Unlocking Us with Brené Brown - Brené with Esther Perel on Partnerships, Patterns, and Paradoxical Relationships

Episode Date: September 22, 2021

I’m talking to Esther Perel, psychotherapist, New York Times bestselling author, and podcaster, about relationships in the pandemic and beyond. She blew my mind around some patterns that Steve and I... have discovered over the past months in lockdown. We also talk a lot about paradox and straddling the tension of two competing ideas that can both be true. It’s maddening and inspiring. And you’ll hear in real time how I’m wowed, impressed, and completely Esther Perel-ed before it’s all over. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Hi, everyone. I'm Brene Brown, and this is Unlocking Us. Woo-wee. Let me just tell you, I'm talking to Esther Perel, who is a psychotherapist, a New York Times bestselling author and podcaster, and I'm officially changing her name into a verb because I literally get Esther Perel during this podcast in real time. I mean, she blew my mind. I've always followed her work. She is completely dedicated to helping us navigate the complexities of modern relationships, romantic relationships, family relationships, workplace relationships. She gets it. She gets what it means to be human. She makes things accessible. I just feel like she's one of those people where everything she says is profoundly moving and I
Starting point is 00:00:52 need to write it down. In this episode, however, she blows my mind around some patterns that Steve and I have that, I don't know, while aware of them, I wasn't sure exactly what was happening. So what an incredible episode. I cannot wait to dive into this with you. I can't wait for you to get to know Astaire better. She's just amazing. And we're going to talk a lot about paradox and straddling the tension of what seems to be opposites, but are not. We're going to talk about how two competing ideas can both be true, which makes me crazy, but that's what it means to be alive. Welcome to Unlocking Us. I'm glad y'all are here. Support for this show comes from Macy's.
Starting point is 00:01:36 Fall is in full swing, and it's the perfect time to refresh your home and wardrobe for the sweater weather with new finds from Macy's. From October 9th to October 16th, get amazing deals on shoes and boots on sale at 30% to 40% off. We'll see you next time. to 60% off on top brands when you do. Plus, get great deals on cozy home accessories from October 18th to October 27th. Shop in-store or online at Macy's.com. About a year ago, two twin brothers in Wisconsin discovered, kind of by accident, that mini golf might be the perfect spectator sport for the TikTok era. Meanwhile, a YouTuber in Brooklyn found himself less interested in tech YouTube and more interested in making coffee. This month on
Starting point is 00:02:31 The Verge Cast, we're telling stories about these people who tried to find new ways to make content, new ways to build businesses around that content, and new ways to make content about those businesses. Our series is called How to Make It in the Future, and it's all this month on The Verge Cast, wherever you get podcasts. All right, before we dig in, let me tell you a little bit about Astaire. She is a psychotherapist and a New York Times bestselling author. She's recognized as one of today's most insightful and original voices on modern relationships. I think that is absolutely true. She is fluent in nine languages. She leads a therapy practice in New York and serves as an organizational consultant for Fortune 500 companies around the world. Her celebrated TED Talks have garnered more than 30 million views
Starting point is 00:03:16 and her bestselling books, Mating in Captivity, which is such an amazing title, and The State of Affairs are global Global Phenomena, translated into nearly 30 languages. She is an executive producer and host of the popular podcast, Where Should We Begin? and How's Work? Her latest project is
Starting point is 00:03:36 Where Should We Begin? A Game of Stories with Esther Perel. Let's jump in. Okay, I might, Esther, be smiling too big to even talk right now. It is just so comforting and exciting to see your face. So when you came on, you know, I had you in minimized version and it was like your small face was just entering into my heart expanding. And I said,
Starting point is 00:04:07 oh my God, I haven't seen her. I haven't been near her. We used to just kind of crisscross into each other's orbits. And it's a real pleasure. I'm really moved. I'm not only excited, I'm moved. Of course she has the right word. No, no, no, no. No, I am moved too. I am, I feel emotional to see you. That's it. That's it. Yes. Same. And I was thinking, when's the last time I saw her? And everything goes back two years, like 18, 19 months. That's even like where the clock stopped somehow. Then I wind back from there. I kind of want to say last year. Every time I say last year, it's actually two and a half years ago. Yeah. We're going to talk about that. How have you been? Can I just ask you that? Yes. That's what I was going to start with.
Starting point is 00:04:50 I asked first. Okay. I have been holding on. Yeah. It has been stressful and scary and disheartening. At the same time, I feel very close to my family right now. I'm going to use the word that I want to talk a lot about today with you. It has been a very difficult, paradoxical experience the last 18 months. It's been the hardest season of my marriage. And Steve and I have been together for 30 years, by far the most difficult season of our marriage. And also, we probably are closer in some ways and know each other better in some ways than we've ever known each other in three decades, but also the most difficult. It's been hard. I think there's something about straddling the tension of contradictions that is exhausting. Has it changed over time? Like, is your answer evolving?
Starting point is 00:05:55 Or do you feel like you felt similarly a year ago? Or do you think that in the beginning, and then there was that phase? I have phases at this point. Yes. I think I went to war with uncertainty. It, of course, won. Yeah, I thought I could beat it down. And I've learned to move with it, but almost kind of like riding a wave. Sometimes I'm right on top of it, and we're riding together, and's, you know, me and uncertainty are moving together in this kind of rhythmic way. And sometimes it crashes over me and takes me down. So I'm on that ride. You have this definition somewhere of vulnerability
Starting point is 00:06:38 as comprising emotional exposure, risk, and uncertainty. And I thought, this is actually not just a definition of vulnerability inside of us. This is actually a definition of the world we live in. It's no longer just an individual experience. It is really a collective experience. We are in a phase of prolonged uncertainty with no end in sight whatsoever. We are dealing with risk and trust and risk and safety, and we're straddling that whole thing. And then we are trying to remain connected in the midst of all of that. And what
Starting point is 00:07:20 is the emotional exposure that that connection invites us to do? And I just thought your triad here is just a perfect description of the world at large and not just of the individual psychology. I don't like that, Esther. I do not like this. I think you're 100% right, but I don't like it on a macro level because I like to think of myself as trying to learn to be vulnerable emotionally on a micro level. But then when I'm trying to be vulnerable in a vulnerable world, that's really scary, right? Yeah. Yeah. Let me ask you something. Do you, pre-pandemic or in your life in general, do you live with a sense that you somewhat control your destiny? Do you live with the notion of, I have a sense of agency
Starting point is 00:08:16 over my fate, I make the decisions, they carry me, that you can kind of predetermine certain things? Or did you, even before that, live with that notion of uncertainty that everything can just change from one day to the next? I think I straddled the paradox of I have a profound sense of agency and shit happens. Yeah. Yeah. I think there was both. Okay. I know people use your name as a verb. I feel like I'm being a stare Peralta. Okay. Let me flip it to you. No, but I've listened to you so much this year. And every time I said, and how is she doing? She's, you know, we both try to translate, right? We try to put words to
Starting point is 00:09:00 the experience. We try to give clarity, to give reassurance, to give meaning, etc. I mean, I've really listened to quite a few of your interviews. It accompanied me too. And I would say, how is she doing? Where does she come from? Like, is this a sense that for the first time in her life, there's this notion that you don't have the reins on anything? Or does she actually come from a history where that has always actually been the case? She has a sense of agency, but she's prepared at any moment. And I really think that those of us who experienced bad things at some point in our life
Starting point is 00:09:31 and in the world we've lived in had a certain preparation, even though we hoped it wouldn't happen. We had a sense that this stuff happens. You think you know the world you live in and from one day to the next, it just can topple. But there are other people who I've always looked at and I say, oh, these people seem so rooted. They know where they belong. They know why they are here on this earth. You know, they don't question their existence all the time. And those people,
Starting point is 00:10:00 I feel like, you know, they really thought that they can control stuff. You know, of course, it's the dose is just imaginary dose people in my head. It's two different stances. It's not personalities per se. It's a stance in the world. What is your stance? Complete agency and control or bad shit happens? No, I come, you know, I come from a family that lost everything and everyone as a Holocaust survivor.
Starting point is 00:10:33 So I grew up with that notion all the time that from one day to the next, everything can disappear. And I live with that sense of dread constantly. But it's masked by also a sense of optimism and a kind of an erotic charge at life. And if I'm here, if I am this miracle child that wasn't meant to be, I better do something with it. I better, you know, give it meaning and vigor and robustness. But internally, no, no, I have a little bit like you, but in my version, I live as if I can take charge, but I constantly feel that at any moment, somebody up there can smile at me and say, oh, you want to see? Oh God, yes. I'm glad you talked about where you come from. I want to start with asking you if you'll tell us your story all the way, if you'll tell us your story, like from baby Esther. Well, maybe to kind of go into what
Starting point is 00:11:28 I just described, baby Esther came 12 years after my brother. And so in effect, baby Esther was considered a bit of a miracle child that my parents wanted and were hoping for, but wasn't coming. And, you know, for many, many Holocaust survivors, having a child was a sign that one still is human, that one can still procreate, that you haven't killed off all the Jews, that there is a way to rebuild, that there will be a name, that there will be continuity, that, you know, there will be, there will be, and not just there was. So I think that baby Esther basically was born with that. You know, you have a mission. You were not meant to be, but you are here and there is all this weight put on you that you are so special, which as always gives you on the one hand, you are special and on the other hand it's a heavy
Starting point is 00:12:25 burden you know and I think I've lived with that awareness all along that if I was going to have to do something important I didn't know what but it was a sense of like don't waste a life when you are living the life that so many people couldn't have. Maybe Esther was filled with energy. I think I'm a sublimated hyperactive, basically, you know, but at the time you could just be outside and play ball and be on the bike. And so, you know, nobody thought, you know, she can't sit still. It was just, you know, she likes to be outside. I was very physical and very active. And that's a little bit later. Little child, Esther, and pre-latent child, Esther, I would say is very imaginative. I spend a lot of time doing imaginative play, storytelling. I mean, it's really a direct line to what I do today, all the way straight to the podcast. And I told stories.
Starting point is 00:13:25 I ran a tennis club where I was the owner, the players, the audience, you know, the people that came to watch. And I had all these intrigues in the clubs and I was every character. And I spoke out loud while I was playing against the big wall behind my house. I ran a hit parade program on TV and I was the jury, the singer, the writers, the audience, the presenter. You know, I played all the characters and I stood with my guitar in front of my mother's commode and performed all the roles. So I was heavily into imaginative play, always curious, very, very curious, very sensitive to rejection, very sensitive to rejection, partly because I had absorbed that larger story of the rejection that my family had experienced.
Starting point is 00:14:14 And as a result, I always thought I will find a way for the doors to not close on me. Somehow I will be invited in. This theme, really, I find that it reemerges everywhere, but it's not just rejected because I was rejected. It's rejected because I carried a legacy story of rejection of my people. And then that translated on to me. You know, we were the immigrant family on the block. I lived above my parents' store. I worked in the store since I could talk. And it was like the parents with the accents and the customers, everything that one often hears. And I would say that around adolescence,
Starting point is 00:14:59 I began to really want to travel and leave. The world had to be bigger for me. I did my first trip in the US when I was 17 after high school and I hitchhiked across the country for almost two months. And I saw America like I will never see it again because I was ignorant and open and grateful for the kindness of all strangers. Wow. And then I went to study and I think I always knew I was going to do psychology because I was fascinated by human beings. I was fascinated by the suffering of human beings, by what makes you want to continue, by what makes you wake up. I would
Starting point is 00:15:39 always ask my parents, what made you want to wake up the next day in the concentration camps? I mean, how did you do it? How did you? And wondering, would I have been able to do it? What would I do if I was in dire circumstances? What's my real strength? Not what I show to people. I spend a lot of time talking about these things to my friends as well as by myself.
Starting point is 00:16:00 And then I really thought family therapy was going to be where I landed because a system, a family system, ites, will satisfy that same curiosity and that same ability to enter into other people's experiences. So it was a very natural thing for me to become a therapist, which I still am. Here I am, 40-something years later. I have goosebumps because maybe this is true for all of us in some way, but you make it so clear that a whole world already lived in you when you were born. Like a whole world of legacy, of expectation, of sorrow, of grief, of pain, of hope. I mean, it's like there was a whole cosmos in little Astaire as a newborn. Has story always been important to you? It feels like it's a thread in your life. Story has been a central theme for me. Yes, because, and I'm actually, I just had a
Starting point is 00:17:16 thought, which I've never said out loud, but it's beginning to make sense for me. Because there was such a massive disruption in my family. I had no grandparents, no uncles, no aunts, no nothing. My parents came from a family of nine for him and a family of seven for her, and they both were the youngest. I knew the story had been severed. The narrative was cut and deliberately.
Starting point is 00:17:43 And so we lived in two kinds of homes. Clearly, we would say, do you have parents who talk or do you have parents who never talk? Do your parents tell and do your parents not tell? And what do they tell? So the only way we could know where we came from, what was our history, what was the bigger story behind us was literally through the parents telling,
Starting point is 00:18:06 through their storytelling. And I happen to have had very, very good storytellers. My parents would talk and my friends would sit around the table and just listen because they had understood naturally, they had a way of talking that basically put their denial system in place so that when it became too horrible,
Starting point is 00:18:24 they just didn't go there. So they told stories that were accessible to us. We didn't choke when we would listen. We were in awe. We were like amazed. We couldn't believe what we were hearing, but we were not running away because it was so unbearable. So the storytelling is part of what created continuity, what creates continuity in all communities that are uprooted, dismantled, broken. Everybody, there's nothing unique in here about, it happens to be my personal Jewish Holocaust stories,
Starting point is 00:18:55 but every community worldwide. Storytelling binds you to people, binds you to the past, binds you to the transmission, et cetera. I also think that I understood early on, and this came back in the pandemic very clearly, that freedom in confinement comes through your imagination. When you are physically incapable of living, the only place that you can live through is your creativity, your mind, your imagination. The stories you tell in your head can make you think
Starting point is 00:19:27 that you're sitting with the person that you haven't seen in 10 years or that you're talking to the person that you lost. That notion that your mind, your imagination, it is really not just the mind, it's the imagination part of the mind, is what allows you to feel free even when you are captive like this year like my parents for five years and stories imagination that goes hand in hand you know
Starting point is 00:19:55 and I am trained in narrative therapy I do think of people's life as a story people's relationship as a story people come in talking to me as a story. Where should we begin? The podcast is really built on that notion. People come in, they tell you a story, and hopefully by the end of the session, they will leave with a different story or the possibility of a different story. Because language shapes the experience. Yes. Which was a notion that I, for me, that of Foucault that I met, I cared a lot
Starting point is 00:20:26 about. And I think languages, I speak a few. And so that too, really, you tell the story differently in a different language. Right. I've never spoken as much about this, but it's really true that story is there from the beginning. If you don't tell the story, you're left with gaping holes. Oh my God, I have so many thoughts. Let me just pause for a second and just take in what you've just said. I just feel like I don't know that I've ever heard anything more important in my life. So let me just, let me just take a breath for a second. Hmm. And this is from one storyteller to another.
Starting point is 00:21:17 Yeah, no. Because you are a storyteller too. Yeah, I have a very profound reverence for story. Our data with the soul. Yeah, data with a soul. That's it. I never forgot the way you said that in one of your first TED Talks. And I said, oh, this woman is music to my ears. Yeah, no, that's what I'm hearing a symphony right now from you. And so I'm just sitting into it. Someone made a joke one time and said they were going to start calling my podcast The Pause Cast. We don't pause very much in the real world anymore. And what you just said is so important. It feels like I need to pause to think about it. I want to ask a bunch of questions.
Starting point is 00:21:52 I want to walk into what you just said a little bit. This is not the first time I've heard someone say, especially talking about Holocaust survivors, and I think it's true of other experiences of collective trauma, that there are people who tell the story and people who do not tell the story. I have friends who have told me, you know, my parents were in concentration camps. The rule was we never spoke of it. Is that a bearability question? Is that like on a level of catastrophic dehumanization and genocide, the Holocaust is an example. Slavery is another example. We see examples around the world.
Starting point is 00:22:36 Unfortunately, it's like we're not learning. How would you describe the difference between people who carry and share the story and those who just can't? Is it a willingness issue or a capacity issue or both? Neither. Okay. I think one of the primary reasons not to tell is to protect the children, to protect the others. Say more. I don't want you to be contaminated by this.
Starting point is 00:23:07 I don't want you to think that the world can be so inhuman. I don't want you to suffer from the suffering that I went through. The primary mode reason, and I think this is true for many people who don't tell the story, it's not the thing we emphasize. We typically think that there's something inside the person who experienced the pain, the suffering, the loss of why they don't want to tell. But when people experience massive psychic loss, psychosocial trauma, large scale collective trauma, disasters and all of that, and particularly when they have been tortured, dehumanized, war, all of those, same with the veterans. You know, one of the prime reasons for the silence is to protect the people around from the evil, from the gross, from the disgusting, from the cruel.
Starting point is 00:23:59 Then when people tell the story, there's another distinction. In the storytellers, there are those who emphasize the heroic and those who emphasize the victimization. Those who tell a story of survival and those who tell a story of woundedness among the survivors. And by the way, when I say those, those, really, it's not like the world is divided into camps, but it's a continuum where you look at. And that is a very interesting thing. Did people describe what they went through to talk about the human spirit, the way that they fought, the way that they fought to stay alive, or did people primarily emphasize on what had been done to them? And that created a different legacy onto the children.
Starting point is 00:24:49 You know, one of the main experiences of a lot of children of survivors, and I think that that may be so for children who have parents who have went through major life events, is that you ask yourself, not just would I have been able to do this? Would I have survived? How would I have done this? But you also say, my problems are not really worthy of problems. Oh my God. Yes. No problem. Nothing you're dealing with is important enough because how can you compare with Auschwitz? Yeah. It's a comparative suffering. Yes. How can you compare with, just fill in the blank of whatever, you know, the specificity of your story.
Starting point is 00:25:28 And so you start to feel like you don't really have a right to be unhappy or to suffer or to have problems because they are minuscule in comparison to the big issues. The jail, the poverty, the hunger, the freezing cold, whatever the things that people experience all over the world. And it's really once you start to actually say, you know, it's a fantastic thing that people can feel about small things, not that different than they feel about big things.
Starting point is 00:25:58 Or in other words, I'm going to give you an example. We had a 20th anniversary of 9-11. I, at the time, worked with firemen and not the policemen, everybody else in the community. I was living in the community. My children were at the school two blocks from the World Trade Center. And we would play it in front of the audience and the audience would respond and we would incorporate this into the next.
Starting point is 00:26:38 And a lot of people were busy with the comparative of suffering at the time. Haiti versus New York. It was all over, you know. And when we would perform things, and especially when we would perform with other groups of victims of political violence and torture, they would tell us, there's two things you cannot miss when you tell our story. One is you have to bring in the humor. Because humor is, you know,
Starting point is 00:27:06 helped us a great deal. And two, small things bothered us just as much as the big things, because the small things made us continue to feel like we were still normal people. And that gave me the permission to then think, oh, well, my small things, then they're okay. I don't have to spend another two years in therapy to ask permission to sometimes not feel good. Yeah. I write a lot about comparative suffering because I see it all the time. Even when I'm teaching a university class, I'll see someone kind of silencing their own story because it doesn't measure up to the story. And I remember after Hurricane Ike, my friend who's a therapist called and said,
Starting point is 00:27:46 how are you doing? And I said, oh, I'm good. We're so lucky. You know, like everyone's okay. And you know, we won't have power for six weeks, but we're good. And you know, the neighborhood's torn up and we can't open the door because there's a tree in our front yard, but we're great. And she's like, yeah, that sounds terrible. How are you? And I said, oh, we've got so much to be grateful for compared to so many other people. And she goes, yeah, I bet you do. So how are you doing? And I was like, I'm fucking losing my mind. The kids have strep throat.
Starting point is 00:28:15 The house is full of mosquitoes because we have to sleep with the windows open because it's 100 degrees outside. I'm sick. Steve's taking care of people and bringing home I don't know what. And she goes, there we go. And I remember in that moment thinking, I had no compassion and empathy for other people or very little at the time
Starting point is 00:28:38 because I wasn't owning my own pain during what was happening. Does that make sense? Yes. If you talk to yourself and you say, you have nothing to complain about, it's very unlikely that you will respond to other people with what do you have to complain about?
Starting point is 00:28:54 Or you say, you have something to complain about because yours is really worse and I have nothing to complain about. It goes in two directions, right? Either it's, if I don't cry, what the fuck are you crying? Sorry. Well, you know, what's the matter with you?
Starting point is 00:29:10 You know, lift yourself up and continue. Get your shit together. Yeah. Yes. Pull yourself up to active. But the other version of the denial, you know, is if you see people who are really weaker than you and worse off than you,
Starting point is 00:29:24 then you can really experience vulnerability because they are below you in a way. You see them as more helpless, below in the sense as more helpless. And you feel like you can be there for them, but you don't know how to do the same thing with yourself. You don't know how to take that part of you that feels also sometimes weakened or fragile or brittle and apply the same kindness, the same
Starting point is 00:29:51 gentleness, the same, in French, you have a beautiful word, bienveillance. It's like benevolence, caring benevolence onto yourself. With yourself, you say, you know, and with patients like that, you often have to ask, if you were doing this to a friend, how would you be talking? And how is it that that friend doesn't come back home with you? God Almighty, it's two things come up for me when you say that. One is the danger of ranking suffering. And two is this whole idea of talking to yourself like you would talk to someone you love and respect. Yeah. Which is really hard. So the danger of ranking suffering is something you come across in a lot in when you do couples therapy or family therapy for that matter. You know, family members compete, couples often compete, who does more, who does less, who is more deprived, who lost more. Oh, hell yes.
Starting point is 00:30:47 You know, loads of competition. So that is kind of daily breakfast. When parents don't share, whether it's something as catastrophic as the Holocaust or a traumatic upbringing with poverty and violence and whatever the experience is, when they don't share an effort to not contaminate, which I think is a really strong word that you use there. And I felt that word when you used it. Does that actually stop
Starting point is 00:31:17 the spread of the experience? It's a great question. So some parents do not speak to protect. Some parents do not speak because they don't want to relive. Some parents do not speak because they feel shame. Yes. Sometimes they feel shame for what they experienced, for how they were made to feel. Sometimes they feel shame for how they survived, for what they had to do to still be here. Yes. Sometimes they don't speak.
Starting point is 00:31:46 And this was actually one of the first ones that my parents would often tell me because they didn't believe that people would believe them. That what they were telling was so unimaginable, indescribable, that nobody could believe them. And so for the first decades, they were quiet. They didn't talk about that. And then sometimes people don't talk because they want to focus on rebuilding life. And the focus is really on that. So now, before I go back to your specific question, then what do people do? And that is a very, very important thing, especially with the period that we are in now, is that they come together with other survivors. They understand collective resilience in a very, very intuitive way. None of them ever went to therapy. This was not their culture. They come together, but they don't come together to sit in a circle and talk about what they
Starting point is 00:32:48 went through. They come together to be in a circle with people who would kind of have enough of an idea of what they went through because they went through something quite similar. So they don't have to talk about it. And instead they can play cards, they can eat cake, and they can do all kinds of remembrances of other things. Very, very clever. Very clever.
Starting point is 00:33:07 You know, it creates enough of the familiarity and the continuity without having to dig into the muck. Now, what happens to the second generation? So these are a few of the reasons of what happens in the telling and not telling. We could spend an hour just on that. And this is true in families in general when you sense something. You sense something that was never told. telling. We could spend an hour just on that. And this is true in families in general, when there is,
Starting point is 00:33:25 when you sense something, you sense something that was never told. So it depends. You know, one thing would be to say, did my parents describe or did what went through, not just in the camps, it's also when they come back to Belgium, it's when they went back to see if anybody had survived. It's a lot of different pieces, but there's a different thing between that and the parent who doesn't tell that they actually had a family and that the whole family perished, that they actually had two children, that if they can't attach to you, even though they wanted you, you child, it's often because they are so afraid if they get attached, they will lose you again. And so they've become this kind of remote, aloof parent. That's one story. I mean, there's many. Another version is you don't know,
Starting point is 00:34:11 so you fill in the gaps. In general, when we don't know, we fill in the gap. It's like Swiss sweets. And then you start to invent all kinds of things. You start to imagine things and you have no idea if it's true or not. And often you imagine worse than what may be. So the good thing is sometimes to be able to go to talk to other people. So of the best, most interesting work I did on this was large groups, 100, 200 people with families, but the parents were not with their own children. Children were with other parents so that the parents could talk, but they didn't have to deal with the fact that they were talking to their own kid. And the children could ask questions and they didn't have to worry that they were going to re-traumatize their parents.
Starting point is 00:34:52 They're very, very powerful, large group communal settings where people came to fill the holes, so to speak. Wow. You know, to me, it was one of the most generative experiences in terms of telling the stories in a way where you can ask and somebody can answer in a safer way than if it's done just in the family. Afterwards, you can go into in the family, you know. Oh, I was born in that haystack with you when you were in hiding and I already had a sister and I didn't know that I already had a sister. Something doesn't make sense when I calculate the numbers. I mean, you know, the stories were often- Missing big pieces, yeah.
Starting point is 00:35:32 Yes, yes. One thing I thought of when you said how genius it was to come together and play cards or eat dinner or have a potluck, I think about some of the research on what it was like for soldiers coming back to the United States, just the PTSD, the difference when they got on ships with each other and traveled for several weeks together back. And they told each other stories and they played cards
Starting point is 00:36:02 as opposed to you're on the front line in a war zone and 24 hours later, you're shopping at the grocery store with your partner and your kids. And there was just no being with people who had gone through the same kind of trauma and no place to put it. The other thing that this brought up for me is I'm really curious about this. Tell me about the phenomenon, I hear this a lot when I interview people, about people in a lot of pain who when they try to express their pain and their experiences of shame or their experiences of not feeling loved, the perspective of their parents is you have no idea what it's like to grow up in a hard time. Like we gave you everything compared to what we have. And I can't believe you have any issues with the way we raised you. Does that make sense? Like this? That's another form of the competition for greater victim. Oh, got it. That's actually the of the competition for greater victim. Oh, got it.
Starting point is 00:37:07 That's actually the same. It's like, you know, what do you have to complain about? If you only knew what I went through. So this is a variation of the, what you call suffering comparatives. Comparative suffering, yeah. The very interesting thing is this. The parent who says this, you have no idea what I went through. At 10, I was going with the newspaper every morning.
Starting point is 00:37:32 I worked in an elderly house. I worked in a cafe. I swept the floors. I did all these things. You have it so easy. It's that that parent wanted the child to have it easier than them. I see quite a few parents who tried so hard to have their kids not have to deal with what they had to deal with, whatever it was, irresponsible parents, addicted parents, parents who they,
Starting point is 00:38:02 the children had to take care of them materially,, etc. But what's important is they then find themselves in a kind of an ambivalent stance. On the one hand, they wanted the kid to have it easier. And on the other hand, they go and they say to the kid, you have it so easy. You don't try hard enough. You are lazy. If only you knew. But at the same time, they then come back and they try to give the help that the kid needs to keep it be easier. It's this constant loop. You know, I don't want you to suffer the hardships that I suffered. And then I put you down for not having suffered enough and for thinking that life is owed to you. When in fact, I'm the one who taught you that by giving to you, because I wanted everything for you not to feel what deprivations I had experienced.
Starting point is 00:38:54 God, we're kind of back where we started in a way where- You get this one? Oh no, like I get it as a parent. I get that I am parenting my two kids in a way that I would have killed to have been parented. And I get that it is imperfect and I will probably need to hear hard things as they get older about things that affected them. But the only way that I can really navigate that is because I believe in paradox, that I believe both things can be true. I believe that I worked really hard to overcome some of the ways I was parented and do it differently, and that I did it imperfectly. Like I can straddle the tension of both of those things being true.
Starting point is 00:39:51 Hello, I'm Esther Perel, psychotherapist and host of the podcast, Where Should We Begin, which delves into the multiple layers of relationships, mostly romantic. But in this special series, I focus on our relationships with our colleagues, business partners, and managers. Listen in as I talk to co-workers facing their own challenges with one another and get the real work done. Tune into Housework, a special series from Where Should We Begin, sponsored by Klaviyo. What software do you use at work? The answer to that question is probably more complicated than you want it to be.
Starting point is 00:40:26 The average US company deploys more than 100 apps, and ideas about the work we do can be radically changed by the tools we use to do it. So what is enterprise software anyway? What is productivity software? How will AI affect both? And how are these tools changing the way we use our computers to make stuff, communicate, and plan for the future? In this three-part special series, Decoder is surveying the IT landscape presented by AWS. Check it out wherever you get your podcasts.
Starting point is 00:40:56 I want to read this to you, and I want to get your thought on this. Are you a Carl Jung person? Are you Jungian in nature? I'm not a Jungian in nature, but I have read Jung and respect him tremendously. Yes. So this quote, the paradox is one of our most valuable spiritual possessions. Only the paradox comes anywhere near to comprehending the fullness of life. so paradox is both and yes it's thesis anti-thesis it's the ability to straddle contradictory beliefs attitudes feelings at the same time without having to think that it's an either or this or that which is when i said there are those people and those people, I keep wanting to say, I speak as if it's binary, but it really is a tension.
Starting point is 00:41:49 I am interested in that tension between those two polarities. That's the paradox. Look, I think that is one of the things we share a lot. I wrote Mating in Captivity to explore the paradox between love and desire, between our need for security and our need for adventure, our wish for commitment, but our longing for freedom,
Starting point is 00:42:12 our quest for togetherness, but our hunger for separateness, you know, for safety and excitement. I mean, the whole book was examining that tension of these two fundamental sets of human needs, you know, that we have from Ulysses on, you know, the journey and the home. So I think in paradoxes all the time, all the time. It's the tension that fascinates me. I think a lot of the way that I change the story that people bring to me,
Starting point is 00:42:43 it's like if you listen to, where should we begin? You'll see that people come in with a story that is often either or. Shall I stay or shall I go? Yes. Shall I have a kid or shall I not have a kid? He wants this and he wants that, you know. And my work is about taking those polarities out of their corners, making them looser so that they can become more intertwined with each other. In a couple, it's a fascinating thing what happens to a paradox. It's called to split the ambivalence. Okay, wait, say that again. It's called what?
Starting point is 00:43:19 Splitting the ambivalence. Okay, what does that mean? So when I say a couple, it doesn't have to be a romantic couple. It can be any polarized relationship. It could be two nations. It doesn't matter. Since I work more in the small system, for example, one person says, I want to have a kid or I want to get married or I want to move, whatever. I want X. And the other person says, no, I don't want. When they position themselves, it looks like one person has no doubt. They are 100% sure that they want X.
Starting point is 00:43:55 And the other person has all the doubts. One person says, I don't want a kid as if that's the whole picture. When in fact, the person who says no may say no because there is context. The context says we're too young or we're too old or we're not economically secure. Or there are things that are making them say, no, I don't want this. That doesn't mean they don't have a longing for it. That doesn't mean that they don't have a desire somewhere at some point, but the splitting of the ambivalence makes each person take up half of the equation, polarize against the other, and it becomes an either or. When in fact, both people experience both needs inside of them. Security and adventure. You can't have one person who likes adventure and
Starting point is 00:44:43 excitement and change and novelty and the other who only wants safety, etc. Why? Because if the one that wants safety only wanted safety, they would not have chosen you. Wait, this is so uncomfortable. I'm getting ready to get hysterical. Like, this is... Who do you want to invite into your office right now no i'm just telling you right now i just showed this to barrett hot put down ac like it's getting
Starting point is 00:45:13 uncomfortable it's getting uncomfortable in here okay understand if you only wanted freedom and adventure etc you wouldn't choose the other person definition, your choice of the other person who represents the part of you that is being often denied or pushed out or dimmed, but is there. So instead of people reconciling the paradox inside themselves, what they do is they split the paradox and they take half of the story and they put the other half on the other person. Oh, my God. OK, stop. Okay. Stop. Yes. It's so funny.
Starting point is 00:45:49 I didn't understand this. I can't believe that splitting the ambivalence. So like, I'm always the certain directive. We're going to do this. We should do this. We should do that. And then I'm like, Steve, you're the parade rainer. You're always like, well, what about this? And I'm not sure about this. And I always say, I'm the microwave. He's the crock pot. It takes forever. But the minute
Starting point is 00:46:13 he says, okay, let's do it. I'm like, I have a lot of fears about this. I'm not sure we should really do this. Right. And the only way you can be so certain is because you have somebody else articulating the part of you that is being disavowed. Stop it. Stop it. We have to, we have to cut this whole place. I mean, someone's laughing behind me right now, but when anybody that knows me listens to this, everybody will be laughing because, oh, okay. And you see, when you talk about the slow cooker and the microwave and this and that, that is already the story. And that is how the story reinforces the roles. So now the roles become, you're the certain one. And instead of seeing it as a role in response to Steve, it becomes a personality. You're the certain one.
Starting point is 00:47:03 And now you are the one who always has to be certain because he's taken up the quota of the person who can ask questions, who can doubt, who can wonder, who can deliberate. And the more he deliberates and the more you feel like
Starting point is 00:47:16 you have to be certain and the more you are certain and the more he needs to strengthen the deliberation because this is splitting the ambivalence. It goes on and on in how it's a fascinating dance that takes place in relationships. I think it's what takes place in partisanship as well.
Starting point is 00:47:34 The opposite of paradox is polarization. You have blown my mind. I'm so, I'm like, because when I say that the pandemic was the toughest season in our 30-year relationship, but in some ways we're closer, I think what happened was the level of uncertainty. You could not remain so certain anymore. No, no.
Starting point is 00:48:01 And it had to create an adjustment in the relationship because you needed space to be able to say I'm scared I don't know I'm not sure what am I gonna do and all those expressions of uncertainty and for that you needed to know that he a can handle it won't collapse from it won't say oh you're stepping out of character and so he could actually finally step out of his character and it probably created a much needed adjustment. And when it works well, it really gives a new breath of fresh air to the couple. How did you know that?
Starting point is 00:48:36 I mean, this is like, this is crazy talk. How did you know that? I don't know. I just, because it's the way this works. Because these are roles. Roles are interdependent parts that people play. And when you loosen it a little bit and it takes, you know, did you hear that? It's very funny. I've never seen the show, Ted Lasso. Do you watch this? Yes, of course. So they quoted me a week ago, two ago. I had never seen the show.
Starting point is 00:49:05 And the quote they took is exactly this. It takes two people to create a pattern. It takes one person to change it. So you needed to change a pattern. You needed the permission. But it's not even that you need it. You had no choice. You had to.
Starting point is 00:49:26 You can't just go on a normal code. So, but it wasn't something that had been established in the relationship because of roles and that's okay. Roles are fine. It's just when they become rigid, that's a problem. You know, there was a new reality. That reality meant that there is this uncertainty. And that means that you too need the possibility of saying, I don't know.
Starting point is 00:49:50 But the person who's always known, who begins to say, I don't know, that is very scary. Terrible, hateful. Yeah. And you want to know that the person next to you can do it. You know, it's like in order to let go or your third dimension called emotional exposure, which is letting go, opening up, letting go, surrendering. You can only fall if this person stays steady. You need to know that this person can withstand your fall, your openness, your softening, your vulnerability, and that they can stay steady. If you feel that
Starting point is 00:50:25 they're going to fall flat with you, it's this old game on the beach, you know, where you can lean back. Yeah. If you feel that the other person's hands are going to make sure that you don't hit the ground. And for him to be able to have those hands must have felt so wonderful. It did. But I'll tell you what happened that was weird. And I was really telling you something, I was ass high in your books during this period of time. I was just reading them like constantly. What was interesting is,
Starting point is 00:50:54 and I think I put a lot of pressure on Steve during COVID because he's a physician, he's a pediatrician. So I was like, you know what? We have to make decisions about our kids doing this event or going here. And I don't know what the answer is. And that's not like me to say, I don't know what the answer is. I don't know what to do.
Starting point is 00:51:08 And he caught me in the most incredible way. Because what he said is, I don't know exactly either, but we can talk it through and figure out something together. And so what his certainty was, wasn't, well, we'll do this and this and that. His certainty was the belief, well, we'll do this and this and that. His certainty was the belief in our ability to come together and make a good decision in our values. And so what ended up happening is it's like we broke that thing that kept us in the corners. Like we did the thing where we loosened those things in the corners.
Starting point is 00:51:51 But you know, Brene, when you say the word, I am certain, and it's not like me not to know, that's very telling. So you ask me, how do I know? Oh God. Because it's tempting because I know you get it so fast. I do. I get it really fast. It's painful as fuck. To say I am certain is also often to say I can't tolerate not knowing. Of course. Yes. And when you come from medicine, especially pediatrics, you live in a more uncertain reality. You do the best you can, but you have learned to know how to live with the unknown. Yes.
Starting point is 00:52:31 And the beginning of a pandemic or the trajectory of a pandemic is filled with this unknown. And so he says, I don't know either, but I'm used to this. And I can tolerate living in that zone of unknown. And this time it is actually what we both need. And from that place, we'll decide what we want to do with the kids and what they can do and not do. Yes, that is exactly what it was. I remember I asked her. So that's a very definition. From now on, you no longer describe yourself as the one who knows and the one who hems and haws.
Starting point is 00:52:57 No. You can describe yourself as the one who has a harder time and gets very anxious when she doesn't know, living with a person who actually has more tolerance for uncertainty and for not knowing. That is the worst bullshit reframe I've ever heard in my life. I have been Esther Peralt. Reframe. I wish I could see her right now.
Starting point is 00:53:24 Not only, of course, is is she beautiful but she's laughing hard right now at me um no because reframe is one of the most beautiful things we can do with the story and it opens up a whole new vista is it bullshit or do you think it actually has some peace to it no it's so painfully true and accurate that it is, but it actually saved us in a way. And it was exactly what you said. I remember he changed his mind about something. And I was like, how dare you change your mind about letting one of our kids do something?
Starting point is 00:53:57 And he said, Brene, this is a pandemic. Every day, the calculus changes. Every day, we have to weigh social and emotional isolation with the data that we know about the virus. This is not something that is certain. And I said, well, I can't take it. And he said, I get it. But if we're trying to make the best decision for our kids, you need to understand that this is a ever-changing calculus that we really are just doing the best we can with the information we have. That is like nails on a chalkboard to me, but I also respect him and know it was true.
Starting point is 00:54:33 And so this is, yeah. To be continued. Hell no. Okay. Let me ask you this before, I don't know what I'm going to go do. Probably call Steve. Tell us about some of the exciting things happening in your life. Tell us about your new game. Tell us about your podcast. I know people are able to make them accessible to us in a way that's so human and profoundly moving. How can people dig in and learn more about you and your work? Where do they find you?
Starting point is 00:55:21 What do you have going on? So the gate to the vault is estherperel.com. But what you will find there is, I would say that my work is dedicated to helping you navigate the complexities of modern relationships, particularly romantic relationships, but also family relationships
Starting point is 00:55:44 and relationships in the workplace. Why? Because I think that our expectations of relationships are magnified more than ever, particularly because of the loss of some of the social structures, communal structures, religious structures, pre-established rituals, et cetera. So we turn to our relationships today, to our work relationships as well, for meaning, for grounding, for belonging, for transcendence, for things that people often used to look for in the realm of the divine, which is actually-
Starting point is 00:56:16 Oh, yes. Yeah, you understand. It's like, it's actually a statement of a Jungian analyst, Robert Johnson, who really made me think about that. This notion of, you know, all these things that people used to look for in the realm of religion that have to do with wholeness and ecstasy and transcendence. We want them today in our relationships because many of us no longer go to the traditional structures. So I've done it
Starting point is 00:56:42 through the books, Mating in Captivity and The State of Affairs, but I've also done it through the podcast, Where Should We Begin, which we are now producing season five. That will come out soon. With some amazing surprises, including going back to some couples that I saw three years ago
Starting point is 00:57:02 and really looking at what happened to them since and a few other surprises that I will keep surprise. And then I started during the pandemic in the beginning, in the month of April, May, really at the start, I went and did a whole season of couples in lockdown, which was the best way I could use the fact that we were on Zoom
Starting point is 00:57:23 and the fact that I was working with couples, but here we were. So I could go meet them in Lagos, Nigeria, and I could meet them in Sicily, but in my Zoom. And that made me feel like I can do something. I think that couples are isolated. I think that couples often don't really know what's happening in the neighbor's house these days. And the isolation was ever more so during this last 18 months. And so everything I did was to try to bring private dramas into the public square so that we can have the difficult conversations that we need to have. And I created a second podcast that's housework, which is the same principle.
Starting point is 00:58:01 Live, one time, three hour couples therapy sessions, but this time with people who work together and they are out in the open. Now you can go binge on them as much as you want. And then I thought, and this goes back to the beginning of our conversation with my parents, you know, where I would say, what kept you going? Like, how do you maintain hope in the midst of anguish like this? How do you stay connected to the erotic, aliveness, vibrancy, life force, vitality?
Starting point is 00:58:31 And that is play. You know, I had received a video of the children of a friend of mine and the kids had taken in this, they were confined in a tiny, tiny apartment, but the kids took the boxes and with the boxes, they build a hut. And with the hut, they took a few books and the books were now the rocks in the river.
Starting point is 00:58:50 That's what I mean. Freedom in confinement comes to your imagination. And I thought, this is not just true for children. This is really true for us. I'm going to create a game. I want to create an experience that is playful and not just talk about playfulness. We lost basically the connection to the erotic in the pandemic, right? The erotic in the sense of spontaneity, happenstance, curiosity, chance encounters, you know, the stuff that makes you look outside because every person could be a
Starting point is 00:59:19 potential contamination. So you were just closing off, closing off, trying to go safe, trying to go safe. And then people began to talk about being exhausted and flat and numb and without energy or what Adam Grant called languishing. You know, that was for me the loss of the earth. I said, I'm going to create a game. You know, that game called Where Should We Begin is a card game. Me who never plays. I'm not a card game player one bit. But I thought there's a way of helping people with the social atrophy, to help them connect and to reconnect.
Starting point is 00:59:50 You can play it with your partner, with your friends, with your kids, with people you've never met. It really actually really applies. You just take out certain cards that have a pink code and then you can really play with everyone. And it was my happy project. My team got involved.
Starting point is 01:00:07 We tested the card games. We use them on ourselves to tell stories. And it's a storytelling game where you begin to unlock the stories within. But de facto, it also becomes storytelling that connects you to the people that you're playing with. So, you know, relationships and any way that I can
Starting point is 01:00:26 support people to be more confident in their relationships. And the last thing was, I have a program called Sessions that is for therapists, coaches, all mental health professionals. And I really wanted to see as a clinician, like you say, I'm a researcher and you continue to do research. And I, no matter what else I do, I have two days a week. I see patients, I'm in my office and I stay close to the trade, you know? And I thought, how do I support all the other providers,
Starting point is 01:00:58 all the service providers? So we have the annual event coming up soon and it's really that, the great adaptation, which I think is part of what we've been talking about. Yes. How do we stay grounded when the ground is moving?
Starting point is 01:01:10 Because therapists, clinicians, doctors, Steve, all of the people who have been frontline and healthcare and mental healthcare providers, the burnout is enormous. Oh God, it's huge.
Starting point is 01:01:21 It's really the question, how do you continue to support others emotionally when you are under supported yourself? And when for the first time therapists are going through the same thing as their clients. That's right. That's right. So that became another major piece. I said, I'm going to really plunge back into my own community and see what I can offer. So this is the upcoming Sessions Live. We are going to put all of this on the episode page at brennabrown.com.
Starting point is 01:01:55 So you can find links to the game, the podcast. If you're a helping professional, how you can learn more about the conference on staying grounded while the ground is shifting as we speak, you'll get links to everything. Are you ready, Esther, for the rapid fire questions? Let's go. Okay. Fill in the blank for me. Vulnerability is? I love your triad.
Starting point is 01:02:18 It's uncertainty, emotional exposure, and risk. It captures it. I don't have to go find my own definition. I refer to the work of Brene Brown. You're called to be very brave, like you personally, but your fear is real. You can feel it in the back of your throat. What is the very first thing you do? Oh, I'm a complete counterphobic. I tend to throw myself into the things that scare me the most. And then I go, ah! So throw, then scream.
Starting point is 01:02:57 Okay, what is something that people often get wrong about you? To go back to the very question, I look like I'm fearless, but I actually am riddled with fears. And both are true. Yes. That's the paradox. And I think that's something you said early on in our conversation too. Both things can be true. Yes. What's the last TV show that you binged and loved? Oh, I don't know yet if I love it, but I'm watching it right now because I'm going to be doing an interview with the main actors. I am watching Scenes of a Marriage, the new Scenes of a Marriage by Haggai Levy. And I was a massive fan of Bergman's original Scenes of a Marriage. So I can't yet say because I've only watched two episodes. I don't want to
Starting point is 01:03:44 speak, but that's what I'm watching right now. Oh, I love it. Oh my God, goosebumps thinking about you commentating on that. Okay. Favorite movie or favorite film? Oh, I don't have things like that. Favorite, I don't know. What's one that you really love?
Starting point is 01:04:03 I mean, I could definitely say that Scenes of a Marriage was one of the movies that, you know, when you read that first book or you watch that first movie that shows you the insides of relationships, like a real anatomy lesson. Oh my God. I was 14, 15 years old when I saw it the first time, I was like, that is love. Okay. A concert that you'll never forget. Oh, many. Genesis, Pink Floyd. Yes. Supertramp. I mean, big concerts. The concerts you least forget are the ones when you are rained out. Oh yeah. And it pours on you.
Starting point is 01:04:48 Yeah. And everybody stays under the umbrella while the music keeps going, you know? So Pink Floyd in Munich was a big one like that. I wish I could have been with you. Oh, that sounds fun. Favorite meal? Oh, favorite meal is, it has nothing to do with what I eat. It has everything to do with being outside in a garden with a full moon, some candles on the table and some fantastic people with whom I'm having an immersive conversation. Beautiful. That's a favorite meal. I can see the twinkle lights already. I mean, there's lots of things I would love to eat, but it's good food with no soul around the table.
Starting point is 01:05:32 Good soul around the table and also good food. Oof, heavenly. What's on your nightstand? On my nightstand is a candle, water, my book. I'm currently reading. I'll show it to you. It's actually not a happy book, but it's an incredible. I read in French, mostly for pleasure, I have to say.
Starting point is 01:05:59 Delphine Orvilleur, who is a magnificent French philosopher, rabbi. And it is really about living with our death. It's a book about memory. But I would say this whole summer, I had one novel after another on my night table because the pandemic made it very hard for me to read fiction for the last two years. I couldn't leave my reality
Starting point is 01:06:22 to plunge into the story of a character. And I knew this summer that I had turned a corner when I could just read one novel after another. I have my night cream and that's about it on my night table. I'm looking at it. Yeah, I love it. Okay, give us a snapshot of an ordinary moment in your life that gives you true joy, just a singular moment that's joyful for you. I'm sitting on the couch. We have a big red chair in the living room. And one of my boys comes and lays and sits all over me as if they're still two
Starting point is 01:07:02 years old. Yes. When they're like these big men and just kind of come to snuggle. Oh. And I'm thinking, I did this well. Oh, God, I have goosebumps. They're both back home for the moment. So it's really, that's like, oh, wow. You know, you just want to come and lay on me like that, like you used to do when you were like this. I told Steve the other day, my son's 16. And I said, you know what I miss? And he said, what? I said, I miss the full weight of his body on me. So I had one of those heavyweight lifter, 28 year olds yesterday on me like that. And then the other one was sitting next to and Jack was there. And then when Nadam left, the younger one came and laid on top of me like that. And then the other one was sitting next to and Jack was there. And then when Nadam left, the younger one came and laid on top of me like that. And I just thought, man, this is like, you know, there's nothing more. That's it. That's fine. That's it. Yes. Okay. Tell me one thing
Starting point is 01:07:57 you're deeply grateful for right now. I mean, I think that this is going to come very obvious. I'm basically really grateful that I have an amazing group of people in my life. Friends, but my team, my friends, my husband. I really am well surrounded, I have to say. I see people who don't have enough. Yeah. Who don't have enough. I say, who can you call?
Starting point is 01:08:26 Who knows about this? Who have you spoken to? And I'm thinking, you know, you are famished. You are famished. And when you are well-supported relationally, you can go do a lot of things. You know? Yeah, I do.
Starting point is 01:08:46 We take it for granted sometimes, don't we? When we're well surrounded. I actually, I don't take it for granted, but I always ask myself, why is it so easy for some and so hard for others? And I do realize that a lot of my work involves my helping people to create community for themselves,
Starting point is 01:09:09 to know how to reach out, to not be afraid, and I'm very directive about it. I have opened my office. I say, I want you to bring someone to the next session that you would like to get to know more, and I then do it.
Starting point is 01:09:23 You know, Zoom has opened up multiple possibilities of things I then do it, you know, Zoom has opened up multiple possibilities of things I can do in a therapy session that is just rich, unending. And so I'm sitting and the friends may be in another part of the country. And I say, your friend asked
Starting point is 01:09:37 to invite you to the therapy session because I asked him or her or them, who is someone who you would like to get closer to? And you were chosen. And I really appreciate you joining us at the therapy session. I know it's rather unconventional, but I think we're going to make it an interesting hour. And, you know, I know that this doesn't end at the end of the session. So that is a different way of understanding emotional support.
Starting point is 01:10:07 It's not one-on-one. It's me helping you have more of others. Okay, we asked for five songs you can't live without. You gave us six. I like that. Nonconformist always, Esther. Okay, so you may have to help me with some of them. Hallelujah by Leonard Cohen. No Me Quippa, Jacques Brel. Oh my God. Is that the most
Starting point is 01:10:33 beautiful song in the whole world? But now we can decide if it's by him, by Nina Simone or by Grace Jones. I didn't know anyone sang it but him. Oh yes. Oh, Grace Jones and Nina Simone both sing it too. I just grew up with him. So, you know, he was Belgian, like me. So it's very interesting. And then we had Saint-Germain, Rose Rouge. Me Velo Guarril?
Starting point is 01:11:01 Me Velo Guarril. By Tam Tam? Yeah, yeah. Bowie? By Idan Reichel Reichel and Fallen by Alicia Keys
Starting point is 01:11:14 it's an unusual list right? It is but I want you to tell us in one sentence what this mini mixtape says about you Esther that I'm a person of the world, that music from all corners of the world enters into my vein, that I can sing it and play it even when I don't understand a word I say. I learned an entire English repertoire without knowing what the words meant
Starting point is 01:11:46 as a kid, but I sang it phonetically. I made this little list with my younger son, Noam, because he's my musical interlocutor. He's the one we talk and share music. I turned him on to some of these. He then feeds them back to me. There's acid jazz in here. There is salsa and Latin American music and Brazilian music, which I was in a Brazilian band for quite a few years way back. There is French chanson because that's what I grew up with. And then there is Hallelujah because I think Leonard Cohen is the most transgressive of them all, the poet of them all. And because it's meant to be an incantation and of praise, you know, and it's complete hedonistic, you know, and it has the paradox in it, the way that we described it.
Starting point is 01:12:31 So that's what it says about me, multicultural from everywhere. I don't need to understand the words to know what they say. And it's an incredible dialogue to share with your kids or a friend or someone. I actually wrote a letter to one of my childhood friends asking him, you who turned me on to so many bands, because he was the real American rock person that I knew in Belgium, what would you say were your main ones? And he said, do you remember? We were 14 and we went to the first concert of Genesis.
Starting point is 01:13:04 And then we had that guitar solo. And I mean, it was like, I hadn't spoken to him in two years and he wrote me our history musically. It's beautiful. Concert. And I said, just that question from Brene has been so wonderful to go back to, you know, it's an amazing dialogue to have with people is the shared love of music. It's beautiful. I am so grateful that we are sharing this time and space on earth with you. I really am.
Starting point is 01:13:30 That's all I can say, that I am so glad in a big universal way, our paths have crossed many times. And I hope with more intention in the future. The last time we spoke and we said we should do something, we were both at South by. Yeah. South by Southwest. And I said, I would love one day to talk together because you and I talking together is like those songs put on the same list.
Starting point is 01:13:57 We bring very different landscapes, very different metaphors, but they speak to the same thing. Oh, it's beautiful. Well, I will sing with you anytime. Let's do it. Thank you, Esther. My pleasure. Thank you so much. Let me just go on the record and say that I will talk with Astaire anytime about anything. I will sing with her. I will try to read in French with her. I just, she's incredible. I'm so happy that we got to talk to her on Unlocking Us. I hope you learned from her as well. And I hope you were feeling bad
Starting point is 01:14:41 for me while I was in the middle of the Astaire Perel Smackdown. You can barely call it a Smackdown. Would you call it a Smackdown, Barrett? I wouldn't. I'd say you got stared. Oh, I got a stared. Yeah, I did get a stared. She has stared me down. Y'all can always count on some really good jokes from me. We have an episode page for every podcast. And so if you're looking for Esther's books, her podcast, her game that she talked about, which is really interesting, you can find all of that on brennebrown.com.
Starting point is 01:15:16 Just go to the Esther Perel podcast page. Or you can go directly to her website, which is estherperel.com. E-S-T-H-E-R-P-E-R-E-L.com. She is on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook. All the handles are on our episode page. So grateful that you're joining us for both Unlocking Us and Dare to Lead. Y'all stay awkward, brave, and kind. Take care. See you next week. Unlocking Us is produced by Brene Brown Education and Research Group. The music is by Keri Rodriguez and Gina Chavez. Get new episodes as soon as they're published by following Unlocking Us on your favorite podcast
Starting point is 01:15:59 app. We are part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Discover more award-winning shows at podcasts.voxmedia.com. Well, that's why we built HubSpot. It's an AI-powered customer platform that builds campaigns for you, tells you which leads are worth knowing, and makes writing blogs, creating videos, and posting on social a breeze. So now, it's easier than ever to be a marketer. Get started at HubSpot.com slash marketers. Support for this show is brought to you by Nissan Kicks. It's never too late to try new things. And it's never too late to reinvent yourself.
Starting point is 01:16:50 The all-new reimagined Nissan Kicks is the city-sized crossover vehicle that's been completely revamped for urban adventure. From the design and styling to the performance, all the way to features like the Bose Personal Plus sound system, you can get closer to everything you love about city life in the all-new, reimagined Nissan Kicks. Learn more at www.nissanusa.com slash 2025 dash kicks. Available feature, Bose is a registered trademark of the Bose Corporation.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.