Today in Digital Marketing - ANNOUNCEMENT: What's Ahead For This Podcast
Episode Date: November 22, 2024Changes are coming to this podcast and our newsletter starting next week. Today, Tod lets you in on the big secret.📰 Get our free daily newsletter📈 Advertising: Reach Thousands of Marketing Deci...sion-Makers🌍 Follow us on social media or contact us.GO PREMIUM!Get these exclusive benefits when you upgrade:✅ Listen ad-free✅ Back catalog of 20+ marketing science interviews✅ Get the show earlier than the free version✅ Member-only monthly livestreams with TodAnd a lot more! Check it out: todayindigital.com/premium✨ Premium tools: Update Credit Card • Cancel.MORE🆘 Need help with your social media? Check us out: engageQ digital🌟 Rate and Review Us🤝 Our Slack.UPGRADE YOUR SKILLSGoogle Ads for Beginners with Jyll Saskin GalesInside Google Ads: Advanced with Jyll Saskin GalesFoxwell Slack Group and Courses.Today in Digital Marketing is hosted by Tod Maffin and produced by engageQ digital on the traditional territories of the Snuneymuxw First Nation on Vancouver Island, Canada. Associate producer: Steph Gunn.Some links in these show notes may provide affiliate revenue to us.Our Sponsors:* Check out Kinsta: https://kinsta.comPrivacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Transcript
Discussion (0)
It is Friday, November 22nd.
Today, big changes ahead for this podcast
and its sibling newsletter.
And today, I can finally share the details with you.
As you may know, over the last few weeks,
we've been soliciting your thoughts
on what we can do to make our podcast
and our newsletter even more valuable for you.
Many of you said you like getting all the news,
but find it hard to keep up
with five episodes a week. You've told us that for busy weeks, getting around to listening to
that day's episode feels like yet another task on your already long to-do list. Some of you,
most of you, myself included, find the ads on the free feed overwhelming. Many of you told us you
wished we could do more boots on the ground stuff like case studies. And one guy named Dave said he didn't like the sound of my voice.
Fair, but sorry, Dave, that's not changing. Pretty much the rest is though. Let's start with a bit
of background. I started this podcast about four years ago. It was right when the ad market for
business podcasts really started
to take off. And we benefited from that. We were profitable almost immediately. The podcast started
to consume more of my time than the agency that I also run. Did I mention our main business is
actually an engagement and moderation agency? Then two things happened. First, Apple changed how it downloads episode files to its popular podcast app.
And that hit podcast download numbers hard, especially for daily shows with a big back catalog, just like ours.
Our download numbers were slashed by more than two thirds pretty much overnight. Now, to be fair, the new numbers are probably indeed
a more accurate representation of our actual listenership,
but it was still a painful decline
because the second thing that happened
was that our ad revenue, of course,
fell along with this decline in download numbers.
And right when things started to stabilize there,
the tech bros unleashed AI on the world,
and there are now tens of thousands
of fully automated AI-generated podcasts
that purport to do a daily rundown
of everything you could ever think of.
And sure, they sound terrible.
And sure, the AI doesn't know
whether a bug on Meta's ad manager is a more important story than how Google's algorithm changed that day.
And I like to think my dad jokes are better than its dad jokes.
But the fact remains that these fake podcasts had started to swarm the landscape.
And they're monetized, meaning ad campaigns are spread more thin and the supply and demand change
has pushed CPMs way down.
All that to say, this daily podcast hasn't been profitable for some time now.
And while I was happy to float it for a while to see if things would improve, I think there
are enough signs that any improvement may be a ways off.
Meanwhile, newsletters, on the other hand, have taken off.
The ad market is strong.
It's much easier to know when a subscriber joins and how much we paid for them if they came from an ad campaign.
And frankly, newsletters take less time to produce than all the extra little stuff that goes into making a podcast.
Our newsletter was essentially the podcast script script along with some images and links.
And while that was good to get us off and running
at the beginning, it really limited us
in terms of making it read
like a daily industry newsletter.
We wanted the newsletter to be easier to digest
and like the podcast,
not something people think of as a chore.
So friends, here is what is changing starting next week.
First, the podcast will be going down to two episodes per week, Fridays and Tuesdays.
On Fridays, you will get the week's wrap-up of all the digital marketing news that happened.
Yes, that means a lot more stories, but they will be shorter.
Somewhere between the lightning round stories
that you've probably heard here
and our previous length stories.
I expect this weekly episode roundup
will be a little longer than our daily ones have been,
maybe 15 or 20 minutes or so.
But from what we've heard,
you'd rather spend 20 minutes once a week catching up
than eight or nine minutes, five times a week doing it.
Some weeks will also do a big story at the top, whatever the most important development of that
week was, which will give us more time to get you an interview with an expert or more analysis,
or let's face it, more likely, more snark from me. We'll also be grouping stories by marketing
discipline, all the SEO stories together, all the ad stories, all the social media stories together,
so your brain can more easily tune into what's relevant to you.
That's Fridays.
On Tuesdays, we'll be diving deeper into the topics you have been asking for.
More case studies, more marketing science research, more step-by-step tutorials,
more episodes of Behind the Ad,
more like a traditional weekly marketing podcast you might hear elsewhere.
But the difference is, ours will be edited.
No rambling, no two hosts bantering on forever about in-jokes that only they understand and
aren't funny anyway.
I should mention, this Tuesday episode will take us a couple of weeks to get ready for
and to gear up for, so you may not see those Tuesday episodes for a few weeks. People on the
free feed will get most of these episodes. Our premium podcast subscribers will also get bonus
episodes and content that doesn't make it to the main feed. That's the podcast. Okay, second,
the newsletter. It will remain daily. So if you really need a daily fix
and don't want to wait until the Friday podcast roundup, that newsletter is still free and you
can sign up by tapping the link at the top of today's show notes or going to todayindigital.com
slash newsletter. But it will change. Rather than being the script of the podcast, it will now have two sections.
First, the daily big story, a much deeper dive into whatever the top story in the digital marketing world each day is.
And second, like the new podcast, a series of short stories grouped by discipline of the developments of that day.
We're also adding to each short story a section that calls out what that development means to the day-to-day work of digital day. We're also adding to each short story a section that calls out what that development
means to the day-to-day work of digital marketers. And because the newsletter will have shorter
stories, except for the first one, we think it should all fit within Gmail's stupid character
limit, which kept cutting off many of our issues. We hope that this will make it easier to read,
less of a time commitment, and more actionable for your job. It's my hope that this will make it easier to read, less of a time commitment, and more
actionable for your job. It's my hope that the podcast ad market will return, in which case
we'll reach out to you and ask if you like it the way things are or would like to return to the
daily episodes format. So those are the changes. Fewer podcast episodes per week, but less of a
time commitment to listen. You'll still get all the news, plus more regular deep dive shows.
And a refreshed daily newsletter that's easier to read, faster to digest,
and still covers the most important stories every day,
soon with more depth and richer analysis than you'll get elsewhere.
All that starts next week.
I want to thank everyone who submitted their suggestions to us
and for every one of you who subscribes.
You know, I still consider this podcast
more like a labor of love
and my attempt to give back to the community
than any revenue-producing business unit.
And I will be grateful to hear your feedback of the new format
once you've heard a few episodes.
And if you don't mind,
bear with us for a couple of weeks
as we find our footing with this new format and schedule.
So that's it.
Thank you for your time.
And I'll see you next week.