Timesuck with Dan Cummins - 510 - Black Death: The Bizarre Kidnapping of Chloe Ayling

Episode Date: June 8, 2026

A young British glamour model flies to Milan for what she believes is a routine photo shoot in 2017 — and vanishes into one of the strangest kidnapping cases in modern true crime history. Drugged, s...tuffed into the trunk of a car, and allegedly marked for sale on a dark web sex auction by a shadowy group called “Black Death,” Chloe Ayling’s story quickly spiraled into an international media frenzy filled with bizarre twists, contradictory behavior, and public skepticism. Was she the victim of a real human trafficking plot, the target of a delusional criminal fantasy, or part of an elaborate publicity stunt gone horribly sideways? This is one the weirdest, most confusing, and strangely fascinating abduction stories of the internet age. Merch and more: www.badmagicproductions.com  Timesuck Discord! https://discord.gg/tqzH89v Want to join the Cult of the Curious PrivateFacebook Group? Go directly to Facebook and search for "Cult of the Curious" to locate whatever happens to be our most current page :) For all merch-related questions/problems: store@badmagicproductions.com (copy and paste) Please rate and subscribe on Apple Podcasts and elsewhere and follow the suck on social media!! @timesuckpodcast on IG and http://www.facebook.com/timesuckpodcast Wanna become a Space Lizard? Click here: https://www.patreon.com/timesuckpodcast. Sign up through Patreon, and for $5 a month, you get access to the entire Secret Suck catalog (295 episodes) PLUS the entire catalog of Timesuck, AD FREE. You'll also get 20% off of all regular Timesuck merch PLUS access to exclusive Space Lizard merch. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 In the early hours of July 11th, 2017, Chloe Aileen, a 20-year-old British glamour and page 3 model arrived at a studio in Milan, Italy's fashion capital, for what she believed was going to be a leather-clad motorcycle-themed photo shoot. But instead, by the end of the day, she would be drugged with ketamine, stuffed into the trunk of a car, stuffed into a bag, driven across northern Italy by a man claiming to be part of a shadowy criminal organization known as Black Death, an organization of nefarious agents spread out across Europe that was going to sell her into sexual slavery via a dark web auction being held in just a few days' time, unless she could come up with several hundred thousand dollars that she did not have, and ransom money. Italian investigators and their British counterparts, and then the public at large will struggle mightily to make sense of this story. When she makes it out alive, journalists will
Starting point is 00:00:56 zero in on some of Chloe's seemingly strange behavior witnessed during her captivity and directly following her release, and the British public will ridicule her. Many will question whether a kidnapping had ever occurred, or if Chloe alien's abduction had actually been a staged publicity stunt. What if the two men arrested for the crime were not her captors after all, but instead were her accomplices? So what really happened in Italy that summer? Was this a failed human trafficking attempt? A bizarre ploy of love and obsession? Or an elaborate publicity stunt that spiraled out of control?
Starting point is 00:01:34 Today we are diving into the highly entertaining and very unusual story of the abduction of Chloe Aileen, where the line between victim and suspect was blood. for so long by so many, and still is today by some, on this true crime or is it fake crime edition of TimeSuck. This is Michael McDonald, and you're listening to TimeSuck. You're listening to TimeSuck. Well, happy Monday. Welcome or welcome back to the cult of the curious.
Starting point is 00:02:15 I'm Dan Cummins, the Suckmaster, Dan of God, Nova Scotia, Royal Canadian Mount of Police Auditor, and you are listening to TimeSum. suck. Hail Nimrod, Hail Lucina, praise me to Good Boy Bo Jangles, and Glory B to Triple M. One quick announcement, well, you know what? It's a little bit of a longer announcement. And then we were off into the story. If you are thinking of attending the wet, hot, bad magic summer camp this fall, you're going to want to get your tickets soon. Because this year will be the last year we were ever going to hold the wet hot bad magic summer camp. I know, not the greatest announcement to start off the show. But also, only one more of these makes this next
Starting point is 00:02:52 one that more special. Here's the reality of it. Our first camp hosted a little over 500 people. But each year, the attendance has dwindled a bit. This year, we have around 300 campers as I record this. We've had a lot of the same people keep coming back, which I think speaks to how fun this event has been. But those same people can't keep coming back every year.
Starting point is 00:03:12 It's just not financially responsible for us to keep taking this big risk going forward. And I'm not actually upset about it. I mean, I'm a little bit sad, sure, but also so great. way more grateful than that we were ever able to pull it off even one time camp is a huge ask it's not just the cost of the ticket it's also transportation time off of work days spent away from your family which could also mean incurring child care costs you know giving up pto for a vacation with us instead of somebody else you know we know that we've been asking a lot of you year over year and travel costs have gone up a lot more recently and might not be going down anytime soon
Starting point is 00:03:49 and also, you know, all good things come to an end. It is just a natural cycle of life. And sometimes, though, when one thing ends, something else begins, something really cool, another reason for Rapid Camp up this year is a selfish one on my part. I want to be focusing more on fiction, on creating stories starting next year.
Starting point is 00:04:11 I've been very creatively inspired, writing nightmare fuel short stories over on the Scared to Death Feed is where we've been releasing them. I thought I would like writing them when I started working on them a little over two years ago as an experiment, well, I like it way, way more than I ever hoped I would. And the feedback has been tremendous.
Starting point is 00:04:29 I want to start writing books. I want to start doing more with these stories, you know, converting them into different formats. But to do that, I need a lot more time. Time I definitely do not have right now. Camp after this year will partially be a casualty of me creating more space for something new. But that said, I am so looking forward to. camp this year. I truly am. Every year, so many special moments have been made. I expect no difference this fall, you know, no different. So if coming to camp this year is an option for you, or if you know,
Starting point is 00:05:00 we're really hoping to come to camp at some point in the future, well, you're going to want to do it now. If you want to join us for the final camp hurrah, the big blowout, tickets are still available until August 3rd. Camp is going to be September 10th through the 13th in Equinong, Pennsylvania. I think Woodstock of the famed music festival. It's nearby. that. We will be there full of gratitude for the years of memories made. It's going to be fucking awesome. It really is such a unique and special event. I don't know of any other podcasts who have put together something like this, you know, over and over. And again, I'm so grateful that we were ever able to do it even one time. So a huge thank you to everyone who has come in years past
Starting point is 00:05:40 and everyone who will be coming this year. I hope some of you will end up and join some of the new things I will be working on starting next year. I have a really good feeling about them. Sorry to be a little cryptic, but I don't want to share any more about next year right now. Please go to bad magic productions.com. Scroll on down to the graphic for wet hot bad magic summer camp 26
Starting point is 00:06:01 to learn more if you are interested. Okay. I know that was a lot, but now let's dig into another wild one. Not going to say much before the timeline today. If you haven't heard of this story, you know, if you're not familiar with it, I think this is going to be more entertaining
Starting point is 00:06:25 than if you had. It'll be captivating, very confusing in moments, but by the end, I think you'll be like, oh, okay, now it all makes sense. Holy shit. If you've heard of this before, I think you'll find new details about this story revealed here that didn't make the final cut
Starting point is 00:06:43 in various docu-series and other media about this all. It is such a ridiculous story. And I'll tell it all chronologically in today's TimeSuck timeline. Shrap on those boots, soldiers. We're marching down a time-suck timeline. Chloe Aileen was born on July 14, 1997 in Colesden, a town of about 25,000 people in the south London borough of Croydon. While Croydon itself has a lingering reputation for being a little rough around the edges,
Starting point is 00:07:22 Colston is generally seen as a quieter, more pleasant commuter town. It's quaint. It's right on the very outer edge of Greater London. So while it is technically inside of the London Metro Air, It is not the London that most of us probably picture. This is not an urban area. It's decidedly suburban, teetering towards rural along its outer edge. It says very close to the ceremonial county of Surrey, a county bordered by the greater
Starting point is 00:07:46 London to the northeast, and therefore its residents have quick and easy access to the countryside, to golf clubs, the woods, a bunch of British pubs, but nearly everybody in England has access to a bunch of British pubs, I guess. Chloe's mother, Bieta, is Polish. Her father was English, but he wasn't in the picture for most of Chloe's life. In fact, he largely abandoned Chloe and her mother and didn't get back in touch until Chloe aliens started making all the newspaper articles and TV shows because of this abduction. So he sounds like a really cool dude. What?
Starting point is 00:08:22 My daughter's famous now? Oh, shit. Well, I guess she might be worth checking in with. Well, maybe she's rich, too. Papa needs a new pair of shoes. I would share his name, but his identity has never been publicly revealed. So Chloe was raised by a single mom, a Polish single mom. So you know that life was super hard for her.
Starting point is 00:08:42 She was essentially raised by wolves, or rather a wolf, someone mentally incapable of fully learning a human language, someone barely able to walk upright, more beast than human, a creature of the night who undoubtedly ate mostly raw meat, shit in the yard, and literally howled at the moon. No, actually her mom seemed to be consistently awesome. Hardworking, caring, smart, attentive, strong, beautiful woman, and hot. I love the way so many Polish women look.
Starting point is 00:09:08 My Polish, Lucifina, Lindsay, being at the top of the list. What is this about Polish women? I swear I didn't do, or I swear didn't know, excuse me, that Chloe was Polish before deciding to do this topic, by the way. Had not heard of this tale before a researcher suggested it. Anyway, Chloe and her mom are but a few of many polls around London. the Polish community actually currently forms one of the largest foreign-born populations in the entire country. Estimates range between 650,000 to 750,000 Polish citizens currently living across the UK, with the vast majority residing in England and the largest concentration in the capital
Starting point is 00:09:43 where roughly 127,000 Polish nationals live, right there in London. Massive wave of migration began after Poland joined the EU, the European Union in 2004, seven years after Chloe was born, when the UK immediately opened its borders to Polish workers. Now enough poll talk. This isn't the fucking Poltok cast, okay? Despite Dad not being in the picture, she, her mom, and others have said that she was a very, very happy child.
Starting point is 00:10:11 Always giggling, always smiling, the sort of kid who made adults stop and comment on how cheerful she was. Chloe's primary school teacher even used to call her smile. Pretty adorable. It was a fitting nickname because, Chloe rarely cried. She found crying to be very embarrassing. And if she did need to shed a tear,
Starting point is 00:10:30 she would typically wait until she could be behind closed doors and alone so no one else would see her. Chloe also didn't read people the way other kids did when she was very young, the way most other kids did. She didn't pick up on the hints and social cues that most of the kids around her, you know, noticed and picked up on. She needed everything spelled out very directly, not good with sarcasm or absurdity.
Starting point is 00:10:51 her mom would accompany her on school field trips when she was little, partially because she was worried that her daughter would not be able to properly communicate what she needed or even realize if she was in trouble. Chloe herself said that when she was a kid, somebody could tell her off right, they could blatantly bully her, and she would be blissfully unaware of that fact and just smile back at them. More on why she is emotionally and mentally wired like this at the end of the episode. As a teenager, Chloe, an only child, by the way,
Starting point is 00:11:21 attended Woodcoat High School in South Croydon. She did well there. She got good grades. The only subject she failed was history, which she later has said that she hated. She found it to be painfully boring. And I do get that. I love history,
Starting point is 00:11:35 but I will say there are definitely some boring-ass history teachers out there, which is a shame. And sometimes not their fault, because they're handcuffed by their, you know, administration by what they're allowed to kind of teach and how to teach it. And it's a bummer because so much of history is so naturally exciting
Starting point is 00:11:51 and wildly intriguing. You know, like you have to fucking work hard to suck the fun and interesting aspects out of a history lesson. Chloe said she would sit in history class staring at the clock waiting for it to be over. She did not see the point in studying the past. She preferred to focus on the future.
Starting point is 00:12:06 No, Chloe, no, you got, looking at the past, you can actually help with the future, help you predict it, help you understand the present as well, right? It can help you handle adversity as you look forward as you realize no struggle is truly new
Starting point is 00:12:16 and patterns repeat. Growing up as Chloe began to read people a little better, she began to tend to deal with problems in a very matter-of-a-fact way or matter-of-fact way. She was a problem-solver who did not get caught up in emotion. She did not dwell on things,
Starting point is 00:12:31 tended not to overthink or sit with uncomfortable emotions. In fact, she hated talking about big feelings and preferred to keep everything happy and surface level. It was Woodcoat where Chloe met her best friend, Tony. The two girls quickly became inseparable. They were like sisters and came up with matching nicknames for each other. Chloe called Tony toenail, and Tony called Chloe.
Starting point is 00:12:51 clonail. Love a good nickname, right? Solid work. In high school, Chloe became the kind of girl, not surprising at all for a future model who put a lot of time and energy into her appearance. She carefully styled her hair every single day before school, getting her makeup just right as well. She would transform her long blonde hair into a quiff hairstyle, which was, you know, very popular in the 2010s. If you would ask Chloe back then what she wanted to be when she finished school, she would have told you without hesitation that she wanted to be a successful model, that she wanted at least 100,000 followers, that she wanted to travel and see the world's most beautiful places, that she wanted to make her own money in a bunch of it. One of those people, rare in my
Starting point is 00:13:29 experience, who knew who they were, knew what they wanted to be, what they wanted out of life, you know, at an early age. Growing up in Colston, Chloe would walk her dogs around the streets of the, you know, suburbs, up into Surrey, and look at all the grand houses with pillars. She loved big houses with pillars specifically. She would look at them and think, I want one of those. And unlike some people, she actually believed that she could get one of those. Her mantra was that if you want something badly enough, you will get it because you will not stop trying and you will not accept anything less. She trusted she could make all her dreams happen.
Starting point is 00:14:02 She just had to work hard for them. She was prepared to do whatever it took to become famous. And this open ambition of hers would help lead a lot of people in the wake of her kidnapping to think that she had staged it. She was maybe, you know, according to some people, too honest, too transparent. about her ambition. Though better at reading people in high school, she was still far from great at it. She was a beautiful girl, didn't always realize others' intentions towards beautiful girls. When Chloe was around 15, one of her teachers, grown-ass man, obviously, and in a position
Starting point is 00:14:35 of authority above her, asked her out to lunch, and she accepted. He picked a quiet table at the back of the restaurant. Luckily, her best friend, Tony, was a lot more street-smart than Chloe was. She came along to keep an eye on things. She immediately thought the situation was bizarre and which was, was obvious to everyone that this teacher was what they were trying to do, obvious to everyone except for Chloe. She didn't think there was anything wrong with a male teacher, taking his minor female student out to lunch far away from the school, just the two of them, in a little quiet spot to her. That was just lunch. Not an obvious date. She never went anywhere alone with that teacher again after that.
Starting point is 00:15:12 Not sure if he ever got into trouble for that. Sadly probably didn't. You know, probably just was a, what? Inappropriate. I just wanted to talk to her about her stuff. buddies. God, you can't put a little extra energy into teaching now and to taking care of kids? Wanted to make sure she felt good about the assignments, you know? Why are we trying to turn this into something it's not? I was hoping to bring her back to my place where we could talk about school in private, you know, without the distraction of our clothes.
Starting point is 00:15:34 I mean, other people around. Chloe's described herself back then as being incredibly naive. She truly believed that the world was full of mostly good kind people. She thought that if she just stayed out of people's way, didn't bother them, then nothing bad would happen to her. That worldview lasted through most of her teenage years, lasted until she started modeling. And then, well, then things changed rather quickly. Before modeling, not long before, at the age of 16, Chloe completed her GCSEs, the UK's main standardized exams,
Starting point is 00:16:07 roughly equivalent to finishing 10th grade here in the States, and then moved on to what's called sixth form, where British students spend two years studying just a handful of subjects before university. With hopes to become a lawyer, if her modeling career didn't take off, she chose law, business, and psychology. But Chloe wouldn't finish. Life had other plans. In early 2015, she got pregnant.
Starting point is 00:16:29 The summer before her final year of high school while on holiday in Spain, she'd met a man named Connor Keys, a carpet fitter from the UK. Sounds like he's about the same age as her from references to him made in the media. Within a year of her age, it sounds like, so they were both kids. The two had an on-again-off-again, dalliance by the middle of 2015. relationship was over, roughly six months after Ashton was born. Some sources say they broke up earlier than that, you know, before she gave birth. So I guess that would have been, they broke up between the middle of 2015 and early 2016, actually.
Starting point is 00:17:04 In November of 2015, Chloe had Ashton when she's still 17. And her and Connor, since the breakup, have shared custody maybe evenly, I think, probably. there was a lot of British tabloid speculation about all this, including about exactly when she had her kid. According to an article in the UK's Daily Star, Connor has largely raised Ashton, or at least was mostly raising him back in 2017. He was quoted as saying shortly after her kidnapping that year,
Starting point is 00:17:34 she can come and see him whenever she wants to, but the thing is, I am still waiting for her to do that. And he also maybe said, she wants to be a model, and she can't do it when she's 40. But for now, she's young and dumb, since I was with her, she has changed. She's already doing stuff that she didn't when I was with her. Did he really say that?
Starting point is 00:17:54 Is that true? The Daily Star is like the U.S. is Star magazine when it comes to its level of journalistic integrity. Maybe slightly more reliable than like the weekly world news. In a UK Daily Mail interview, another tablet, there's so many fucking tablets in the UK. Mr. Keyes described Chloe as being, quote, 100% focused on her modeling career
Starting point is 00:18:12 and said that their son Ashton spends much of his time with him because Ms. Alien is often too busy abroad on photo shoots. So maybe that shit was true. Or maybe he's a fucking loser and is jealous of her and spiteful. Who knows? Regardless of the custody situation, studying on top of trying to raise a child and start a modeling career proved too much for Chloe and she failed her A-levels,
Starting point is 00:18:35 a legal career now off the table, at least for the moment, so she decided to really get serious about modeling. However, even when her body had returned to its pre-pregnancy shape, there was still a big problem for her modeling career. At 5'6. Chloe, two inches below the industry minimum for women looking for runway and high fashion work. She is also quite curvy, which is frowned upon for high fashion cover models. One of the reasons I've always found girl next door types, non-runway models, actually far more attractive and sexy than runway models.
Starting point is 00:19:08 If you're a runway model, no offense, obviously most of the world thinks you're incredibly gorgeous. I don't think you're fucking ugly. At all, you're far more attractive than I am. Just not my type, right? I recognize, again, runway models often very beautiful, just not to look for me. Isn't it wonderful, by the way, that beauty is so subjective for all of us?
Starting point is 00:19:28 Anyone struggling with her self-esteem, appearance-wise, man or woman, just remember that. You don't need to conform to somebody else's look to some other standard. You need to find somebody who loves your look. And they are out there. Beating off or diddling away to thoughts of your sweet naked ass,
Starting point is 00:19:42 whatever size it happens to be right now. now. So go fucking get it. Just have good hygiene. Put a little effort into your appearance. Have some pride. You know, just fuck that shit about it, about pride coming before a fall. Have a little pride.
Starting point is 00:19:55 And go get it! Anyway, for Chloe, her lack of height and having, well, hips and boobs meant that a modeling career in glossy magazines, haute couture on catwalks was pretty unlikely. Most agents wouldn't even consider her for that.
Starting point is 00:20:11 Fortunately, modeling, not just high fashion and runway, There's all sorts of modeling, hand modeling. Do you guys know I was a hand model? I wasn't. Fitness modeling. Do you know I was a fitness model? You knew I wasn't.
Starting point is 00:20:23 Glamour modeling. And that's what Chloe chose, you know, for which Chloe, a curvy figure, blonde hair, was a natural fit. In this kind of modeling, the goal is not to sell clothes, it's to sell the fantasy of the person wearing them. Launderee shoots, swimmer campaigns, men's magazines, calendars, topless stuff, maybe fully nude stuff. Chloe started doing test shoots, built up a portfolio, signed with her first agency, and quickly became high in demand. Chloe's first major break came in December of 2016 when she appeared in a YouTube video on the JMX YouTube channel titled, One Goal Equals Remove One Piece of Clothing Football Challenge.
Starting point is 00:21:02 17 million views as of this recording, probably infuriating a lot of content creators out there, right? people spend fucking years putting together a stand-up special or, you know, all this time creating a song
Starting point is 00:21:15 and an awesome music video and they're like, oh my God, a million views is fucking incredible. This guy's like, I'm going to play a fucking strip soccer match
Starting point is 00:21:24 with just me and a buddy and two girls, 17 million views. Nothing will ever sell better than sex. In the video, Chloe along with another model. They just took turns
Starting point is 00:21:35 kicking soccer balls and do a goal. It's not even like a good camera they used. There's, production value is very low. For every goal they missed, well, they had to take off an item of clothing.
Starting point is 00:21:46 And the video went viral. Some people called it exploitive. Others loved it, you know, but their opinions did not matter to Chloe. Who didn't take off much, by the way, just like her shirt. But, you know, she had something else underneath it, a lingerie type of thing.
Starting point is 00:22:03 A lacy camisole, I think. I'm not great with identifying various types of clothing. Despite not revealing much, the video going viral in tandem with her personality and natural looks led to her Instagram following exploding. By the time the video had run its course, Chloe had around 200,000 followers. And that led to some amazing new job opportunities. She started booking out a bunch of modeling jobs, making around 600 pounds a day for these jobs at 19 years old, right? That's some serious bank.
Starting point is 00:22:28 However, all this newfound attention, you know, came at a cost. According to her buddy Tony, old toenail, as Clonel's social media following grew, so did being DM'd by a bunch of creepy delusional, mostly older men. The kind of guys who think sending a young woman, or any woman, a pick of their dick, along with a not so clever line, like, want to ride it or down to fuck, might actually lead to real-life sex. I'm not kidding. Back in 2016, so around this same time, I was hosting a show down in Los Angeles for the Playboy Channel,
Starting point is 00:23:01 the Playboy Morning Show. I hosted it in 2015, 2016. We had nude models doing silly, campy games, four days a week, and the models liked me platonically, because I was already dating Lindsay, was engaged actually, and not trying to fuck them. A lot of them, they were really funny, and they would tell me these wild stories, including stories about guys that messaged them all the time. And I was shocked back then to hear these stories. I wasn't jaded by time-sook yet.
Starting point is 00:23:25 But they would tell stories about how many guys literally sent them pictures of their fucking boners. just unsolicited photo after unsolicited photo of a weird dude holding his hard dick in his hand you know plus some you know little message of like hey what are you doing you like what you see and they weren't joking they weren't doing
Starting point is 00:23:47 for shock value they were just like this is like oh this is how you flirt uh always a curious person I asked them all kinds of questions one being does that literally ever work and as best as I can recall not a single model and we had dozens and dozens on the show literally ever went on a single date with the guy who did that.
Starting point is 00:24:05 I don't remember a single one of them ever saying that they even liked it, that they liked getting unsolicited picks of dicks. It didn't matter how nice the dick looked. Apparently, if you got a real aesthetic, you know, Dick, they still don't want to see it. Not in just a random fucking photo just out of nowhere. Just bam, you want that?
Starting point is 00:24:20 You like it? You want to suck it? No, they don't like that. You know, not once where they're like, oh, mama like, I wasn't a whole any moment ago. But after seeing that unsolicited hot cock, ooh, mama's about to drown these jeans. By 2017, Chloe getting, you know, she's getting some fame on the internet.
Starting point is 00:24:41 She'd signed with Supermodel Agency in London, a supermodel agency founded by Phil Green in 1987, represented glamour and commercial models, promotional personnel, actors across the UK. Many of his higher profile models also doubled as influencers as the internet is changing. so it was a perfect fit for Chloe and Chloe and her agent Phil
Starting point is 00:25:00 quickly became close to Chloe Phil was a father figure he offered the kind of stability an older male wisdom that she had not had growing up that she craved she said she trusted him completely and it does seem like
Starting point is 00:25:11 like maybe he's a good guy at least not he doesn't seem like a terrible guy there are for sure a lot of Harvey Weinstein type creeps amongst modeling agents and producers I got a lot of those stories too for the models I used to work with sadly wasn't surprised
Starting point is 00:25:26 but I can't find any dirt on Phil Green and he's been doing it a long, long time. Still, Chloe's trust in him would soon be tested and broken. As her following grew, so did her profile and reputation within the industry. And in February of 2017, less than a year after she had started modeling, Chloe landed her page three debut in the Daily Star.
Starting point is 00:25:46 For glamour models in the UK back then, page three was not just a job. It was, you know, it was a badge of honor, a sign that you had attained a certain level of, you know, fame within that niche industry. The rough equivalent of a vogue cover for a high fashion editorial model. The shoot was photographed by Jeannie Savage. The blurb on her printed photo shoot read,
Starting point is 00:26:08 Curvy Chloe, making her page three debut today, and what a frilly thriller she is. The 19-year-old Surrey Sweetie is studying, who fucking writes this, studying to be a lawyer, but always had a secret yearning to appear in briefs in your favorite paper. I added that. She's Dick laugh.
Starting point is 00:26:27 She wasn't actually studying to be a lawyer, by the way. But I guess they thought that sounded cool. The iconic topless page three model tradition has largely ended recently in mainstream British print media. The son officially stopped publishing topless models in print in 2015. They transitioned to clothed or lingerie-clad photos, which are now primarily hosted on page 3.com. And the Daily Star would shift away from to topless images to bikini-style shoots in 2019, then officially drop pin up photographs on page three entirely. Chloe's debut, page three, would not be topless.
Starting point is 00:26:59 I studied in London for a semester way back in 1997. Yes, I'm ancient. And I distinctly remember flipping through a tabloid and seen a topless model in print like that for the first time and my prudish ass being a little embarrassed. And then, of course, later in private, maybe I remember beating off in a bathroom. I was 19, okay?
Starting point is 00:27:18 Who am I kidding? I still might sneak into a bathroom with the page three pick today. I was shocked, though, that their tabloids sold all over the place to everyone had nudity. Now I think it's probably a better way to go. We make nudity too taboo in this country, my opinion. You know, makes us too many of us sex negative, makes nudity seem so shameful, overly secretive. Female and male bodies, just bodies. So many of us are such weird puritanical prudes over here.
Starting point is 00:27:45 I know I've said this before, but I stayed with a totally average British family when I studied there and in the middle of a photo collage of the fam hung on the wall in the living room, mom, dad, three kids, there was this one picture of mom on a topless beach. Tits out. Big tits out, I should add. Actually, pretty fucking fantastic. But I thought it was so fucking weird. I remember, like, there was another American student with me and just like,
Starting point is 00:28:10 dude, what the fuck? Look at this. But the kids didn't think it was weird. No one else in the family thought it was weird. Looking back, they all had a much healthier view of sexuality than I did. I was the weirdo. Anyway, when it came to glamour modeling, the page 3 spot put Chloe on the map. Month later, March of 2017, her agent Phil receives an inquiry from a man calling himself André Lazio,
Starting point is 00:28:30 claiming to be an Italian photographer who wanted to book Chloe specifically for a motorcycle and leather-themed shoot in Paris. Chloe was absolutely thrilled. Her dreams of being a model traveling the world are coming true. As her agent, Phil, he handles all the logistics and the vetting. He asks Andre all the regular follow-up questions, checks out his website, confirms the studio address, place called Belis mafic. And requested shoot dates and examples of previous work. The model's backup playboy used to fly around the world for various photo shoots like this as well.
Starting point is 00:29:02 Oh man, it used to make me so nervous. Even back then, I guess I had some anxious Papa Bear energy in me. They did not always have agents. They fortunately rarely went alone, usually insisted on going with at least one other model that they knew, but not always. Sometimes they just fucking winged it, got on a plane, flew to some other country, just hoped the fucker, you know, picking them up at the airport. wasn't some rapy creep. I mean, I think they usually at least ask for references, contact other models who had worked with them previously,
Starting point is 00:29:25 but still, so glad neither one of my kids are doing this kind of work. I don't have moral, sexuality-based judgments about this kind of stuff. I really don't, but on a basic safety level, I would probably be riddled with ulcers. My hair would fall out after, you know, a year of just the stress and worry if my kids were doing this.
Starting point is 00:29:42 Too many creeps in the world. Green, however, Phil Green had no concerns about Chloe's safety for this particular shoot. everything looked to be above board and what's more, Lazio paid part of Chloe's fees and part of the agency's fee about 900 pounds up front along with all the travel expenses.
Starting point is 00:29:58 Later though, looking back, there was one detail Phil thought he should have questioned. Of all the bookings, Phil Green handled, the Paris job was the only one where the photographer had requested Chloe by name. Usually the way modeling castings normally work, or at least did then, was an agent pitching a selection of models
Starting point is 00:30:14 to a photographer. A photographer narrows it down, then multiple girls go out for the same job. A single name request from a first-time booker, highly unusual, especially since Chloe had never worked with his photographer before, and wasn't that well known. He hadn't even met her in person, or had he. On April 20th, 2017, a Thursday,
Starting point is 00:30:36 Chloe boarded a flight, flew from London to Paris. She's 19 years old. She hadn't, it doesn't seem, traveled much outside of the country before this point. She's a small person. she is not skilled in self-defense, admittedly naive, still not great at reading people's intentions and social situations,
Starting point is 00:30:53 and she's alone. Right? Yikes. The photo shoot was scheduled for Friday, so on Thursday she was free to do what she pleased, and she spent at doing what she had always dreamed to do and exploring a city she had never seen on somebody else's dime, right? So far so good. But then that evening at around 9 p.m.,
Starting point is 00:31:09 a gray Audi pulled up alongside a police fan on Avenue de gens al-Aise. A big, broad, famous street known for its theaters, cafes, luxury shops, the Finnish the Tour de France, the cycling race for its annual Bastille Day military parades. The driver, 39-year-old, Kareem Sharfee, stepped out carrying a Kalashnikov gun and shot a police officer twice in the head, killing him before opening fire on surrounding police officers on the pavement, wounding two more and then injuring a German tourist. Shafi then tried to flee on foot, did not make it far before he was shot. dead by responding officers. Central Paris goes into lockdown. Metro stations are closed,
Starting point is 00:31:52 tourists and locals flee the area. Sirens and armed officers are smother in the streets. No one knows if this is part of a bigger coordinated attack or not. Luckily, it was not. Shortly after news of this broke, Chloe's cell phone rings. It's her agent Phil Green. He'd heard there was a terror attack in Paris. He told her to get off the street. And I do love that. Chloe ran to her hotel, which was actually very close to where the shooting had occurred. From her hotel room, she could hear sirens outside, Phil told her to stay inside and she did. The next day, Andre got in touch. He told Phil he was very sorry, but his studio had been ransacked in the chaos.
Starting point is 00:32:27 The photo shoot would have to be rescheduled. There was a taxi on the way to take Chloe to the photo shoot, but now it would instead take her to the airport. Chloe packed up her things, got into the waiting taxi, and then when she arrived at the airport, Andre was waiting for her. He was wearing sunglasses and a hat, handed over 90 pounds in cash to cover some of her expenses. She never really got a proper look at him, and then she went home. Back in England, her life resumed normally.
Starting point is 00:32:53 The Paris job was filed away in Chloe's mind as nothing more than bad timing, an unlucky tragedy for those actually caught up in it, did not impact Chloe emotionally, and she was able to easily put it behind her. But the Daily Star couldn't. The day after the Sean's Alijé attack, they ran a story about the shooting and illustrated, now they used a topless page three shot of Chloe. Okay. Headline read, page three model forced to flee Paris's terrorist attack.
Starting point is 00:33:21 And then the subheader read, a top daily star page three model was left terrified after getting caught up in the drama of the Paris terrorist attack last night. Chloe later insisted that she had no say in this coverage, that she didn't ask for it. They just used a photo of her that had already taken before the attack that they had rights to. Now it's out there, and soon this will matter more than she could have ever possibly known. less than three months later in early July of 2017 Andre Lazio, same guy from the parachute.
Starting point is 00:33:52 Contacts Phil Green again, saying he wants to reschedule a shoot for the 11th of that month. This time, he suggested Milan. He asked Phil again for Chloe's measurements so that he can order more sexy leather clothes for her, and he sends pictures of his new studio with the same Belis Mifique sign.
Starting point is 00:34:09 And Andre wrote, I'm looking forward to seeing Chloe in better circumstances than last time. Chloe is stoked. But her mom, Biatta, she has a bad feeling about the Milan job. She begs her daughter not to go, but Chloe trusts Phil. This is his industry. He is a veteran.
Starting point is 00:34:22 And she again, right, she trusts his judgment. I'm not sure how old Phil is, but he had founded this agency back in 1987, his agency. So he had been working and modeling for at least 30 years at this point and probably a lot longer. I imagine he worked for somebody else's agency, built up his name before he ever founded his own agency. Chloe promised her mom that she would send her. regular updates throughout the whole trip, and then off she goes. And we will learn all about this trip
Starting point is 00:34:49 right after today's first of two mid-show sponsor breaks. If you don't want to hear these ads ever again, please sign out to be a space lizard on Patreon, help us make monthly charitable contributions, get the catalog ad-free, episodes three days early and more. Thank you for listening to our sponsors.
Starting point is 00:35:05 Now let's head to July 10th, 2017, when Chloe Aileen flies to Milan, Italy for the most dramatic, terrifying, and life-altering trip of her life. On July 10th, 2017, Chloe, barely 20 years old now, boarded a flight to Milan. When she landed, she checked into the
Starting point is 00:35:22 Hotel Galiz, headed out to dinner, had an early night, day one, everything great. The next morning, July 11th, the day of the scheduled shoot, Chloe wakes up early, makes her way to the studio
Starting point is 00:35:33 for an 8.30 a.m. start time. When she arrives, she calls the studio number to let them know she is outside. Man answers. He says his name is Daniel. He tells us. are that Andre, the photographer, not there yet. But to go ahead and come on in.
Starting point is 00:35:47 She hangs up, opens a door to the studio, and steps inside. And then curiously, no one is there to greet her. This Daniel fella is nowhere to be found. She pauses in the entryway, a little confused, uncertain which door to go through next. And then shit goes off the rails, and her eagerness for her first Italian photo shoot quickly turns into terror. She feels a gloved hand clamp over her nose and mouth from behind. She can't breathe as she sees another man step in front of her, holding a syringe.
Starting point is 00:36:17 He's wearing a mask that completely covered his face. Both men wearing masks and both men wearing gloves. He moves to inject her. Chloe panics. She struggles to get the hand off of her face so she can breathe. She's fighting. She's wriggling, doing everything she can to avoid being injected. But again, she's a small human.
Starting point is 00:36:32 These are two larger, stronger grown men, and they've snuck up on her. Caught her off guard, shocked and confused and terrified her. The last thing she remembers from this interaction clearly is the the syringe going into her right forearm. She then feels a bizarre sensation, almost like she's sinking into water, and then shortly after that, she blacks out. What a fucking nightmare. When Chloe regains consciousness, her terror increases.
Starting point is 00:36:56 She comes to, in the trunk of a car, stuffed inside a black hold-all sports bag. Holy shit. Even more alarmingly, her jeans, shirt, and shoes are gone. She's been undressed. She's also been putting some other clothes. She's now wearing nothing but a pink body suit and gray socks. Her wrists and ankles are bound, adhesive tape covers her mouth, and there's only a small breathing hole poked into the back.
Starting point is 00:37:21 Chloe will later say, I can still remember some parts of it so visually. I was so heavily drugged, but waking up, I can still remember the feeling of, was it on a boat or was it on a ship? Like it was a crazy dream. As Chloe slowly emerges from a drugged unconsciousness, the car winds through unpaved mountain roads, driving from Milan northwestward toward the Piedmont region. not that she knew any of that at the time.
Starting point is 00:37:43 She is fortunately able to move her bound hands up to her face, pulls off the tape, pulls it off her mouth. She can breathe a little more easily. She starts screaming, driver, driver! Soon the car pulls over and stops. She can see barely a bearded man's face through a tiny opening in the zipper of the bag she's in. Then a few moments later,
Starting point is 00:38:00 the bag she's in is unzipped to masked, gloved men, same men from before, looking down at her. She starts yelling questions, where am I? Why are you doing this? What's happening? They don't respond. one of them leans forward and again puts tape across her mouth they tighten the handcuffs on her wrist zip her back up
Starting point is 00:38:16 slam down the trunk get back in and start driving again soon she's able to get the tape back off her mouth and she starts yelling again and once again they pull over slow to a stop open the trunk uh she tells them she's thirsty they open up a bottle of water pour some of it in her mouth she is covered in sweat from being stuck inside this fucking bag now they take her mostly out of the bag take off her handcuffs
Starting point is 00:38:38 but then handcuff her again with her arms now behind her back. She gets a glimpse of a partially opened empty black suitcase in the trunk wall this is going on. Wonders if that's for her. Is her dead body going to be stuffed inside it? After she's been raped, tortured, and killed, she wonders. Then they again put tape across her mouth. Same piece of tape from before. And when they start driving again, she basically is able just to move her mouth around and shake it off.
Starting point is 00:39:02 After yelling again now, they pull over a third time. And now, this is fucking weird. one of the masked men gets into the trunk with her and is basically spooning her now. So strange. This will all make sense by the end of the episode, at least to me, but what the fuck? Once he's behind her, he also takes off his mask so he can talk to her. He tells her not to worry, that she's not going to be hurt.
Starting point is 00:39:24 There's no need to yell. He speaks in broken English, not in an Italian accent, but something else. She asks where they're going. He says he doesn't know. She asks more questions. He continues to say he just doesn't know. But now she starts to cry. he tries to reassure her. Don't cry. Nobody's going to hurt you. Don't cry.
Starting point is 00:39:41 She complains about how bad the handcuffs are hurting her wrist, still crying. The man of the trunk yells to the driver. Key, key, he hands it to him. Now the man takes her off for handcuffs, but says, only for journey. Finally, after approximately two hours of this, of this driving, the car pulls up into this remote cottage near Viu. A remote alpine Italian village located away from the mountains around 18 miles northwest of Turin in the Piedmont region, a charming mountain town. known for sweeping scenery, hiking trails, access to alpine peaks and lakes. It's an isolated retreat, far removed from any urban center.
Starting point is 00:40:15 Only about a thousand people live there. Soon after the car stops, the trunk opens again. Guy with her in the trunk, puts his mask back on, gets out. Now the two mask men handcuffed, Chloe again, stuff her back into the fucking duffel bag, essentially, the big duffel bag, after giving her a few more
Starting point is 00:40:31 tips of water. Then they carry her inside of the cottage and up some stairs. She's taken into a dimly lit bedroom. next to a bathroom. After letting her use the toilet, they then chain her by the wrists and ankles to a heavy wooden chest of drawers in this bedroom. They give her a sleeping bag to lay on top of,
Starting point is 00:40:47 and then they leave the room. They locked the bedroom door. You know, she's left alone. They go downstairs, and she hears a bunch of fucking yelling in some other language. She's terrified. She's also somewhat grateful
Starting point is 00:40:58 that so far, it seems like they have tried to be somewhat gentle and not rough. They had not done anything perverted, hadn't groped her, hadn't made any threats of rape or violence, violence. Still though, how would you be doing about now? I would be freaking the fuck out. Later in a 2025 docu-series about all this, Chloe Aileen, my unbelievable kidnapping,
Starting point is 00:41:17 Chloe'd explain she was still feeling the effects of being drugged, was more curious than scared as to what was going to happen next. She still hoped that this was, you know, not about sex trafficking, not about her being a woman, she genuinely thought, or at least wanted to think they probably got in the wrong person. This was the case of mistaken identity. I probably would be thinking that I was as good as dead And that before I was dead Some really bad shit was going to happen to me Meanwhile this evening
Starting point is 00:41:42 July 11th When Chloe fails to return on her flight to Gatwick Airport Just south of Greater London Her mom, Biatta, phones Phil Green Tells him that her daughter has not come home like she was supposed to Phil at this point Isn't too worried He presumed that Chloe's phone
Starting point is 00:41:59 Had likely just died You know, she'd probably been on it a lot That's why her mom wasn't able to get a hold of her. By calling people all day, taking lots of photos. Maybe things went so well. She decided to stay a little longer than originally she had planned. Not terribly uncommon in this industry. But Bietta, not convinced.
Starting point is 00:42:16 She knows her daughter very well, including knowing she is still far too trusting of people. She pushes Phil to take this more seriously. He relents. He checks up with the airline. Sees that, you know, Chloe had not, in fact, boarded her arranged flight. He also knows that she has a photo shoot scheduled in the gorgeous Spanish island.
Starting point is 00:42:32 on the gorgeous Spanish island of Abiza. Abita, July 13th, just two days away. Phil wonders if, you know, maybe she flew straight to Spain. He tries again to call her, but it goes again straight to voicemail. The next day now, Wednesday, July 12th, 2017, there is still no sign or word from Chloe, and Phil and Biatta they called the police. Meanwhile, back in Italy, Chloe is trying to stay calm.
Starting point is 00:42:57 The night before, back on the 11th, one of her kidnappers had come into a room without his mask now, and the bearded man had asked her in the dim light if she remembered him from Paris. He was the guy. He had gone then by Andre who had set up that previous photo shoot. The man she did not get a great look at
Starting point is 00:43:13 when she had handed over 90, or when he had handed over, rather, 90 pounds in cash to her to cover her expenses at the airport. When she asked him directly, if he was Andre the photographer, he smiled cryptically and said, I'm definitely not a photographer. Now she's getting pretty scared.
Starting point is 00:43:29 This is not an accident. This is not mistaken identity. he had targeted her. He had been intending to kidnap her for months. Then he said, those stupid Romanians, they weren't made to take you. Now she's confused. They can't understand English, he continued.
Starting point is 00:43:45 Stupid Romanians, they couldn't understand the difference between must and mustn't. She asked him if she could just go home. He tells her, not so simple. She for sale. Holy fuck. He also tells her that she can call him MD now.
Starting point is 00:44:00 M.D explained to her that most girls who end up, you know, in her position are screaming, hysterical. He's surprised she's not more obviously freaked out. But that's just not in Chloe's nature, not in her nature to panic. She knows if she becomes emotional. She freaks out. She won't be able to think clearly. So she is able to remain calm. She starts asking MD more questions, right?
Starting point is 00:44:19 How is she for sale? He tells Chloe, uh, I look for organization called Black Death, right? This violent organization of Romanian human traffickers that run a business on the dark web. he says these Romanians had sent him a photo of her, made it clear that they wanted her, thought she would be very valuable and good to sell. He told Chloe, she had been kidnapped to be sold into a sex trafficking ring,
Starting point is 00:44:41 that she was scheduled to be auctioned away on Sunday, four days away. He explained that there were only two possible outcomes for her now. She would either be sold to the highest bidder, who would then use her as he pleased, probably very roughly, you know, in her lifespan would be very short, or somebody she knew would pay the opening bid's price to release her.
Starting point is 00:45:02 And that opening bid was $300,000 U.S. dollars. Holy shit. Can you imagine how you would feel now in the situation? You don't know who these people are. You don't know where you are. You've been drugged. You've had your clothes taken off you while you were unconscious. You've been tied up, driven in the back of a fucking car,
Starting point is 00:45:18 putting a bag for hours, you know, taking somewhere. You don't even know where somewhere in a country that's not your home. Now you're being told unless you come up with $300,000 in four days, U.S. dollars, you are going to be somebody, slave, somebody who will rape and then very likely kill you. It's like you're the star of a very upsetting movie. You're in Taken, except there is no Liam Neeson. You don't know anybody with a special set of skills to come in for you.
Starting point is 00:45:43 Chloe told him that she couldn't pay, that she didn't have anywhere near that much money. Neither did her mother or her agent, Phil Green. I mean, Phil probably did have that kind of money, but she's, you know, aware that he's probably not going to hand it over for this guy. MD told her to come up with three names, three people in her life who might be able to to release her. So she comes up with three. He gives her like 50 minutes to do this.
Starting point is 00:46:02 She comes up with Roy McCarthy, a close friend who, you know, she thought would help if he could. Dave Reed, a celebrity agent who did PR for 66 magazine, a publication she'd modeled for. Paul Chaplin, the owner of Loaded Magazine, a men's magazine she'd also worked for. She wrote their names down, said that, you know, and then he said, excuse me, that he would email her agent, Phil, these names, and see if he could get the money together before Sunday. or she gets auctioned. Later that evening, he lets her brush her teeth, go to the toilet again, gives her some food, and then locks her back in the room,
Starting point is 00:46:36 leaves her alone terrified and exhausted. And finally, in this state, she falls asleep. The next day, Wednesday the 12th again, Phil opened his inbox to find the following email. Hi, Phil Green. I go by the name MD. I'm a mid-high-level contract killer working for Black Death Group.
Starting point is 00:46:54 Chloe has been taken and is currently under my wings. And as long as I live, will happen to her. I give my word. Email goes on to say that Chloe would be auctioned off as a sex slave on the dark web unless Phil can raise the funds from the three men that Chloe had named, two of whom Phil recognized his clients and the other Rory an investment banker. The sender used and encrypted account and went on to tell Phil that contacting him put his life at risk. Still, he said he had no choice but to follow the rules. He could not release Chloe.
Starting point is 00:47:22 The penalty for that, he wrote, would be death for myself and Chloe. No more and dice leave black death unpaid they'll respond to this email which is a single word received later that day md brought chloe some rice cakes after she woke up uh or guess you know uh also early that day probably wasn't that late uh he set them down beside her then sat on the bed in the room then started to tell chloe more about who he was
Starting point is 00:47:48 what he did uh all all sorts of shit all sorts of tall tales he starts telling her that he kill people poison was his cleanest method preferred method no one ever questioned to heart attack he said. He'd love to talk about himself. A lot of grandiose. I'm a very important and ruthless and feared man stories. But also did they told these stories in a way that seemed more like he was trying to impress her than scare her. Make her think that he was, you know, the baddest motherfucker of all time, but also could be a sweet bad guy who had a soft spot for her. So weird. He acted like he felt sorry for her in a lot of moments. You know, acted surprise that Phil had only sent back
Starting point is 00:48:24 that one word email, which crushed Chloe, by the way. Did he just not give a shit about her? At one point he said he hoped that a deal could be reached That maybe black death would take less than 300 grand You know whatever whatever her family could afford He said he talked to his black death boss CK about it Also said that he himself had plenty of money He could easily pay $300,000
Starting point is 00:48:44 But the black deaths they wouldn't allow that Against the rules for him to pay it It just wouldn't be fair To the other trafficking victims So strange This whole fucking kidnapping section is going to be strange by the way He will tell her so much crazy often contradictory, sometimes nonsensical shit.
Starting point is 00:49:01 Always making himself look like a very big deal. So much over the top, you know, bragging. This is definitely the weirdest kidnapping I've ever read about. And making it all stranger is that whatever he says, Chloe believes him. Again, she is not good at reading people. She accepts a lot of what people say no matter how absurd at face value. Whenever Chloe asked him something, she said he would go into long, detailed explanations. He told her how common these kidnappings were, how the group operated.
Starting point is 00:49:27 How they've been getting away with it for years. According to him, they've been taking three, four girls a week, mostly from Eastern Europe, but, you know, sometimes from the UK for years. He made it seem like Black Death was a truly massive, nearly all-powerful organization with agents all across Europe. He made her feel that it would be pointless to ever go up against them, even if she did escape. They'd find her.
Starting point is 00:49:47 They'd find her mom. They'd find her son, Ashton. They might kill them all. You know, her price, it had to be paid, or there was going to be terrible consequences. At one point, he shows. her a black death pamphlet some sort of official document
Starting point is 00:50:02 that made the group appear to be more legit a true international sex trafficking network this scares her also though what kind of clandestine international terror and trafficking group has a fucking pamphlet why would they need that
Starting point is 00:50:16 what are they doing with this pamphlet are they sticking it under the windshield wipers of parked cars and you know grocery store parking lots attention black death is in town. We're probably going to take some of your sexy young women. That is how we do. And we just want to let you know there's not the damn thing you can do about it, because we're
Starting point is 00:50:37 black death, baby. Most powerful, ruthless, mostly Romanian, group of psycho killer kidnappers in the world. Go ahead. Call police. I dare you. Some of those cops probably are the work for us. They'll arrest you, hand you over, hand your daughter over, maybe mom, to black death. Got any questions? If you do, email us at I Am Scared at blackdeth.biz. Or come to our Q&A in basement of Elklauch, Thursday,
Starting point is 00:51:08 8 p.m. maybe. We're black death, baby. We don't have to do anything we don't want to do. And one more thing. Want to be a black death agent? Email us at I am very dangerous and tough at blackdead.b's. Thank you for your attention to this matter. Anyway, he showed her this weird fucking black death pamphlet.
Starting point is 00:51:27 and it scared her. Also, as he spoke, all Chloe could think about was her mom and her son, what they must be going through. Guilt begins to creep in. She blames herself for wanting this life for chasing it despite knowing there are risks. She feels stupid for not being more aware that there were seedy people like this in the world. You know, why did she need more? Why couldn't she just been content with what she had? Why did she have to be so ambitious in this way? By this point, the UK Metropolitan Police are made aware of concerns over the welfare of a woman overseas. her agent Phil and her mom again had contacted the authorities after Phil got the email
Starting point is 00:52:00 on the UK side the case was assigned to a detective superintendent with 30 years behind him working in counterterrorism, organized crime, intelligence, and cybercrime. He did not get permission to have his name or face used or shown on camera and interviews about him.
Starting point is 00:52:16 So let's just call him Detective Richard Bacon. Dick Bacon. The call to Dick Bacon came in from the National Crime Agency. A 20-year-old woman from Croydon had been kidnapped in Milan. The first thing Detective Dick Bacon did was build a profile of Chloe Ailey,
Starting point is 00:52:33 who she was, what she did, what kind of life she lived, he pulled up her social media, looked at her career, and what he found, introduced a complication for him. According to Dick Bacon, Chloe was a young woman
Starting point is 00:52:43 who really craved the spotlight. She'd been in Paris during the terror attacks, and afterwards she'd appeared in the media about it. Maybe she'd gotten a taste for that kind of attention and wanted to replicate it. Dick Bacon was under the impression that she had used the moment of a terrorist attack for her own personal gain,
Starting point is 00:52:58 and now he wonders, is this a genuine abduction, or is this a young, ambitious model, engineering a story to get herself back into the news after realizing how being associated with a shocking crime was a quick and free way to gain a lot of exposure. Exposures she could monetize. The morning of Thursday, July 13th,
Starting point is 00:53:15 Dick Bacon walked into the office at 8 a.m., half expecting to hear that the Milan kidnap case had resolved itself overnight. It hadn't. In fact, what was waiting for him, said was a second email. And this one came with attachments. Three JPEG images of Chloe lying
Starting point is 00:53:30 in a velour jumpsuit. Makeup smeared on her face, left breast, hanging out of her jumpsuit a little bit, eyes open but seemingly unconscious. I've seen the pictures. They're fucking creepy. Dick Bacon's first thought, looking at the photos,
Starting point is 00:53:44 is that she's already dead. Underneath the images is a kind of listing. It read, Chloe, born in UK, abducted in Italy, held in Germany, 18 years old Caucasian
Starting point is 00:53:55 She's not 18 32 double D 22D 25 inch waist 35 inch hips beginner model Starting bid 300,000
Starting point is 00:54:05 auction takes place Sunday July 16th 2017 So Germany added to the mix You know Apparently to throw investigators off of her real location Chloe had also been told
Starting point is 00:54:13 by MD that she was no longer in Italy by the way And now mostly based on the photos Detective Dick Bacon Where this might actually be a real kidnapping that she might actually be auctioned
Starting point is 00:54:24 and their life is actually in danger. You couldn't afford to simply brush it off as an attention grab the situation she might be in was potentially deadly. If he got it wrong, if he underestimated it, you know, the cost would not just be professional. It could be her life. So soon a coordinated operation is underway. Officers from the East Midlands Special Operations Unit arrived at Phil Green's home, take over all communication with the kidnapper or kidnappers, specially trained negotiators will remain in and around Phil Green's house,
Starting point is 00:54:49 working around the clock for days now. Meanwhile in Milan, the case is picked up by two Italian officers, Jean-Lucca Simontace and Sarina Farare. Fuck yeah, bro. Serena Farare. That's the kind of Italian name I was hoping for. Mazare, Bugatti, spaghetti, Antonio Banderas, a Serena Farare. The officers are briefed about the situation, what the U.K. side is working with,
Starting point is 00:55:12 a young British model in alleged dark web Romanian auction and a deadline just a few days away. To the Italian investigators, the idea of a dark web auction like this, This is completely unfamiliar territory. They had nothing to compare it to. They went to the address where the photo shoot was supposed to take place, found no functioning studio, just a storefront, an empty warehouse like space. Inside they found Chloe's belongings scattered across the room,
Starting point is 00:55:35 her phone, her wallet, her suitcase, even a pair of white Adida sneakers with shimmer stripes. I'm sure. Senina Ferrari is a freaking out. She does not know what to do it next. Meanwhile, Chloe, still chained inside the cottage, isolated with no clearer sense of what's going to happen to her. And the story MD is telling her keeps changing.
Starting point is 00:55:54 At first, as I've mentioned, MD told her he was part of a group called Black Death, right, these ruthless Romanian traffickers. He led her to believe he had worked for them for quite some time that he was also a ruthless, cold-blooded killer. This is all just business for him. But then he starts to relax a little. He begins letting her go to the bathroom without being handcuffed. She said she didn't consider trying to escape because she didn't know if others might be nearby.
Starting point is 00:56:15 Also worried that he would kill her for trying. He made a point to tell her. he's armed with a concealed handgun. Then he offers to let her lay on the bed with him. She said she didn't worry about him trying anything sexually. He hadn't indicated he would do anything like that. He continued to act like she was just a product. He wouldn't want to damage it and face repercussions from the Romanians.
Starting point is 00:56:34 There would be penalties for him if he were to, quote, devalue her. Sometimes he acts like he's a subcontractor for Black Death, not part of Black Death. So she begins to lay on one side of the bed. He lays on the other, and now she's not tied up to anything. this guy is so fucking weird this whole situation is so fucking weird MD kept talking talked and talked and talked
Starting point is 00:56:55 she asked him how he would lure in girls who weren't models because he said he's getting girls all the time he said he'd go to nightclubs you know get him drunk maybe drug him walk him outside load him into a van he'd hold him for a week you know put him up for auction then transport them typically to the Middle East he told them he'd take girls as young as 14
Starting point is 00:57:11 you know young virgins were the most valuable and they got the most money at auction then he started talking about how he usually didn't stay with captives, though. Not anymore. Nah, bro. No, that wasn't a long time ago in the past. He was now way too high up in the Black Death hierarchy for that shit.
Starting point is 00:57:27 He's like, he's hired than a lot of the Romanians, actually. Big fucking deal in the organization when you come to think about it. Also, three times a day, morning, afternoon, and again at night, he'll check his email to see if anybody had paid for him. And then soon he starts to talk about how he wants out of the Black Death. He's all over the place. He starts saying that his face. and Chloe's are actually bound together.
Starting point is 00:57:50 He speaks to her about how he'd really like to help her, actually, to pay for her himself. He wishes he could. But to free her and to also buy his own weight out of the group, he'd have to raise about, I don't know, $300,000 euros. So I guess it's weird that it's the same fucking price, essentially, for him to get himself out and her out. And to do that, to get the $300,000 euros,
Starting point is 00:58:11 he would have to sell a bunch of properties, he claims to own. And he doesn't know if there's going to be time to do that before Sunday. And, you know, if they can't pull it off, well, then they're both dead. And yeah, earlier he did say he had plenty of cash, just cash, and could pay for her, obviously, but that was against the rules. He's seen a lot of confusing, contradictory, nonsensical shit. MD, excuse me, would most certainly be killed if he wasn't carefully told her. And Chloe, if a buyer did end up taking her after MD had tried to buy her but was not successful, well, then she'd obviously be fed to tigers. Once the owners grew bored of her, of course.
Starting point is 00:58:46 what? Then the story changed yet again, constantly changing. MD told Chloe that the higher-ups in Black Death were actually angry that she had been taken at all. She should have been taken
Starting point is 00:58:55 because she was the mother of a young child and that made her a liability harder to sell bad for business, for 1,800 business, ethically off limits, even by their nefarious standards.
Starting point is 00:59:05 He explained that they hadn't known she was a mom initially, but then they looked further down in her social media feed and then they saw, oh shit, okay, pictures are her and baby boy,
Starting point is 00:59:13 oh, fuck. Black Death were cutting corners, I guess when it came to the Instagram intel gathering. Then he reassured her that he would find a way to free her. And at one point he suggested a deal. He'd pay part of the money himself. Chloe would cover the rest, you know, as soon as she got released. Kind of definitely sounds like he was just making all this shit up as he went along, doesn't it?
Starting point is 00:59:34 Soon, MD claimed he had not kidnapped her at all. No, no, no. Two low-ranking Black Death Foot soldiers snatched her from Milan. He was a senior Black Death figure, clearly. he rushed in the moment he heard that she'd been taken because he knew she was a young mother. The original kidnappers then recognizing his rank, well, they just fucking handed her over and left. They didn't want to get killed. Is he mentally ill or just not a good liar?
Starting point is 01:00:01 MD then reiterated that Black Death agents were everywhere. They're watching the farmhouse right at that moment, escaped not an option. She had to trust him because he's risking her life for her now. And Chloe's own words, he always made out that he was the one who saved me. I looked at him like, what could I do without him? He said that if I escaped, not only would I die, he would as well. He was the only person who seemed to care that I could be free or that I would be free. It's like he read a book about Stockholm syndrome and wanted to see how quickly he could scare or confuse somebody in developing Stockholm syndrome for him.
Starting point is 01:00:32 It's like he'd seen a photo of her online, become obsessed with her, and then thought, I wonder if I can kidnap her, convince her that her that her life is in grave danger, then convince her that I can save her from that danger, and then she will fall in love with me and also will get money for people paying to save her and we will live happily ever after. Second night in bed together, Chloe said he again did not try and touch her. She slept on her side,
Starting point is 01:00:54 he slept on his, and she quietly cried herself to sleep. The next day on Friday, July 14th now, Chloe was allowed to take a shower. She changed into an old t-shirt and a pair of boxer shorts, said she, that key, MD, did not watch her shower but did make her keep the bathroom door open. When she was done, she was informed,
Starting point is 01:01:12 She still had to remain upstairs, could only move about the bedroom and the bathroom. Also, by the way, she hasn't seen the second kidnapper in quite a while now. It's just MD. By this point back in England, Phil Green has finally heard back from three people, Chloe had named to pay for her release. Only one of them was in a position to even consider pain. The only two couldn't or would not pay. The third person was Rory McCarthy, the investment banker. Some tabloids would later describe him as Chloe's ex-boyfriend.
Starting point is 01:01:39 She has said that it's not true. They've always just been friends. According to Chloe, they had known each other since 2015, two years before the kidnapping, weren't even speaking at the time she was taken. It had some kind of argument. So when he offered money, she was surprised and touched. But Rory said he could only pay 20,000 pounds. MD had, of course, made it clear in moments that he needed to pay $300,000 U.S. dollars.
Starting point is 01:02:03 When she found out that nobody could pay the money, Chloe accepted she was going to have to rely on herself and only herself to get out of this strange mess. And she was starting to lose hope. She desperately wanted to believe that MD could save her, but his story was so confusing. You know, he was only a small part of a much bigger and more dangerous operation. There were other more ruthless people
Starting point is 01:02:22 far above him in Black Death with more power and reach. Why would anyone up the chain agree to just let her go? Around this time, MD now told her how he'd come to be involved with the Black Death. He said he'd been a soldier in the Army. He liked it. Was very good at it. And someone introduced him another soldier
Starting point is 01:02:41 to the organization. When he spoke with them, he was told that thanks to his military experience, he would not have to start at the bottom. I know, he told Chloe, that most new recruits start at level one, which makes sense. The highest rank, by the way, is level 20.
Starting point is 01:02:55 Does this sound real to anybody listening? Sounds to me like an in-cell fantasy fever dream. MD said he was able to start out on level eight, and that after five years of working for Black Death, or being part of Black Death, as you kept going back and forth. He was now at level 12. and what do level 12 black death soldiers do you may wonder mostly assassinations
Starting point is 01:03:14 totally cool story bro and this motherfucker oh man he had been assassinating people left and right god if only he had a nickel for every fool he assassinated he spoke about killing people with no more emotion than someone who worked at a grocery store talking about stock and shelves he literally told her that he had killed get ready for this thousands of people assassinated thousands of people Nothing. You just don't turn it off. He's a one-man army, a killing machine.
Starting point is 01:03:44 He's a Terminator. Around this time, Chloe realized that MD was romantically interested in her. When he started talking yet again about how he wanted to help her, he alluded to his own mother having once been kidnapped and trafficked, and that he had never seen her again. And by golly, he sure wished it someone. Some kind of, I don't know, hero could have helped save her. And that is why he wanted.
Starting point is 01:04:08 to help Chloe. What? I need a hero! So MD is a cold-blooded Black Death motherfucker who has killed thousands of people and has helped traffic hundreds, if not thousands of girls as young as 14, for around five years.
Starting point is 01:04:34 But also did all of that, knowing that the same kind of shit had happened to his mom, but now understands how wrong this all was and wants to be Chloe's hero and save her. Got it? After he shared all that nonsense. MD leaned in and tried to kiss Chloe. She's surprised.
Starting point is 01:04:51 She pulls a little. way slightly. Then she tells him this isn't the right place for this. She's not the right headspace for romance. Not now. But maybe, probably, almost certainly, if he were to release her, if he were to be the hero and save her, well then they would be in a relationship.
Starting point is 01:05:07 She's falling for him too. And now MD, which probably stands for, I don't know, Melvin Dip shit, he lights the fuck up. So you're telling me there's a chance. This was the moment Chloe later said everything changed. Now she knew what game she had to play. after the foiled kiss.
Starting point is 01:05:24 Chloe later said she started talking to Melvin about their future, about what the two of them, you know, what they could be together when she was out. Her only strategy is to make him believe in this version of the future that he wants. That is truly possible. If and only, she has released. Over the days that follow, he will ask many, many times,
Starting point is 01:05:40 you know, when they might become a couple, and she'll just keep saying in the future when I'm released. Now the tone of the abduction shifts towards Chloe and MD working together, and they hatch a new plan. push back on the black death level 20 bosses negotiate an alternative pay shortly after release rather than up front no auction
Starting point is 01:05:58 okay I took a while to come up okay all right after much brainstorming and what I can only imagine was one of the dumbest conversations of all time MD agrees to take their case to the people above him the next 24 hours will be the most stressful yet Chloe keeps telling Melvin
Starting point is 01:06:13 that whatever black death requires for her release she will do it she will pay and Melvin he believes her because he is for sure a fucking dipshit he acts more and more convinced that if the Black Death let her go, she will truly follow through on every condition. He thinks she cares about him. He tells her that when he presented her case for release to Black Death,
Starting point is 01:06:31 he backed her. He argued for her freedom. But he told her, when he checked his email on Saturday night, July 15th, he still hadn't heard back. Another night in captivity, another night laying side by side in bed with his freak. And thankfully, another night when he does not touch her. And now let's take our second of two mid-show sponsor breaks before exploring the big day. The day of the Black Death auction,
Starting point is 01:06:53 Sunday, July 16th, 2017. Thanks for listen to our sponsors. Hope you heard some deals you liked. Now let's head to the day of the alleged black death sex trafficking auction Sunday, July 16th, 2017. Soon the clock struck midnight, flipped the calendar over to the payment deadline of Sunday. With no money coming through,
Starting point is 01:07:13 UK investigators led by Detective Dick Bacon, feared Chloe was about to be put up for auction, no one had a clue yet where Chloe was or if she was still alive. Then around three in the morning, an email landed in the investigator's inbox. Just three words sent from presumably Melvin Dipshit. She's gone, mate. And that's it.
Starting point is 01:07:32 Chloe is being auctioned. The investigators didn't know where she was headed, how long she would be held, what she was about to endure. But their very word is going to be very bad. For Dick Bacon, this is one of the lowest moments of his career. He had been handed one responsibility to bring Chloe home.
Starting point is 01:07:46 And as far as he knew now, he had failed and she had died. But in reality, Chloe was still inside the Italian farmhouse where she'd been the whole time. And around 9 a.m. on Sunday morning, she took a little trip into some local town near where she was held in captivity. MD walked her into a clothing store
Starting point is 01:08:00 that she later described as a mountain hiking type of place. She said Melvin walked her out the front door of the farmhouse after she put on some sort of track suit. She hopped into the passenger seat of his car, a cobalt blue sedan, and MD began to drive. No more riding in the trunk, no more handcuffs, nothing. But he did remind her he's armed. And he would shoot if he had to.
Starting point is 01:08:19 After 15 or so minutes, they made it close to the little shop she spoke of. Then they parked. They walk away together before entering the shop. On the way as they're walking, she said Melvin reached out to hold her hand. Of course, she took it. She is not in a position to reject him. She still needed him to think they're going to be together soon. Then they walk inside, smiling, holding hands.
Starting point is 01:08:37 She's laughing at his jokes. She buys her some shoes. Then they walk back to the car. You get some fruit from a little stand along the way. Still smiling, laughing. then they get back in the car, drive back to the farmhouse. There they eat the fruit, hang out upstairs, wait for word from Black Death. At 6 p.m. Melvin said that the answer finally came back, or he pretended it had.
Starting point is 01:08:58 Black Death had, against all odds, agreed to let her go. But only if she accepted four conditions. The first was that she not speak to the police about any of this fucking ever. Feels reasonable. The second, any police investigation that had already begun needed to cease. Looking at you, Dick Bacon. Third, she would publicly promote Black Death as a leading terror organization. What?
Starting point is 01:09:25 In his words, you're from the UK and we don't have an audience there. So I need to promote Black Death. That might be the most absurd thing he's done yet. What? How is she supposed to promote Black Death? Through Instagram posts. Hi, I'm sexy model Chloe Aileen. I do sexy shoots all over the world because I'm sexy.
Starting point is 01:09:44 I know he got kidnapped and auctioned off into sexual slay. by the world's leading terror organization, Black Death. They're very scary. If you are also a sexy model but would like to be kidnapped and auctioned off into sexual slavery, head to Milan and book a photo shoot with Belize Mafique Studios. Tell them I sent you. They will kidnap the shit out of you.
Starting point is 01:10:02 They can also be hired for assassinations, anybody you want dead but don't want to kill. They will do it. They'll kill anyone. Find them and follow across all socials. Be sure and click the subscribe button. Like, what the fuck? Fourth condition is,
Starting point is 01:10:16 within a month of her release, she has to pay $50,000 in Bitcoin. Oh, sweet Christ. Now it's $50,000 instead of $300,000. Chloe agrees to the first three straight away. Only the last one makes her hesitate. She doesn't know. She has that kind of money.
Starting point is 01:10:27 But then she's like, okay, I'll get it. And she, of course, said yes to. She has to. She has to say whatever she needs to say to get released. They go to bed that night around 10 p.m. Side by side, again, no funny business. MD tells Chloe, it's going to be a long drive the next day. He wants to head out at 4 a.m.
Starting point is 01:10:43 Monday morning, July 17 to 4 a.m. who leave the house again. They drive and drive to the Italian countryside, down a bunch of whining roads. Then after a while, M.D turns to her and asks, Did you ever think I was lying to you? That I was just doing all this to trick you?
Starting point is 01:10:58 She doesn't know what he's talking about. So M.D. tells her a story about a supposed former black death, level 20 final boss of his. Oh shit. Who had dumped something like this once before. He promised a girl that she was going to be released. Then he drove her not to safety,
Starting point is 01:11:14 not to a consulate. but to a small airstrip, somewhere she could be loaded onto a plane flown to a nasty buyer in the Middle East. Chloe sits very still. She does not want him to see the fear. She now feels. She tells him that no, no, she trusts him.
Starting point is 01:11:27 And then she lets her eyes half closed as if she's tired, and she rests her head against the window, unbothered on the outside, terrified on the inside. The car keeps moving. She watches the street signs. They're heading back toward Milan. When they reach the city, MD navigates to the tight corners, weaving past scooters, trams,
Starting point is 01:11:44 aggressive drivers on the way to work. work. The plan is for him to drop her about 20 minutes from the British consulate. Far enough away to stay clear of cameras, but Chloe does not like that idea at all. She doesn't want to be left alone. She actually wants him right beside her. Quote, I relied on this man totally, she said later. When he wanted to drop me off 20 minutes from the consulate, I couldn't bear to think about being separated from him because I thought other members of Black Death would get me in the time it took to walk there. It is so fucking sad. She's scared by this.
Starting point is 01:12:13 When they reached the consulate, it's still close. not going to open for another two hours. They can't just wait around outside, right? They need a different plan. So, Chloe and M.D., they go to a cafe near the consulate and they have breakfast together. Witnesses will later tell reporters the two of them were laughing and joking. As Chloe put it, I can see why people think it's weird. In my eyes, he is the guy who saved me.
Starting point is 01:12:33 After their breakfast, MD decides on a riskier move, he'll walk her straight inside of the consulate now. He coaches her on what to say, that he was just her only friend in Italy. and then after escaping her kidnapper she borrowed a stranger's phone and called him for help and he answered she was to say that his name is Daniel Zawatta Melvin Dipshit figured that he would just hand her over
Starting point is 01:12:54 and just walk out a free man because he is truly fucking stupid once the consulate opens MD drives up to the gate in his car with Chloe alien in the passenger seat beside him CCTV shows the two arrive together Chloe smiling in the front seat looking relaxed MD leaning out to press the button for a parking
Starting point is 01:13:11 ticket. The automated gate lifts. They drive onto the underground car park. M.D. and Chloe get out of the car. They walk together through the underground car park into the consulate. Chloe wearing an oversized jersey. Her hair piled on top of her head and a messy bun. They walk up to the front desk together. Chloe introduces herself telling staff she has been kidnapped with MD standing at her side posing as this friend Daniel Zawada.
Starting point is 01:13:35 The staff already knows who she is. News of her disappearance has been a huge story, right, for days locally. They take Chloe to an empty room to talk privately. MD moves to follow her in, but the embassy staff tell him, no, you're not allowed in there. Chloe then begins to rattle off the agreed-upon cover story, that she had been kidnapped,
Starting point is 01:13:53 that she escaped, she borrowed a stranger's phone, called the only friend she had in Italy, Daniel, and that he had picked her up and driven her to the consulate. The consulate alerted the police, and they arrived quickly. The first question they asked is a simple one. So what's Daniel's phone number?
Starting point is 01:14:09 Chloe doesn't know it. whoopsie uh overlooked a pretty important detail there this of course made no fucking sense if dania was her only friend in italy if she had memorized his number well enough to recite it to a stranger and asked to borrow a phone right just that same fucking morning she should have 100% for sure been able to recite it to police now but she can fucking pull any of the numbers out of her ass uh chloe then turns to nicoletta the translator and says i need to get this off my chest but i am scared and now she tells her the truth but not the whole truth but not the whole truth doesn't tell them about shopping with MD and that admission is about to catch up with her. Police asked Chloe where she had gotten the new clothes she's wearing. She replied at the farmhouse and while that was true of the tracksuit, it was not true of the sneakers.
Starting point is 01:14:54 Chloe Aileen also did not tell Milan police. She'd been held in one location. Serena Ferrari, she's some maddera. And doesn't mention ever leaving left the house. She did tell them about the syringe, the two men, the faux romance, the auction, and more. Her story is so unusual, so far outside anything Italian investigators had ever seen, they struggled to believe it as it unfolded.
Starting point is 01:15:16 Of course they did. It's a fucking insane story. She has been fed dozens of hours of maniacal borderline gibberish for days. The officers kept asking Nicoletta, the interpreter, to repeat and double-check what Chloe had said. More than once, they asked, are you sure that's what she said? Serena Ferrari, she's freaking out. Are you sure that's what she's talking about? It makes no sense.
Starting point is 01:15:38 They just can't believe what they're hearing. yeah i bet each time nicoletta confirmed though yeah no that was that was what she said uh this goes on for hours and hours and hours roughly 10 to 12 and then after all this the police bring out uh some cctv footage they tell chloe they had footage of herself and daniel uh you know this daniel md character out and about shoe shopping holding hands they showed her the footage they showed her the footage made her watch it also presented cloy with a statement from a saleswoman who said that she had sold shoes to the model the day before uh chloe watching the footage played back to her she breaks down sobbing it was she would later say devastating she would later say devastating She just spent about 12 hours, given the police, every detail she could think of, but she hadn't told them that. And now they're going to use it to say she's not telling the truth. A lot of people will analyze all this and quickly point to the shoe shopping footage combined with not telling Italian authorities about the shopping excursion immediately. As proof, definitive proof, she made all this shit up. She was, you know, part of this supposed abduction. When asked later why she didn't tell police about the shoes, Chloe explained, it was the end of the interview.
Starting point is 01:16:36 I've been speaking for 12 hours. I just wanted to leave. I thought that would be another whole load of questions and it would drag on for so much longer so I just didn't mention it. Her Italian lawyer, Francesco Pesha, would much later defend the strangest of the shopping footage in his own words saying,
Starting point is 01:16:51 She did it to testify that she went out to her captor to buy the shoes about the groceries. She does appear to be strange. I understand this. I would continue to respond to this. She was a tall barres man and many people of this black dead organization around her. Even if she tried to flee, she's going to die.
Starting point is 01:17:08 I know I'm being ridiculous. For the Italian police, this submission opened up a question that will haunt Chloe alien for years. Still haunts her, in fact. Did she stage her own kidnapping, right? A question will not be answered in the British consulate in Italy that day
Starting point is 01:17:21 won't be answered for many months, and the end it'll be answered in court. The one thing Italian police are sure of the evening of Monday, July 17th, is that the man who had walked in with Chloe is an obvious suspect. Either he is her kidnapper or part of a plot
Starting point is 01:17:34 Chloe may or may not have been a part of. Next morning, Tuesday, July 18th, 2017. After being held for over 24 hours, question for much of that time, Melvin dipshit, officially arrested, charged with kidnapping for extortion. When officers searched him, they found what looked like some sort of Polish ID in the name of Daniel Sawata, but Italian police later discover that no legitimate document existed under that name. Melvin also carrying a business card, the card read, permanent solution. One side has a logo of the Grim Reaper. Other side has a complicated dark web style email address printed across it. Oh, 1,800.
Starting point is 01:18:08 business vibes. And now while Chloe is again being questioned in one room, Melva isn't another, telling his version of events. At first, he sticks to the story. He and Chloe is supposedly cooked up, but it doesn't take long before his story starts to fall apart because it's garbage and he's a fucking idiot. Eventually, Melvin admits he was involved in a plot to kidnap Chloe. Meanwhile, investigators run all of his suspected alices through their systems.
Starting point is 01:18:31 When they trace Andre Lazio, the name used to book Chloe's photo shoot in both Paris and Milan and to rent the fake studio with the abandoned show. shop front she was sent to they don't find a clean identity. Instead, they uncovered a trail of layered fake IDs and aliases, all pointing back to one real person. Lukash Herba, Melvin Dipschitz real name. Lucas Herba is a Polish-born man who had actually been living in the UK for years, working as a computer programmer sometimes. He lived in Oldbury, was connected to nearby Tivodeo, two industrial towns at the heart of the black country, a region in the West Midlands of England, roughly 150 miles northwest, where Chloe was a
Starting point is 01:19:08 living. He shared a flat with his older brother Michael, and on Facebook he claimed to be the chairman of a tech company called Karmik. Karmurg. There's no such company. Story keeps getting weirder. Lukash opens up more and more about his supposed part in the plot in the investigation room, and insisting
Starting point is 01:19:24 his role is limited. He tells them that he was only involved in renting properties around Europe, such as the shopfront, Milan, and the farmhouse NBU to store garments that some group of Romanians who had hired him were supposedly selling. What? Black death, in addition to extremely lucrative sexual trafficking, and I would think lucrative
Starting point is 01:19:42 assassinations as well, since Melvin, I mean, Lukash has personally killed thousands. They're also in the garment business, even though a bunch of garments were never found at either location. The fuck is wrong with Lukash Herba. This idiot now tells police the kidnapping was orchestrated by a group of Romanians who paid him 500,000 pounds. Man, a lot of money in the garment business. Only reason he agreed to take part, he says, is because he's He has leukemia. He needs the money to pay for medical treatment. That's such a preposterous lie.
Starting point is 01:20:15 Why would you fucking tell that lie if you have any brain in your head? As if they can't, I don't know, Melvin, quickly check your fucking medical records. Easily prove you don't have, have never had leukemia. Well, when the police press him on leukemia, Lucas can't give them the name of a single doctor. Cannot provide any evidence whatsoever that he's sick, you know, because he's not sick. Also, not once in this entire interview does Lucas Herba. ever mentioned the words black death.
Starting point is 01:20:40 Lucas then confirms to police that he met Chloe months earlier in Paris. He said he canceled the Paris job when he realized that there were three Romanians, these garment fucking motherfucker, who intended to kidnap Chloe back then. According to Lucas, he called Chloe's hotel pretending to be the photographer, claiming his equipment had been stolen in order to cancel the shoot and get her back home to safety. He's a hero. And then once Chloe was abducted in Milan,
Starting point is 01:21:04 Lucas told police he came to her aid when he saw her photos posted with an online auction. What? How would he know where the Romanians were keeping her if he had just fucked over the Romanians
Starting point is 01:21:16 previously in Paris? He also said that she was free to go once the Romanians had abandoned the farmhouse but she just stayed because I guess she loved him. Meanwhile, when she heard
Starting point is 01:21:27 about Herba being arrested, Chloe actually got confused. At this point, she still believes that he has rescued her from Black Death. She will later tell the guardian, I was grateful to him,
Starting point is 01:21:36 I felt sympathetic to the fact he was in jail, and the Romanians were still out there. While Chloe was feeling sympathy for Herba and town investigators were still looking at the possibility that Chloe and Herba were collaborating. Now, maybe they did it together.
Starting point is 01:21:49 We don't know you. At this point, they started to ponder whether the case was bigger than just the two of them. In fact, the police were actively looking for as many as four accomplices. Around the same time, Chloe's pathology test come back. Her urine shows
Starting point is 01:22:01 no trace of drugs in the past couple of days which suggests she had not ingested anything very recently, Orban, you know, stuck with a needle. But then her hair test positive for ketamine. The drug I was supposed to take a few months ago. I mean, the powerful horse tranquilizer, that fast-acting, disassociative, anesthetic
Starting point is 01:22:20 sometimes referred to as a psychedelic that alters perception, pain, and consciousness. The drug that while historically used as a surgical sedative for humans and animals has also emerged as a widely prescribed, highly effective treatment for severe mental health conditions, and a drug that is also used recreationally around the world a drug that maybe I got my hands on some more of that's actually clean and we'll be trying soon. What? Forget I said that. The drug that if you are given a high enough dose,
Starting point is 01:22:43 it can c-hole you into fucking oblivion and leave you technically unconscious in a state of disassociative anesthesia, maybe looking like somebody lying half, you know, looking dead with her eyes open in that photo that was sent to the police earlier. So circling back, Chloe had clearly taken the drug at some earlier point, maybe by choice, not necessarily by choice. But then they found a puncture mark on her wrist consistent with the needle. and bruises on her wrist and ankles consistent with being handcuffed for an extended period of time. Meanwhile, Italian police
Starting point is 01:23:12 shifting through thousands of hours of CCTV footage and they find footage of Lukash walking the streets with another man who looks a lot like him also find a set of fingerprints that likely belong to a close relative pointing towards his brother Michael
Starting point is 01:23:26 working with Italian authorities British police search a house in Oldbury thank you Dick Bacon for your assistance a house linked to the brothers and they seize computer equipment for forensic analysis. At this point, they are still not sure
Starting point is 01:23:38 just how big this operation is and how many accomplices might be out there. After several days of police interviews, the Italian prosecutor and officers decide Chloe needs to stay in Italy while they continue their investigation. There is no clear timeline
Starting point is 01:23:50 for when it will be over. She's simply told she has to remain in the country until further notice. They can't decide if she is the victim of a crime or the suspect, a suspect in committing a crime. She's placed in a safe house where other victims of crimes
Starting point is 01:24:04 like kidnapping are housed when their safety needs to be guaranteed, where they can access mental health support. Chloe arrives at the safe house, finds two females sleeping on two single beds, more like cots almost. There's a third single bed in the middle. That's hers.
Starting point is 01:24:17 The room's very stuffy. No air conditioning. Very hot. It smells. After all that she's just been through, she doesn't want to stay there. Can't blame her at all. When she talks to Italian police,
Starting point is 01:24:26 they tell her that if she wants a hotel instead, she'll have to pay for it herself. But she doesn't have any money because she doesn't have her credit cards, ATM cards, etc., that she lost in the abduction. so now Chloe calls her agent Phil First time they've spoken since kidnapping
Starting point is 01:24:38 she tells him she has to remain in Milan for further questioning She's being housed at a women's shelter She does not want to stay in Phil pays for a couple of nights at a hotel Neither than know how long she's going to be there Next day she picks a lawyer from a list of English-speaking attorneys She chooses Francesco Pesha
Starting point is 01:24:55 When we heard a quote from earlier Pesha knows what he's in for He admits to the Associated Press That the case looks and sounds totally bizarre and unbelievable he acknowledges that investigators have, quote, more than understandable doubts about her story. According to Pesha, it seems incredible. A man of kidnaps together with others,
Starting point is 01:25:12 a girl, and after a week, certain particular reasons, are companies had inside a causally that practically hands over to the police. While the Italian and British police, sorry that's annoying again, but I amused myself, while the Italian and British police continue to ponder over whether or not Chloe's a victim or an accomplice,
Starting point is 01:25:30 Chloe has no idea that that is what's happening. according to her, she is still living inside the rules of the kidnapping at this point. She still believes she owes the Black Death or Black Death everything that they told her, or that, you know, he told her a fucking dipshit that she owed them. The silence, the 50,000 euros and Bitcoin, the very confusing promotion of their services in England, all of it. Sure, she's technically been released, but she doesn't feel relieved, not even close. She's terrified that when she finally gets back to England, she's only going to have a small amount of time, you know, with her family and friends before they come for her again.
Starting point is 01:26:03 or, you know, come for her mom or for her baby boy, Ashton. The fear consumes her. You know, she's not worried or thinking about what the police, what the press, what the public are thinking about all this right now. The idea that people might not believe her hasn't yet crossed her mind. But then Italian police lay out their concerns to her face to face. And for the first time, she understands people aren't buying her story. The Italian police admits they're struggling to make sense of all this. They tell her, look, maybe your story is genuine, but you got no documents, no video, no witnesses.
Starting point is 01:26:29 All we have is your word. they also say they find it strange how composed she is that she's able to speak about it all with no emotion just matter of fact and a clear and steady voice that doesn't waver within days of her turning up in that consulate dozens of officers have been assigned to the case and the Italian police decided to run a test now they'll take Chloe back to every location she mentioned in her statement
Starting point is 01:26:49 and watch and see how she reacts this is so very Italian a remarkably calm Chloe pulls a pair of blue forensic gloves on takes the investigators on a tour of her kidnapping First, they drive Chloe to the fake studio where she said she was taken. They watch her closely. She retraces the route,
Starting point is 01:27:06 describe the initial attack in detail. They watch her body language, her facial expressions. They look for a sign of trembling hands or fear or tears. They're all body language experts now, apparently. The whole time, Chloe remains incredibly calm.
Starting point is 01:27:19 Then they drive to the village where she and Lukash had gone shoe shopping, retracing the route step by step, the spot where he parked the car, the walk to the shop, the route back, the place where they bought fruit.
Starting point is 01:27:31 Next they drive to the house where she's been held captive. And inside, Chloe points out the floor, on the floor where she was made to lie, the spot where the sleeping bag even placed before she ended up sleeping next to Melvin Dipshit, the place where her hands had been handcuffed, and finally she breaks down. The Italian police watching her closely. I don't know, she looks up pretty sad to me now. She's definitely crying. She must be innocent.
Starting point is 01:27:53 For days, right, she's been impossible to read, calm, matter of fact, dry-eyed through a story that should have rattled anyone, or at least they felt it should have rattled anyone. But as many of us know, or at least I hope many of us know, the way humans react to tragedy differs wildly, thanks to all the neurodivergence and broad spectrum of emotional makeup and upbringing, etc. Stand in the room where she had been held, Chloe became visibly shaken, and the Italian police, rightly or wrongly, believed that emotion appeared genuine. At that moment, things changed for the Italian investigation.
Starting point is 01:28:22 They now started to trust that what she was recounting could only come from someone who had actually experienced something deeply traumatic, despite having the Italian police now on her side, Chloe still can't leave Italy though. And she claimed she grew more and more terrified day by day that one of the black deaths henchmen were going to come hunt her down. She becomes convinced that some level 20 big boss
Starting point is 01:28:41 end game motherfucker who's going to bribe a hotel receptionist to let, you know, to be led into the room, to take her. She doesn't trust that the police can catch all of them. She believed that there would always be more accomplices out there and they would come for her just a matter of time. Meanwhile, the Italian police still have Lucas custody. However, they still don't know if he's acted alone or if there's a whole network out there are men like him that they don't know about. So detectives start to dig into their
Starting point is 01:29:05 existing leads on dark web activity. Trying to figure out where Chloe could have been sold, what platforms, what internet auction spots the Black Death may have used. But this is a near impossible task because the dark web does not work like the regular internet. As I learned, when I researched a dark web episode in the early days of time suck and got pretty freaked out and deleted Tor or the onion router from my computer. Sites are not indexed. Sites are not in You don't know what you're going to find until you fucking just get there sometimes. You can't just type a name into a search bar and find a bunch of stuff. Each, you know, place is hidden behind a jumble of random characters.
Starting point is 01:29:37 You can only get there if somebody gives you the exact address. That means most of the dark web's legal activity lives on a small number of hidden sites that only insiders know about. Outsiders will never be able to find them unless somebody gives them that exact address. The Italian police, they search through all the known dark websites on their radar come up empty. There's no listing for Chloe. no black death link platform they can identify. After a few weeks of investigating now, the case breaks.
Starting point is 01:30:03 Over the weekend of August 5th, Italian police and prosecutors lay it all out the kidnapping, the mysterious black death group, the online auction, the miraculous escape described in full detail at a press conference. The British press picks up the story immediately. They also run it alongside the raunchiest photos they can find of Chloe from her social media,
Starting point is 01:30:21 very British tabloid. It doesn't take long before the public starts to raise serious doubts about all this. Chloe is finally cleared to go back to England, though, and on Sunday, August 6th, 2017, about a month after she first flew to Milan for what she thought was going to be a photo shoot, Chloe arrives home in Colesden, South London. There's cameras and reporters waiting on her street outside her home. The story of Chloe's abduction by this point has gone global. And again, many people, including many reporters, if not most, they don't believe her. So after all she's gone through, she does not get a sympathetic welcome. She gets ridiculed instead of celebrated.
Starting point is 01:30:54 and she just desperately wants to be left alone. Shortly after Chloe arrives home, she connects with her friend Rory, who gives her some advice. The only way to get the reporters and photographers to go the fuck away is to give them something. You got to say something. Give them what they want.
Starting point is 01:31:06 Chloe doesn't know what to say. So Rory gets out a pen and paper, writes a note for it, she skims through it, and she goes outside and she reads it. Only an hour after Chloe has arrived home, she steps outside her front door holding a piece of paper. Her dog runs out of the house behind her.
Starting point is 01:31:19 She's wearing hot pants, a low-cut top that a lot of people found odd and inappropriate. she's smiling doesn't appear shook up or upset at all her hair's looking great all done up her makeup's on point she looks like she's ready for a photo shoot she clears her throat reads a brief statement to the reporters i'll play that for you now so you can just hear it in her words i've been for a terrifying experience i feared for my life second by second minute by minute hour by hour i am incredibly grateful to the italian and the uk authorities for all they have done to secure my safe release
Starting point is 01:31:51 I have just arrived home after four weeks of being in Italy. I haven't had the time to gather my thoughts, so I'm not at liberty to say anything further until I have been debriefed by the UK police. After that, she smiles, poses with her dog for a flashing camera, and then she goes back inside the house. Later, journalists and reporters covering this case will talk at nauseam about how strange they found her demeanor.
Starting point is 01:32:14 Most of them had expected her to look very haggard, a little withdrawn, under the weather, but rather Chloe, you know, had only landed an hour or so earlier, and she stepped straight to the media circus, smiling, posing, seemingly composed, self-assured. And before moving forward, I'd like to refer to the Playboy models I worked with again around the same time.
Starting point is 01:32:32 While maybe you would not have dressed, like Chloe, in that situation, I'm 100% positive that most of them would have. Some of the models regularly had to be told to put their cameras down and stop taking selfies so that our show's photographers could take more photos of them.
Starting point is 01:32:46 And then once those photos were done being taken, and they would immediately take more picks of themselves with their phones. And why? It is literally their jobs to be filmed looking sexy. And many of them, I'm sure, would have practically rather die
Starting point is 01:32:58 during the kidnapping than do have looked haggard after being released, truly obsessed with their appearances, not making a judgment call about this, just is what it is. Obsessed with looking as hot as possible, as often as possible,
Starting point is 01:33:09 to a degree, I don't think most people can relate to. And that quality fucked her now in the court of public opinion. On August 11, 2017, just five days after Chloe landed back, in the UK, the court of Milan issued a European arrest warrant from Michael Herba, a Lukash's older brother. Italian police now believed he was in the car with her on the initial drive to the farmhouse and played a part in her abduction, that he was the second man.
Starting point is 01:33:33 The second man she was attacked by when she was injected with the ketamine. Because he again was based in the UK, the warrant is certified by the UK's national crime agency the next day. Thank you, Dick Bacon. Meanwhile, Luke Kush remained in custody in Italy. And then on August 16th, British police moved in and arrested 36-year-old Michael. Herba at an address in Tivodeau. He denied any involvement in Chloe's kidnapping, and the next day in Westminster Magistrate's court,
Starting point is 01:33:55 he announced he was going to fight his extradition to Italy. Speaking of Italy, a court there now heard how the alleged plot to kidnap Chloe, Chloe, was financed. Lukash had taken out a loan to cover the logistics. Of course, that dips you did. He had rented the fake studio facade in Milan. He had rented the farmhouse in the mountains, all under aliases.
Starting point is 01:34:16 He and his brother Michael had bought a car in Poland, shipped it all the way to Italy, and tellingly, the Italian police found absolutely no communication whatsoever between Lukash and Chloe after rigorously searching phone, email and social media records, etc. for weeks and weeks, nothing at all to suggest she was ever a willing partner in any of this. According to prosecutors, she was abducted primarily as an intended investment. Two very stupid men sunk real money into an operation they were betting they would recoup the moment somebody paid Chloe's ransom. But was that all? Of course not. If this was only about the money, why give up so quickly when no ransom is paid? Why did Lucas so eagerly conspire with Chloe to help her not have to pay the money, or at least not most of it? Why did you let her go? Obviously, for the possibility of a romance. So delusional. Meanwhile, Chloe was doing the rounds on the UK media circuit now.
Starting point is 01:35:07 She was interviewed by The Daily Mail, then appeared on television, the British talk show this morning. And as Chloe sat across from interviewers and told her story, she failed to win over the British public sympathy. They were suspicious. If Chloe was telling the truth, why had she been caught on CCTV footage in an Italian village? Why did she seem so chirpy one moment, devastated the next? Why when her kidnapper took her to buy shoes? Didn't she just run? Why when she was finally freed did she not mention the shopping trip to the police?
Starting point is 01:35:34 And most puzzling of all, why did her kidnapper just let her go? She had seen his face. She knew where she had been held. Chloe insisted that she was let go because he found out she was a mother. But the British public did not buy that answer. It all sounded too strange. It didn't make sense. You know, we know that nothing about any of this made sense because of Lukash's bullshit.
Starting point is 01:35:54 But reporters either weren't willing to do their due diligence to find that out or could not access that information yet, or just didn't care because it would not give them the polarizing story that they wanted to fuel ratings. There was also concerns over the ketamine. Chloe said, of course, that she had been injected with it. But in some of her interviews, it was pointed out that ketamine was a very popular party drug in the UK at the time. She could have easily taken some as she was in the party seeing herself or strong. strongly was assumed to be, but Chloe denied she did drugs, said she barely even drank. But again, the public doesn't buy that.
Starting point is 01:36:24 Most seemingly have now made up their minds that this whole thing was nothing more than a disgusting publicity stunt. And that is exactly what Lucas Herba will now claim in court that he and Chloe orchestrated the entire thing together. In October, three months after the kidnapping, the British public still has not moved on. Neither has Chloe. She agrees to appear on Good Morning Britain, where hosts Piers Morgan and Susanna Reid are waiting to question her. And I will preface this next part by saying, I have long fucking hated Pierce Morgan. I truly find him to be a despicable human being.
Starting point is 01:36:56 I do not understand why anyone ever likes him ever, ever, ever. I watched this interview before reading over the preliminary research assembled for this episode, and I got so fucking mad. I literally typed into my Google Chrome search bar, quote, Pierce Morgan is a cunt. I just wanted to see if that judgey statement resonated with anybody else out there. immediately I was given the following
Starting point is 01:37:15 AI overview, not joking. This is what it shot back verbatim. That is an extremely common sentiment. Millions of people find him insufferable. And he has made a massive career out of being intentionally provocative, loud and argumentative to drive up his engagement and ratings.
Starting point is 01:37:30 Clearly, even whatever AI fucking Google Chrome is using hates him. And that's saying something. Millions of people find him insufferable. I'm not even sure if that's true, robot, but I like you claiming that it is. I'm glad we both can't stand him. Here's an excerpt of them talking about the shoe shopping, about the CCTV footage,
Starting point is 01:37:47 eyewitnesses who saw Chloe and Lukish laughing together in the village square. But one of the reasons that people, I think, have been skeptical, is because this information has come out that you light police about a pretty key moment. But it hasn't just emerged. It was already in the police report. So they already knew about that. They're just trying to make me look like a bad person to get readers. The papers are portraying the story in something it's not. And that's what's creating the doubt is.
Starting point is 01:38:11 Well, the papers were portraying you with some sort. skepticism and then it emerges this week. But it didn't emerge. It was already out there. Well, it's been published this week, being reported that you lied to the police. And that's the problem is that no one can quite get their head round why you would lie to the police about such a key thing. I just brushed it off. I was shut it completely. But it's not insignificant, is it, to be going shopping with one of the alleged kidnappers and buying new shoes? No one understands the reasoning. Unless you were in my position and actually went through what I've been through,
Starting point is 01:38:37 no one can tell me how I should have behaved with a kidnapper or how I should be reacting now. exactly at another point peers tells chloe if you're going to conduct media interviews where you're being paid money and you're doing a book for thousands of pounds before there's even been a trial i think we're perfectly entitled to ask you difficult questions and then chloe says if i was just a normal 20 year old not a 20 year old model do you think people would have the same opinions the interview goes viral and the comment section under the good morning britain facebook post tells you a lot about british sentiment surrounding chloe ailing at the time but also you know these are a lot of people who don't fucking hate Pierce Morgan, which I think says a lot about them. Like, if you're like, I fucking love Pierce Morgan, I have concerns. I don't think you and I could ever be friends.
Starting point is 01:39:24 But yeah, here's the sentiment. This certainly doesn't pass a smell test to me at all. If I had been drugged and kidnapped, I am more than 100% sure. I would be more traumatized than she appears to be. Okay, it's a fucking hard take, you know.
Starting point is 01:39:38 Get her on the Jeremy Kyle show for a lie detector. I smell bullshit, just a gold-digging fame-starved wannabe. Don't believe her at all. You wouldn't be on TV if this had happened. And you wouldn't be dressed like how she's been dressed in all her interviews. Feel sorry for her child. Wonder who looks after him slash her while she's doing all this.
Starting point is 01:39:58 Yeah, how dare a mother work. She'll be on, I'm a celebrity, get me out of here next year. Total lie. If I found out, oh, excuse me, if found out to be lying, she should be banged up for real. well I hope other young models do not see her and her story as a way of making money but she seems too relaxed and polished to be lying but then again this reminds me of taking okay while Chloe's appearing on television negative personal stories are being leaked to the press her former boyfriend Connor
Starting point is 01:40:24 Keyes the father of her young son Ashton tells the press as I mentioned earlier that Chloe has not come to see her son since she has returned he too cast a shadow of a doubt over her story and behavior then a Facebook detail emerges that she that some of the tabloids cannot let go of Chloe and Lukash had been Facebook friends for a couple of years before the kidnapping. That was really bad. Dun, da-da.
Starting point is 01:40:47 Dun-da. So kind of bad. Chloe explains it the only way she can. She was naive, she says. If people wanted to be Facebook friends, fine. The more she had to hire her profile. She accepted everybody. And I can see to some how that could have looked suspicious.
Starting point is 01:41:01 However, a long time ago when I was trying to build up a Facebook profile, she'd be to raise my follower account before I ever had a fan page. I think before fan pages even existed, back when you had to accept or deny each person, I also accepted literally everybody because the more followers I had, the easier it was to get bookings and keep my career going. It was incredibly common.
Starting point is 01:41:20 It was the norm back then to accept literally everyone if you're in her position. And the journalist, they fucking knew that. Around this time, Chloe dropped Phil Green as her agent, signed with a new representative, Adrian Sington of the Kruger Crown Agency. Sincton is a publicity agent,
Starting point is 01:41:36 not a modeling agent, his specialty is media strategy, book deals, and public-facing campaigns, and he brokered a book deal for Chloe's blink publishing. Phil Green also appeared on Good Morning Britain saying he was hacked off, aka very annoyed slash angry, at being dropped as her agent. Chloe will later say that she dropped him as her agent because she believed he had compromised her safety
Starting point is 01:41:56 by setting of a photo shoot that led to her being kidnapped. And I will say regarding that, he should have asked for referrals to speak with other models, who'd work for him, work for this, you know, Andre person. But he didn't. But that also might have been the industry norm. You know, I've had a lot of agents over the years, and I have found most of them, frankly, to be fucking lazy.
Starting point is 01:42:16 Way more talk than action. Not my favorite group of people overall. More concerned over, you know, where they're having lunch, who they're being seen by, what they're driving, than, you know, doing, like, real work. In the 2025 docu-series, Chloe Ailing, my unbelievable kidnapping, Chloe's new agent, Adrian Sington describes the choice
Starting point is 01:42:33 he and Chloe faced in their PR, first agent client, relationship, Sington says he essentially gave Chloe two paths. She could become a poster girl for anti-slavery and women's abduction campaigns, or they could focus on making money and controlling the narrative, and Chloe chose the latter. And that choice would also prove to be controversial. How dare the young mother try and make money? To Chloe's critics, this was another sign of her ruthless ambition to become famous at all costs. A young glamour model abandons her old agents, signs of the publicists within weeks of the kidnapping. Dropping agents, by the way, when a better one
Starting point is 01:43:06 comes along standard practice in this industry. Chloe insisted she never really wanted the publicity, not for this anyway, but it was only after talking with Adrian that she decided that after having been through such a terrible ordeal, something good should come from it for her. What the public does not see in any of this is this version of Chloe that lived at home with her mom at this time. For the first few months, she told The Guardian in 2018, I stayed up while my mom slept and would then sleep during the day. Every little noise I heard at night. I would run into her room. At one point, I even pushed the chest of drawers against the door because I was so scared.
Starting point is 01:43:38 For the rest of the year, leading up to a February 2018 trial in Italy for all this, Chloe kept herself busy, traveling a lot to Milan, to New York City, three times to L.A., Miami, Vegas, Dubai, Maldives, giving interviews, and also being paid for photo shoots. Her explanation outside of this literally being her job, quote, I've traveled so much to put it all to the back of my mind as much as possible. At some point during this time, Chloe heard that Lukas Herba was violently beaten in prison by other inmates because of his involvement in a crime against a woman. Hearing that scared her more
Starting point is 01:44:07 because in her head, Lukash still the man who saved her from Black Death, who she claimed she still believed in the existence of. If he was locked up and worse, if he was getting hurt in there, who was going to protect her, she thinks? That fear allegedly lingered right up until the pre-trial hearing when the Italian police
Starting point is 01:44:23 finally told Chloe the truth. The police sat her down and explained to her that she did not need to live in fear of Black Death because after months and months of looking into it, they were absolutely certain there was no group of traffickers. Never was. No group of killers called Black Death. And you knew that by now, right? We all didn't do that.
Starting point is 01:44:41 Chloe also learned that the photos of her lying on the floor, half naked and drugged and unconscious, were found on Lucas's phone. She was shocked. She thought, how was that possible? He wasn't even at the studio, right? That's what he told her. He told her so many lies. She also learned that the police had concluded that only two people were involved in her abduction, Lucas Herba and his brother, Michael. There were never any Romanians. There was no second team, no mysterious criminal syndicate, Lukash and Michael alone had orchestrated the entire thing. It wasn't until Lukash's pretrial hearing
Starting point is 01:45:09 that the remaining pieces for all this had fallen into place. The prosecutor revealed that Lukash had bought the ski mask used during Chloe's abduction himself, matching the men Chloe described that he had created a so-called Black Death pamphlet, right, that fucking weird document used to convince her that she was being held by an international trafficking network. They also presented drafts of ransom emails
Starting point is 01:45:29 pulled from his computers, including one sent to her agent, Phil Green, a message Lukash sent to his brother instructing him to, quote, clean the boot of the car so that her hair will not be found. Boot being the car's trunk. It strongly appeared that based on all the gathered evidence, his only real accomplice was his brother Michael. But Lucas was not getting down, or, you know, going down,
Starting point is 01:45:49 without telling another story. It was leaked by his defense team that Lukash would take the stand at his trial and claim he had fallen in love with Chloe and that the two of them had stayed the entire kidnapping together, not as a hoax for notoriety, desperate scheme to pull her out of financial trouble after the birth of her son. Lucas was planning to testify that he had used his supposed involvement with Black Death to scare her into compliance. He wanted to believe she was in danger so she wouldn't back out of this plan.
Starting point is 01:46:17 What? That defense strategy is crazy. So she conspired with him to stage this kidnapping hoax to give publicity to then become famous and make more money modeling to provide for her son, but then changed her mind. And then he decided to scare her into going through with it anyway, uh, despite being afraid that she's going to be raped and killed. And that's going to get him acquitted. What the fuck?
Starting point is 01:46:44 Is his lawyer as stupid as he is? The trial of Lucas Herba opens in Milan, February 7th, 2018, and Chloe's not there. While the case first unfold, she is reported to be in Switzerland, scheme. To her critics, yet another damning piece of evidence against her. Her lawyer, Francesco Pesha, he argued she should be. be excused from testifying that after six days of being terrorized, threatened with death, abused both mentally and physically, putting her
Starting point is 01:47:08 in the same room as Herba would only re-traumatize her. Herba's lawyers fought that. They wanted her on the stand, but the court sided with Pesha and Chloe stayed away. The prosecution opened with prosecutor Apollo Starare, panting of Lucas as a, quote, fantasist. He's a, he is a fantasist
Starting point is 01:47:26 with narcissistic tendencies. He is a metamaniac adventurer. Now, he did say that he was a mythomaniac adventure whose entire criminal persona was built on grandiose, self-inflated lies. Nailed it. The prosecution pointed to his tendencies to create elaborate over-the-top stories, including the fact that he had actually built a website where he advertised women being sold to the highest bidder
Starting point is 01:47:48 and described himself as a killer for hire who had worked for the FBI and the CIA and Musa. Nothing is over. Nothing. You just don't turn it off. This pattern of self-mythologizing, I think that's how he said the word, ran all the way down to the small details. Like on Facebook where he claimed to be the chairman of that fake tech company, right? One-800 business, baby.
Starting point is 01:48:11 And this was all before he had met Chloe. Yeah, again, this dude's fucking nuts. The court heard how Italian police recovered from Herba's phone and from his rented properties, the following evidence. The two ski masks, again, Herbert purchased before the kidnapping, matching Chloe's description of the men's masks who first grabbed her, photographs on Herba's phone of Chloe line drugged, unconscious, partially nude, a printed black death pamphlet. The document Herba had used to convince Chloe,
Starting point is 01:48:37 she was being held by an international trafficking network, drafts of ransom emails, including the one sent to Phil Green. Finally, a recovered message. Lucas is sent to his brother Michael instructing him to again, quote, clean the boot of the car so that her hair won't be found. The court also saw the physical evidence. Lab results reporting ketamine traces found in Chloe's hair, an injection mark from her right forearm,
Starting point is 01:48:57 are into it, the deep bruising on her wrist and ankles. Lukash's defense, led by Katia Kalawaska. Instead of denying the kidnapping, they accept that it happened. The evidence, the photos, the messages, the ransom emails, the ketamine traces, the ski masks. It all made it extremely difficult to dispute. The defense argued that the kidnapping was, in fact, a publicity stunt and that Chloe Aileen agreed to the scheme to boost her career. But if that was true, why make the stupid fucking black death pamphlet?
Starting point is 01:49:25 why email the brother to clean the car? Why actually inject her with ketamine? If they're all in on it and it's just going to be a publicity stunt isn't that a lot of overkill or at least regarding the pamphlet shouldn't she have taken it and given it to investigators
Starting point is 01:49:39 complete with having memorized some dark web addresses where they could then you know punch that in find this website or websites about black death to help build out its mythology make it seem possible
Starting point is 01:49:51 this defense is weak as fuck also if they were really all in on it in no world does Lukash go with her to the consulate, right? He shouldn't be found ever if that's the plan. They should have never walked into the village, bought the shoes. All that reeks of a weird delusional guy trying to get her to fall in love with him as opposed to what the defense is claiming. Lucas's lawyers point to CCTV footage of her holding hands with him as they stop for shoes
Starting point is 01:50:13 during captivity is proof even though, as I just laid out, that actually hurts this claim. If you think about it for a few minutes. In Italian courts, defendants have the right to make a personal declaration without being cross-examined. Lukash Herba used that right. He claimed to have been in love with Chloe Aileen, telling the court, quote, I never hurt the girl. I was not violent with her. If she felt forced verbally in any way, I'm very sorry.
Starting point is 01:50:36 But it certainly was not as Chloe has described. I was in love. I was hoping that once her fame took off, she would repay me with feelings. We would share the money. This guy is a fucking maniac. I hope many times that if she go famous, she repay me with feelings. I just want feelings with her and we share money. He said he met Chloe on Facebook in 2015.
Starting point is 01:50:59 Fell in love with her. He didn't meet her. She accepted your friend request, you fucking weirdo. He also said the two had met in person at least once before the kidnapping. Yeah, I bet you approach her on the street and we're like, hi, are you Chloe? And she's like, ah, yes. And then she took off.
Starting point is 01:51:13 Then during closing arguments, Lucas lawyer cited an email she had received from U.S. film producers that Chloe's story closely matched the plot of a movie titled By Any Means. which was released only eight weeks before the 2017 kidnapping. The IMDB logline for this film reads, A C-List Celebrity gets kidnapped and held hostage after a nightclub appearance. When the police interrogate the man she accuses, they question whether she's after justice or a front-page story.
Starting point is 01:51:38 Here is the trailer for this extremely low budget, terribly mixed, abysmal-looking production that truly almost no one watched. What's this for? To prove you're alive. Yes, hold it, mold it. Nice. Let's just bring it back to Mimi.
Starting point is 01:51:59 What do you make up this media frenzy? Oh, I think it's an absolute outrage. She's supposed to be America's It Girl. My name is Mimi Wyatt. My name is Mimi Wyatt? No way. For now, you've got to get out there more. We've seen enough.
Starting point is 01:52:12 It has no rating. All right, listen to enough. It has no rating on Rotten Tomatoes because literally not a single actual critic ever reviewed it. It doesn't have an audience score because no audience members bothered to review it either because it was never shown in theaters, never streamed on a proper platform.
Starting point is 01:52:26 It basically might as well be a home movie. Lucas's defense argued that this movie that no one saw was their inspiration and then Lucas himself confirmed that by any means served as a blueprint for what unfolded. I highly doubt he watched it. I highly doubt he would have ever even heard about this film.
Starting point is 01:52:42 Had the film's actual producers, one of the fucking very few people like small, like a group of the very few people on Earth who have actually seen this movie if they had not sent him an email. Although one of Tomb Fitness, one of two film festivals, it was screened out, was in Poland, but a small one, and he was living in England. In his closing speech, prosecutor Paolo Serare, tore apart to publicity stunt defense by breaking down the numbers again.
Starting point is 01:53:06 The 10,000 pounds, herb is spent on property rentals, travel, ski masks, fake studio, that he turned to the court and asked, Why would a man in love with a young Amaro blow his other 10,000 euros on all that? For a stunt, I would supposedly get him on nothing in the Tana. He said it made no economic sense, made no sense. sense of any kind didn't add up. Paolo Starrari requested 16 years and eight months in prison for Herba, citing the very real possibility that Chloe could have died at numerous
Starting point is 01:53:31 points. She could have stopped breathing from the ketamine, suffocated in that fucking bag in the trunk of the car. He argued the sense needed to reflect not just what Herba did, but what could have happened. On June 18, 2018, 2018, four months after the trial began, the Milan court delivered his verdict. The court found,
Starting point is 01:53:47 Lukashar Herber is a guilty of aggravated a kidnapper for the purposes of extortion. he receives a recommender a sentence of a 16 a year and a it a manza. Lucas's defense lawyer, Katia Kolokaska, announced her intention to appeal, arguing the sentence should have been limited to one to eight years, given that Chloe emerged unharmed.
Starting point is 01:54:08 Chloe's lawyer, Francesco Pesha, announced that he would seek $500,000 in euros and damages in separate civil proceedings, although conceded that that was unlikely because Lukash would probably not be able to pay it. In a statement, Chloe said, I'm so very happy this is all over. I'm very pleased and relieved by the outcome of today's hearing and feel the justice has been served
Starting point is 01:54:28 and I can get closure on what has been a terrible time for me. I am desperate to put this ordeal behind me, move on with my life, and forge a new path now that the world can see I was telling the truth. Lucas Brother Michael also sentenced to 16 years and eight months for helping kidnap and drug Chloe. Right, good, they're both dipshits. Both Chloe and her former agent, Phil Green, have since written memoirs about the ordeal. In July 2018, Chloe Alien's memoir kidnapped the untold story of my abduction was published, Just weeks earlier, Phil Green published his memoir in confessions of a model agent.
Starting point is 01:54:58 In it, Phil insisted he did everything in his power to help Chloe. Writing about Chloe's time in Italy, after the kidnapping, Phil described himself as her lifeline, saying her calls to him sometimes two or three a day lasted up to an hour each. But according to Chloe, she felt like she had no real option except to call Phil, since he was one responsible for booking her hotel.
Starting point is 01:55:15 She also claims her mother told her that Phil actually had been rather difficult to deal with and had told her to stop calling while she was trying to find out where her daughter was. Chloe ultimately held Phil responsible for what happened, arguing that he had failed to carry out the basic checks any agent should have done before sending her abroad to meet a photographer she did not know. Phil, however, maintained he did everything he was supposed to do. August 16, 2018. Chloe entered Celebrity Big Brother UK as a day-one housemate.
Starting point is 01:55:42 During her short time in the house, much of the attention focused on her flirtation with former footballer Jermaine Pennant, who did not disclose to her that he was married. The two grew close, even breaking house rules by exchanging handwritten notes using Chloe's eyeliner. Chloe's ultimately nominated to be evicted by her housemates who complained about her not participating in chores and general disengagement around the house. She was evicted on day 13, making her the second housemate to leave. After her eviction, Chloe said she was shocked to learn that pennant had been married since 2014, insisting she had no idea he had a wife. Once again, this gives more fuel to her detractors who continue to insist she was part of a kidnapping plot, despite all evidence presented at the trial, and the conviction.
Starting point is 01:56:20 for kidnapper. They just think that she's a terrible human. January 2020, an Italian appeal court ruled to reduce Lucas Herba's sentence because he, quote, acted compassionally during the kidnap. Kidnapping. In its judgment, the court noted he had acted out of love. Okay. Adding that he had not abandoned her in an isolated area when he released her and drove her to the British consulate in Milan. All right. This meant that Lukish would now serve 12 years in one month instead of 16 years and eight months. I mean, I guess he did, you know, return her. Maybe they thought that they're reducing the sentence would give future kidnappers incentive to, you know, release people unharmed. I don't know. Next year in March of
Starting point is 01:56:59 2021, a Milan appeal court cut Michael Herbert's sentence all the way down to five years and eight months, downgrading his conviction from kidnapping for extortion to simple kidnapping, since he was not the primary planner. And then Michael will end up being released 18 months earlier than that back in 2024. I don't like it. Neither did Chloe. I think he should have been in prison for a lot. longer. Aileen told the BBC of Michael in August of 2024, she added the fact that they still don't take accountability and still want to make lies and not be responsible
Starting point is 01:57:27 for what they did is even more annoying. Yeah. Backing up a bit, in April of 2023, BBC 3 announced a six-part drama based on the abduction made with Chloe's blessing. English actress Nadia Parks, played Chloe in the series. Head of the launch, Chloe said that she hoped the series, quote,
Starting point is 01:57:43 encourages people not to doubt victims based on the way they react to a traumatic experience, based on the way they dress, their job, or what they did to survive. I hope it encourages people to look deeper than headlines, not to judge a situation or story based on what you read, not to be so easily influenced by media, and to keep an open mind before jumping to conclusions. Yeah, Pierce Morgan, you daft fucking twat.
Starting point is 01:58:05 Two months after the BBC drama aired, Chloe's former agent Phil Green gave his most extensive interview yet to Ladb Bible. He walked a reporter through the original André Lazio contact. the due diligence he says he carried out in the moment he received the black death email. Then he got to what everybody wanted to hear. What did you think of Chloe now? On the one hand, he said he was empathetic
Starting point is 01:58:26 because there was no way the kidnapping was staged. But he was critical of what came afterwards the way Chloe behaved post-release, Phil said, made it look as though she loved the attention. The press, the TV interviews, Celebrity Big Brother. In his view, she had made some bad decisions. And so no wonder people came away thinking she was just in it for the money.
Starting point is 01:58:44 He also offered a theory about why she'd be been targeted in the first place. Social media, Instagram in particular. Models, he said, put everything online and he had no doubt the attacker had been following her. After seeing how larger audience was, assuming a bigger ransom was within reach, people don't always know who was watching them, he warned, and he thought that that made it all a little dangerous. And I couldn't agree more with Phil there. That BBC drama still was not enough to convince everyone that Chloe was telling the truth. And so in August of 2025, a three-part documentary referred to
Starting point is 01:59:15 throughout this episode, Chloe Ailing, my unbelievable kidnapping, premiered on BBC 3 and BBC I player. In its third and final episode, the series surfaced something that reframed Chloe's entire experience. Something that I alluded to talking about before this episode was over,
Starting point is 01:59:31 much earlier, right, at the beginning of the timeline, the reason for Chloe's inability to pick up on certain social cues, why she trusted the wrong people, why she didn't show what other people thought were appropriate emotions, why she seemed so cold illogical when others thought she should be, you know, more emotional. Chloe had been formally diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder. It all started when a primary school teacher emailed Chloe
Starting point is 01:59:55 explained that she thought Chloe might have autism, that it could be affecting the way she behaved, and that was why people could not relate to her or understand her reactions to things, why she could not always understand why her peers behaved in certain ways. Chloe sought out an assessment, and the assessment came back positive. In the documentary, Chloe describes that for her entire life, she, quote, had a lot of difficulties with the communication.
Starting point is 02:00:16 If I was being told off, I would smile. I just had the wrong reactions to things. She added for ages, I said, I'm not an emotional person. But now I realize that no matter how hard I try, I just can't show it. My calmness saved me in the kidnap, but it backfired in the press. So how about that, huh? Again, fuck you, Pierce Morgan, you piece of shit. A guy who never apologized for tearing into her.
Starting point is 02:00:38 of course not, pompous ass. I would not give a shit if he was kidnapped someday. Get him black death, sell his ass. Not that you could probably get much for it. Chloe's diagnosis explained everything the British public had been bitching about. The chirpy demeanor in interviews, the smiling on her doorstep, the flat affect, as she described her own trauma,
Starting point is 02:00:55 the fact that she was never very emotional on television. In 2025, Chloe told a journalist for Stylist magazine, autism plays a big part in the way that I reacted. And that was confusing to neurotypical people. However, there are other reasons. why people could react in the way that I did, or in an unusual way that doesn't fit the normal box. People disassociate with events that have happened
Starting point is 02:01:16 or have a delayed reaction, especially after trauma. So it can't all be put down to a diagnosis, and that shouldn't affect the way people treated me. Someday when I have more time, I would like to get tested myself. I have also been told that my own emotional reactions, especially by everybody I've ever been in a romantic relationship with of any significance, they are not normal.
Starting point is 02:01:36 that my flat affect in certain situations where others are often emotional confuses people that I've very delayed responses to things in particular I rarely express a lot of obvious excitement and joy over good news Lindsay for sure thinks
Starting point is 02:01:52 that I'm pretty autistic yeah and I've struggled with that I guess for a long time I'm glad there's more terms for it now you know we really do all have different kinds of brains to produce all different kinds of reactions to similar events in the documentary
Starting point is 02:02:06 Chloe says the fallout after the kidnapping had impacted her just as much, if not more, than the kidnapping itself. Even years later, she said she still got regular abuse online. People still call her a liar. Chloe also recently did something that by her own account brought her the closest thing to real peace she has felt since 2017. She moved away from the edge of London to Snowdonia, North Wales. Snowdonia, a mountainous, gorgeous region, a national park in North Wales, home to only three towns within the park's boundaries, a bunch more immediately beyond it. A most populous town has, you know, not quite 3,000 people. It's awe-inspiring landscape is dramatic, rugged mountain ranges, jagged peaks, deep glacial valleys, waterfalls, lakes shaped over hundreds of millions of years, including by ancient volcanic activity. In the quieter months, especially midweek, the trails feel almost empty.
Starting point is 02:02:54 So if you live there, that Chloe, you know, people like her, they have the waterfall, summits, lakes pretty much themselves. For Chloe, the main appeal is the isolation and natural beauty. She found a house that she loves That overlooks the water She bought it Good on her How often is her son there Not sure
Starting point is 02:03:10 I didn't look that hard She clearly wants to keep that part of her life private And good on her Luciferina is proud And now After that pretty happy ending To all this madness Let's get out of this timeline
Starting point is 02:03:23 Good job soldier You've made it back Barely What an insane story Such a unique and crazy convergence of a delusional, self-aggrandizing, pathological liar, kidnapping a love interest, who is neurodivergent in a way that makes it very hard for her
Starting point is 02:03:46 to understand just how nonsensical and full of shit he is. Woo! Glad that that did not end a lot more tragically than it did. Chloe Ailing has said in some of her most recent interviews that she can see in hindsight why many people have doubted her. She admits some of her own choices and inconsistencies didn't help, but also thinks the backlash went deeper than that. People saw her smiling, assume that that meant she was not traumatized, and she says that a lot of the public judgment came from the fact that she was a model, and I think she's right.
Starting point is 02:04:16 Go online and poke around. A lot of in-celled dudes love to hate on pretty girls. And so many insecure women also love to hate on pretty girls. I mean, holy fuck do they get it from all sides. It is truly pathetic. The fuck do you care if an influencer is wearing a tight tank top at the mall, showing some cleavage? Are you mad because you don't have her tits? Are you pissed because you know
Starting point is 02:04:38 She'll never let you play with those tits? Either way, grow the fuck up, loser Worry about yourself. Stop acting like a fifth grade bully. You know, stop being a pathetic keyboard warrior douche. Would you go up and say what you just type to someone's face You know, in real life? No, then probably don't type it. I say a lot of shit, you know?
Starting point is 02:04:55 On here on this podcast, it's negative. But I really try and limit it to people who act in negatively egregious ways, right? Looking at you, Pierce Morgan. He would never give me the time of day, but I would fucking love to say a bunch of shit to his face. But even if you do go after Chloe, she probably won't care. She's pretty logical, analytic. She knows the odds are her life is probably better than yours if you're that kind of person.
Starting point is 02:05:15 Right? She's living a natural splendor and a home she owns overlooking the water, making good money, probably having hot sex. What are you doing with your days? Getting pissed off that mom burnt another casserole, frustrated that your dick keeps getting chafed from beating off too many times with a cheap lotion. Trolling is a dead giveaway that you're a miserable fuck and that your life is probably in shambles. Every day. Every day.
Starting point is 02:05:43 We rid with this dude. So, interesting story, right? There are still questions that haven't been answered, at least not for some people. Why did Lucas truly let her go? Chloe still doesn't know. Maybe he believed they had a future together. Maybe he didn't know what to do next.
Starting point is 02:05:56 Maybe he was just crazy. I mean, one of his demands was for Chloe to publicize Black Death, even though it doesn't exist. So he's truly nuts. The going theory is that Lucas Herba had orchestrated an extraordinary kidnapped plot in an attempt to win the model's affection or perhaps kidnapped her in the hope of getting
Starting point is 02:06:13 a ransom, but in the process of plenty of the abduction became romantically obsessed with her by posing as her savior. He was hoping that Chloe would fall in love with him and the two could start a relationship, and I feel like that is correct. Right? He has some kind of serious personality disorder. He's truly mentally ill. I think he stalked
Starting point is 02:06:30 her, kidnapped her, thinking that his bat-shit crazy ramblings would somehow get her to fall in love with him. Its primary motivation, you know, was to get $300,000, or I'm sorry, his primary motivation was to get her to fall in love with him, his secondary motivation, you know, to get $300,000. And then when the money was not going to come,
Starting point is 02:06:46 you know, he pivoted. I hope he could still at least get $50,000. But most importantly, you know, her undying affection and devotion. I think he's a dangerously deranged in cell with no proper understanding of how romantic relationships work in real life. And to refer back to those Playboy models I worked with around the time
Starting point is 02:07:01 Chloe was kidnapped, I remember a number of them talking about dealing with crazy stalker type fans who are nuts like him. I feel bad for women in that way, right? There are a bunch of people out there, men and women who just do not fucking get how life works. And they delude themselves into thinking that because somebody once accepted their friend request or liked their comment or replied to their DM that one time
Starting point is 02:07:21 that that that person feels the way about them, that they feel about this influencer, model, musician, etc. And with female models, those fans highly sexualized, more prone statistically to violence. So if you're a sexy lady being sexy for a living, Lucifina begs you to be careful. There's a lot of variations of Lucas Herba out there. Looking back, Chloe wishes she had done things differently, was more protective of herself.
Starting point is 02:07:44 She's a little older and wiser now. She's thought a lot about what, you know, whether bringing somebody with her to that shoot, how that might have changed everything. Has anything positive come out of this experience? According to Chloe, it's made me a lot stronger, and I'm a lot wiser. I'm more paranoid and cautious. Good, Chloe. I hope he thrive.
Starting point is 02:08:04 If you're not thriving, you're dying! Time for the day's. takeaways. Time shock. Top five takeaways. Number one, Chloe Aileen grew up in Coleson, South London, raised largely by her mother, single mom, became a mom herself, the teenager, gave birth to her son Ashton. She was barely a year into her modeling career when she was taken.
Starting point is 02:08:27 She'd been working the glamour in page three end of the industry and signed with Phil Green's agency in pursuit of bigger jobs and a bigger social media following. Number two, Chloe's abduct. in Milan, Italy in July of 2017, after being lured to a fake photo shoot, grabbed by two masked men, injected with ketamine, stuffed into the trunk of a hired car,
Starting point is 02:08:48 or trunk of a car, and then driven to a remote farmhouse near Turin, where she was held for six days. Her captors claimed to be working for a dark web crime syndicate called Black Death, who one of them said would auction her off as a sex slave, unless $300,000 US was paid as ransom.
Starting point is 02:09:04 But the Black Death does not exist. The whole thing was in a last, elaborate plot orchestrated by two brothers, Lukash and Michael Herba, because Lukash had fallen in love with the model he did not know. Number three, Chloe Ailin's primary kidnapper, Lucas Herba, was a Polish computer programmer who, prosecutors determined to be a narcissist,
Starting point is 02:09:22 a fantasist obsessed with concocting elaborate, delusional, fanciful stories in which he always emerged the hero. Dude was a one-man-killing machine in his mind, and reality is sad, insufferable, delusional loser. Number four, despite a criminal, conviction confirming her account, large parts of the British public refused to believe alien had been kidnapped at all.
Starting point is 02:09:44 The doubt centered on her demeanor. She smiled, posed for photographers, was unemotional, retelling her story. To many of this behavior read as, you know, somebody who had staged the whole thing for publicity. To Alien, it was the behavior of someone doing whatever it took to survive by making her capture believe that she had feelings for him too. In a documentary about her case, Alien revealed she had been formally diagnosed with autism. The diagnosis offered a new framework from which to assess her supposed to. of the odd behavior.
Starting point is 02:10:09 And number five, new info. Want to support Chloe's modeling career today? Well, she's on only fans. At barely Chloe. Offering some kind of limited free trial for 30 days, over a thousand pieces of media, all natural peach and melons, according to her emojis.
Starting point is 02:10:25 I'm probably not promoting this well. If you think it's weird that I'm promoting her only fans, please hear one last reference to my days working with the Playboy models. They were only paid, I think, $100 in appearance to come on the show. they were not paid more when their photos were repurposed online or you know magazines sometimes some of them also did porn were paid next to nothing for that even when they were flown to exotic
Starting point is 02:10:49 places for photo shoots they were often not paid much more than travel expenses but the people who took their picks the people who made the videos well they got to monetize that content however they wanted in perpetuity prior to only fans exploitation and adult content was off the fucking charts everybody was making money except the women getting naked so many whole horror stories. But with OnlyFans and similar sites, suddenly models like Chloe, they got a way to monetize their social media followings. Suddenly, they don't have to be taken advantage of by some shady producer or shady agent of which there are many. They get to keep 80% of their subscription costs. Idiotic moralists want to destroy sites like OnlyFans, and I guess just let those women be financially
Starting point is 02:11:25 taken advantage of again. Same mentality people have with abortion, right? Shutting down abortion clinics, doesn't end abortion, just pushes it further into the shadows where it's infinitely more dangerous. Porn will never, ever, ever, ever, ever, ever go away. So to me, the obvious, maybe autistically and unemotionally logical choice is to not push it into the shadows. Let somebody like Chloe control her own narrative, her own business, right, control every aspect of her own photo shoots, to own the content, buy her own equipment, own her own studio, hire her own camera operator, or just do it herself, never have to worry again about work for some psychotic creep who might rape her or kill her or pretend he is going to auction her off her,
Starting point is 02:12:04 auction her off to Black Death. Hail Lucifino, motherfuckers. Time suck. Top five takeaways. Black Death, the bizarre kidnapping of Chloe Alien has been sucked. Thank you to Bad Magic Productions for the team here for help
Starting point is 02:12:22 making time suck. Thanks to Queen of Bad Magic, Lindsay Cummins. Thanks also Logan Keith, helping to publish this episode, signing the merch for the store at Bad Magic Productions.com where again you can get those summer camp tickets. Thanks to Laura Woods for the initial
Starting point is 02:12:34 research and let me know about this topic. Also thanks to the all-seen eyes, moderating the cult of the curious private Facebook page, the Mod Squad for making sure Discord keeps one and smooth and everybody over in the TimeSucks subreddit and Bad Magic Subreddit. And now let's head on over to this week's Time Sucker updates. Get your Time Sucker updates.
Starting point is 02:12:59 Mathematical Meadsack, Michael Broughton, sending a message to Bojangles at Timesuckpodcast.com with the subject line of two out of three stars versus three out of five stars. one of many people, I should add, who wrote it with a similar message. And Mike wrote, Damn it, Dan, three out of five equals 0.6 or 60%. Two out of three or 0.667 or 66.6%.
Starting point is 02:13:24 Hell Satan. He rated you higher, not lower, not sorry at all. Mike, former math teacher. I suspect a new fan who wrote in also is. God damn, Mike. I was so confident when I act like 203 stars was less than 3 out of 5 stars. fucking fractions. This reminds me of a story
Starting point is 02:13:42 that my son, Keiter likes to tell. In the 1980s, to compete directly with McDonald's wildly successful quarter-pounder. ANW introduced a one-third pound burger for the exact same price,
Starting point is 02:13:55 offered more meat, even beat the quarter-pounder and blind taste tests. Despite that, the burger flopped. Why? Fractions. ANW hired a market research firm to investigate the poor sales,
Starting point is 02:14:06 found that a large number of customers incorrectly believed that a quarter pound burger was bigger than a third pound burger because the number four is bigger than the number three. And I've laughed at that so many times and then I did the same shit thinking for a second that because five is bigger than three, three out of five must be bigger than two out of three. Dunst cap activated. Now for something silly. Known drug user, Lee Stamper, sent in a message with a subject line of acid and sharks. this in regards to me talking about how tripping on acid actually sometimes reduces my anxiety
Starting point is 02:14:41 and I was able to tread water out in the ocean because everything felt so beautiful when sober there's no fucking way that happened ever but Lee writes Hi Dan You mentioned being terrified of sharks So I decided to share this story In my early 20s my whole extended family
Starting point is 02:14:54 rented out some cabins at Pacific Beach in San Diego I decided to do acid Swimming the ocean Combining two of my favorite things I'm not afraid of sharks But the whole time I was in the water I was convinced I was going to be eaten by sharks Every piece of kelp
Starting point is 02:15:06 The touch of my legs sent me into a panic But I was too scared To go back to shore Because I didn't want my family To see my eyes And know I was on something So I spent hours
Starting point is 02:15:14 During the peak of the trip Just floating terrified that sharks Were going to eat me At one point A few of my cousins Swam out to me And I kept swimming away from them
Starting point is 02:15:22 So they wouldn't know I was tripping Which was ridiculous Because they would not have cared at all And really that just made me seem like a complete weirdo At some point I became aware I was getting very sunburned And needed to get out of the water
Starting point is 02:15:33 And an idea struck me if I wear sunglasses, nobody will see my eyes. Such a good idea. So I threw my shades on and I went back to my family. I love that that took you hours to come up with that when you were tripping. I went back to my family and nobody noticed a thing. The downside was that I saw my sunburned in the bathroom mirror and spent the next few hours convinced I permanently disfigured myself.
Starting point is 02:15:52 The takeaway here is that apparently my social anxiety overwhelms any fear of sharks. I was willing to die rather than have an aunt or uncle know that I was on acid. Thanks for everything you do, sincerely leave. Oh man. Thanks, dude. thanks for sending in that message, Lee. It really made me smile and laugh. So funny to think that you were truly willing to be eaten by sharks
Starting point is 02:16:10 rather than have some family members find out your tripping balls. And now one more. From furious sack, Megan Magley. Sent it with a subject line of how dare you make me feel my feelings. And then Megan writes, hey Dan and everyone in bad magic, fuck you.
Starting point is 02:16:28 Apologies for coming in a little hot. I just listened to the big wheel short suck. And even before I listened, when I read the notification about a new episode, episode when it popped up on my phone early because I'm his base littered, Hill Nimrod, I started crying. Let me explain. My dad used to beat the shit out of me with the big wheel for fucking seven straight years. He would nearly kill me. No, she didn't write that. Let me explain. My dad used to talk about being a kid, maybe three or four years old, and this story about
Starting point is 02:16:51 his big wheel toe. Basically, it was run over by those whack-ass tricycles and was all fucked up ever since. And it's at least partially to blame for my serious aversion defeat because his toe and specifically toenail were nasty. Obviously, it wasn't a big injury. but the way he talked about it, you would think he had lost his whole toe in an accident. And he fully blamed my grandma, his mom, for letting somebody run over his foot and not take him to the hospital.
Starting point is 02:17:12 I'm pretty sure he was just joking whenever he said that, but it got a rise out of her. Anyway, he passed away suddenly three years ago at the end of May. So your timing for this episode is just impeccable. I usually get some kind of anniversary grief around this time, but I thought I was ready for this year. So well done, son of a bitch, you got me. Seriously, though, I do want to actually thank you for this surprise grief.
Starting point is 02:17:31 To me, grief is love, persevering. I loved my dad. And I know if he were still around today, he would have gotten a kick out of you talking about a toy that ruined his kickball tail. Thank you for everything you do for our community and for our listening pleasure. Can't wait to make everyone uncomfortable with my dead dad jokes at camp. Megan Magley. Oh, Megan, I'm sorry for your loss, but thank you for the message. I love your thoughts about grief. Yeah, it's love persevering. How great to have the honor of loving someone so much it physically hurts when they're gone. How great to be loved by someone so much. You make them feel something powerful physically. You move them to tears. Tears of longing, but also tears of just real love when you leave.
Starting point is 02:18:10 May we all be loved by somebody that much, and maybe we all love someone that much. And that's hilarious about the big wheel accident. We've got lots of big wheel messages after that suck. A lot of meat sacks. We're lucky enough to have a Knight Rider big wheels. I went into a toy store in Boisey with Lindsay and Monroe the other day before my nephew Emerson's graduation party,
Starting point is 02:18:30 proud of UM. And they had a new big wheel. in the box. I just stared at it and smiled, man. I loved that that toy, you know, was so memorable that it hit so hard. That mangled toe was worth it for your debt. I bet he had some great times on a big wheel when he wasn't getting run over by one. Rest in peace, Megan Magley's dad. Save a spot the next world for the rest of us or say hello here if you're cycling back through. Hail Nimad, everybody. I'm suckers. I needed that. We all did.
Starting point is 02:19:02 Hello, hello. Thank you for listening to this bad magic production. If you have a second, please go ahead and rate us online, rate and review. If you haven't done that before, and don't start spending months this week planning an elaborate kidnapping hoax in order to get rich and have somebody you desire fall in love with you. You're not going to get rich. You're not going to find love. You are going to find prison. You are going to be mocked. Just get a job.
Starting point is 02:19:26 Learn how to save. Learn how to date. You know, put in the work. Have some basic, decent hygiene. Don't be your fucking dipshit. And keep on sucking. Attention. This MD, level 20 black death agent. Don't act like you have not heard of black death?
Starting point is 02:19:57 You surely have seen one of our men in pamphlets. We're a most powerful, ruthless, mostly Romanian group of psycho killer kidnapper sex traffickers in the world. Call the police, I dare you. Tell them you heard about the MD, level 20 black death agent. What are they going to do? Arrest me? Act like I could not literally murder them all. I've killed thousands. What's a few more?
Starting point is 02:20:18 Question. Do you know where your mom is? Your wife? Your daughter? Answer. Wherever I allow them to be. If I want them, I get them. You're not going to be able to stop me.
Starting point is 02:20:29 I'm part of black death. Biggester scariest part. Don't piss me off. You piss me off. I'll ask you enough entire family. I forget my accent sometimes. In the sexual slavery on Dark Web. One by one.
Starting point is 02:20:42 I make you watch the whole time. I need 300,000. I'll get three. $300,000 pop for them. When my client's stuff, we're gonna fucking, we'll feed them two tigers. Why? Because that's how we, that's how we do,
Starting point is 02:20:56 block of death. One more thing. Does this all sound cool to you? Won't be blocked death, they do too? Heads up, man. Fucking, you want to be black dead? You start a level one. Level 20, probably out of reach forever.
Starting point is 02:21:10 Well, if you want to try to hang with me, ha-ha, email me, uh, fucking dude. I mean, my brother, email my, I mean, our clandestine. Very large organization. at I am very dangerous and tough at Black Death, top is, okay? Thank you for attention to this matter. It's a jazzy little jam.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.