Transcript
Discussion (0)
From Relay, welcome to the 12th Annual Upgradees,
simulcast from London, England and Mill Valley, California.
This broadcast is brought to you by Century, eCAM, and FitPod.
My name is Mike Hurley, and I am honored to be joined by my esteemed co-host,
a master of ceremonies
Jason Snell
Hi Jason Snell
Hi Mike Hurley
It is good to finally get the ceremonies in line
They were out of line
They were causing trouble
Yeah
But I've gotten them back in line
As is my job as the master of ceremonies
So this is what we rely on you for
Ceremony's lined up all
We're going to fly right here
It's the upgradeies again
12th annual remember
Unbelievable
I like to think of it as the
What 11th anniversary
Of the first annual
I think about this often
Whenever I hear somebody say
first annual, because you hear it, and then
someone inevitably goes, you can't say
that, I think to myself, you can't say that. You absolutely can.
You can, you're just wrong. You can't. You did say it. Twelve years
later, here we are.
12 years later, here we are. Because I knew it. I knew this
is going to be a success. I knew it was.
The upgrade is at the award show
where we get to crown our favorite things
of the year in a wide variety of
categories from media to hardware to
stories of the year. You can find
a history of previous winners,
over at Upgradees.com
and in the show notes of this episode
there are appropriate links to all of the nominees
so I guess spoilers for the show notes
people ask for this every year
so I've gone through and taken care of that for you
the way that the Upgradies works
is Jason and I will be sharing
our personal nominations where we have them
for each category
will also share the top three nominations
as voted for by our listeners
and you'll get to hear us then
between the two of us deliberate
who and who we think
deserves the trophy of the year.
And also, as a reminder, for a category that can only, you can only win on an app or a podcast
or whatever can only win a category, a maximum of three times.
And then that winner will be raised into the rafters, given a lifetime.
Upgraded to the Hall of Fame, really?
Lifetime achievement.
Hall of Fame is a different thing.
Oh, you're right.
You're right.
Upgraded to the Lifetime Achievement.
The Hall of Fame is.
is something that we honor every 10 years.
That's a ridiculous.
So we had our first Decadal Hall of Fame.
Yeah.
I was thinking about this today.
Of like,
maybe it'll be five years.
Maybe we'll do around in five years.
It might actually,
that's actually a good idea.
We'll see.
But even every five or ten years,
we take a look at all of the previous winners
and then we decide who gets to be put into the Hall of Fame.
But Lifetime Achieve.
Award is what you get. And if you're a lifetime achievement award winner, you are forever
mentioned in the category in which you've won. So it's a little nod to you, but it's so we
won't have, I don't know, ATP win forever. Basically, this is the ATP rule. That was why
it was instituted. And now everybody else benefits. Before we get into the first categories,
I would like to mention this is the absolute last call to get 20% off an annual plan of Upgrade
Plus. So you can get for just $56 a year, longer ad-free episodes, you'll be helping to support
this show. If you're listening to this episode and you're enjoying it, you're an upgradian
and you absolutely should become an Upgrade Plus subscriber because you're in with us now.
You know, like you're in it. You get it. If you like this, you'll definitely like Upgrade
plus. It's an additional bonus topic every week. It's always a good fun time and you don't
have to have any interruptions in your listening. But yes, with the code 2025 holidays,
check out at getupgradeplus.com.
This will only be available until the end of the year.
So if you're listening to this and you've yet to sign up, then please go and do that.
And you'll be helping to support the show too.
Thank you so much to everybody that does.
Shall we get on with the first category, Jason?
Yeah, before we do, I have a little disclaimer I want to make here.
I just want to make this clear to people.
While other podcasts and websites in our sphere have decided that they're going to manufacture
your trophies and mail them out to people,
we don't.
No.
Just to be clear, if you're a winner,
do not wait by the mailbox for your trophy.
If you are a winner and you would like a digital trophy,
I can send you artwork and assets for your heart's content
if you want to display it on your website, as many people have.
The reason that we don't do trophies is because we don't just award, like, indie apps.
We're also awarding, like, best movie of the year.
And I don't think water brothers
We don't send a Lusite slab
To the winner of the best book
That I pick every year
I mean we could
We could
Especially if Dan Moran wins
I know that Dan will take the award
Like I
He's gonna be in the Hall of Fame
Runners Up Hall of Fame
That's where he's gonna end up
For dad
Did we put him in the Hall of Fame
I don't remember
No
No because he never wins
He only is a he's only always a runner up
I do want to say
I want to shout out
Rogamiba
because if you scroll down to the bottom
of the audio hijack page
and this was something
that we may have actually helped instigate
with
with Paul Kaffasas at Rogamiba
but it says what people are saying
about audio hijack and the first one
is three-time best Mac app winner
enshrived in the life
in the lifetime achievement section
with a big logo
we love to see it
if you want to do that
we'll be happy to provide
I'm just saying don't wait for the trophy
I provided some of these assets
so that could be done
because the little reef one is of that.
Yeah, so like, and there's many people
I think Casey has put it on the
core sheet
website. Oh yeah, that's true.
That's true. Many people have used it.
Official keeper and Upgrady's historian Zoe Knox
points out that Dan Moran did win
for the Caledonian Gambit his first novel.
So way back in 2017.
I didn't have my spreadsheet open enough
to see that way back in 2017.
The spreadsheet is so large.
now because we've been doing it so long.
Spreadsheetsheet's too big.
Spreadsheet can be helpful, but it's a big old spreadsheet.
So we get into our first category, which is the best overall iOS app.
So we have a newcomer iOS app that we'll talk about in a little bit.
There are two Lifetime Achievement Award winners of this category.
So we would like to recognize both Overcast and Flighty to apps that continue to get lots of great updates year after.
a year. So they are definitely
two of my favorite and most use
apps. I would still pick them
if I could. I honestly
every time, I traveled a lot this year
as I know from my flighty
passport that I received.
Yep. And I
rely on flighty more and more
as time goes on.
This is the least
I have flown
since I started using flighty
this year. Interesting. I flew more
in 2020 and I did this year.
Wow.
Yeah.
Well, at the beginning of 2020, we were going all over the place.
Like, we had some family stuff going on.
We also went on a California vacation.
We had a great time.
So for me, 34 flights, four days of flight time, almost 39,000 miles.
Yeah.
Now, I will say you said you would recognize it.
You actually did put it in the document.
So you put flighty in there.
Yeah.
Well, you didn't have the lifetimes in there.
And so I figured we would get there when we got there.
And so Jason did one.
to award flighty again but again why not why not well i tell you why not because that's the rules
that's why not so jason what do you have is your nomination your personal nominations for the best
ios app this year you know i i i struggle with this because i every year we do this and i struggle with
it because the fact is i find these apps that i really rely on and like flighty and overcast and i
stick with them of course i'm i'm i'm a i'm a committer mike i say that because and people don't
need to know this, but they can figure it out from the fact that, for example, this is episode
596, that the incomparable is it's episode 798. I've been married for 31 years. I've lived in the
same house since 1999. I'm a committer. I like commit. And when I'm in, I'm in all the way. And the
problem with that is I'm not of a mindset. I like, I will try things, but to integrate something
into my like core workflow it's a high bar because i've done a lot of optimization and like
it's a high bar so it is hard for me with i'm not somebody you know like i admire the max stories
folks that they do like here's 15 different weird apps that i tried this year i just i i mean
i'll sign up for a test flight i'll try stuff i'm just saying it's a tough nut to crack yeah uh
And iOS has become increasingly more so because as the platform has aged, I have optimized even further.
I would love to have a revelation about a different text editor for my iPad than the one I'm using now.
But it hasn't happened yet.
I've tried.
So anyway, this is me lamenting the state of my ability to give awards and app categories before we start the app category.
I, Mike, you have multiple recommendations.
Overcast and flighty are.
off the board. So, okay, I've got two. One is Final Cut Camera, which we relied on a couple of times
this year. Yep. And it's, it's on the iPhone, turns the iPhone, I mean, you can use it in a bunch of
different ways, and it is like a camera app, but it is also the remote for Apple's pretty cool
final cut for iPad remote camera capture feature that I like a lot. I don't know why it isn't
supported on the Mac, too. But it's not, I don't know. There are a lot of mysteries about Final Cut,
but I'm not nominating Final Cut for iPad here. I'm nominating Final Cut camera,
which I was just very impressed with its performance. We used it a lot. That's an app I hadn't
really used before. And it's not grandfathered in in this category. So I'm going to say
Final Cut Camera. And then the other one that I wanted to mention is Call Sheet. I mean,
I know it's by our friend Casey Liss and therefore we are, you know, we don't recuse ourselves.
We'll pick, you know, we'll give our friends awards if we want to.
Colchite won best newcomer in 2020.
But here's the truth of it is, I just use Colchid all the time.
I mean, it's true.
I use it all the time, all the time.
And Lauren uses it all the time.
And to look up, we were just doing it last night.
We're literally like what we watched Wake Up Dead Man, which was great.
And the main actor in that were like, where have we seen him before?
And Lauren took it further.
She's like, well, it's Prince Charles from the Crown, but where else have we seen him?
And it's like, to the call sheet.
Like, that is where you go.
Turns out where we'd seen him recently was in the trailer for the new Steven Spielberg movie.
That's where we saw him recently.
Oh, in an upcoming.
Anyway, so call sheet absolutely is one of the, is one of mine.
What do you have?
I would just say, I love the news, call sheet all the time.
do just want to echo final cut camera. That is a stunningly impressive piece of software.
Like, what that is doing to do the multi-cam stuff is, feels like it would be incredibly complicated.
And that it's absolutely fascinating that it is able to do what it is doing and the way it is doing it.
I think that is really interesting and a really cool piece of software.
My nomination is Mango Baby. So Mango Baby is a baby tracking application of which there are
many available.
Find my baby?
Yes, find my, where's my baby?
Where's a baby?
Track the baby now.
Track the baby, where's the baby?
It's not.
It's like tracking the behaviors of your baby, right?
You're not actually tracking your baby.
You should know where your baby is at all times.
Sleep, bottles, medication, all this kind of stuff, right?
So this is a thing that basically many new, I won't say all, but many new parents do now.
They have some kind of app and they're tracking something.
And different parents track to different degrees.
there are lots of apps available
and most of the apps that exist
are really expensive subscriptions
that are very surprising to me
you know like we've tried out some
apps that are 10, 20 pounds a month
which is just it's a lot of money
for an iPhone app like
I just have a lot of money for an iPhone app
and I think that a lot of the times these apps
are priced this way because they know parents are desperate
and they hope that the sleep tracking
app will help them get their baby to sleep.
Mango Baby is simple in that it is not trying to do anything predictive or anything like
that.
You're just tracking the things that have happened.
But it is a, I believe it's a subscription app, but it's a yearly subscription and it's
very fairly priced.
I love that it allows you to sync with ICloud between multiple parents, which is also
great.
Jason, some of the apps that I've used, they're like.
yes, you can use the multiple parents.
Just share the login.
It's like, that's not, that's not, that's not what we're doing here.
Like, let's try and find a system to sync this information between two people.
But it's also, it is an indie app made by an indie developer.
So it looks great, acts great, shortcuts, actions has built a bunch of great shortcuts using it.
It has widgets, which are really great, nice charts.
I love Mango Baby.
And I'm so happy that an app like this,
existed. I think I asked on this show if people had recommendations before the baby came,
and this was the one that I got recommended to me. Great live activities too, great live
activities, but to be fair, they all have that, which is really good. The Upgradions,
this is one of the categories where we get the most votes. The iOS, like the most singular
different things, if that makes sense, different nominations, different apps. So at 6% of the vote was
Carrot weather. Ivory comes in at 5.4% of the vote and call sheet at 4.3% of the vote.
So, okay, trying to work out a winner for this is complicated because there's not a lot of overlap here.
Right.
So I would like to give Final Cut camera a runner-up.
Okay. Sounds good.
I don't think we would say it was the winner.
That's fine.
I'm not opposed
But I feel like that
For me and you at least
This is a good app to put in
Because we have used it to success
This year multiple times
Yeah
Obviously Mango Baby
I don't think I'm gonna be able to push that to win
I mean this of the year you had a baby
I'm not opposed to it
It's one of my favorite apps of the year
Like I think
And I think it is a fantastic app
That I want more people to know about
And so I would love it to be the winner this year
Because I just think it's brilliant
Call Sheet is obviously in the Upgradians votes
And is in yours as well
I will mention
Carrot Weather
Carrot Weather has won twice
Twice, yeah, it's right on the threshold
Yeah
It's also a Hall of Fame
It's a Hall of Fame winner
Anna's won this category twice.
And Carrot Weather is an app
that continues
like the ones we mentioned previously
to just get better and better
and better and better all the time.
Brian Carrot, Brian Weather,
does not stop.
Brian Carrot Weather.
Brian, the carrot weather.
Yeah, Brian Carrot Weather.
Carrot weather.
Doesn't stop. It's true.
Okay, so I like carrot weather a lot.
I will say that we recently
had a lot of rain here. I know
California. How is it possible? But it
rained for eight straight days. Are you blaming carrot
weather for the rain? What I found
is that
Apple weather did a better job of telling me
when the rain was going to stop.
Like Apple weather seems much more aggressive of
like the rain is stopping in 15 minutes and then
resuming two hours later.
So basically go walk your dog now.
And Carrot doesn't do that.
Although maybe it does do that and I just don't have it set
to do that because maybe
I just have it set wrong. But I
I found myself turning to Apple weather
a little bit more. I guess in that
scenario, you could have the Apple weather
source in carrot weather. Yeah,
I just don't know if it warns me the same
way that the weather app does about
like the comings and goings of rain.
It wasn't. I will say
for me it does. Absolutely.
It does. Okay. You can even have live activities
pop up and stuff like that
to tell you. All right.
Okay, I guess I need to reconfigure
my carrot weather. So that was a thing. And then I also pay for
another weather app, which is Mercury Weather. And I do
that primarily because it's got that trip
setting that lets you
have a widget that shows you the temperature
where you're going to be in the future
even if it's not where you currently are.
It's just a great feature. It's just a great feature
and it's worth
it for me to pay for that. So my own
I like care of weather a lot. It's on my home screen.
My only hesitation there is that I use three
different weather apps.
That's good. Look, Jason,
you're a weather aficionado.
You're using three different
weather apps, no matter what. You know, no matter
what, you're using a bunch of different weather. Actually, the best thing about
carrot weather to me is that it does actually let me plug in my
my ID from my weather station. And so when it shows the temperature, it is
my weather station temperature, which I love. It's a pretty great feature.
It is. It is. I do love carrot weather. What do we want to do
here? Well, what I want to do is give Mango Baby
the wind and Carrot Weather the other runner up. Okay,
let's do that. Amazing. So Mango Baby is the best
iOS app of 2025.
Let's do it.
This is also a personal thing because Mike had a baby.
Let's do it.
So my baby is also the best iOS app.
Best baby.
Best baby.
Your baby is now the mango baby.
Best baby of 2025 is a secret category.
Yeah.
Boy, it would be a shame if she didn't win that one, right?
Can you imagine?
I think technically, technically she could be the upgrade baby now.
She could just be the new upgrade baby.
That feels a bit bad to original
Upgrade Baby, to take that away from them.
The original Upgrade Baby is like
12 now.
Yes, absolutely.
Are you ready for the next category?
I'm not because I have no nominations
in the best newcomer iOS app category.
I'm sorry.
I apologize to all developers everywhere.
Jason, Books is coming, you know?
I know, books is coming.
I'm going to fill in.
I'm going to kill it with books.
I have one.
this year. I have multiple apps I could name here, but I'm making one because I am so impressed
with this app. And so I want it to stand alone. And it's called Athletic. So I had been trying
out a Whoop band for the best part of a year and never really got into talking about it because
I was never sure that I actually liked it. And what was interesting about Whoop is
whoop would do things
that Apple Health will not do
and it's a consistent frustration
I have of Apple Health
which is you have all of this information
about me
but you never overlay this data
to try and give me anything useful
and they're continuing
to do this
so like now they give you
your sleep score but they're not
taking into account
anything other than
how many hours you slept
essentially to give you that score
when there are vitals information
that they could take and put into that
which everyone else does
everything else that tracks your sleep
if it has access to vitals information
will also take that
into building like a recovery score
or a sleep score for you but Apple still
refuses to do it I don't understand
but whoop this is their whole thing
but I felt like
whoop was a little bit more
focused on athletes
like people who are much more
focused on that kind of fitness than me.
You're getting imposter syndrome from your health band.
Yes, absolutely. Absolutely.
And also, I didn't like wearing a second thing.
I just, over time, it became frustrating to me.
And then many people recommended this app to me, Athletic.
Athletic is essentially taking the data from your Apple Watch and showing it to you in a
whoop-like interface.
It has great charts.
It comes up with sleep scores, recovery scores, exertion scores.
exertion scores. So like taking information about you throughout the day and it shows you how
this information works together. It uses on-device Apple intelligence like the local models to like
take a look at the data from a workout and say like, hey, this one was a little bit lighter than
your previous workouts and this is how it might make you feel like little things like that.
Looks great. Works great. I am really impressed with this app. I think everyone that has an Apple Watch
should at least download and try this app out
because I think it is doing a really, really good job
of taking the information
that you're giving to the health app
and doing something genuinely useful and interesting with it.
So big, big recommendation from me.
The Upgradians voted for Tapestry with 8.7%.
Focus friend with 7.6%.
Athletic with 4.3%
and cassette with 4.3%.
Cassette is a great app.
Cassette is that app that came out.
It had a little bit of a splash earlier in the year
where it had like a really cool interface
to turn your video library into basically like a VCR kind of thing
where you could press play it
and it would like load videos
and just start playing video clips from your library.
It's a really nice app that one.
Yeah, that was an interesting app.
I never really got it to work the way I wanted to work.
Yeah, but it's nice.
It was a nice app, like just like a fun thing to play around with for a little bit of time, but it's not going to, at least for me, at least, is not going to become like the main way that I start watching videos on my iPhone.
I wanted to mention here, by the way, I am on a test flight of two apps that are not out of beta that perfectly fit this category.
But I, they're not even public.
I mean, I think they're both known to exist, but they're not even like more broadly being beta tested.
so I have to sit on those.
I just have to.
Well, next year, Jason's going to come in with a stormer in this category.
I'm just roaring in with newcomer iOS apps here and there.
Cool, Abe man.
Yeah, yeah.
I mean, your case for Athletic is great.
I think that, I think, I mean, I want to get it right now.
Try it.
Seriously.
And check it out.
It's really, really great.
So I have no problem giving it the win here.
Yes.
Um, I'm, I'm going to say something. We're so positive here on the upgrades. Yes. I'm going to say something a little negative here. Oh, oh. Which is, um, I want to be as kind as possible. Um, tapestry number one from the upgradians. Yeah. I haven't written about tapestry very much. I haven't talked about it really much. It feels like a miss to me. And I was the biggest fan of Twitterific out there.
I feel like they decided to do this kind of,
we're going to reinvent everything.
They were so burned by focusing on Twitter.
And I understand that.
They're like,
we're going to just have it be feeds.
But I just think all of those,
we're going to build an all-purpose feed reader app
are a misfire.
The whole concept and the whole category,
reader would fit into this as well.
Yes.
I feel like I want to use social media
in a different place than I want to read news.
Yeah, I absolutely agree.
Or see images.
And what they've implemented is technically impressive.
And every time I use it, I'm like, this is a very cool app.
And then I stop, but I never keep using it because I think it's just completely misguided.
And again, I think coming out of the Twitter client debacle, I understand their reaction.
But as somebody who always preferred Twitterific to tweet bot,
I still think it is a cry and shame that the icon factory doesn't make a client for Mastodon and or Blue Sky.
Yeah.
Because I would love to see that.
And instead, they've built this app that just, I mean, if you love it, that's great.
But every time I open it, I think this is just not the way, this is not an app I want to see.
I don't think it works at all like I wanted to work.
And it just frustrates me because I like the work that they've done before.
that Sean and Craig have done, especially in the past, on this kind of thing.
And I think it's technically very interesting.
But, and it's not just them.
But like, like I said, I think this whole idea of we're just going to have this neutral feed reader thingy, it's like, I don't, I don't live like that.
And also, I don't consume that content in that way.
That's the, that's the truth of it is.
A news story is not the same as a social media post.
Or a YouTube video.
Or a YouTube video.
It's not that, look, it's not that I couldn't see a scenario where I use a single app to browse two or three of those media types, but not in a one-size-fits-all container, which is what these apps provide.
Yeah.
I would never, I mean, you basically need to become a meta app at that point where I can go into video mode or go into newsreader mode.
And at that point, yes, you are building a newsreader separate from a social media client, separate from,
a video player, at which point I would say, perhaps you should just build one or more of those
apps instead of this thing that's kind of not good enough. And, and, you know, anyway, I don't want
to beat up on the icon factory here, but I will say that they keep adding, like, bookmarking
features or reply and it goes to a different app. And like, I just, I wish they would just say,
you know what, we're going to embrace our knowledge of social media clients and actually build a
proper social media client because I think they would kill it.
And it's sad to me. So I appreciate
the Upgradians voting for Tapestry, but like
I just think I think that whole category of apps is a failure.
Yeah, I'm very happy for them
that they have a user base that love it as much as they do,
that it was the top newcomer iOS app as voted for by the Upgradients.
I think that's fantastic. But I could not agree with you more.
I don't understand these types of applications.
Like, it's mixed media for me.
Like, maybe I'm old school, but I would like my RSS and an RSS app, YouTube and the YouTube app, and social media and social media apps.
Like, that's just where they are very different types of media for me.
Now, of course, I very often will see an article on Blue Sky and read it, but I'm reading stuff I'm not already subscribed to in that scenario, right?
And so that's why I might check something else out that is new.
To put it all in one spot, and yes, the new reader is exactly the same.
Yeah.
I think these apps are built on a promise of federation that has not come to pass and will not.
I'll even, I'll go one step further, which is to say I think they're built on the premise that the important part is the feed.
And that is a very purpose.
programmer-centric view of the world, and as a consumer of content, who knows enough to know that they're all coming in from feeds, the fact that they come in from a feed is immaterial to me, because it's not how I use the content. I use the content because that is a blog post and an RSS feed or a news headline. And that is a social stream. And if they, if, again, like another version of this app that could exist is one that curates your social stream, like Nuzzle, you.
used to do. And Sill sort of does, but you've got to use, like, I would love a good app that looked
at all your social streams and pulled the headlines out of them and generated a headline feed
for you. That would be a thing that would be feed-based. But again, the fact that it comes from
feeds, while important as an implementation detail, is immaterial for me as a consumer of content.
Like, the fact that my social media can come in a feed and my news articles can come into feed
doesn't make them the same. And I think all of these, I get why programmers would say this is a
beautiful future where everything is an open feed and that's all we're going to support.
I totally get why you would do that. But as a user, I just don't want it.
So that's sorry. Sorry, there's our, there's our side. Our side in this category. Athletic is the
winner. Um, runners up. I don't know. I think cassette is actually a good runner up. I agree.
Right. Completely. Yes. Because it's, it's a fun thing that people should check out.
Um, I think Focus Friend is a really interesting app. Um, this is like it's a like a,
essentially like a
Pomodora timer
but it's one of these
apps
part made by
Hank Green
it is one of
these apps
which is taken
as far
edge of the
screen time
APIs
there's a few
of these now
where you can
have essentially
have an app
locked down
your phone
and so you
can't use
apps that you
shouldn't be using
for a period of time
I think that's
really interesting
or we
embrace it
and put tapestry
as a runner up
even though
since we slagged
it I'd love to
put tapestry as a runner up
because
I think it's technically very impressive. I just, I just, I think it's unfocused and or misfocused, and I would like to see them turn it into something different, because this isn't it. But we'll give it, like, I appreciate that from the ashes of their relationship with Twitter, the icon factory built this, uh, impressive piece of technology. I just, I just think it's a misfire. And they, they should recalibrate.
This episode is brought to you by Century.
applications break in all kinds of ways from crashes to slowdowns to regressions the stuff that you only see once real users are using it
sentry though it catches all of it that's s-en-tr-y century you get traces replays errors profiles and the details around them like stack traces commits releases
and the developers who broke it all in one connected view so you're not jumping between tools trying to figure out what happened
Sentry shows you how the request moved, what ran, what slowed it down, and what the user saw.
I think this stuff is really important when you're thinking about your app, right?
You want it to work well for the user.
You've spent all this time crafting this great experience.
When people are using the app, you want it to be smooth, you want it to run well, you don't want them to be hitting errors and bugs.
But also the thing that I find really valuable about this is developers want to be making new features.
they don't want to be fixing bugs.
If you can help them fix their bugs faster,
then they're going to be able to get back
to doing the things that they want to do.
And there is SEA, Centries AI debugging agent.
It takes everything from there for you.
It uses all of that Century context
to tell you the root cause
and suggests the fix
and can open the pool request.
It also reviews your pool request for you
and flags breaking changes with a fix already ready.
Try it for free at century.io,
that's S-E-N-T-R-Y.
and tell them that we sent you.
They have a free dev plan
and listeners of this show
can use the code
upgrade 26 to get $100
in Century Credits.
Our thanks to Century for their support of this show
and Reli.
So we now move on
to the best overall Mac app.
The Lifetime Achievement Award winner
in this category
is Rogamiva's Audio Hijack,
an app that we're both using
right now.
Right now.
In fact, I just used it to
your voice uh during the ad read i put your voice on the speaker out in the living room that
it's also an audio hijack thing upgrade plus listeners upgrade plus content they know what that's all about
they know what that's all about people know what's going on there i have a lot of nominees in this
category see look at him go let's do it i'm i am a mac user through and through including a
surprise that i that i added just as we were recording so you're going to have to add it to the show
notes after the fact little behind the scenes i'm sorry i'm just i'm still riffing
here. I'm revving up my creative engine. Numbers. I added numbers. I, and I probably said a version
of this before, but just to say it again, I stopped paying for Microsoft 365, which I used to pay for
for ages because I had so much internalized Excel knowledge. And I realized that at some point
in the last couple of years that Excel was no longer my home and that I felt more at home in
numbers and Google sheets. And so why do I need to pay Microsoft?
anything and we dropped it and that does mean that every now and then Lauren's like what is going
on here I'm like sorry sorry we don't have Excel anymore but um I've used numbers I did a bunch of
stuff with numbers to modify the way I do my charts I do all my charts that way I had I was on a
podcast with Allison Sheridan where I complained about having to move all the little bars around
every month or every quarter and somebody said you can use this uh formula to build a version of
your chart that auto updates and I did that I spent a bunch of time uh in a bunch of
bunch of different apps or a bunch of different spreadsheets in numbers digging through
numbers formulas and they're really powerful um my only complaint and it's a funny one like the
advantage one of the great advantages of google docs is that it's fundamentally multi window because
it's a shared thing so if i have a giant spreadsheet with a couple different tabs i need to be in
at once i can open multiple browser windows and do that and numbers still doesn't let you open
a second window into the same sheet it's also like while you can share
and collaborate in numbers,
it's not as easy
or as slick as sheets.
Yes, anything I do
with a collaborator I do with
Google Sheets. Yeah, absolutely.
Basically.
But I use this, I use it a lot.
I love it. I think it is my favorite by far.
And I used to use, I used to use Keynote a lot.
And it's also great.
I don't use pages. Don't at me.
I just don't care.
But numbers is great.
I love numbers and use numbers all the time.
If I'm ever making a spreadsheet for myself,
if it is never going to be shared,
I will definitely always use numbers for that.
Because I just like the way it looks.
I like the way it works.
It's very simple.
I will say I also never use pages,
except if you ever need to create an invoice,
pages is very good templates for that.
Yeah, that's literally the only way I ever use pages is to make an invoice.
It's good for that.
It's great invoice.
They should call it invoicer.
Invoicer.
Invoicer.
Envoicer.
So numbers is good.
Mimstream, which has won the best newcomer twice.
It's my Mac email client and I love it and it's really good.
I mean, what can I say?
It's really good.
It's a Gmail client.
It's great.
Wouldn't it be great if they had an iOS app?
Well, if they did.
it's still in test flight
and I can't give it an award
so we'll be incredible
when they win
best newcomer again maybe
in a different category
in a different platform
three time best newcomer
award that would be amazing
I'm going to say
and this is maybe a little controversial
but
I put chat GPT and Claude in here
and here's my reasoning
both of them have interesting
connections that they can do
to things
on your Mac
that I think
make them intriguing.
ChatGPT
supports...
Is it chat GPT supports
M...
Is it chat GPT
or is it Claude
that support
connectors?
Claude is more
of the connectors
on the MCP stuff.
Claude is better at this.
ChatGPT has some interesting things.
Claude is better at this.
Yeah, Claude supports on-device connectors
so it's connected to
long play
which is an app
that supports
the format
the MCP format
um
Claude supports
control your Mac
which is basically
like
command line
and OSA script
which means it can do
Apple script
I actually have a statement
here's here's the
give and take of these apps
Claude
has no way
to remember a phrase
and fire it off
on command
no way to do that
nor is it scriptable in any way
so it is ironically
uncontrollable but good at controlling things
which just drives me mad
but I have a paragraph block
that I was doing over the weekend
based on a Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Rang post
about using LLMs as proofreaders
and his was more like he gets the chatbot
to give him a list of corrections
and I said well what I would like
is for the chatbot to take my file
look at it,
insert the corrections in line
below each paragraph
where the corrections are there
with a little flag
and then put it back in my text editor.
And I can get Claude to do that.
Claude will look at the top window
and BB edit using OSA script.
It will then proofread it.
It will insert its corrections
as I request,
you know, not in line,
but below the paragraph where the correction
is there with a big
like a bunch of greater than symbols
just as a marker, and then we'll take that and open a new BB edit document with that
as the contents. And it just does it, which is amazing. Except, again, okay, great, how do I
wire that up to a keyboard shortcut? I can't. I can't. Instead, you have to, like, script the
interface. It's so, so dumb. So it's, on the one hand, it's super brilliant. And both of these apps
are like this. They have really nice aspects of them and then really stupid aspects of them. But what I,
what I like and the fact that they bought
that ChatGPT bought Software Applications Inc
or OpenAI did is
I feel like we're right on the verge of something
even more interesting in terms of
really proper
integration between these. Now I could do this now
using shortcuts and
on device models or the private cloud compute
models but we know you know it's Apple's models
they're not quite as good
but anyway so having those apps exist
and be Mac apps and have some
things about them that, like, do things on the Mac, I think is really good because I'm much more
interested in using these things when they're integrated into my Mac than I am when it's a
web browser window. So I want to mention both of those. I'm glad that these companies that Anthropic
can open AI are actually doing Mac apps and that there's the potential that these Mac apps could
become even more interesting over time. I like that. ChachyPT also does, they have an Apple Music
integration now, which is kind of nice. Yeah, anyway. And then the other app I wanted to mention is
ICE because this is, you know, bartender got, you know, there was a question about like,
bartender got sold and like, who are the new developers? And then the people who have used the
new version of it say it's not that impressive, but it broke, Tahoe broke compatibility with it.
And so everybody went around looking for other menu bar utilities. And ice is a good one that is
a free open source and works. And I like that, that it's those things. So I want to mention ice as well.
The Upgradians voted for ChatGPT with 6.8%.
Mindstream with 5.3%.
Obsidian with 3.4% and Things at 3.4%.
Got a lot of organized...
Things is in this every single year.
Every year. Things is voted for by the Upgradians.
I know.
You know, every time I use things, I like it.
I appreciate it and then I just go back to Reminders
because Reminders is more than enough for me,
even though things is very impressive.
I'm just not,
I'm not Omnifocus either.
I'm just, these are not, this is not my life.
I, I, I, I love Mimstream as a nominee or winner.
I like, I like numbers as a nominee or winner.
What do you think?
I would struggle to make ChatGPT the winner.
Well, this is what I was going to say is,
I think Claude is better than ChatGPT.
Okay.
That's the thing.
I think Claude is better than ChatGBTGT.
Okay.
As a Mac app.
Even then, yeah.
All that control over your system and the MCP server
and can talk to other apps like LongPlay.
ChatGPT does interesting stuff where it can detect your window, right?
I mean, you can...
It does. It does.
It's using accessibility framework so it can look at your window.
it's true it's true it's got things too that's why i mentioned it yeah i would um if this is me
and you i'm putting numbers and it is me and you i'm putting numbers of the winner because i i think
that's fun and i also use it and i think that's hilarious so let's let's make numbers the winner
numbers is the winner and then let's put claude as a as a runner up and mine stream too yeah i think so
more to come yeah from these AI apps but i i feel like the AI apps have the potential to do some
really interesting things and integrate with the Mac and elevate the Mac experience a little bit
more. But it's early days yet. But I'm really interested in these kind of, my feeling about AI in
general is like if you can come up with targeted, focused, tool-based things that use them that are
good and help you in your life, great. Like, that's the stuff that I'm interested in. I'm not
interested in having a conversation with it. I definitely agree with you. We move on to the best
newcomer Mac app
what have you got Jason
Longplay came out for the Mac
I mentioned it earlier
it's got an MCP server
it very much is like
it'll do shortcuts
it'll do AppleScript
I talked to the developer
and the developer is like
I had to figure out
how to do an AppleScript dictionary
it may be the last
new app ever
to have a full AppleScript
dictionary but bless it
it does that
it's controllable in all the ways
what it is it was one of my favorite
iPad and iOS apps
I've mentioned it before
now it came out on the Mac
if you want to listen to a playlist all the way through
or an album all the way through long play
it's a very nice interface it shows you your albums
in your library you can you can play them
so the new mac version came out it's very controllable
so you can actually ask
as Claude to say you know can you
find me an album that fits these things
and play it in long play and it will just do it
which is awesome that's a very cool feature as well
that's supported by this and you can write your own
automations if you want to because it's totally automatable
its biggest weakness is that there's a failing in the APIs
of by Apple to do AirPlay
so the only way I think this is still true
certainly in the beta process the only way to play
and I use AirPlay speakers to play music from Longplay
through AirPlay speakers was either to use a third party app
like Sound Source from Rogamiba
or to set all of your max audio output
to an AirPlay speaker which is not great
because things get weird.
Then you want to play a video
and there's a weird delay
and like I don't like it.
But so glad to see this app on the Mac
because I listen to most of my music on the Mac
and I don't, you know,
I shuffle through lots and lots of playlist,
but I do have some desires,
you know, where it's like,
I want to listen to this album.
And this is a really nice way to do that.
Plus I like the innovation.
I like the fact that this developer
built in every kind of automation possible.
This is kind of like the perfect new
mac app in that it's got one foot in the past with apple script it's got a second foot in the
present with shortcuts and it's got a third it's got its eye on the future how about that there's
no third foot it's got its eye on the future with mcp so okay um other ones in here super whisper is a
really interesting app that uses uh AI stuff not only to do speech interpretation so you
run it and then you talk to your mac but it will process your audio into
text, but it will also then you can set it up to use it to use an AI API to process the text
that you're doing in interesting ways. And it can change based on context, based on what app you're
using. I paid for it for a little while and then sort of realized that I wasn't really using it.
I'm not a strong kind of like dictation person. But like I really admire the the expansiveness of
this idea that you can have like when you trigger your microphone and you're in this app, you
want a totally different prompt and a totally different set of output than you do when
you trigger it in this app.
It's just really smart.
So that's Super Whisper.
Put ICE in this category because it is, I don't know if it's new, new, but it's new to me.
Claude and ChatGPT are in here.
And then Simon Sturving's Festivitas, which came out very, very late last year.
And so we didn't really cover it last year.
But it's back this year with a 2.0 update.
And so I think it is going to be under the wire as in it's new enough.
since the last upgradeies, and it puts holiday lights on your desktop and snow, and it's
automatable as well. So I have, I talked about this on a previous podcast, and I just want to say it
again, now that it's happened. Like, I built a shortcut that has a random number generator in it
to only drop snow in festivitas. It runs every 20 minutes, but it only drops snow one in seven
times. And I cannot tell you how delightful it has been over the last month where I'm just
using my Mac and it starts snowing. And I always have that same thought, which is, oh, it's
snowing. And it's delightful every time. It's so delightful because it's random. When it happens,
it's just kind of amazing. So I think Festivitas is a lot of fun. Is it necessary in life? No.
Does it make my Mac a nicer place to be in the holidays? Yes. And in fact, I may keep
I may turn the holiday lights off
and keep the snowfall on
for a while longer
because it's just that much fun.
My best newcomer Mac app
is also festivitas.
What I like about this app
is it is
I mean, I love it on the iPhone too.
But what I love about this app
is it is essentially
pointless.
Right?
Like, you know,
its usefulness is that it doesn't have it.
Except that it is fun.
And there has always been
a long history of Mac apps that exist
just because they are fun to have
because the Mac allows you to do weird things like this
that other platforms do not allow.
It is firmly in the tradition of the talking moose
which lived in your menu bar
and watched your mouse move around and would say things,
which was, did it do anything?
The extension that turned your trash can on the desktop
into Oscar the Grouch trash can from Sesame Street
and he would come out when you empty your trash
and sing a little song of After Dark,
the screen saver that included, of course, the Flying Toasters.
And the one that it really reminds me of is there was an
after dark kind of like competitor called Underwear.
And its whole premise was basically like
it was drawing essentially screensavers,
but it was on your desktop.
And it would do things like a guy,
a window washer would come out and like squeegee
one of your finder windows in the background
and it's just like
did this take up
CPU time? Yes. Was it a waste
of time? Yes. Was it delightful?
Yes. And part of the fun
is to do stuff like that. So this is a
great, I would love
to see more Mac apps like this
because again, it does
it gives me something. Is it, is it
a productivity utility? No. But does it
delight me and make me enjoy
using my Mac, which is a device that I also
used to be productive? It absolutely does. I wish there were more apps like Festivitas. So congratulations to Simon Festivitas. Stovering. Simon Festivitas scriptable. Stovering for his win because this one's going to win. Yeah, it's absolutely going to win. So I'm going to put that in now. So Festivitas is the winner. It's a winner of the best newcomer Mac app for this year. The Upgradians voted with for Affinity at 5.5%.
hyperspace at 5.5%.
It's on Syracusa.
ChatGPT at 4.6%.
But there's more.
But wait, there's more.
Ghostie at 4.6%.
And tapestry at 4.6%.
There are five here because there were two sets of ties.
Ghostie is a terminal app I'd not heard of.
Yeah.
And obviously, Affinity is the designer
kind of Photoshop competitor,
which is also now interesting because it is
completely free. It was bought by Canva, and they've made it completely free now. So I'm sure
more and more people are using it. Apparently, it's very, very good. So a lot of great new Mac apps
there. What would you like to make as a runner-up? Should we put long play in there? I think we should.
Long play for sure. For sure. And I want to put, I think, Super Whisper in there, because even though
it's not quite for me, what I like about it is it's using AI tech to do something interesting
with the Mac and not just be an empty box where you type things.
And I like, I want to see more of that.
I think as we said in our last round,
I feel like ways of taking the Mac interface and just pumping up little bits of it
with AI stuff, that I find very interesting in a way that, again,
here's a blank screen with an empty box.
You type in.
Like I know this is very popular.
I find it so uninteresting because it is the equivalent of a command line.
And I know that it's very powerful and I use that stuff too to do very targeted work.
But like in the long run, a chatbot box is the wrong interface.
It just is the wrong interface.
A box you type in in an app that's targeted or something that knows what app you're using or what tool you're using or what project you're in and that can help you.
Very interesting to me.
Yeah.
It's already coming with a lot of the context baked in.
The developer has done that you don't need to do that.
Exactly.
So a relatively context-free window you have to type a whole command into,
while I do find the act of crafting a command can be very focusing
and a good intellectual exercise and I think is actually work,
I'm less interested by the interface list, context list.
Well, to bring up that proofreading example again,
I appreciate that Dr. Dr. Dr. Drang can paste his story in a, his blog post in an LLM and have a prompt that he wrote that says, please proofread this and give me back.
And then it does that and it gives him back text in that window that says, here are the mistakes I found.
And then he can switch to his text editor and implement those himself.
Like, I appreciate that.
But like, there's got to be a better way, right?
Like, those tools should be integrated into the text editors.
And if you don't want them to change your words, that's fine.
They should be able to mark your words or like I did with my experiment, put them right under and say, here's a thing you should look at.
Just more integration because as users, we should demand more than, I mean, like, as amazing as some of the responses to a chatbot can be in an app.
Like, it's not good enough.
It's just not good enough.
It needs to be better.
They need to be way better.
So I like to see apps that are trying that.
And Super Whispers is a good example of like.
What if we could give some more context to what's going on here?
We now move into the best feature round.
So this is a category that changes year to year.
So we will pick a feature in the Apple platforms as the thing that we would like to see highlighted.
So the first year was the best example of this so far, which was widgets.
So like the best app that have widgets.
The problem is in like in past years in 24 and 25, Apple has kind of not really had something
in the OSs that can be widely adopted.
I mean, you could have said look at glass this year maybe, but anyway, we came up with
best implementation of a 26 year OS feature.
Now, when we came up with this, my thought was a third-party app that takes one of the features
and does a good job of it.
But everybody else, including Jason, has just recommended different features from the different 26 platforms, which is fine.
Yeah, I thought about it, right?
I did think about it.
And I thought about my apps that I use that do a good job implementing liquid glass.
You know, unfortunately, apps only really have access to onboard models, AI models.
if they had access to private cloud compute, things would be a little more interesting.
But they don't, which means you have to bridge it with shortcuts, which makes it not really integrated.
But in the end, I decided that my favorite 26 features deserve recognition.
So that's sort of where I went with this category.
And what are they?
iPad multitasking is number one.
They did it, Mike.
They did it.
I remember having our conversations in June about,
I mean, we have been talking about iPad multitasking for so long.
And it's been so, you know, there's the potential
and there's the frustration and all of those things.
And I think they did a great job implementing it.
And then with point one and point two,
they have filled in a lot of the cracks that remained.
I like, you know, I like the idea that like the platform isn't solved.
There are lots of problems on the iPad platform involving software.
Federico has talked about this a lot.
But interface-wise, I feel like it is where it needs to be.
I feel like there's this toggleable thing.
You can go into this mode, and then it can be as multitasking as you want it to be.
And like, I think they did a good job.
It feels right.
It feels good.
I have little to no criticism of how they implemented it.
It really is a very good implementation.
what else um clipboard history on the mac this is the year so the short version of the story is two or three years ago i had a
a reader wrote into six colors and said you know what utilities should i install when i first get my
mac because i'm switching platforms like what utilities do you recommend and i thought this was actually
a really good intellectual exercise for like where are the gaps but the truth is most of the utilities that i rely on
have been replaced by system features.
And I do fundamentally believe
that if you can use a system feature,
you probably should give it a try
because adding another app on top of it,
not only do you have to pay for that app,
which, you know, if it provides you a feature,
then pay for it, by all means,
support that developer.
But like, over time, what's happened
is that Apple has improved macOS underneath me
while I, you know, back 20 years ago,
installed LaunchBarr or whatever
and because Spotlight wasn't good enough.
And this whole thought press has led to me realizing the one great unimplemented feature on the Mac ever is clipboard history.
That I rely on multiple clipboards and clipboard history all the time.
There are a bunch of apps that do it.
And those apps can do things that are, like I know people in Tahoe who still use Pacebot because it does things they like that the clipboard history doesn't.
But to provide to all users a clipboard history where even if it's just a friend,
who doesn't know anything about this.
And they're like, oh, no, that text only, I lost my text and it only exists on my
clipboard.
And you can be like, has it been within the last seven hours?
Let's go and look at your clipboard history.
And you can retrieve it from the clipboard history.
Such a good feature.
And I'm using it now.
You know, this is, I stopped using launch bar, which I use for clipboard history.
And I just am using the system clipboard history.
And it works great for me.
So it's just a huge step forward for them to do this.
This is, this is, it.
It made me one of my favorite things in Tahoe because it feels like Apple actually paying attention to the empty spaces in the Mac where they could potentially do some good work and doing it.
And it works well for me.
So, a couple of history.
And then my last one is what I mentioned just a moment ago, private cloud compute and shortcuts.
I, you know, Apple's models aren't the best, but Apple's cloud model is way better than it's on device model.
and I've built multiple shortcuts
that use Apple's cloud model
and right now it's basically free
like there are other
you can get API access to chat GPT
and Claude and all of that
but like private cloud compute
you just get it because you're a Apple
device user and you can write a shortcut
and so like my best example is that
I updated my shortcuts
that upload images to six colors
when I'm writing especially on the iPad
and like now it it generates alt text it generates a file name that's relevant based on the
contents of the image and that's because i'm uploading the image a scaled down version of the
image to private cloud compute and saying okay give me a description give me a file name and uh i crafted
that prompt and then i got to check it a little bit because lLM's that can do weird stuff but like
it does it and it's a revelation so having access to an lLM essentially for free to use in my
automation so you can take things that used to be impossible to automate because they were linear
and turn them into these things that are you know you never really know what you're going to get
but it means that instead of having like i run the command and then i have to sit there and like go
through and i have to show it shows me the image and then says what do you want to name this image
and then what do you want to have as the alt text and all that and it's gone and i see the result
and i can decide whether i like the alt text or not and like the file name or not but um i think
it's a really great feature that augurs good things for the future that Apple has built
it in, even though, yeah, they need to be able to provide app developers with access to it
as well. For me, I recommend one app, which is athletic again, because I think that it's done a really
good job of the liquid glass design aesthetic from a style perspective and a navigation
perspective. I think it looks and works really great, but also they are using the on-device
models for giving workout insights in a way that I think is quite impressive.
But then also, I recommend, I'm nominating iPad multitasking because it's fantastic and has
totally changed the way I use my iPad for the better.
And I'm also going to nominate Liquid Glass.
I think overall, while it is not perfect, I think that it is a good step forward for iOS,
personally.
I think that the system is more interesting to use again.
And I think, I know, what monsters, what monsters would recommend liquid
Glass.
Boo-uns?
Was that
Boo-uns?
So, Mike, what
of the
upgradins say?
50.
This,
this to me,
was one of
the most exciting
things that
could have possibly
happened.
With 15.7%
of the vote is
liquid glass.
Look at that.
And that to me
really is like
that, you know,
like the loud,
like there is a group
of people that are really
loud about liquid glass,
but even in our audience,
nearly 16%
of the people who wrote in said that Liquid Glass was their favorite thing over iPad multitasking,
which is the next one, at 8.8% of the vote. So twice the amount of people said that Liquid Glass
was their favorite feature of like 26th year. And then at third is call screening at 6.9%,
which is a feature that I really like. I think this is a great feature where essentially your phone
starts having a conversation with the person who's calling you, and it will show a little.
little icon and then it will eventually pop up and show like a text conversation going
through. I think it's really well done and I like it and use it a lot. I think the winner of
this should be probably iPad multitasking. Sure. Yeah, I agree. Because it's on everybody's
lists and it is fantastic. I agree. And then I guess what? Liquid glass and clipboard maybe.
That works for me. Yeah. Because I also, I'm happy, I'm really happy that the
clipboard history is there
but I'm still using Raycast for it because
honestly I know this sounds
this sounds wild but the main reason
I've continued to use Raycast is it's one keyboard
shortcut not a keyboard shortcut
and then another keyboard shortcut
to get to the clip well that's that's one of the things
that I think that they need to fix is that you need to make
you should be able to assign a keyboard
shortcut to clipboard history
that said I have
my old keyboard shortcut
for clipboard history on
launch bar. I have that in keyboard maestro where I press it and it does the double key entry
to get me there. And it's transparent. So I do command backslash and immediately the clipboard
history shows up. But that should be a feature. You should just be able to assign a key. You
shouldn't have to enter spotlight and then enter clipboard history. That's real dumb.
This episode is brought to you by eCAM. If you're a Mac user who creates videos or
podcasts, you need eCAM. ECam Live is the all in one.
studio built exclusively for Mac, so it looks, feels, and performs like a native pro app on the
Mac should. Whether you're live streaming, recording a podcast, or producing training videos,
eCAN gives you broadcast level quality control with drag and drop simplicity. Switch cameras,
share your screen, queue overlays and control audio all without ever leaving your Mac. With
ECAM, you can brand your show with titles, graphics, and lower thirds. You can also pull in
guests via interview mode or record multi-track audio for perfect post-production. And if you're
into automation, ECAM works beautifully with tools and apps like StreamDack and Loopback, as well as
many Mac tools and apps that you already know and love. Now, one of the things that I really
like about Ecam Live is how Mac like it feels. Like you really feel like you were just using a Mac
app. It doesn't feel like an open source app that has a wrapper around it or anything like
that. It feels like a Mac app, works like a Mac app, and actually makes live streaming and controlling
lots of video and audio inputs a really possible and easy thing to do on the Mac, which hasn't
always been the case. You can upgrade to Pro and unlock ECAM for Zoom that lets you feed your
polished setup straight into Zoom meetings or webinars, share Zoom comments on screen, and even capture
each participant's audio and video separately for easy post-production work. To get 15% off, go to eCAM.com.
slash upgrade FM and use the code
Upgrade FM. That is 15%
off at eCAM.com
slash upgrade FM. That's
E-C-A-M-M-D-M-E-C-A-M-W-E-C-A-M with the code
Upgrade FM are thanks to ECAM
for their support of this show and Reli.
Time for Game of the Year, Jason.
What is your game of the year?
Yeah, I don't play a lot of games.
People know this.
I...
Actually, the game I played...
maybe the most this last six months on the iPad is the
carcassan game by the coding monkeys that's no longer in the app store,
but still works.
Oh, wow.
They lost the license.
It not only does it still work, we had a conversation on Mastodon about this.
The way they implemented the graphics means that even though it was made a long time ago,
the graphics still looked like super sharp because they're high-res graphics that just get scaled.
It still works, and it's great.
And the shame there is basically they built this amazing Carcassonne game and then they lost the license.
And the new Carcasson game is bad because we people have seen this with other things, too.
I think Scrabble this happened too, which is like at some point, one of these really bad game companies buys, they've got money to buy a license.
And then they make a garbage app.
And you can see the difference between an iOS app built with care by like an indie game studio.
and then in comes this game studio
that just does a crappy job
with a, it just a lousy app
that's full of garbage.
So I played carcass on a lot.
I'm not going to give it an award,
but just to say that if you bought it back in the day,
it still works.
You should download it.
Because it's still in the app store
as a purchased item.
It stays there forever,
which is awesome because it still works.
The game that I played that came out this year
that I really loved and played all the way through
was on the Switch 2 and it was hurdling,
which was published,
by panic.
Yep.
It is like journey except with herding, journey with goats.
It's more, they're not goats.
They're like weird beasts, but journey with weird herd beasts that you go around with.
Great music, great visuals, really affecting.
And also you can do it in like three hours, which I really love in a game.
It's such a good game.
So that was my real winner.
There are other games that I have wanted to play more.
I do have a switch to.
I have played it very little.
But Herdling came out and I realized this is the kind of game where I should just buy it and we're going to sit down one night.
I think we finished it the next night.
Lauren and I are just going to sit down and take turns playing.
It's a single person player.
But I played the first few levels and then handed her the controller and then she did the next few levels.
And it's just a really delightful experience.
if you have a platform that Herdling is on,
I highly recommend it,
especially if you like games like Journey.
It really reminds me of Journey,
and I think Journey is one of the all-time grades.
So it's the classic artsy-fartsy short, you know, narrative game
with pretty visuals and pretty sound.
And I just, just a great vibe.
Loved it.
What do you have?
Donkey Kong Bonanza is my game of the year this year.
Yeah.
This was a game that when it was first shown off
when the Nintendo Switch 2 came out,
I was intrigued about it, but couldn't imagine that it would be to the level of which, of the quality of which it is.
And then information started coming out about this game and who was behind it.
And it was the same team who made Mario Odyssey from nearly 10 years ago.
And then things started to change.
This game is fantastic.
I've never played a video game quite like it.
There is a game that is like so destructible and interesting.
and it's doing some, like, really
fantastically weird stuff
with the fact that you can just essentially destroy
everything in the game.
You can just tunnel down into the ground.
It sounds like so much fun.
I just haven't gone there, but I want to play it.
It sounds like amazing.
It's really fun.
My only knock on this game is it is a tad long.
There is a part in kind of like towards the end
where you're like, okay, we could skip a couple of these levels.
But this game ends in an absolute,
fantastic crescendo.
I loved this game.
I had so much fun with it.
The Upgradians give 10.1%
to Donkey Kong Bonanza.
Bellatro at 8.1%.
Definitely not a 2025 video game.
I did play a lot of
Balotro this year. Me too.
Oh, I've gotten back onto Balotro
big time on my iPhone.
Again, I went back on...
I did Balatro and then I...
So it was the progression mic
was Marvel Snap
to Belatro.
To Suwika.
game to Carcassan.
Oh, see, I went from
a swicker game back to Balatro.
And then Clare Obscure
Expedition 33, which is a game
that I have started after
it won. It's basically swept up
at the game awards. This is a very
interesting, and I can tell a very special video game,
but I'm not very far into it yet.
So, Balatro
won Game of the Year last year.
So what I
would like to do for this category is Donkey Kong
Bonanza as a game of the year, with
Huddling and Claire Obscure as a runner-up.
I love it.
Favorite movie time, Jason.
What are your nominations for favorite movie?
Four favorite movies that I've seen this year,
Thunderbolts, Marvel, it is a great,
for people who have gotten tired of Marvel movies
and are like, whatever,
and Thunderbolts has no real recognizable characters
and it's minor characters from other Marvel movies.
We did an whole incomparable episode about it.
It is great.
It is a great movie.
It is fun and fun.
it has something to say about like
because these are kind of like
it's really easy to read it
as being the Marvel version of the suicide squad
which is it's a bunch of terrible people who are put
together and forced to be heroic. That's
not what it is. It is more like
Guardians of the Galaxy in the sense that these are
people who are kind of
in difficult places
even more than guardians. They're more
rag tag but they're like they've made
mistakes and are in bad places in their
life and it's a real question of like
are you going to dig yourself out
of it and how do you do that and one of the ways the answer the movie says is
is making connections with other people is really important and that's the theme of the movie
it's funny it's got david harbour gives a great performance as the red guardian who is the who is
the dad of the new black widow which is florence pew gives a great performance he's the russian
captain america essentially which is yeah he is the russian he's like the the the kind of old
fat russian american russian captain america hilarious character um and then there is
is like Bucky is in it, right?
And he's used in a funny way.
And Julia Louis Dreyfus is actually pretty good as the kind of villain of the piece.
But like it's funny.
And there is a moment midway through the movie where it just takes flight.
And I'm not going to spoil it.
But there is a scene that happens out in the middle of the desert after they've sort of
been ejected from where they have been held captive, where everything kind of falls
of part and then David
Harbour arrives on the scene and it
just takes flight. It is a delight.
I love it so much.
So like if you have not seen a Marvel movie recently,
please give it a shot.
And I adore Julia Louis Dreyfus
in that movie. She's fantastic in it as well.
So really great. Really, really great.
Yeah, yeah. So that's Thunderbolts.
Great. Superman. The new Superman was really good.
Yeah. I saw that in the theater.
and we saw Nymax and even my son,
my 21-year-old son, we walked out of it and he's like,
that was too loud.
Which I thought was really funny.
It was too loud.
They had the volume of too high.
We watched it again when it came out on home video because Lauren didn't go with us to see it
because we saw it like during the week on a weekday when she has to work her job.
And I took my son and we went and saw it in IMAX.
It's still really good.
I watched it again.
I was like, oh, I really like this.
I really like Nicholas Holt's performance as Lex Luthor.
I think he gives the best performance in the movie.
I was so impressed.
He apparently read for Superman and James Gunn was like,
how about Lex Luthor instead?
But I think he does a really good job.
He's not Superman.
As with most blockbusters,
I could play the game where you look at any blockbuster movie
and there's at least one action set piece
that I would just like to delete from the movie
because it slows the movie down and makes it too long.
And it's like, guys, you got a Superman movie here.
You don't need this.
You don't need the scene where there's the anti-matter river and they're, like, you don't need it.
It's a waste of time.
It's boring.
The rest of the movie's great.
What's her name?
Mrs. Maisel is great.
Rachel Brosnahan.
Yeah.
Is great as Lois Lane.
Love her as Lois.
And the two of them have such great chemistry.
Yeah.
No, no, it's really good.
It's really good.
And he's a good.
What's his name?
David Correnswe.
David Corencewet is a good Superman.
I like this take on him.
There's some funny robots at the beginning.
I like the idea that he's trying to live up to his parents' ideals,
but his parents' ideals might not be what he's living up to.
It's his own ideals.
I thought that was a really good twist.
And the choice James Gunn makes to have other superheroes in the movie
and have them be interesting and funny,
like there's,
Mr. Terrific, who is, seals the movie in many ways, is so great.
And you've got Green Lantern, and it's a jerky Green Lantern, which is great.
And then Hawk Girl, and they all have their kind of like interactions together.
That part is really fun, too.
So Superman, really good movie.
Highly recommend.
Turns out James Gunn can make a good superhero movie.
Like, if we didn't know it already.
I think actually it turns out that James Gunn is a flexible enough director to also get the material for Guardians of the Galaxy
and get the material for Superman.
and realized, and he did the
suicide squad, the second
suicide squad, the suicide squad,
I guess. A good one.
And thematically, like,
you got one that's kind of dark,
one that's really dark, and then you got
Superman, and the fact is, he has range.
He understands the
tonal range necessary for that
character, and so Superman
does not go places
that you might think from James Gunn.
It goes some places you'd think, but other
places it knows what Superman
is what he represents
and why he's a good character
and not a character
who previous Superman director
sometimes treat him as a very boring character
and that's the wrong take to have
if you're going to direct a Superman movie.
Also, on this list,
the winner for Best Animated Feature
at the Oscars this year was Flow.
It is a dialogue list movie
about animals in a flood.
It includes the greatest lemur
and, oh, there's another great,
lemur and a capybara are in it.
amazing and it's about a cat
and it goes some weird
places and I love it. It looks, does it look
like a very long video game that you don't
play? A little bit, they made it entirely in Blender
but like it's a really good movie. They made the movie
in Blender? In Blender. The entire movie is in Blender.
Whoa. Whoa. Wow, that's good for Blender.
Yeah, yeah. Oh yeah, it is good for Blender.
It's good. It's real good.
And this is a movie that I think people
haven't seen because the title is probably
a turnoff. But
there is a movie called
My Old Ass
The concept of the movie
is that
that Aubrey Plaza
is an adult
39 years old
and
and that same
when she was 18, she's played by a different
actress and she
gets high on mushrooms and
sees her future self
basically like this. The premise is
She gets high on mushrooms, and what she ends up seeing is she has a conversation in a series of ongoing conversations with her future self.
And her future self is like, you get the sense that there are terrible things happening in the future, but the future self is trying to insulate her past self from them.
It is a really great movie.
I highly recommend it. People should see it.
It's kind of like the movie it's most like, and maybe this will sell some people on it, is a rival.
And I know that seems unlikely, but it is.
it's like a rival but instead of spaceships there's a boat so my old ass good movie overlooked
definitely worth your time on my list is Superman I loved Superman I was so excited that
Superman and Fantastic Four were coming out like so close to each other and to me it was like well
Superman is you know it's going to be a good time but I'm gonna Fantastic Four I was so hyped for
Fantastic Four, I liked that movie.
It's a good movie.
I loved Superman.
I cried like three times watching Superman.
Like, there is something about this movie that is so good.
And James Gunn understands how to, like, hit an emotional moment with an image and a piece of music.
And they use the Superman theme in this movie, maybe better than any title theme I've ever heard used in a movie.
They just, every time they use it, it is perfectly used.
and they use it in a perfect way.
This whole movie, I loved it.
I love this movie.
Makes you want to stand up and salute.
It absolutely does make you feel like that.
It's wonderful.
Thunderbolts, I had forgotten, came out this year
until I saw it in your list.
And I also really liked this movie.
Again, I would probably want to rewatch this
before I want to rewatch Fantastic Four.
I liked Fantastic Four.
I was just let down by Fantastic Four
because I wanted to be blown away by Fantastic Four.
I liked it a lot, but I think Thunderbolts is the best Marvel movie of the year by far, which is not what I, this is the thing, it's all about anticipation. I was very surprised going into Thunderbolts and I just thought it was great. Fantasy Four is good though. It was really good. I don't think it was a bad movie, but this was an expectation that's not met kind of scenario for me. But unfortunately for Fantastic Four, my expectations were incredibly high and didn't meet that. And then F1, I loved F1. I loved F1.
I thought it was a really great action movie
of the kind that they
aren't really made anymore
and I think that they did a good job of it
I think technically it was very impressive
and it ticked all the boxes
that I wanted ticked for a movie like this
I've really enjoyed this film
we watched F1
the same day that we watched
we re-watched Top Gun
for an incomparable episode
and then that night we watched F1
so it was
really, and I was struck by how similar they are.
They are movies that are more about, and you know, and Tom Cruise did a, did a racing movie, Days of Thunder, but like where they tried to do Top Gun but racing, but F1 feels very much like Top Gun but racing in the same way that, you know, Brad Pitt is great and he holds it together just like Tom Cruise and Val Kilmer do in Top Gun, but the point of the movie in Top Gun is that there.
are planes flying around.
And the point of the movie in F1 is that there are cars.
And there are some shots in F1 that I kept thinking this is doing to me what Top Gun did.
There are some shots in F1 where you're in kind of like behind the driver in the car and you're looking through the windshield and crazy things are happening on the track right in front of you.
It's just like, oh my God.
Like this is what movies were made for, right?
On one level, on the pure, not on themes and et cetera, et cetera.
not on that level.
On the level of pure motion picture,
what can it do to an audience
to excite them with sound and visuals?
There are a few moments in F1
where I'm like, look at that, look at they did that.
And I think, I didn't love it
because I think part of it was the comparison
to Top Gun, which I actually think is a better movie
because it's even more impressive,
but the original.
But they're both of a kind in a way
where it's like, I appreciate the filmmaking,
here. And I didn't, you know, for it to be
transcendent, that amazing visual
stuff needs to be kind of like coupled
with a really great story. And I thought
that the F1 story was, fine.
It's not a bad movie. It's a good movie.
But like, some of those visuals are incredible.
I saw it in IMAX.
Like, one of the huge
IMAX screens, like it's one of the
screens that they show 70 millimeter IMAX
on. It was
intense. I love
that movie. The Upgradians voted
with 13.1%
for sinners, 11.9% for F1, and one battle after another at 11.1%.
I've got sinners on my list. I guess I got one battle on my list as well, but sinners is like
on my list of the next couple of movies I need to see, and I just haven't seen it.
Part of that is I'm not sure whether Lauren wants to watch it or not. So I got to really
ascertain that because she may not be interested in a movie that's got some of that content
in it that might turn her off. So we'll see. But I've got I've got sinners on my
on my list and it sounds great.
So I don't, I just haven't seen it.
What do we want to make?
Because of our movie of the year?
I don't know.
What would you vote for here?
Superman?
Hmm.
Yeah, I'm okay with that.
I'm okay with that.
And then F1 and Thunderbolts?
Yeah.
I was just, I was so blown away by Superman.
I was very surprised at how good that movie was.
Yeah, it's really good.
Marketing campaign of the year goes to Thunderbolts, though.
if we did that. That was the marketing campaign for that was very fun. Yeah, I still think a lot of
people just gave it a skip and they shouldn't. You should go back and watch it. It's good.
Favorite TV show, Jason, what have you got for us? Got a big list here. Good year for TV. Good year
for new TV. The Pit on HBO Max starring Noah Wiley, brought back the ER-style hospital drama. I know
there's a lawsuit, but he's playing a different character. And it's really kind of taken a modern take on
on this.
Also really taught
the team they took a gamble on it
because it's like 15 episodes
but they shot it on
it's primarily on just a single set
in this in this emergency room
and I think a lot
of other streamers
are going to try and replicate it
because it's this idea
that you can get 15 episodes
a year out of a show
instead of eight or six
every two years
is a good one
and they killed it.
It's just it's it's emotional.
It's pulse-pound
It is, like, there's so much life and death, life and death drama and human drama to be found in intense medical situations and the pit knows what it's doing.
There are a bunch of, you know, the premise is similar to ER in the sense that and, and to ERs in general and emergency rooms in general, which is you've got attending physicians who are like the bosses, but then you've also got a bunch of people who are like interns and medical students who are also working.
And so you get young people who are being exposed to these things for the first time.
You've got people who are a little more jaded,
and then you've got kind of like the senior people
who are often really jaded,
but also can be wise.
Really good combination from Noah Wiley.
He was the fresh-faced medical student in ER,
and he is the grizzled veteran here.
Great performance, great show.
Loved it to death.
Coming back next month.
Coming back in a few weeks for another extended run.
So I love that, too,
that they can make more of this show.
Still, not available.
Not available in the UK.
So HBO Max,
is launching here in March
and for some reason
they're holding the pit for that
even though they're continuing
their deal with Sky as well
which has some shows. I don't know why
the pit has been kept in this limbo
but it has. So at some
point I'll watch the pit and I'll look forward to it.
Maybe I'll have two seasons. Yeah. That'd be good for me.
That'd be good for me. All right.
Pluribus on Apple TV.
Yep.
I love it. Fantastic.
The whole thing
really makes you think
looks great, interesting characters.
Another, you know,
it's just Vince Gilligan doing his thing.
It's really good.
Love it.
Great performance by Ray Seahorn.
Just good stuff.
Ludwig, which actually came out in 24 in the UK,
but it hit the U.S. in 25.
This is David Mitchell as a puzzle creator
whose identical twin brother
is a detective who solves crimes.
His brother goes missing.
They make the bad decision.
of replacing him
pretending to be his brother
and so he doesn't know
anything about police work
but he does know how to solve puzzles
and David Mitchell is so funny
and it is there are good mysteries
but also just kind of ridiculous
at the same time
it was a real find
David Lora recommended it
on the incomparable best of last year episode
and a bunch of us like
that feels something like David Lowe
would like that feels like a David Lowe
TV show
yeah I mean it's a mystery kind of thing
but it's so good
I just, it's so good.
So it's on Britbox in the US and BBC in the UK.
So you can just check it out.
So good.
It's like six episodes.
It goes by fast, but it's exactly my jam.
British TV.
Exactly my jam.
Severance.
They did it, Mike.
They made another season of severance and they didn't blow it.
Seriously, a very hard task that they succeed.
Yeah.
And I mean, it sounds like they spent a lot of money to make that
because it seems like they reshot a bunch of stuff at the end.
Yeah, they had to fix a bunch of stuff.
of stuff. They brought in Bo Willemont to run
season three and he ended up having to run
the back half of season two in order to get it
where they wanted it to be. But they did.
They did get it there. And, you know,
there's one episode this season that I didn't like, but
most of them I really liked. And I
feel like they carried it off. And it's not
I mean, of course, season one was so great.
But like, honestly, at the end of season one,
I was like, this is amazing. This was an amazing
ride. But I also had
part of me that was like, I'm a little worried about
whether they can carry this off going forward
because they're going to have to complexify the world.
and the details and the characters.
And are they going to be able to do that
without losing the magic?
And the answer is that they did.
We'll see if they can do it for season three,
but they did it for season two.
It really, they killed it.
Absolutely.
And I forgot that this was this year.
And then I was reading one of these
stories that this TV show is based on
and I realized that it was this year
and I want to give a shout out to another Apple show,
MurderBot, based on the series of novellas
by Martha Wells about a killer robot.
that becomes
is freed from its servitude
and has to figure out
how to navigate the world.
It is a sci-fi comedy.
It is both a good sci-fi show
and a funny show about humanity.
And yes, the killer robot
teaches us all about humanity.
It's a humanoid robot.
It wears like a mask and stuff
to look like a robot,
but then it takes off the mask
and it's just a person.
and that deeply disturbs the other humans
because it's not a human.
It's a person but not a human.
And what does that mean?
So it's got some real depth to it
while also being fun and exciting.
So like it's right at my alley.
Murder Bot.
I highly recommend it's great.
I will echo Severance,
which is brilliant.
Loved it.
Loved every second of it.
Great show.
Expertly done.
Incredible performances all around.
Like wonderful.
but my show of the year was the studio.
I think the studio was a creative tool to force.
Yes, it was a very like, do you like Hollywood type show, right?
Like, I think that that helps.
Like, if you care about how movies and TV are made,
you're going to enjoy this more.
But I don't think it is a prerequisite to enjoying the show,
but I think there's a lot of inside jokes that you would enjoy.
Like, basically, if you listen to The Town,
which is a podcast that we love and recommend
and I think as a previous favorite podcast winner
then you will love the studio
but I think that it is just fantastic
every little thing you see about how this show was made
only elevates it in my mind
but irrespective of all of the technical stuff
it is just a very fun, funny, entertaining watch
with great casting the whole way through
fantastic guest performances
I adored this show
brilliant, brilliant, brilliant stuff
Great show.
The Upgradians voted for Pluribus at 21.5%.
I should say, I haven't finished it yet, by the way.
So it's not going to get nominated by me because I haven't seen it.
We're only a few episodes in.
Severance, 18.2%, and the studio at 7.4%.
I think maybe you wouldn't put the studio as the winner.
It's not in my top five.
It is in my top 10, but it's not my top five.
But I would be very happy to put severance as the winner.
Yeah, yeah, let's put severance at the top.
And what do we want to do as our runner-ups?
Peribus?
Yeah, yeah.
We can do pluribus in the studio.
That's fine.
All Apple.
Well, we spoke about this in the draft.
They're doing great stuff over there.
They are.
They are.
All right.
It's your time to shine, Jason Snell.
Favorite book?
Oh, right. Mike doesn't read.
Correct.
I did like Apple and China, a book that you should read.
Yeah, I will. I absolutely will read that book.
You know, when you're trapped under a baby and it's five in the morning, one thing you could do is read.
I was trapped under a baby at 5 o'clock in the morning, but what I didn't want to do last night was to stimulate my brain in any way because I wanted to go sleep so I could recall the upgrades today.
Yeah, yeah. I had a moment where I realized that I was chatting with Mike, and he was awake in the morning and I had not gone to bed yet.
Yep, it was rough, rough stuff.
Yeah, I just watched a football game.
and then there's Mike texting and I'm like Mike what's going on and like there's a baby what's
particularly bad is if me you and Stephen are in the group chat together talking at the same
time because I can wait most mornings I'm awake before you could conceivably have gone to bed
right but this was like yeah we're we're middle of the night territory now that's yeah because
it was like 930 here yeah yeah and Stephen was still up late they were still up
They were still up, which is...
And you were awake.
And I was awake.
Anyway, Apple and China, it's good.
Patrick McGee.
If you're looking for nonfiction about Apple, that is the pick.
It is one of the best books written about Apple ever.
I got to read it.
I got to read it.
Great, great details.
Just amazing details.
What a good job.
I can be one of those podcasters that says,
it's like what they say in Apple in China, because I hear that all over the place now.
Oh, yeah, from the Apple in China book, they say that this happens.
You should probably read it.
I could also be one of those podcasters.
Yeah.
or I don't know
is there an audio book
Get the audiobook
There is
And that's how I would do it
That is how I would do it
But right now
Jason I'm re-listening
To a bunch of the rest of this history
Because I can't be stopped
I'll talk about this in a minute
Okay
Two best books I read this year
Are
Moonbound by Robin Sloan
Moonbound
So this is the author of
Sourdough
Which was kind of like a tech industry book
that's fun and weird
and
oh, Mr. Penumbra's
24-hour bookstore, which is also a very
good book that I really enjoyed.
But moonbound,
it's a wild book. It is
sort of sci-fi and a little bit
fantasy. It's
set in the far future,
but it's got some concepts
from the present or the near future
mixed in. There are dragons
on the moon. There are
sentient robots that have their
bodies distributed all over Earth, but they have one consciousness.
There's a character who's on a quest, very fantasy-like.
There is a secret spaceship that is revealed at an interesting time.
There is a character who's basically like an Instagram influencer from the 21st century who just appears on the scene.
You're like, what?
It's bananas and great.
I loved it.
Moonbound, Robin Sloan, highly recommended.
And then the other book I want to recommend is Automatic Noodle.
by Annaline Newitz.
That's a great name.
I've read a bunch of their stuff.
This is really good.
It's short.
It's basically a novella.
And it is cozy.
It is a very nice story about a bunch of robots in the mid-21st century after a kind of
apocalyptic civil war in San Francisco.
Cozy.
But it is.
This is what I'm saying.
So the world around them is strange and a little bit disturbing.
but in the end, what do the robots want to do, these sentient robots?
All they want to do is open a noodle shop and make noodles for people.
That's all they want to do.
Are there any people, though?
There are people.
Oh, yeah.
Yeah, it's not.
No, there's people.
There's like a civil war.
So California is now its own country.
And they're like, some of these robots used to be war robots, but now they just want to make noodles.
And like, and there's some plot stuff that goes on.
But like in the end, like how Travis Baldry wrote a book called, what was that?
that called Legends and Lates.
That was basically a fantasy novel
about a warrior.
But really
what she wants to do is open a coffee shop.
This is like that,
except it's more sci-fi because it's
about robots. But it's the same idea that robots
just want to open a neutral shop
in San Francisco. That's all they want to do.
They have to deal with mean review bombers
who give them bad reviews online.
It's great.
I love it.
Automatic noodle by Emily Newitz.
The Upgradians voted for Apple in China by Patrick McGee at 10%.
The Corrie Docter O book, the title that I don't want to say on the show, is 2.9% of the vote.
Also, it's just a phrase that really annoys me.
Yeah, I just really annoy me.
People have really attached to it.
Oh, and it's just not a good phrase.
And like, I just don't like it.
And sometimes you can make your point about using that language.
And people misuse it, too.
Yeah, it's too clever by half.
I never liked it.
Anyway, so that one's not winning
And everything is tuberculosis by
John Green also at 2.9%.
Yeah.
What would you like to be the winner
of the category, Jason Stone?
I think it is going to be
moonbound.
Love it, moonbound.
Congratulations to Robin Sloan.
Great book. And then
Automatic Noodle and Apple and China
are our runners-up.
Perfect.
Does your list?
Because I can, you know,
I get to choose
and I'm not going to, I know there's a tech nonfiction book about Apple that we could make the winner, but I'm just not going to.
It's a good book, though. People should read it.
Favorite podcast. There are two Lifetime Achievement Award winners in the favorite podcast category.
That is ATP, the Accidental Tech Podcast, from when we had a favorite tech podcast category, but we folded those together over time.
And the Flop House, which was also a Lifetime Achievement Award winner.
Jason, what are your nominations for Favorite Podcast of 20?
Well, my overcast tells me that the podcast I listen to the most this year is the rest is history.
Yes.
And that's accurate because I love the rest is history.
It is the best.
And then my other nominees are connected, which I still listen to as well.
It's a very nice podcast.
And I want to do a shout out to the Crash Course Podcasts, The Universe, which is a
It's a limited
like nine episodes series.
It came out last year,
but I found it this year,
so it counts.
It's Katie Mac,
the astrophysicist,
who has been on,
she was on the top gun episode
of The Incomparable,
which was great because
there's somebody who has a PhD
in astrophysics in that movie,
and they're people who fly planes,
and Katie does both.
Oh, that's great.
Anyway, Katie,
theoretical astrophysicist,
wrote a book about the end of the universe,
and she walks,
John Green through how the universe came to be and all the way it works and all the way
into the far future and how it will end over the course of nine episodes. And John Green comes
from a place that I think listeners will appreciate because he comes not understanding a lot
of this stuff and having Katie explain it to him and asking a bunch of questions and being
upset by some of the facts that come out and then being encouraged by some of the facts that come
out. So, um, so we're getting the Green Brothers in the upgrade this year. Um, but, but Crash
Quartz Pods, the universe, really great podcast that I enjoyed this year as well. So those are my
three that I picked. Uh, my nomination is the rest of history, uh, is number one. The Rest
History is one of my favorite podcasts of all time at this point. Um, I have actually
started re-listening to episodes I listened to a year ago. I don't think I have,
I have ever done that to a podcast.
Basically, one of my other favorite podcasts that I listen to every day is a way for holiday break.
So I have less stuff to listen to.
And I was looking for some comfort podcasting, like just things that, like, I didn't want news.
I wanted, you know, it's the holidays, just want, you know.
So what I decided I'd listen to was assassination of JFK.
I was like, it was a comfort, I guess.
Easy listening.
But it's incredible.
So I listened to that.
then I listened to America in 68 again
then I listened to Britain in 76 I think is the series
and then I just listened to the
the assassination of Franz Ferdinand
and the lead-in to the first world war one
and basically I'm I essentially ended up reminiscing
on me of a year ago I listened to all of these a year ago
when I first discovered the show
and I've never done this before
but like it's so relistenable still
because now I'm listening to those shows
understanding a lot of the references I didn't get
because I've now listened to a lot more
of the history of the show
I still have perfect things in their archive
that I want to listen to me too
that I would pick out before
although I'm running out but there are still ones
that are in there.
This was purely a...
You just wanted to have the relisten experience
I wanted an easy thing to listen to
that you'd already heard.
Yeah, it's a great podcast.
I mean, I've recommended it to so many people.
And, you know, everybody seems to go, oh, oh, yeah, actually.
I get so many people who come back to me and say, I can't, I can't believe.
And yes, it was Apple's podcast of the year, but it was our podcast of the year last year, too.
So we were there first.
And it is great.
And I highly recommend it.
And I recommend, it's actually a little like the flop house where I'll say,
go in the archive and find a subject you're interested in.
The one that hooked me was the American Revolution, because it was,
was British historians talking about the American Revolution and they had a totally different
viewpoint than any American school child has ever heard. And I've been thinking about those
episodes a lot while watching Ken Burns's The American Revolution documentary and noting the way
that it's framed. And that there are things in it that I'm like, aha, that is, the rest
is history made that same point that, you know, sometimes it's parliament and not the king.
The king was an easy punching bag for Americans who wanted political support.
but parliament had a lot to say about it too um yeah really interesting uh podcast totally worth
your time find a subject that interests you uh and dive deep because those guys uh dominic and tom
the hosts are historians they're great storytellers yes and they do their yeah they it's a very
funny relationship um and they do a great job of like one of them takes the lead in doing
the research for the episode and then the other one kind of like chimes in
and it works
it's just very effective
to get their perspective
on this stuff
that's why the show works so well
they just did a Jack the Roper series
which was brilliant
it's great
it really is great
just a brilliant
show
I also want to recommend
so I mentioned
one of my favorite shows
is off right now
it's the kind of funny games cast
this is a show
it's about video games
but I essentially just
listen to this show
every day
it is a daily show
because I just love
the relationship between the people
like it's like
a group of 11 guys
and it's like a rotating panel
and I just
I just enjoy so much
the ways in which they interact
of each other
and so I love it
is it
it's up there as well
like these two are like
my favorite podcast
but the racist history
is just like a different level
of the kind of show
and what it is
I also want to recommend Waveform
which is MKBHG's podcast
what I like about Waveform
it is a you know
ostensibly quote unquote new
it's been around for many years
but like a new-ish tech podcast
which is like the types of shows
that we make. It's like people that enjoy each other's company talking about tech. And
that is just becoming a rarer and rarer thing in technology podcasting. And so I love that
they do that and they do a good job with it. And of course, Marquez has access to everything.
So that really helps from a topic-based perspective. And then all favorite the town. I still
love the town. I listen all the time. I think it's a brilliant show. And it's been really good
the last few months of all of the wild stuff going on in the entertainment industry.
the upgrading is voted for the rest is history at 12.7% of the votes connected at 11.3% of the votes
and the little podcast that could upgrade at 10.6%.
Someone put in brackets like, come on, you've got to do it.
And the answer is no, we will never do it.
So obviously the rest of history is the winner for the second time in a row.
It is going to rocket itself into the lifetime achievement.
category, I'm sure.
So look out for that next year.
What are our runners-up?
Oh, boy.
I want to put CrashCorp's Pods of the Universe in there.
Yeah.
Katie and another green in there?
Yeah.
And then you want to pick one from your list?
Yes, I do.
And I'm going to pick the kind of funny games cast,
because that's just a thing that I, that's for me.
That one's for me.
Love it.
Paul Stephen Hacker.
He had a writing campaign and everything.
It was successful.
Not even nominated.
Not to get up to 11.3%.
No, Connect is up there, 11.3%.
That's what we're doing.
Yeah, I know, but it's not one of the finalists.
Ah, yes, it's not one of ours.
Because you asked me what I want to put in there,
and you know my rule.
I'm not, I'm not going to award anything that I do.
I know. I know.
And I wasn't going to push it
because I wanted to put Crash Course Course Pots
the universe in there instead.
So there we are.
And there it is.
This episode is.
brought to you by FitBod. If you're looking to change your fitness level, getting
start, it can be tough. This is the time of year when a lot of people think about this kind
of stuff, right? You're thinking about the year that is ahead for you. Maybe you've indulged
over the holiday period. You want to check out FitBod. It is an easy and affordable way to
build a fitness plan that is made for you because you're going to see great results when you
have a fitness program that is tailored to suit you exactly. FitBod make sure that they understand
your needs. They understand your body, your experience, your environment and your goals and they
tailor a workout program to meet you. It will adapt as you improve so every workout remain challenging,
pushing you to make the progress that you want. FitBod stores the information it has about you in
the FitBod Gym profile. It tracks your muscle recovery so you're avoiding burnout and keeping up
your momentum. They build your best possible workout by combining AI and exercise science. FitBod
have analyzed billions of data points that are fine-tuned by
certify personal trainers to make sure that your muscles are working together with your entire
muscular system with the workouts that are giving you because overworking some muscles
while underworking others can negatively impact your results. So FitBud builds that best possible
workout program for you. And when you're learning new movements, they're going to make sure that
you're going to be able to do it easily. They have more than a thousand demonstration videos in the
app, which I love this feature. So when I find something new because they're always recommending
new stuff to me because of the way that they design.
a well-balanced workout routine, so it's mixing up the different types of workouts that you're
doing. I want to know that this is a new, like an exercise that is new to me. I want to know
how to do it and have to do it well, and these videos really, really help. The FitButter app is
really easy to use. You can stay informed. We have tracking charts, weekly reports, and sharing
cards. It's to let you keep track of your achievements and personal bests and share them
with our friends and family. It also integrates with your Apple Watch, Wareware, Smart Watch and
apps like Strava, Fitbit, and Apple Health. Personalized training of this quality can be
be expensive. FitBard is just 1599 a month or 9599 a year, but you can get 25% of your membership
by going to FitBOD.me slash upgrade. So go now and get your customized fitness plan at FITBOD.
dot me slash upgrade. Once again, FitBod.combe for 25% of your membership.
Our thanks to FitBard for their support of this show and Reli.
Jason, what is your or what are your favorite Apple Pro?
product of this year.
Oh, boy.
That's a tough one.
I think Apple had a kind of low-key good year.
Yep.
Not super dramatic year, but a low-key good year.
And a good example of that is the iPhone 17 Pro, which they redesigned.
It has a color.
And it just, it's a really nice phone, a really good design.
They fixed the biggest issue, I think, with the,
16 Pro, which was the heat
issues. I have none of them.
And again, I just want to emphasize they made a pro phone
in orange, which is incredible.
And they did a great job. So
from a distance, you'd be like, it's just another iPhone. I was like, yeah,
but they really killed it.
Also, the iPhone Air, which is
a, I think, an amazing product.
I feel like it feels like, it feels like the
future. I know there are issues. People don't like the battery life. I think the screen, it makes it harder for me to hold it, but like I really do appreciate that larger screen in this thin and light device. And I, I, using it makes it feel like I'm using future tech, which is one of the things I really love about technology. And it makes me excited for what is to come because they're flexing their muscles here in a way that they haven't before. And I think it's going to lead to interesting things next year as well.
Yeah.
The iPad Pro M5, I know it's just a, you know, an update.
I bought one this year.
I hadn't bought an iPad Pro in a while.
And so I bought the M5 iPad Pro.
And it's like that M4M5 iPad Pro generation is just so good.
I have the larger one.
So it's the super thin one as well.
And like it's great out of a case.
It's super thin and light.
In a case, it's great.
In a keyboard, it's great.
It's got the multitasking.
It's got everything.
Like, it's just, it's just such a great example of that product.
and then I'm going to throw out the MacBook Air M4
because again I just think the MacBook Air continues to kill it
it is an amazing product, an amazing value
and having it be on the M4 processor
and soon on the M5, I think they keep doing a really great job there
and of course this year, sky blue,
a color that is taking the world by storm
if you can notice that it is not silver.
for me it is the two main iPhones of the year in my mind at least the iPhone 17 Pro and the iPhone Air
I think that they are both great examples of what Apple does well the iPhone 17 Pro is a really good
incremental improvement of the iPhone Pro line so the color is great I love the design
the edge to edge plateau the iconic plateau but also the
the two-tone glass design. I really like that. I've also been really happy about the fact that
there have been very few occasions where I felt my phone even get slightly warm since I've
had it. This was a big problem for me with previous phones getting too hot to touch when being
charged, for example. Well, kind of like downloading apps, like it was, well, like every time
I went into the lock screen customization, my phone would get too hot to holes. Like, that's not,
that's not right. Something bad's happening. Don't have that anymore. And then the iPhone
Air is just an engineering Marvel.
Also with the Pro,
the 17 Pro actually, I've really
liked the advancements to the camera,
both the selfie and the
4 and 8 times zoom
as well as the, you know, the whole
camera system. I've been really impressed
with this year. But
the iPhone Air is
really a fantastic device.
It feels wonderful to use.
They put way more
high power technology in that device
than we didn't necessarily expected they would
like promotion and stuff like that.
They did a really, really good job with that phone.
And it's a shame it hasn't done well for them,
but I don't think that that realistically feels like a problem, essentially.
Like, this phone is a, it is kind of a development ground for different technologies
in a way that the fourth phone spot wasn't before.
The mini, they were not developing anything new with the mini.
The same with the plus.
They were just like, here's things we can do.
but it's not going to proliferate across the line.
But there are a bunch of technologies in the air
that I expect, we all expect at this point,
will come to other phones,
whatever they might be in the future.
The Upgradians voted for the iPhone 17 Pro
at 25.9%.
The AirPods Pro 3 at 15%.
And the iPhone Air at 14.7%.
Airpods Pro 3, I like those a lot,
but I had such a new.
negative first impression.
I just couldn't imagine putting them
even as a nomination.
So I guess which iPhone
do we want to be the winner?
Hmm.
Hmm. That's a good question.
I think it's the 17 Pro.
I think the fact that they did a good...
It's good execution,
change of the design in a way that I really like.
I really like the curve back and all that
and then the orange on top of it.
Yeah. I think that's the winner.
And then I'd like...
like to put the Air and the, I don't know what the third one should be.
What do you think?
Maybe the iPad Pro.
I mean, I have the M4 version and love it.
And at least that is a more recent revision than the MacBook Air as such.
So iPhone 17 Pro is the winner.
iPhone Air and iPad Pro M4 as runner-ups.
Now we move into M5, M5, M5.
Because it's one better.
4, but it's M5.
It's M5. It's one better.
And then again, one of the features of the Upgradees is that you get to see.
Back when I did the Eddie Awards for Mac user and Macworld, we would get in a room and we would argue this stuff.
And then you just present the winners and nobody is privy to the conversation, whereas our listeners get to hear the conversation that leads to the awards.
That's the beauty of it.
Beauty of the Upgraties.
It is beautiful.
Favorite non-Apple product?
What have you got for us, Jason?
A couple weeks ago, I haven't read about this or anything.
talked about a couple weeks ago when iRobot filed for bankruptcy and got taken over by a
Chinese company that was its uh i guess uh yeah they were the manufacturer they they're they owned
the chinese company manufactured the robots and i robot owned that owed them a ton of money yeah exactly
so they took it over um the story of i robot is is long it includes the fact that they were prepped
for sale to amazon and then regulators said no they're too dominant and we can't allow
to be dominant here, which, ironically, by rejecting that, they basically killed that company.
So, so much for it being dominant, they also, partially because of that, but in general,
they resisted a bunch of innovation that was happening with Chinese robots, the robot vacuums
that got way ahead of them.
Anyway, over the, over the holidays, I bought a Robo Rock vacuum for like $220.
And I've only had it for a couple of weeks.
It's not the fancy ones because there are a lot of $1,000 robot vacuums out there.
This one was a couple hundred bucks.
And it is superior to my old Roomba in every conceivable way,
except that it, although it claims to have short cuts support, it doesn't work.
So I guess that is bad because its shortcut support is bad or broken.
It's Siri support is broken.
But in every way, as a vacuum, it is superior.
It's quieter.
Its app is better
It shows you where the robot is
It's like
And I had that moment where I thought
Oh
This is why I robot is going out of business
Because although they have added some things lately
In some of their newer revisions
To try to catch up to the competition
This vacuum cleaner
It's got like
I don't know whether it's got LIDAR
And cameras or whatever
But like it knows where it is
It vacuums in a proper way
It's just night and day
So it was like, I, anyway, I'm only a couple weeks in, but that's a pretty cool product.
The Switch 2 is great.
Yeah.
I haven't played it enough, but I have one and it's great and I love it.
Combustion is a company that makes a, it's like a temperature probe for when you're cooking stuff and you stick it in the stuff and it's wireless and then you can look at it on your phone and it will predict when it's going to be ready based on the target temperature.
It's really smart.
and I use that a lot
when I'm cooking
and I've enjoyed
my Trager pellet grill
this year
where I've made a bunch of things
using wood pellets
and smoking meat
and it's been really nice
so those are some of my favorite
Apple products for this year
non-apple products
for me it's an easy one
it's the Nintendo Switch 2
I was waiting for this device
for years and years
and I think they did a really good job
they did not do a perfect job
I wanted an OLED screen
but I will have to wait
for a revision for that.
It's a very powerful
piece of hardware that provides
me of a much better gaming experience
for my Nintendo games
and others. And now, like, it is
now my preferred system to play
games on. It was the seam deck
for a while, but I prefer the hardware.
I have to Switch 2
to the seam deck. So, really
an excellent games console. The Upgradians
voted for on the Nintendo Switch 2
at 34.4%.
the Bamboo Labs P2S 3D printer at 3.8%
and the terminal e-ink display at 3.2%.
There's a big drop-off from the Switch 2 to everything else.
Switch 2 is clearly the winner.
Yes, obviously.
Yes.
Clearly the winter.
Clearly.
Let's put your, let's put your Robo Rock vacuum in there.
Robot vacuum.
Yep.
I don't know what I'm going to do in the future.
I have a Rumba that I really like, but who knows what's going to go on with that
company going into.
tell you, I'll tell you. It's really, like, it's $200 or $220 that includes the cleaning dock.
Like, it's, it's, I mean, yeah, I know, right? And there are so many that are $1,000 robots that are out there that I'm sure they're great and all that, but I was not going to take a flyer on a $1,000 robot vacuum. I just wasn't going to do it again after having gone through two Rumbas now. I was like, I'm just going to, I'm going to take a flyer on this thing that, uh, wirecutter said was quiet and good and a good value. And yeah, it's a winner. I would love. I would love.
to put the combustion
you got it
in there as a runner-up
because that is a
it's good
it's really good
their first generation
kind of it died on me
and they were like yeah
we had a production problem
here's a new one
like great
and then now they've got
the second generation one as well
and the app is really good
it'll do a live activity
it's really nice
Jason what is your
worst gadget
or most disappointing
technology of the year
okay my nominees
are
One, the sky blue MacBook Air.
The same one that was nominated in.
Well, yeah, it didn't end up getting nominated, but I mentioned, yes, yes.
It was, right, the MacBook Air M4?
Was that not the...
No, I think we were with the iPad, right?
Yeah, but you mentioned it.
It was in your nominations.
Oh, I mentioned it, sure, but I know it was good wins.
It's funny, it's funny, it's funny.
So most disappointing tech, we have wanted Apple to embrace color.
They finally did it in the iPad Pro.
We really wanted them to embrace it in the MacBook Air.
We thought that would be a perfect place for it.
Could they do at least one color option
that was not silver or midnight or starlight or, you know, or whatever?
And the answer was yes, they did a color.
They called it sky blue.
And in their photography, it looks like a light,
not super exciting, but a light blue MacBook Air.
And then they sent me one.
And I literally had to look at the box,
the sticker on the box, to see if they had just sent me a silver one.
and it said sky blue, and I couldn't see it.
And in certain light, in certain light, I could see, oh, it is a little bit blue.
But I would say this is one of my greatest disappointments at the year that Apple finally added a color to the MacBook Air.
And it is the least fun color because you can barely even tell that it's there.
And I hate it.
It represents everything that's wrong with Apple's color decisions in a year where they got the iPhone Pro Color right.
So that was a big disappointment for me this year.
I remember those moments of hearing about them doing a sky blue
and then seeing the pictures and then getting it and realizing.
I mean, when they said it,
I remember getting the briefing.
I literally got the briefing while I was on vacation in Hawaii.
So I remember very clearly getting the briefing
and then going down to the pool and writing an article about it.
And I remember thinking at the time,
is it really going to be sky blue or is it going to just look silver?
And then I got, oh, open the box.
I was like, oh, they sent me the silver one.
I'm not going to be able to judge the sky blue.
And then I looked at the box and went,
oh, this is the sky blue.
Oh, no.
Oh, great.
Not surprising, but disappointing.
I read a lot about e-readers, and so a few months ago,
everybody was talking about this new cheap-ish e-reader that, and they're like,
it has mag safe on the back, and it's little, and you can carry it with you,
and it is the X-T-E-Ink X-4.
So I bought one.
And I'm going to write about it at some point,
but I can't really decide how I'm going to do it because
I don't want to beat up a product
nobody's ever heard about, but I had so many people write me
about this thing. And it's just, it's, it's, it's
super disappointing. It's just not good. It's cheap.
But like, its ePUB rendering is bad.
Its interface is terrible. It has,
I'm a known fan of physical buttons on an e-reader.
This thing has too many buttons.
It's got like, it's got like an on-off button and a
up and down button and then on the front it's got two buttons but they're actually rockers so
they're four buttons it's like i don't know which one to press uh and then the software on it
is bad uh a thing that i've learned in covering these um chinese e readers uh like the ones
from um from books right is that over the years they've gotten much better at sort of like
customizing android to have it work the way you want it to work as an e reader and they've really
advanced. I mean, they're taking a lot of like standard hardware off the shelf, but then
they're, they're, they've really advanced in their knowledge of like how to get your,
your Android customization to be an e-reader. And this thing is just, there's nothing. It's not,
I think it's not even Android. It's just, it's bad. It's bad. And if it was cheap and you could
stick it on the back of your, your iPhone or whatever, or just in your pocket, I would say, you know,
but it's worth it. But like, the e-reading experience, experience on it is so bad that I would never
want to read anything on this thing.
So, oh, also
the whole, it fits on the back
of your phone concept.
The, not the iPhone
17 Pro, it doesn't.
Oh, the iconic plateau became too iconic.
Two, I mean,
it fits sideways. It's the classic. It fits
sideways. Probably fits good on the air.
I've got it, I'm sorry, I was
laughing too much there.
Not at your reading. I went to the product
page for this thing and
they have like a, like a product image.
and the image is the e-reader
and it's got a bunch of phrases on it
and I'd just like to read them.
Yes, please.
Uncompromising.
Minimalism.
Brave.
Confidence.
Kind.
Lose yourself in the words.
Good night.
Unique.
XTE Inc.
Independent.
Excellence resolute.
Reading at your fingertips.
Pure.
Let every word linger.
Do not go gentle
into that good night.
Makes you think, doesn't it?
Why is that one on there?
Makes you think.
Do not go gentle in today.
Good night.
So what I will also say is it doesn't have a light.
So if you want to read it in a room that's not well lit,
you have to like turn on a light or get a book light.
So that's a real loser.
I mean, I get it.
It's cheap.
But like without a light, any ink reader that doesn't light,
is a non-starter for me, and then the software is really bad.
So, yeah, it's just a bad, look, a little tiny e-reader is a great idea.
The, the, um, books palma is like a phone-sized e-reader, and it's not for everybody,
but like, that is, I think it's really interesting to get to the point where you can have
a little teeny tiny e-ink device that you take with you and it literally will just fit in
your pocket, even if your pockets are tiny or in a bag and you can just, like, I'm a big
believer in e-readers as a
standalone product. Like, you don't need
to have it on your phone. You can bring this little tiny thing
and it's not distracting. That's all great.
I would like to see more things like this thing,
but this thing is not good.
It's just not good. Just that it exists
is not enough. It needs to be good and it's not.
So disappointing.
And then my other
example here
is I want to, kind of a
concept piece, which is the cord
cutting drama.
It has gotten
so hard to figure out how what services you need because everybody is fighting with
everybody else now. So I'm going to give you an example, which is I have been a subscriber
of Fubo and of YouTube TV. These are both streaming services that offer you essentially
a cable subscription. And in the last year, both of them have had extended outages where they've
been in a dispute with another company.
So YouTube TV was in an extended dispute with ABC and ESPN, so Disney, over those
channels.
And Fubo is still in an extended dispute with NBC Universal over their channels.
And it means that you end up in a scenario where you can't watch stuff.
And they try.
So, like, YouTube TV basically said, we're going to give you $15.
off for as long as this goes
and just go by
you know, go get, go subscribe
to ESPN over the top
and you'll get everything that you're missing.
Yeah. And that was true. Although
I don't think it got them everything
that was on ABC stations. I don't
think it did. I don't think you can
watch, you know, everything
over the top on your ABC station. So it wasn't
entirely accurate.
And as I was on Fubo
and the NBC stations went off
and again, the attitude now is
that everything is everywhere and that if you can't get it from us, you can get it from
somewhere else. So Fubo is like, look, we're sorry. We're in a dispute with NBC. But here's
the good news is you can get everything that NBC does on Peacock. So we're going to give you $15
off and just go sign up for Peacock. Except it's not true. It's not true because what NBC
Universal does is withhold some of their content, some of their content like Premier League
Soccer. There's one game that's on a cable channel that they don't even own anymore.
It's USA Network. It's Versant. It's, they spun it off, but it's still there.
So, so, so one morning, I come out, I want to watch the Arsenal game and it's not on Fubo.
And I think, oh, right, carriage dispute. And so I go to Peacock. And it's not on Peacock.
Why is it not on Peacock? Because they've decided, NBC Universal has decided for strategy reasons to put it on a cable channel that they don't even own anymore.
And if it's on that cable channel, literally the only way you can watch.
it is by subscribing to either cable TV or to one of these $70, $80, $90 a month services,
but not the wrong one because they're in a carriage dispute.
I love it.
It's like, it's not on Fubo.
It's on version.
It's like, okay.
It's not, yeah, it's on.
So I actually canceled Fubo and went to YouTube TV because I, that was.
And the attitude of these companies is like, oh, just subscribe to whatever.
And it's like, well, I'm not going to pay two $80 a month things to get different chance.
Like, that's not.
Only one is going to.
win. And if it's not you, it's going to be them until it's not them. And then maybe it'll be
somebody else. But this is, and this is why I say court-cutting drama. Part of this is we're in
this really weird situation now where a lot of stuff that used to only be on standard
television is now on streaming, which is good. But there still exists a little bit of stuff
that if you don't have a 70, 80, $90 a month package, whether it's from your cable company
or it's from one of these over-the-top providers.
You can't watch it because it's locked to cable
because in many cases it's this old strategy,
which is, well, we need to give value.
Like, HBO Max has everything that's on T&T.
And I believe the ESPN service has everything
that's on ESPN and ABC, I think, at this point,
for sports only.
But like, I fell through the cracks
with the Premier League on USA.
which disappeared from my TV provider.
And I, like, we, it's 20, 25. It is almost 2026.
If you're going to do disputes like this, make the content available, in this case, on
peacock. I, I'm, I'm, I'm, so I'm super offended by Fubo for saying, oh, just get peacock,
which is not true. And also by NBC Universal having a service that theoretically contains,
all of their sports content,
except then they take
pieces of their sports content
and put it on cable TV
and just say,
sorry, even if you pay for our stuff,
you can't get it.
I hate...
So at a time when we ought to be
emerging from the fog
of streaming service choices,
we are actually worse off.
Terrible.
I hate it.
So my nomination in this category,
I actually think is better
discussed in a different
category, so I'm going to hold it.
Okay.
I will refer back to it later on.
The Upgradians voted of 18.6% for AI, just in general, AI.
Yeah, sure.
Liquid glass, 8.7%.
So here's the other side of the coin from earlier on, and Apple Intelligence at 7.7%.
I also, I want to talk about Apple Intelligence, and I'm saving that for a later category.
Yes.
I, okay, so this.
This is tough.
Yeah.
This is tough.
I was not disappointed in AI because my feelings about AI over this last year haven't really changed that much, which is that it's overhyped, but there's still some value in it.
But it's overhyped in lots of terrible ways that are bad, which is not a great take, right, to say, well, you know, it's 70% bad, but 30% good.
It's like, okay, well, what does that, where does that leave us?
Yeah.
I
I don't know what to do in this category
honestly I mean I think that
I think that fundamentally this is the year where
Apple intelligence disappointed everybody
yeah
I think we should do it here
I think I think it can win this is the year where Apple came out
and last year was the year of Apple intelligence
and then this year was the year where Apple came out and said
that the stuff we promised you about Apple intelligence
we can't do it
Yeah.
And maybe it'll happen next year.
In the coming year, a phrase designed.
We say maybe.
Yeah.
But in the coming year, a phrase designed to obfuscate what they were saying, which is that
we've delayed this thing we promised in 2024 until 2026.
That year is still to come.
It's still to come.
As of this recording, it is still the coming year.
Oh, boy, imagine when it's the actual year.
I can't wait.
So I think Apple Intelligence as the winner of this category is fine.
Yeah.
I would really like to put the sky blue MacBook Air in as a nominee because,
I am super disappointed in it.
And, you know, I'd be okay
with liquid glass, but I kind of want to go
with cord cutting drama. I think we should put cord
cutting drama in there. I think that that is
I like that more as a thing. Okay.
It's more interesting to me personally.
Great.
Most life-changing hardware now.
All right. My nominees here are, again, the Robo Rock
Vacuum cleaner, the Compustion Probe Thermometer.
my M4 Max MacBook Pro I bought this year
and a second desk in a different part of my house
with a thunderbolt one cable thunderbolt connection
to either desk in my house that I want to work on.
Well, that computer changed your life so much
that you could come work here.
Truly life-changing hardware to be able to do that.
Well, I could have come and work there too,
but I was able to come and work there.
Well, except I didn't bring my laptop.
That was the problem.
Oh, yeah.
Only brought my iPad.
Forget what I said.
I should have brought my laptop.
I was thinking in Memphis.
You had your laptop.
In Memphis, I did.
I have my computer with me.
My whole computer.
That's when I travel on my,
I have my whole computer with me.
I don't have to set it up and sync it up and update the apps or anything.
It just is my computer wherever I go.
I was needed to do something this weekend and I don't heat the office on the weekend.
And I just walked in here into the cold garage and picked up my laptop and took it out into the warm living room.
It was like, my computer came with me.
Imagine a computer you can take with you.
What would we call it?
some sort of laptop.
And then I also bought some Lutron shades for my bedroom.
And it's early days yet,
but those are also looking like it's life-changing.
Because, again, the idea here is you want,
especially in the summer,
you want the shades closed
when it's starting to get light
and you want to be still sleeping.
But when it's time for you to wake up,
you do want to see the light from the outside
and not oversleep.
And the Lutron shades,
I can settle that.
I can automate that so that they're open.
open during the daytime and then they close at night
automatically. My old shades
were basically, you know,
one of them was basically closed all the time and they
were, they're translucent so they let in light
but they that were in that
you couldn't see out and they couldn't
be blackout curtains either. And these
are a little bit of both. I really like
Lutron, we've talked about it before.
I saw Neely Patel throwing shade at Lutron
the other day and like, I don't know what you're talking about
dude. This stuff is rock solid.
I love it. It's the best
smart home tech that exists. I was
confused about that too. I think what
that person, because Lutron have this
whole thing where you can control your entire
house via a box
that they sell. Yeah, don't do that.
That's what he was starting to say that. Don't do that.
Yeah. Because the reason I know this is because
when we were looking into Lutron here, it's basically
the only way Lutron will work. They have to do the whole home
install thing. Oh no, no, no. Just not wanting that.
No, no. Not wanting that.
So for me, uh, the VTech RM 7767 HD,
which is the baby monitor that we have.
It's amazing. I saw it. It's amazing.
Yeah, it's super good.
I actually don't think they sell this model anymore.
They're probably going to update it or something.
But there are a few things I like about this model.
One, the screen is big.
It is a 7-inch screen.
I like that.
I like that we have a big screen
so we can see the baby.
You can see it very clearly.
The picture quality is very clear.
We have it connected via radio.
It has Wi-Fi option two.
parents go ballistic when you mention Wi-Fi.
There is like,
there is just a feeling that if you have a Wi-Fi-enabled baby monitor
that people will look at your baby.
Spies.
This is a prevalent thing.
Realistically, what you need to make sure is that you have a Wi-Fi model
that has some kind of video encryption,
which basically they all do now.
and that it is safe
like you have good passwords or whatever
I'm sure that there was a story
that this was happening
that some model was bad
but essentially we don't use the Wi-Fi
but I expect at some point we will
because they have an app
and you can watch from outside of the house
but we don't need to do that
in some bigger homes
the Wi-Fi can be helpful
to extend the range
but we found the range
on just the radio antenna to be excellent
and it has less latency
the Wi-Fi would have more latency.
So we like it.
So it's good and it's one of these cameras.
You know, the camera has a bunch of sensors in it,
like humidity and temperature, which is helpful.
And also you can move the camera independently from the display, right?
You can move it like tilt, left, right, up, down.
It's really cool.
Additionally, having an iPad Mini mounted on a 12 south display arm thing
in the nursery, super helpful.
when the baby was really young
and we were doing a lot of contact napping
it was good to be able to watch TV shows
but it's also we use it as our white noise machine
so we play white noise from it
and we have easy access to all of our tracking apps as well
so super good
just baby and we'll baby tech this year
Upgradions voted at 9.3%
for the AirPods Pro 3
the Apple Watch at 4.2%
and the Nintendo Switch 2 at 3.3%.
This feels like an incredibly difficult category, this one.
We're going to do the baby monitor as the winner.
Oh, it's baby year.
It's baby year.
That's right.
Baby monitor is the winner.
My M4 Max MacBook Pro is the runner-up.
And let's put AirPods Pro 3 in this category.
Let's do it.
Because the Upgradians liked it, and I will agree,
this is the year where, I mean, the two also has it, but it's the, we got live translation and
hearing aid and stuff like they are a life changing bit of hardware. The noise cancellation
is incredible. And it's so much better. In incredibly good. Change my life in that I don't
need to travel with AirPods Pro Max in my backpack anymore if I don't want to. So I'm excited about
that. I've yet to deal with the whole thing of like needing headphones to record. But like,
that's a problem for future me. But amazing.
Final two categories now, Jason Snell.
We're getting close to the end of the 12th annual upgradeies.
So I'm going to move into Favorite Tech Story of the Year.
I have a few.
I feel like this is the year of people in over their heads a little bit.
And these are kind of like they're tech, but they're also not.
But I'm going to merge tech and entertainment and streaming together.
together in one big morphous blob.
That's this show, baby.
That's what it's all about.
So I, actually, my two favorite stories of the year were both by Elizabeth Lepado at
The Verge.
Yeah, Elizabeth had a bit of a bang a year, I think.
There's a real, these are trends, but like these stories are the ones that really
were not afraid to throw elbows.
And I like that.
So one of them is called Larry Ellison's big, dumb gift to his large adult.
son, which is a story about how Larry Ellison's kid, David Ellison, got money from
his dad to buy Paramount and now wants money from his dad to buy Warner Brothers and merge it
with Paramount. Yeah. And, you know, we talk about like, oh, Warner Brothers wants to, or Paramount
wants to merge with Warner Brothers. But if you zoom out, and Elizabeth Lapado's story does this,
like Larry Ellison is one of the richest men in the world
and his son is like Daddy I want that thing
it'll be $40 billion and if you're Larry Ellison
you're like am I going to throw another $40 billion at this kid
maybe he likes the idea of controlling the media
I mean who wouldn't but also there's a dynamic of it that is
that I enjoy I mean David Ellison is an adult
and probably has things
that you could say about him
that are positive
but what I would say about it is
it's very hard for me
to get over the fact
that it's a kid of a billionaire
who wants to be a mogul
and is pointing at Hollywood icons
and big companies
and saying,
buy that for me, daddy.
And Elizabeth Lapado's piece
about their attempt
to hostily take over
Warner Brothers Discovery
and beat Netflix out,
which itself is a huge story.
right. Netflix buying Warner Brothers is a potentially huge story, but the fact that the kid of a billionaire who already bought one Hollywood studio and wants to buy another and merge them together for an amount of money that does not make any business sense. It just is like Paramount as an entity would never buy Warner Brothers. It doesn't make any sense. But because it's David Ellison and his dad has hundreds of billions of dollars,
they could just do it.
Even if it doesn't make a lick a sense, they'll do it.
And not only will they have long-term ramifications
because it'll never be worth it.
And it will destroy a Hollywood studio, essentially.
And the political dynamic of the fact that, you know,
David Ellison's tantrum when Warner Brothers Discovery
chose the Netflix offer over his
seems to have been in part the fact that,
again, I think part of it was,
but I said I wanted this to my daddy
and why are you not giving it to me?
But also,
but my daddy gives a lot of money
to Donald Trump
and we told you that
we intimated that that was good
because we could make a deal.
And then the report came out
that like 10 Sarandos
that had been having dinner
with Trump and stuff
and like there was
and then Trump started complaining
about things that CBS was doing
that, you know,
after David Ellison bought it.
Like I think he got played
and I think he exposed himself
as a little bit of a,
uh, an amateur.
but Daddy's got lots of money
so in the end if Daddy wants to up
his offer
Netflix will probably not match it
and then he can give his son
another toy to play with
so anyway I think that there's a story of the year
in general
and then Elizabeth Lapato's story
is kind of savage and it's a banger
and I really liked it but more generally
it's Netflix buying Hollywood studio
David Ellison buying Hollywood Studios
I think that's a story of the year
the other angle on this story
that preceded this
another banger from Elizabeth Lepado, which is memo to Bari Weiss regarding CBS News, you're doomed.
Which is...
Just good headlines.
Just really good headlines.
Yeah.
So this is, this is, and there's an alternate version that's like you're hitting the glass cliff.
The point here is that David Ellison put Bari Weiss an unqualified person whose qualifications are starting a substack and being an opinion editor at the New York Times for a little while before quitting and using that to start her substack.
being the editor-in-chief of CBS News
completely out of speaking people out of their depth
completely out of her depth
we've already seen with a 60-minute story
how she completely blew it
not that the editor-in-chief of CBS News
shouldn't have opinions about 60 minutes
but when she doesn't show up at the meetings
and doesn't watch the video until the very end of the process
and then she gives her notes
and they take her notes
and then she and they promoted the story
and it's ready to go and then she pulls it again
for reasons that I would say journalistically
are deeply dubious. Like it's a great example
again of somebody who is not qualified
for their job. That happens sometimes
and is showing, as Elizabeth
Lepado called it, showing that
she's completely in over her head.
Now, again, as with the purchase of
Werenb Brothers Discovery, money
goes a long way. If the rich guys
want her to be in charge of CBS News
regardless of how badly she screws it up,
she will remain in charge of CBS News.
But she's already in the
process of making terrible decisions that
expose the fact that she doesn't know what she's doing
because she is utterly unqualified to even be involved in journalism, quite frankly.
Don't at me.
I just look at her background.
She got this job for one reason,
and it's because she's a darling of the people who work in the White House,
and that's the only reason she has the job.
She has no qualifications for it,
which is not me saying that CBS News is not maybe insular and delusional
and thinks it's more valuable than it actually is in terms of business.
I'm not actually saying that.
I'm just saying that you put somebody in charge who doesn't know what they're doing,
and isn't that focused on it.
And even the people who are friends of hers
will say she's legendarily kind of like,
the quote I saw this weekend was,
she can't even keep her calendar.
She's supposed to run a network.
Okay.
Anyway, those stories were both bangers,
and I thought they were great.
So those are the trends of the year for me
in the tech world.
One of mine is the ongoing Apple succession story,
which has been playing out for a lot of the year,
but really kicked up a gear
in October and November.
So Mark German wrote like a big piece in October.
And then there was the Financial Times stuff in November.
And then there was, you know, the week of retirements.
What was it like, what was the episode title of like everybody left or something?
Like the week where everybody left or something like that we called it.
That has been just something that I've been really interested in.
This is something that feels essentially unprecedented.
It is something that is unprecedented in the years that I've been covering Apple.
to see so much movement in the executive ranks when just any movement in the executive ranks
has been a big story in history, like in the time that we're doing this show.
And in the last month, there's been like three retirements.
And there's been like four or five in total in this year.
It's really a fascinating time.
So that's been super interesting.
But for me, my absolute favorite story of the year is something rotten in the state of Cumpidino,
which Sean Gruber wrote in February.
March, whenever it was, which was essentially the article that he wrote after getting the confirmation
that Apple intelligence was going to be delayed. This story was just fantastic writing all around
from John with big ramifications. It hit big and broke out of our world for sure. And I think
the reverberations of that are going to be are going to be ringing out at least into 2026 and beyond.
John made a lot of claims.
He had a lot of information.
It all kind of lines up with what I expect was going on at Apple.
And also it was just a very good introspective piece
about how we've come to trust Apple
and the way that they demonstrate their products in a certain way.
And now that has changed.
And I think I expect for the next many years,
Apple demoing things is going to just become more and more complicated
because now we just don't trust them in the way that we used to.
Super fascinating, well-written story, big ramifications.
I think it doesn't come down to one story,
but I think this is the biggest example of it.
And you can see in how Apple handled 2025 at WWC,
that they know how badly they screwed it up, right?
And so I think from now on, for a while,
Apple is going to have a policy where they're not going to announce anything unless they're confident that it will ship.
Like everything that they announced at WWDC 2025, I believe, has shipped now.
Yes.
Because they're not going to do this again.
But John Gruber calling them on it, somebody who Apple is used to being someone who defends Apple and understands Apple, but like comes at it from Apple's perspective and is frequently the dissenter who says, you guys don't understand.
Apple is doing this because of this
and John was like, nope,
nope, they, I, I,
and he was like, I'm kicking myself because
I should have seen it and they,
and, you know, he went into detail.
And, you know, did Apple retaliate
by like not, not supplying
executives to the talk show live at
WBC and screening F1
opposite his time slot?
I think, uh, we have no evidence,
but I think it would be hard to imagine.
the F1 part I'm not sure about right like I feel like I don't have an answer for that
I mean potentially it could have just been bad timing but not having people go not having any
Apple executives at the talk show was absolutely retaliation absolutely it was retaliation
what this is the year you know what a surprise you know what that's how the game is
played you still got to say what you got to say and he did and let them do what they're going to
do and I would say that them doing that is probably stupid the episode of the talk show that
he made this year was the best one in
years. He had
Mila Patel and Joanna Stone
and it was
great. I thought it was a better
episode of the talk show at WWC
than it would have been otherwise. Of course
because the problem with Apple executives is that
they are very good at staying on message
and that means you don't glean a whole lot unless they're
willing to share something and sometimes they are
and that can be interesting but like
it's just a different thing
so it's fine. I mean John did what he
needed to do. I agree. I think that in our
world that was the biggest story of the year. The Upgradians voted for Alan Dye leaving Apple at 24.1%.
The AI arms race at 7.2% and the announcement of the Steam Machine at 6.6%.
Steam machine thing I'm very excited about. We will talk about this, I think, on this show at
some point next year, because I do think that there is an interesting story about the state
of technology when looking at this product. I think Alan Dye leaving Apple is a, what is the thing
It's a recency bias thing.
Like, yeah.
This,
yes,
this was a big deal.
It was not that big of a deal.
Like,
it's not that big of a deal.
Like,
that it is the most important story of the year or like the best thing that happened
this year.
Like,
I don't know.
To me,
it just doesn't ring.
But I feel like we spoke about that to death.
But I do think it's worthy of a runner up.
It was a really big story.
I think maybe,
you know,
I'm going to put,
as a runner up,
I'm going to put Alan die.
Slash Apple Succession.
Slash Apple Succession. I'm going to lump them in together.
Okay. All right. I don't know. I think it's part of that story, I think.
I'm going to put Apple Succession first.
Yes, thank you.
Thank you.
And then why don't you put in, how about like movie studio consolidation as a runner-up?
Yeah.
That covers mine.
Yeah.
and we'll put something as rotten in the state of Cupertino
as the winner.
I think it is rare in this category
that an actual just article wins has happened before,
but it's rare,
but I do think that this is one of those times
when absolutely just the article
is the story of the year.
Final category
for the upgrade is this year
is the favorite tech screw up.
What is your favorite text grew up with the year?
I have two.
Yep.
One is Apple gives up on personalized Siri until the coming year.
Yeah.
The classic, I think the definitive.
Yep.
And I actually think that Johnny Ive and Sam Altman's super awkward video where they share a coffee in San Francisco and vaguely talk about how they're going to do cool stuff that is hardware but is open AI and whatever and we're buddies and we're in San Francisco.
I would, that was one of my.
favorite things that I view as a screw-up because all it did was make me deeply suspicious
of both of them and not believe anything they said.
I was very excited about this news when it happened because I just think that it is fascinating,
interesting news. I now view the way that they announced this as a screw-up because I don't
think, well, I don't need to think this. They did not have a product at this point.
Nope. And they may have a product now, well, then they should have announced it now.
they should not have
I mean I know it's actually quite complicated
like how would they have announced this
because they were actually acquiring the company and the people
but nevertheless they shouldn't have made the big deal
out of it that they did until later
but at the same time if you're Sam Altman
of course he's going to make a big deal out
of essentially buying Johnny Ive
but nevertheless the way in which they did it
they shouldn't have done it
they should have just announced it
without the video right
And I think that would have been fine.
But the video was, the video was too heavy-handed at a time when they didn't have something to show.
So I'm looking forward to the product announcement in 2026 that they promised.
So we'll see what happens there.
I will say the one thing I admire about that entire rollout is the purity of it, by which I mean it's 100% BS.
So they didn't muddy it up with facts or reality or anything like that.
Jason, they get in a way.
Ego-maniacal fantasy.
And I hate it.
That's get in the way.
They get in the way.
Mine are Apple intelligence being delayed again.
I think that is just,
it is one of the monumental screw-ups.
Like, it's one of the biggest.
Apple's biggest screw-ups ever.
Yeah.
It is so high up there.
Because the ramifications of this are massive
and will be felt for years.
Like, just, they could not have bungled that more than they did.
The other one for me is Apple, Epic, Judge Gonzalez-Rogers,
the whole thing that resulted in Apple losing the ability to charge 30% on the in-app purchase stuff,
being held in contempt, all that nonsense, where it was essentially Apple lost an appeal,
which has resulted in the, like still at this point, they can't,
developers in the US
can take third-party payments
to don't have to give Apple anything.
This will change.
There is going to be a point
where it is an amount of money
willing to go to them?
That's part of the screw-up, right?
Is that they agreed,
the appeals court,
agreed with Judge Gonzalez-Rogers
that Apple was in contempt
but did not agree with her remedy
of banning Apple
from ever charging anything.
Which means that there's going to have
to be another process
in that court again
where Apple proposes
a regime for charging
that she deems fair,
which is going to be another circus.
Like, that is all she wanted.
Like, this time in between,
like,
realistically, this is the punishment
that she wanted to give that.
This is their punishment.
Like, yeah.
And so.
Because they didn't,
they didn't make a realistic attempt.
They made this kind of bogus attempt
to inflate it back up to back,
right?
They basically backdated it, right?
Because they wanted to re-inflate it
back up to 30%.
So it means that they then claimed poor facts.
And so, yeah,
the circus continues.
But yeah, that was a heck of a circus.
The upgrading is voted with Apple Intelligence at 11.6%.
The AWS and Cloudflare outages at 7.9%.
And liquid glass.
Liquid glass is all over the place at 7.9%.
The outages is an interesting one.
I didn't think about that.
Sure.
We rely on stuff.
No, real bad.
Let's put Apple Intelligence delay has got to be number one, right?
Yeah.
Yeah.
Apple intelligence delay is number one.
and then I think that the epic Apple thing
and Johnny and Sam are runners-up.
I absolutely agree.
I'd already written Johnny Ivan, Sam,
Alman, it was a nomination.
So, oh, yeah.
We've done it.
We've done it for another year.
For better or worse, we did it.
But there are still some technical achievement awards
that I would like to give out.
You know, like there's always the secondary award show.
This is the credit rolling at the end of the year.
For audio editing, Jim Metzenorf,
video editing, Jamie Snell,
Visual design, J.D. Davis. Music, Chris Breen, audio design, new category for Lex Friedman, record keeping. Zoe Knox, production, Mike Hurley, for good takes, Jason Snell. And the award for the best listeners, the Upgradians.
To the Upgradians. Oh, what an upset. Oh, amazing. The rest of history finally loses.
Yeah. To the Upradians.
Thank you so much for listening to this show this year.
This is our last episode of the year, of course, because there's no more Mondays in 2025.
No more Mondays.
No more Mondays.
I want to thank you all and wish you all the happiest of New Year's.
I hope that you celebrate 2026 is beginning in a way that it is good for you.
If you would like to send any of your feedback, follow-up questions for the show, go to UpgradeFeedback.com.
Thank you to everyone to support solicit of a membership.
You can go to Get Upgradeplus.com to sign up.
We appreciate you.
You can find this show on YouTube by searching for the Upgrade podcast.
If you do that for this episode, you'll see that Jason and I are wearing matching clothes.
And we got our upgrade shirts.
Of course.
Thank you to our sponsors for this episode.
That is Century, E-CAM, and FitBud.
But most of all, thank you for listening.
We'll be back next time.
Until then, say goodbye, Jason Snell.
Happy New Year, Mike Hurley.
No host.
No host.
Happy New Year to all.
and to all a good night.
