Unseen - The Cherry Hill Serial Killer | The Case of Jennifer Wertz | UNSEEN

Episode Date: January 11, 2024

“I think I got mom’s blood on me.” -- On February 22nd, 1991, Dede Rosenthal disappeared from her Cherry Hill apartment: there were no signs of any disturbance, and the case grew cold, but no one ever expected that only 4 years later, another crime took place but this time, to Dede’s neighbor. However, 14-year-old Jennifer Wertz survived the night and would become the key to the mystery of Dede’s story. External Footage from: "ID", "Peacock", "Dead of Night", "Redish", "NBC", "Lifetime", "Unsolved Mysteries", "Dede Rosenthal", "Weinberger", "On the Case", "The Cherry Hill Murders", "Discovery", "RMM", "Signs of a Psychopath". Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

He wanted me to kill him. Jennifer, she's just crying. How did you want to do with her? He said he couldn't spend his life in jail. Some hell or another that popped into my mind. That killer. And so he wanted me to stab him with a knife. The voice you've just heard is 14-year-old Jennifer Wirtz.

The man she's referring to is known as the Cherry Hill killer. May seem like she stabbed him to save herself, but the truth is much more disturbing. He told me not to look. I could hear the blows. I was covered in blood. On October 6, 1995, police found Jennifer sitting quietly on the front porch of her house

after someone called 911, but nothing could have prepared them for what they were about to discover inside. The scene behind me was one that nightmares are made of. It was difficult to recognize that she was even human. February 22, 1991, four years before Jennifer was found, D.D. Rosenthal disappears from her seventh floor,

apartment, no sign of entry is identified, but what's most disturbing is that, at the time, Didi was Jennifer's next-door neighbor. And now she feels completely shaken by all this. Police were taking no chances with this guy believing him to be extremely dangerous. To this day, the Cherry Hill killer is still alive, and it is now up to Jennifer, the only survivor, to take him down before he makes another victim. Obviously, this is a tragedy. It is a violent end to an already horrific story. Seven years before Jennifer's attack, following a difficult divorce, Rebecca Words and her daughter Jennifer moved into the Somerset Tower, a seventh floor apartment building located in Cherry Hill, New Jersey.

My father was kind of in and out of our lives. I think that my mom was very lonely at that time. But Rebecca didn't stay single for long. She met an eccentric janitor named Eddie, who worked in the same apartment complex. In no time, he moved in with them, and together they formed a new, happy family. He was full of smiles and laughter and she was happy around him. But this didn't last. Eddie had a few quirks for sure, but as time went on, his behavior became increasingly erratic, especially towards Jennifer. Once we lived in the apartment, he definitely changed. He was very controlling, just very strange, very weird behavior.

Despite his occasional antics, Eddie gained Rebecca's trust over time and was tasked to watch over her daughter while she worked on the weekends. This is where Jennifer's abuse. where Jennifer's abuse at the hands of Eddie started. Even at only seven years old, she knew she had to do something. So she gathered all of her courage and revealed everything to her mom. Rebecca coldly told her that she simply imagined things, but Jennifer wasn't duped. She knew the things Eddie forced her to do were wrong.

And I'm like, what is happening? What are you doing? And I got really angry with my mom. On February 26, 1991, three years into Jennifer's ordeal at the Somerset Tower, police knocked on the door of her mother's apartment. They explained that four days ago, their next door neighbor disappeared without a trace. Detectives were now investigating every resident and employee in the building. Earlier that day, they interviewed Eddie and were surprised by the fact that he personally knew the victim. How longed with Ms. Rosenzell got with the apartment complex?

I would say he was there a year. You had a day in the meter? I'd welcome her a few times in the hallway, at least. She leaked to her. No, I thought she was pretty nice. Didi Rosenthal, an autism therapist who immigrated to the U.S. from Canada, less than a year ago, was last seen on February 22nd. According to her brother Blaine, she chose to move to New Jersey to accomplish her dream of joining the Elwyn Institute of Philadelphia, a clinic tailored for mentally disabled children. But her brother knew that the U.S. could be a little rough around the edges compared to Canada, so he insisted she'd pick an apartment on the top floor of a secured building.

If there was anything I could have done to get her not to go to the U.S. I thought, give her a year, give her two years, and then she'll come back. I was wrong. Hey, honey, it's mom. Did you know if we switch to Verizon, we can get four phones for $0, plus four lines for $25 a line? Call me back. Me again. That's just $100 a month for four lines on Unlimited Welcome.

Plus four phones, no trade-in needed. Call me. It's mom. America's Best Network, Verizon, that's the one we're talking about. I'll send you text. America's Best Network based on Root Metrics, Best Overall Mobile Network Performance, U.S. second half, 2025. Four new lines and a limit and welcome and auto pay.

See Verizon.com for details. At that point, the police had two suspects in mind. Both were part of the apartment complex maintenance team. The first, Steve Gomez, was Dee's boyfriend. The second, Charles Reddish, was simply too strange for the police to ignore. The thing is that, to most people, he was known by another name. What was that name? That was crazy, Eddie.

Something just wasn't right with Eddie. The man claimed he spent the night of the 22nd with Jennifer's mother in their apartment. They spoke with Rebecca Wirtz, and Rebecca told the police that Charles Reddish had been home in their apartment all night long. The prosecutor couldn't help but notice Jennifer's fear when he mentioned Eddie in front of her mother. I'll never forget to look on her face. I wanted to do anything I could to protect her. Before the police got a chance to do a second. second interview with the Warts, the family moved out of the building. It may seem suspicious

now, but at the time, many residents left Somerset Tower after what happened to Didi. The circumstances surrounding her disappearance didn't add up, and when detectives ran forensics on her apartment, they were baffled by the results. What they found was a pristine apartment. There was no forced entry into the house. There's no blood spatter, there's no shell casing. Even the bed was made. There was no physical evidence whatsoever. The only piece of evidence of value they gathered was hidden inside Diti's date book. She had tucked a receipt for $80 into her date book from an automated teller machine. But what really convinced them that she didn't just run away was her downstairs neighbor's testimony.

An elderly lady who lived alone woke up and it was around 4 o'clock in the morning and she heard a thud on the ceiling of her apartment. and it would have been the floor of Dee Dee's apartment. With no other suspect or clues, the case slowly went cold. But the incident struck the imagination of the American public. Various TV shows and publications picked up the story, including NBC's massively popular Unsolved Mystery Series. From her new home north of Cherry Hill,

Jennifer couldn't help but feel sorry for Dee Dee and her family. For them, for years, they had no idea what happened to her. She just was missing. To most, the police clearly did everything they could, but this wasn't enough for Dede's brother, Blaine Rosenberg. That's all. I wouldn't give up. I traveled to Cherry Hill 67 times. I went into local bars, local restaurants with her picture.

As the years passed by, Blaine tried his best to balance his personal life and his quest to find his sister. But eventually, his obsession got the better of him. When I got home, my wife said, Blaine, I want you out of the house. this is no joke. Get out. The disappearance of Dady cost me everything. And as Blaine hit rock bottom,

so did Jennifer and Rebecca. Since the family moved, they came to understand why Eddie received his crazy epithet. The man was totally out of control, constantly acting like a child and shooting violent insults.

His anger towards Rebecca kept growing to a point where, even if she never saw him directly hit her, Jennifer knew her mom was also a victim of him. his. I felt like whenever my mom would try to stand up to him, he would throw a fit, just getting angry. Jennifer had endured Eddie's abuse for seven agonizing years, and now her own mother was getting thrown into the mix. She knew this couldn't last any longer. So, after arguing for hours, Jennifer eventually convinced Rebecca that she needed to leave Eddie. Everything was planned in advance,

but Rebecca made one crucial mistake. She told Eddie about it. We were going to be moving into my grandmother's house. She promised me that he was never going to be there. I would never have to see him. I was ecstatic. On Jennifer's last day of school, Rebecca got her daughter to pack all of her things and promised her that she would be waiting for her by the schoolyard at 6 p.m. right after her last field hockey game. I walked off the field and her car was there, but Ed was driving. So I immediately got angry, yelling at her that I knew that this was going to happen and why could she never keep her word? and she just, just Jennifer get in the car. The silence in the car was heavy.

In the rearview mirror, Jennifer couldn't help but notice that Eddie was fixating on her. She couldn't pinpoint what, but something felt terribly wrong. I just knew that he was going to do something to stop us from moving, but I never imagined what would happen. Once they arrived, Eddie claimed that all he wanted was to have one last dinner together as a family, but Jennifer was worried. We get there and I said, there's not. Not even anything made.

There's no dinner here. You know, what are we doing here? Eddie Sloppily tried to pull together some form of explanation before insisting that he needed Rebecca's car for groceries. Before she could answer, he left with the keys in a hurry. Now that they were alone, Jennifer tried to convince her mother to leave before his return, but Rebecca ignored her. In a fit, Jennifer ran upstairs to her room.

Then, without fully realizing it, the teenager fell asleep for hours. Later, in the middle of the night, a loud noise suddenly woke her up. It was about 2 a.m. I knew that something was really, really wrong. Jennifer stood up and started walking down the stairway. As she grew closer, the noise became clearer and louder. Midway through, she realized what was happening. It was the sound of him punching her in the face.

I don't know how long he had been hitting her. I don't know. But it was already too late. Before she had time to react, Eddie suddenly stopped. And he turned around and came back. towards me with rage in his eyes. Eddie then grabbed Jennifer by the back of her hair and dragged her into the living room. As she grew closer to her mother, she couldn't even grasp the state she was in.

I don't know if she knew that I was there. I don't know that she saw me. I know that her jaw was broken. Her arm was broken. I was asking him to please not hurt her. You know, please just let us go. Eddie threw the young girl onto a chair next to the couch Rebecca was on. He turned back to pick up a drape and a small hatchet he had laid on the floor.

As he slowly walked towards her, Jennifer started panicking. I just immediately started yelling for him to stop. He draped the sheet over top of me, and I just remember going up at a ball. From under the drape, Jennifer could hear her mother breathing. She knew she was still alive. But within seconds, Eddie began striking Rebecca with the hatchet. I could hear the blows. I felt her blood.

After what seemed like a lifetime, he took the sheet off of me and took me upstairs. Eddie dragged her into the bedroom. In there, he did his worst to the traumatized and defenseless teenager. I wasn't out of my sight for another four to five hours. He tortured me for that time. I was covered in blood. I didn't really think that it was ever going to be over. As the sun was rising, Eddie stopped and sat next to Jennifer,

amidst all the horrible things he did to her that night, what he was about to ask her next was simply too much for the young girl. And then he asked me to kill him. I said that I couldn't do that. So he said that he would just kill me and then kill . Faced with an impossible dilemma, Jennifer summoned her courage and attempted to guide Eddie toward a third option. Just like a hostage negotiator, the 14-year-old used de-escalation tactics to calm him down

By listening carefully, asking questions without judgment and showing understanding, Jennifer slowly convinced Eddie to spare not only her life, but also his. They said, if you turn yourself in, they're going to give you a deal. They'll go easier on you. You can just say that you had a moment of insanity. Hesitant, Eddie stood up and started pacing around the bedroom, hatchet in hand. He was visibly shaken by her words, almost like he slowly came to realize what he had done. Against all odds, she persuaded him to give himself up.

He called his own mother, who then called the police. He said to get dressed and that we had to go outside and wait for the police that they were on their way. That was in shock. We went out on the front porch and wasn't even sure that he still wasn't going to do something before the cops came. He was so unpredictable. It must have been certainly a surreal experience to be sitting there with the man who just killed your mother and said, When the police arrived, they immediately separated Jennifer from Eddie. Their next concern was Rebecca.

James Ronka, one of the prosecutors in charge of the case, recalls Eddie's strange reaction when the police asked him about her whereabouts. Reddish made some cryptic statement about the victim being inside and he asked if she need an ambulance and he said no. It's too late for that. Once in the hands of the police, Jennifer had a hard time assessing what happened. Even Ronka, an experienced prosecutor, never had to deal with a victim so mentally shocked before. Jennifer was very traumatized.

She was still wearing her field hockey uniform, looking just so absolutely forlorn. After Ronka finished interviewing Jennifer, reinforcement from the Cherry Hill Police Department arrived at the station. Detective Brian Mallow, the same man who questioned Eddie four years ago at Somerset Tower, was asked to interview him once again. We drove up to Burlington County. They allowed his access to him in a room, and we brought a tape recorder. For the most part, Eddie and Jennifer's versions of the event were roughly concordant until the assault in the bedroom.

Seemingly, Eddie refused to admit what he did to Jennifer. Did you have any f*** with Jennifer? Why do you think that Jennifer would mention it? you know, because of a lot of it. That's why I always liked her. You know, just cute, all. He literally is laughing as he is talking about a 14-year-old girl.

Following Eddie's full confession regarding Rebecca's murder and Jennifer's assault, Detective Molo, who had never forgotten Eddie since Dede's disappearance, knew there was more where that came from. I thought at this point he would be particularly vulnerable. And they start asking Charles Reddish, again about the disappearance of D.D.

To the surprise of the prosecutors and the detective, Eddie immediately confess. After four years, he finally tells what happened. You know, they asked you some question regarding the disappearance of D.D. Rosenthal at the Somerset House apartments in Cherry Hill, New Jersey. Figure, it's time. People know the truth. For some reason, I took the stairs. to the roof, I swung down onto the balcony of D.D. Rosenzville apartment.

And she spotted me. He let it out a screen. And he realizes she's going to recognize me. And at that point, he makes the decision to kill her. There was a minor struggle, and she fell off the bed, which was the thud that the lady downstairs heard. I knew that he passed away. I went to the kitchen, found $80 exactly in care of her pocketbook. I took that.

And I peaked down to the hall, nobody was around, took her in a shopping cart, down and out the back door of the apartment complex. He brought her out through these doors across the parking lot. Could you describe where you took Ms. Rosenthal off a route 130? There was a dirt road that you could drive back there and I took her from the car. into weeds and left her there. We found out that every year they dredged the Delaware River and pump the dredge waste into this area. By the time we got here, Dedi would have been under between 50, 75,

even up to 100 feet of dredge materials. Yamava Resort and Casino at San Manuel is California's number one entertainment destination for today's superstars. Catch the Jonas Brothers return to the Yamava Theater Stage on April 30th, the powerful vocals of Demi Lovato on May 17th, and the signature Southern Country Rock of Eric Church on July 19th. Tickets on sale now at yamava Theater.com, only at Yamava Resort and Casino,

celebrating its 40th anniversary. You in? Must be 21 to enter. After the search for Dede's body was abandoned, the two cases fell into the hands of Prosecutor Albright from Cherry Hill and Ronka from Burlington. After meeting his attorney for the first time, Eddie immediately recanted both confessions. And even if he wouldn't have, a confession alone wasn't enough to sentence him. In New Jersey, under our law, you can't convict a person on their word alone, i.e. their confession. You have to corroborate the confession.

This is when the rigorous police work that took place in 1991 came into play. Even if Eddie removed all traces of Dede's murder after the act, there remained one little thing he forgot. The ATM receipt the police found tucked behind the cover of Dede's date book. He specifically tells the Cherry Hill detectives that he took $80 out of that pocketbook. For me, the ultimate, the cherry on the corroboration Sunday was that macroceit, and I couldn't wait for the jury to see that. Since Jennifer survived, thanks to her own negotiating skills, the first trial was a swift one. The jury took less than 40 minutes to come back with a guilty verdict after hearing her testimony. For the murder of Rebecca and the assault of Jennifer, Eddie received a life sentence.

Meanwhile, Albright was preparing for the second trial. She wanted more than a double life sentence. She was aiming for the death penalty for Didi's murder. So legally, justice is done. But in real life, what is justice when you've lost your family member to murder? With his confession recanted, Eddie had a very good chance of being found not guilty. His lawyer used all the tips and false sightings the police received after Didi's appearance on unsolved mystery to misrepresent the case. He was attempting to fool the audience

into thinking that Didi was alive and well that she simply abandoned her family and her career to start anew elsewhere. I wanted the jurors to know that Didi was not some flighty young thing who just decided one day, you know what? I'm tired of Cherry Hill, I'm tired of my job, I'm tired of my family.

Because to believe that she was still alive, you would have to believe all those things. And it worked. This angle, joined by the ATM receipt, suffice to convince the jury. Jennifer and Dede's brother Blaine, though emotional, celebrated their victory. I cried my eyes out. The first time I really cried my eyes out. That was when we put up a marker. We had flowers. It was over. Until 2004, a review of the court proceedings proved that the judge presiding over the audience made a mistake in his address to the jury. This was enough for the court

to ask for a retrial, and Albright knew that the New Jersey jurisdiction, was about to abolish the death penalty. I convicted him once and I was pretty sure I was going to be able to convict him twice. With the death penalty impending abolition, avoiding a trial was the soundest option. So, after talking with Blaine and Jennifer, the prosecutor offered Eddie a deal. That he would plead guilty to Deed his murder and he would receive a sentence that would keep him in prison for the rest of his life. Eddie was finally sentenced in the summer of 2005, 10 years after his initial arrest, in 1995. During that time, Jennifer rebuilt her life from the ground up. She moved in with Shannon,

one of her adult sisters, and ultimately got the chance to experience a normal life. She attended Catholic school, joined a cheerleading team, and made many friends along the way. Not only that, but Shannon and her two other sisters all formed a strong support system around Jennifer. As a teenager, I really worked very, very hard to not let it affect me. As an adult, Jennifer continued to thrive and eventually even became a mother herself. But her past ordeal took on a new meaning after she gave birth to her two daughters, especially in the way she perceived her own mother's tragic death. Now as a mother, it's a different type of pain.

I think of my girls getting married. My mother never got to see any of her girls get married. That's how it affects me now, just missing the things for her. Although Jennifer got some form of closure after Eddie's arrest, the same couldn't necessarily be said about Dede's family. Without a body, they may never know what really happened to her. All they have is Eddie's word. After learning about Didi's murder,

as horrific as what happened to me was, at least I know what happened. To honor his sister's memory, Blaine started a foundation bearing her name, which provides support services to women experiencing physical or emotional abuse. Overall, he chose to focus on her legacy more than anything else. There were a lot of memories that I'll never forget. I miss Didi. I'll never forget Didi. And the same is true for Jennifer. There's no way to be sure, but Rebecca was probably also a victim of Eddie's abuse,

long before the murders, which could have led to some of her questionable decisions. in the past. Some may say she could have done much more to protect her daughter, but it doesn't mean there weren't moments of genuine love between the two of them. And these earnest memories deserve to be celebrated. I miss my mother every day. Going to the beach with her, singing with her, dancing in the kitchen. That's what I like to think of.