True Crime with Kimbyr - Part 1: Mysterious "Grilling" For Days Lead Police to A Horrific Murder - Tynesha Stewart

Episode Date: November 7, 2025

In this chilling episode of True Crime with Kimbyr, Kimbyrleigha unravels the haunting case of Tynesha Stewart a bright college student whose sudden disappearance led to a nightmare no one could imagine. As police followed the trail of a “grilling” that went on for days, the horrifying truth behind her murder was revealed. What drove someone so close to commit such an unthinkable act? And how did investigators finally piece together the clues? Dive into this tragic story of betrayal, obsession, and justice on True Crime with Kimbyr. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Where there's smoke, there's fire. You've probably heard that saying, and usually it's just a metaphor for suspicious rumors and buried secrets. But in some of the most unsettling crimes, that old phrase turned literal. Investigators and bystanders caught the scent of smoke or saw it billowing out of chimneys or from a roadside and discovered something far more sinister. Hidden remains and horrific murders, like in the case of Chandler-Halderson.

He killed both of his parents, dismembered their bodies, and attempted to burn them in the family fireplace. He thought he was smart, that he would cover up his crime and everything would just become ashes. But ring camera footage showed the smoke and the flames coming from the fireplace, and his sickening deeds were exposed. Or what about the firefighters who get a call for a car fire,

thinking it's the usual mechanical malfunction, and when they arrived, they saw a burning figure covered in flames walking toward them in the dark. It turned out to be 19-year-old Jessica Chambers. who was burned alive and left. Yamava Resort and Casino at San Manuel is California's number one entertainment destination

for today's superstars. Catch the Jonas Brothers return to the Yamava Theater stage on April 30th, the powerful vocals of Demi Lovato on May 17th, and the signature Southern Country Rock of Eric Church on July 19th. Tickets on sale now at Yamavatheater.com, only at Yamava Resort and Casino, celebrating its 40th anniversary.

You in? Must be 21 to enter. for dead. An unbelievable tragedy. But fire is terrifying on its own. It devours everything in its path, leaves near irreversible damage, and when it's used to erase evidence and cover up a crime, the horror only multiplies. Today's case begins in an ordinary apartment complex, neighbors who come together for weekend cookouts, sharing their grilled meals with one another, totally normal. Until one day, neighbors at the Red Oak Place apartments begin to notice a very putrid smell in the air, some black smoke coming from the second-story unit, Unit 224.

A resident whose balcony faced the unit where the smoke was coming from saw flames rising up from not one, but two barbecue girls. At first, sure, it was a little odd and over the top, but residents figured it would be over soon, but it wasn't. In fact, this person was grilling non-stop all day and throughout the night for days on end. That's when the awful smell really started to bother those closest to the balcony. One neighbor was disturbed by how the blaze was alarmingly close to the balcony's roof. He kept thinking, this isn't cooking. It's burning. There's a difference. That neighbor eventually called 911, but by the time firefighters arrived, the flames had calmed, and the occupant in Unit 224 assured them that everything was under control. Even the apartment's leasing agent

took notice of the dense smoke and intense heat and confronted the occupant about this seemingly odd activity. Another resident who would play video games and grill out with the same individual grew suspicious after being excluded from these more intense supposed cookouts that he was having. When he asked about it, the occupant claimed to be preparing food for a wedding. And a day or so later, another tenant saw the grills, still reeking of char and being hauled off to a nearby trash bin. It left the entire complex on edge. They were dreading to find out the unsettling truth behind those relentless flames, but since it stopped, and the authorities seemed to clear the occupant of anything suspicious, everyone seemed to just let it go and move on. But soon this mundane

apartment setting transformed into a chilling crime scene, unraveling exactly why, where there's smoke, there's fire, because it became more than just a cliche. It became the catalyst for uncovering a horrific murder. Hi everyone, welcome back to my channel, and if you have never been here before, I'm Kimberlea. It's nice to finally meet you. Today I'm going to be taking you to Houston, Texas, and as a matter of fact, every week we go on a journey to a new place. I want you to imagine for a second that you are a 19 year old, you're home from spring break. You're excited for a week of fun, catching up with friends, and most importantly, getting ready to see Beyonce live. It's supposed to be the best night ever. You're texting your friends, you're making plans, you're getting

your hair done, just normal teenage girl things. But then out of nowhere, you stop replying. Your phone goes silent. Your best friends? They don't hear from you. Your mom? You never miss a check-in, but you're not answering. Your college professors, well, you don't even show up for class.

It's as though you just vanished. Your family knows something is wrong. You would never disappear like this. You're a girl who has everything planned, the one who never leaves anyone hanging. But when they go to the last place you were seen, your ex-boyfriend's apartment, He says, oh yeah, she was here, but she left last night on foot.

And that is when the real nightmare begins. Because one by one, the red flags start stacking up. A fire in an apartment. Neighbors noticing an awful smell. The bathtub running non-stop. The garbage disposal running for hours. And then there were those barbecue grills. The ones that were being used nonstop for days.

By the time police start putting the pieces together, it's much too late. What started as a missing person's case has become something far worse, something so unthinkable that even seasoned detectives would later say they'd never seen anything like it. This is the disturbing and tragic case of Tynisha Stewart. Before we get into the nightmare that unfolded, let's talk about who Tynisha really was, because she wasn't just a victim in a true crime story. She was a daughter, a sister, a best friend, and a young woman with big dreams. Tynisha Devana Stewart was born on July 10th of 1987 to her mother, Gail Shields, and her childhood was imperfect. Her parents divorced when she was young, and when she was just six years old, she faced her very first heartbreak.

Her father passed away from an aneurysm. It was a loss that no child should have to go through. But even then, Tinesia was resilient. She grew up in Bordersville, Texas, a tight-knit black community, filled with small businesses and deep cultural roots. The kind of place where family isn't just blood. It's the people who surround you. Tynisha was the fourth of six children, and she had a personality that stood out.

Her older sister, Gayla, described her as the girly girl of the family, organized, meticulous, and always put together. Gail, on the other hand, was laid back and not so much into girly things, so in a way, they balanced each other out. But beneath all of that, Tynisha struggled with something that a lot of young girls do. Insecurity. She often compared herself to others, wondering if she measured up. But here's the thing.

Tynisha didn't let those insecurities define her. She transformed them into confidence. She became the kind of girl who set her goals and then crushed them. She had big dreams, and she was determined to make something of herself. She loved music, and I mean, she really, really loved music. Growing up in Houston during the rise of Destiny's Child, she and her friends started their own girl group called Four-Part Harmony. Tynisha didn't just like her.

singing, she was extremely talented. She had a voice that would fill up a room, and people described her voice as powerful, rich, and impossible to ignore. Kind of like her presence. It was magnetic. People were just drawn to her, not just because she was talented and beautiful, but because she was kind, funny, and full of life. She was also an overachiever. When it came to school, Tynisha took her studies very seriously. She attended Nimitz High School, the same school of some really big names, like her uncles, Jason and Aaron Glenn, both of whom played in the NFL. Jason was a linebacker for the Minnesota Vikings, and Aaron was a defensive back for the Dallas Cowboys. Talent ran in their family. The school had a history of producing top-tier athletes, including

Major League Baseball player Michael Born and WNBA star Brittany Griner. But sports, not for Tyneisha. She wasn't about the sweaty life. She said it herself when coach Debbie Jackson asked her, why don't you try out? Her answer, I don't like to sweat. Instead, she took on a managerial role for the basketball team. And even though she wasn't on the court, she was running the show behind the scenes, keeping everything organized and under control, which was completely aligned with her personality traits. And when she wasn't managing the team, she was stealing the spotlight in another way by singing the national anthem at games. You could just picture the pack gym, a hush falling over the crowd before the game started, and then Tynisha's voice filling the eight.

She wasn't just involved. She was everywhere. She was a high achiever balancing honor courses, extracurricular activities, and a part-time job, all while maintaining a thriving social life. The principal of her high school said that Tenisha was one of the most driven students he had ever worked with. He said she had a plan and did something every day to make it happen. She wasn't shy about reminding the staff what they needed to do to help her succeed either, but her biggest goal was Texas A&M University. She wanted to follow in the footsteps of her uncles, but not in sports. Instead, she wanted to be a civil and chemical engineer,

and she wasn't just dreaming about it. She was making it happen. Tainisha graduated in the top 3% of her class cum laude, and she earned multiple scholarships, totaling $40,000, including the prestigious Linda Larell Scholarship, which was only awarded to 15 students out of hundreds of applicants. Linda herself, the former KPRCTV anchorwoman behind the scholarship, described Tyneisha's drive and determination as phenomenal.

Tanya Driver from Texas A&M's Department of Multicultural Affairs recalled meeting Tynisha during an outreach event. In fact, Tynisha was the first student to show up so early that the announcement hadn't even finished. This was a girl with a future. This was a girl who was going places, and that's what makes this story and what happened to her so much more devastating. For all of Tynisha's confidence, her ambition,

and her larger-than-life personality, There was one part of her life where she was still vulnerable, in love. Tainisha's first real boyfriend was Curtis, a handsome, well-liked, popular guy that a lot of girls at her high school had a crush on. But his attention, it was always on Tynisha. Curtis was the type of boyfriend who did everything right. He opened doors for her. He held her hand. He treated her like she was the most important person in the world.

They were the kind of couple that looked perfect together, especially at homecoming, at school events, and pep rallies. But here's the thing about young love. It's passionate, but it's also unpredictable. Their relationship turned on and off for a while, and they had their ups and downs, but Curtis was always there. He loved her, he respected her, and he wanted the best for her. But during her junior year, something changed. While working part-time at Pizza Hut, Tanisha met someone new, Timothy Shepard. He was a delivery driver, he was nice, dependable, and handsome, and for reasons that, But even she might not have fully understood at the time, Tenisha decided to end things with Curtis for good and start dating Tim.

The breakup was really tough on Curtis. He really loved Tenisha. And this thing with Tim, it wasn't just a casual high school romance either. It was more serious than that. Tanisha's family took a liking towards Tim right away, especially her mother, Gail, and her younger siblings. They thought there was a real chance that Tim and Tynisha were going to make it last, a forever type of love.

He was quite charming. Tim didn't just date Tynisha. He really became part of her family. He was at their family events. He was hanging out at their house, spending time with her younger siblings, and her little brother and sisters, they looked up to him. Eventually, the two moved in together. And when Tainisha graduated from high school in 2006 and

2006 A&M University that fall, she and Tim decided to stay together and try to make the relationship work long distance. But there was one thing that nobody knew. Tim was eight years older than Tynisha. He was 24 and she was only 16 when they first met. And you know what? She never told anyone. Maybe she thought it didn't matter.

Maybe she didn't want to deal with all the questions or maybe. Deep down, she knew that maybe not everyone was going to prove. But the relationship ended before Tanya could even think about the future. Tim broke it off with her. They planned on making things work apart. But Tim's ex-girlfriend came back into the picture. and they got together and Tynisha was heartbroken. But she was always moving forward.

She had a vision for her own future, regardless of who was by her side. And when she went off to Texas A&M, her world opened up. For the first time, she was truly independent. She was surrounded by new people, new experiences, new possibilities. But as time passed, guess what? Tim realized he made a big mistake.

He missed Tinesia and he wanted her back. He called it off with his ex. He tried it off with his ex. He tried to make. traveled to Tynisha's college and he surprised her. She was, of course, very happy to see Tim, but definitely surprised. She had been talking to other guys by that time,

and there really was never a shortage because Tynisha was naturally beautiful, and it was also her personality that drew people in. But she and Tim talked and they realized there was still something there, so they got back together. While she and Tim tried to make it work long distance one more time, the reality was, Tynisha was changing. She was growing. She was meeting new people, experiencing life in a way that made her question whether holding onto the past was really worth it.

And that's when she met Mark, a fellow student at A&M, and Mark was different. He was her age, her pace, her energy, and while part of her still loved Tim, she also knew she wanted to experience college and other people. So after about two years of being with Tim, Tenisha made the choice. She decided to end the time. She decided to end the time. things with him for good and started hanging out with Mark. But they were taking it slow. He was a friend first, and they were just enjoying each other's company more than anything else. But here's the thing. Tainisha didn't just cut him off. You know, sometimes that happens in breakups where you never speak to your ex again, but that wasn't who Tanisha was. She believed that just because love changes, it doesn't have to disappear. So she stayed in touch with Tim, just like she still talked to Curtis and other ex-boyfriends because in her mind, love and friendship could

coexist. And speaking of friendships, she made so many new friends in college. She shared a dorm room with Lindsay Stuyken and a suite with Megan Wallace, two girls who quickly became more like sisters than just roommates. Megan said that Tanisha was the person she could always count on to brighten her day. And Lindsay, the one thing that stuck out to her was that Tynesia was unapologetically joyful. Tynisha lived by the saying, dance like nobody's watching, and she did. everywhere. She even sang in the shower, even when her sweetmates and their friends were around. She would laugh loudly, fully without hesitation, and she didn't just go through the motions of

college. She embraced every minute. At first, of course, Tainisha didn't know much about A&M's traditions, but it didn't take long before she was fully immersed in Aggie culture. She loved saying howdy to people on campus, because at A&M, being an Aggie wasn't just about where you went to school. It was about who you were. And one of her other favorite traditions, the midnight yell. This is a massive pep rally that happened the night before home football games, and sometimes she and her roommates would head to Kyle Field to scream their longs out with thousands of other students. But if they couldn't make it, they would actually hold their very own midnight yell right in their dorm room. Tanisha knew how to have fun, but she was also

laser focused on her future. One of her psychology professors, Robert W. Birch, said that she had something that most students didn't. She had this openness and honesty that made her stand out. She participated in the class in ways that most students didn't. And by March of 2007, Tainisha was thriving. She had adjusted to college life. She had an exciting future ahead. And most importantly, Tainisha was happy. She was counting down the days to spring break. She was eager to reunite with her hometown friends back in Houston. And the biggest plan of all, she was going to see Beyonce live, something that she'd been looking forward to for weeks. She was still seeing and they'd been planning this for a while.

Her friends were all coming back home from college. It was going to be one of the best spring breaks ever. The concert was on March 15th at the Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo at the NRG Stadium, and she also had plans to travel to Padre Island for the last part of spring break and then returned to campus. On March 14th of 2007, she was back in Houston and Tyneisha spent the evening doing what teenage girls do best, getting ready for the next day's festivities. She and her friends did each other's hair.

They shared inside jokes. They laughed until their stomachs hurt and caught up on everything they had missed while being apart. She spent the night at her friend Lois Greenwood's apartment. And that night, it was supposed to be a night filled with memories. But instead, it was the last time anyone would hear from Tynisha. Later that night, she called her mother Gail, and she asked her, can I borrow the car for the concert tomorrow?

And Gail agreed. She was happy that her daughter was enjoying her break. but neither Gail nor Tynisha could have had any idea that this would be their very last conversation. That's when everything just stopped. First, it was the concert. Tynisha never showed up. But not only that, she wasn't at Lois's apartment when she woke up.

There was no sign of Tanisha at all. It's like she vanished. And next it was her phone. Everyone began calling Tanisha to find out what was happening and where she was, but no one was getting an answer. And she didn't respond to text either. She didn't answer, call, she didn't check in with her mom or anyone else.

For some people that might not seem that strange, maybe she was just busy, maybe she wanted space. But this was Tynisha. She was always connected. She didn't just go off the grid like this. And that's when Lois realized Tainisha's phone was actually still in her apartment. Now that was odd.

Who would leave without their phone? Where was she? At first they tried to come up with reasonable explanations. Maybe she stepped out for some fresh air. She's on a walk. Maybe she's with Mark, but she wasn't. And it was getting later and later, and the concert was that night,

and that was the next sign that something wasn't right. She would never just skip the Beyonce concert. These were plans that were made well in advance. All of her friends were concerned, especially, when Tynisha never showed up, and by the next morning, Friday, March 16th, her friends were really worried. Lois got in touch with Gail,

and she said she hadn't heard from her daughter since Wednesday night. And by that afternoon, Her family knew that something was very wrong. And by the end of the day, panic was setting in. Her mom started calling everyone, classmates, friends, anyone who might have seen or spoken to Tynisha. Her sister, Gaila was surprised and no one had heard from her, and she remembered something really eerie.

A few days before this, Gaila had a nightmare about her sister. She even told Tynisha about it. In the nightmare, Tynisha was getting beat up by these jealous girls, and they actually ended her life. and they hid her body and no one could find her. Of course, it wasn't real, and Tainisha told Gayla, don't worry, nothing is going to happen to me. But the fact that she was essentially now vanished,

it's like the nightmare was coming true. Gayla decides that she's going to reach out to Tim, Tainisha's ex, just in case maybe he'd heard from her since she was back in town. When he was told that Tanisha was missing, he's like, what? What do you mean she's missing? Now, he admitted that she reached out to him on Thursday morning,

but that was the last he'd heard from her. That would have been the morning before the concert. So now it seems like Tim might have been the last person to be in contact with Tynisha. So her family didn't wait another minute. They started their investigation on their own with Gail going straight to Tim's, his apartment on Red Oak Drive,

to speak to him face to face and gather additional information, even though everyone and Tynisha's family liked him, that is in the beginning. As the relationship began to break down, they weren't as fond of him anymore. Neither Gail nor Gaila trusted him, and they couldn't really put their finger on exactly why,

but it was just a gut feeling. They were both very protective over Tynisha, so it could have been that, but there was just something about him that made them uneasy, and now that she was missing, that feeling intensified. Once Gail got to Tim's apartment, she knocked on his door, and she wanted to know details about the last time he saw Tanisha.

Tim explained, they chatted the night of the 14th after she and her friends were done hanging out and by 2.30 that morning, they decided they were going to meet up. He said he drove over to Lois's apartment, picked up Tynisha, and brought her back to his place around 3 o'clock in the morning. But he said while they were on the way to his apartment, she got a phone call and he knew it was a guy. But wanted to know why a guy would be calling Tainisha at that hour, and Tynisha didn't want to talk about it. She planned to hang out with Tim that night, have fun with him, discuss it maybe in the morning.

she didn't want to ruin their night. But once they got inside Tim's apartment, he said it turned into Tynisha just shutting down. What was supposed to be a good time reconnecting for the night and just hanging out, the two of them began bickering over the phone call. Tainisha wanted to table the conversation until the next morning, and Tim wanted to discuss it right then and there so they could resolve it and get on with their night.

But what Tim told Tynisha's mother next caused a lot of concern. He said, she left. That's right. She just stormed out of his apartment. sometime around 4 or 5 o'clock in the morning, and she left on foot, alone, in the middle of the night. Tim did even seem concerned at the time. There was no urgency to make sure she was okay. But it's true.

She's from Houston. She's familiar with this area, and it's a safe part of town. Gail knew her daughter. She knew Tynisha didn't even like walking across the street alone. There was no way. She just walked away in the middle of the night. Something wasn't right.

And by Monday, March 19th, Gail was filling out an official missing persons report at the police station. She provided the officers with the description. Tenisha was 19 years old. She was five feet tall and approximately 120 pounds with black hair, brown eyes, and tattoos. There was one on her right hip. It was of her nickname Ty, another of an apple in the center of her back, and a butterfly tattoo on the left side of her back. She was last seen by Lois wearing a white shirt and rainbow-colored pajama pants. Her longtime friend Kenesha said, that she spoke to Tanisha right before she went over to Tim's, and she even questioned her about why she was meeting up with him.

Tanisha explained they were just going to hang out, they were just going to talk, get some more closure about the end of the relationship before she went back to campus. Her friends thought that Tim may have dropped her off somewhere alone after they got into this argument with no way for her to contact anyone. So of course, Gail expected the police to just jump into action,

but instead they kind of just brushed it off. They were like she's a teenager on spring break. She probably just needed some sort of space. Space? This wasn't a girl who needed any space. Gail knew that. She was supposed to be at a concert. She had classes to go back to. She had a life to live. And now she was just gone? A police officer just handed Gail a card. Can you imagine being a mother and they're just like, here you go. You know, we'll look into it. That's what they told her. And they just sent her home. And it angered me when I heard this. She's a teen. I know she's legally an adult by law, but she's a teenager. She's only 19.

She's alone, and days had passed, and nothing was happening. There were no answers. Tynisha's sister Gayla was particularly frustrated with the lack of action from law enforcement. She was trying her hardest to go through the proper channels, but it felt like no one was taking them seriously. As Friday turned into Saturday and then Sunday, Tainisha's family and friends became more and more worried. They knew the time was passing and it was critical, so Tanisha's family took matters into

their own hands. They were actually into true crime. They watched enough episodes of shows like Dateline to know how quickly a missing person's case can turn into something way worse. So they were calling hospitals, they were calling jails, they called her old classmates, neighbors, anyone who might have seen her. And when that wasn't enough, they actually started to search the street themselves. They printed flyers, they knocked on doors, they went into wooded areas, even if it was dangerous, they went into bayous, even sewers. Desperate to find any clue to Tynisha's whereabouts. Spring break was now coming to an end. They thought, was there a possibility she might have gone out to Padraig Island with friends from college,

forgot her phone, but surely she would have used someone else's phone to check it. So the wait continued. But when Tynisha didn't show back up at class at Texas A&M following spring break, their fears grew. Her loved ones were still without any police assistance. And so they organized the vigil at Abiding Word Lutheran Church to bring awareness to her to her decision. The community showed up in force. They handed out flyers. They were rowling for her safe return. It definitely got some attention that led in the right direction because Deputy J.D.,

who worked in the Harris County Sheriff's Office, missing persons unit, received a call from his supervisor about the case. And he was instructed to go over to that church and see what was going on. The louder you are, the more you can't be ignored. Remember that. By the time Deputy J.D. pulled into the church parking lot, the scene was chaos. Tenetia's family and friends rushed over to him. Their voices were all overlapping. They were screaming.

They were frantic. They were desperate. They were saying things like, she wouldn't just disappear. Have you checked with her friends? You have to do something. And through the commotion, one voice stood out, and that was Tanisha's cousin.

She was yelling. She was last seen at Timothy Shepard's apartment. And they realized that his apartment complex was right down the street. So without wasting any time, JD got all the information, crossed the street, and knocked on Timothy's door.

in Unit 224, but there was no answer. The hallway was quiet until a neighbor said that they remembered hearing gunshots coming from the nearby woods. And this happened recently, like in the last couple days. They were concerned that maybe Tiny Shum might have been injured or worse. So Deputy J.D called in canine units

to search the wooded area across from the apartment complex. Officers spread out with the canine's noses to the ground, and almost immediately something was detected. It was the unmistakable stench of decomposition. 100 yards in, and the smell was stronger. 150 yards in, and Deputy J.D. was bracing himself. He was thinking, this is it. We're going to find her. But when they reached the source, it wasn't Tynisha. It was actually a dead animal. But for a brief second, there was this feeling of relief, but then it turned into dread, because Tynisha was still missing. So the deputy

returned to the church parking lot again, and he was swarmed with community members and nearby residents that were trying to provide clues, details, and tips. Someone that lived in Tim's complex said, there was a fire in his unit a few days ago. Deputy J.D. was like a fire? And apparently just days before Tainitia was reported missing,

firefighters had been called out there to see what was going on. Neighbors had been concerned because there was heavy smoke, billowing from the back of 224 for hours and hours on end. So Ponderosa volunteer fire department responded to this call, and when they knocked on Tim's door, he refused to open it. A deputy finally came out and they were banging like crazy, and there was still no answer, but then when he finally didn't answer the door, firefighters found him just cooking meat on his balcony.

He was cooking on a couple of grills side by side. However, what struck responders as strange was what they found inside the bathtub. There was a bunch of wall. and melting ice and more meat. They asked him, what is all this for? And he said he was thawing it out for a barbecue. The firefighter said that the cuts

really didn't look like anything they'd ever seen before. They didn't know if it was ribs, chicken, sausage. They had no idea. There were also three small burned chickens sitting on Tim's stove. But they were called there for a fire, not a crime, and it wasn't a crime to be cutting and grilling meat in your own home. So they just left.

And Tim, just went back to his normal life, or at least he'd tried to, until more knocks came to his door. Then phone calls nonstop, and finally, Tanish's cousin tells Deputy J.D. that Tim was on the phone right then and there, willing to meet with him, and it wasn't long, before Timothy Shepard was standing right in that church parking lot.

And to everyone's shock, this man was calm. He wasn't anxious, he wasn't panicked, he was collected and cooperative. But J.D. wasn't taking any chances. He wanted to protect him because this crowd was growing. So he placed him in the backseat of his patrol car, and Tim didn't protest. He didn't even ask any questions. He just sat there quietly just waiting.

And soon, two new faces arrived, Detective Sidney Miller and Captain Dennis Fields, a veteran investigator. This was their chance. They had the last person to see Tanisha right there. So they escorted Tim to the police station for questioning. But the moment Tim opened his mouth, they heard exactly. the same story that he gave to Tanisha's mom. Nothing changed. He was completely composed and he repeated that he picked Tanisha up from Lois's apartment in the early morning hours of March 15th and maybe four or five a.m. He admitted they got into an argument, but according to Tim,

Tynisha left on her own accord, just walked out of his apartment on foot with no explanation and no phone and no car. Detective Miller considered the possibility that Tynisha might have been abducted by a stranger after leaving Tim's apartment. I mean, she was all alone. She had no way to get in touch with anyone. She could have been wandering aimlessly and picked up by someone. The thing is, the detective also knew, statistically speaking, harm more often comes from someone the victim knows.

But with no body, no hard evidence, no witnesses, and not knowing what happened to Tynisha, Timothy Shepard was allowed to leave. He walked away as a free man. But as he did, Tyneusia's family was still out there. They were begging for her safe return. Tynisha's family was hitting a wall with the police. The community was outraged by the lack of apparent action,

and they also knew the media's bias. News channels often prioritized missing white women. And as a young black woman, Tynisha's case sadly faced an uphill battle for attention. Tynisha's family was so broken. They really felt like nobody cared, and that is heartbreaking. However, her family had an advantage that many others didn't. Her uncles.

They were former NFL stars. They had big followings. Jason and Aaron Glenn used their platforms to appeal for her safe return, to get some attention on her case. And that is when something shifted. Tainisha's sister Gayla got connected with someone who could make even more noise, Quinell X. Now, if you don't know that name, Quinell X is a civil rights activist. He's known for stepping in when Black families or other marginalized

communities feel ignored by law enforcement. He becomes their voice. He had a reputation for holding police departments accountable. And when Gaila reached out, she was desperate. She told him that she knew in her heart, that her sister was still out there, that she was still alive, and that she couldn't bring herself to entertain the possibility that she wasn't. She knew they needed to hurry. Quinell listened, and he stepped in. He promised he would do everything in his power to uncover the truth. As Quinell started to speak up about Tanisha's case. That's when police finally started to take it seriously. It's about time, right? It had been nearly a week since Tanisha disappeared. Detective Miller started taking a closer look at the 911 call that had come in three days prior to Tanisha's mom officially reporting

her missing. This was the one about the fire at Tim's apartment. The caller Louis Evans, whose balcony faces Tim's, mentioned the smell was like burning hair, singed flat. There was just something very unnatural, and the flames were so high he thought it was going to catch the building on fire. Detective Miller went out there to speak with nearby residents. 18-year-old James Herbert told the detective that he and Tim they played video games together, and they often grilled together on a number of occasions. So much so, James actually left his grill over at Tim's, and they would use it along with Tim's smoker. But on March 16th, James noticed that Tim was just grilling all by himself, and he wanted to do that Tim was just grilling all by himself, and he wanted to be

wondered why wasn't he invited over? So he approached him and Tim said he was catering for a wedding for extra cash so James wasn't allowed to have any of the meat even if there were leftovers which was really odd since Tim was always very generous he shared anything that he grilled and he was also using James's grill. Clemencia Whitaker also recalled a smell that was so intense it filled her entire apartment and it reminded her of burning tires when she said something to Tim he said that it was all the spices that he was using. But she insisted it did not smell like spices, and it didn't even smell like meat.

She had never smelled anything like it before. And then there was another neighbor, Ashley Smith, who mentioned something else. Tim had actually come over to her house for some favors. He wanted to borrow a broom, some foil, and some seasoning. Ashley didn't think anything of it at the time. But now it made her stomach turn. She told Detective Miller, he didn't want me to go inside his apartment

like I usually did. And when Ashley did manage to step closely inside that door frame through the threshold, she noticed the strong smell of ammonia and bleach. Later Ashley said, she saw another neighbor about to eat something off of Tim's grill and she stopped him and she said, I wouldn't eat that if I were you. There was something that just didn't seem right about it. But it was when Deon Whitaker said that she saw Tim carrying both of those barbecue grills to the apartment's trash area to dispose of them that Detective Miller thought it by bit, the pieces were starting to paint, a very disturbing picture. Would Timothy looking more like a suspect now?

Detective Miller begins digging deeper into his background. He came from what appeared to be a respectable family with a good reputation in the community. His mother worked as a pharmacist, his stepfather was employed by Dr. Pepper. But tragically, Timothy's biological father passed away when he was just two months old, so we never got to really meet him or have a relationship with him. The Shepherd family regularly attended Greater Galilee Missionary Baptist Church, where his stepfather served as a deacon, and his mother sang in the choir. Timothy also had a younger sister who was studying law at the University of Houston.

This seemed like a close-knit family, and Timothy himself was a father to a four-year-old daughter, for whom he had obtained full custody. Those who knew him described him as quiet, reserved, and well-mannered. Neighbors who had lived next door to his parents for years told the detective that Timothy had always been polite and courteous. Another neighbor commented that he was a dedicated father who seemed to genuinely care for his child. But there was one neighbor that noted there had been some problems with Timothy over the years, but they didn't really go into detail. After high school, Timothy attended Texas Southern University and Houston Community College, but he never completed an official

degree. And while it seemed like he led a relatively normal life, Detective Miller did uncover two prior arrest that hinted at least some trouble in his past. In 1998, Tim was arrested in Austin, Texas for possession of a controlled substance by fraud. He later pleaded no contest to a reduced charge of a misdemeanor. Then in 2002, Tim was arrested again in Houston for possessing less than two ounces of marijuana, and he pleaded guilty to that charge. I mean, these were not major charges, and these offenses didn't directly connect to Tainitia's disappearance in any way, but I guess they did reveal a different layer to Timothy's character, one that maybe some people didn't know about.

So Detective Miller decided he was going to make a visit to Tim's second floor apartment, Unit 224. When Tim was being interviewed earlier, he provided written consent for the authorities to conduct a search of his place. In the moment Detective Sidney Miller stepped inside, he noticed two things immediately. The smell. A mix of bleach, ammonia, and then something else that he couldn't quite place. And then he noticed fresh paint. He didn't just smell it, he saw it. White paint, it was like it was a sloppy kitchen remodel, haphazard streaks, up and down the cabinets, up the walls, even the door frames. And then the carpet had bleach stains all over it. There was a bunch of that plastic that painters put down to prevent paint

from splashing around, dirty mops, a bag of latex gloves, and in every room there was fresh paint. It was everywhere. It was too fresh and too suspicious. And then he reached the bathroom. It looked unnaturally spotless, almost like it had been really deep cleaned recently. The tiles had been scrub with ammonia, so much the floor was still damp with the bottle right there under the sink. Even the inside of the sink cabinet was painted. You know underneath where all the pipes are? Yeah, under there as well. The sink and the tub drain had been deep cleaned, as well as the bathtub. It was bleached. It was spotless. As if something had been thoroughly washed away for a reason.

Crime scene investigators were called in, and they were swabbing for DNA and collecting evidence. But at this point, there was a lot more to be done in this investigation, and nothing to hold Timon. So it was back to canvassing the area and speaking with potential witnesses. But wait until you hear this statement, I have it printed out right here, this entire statement from one of the neighbors. This is what they told the detectives,

they witnessed on March 16th of 2007. Now, I have to read it to you word for words so that I don't miss anything, so I'm gonna put something else up on the screen. But here we go. The witness said, and I quote, on Friday, March 16th of 2007, I was at home on my day off.

I woke up sometime after 11 a.m. and heard the sound of water coming from the bathroom from apartment 224. Because I lived here for a while, I can differentiate the sound coming from the sink, the toilet and the tub. The water I heard was coming from the tub of apartment 224, seemingly running full blast.

What was strange about this is that the water continued to run hour after hour nonstop. I remember one break when the water turned off. It was off about five or ten minutes and then it started right back up again. This was so unusual that I thought about contact in the front office and telling them that they may have been a broken faucet or something. I decided to let it go.

People do not just leave their tubs running that long. I went about my normal business at home. I do not remember the exact time, but on this same day, I also heard a loud pounding. It sounded like pounding against wood or a table. It could have been the floor or a counter. I just don't know. The pounding was continuous for about half an hour.

The noise sounded like it was coming from either the kitchen or the living room area. I heard things all the time from that apartment, So I just ignored it and filed it away in my mind. It started to make me suspicious. I remember when I went into my kitchen, I heard what sounded like the garbage disposal unit going on. This went on for about five minutes,

and this is when it caught my attention. A person does not run a disposal that long. About 4 o'clock p.m., I left my apartment and decided to go on some errands. When I left, the water from 2-24 was still running to the best of my recollection. I went to Kroger's grocery store. After leaving Kroger's, I drove around in my car for a while and returned home around 8 p.m. By this time, the water had stopped. Later that evening, I noticed a metallic, dark blue sedan parked in the tollway zone in front of my building below my balcony.

The car appeared to be a Lincoln or a Mercury. It was parked diagonally next to the garbage dumpster, which was right next to my apartment. There were other open parking spots, and I recognized this car to be someone who lives in the complex. I had seen the car parked in nearby spaces before, but never in the towaway zone. The following morning, the car was still there. Around midday, the car was gone, and I thought great. However, the car came back, about a half an hour later and went back to the same spot with other spaces open. I saw a young black male in his 20s get out of the car carrying what looked to be a bag of fast food.

I was standing on my balcony and I called out, buddy, that's not a parking spot. He looked around and said, is someone talking to me? He said this in a timid way. I didn't say anything and just backed into my apartment. We didn't make eye contact. It must have had some effect because 10 minutes later, the car was gone.

I have not seen it since. On Saturday, March 17, 2007, or Sunday night, March 18th, 2007, I was walking to get my mail. I usually walk around the north side of the building along the sidewalk. There are four air conditioning compressors on this side of the building.

As I was walking, I noticed that the air-conditioned compressor of Unit 224 was running. This was unusual because it was a cool evening, and this was the only unit running. As I continued around the building to the west side, I looked up and noticed the sliding glass door to the living room of 224 opened about a foot. The blinds were drawn, but they were moving as if a fan was on.

Okay, that is the end of the statement. Wow. This resident really paid attention. They saw something and they said something, but it's more like they heard something, they saw something, they analyzed it, committed it to memory, and then told all. But cops weren't saying anything.

They were remaining tight-lipped, but there was someone talking, Tiffany Shepard's cousin. I'm going to be telling you about that in a moment. I want to go back to this statement. I know none of us are going to think that we're going to see anything. But if you do, this is just an example of how someone can really,

help an investigation, this man, he knew something was up. The smells, the sounds, this wasn't normal. And if you hear something going on for a prolonged amount of time and it's not construction, it's probably something else and it's worth maybe looking into it or calling the police. But I also know a lot of people who live in a multi-unit complex, they don't really want to get involved. Totally understood. But my point is remembering these things, maybe even jotting them down, could be really important. You just never know. But back to Timothy Shepard's cousin.

He was talking. He was talking to the same man who promised to find Tynisha. Quinell X. On March 21st, Tim's cousin got in touch with Quinell. He said, Tim needs your help. Juan Al was torn. He was deeply committed to finding Tynisha

and uncovering the truth for her family. However, he also felt responsibility to ensure that Tim's rights were protected. Quonel had been vocal for a long time about his distrust of law enforcement. He didn't know if Tim was involved in any of this. The cops could be trying to pin it on him. They had him in an interview room for at least 10 hours at one point. So Quinell needed to get to the bottom of it. When speaking with those close to both Tim and Tyneisha, they shed light on some of the more negative aspects of their relationship. Now, it might have

started out great, but soon it was volatile. They argued all the time. And by the the time she left for college, she confided in those closest to her that she was afraid of Tim. He was known as possessive, jealous, and controlling of Tunisia. He would call her nonstop wanting to know where she was and who she was with, even when they broke up. Sound familiar to some of the other cases we've done? She was crying every day at college because Tim would even call her roommates looking for her and then leave them angry messages. That's quite embarrassing, especially for someone new to college, making new friends, and then you've got your, like, crazy ex-boyfriend

who seems to be harassing not only you, but people you just met. Tanish's sister said that one time, they were in the car together, and Tanish's phone rang, and when she picked it up, Tim got mad and he yelled at her, and then he started to actually physically shake her. The thing is, Tynisha wouldn't open up as much to her family because she didn't want them to worry,

but she confided in her roommates that Tim had choked her and threatened to end her life. And that happened about a year and a half ago. He wouldn't let her leave his apartment. But since then, things had kind of cooled down. With her now being away at Texas A&M, Tim had stopped bothering her. That was until February of that year.

So a month before she was set to come back for spring break, he knew that she was going to be in town. And Tinesia was worried that he was going to get all in her business, wanting to know who she was with and even maybe follow her around. She thought about not even coming back into town, but she wanted to have fun with her friends. She decided to appeased him an attempt to just be friendly, hoping that everything would be okay. The truth is, Tynisha was still in love with Tim. Even though he wasn't good for her, and we've heard this before, he was convincing,

and he convinced her to come to his place that night. The night that they met up, he was playing nice. he was showing his lovable side. He knew how to get his way with her. Quinell got on the phone with Tim, wanting to hear his version of events, and Tim agreed to meet Quinell at his apartment. But Quinell didn't want to go there alone.

He thought it was only right to bring Tenetia's sister Gala along, but she waited in the car as Quinell went up to speak with Tim alone first. Just give them some time to kind of be by themselves, man to man, and talk. When Quinell arrived, Tim was already shaking. His hands were fidgeting, his eyes were darting around his apartment. He was crumbling. Quinell asked if the cops had done anything to them. Had they hurt him? And he said, no, they just kept pressing me to confess.

So Quinell embraced him. He put Tim in a hug and he asked him, are you all right? And Tim just put his head down. And he said, no, not really. And as Quinell walked inside, there were no words. I mean, just silence as he was glancing around at all the investigative measures that law enforcement had taken. There was black fingerprint dust on practically every surface. But when he entered the bathroom, Quinell froze. It was unmistakable. The entire bathroom was glowing blue.

And if you've ever seen luminal light up bloodstains, this was like the bathroom had been painted with blood. It was everywhere. Before the luminal was applied, this bathroom appeared spotless. But now, all the hidden blood stains were in plain sight. The floor was glowing, the walls, the shower. It was like pouring down in streaks. The tub looked like at one point it had overflowed with blood from the way that the luminal illuminated the stains. I'm actually showing you police footage of this bathroom and how it lit up. It literally painted a story of what happened. It was now undeniable.

Something had happened there. Not just something, something deadly happened there. These stains, they were on the toilet seat, the tank, where you would flush it. It was everywhere. You could sit there looking at this picture, looking at these video clips, and imagine every move, how someone tried wiping back and forth over the blood just smearing it on the tiles. That's when Quinell looked at him and he said, tell me the truth. Do you know, know, what happened to this girl? And Tim just hung his head down. Quinell urged him to consider Tynisha's family. They were desperate for answers and he told him, don't prolong their suffering

if you know, tell me the truth. Quinell then asked the question that no one really wanted the answer to. Is Tynisha dead? And there was this long pause and then the words that changed everything. Tim said, man, they're going to kill me. They're going to give me the death penalty and at that moment, Quinell had his answer. Tyneisha was gone. And Tim, it was obvious. He had done the unthinkable. But Quinell came there for answers,

and now he needed to answer to Tynisha's family, and her sister was inside the car downstairs, waiting. I can't even begin to imagine both having to tell a family member their loved one is dead, and being that family member whose hopes are just ripped away.

The second Gala saw Quinell X step out of that apartment. She just knew. He looked different. He looked like he saw a ghost and her stomach just dropped. She's like, what did he say? And Quinell locked eyes with her and there was just this silence. And then he said, Timothy confessed, Tainisha's gone. And that has to be so heartbreaking.