Up First from NPR - Biden Falters In First Debate, Trump Spews Falsehoods, New Oklahoma School Mandate

Episode Date: June 28, 2024

President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump attacked each other's presidencies during their first presidential debate last night. While Trump spewed falsehoods, Biden, at times, just didn't make sense. And in Oklahoma, the top education official has ordered public schools to begin teaching the Bible in classrooms. Want more comprehensive analysis of the most important news of the day, plus a little fun? Subscribe to the Up First newsletter. Today's episode of Up First was edited by Megan Pratz, Lisa Thomson, Tara Neill and HJ Mai. It was produced by Ziad Buchh, Chris Thompson and Nina Kravinsky. We get engineering support from Robert Rodriguez. And our technical director is Zac Coleman.Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoicesNPR Privacy Policy

Last night, President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump attacked each other's presidencies in their first debate. But what defined the night were the falsehoods Trump spewed while Biden at times just didn't make sense. I'm Leila Faldil, that's Michelle Martin, and this is Up First from NPR News. The two men took jabs at each other during the 90-minute debate. This place, the whole world is blowing up under him. This guy's three years younger and a lot less competent. And somehow the night ended with Biden and Trump trashing each other's golf game, who scored more points with the American public.

And Oklahoma's top education official has ordered public schools to begin teaching the Bible in classrooms. What does this mean for students and teachers? Stay with us. We'll give you the news you need to start your day. Now Our Change will honor 100 years of the Royal Canadian Air Force and their dedicated service to communities at home and abroad. From the skies to our change, this $2 commemorative circulation coin marks their storied past and promising future. Find the limited edition Royal Canadian Air Force $2 coin today. We all hear things differently,

and that can be tough when there's so much noise. This election year, we're a space to speak up and to listen. Listen to 1A for the latest on election 2024, only from NPR. Democrats and Republicans alike are absorbing what they saw in last night's presidential debate. President Biden and former President Trump took questions from CNN moderators. Biden's voice was raspy and he was sometimes hard to follow. That alarmed prominent Democrats about a president who is 81, asked a question about the national debt. The president said he would wipe it out. And then he said his administration would also help with child care and health care.

Making sure that we're able to make every single solitary person eligible for what I've been able to do with the COVID, excuse me, with dealing with everything we have to do with, look, if we finally beat Medicare. Thank you, President Biden. On his turns at the mic, Trump confidently and repeatedly made assertions that were often factually wrong. He also repeated parts of his campaign speeches with little pushback or rebuttal, and each candidate described the other's presidency as a failure.

Our country doesn't have a chance, not even a chance, of coming out of this rut. We probably won't have a country left anymore. That's how bad it is. He is the worst in history by far. Thank you, President Trump. President Biden? We're the most admired country in the world. We're the United States of America. There's nothing beyond our capacity. We have the finest military in the history of the world, the finest in the history of the world. No one thinks we're weak. No one wants to screw around with us. Nobody. Our colleague Steve Inskeep anchored NPR's coverage of the debate. And we have on hand some of the NPR politics team who was watching with me,

Daniel Kurtzleben and Domenico Montanaro. Good morning to you both. Hey there. Hey. What did you take away from this meeting? Well, I mean, first and foremost, I mean, the elephant in the room was that Democrats really were very nervous about the performance that Joe Biden gave. You know, people close to him on the record were talking about how this was a disappointing effort. You know, his campaign said that he had a cold. That's why his voice was hoarse. He sounded weak, somewhat feeble. And the problem with that is it plays into his key vulnerability,

which is his age and his competency to do the job. And it didn't do anything to reassure the very voters that he needs to be reassured that he needs to go out and vote for him. I guess we should note the elephant in the room in this case would be a donkey. But, Danielle, what were your impressions? Well, I'll take the Trump side of this here. Let me just say that looking at my inbox, looking at Twitter, I guess we now call it X, Republicans especially are sort of doing a victory dance, saying that Trump looked so strong compared to Biden, who just looked old. But let's also keep in mind here that this is Trump, so he said a lot of things that are flat out not true. Let's go through some of the issues that were discussed in the last several days on NPR News. We had debate prep. We went through various big issues we expected to come up, and they did. So we brought back some of our correspondents who were listening. I'm Scott Horsley. I cover the economy for NPR. And what struck me about the debate tonight is how little we heard from either candidate about where they want to take the economy from here. A lot of finger pointing, a lot of dubious claims,

and very little in terms of where these two men want to take an economy that has performed well, but where people are still anxious every time they have to buy groceries or pay the rent. Danielle, what do you make of that? Scott's right on that. Viewers watching this just probably didn't get great ideas of what these two want to do on the economy. Now on Trump's side, here are a couple bullet points. He favors 10% tariffs, a blanket across the board, which economists say would raise prices on U.S. consumers, meaning it would add to inflation, which is one of consumers' biggest economic concerns. Now Trump was asked about this and he denied it, but tariffs very much do raise prices. Now, one other plan that Trump has is to extend the 2017 tax cuts that he and Republicans in Congress imposed, the Tax Cuts

and Jobs Act. That expires next year and the next president would have to work with Congress to extend it or not. Now, this is one area where they really differ. Now, Biden wants to extend the tax cuts for people earning under $400,000 a year, which is to say the overwhelming majority of Americans. But that also means he wants to raise taxes on high income Americans, which is a very popular policy idea. Let's hear from another of our correspondents who is listening in. I'm Sergio Martinez Beltran, and I cover immigration for NPR. And one thing that I found interesting about this debate was the part when President Trump was asked whether he was going to deport millions of undocumented immigrants, and he didn't respond. And I thought that was interesting,

because that has been a promise that President Trump has made. And this was his moment to arguably explain what would that look like. And he didn't respond to that. Why is that significant? Well, immigration has been the top issue for Trump and Republicans, certainly blaming Biden for the surge of migrants who've come into the country. But there are millions upon millions of people in the country who've been here for a long time, paid taxes. And it's not quite as popular to say, we're going to deport everyone who is in the country who've been here for a long time, paid taxes. And it's not quite as popular to say we're going to deport everyone who is in the country outright carte blanche as opposed to keeping people out. Yes, Trump did pivot away from deportation, but on multiple other questions,

he did bring things back to immigration. And these are questions about things that a lot of Americans care about, child care, addiction, also lingering concerns about January 6th. And on all three of those, Trump pivoted back to immigration, tried to talk about immigrant crime that has happened while Biden has been president. This is, of course, one of Trump's big lines in his rally speeches and pretty much any interview he gives. So that's where he's comfortable. It's a thing that he just wanted to keep talking about. And that means he did not really answer questions about January 6th or about accepting a free and fair election. Let's hear another of our correspondents who sent a voice memo. I'm Frank Ordonez. I cover the Trump campaign. And what I noticed in the debate was while Biden struggled with a raspy voice throughout the debate, he really perked up when Trump started to attack him on foreign policy.

Biden started to speak more forcefully when addressing his son, Beau Biden. But he also pushed back when talking about Ukraine and taking on Putin and bringing allies together. Did we hear the things that Biden really cares about there? Well, I mean, arguably, there's no greater cleavage than foreign policy between these two men, because they just feel completely differently about how to handle it, how to appear on the world stage, how to unite allies together, whether or not you should even be involved in NATO at all. And this is something that Biden has dealt with for decades. He was chairman of the Foreign

Relations Committee while he was a senator. He feels very strongly about this. He's traveled all over the world, takes it very personally, especially when Trump attacks him, saying that he doesn't care about veterans or veterans don't like him. And he was able to use that to sort of talk about his son, Beau, who had died and to sort of throw that back at Trump to make Trump look like somebody who doesn't care. And Piers Domenico Montanaro and Daniel Kurtzleben, thanks to you both requires all schools to teach from the Bible. State Superintendent Ryan Walters says the requirement will ensure students grasp the, quote, core values of our country. But the announcement brought an immediate backlash. Beth Wallace is an education reporter for State Impact Oklahoma, which is a nonprofit reporting collaboration among NPR stations.

And she's with us now to tell us more about this. Good morning, Beth. Good morning. So what exactly does this new requirement say? So Walters originally announced that every classroom would have a Bible and every teacher would teach from the Bible. But those details began to evolve throughout the day. In a memo to schools and when pressed by reporters, he clarified that it would only be for fifth through 12th graders and only for social studies and English. I should also say Walters is a conservative who has made a name for himself nationally by vowing to get wokeness out of the classroom.

So this is very on brand for him. But the obvious question here is, can he do that? I mean, separation of church and state, you know, the prohibition against the sort of promotion of one state religion. Those are core American values, not to mention constitutional requirements. So can he do that? Well, so in Oklahoma, our social studies standards say you should teach religion as part of history. And it outlines several ways religious history should be incorporated. For example, the role of Christianity in colonial America or the significance of religion in world geography and borders.

And Walters did clarify that he wants teachings on the Bible's impacts to be, quote, strictly from a historical perspective, which that's pretty close to what the academic standards say anyway. But he's also not leaving out of his argument these very common refrains we've heard a lot from him about what he considers to be leftist influence in schools. What we have done is taken God out of schools, taken the Bible out of schools, and it doesn't make sense to teach American history without understanding what the founders were saying as they were doing these momentous things. You know, I also think it's important to note that Oklahoma law is very clear on decisions

about textbooks and curriculum and instructional materials. Those decisions fall exclusively under the purview of school districts and not the State Department that Walters is in charge of. Given all that, what's been the reaction? So I talked to the State Attorney General's office and they said they've looked at the letter to schools. They actually don't read it as requiring the Bible to be taught. I also spoke with a Democratic state representative, Jacob Rosecrans. He used to be a middle and high school history teacher, and he said he's been reached out to by hundreds of teachers who are concerned and confused. And they're like, okay, this is really, really bad.

Like, why would somebody even do this? We already had the freedom to do this. Why would somebody even do this? We already had the freedom to do this. Why would somebody mandate this happen? You know, we're also seeing civil liberties groups come out against this. The group Americans United for Separation of Church and State, they already have a few lawsuits against Walters. They said in a statement that they would do everything in their power to stop the mandate. That is Beth Wallace with State Impact Oklahoma. Beth, thank you so much. Thank you.

And that's Up First for Friday, June 28th. I'm Michelle Martin. And I'm Laila Faldil. Don't forget, Up First airs on the weekend, too. Aisha Roscoe and Scott Simon have the news. It'll be here in this feed or wherever you get your podcasts. Today's episode of Up First was edited by Andrea DeLeon, Megan Pratt, H.J. Mai, Jenea Williams, and Lisa Thompson.

It was produced by Paige Waterhouse, Ziak Butch, Chris Thomas, and Katie Klein. We get engineering support from Stacey Abbott, and our technical director is Zach Coleman. Our executive producer is Erika Aguilar. Join us again on Monday.