Timesuck with Dan Cummins - 228 - The Strange Story of Serial Killer Israel Keyes
Episode Date: January 25, 2021Possibly the most meticulous Serial Killer the world has ever known, Israel Keyes spent years planning murders all across North America. Burying what he dubbed “murder kits” in various locations a...cross the United States, he would travel thousands of miles to uncover a kit, racking up lots of frequent flier and rental car miles - before picking a random victim to slaughter. This careful planning, and the extreme lengths to distance himself from any connection to the disappearances of his victims, kept him from being captured for years. But then, in 2012, he got sloppy and attempted to get $30,000 in ransom money for the safe return of a young barista who lived just a few miles from his house. A barista he'd already raped and murdered. Today's tale is a crazy one. And Israel's murders and other crimes may be the least interesting aspect of his story. He was raised by paranoid, anti-government, white supremacists spiritual seekers and he spent most of his childhood living in a one-room cabin with no electricity or running water, being homeschool by zealots. Watch the Suck on YouTube: https://youtu.be/RVS-50M_Cjw Merch - https://badmagicmerch.com/ Discord! https://discord.gg/tqzH89v Want to join the Cult of the Curious private Facebook Group? Go directly to Facebook and search for "Cult of the Curious" in order to locate whatever current page hasn't been put in FB Jail :) For all merch related questions/problems: store@badmagicproductions.com (copy and paste) Please rate and subscribe on iTunes and elsewhere and follow the suck on social media!! @timesuckpodcast on IG and http://www.facebook.com/timesuckpodcast Wanna become a Space Lizard? We're over 10,000 strong! Click here: https://www.patreon.com/timesuckpodcast Sign up through Patreon and for $5 a month you get to listen to the Secret Suck, which will drop Thursdays at Noon, PST. You'll also get 20% off of all regular Timesuck merch PLUS access to exclusive Space Lizard merch. You get to vote on two Monday topics each month via the app. And you get the download link for my new comedy album, Feel the Heat. Check the Patreon posts to find out how to download the new album and take advantage of other benefits.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Do you remember where you were on February 2nd, 2012?
Maybe not specifically that day, but around that day.
What were you doing, where were you living?
It was only nine years ago.
I was touring, finishing working out some material
for a stand-up comedy album called Hear This.
I'd go on to record a few months later in May of that year.
It was breaking up with a girl I dated for about nine months
in Santa Monica, likely taped an episode of a silly show
called World's Dumbest, Around That Date If Not On It.
It was a Thursday.
If I wasn't spending that night in the little apartment I lived in on the edge of Santa
Monica and Bundy and West LA, right, kind of where West LA and Santa Monica meet, I was
on the road somewhere doing a show.
And while I was probably out telling jokes somewhere, a few months before I would meet my
wife, Lindsay, 18 year old high school senior, Samantha Koneck was being
kidnapped by a sexual sadist and true predator. Well, working at a little drive through
coffee shop in Anchorage, Alaska. Following her kidnapping and investigation, of course,
ensued. The FBI was brought in. And finally, Israel keys was arrested. When investigators first caught him,
they thought a kidnapping might have been his only offense.
Far from it,
Israel keys had gone undetected by police for years,
since he started his terrible career of murder and mayhem,
possibly even probably as early as 1996.
Many new Israel keys as a father of boyfriend
and army veteran,
the owner of keys construction and
anchorage. He was the second oldest of 10 children who'd had a very unconventional upbringing, to say the
least. But then he seemed to have made a life for himself, a nice normal life, but he had not, not even
close. The real Israel keys, the one he had hid from family and friends far from normal. The real
keys just knew what mask to wear to fool everyone around him.
It was really good at that.
He knew that he had to be if he wanted to keep living free.
He knew that no one who knew the real Israel keys would accept him for who he was because
who he was was a monster.
The real Israel keys was a serial killer kidnapper, bank robber, arsonist, rapist, cold and
calculating.
Keys was a master of all things related to murder who studied biographies and novels about
serial killers, learning how to perfect his dark craft.
We'll never know how many people he really killed, only the few murders he confessed to.
If Israel Keys had been killing for years and years prior to his capture for over a decade,
how did he go undetected?
What insane lengths did he go to
to make sure his murders wouldn't be traced back to him?
We explore all that and so much more
on today's horrific as fuck sociopathic,
true crime, so many flights
and so many rental cars edition of Time Suck.
This is Michael McDonald and you're listening
to Time Suck,'re listening to Time Sun.
Yeah.
Have you Monday, meat sacks?
Hail Nimrod, Hail Lucid Fina,
praise both jangles and serenade us
through some true crime, darkness,
Michael motherfuckin McDonald.
You see, you ever gonna listen to this podcast, by the way.
How much is it gonna creep him out if he ever does?
I'm Dan Cummins, Operation Paperclip, Paper Shredder,
Shrub Slut Support Group Counselor,
Kroles Cafe Bus Boy, and you are listening to Time Suck.
30% off, last chance sale for a lot of the 2020 merch.
We have a badmagicmerch.com to make room
for some 2021 goodies.
Sale runs from the release of this episode,
by the time you hear it, to this Friday, January 29th
at midnight, Pacific time, store at badmagicproductions.com.
That's the email if you have any merch questions
or concerns.
And that's it today.
All right, we're just, we just burned through
just a tiny little announcement.
And now let's get to some show.
Let's, let's yip yip yia this shit and just get into it.
It's shit bird of clock.
Time to learn about Israel keys.
We've talked a little about the unorganized versus organized dichotomy in other time sucks
before regarding serial killers.
How serial killers usually fall into one of these two categories,
created by FBI profiler John Douglas,
and FBI profiler Robert Restler,
who we covered in episode 203 about the behavioral science unit.
Douglas and Restler found that serial killers,
yeah, usually organized or disorganized.
Not always, but often,
either meticulous planners who do things like stock weaponry
and clean up after themselves, such as Wichita's Dennis Raider, aka BTK, or Washington States Ted Bundy before his final
few days of freedom, or they're disorganized, people who suffer psychotic episodes, or otherwise
too mentally disturbed to be capable of organized kills, like Richard Chase, the vampire of Sacramento.
People who maybe don't intellectually
fully understand what they're doing,
like Wisconsin's skin suit in the moonlight
wearing Google Ed Geen.
This organized killers murdered much more randomly,
leaving chaos in their wakes,
typically not worrying about leaving evidence behind,
which is scarier.
Is it more terrifying to think about someone stalking you,
right, maybe staking you out for weeks or months, or that you could be the victim of some random
murderous choice made in the spur of the moment by someone who just seen you for the first
time.
Both pretty scary.
Have I ever mentioned before that my dad is an organized serial killer?
He hasn't been caught yet, but he's talked to me a lot about it.
And I have an uncle who was arrested years ago who was a very disorganized serial killer.
So I've thought about this more than most
and growing up really hard to say,
like, you know, which guys scared me the most.
Israel Keys, outside of his last murder
and the crimes that followed it
was the perfect example of a very organized killer.
Ultra organized.
He'd say to investigators,
there's always a specific way I wanted things done.
And I have the whole thing planned out. I have everything I need to do it. He never randomly
went on a trip to search for a victim. He did randomly choose his victims, though, based on
opportunity. He often looked for victims at parks, cemeteries, campgrounds, anywhere where there
would be few witnesses. In one interview, he said, glibly, people never expected this stuff to
happen to him. Yeah, who fucking would? Although he never confirmed it, the FBI believes, be few witnesses. In one interview, he said, glibly, people never expected this stuff to happen
to him. Yeah, who fucking would? Although he never confirmed that the FBI believes keys murdered
11 total victims, he would only ever tell them the number was less than 12. But considering
he was an expert liar, able to give his entire murderous double life, you know, secret for
or keep it secret for possibly over a decade from everyone who knew him. Can we trust this
count? It could be lower lower, could be much higher.
Also speaking of line, my dad is not a serial killer,
that I'm aware of.
I don't have an uncle who is a serial killer, probably.
Do you have a fucking couple weird uncles?
And you know, to be totally transparent,
I don't always know where my dad is, you know, so who knows?
You know, he has kind of a temper.
A lot of things are possible.
Back to keys though. He was getting away are possible. Back to Keyes though.
He was getting away with his murders less than a decade ago.
There's recently, he's 2012.
What else was going on that year?
Let's explore that a little bit.
Gangnam style.
Rain, Supreme of over America.
Remember that?
50 shades of gray scandalized the nation,
the London Olympics warmed our hearts,
the twilight saga tragically ended.
I forgot about Gang of Style, right?
The Wulphum Gang of Style.
That whole dance.
Oh my God.
I remember the kids doing dance that song
when Lindsay and I first started dating.
I remember watching a Dodgers game in LA,
where they started playing that and saying
like everybody in this stadium knew the lyrics
and knew the dance.
Oh, Sai, he's still out there somewhere making music,
making tons of money.
The official video video for that song, by the way, has almost 4 billion views on YouTube.
I guess it's insane.
On 2012, President Barack Obama was the first president to publicly give support of same
sex marriage.
The Aurora Colorado shooting took place that summer.
Hurricane Sandy devastated the Northeast.
The Sandy Hook shooting devastated the country in December.
Alaska in 2012, where keys lived,
was predicted to exceed $8.9 billion in revenue
from the oil industry,
rising oil prices, good for the state economy,
but not Alaska residents,
because they had to pay more for everything
that was imported into the state,
which was, or anything that was imported into state,
which is basically everything.
Alaska's economy is mostly run
from natural resources like oil, minerals and forestry.
A lot of people did make good money living in Alaska in 2012.
You wanna see 2012 now, because of 2020.
I never set it back that way back then though, 2012.
The median income for an Alaska and family
that year was 67,712 compared to 51,371 for the average
US family. Construction company owners like Israel Keys, working in Anchorage made on average
about $60,587 a good money. Good money, but not like crazy, amazing money, not enough money to
explain the extensive traveling, rooms rental cars uh... flights
the keys will take in the suck
seems that some bank robberies and other crimes of theft may have padded his
income substantially
we're going to that today
uh... two thousand twelve anchorages population was two hundred ninety eight
thousand two hundred thirty three sizeable chunk of alaska total population
well under a million
uh... between seven eight hundred thousand and enough for a careful sadist like he's to lurk about undetected for quite some time.
We've been to Anchorage before here in the suckverse with serial killer Robert the butcher baker Hansen,
subject of episode 148. Also in 2012, like I mentioned up top, a young woman was murdered in Anchorage,
one of at least 30 people to be murdered in Alaska that year. In 18-year-old Berista, Samantha Coneg was kidnapped and killed, taken a gunpoint from her
job at a little drive-through coffee stand that sat near a home depot and an eye-hop on
a busy road.
Security footage shows her given coffee to the customer, suddenly jumping back, holding
her hands up.
She then turns off the lights.
A large man comes into the drive-through window, proceeds to walk Samantha out of the coffee shop into his vehicle.
Three weeks later, a text from Samantha sent her boyfriend's phone,
instructing him to go to a nearby park to find a ransom note.
The note shows a picture of Samantha and demands $30,000 for her safe return.
A return that will be impossible. No one knew at the time, but in the picture of her used for
the ransom note, she was already deceased. Over the following weeks, a nationwide manhunt led by the FBI
would track Samantha's kidnapper through his ATM withdrawals. And after weeks of hoping
and praying that she was still alive, Samantha's friends and family informed that she had
been murdered. Her body dismembered dumped into the frozen lake, uh, Madanuska. The one
and only fortunate thing related to her death was that it finally led
investigators to Israel keys.
He went up to a lot of shady shit for a very long time and had he not been caught
following her murder, he would have undoubtedly killed again and again and again.
He said as much to investigators who's a bad, bad dude, who let a strange, strange
life.
Let's learn about his life today in today's time suck timeline.
Shrap on those boots, soldier.
We're marching down a time suck timeline.
On January 7th, 1978, Israel keys, no middle name, born in Kov-U-Tah, tiny little 400
and some person, census designated community, off of highway 91 near the Utah Idaho border.
It looks creepy.
It looks like a place that would have a cold compound.
Sorry if this cost me a lot of Kov-U-Tah listeners, but I don't think I'm ever going to go there.
Keys is born to parents Heidi and John Jeffrey Keys, the two had met as teenagers and their
native Los Angeles.
It was the second oldest of 10 siblings, the oldest son.
Most of the siblings' names have not been made public.
We know he had at least four sisters, Autumn Rose, Hosanna, Sunshine, and Charity.
Don't know other ages.
Don't know much about his siblings.
The keys family went to great lengths to live off the grid, not leave a paper trail.
All the other kids have kept pretty quiet for the most part about their brother since his
arrest for years.
Many of them never had birth certificates or social security numbers just because of the
way they were raised.
We'll get into that.
These kids had a very unique childhood.
Heidi and John Keyes, not normal parents,
not even fucking close.
I was guessing they might not be super traditional
just based on the names of their kids that we know.
No Kims and Annie's,
Hosanna, Israel, Sunshine.
They chose to have their 10 kids at home
because, quote, hospitals had too many rules. That's what they told so what few friends they had.
Jeff hated doctors, didn't believe in modern medicine, big anti-vaxxer conspiracy dude.
None of the children would ever have social security numbers until they left his house or
go to school.
Really big off the grid guy.
If he would have had the money, I have no doubt he would have built the family a big
compound, complete with the Doomsday bunker, you know, daily multi hour long prayer slash apocalypse
preparation meetings, paranoid wackadoodle for sure.
I like to hear different, different viewpoints, so I don't get lost in some little echo chamber,
but I honestly don't think I could be friends with anyone who hates doctors or just doesn't
believe in modern medicine.
It's just such an absurd belief system.
Fear big pharma's evil empire, the illuminati web of deceit,
all the healing you need comes from mother nature and God,
duh, you don't need a vaccine.
Let's go chew on some elderberry roots.
Pray away that virus.
Brings some apple cider vinegar.
You just gotta get your root vinegar ratio right
and you'll live 120 years without ever setting foot
in a filthy, heathen hospital.
Doctors don't go to medical school to heal, wake up, sheeple.
They go to learn how to rob, lie, spread their new world,
orders, globalist agenda,
yay lack of a good education.
They need to fear in paranoia.
Initially Mormons,
keys his parents sometime early in his childhood when he's around the
age of four, Heidi and John converted to an extreme form of Christianity called the
Ark.
Here we go.
I really like what this timeline is starting.
No boring, how did such a dirt bag come out of such a nice family snooze fest here?
No starting this shit off in the suburbs, some emotionally distant father, maybe a domineering mother, but otherwise traditional childhood.
No, sir, getting straight to crazy.
Uh, when Israel and the siblings learned to read, it was to memorize scripture, no secular
bullshit, no comic books, no fucking socialist fairy tales, no hearty boys, Nancy drew
bullshit.
What's Nancy wearing on that cover?
A skirt?
Ha ha!
The barely covers her knees. Are you fucking, are you kidding me? Back to the shrubs shrubs, slut. Keep away
from our innocent brood, Harlett. In the Keyes patriarch and matriarch switched religions.
They also switched locations. They moved to just north of Colville, Washington to live
in a tiny one room cabin that John Jeffrey built himself while he and the family lived
in a tent for a while.
Sweet, living that good tent life.
Flashbacks to the bloody bender suck.
Colville is not far from where I'm recording right now.
It's almost exactly a hundred miles from the suck dungeon, quarter length.
Just a 40 mile drive from the Canadian border.
Almost 5,000 people living in a fairly isolated community far, far from the freeway, far
from so many
wicked sin folk.
We should always so lucky to live in a tent outside of Colville with our batshit crazy
parents, you know, who batshit crazy dad who built an old time, he pioneered homestead
cabin to dwell in and reed scripture by candlelight like we just left the fucking Oregon trail.
Colville seems to be a timber town.
They have what seems based on some googling two sawmills.
A lumber town surrounded by pine forests.
My dad calls towns like this God's country.
He says stuff like that when he's not serial killing, you know.
I might reference that with my dad a lot today, you know,
just enough.
So some people start to really wonder,
is he a serial killer?
He's been saying that a lot.
And I want to do that just because I'm sick
and it amuses me.
Officially incorporated in 1890 in an area settled in the 1820s. Colville literally designed for lumber.
The roads built super wide, wide enough to allow a 16 horse team of log hauling horses to turn a load of logs in the street.
Very cute little downtown based on pictures.
I've been through once but years ago, and I don't really remember.
Colville seems to be doing well for small community. And I'm sure being from an area
similar to Colville, it has no shortage of John Jeffrey Keys paranoid conspiracy types.
After more years, brought the family more babies, Israel and his sisters would spend
these summer months sleeping in a tent outside. Then in the roughest months of the winter,
Heidi started taking the children to her. mom's trailer in Palm Springs because there just wasn't enough room for everyone
of the family to stay in that little cabin. It all sounds so terrible.
Except for the Palm Springs part, at least they escaped to Palm Springs in the winners
for a while. Love Palm Springs. When things open up again in Southern California, if you
want a nice weekend at an LA, if you love mid-century modern architecture, laid back bars,
solid food truck scene, great hotels, head to Palm Springs.
Lindsay had one of the best weekends there. I don't play golf. It's great golf town.
Tons of spots. When not among civilization of Palm Springs went out in their little
cabin, the keys family, the grew to 12 members lived way off the grid. They lived very simply.
They're, they're a little shack cabin, no heat, no electricity, of course, no AC
then, no TV, no phone, nothing.
No one of this motherfucker turned into a serial killer.
I love the outdoors, but also love modern living.
No electricity, no TV, get the fuck out of here.
If one of those people who could just never find anything good to watch on TV, there's
all these channels, but there's nothing on, you're just not trying hard enough.
There's a lot of good stuff.
The keys, homes home school, their children
avoided interactions with the government
and law enforcement at all costs.
They avoided interactions with most of their neighbors.
They didn't want to risk the souls of their children
by interacting with too many people
who didn't believe exactly what they did.
It's so crazy.
They had very little contact with the outside world
except for John Jeffery's job as a maintenance man.
Heidi was to stay at home mom as the kids were, you know, stay stay in the cabin, stay in
the tent kids.
Why live this way?
It was the lifestyle demanded or mandated.
I tried to combine demanded and mandated in one word.
It was the lifestyle mandated by the arc.
What exactly is the arc?
In a word, insane.
Let me describe it now with more than one word.
The arc and the Christian covenant church that the keys family would later attend
preached Christian identity theology. And Christian identity is not very Christian, it's terrible.
It's a uniquely anti-Semitic and racist theology. Christian in name only, it asserts that white people, not Jews,
white European people, those of European white descent, the true Israelites favored by God
in the Bible. Identity believers often described themselves as the true Israel. The local
arch church was pastored in Colville by 83 year old Dan Henry who preached that white
people were the superior, chosen race, and that the Bible was their story, and no one else's.
He preached that the Jews literally biologically descended from Satan.
Fun.
What fun stuff to be taught by all the adults you trust around you, and to have no other
opposing voices because your family basically lives on a tiny compound because your dad
makes you live in a weird fucking tent, a homestead situation.
The keys family were close with a fellow arch churchers, the keyhose, who like them lived
north of town off the grid.
The two families lived about a half mile apart off a ladden road, and the keyhose were
just as bad shit crazy as the Keys.
I had no idea all this stuff was happened, you know, from people who came from Colville.
Israel was good friends with Chevy and Shani,
I believe it's says, Keeho.
Two guys who are now serving lengthy prison sentences
in connection with a deadly rampage
they conducted in the name of the Aryan Republican Army,
which included Chevy Keeho's 1996 torture murder
of a whole family, a family of three in Arkansas.
So much murder has come from a few dudes, a family of three in Arkansas.
So much murder has come from a few dudes who spent most of their childhoods just outside
of Colville.
An old A&E criminal justice series called American Justice profiled Chevy Keyho's white supremacist
motivations on season 10 episode 14 raised on hate that originally aired on August 8,
2001.
We can do a whole suck on these two brothers.
Chevy will likely, very likely die in prison.
He's serving three sentences of life in prison
without the possibility of parole for the three murders.
One of the murders, an eight year old girl,
real hateful piece of shit.
His brother, Cheney Keo,
served a 24 year sentence for Fologus Assault,
attempted murder, and carrying a concealed weapon
connected to a 1997 shootout with police in Ohio. year sentence for philonious assault, attempted murder, and carrying a concealed weapon connected
to a 1997 shootout with police in Ohio.
A shootout he got in with his brother.
And these guys were Israel's neighbors and his buddies growing up.
These guys went to the same church with him.
He grew up just surrounded by so much insanity.
Both families eventually grew tired of the arc.
I don't know, maybe not crazy enough or racist enough for them or something.
They started attending another Christian identity church
in the area, Colville just ripe with fringy weirdos
in the 80s apparently.
They started attending the Christian Israel Covenant Church.
It feels like it's probably a splinter group.
Doesn't say in the sources,
but it feels like this splintered out
from that first church, headed by Pastor Dan Henry.
Henry was a hateful, crazy white supremacist
who moved from Nevada to Colville
to open this church in the 1975.
Israel would also later admit to investigators
that when the Oklahoma City bombing happened
on April 19th, 1995,
many of the people at this church
thought Timothy McVeigh
an admitted white supremacist was nothing short of a hero.
More on the Oklahoma City
bombing, check out episode 181. In the early 90s, keys becomes a troubled teenager, not even a little
surprise here. He did shit like breaking into his neighbor's homes to steal their guns, then he'd
wait outside for them to come home. So he could, he could watch them freak out when they noticed that
their stuff was missing, like to watch the rage. It's kind of weird.
Rebelled a little bit harder than the average teenager.
Keys also enjoyed not just hunting animals, but torturing them because he's a budding
sociopath.
One day, one of his sister's cats got into the trash, I guess, one too many times because
apparently he had to clean it up.
So to punish this cat, Israel took a cord tied it to a tree.
He tied the other end of the, around the cat's neck and then shot at the cat until it wrapped itself
around the tree and choked itself to death.
And then he did not have a reaction of,
what the fuck did I just do?
Oh my God, holy shit.
I need to get counseling immediately.
Now he's just like, yeah, whatever, cool.
His childhood is starting to sound more and more like
fodder for a resident dark comic,
Steph Cox curvy, Bizarre World, Jeff Foxworthy,
to make a time suck routine out of.
If you was raised in a tent in a one room cabin,
my Christian identity zealots,
and your hobbies was watching neighbors
frantically search for gun yeast dough
and shooting at your sister's cat, you might be killer.
Neighbor said that keys was awkward, quiet,
a loner makes sense,
given how isolated his family was.
Once keys did speak to a neighbor about a deer he killed,
and he freaked this neighbor out.
Talking to a neighbor about a deer he killed,
a very common thing to do,
a place like Colville, not unusual.
How he killed this deer though, extremely unusual.
He said that his first shot didn't kill the deer, but did incapacitated.
And then instead of shooting it in the head to put it out of its misery, or at least
slicing its throat to let it die relatively quickly and painlessly, he decided to slowly
gut it while it was still alive.
This was troubling enough for this neighbor.
And then others, when word got out to avoid Israel after that, starts getting a reputation as just a fucking weirdo, a dark weirdo. If when you was hung growing up,
you shot to wound and not to kill. So you could slowly get your dear to death. You might be a killer.
Young Israel was creeping out other country folks outside of Colville, right? I'm guessing that
wasn't real easy to do
he uh... keys would later say that he knew begin at the age of fourteen
this ideas did not conform with societies
the things he thought were okay and normal
while we're things society considered the opposite
what an interesting way of admitting that you had long been a sadistic
conscious list monster
uh... some point is teens
he also secretly gave up on Christianity,
the strange and hateful form that his nutty parents had been pushing on him. He did this,
you know, it doesn't tell them at this point. He keeps participating in the activities of the church
to keep up public appearances. And he doesn't have a real choice at this age unless he was willing
to run away to, you know, actually leave the church. You know, parents who move their family off
the grid, who have, who hate doctors, who hate the government,
who subscribe to some extreme religious ideology,
very racist ideology don't seem to me
like the kind of people to just say like,
oh yeah, cool, no problem.
Oh yeah, we don't care if you don't wanna go anymore.
You do you buddy, you know, when you tell them you're done.
Strongly assuming the keys household
was very authoritarian and patriarchal.
Israel when he's 14 believed to have been one of two teenage boys in the keys household was very authoritarian and patriarchal.
Israel when he's 14 believed to have been one of two teenage boys in the keys family
who showed up along with those murder neighbors, Chevy and Shaney Keeho.
At a 1992 rally near Colville where humans' rights activists were attempting to organize
and counter a growing number of racists and neo-Nazis in the area.
So 14 years old, he's rallying against human rights. Parents are probably
proud. 1994 to age 16 Israel builds his first log cabin by hand in Stevens County, Washington
on his parents' property. Move in, even though his mother protested. I don't know what
exactly she was protesting there. Son, why are you such a hurry to leave our wondrous tent?
Why can't you just stay in our tiny cabin with the other 11 of us?
What do you need privacy for for sitting?
1994, he's the rest of a shoplifting locally,
gets off with community service, parents, you know,
obviously not happy.
After his arrest, they search his cabin
and they find stolen guns.
His parents make him return these guns to their neighbors
and then move back into their cabin
and be because even though this happened in the nineteen nineties not the eighteen
nineties he has to chop firewood to pay his victims back
uh... israel is furious
right what really he steals a bunch of his neighbors guns and somehow he's the
asshole
uh... he actually was really mad
he thought his parents were being very hypocritical
uh... they'd encourage him to hunt even though they knew he was poaching, that's illegal.
They had no problem eating this technically illegal meat.
You know, they never questioned him about where he got the guns.
He was using to hunt these animals with.
So it's okay for him to hunt illegally,
but what, he can't shoplift.
He truly didn't get it.
And I can truly picture this dude in his dysfunctional family.
Israel is almost exactly the same age as me.
He graduated a year behind me, actually,
we grew up in similar places.
I knew a family similar to his off the grid types,
paranoid types, living in cabins outside of town.
What a terrible way to grow up.
So, included in ignorance
without literally one decent open-minded
educated person in your life.
Not one.
How do you not end up some Some kind of fucked up after that.
March 2nd, 1996.
Israel Keys is now an 18 year old psychopath,
living with his crazy family outside of Colville.
He's a dude who likes to shoot at cats,
steal guns, gut deer while they're still alive.
He's a violent white supremacist
whose best friends are other violent white supremacists.
And at the age of 18,
he also seems to have likely become a murderer.
On March 2nd, a 12-year-old callville girl named Julie Harris disappears while walking to church.
Julie was a special Olympics athlete who had two prosthetic feet. She'd want a gold medal in
downhill skiing. She was five foot one, 115 pounds, funny bit of a prankster, good kid.
Last conversation she'd had with her mom had not been a pleasant one.
Julie's mom shared a told her that since her grades were suffering,
she would not be able to attend the special Olympics that year.
You know, Julie's furious.
Julie's mother and her brother then left the house,
leaving Julie alone with her mom's boyfriend,
who would become a suspect.
Julie then went to wait by the side of the road for her neighbors
to get picked up and take into church.
But when the neighbors got there, Julie was gone. At first, Julie's mom
thought that Julie ran away. Angry about the situation with this special Olympics.
But police later reported she had last been seen, quote, with a man in a trench coat.
Then about a month after she was reported missing on March 3, Julie's prosthetic feet are found
near where the Colville River flows into Lake Roosevelt,
Lake Roosevelt, excuse me, at Kettle Falls.
And a year later, the following spring on Saturday, April 26, 1997, her skeletal remains
found by children playing three miles southwest of Colville.
In the vicinity of Holler Creek Road and Rital Creek, dental records will confirm the
bones belong to Julie.
Initially, police thought sharingerry and boyfriend were involved
uh... and then you know possibly just a boyfriend uh... they are actually still
considered persons of interest by the police but no charges have ever been brought
against them
many believe that julie was israel keys first victim
sherry didn't know it at the time but after seeing a picture of him
uh... she remembered him frequently being at the house that Julie used to visit.
Jerry said that she had an icky feeling about keys when she saw him and Julie's friends also had
allegedly seen keys talking to Julie at the local swimming pool. The stuff all came out, you know,
kind of much later. And then the fact that she was born with a physical disability,
even though she could ski with prosthetics, she did, she did still struggle to walk.
This fact may have increased her odds of becoming the victim of a serial killer. Many of them do seem to pray on those they can easily
overpower, especially at first, smaller women, women, children, someone with some kind of disability,
someone that can be easily physically overpowered, while a buddy in serial killer is building confidence.
Keys has never formally been connected with Julie's murder, but her mom remains convinced
that her daughter was his first victim. No word on whether or not he wore a trench coat
around that time, but seems exactly like the kind of dude who wore a trench coat in 1996,
doesn't he? Backing up a bit, Keys got a job in 1995 in Calville. When he was 17, it
last until 1997, when the family moves
He worked in callville for a contractor named Kelly Harris and he learns the construction skills He'll use to become a contractor himself later
I guess his parents didn't think working in construction was too devilish. Hey Jesus. What's Carpenter?
So they let him do it and early 1997 sometime around June the keys family moves to Mopin, Oregon and
19 year old Israel moves with them.
Now why do they move because they're insane.
This is so ridiculous.
Israel had begun to date his contract, contract or boss's daughter and he wrote in his journal
that he was having sexual thoughts about her.
They weren't doing anything.
Nothing all, but he was having sexual thoughts.
Holy shit.
A 19 year old heterosexual male having sexual thoughts. Holy shit.
A 19 year old heterosexual male having sexual thoughts
about a girl, his own age.
What the fuck?
Why not grab the devil's actual dick and gag on it, Israel?
Be gone, those defina.
That selfish, dirty purve,
puttin' his entire family's spiritual lives in great peril.
Obviously I'm being ridiculous.
And the way I'm presenting this,
but this actually would be part of the family's motivation
to move.
Israel's parents forbid their grown-ass son
from seeing this girl anymore.
She was not part of their church, right?
When they learned of his disgusting sexual yearning
when someone came across his journal,
found out, is like a fucking big emergency meeting
in the family.
Also Israel's sister, Autumn Rose,
she was having a spiritual crisis.
This is even more ridiculous.
And she told her parents about it.
She was literally worried about her soul.
And this was the tipping point that led them
to fleeing from Colville's sin folk.
Autumn Rose, apparently, a few months earlier,
I don't know, doesn't say exactly when,
but you know, some time earlier to her spiritual crisis,
you might wanna sit down for this.
She started listening to Christian secular music,
uh-huh, modern music.
Maybe even Creed, and it was given her new thoughts,
watching Scott's step, gyrate his Satan hips around
with his arms wide open.
She doesn't say she listened to Creed,
but they were getting pretty popular, you know,
around this time.
She may have even listened to Striper.
That Christian metal band,
we wouldn't put it now Christian,
but maybe still kind of naughty but rock.
Since 1984, they had that big album
and track of the same name in 1986 to Hell with the Devil.
We'll speak up and down.
Sing it Striper.
We know when we're mine. Get him out of here.
Okay, good. Get him out of here.
We got him, Dave. He is a liar to be.
Huh?
Ah, they really bring it, don't they?
Wait, oh, way for the chorus
This work is crazy
Sorry what what
Whoa guys, I think you meant to heck with the devil gosh dang
Pretty scary how they didn't even notice Satan slipping into their own tune about San away from Satan.
Anyway, Autumn Rose Keys, you know, she's apparently listening to a profane filth like this.
She starts watching movies that weren't, you know, specifically made for a Christian audience, you know, but supposedly good.
That's how he fucking gets you. That's how they double get you.
You know, she's watching stuff, you know, maybe like 1996's Matilda.
I'm sorry, what? This is illegal. Oh, oh my god. Oh my god. Do you
have a job? Uh-huh. But don't people need good cars? Oh, Matilda, do you hear that? She
just disrespected her father. How was she not immediately and savagely beaten, right?
She did not honor her father.
My gosh.
It's one scene alone.
Could have just thrown the entire key's family's faith
into the toilet.
Matilda's dad unfortunately does not stone her to death,
following that transgression.
Because of these corrupting influences.
I'm not, I'm being ridiculous about this,
but it really was this level of nonsense.
Autumn Rose felt her face was being eroded.
She was having a spiritual crisis.
According to an interview with Autumn Rose many years later, because her parents felt
like the devil was corrupting their family in Colville.
Colville, Washington, aka the beating heart of Biel's above, her dad decided the keys,
family needed to get out quick, right?
Find a godly or locale to live in.
This family is so crazy.
I love it.
Story wise, I love it.
So fleeing from sand, the keys move to Mopin.
Mopin is maybe just as remote as Calville,
but much smaller, right?
Less centers around 400 people total.
Not sure how many heathens census doesn't give that information.
It's a little whitewater rafting town on the DeShoot River.
Very similar to where I grew up in size and industry, not too far from where I grew up. Very outdoorsy,
hunting, fishing, rafting, hiking, and also I'm guessing plenty of be afraid of the big
bad Satanic government. Get off the grid, paranoid conspiracy types, living, you know, far
from the freeway in this little area. The Keys family live again in tents on some raw
land outside of town while
Israel and his dad build them another shitty no electricity no plumbing nothing having cabin
right after the keys move in something bad happens to a local woman in the area
where violent crime rates usually hover around that shit doesn't happen here
weird somewhere between June 1st and September 1st, 1997, Israel later claims he kidnapped and
raped a woman near Mopin. She was the only victim he ever claimed to release alive.
Has he lied about this? Maybe, you know, this woman's never came forward, whoever she is,
FBI investigators who interrogated and interviewed him. Don't think he was lying about this.
He's told them he didn't want to kill her. She, that he wanted to excuse me. He did want to kill her, but she begged him to let her go.
And then he did.
And he said he later regretted this saying to investigators,
I wasn't violent enough.
He didn't worry. She would turn him in.
He said, I made up my mind.
I was never going to let that happen again.
This is way back in 97.
Also in June and 97, right when the keys were moving to Oregon before Israel left,
he stayed a month behind for some reason.
It's never made clear.
And another little girl goes missing in Colville, not normal at all for two little girls to go
missing from such a small town and later have their murdered bodies found for both murders
to occur in a period of less than 18 months.
For the girls to disappear from a town, you know, we, we now know has a known
serial killer or had one living there, you know, a killer who was there when the girls
went missing. This is a wee bit suspicious, obviously. He's would never be charged with
either killing, but clearly it doesn't look good. Just like, you know, with Julie Cassie Emerson,
yeah, 12 years old when she disappeared, she lived with her mom Marlene in a trailer
was reported missing after the trailer was destroyed by Arson.
Her mother's body found inside.
He's would never admit to killing Cassie or Julie,
or the, you know, to Cassie's mother,
but later he would tell investigators
that the first thing he ever burned down was a trailer.
So even more suspicious.
Cassie's remains found the following April 1998
in the woods near
Kettle Falls, a 13 minute drive from Colville. And when her body was found based on how it was
disposed of, local law enforcement did connect it to Julie. Since remains of both girls were found
so long after they've been killed, investigators weren't able to determine if either of them
had been sexually assaulted prior to being killed. Israel will be long gone by the time Casties
remains were found.
Shortly after the summer of 1997, the family moves again.
This time they moved to North of Malone, New York to live on 10 acres land near the Canadian border and a shitty dilapidated old farmhouse. Of course, no electricity running water.
Again, not clear why they made this move probably too much sin in Oregon.
Maybe pop a keys found a found a Scott Stap poster hidden
in one of his daughter's beds again, huh?
Maybe found a striper CD.
To hell with the devil.
Gosh dang, guys, easy with the HG double hockey sticks.
My ears are burning.
Then the family except for Israel moves to Smurna main where they join an Amish community
and start making honey.
So fucking weird.
John Jeffrey Heidi, the fam minus Israel, now they're Amish, because why not?
Israel is done at this point.
He's tired of moving around.
He's tired of following his parents in sane spiritual quest to seemingly live among
whomever they think is the least sinful.
When his family moves to main, Kees informs his parents to earn an argument with him
about not wanting to move with them,
that he's no longer Christian.
Hasn't been for years, he's sick of it.
And his dad responds by disowning his sinful son.
Literally ends their relationship forever.
Says a lot about what kind of motherfucker he is.
Right, I doubt God would approve of him
being such a terrible father.
Crazy ass isalot.
There are also rumors he'd been physically abusing Israel and all the other kids for years,
you know, abused him constantly when they're growing up.
Of course he did.
Definitely a hardcore spare of the rod and spoiled a child type vibe with that guy.
Keys would keep and lose contact with his mom and siblings, but, you know, no longer
ever having any contact with his dad after this and no longer
part of their strengths, it'll flock in the same way and would not be again going forward.
His family would keep moving.
You don't know exactly every place they lived years later after his dad's death, four sisters
in Heidi would end up in Indianapolis, Indiana for a while where they met two young men
Heidi described as street preachers.
Charismatic evangelicals who convinced the keys women to move
nearly 900 miles south to join their congregation slash cult compound. I'll talk about later.
They would move to Dallas and then down to Wells, Texas. Israel leaves upstate New York after
sticking around long enough to study for and get his GED. And then on July 9th, 1998, 20-year-old
Israel travels to New Jersey and enlists in the army.
Two ex-girlfriends would later say he did this as a way to rebel against his parents who
still hated the secular and sinful U.S. government.
Right?
These are the hate of the, just like Westboro Baptist Church-type people, right?
Hate of the military.
He becomes a specialist in the Alpha Company, first battalion, fifth infantry.
The 20-year-old was now six foot two, 230 pounds,
a pure muscle, the saddest, the dude who would likely killed two little girls already raped
another woman, now learning how to become more violent. This is not going to be good for
anyone. From 1998 to 2001, he'll serve first at Fort Hood, Texas, then at Fort Lewis,
Washington. On base, he starts drinking heavily, something he never got to do, live it in, you know, shitty
cabins and tents with his fun, hate and parents. He said later, he liked to binge drink, but
never felt like he had a drinking problem because he could stop at any time. He could go
through weeks of training without touching the stuff. I don't know, I think that part
is pretty normal. Also tried LSD and cocaine, also pretty normal to me. Overall, it seems
like he actually kicked ass in the military. Members of his platoon would later call him a super soldier to investigators, someone who could carry
over a hundred pounds on a 15 mile march. You started watching football games that are
guys, you know, just doing more normal things, going to some concerts. He went to a red hot
chili peppers and stone temple pilots concert at Kierina in Seattle on September 22, 2000.
Actually saw that same tour, saw the same show three nights earlier
in the Spokane Arena.
So, you know, things are getting crazy.
Red Hot Chili Pepper, she's turned his back
on his family values.
I don't know if you know this,
but they've done a lot of drugs over the years, you guys.
They've had a lot of sex before marriage.
They sing about it.
Yeah.
They use language, you know, even more sinful,
then striper.
Also in his psychiatric evaluation, he tells a military doctor he had known he was bisexual
for a while.
He had accepted that about himself.
Man, if he had told his dad that, I'm guessing his dad's head might have literally fucking
exploded. Now, let's back up about a year after he joined the army.
On September 28th, 1999, Israel rents a vehicle from an enterprise in rental car, you know,
company in Lakewood, Washington.
November 26th, he rents from Yousave in Fort Lewis, Washington.
November 29th, he rents from a different vehicle from Yousave in Fort Lewis.
January 4th, 2000, he rents a vehicle from a budget rental car from you save in Fort Lewis, January 4th, 2000, he
rents a vehicle from a budget rental car, a place in Spokane, Washington.
And why do these dates and rentals matter?
Because keys will later admit to investigators that he killed four people in Washington
State, claims, you know, which are the subject of an active investigation still by the FBI,
those dates correspond to the murders.
And as we'll soon learn, renting cars was part
of keys M O from January 15 to June 1, 2000. Keys was deployed to Sinai, Egypt. Unfortunately,
for him, he had to take a short break from his criminal activities to go do his real
job. Maybe he didn't take a break. I don't know. I guess he could have killed over there
too. If he snuck off base to kill some locals, he never alluded to it. On October 1st, 2000, keys makes a down payment on an engagement ring for a girl he's been
in a long distance relationship with for quite some time who lives back in.
Callville, the former boss's daughter, still lost an after, still writing in his journal.
He never forgot about the girl his parents forbade him to see any longer.
You know, they had stayed in lose contact.
Keys had journaled about
her extensively during their time apart. He was mad at himself for not sending up to his
family when they moved to Oregon and, you know, he knew's mad that he didn't just stay with
her at that time. He's already an adult. She said, yes, when he asked her to marry him,
believe in Israel, when he told her that they were both going to be virgins until they
got married, that he was still very religious. A little did she know that by this point, he
had changed a lot. He'd had several sexual relationships.
He'd hired sex workers.
And, you know, he was also sexually attracted
to men in addition to women.
Their storybook reunion would not lead to marriage.
By the spring of 2021, she notices that keys
is acting real strange.
He's been evasive.
Soon he stopped returning her calls.
Why?
Because he'd met another woman in Washington named Tammy got in her pregnant several months earlier
He and Tammy have then broken up for a bit, but now they're getting back together
So he breaks up with little Miss Colville to stay with Tammy and be there for their child
And may of 2001 in Thurston County, Washington keys now going by is
Receives DUI has his license suspended.
This is the only criminal charge or interaction
with law enforcement he'll have until his later arrest
for kidnapping and murder in 2012.
On July 8, 2001, he's is honorably discharged from the army.
Before his discharge, he's received a medal
for a meritorious service for being a gunner
and several other commendations.
Seems from every source we can find that he was a, yeah, by all accounts, an excellent
soldier.
Keys moved then to tiny little Nea Bay, Washington, after he's discharged, living with Tammy
and her eight year old son, Keaton.
Apparently, he was a good, you know, stepdad, they weren't married, but you know, moving
in with Tammy, more rebellion from his past. They're not married. She's pregnant. And the kid who was raised as a white supremacist
is now having a child with a woman who is half, you know, Native American, American Indian
and half black. Is got a job in parks and recreation fixes up their three bedroom, one
bathroom rental to prepare for a kid. Nea Bay was like most of where Israel had lived, small and remote.
It's also the most northwestern point in the entire continental United States.
A census designated place of about 800 people on the Macaw tribal reservation on the northwest
tip of Washington State, far from Seattle or even any big towns.
Hopping about motor about five miles off the coast and you're in Canadian waters.
Then from Nia Bay, Israel does a lot of strange traveling, alone, for a guy who didn't have
a job that required any traveling, really.
All this traveling, investigators believe, was for crimes of various types, sometimes
robberies, sometimes murders, sometimes preparing for future murders and or robberies, hard to
say how many murders he committed on these trips on these trips.
It's so meticulous about covering his tracks.
His Emma was to fly somewhere, Renekar, drive a couple hundred miles away.
Sometimes over a thousand miles away, usually to another state.
He's planned murders long ahead of time to extraordinary measures to avoid detection.
Unlike most serial killers, making traffic, making tracking him,
I got even ever harder,
he didn't have a victim profile.
Yes, the first two supposed murders were 12 year old girls,
but after that, he was all over the place.
He tended to kill far from home,
almost never killed in the same area twice.
On his murder trips is also kept his cell phone turned off,
paid for items with cash for the most part to make it that much harder to track him to any particular location.
He also left murder kits in various locations around the country that contained among other
items, weapons and cash.
The money came from various bank robberies he committed to support his other criminal
activities.
These cash is provided further cover because keys didn't have to risk boarding an airplane
with the weapon or using credit cards that could later connect him to a crime in a particular area.
He would take one trip, go hide his murder kit, then he might return that area to retrieve
it, maybe months later, maybe years later, to actually commit violent crimes.
At least that's what investigators believe.
He's also traveled between cities and states with victims, often killing them, burying
them far from where he had taken them.
He also once he left Colville, hunted only strangers, burying them far from where he had taken them.
He also once he left Colville, hunted only strangers, most of whom, you know, came, he came upon
in remote spots, just campgrounds, boating areas, sometimes even in cemeteries.
He bound victims with plastic ties.
He would run them down quickly, tackle them if they tried to run.
He was a pretty physically, physically imposing dude.
He sexually assaulted, is fixated, his female victims.
He also apparently did a lot of research
about how to be the best killer,
like he literally researched other serial killers,
studied some dark role models.
He admired Ted Bundy very much,
shared several similarities with him,
both were binge drinkers, methodical, intelligent,
built a possession over their victims.
On April 29th, 2002, keys reserved a room
at the Hong Kong Inn in Port Angeles, Washington. Another murder. Why? Or maybe we don't know.
The fall of 2002 is and Tammy's daughter is born, thankfully, at a hospital. I have more
details about her that I could share, but I'm not going to share them today. She seems
like she's tried really hard to keep from being associated with her dad and
who can blame her.
She's a young adult now trying to move on with her life based on not doing any interviews.
It doesn't seem to want anyone reaching out on social media to ask her about her monster
of a father.
Her mom, Tammy, would later talk about how strange life was with is around this time.
She said when he get drunk, he get real weird.
Talk about how we had a black heart. Talk about how we wanted to get an upside down cross tattooed on his chest,
a pentagram on his back that he felt evil. She also said he was very controlling. He insisted
that she do all the housework. He didn't have to tell her what he was up to ever, but she
always had to tell him everything where she was, who she was with, what she was spending money on,
et cetera, where he could just leave town for several days and not have to say shit about it.
I talked down to her and her friends.
It could be incredibly arrogant, almost never talked about his father, apparently asking
about his dad was off limits, but long for his mother's approval.
Just mother, why?
Why don't you love me, mother?
His mom didn't seem that interested in her black sheep's son.
She showed no interest in ever coming to visit them. She never met Tammy, never met their child. Tammy never once
even spoke to Israel's father. Not long after his daughter was born, his dad, John Jeffrey
Keys, passes away on November 13th, 2002. After years of not speaking, Keys attends his
father's funeral to finally say goodbye or to say a final goodbye, excuse me and see
his mom.
And this seems like the best place in this narrative to stop down for a quick sponsor break.
Thank you all so much for supporting this show by supporting our sponsors.
Get those deals, get them.
Well, thanks for listening to our sponsors, Meet Sacks.
I appreciate so much back to story time now, following the death of Israel keys father.
In mid 2003, when Israel and Tammy's daughter is around eight months old,
Tammy is diagnosed with uterine cancer.
She'd had stomach pain since towards the end of her pregnancy.
And now she has a full hysterectomy and she's given opiates for post-surgery pain.
And it seems she developed a pretty powerful opioid addiction.
And that this addiction led to relationship troubles with this.
That and him, you know, being a controlling murderous piece of shit led to relationship troubles.
There was also that Tammy would later say the Israel was taking more unexplained trips that
he wouldn't talk about. I mean, just starting to drift away emotionally. On August 28,
2003, keys takes one of his mystery trips and rents a room at the port side in in Port
Angeles, Washington on October 19th. He again rents a room at the port side in and port angeles washington on October 19th. He again
rents a room at the port side in and port angeles washington. So you have an affair, something more
sinister from February 6th to February 13th 2004. Keys rents a silver Volkswagen Jetta with the
Utah license plate of 267 WVW in Salt Lake City and drives it 522 miles before returning it.
Probably something more sinister with this trip.
By the summer of 2004, things at home really not good between Tammy and Israel.
Tammy's opiate addiction is leaving her sleepy, checked out, interfering strongly with her
ability to parent, is had essentially taken on the role of being a single dead and he decides
to move out with his daughter to a nearby house. still living on the reservation where according to numerous others who
lived there at the time, he was considered quite the catch.
He was a hard worker devoted to his daughter, real handy, able to fix anything, also muscular,
pretty good looking dude, and apparently hot in the sack.
Not kidding.
Tamulator described him as the best lover she'd ever had.
He would date several other local women
on the reservation in 2004,
and take more mystery trips.
It would take at least one more mystery trip in 2004
from October six to the 16th,
took a Southwest Airlines flight from Seattle,
Washington to Manchester, New Hampshire.
And then he rents a vehicle in Manchester,
a red Kia Amonte,
and he drives it 1,745 miles before returning it.
Never gives an explanation for this trip.
Guessing someone died because of this little vacation of his, at least one person, that's
a lot of miles to just, you know, put on a rental car for no explainable reason.
On March 1st, 2005, is goes on a day long canoe trip to an unknown location in Washington
State.
It was then seen camping at a location that could be only reached by boat or canoe.
And anyone guess what he was doing there? Body disposal, maybe on March 12, 2005,
keys goes on another day long canoe trip to an unspecified lake,
fishing, murdering body disposal on April 9th, not even a month later.
Keys picks up a boat.
He purchased in Port Angeles, Washington, later tells investigators,
he used this boat to dump bodies in Lake Crescent, Washington.
He take at least three more mystery trips in 2005, a day alone at another unspecified
lake in Washington on June 17th, 10 days in El Salvador in October, and then a trip to
Gresham, Oregon, the days in.
He stayed the days in for a few days in December.
Before the year was up, he also met a new lover, Port Angles resident Kimberly
Anderson, whom he started up relationship with.
Also started sleeping with Tammy again, but then in summer and the summer of 2005,
she wrecked her car while high on painkillers, which been 25 days in jail, two months in
an inpatient rehab center, that fall.
And by the time she's out, there's no chance to get in back together with keys.
He decided to stay with Kimberly, uh. We don't know much about. He'll stay with her for the rest of
his life, or at least until he's arrested. Is does a ton of solo traveling in 2006. He spends a
day in Port Townsend, Washington, February 22nd. He rents a room with the Travelers
Intervictory British Columbia on April 22nd. He flies to San Diego on May 10th from Portland and crosses
the Mexico border into Tijuana before crossing back and flying back from San Diego to Portland
on May 15th. He wrote three words regarding this trip in his journal, Travel to Surgery.
Okay, more on the surgery later. On June 11th, keys rent a room at the red line in Port
Angeles, Washington on the 21st. He writes, Meeting Up with Dan Klemens, not the comic, but his dad for body disposal training.
He writes that in his journal.
And that's, you know, concerning.
No, he wrote Mexico for surgery follow up on June 22nd, 2006.
Keys drove from Nea Bay, Washington to Ridgefield, Washington, picks him a ATVs up for work, then less than a month later. July 11, 2006, Mary Cooper 56 and Susanna Staten 27, a mother and daughter are murdered
along the pinnacle lake trail in Mount Baker Snow qualmy national forest on July 11.
The gun hiking their bodies were found on July 12.
Both had died from fatal gunshot wounds and the two women were lasting alive at the trailhead.
To this day, their killer has never been found.
We don't know that Israel keys murdered them,
but he had recently been in that area,
grabbing those ATVs.
May have returned to the area on the 11th.
Many think he killed them.
In the fall of 2006, it is takes two trips alone
to Anchorage, Alaska,
another trip to both San Diego and Tijuana,
where he may or may not have met my dad for drinks
and watched what my dad has called the Donkey show.
Not sure what that's all about.
Some of these talked about.
March 9th, 2007, Kees moved to Alaska,
began his own construction company in Anchorage,
which he calls the Kees Construction Company,
pretty straightforward.
It works as a handyman, contractor, construction worker,
by all outside appearances, living the American dream.
Have yet to have a dissatisfied customer
he wrote on his website, which might have been true.
I doubt he was raping or murdering his customers.
14 years after serial killer and former suck subject,
Robert Butcher-Baker Hansen was arrested,
Anchorage now has a new human hunter in town.
He's construction company, gives him a good excuse to travel around.
You can say that he's, you know, scouting out some new jobs.
He's checking out some new equipment, maybe even taking a job out of state for a few weeks.
Keys with successful, well liked around town, known as a reliable, hardworking man who always
did a good job.
He lived with Kimberly Anderson, who moved up there with him.
Also after a short time, he was able to get full custody of his daughter, take her out of state from Washington to live with him in Alaska.
Neither Kimberly nor his young daughter have a clue who he really is. According to their
Anchorage neighbors, keys in Anderson were quiet and polite through a couple small parties
each year. And outside of that, it just kind of kept themselves.
The only complaints neighbors ever had about him were noise related. He spent a lot of
time running saws, other equipment in the yard for his construction business,
occasionally pissing people off because it's a loud late evening cutty.
We have someone in the neighbor who does that too.
It'll be like 10 p.m.
Sometimes you can hear a fucking table saw if you go in the backyard.
Not sure who does that, but pretty sure that they are an asshole.
Does he give a shit if it bothers anyone else around?
Keys took so many solo trips in 2007, three days in Vegas, a day in Kash Creek, British
Columbia, rented a room for a day at Cedar Lodge and Watson Lake, Yukon, Canada, stayed in a
motel and destruction bay, Canada the next night, flew into Oakland, rented a car, drove
it almost 1500 miles at the end of April. According to his journal, he hit up San Diego
and Tijuana on that trip. On April 29 journal, he hit up San Diego and Tijuana
on that trip.
On April 29th, he had an appointment at Cosmed,
a plastic surgery clinic in Tijuana.
What kind of cosmetic surgery was this super fit,
29 year old veteran who was training to run marathons
around this time getting?
He would never tell investigators what type of surgery
he had or surgeries, plural.
They think many of his Tijuana trips may have been
surgery related. If it was plastic surgery to T-wanna trips may have been surgery related.
If it was plastic surgery to change his appearance, it must have been subtle because he didn't
look much different, you know, before and after according to investigative comparisons
of photos from around that time.
Investigators wondered if he was trying to do something like have his fingerprints surgically
modified, maybe have some body hair lasered off,it perspiration, stock with Botox.
Keys would later admit that the one thing he worried
about leaving at crime scenes was his sweat.
He also, according to journal entries,
may have had gastric bypass surgery, super strange,
because he was never overweight.
Why would someone do that?
Investigators have a theory.
They think if he wanted to drive for hours on end
without needing to stop or spend a 12 hour stretch focused on hurting a victim, not needing to eat could be very helpful.
Did keys try to bio hack his body in some weird way that would help him become a better
serial killer would not be surprised.
And later later in August, keys flew down from Alaska to Washington for a few days, rented
a room at the Ramada Inn and squim one night at the Lakinta in and Linwood on another.
Then flew on to Salt Lake City where he rented a car for four days, went on some kind of
hunt and trip with my dad.
Maybe, you know, he never mentioned hunting on a trip with my dad, but I don't know.
I don't know where my dad was at that time.
Law enforcement, things he traveled around Utah went to Wyoming for September 2nd through
the six before flying back to Anchorage.
So many trips.
On October 29th, keys flew to Los Angeles, rented the car drove 95th before flying back to Anchorage. So many trips. On October 29th, keys flew to Los Angeles, run to the car, drove 95 miles, flew back to
Anchorage on November 2nd.
See if I can do it.
Like, there's no word on it.
If you had any business, knew anyone down there.
December 4th still somehow in 2007.
This guy's busy.
Flies down to Washington.
See it again.
Spends time in Edmunds, Washington.
And he flies to Fort Wayne, Indiana, rents a car for four days between December 8th and the 11th.
I drives it 537 miles to somewhere.
Maybe my dad's house.
I don't know.
I don't know where exactly he lived.
You know, on those dates, I don't know.
Keys returned his car one day late.
December 16th.
He was back in Washington.
He stayed at night in Kingston.
Another night in the Ramada and Squim flew home on the 17th.
January 28th 2008 keys takes a series of flights
That leaves him or he ends up in Mobile, Alabama
Rentsacar drives it almost 700 miles to fucking who knows where
February 6 2008 keys takes in Alaska Airlines flight from Dallas, Texas to Seattle from February 6th to the 15th
The Rentsacar and Seattle drives it almost 1200 miles now at that time, I will say my dad lived in Donnelly, Idaho, 483 miles away.
So the math works for a round trip.
Let's run through that out there.
February 11th, he takes an Alaska Airlines flight from Seattle to Anchorage, then immediately
returns back to Seattle because he said he forgot to return the rental car.
Sounds like a fucking very lame excuse.
How do you hop on a flight after forgetting to return the rental car. Sounds like a fucking very lame excuse. How do you hop on a flight after forgetting
to return the rental car?
And then why do you fly back to drive it
to the rental car place?
Why can't you just tell them where it is?
He has no explanation for this.
It sounds like a very weird excuse, very weird story.
He goes back, says he returns the car,
then heads straight back to Alaska.
I wonder if he just left evidence somewhere
and panicked and had to go back and retrieve it.
There were so many more trips in 2008. Four days in Salt Lake City in July, three days
in the LA area in September, a day in Seattle in October, five days that started in Grand
Forks North Dakota and ended all the way in Phoenix, Arizona in October.
Those cities are in over 1700 mile drive apart.
They also spent a day in San Francisco in October, spend six days in Seattle, start
November, be home for, you know, a little while before going to Honolulu for three days in
December, buy himself so much fucking traveling, then he'd spend two weeks in Cancun, a
few other cities in Mexico, all still in December, buy himself. That reminds me that my dad
really liked Mexican food, which is interesting when you tie it with everything else I've been talking about
More strange trips in 2009 as we draw closer to some confirmed murders
He flew into Burbank in February disappeared for four days before returning to Anchorage
He was away from from home for the first two weeks of April
We've been Seattle, Squim, Washington, Manchester, New Hampshire, upstate, New York
Who the fuck knows where else over a thousand
miles on rental cars again. On April 9, 2009, investigators think he's kidnapped and murdered
a woman near Tupper Lake, New York, Deborah Feldman, 48 years old. Not counted as one of
keys victims, but the FBI does think he killed her. Deborah Feldman disappeared from her apartment
in Hackensack, New Jersey, 280 miles south of Tupper Lake.
She was last seen April 8, 2009.
By all accounts, I guess she was kind of a drifter, deeply troubled woman, struggling with
a drug addiction who occasionally engaged in sex work.
Later when Keys was caught, he was shown a series of pictures of missing people and he
just kept saying real flippantly, nope, nope, nope, to each picture until he got to
Debra's picture.
When he saw her, he hesitated and then said,
I don't wanna talk about her yet.
Deborah's body has never been found.
In addition to probably killing Deborah in or around Tupper Lake
on April 10th, 2009,
he's also suspected of robbing the Tupper Lake community bank.
All right, trips, this is what his trips for about.
Investigators think, a lot of them.
And I'm speculating here, but maybe he was telling Kimberley
this whole time that he's been going to take out
of town construction jobs.
Right, high pain, you know, a little quick jobs,
jobs that paid cash, which having a lot of carpenters
and contractors in my family is somewhat common.
You know, definitely something a lot of dudes would fly
somewhere to, you know, to do, to take some under the table
money that you don't have to pay taxes on.
My dad has done a lot of these jobs over the years.
I did mention that my dad's a carpenter, right?
Been a contractor.
A lot of pieces starting to fit here.
But seriously, if he's bringing this cash home,
you know, why would she assume
that he hadn't done an actual job to get it?
It would actually check out.
She's probably not gonna assume he's rather than banks
or an engaging in some other kind of theft.
Probably not gonna assume that he's flying to New Hampshire to rob a few houses and kill someone. That all feels very
possible to be probably even. This is alibi, alibi's. But again, total speculation on my part.
FBI, investigators think Israel wore sunglasses, a jacket, jeans, grace sneakers, gloves,
and a fake mustache when he robbed this bank. If he robbed this bank, I should point out that
in 2009, my dad did have a mustache. Whoever robbed it entered with a 40 caliber Smith and Western
pistol had an additional 22 caliber pistol on him. They robbed the bank, fled the scene,
and then a toolbox related to the bank robbery was discovered later, less than a mile away,
just across the state line in Essex, Vermont. And that night, keys rented a room at the Hampton Inn, less than five miles away
from Essex in Colchester, Vermont. So very suspicious. Later in 2009, one night in June, and on another
night in September, keys rents himself hotel rooms in Anchorage just a few miles from where he lived.
On October 6, 2009, keys took a little solo vacation to Key Nile Asuka, a little over two months
later. Sember 17, he flies from Anchorage to Orlando, goes on a little solo vacation to Key Nile Asuka a little over two months later. Sember 17.
He flies from Anchorage to Orlando.
Goes on a little celebrity cruise by himself.
Cruise travels from the Saint, a San Juan, Saint, uh, Qua, uh, Saint Kits, Panama, uh, Saint
John.
He disembarked from the cruise and on December 29th, the Keys takes an Alaska flight from Orlando
back to Anchorage.
The Alaska Airlines flight.
And then he stays home for six months.
We think he at least didn't fly anywhere based on FBI,
the FBI investigation.
In the summer 2010, he spends a few days in the Seattle area
racking up over 300 rental car miles.
Then he flies to Sacramento, racks over another 200 rental car
miles over a few more days, then flies home,
five days later, flies to Denver, drives a rental car
to Las Vegas.
My dad used to live in Las Vegas and he lived in Anchorage, not kidding.
A lot of weird connections, getting hard to ignore.
From July 18th to the 22nd, Kees reserves a room with the Flamingo Hotel in Vegas.
July 21st, he takes a flight to an unknown location.
Some reason the FBI can't pinpoint where he went on that trip.
Some record must have been lost.
Then on the 22nd he ends up back in Anchorage
where he'd stay until October.
On October 15th, he flies from Anchorage to Chicago
to Boston and then surprise surprise.
He rents a car.
He drives to Maine, racks up a whole bunch of miles,
goes to where God knows where else flies back
out of Boston to Anchorage via Chicago on the 25th.
Incredibly, he would not take any more loan mystery trips again for about six months,
not leave it until April of 2011. On April 23rd, he flies to Juno, Alaska.
Shocking, I know, he rents a car in Juno, stays at the best western for two nights before returning
to Anchorage. The bestigators believe that at this time during this trip,
he built a homemade silencer.
A silencer he would soon use in a horrific crime.
I got to say, my dad likes it when things are silent.
He used to yell at me for talking to my story movies.
I find that weird.
June 2nd, 2011, keys flies back to Chicago where he rents a car, begins driving east.
He makes multiple transactions on an Indiana toll road, and then eventually ends up in Vermont.
It's just fucking ping pong all over the place.
He confesses later to digging up a kill cash,
he stowed previously in Burlington.
On June 7th, he checks into the handy sweets
and Essex Vermont.
That afternoon, he went shopping at Lowe's,
drove around town a little bit,
did a little fishing in a national park nearby.
Then as the sun went down, took a stroll around town, started to follow
a man who got out of his VW bug with the intention of killing him.
It felt right.
But the guy moved a bit too fast, got away.
So he went back to the hotel, collecting himself, prepared to head out again,
kill someone else.
He left the hotel again shortly after midnight.
Meanwhile, not far from his hotel in Essex in, in the early minutes of June 8th, 2011,
Bill and the rain courier are fast asleep in their bed.
The two home bodies lived a quiet normal life.
Bill was 50, the rain was 55,
they shared a home on eight Colbert Street,
and not long after midnight,
keys walked from his hotel into their neighborhood,
searching for victims.
He later said he chose Bill in the rain's house
only because it fit the criteria he'd set. No kids, no dogs, a house with an attached
garage doesn't say exactly how he determined all that. I'm guessing he staked it out
earlier. Their home just happened to be the first home he came across at Metis standards.
His work and construction allowed him to predict the floor plan of the house pretty easily.
After cutting the phone line, he hoisted himself to the garage window, entered the kitchen.
From there, he said it was a straight shot down the hallway to the bedroom.
He quickly entered their bedroom, seconds after entering the house, calling it a blitz attack.
He stood over building the range, shining a headlamp in their faces to wake them up.
He told them what to do while he zipped high them, holding them a gunpoint.
He asked them if they had a safe, that a gun where their ATM cards were. Lorraine told them they
did have a gun, which he took a 38 Smith and Wesson. Lorraine had been sleeping in her t-shirt
and shorts. He took some lingerie from her drawer, you know, taunted her about the lingerie,
later told him FBI investigators. His motivation going forward with this attack with what he did
that night was almost completely sexual.
A few moments later, while Keys was stripping the sheets from the bed, Lorraine tried
to make a break for it.
She struggled attempting to roll off the bed onto the floor.
Keys grabbed her, forced her back under the bed, threatened her saying, if you try that
again, I won't be happy.
Keys kept rummaging through drawers at one point, finding a military insignia called an
electric strawberry.
It was quite the coincidence.
Bill had once served in the same unit as Keys hat, the army's 25th Infantry Division.
Keys told Bill this, letting him think that because they had something in common, he wasn't
going to kill him.
Keys forced a couple into their own car, drove them to an abandoned farmhouse down the road.
He'd scouted out before.
As they drove, he told them he was kidnapping them for ransom.
Other people he said would take it from there.
All lies.
Once they're at the farmhouse, he's tied bill to a stool in the basement, leaving the rain
alone in the car.
The rain managed to escape briefly, ran towards Route 15.
Keys much faster than her, runs her down, catches her, drags her screaming back to the,
you know, this location where he has her husband tied up, he ties her to a bed throughout
all this bill is frantic.
He shouting for the rain when keys goes to check on him, he finds that he had worked
himself free.
The stool he'd been tied to is in pieces.
He started thrashing against keys, which pisses keys the fuck off.
His plans are being disrupted.
He does not like that.
Investigators later asked what his plans for bill were at this point.
He displayed the same reticence he would later display when asked about sexual activity saying, I'm not going to say what I was going
to do to him. He's hit bill with a shovel twice ran upstairs to find his 22 that had that
silencer. By the time he got back downstairs bill was up again still trying to fight fucking
tough dude. He's opened fire on him. Shot bill in the arms, the neck and the chest bill
fell to the floor dead. He's exhaled deeply. This Bill in the arms, the neck and the chest, Bill fell to the floor
dead. He's exhaled deeply. This was not how he planned things. Night was going sideways.
He goes outside to clear his head. He smokes his cigar for a little bit and he goes back inside,
cuts off the reins, clothes, gags her with paper towels and duct tape and rapes her twice.
During the second rape, he chokes her and tells she loses consciousness. Then when the rain comes to, he brings her downstairs, shows her bill's dead body
just because he's a total piece of shit.
And he puts on a parallel leather gloves and strangles her with the rope.
How terrifying.
These people were not connected to him in any way.
He literally had never heard of these people.
These people had never seen him before he just shows up in their bedroom that night.
He's left their bodies in the farmhouse after he just shows up in their bedroom that night.
He's left their bodies in the farmhouse after pouring drain over their hands and faces,
apparently to destroy some evidence, maybe to destroy some of his DNA, then he begged each of
their bodies, piled garbage and wood over the garbage bags. By the time Israel left, the sun was up
and locals were heading to work on Route 15. Please, had no clue what happened to Bill and the
Ray. The only sign that something was a miss
was a broken window that looked like they had just decided
to drive away from their home.
It would take almost a year for the truth to be revealed.
The house was demolished.
The house that their bodies were left in was demolished
shortly after the couriers were left there.
And the materials were taken to a landfill.
By the time the FBI searched for their bodies,
you know, over a year later, they just couldn't find them.
They searched for 10, 12 weeks, couldn't find the remains.
After killing the couriers, Israel moves on to New Hampshire
where he burns their belongings in the woods.
Then he drives to Maine to visit his brothers.
Some of his brothers live in there.
And on his way back to Chicago,
he drives through Essex again,
right past the courier's house.
Just to relive the high he felt when he'd
killed him.
Oh, he's fucking people.
June 15th, 2011, is flies from Chicago to San Francisco where he'll spend the night
before flying to Anchorage the next day, over main in Anchorage for the rest of 2011.
So much work for all this.
Just fucking flying all over the place, driving all over the place, storing these kill
kids.
So weird how we just, you just treat it like a job.
Now let's jump to 2012.
Take a quick break from Israel to meet Samantha Kohnik.
Samantha was 18.
We met her briefly before I know.
She gets to know her a little bit better.
She was a popular high school senior,
who sometimes cut class, seemed to get along with everyone,
not just the cool kids.
She had some troubles, you troubles, some struggles with drugs,
struggles with her mom,
but nothing that out of the ordinary teenage rebellion stuff.
She was doing well the last semester of her senior year
on track to graduate from Anchorage's West High School.
She planned on either working with animals
or becoming a nurse.
Thought she might join the Navy after high school.
She had a boyfriend, Dwayne, who she'd been dating for almost a year.
She was living with her single father, James,
a burly blue eyed man who was known to most as sunny,
when she disappeared.
Dwayne had recently moved in with Samantha and James,
working as a dishwasher at the seafood restaurant,
sweet 100, while he saved up for something better.
Samantha had a part-time job as a barista,
and one of the many little small drives
through coffee shacks in Anchorage.
Place called common grounds. So many of these places around Cordelaine, is at Berista, and one of the many little small drives through coffee shacks in Anchorage. A place called Common Grounds.
So many of these places around Corde de Laine.
I go to one almost literally every single day.
She was only, I had only been working there
a few weeks before meeting the man who would enter life
on February 1st.
That night she was working alone in charge
of closing up Common Grounds for the night.
The weather was brutal.
Of course it was.
It's Anchorage in February.
It was just over 30 degrees, snow banks line in the streets.
It was slow that night. She was texting with her boyfriend Dwayne telling him to leave her alone.
She was certain he had been cheating on her and she texted her dad asking him to bring over some dinner for.
If only she had texted him just a little bit earlier that poor man.
Enter Israel Keys after observing the kiosk this little coffee,, this little coffee drive through spot for several nights in a row,
he had decided to rob it.
He's got a little more brazen with his crimes.
This was the kind of crime he would usually reserve for some out of town trip, not something
he would do where he lived.
If you just got in the way with shit for so long, you started to feel invincible.
He decided to rob a little coffee shack, even though it was on a main road, but it was
flanked by five foot tall snow drifts.
I guess he figured it would eliminate those snow drifts, would eliminate, you know, possible
witnesses.
If we're heading to Samantha that night, he stopped at Carr's grocery store where he
picked up a Snickers bar, a wild mild cigars.
They made his way over to the Home Depot near the little coffee shop where he parked his
car close to an I hop.
It seems to have shared the parking lot.
Then grab his coffee mug, a pair of
plastic zip ties, his headlamp, and a 22 torus for Volvo. The wore a tiny police scanner in his ear
so he could get the jump on anyone coming for him. And again, he just, he treated this shit like
it was a job and he just needed the money. Very different than most of the people we have talked
about on serial killer sucks. He's walked up to the window ordered in Americano around 8 p.m. Samantha's closing time. When investigators later asked him why
he went to the common ground's coffee stand that night at that time, he said, because
they're open late. Security camera footage showed Samantha serving someone just before
eight wearing a lime green top with her long brown hair worn down. Whoever's outside,
you know, remains just out of range in the footage.
Samantha can be seen chatting casually.
She's making the coffee, then two minutes and six seconds into the tape.
She freezes at this moment.
Israel's pointing a gun at her.
You can't really get a good look at him.
Just see a blurry figure on the security footage.
He tells her to turn off the lights.
She does her hands go up.
She moves gingerly to the counter, gets on her knees, where she remains for about three
minutes. After that, she goes to the register, scoops out the money from the drawer, then
goes back to kneeling. The figure, Israel, leaned through the window now, starts to tie
her hands behind her back. Israel then climbs inside the window, landing to Samantha's
right, kneels beside her, lifts her up, and then the two walk out of the little coffee
shop into the parking lot, his arm around her shoulder.
As they walk,
he spots a camera on the ground,
a new cannon worth about 300 bucks.
He estimated he bends down to pick it up
and then Samantha breaks away and tries to run.
He's in Chaser's or tackles her to the ground,
tells her that his gun has quiet ammo
that he will use it on her if she tries to run again.
Security footage from the Home Depot across the street,
from the little Kiosk shows keys
walking her across two to road
Onto into a parking lot between restaurants
There were people around but Samantha was just too scared to call out for help
Samantha told keys her family didn't have a lot of money
She tried to talk herself out of the situation, but with this sadistic murdering rapist. That's not gonna work
He's finds out Samantha has left her phone back at the coffee shop with her in the vehicle.
He drives back, grabs it, also goes into her car, grabs her house keys.
It was about 11 pm now.
They send off or he sends off a couple of texts from her phone making it seem as though
she's pissed off at something her boyfriend had done just kind of furthers that.
And then around 1 a.m.
The following morning, keys with Samantha still in his car asked for her ATM card.
She tells him it's in the truck at her house.
He's then take Samantha to the shed at his house, ties her up, turns the radio all the way up in this shed so no one can hear her scream.
The shed was set up for Israel to work in it during the day, so it had two heaters going, a tarp spread on the floor.
He turned the heaters on, gave her a bucket to pee in. Later, keys would say, I moved her hands so that they were in front of her so she could smoke and stuff.
And yeah, I just told her to chill out.
Fuck is wrong with this guy. Hey, just just enjoy yourself here in this shed.
Just make yourself a hump. I'm gonna go to a Dranger Bank account.
Then I might come back and let you live or I'm like, I might kill you.
I don't know. Hey, you know what? For right now, I want you to just chill out.
2.30 a.m.
He's then drives this man to his house, breaks into a truck. He's interrupted by her boyfriend, Dwayne, who sees you to just chill out. 2.30 AM, he's then drives this Samantha's house, breaks into a truck.
He's interrupted by her boyfriend, Dwayne, who sees a man in a mask, is closed as the door,
flees, Dwayne runs inside, tells her dad James, who searched the truck, realized that Samantha's
driver's license is missing.
Ease manages to get the ATM card before Dwayne spots him.
He'd figured that he'd forgotten the pin number, though, that Samantha had given him. So he has to go back to his house now between three and five
a.m. he goes back to that shed, ties Samantha in a more complicated way now and then rapes
her twice. The fucking creep would later say to investigators that it took a while, maybe
two or three songs on the radio. When he was done, he stood above her naked and Samantha
asked if he was going to kill her and she tried to talk him out of it. He then put on a pair of leather gloves and
strangled her, recalling later that it took a while for her to die, which annoyed him.
He remembered thinking that he still had to shower for the day's activities, just like
no empathy at all these people. He then stabs her once below her right shoulder blade in
her back, make sure that she's dead, leaves the body while he wakes up his daughter so
they can get ready, you know, for their day.
While his daughter is getting ready, he goes back to the shed, rolls Samantha's body in
a tarp, hides her remains in a lower cabinet, turns off the heaters, double locks the shed
doors, and then calls a cap.
He does this by 5 a.m. and then he's off to travel around the country again.
At same morning, Samantha is reported missing, originally police think she had just run away.
There was a panic button in the common grounds.
Kiosk, she hadn't pressed it.
But the more they thought about it, the more unlikely it seemed that she would run.
How would a teenage girl run away on foot through Anchorage, cold snowy, not very
walkable?
How did she have the money she'd need to run away if she was just being paid a
barista salary?
A job she had just started.
Poor dad, James spends the next day standing outside, or I guess this day, the day after
she disappears, standing outside the kiosk, during his daughter's shift, stands there from
nearby, from 1 p.m. to 8 p.m. just waiting for her to come back.
Later that morning, keys hops on an Alaska Airlines flight from Anchorage to Houston, Texas,
solo.
He arrives in Houston, rents a car, drivesar drives it 2847 miles. What is he doing?
That's a long way to drive in a rental car. Also, my dad has two brothers that lived in the
Houston area at that time. I don't remember talking to him on those dates. Could have been down
there. February 2nd to the 5th, 2012. Keys, Rentsons a room in America's best value in a Lafayette, Louisiana. February 6th to the 11th keys takes a carnival cruise line
strip with Kimberly and his daughter. They had flown into New Orleans. The cruise departed
or they flown in, you know, down there to join him before the cruise departed. This
fucking psycho. Rob's rapes, murders, a high school barista, rolls her up in the shed, flies
down, commits, I'm guessing more horrible crimes. And then a couple days later, just enjoys nice family cruise.
He stays night in New Orleans after the cruise, then his girlfriend Kimberly flies home while he
stays down there with his daughter. On February 13th, Israel and his daughter visit Israel's
mother Heidi in the little town of Wells, Texas, where his mom is a member of a church various articles have referred
to as a Jim Jones type cult. Sounds about right. For Mama Keith. This is worth a brief
detour. The church of Wells showed up in the little backwoods town of about 800 people
in 2011. Heidi and a few of her daughters showed up with it. Of course they did. Heidi
is a fucking maniac, who along with now deceased husband, did a great job,
fucking up all over kids with fear and paranoia.
If only Striper had been around to set them all free,
maybe they just needed to listen to just a little bit more. [♪ To hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to hell with the devil, to likely. Sorry about that. Back to the Church of Wells,
Church of Wells born out of discontent
with mainstream Christianity
and a desire to live a true Christian lifestyle.
When Church of Wells elder wrote,
the anti-Christ, oh boy,
reigns today in professingly godly Christian America.
Just a few months after is and his daughter visited
in May of 2012,
a Church of Wells members 3D,
three day old baby would die of natural causes.
And the family would not call 911 until the conclusion of a 15 hour prayer session, following
the baby's death.
That did not sit well with locals.
Got them some bad press rumors were beginning to spread by the time is visited.
The church was buying up a lot of property in town, promoting arranged marriages, converting
the town's youth into a cult.
People were talking about how they wanted to build a waco like compound and walled themselves
off from a sinful world.
Members of this batshit congregation have written online in recent years about the various
ways the devil could sneak up on you and take you away from the Lord.
Like through things like, uh, enjoying the trans, uh, transformers movies or listening
to M&M
or going to Disney World too many times
or watching reruns of the wire on HBO, not kidding.
These are real examples they've written about.
And this is where Heidi Keys and a couple of her daughters
may still be living today.
It's the last known definite residence I can find.
Back to Keys visiting Wells now on February 13th, 2002
with his nine yearyear-old daughter
Crazy ass Heidi Heidi
Would later say that it was clear something was wrong with her son because on this visit
He snuck out of the house sometime early in the morning like a teenager
Left the note in his bed said gone to fix the window and find a place to hide my guns
The window Heidi would say referred to his rental car and this next sequence of events is so strange.
When she found the note the next morning,
Heidi sent a text to the family group chat at 8.05 AM.
Is he, we can take your guns to,
and then that next part's redacted.
If you want, no problem.
I love how fucking weird this family is.
Mom, I gotta go find a place to hide my guns.
And then the mom was like,
oh, no, no, don't worry about that.
We know some people looking to hide your guns, no problem.
There was no word back from Izzy all day.
Then that night Israel texted, texted them back.
He was stuck in the mud.
He said in the middle of nowhere.
At 8.34 pm, Heidi texted him, we want to get you if you have any idea where you are.
No response.
8.52, she texted again.
We have four wheel drive.
If you can give us an idea of where you are, we'll come get you.
And he does not respond until the next day.
What is he doing?
Next day, Valentine's Day, February 14th, Israel texts to say that he was parked near a big
shopping center in Cleburn, town of around 30,000 South to Fort Worth a couple hours drive
away.
The family drives to pick him up.
It's a long drive. When they get uh, he's nowhere to be found. They spend the night sleeping in their van
in the parking lot waiting for his next text. What the fuck? Next day, 15th, he's kept them wondering,
also kept his daughter wondering where the hell he has been now for about two days. And now Israel
calls to say that he's just a few hundred, a. He's just on the other side of the mall.
Oh, you've been in the mall already?
For about 12 hours, sleeping in a van,
the parking lot, whoops, I forgot to check my phone.
I thought I'd already texted you back.
I went a little hard on Auntie Anne's pretzels
and I fell into a car coma.
I'm just sleeping on the other parking lot.
Heidi and a few other family members,
they find him across the mall. He's disheveled, he's incoherent, his rental car, a little blue key of soul,
it's splattered with mud.
He starts spouting off a variety of excuses regarding where he'd been.
You know, he said he'd run out of gas, his credit cards have been frozen.
He was just acting confused.
He hadn't eaten or slept in days, he said.
They didn't know what the fuck was wrong with him,
but they didn't really pursue it uh... because they're insane
and he was a psychopath so they don't ask too many questions
where the hell had you been we still don't know
uh... we do know that since you left Alaska he couldn't stop thinking about the
thrill he had felt killing Samantha he would tell investigators that later
when he got to texas he considered doing something uh... to give him an even bigger
rush
he would later tell investigators he considered burning a church
or murdering several people
inside a church and then leaving them for the Congress to find.
He wanted to take things further.
When investigators asked him about February 15th, if he'd really gotten stuck in the mud,
he said, yeah, I just, the longer I stayed in Dallas, the longer I was down south, the more
I was thinking I, I wanted to do something else.
On February 16th, after driving back with his family to Wells, keys drove to a house in
alto, Texas, just 15 minutes up the road and broke in.
He found some cans of gasoline in the garage and he decided, I want to set the fucking
house on fire.
So he burns down a house and he drives over three hours and Rob is the national bank
of Texas and a Zool Texas, just west of Fort Worth.
He robs this bank in just two minutes.
He walked in with a hard hat, mask sunglasses and gloves and he buries the money he got
at a cemetery in Glenrose, Texas. He's fucking all over the place right now. Then he goes
to a laid out Texas that same day and burns down a house and burns down a barn just for
funsies. He had also planned to abduct a woman near Glenrose, Texas that day, but decided not to
it's last second.
Dude is no longer cool and calculated.
He isn't a fucking murder frenzy.
The mayhem frenzy, not behaving like an organized killer.
He's out of control.
The next day his mom buys him and his daughter a ticket back to Anchorage.
He pays her $900 cash for the flights.
He didn't want to make the purchase under his name.
They left on the 18th.
February 21st, keys back in Alaska, waits until his daughter has left for school.
It's a Monday.
Then he dismantles the cabinets in his shed, chopping up the wood for firewood.
The cabinets were permanently stained with Samantha's blood.
He then rolled Samantha's body out of the cabinet.
The sleeping bag she had been wrapped in, he later say, was pretty much soaked with
blood.
He disposed the Samantha stuff.
Later after his daughter had gotten back from school, done her homework and gone to bed,
he went back to work, destroying evidence.
He built a fire in the living room fireplace around 1 a.m. on the 22nd.
All this girlfriend and daughter slept, he burns the tarp, burns everything he could
think of that Samantha had touched.
Then he hangs Samantha's body up in the shed by ropes around her wrists and has sex with her corpse.
My God, she has been dead for three weeks now. He is spiraling into darker and darker shit.
While having it in necrophilia in the shed,
or not long after, his daughter comes looking for him. She knocks on the shed door.
He tells her to go inside, eat her breakfast.
She'll be in there in the minute in a minute.
How terrible for her if she is familiar with the story now.
I hope she is not.
I hope she avoids us seem to or reading anything
associated with her dad.
Later that day, he goes to Target to buy a Polaroid camera.
He's got a new idea.
An idea that's gonna lead to his capture.
On February 24th, he decided to try and get
some ransom money from Samantha's family. Problem is, she's already dead. Been dead over
three weeks now. If he were to write a ransom note, he would have to make it appear as
though she were alive and could be returned to her family, so that's what he tries to do.
He wants to take some pictures of her. The problem is, you know, she's been dead for a
little while. Her muscles are slack. No amount of posing is going to give her some type
of human-like facial expression.
He apparently spends hours with her corpse trying to get her into the right pose.
He is lost. What's left of his mind?
He then posts a ransom note at Connor's Bog Park and Anchorage,
complete with Xeroxed pictures of Polaroids of Samantha, who is supposedly alive.
One picture, what looks like silver duct tape covers her mouth and chin.
She's wearing eyeliner, looking at the camera, her hair was braided, her head is being held up by a man's
hand. After he took this and other pictures, he dismembered her body and then dropped it
into a nearby frozen lake over three trips. The throwoff suspicion, he builds a shed over
the hole he'd cut in the water. Alaska ice fishing is common. He knew no one would question
a man building a small shelter while fishing at 7.56 pm. Samantha's boyfriend Dwayne gets a text from Samantha's
phone. Connor Park sign under pick of Albert. Ain't she pretty? Police rushed to the park
where they find his ransom note inside of a plastic bag. Tack of a poster of a dog are tacked
up under a poster of a dog named Albert. The note was typed on plain white paper
and red. I may not use the card much in Alaska due to small poppies in population, but as
I will be leaving soon, I will be using it all over. Israel had requested $30,000 to be put
in her bank account, implying that she had been moved to an arid state in the lower 48.
She did almost get away twice. The note read, once on two to road and once
in the desert must be losing my touch. It said that if demands were met, Samantha would
be freed in six months. No one knew that the picture was of Samantha's dead body. And
that even with the demands met, they would never see her alive. It was now considered a kidnapping
case, a federal crime. This is how the FBI gets involved in this investigation. That will
end in the arrests of Israel keys.
On the advice of police on February 29th, 2012,
Samantha's father, James, deposits $5,000
into the account, hoping that they can lure Samantha's
kidnapper into making contact.
And it works beautifully.
Before this, the account Dwayne and Samantha shared
had less than $5 in it.
Four hours later, just before midnight,
detectives watched amazed as someone actually tries
to withdraw cash from an ATM in Anchorage.
The guy tried to withdraw $600,
but most ATMs only let you take out a maximum
of $500 a day.
Not two hours after the first attempt comes another.
A successful one this time, $500 from an ATM
at the Denali Federal Credit Union,
a six minute drive away from the side
of the first failed attempt, not playing it cool.
At this point, it feels like part of Israel wants to get caught.
Half an hour later, at another ATM across town at Debar Road, there's another withdrawal
for $500.
And pretty sure my dad has used at least one of these ATMs before, if not all of them.
That just bothers me a little bit since I don't know where he was at day. Two days later, the security footage from the Danali ATM makes it to an FBI lab in
Quantico. By the next day, analysts found that despite the bulky clothes, the man in the picture
was wearing, he had an athletic frame or in the video was wearing. His dark jacket was possibly
hooded. It looked like there was some light-colored paint splatter on the left chest. Later on in the
back seemed to read core.
They wanted the suspect had been or was now a marine or a member of some other branch
of the military.
The man was wearing clear or light colored eyeglasses, a gray face mask, gray gloves, dark
pants, light or white shoes.
On March 6th, keys leave town again on a flight to Vegas with his daughter.
Around 11 p.m. on the seventh.
Keys uses Samantha's debit card to make an ATM withdrawal in Wilcox, Arizona, almost
4,000 miles away from Anchorage, the FBI, against other pin, little ping, excuse me, security
footage.
This ATM captures his car a white Ford focus and gives police the lead.
They desperately needed also show the same figure they had seen in the Danali ATM footage, about six feet tall, wearing bull, he clothes and white tennis
shoes. Just over an hour later, from the previous withdrawal at 12.30 a.m. on March 8th,
he's used a Samantha's debit card to make a withdrawal in Lord's Burg New Mexico in
hours drive from Wilcox. Then at 2.35 a.m., the card pings again from the same ATM, a balance
inquiry. There was $3,598 left in the account.
Another minute goes by, another $80 come out. He's pulling close to the daily $500 limit
now. Then he makes it withdrawal in Shepherd, Texas several hours later, at 10 pm still on
March 8th, Israel and his daughter arrived back at his mother hidey's house in Wells.
Keys visited his mom and some of the siblings who were in Texas to attend
his sister's wedding. Two days later on March 10, 2012, he uses Samantha's debit card again
to make an ATM withdrawal in Umbell, Texas, just outside of Houston. One of his sisters
used this visit as an opportunity while he's down there to convince him to convert back
to their special brand of Christianity, a pastor from the Church of Wells, who's president
at the home, was part of the discussion.
And keys apparently told this pastor, you don't know the depths of darkness that I've
gone to.
You don't know what I've done.
It does feel like he is just really spiraling out right now.
March 13, 2012, police in Lufkin, Texas, less than 20 miles from Wells, get a call from
a state trooper.
It was around 11 in the morning.
The state trooper had been driving around hotel parking lots. And they and the trooper had found that white Ford focus that he was
looking for. Police then headed the quality and in suites find the car outside of room 115.
Some officers head in to talk to the manager and then get a call from some other officers
down a squad car. They say, I've just seen a guy on the upper floor looking or yeah, I've just
seen a guy in the upper floor looking down at the, I've just seen a guy on the upper floor looking down at the car I've got eyes on.
Then another call from a car comes in,
a white male adult exited room 215.
He's placing items in the white Ford Focus,
he's getting ready to go.
They then follow him at a safe distance,
and then when his car has gone two miles over the speed limit,
and hits the 57 miles per hour,
they pull the Ford Focus over. The driver calmly pulls over, stops in the parking lot of the cotton patch,
cotton patch, cafe, excuse me, my dad wears a lot of cotton.
Huh. Anyway, Texas Highway Patrol, your western officer says, where are you from? Alaska
answers keys. The Astacy is driver's license. Keys tells them that he's in town for his
sister's wedding. He gives him more details about the wedding, including who's gonna be there.
Too many details.
Investigators think without being prompted.
He's nervous.
He's sweating profusely.
They ask you more questions about when he'd gotten in, how he'd paid for the gas,
astacurches wallet, then keys says impatiently, you aren't searching anything.
Am I under arrest?
Well, he sure as shit was.
On March 13th, 2012,
Keezes finally arrested,
and his car investigators find all kinds of stuff,
including a pair of white sneakers,
Amber Tinted Sunglasses,
Rolls of Cash, and Energy Drink,
a pink backpack, a green backpack,
one gray DVD case containing pornographic images
of a black female, pornographic DVDs, including transgender
based pornography, one copy of the first ever platinum selling CD released by Christian
Metal Band strippers 1986 classic to hell with the devil.
All right, maybe they didn't find that.
They did find in the last airlines flight confirmation for Israel Keys and his daughter to depart Anchorage
on March 6th, arrived in Seattle, Washington before connecting to Las Vegas.
They found several bottles of alcohol, still chilled and Walmart bags, a laptop, a black
Samsung cell phone, the slider kind with the battery and the SIM card removed, a handgun,
parabenoculars, a ski mask, and a headlamp.
And then when they search his wallet, they find something really incriminating.
Samantha Coneg's driver's license. The Texas police then start to interrogate keys.
They would say later that he struck everyone as being very smug, arrogant, superior.
When they told him, we found the ATM card. The one belonging to Samantha's boyfriend in your wallet.
Keys didn't flinch and said, I don't want to talk, but he didn't ask for a lawyer. So they press
on the FBI has pictures of you and your truck at the crime scene. One of them said he's
just shrugged. He said, if they had that, they would have already talked to me. Local officers
were still were just shocked. I guess the way he kind of carried himself. They found
him with some, you know, the Samantha drivers license. He acted like he still
didn't have a care in the world. He refused to talk further. So they cuff him, take him to Beaumont,
Texas, where keys is going to be held in federal, in a federal penitentiary before his arrangement
the very next day. On March 14th, some FBI investigators from Alaska, land in Houston, they go to talk
to him and try to tell him that they know he's not a bad guy. He's not a monster that he had, you
know, some reason for doing this, but he just won't bite.
Won't really talk to him.
They ask him, you know, how can he explain the ATM card in his wallet, you know, her driver's license?
Someone key said he'd left a ziplock bag on the front seat of his pickup truck a few weeks before.
Inside that bag was a cell phone, ATM card with a pin number scratched on it, you know, all the
dammit of it. He
assumed he was someone he had done construction work for who just owed him money and they
left that as a payment. Viscators do this was a ridiculous story. They told him, come
on, dude, we knew you, we know you did this. He says, I don't know what you're talking
about. Not able to get any further with him at this time. Investigators leave. And when
they leave, the building, they run into his mom. His keys was being arranged while the investigators waited on the steps of the prison.
They saw a woman wearing her long white hair braided down her back wearing a simple cotton
dress that looked homemade as it was.
It was Heidi Keys.
Detectives go up to her ask her if she knows anything about her son's activities.
She says she can't help them.
They beg her telling her about James, Samantha's father.
How much he just wanted to get his daughter back. And then Heidi says, well, if God wants that girl to be found, she'll be found.
And then she just turned and walked away. Of course, that's how she reacted. You know, that's what
Jesus wanted to do, cover up for her murdering son. I fucking hate his parents. Keys is taken
back to Anchorage on March 30th at 5.45 pm Friday, March 30th investigators and interrogate
keys at the US Attorney's office.
They're still hopeful that Samantha is alive until keys makes a reference to transporting
different bags down to Madanuska Lake.
They ask him what was in the bags and he says, well, the first day was the head, legs and
arms.
They ask him of Samantha Konegg and he just says, yep, well, at least now
they know I guess. They then ask him to go through the night of her kidnapping and he
is surprisingly calm and honest. What were you thinking at the time they ask? What about
taking it with me? He says, yeah, he says, hmm, I liked her. The point of that he was scheduled
to head out to travel to catch crews the next day. He says, yeah, in a few hours, yeah,
I was kind of part of the idea. He then mentioned that once he got Samantha in his car,
he tried to talk to her, the more she replied,
the more he talked until they seemed like they had
some kind of rapport.
I was trying, you know, to seem like a normal person,
he said.
And when he says this, this tips off investigators
that keys does not consider himself to be a normal person
that he might have done this before.
Now they start to think that they may have captured
a serial killer.
They try to get him to say how he'd killed Samantha.
He suddenly turned defiant.
He said he won't admit how he killed her
just that he was responsible for her death.
And then he starts making some demands.
He tells the police stop going through
his girlfriend Kimberly's stuff at their house.
And if they keep doing that,
he's not gonna tell them how he killed Samantha.
He said, I don't wanna hear about you questioning her again. You know, like I say, obviously, you have no
reason to trust me, but I can tell you right now, there is no one who knows me, who has ever known me,
who knows anything about me, really. I'm two different people. And the only person who knows
about what I'm telling you, the kinds of things I'm telling you is me. How long have you been two different people? They ask a long time.
Your applies 14 years.
All those mystery trips.
Makes me think about that.
Also makes me think about, you know, my dad, I don't know what he's doing right now, even.
The interview continues the following day.
April Fool's Day.
Keys would end up being interviewed 24 times over seven months.
The FBI has only released five of these interviews to the public
We know from what info has been released the keys wanted the death penalty
He wanted to be executed as soon as possible. He wanted no media exposure. He did not want to get famous
Also, he wanted to be charged federally not by any individual state because he didn't want to go through a lot of trials
During his interviews keys often hinted at other victims people he may have killed on his travels, how he operated.
He seemed to enjoy playing a little back and forth
game with the FBI to negotiate his sentence.
Investigators learned soon after his arrest,
that keys was a big fan of serial killers.
Mickey Doll and Anchorage Police Officer
had overseen the search of Kimberly's house
and found scores of books on serial killers.
She knew that Israel thought of himself as an official notto, so she took on a kind of humble tone when she spoke to him, resembling Clarice
Starling's approach, you know, with Hannibal Lecter in Sounds of the Lams, telling him she wasn't
up to speed, needed his help to solve some of his crimes, carefully calibrated, moved, play
up to his ego, and through this little game she played with keys, you know, keys tells her about bill in the rain
courier's murders.
That's how they get solved, that Vermont couple.
Keys hints that they were two of just many other victims.
Keys gave another interview on April 5th,
another on April 6th, in the April 6th interview,
he told investigators that he would tell them everything
if and only if they gave him an execution date
and it had to be soon.
He wanted to be executed
quickly. He told investigators if everything could be wrapped up in a year, his daughter would
have a chance to grow up without a trial happening during her teenage years. Lesson two months later,
maybe rethinking the whole getting executed thing. Keys tries to make a run for it. He tries to
escape. He was in a packed federal courtroom bound by leg irons and handcuffed to a chain seated
at an offense table.
He was surrounded by eight armed guards.
There were six US marshals in the back of the room and he still decides to try and bust
out of there.
Suddenly he springs out of his chair.
He had secretly freed himself from his handcuffs.
He was able to leap over the gallery's railing and he started jumping between the rows.
It took a taser to finally bring this crazy fucker down crazy that with all this law enforcement
he still made as far as he did.
Members of the public in the courtroom that day as he's being tackled, start screaming
kill him kill him.
Pretty crazy spectacle.
Five days later on May 29th, keys is interviewed by officer Jeff Bell, special agent Steve
Payne and assistant US attorneyS. attorney Frank Russo.
Russo gives keys and update on an agreement with Vermont about charging him for the courier
murders.
Russo says a new letter gives both sides what they want, but he reminds keys it's not a
legally binding document to show a good faith to keys in a state of Vermont.
With this letter, Vermont says they will not release information to the press or charge
him under Vermont state law.
Russo says it would be political suicide if they go back against what the letter said.
Keys says again, he just wants to avoid publicity.
They summarize the deal to the letter proposes.
Keys avoids media attention and law enforcement will not publicly identify him in connection
with the courier murders.
As long as he cooperates by providing information about other crimes, locations of bodies,
and the names of other victims.
Pain tells keys they are having trouble locating the courier's bodies in the landfill.
Keys response, I feel almost guilty.
Costing the taxpayers a lot of money to find them.
Never said he felt guilty about murdering innocent people, but said he felt guilty about
cost and taxpayer, you know, there are some taxpayers some money.
Okay.
Pain informs keys that since investigation
is an ongoing federal investigation,
this will decrease the amount of information
that gets released to the public.
He's telling you my concern, the problem is nowadays.
The more stuff my name is attached to,
the more likely it is that somebody's gonna try
and do some stupid freaking TV special,
or you know how it is.
Nowadays, like with all this true crime bullshit,
the people are obsessed with, I'm concerned about that.
That makes me feel good.
Knowing that Israel Keys would not like this podcast
being done about him.
Also, love that a serial killer is judging people
for being obsessed with stories about serial killers,
like they're the problem, not him.
Bell tells him that they have 10 missing people
that they think are connected to him,
but the FBI is hesitant to ask New York for assistance
and finding the bodies, because that will most likely lead to releasing information to the media.
Bruce wants to show keys, pictures of his boat in Washington, asking questions, but keys
refuses to reveal information until the issue with Vermont is resolved and the issue with
New York is settled.
He's worried that pressure from higher powers in the government will force him into a stand-off
with the FBI where he has to give information or they do a press release. Officer Bel encourage him to give them that info sooner, so that won't happen. He's
agrees to tell them about some bodies in Washington state then. There were four he said, two on one
side of the state, two on the other. The first two victims, he murdered sometime between July
2001, or I mean, I'm sorry, July 2001 and 2005, they had been together. The other two, he took and killed separately,
sometime between the summer of 2005 and 2006. He said in one case, he used a bail
on her boat. He'd purchased from his ex Tammy's ex-husband to dump a body into late crescent.
And that was all he would tell them about those murders at that time. On June 7, 2012,
keys is interviewed by Officer Bell, special agent, special agent, pain and US assistant attorney, Russo.
Again, at this point, the interview was going off for a couple of months, and the FBI was
getting very frustrated with a lack of progress with Keys.
He didn't want to be charged in any other states.
The deal was for Mont.
It was not going the way he wanted.
He's getting pissed for Mont wanted to him, so did New York.
It was predicted that Washington would charge him when they managed to recover the victims.
Investigators are still trying to convince him to complete the deal with New York.
If he gave information in New York about the location of that victim's body from Montwood
and charge him, then the case would remain federal.
But before giving info about other victims, keys wants to maximize what he can get by giving
that information.
He admits in an interview that he has a schedule of how he would like things to play out.
Man, a true
serial killer obsessed with control, right? The organized killer. Keys informs the men that, no matter what they tell him, he won't give them anything until the next week. At this time,
he says there's going to be a lot of frustration before this is all over, but I mean,
there it's already been years of frustration for a lot of people. So they're going to have to learn
to live with it for a little bit longer. Investigators then presenting with two options.
Option A, he cooperates, keeps the deal with Vermont.
Things move on the timeline he wants.
Option B, Vermont gets frustrated.
He's not providing info about the New York victim, so Vermont charges him based on state
laws.
He doesn't want that.
Vermont doesn't have the death penalty.
He asks them to wait a week so we can talk with his lawyer about this deal.
He's mentioned that he wants the other states that they're starting to talk about,
possibly Wyoming and Utah, not to find out about his victims until his death because
they can't prosecute a dead man. He's planned as to wait until right before his execution
to tell them about all his victims so we can avoid the media attention that he does not want.
So odd this way, right? So many of these dirt bags, they love that attention.
July 26, 2012, Keith's interviewed again,
the FBI and police find out about the boat purchased,
or find the boat, Keith's purchased in 2005.
They believe he used this boat to dispose of bodies
in crystal lake.
They tell him they find stains or they found stains.
They could have DNA on them, fibers,
ball of hair, other things.
Keys tells the interviewers that if the case goes to Capitol
Crimes Unit, he wants to be guaranteed to be approved for
the death penalty.
And again, he keeps harping on this, doesn't want to details
to be public.
He says there are certain aspects of the things that I've
done that I don't, I would prefer never to become public.
As far as different things that were done with the bodies
and the sexual assault stuff, that type of stuff, I just don't, we got to figure out something different. He's
expressed his frustration that a reporter from Vermont somehow got information and released
at the public already. He also tells them that he's upset with the interviews that he's
been doing that they will be shown during the hearing. He also says he doesn't want to
be charged for every crime he's been, you know, that he committed. He was already facing
charges for car jacking, kidnapping, sexual assault and murder for
the couriers.
And he has a real problem with the car jacking charge.
I would have fucking weirdo.
Like that matters at this point.
Also apparently upset that his family in Texas has heard that he is responsible for the
couriers murders, even though he was responsible for them.
Investigators tell him about a letter of intent that says that if he pleads guilty in Alaska, he won't have to travel to Vermont to Vermont to be charged.
And that then he has a chance to either be prosecuted by the state of Alaska or federally.
He's response, I'm going to end up frickin frickin max lockdown year after year. You guys bounce me around.
Poor baby, how tragic is not going exactly the way he wants.
On November 29th, he is interviewed for the last time.
His investigators don't know this is going to be the final interview, but it will be.
Investigators inform him about the search for the New York victim, which is still ongoing.
They know that the body is near the area of the banky rob in Tupper Lake.
They want to set up cameras, have him watch the cameras to guide the search crew.
They also searched a house to keys, stating with his family,
a for evidence near the house they found a mattress
in the woods with women's clothing under it,
as well as a man's ring and beads from a necklace
in the fire pit area.
They then informed him that they found his perfect right
thumbprint on an ammo tray.
He doesn't believe he could ever have made such a mistake,
but they tell him it's true.
He says he was just too lazy to dig a hole
for the New York victim that he just put rocks in the body.
He adds that he was planning on going back
to that crime scene in the summer of 2012
to bury the body at an abandoned house.
And then he was gonna burn it down afterwards.
He's always taking these multiple trips.
I think sometimes he would just go back to crime scenes
and investigators and pivot to talking
about the Washington victims who are still unknown.
No bodies recovered.
Israel tells them there's no possibilities
the bodies could still be intact
because they weren't contained in a bag or a box.
He tells them a knife he'd bought at a Walmart
and Port Angeles was used in those murders
and also other weapons.
He also tells them that neither Washington victim
was shot and then would not answer them
when they ask if he had strangled them,
saying you'll get the whole story eventually.
He fucking loves this. Loves controlling how he dispenses the information that they need to solve
or not solve these cases. He says then informed that they found a note in his cell about a male and
female couple that he killed in Washington and he admits that he did kill one couple in Washington
and that there are at least two victims in light crescent. He says he used about four to five milk
jugs per victim to weigh them down.
At the end of the interview,
key requests an hour of internet access
to search for any media articles about him.
He must not have liked what he'd found.
Or maybe he was emailing with my dad
and he didn't like what my dad sent him.
I don't know who my dad emailed on November 29th, 2012.
Two days later, on the night of December 1st, 2012,
Israel keys found dead in his jail cell.
Garge were warned that the keys shouldn't be given
a razor blade, or they had been warned about that,
but he somehow got a hold of one anyway,
and he slid his wrists, strangled himself with his sheet
while he lay in bed.
He wanted to go out on his own terms,
that's what he did, his final act of defiance,
dark victory of sorts.
He controlled things, not the FBI.
The following morning, when his body is discovered, FBI and police are shocked.
They did not see this coming.
They thought he was enjoying this process of negotiations.
The thrill he got, the power he felt, from withholding information from them.
Also, they were surprised by the very lengthy suicide note.
He left very odd suicide note.
Police also found so creepy, 12 individual pieces of paper
in his cell with skulls drawn on them in Key's Blood.
One of the paper says, we are one,
and then the other pieces of paper, yeah,
just skulls drawn on them.
And please believe that these skulls
represent the 11 victims and then himself.
What the fuck?
And then here's the note. it's like a weird poem.
Where will you go?
You clever little worm if you bleed your host dry.
Back in your ride, the night is still young.
Street lights, push back the black neat rows.
Off to the right, a graveyard appears.
Lines of stones, bodies molder below.
Turn away quick, bob your head to the seat.
As straight through that stop sign, you roll loaded truck with lights off, slams into you, broadside,
your flesh smashed as metal explodes. You may have been free, you loved living your lie, fate had
its own scheme crushed like a bug, you still die. Soon now you'll join those ranks of dead
or your ashes, the wind will soon blow.
Family and friends will shed a few tears,
pretend it's off to heaven, you go.
But the reality is you were just bones and meat
and with your brain died also your soul.
Send the dying to wait for their death
in the comfort of retirement homes,
quietly, quickly say it's for the best.
It's best for you so their fate you'll not know.
Turn a blind eye back to the screen, soaking your reality shows.
Stand in front of your mirror and you preen in a plastic castle you call home.
Land of the free, land of the lie, land of scheme, American eyes.
Now it's like a weird song.
Consume what you don't need, stars you idolize. Pursue what you admit is a dream
that it's American die. Get in your big car so you can get to work fast on
roads made of dinosaur bones, punching on the clock and sit on your ass, playing
stupid-ass games and your phone. Paper on your wall says you got smarts. The test
that you took told you so but you would still crawl like the vermin you are
once your precious power grids blow.
Land of the free, land of the lie,
land of the scheme, Americanize.
It is like a song.
I think you wrote it like a weird,
like the shittiest rage against the machine song.
Now that I have held you,
now that I have you held tight,
I will tell you a story.
Speak soft in your ear so you know that it's true.
You're my love at first sight
and though you're scared to be near me, my words penetrate your thoughts now in an intimate prelude.
I looked in your eyes, they were so dark, warm and trusting as though you had not a worry
or care, the more guileless the game, the better potential to fill up those pools with
your fear.
Your face framed in dark curls like a portrait, the sun shown through highlights of red,
what color I wonder, and how straight will it turn plastered
back with the sweat of your blood.
Your wet lips were a promise of a secret unspoken,
nervous laugh as it burst like a pulse of blood
from your throat.
There will be no more laughter here.
I feel your body tense up, my hand now on your shoulder,
your eyes, forget the lady, called luck.
She does not abide near me.
For her powers don't extend to those who are dead.
And then it's a bunch of eligible words.
Then would that I could keep you, let you be the master of your own fate, knowing full
well what's at stake, my pretty captive butterfly colorful wings, my hand smears, I somehow repaying
them with punishment and tears.
Like every once in a while, he rhymes and everyone's always like, ah, fuck it.
Violent metamorphosis,
emerge my dark moth, princess.
I would come often and worship it
on the altar of your flesh.
You shudder with revulsion
and try to shrink far from me.
I'll have you tied down
and begging to become my Stockholm sweetie.
Then you write some notes regarding
the last three sentences being
read to a specific song.
Okay, talk is over. Words are plasti and weak. Back it with action or it all comes off
cheap. Watch close while I work now, feel the electric shock of my touch. Open your trembling
flower on your pedals or your pedals.
I'll crush.
Maybe didn't leave those music instructions, but you know, it feels right, it feels right
tonally.
On December 8, 2012, only eight people attended funeral of Israel keys, his mom, four of his
sisters, three of his brothers-in-laws, brothers-in-law, his girlfriend and daughter do not attend,
good for them.
Not sure, can't say for certain if my dad was there or not.
I don't know where my dad was in December of 2012.
Some point following his death,
it seems that his daughter ends up with her mom,
again in Washington state.
I hope she got a lot of counting for all this.
And with that, our time suck timeline has come to an end.
Good job, soldier. You've made it back. With that, our time-sack timeline has come to an end. Israel Keys, what a dirtbag.
And sorry if I had some awkward pauses around some of the dates, there was some of these
timelines, this FBI information, so many like rental car dates.
And I kind of went back and forth to be reading
like how much of those to include.
So it got really repetitive.
I cut out a lot of them and then just combined
quite a few because it's just like, okay, I get it.
I get it.
You went here.
But I did find it all very interesting.
I found this one of the more interesting true crime ones
in a while, just his upbringing, so strange.
It's such a control-free, exatist.
Yeah, and just born into that such an odd family
of religious extreme fundamentalism.
Interesting two out one from like Mormonism
to then this Christian identity,
a couple different like branches,
to then Amish, to then the mom ends up
in this fucking cult in Texas. Like what?
Uh, keys, the second oldest of the keys kids learned to hunt, build shit in the woods. Uh, where
he also learned, you know, to hate Jewish people and non-whites and fear the Illuminati. Uh,
he rebelled dark ways, secretly gave up on his parents' faith, tortured at least one cat
to death, said a bunch of shit on fire, broken in neighbor's home, stole their guns, maybe
even killed two local 12 year old girls.
When he told his family, he was done with religion, his dad stopped speaking to him forever.
Potentially, it's early 1996.
He's, you know, started to murder, started taking odds, solo trips around the country,
not that long afterwards, wrecking up a shit ton of rental car miles and committing
all likelihood, at least around a dozen kidnappings, murders and rapes, who knows how many bank robberies.
Keys finally arrested in March 2012 for the murder of 18 year old Anchorage, Berista
and high school senior Samantha Kohnig, a victim he also raped, while in custody.
Keys confessed to killing multiple additional people, but he only ever gave two additional
names.
Bill and the rain courier from Essex for Mont gave a lot of clues about other victims, but
wouldn't help the FBI actually track down their bodies, wouldn't give them actual names.
And a lot of those people are still being looked for, the remains are still being looked
for.
As a serial killer, yeah, incredibly unusual.
He borrowed from some of history's worst dirt bags, taken inspiration from people like
Ted Bundy, though the people he went after didn't fit one physical type, gender or age,
usually strangled them, but killed Bill Courier with the gun, likely shot other victims that
haven't conclusively been linked to him. Like to set fires, sexually assault victims,
sometimes when they were alive, sometimes when they were dead. He could be extremely calculated
and meticulous, usually was, but then at the end, very reckless with his final crimes.
Prior to his last few weeks of freedom, he left murder caches all around the country.
So we could come back and make a kill later that would be difficult to trace back to him.
These caches contain weapons, money he got from bank robberies, other tools, and some of
them might still be out there.
He was held a lot from the FBI,
never said exactly how many of these he had stashed around.
Keyes enjoyed killing, showed no remorse,
openly admitted to the FBI
that he would have continued killing
if he had not been caught.
Once he was caught in Texas,
then he began to try and control
and manipulate the investigation.
He did that from the beginning to end.
We could tell things,
we're gonna go the exact way he wanted them to.
He decided to commit suicide in jail cell on December 1, 2012 and left that very strange
suicide note slash poem slash, I don't know, weird insane clown, posse fucking song.
He wanted to die quickly after his capture.
He claimed to protect his daughter for the attention of having his serial killer for
a father.
He clearly cared about how this would all affect her,
but he sure didn't give a fuck about anyone else's daughters.
I seem to care about his girlfriend,
definitely care about his daughter,
seem to care about his mom,
seem to care about himself,
but didn't seem to give a single fuck about anyone else.
You may have liked my dad,
I don't know how well they were getting along
towards the end, if they even knew each other.
There's a lot I don't know.
Glad he's dead, Israel Kees, not my dad.
He's doing fine and guy knows what he's up to right now.
Wish of course keys could have, what a confess to everything to get the family's closure,
but at least with his death, you know, one less sadistic sociopath in the world. That's
about the most positive takeaway. I can take from any of this. Let's look at some more
takeaways in today's top five takeaways.
A number one Israel keys definitely killed for may have killed 11 or more victims. His victims ranged vastly in agent appearance with some of them maybe being his young as 12 or as old as 55,
male and female. This along with the fact that he's traveled such great distances
all over the U.S. from Maine to Alaska to Hawaii to San Diego, all over Texas, etc.
Often driving for days in rental cars to unknown destinations has made it extremely difficult
for the FBI to track down his victims. They are still working on tracking down many of his victims.
Number two, Israel Keys had such a strange childhood. For most of
his childhood, his fun, Hayton, World Fearing parents raised him in his nine siblings
out in the wilderness around Colville, Washington, completely isolated from society and technology.
There the keys kids were homeschooled and attended a white supremacist Christian identity
church. Is this childhood turn him into a serial killer? No, I don't think it did, but maybe,
you know, probably definitely not the best way to raise your kids. Number three, Israel keys wanted a quick
execution to prevent his daughter from growing up with a trial for her serial killer father
playing out in front of her. Was he really a good protective dad? We have no idea. You
know, how he really behaved when no one was watching. We don't know. Is he himself said,
no one really knew the real Israel keys.
Number four, strippers in American Christian heavy metal band
from Orange County, California that formed in 1983.
They released 12 albums.
One of them has gone platinum.
Two others have gone gold.
Heaven's metal fanzine has ranked two hell with a devil.
Number six on his top 100 Christian metal albums,
all time best lists. In 2018, the band released an album called Goddamn Evil and I have to say, I don't care for the cursing. Number six on his top 100 Christian metal albums, All Time Best List.
In 2018, the band released an album called Goddamn Evil
and I have to say, I don't care for the cursing,
the title and I doubt Heidi Kees approves either.
And number five, new info, we didn't mention this,
but Kees was apparently really into the insane clown posse.
Seriously, he may have never listened to Striper,
but he was big into ICP.
Just when you thought you couldn't like him any less, he was a rapist, a murderer, and
he liked Insane Clown Posse, easy jugalos.
I'm kidding around kind of.
Keys love these dudes.
He might not have been a true jugalot, but he did have several large ICP posters hanging
in his barracks when he was in the army.
Insane Clown Posse often abbreviated as as ICP in American hip hop duo composed of Violent J.
His real name is Joseph Bruce and also Shaggy Tudope and that is Shaggy Tudope.
That's his birth name.
I wish.
Now, his real name Joseph Utsler founded in Detroit 1989 in St. Clown Posse performs a style
of hardcore music known as horror core.
Super Violent, often cartotishly violent lyrics.
The songs have been saying clown posse,
center, semantically on the mythology of the dark carnival,
something the duo made up, it's a metaphoric limbo,
which the lives of the dead are judged by,
one of several entities.
Do I think listening to ICP can turn someone
into a sadistic murder?
Absolutely not. Am I surprised to know that keys
was into them? Nope. He knew mommy and daddy would have hated ICP. He sure as shit didn't
get to listen to the the juggler music back in his coalville, little no electricity, no plum
in heaven. Five, suck, top, five, take away.
Israel Keys has been sucked, darkly interesting tale.
I probably had more fun than anyone else
is going to have listening to me talking about throwing
my dad into it.
He may not find it, it's funny as I do.
But I was musing myself, acting like my dad
may have been Israel Keys's serial killer partner.
What's wrong with me?
Thank you to the Bad Magic Productions team
for all the help making time suck.
Queen of Bad Magic Lindsey Cummins,
Reverend Dr. Joe Paisley, the Scripps Keeper Zach Flannery,
Sophie Fax, Source Risk Evans,
Bidelix, her Logan Keith, the Art Warlock,
running BadMagicMarch.com and doing the social posts.
Thanks to all of those who have joined the cult
of the Curious Private Facebook group,
over 25,000 members in there. That is fun to say. Go make some friends. Thanks to Liz Hernandez and who have joined the Cult of the Curious Private Facebook group, over 25,000 members in there.
That is fun to say.
Go make some friends.
Thanks to Liz Hernandez and our all-seeing eyes running the Cult of the Curious Facebook
page.
And thanks to Beefstake and the Mod Squad running the TimeStuck Discord.
And thanks to all of you space that's just playing the TimeStuck trivia game on the app,
Bodie 210, currently the round 7 leader with 4,357 points. Good luck Bode and everyone else.
Nice work. Next week and have a lot of fun, going to go full whackadoodle.
Haven't done that for a while on TimeSuck. We're going to dive back into the world of conspiracy theories.
Look at a very populated, very well-known building. Some think it might be one of the gates to hell
or a UFO base or a secret government testing facility.
We've touched on it before.
Now we're diving fully in and talk about the Denver International Airport all road lead
to the Denver Airport.
Since its inception in 1995, some have thought that there is something very suspicious about
DIA or starters.
It is massive.
The property built on it's built on bigger than the entire area of Manhattan entire little island roughly 53 square miles
And it's filled with things that might give a normal person pause things like giant murals to pick in violent conflict environmental
Destruction gargoyles by the baggage claim a statue of the Egyptian god of death
The airport's most famous art installation is a 32 foot statue of a blue stallion with glowing red demonic looking ice
It is pretty creepy.
I think it also looks pretty awesome.
But is it actually loaded with symbolism
about the end of days and the new world order?
Is there illuminati messages being spread
by these art installations in the Denver International Airport?
Maybe, probably not, but maybe.
Series about the DIA run the gamut from paranormal to extra
terrestrial to government secrets and beyond. People think it's the place where the elite will
convene at the end of days to bring the world under one globalist government. Or that the many
tunnels beneath it are being used to transport UFOs or bodies. We'll get into all these theories
including their supporters as well as many other things of note about the DIA, including what makes
it such a fantastic airport. It consistently gets good ratings from travel magazines. their supporters as well as many other things of note about the DIA, including what makes
it such a fantastic airport. It consistently gets good ratings from travel magazines.
I always preferred taking a layover at Salt Lake City or Minneapolis or Seattle,
but maybe I was just connected to the wrong terminal.
And then, Aliens Gargoyles conspiracies and more next week on Time Suck.
Right now, let's head over to today's Time Sucker updates.
to today's Time Sucker Updates. Updates, get your time, sucker updates!
Super Sucker Joe Krab has a commons law moment to share and a cool update to last week's
Operation Paperclip Suck.
He writes, Hello Suck Master, so I just realized while listening to the Emanuel David cult
suck that I've sent in two messages to the wrong email address.
My wife and I have been huge fans of your stand up for a long time. My wife got me into
scared of death, which led me down the rabbit hole to time suck. I've been binging my way through
the episodes and while at work, I was listening to the Yahooem Crowl suck on my Bluetooth speaker
when a coworker walked into my office. All he heard was you describing Crowl prematurely
ejaculating onto his date. And he just simply asked, what the hell are you listening to?
Fortunately, I work at a laid-back wood shop and it's hard to offend the people I work with.
While listening to the latest episode of Time Suck, I was reminded of a person from my area
I grew up in Terahot, Indiana. There's a museum there called Candles, children of Auschwitz,
Nazi Deadly Lab Experiments, Survivors. It's a Holocaust Museum, the Candles Holocaust Museum,
which was started by an amazing person named Eva Kor.
She was a survivor of testing done by Joseph Manglei on twins.
She and her twin sister were some of the very few
to survive until the Red Army liberated them.
The rest of their family were killed
in the concentration camp.
When I was in middle school, she came and talked to our school
about her life and what it took for her to deal with the life she had been given. She was eventually able
to forgive the people who experimented on her. If it were me, I would have a hard time doing that
to someone who did that to me as a child. There's a video on YouTube, which I will include,
that is her telling her story. Sorry for the long message. Love the podcast. Three to five stars
wouldn't change a thing. If we can ever get past this COVID stuff and get back to comedy shows again,
my wife and I will definitely be up front and center, Joey.
Man, thank you, Joey.
And do one intense YouTube video you passed along.
And I watched it, anyone else who wants to watch it,
it's about seven, eight minutes long,
is titled, Eva Kor, the Holocaust survivor
who forgaves the Nazis.
It's on the BBC Ideas channel.
Linkin' today's show notes on the Time Suck app
to the video as well. It's powerful shit. And what a cool museum. I checked out the website.
How terrible that some, you know, fucking Nazi neo-Nazi idiot, set it on fire in 2003.
Fucking Holocaust deniers, Aryan nation assholes, even had it rebuilt in 2005 for stories so
tragic and inspiring at
the same time, or a special meat sack.
She died last year in 2019 at the age 85, and there's a documentary also that I have not
watched 2006 documentary about her story titled Forgiving Dr. Mengele.
Yeah, she actually, in the YouTube video I watched, she talks about she got one of the
doctors from Auschwitz who had the job of confirming how many people died.
Each time a group was killed in the gas chamber to go with her two Auschwitz and sign a document
confirming it really happened in his advanced years and his 80s he does this.
It's a very cool video.
Thank you, Joey, for turning me on to her very powerful story.
She talks about forgiveness is really inspiring.
Hilden and Rod to you.
Awesome sucker, Heidi Wallace, not Heidi Keys.
Also has an update inspired by Operation Paperclip.
She has an important message. She writes,
Good morning, both jangles and master sucker.
I am finishing the Operation Paperclip suck and you spoke of
a disease that my husband has been fighting for 22 years.
My husband was diagnosed with chronic lymphocytic leukemia in June of 1999 when we had an 18-year-old
and eight-year-old, a one-year-old, and a five-month-old.
Damn.
He has gone through chemotherapy on and off for the last 22 years.
He has been on chemo nonstop for seven years now.
It is mutated into aggressive form and he's still
fighting. This disease has been hard on the entire family. It's still in so much
from our family yet has given us so much. We've married 26 years. So for 22 of
the 26 years, he's been fighting for his life. The only cure for it is a bone marrow
transplant, but there have been zero matches for him. I plead with everyone to
sign up to be an organ and tissue donor. It may save someone you love. Thank you
for keeping me entertained while I work from home.
Thank you for making me laugh
through all this crap going on in the world.
Take care, love your family, sorry.
Love your family and remember to tell them you love them.
Thank you Heidi.
Yes, I am signed up.
So is Lindsey.
Yes, sign up for that shit.
Sign up to be an organ donor, tissue donor.
Yeah, you don't have to be alive to save an organ donor, you know, tissue donor. Yeah, you don't have
to be alive to save someone else's life. Pretty, pretty powerful. And your husband, my God,
what a tough son of a bitch. Good on him for being such a fighter. Both jangles is very
impressed. I'd say, you know, I hope he keeps fighting, but I don't think anybody needs
to say that. Sounds like, of course, he will. It's just who he is, what he does. Yeah, thank
you for sending that message
and spreading the word.
Another operation paper-clip-related message,
embarrassed sucker, Russ McCrory was put
in an awkward situation due to my magnus von Braun lies.
It writes, dammit, Dan.
So I'm listening to the latest episode.
I'm listening to you talk about the Bavarian werewolf.
And right after you finish this story,
but before you can get into the announcer bit,
I have to pause to join a Zoom call for work.
My coworker has a degree in history and is a World War II expert slash nerd, so I could
not wait to impress him with this new knowledge that I gained on a lesser known World War
II figure.
So I launched into the story, he's smiling the whole time I'm telling it.
After I finish, he just says, where do you hear that from?
I tell him about time, suck. He responds with,
Magnus Von Braun was definitely not a professional wrestler
and did not take on a gorilla.
But I'm most definitely gonna check out this podcast
because it sounds hilarious.
So good news, we might have a new sucker.
Bad news for me is you got me, you bastard.
We had a good laugh.
I told him I'm almost positive.
You got me with one of your many diversions.
After the Zoom call, I press play to continue the episode
only to hear you give us the classic,
check, hey, gosh dang. And I text him to tell him that I got got. I have a video of this video. I have a video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of
this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of
this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of
this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this
video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of
this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this
this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this
video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this
video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this
this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this
of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this
of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video of this video coworker happy to have another history buff in the cult. Very happy. I just wanted so badly for at least one person
to fall from my very, where we'll full shit.
I'm so glad that you did.
And I hope I see you on the road someday
and hope you continue to enjoy the show.
And now, suffer in sucker, Wade Brander could use a shout out.
As Karing sack Daniel Dack has brought to our attention,
she writes,
first of all, hail Lucifina and praise Nimrod.
I'm from Pierre
South Dakota. I'm a volunteer firefighter on Pierre Fire and a correctional officer at
a local at our local prison. I have to thank my boyfriend Wade for introducing me to
TimeSuck and anything associated. My weekly listen is scared to death, creeper for life,
Lindsay is my idol. That's adorable. The reason why I messaged is because my boyfriend
Wade is a big fan of Dan, all of his hard work, he can't go a day without a Dan comments quote, sadly the evening of Thursday, January
14th, he lost everything he had when his apartment building caught on fire.
Everything considered a complete loss between fire and water damage.
I managed to save only a couple items from his apartment after walking to ankle deep water.
One hat of his was a time suck hat that was miraculously completely untouched.
I'm trying to lift his spirits a little
because of his current situation.
Are there any way you guys can give Wade Brander
from Pierce, South Dakota a shout out?
I know hearing Dan Cummins say his name
will definitely put his long lost smile on his face.
Sorry for the long message, wishing everyone is safe and well.
Wade!
So sorry about the fire.
So glad you weren't hurt in it.
Fuck man. Yeah, super shitty.
No way around that.
Luckily they can't burn your memories.
Glad you still have those and you have a super caring
girlfriend, that's huge.
Luis of Fina and I wish you so much sympathy sex.
I wish you nothing but good health, but if you do die soon,
I hope it's due to Danielle literally fucking your brain
down.
So here's the hope things turn around
and you're awesome for sending this message in Danielle.
And yeah, wait, man, hope you see on the road one of these days
and hope life is a lot better for you when I do.
Last one now, a quickie from male carrying meat sack, Joshua.
This is ridiculous, you have a ridiculous last name, which you know, O L S Z T A. What's
that like, check this vacuum?
Joshua, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh from the guys at small town murder, finally got a chance to start listening to their day. Love in the content so far. I was finishing up the dark ages suck, which I almost changed and stopped listening to
when you were joking about it,
not being a good episode.
I'm glad I stuck with it because when it was time
for emails, I was blown away to hear you utter
the name of a letter carrier that I trained a few years ago.
The thoughts of simulation theory were screaming in my head.
Thanks for the laughs, love to the other male carriers
out there.
New meat sack listener, Josh. Josh, oh, it's, uh, it's, uh, too funny, Josh.
I wonder if anyone else heard my lie that it was just a terrible fucking episode and skip
it and actually did skip it.
That would weirdly make me happy.
Cool that you heard a coworker who had written in or, you know, heard their name.
Thanks for keeping that male coming also during a challenging time.
My God, it got to deliver shit.
I hope you keep enjoying the show.
Big thanks to James and Jimmy over at Small Time Murder
and Crime and Sports for pushing our direction.
Love those guys.
And yeah, and thank you for me as well.
It's all the mail carriers, all the Amazon drivers,
all the UPS drivers, FedEx delivery drivers,
more and more people getting shit sent to their house
with since COVID kind of changed the way people purchase things. And it just has put weird pressure on a lot of the, a lot of drivers I know to handle bigger,
yeah, bigger volume of packages to work longer hours. Also, some of them, you know, we don't know
their health situation. Some of them worried about COVID, but still happy to do this as essential
workers and blah, blah, blah. In any way, I'm way I'm just thankful for you guys doing what you do.
And gals, of course, I shouldn't use the guide default.
Thank you for you for your meat sacks.
Do what you do.
Thank you to everyone.
Thanks, time suckers.
I need a net.
We all did.
Thanks again for listening to meat sacks.
More bad magic productions, content,
come in every week if you want wanna watch it on video form.
You can't on YouTube, you wanna hear it in audio form,
you can find it all over the place.
Spooks with scared to death late Tuesday nights,
silliness with Is We Dumb Wednesdays at noon,
Pacific time, also I do host a podcast show,
Little Inspiration Nuggets every morning,
Monday through Friday,
little seven, eight minute episodes, incredible feats.
Please don't raise your kids in a tent this week,
because you're afraid of the government and of the devil.
When you're famed, you just, instead, keep on suckin'.
I'm so excited.
I'm so excited.
Oh, shit.
Oh, shit.
Oh, shit.
Oh, shit.
Oh, shit.
Okay, so this will just take a second.
Okay.
We have some murder photos, use some cold cases.
Oh, oh, okay, you might know
One of the gentlemen that's in the background of every single one of these pictures. Really?
So it's um, oh my god. Oh, that's my dad. That's your dad right there. Yep. That's my dad for sure
Um, this one is that oh, yeah. Yeah. Oh, that's yeah, absolutely. That's my dad. I recognize that shirt
I bought him that hat. That's my dad
And then this one yep. Yep. That's my dad. I recognize that shirt, I bought him that hat. That's my dad. And then this one?
Yep, yep, that's my dad.
I can absolutely confirm that.
And last one, this is just a picture of your dad.
Yeah, that is my dad.
That's also my dad.
And then this was in one of the bodies?
That knife was in one of the, that's my dad's knife.