Today, Explained - Badlands

Episode Date: November 18, 2020

Covid-19 is surging across the United States, just in time for cold weather and major holidays. North Dakota is doing particularly badly. Vermont may offer hope. Transcript at vox.com/todayexplained. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Get groceries delivered across the GTA from Real Canadian Superstore with PC Express. Shop online for super prices and super savings. Try it today and get up to $75 in PC Optimum Points. Visit superstore.ca to get started. 2020 has been a carnival of anxieties from election to pandemic to protests, back to election, back to pandemic, back to election, back to pandemic. COVID-19 is once again top of mind across the United States and the planet, as much of us are heading into the cold winter months and some of the headliner holidays and the pleas to refrain from travel abound, especially in the United States, where Thanksgiving usually brings the most domestic travel of the year. With so much at risk across the country, we thought we'd take a

look at how two states are handling this pandemic very differently today. One's doing a relatively great job, Vermont. And then there's North Dakota. North Dakota has held the unwanted title of most COVID deaths and new cases per capita for really most of the last two months. North Dakota now has the highest COVID-19 mortality rate in the world, according to new analysis. In the world, mortality rate, people dying from this. And then about 65% of the COVID deaths that have happened in this state have happened since October 1st. So the last two months have been really devastating. Just this week in North Dakota, we heard that some facilities are running

critically low on supplies and that nurses are being asked to transition and work in other units for which there hasn't been time for orientation and for adequate preparation or training for that. There are two really core issues here. There's the issue in nursing homes, and obviously that's a massive issue because most of the state's deaths come in nursing homes as they did during New York City's outbreak, during Washington State's outbreak in the beginning. And then the second really core issue is there is a severe strain on hospitals due to sort of this intense shortage of healthy available nurses. In North Dakota, hospital staffing shortages are so severe, the state made the controversial call to allow health care workers who have tested positive for COVID-19, but are not showing symptoms, to continue to work in COVID units. The governor said last week that hospitals are at 100% capacity.

And we've heard, you know, increasingly more cases of people in dire need of medical attention sitting in an ER waiting room for hours because there are no available beds. There's nobody to staff those beds. We've heard of hospitals increasingly going on divert, which means they're diverting ambulances en route to the hospital because they just simply can't take any more patients in. And obviously this is an issue

that could affect anyone in the state. It sort of supersedes COVID because whether you have COVID or you were in a car accident or you have a heart attack, it's the same issue. You're just not going to be able to guarantee that you'll have medical care in a hospital. Jeremy Turley, Forum News Service, Bismarck, North Dakota. What did your state look like in March when a lot of cities and states on the coasts were locking down? Right. So our first

case came here on March 11th, which is around the same time that a lot of other states got their first cases. But the spread of the infection was pretty slow in the beginning. We did have a semi lockdown. Schools were closed and certain sort of public-facing businesses were closed at that time. But it was nothing like the total lockdown that you saw in coastal states and in big cities. I covered a baseball game with paying fans. Seating capacity is only at 500 to promote social distancing guidelines. But boy, the fans have a lot of smiles. On June 15th, between the Bismarck Larks and the Mandan Flickertails, that was a team that was born from COVID. They were not a team

before the pandemic. And they formed this three-team makeshift league in Bismarck because the infection rate seems so low that they could play baseball. Baseball is back. A big swing and a miss by Lofton to kick things off here from Bismarck. An 0-1 count. There's a quote in this story I wrote, we're the big show in the country for at least the next couple of weeks. People really thought that this was like the only baseball league that was operating at this time. I would call my mom in Chicago and she would obviously be worried about me. And I said, this is the best place in the world to sit out the pandemic. I mean, there are just like no cases here in Bismarck.

We might get like 10 cases a day for a while or even fewer than that. I remember a time over the summer when Burley County, which is where Bismarck is, had 40 active cases. And that was it. And we do a lot of testing here. That's really like indicative of how small this problem was for much of the summer. When does the pandemic get to North Dakota in earnest? So there are a few dates on the calendar that epidemiologists here point to as perhaps having ushered in this upward trending curve of cases

that we still have today. The 4th of July is often viewed as like this super spreader weekend because the weather was nice and people congregated at barbecues and parties. There was this one infamous photo that the governor featured at a press conference of a large group of people posing on a sandbar in the Missouri River. And obviously nobody was wearing a mask. You know, we're back to the same things we've said about being North Dakota smart, which is, you know, again, if you can keep six feet of distance away, that's great. If you can't wear a mask, you know, wash your hands, you know, and practice good hygiene. Then there was the Sturgis motorcycle rally, which happened in South Dakota. 250,000 people from across the country expected to attend with no mask mandates in place. The mayor urging personal responsibility,

saying he can't stop people from coming. We will never have any idea how many cases stemmed from Sturgis, but it was, by all accounts, a lot. And then around that same time in late August, most of the schools and colleges in the state reopened. There were flare-ups, especially in college towns. And then after that, it really took off into what you would call exponential growth. And deaths have grown exponentially as well, obviously. The three deadliest months of the pandemic here are the last three months. November is already by far the second deadliest months of the pandemic here are the last three months. November is already by far the second deadliest month of the pandemic. And we have, you know, half the month to go still. And you mentioned that motorcycle rally in South Dakota.

Our team was passing around a video just the other day of this nurse in South Dakota talking about how dire things had gotten there. People want it to be influenza. They want it to be pneumonia. They want it to be pneumonia. They want it to be, I mean, we've even had people say, well, I think maybe it might be lung cancer. I mean, something so far-fetched. And the reality is, since day one, when COVID started in this area in March, you've kind of been able to say, if it walks like a duck and talks like a duck, it's a duck.

Like, I hate to tell you that you have COVID, but that's what you have. You know, even after positive results come back, some people just don't believe it. People in the Dakotas will tell you there's sort of a libertarian streak here. People don't like listening to the government. They don't like being told what to do. So that could certainly be part of it. But like I mentioned, I think the virus was severely underestimated here. People had a good reason to believe that it wasn't going to be a problem in June, because it wasn't a problem. And so they were lulled into this false sense of security. And when it got really bad, perhaps there were these behaviors that were already ingrained.

Not wearing masks, not social distancing, you know, not refraining from these large gatherings that turn into super spreader events. Obviously, there is less reason for the government to take a sort of heavy hand in this in the spring and even the summer. But what's the government in North Dakota doing now? So there has been a recent development on Friday night. That was the 13th of November. The state implemented a mask mandate, which Governor Doug Burgum had previously been adamantly opposed to. Our situation has changed and we must change with it. To be clear, these are statewide requirements, not simply recommendations. Burgum also put in place some restrictions on restaurants, bars, and event venues.

But to my knowledge, there are no business closures. There's no mass shutdown like you've seen in some other states that are really hard hit. But I will say that the road to a mask mandate was very drawn out. There were plenty of criticisms of the governor saying you needed to do this a few months ago. He maintained a strategy of relying on personal responsibility of North Dakotans to be trusted to wear masks and social distance and refrain from these large gatherings. And I think that the development we saw on Friday is sort of an admission that that strategy just wasn't working in keeping the virus out of nursing homes and maintaining our hospital capacity.

Another thing I should note here is Dr. Paul Carson, who's an infectious disease professor at North Dakota State University, said in our story over the weekend that it might take everyone in the state knowing someone who has died or suffered a serious illness from COVID to start taking it more seriously and start changing their behavior. It's sort of a frightening thought to think that's the only thing that might change behavior, but it just doesn't seem like what we're saying or what the governor is saying at his press conferences is really getting through to people. Jeremy Turley, he's with Forum News Service. You can find and support his work at inforum.com.

After the break, Vermont. Thank you. Number one digital photo frame by Wirecutter. Aura frames make it easy to share unlimited photos and videos directly from your phone to the frame. When you give an aura frame as a gift, you can personalize it. You can preload it with a thoughtful message, maybe your favorite photos. Our colleague Andrew tried an aura frame for himself. So setup was super simple. In my case, we were celebrating my grandmother's birthday. And she's very fortunate. She's got 10 grandkids. And so we wanted to surprise her

with the Aura Frame. And because she's a little bit older, it was just easier for us to source all the images together and have them uploaded to the frame itself. And because we're all connected over text message,

it was just so easy to send a link to everybody. You can save on the perfect gift by visiting aururaFrames.com to get $35 off Aura's best-selling Carvermat frames with promo code EXPLAINED at checkout. That's A-U-R-A-Frames.com, promo code EXPLAINED. This deal is exclusive to listeners and available just in time for the holidays. Terms and conditions do apply. Download the app today And no matter your team, your favorite player, or your style, there's something every NBA fan will love about BetMGM. Download the app today and discover why BetMGM is your basketball home for the season. Raise your game to the next level this year with BetMGM,

a sportsbook worth a slam dunk and authorized gaming partner of the NBA. BetMGM.com for terms and conditions. Must be 19 years of age or older to wager. Ontario only. Please play responsibly. If you have any questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, please contact Connex Ontario at 1-866-531-2600 to speak to an advisor free of charge. BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGaming Ontario.

Julia Blues! Vox! It's been a minute. You still a health reporter? I'm still a health reporter. I think since the last time we talked, one baby and two lockdowns later, but still a health reporter. Well, it's great to have you back. And you've been reporting on a state that's doing a better job than most?

That's right. I'm reporting on Vermont. So they've consistently had some of the lowest case counts, infection rates, test positive rates in the country throughout this pandemic. And Vermont is pretty far from North Dakota geographically, but in spirit, there are similarities here. It's spread out, lots of nature, similar size population-wise, and yet Vermont is doing way better. The fact that Vermont's a rural state, the fact that it's a small state, that does not at all fully explain its successes. And yet when you think about the raging outbreaks now in the U.S., Wyoming, it's smaller than Vermont.

It's one of the worst outbreaks in the U.S. right now. The Dakotas, they're in the U.S. Wyoming, it's smaller than Vermont. It's one of the worst outbreaks in the U.S. right now. The Dakotas, they're in a mess. So, yeah, there are a lot of other things that Vermont has been doing right. And actually, they told me, apparently, your friend Anthony Fauci dropped in on a state health department meeting there and basically started off by saying... This should be the model for the country of how you've done it, notwithstanding that you're a small state, but it should be the model of how you get to such a low test positivity that you can actually start opening up the economy

in a safe and prudent way. What are they doing right? So what's really interesting, since almost the beginning of the pandemic, we started to have evidence that certain groups were more at risk for the infection. So we know that places like homeless shelters, prisons, long-term care facilities, these are settings where we've seen many, many outbreaks in the United States. They're very high-risk settings because you have lots of people living in a more crowded place. This strategy is focused on protecting our most vulnerable, which based on

science and data means the elderly and the very ill. And Vermont identified this immediately, so they expanded a program that they had in place for homeless people that they could stay for free in motel rooms instead of shelters. So basically they were kind of reducing the pressure on homeless shelters to avoid outbreaks there. And in some places in the U.S., we've seen rates of transmission in shelters up to like, San Francisco has something like a 66% infection rate

among people who are homeless. And until recently, Vermont had had only one infection in its homeless population. Nice. So at the beginning of the outbreak, they had outbreaks in old age homes. And very quickly, they started to address that by ramping up testing, by always making people quarantined. So before new people moved into old age homes, they also did this with prisons. They tested them and also put them into quarantine. So basically reducing the risk that someone would move in and potentially bring the virus with them. And until this recent uptick, they haven't had any outbreaks in their old age homes anymore. They were quick to respond and take

the pandemic seriously, but they were also really quick to use these very targeted policies for these vulnerable communities. The other thing that they're considering now is a stipend to support isolation. So we know that, again, people who tend to be most at risk for the virus are the ones who are more likely to live in these congregate housing settings and more likely to leave their homes for their work. And they might be also less likely to isolate if they've been exposed to the virus or just have a harder time doing that.

And so Vermont now is considering a policy that would actually pay people to isolate if they've been infected. Who deserves credit for Vermont doing a good job here? Ben, Jerry, Bernie, the governor? It might be the humility of the Vermonters. They're like a pretty relaxed, in fact, people I've gathered and the many conversations I've had over the last week. But they kind of always point to each other for credit.

So there was strong leadership by the governor, who is also a Republican, I should point out. I know these are not easy times. There's a lot of economic uncertainty and much concern about the health of Vermonters due to the COVID-19 pandemic. I share the concern in both of these areas. But as we look at the challenges ahead, public safety must come first. And he comes from a business background,

and I think it pained him to shut down businesses, but he always prioritized public health in his decision-making. There was strong leadership in the state health department, but then there was a lot of work at the community level. So homeless shelters, social service agencies, or other types of social service agencies, people who are helping with food delivery for and transport for communities or households that might have more trouble with the stay-at-home orders. I talked to researchers at Dartmouth who studied Vermont's response and they talked about this kind of whole activation of the

community there and how at all the different levels so from the state to these non-profits to other types of social service agencies, people really activated and took pride in keeping infection rates down. It's sad, Balooz. I mean, there's like a clear path here on how to handle this pandemic responsibly. And so much of our leadership and our fellow citizens are just choosing another one. You know I was talking to someone this morning who works in global health and he was saying like our failure to look to other states to look to other countries is literally killing people. So if we learned early on like what's happening in China from their experience or looking to Taiwan or Rwanda, like they've consistently using some of the approaches

I just described in Vermont. If we looked to other places, we might have been able to avoid some of this and to know like these places aren't exceptional. On the other hand, you know, you understand going into the holidays, like we want to see our families. We want to relax at home with the people we love and that we haven't seen for months and months.

And it's completely understandable that people are tired. But I just really hope that, you know, we'll take a longer view and know that it's hopefully just a few more months of this and that we can kind of hang tight until then to avoid even more tragedy than we've already seen. Julia Blues, if you want to read Julia's reporting on what Vermont is doing right, it'll be up at Vox.com come Thursday. Julia's hopeful about the next few months because we got even more good pandemic news this week. Today, Pfizer said that its vaccine we told you about last week is 95% effective and has no serious side effects. And on Monday, Moderna announced that its vaccine

was 94.5% effective. Added bonus, one of the actual angel investors on that Moderna vaccine was Dolly Parton. Thanks, Dolly. Vaccine, vaccine, vaccine, vaccine. I'm begging of you, please make me immune. Vaccine, vaccine, vaccine, vaccine. That scene, that scene, that scene from Zane Please get me off this godforsaken zoo Today Explained is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.

The team includes Amina Alsadi, Will Reed, Muj Zaydi, and Halima Shah. Afim Shapiro is our engineer. Golda Arthur is our supervising producer. And Liz Kelly Nelson is Vox's editorial director of podcasts. Extra help this week from Bird Pinkerton. Fact-checking by Cecilia Lay. Music by the mysterious Breakmaster Cylinder. And Noam Hassenfeld.

And just this once, vocals by Noam's mom, Joan. That scene, that scene,am's mom, Joan. from sin Please get me off this God forsaken zoo