True Crime All The Time - Cody Johnson

Episode Date: May 18, 2026

Jordan Graham and Cody Johnson were the picture of happiness on their wedding day, but soon after, Jordan was unhappy and already having doubts. Just eight days after the wedding, Cody Johnson ended up dead at the bottom of a cliff. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss Cody Johnson. Jordan pushed Cody off a cliff at Montana’s Glacier National Park. Prosecutors argued that Jordan could have walked away from the argument, but she was overcome by anger and intentionally pushed him. Jordan claimed her new husband’s death was a tragic accident.You can help support the show at patreon.com/truecrimeallthetimeVisit the show's website at truecrimeallthetime.com for contact, merchandise, and donation informationAn Emash Digital productionSee Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

You know, folks, making that decision to start a podcast or really any type of business, it's scary. It was for Gibby and I as well. What if no one listens? What if we make fools of ourselves? And it can be really hard to get over that doubt. But choosing to make that leap was one of the best decisions we've ever made. Another great decision was picking Shopify to help with our podcast merch.

It really does help. When you have a partner like Shopify on your side. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10% of all e-commerce in the U.S. from household names like Jim Shark to true crime all the time to brands just getting started. There is a lot to love about Shopify. I love the fact that they're now packed with helpful AI tools that help you write product descriptions and even enhance your product photography. You can easily create email and social media campaigns. And if you get stuck, Shopify is always around to share advice with their award-winning 24-7 customer support.

It's time to turn those what-ifs into with Shopify today. Sign up for your $1 per month trial today at Shopify.com slash teacat. Go to Shopify.com slash teacat. That's Shopify.com slash T-C-A-T-T. Hello everyone and welcome to episode 498 of the True Crime Mall of the Time podcast. I'm Mike Ferguson. And with me as always is my partner in true crime, Mike Gibson. Give me, how are you? Hey, I'm doing pretty good. How about you? I'm doing great, man. Yeah. We just have so much stuff coming up. We do. We'll be at CrimeCon in like two weeks.

Do want to announce that we're having a meet up Saturday night. That's the 30th at 8 p.m. In the Vista cocktail lounge. And that's at Caesar's Palace, where Crime Con is. So, Vista. Yeah. If you're going, come out. See us. I have a couple of Coca-Cola. Polas? Yeah, or something. Have some fun. We'll be the guys over there in the one corner. Let's go ahead and give our Patreon shoutouts.

We had Joanne Bat. What's going on, Joanne? Kimberly. Hey, Kimberly. Robin Moore jumped out at our highest level. Man, that's awesome. Thanks, Robin. HB girl.

H.B. Girl. I'm trying to think what the HB would be. Who knows? How would you even figure it out? I don't know. Sweet P. What's going on, Sweet P? Nicole Crane.

Hey, Nicole. And last but not least, Elizabeth Van Lienputt. Oh, the old lean putt. Yep. Yeah. And then if we go back into the vault, this week, we selected Cindy M. Well, thanks, Cindy. Yeah, great new support.

We really appreciate it. We have an episode out right now on True Crime All at the Time Unsolved. We're talking about Deborah Lindley. She was murdered on a train in 1988 in London, outside of London, I think. And it's a fascinating case because there were like 70 people on this train. Yeah. It's a good case. And it was like a really vicious attack, but only one passenger reported hearing anything suspicious.

So Gibbs next Sunday night is our 500th episode. Man, that's amazing. It is amazing. And we have a big one plan. Somebody's actually already guessed it on Patreon. Yeah, I don't want to say who it is because then that'll give it away. Yeah. But we do have $4.99, which is coming out Thursday.

And that's on Samantha Josephson. She was kidnapped and murdered during a night out with friends when she got into a car that she mistakenly thought was an Uber. Oh, man. Yeah, a fascinating case. And it's a case that led to a bunch of ride chair safety changes and things like that. All right, buddy, are you ready to get into this episode of True Crime all the time? I am. I'm ready.

We're talking about Cody Johnson. Jordan Graham and Cody Johnson were the picture of happiness on their wedding day, but soon after Jordan was unhappy and already having some doubts. Just eight days after the wedding, Jordan pushed Cody off a cliff at Montana's Glacier National Park. Prosecutors argued that Jordan could have walked away from the argument, but she was overcome by anger and intentionally pushed him. Jordan claimed her new husband's death was a tragic.

accident. You know, people do things they might not ever do when they're really upset, enraged. Yeah, we talk about a lot of people, right, who do things that maybe they wouldn't or haven't ever done before, you know, because they're in a certain state of mind. But I do want to say, this is one of the reasons why I don't go hiking, just one. Yeah. I don't want to be pushed off a cliff. You mean go hiking with me? or hiking money with anybody. Yeah. Okay.

Cody Johnson was born on April 8, 1988 in San Jose, California, to parents, David Clarence and Sherry Ann Johnson. Cody and his mother moved to Calispell, Montana in 2002. Cody settled in easily and made a lot of friends because he was said to have been very charismatic, and he had a really funny personality. Kind of like you. Yeah, maybe. He loved Montana because of all the outdoor activities.

And I just said, right? I'm not the biggest outdoors person. But if you are, Montana's probably a great state to be in. Yeah, seems like a good place to go. As a teenager, Cody became interested in both fixing and racing cars. This remained his favorite hobby throughout adulthood. He still enjoyed hiking and spending time outdoors. But it was said that he was happiest either working on cars.

cars are going out for a fast drive. Man, I love a fast drive. You get a fast car. So, again, I've never been one to really work on cars. I don't know a lot about engines. And nowadays, I think some of the new cars are hard to work on anyway. Right. So much computer stuff.

But Cody worked for Nomad Global Communication Systems, a manufacturer that designs and builds connected mobile operation centers and specialized vehicles for defense, government, and commercial sectors. Sounds pretty techy. Yeah. So, I mean, he probably had some smarts. Cody decided he wanted to get married and start a family in Calisbe. In 2011, he met a woman named Jordan Graham. She was a few years younger than Cody and grew up in the area. Jordan was described as quiet, introverted, and shut. She enjoyed being outdoors and was active in her church. She loved children and participated in her church's Sunday school and daycare programs. And I think I probably said it before, but my wife is very introverted. She can be very shy around new people, people she doesn't know. And I think when we first got together

30 years ago, because this month is my 30th anniversary of being married. So we've been together like 32 years. I think people, my friends thought we were kind of an odd pair because I at the time was even more extroverted. Right. And she was an introvert. But, you know, they say opposites attract. You kind of bring her out of her shell too. Sometimes. And she over the years has kind of helped put me back in my shell because I was a little bit too out there. She reeled the end. Yeah, at times. After graduating high school in 2009, Jordan's started working full time as a nanny. She dreamed of having her own family one day.

Now, she wasn't actively looking for a husband, but she met Cody a few months after she turned 20. So we've kind of heard about both of them wanting a family. Right. Cody made the first move when he started talking to Jordan. It was clear to others that she was interested in him, but because she was so shy, it took her a while to accept his romantic advances. Jordan also wanted to find a man who was serious about his faith.

And she helped Cody get more involved in church. They officially started dating in November 2011. Cody often told others that he knew Jordan was the one. The one. You knew your wife was the one, didn't you? I did. I did. Which is probably why we've been together as long as we have.

He proposed in December 2012. And Jordan said yes. They started wedding planning and, and looking for a place to live. And I'm kind of in that spot right now, not me personally, but with my daughter and my future son-in-law. They're getting married next month.

They're looking for their, you know, first place. Right. It's always a fun time. Yeah, but it's also stressful. My daughter is very stressed. Yeah. Number one about the wedding. I think maybe even more stressed about finding a place to live.

There's not a lot of houses right now, available and the ones that are get gobbled up extremely quickly around here. I think that's the difference between when you and I were getting our first places. We didn't have that competition. At least I didn't have that type of competition. There seemed like there was plenty of the homes to look at. Yeah. You didn't have to worry about, you know, being beat out left and right.

No, now rates, I think were a little higher. They were. But maybe that's part of it. I don't know. Yeah. On June 22nd, 2013, they moved into the, their new home and Callispell. A week later on June 29th, Cody and Jordan were married.

Their photos and wedding video showed a couple who seemed perfectly happy and in love. And, okay, I understand that, but who doesn't look extremely happy and in love at their wedding? If you don't, you got a serious problem. Exactly. I mean, if you're looking sad and depressed or angry and mad, I mean, you know, you might want to go ahead and just tear that piece of paper up now. It's like it never happened. It's probably not going to go great from there.

On July 8, 2013, Cody was reported missing by his friend and boss, Cameron Fredericks. Cody was normally at work by 6 a.m. It was highly out of character for him not to show up. Cameron was so worried about Cody that he broke into his house to search for signs that anything was wrong. Cameron found Cody's phone in the garage, which was a red flag because Cody never went anywhere without his phone. And let's face it, most people don't.

You know, especially with these phones today having your whole life on them. Yeah. Now, this was 2013, but even back then, by that point, a lot of people were really attached to their phones. But the timing on this thing, right? We set it up front. But, you know, they move in. together into this new home on June 22nd. They get married one week later on June 29th.

And then Cody's reported missing on July 8th. It's a very short period of time. It is. Cameron called friends and family and learned no one had seen Cody since the previous evening. He went to church and was seen at the Dairy Queen in town, having dinner with friends. So Jordan was first interviewed by the police on July 9th. Obviously, she has to be interviewed, right? She's the wife. She confirmed that on the evening of July 7th,

she and Cody went to church and then to Dairy Queen, she mentioned that Cody received a call earlier in the day that made him upset. That evening, she received a text from Cody saying he was heading out with a friend from out of town. She said she saw a dark colored car pulling out of the driveway. She also told police that she and Cody regularly deleted their text, and that was why she couldn't produce the text for law enforcement. Oh, well, I know you want to see some text messages between him and I, but we've always just kind of deleted them because we didn't want them on our phone. A little suspicious, right, if you're a detective, a police officer. Okay, I'm sure there are people who regularly delete their text, but I think the percentage is probably probably, pretty small. I know I don't because I want the ability to go back and look if somebody says,

hey, I texted you that, you know, a month ago. Yeah. I want to make sure they're telling me the truth. You do that with me sometimes. Yeah. Sometimes you're right. Sometimes you're not. On July 10th, Jordan and her mother met with the police to show them a suspicious email from a man named Tony, the email which was released by the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Montana, read as follows, Hello, Jordan, my name is Tony. There is no bother in looking for Cody anymore. He's gone. I saw your post on Twitter and thought I would email you. He had come with some buddies and met up with me on Sunday night in Columbia Falls. He was saying he needed to be with buddies for a bit and take them for a jury ride before they had to go. So he said by to me and they took off in a black car for a ride.

Three of the other guys came back saying they had gone for a ride in the wood somewhere and Cody got out of the car and went for a little height. And they are positive. He fell and he is dead Jordan. I don't know who the guys were, but they took off. So call off the missing person report. Cody is for sure gone. Signed Tony. I mean, Just looking at that email, it's just so bizarre. Yeah. I mean, very bizarre, right? Number one, hey, I, you don't know me, but I want to tell you what happened.

And, oh, by the way, make sure you call off that missing person report because Cody's, he's gone for sure. Yeah. And how many car rights have you been with buddies that the one buddy would say, hey, pull over. I want to get out here. I'm going to hike for a little bit, guys. Continue your, you know, driving this car fast and having all that type of fun. But I need to get out here right now and hike. I'll make my own way home. Yeah. Yeah. The following day, July 11th, Jordan contacted a ranger at Glacier National Park to report finding her husband's body at the bottom of a ravine in the loop trail area. Cody's body was found at the bottom of a 300-foot

clip face down in a shallow creek. When the park ranger commented that it was unusual, that Jordan was the one to make the discovery, she said it was a place he wanted to see before he died. He would come up here with friends to drive fast when his friends were visiting from out of state. Okay. I mean, this is strange as well. Yeah, it is.

Cody's missing. Jordan meets with the police. she gets this anonymous email or not anonymous, but from an anonymous person named Tony. We don't know who he is. She doesn't know who he is. And then the next thing you know, she is the one to find his body.

I mean, if you're a detective, any type of law enforcement, none of this smells right. No, it's very suspicious. Chime is fee-free banking built for you. are not like the stuffy traditional old banks charging you overdraft and monthly fees chime does things differently they also have thousands of fee-free ATMs why in the world would you pay to get your own money chime is rated five stars by USA to day for customer service they have real humans

24-7 and i mentioned that chime is different they have spot me which lets you overdraft up to two hundred dollars fee-free you can even get up to five hundred dollars of your pay-free you can even get up to five hundred of your pay when you want with my pay. With the Chime card, you can get 5% cash back in a category of your choice like gas or groceries. I would have benefited so much from Chime when I was younger. I can remember just not even knowing all the different fees I was paying back in the day. Chime is not just smarter banking. It's the most rewarding way to back.

Join the millions who are already banking fee free today. Head to chime.com slash T-Cat. That's chime.com slash. T-C-A-T-T-T. It only takes a few minutes to sign up. Chime is a fintac, not a bank, banking services for MyPay and Chime card provided by Chim's bank partners for more information on APY rates. MyPay, Spot Me, and Travel perks, go to chime.com slash disclosures. Optional products and services may have fees or charging. Cody's body wasn't recovered until July 12 because police had to bring in a helicopter

due to the steep cliffs. His death was investigated by the National Park Service, the FBI, the sheriff's office, and the Calispell Police Department. And we've talked about this before, but, you know, when someone is killed on federal property, you are going to have a boatload of agencies involved. Yeah. Cody's autopsy results were released on July 19, confirming he died of a fall. Jordan went voluntarily to talk to authorities on the 16th.

This time, she had a completely different story. She admitted that on the evening of July 7, 2013, she and Cody went to Glacier National Park. She told federal investigators that Cody tried to hold me down during an argument at their home shortly before they went on a hike. Their argument resumed near a narrow ledge above a ravine on the loop. trail. She said when Cody tried to grab my arm and jacket during the dispute, she acted in self-defense by pulling away, but also pushing Cody at the same time. According to Jordan, he went to grab my arm and my jacket and I said, no. I said, I'm not going to let this happen this time. I'm going to defend myself. So I let go. And I pushed and he went over. And then I took off and went home.

Just like that. Just like that. But what do we always talk about, right? You meet with investigators. You don't have any idea what happened to Cody. Next thing you know, you're finding his body. And then the next time you meet with investigators, you have this completely different story of self-defense and pushing him to his death.

And then you have this email. So how do you respond to that? Well, it's going to be tough, right? Because now it makes it look like that email was a hoax, maybe perpetrated by you to throw authorities off the trail. Yeah. But Jordan wasn't immediately arrested after this interview. It wasn't until September 9th of that year that a criminal complaint was filed

accusing Jordan of second-degree murder. Jordan made her first appearance that day. According to the affidavit, Jordan provided false statements about Cody's death before admitting to pushing him in her July 16th interview. And it's kind of hard to argue with that because she obviously did. The affidavit summarized the argument on the trail. It said at one point in time during their arguing, Graham turned and began to walk away. She stated, Johnson grabbed her by the arm. After removing Johnson's hand from her arm, Graham stated she could have just walked away.

But due to her anger, she pushed Johnson with both hands. In the back, and as a result, he fell face first off the clip. The charging documents also revealed that Jordan told a friend. She was having second thoughts about the marriage, and she wanted to talk about her doubts with Cody, the night he died. She texted her friend on July 7th. Oh, well, I'm about to talk to him. Her friend responded, I'll pray for you guys. Jordan responded by saying, but dead serious, if you don't hear from me at all again tonight,

something happened. I really don't know Gibbs how it could look any worse for Jordan. Now, I get it. She has her story of this being self-defense, but I mean, you look at all these other things and it's kind of hard to think that that's really true. Yeah, I mean, it kind of looks like a cover-up plus the fact that she says she could have walked away but chose not to and pushed them in the back. That doesn't scream out self-defense.

Does not. Another close friend of Jordan's told law enforcement that Jordan told her about an email she received saying Cody had left with three friends when hiking had fallen was dead and the search should be called off. Siblings Levi and Latani Blasdell, who were friends with the couple, spoke with the Calispell Daily in her lake after the criminal complaint was filed.

They said they had known Jordan since she was three and had known Cody for a handful of years. They stopped speaking to Jordan a year earlier. Latani said about Cody, he's the best person ever. He's the guy that every father wants for his daughter. That pretty much sums him up. Levi agreed saying, Cody was the type of guy that was genuinely sincere with everyone.

He welcomed every new friend with open arms and without bias. He supported each and every one of his friends, and he was the person you knew would be there if you ever needed him. Levi said he was the one who introduced Jordan to Cody. According to Levi, he was completely smitten with her. But Levi told the paper that he noticed one unsettling aspect about Jordan, up to and beyond the wedding. She seemed emotionally distant from Cody. He said, we all had our reservations about their relationship. She seems so remote

from the relationship, so withdrawn. And they said they noticed this at Cody's funeral as well. Levi recalled, at the funeral, a number of us had spoken. And while I gave my memorial for Cody at the podium, she was messing around on her phone. It was very hard for all of us to be there crying and mourning the loss of our friend. And she was so unresponsive to that. Really no emotion, no crying, very sober. It's so strange that she was so unemotional about their relationship, you know, because they were newlyweds and to be so unemotional at the funeral, too. Yeah, both of them are strange. You know, we've talked about it before, but, you know, the time leading up to your marriage,

I mean, that's like, you know, you're still kind of new, fresh. Everything should be clicking. Yeah. Right. And it doesn't sound like that's the case. If so, why did you get married? And then obviously, it is going to stand out to everyone. if, you know, everybody is emotional at this funeral because, let's face it, Cody was a pretty

young guy when he died, right? Those funerals are even more emotional because the person hasn't lived their life, but yet the person they just married is playing on their phone. That is going to draw some attention for sure. It just really doesn't make her look good being on her phone. I don't know what she was thinking. Well, I think if, you know, you're on the side of law enforcement, you're on the side of the prosecution, you're probably chalking that up to she didn't care. She wasn't remorseful because she wasn't sad that he died. The day after the funeral, Jordan posted photos of the children.

She babysat as if nothing happened. And I think, you know, a lot of people are going to see that as strange as well. I get it at a certain point, you got to work through your grief and get on with your life. For most people, it's not the very next day. No. You don't go back to posting on Instagram and Facebook and all of these places unless it's to talk about your loved one. But it's not about, hey, I just had this great dinner or, you know, look at the kids. that I babysit. It was said she behaved the opposite way.

At her wedding, she was emotional and cried before walking down the aisle. Latani described Jordan as 100% normal, but very quiet. She told the paper they didn't start to suspect Jordan until she gave different stories about what happened to Cody in the days he was missing. Levi questioned the story Jordan gave to investigators because of her. differing statements. One of his primary questions involved the location and nature of Cody's death because Cody was extremely afraid of heights. Levi recalled traveling to New Orleans with Cody and standing at the top of a parking garage. He wanted Cody to take a picture with him by the ledge,

but Cody refused. And I get that because I've said it before, but I am, you know, afraid of heights. Yeah, you are. I'm not a sure. shame to admit that I have a fear of heights. And if you are a person who has that, there are certain things that you don't want to do. Stand next to a very big drop is one of those things, whether it's at the top of a large parking garage or at the top of a big gorge in a national forest or something like that. That would freak me out. You're staying away from that. Yeah. Cameron Fredericksen, the friend who reported Cody missing, told the daily interlake, he immediately suspected Jordan after Cody was found dead. He said, I almost instantly thought Jordan knew

something, did something, or was part of what happened to Cody. When Cody told me that he was going to propose to Jordan, I wasn't real supportive of it. I did have a conversation with him, saying I think he should reconsider. And to me, that is. strange. You know, if one of your friends comes to you before you're about ready to get married and says, oh, man, I don't know about this. I think you ought to think this one over. Okay. I don't know how many people have had that happen to them. It would be tough to hear. You know, I mean, especially if it's like one of your best friends, you're like, you're supposed to be here to support me and you're telling me maybe I'm doing the wrong thing. But here's what I think.

I think a lot of people around the couple were seeing things from Jordan that were red flags to them. My assumption is Cody wasn't seeing these because, you know, as it was described, he was so smitten with her. Yeah. And when you're so totally in love with someone, I don't think you see some of the, I don't know if it's negative, but some of the signs that other people might pick up on. I think that's true. On September 12, 2013, a U.S. magistrate judge ordered Jordan's release. She was put on house arrest in order to undergo mental health evaluation and complete the recommended treatment. Prosecutors filed a motion against her release based on the risk that she presented to the community, the seriousness of the charged offense, her repeated false statements, and her mental health.

I think what they're saying is we believe she's a killer and we don't think she should be, you know, free to leave the jail. Yeah. Let's not let her just be out in public now. At a hearing on September 13th, Jordan's defense attorney Michael Donahoe told the judge that Cody's death was an accident and Jordan was acting in self-defense. Donahoe also said that prosecutors misrepresented events to incite national media attention. mention and win public favor. He contended that Jordan's pushing of Cody was part of her action to free herself after being grabbed.

This is all one motion, this grabbing, this pushing. That's what he said. Her attorney conceded Jordan did engage in some deception, but that didn't indicate malice or premeditation. Still doesn't explain when she made the statement she pushed him in the back, though. Yeah, right. I mean, I get what her attorney is trying to do. It doesn't indicate malice.

It doesn't indicate premeditation. But it does seem to be more than this self-defense story. That it all just kind of happened in one motion, a blur. Like, those things can happen. Yeah. But when you say, I could have walked away, but I chose to push him in the back. you know, if that's what she told investigators, that does not scream self-defense, if anything,

it screams the exact opposite. Now, it may not be premeditation, but it's certainly not an accident or self-defense. Yeah. On October 3rd, 2013, Jordan was officially indicted for first-degree murder, second-degree murder, and providing false statements. According to documents unsealed by the prosecution, in November 2013, Jordan told Park Rangers where Cody's body was, so the search would be called up. The affidavits were provided by National Park Service Special Agent Justin Ivory, written in support of search warrants, seeking evidence from Jordan's social media, iPhone, and email. According to the documents, Jordan texted her friend, whom she told earlier she was going to talk to Cody about, her doubts concerning their marriage late on July 7th saying she talked to Cody and all it did

was caused me to get scratched and him to leave one of her text said dude I'm freaking out I'm about to go for a walk or something jump off a freaking bridge I don't know I've lost it so it sounds like she got angry about how the supposed conversation went yeah I think one of the problems is you have to wonder if these texts are even real. Yeah. Or were they sent as, you know, maybe part of a smoke screen or something like that? Or is it showing that she was really angry? You know, folks, it's summertime. And that changes how I get dressed. You know, I want pieces that are breathable, easy, but still make me look put together. And that's why I just keep coming back to Quince. You know, Quince has high quality pieces that feel and look amazing and the prices are unbelievable.

Everything at Quince is priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. This is because they work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middlemen. So what you're paying for is quality and not brand market. They have European linen pants and shirts starting at just $34. I love everything I've bought from Quince. but my absolute favorite is their flow-knit active wear. Joggers, tops. It's my go-to.

But Quince goes beyond clothing. They have everything from sofas to ceramic cookware, and my daughter loves their premium bedding. Elevate your summer wardrobe. Go to quince.com slash T-Cat for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada, too. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E-D-C-T-T for free shipping and 360-6.

day returns, quince.com slash teacet. Investigators also discovered that on the morning of July 10th, Jordan created an email account named Carmen Tony 607. From her father's IP address, Jordan had been living with her parents since Cody disappeared. A few minutes after the account was created, she emailed herself the suspicious message. Now we know who Tony is. Well, and I always wonder how people think they're going to get away. with this stuff, how they can't see that it's just a digital footprint that is going to be found at

some point. Later on July 10th, Jordan drove to the hiking trail in Glacier National Park and said that if the body was found, the investigation would be called off, according to one of three people who went with her. Jordan said, I don't care if they questioned me. I want the body found and the cops out of it. That's interesting. It is. I mean, the whole thing is fascinating to be honest with you because you go from, oh my gosh, my husband's missing. I think he went off with some friends to knowing where the body is, being able to tell park rangers where it is. And then obviously because of that, you have to craft a different story putting yourself there because how else would you know where the body is? But she's also thinking they're going to call the investigation off.

They're going to call the search off. Yeah, but the investigation is just going to get heated up, right? Because nothing seems to make sense. She said she wanted to check a spot where Cody liked to hike, but the others talked her out of climbing down a retaining wall. The next day, July 11th, Jordan and her mother and at least one other person returned to the area. And Jordan told them she saw Cody's body from the cliff's edge. On the way home, Jordan said, now that we have the body, we can have the funeral and the cops will be out of it. It's such a weird thing to say.

Yeah, because she just wants them to go away, right? Don't investigate. You don't need to look for him anymore. because he's found, obviously it was an accident, so nothing to see here type of situation. Move it along. Move it along. In a defense brief filed that same month, Jordan's attorney said she was a victim of a witch hunt and a conspiracy involving attorneys, local police, and the FBI, colluding to deprive her of due

process and a fair trial. Well, I think they have that wrong. not to say that conspiracies don't happen, but based on everything we've talked about, there was no conspiracy needed here on the part of the FBI, the police, or anybody like that, because,

I mean, she had basically dug her own hole. Yeah. They didn't need to dig one for her. The defense argued that Jordan's July 16th interview with the FBI was mishandled. They said the government selectively preserved evidence. By recording only those portions of the defendant's interrogation, it felt would benefit its case,

presented incomplete evidence to the grand jury, which rendered it false, and deliberately sought to acquire an early tactical advantage, by deftly refusing to arrest the defendant at the conclusion of her interrogation by the FBI, only to turn around two months later to proclaim publicly that the defendant is a socioburned, path deserving of immediate incarceration. The brief noted that no part of Jordan's interrogation was video recording. Additionally, according to the brief, although defendant had been at liberty for those two months, the government consciously elected to proceed to charge the case by way of unsealed complaint, knowing all the while that no grand jury would be convened for at least

two more weeks. Prosecutors knowingly sought to influence the public with negative evidence that in the ordinary course would have remained confidential before the grand jury. They said that as a result of the prosecution's indirect use of the media, Jordan would never receive a fair trial. And for me, Gibbs, you know, it's always tough to know how much of this is really true, how much of this is what you might call defense spin, right? because we know defense attorneys have to try to spin things in a certain way because, let's face it,

I think her attorney is up against it. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I think there could be some truth in there. Well, when you talk about someone getting a fair trial, I mean, anytime there's a lot of media coverage, does it become harder to get a fair trial? I'm sure it does. people are sitting at home, they're listening to what the news has to say.

Maybe there's, you know, pundits or talking heads giving their opinion. I'm sure that can sway people. Yeah. And I think a case like this is going to get more attention because it's not your typical murder or accidental death. Yeah, I think the fact that they'd been married, what, less than a few weeks or something like that, that's going to be part of it. They're newlyweds. I mean, who kills their spouse a week and a half to two weeks after they're married?

Off of a mountain cliff to, you know. Oh, also, yeah, that's a part of it, right? The brief contained details about the July 16th interview that were previously unknown to the public. The interview was led by FBI agent Stacey Smadala, who was called in due to his his experience with administering polygraphs, Jordan was introduced to the agent by a detective she had previously spoken to. In a signed affidavit, Jordan said she, the detective, and agent Smodala, sat in a room and she agreed to a polygraph. The detective left a few minutes later. What followed was an unrecorded interview with Agent Smodala that lasted over and out.

Jordan was distressed by Agent Smodala's body language. He put his chair close to hers, so their knees were touching. And he put his hand on her knee. And he kept it there the whole time. She tried moving back, but he just moved closer. Jordan admitted that she began her interview by telling the same line. But she soon realized she needed to tell the truth. She described the events of July 7th and how Cody fell off a ledge,

according to her in what I truly believe was an accident. At one point, she physically reenacted, how Cody grabbed her and how she pulled away and pushed him in a single motion. According to Jordan, per the signed affidavit, when I first read the complaint after I was arrested, I was shocked. I never told Agent Smodala that I started to walk away

and then decided to turn around and push Cody off the ledge with two hands. those were his words. That is not what happened. Jordan's defense argued that the explanation of events in Smodala's polygraph exam report in which he stated, Jordan pushed Cody in the back with both hands due to extreme anger.

Was fabricated evidence. Jordan recalled that after a while, Agent Smodala told her she passed and he thought she was telling the truth. The detective returned to the room and a recorder was turned. on. Jordan did a 12-minute summary interview, briefly going over each part of her statement. And so this is a fascinating piece of the puzzle. Now, this is Jordan saying this happened.

Yeah, we're just hearing one side of the story. Right. So it doesn't mean it's true, but this is what she said in an affidavit. If it is true, then I think you would have to question some of the actions by this FBI agent. Right. If she's, She never actually said, I turned around and I pushed him in the back with two hands. Okay. That's a big deal. It is a big deal. Because to me, it's a very important part of the case.

So if it didn't happen, big deal. Also, this idea of kind of having the interview not recorded and then turning on the recorder later, to me, that's obviously not best practice. It's not a good way to do things. No. And I don't know why he would put his hand on her knee. Yeah, that's the other thing. I mean, she really made it sound like,

I didn't take it as though it was like sexual. I took it more as like very intimidating. Like he's right next to me. Yeah. He's got his hand on my knee, almost like he's trying to intimidate me to make me say something. But this is why I always say Gibbs that, you know, a jury has a really tough job.

You know, when you've got to sit and weigh, who's telling the truth? Is the FBI? Is law enforcement telling the truth? Or is Jordan telling the truth? And a lot of times, it's tough to take someone like Jordan's side because they've already lied about a bunch of things. Yeah. So are they now being truthful in this affidavit?

In her interview, Jordan said, she and Cody went to church, then to Dairy Queen on the seventh. she discussed a surprise for Cody with his friends. She said she could tell he needed a break. So she planned to barbecue with his friends. She and Cody went home and got into an argument about their marriage during which Cody held her down. She said he didn't hit her but controlled her movements.

He just kind of pulled me and told me that I wasn't leaving until we sat there and talked. And then he would hold me down and I could not. get up. Jordan recalled that Cody once told her that if he ever hit her, she could leave him and never come back. After the argument, Cody came up with the idea to go for a drive to the park. They walked down loop trail and began arguing. According to Jordan, I was kind of getting some built-up anger, not very happy that he was talking at me like I was a child. And when I was trying to tell him how I was truly feeling.

At one point, Cody began bragging about not being afraid of the clip. And he said, I could do this with a blindfold on. I could just put it on, take a step, but I wouldn't even fall. And I was like, and it just keeps going through my head that, um, you're going to fall or something. Cody tried to grab her arm. I said, no, I'm not going to let this happen to me. I'm going to defend myself.

so I kind of said let go and I pushed and he went over. Jordan said about to push. I took two and I just pushed like to get him off me like pushed. It was it was two hands. All right. So let me go back to the fear of heights thing for a minute. I was thinking the same thing. If this person was truly afraid of heights,

as many people said he was, I just don't see someone. I know I wouldn't do it. I wouldn't get anywhere near the cliff. And I certainly wouldn't be playing around next to it. You know, saying, oh, I could do this blindfolded or there's no way I'm going to fall over. The whole time I'd be thinking, if I get close to this, I'm going to fall over. Yeah, and you would not do it.

I wouldn't. So I kind of side with you on that, that I doubt that's something he would do if he had that type of fear. Yeah, it doesn't mean it couldn't have happened. It just doesn't seem very likely. She was asked if she could have avoided pushing Cody and just walked away. She responded, yes, looking back, I guess I could have. When asked why she continued to turn around and push Cody, she said, it was because of high emotions. I was frustrated. I was angry. I was every emotion that I could ever think of all at once. And I had never felt like that before. I had never experienced that such high emotion. So again, if you're the jury, what are you making of all of these different

things that Jordan has said? I mean, they seem to be all over the place. They do. They do. I mean, but even in the parts where she's trying to make it seem like an accident, even then she's, she's saying, yeah, I could have walked away. Yeah, I didn't have to do it. I was just so angry that I did it. So if you're a juror, are you saying, yeah, that was self-defense or, no, maybe that was not self-defense. I don't think it's clear cut that it was self-defense, that's for sure. Right.

In the brief, the defense called the investigator's failure to record all of Jordan's statements, a grand government strategy designed to avoid creating a complete electronic record. of the interrogation. Due to these issues, the defense argued the indictment should be dismissed on constitutional ground. But on November 15, 2013, the judge rejected the request to dismiss the indictment. Towards the end of the month, prosecutors filed more documents, indicating Jordan spoke about killing her mother and stepfather in the weeks before the June wedding.

Prosecutors planned to introduce this evidence at the trial. her remarks would be used to negate innocent intent and demonstrate the likelihood that the defendant did act with the requisite intent in the charged case. That's what they said. Those are not my words. Because there's a lot of big words in there. You could have said there were my words, but. But then everybody would just know, I'm lying.

But yeah, I mean, if that's true that she was thinking about killing her mother and stepfather, That's big. That's big news. Yeah, because what does it mean if it's true? If she's thinking about doing that, is it much of a leap to think that she could possibly have killed her husband? Prosecutors also intended to prove Jordan lied about alleged abuse she experienced in previous romantic relationships, which provided insights into her state of monies. and credibility. Jordan's trial began on December 9th, 2013. Prosecutors told the jury that Cody was head over heels for Jordan, but she was having serious doubts that came to a head during their argument on the trail. The day after the wedding,

Jordan told a friend, she totally had a meltdown and was having second thoughts concerning her marriage and wondered what the heck I just did all this for. Now, I'm sure Gibbs, there are people that after the marriage think, oh, did I mess up? Seems awful strange that the day right after. Yeah, I mean, why go through with it? I mean, if you probably had those feelings going into it. Yeah, that was my thought. I mean, this wasn't like a hangover situation or hangover to, whichever one it was. Yeah. I think it was the first one where, you know, he got married after a drunken night in Vegas. Yeah. Yeah, you're going to have maybe some. regrets the next day after that, but...

I mean, this is something that they planned together. You know, according to people at the wedding, she was emotional and crying and happy, and now she thinks she made a mistake. Several witnesses testified that on July 7, 2013, Cody said Jordan had a surprise planned for him later that day. The prosecution argued that Jordan lured Cody to Glacier National Park, with the promise of the surprise. During their argument, she intentionally pushed Cody off the clip and drove away without seeking help. She lied to family, friends, and the police about what happened to Cody and fabricated the email from Tony claiming Cody was dead.

The prosecution noted that multiple people reported Cody missing on July 8th, but Jordan wasn't one of them. See, that doesn't look good. No, it doesn't. You know, if you just look at all of these things from kind of the perspective of the jury, you're just like, oh, that doesn't look good. Oh, that doesn't look good. Yeah. Because, you know, things go to a person's credibility or against their credibility.

Obviously, the different stories go against it. When you don't report your new husband, very new husband missing, but yet a whole bunch of of his friends do. Okay. That is going to have to be put in the go against you column. She's done a few things that goes against her. And, and of course this email, right, because we've talked about a few times. The revelation that it came from her father's IP address. And she was staying there at the time, you know, to me that that would be a big deal. Just kind of another piece of this, I'm making up this grand story. She communicated with numerous people in Caldespel about what happened to Cody, telling them he left with friends.

But then she led authorities to his body. After providing several false statements and impeding the investigation with false information, Jordan ultimately admitted to pushing Cody from behind. Jordan's defense said she had fired. finally worked up the nerd to talk to Cody about her doubts on July 7th, but their argument ended in a tragic accident when he grabbed her and she pushed him to remove his hand. As quoted by the daily interlake, the defense said, arguing on this small ledge was like arguing in a phone booth. Jordan lied because she was afraid no one would ever let her explain

what happened on that ledge. The defense characterized Jordan as naive. immature and shy. She dealt better with the children she nanny than with adults. She was awkward around Cody's friends and since they didn't like her. So she avoided them. She didn't want to report the accident because she was afraid. And in her naivete, she created an implausible story. And that's the one thing I do agree on. It was an implausible story. Yeah, she really did fabricate it. But, I give it up to the defense team. They're trying hard, right? To put a spin on her situation.

I just think this is a really tough one to spend. Because there are so many things that are just not making her look good at all. Yeah, I mean, she kind of set them up. Like she didn't give them a lot to work with. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. I get you. On December 12, 2013, Jordan Graham pleaded guilty to second degree murder on day four

of her trial. The plea deal was announced after the prosecution and defense, rested their cases, and took a courtroom break. They had not yet begun closing arguments. When the trial resumed, the judge said there were new developments, and the prosecution announced the deal had been made. Prosecutors agreed to drop the first-degree murder charge and the count of making a false statement. Jordan was asked to recount exactly what happened on July 7th. She described the argument and how she pushed Cody when he grabbed her saying, I wasn't thinking about where we were. I just pushed.

On March 27, 2014, Jordan was sentenced to 30 years in prison, plus five years of supervised release. She was ordered to pay $16,910 in restitution. But then Jordan filed a motion to withdraw her guilty plea. but the judge denied her motion. I mean, she is just so all over the play. It really is. Seems almost uncontrollable. And I just wonder with this latest thing, you know, was there something along the lines of,

okay, they're going to drop first degree. They're going to drop making a false statement. It's going to be second degree. But then she finds out she's going to have to do 30 years in prison. So she's like, oh, I'd just rather take my chances. Yeah. I just wonder if it was something along those lines. I mean, it could have been, but I don't think she would have fared any better.

No, I don't either. But I understand, you know, from the prosecution standpoint, do you even want to take the chance? They had to believe their case was pretty strong. But you never know with the jury. That's true. Jordan took the stand and apologized to her family and Cody's family, as reported by the Daily Interlake, she said she still loved Cody.

It was a moment of complete shock and panic. I have no other explanation. Judge Donald Malloy indicated he had continuing doubts about her honesty, and he was waiting for her to say she was sorry for killing Cody. He added, there's only one person in this room that knows what happened, and I don't think she's been entirely truthful about what happened. And that's, to me, a very interesting statement.

And one that I was kind of thinking about, you know, based on what she said after her plea deal, to me, it didn't even seem that after that she fully came clean because she really didn't say that much different from what she had already been saying. She kind of held the line there. Right. We had an argument. I wasn't thinking about where we were. I just pushed. That's what she said.

To me, that's not admitting you did it on purpose at all. That is still kind of kind of self-defense, but also kind of, yeah, I pushed him, but I didn't mean to push him off the cliff. Yeah,

and she didn't follow it up with. And I'm sorry it happened. And she never said, I'm sorry, yeah. And I think the judge wasn't happy about that. According to NBC, Montana, Jordan was moved to a federal prison in Alabama. Her release date is listed as June

2014. So as we wrap this one up, Gibbs, you know, I think the judge said it correctly. Jordan's the only person who truly knows what happened at the cliff's edge in Glacier National Park. Prosecutors argued that Jordan could have walked away, but she was overwhelmed by anger and pushed her husband of eight days to his death, Jordan's defense argued that it was a tragic accident that occurred when Jordan acted in self-defense, pushing Cody away when he grabbed her. And there are quite a few elements of this case

that you know would make the media, right? People pay attention to stuff like this because it's salacious. You have the, all right, they were only married eight days. There's kind of a self-defense argument to it, but yet she's caught in a number of different stories. I'm kind of with you. I don't see how, and obviously we didn't talk about everything at trial, but I don't see how a jury with what we know of wouldn't have found her guilty.

Yeah, I can't see that either. I think to me it's a slam dunk of guilt. But it does sometimes get tricky with that first degree, right? Premeditation and 10. Things like that, you know, sometimes a jury, they have problems with that. Because could they see an argument breaking out? And in the heat of the moment, she decides to push him off the clip. Even if it wasn't in self-defense, would it truly be?

first jury murder. And that part, I don't know. I think it probably goes to maybe, again, the prosecution's thinking of, well, we'll do a plea deal. She'll tell the whole story. But I'm not sure she actually did that part. Yeah. And like you said, the fact that she didn't apologize and the judge had to call her out for not apologizing or feelings bad about it or sorry.

I mean, I think that tells you a lot. It does. already had the plea deal. She could have said anything she wanted. So what she chose to say and what she chose not to say, I think is very telling at that point. Very. But that's it for our episode on Cody Johnson. We got a voicemail. You want to check that out? Let's hear it. Hi, Mike. Hi, Gibby. Hope he's are both doing well. This is Charles from North Lanarkshire, Scotland here. Just a wee message to thank you for all the great episodes over the years. I'm actually the long-term listener

I've recently signed up to Patreon. I've done to chocolate. The last one I listened to Kelsey Barrett where Fergay mentioned her friend Ashley Cockburn many times. It's just that here in the UK if the surname was spelled Cockburn it's actually pronounced Coburn.

I think it would be the same in the States as well, but maybe it's a little bit different but to me that sounds like something you need to put a cream on. And Gibby, don't let anybody say your Scottish accent isn't up to scratch because I think you day an absolute great impression they must use doubtfire when you try it. Thanks for the great work guys. Stay safe and keep your own time ticking.

Goodbye dear. Okay, so that one actually made me laugh when I heard it. When he said that sounds like something you should put some cream on. Okay, if it's pronounced Coburn, then why is it spelled C-O-C-K? Why is it not spelled C-O-B-R-N? Now, you're asking for too much now. Come on now. You know, did you feel like you were home when he was speaking? Oh, not. No, because I've never been to Scotland. I know what you're getting at.

I am of Scottish heritage. Right. But that accent, man, you know it. That's my favorite accent of all time. And I know they have different Scottish accents, just like we have different accents here in America. But there is something about the Scottish accent that is just, it's one of my favorites.

It really lit you up. I've seen that. Yeah. It just, it makes me happy to hear. I really, I've got to get over there, but it's a long flight. And you understood everything he said, didn't you? I did not. There were some things I didn't. I tried really hard. But we, I don't know if you ever worked with him, but there was a guy that worked at the place that I used to work at. You used to work at. I used to play golf with him. He was from Scott. Okay. And he had a very thick.

rogue or whatever you call it. Scottish. Scottish accent. And I used to just like go golfing with the guy so I could hear him talk. Yeah. You had like a little man crush. I wouldn't call it that. I just enjoyed his accent.

Okay. That's why he ate lunch with him every Wednesday and one lunchroom that nobody ever went in. Okay. All right, buddy. That is it for another episode of true crime all the time. So for Mike and Gibby. Stay safe and keep your own time ticking.