True Crime All The Time - The Murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart

Episode Date: August 16, 2021

Cassie Jo Stoddart was a 16-year-old girl from Pocatello, Idaho who was murdered by two friends in 2006 while housesitting for her aunt and uncle. The crime scene was a horrific sight, and th...e perpetrators turned out to be unlikely suspects- two of Cassie’s high school friends. Cassie’s murder case is often called “The Scream Murder” because Torey Adamcik and Brian Draper were inspired by the movie Scream.Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart. At just 16, Cassie had her whole life ahead of her when she was murdered by two boys she considered friends. Adamcik and Draper aspired to be more infamous than serial killers like Ted Bundy and John Wayne Gacy. They wanted to make their own claim to fame by turning Cassie’s murder into their own homemade horror film.You can help support the show at patreon.com/truecrimeallthetimeVisit the show's website at truecrimeallthetime.com for contact, merchandise, and donation informationAn Emash Digital productionSee Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:33 Hello everyone and welcome to episode 246 of the True Crime All the Time podcast. I'm Mike Ferguson and with me as always is my partner in True Crime, Mike Gibson. How about you? I'm doing good. How about you? I'm doing great. Yeah. Good.
Starting point is 00:00:46 Just one time. I want you to say something else. Okay. I'm doing horrible. I hate you. I'm done with this. No, I don't want you to say any of that. I'm out of here, man.
Starting point is 00:00:58 That's the thing about you, though, man, that I've always really liked is you just kind of of always in a good mood, you're upbeat. Yeah. You know, I think that's maybe why you and I get along so well, because I am not always that way. You know, they say opposites attract. Yeah. And so my emotions kind of can run the gamut for sure.
Starting point is 00:01:21 They do. But you're pretty even keeled. I try to be. Yeah. You should. It's good. It's good way to live, man. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:01:28 Wish I could rain mine in sometimes when people cut me off or. Something like that. Doesn't happen. Doesn't happen. It doesn't happen. It probably wouldn't ever happen. No. No, I mean, by this age, I don't think I'm changing.
Starting point is 00:01:40 Probably just get worse as you get away. It probably will. Get off of my lung. Yeah. All right, buddy, we got some shoutouts. Let's give those. We had Mara Yeager. What's going on, Mara?
Starting point is 00:01:50 Katrinka Dotson jumped out of the highest level. Well, thank you, Trinca. Carrie Bevan. What's going on, Carrie? What's going on, Carrie? Claudia Margiata. Margieada. Cody Cole.
Starting point is 00:02:00 Hey, Cody. Ann Perkins. Appreciate that, Ann. El Jasper. What's going on, Elle? Dana Venturi. Hey, Venturi. Kimba S.
Starting point is 00:02:07 Appreciate that, Kimba. Carrie Sorensen. Ooh, Kelly. Miranda Humphrey jumped out of our highest level. What's going on, Humphrey? Kalisha Simpkins jumped out of our highest level. Man, Simpkin in the house. We had Karen.
Starting point is 00:02:19 What's going on, Karen? Jamie Fogel. Hey, Jamie. Teresa Ann. Hey, Teresa. Kathy. Appreciate that, Kathy. Francesca Batagliolioli.
Starting point is 00:02:27 Jumped out of our highest level. Batakiodi. Boy, that. I don't think that's right. And last but not least, we had Gabrielle Vance. Hey, Gabrielle. And then if we go back into the Vault Gibbs, this week we selected Allie G. Boom, Allie G.
Starting point is 00:02:44 Yeah, been with us a long time. We appreciate all the new support, the continued support on Patreon. We also had some great PayPal donations from Christy Della Serta. Delacerta. Jamie Lynn Hamby. Darlene Half. Hey, darling. Lauren Porter.
Starting point is 00:03:01 Hey, Lauren. and Megan Hunt. Oh, appreciate that, Megan. So all of that is very much appreciated. Gibbs right now on true crime all the time unsolved. We have an episode out on the Chicago Strangler. Yeah, it was a good case.
Starting point is 00:03:17 It is. And I don't, I think you said it on our weekly Patreon episode that, you know, this is a case that is not as well known as a lot of, you know, infamous unsolved cases. Right.
Starting point is 00:03:30 And I don't know why. Yeah. I mean, we're talking about possible victims in the number range of 50 plus here. It's a lot of victims, man. Yeah. So we'll get into all the details around that. Don't forget about CrimeCon. You know, if you're going, if you're wanting to go, make sure you get your tickets.
Starting point is 00:03:52 We want to understand they're going quick. They're going really quick. And so if you go to CrimeCon.com, use our promo code TCAT. You'll get 10% off your stand. standard batch price. T-C-A-A-A-T-A-T-A-T-A. Yeah, say that 10 times fast. True crime all the time. Yeah. All right, buddy, are you ready to get into this episode of true crime all the time? I'm ready. We are talking about the murder of Cassie Joe Stoddard. You know, this is a horrendous case. And some of the details are, frankly, unbelievable.
Starting point is 00:04:27 It was on September 24th, 2006, that Cassie Joe Stoddert was found stabbed to death inside her aunt and uncle's home. The crime scene was a horrific sight. And the perpetrators turned out to be two pretty unlikely suspects, two of Cassie's high school friends. Cassie's murder case is often called the scream murder because these two guys, Tori Adam Chick, and and Brian Draper were inspired by the movie Scream. Now, they were also inspired by some serial killers, Bundy, Gacy, and others. But they wanted to make their own claim to fame Gibbs by turning Cassie's murder into their own kind of homemade horror film.
Starting point is 00:05:15 It's checked up, man. It is. And we're going to get into all of it. We are. Cassie Joe Stoddard was a 16-year-old girl from Pocatello, Idaho. Gibbs, everyone who has talked about Cassie has had nothing but positive things to say about her. Almost all the kids at Pocatello High School liked her. You know, she was getting good grades.
Starting point is 00:05:40 She was on the right track to get into a top college and have a successful future. Christy Stoddart, her sister, told to show your worst nightmare that Cassie was always determined to do well for herself. she was a kind person who was always there to reach out a helping hand. Cassie's uncle, Frank Contreras, told the Idaho State Journal. Cassie was a good girl. She didn't drink. She didn't use drugs. And she was a straight A student. She was responsible. She was a model student. And a model person. Yeah. I think. I mean, both together. It's sad. You know, when we talk about victims, you hear this a lot. Now, it's. It's. You know, it's. You know, sad when anybody is murdered. Don't don't get me wrong, even if they had some negative things to say.
Starting point is 00:06:30 Right. And I think there's also the factor of, okay, is anybody really going to say negative things? Well, we just had an episode recently. We did. Where somebody did say some negative things about the victim. We were shocked. Happened in another country. It's still shocking. But I like to think that, you know, these people, these victims that we talk about, especially the young ones. they are just really good people. Yeah. Haven't even really started their lives, but they all seem to be on the right track, right? They get good grades. They're thought of as nice people. They're well liked by their friends.
Starting point is 00:07:09 And I think some of them are just too trusting of others, right? There's no doubt. There's no doubt that sometimes when you peel back the layers of what exactly happened, And we do find out that, you know, a lot of these people have a very trusting nature. Yeah. And sometimes that does lead to, you know, what ultimately happens to them. That's sad too because you want people to be like that. Right.
Starting point is 00:07:38 You should be able to trust others. You should be able to lend a hand and not think that everybody that you meet is a killer. I remember when my daughter was in that middle. school age. Her middle school age or your middle school age? Because there's probably about a four or five year difference. Oh, that hurt, man. That hurt. No, yeah, her middle school age. I just remember she was like, anywhere we go, she was like super friendly. And I was like, hey, too friendly. Too friendly. To dial it back. And you hate to say that. But, you know, it's a scary world out there. We all know that. Cassie was dating a boy named Matt Beckham. And he was a good guy. By all accounts, he was a very nice.
Starting point is 00:08:21 guy and a good boyfriend to Cassie. Her parents have said that they trusted him and they liked him a lot. Matt and Cassie were friends with two other 16-year-olds named Tori Adamchick and Brian Draper. Tori was passionate about filmmaking. Brian was outgoing and he played on the high school soccer team. They both seemed like normal teenage boys. The problem is Gibbs, they were hiding a secret fascination. with serial killers and especially the Columbine shooting. Now, the one thing I will say, Gibbs, is that, okay, a fascination with serial killers and even the Columbine shooting, I think on its own doesn't necessarily mean it's bad, right?
Starting point is 00:09:11 Do we have a fascination with killers and serial killers? Do people listening have a fascination? I would say the answer is probably yes. Absolutely. I think they do. No, it doesn't mean they want to be like them. They don't want to pattern their actions after them. They're fascinated because they can't understand them.
Starting point is 00:09:30 They're trying to, you know, understand what makes these people tick and what causes them to do the things that they do. I think we're talking about a different type of fascination here with these two boys. Yeah, I think listeners aren't idolizing. No, absolutely not. And neither are we. I mean, right? We're very careful. not to glorify these people that we talk about, if anything, we kind of put them down sometimes
Starting point is 00:09:58 because, you know, they're pieces of, you know what they are in a lot of case, in most cases, I would say. Brian had a website with memorials to three of the victims of the Columbine shooting. His website was titled, You Will Be Missed. Okay. That seems like a good thing, right? develop a website, put it out there, memorialize the victims, and I'm saying, hey, you know, you will be missed. It is nice until you scroll down to the bottom of his webpage because he had more victims to come.
Starting point is 00:10:33 Yeah, at the bottom of the page, more victims to come. Okay, now that's creepy. It's not known if anyone knew about this website or if they did if anyone reported it as a threat. I think today, for sure, we would look at that as a sign that, okay, something's going on here. Yeah. That would be viewed as a threat. Absolutely, I think, in today's culture. I think there'd be some investigation going on.
Starting point is 00:11:03 Yeah, absolutely. Brian and Tori's biggest secret was that they were planning a murder of their own. And they wanted to film the entire process as part of, you know, what they were thinking would be this type of, of real life horror movies. Now, as you can imagine, these boys were very secretive about their plans, right? You can't go around telling your mom and dad. You can't be sitting at the dinner table over pork chops and mashed potatoes saying, okay, here's my plan.
Starting point is 00:11:33 What do you think? Because that's not going to go over well in most families. I think somebody at the dinner table would be like, um, excuse me, boys. We need to call somebody right away. Yeah. Really only Tori and Brian knew the full. extent of what they were going to do one day. Their 18-year-old friend Joe Lucero helped them purchase knives from a pawn shop.
Starting point is 00:11:58 On August 31st, 2006, Joe received a phone call from Tori asking if he would buy some knives from them. Okay. These are two 16-year-olds. They can't just walk into a pawn shop. Heck, they can't even walk into a Cabellas, right? And buy a knife. I think you have to be 18 years old.
Starting point is 00:12:17 pretty much anywhere to buy a knife these days. I made my own back in the day. Yeah. That would not surprise me. You and I talk a lot about knives. It's something that we're kind of into. We collect knives. We have a lot of knives.
Starting point is 00:12:32 You know me. I collect a lot of things. You do. So Tori and Joe went to a local pawn shop to buy knives. Brian provided the money, $40. And for that $40, Tori got one knife and Brian got, got three. Obviously your money goes a long way at a pawn shop for a lot of things.
Starting point is 00:12:53 So let's shift focus back to Cassie. Right? Like most 16 year olds, she really won a car. And so she was looking for ways to make money so that she could buy herself one. When Allison and Frank Contrares, her aunt and uncle offered to pay her to house sit while they went on vacation, that seemed like the perfect opportunity to make some money. Easy money. Easy money. And I know a lot of kids that do that. My daughter's boyfriend has done that for a number of years. He has like a list of people. And they know if they're going on vacation, okay, we're going to call him. He'll make sure the, the pets are taken care of, the trash is taken out, whatever it is. Yeah, but strangely, he said no to my requests. Yeah. I don't think he was ready for that. Okay. You know, yeah. He's pretty experienced. I don't think he was
Starting point is 00:13:45 ready for Chateau Gibson. He just said, no, no, no, thank you and disconnected. Yeah, which I applaud him for. But I think I've said it before Gibbs. You know, I admire kids, 14, 15, 16, however old, looking for ways to make their own money. Absolutely. You know, whether back in the day it was having a paper route. That was a big deal. You had to get up early and, you know, fold the papers and do all that. that ride your bike around town throwing papers on people's porches whatever it is i really have a lot of admiration for kids who want to make their own money i think we have probably less and less of those kids now than we did in years past oh i think so yeah i think it's dwindled on friday september
Starting point is 00:14:36 22nd 2006 at 530 p m cassie's mother dropped her off at her aunt and uncle's house they lived in the town of Chubbock. That's what I'm calling it. I know I'm going to get email saying that I'm pronouncing it wrong, but it was about 15 minutes away from Cassie's home. Her mother planned to pick her up on Sunday morning when her aunt and uncle returned from vacation. So she was going to be there the entire time, which is somewhat normal, I think, in a house sitting. Sometimes people leave. They just come back to feed the pets and let them out. But, you know, different situations. One of the problems Gibbs is, Cassie had no car. We just talked about it. Yeah. So she's going to be stuck there.
Starting point is 00:15:18 Right. Unless, you know, her mom or somebody was going to come pick her up and take her back and forth. Or she called a friend for a ride. She had no way to really leave. And her aunt and uncle lived in a pretty remote area. I guess their nearest neighbor was about a half a mile away. Yeah. So as a friend or a parent, you're probably like, you know, did they really want to make that drive out there again and again? needed something. I think some people would, but I'd be like, you sure you need me to come out there? Are you sure? So you're telling me you wouldn't drive 15 minutes to go pick up your kids and drop them off and take them back? No, it costs too much gas money. Oh, I forgot. Who am I talking to? Yeah. Why would I even ask that question? So we have to talk about this house, right?
Starting point is 00:16:06 Set it pretty remote area. It was also an older home and like a lot of older homes. It made lots of noises, it had creaky floorboards. It's thought by many people that Cassie was probably a little nervous about being there alone. I don't know how many different people she relayed that to, if that's a fact or that's just an assumption that many people have made. It would be a little freaky, you know, if you staying in a home like that and you're out kind of rural area, I mean, every time you hear a noise, you're probably thinking, who's that? Yeah, what is that?
Starting point is 00:16:43 Yeah. Well, and let's not forget, she's only 16 years old, but she wanted the money. I think at the same time, like a lot of kids, she wanted to show her mom that she was mature, that she was responsible, and that she could handle this on her own. Well, yeah, she made that commitment to do it. Her aunt and uncle's gone, so if she doesn't do it. Letting them down. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:17:06 And maybe in her mind feeling like she let herself down and is looking bad in the the eyes of others. I get that. Matt was dropped off to see Cassie about an hour later. And Cassie's aunt and uncle had given her permission to have Matt over. And both of their parents were fine with them hanging out at the house unsupervised. Again, we talked about the fact that these were both good kids. And I think Gibbs, they had built up an extreme amount of trust with their parents. That's what happens. When you do the right thing consistently, you know, you build up that credit in the trust department. At 8.30 p.m. Tori Adam Chick and Brian Draper showed up to the house. Matt had invited them over and told them that Cassie was having a party. When they got there,
Starting point is 00:17:57 they saw, okay, no party. Now, Cassie was angry that Matt invited them. Her aunt told her specifically that Matt was the only person she was allowed to have at the house. And, you know, Gibbs, like we said, Kathy was a good girl. She was. She was. wasn't a rule breaker. But at the same time, she also wasn't a rude person. So, you know, she didn't want to confront these boys and say, you can't be here or, you know, say something to try to send them away. Because of that, Tori and Brian stayed at the house for about two hours. Yeah, at some point, Brian told Cassie and Matt that he wanted to leave because he didn't like the movie they were watching and he wanted to go to the movie theater and see something else.
Starting point is 00:18:41 Tori and Brian left around 10.30 p.m. Yeah, but before they left, that Brian was a little sneaky guy because he went downstairs and he unlocked the back door to the house. Yeah, yeah. I think sneaky might be a euphemism here, right? There is definitely some bad intentions involved, for sure.
Starting point is 00:19:02 So Tori and Brian had left. Cassie and Matt were alone in the house. They finished their movie. But then just after 10.30 p.m., All of a sudden, Gibbs, all of the lights in the house went out. Okay. You're in a home that's not your own. Now, it's your aunt and uncles.
Starting point is 00:19:19 You're probably somewhat familiar with it. But still, you're in a remote area. The closest neighbor is about a half a mile away. That's a scary proposition. I think even when your boyfriend is there with you, Cassie was scared. And she asked Matt to go check the circuit breaker in the basement. But just before he went down, the lights came back on.
Starting point is 00:19:42 And then around 11 p.m. Matt's mom came to pick him up. I think the problem for Cassie was this was just about, what, Gibbs, 30 minutes after this whole light thing. Right. So she was still on edge, on edge, a little bit freaked out, a little scared. And she asked Matt to see if he could stay with her. He went outside and asked his mom and she told him absolutely not.
Starting point is 00:20:09 probably wanted a little chaperoning going on if that was going to happen yeah i get it i get it right 16 year olds most parents really don't want them staying overnight by themselves so she told him no way but he did say that if cassie was scared she could spend the night at their house and she would drop her back off in the morning so obviously she was being very nice It wasn't because she didn't like Cassie. It was probably more so because, you know, everybody knows what happens when, or what can happen when boyfriend and girlfriend get together.
Starting point is 00:20:47 They're allowed to stay by themselves at night. Okay. Parents watch out for that. Yeah, they do. Not always successfully. They try to. They try. So obviously Matt relayed that information to Cassie.
Starting point is 00:20:59 Yeah, she wasn't happy. She was still scared. She wanted to go with Matt, but ultimately decided not to. She figured it would be best if she stayed at the house. I think Gibbs, she was looking at it from a responsibility standpoint. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:21:13 Right. It was her responsibility to watch the house. She was getting paid to stay there, not at Matt's house. So Matt left her just after 11 p.m. All right, Gibbs, let's talk about good RX for a minute. You know,
Starting point is 00:21:26 getting the care you need to stay healthy shouldn't be hard or expensive. Everyone should be able to afford their medication. So check out. Now Good RX. They help me find the lowest price of my prescriptions every time. With Good RX, you can instantly compare prices for your prescription at every pharmacy in your neighborhood and save up to 80%. 80%. Good RX is free and easy to use and many times it's often cheaper than using your insurance co-pay or Medicare. With Good RX, you can find discounts for your prescriptions
Starting point is 00:21:55 at over 70,000 pharmacies like CVS, Kroger, Walgreens, Rite Aid, Vons, Walmart, and more. Good RX is the number one most downloaded medical app. And millions of Americans use Good RX to get affordable health care every month. Ever since I learned about it, I'm using it every time now. I even got my mother-in-law to use it on her phone. She was blown away by how much money she was able to save just by shopping around, using the information on Good RX. So start saving up to 80%.
Starting point is 00:22:26 On your prescriptions today, go to goodrrx.com slash T-Cat. That is goodrx.com slash teacat. Goodrx. Dot com slash teac. Good RX is not insurance, but can be used instead of insurance. In 2020, Good RX users received an average savings of over 70% of retail prices. On his way home, Matt called Tori and told him that he was headed home for the night. Innocent, right?
Starting point is 00:22:54 This is an innocent phone call. Right. The problem is, and there's no way that Matt could have known this, but. Basically what he did was give these two boys the signal. Yeah, setting it up. That Cassie was all alone in the home. They were clear to carry out their plans. Matt later recalled that Tori was whispering quietly and said he was at the movies.
Starting point is 00:23:19 Well, it turns out he wasn't. In reality, he was outside of the house where Cassie was staying, just waiting to go back inside. Yeah. Now, Cassie thought she was safely locked inside the house, right? She probably went around, made sure all the doors were locked. The problem is she didn't know that before he left, Brian had unlocked the back door leading to the basement. Sometime after 11 p.m., the lights went out again. So now you're talking about real fear.
Starting point is 00:23:51 She was scared before. Oh, sure. And that was when Matt was there. Now Matt's gone. She had to have been almost frozen. Yeah. with fear. And there's no way she was going to check out the basement. No. No, I mean, anybody that's seen a scary movie knows don't go into the basement.
Starting point is 00:24:08 Now, the accounts given later by Tori and Brian differ a little bit on exactly what happened. But the basic facts are the same. Tori and Brian continued to turn the lights on and off, scaring Cassie. What they were trying to do, Gibbs, is get her to come downstairs to the basement to check out the circuit breaker, but she never did. So they ended up coming upstairs wearing masks and dark clothing. At some point, Cassie heard their footsteps and yelled, who's there? The boy snuck up on her and they both stabbed her multiple times. She tried to fight them off, but she couldn't, right? They overpowered her and they killed her. Afterwards, they fled the scene and they took the clothes and the murder weapon with them. But they left Kempowered.
Starting point is 00:24:59 Cassie's body in the house. Gibbs the very next day, Matt spent the day with Tori, not knowing that he had just murdered his girlfriend. So, I mean, I think you got to take a step back here, right? These are 16-year-old boys. Yeah. You're able to spend the day with your friend who happened to be the boyfriend of a young girl that you just murdered.
Starting point is 00:25:24 What does that say about this kid? He wasn't shaking in his. boots, right? He wasn't sitting in his basement crying over what he had just done. Just cold and callous. And basically acting as though it was any other day. Hey, let's hang out like we always do. On Sunday, September 24th, Cassie's family came back to the house. It was her 13-year-old cousin Kelsey who ran in the head of her parents and found Cassie's body laying on the living room floor. Well, for a 13 year old to come in and see that, had to be shocking. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:26:02 Well, number one gives, I think, to find a dead body, to see a dead body, that would shock anyone and, you know, you're going to be working through a lot of things for a number of years, but to find your cousin who's only three years older, I bet you they were pretty close. Yeah, that must have been extremely tough for her. And the aunt and uncle as well. Well, and it's been two days too. Yeah, that's a good point. You know, it's not like they found her within a couple of hours of her being killed.
Starting point is 00:26:36 It was essentially, you know, almost two days later. They immediately called the police. Christy Stoddard was at work. When her uncle came in during her shift, he told her there had been a family emergency. Someone stabbed Cassie and she was dead. Christy didn't believe it until she went to the house and saw the crime scene. Cassie's mom didn't find out that she was dead until she arrived to pick up her daughter. So you talk about shocking, right?
Starting point is 00:27:04 This whole family is in shock. They have no idea what happened. They only know that Cassie's dead. Yeah. And when we say she was stabbed, it wasn't just one or two times by these kids. Now, it turned out that she was stabbed over 30 times. And it was stated that 12 of those wounds were fatal. They determined that she was stabbed with two different knives, which indicated to police that two different people were involved in her murder, which I think is a safe assumption.
Starting point is 00:27:37 Now, could you have one person who has two knives and uses them both? Yeah, you could. I'll sure you could. But I think the natural assumption, whether it's determining two different knives were used or two different caliber of bullets were used, that assumption is going to be that there were more. multiple people involved. Yeah. Well, Cassie's mom knew that Matt was one of the people that saw her last because she gave permission for Matt to come over and stay there with her.
Starting point is 00:28:06 Yeah. So, I mean, I think naturally, right, Matt was going to be the first suspect. Like you said, police found out. He was at the house. He was the closest person to Cassie. So a detective went to his house to talk to him. And this encounter, this interaction, Gibbs has been described. as it relates to Matt is him being emotionless, which, you know, right away, detectives are going to be
Starting point is 00:28:34 suspicious. Hey, we're talking to you. We just told you that your girlfriend was murdered, no emotion. But at the same time, they felt as though Matt was being truthful during their conversation. And then Matt told a detective that Tori and Brian were also at the house that night. night. Tori and Brian were interviewed separately. And I think initially, police weren't real high on them as suspects in the murder. For one thing, I think it's hard for a lot of us to think that, you know, a 16-year-old boy is capable of this type of violence. Yeah. Could they plan something like this? Carry it out. Now, we know boys fight, right? Sure. You and I back in the day, probably got in our share of scrapes.
Starting point is 00:29:26 I know I did. Not always on the winning side, unfortunately. I know you were. Of course. Because you were a master in all kinds of different disciplines. But, you know, in all seriousness, when you think about 15, 16 year olds, you don't think about them sitting around planning, master minding, you know, this type of heinous murder. Now, we know, it's possible.
Starting point is 00:29:53 because we've talked about a bunch of them. But I think right off the bat, it's just not something that you would immediately go to. No. But police are going to get there. We know that. Sure. Yeah. And I don't think it took them all that long.
Starting point is 00:30:06 Gibbs, I think they changed their minds about Tori and Brian after the first interview. So the first story that the boys told was that they went to the house for a party. When they got there, they found out that there was no party. so they left and they went to the movie. The problem they ran into was that they couldn't tell the detective the name of the movie they saw, who was in it or even the basic plot of the movie. So sounds very much like you when you bring up some movie that you all of a sudden
Starting point is 00:30:43 can't remember a single detail about. Yeah, but that's me. That is you. And you're not trying to cover your tracks for a moment. murder. No. So, I mean, you think about this. Again, they're 16 years old. How, how smart are they? How cunning are they? Do they not think that when they are giving their alibi to police that, you know, detectives might dig in a little further. They might ask some probing questions. Well, look, I'm no movie expert. That is for sure. And that's where I differ from these boys. Yeah, because at one point,
Starting point is 00:31:21 they both called themselves movie experts. So that's very unusual for somebody to say that they're a movie buff. And let's go further. I'm a movie expert. Yeah. But I just saw a movie a few days ago and I can't tell you anything about it. Main character, the plot, nothing. Really?
Starting point is 00:31:41 That's what I always say about you when you start down a path and then can't tell me a single thing about it. And somehow I know what the movie is anyway. So I'd have to bring you and I'd be like, hey. I need to make a phone call. They're like, oh, great. He wants his attorney. Like, oh, no, no, no.
Starting point is 00:31:54 I just need Fergie to tell me what movie I saw. Because he'll remember the movie. As I explain it to you, he'll get it. Matt came into the police station to take a polygraph. He passed and he was cleared as a suspect. So really after that, police zeroed in on Tori and Brock. Really is their two main suspects. They were interviewed a second time, a third time.
Starting point is 00:32:20 a third time, and every time their story changed a little bit. Okay. That's not good either. You know, when you're talking to police, they're checking for that, right? That's why you go through a bunch of different interviews. Sometimes asked the exact same question multiple times. They want to see if your answer the third time is the same as it was the first time. It's kind of like a spouse questioning another spouse when they don't believe they're being told the truth.
Starting point is 00:32:54 Yeah, they might wait a day, a couple days ask you again, wait a couple more days, ask you again, just to see if they're getting the same answer. Yeah. You know, slip up or an aha moment. Some spouses can be amateur detectives, like I'm sure a lot of our audience can be as well. Sure. Some people take pride in that, uh, that, that amateur detectives. mature detective label for good reason. But like I said, their stories changed. In Brian's second interview, he told the officer that they were actually out burglarizing cars and that the reason
Starting point is 00:33:32 he said they were at the movies was to cover that out. And I know Gibbs we've talked about this before. I get the reasoning behind it because obviously burglarizing a car is not as bad as murder. Sure. but this is a very common tactic used by, you know, a lot of people once they've been kind of caught, not caught, but you know, like they feel trapped. Yeah. So they will admit to something they deem to be lesser in severity, hoping, I guess, that they'll get slapped on the wrist for that, but the police won't continue to look at them as a suspect in the murder. I don't know how many times it works, but I guess you got to try something. But officers weren't buying the story.
Starting point is 00:34:23 After this second interview, detectives received permission from Brian and his parents to search his bedroom. Inside his bedroom, they found a knife. Brian said the knife belonged to one of his friends and he had no idea why it was in his bedroom. Likely story. Likely story, but also, you know, I'm thinking there's no plan here, right? This is not, you know, I was, I was thinking about comparing this to a movie. And in my head, I had, I think it's called Murder by Numbers. Have you ever seen that one?
Starting point is 00:34:57 I think that's the one with a young Ryan Gosling where these two kids are kind of pitted up against. Sandra Bullock? Yeah. I think, I think that's the name of it. But you know the movie I'm talking about. Michael Pitt's in it as well. Who? Michael Pitt.
Starting point is 00:35:14 Yes. He played in Boardwalk Empire. And they're trying to use all this forensic knowledge and trying to get over, commit the perfect murder. There's none of that here. I mean, it seems very fly by the seat of our pants type thing where you don't have an alibi. You use an alibi that you can't back up. You just leave a knife laying in your bedroom, have no idea how it got there. I never understand when people do that.
Starting point is 00:35:45 I'm glad they do it because that's the way that some people get caught. Yeah, we don't want people to get away with anything. But it makes you shake your head. Like, why wouldn't you've gotten rid of that? If it is the knife that was used, why would you have kept that? Tori and Brian were arrested on September 27, 2006. They were charged as adults and held on a million dollar bond. according to Tori's second interview, Brian stabbed Cassie first.
Starting point is 00:36:15 She screamed loudly. Brian told Tori that he had to come and finish it. So Tori told the detective, I had to do it. Why? Because your buddy told you to and you didn't want to look like a punk in his eyes or like you chickened out or, I mean, he's already admitted that he did it. It's just the reasoning behind it. It's so strange.
Starting point is 00:36:39 What you had to do was stop, call 911 and get her help, but no. Now, in Brian's third interview, he said he was in the house, but he never stabbed Cassie. He thought the whole thing was just a prank. He admitted that they unlocked the door, but they were just planning to scare her. But it was Tori who took things too far, and Tori threatened to kill him if he said anything. He confessed that they buried the evidence in Black Rock Canyon. And Brian even took the police to the location where they uncovered some black clothing, three knives, two masks, and a video tape. So the boys are up against each other.
Starting point is 00:37:21 Which often happens, right? When two people commit a crime, it's very natural for them to turn on each other. Because nobody wants to take the blame, right? You want to put the blame on someone else and minimize your role in the whole thing. But the videotape is important here because neither of the boys had ever mentioned a video. So police uncover this. And you know Gibbs, they had to be worried about what they were going to see on this video. When they watched it, it had to be bad because why would somebody hide it, right?
Starting point is 00:38:02 Along with all of the other tools that they used to commit the murder. a detective told to show your worst nightmare, you could have heard a pin drop in the room when the tape began. And Gibbs, the tape was as horrifying as they were afraid it would be. In the days before and after Cassie's murder, the boys filmed everything. They filmed their entire plot to kill her. And they filmed the moments after her death. They recorded videos on September 21st, 22nd and the 23rd. In total, there was about 31 minutes of video of them planning and even confessing to the murder. So I do want to read some excerpts of this video with a little warning that there is some pretty vulgar language. You've got 16 year old boys. You're going to have that.
Starting point is 00:38:59 But I think it's important to read it as it was said. In one of the earliest video clips, Brian said, I feel like I want to kill somebody. I know that's not normal, but what the hell? Tori responded, I feel like we need to break away from normal life. And to me, you know, this is important, Gibbs. You are getting an inside glimpse into what these kids are thinking, feeling in the moments, days before the murder, after the murder. And as their parents, you have to be sick to your stomach.
Starting point is 00:39:34 Oh, my gosh. you watch this. Yeah, I don't often think about that. It's a good point. You know, what, what a parents think when they have a child who kills someone? That's got to be horrific. Then you've got this videotape that comes out that, you know, really kind of puts a spotlight on just how callous and depraved, you know, these two kids were. Because, you know, throughout the video, they laugh about killing someone. They even mention that they've tried to kill someone. And they even mentioned that they've tried to kill someone eight or nine times. But the people that they targeted had never been alone.
Starting point is 00:40:12 Or if they were alone, their parents showed up before these kids could carry out what they wanted to do. One point, Tori said to Brian, we're not going to get caught. Brian said, we're going to make history. We're going to be just like scream, except in real life terms. This is where the scream murder. comes in because he specifically references the movie. And I guess the boys talked about the scream movie a lot.
Starting point is 00:40:41 They also compared themselves to Ted Bundy, the Hillside Strangler, and the Zodiac Killer. Okay. Not people you really want to emulate. These are the wrong people to idolize for sure. Tori even said at one point, those people were mere amateurs compared to what we are going to be. So, you know, if you're calling Ted Bundy an amateur killer and your thought is you're going to surpass him. Scary.
Starting point is 00:41:12 Yeah. Because Ted Bundy, Hillside Strangler, I mean, they had a body count. Yeah. And so to me, that means you're not planning on killing one person. If you're going to surpass these infamous killers, you're planning on killing multiple individuals. Now, initially the boys decided they were going to break into Cassie's home and scare her. But they said that that plan changed just a few hours later. On September 21st at 8.36 p.m. Tori and Brian decided that Cassie was going to be their victim,
Starting point is 00:41:51 even if she was their friend. They didn't care. They made that decision, I think in part gives because they had just found out that she was going to be house sitting alone. Brian said on the tape, as sad as it may be, she's our friend, but you know what? We all have to make sacrifices. Our first victim is going to be Cassie Stoddard. We'll find out if she has friends over. If she's going to be alone in a big dark house out in the middle of nowhere, how perfect can you get? Gibbs Tori said, I'm horny just thinking about it.
Starting point is 00:42:28 These kids are messed up. sexually excited over the fact that they're about ready to kill their friend. Brian said, hell yeah. So we're going to fucking kill her and her friends and we're going to keep moving on. I heard some news about a girl. She's going to be home alone from six to seven. So we might kill her and drive over to Cassie's thing,
Starting point is 00:42:52 scare the shit out of them and kill them one by fucking one. Hell yeah. Now, I know a lot of. of 16 year old boys talk like this, right? I play Xbox. I hear him talking all the time. Not about killing people. They use a lot of profanity. They think that's cool. All right, I get it. You and I probably cussed a lot more when we were younger too. We don't as much anymore. But when you're doing it in the context of talking about, you know, killing multiple people. And let's not forget, I mean, Cassie was their friend. They,
Starting point is 00:43:29 considered her friend she considered them friends i mean it is just something on one part of the tape brian said i'm sorry to cassie's family but she had to be the one bizarre thing to say why did she have to be the one and you think the family really wants to hear that sorry i'm sorry family no they're not putting it they wouldn't put any stock into that and we're going to talk more about the tape in just a second but you think about this tape you and i often talk about you and i often talk about evidence and good evidence and slam dunk type evidence. I don't know what else you're going to get here. You've got these kids laying out pretty much everything, what they're planning to do. And as we're going to find out what they did, right, talking about it after the fact. On the 22nd,
Starting point is 00:44:20 the boys filmed themselves at school. They recorded a video of Cassie at her locker. They sat at a table openly talking about killing people. But I guess Gibbs, no one overheard this conversation, or at the very least, no one reported it. So that was the day of the murder. Yeah, during the day when they were at school, it seems like by that point, they had already made up their mind, right? They were going to kill someone. They even said they had either attempted or started the process eight or nine different times, got foiled, whatever. At 9.53 p.m., the boys recorded a short video, talking about how they had unlocked the back door to the house where Cassie was house sitting.
Starting point is 00:45:06 At 1130 p.m., the boys recorded themselves after they killed Cassie. On this part of the tape, Brian said, I just killed Cassie. We just left her house. This is not a fucking. joke. Tori said, I'm shaking. I stabbed her in the throat. Brian replied, and I saw her lifeless body just disappeared. Dude, I just killed Cassie. That felt like it wasn't even real. I mean, it went by so fast. Tori told him to shut the fuck up and said, we got to get our act straight. And Brian said, it's okay. We'll just buy movie tickets now. So obviously, they had the movie idea ahead of time as a cover.
Starting point is 00:45:51 As we know Gibbs, it didn't go well because they didn't get the details right. Now, the boys didn't film themselves killing Cassie and they didn't record any footage of her body. But as disturbing as this tape is, police have to be, I don't use the word ecstatic, but they have to be feeling good because this is really strong evidence. Oh, absolutely. I mean, before this tape was found, you had one of them saying, I didn't stab her. and one of them pinning it on the other. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:46:23 On this video, you got them both, I want to say they're like high-fiving each other, but they're pretty close to it. Yeah. But at the very least, they're admitting everything that they did. Now, you know, speaking of the video,
Starting point is 00:46:35 you know, obviously Cassie's family was heartbroken, but they had to have been, I almost hate to use the word, I hate to use the word, glad, but they had to have been, I don't know what else to use,
Starting point is 00:46:46 Gibbs, glad that these boys didn't tape the murder, didn't tape her body, didn't record that part so that they didn't have to see that. It'd be rough to see your child go through that. Actually being murdered. Yeah. Or seeing her dead body, you know, just after the murder.
Starting point is 00:47:09 You couldn't be there to protect her. Bad enough knowing it happened. Even worse, I think seeing it actually happened. On September 28th, Brian confessed that he did staff. Cassie, but he said it was only because Tori made him. He said, Tori told him to stab Cassie to make sure she was dead. He also revealed that they created a hit list, including Matt Beckham, but they didn't kill him because he didn't stay at the house.
Starting point is 00:47:37 Well, sure didn't sound like Tori made him do anything in that video. No, I mean, again, I think they're still trying to play the, it wasn't me, it was him, or at the very least, I'm trying to minimize my role. It's pretty tough to do that, though. When you have this videotape that kind of lays it all out, I mean, they each said after the murder what they had done and they were excited about it. How are you going to beat that in court? And I mentioned that after they were arrested, they each got a million dollar bond.
Starting point is 00:48:11 Well, once police got this video, those bonds were revoked. As they should have been. Cassie's family in the entire community experienced extreme shock and grief. Her classmates painted her portrait on a boulder on the property of the school as a memorial to her. All of the football players wore her initials on an armband and they had a moment of silence for her during games. Brian Draper's trial began on April 11, 2007. And, you know, this was a very high profile case. Gibbs, police had to use some extreme security measures. Everyone had to pass through metal detectors and the jury was sequestered and monitored around the clock. They also had extra security
Starting point is 00:48:58 for Brian's transport to and from prison. I'm sure there's a few people who wanted both Brian and Tori taking care of. Yeah. Yeah. I'm sure there were people in the community that at least thought about it. However, seriously, that maybe they should take the law into their own hands and not wait for a jury to decide what should happen to them. Yeah, I know as parents, we've talked about it before. If that was our kid, what were we do in that situation? And, you know, I know I've said, and I think you have two, we would jump over whatever was keeping us from getting to that kid. It would be hard not to. Yeah. It would be hard not to. I'm not saying I would hurt somebody, but it would be hard not to want to go after the person that I knew murdered my child.
Starting point is 00:49:47 Yeah, I would hurt somebody. I think you probably would. I'd be okay going to jail for it. Brian's attorney opposed the video being used as evidence, but his motion to suppress it was denied. I mean, you're going to have to try that, right? Because if that video is allowed to be entered into evidence, it's game over. for your client. I mean, there's just no way around it. How is a jury going to view that videotape and not find these guys guilty? At both Brian and Tori's trials, the prosecution showed graphic photos of
Starting point is 00:50:23 Cassie's body. I'm sure that along with the videos help sway the jury in their favor. The prosecution also played videotapes of Brian's interviews, kind of showing how he, you know, had lied from one interview to the next. You almost want to like play a little bit of that interview. Play a little bit of the other tape. Yeah. Yep. Yep. So Brian's attorney's tactic was to basically use the statement that Brian had made that Tori threatened to kill him if he talked to the police. So he argued that this whole thing was Tori's idea. But again, Gibbs, with the videotape, I just don't see how a jury would buy that argument. This one didn't. They convicted Brian of first degree murder and conspiracy to commit first degree murder on April 17th, 2007.
Starting point is 00:51:18 Pretty quick. Six days. Yeah. Yeah, it didn't take long, but it's quite a bit of compelling evidence, right? You got the videotape. They were led to the site where, you know, the items used in the murder were dumped. Tori Adamchick's trial began. May 31st, 2007. His lawyer argued that the videotape shows that Brian killed Cassie, not Tori. So he basically did the exact same thing that Brian's attorney did. He just tried to blame it all on Brian. He said, Brian was a troubled team, fascinated by Columbine. According to the Times news, Tori's attorney said, the state will tell you, Brian Draper says, we just killed Stoddard.
Starting point is 00:52:09 It does not say we. It says, I killed Cassie. But what I found interesting Gibbs was that Tori's lawyer did not try to suppress the video. He actually used the video to try to show the jury that Brian acted alone. He also said that DNA on a t-shirt and a glove proved that Brian acted alone. He said, you will see that. He is obsessed with Columbine. You're going to hear that he had writings, fantasizing about school shootings.
Starting point is 00:52:43 All of the evidence is consistent with one murderer and they already caught him. His name is Brian Lee Draper. And again, I know I've said it before, Gist, but what else is this guy going to do? And I think Tori's attorney had the advantage of the fact that Brian had already been convicted. So I'm sure he tried to use that, right? They already convicted this guy. They already put him away. He's the one who did it.
Starting point is 00:53:13 Right. Set my guy free. But even with that advantage, it's not going to help their case. No. No, there's no way. Get that video out there. It's just so. Yeah, Tori was found guilty of first degree murder and conspiracy to commit first
Starting point is 00:53:26 degree murder on June 8th, 2007. So again, fairly quick. Neither one of these trials lasted more than. what about seven, eight days. On August 24th, Tori and Brian were sentenced to life in prison. They were both sentenced to a 30-year fixed sentence for murder and an indeterminate life sentence for the conspiracy charge. The judge said that their ultimate motive was famed.
Starting point is 00:53:52 They wanted to be famous like other serial killers and kill as many people as they could before they were caught. And they wanted to both know how it felt to actually kill. kill someone. The judge rejected the arguments that only one boy was responsible. He said, they both knew what they were doing. And again, I don't know how anybody would view the tape or even look at a transcript and not understand that. Tori made a motion to seek a more lenient sentence, but it was denied on March 10th, 2008. His attorney argued that he had neurocognitive deficits in his prefrontal lobe, which led to impaired judgment.
Starting point is 00:54:36 He said he was a boy with absolutely no hope. Every day the routine would be the same until he dies. Okay. I don't know if any of that is true. I don't know if he's throwing, you know what at the wall and seeing what sticks. I never saw this as a diagnosis. I never saw where a doctor testified. Maybe they did and I just missed it.
Starting point is 00:54:58 I don't think Cassie's grandfather thought the punishment was enough. He told the spokesman review. So what if Tori is in a tiny little room? My granddaughter will never leave her casket. That's pretty valid. Yeah, I think that's a normal reaction from the family member of a murdered victim. There's not going to be any sympathy for the fact that, you know, this kid's got to spend however much of his life sitting in a 8x or 8 by 6 or whatever it is. or whatever it is, it's not going to bring my granddaughter back to me.
Starting point is 00:55:36 I mean, they plan this murder by evidence of their video. Wasn't a spur of the moment thing. It wasn't like, oh, we walked in, we didn't know that we were going to do it. It just happened. No, it was planned. Oh, yeah. It was calculated. They'd been thinking about it for some time.
Starting point is 00:55:54 And not only that gives, but they had plans beyond this. And I think that scared a lot of people as well. Well, Cassie's family filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the school district on claims of negligence. They said that the administration should have known that Tori and Brian were threats to students at the school. The judge threw out their case in September 2010. And the Idaho Supreme Court ruled that the school district was not negligent because the actions were not foreseeable. And I get that. Now, if somebody had overheard them talking in the lunchroom and they had brought that to the attention of a school administrator, sure.
Starting point is 00:56:39 And that person did nothing. Then I think you're talking about a different situation. I agree. But if the school had no knowledge of it, it's kind of hard to say that they were negligent or that they did anything wrong. Brian appealed to the Supreme Court of Idaho. And that appeal was decided on September 13th, 2011. His conviction was upheld. In September 2013,
Starting point is 00:57:05 Tori sought post-conviction relief based on ineffective assistance of counsel and on the grounds of cruel and unusual punishment. Which we hear a lot of. We do. We do. The district court denied his claims. So his attorneys appealed again. The Idaho Supreme Court ruled that,
Starting point is 00:57:25 ruled that Tory failed to prove ineffective assistance of counsel. They also ruled that the court appropriately considered his age at sentencing. A life sentence for a minor under these conditions did not violate the Eighth Amendment. And on December 28th, 2017, the Idaho Supreme Court upheld the conviction of Tori Adamchick. Tori's mother Shannon wrote a book about the case titled The Guilty Enron. Gibson. She basically wrote this book about everything from her perspective. She told the Times news, it's important to me that people who want to know what happened have the opportunity to know what happened. Now, she insisted that Tori didn't participate in stabbing Cassie, but she doesn't deny
Starting point is 00:58:15 his involvement in the conspiracy to kill her. She says that the physical evidence of stabbing points only to Brian, which I think is a point that Tori's attorney tried to make it trial. She doesn't think her son is completely innocent. He did lie to the police. He did drive them to the crime scene and he helped bury evidence. But she said Tori was just acting on his desire to make a horror movie. It was Brian Draper who came up with the plot to kill Cassie. They talked about murder because it gave them thrills. But Tori was, you know, was only pretending and he wasn't really going to hurt anyone. So he was only pretending on the tape, what he said?
Starting point is 00:59:01 That he stabbed Cassie? Mm-hmm. Yeah. Now, we just talked about it earlier. Gibbs, right? How does a parent react when their child murders someone? I think it's going to be tough to believe in your heart that your child really did this. Now, I think most people disagree with.
Starting point is 00:59:22 Shannon. They think she's biased, obviously, because she's Tori's mother. Cassie's family experienced extreme depression after her death. Her aunt lost her job. Her cousin tried to take her own life. We talked about it gives. What's it like for a 13 year old girl to discover the dead body of her 16 year old cousin? Yeah. How difficult would that be? And then to continue to live in that house for however long they did, knowing that that's where she died. Yeah, that's true. We don't know how long they live there. Frank Contreras left his family after he struggled with alcoholism. He felt like he couldn't love his family anymore.
Starting point is 01:00:02 I think the Contreras family thought that they were living in their dream home. But obviously, after this happened, it turned into a nightmare. They bought the home in 2005. They'd only been living there about a year when the murder happened. They struggled to sell the house even at a discounted price. Tori and Brian are both 31 years old and are both incarcerated at Idaho State Correctional Institution. As we wrap up this case, I think it's very difficult for people to believe that no one else
Starting point is 01:00:39 noticed that these two boys were planning a gruesome murder. They had talked about it openly, maybe not specifically to people, but it doesn't seem as though they were trying to hide it all that much. If they're sitting at, you know, let's say a lunch table talking about the fact that they're going to kill someone, there's no doubt they were obsessed with violent horror movies. Again, I don't want to put too much stock into that. I like horror movies. My kids love horror movies.
Starting point is 01:01:11 We watch them together. You guys do, yeah. I never sit there thinking that these movies are going to influence my kids to go do something bad. I don't think that. I think you're worried more about me influence, though. I'm very worried about your influence. Now, what I do think should have been very worrisome is the fact that Brian was obsessed
Starting point is 01:01:33 with the Columbine school shooting. You know, we talked about the website that he had. It looked as though it was a good thing until you got to the bottom. And there will be more victims. Again, a little website, I don't know who else would have seen. it. If anybody had, I don't know how you take that as anything other than an ominous kind of premonition or a warning that, hey, something bad is about to happen. They talked openly about killing at school, which is probably what led to that lawsuit or... Yes, I'm sure it did. I'm sure
Starting point is 01:02:11 that was probably the basis for it. Like you said, if an administrator didn't hear that or they were not told about it. Yeah. Then really what could they have done because they had no reason to do anything? It's a tough case, though. I mean, there's no way around that. You know, you and I talk a lot about being parents. A lot of people listening right now are parents.
Starting point is 01:02:36 I think as a parent, you're always trying to walk that line between giving your kids a little space, giving them a little freedom. But at the same time, you know, kind of monitoring who they're hanging out with what they're up to. It's a tough job, right? Being a parent. Sure is. You're not always going to be liked because your kids aren't always going to like, you know, the, the angle that you take. Most kids don't really like you prying into their life, right?
Starting point is 01:03:10 But, I mean, I think as a parent you got to do some of that. Sometimes you do. I like to know who my children's friends are. I like to know what they're, what type of people they are. Well, sure. Because you know there's always those influences. I think one big takeaway from this case and,
Starting point is 01:03:28 and it's a takeaway from a number of cases that we do involving kids, involving school is that, you know, kids have to know. And I think they know this today much more so than they did 10, 15, 20, 30 years ago, they have to know that you've got to report people. If you overhear somebody talking about committing violent acts towards another person, you can't just blow that stuff off anymore.
Starting point is 01:03:59 I'm not sure that you really should have ever done that. But I think today more than ever, you can't let that slide. No. Best alert somebody. Yeah. And again, we've talked about it. It's tough. If it's your friend, you know, you don't want to lose.
Starting point is 01:04:13 that friendship, but do you really want to be the person that knew something was going to happen and didn't do what you could to stop it? Yeah, because you're potentially saving lives, but also helping that friend out by not allowing them to do something that is going to ruin their lives and others. Yeah, that's a good point as well. But that's it for our case on the murder of Cassie Joe Stoddard, tough all the way around. Sure is. We've got some voice. Mel, you want to check those out? Let's hear them. Hey, guys. I am calling from Vancouver, BC.
Starting point is 01:04:49 My name is Ashley. I just want to give a shout out to you guys that you guys are really, I love your guys podcast. I started doing a podcast a few years ago, and I think you guys are fabulous at it. But I really wanted to actually give a suggestion
Starting point is 01:05:05 if you guys could look into and do a podcast episode on the case that was from Calgary, Alberta. It happened to about five, six years ago. It was of Douglas Garland. He had murdered some grandparents and their grandson. It's actually a horrific one of Calgary's most horrific murder murders.
Starting point is 01:05:30 And it was completely, it was very traumatizing for the community. And that I remember it all too well, unfortunately. But I was curious if you guys would do a podcast or not. And anyways, thank you guys so much for your fabulous podcast. Take care. All right. Thanks for the voicemail. And I will make sure that one is on the list.
Starting point is 01:05:50 I can't say I'm familiar with it. What I will say is we have some amazing listeners up in Calgary. We do. Some really good friends also up that way. Hello, Mike and Gibby. This is Mel from Denver. I am listening to the Howard Elkins story right now. And I had to call and stop in the middle.
Starting point is 01:06:12 because I am rewatching the Dexter series in preparation for the new season that's coming out. And I just thought it was pretty odd that there really is a barrel girl. You guys keep your own time ticking and have a nice day. Right. Yeah, brutal story. It is. That Howard Elkins one. I am excited for Dexter. You know that.
Starting point is 01:06:34 Dexter is one of my favorite shows. I do need to go back and watch them all. But I don't know when that's coming out. think it's been pushed back probably due to COVID or something. I don't know what the date is for the release on that. I know you're excited. I see all the plastic that you bought. Yeah,
Starting point is 01:06:51 I like to put it down in case things go bad between you and me. Yeah. During the taping of an episode. Trying to get me to walk over to that area, but I won't. Just in case. You know, I'd like to be prepared. Hi. My name's Michelle, and I am from Leibet, Texas.
Starting point is 01:07:08 And I've just recently started binging your turn. crime episodes. I listen to the new one, but then I go back and listen to all the old ones, and I've just finished your James Rupert podcast, and Gibby is talking about the movie Bernie. I don't know if y'all actually know that that's based on a true crime in Texas, where a funeral home director befriended an elderly lady and follows that story pretty closely that Gibby described. Keep up to good work, and I enjoy.
Starting point is 01:07:42 your podcast, thanks. Yeah, so you will probably hear it as you get further on in the episodes, the older episodes. Yeah. But we actually did a full Patreon episode. We did on Bernie Tita and the murders and all that. Hey, Mike and Jimmy. This is Tiffany from Florida. I am a new listener, but I am totally addicted.
Starting point is 01:08:05 I listen to you guys all the time. I had actually emailed you a couple weeks ago about a couple of suggestions. And I am catching up still, and I just listened to the episode on H.H. Holmes. What a mystery, mysterious guy. I actually called in because there was a show on the History Channel a couple years ago with his relative who wanted to resume his body. He had a theory that H.H. Holmes and Jack the Ripper are the same person. It was a couple years ago. I don't remember all the details, but you get a chance to entirely recommend watching it because some of the connections he made,
Starting point is 01:08:42 is incredible. Anyways, I love you guys, love your podcast, love the show. Stay safe and keep your one time ticking. Awesome. Thank you for the voicemail. We actually had a lot of people give us, reach out to us and ask why we didn't talk about the H.H. Holmes Jack the Ripper connection. I know a lot of people have theorized that. I don't know if the majority of experts, I'll call them, or, you know, people that are really in the know, believe that's the case. I, I think that's kind of why we left it out. Plus, it was a long episode anyway. And you can't put everything in.
Starting point is 01:09:18 All right. No mail bag this week, but a clarification from last week. Nicole from Australia sent us the big bags of Tim Tams. Like some Tim Tams. We love our Tim Tams. The bags, as we noticed, also had animals fornicating on it. I thought it was hilarious. We got a big kick out of.
Starting point is 01:09:38 I didn't say it last week. Right. But there was no note. So I went off the shipping label, which said I still love Australia. So that's who I gave the credit to. Turns out that's the shipping company, I guess. So I got a note from Nicole. She's like, no, no, no.
Starting point is 01:09:54 It was from me. Yeah, I just wanted to clarify that. I guess the note didn't make it into the box. Or maybe I threw it away without seeing it. Appreciate it, though. Yeah, we do appreciate it. But that's it, buddy, for another episode of True Crime all the time. So for Mike and Ghiby, stay safe and keep your own time tickets.
Starting point is 01:10:12 Thank you.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.