of the experiments at Holmesburg Prison from the 1950s to the 1970s. Because it's not a very commonly told story of a really dark-should. chapter in American medical history. Also, I don't think I realize that this story is going to take place in the 1950s to 1970s. That's like just very depressing, Erin. Like how recent? How recent? I mean, what Tuskegee was whistleblown in the early 1970s? I know. I know. Yeah. I know.

I know. And then, yeah, so that is what this episode is going to focus all on the history. How did Retinae get to market? And a little bit more about one of the... the guys who brought it there. Yeah. And then the second episode, which will be your focus, Erin, is do retinoids work? Right. It's going to be more lighthearted episode than this one. So next week we'll get into what retinids are, how they work, do they work? What do we use them for? And a big part, what I'm most excited about in that episode will be what's the difference between an over-the-counter retinoid and the stuff you get by prescription? And is there one? I am very excited for that because the amount of claims that I see both on product but also just on the internet, right?

In social media and whatnot for the magical powers of retinol. I want to know, like, are there magical powers? It is. I mean, it's the supplements episode 2.0. Can't wait for it. It's going to be so fun. But first. But first, we have quarantini time. We sure do. What are we drinking this week, Erin? Erin. This week we could drink only Skin Deep. Skin Deep. Yep. And in Skim Deep, appropriately, is carrot juice because retinoids are derived from vitamin A, ultimately, which is found in great quantities in carrots. Yeah, it's beta carotene, which is like, will convert into vitamin A in your body. It's a long story. Technically speaking.

And it also has ginger and lemon juice. and some simple syrup and some vodka. And it's a tasty little concoction. I might have to play around with the ratios a little bit. It's going to be fantastic. You can find the full recipe for that quarantini and the very healthy and non-alcoholic plusi burita on our website, this podcast will kill you.com

and on all of our social media channels too. On our website, this podcast will kill you.com, there's a lot of things that you can find. You can find the sources for each and every one of our episodes. You can find transcripts. You can find links to our bookshop.org affiliate account, links to our Goodreads list, links to music by Bloodmobile, links to merch, links to Patreon. There's a contact us form where you can say like, hey, do this episode or hey, come talk at

our university, whatever it is. There's also a submit your first-hand account form, you know? It's all there. Check it out. And if you haven't already, be sure to check your podcatcher and make sure that you're subscribed to this podcast, which really helps us. And if you haven't already left us a review, we would sure love it if you did. Okay. Should we get started? Yes. Please tell me, Erin, all about how retinae came to be.

All right, it's a long story. So let's take a quick break before we begin. Dinner shows up every night, whether you're prepared for it or not. And with Blue Apron, you won't need to panic order takeout again. Blue Apron meals are designed by chefs and arrive with pre-portioned ingredients so there's no meal planning and no extra grocery trip. There, assemble and bake meals take about five minutes of hands-on prep. Just spread the pre-chopped ingredients on a sheet pan, put it in the oven, and that's it! And if there's truly no time to cook, dish by Blue Apron meals are fully prepared.

Just heat them in the oven or microwave, and dinner is ready. And here's the exciting news. Blue Apron no longer requires a subscription. You can order meals when you want them and skip when you don't without adding another recurring charge. Order now at blue apron.com. Get 50% off your first two orders plus free shipping with code this podcast 50. Terms and conditions apply. Visit blue apron.com slash terms for more information.

Anyone who works long hours knows the routine. Wash, sanitize, repeat. By the end of the day, your hands feel like they've been through something. That's why O'Keefe's working hands hand cream is such a. relief. It's a concentrated hand cream that is specifically designed to relieve extremely dry, cracked hands caused by constant hand washing and harsh conditions. Working hands creates a protective layer on the skin that locks in moisture. It's non-greasy, unscented, and absorbs quickly. A little goes a long way. Moisturization that lasts up to 48 hours. It's made for people whose hands

take a beating at work, from health care and food service to salon, lab, and caregiving environments. It's been relied on for decades by people who wash their hands constantly or work in harsh conditions because it actually works. O'Keefs is my hand cream of choice in these dry Colorado winters when it feels like my skin is always on the verge of cracking. It keeps them soft and smooth no matter how harsh it is outside. We're offering our listeners 15% off their first order of O'Keef's. Just visit o'Keef's company.com slash this podcast and code this podcast at checkout. A timeless wardrobe starts with pieces that are built well from the beginning. From the fabrics to the fit, everything needs to last beyond one season.

And that's how Quince approaches design. Quince has all the staples covered, from 100% organic cotton sweaters to premium denim made with stretch for all-day comfort and luxe cotton cashmere blends, perfect for the changing seasons. The quality shows in every detail, the stitching, the fit, the fabrics. Every piece is thoughtfully designed to be your new wardrobe essential. and each piece is made with premium materials in ethical trusted factories and priced far below what other luxury brands charge. I recently got a pair of Quince's Bella stretch wide-leg jeans, and they are now in constant rotation. They are so comfortable, the fit is amazing,

and they come in a bunch of different washes, so I'm about to go order some more. Refresh your wardrobe with Quince. Go to quince.com slash this podcast to get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now, of available in Canada, too. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E-com slash this podcast to get free shipping and 365-day returns. Quince.com slash this podcast. How many of you out there listening has in their bathroom cabinet a little bottle of serum or a little tube containing retinol or retinoids? I'm ready my head. I have two. I have one. I have two different kinds. And how many of you have been prescribed retinae in the past? And,

And, you know, it's n of two here, 100%, 2 of 2. But I'm guessing that it is a lot of you out there. I haven't used my retinal in a long time because it makes me break out. But I bought it because I had heard on, like, commercials or on TikToks or, like, the skincare addiction subreddit, that it was great for your skin, for preventing fine lines, reducing the signs of aging, like all of those things. But beyond the question of, does it actually do those things, is a deeper question. whose answer reveals the surprisingly dark history behind this ubiquitous skin care component.

How did we learn about these effects of retinoids on the skin in the first place? Yeah. Lurking beneath these claims of anti-aging, poor cleansing, and acne prevention, claims which I know next week you're going to talk about, like, which is their support for, which isn't their support for. But behind all of those claims is a grim history involving human experimentation on incarcerated individuals. Experiments so profoundly unethical that they were described as a violation of the Nuremberg Code, you know, like the code that was developed in 1947 in response to Nazi doctor war trials. Whoa, Aaron, that's not. How have we never heard of this? I don't know, because it is commonly mentioned alongside Tuskegee Syphilis study,

alongside the Willowbrook State Schools, alongside the birth control pill experiments in Puerto Rico. Like, it's all sort of part of it. I had never heard about this, though, in medical ethics class. But maybe it was just so long ago that I had forgotten. Yeah, or maybe it was just glossed over us, like, the Hillsburg prison and, like, not, not, no detail or something. Right. Still people devaluing human life because of, yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Okay. I want to learn. Right. Okay. So what were these experiments for? How were they allowed to happen? And who brought them to light. So that's the story that I'm going to tell today. And it's not the history of retinoids that you're likely to find on a skincare company website. And to be fair, retinoids are just one part of the story. But I wanted to focus on it today because I think it's a crucial part of the history of medical ethics and it's one that, yeah, you don't hear about that often. How do highly educated and credentialed individuals get to a point where they feel like they're above the rules, where they

lose any self-awareness that would allow them to see that they aren't nobly championing science, but in fact committing atrocities against humans. At the heart of this story is Albert Klegman, an American dermatologist who has been credited with transforming the field of dermatology from a little acknowledged subspecialty to a full-on giant of industry by the end of the 20th century. As the co-inventor of Retinae and an advocate for its off-label uses, Kligman saw the incredible commercial potential of dermatology in terms of pharmaceuticals and cosmetics, cosmaceuticals.

But that is certainly not his only claim to fame. For more than two decades, between 1951 and 1974, Cligman headed a medical research program at Holmesburg Prison in Pennsylvania, where he conducted dozens of non-therapeutic experiments on incarcerated individuals, the majority of which were black. Experiments ranged from assessing the efficacy of certain deodorants to quantifying the impacts of dioxin exposure. Dioxin, if you haven't heard of it before, is a highly carcinogenic substance, like it's sometimes called the most carcinogenic substance known. It's the stuff in Agent Orange that makes it super toxic to humans. So he tested it on humans.

What? Mm-hmm. And although most experiments didn't specify, like, which race he was looking for, you know, this is a call for white people. This is a call for black people. The riskiest ones were reserved for black individuals only. And this is where Retinay was born at Holmesburg Prison. I'm already so mad, Aaron.

I know. You're just, there's so many more pages of being angry. My face is going to be like that. Talk about like permanent wrinkles. Like I'm going to have one. The furrowed brow is going to be too deep for retinoids to penetrate. This podcast does give me one of those, constantly. This podcast will give you a furrowed brow. I'll give you a furrowed brow.com. Worth it. Yep. But before we get into the backstory of retinae, let's first explore how Kligman found Holmesburg or rather how it found him.

Kligman's path to dermatology was not a straight line. He started off by first getting his Ph.D. in botany, studying fungi. At the time, psychology was lumped in with botany or like under the botany umbrella. And then he went to medical school with a specialization in dermatology so he could keep pursuing his interest in fungi, like those that cause athletes' foot. A lot of, like, you know, topical fungal infections. Yeah. Yeah.

A few years after graduating with his MD, Cligman, who was faculty at the University of Pennsylvania, he received a phone call from the pharmacist at Holmesburg Prison. The prison was dealing with a huge Athletes Foot problem, which is common in large residential facilities, and the pharmacist was at his wit's end trying to find an effective treatment. And in his searches, he had stumbled upon a research article written by Cligman about Athletes Foot, and so he called the doctor for advice. Kligman was like, all right, I'm going to see this for myself. So he went to the prison to scope out the situation.

And when he got there, he didn't see an athlete's foot problem, or he didn't see that alone. But what he saw instead was limitless potential. Quote, all I saw before me were acres of skin. It was like a farmer seeing a fertile field for the first time. End quote. Sorry. You go to a prison, see untold numbers of incarcerated individual human beings, and all you see are acres of skin. Acres of skin. Cool. Mm-hmm. Great. So that...

Stand-up guy. I think gives you a little bit of a sense for where his sense of morality was when it came to experiments on humans. I mean, it's a lot easier to do stuff if you're just doing it on skin. Right. It's just skin. It's devoid of humanity. I mean, and I think, well, we'll get into this a little bit more later, but I think he did see beyond skin, but I think that what he saw was he was a little bit of the savior, right? Like he was like, oh, but I am giving them freedom from boredom. I'm giving them money. I'm giving them an opportunity to learn. I'm giving them an opportunity to give back. Like, this is a whole, yeah. Yeah. And so this Acres of Skin comment is the title of the book that where most of this

information that I got for today's episode comes from. It's a great book. It's by Alan Hornblum. It's a really, it's one of the classic exposés of unethical human experimentation in the U.S. In Kligman's eyes, Holmesburg Prison represented a near perfect study environment. And that's an opportunity that rarely, if ever, comes along in medicine. In an institutionalized setting, Holmesburg was not Kligman's first foray, by the way, into institutionalized settings. He also went into schools. But in all of these institutionalized settings, you could control every variable down to how much sleep your test subjects got, what they ate, how much they ate, when they ate, how much sun

they got, when they could shower, how often they could shower, all of these things you could have complete control over. Plus, it was cheap. To have someone enroll in the types of trials that he was interested in trying out and testing, you would have to pay someone who was not in prison lots and lots of money to keep them going, to be willing to do these things. So, by comparison, Holmesburg was very cheap. And so Cligman wasted no time in setting up shop at the prison. Quote, I began to go to the prison regularly, although I had no authorization. It was years before the authorities knew that I was conducting

various studies on prisoner volunteers. Things were simpler then. Informed consent was unheard of. No one asked me what I was doing. It was a wonderful time. End quote. I know. I just can't, like, I can believe it was a wonderful time. It was a one. Informed consent didn't exist. It was a wonderful time. Yeah. Those two sentences cannot go together. Yeah. And I think the other remarkable thing about this is that, so I'm not sure like when that quote was pulled from, but it was, later, like years later, right? It's obviously him looking back on his time doing this, being like, it was so great, wasn't it?

Yeah. Cool. Yep. You know, and he wasn't entirely wrong about things being simpler then. It seems that, from my understanding, Cligman didn't do anything technically illegal while conducting experiments at Holmesburg. Well, I was just trying to remember at what point actually IRBs became a thing, clearly after this.

Yeah, I don't remember either. I know that Tuskegee in the early 70s kind of was one of the biggest wake-up calls for, you know, let's... So you just slipped it right in there. We need more regulation. Yeah, yeah. But it doesn't mean that Kligman's experiments were ethical. It just means that the laws were simply inadequate. At the time, in the mid-20th century, non-therapeutic medical experiments on institutionalized populations were normalized. They really were. especially on individuals in prisons, who were seen as expendable and also as needing to, quote-unquote, give back to society. Prisons were a really popular spot for phase one clinical trials, which were intended to test the safety of a drug, not necessarily its efficacy. And so I've talked about several of these infamous unethical experiments on the podcast before and even mentioned them earlier in this episode. You know, there's intentionally infecting children with hepatitis at Willowbrook State School on Staten Island, New York. There's, of course, said it a million times a famous Tuskegee syphilis experiment. Just a few episodes ago, I talked about how incarcerated, quote-unquote, volunteers were given a slurry containing norovirus intended to study the effects of infection.

Yep. And there are so many more examples out there. Examples that the Nazi doctors being tried at Nuremberg pointed out in their defense in the late 1940s. Like, hey, you guys do this too in the U.S. You do this all the time. But the American doctors conducting these experiments saw themselves as different. Nothing like the Nazis, but noble warriors doing what needed to be done in the name of science and giving their test subjects meaning.

Quote from Cligman. Okay. Quote, many of the prisoners, for the first time in their lives, find themselves in the role of important human beings. We say to them, you're important. We need you. Once this is established, these guys will knock their brains out to please you. If the experiment does not pan out, they get depressed. They become emotionally involved in the project.

The capacity to respond to love is greater than most people realize. I feel almost like a scoundrel, like Machiavelli, because of what I can do to them. End quote. Oh my God, Aaron. I know. This guy is, okay, I didn't read any history papers, but this guy is mentioned in like the textbooks and things like that, not like this. Right.

He is hailed as a modern father of dermatology. Yeah, and they'll be like, oh, and the experiments that he did had questionable ethics. This is like, he is very aware of what he is doing. Right. He is. You know that someone, like, you... You said that to a reporter, clearly. Yeah.

Or you wrote that. Like, you didn't say that, like, at a dinner party with, like, just your derm friends. Right, this isn't a private diary. Dear diary, I feel like Machiavelli. This is like a brag. It's like basically the equivalent of a tweet back in the day. Exactly. You can't take you back.

No, it's there. Anyone who works long hours knows the routine. Wash, sanitize, repeat. By the end of the day, your hands feel like they've been through something. That's why O'Keefe's working hands hand cream is such a relief. It's a concentrated hand cream that is specific. designed to relieve extremely dry, cracked hands caused by constant hand washing and harsh conditions. Working hands creates a protective layer on the skin that locks in moisture. It's non-greasy,

unscented, and absorbs quickly. A little goes a long way. Moisturization that lasts up to 48 hours. It's made for people whose hands take a beating at work, from health care and food service to salon, lab, and caregiving environments. It's been relied on for decades by people who wash their hands constantly, or work in harsh conditions because it actually works. O'Keefs is my hand cream of choice in these dry Colorado winters when it feels like my skin is always on the verge of cracking. It keeps them soft and smooth, no matter how harsh it is outside. We're offering our listeners 15% off their first order of O'Keef's.

Just visit O'Keef's company.com slash this podcast and code this podcast at checkout. This is Matt Rogers from Las Culture Eastas with Matt Rogers and Boen Yang. This is Bowen Yang from Lost Culture Research with Matt Rogers and Bowen-Yang. What if your Wi-Fi was more than just Wi-Fi? What if your Wi-Fi made everything in your whole house just work together better? Well, Xfinity Wi-Fi pretty much does exactly that. It's powered by their best, most elite, high-performing tech. Allow us to paint a very realistic example.

Everyone in your house. Everyone is on their devices at the exact same time. Gaming, working, swiping right, because of course they are. And the finale of your favorite show of all time. time of the week is on at the exact same moment. Well, you can boost the Wi-Fi to your device with Xfinity. And have you ever asked yourself, what if my Wi-Fi could keep watch over my kids for me? Well, probably not, because that's a weird thing to ask yourself. But Xfinity Wi-Fi has parenting skills, even if you sometimes forget yours. Xfinity's like, don't worry, I'll monitor the Wi-Fi.

It's completely proactive, fixing issues before they even happen. Bottom line, Xfinity is smart and reliable. You deserve the peace of mind of having Wi-Fi that's got your back. Xfinity. Imagine that. The greatest to ever play the game. Return to finish what they started. Welcome to Survivor 50. I wanted one more shot. I played the game that I fell in love with 25 years ago. I want to win against the best of the best. I chickened out at the final tribal. Season 50, it's an honor. Light your torch. I've got some unfinished business. Be part of history. I have more to play for this time. Bigger than ever. Survivor 50.

New milestone season begins CBS tonight at 8-7 Central. And I think what's like, Kligman is one of the individuals that has often put forth as an example. And there were some medical ethicists who at the time spoke out against these experiments, but for the most part, conducting research on institutionalized

or vulnerable populations was widely accepted, even outside of medicine. Right? That sentiment that he expressed, maybe minus the Machiavelli part, but the whole like giving meaning, feeling important, giving back, all of these things. That was in the popular narrative about these experiments. So starting in the mid-1950s, for example, Life magazine ran several stories on Kligman and his experiments at Holmesburg with titles like, quote, prisoners volunteer to save lives.

and prisoners aid medical research, 75% here act as medical guinea pigs, or the poison ivy picker of Pennypack Park, which that last article detailed Kligman's quest to find a vaccine for poison ivy, not mentioning the not-so-mild side effects of the alleged vaccine, which caused a drop in blood pressure that made many people pass out. And also just like having to have poison ivy oils rubbed all over your skin. In a 1966 newspaper article, Kligman did acknowledge to some degree the moral issues inherent in his research. Quote, we had an ethical problem.

How much right do you have to cause risk to a prisoner in medical tests from which he has no direct benefit? End quote. Seems like a rhetorical question. I don't think he answered it. In that same article, the superintendent of Holmesburg reassured readers that, quote, we will not approve anything, which on the face of it would be deleterious to the physical well-being of an individual, end quote. And that sounds great, like nice sentiment, but who actually has the power to say whether something is deleterious or not? It was largely up to one man, Albert Klegman.

Let me be clear, though, the experiments at Holmesburg Prison are not the work of one mad scientist given too much power. This was a coordinated effort with many major players involved and ample oversight. Pharmaceutical companies like Pfizer, Hoffman LaRoche, Park Davis, Abbott, all hired researchers to conduct experiments at Holmesburg. Others partnered directly with Kligman for years, and this was a University of Pennsylvania project. Nor was Holmesburg prison the only place where medical research was unethically conducted or the University of Pennsylvania, the only institution that sponsored it. I'm not defending this experimentation in any capacity. I just want to put it in historical context.

Like, this is not a one-off. Which honestly just makes it that much worse. It makes it that much worse. It was just everyone in everywhere. Right. This is just one that got more attention because there's a full-fledged book about it. There are plenty more that could be that are book-worthy, I am certain.

Right. And so on that note, let's get more into the medical research program, at Holmesburg Prison. What had started out as a small program in 1951 to 1952 when he first arrived to assess the athlete's foot problem had by the early 1960s become a full-fledged research machine with expensive state-of-the-art medical equipment, trailers with monitoring equipment and padded cells, and up to 90% of all individuals who were incarcerated at Holmesburg participating in experiments. So there were times when 90% of all individuals at Holmesburg prison were involved in one experiment or multiple, which was a very common situation. Oh my God.

And also like not to mention how being involved in multiple different trials just scientifically is not. Not great. Not great. Between 1962 and 1966, only four years, 1993 studies were conducted at Holmesburg, including 100,000. 153 experimental drugs, and then more drugs that needed marketing permission and drugs whose new uses were tested. So like some of these were purely experimental, most of these. Oh, wow. The types of experiments were wide-ranging, as were the financial incentives. To test hand creams, you could earn a dollar a day. Foot powders and deodorants testing could get you

$100 a month. $150 could be yours if you were willing. to have your finger numbed with Novacane and then your fingernail removed to see how it would heal. Okay. Yep. Other experiments included sticking your arm in a sodium laurel sulfate solution for one hour each day for 55 days in a row. Testing the relationship between chocolate and acne. Walking around with steel cups strapped to your forehead to collect skin cells and perspiration. Testing anti-dandruff shampoo that, oops, made your hair fall out.

slicing skin on your back to try to induce a cheloid, implanting different kinds of gauze or even tissue from a cadaver. To just look at healing and like creams to help your skin heal. Applying enormous amounts of fungi to the feet and being forced to keep your boots on continually for a week, even overnight, to see how bad ringworm infection could get. The riskier the test, the higher the potential reward. like you could get $1,000 to $1,500 to test out eyedrops or hallucinogenic medications. Pills that were meant to speed up sun tanning but gave people violent GI symptoms. Infecting people with pathogens like Staphoreas, Candida albacans, herpes virus, influenza, tests that involved liver biopsies and nearly killed seven inmates.

I don't know why the liver biopsies were needed. Why are you doing liver biopsies in a... What? Yep. Okay. Don't know. Radioactive isotope testing. Exposing people to dioxin and observing the results.

It's like, what happens? What happens if we do this? At one point, the U.S. Army was testing psychoactive or mind-control drugs in those padded cells, I mentioned. People who used to be at the prison said that you could pick out those who were volunteers from those who were, weren't from their checkered backs. Like, so from the firsthand account, how I mentioned the skin test, the patch tests. So many of those tests left physical and emotional scars. Extreme sunburns leading to skin discoloration incisions where the gauze was inserted

and never quite fully healed. Biopsy marks. And then you have like the, from the mind control or psychoactive drugs, you had flash, people would experience flashbacks or bad trips years later. personality changes. But what choice did people truly have? Other jobs at Holmesburg prison, like making shoes, knitting socks and shirts, sewing pants, plumbing, you would get 15 cents a day. Because it's no contest. Put some lotion on your hands, a dollar a day? Sure. Eye drops, if you need to send money back home, yeah, I need to do this. How much choice is there?

And those that were involved in the experiments would often get better treatment, better food, and higher social standing in addition to that substantial financial incentive. And a dark side of this that kind of came out later on was that the financial disparity between people who participated in the trials and those who didn't sometimes led to coercion and sexual abuse. The researchers did not mention the health risks involved in any experiment or even what the experiment was testing. None of the people who participated remember ever hearing the words informed consent. Yeah. Right. I mean, even Cligman himself was like, didn't exist. That didn't exist.

We didn't do that. They remembered signing release forms, but the forms didn't have any additional information on them. As the author of Acres of Skin, Alan Hornblum puts it, quote, A drowning person does not ask penetrating questions about a life raft, end quote. Even if they had asked questions, would they have gotten honest answers? With the large scale of the research program at Holmesburg, Kligman couldn't have expected to fly entirely under the radar, even if he were a careful and detail-oriented researcher, which he was not.

He ended trials prematurely. There was a lot of evidence of falsified data. He had, like I said earlier, people participating in multiple trials, like overlapping that were testing different things. He was just kind of like, oh, this looks like it's not where I'm going. We're ending the trial. Oh, this looks like it's where I wanted to go. We're ending the trial and saying that this is exactly what I wanted to find. And so sure enough, red flags were thrown up as early as the 1960s, which is when it came to light that Kligman was testing DMSO on humans. which was a solvent banned from human testing by the FDA. Like at that point, it had already been banned. And so as a result, Francis Kelsey, who you may remember from our thalidomide episode, as the person who was largely responsible for preventing the lytomide from being marketed in the U.S. She led the charge to disqualify Kligman from testing new drugs. It ended up being temporary, his disqualification, much to the relief of the many pharmaceuticals.

companies who loved the Holmesburg prison as a cheap way to try out medications. And he had a lot of other, like, you know, eminent dermatologists who wrote in on his behalf, like, this is unprecedented. He has done nothing but good for the dermatology community, blah, blah, blah. This is out of hand. You need to let him do the work that he was put here on this earth to do. Oh, wow. Yeah, that kind of thing. But even though Kligman's disqualification was reversed, the tides had begun to turn, not just for Kligman, but for research on institutionalized populations in general. Revelations about the Tuskegee syphilis experiment came to light in 1972, which marked a big shift in attitudes towards medical experiments on vulnerable populations

and what informed consent truly means. Can there be such a thing in prisons? In schools, can there be such a thing? What does voluble? voluntary mean? How can you tell if someone is volunteering or if there is coercion? And this is still very much an ongoing discussion in medical ethics. You know, is it depriving people of an opportunity to earn money? Is it something that like, well, then you're not giving them the right to make decisions on their own behalf? But also, how are those decisions influenced by the power dynamics by the structure. The power structure and the dynamics is it's very difficult to overcome. It is. Yeah. And all of these conversations really seemed to ramp up, of course, in the early

1970s as more and more of these experiments in institutions came to light. Kligman, for his part, never seemed to acknowledge that what he did was unethical, that he exploited a vulnerable population. he saw the work he did as quote unquote quite beneficial to all. In his mind, he gave these individual skills, a reprieve from boredom, money, sure, but also excitement and a purpose. And when the medical experimentation program at Holmesburg was forced to close in 1974, he railed against its closure. Quote, a very good case of the triumph of the do-gooders. All we did is, offer them money for a little piece of their skin. End quote. All these do-gooders. A do-gooder. All these do-gooders. How dare you be a do-gooder? You're a doctor, ma'am. I know, right? Like,

where does this fit under your Hippocratic oath? Yeah, if a doctor is not supposed to be a do-gooder, who is, man? And that's what's so, that's what's the mental gymnastics where he did think he was doing good, right? This is beneficial to all. I don't think. that he would ever admit that he violated the Hippocratic oath, right? Do no harm. Because he did so much good, like the net was good in his eyes. It's like the train and the one person versus the train and the blah, blah, blah. Yeah. Get real, dude. Yeah. Get real, dude. The medical experimentation program at Holmesburg did not go quietly into the night. There was denial of any wrongdoing. There was bargaining that if they improved things, could they still experiment?

There was outrage, basically all the stages of grief, minus perhaps acceptance. Kligman had always seen himself as a maverick. He told his students that rules don't apply to genius, that they just get in the way of creative minds. Yeah. No one could tell him that what he did was wrong and have him actually believe it or acknowledge it, even when the lawsuits came out, which were dismissed because of statute of limitations. Oh, God, statute of limitations. I think there was eventually some settling outside of court, although I don't remember the details of it.

But even when sweeping changes were made to guidelines for obtaining informed consent in medical research and research on vulnerable populations, he still couldn't admit that what he did was wrong. Even when his research at Holmesburg was deemed to be in violation of the Nuremberg Code, he seemed to think that the ends justified the means. Wow.

But what exactly were those ends, right? Was it the advancement of science? Was it relieving people suffering? Or was it simply making money? Making a buck. That's my guess, Aaron. You know, I can't say for certain because I don't know him in his head. But given his words and actions after Holmesburg,

I think that it's pretty clear that money was at least a strong motivating factor. And that brings me finally to the story of retinae. Retinoids, which include retinol and retinae, which is the brand name of Tretanoin, are all derivatives of vitamin A. And someday we'll probably do an episode just about vitamin A. For sure, because we're focusing on like topical retinoids, da-da-da. Vitamin A is its own thing. I mean, it's the same thing, but it's the same thing.

Definitely plenty more to the story of vitamin A. Yeah. And so the short story that I'll tell right now is that people have used vitamin A for likely thousands of years to treat night blindness. Beginning in the 20th century, people grew interested in the other properties of vitamin A and other vitamins. It was like that vitamin Hay Day revolution that I've talked about many times. And one of the things that they noticed was that vitamin A seemed like it might be effective

in treating acne. In the 1940s, a researcher named Jonathan's, Stromfejord, dozed patients with 100,000 international units of vitamin A every day for a minimum of six months. Injections, right? I think so, yeah. Okay. And the results were striking.

79 patients were completely cured, and only three showed no improvement. That's, like, pretty strong results. Later studies conducted in 1962 by Dr. Beer and Dr. Stutgen used vitamin A. acid, which I'm assuming is tretanoin. I'm not sure. I don't know if it went by the name then. This was administered orally. And they found similar benefits. All of these researchers noted the extreme skin irritation in the early weeks of treatment. And one researcher was like, I don't want to do any more of these studies because I am so alarmed at the strength of this reaction. This can't be good for people. But that didn't bother Albert Kligman. When a UPenn

medical resident tried out the vitamin A derivative at Holmesburg after reading Beer and Stutgen's paper, quote, Dr. Kligman saw that it irritated the skin and asked if he could work with it, end quote. So he like saw the irritation and was like, ooh, green flag. Right. Like, oh, this means it's doing things. This means it's doing things. By 1963, Kligman had set up human trials at Holmesburg exploring the potential uses of the medication, which he received free of charge from Hoffman LaRoche, who of course saw its commercial potential. At the prison, Kligman sought to find the right dose, the right delivery system like orally orally, and the right chemical composition of the vitamin, on the backs and faces of the individuals at Holmesburg. He's quoted

as saying that early on he experimented with quote-unquote very high doses. of vitamin A, quote, I near killed people before I could see a real benefit. Every one of them got sick, end quote. Ah, okay. This guy just keeps getting worse, Erin. It keeps getting, I know you're like, surely there's not more to this. Oh, trust me, there is. Yeah.

Yeah. He used doses of 1% vitamin A acid, trinanone, which is 100 times. stronger than the 0.01% that it became later on. One percent? Yeah. Oh my. Yeah. That's way too strong.

And unsurprisingly, that strong of a dose caused intense irritation to the skin. But that didn't worry Cleggman in the slightest. In fact, he took it as a good sign, an indication that this drug was working. This trade of his to keep pushing, push past any obstacle, it earned him the admiration of some, like a former student who said that he, quote, thought retinae would never sell. It caused a severe reaction in patience. Their faces became quite red and irritated. But Kligman has the capacity to push when others won't. He could see the value of retinae as possible therapy. Time has shown that it has positive results. It's a fantastic

drug. He's a genius. End quote. Okay. And there's no denying that retinae has been incredibly valuable for many people. But I think it's important to remember that it wasn't Kligman dealing with the irritation. He wasn't pushing himself. He was just pushing other people who had no say in the matter. More than dioxin, more than radioactive isotopes, more than the mind-control drugs, it was vitamin A acid, trinone that fascinated Kligman the most. And he would be rewarded handsomely for it. After switching allegiance from Hoffman-LaRosia, to Johnson and Johnson, Cligman helped bring Retinay to the market, where it first became available in 1971. The timing for Cligman could not have been better. The research program at Holmesburg

was winding down, it would fully close in 1974, and Cligman was eager to leave that world behind to explore the realm of cosmaceuticals. The immediate success of Retinae gave Cligman the opportunity to think about not just how to study these drugs, but how to market them. He believed that retinae held promise beyond just treating acne, that it could also reduce signs of aging. Cligman, although a lot of literature would have you believe otherwise, didn't come up with this on his own. His patients did. They told him that after a course of retinae, their skin looked younger. They had fewer wrinkles.

It seemed to be brighter. Cligman didn't believe them initially. Quote, I have always told students that if you start to believe your patience, you're going to end up as a quack. I have a doctrine. Don't believe patience. So I was a victim of my doctrine, end quote. Karen, these quotes cannot be real. I know.

I'm like, this is a caricature of one of the worst, like, did he ever study hysteria? I can only imagine, right? I have a doctor in don't believe patients. Oh my. This guy is so celebrated. I cannot. I know. Don't believe patience.

If you believe your patience, you're a quack. He told students. Like, he trained students, right? Yeah. I'm not trained in dermatology, so I am only knowing when I'm reading on papers. So I don't know how much they like him in dermatology circles, but, like, I hope they don't. What?

Yeah. Yep. So there you go. Cool, cool, cool. Yep, yep, yep. I don't know what made him decide to eventually believe, at least these patients. But in the early 1980s, he began running experiments to see whether their claims had any basis. This time he used animal models, it seems.

But the reported results were remarkable. a complete transformation. Retinae could be the most powerful anti-aging drug to hit the market, according to Klegman. There was just one problem, and it was a big one. Retinae was approved by the FDA to treat acne, not as an anti-aging product. To sell it as an anti-aging product, ortho, a subsidiary of Johnson & Johnson that made retinae, would have to get FDA approval for this new use, which meant going through all those steps that would take years and lots of resources with no guarantee of success. And so Cligman proposed a workaround, a propaganda campaign using ortho-sponsored conferences, paid for doctors, ads in medical journals, articles in medical journals,

features in fashion magazines, and testimonials on TV programs to promote the anti-aging, anti-wrinkle properties of retinae. The campaign was a major. success. In 1987, the year before they started spreading the propaganda, 6% of retinae sales were for off-label uses. The following year, it shot up to 65%. Okay. Sales grew to around $1.5 million each day, which is 10 times higher than it had been before the campaign. Kligman, for his part, was getting paid by Ortho for his work as a consultant and enjoying. his share of the royalties. This massive change in revenue stream and in off-label uses,

of course, drew the attention again of the FDA. It was legal for physicians to prescribe off-label usage of retinae for their patients. Like if someone came in and was like, I want to try this out as an anti-wrinkle cream, can you prescribe this for me? Okay, I'm going to use it in this way. But it was illegal for a company to promote such off-label usage. The FDA, began an investigation into Ortho for off-label marketing. And this caught the attention of the popular media, who saw the situation as the latest example of the sneaky doings of the pharmaceutical industry. An article about retinae in Money magazine pointed out the following. It's a hefty list, but I like it because it just have any of these things changed. Okay.

Number one, the pharmaceutical industry's increasing propensity to bypass clinical physicians and promote new prescription drugs directly to consumers through the popular press. I mean, every single ad on my Hulu. Yep. Number two, major corporate publicity of medical researchers who abandoned objectivity for corporate dollars on behalf of new products and lavish PR campaigns. Every single dermatologist and researcher who has their own skincare line now. Okay. Yep. Number three, the extremely close relationships between pharmaceutical companies and doctors. Weirdly, especially true in dermatology? Like, very. I mean, there's supposed to be more things in

place for that than there are. Keep going. Number four, the shallow perusal by the general press of pharmaceutical company press releases in the quest for bold headlines. Oh, hi. Yeah. Yeah. Number five, the Fourslea. FDA's underfunded, understaffed administrative situation in the face of well-organized corporate initiatives and sophisticated publicity techniques. Imagine if we funded organizations that are supposed to protect the public. What a concept. Sorry, this was written yesterday or?

I know, right? 1988, I believe. Yeah. Yeah, so that is just, have things changed? I don't think so. No. But all of this bad press was not ideal for Ortho. And things were only going to get worse because the University of Pennsylvania had caught wind of what was going on and sued Cligman for filing a personal patent for this new anti-aging retinae called Renova, effectively cutting out UPenn and keeping all the profits between Cligman and Johnson and Johnson.

So, sorry, but also, because when you use. said that they sued him. I got really excited. Like, they knew he did something wrong, but no, it's just because they weren't going to make any money off of it. You cut us out. Oh, goodness me. The case was ultimately settled out of court with, to presumably everyone's satisfaction, but Ortho still had the FDA to contend with. And they were panicking. Ortho ordered employees to start shredding documents, destroying videotapes, hiding videotapes, hiding any evidence at their personal, at their employees' houses that they had entirely orchestrated this plan to market retinae for off-label uses.

It was a shred fest. I'm not kidding. Isn't this wild? They really thought that was going to work, though? I know. I know, right? Every time. I don't know how they thought they weren't going to get caught.

It doesn't make sense. And they definitely got caught. Yeah. In 1992, the U.S. government filed criminal charges against Johnson and Johnson, but a lot of the requested documents that were in those charges had been destroyed. So they were also charged with destroying documents. The trial went on for two years, and corporate officials were very aware that every day that the trial went on, the release of retinae as an anti-wrinkle medication was delayed. And so in January 1995, they pled guilty to unlawfully promoting retinae for photo aging and for other unapproved indications. To the question of did ortho knowingly and corruptly persuade and attempt to persuade the employees to destroy,

mutilate and concealed documents and other objects, they said yes. They also answered yes to, did ortho persuade employees to destroy those documents, quote, with the intention to impair the integrity and availability and availability, of those documents and objects for use in an official proceeding, end quote. Their guilty plea brought them a hefty fine, a total of $7.5 million, which is one of the largest ever paid for an FDA violation at the time. Yeah. But to Ortho, to Johnson & Johnson, it may have well been pocket change.

Right. Especially compared to what they're about to make. Exactly. They had already made millions untold. millions on off-label, well, on retinae sales in general, but off-label uses, and they were about to make a whole lot more with Renova. A month after the decision, the FDA approved Renova for sale, with a caveat on the label, quote, Renova does not eliminate wrinkles, repair sun-damaged skin, reverse photo aging, or restore a more youthful or younger dermal histologic pattern, end quote.

Sorry, so it was approved to treat photo aging, but they had to say that it doesn't treat photo. Does it reverse photo aging? Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Histologically. Histologically. Okay. I don't know what the standard for, you know, evidence wise, I guess. Yep. But it didn't really seem to make a difference in sales, right? Or at least like, I don't know if it did, having that caveat on there. Because for every skin care product that promises eternal youth, and a wrinkle-free life, you'll find die-hard supporters, you'll find clinically supported claims, and you'll find it next to impossible to actually get to the bottom of whether or not a product works as it's supposed to, all because of the vast sums of money to be made obscuring the truth.

And I know that that's like a very cynical take, and I'm sure that there are products out there that work or that work for some people. Which is why I'm really excited for next week's episode, where you'll tell me all about the actual data on tretanoin and retinol and all of the rest of the retinodes. But before I finally wrap this up for good and tell you my short list of sources, I want to circle back to what I said at the beginning of this history section, how we don't think enough about where our knowledge comes from and who bore the cost. We know about different hepatitis viruses and had an early hepatitis B vaccine, in part because of the unethical experiments performed by Saul Krug.

at Willowbrook State School on Staten Island. We know how syphilis progresses untreated, in part because of the Tuskegee syphilis study, which continued even though treatment was available. We know how the birth control pill works in part because Gregory Pincus measured its efficacy by testing it out on women in Puerto Rico who were never told the purpose of the pill or any risks involved. We know about trinotenoin as a treatment for acne and possibly for wrinkles, in part because of the unethical experiments performed by Albert Kligman at Holmesburg Prison. I'm not saying throw out your retinol in protest, but just that I think it's so important that we remember how we came about this knowledge

and all the knowledge that we have. I feel like it's also what is so often missing from all of the discussions about the scientific achievements and advancements, like not just current ones, but ones that we don't even think that much about. For me, I know it's one of my favorite parts of this podcast is learning how, even though it's usually very depressing and horrific, like, I can always never believe that we didn't already know this, like, that I didn't learn this in all of the training that I've gotten. It's just, it's so left out of the story. Mm-hmm. It is. And I sometimes wonder why that is. Like, obviously, in a classroom setting, your time is limited and you need to get across this, this, and this. this. But is it, do people think that it's a distraction? You know, so like for instance, how the Upton Sinclair's The Jungle highlighted how gross the meat was instead of the worker conditions. Like, do people think that it's just going to distract from how retinodes help with acne? I don't know.

I think it's bigger. I think it's in part, maybe this is just me like hypothesizing too much or whatever, but I think it's also in part, like, the way that we always learn everything in isolation, right? Like, we're so used to, like, well, you have to learn your history in a history class. And, like, well, you don't take a history of medicine class in med school. That's not a thing. Right. So you're never getting that then, because you learned, like, what, European history or, like, whatever history that you took in college as, like, a, you know, general requirement that has nothing to do with the specific field that you might be in. And you never might learn the history of that field because there's, I mean, there's just too much to know. The same way there's

too much science to know, there's too much history to know, too. Right. Yeah, but it is that sort of like that siloed nature of education where if you learn about unethical human experiments, you're going to learn about it in a medical ethics class. Right, in your ethics class. Right. But you're not going to learn about it in your dermatology class. No. Also, I'm not sure that we even had a specific ethics class in med school. I think I did in my epi-master. Yeah, I might have had one there. But doesn't that seem problematic? Yes, certainly does. We all just need to learn. We need to learn it.

We need to learn more. And speaking of learning it, sources. So I pretty much just had one for this episode, which was Acres of Skin by Alan Hornblum. I also have a few other papers that I'll post that are by Cligman in case you are interested in reading first-hand, how he wrote about some of these experiments. And it's really funny, one has at the top, like this research was sponsored by an unrestricted. educational grant from ortho-pharmaceuticals, which at least it's like, you know, loud and easily disclosed and not like in the subfooting notes or whatever. It's not in the very, very last page after you've read it and you're like, are you kidding

me? Right. This is now like disclosure here. But yeah. So I will post all of those sources and also, Erin, your sources next week. We'll go on the same page on our website. This podcast Will Kill You.com. You can find the list of sources from this episode.

in every single one of our episodes there. Check it out. Thank you to Bloodmobile for providing the music for this episode and all of our episodes. Thank you to Leanna Squillachi and Tom Brighfogle for the incredible audio mixing. Thank you to everyone at exactly right. And thank you to you, listeners. We hope that you enjoyed this episode and are super stoked for next week's episode where we're going to get into what are these retinodes anyways and what is their evidence.

And a big thank you, as always, to our wonderful, generous patrons. We appreciate your support so, so, so, so very much. Yeah, we do. Thank you. Well, until next time, wash your hands. You filthy animals? Truck month is going on now at your local RAM dealer. Hurry in for great deals and exceptional offers on a powerful selection of RAM trucks. And right now purchase and get zero percent financing for 60 months on 2026 RAM-500 Big Horn and Laramie models.

Don't miss this great offer. See your local RAM dealer. Not compatible with any other offers. Zero percent APR financing for 60 months equals 1667 per month per 1,000 financed for well-qualified buyers through Stalantus financial services regardless of down payment. Not all customers will qualify. Contact dealer for details. Offer ends 3-2. Virgin Voyages presents with love from Alaska.

The scenery out here is unreal. Mountains, glaciers, waterfalls, the ship? Designed for panoramic views, which is why I'm pretending to be a wildlife photographer. I am not. Yesterday we were hiking and kayaking. Today, I'm watching for humpback whales. Anyway, wish you were here. Award-winning, Kid-Free Alaskan cruises from Virgin Voyages,

with immersive shore excursions and zero kid energy. Virgin Voyages.com. Lego Star Wars just made the jump to hyperspace. Introducing the Lego Smart Brick. New Lego Star Wars sets with smart bricks inspire your child's imagination, taking their play to uncharted regions of the galaxy. With responsive lights, a color recognition scanner, a synthesizer, and an accelerometer, your child's play doesn't just come alive.

It allows the Lego Star Wars galaxy to play back. May the Force be with you. Shop Lego Star Wars sets now on Lego.com or in Lego Retail stores.