War With A Mate - Episode 74: A Tale Of Two Buenos
Episode Date: May 1, 2026It was the best of times, it is the worse of times. The source and solution of the Buenos are tackled in this airborne episode of War With A Mate. With the guys resolving the first air phase of Turn F...ive, looking to the progenitor of bombing runs in the history segment, and taking criticism of “helpful” suggestions into the stratosphere in this week’s Common Ground. This is most certainly for you.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
stop wasting your nights on a mattress that doesn't get you experience the most comfortable
mattress in the world the sleep number smart bed at the touch of a button you can personalize your
comfort choose firmer or softer adjust cooler to warmer and right now save up to twenty five
hundred dollars during our massive labor day event hurry into your local sleep number store today
Because we have your number.
Hello and welcome to War with a Mate.
With me, James.
Me, Andy.
Andy, who has 13 fingers and is playing the campaign for North Africa?
you me if i had three more fingers in this situation thumbs are fingers
do you where do you stand on that wouldn't have been a great riddle of the sphinx
no that's from the goblet of fire where harry potter's going through the maze books of course
they got rid of the sphinx in the film which makes sense because you don't want a whole sequence
in that big cool monster well it's not really a big cool monster when all it kind of does is so
it asks a riddle about spiders and it's a really bad riddle and then it resolves in like 30 seconds
maybe 60 if you have like dramatic cuts of harry potter going oh what was that again just rubbing
his chin oh what what was it again what doesn't ron like what doesn't he spiders that's it
it would have made an already questionable film far worse there's a lot of plot holes to pick
apart in that film but we won't do that we've got our own things to pick up campaign for north
africa podcast where we are each week we play sbi's campaign for north africa yeah that's what
we decided to do with our lives isn't that cool yeah it's better than a harry potter podcast uh
yeah i suppose i'd probably i think i enjoy this more than a harry potter podcast
because i think i'd just be and this is going to be a fun thing based on what i'm usually like in
this i think i'd be angrier during a harry potter podcast yeah no one wants to see that i don't
think i'd maintain my composure particularly well it's not it's not a fun series of books or films
for me anymore no it's been tarnished a little just a tad just just a a big tad what hasn't been
tarnished is this gem of a game we're of course talking about monopoly no we're not we're doing
this we've been doing turn five upstage one and specifically the air missions and my movement
yes we've resolved both uh tick them both off today yeah you were generous enough last time
to give me first go with your initiative you're welcome i thank you i do actually thank you for
this because it went in a direction that i think you were not expecting and i'm always glad when
that happens i'm always happy to surprise you i'm looking forward to you doing it one day
you did not see this coming you didn't see this coming shall we talk about what happened
we will we'll get to that point and we'll go through the the motions to get there
we started off with the prime time air phase we'd left a bit of a cliffhanger last week wherein we
declared our missions i had three you had six your six were two combat air patrols over the
fourth and the seventh yeah which lined up with two of your bombing missions
okay um and then i also strafed two things the supply dump you have up on the coast
thank you and also the second
and i also bombed the second oh and the fourth no other way around i don't care about the fourth
i care about the second that's up to you no i care deeply about the second i don't care about
the fourth anymore they're fascist italians andy like i know you're just defending yourself because
you care so much about the fourth i don't i don't care about the four of those guys i don't you keep
talking about how cool the fourth are i showed you their cohesion today yeah it's probably the
highest in your army fuck you it's it's like a combination of minus sixes nines and elevens
yeah i assumed that was the average that's actually incredibly good that's bad sorry it's
not good it's not good that's that's very bad for my guys yes that is really bad a lot no no one
else i think is that bad they might actually be the worst off okay at a cursory glance they might
be the worst off. I feel like I've made a couple of you guys retreat twice. No. I know you're wrong,
but I don't have specific examples to the top of my head. Oh, wow. What a great counter-argument
you've presented here. I guess. You've added nothing. It's unnecessary. So we fired off with
with my missions my air missions yes we went off strong we started strong we began with me
doing my strafe on your supply convoy your truck convoy convoy one yes as not only i like to call
them but the counter also demarks them as number one and also my spreadsheets oh perfect i haven't
done a weird shift on the truck numbers from the spreadsheets well that's good because what a weird
way to confuse things further for you because i don't look at your spreadsheet so that's just
confusing your side of things completely.
I strafed them
and I missed.
You did.
So that was a shame.
But you gave those guys a little scare
for a second. That's not enough though, is it?
No, it's not. You don't get any points for
frightening people. Although morale is
a big thing, so I imagine there is an aspect of
intimidation.
Not mechanically.
There is a mechanic for disenchantment.
no there is it's morale disenchantments i guess they're disenchanted with the cause but it's a
weird way of phrasing it well i don't make the rules andy i just read the rules sparingly i hate
doing it so i dropped my my strafe missed that i then went after your guys i went after the fourth
and the seventh yes fourth indian and the seventh armored started with the fourth and i committed
14 planes to that. You did, and I
commuted 14 to that one.
So, one each. SM
79.
Or as Rihanna would say, S and M.
Oh, is that the type of plane?
Well, with Rihanna, it's the name
of one of her songs. A really hit song as well.
Is it about Italian bombers?
No, I think it's about kinks.
Well, I know
it's about kinks. I've listened to the music.
Sticks and stones may break
my bones but getting off most of my bombing load excites me yeah well you got 14 through that one
i got like six or something i think you took out five planes in that one yeah that one i got
pretty lucky i think you hit them hard odds yeah yeah your odds were you needed a i think on
average it was like a 15 16 on the die yeah and you were you hit that pretty consistently i needed
a 12 or lower
so I had two potential die results
that could land me a kill
and I got none
didn't shoot down a single one of your planes
that's what I'm happy about
I'm unhappy about it but I guess we do have to
I have to live with that
you don't have to
you can choose to
quit
I'll throw that out occasionally
just in case
so you ended up taking out
five of my planes
and that bomb total started to dwindle
because every plane you take out
drops 12 bomb points from my repertoire
and I had 168.
So that does start to impact it.
120 is what I'm left with.
So you took out four?
You must have took out four planes.
Oh, it must have been four, yeah.
It's a 12 each.
Yeah, that is it.
Yeah, you took out 48 bomb points.
Dropped me to 120,
which takes me to the next
threshold. Yes, you ended up
going down two, just. Yep,
don't like that. Which
I did roll well on.
Yes. 64 is what I rolled on that
table. Which resulted in two
infantry. Two of them locked down.
Locked and loaded. A little pinned.
Took them away. Siphoned them off.
Put them in the corner. Fair enough.
They are pinned. They are
there, that's safe.
That was less than
what i hoped for because if all my bombs went off that would have been four up to four but with that
result it would have been four yes so 64 is four 64 zoo lane good cartoon don't know if you ever
saw that you should it's worth your time it's certainly worth my time i thought as much so with
that i was then left with the seventh to tackle that went better yes worse planes well you had
better planes for the most part oh yeah actually the blenheims were one better yeah you had much
better planes going on with that so i had a plus three instead of a plus two on the other one i
just didn't get lucky got one plane you took out one plane and the bombing load there was higher
at 16 planes there it didn't knock you down no i stayed quite firmly within that bracket of bombs
so when i did drop my bomb load i once again rolled two snake eyes yep that was the first
time in all of that air combat that i rolled a result of snake eyes of double ones any other
point in that air combat that would have meant i shot down one of your planes instead it meant i
got the worst result possible on that table yes so another two of the seventh infantry
uh yes i took out two of their infantry had them suppressed bombed they can't move
so they can move they can move up to half of their cpa so yeah they can't move but it's
massively reduced them yeah it means they can move five ten well no no five is there
it's now their amount that they can move no because they're motorized so they're 20
yeah but if i was you know let's hypothetically pretend i forgot that oh then it would be five
yeah so exactly so in this hypothetical world where i forgot that they are motorized they can
only move five yeah yeah cool just checking that you now you're on the same wavelength as me man
you know no i get it that was my bombing run that was my my total air mission complete and
successfully i would say i managed to pin a bunch of your guys that's what you want it's what i
need it's what i need keeping them trapped out there in their trucks dwindling forces i've
essentially eradicated a battalion right okay they're gone they're exterminated that's a that's
a bizarre way of looking well the way i see it is what are you going to do are you going to leave
them behind yes okay i've sent so many guys on suicide missions why did you think i'd not leave
300 guys to die in the desert
I don't know
because of the climax of the battle
because we're getting towards the end
yeah which means I can burn them off at a faster rate
right okay
yeah I guess that's true
you know what I've been doing that
so I don't know why I didn't think you would
I've got four groups
mostly divisions just stood
ready to be killed
in the next few upstages
is to take a while dying
okay that's
that's making more sense now okay fair enough well in that case i'll uh continue
with bated breath that maybe this was a good idea maybe maybe regardless i've hurt you but
you were very happy about that would you like to recap what you did andy uh sure
I dropped 270 something bombs on the fourth
Excessive by the way
It's way too many
It's more than you need to
For sure
Dropped 260 something on the second
Yep
Which are the guys I actually care about
Yep
Also strafed them
Yes you did
Killed a tow point of infantry
Took out a tow point on coincidentally the same
Battalion that you previously strafed
I wouldn't say coincidence
I would because I mixed them up, it's random selection
so if it's not coincidence
you're either psychic or cheating
or both
yeah that's a good point
if you're psychic you are cheating
yeah
I guess yeah
it's one or the other, it's binary
if you're playing this game
with me and you're psychic
I guess I have a couple of questions
why you're still playing this if you're psychic
it's not a particularly useful power
I'll come and ground that one day
because that's insane
that's genuinely backwards thinking
but alright fine
and you
yeah you
continued to bomb that wasn't enough for you
yeah well I bombed those
two and then I did two full strafes
on
your little supply dump I got 10%
of it
and then yeah the one I did on the
second where I killed a toe.
So yeah, two carp, two bombing, two strafing.
Nice little
even split. That's a squeaky chair
you got there. Sorry. That's going to make it a
nightmare to edit this episode. I'll stop shifting
around. Stay completely
static. Do not
move a muscle or you're going back
to the floor.
Yeah, I do like it better than the other chair.
Really? I'm all upright.
Is it because you can shift around
though? It is. Does not being
able to shift around and make it less of a good chair.
Partially. Yeah, cool.
Oil the thing up, WD40
that chair, and you'll be able to spin
to your heart's content.
Will do, buddy. But you're shifting
as we speak. I've found
the squeak tolerance.
And you think that gives you power over me?
No. That's a quote
from The Dark Knight Rises.
That's what Guy from Rogue
One says to Tom Hardy.
I draw in a huge blank on that.
It's a really normal, fine, like, 5 out of 10 scene.
Okay.
Yeah, that film fell off on my expectations.
So, moving away from that,
and other films that weirdly coincided in release date
with the several Obama administrations,
that is a thing.
The Dark Knight and The Dark Knight Rises
both came out when obama was elected into office oh okay yeah i don't know if that feels like it
doesn't mean anything no it's just coincidence but it's it's a fun coincidence it's like when i uh
when i go to get on the bus and my phone has no internet connection so i can't show that i have an
a ticket because the app needs internet connection and that weirdly drops when i'm trying to get on
the bus it seems like a con i'm not sure who's behind it but somebody probably is big tech and
big bus colluding once more it's definitely big bus i just don't know how much big tech are in
i don't know if it's a sponsored scam it's hard to tell these days you can't tell what big anything
is it's all big it's all too big but what i had after this was big movement i wouldn't use the
big i'd say everything's big but this movement was small and dare i say cowardly whoa well what
i chose to do for my movement i elected to move the 32nd gaff 32 gaff the tabrook garrison as
they were formerly known before i moved them out of tabrook now they're just garrison
gary s as i like to call him you shouldn't i moved them down one hex south that was my land
movement for this op stage yeah i don't know what that was about well the thing is andy you did
something by giving me my first turn yeah you said that you don't want to go first you want to play
off my movement that's true so i thought well let's not do that let's not give you movement
to play off. All I've done there
is slightly expand the area
that you'll have to traverse around
desert hexes,
plain hexes, clears,
in order to circumvent
my troops and get back onto
tracks to move to
what I presume is Tobruk.
You can assume whatever you want.
Well, you're either going to Tobruk
or you're going to
get stuck in a
kill box at Bardia.
Or I'm going to Benghazi.
You're not going to Benghazi?
I might.
If you try and get to Benghazi, I can get there so much faster along road that you can't utilise.
I can use the road. I just need to get on it.
Well, that's, I guess, yes, that is it.
That's how roads work.
Well, it's part and parcel, isn't it? Because to get to the road, you have to go past my men.
Yeah.
The closest point you can get to right now is to go due north, which takes you right next to Bardia.
if you move further west
going due north
takes you to Tobruk
which I can get to
if you go even further west
you cross onto map B
which I can also get to
at breakneck speed using the road
and then you also not only have to go north
to get to the road
you have to go further north
and you also have to cross weird hexes
where we go into weird stuff like
rough and gravel
and marsh
so
that doesn't seem like a smart
move. We'll see.
It could be a long game that you're playing
and then you're hoping I evacuate
a lot of my troops west to
try and stop you and then you make some sort
of play for Bardia or Tobruk
and all I've got are my weakened divisions.
Could be, yeah.
But the thing is, I would send
my weakened divisions there, onto
that road, people
that I'm willing to just let die.
Okay. And then they're just
a rock in the road okay and that's fine by james you can't do anything about it okay i'm all
powerful sure thing buddy i've got little hexes on a board or you've got no way to stop me from
moving those around apart from applying the rules of the game in a way favorable to you
through tactical and i guess just sound logic that's another one yeah so if you employ either
of those you have a way to stop me but barring that you have no way to stop me i think this will
be an interesting turn i think it will be a very mentally taxing turn for james that's good
it's bad for james yeah good for me yeah that's true yeah you'll yeah if you're andy and i'm james
that's that does track jesus you're right but i just i worry that this game might do something
bad to my mind i don't think so no probably not only if you let it which you clearly are
yeah it's it's it's starting to seep through a tad yeah but that's all right we live and we learn
and we have to learn because i've left you with this situation that you need to learn from you
need to decide what you're going to do going forward i have decided which is i'm not going
to tell you i'm just going to win the game well i'll put it this way you're going to show me next
week so you may as well just say it i'm not gonna show you next week then you're cheating again we're
going back to the psychic thing hell yeah i'm not sorry i'm not psychic do you know that what i'm
not psych i can't read minds yeah i know it's one of your major failings that actually makes me feel
really good about myself why because of one of my major failings is that i don't have a superpower
that's by category there's hundreds of thousands of major failures but are they all superhero based
like that i don't have like magic no some of them are you just you're like a bad guy
some of them yeah so there's multiple major failings where i'm a bad guy yeah there's a
whole category in the major failings for major he's a bad guy list two i don't want to dox you
on the podcast.
I don't want to go spill your beans.
It's crazy that you think you have beans
to spill. You know what
I've got. I don't.
You know exactly what I could say.
I've got inklings. Yeah.
Isn't my
anger towards, I guess,
most of life?
Doesn't help.
No, that is a catalyst.
It's a contributing minor.
What the fuck?
there's metrics all over the place
it looks a bit like a family tree
okay well
I'll take that with a pinch of salt
and with
that pinch of salt I'm going to add an extra bit of spice
here Andy
salt's not a spice
well it is
I'm a white British male
salt is spice for me
it doesn't have to be
but it is because my diet's very very niche
it's very it's not niche it's incredibly mainstream i don't think my diet's mainstream
it chicken nuggets and salt yeah yeah that's pretty i like what i like i'm sure you do i'm
not saying i'm not even trying to stop you liking what you like it's just pretty mainstream it feels
like you're trying to discourage it because if i hear i'm doing something mainstream i won't like
that if i have to trick you into being healthy i won't i always knew you were a good friend i
just didn't know how good yeah until now not very so to add that spice in we're playing the main
game for a meal yes the full game the stakes are whoever wins that that full version of the game
wins a meal we're doing the practice run now six turns and at the moment the current situation is
i hit a win condition which means i win the stakes for this game which is a kinder bueno
we have two turns left there are thereabouts but there is a chance that you can hit a win condition
yeah
so how about this
okay
how about a double jeopardy
okay
if you hit a win condition
after I've now hit my win condition
yeah
and you can hold that for an upstage
I'll get you two kinder buenos
okay
and I guess if I don't I get you two kinder buenos
yes
okay
sure
because I've recently had a hangering for kinder buenos
and I thought this is a way to get two free
Kinder Buenos.
It's a way to try and get them.
It's a way for you to end up paying for two Kinder Buenos
and getting none. Ten Kinder Buenos.
Feels like
it's a start to an actual
amount of money.
Yeah, okay, I'll dial that back.
We'll go with two. I just saw you say yes
and I thought I could probably get some money out of this
because if I get you to buy me Kinder Buenos
in bulk, I can sell those
on the secondary market.
second-hand kinder buenos you'll be surprised go for a lot of money
i am surprised well they go for about the same as a first-hand kinder bueno
because people don't know that they've passed hands
i guess they're all sealed still in the packaging they might have on the package
not for individual sale those are usually the ones that are marked up yes yeah
corner shops they're also the ones you buy yeah yeah well we we found a vending machine
on our latest trip yes our latest war with a mate company expedition well we have to go and get the
kinder winners which is also adding to the price because you have to take a train well i think the
train was it was a durham train station don't dox us we don't live in durham but now someone could
camp out that vending machine i i guess they could but what a weird thing to do so but yes it was on
platform so the the vending machine at durham train station has a kinder bueno in there has
our kinder buenos in it so if we find out there's been some sort of crime committed
that involves that vending machine and it's an entirely non-violent crime we'll know it was one
of you stealing our kinder bueno go full taken on your asses if it was a violent crime i'll
presume that's an unfortunate coincidence and we'll have to delete this episode after the fact
we will it's you know it's respectful it's nice it would ruin the whole numbering system
that's true well we did release an episode twice once i think that's fixed actually you
released an episode twice once yeah you distribute i edit and i'm the special guest every episode
yeah and i distribute and take all the money yeah i'm gonna talk to you about that no you don't
I should
you can talk to my lawyer that the show is paying for
that's part of what I need to talk to you about
talk to my lawyer
why we have separate legal counsel
why we have legal counsel at all
look you can't start an enterprise
with your friends unless you're willing to
screw them over when the time is right
are you Zuckerberg what the fuck is this
I'm a bit of a zuck
you're a bit of a fuck
well
I don't want to talk to you anymore
Shall we talk to some fans?
So we'll do the mailbag
Let's whip out the mailbag
Let's talk to some people who
Unless we've got another Bezos email
Sending us comic strips of cats
Then this should be a really nice experience
Okay
But only time will tell
Shall we see?
Let's look
So delving into that mailbag of ours
Yeah, let's see what we've got
We have today's first email
By Christine
Christine's email is titled
the lost documentary about an impossible house hi y'all love the y'all chrissy here
watch it chrissy sopranos reference great show normally well it's just your name normally i
wait for y'all another y'all love it to read my message before emailing back but i've fallen a
little bit behind and just watched a video essay that i felt james and the audience would enjoy
titled the lost documentary about an impossible house by sagan hawks on youtube it's a deep dive
into the textual analysis of house of leaves with some amazing visuals i highly recommend it to
anybody who's interest who's interested in the book even if you haven't read it yet though it
does help you've been watching that video haven't you i have loved that video i when this email came
through initially i saw the the subject and had a quick skim through and immediately looked at the
video i've been watching the video piecemeal for the last month or so when i've had a bit of spare
time and wow incredible if you've i would i would dare say chrissy to contradict you just a tad
i would say if you haven't read house of leaves and you don't feel like you can commit to reading
house of leaves this is the next best thing this is another medium to digest the book in pretty
much its entirety without having to do so so if you are interested in that don't want to read the
book watch that video it is incredible very well put together and captures all the essence of it
if you have read the book and you want to explore the book further it breaks it down really well
it explores some themes that the book only kind of a lot of the book it sort of touches on and
that you fill in the blanks the video holds your hand through parts of it and also even for me and
i've read the book like five or six times now it just explores it in more open ways so incredible
video incredible book read house of leaves but yes thank you chrissy because that is now up there as
one of my favorite video essay style youtube videos of all time it's it's top five very
comfortably and i watch a lot of those things the only one i put above that in terms of house of
leave so far is my house dot ward by power pack that was the one that like got you into it that
that's how i got it before you read the book yeah i watched that and then then our friend the same
one who got us into this game bought me the book so his sort of mission in life is to have me
invested in all your time in pieces of media or pop culture parentheses that will take all of my
time up but yeah incredible chrissy goes on some of the themes and ideas reminded me of a book i
read recently with so very interestingly world built with so very interesting world building
called void verse that takes place in a universe unlike our own where humanity survives on rocks
of various sizes falling through a seemingly endless void that sounds cool what i want to
check out i think i need to once i get through the other daniel loosky book tom's crossing which
i'm still tackling yep i would love to to read that as well i love a good odd universe yeah yeah
weird universe i like i like it when i'm i'm reading something that is inherently hard to
navigate lindy and pyrenees as well because that's the one that's sort of similar you've mentioned a
few that you've read that are like comparable not it's definitely not as like in depth or anything
but it's the same sort of weird structure adjacent to our own universe type thing yeah something
non-prosaic that you can really sink your teeth into i love that in regards to the recent common
ground with item loans a classic i like this one i suggest you look into library of things
an increasingly common service where libraries keep a stock of useful items ranging from lawn
cooking and home care equipment but also things like dvd players that's interesting and i think
this isn't the first email that's mentioned it yes this does seem to be one which we occasionally
have on common ground where we just accidentally invent something that exists and the fun thing
about it is with our listener base that is a dare i say niche category of person there's you know
it's not a massive listener base we're not uh you know we're not we're not getting in millions every
week but it's fun that there is a crossover that we don't have any idea about something but more
than one person will get in touch and go you've missed this thing that a few of us know about
yeah so the the hit ratio is is very funny i'm excited to see the end of the bracket mostly
friendly practice run i'd say that's getting less and less yeah i i think i swore you a few times
today when you hit me with those bombs just a few friendly swear words at you yeah and to see the
serious hard hitting tactics yeah uh you bring to the main game or your best approximation there we
go i think best approximation more so than and it's funny how best approximation zero and one
can be so far away from each other when you look at them i often feel like a citizen of the early
19th century waiting for news from the front to finally reach the other side of the world
that's that's a nice way to put it and the main game i don't think is going to make it any easier
you'll have the in-depth analysis week by week but i don't know that it's going to make anything
easier or more beneficial you won't feel more clarity chrissy i promise a small suggestion
but it may be worth keeping track of which history segments are in which episodes on the website
as time goes by and the segments become more interconnected it'll be useful to have a way
to go back and listen to your old segments subtly humbly bravely yours chrissy yeah um again i think
multiple people have mentioned it and it's something i do need to get around to um should
hopefully have more free time coming up project at work finishing so hopefully i can start working
on that soonish yeah your job at nasa yeah when that whole thing wraps up when we get a guy at
moon again yeah is that what is the current goal it's the public goal oh i see but there's
something else going on are you the one kidnapping and disappearing the scientists
because i i hear that that's in the the zeitgeist at the moment
getting rid of scientists let's just say the city on the dark side of the moon is bouncing at the
i want to go there can we do an ep there if you get good at science if you get worth kidnapping
Ah, okay. I've got a ways to go then.
Yeah.
I'm barely good at the game.
Dare I say I'm bad at the game?
I'll allow it.
Sustained.
The next email comes in from Matthew.
Matthew is a very dependable source of info
because Matthew is another foe who's playing the game itself.
Yes.
I believe a solo run.
Yes, but he's been keeping us on the straight and narrow
since basically the start.
Yes, which has been a godsend.
Matthew's really thrown in some great advice and corrections in our fledgling days and this one is
titled archaeology yeah uh hi Andy and James when I emailed you guys it's usually about rules
it still will be today but also on a common ground you did sometime last year
I'm sorry to break it to you James but I don't think you won the scenario as the win conditions
only count at the end of six turns
so someone only wins
after the six turns and the win conditions
are met. So Andy, I think
he'll probably win.
Well, first of all, Matthew, you don't know
anything about Andy. Andy's
a buffoon of sorts.
An incompetent,
mischievous,
devilish fiend.
Which really, what does that
say about you? As I started to say
that as well, I was realising... The more I
insult him on yeah well it was more the case of i've described characteristics of usually a cunning
foe so that's that's bad news for me what i'll say to that matthew is um yes uh in in that i
think andy will win and also the fact that we we couldn't find any definitions at the time
as to whether or not you need to hold it until the end of the scenario so we kind of went fast
and loose with it as we have to in these situations and we came to accept it's unlikely that another
win condition will be met within the scenario so we're going off that however as we've discussed
earlier today if andy is to break free from the reins of my current victory then we will double
down and he gets double points or if i manage to hold it i'll get double points so yes you are
right as we've come to learn because you're not the only person who sent this other people have
also mentioned that this is a loose interpretation of the wind conditions yes but i think i mean at
least acknowledging that one was met yes we found that don't hit one i guess you did have one i
think it's fair to say that's the like tiebreaker yeah it gave us a nice climax for partway through
and at the time it was also our empirical understanding of the rule yeah but now that
we've had the clarity it means we know for i will never do this again in the practice scenario but
we know at least going forward what it means and i i do think andy has a good chance at
trying to win this still if we're going off that same principle of holding holding it for an
upstage yeah so we'll we'll see how it pans out but thank you as always matthew for for filling
us in on the blanks because you and others have pointed out this mishap yeah uh then uh for the
other thing remember when you guys did a common ground on building fake things for archaeologists
well there was a rough uh round recently built in the city where i live where the guy moving the
boulders as the ground is very rocky using a digger stack the rocks in almost physics defying
ways every time i drive past them i like to wonder what people will think when they see them in the
future it'll look uh like so it'll look like stonehenge thing with stacks of rocks in two
straight lines going on for like two kilometers and on the roundabouts in zimbabwe uh
they work better than traffic lights uh as we usually only have electricity during elections
or if you live near a minister and when they do work everyone ignores them finally i'm a bit of
a nerd when it comes to military equipment so if you want i can write a little summary on all the
military equipment used uh in the north africa campaign and compare their capabilities thanks
for continuing your very enjoyable podcast a subtle subtle humble and brave matthew well first
of all matthew um thank you for sticking with us for so long you've been a mainstay from very early
on the i'm gonna look at some pictures of this two kilometer line of stones after this as well
that sounds very cool well that's a there's a there's a few cool little snippets in here that
matthew's just kind of like thrown in there as like little side pieces yeah which i've really
latched onto there which is that only having electricity on during elections that's very
interesting yeah that's a or if you live near a minister yeah like that's that's a weird thing
where it's yeah if you're in like localized areas you have electricity but the fact that you can
just have it toggled so they've got the infrastructure they i presume just don't
have the the fuel to keep everything going constantly but it's like elections coming up
it's sort of like a like when you have like you know like decorations on and like the the city
center where we live like at christmas or something or and things go we've got some
elections coming up in this country for like local elections and everyone's got the like vote
whatever party on the door on the like window posters and yeah like but instead of like seeing
posters around you're like oh the lights are on there must be an election coming up that's an
interesting idea as well that traffic lights are only functional during an election yeah i feel
like you should put your traffic lights on like a separate grid you're gonna not have your grid on
all the time but i i don't know yeah it's an interesting thing to focus on during election
time it's road safety well it's just everything that electricity like enables yeah like so much
yeah it's a it's a wild thing that also interests me that matthew's listening in to the podcast
in possibly an area that doesn't have reliable electricity oh yeah yeah yeah and that also
matthew it explains a lot if you don't have access to electricity a lot it explains why
you're playing this game there is a good one for a solo run campaign for north africa in a blackout
essentially is making a lot more sense yeah i feel like i've got a little insight into matthew's life
now do you think the house prices are in like spikes around a minister because they get they
have to be that's they also i assume they live in nicer areas but also like you want to find
where the minister lives so you can be in his electricity aura you want to you want to drain
from the minister yeah that is that is an interesting little side of things when it
comes to equipment and its comparable capability i mean matthew will not commission anything that
feels like it's a gargantuan task yeah but if you do end up happening to do that we'll happily look
at that we yeah we love seeing stuff like that where people have done all sorts of deep dives
between the game itself what we're doing what they found so if if you happen to you will love it
but do not go out of your way to do this unless you're already bored and doing it yeah and i will
say uh some people have done similar like arrow for instance um who's probably wondering when i'm
gonna get to what they sent me uh very sorry about that uh things keep coming up the structure's
pretty loose in terms of what
I find interesting. But the
stuff you certainly will be used
before the end of the scenario, I do
promise that. We hyper-fix it
and usually it's on the game, thankfully.
But sometimes I
find out about the Ottomans and that's
three weeks that I wasn't planning
on doing. Yeah, it's part
of the restructure after the scenario
wraps up where we're
reshuffling,
rebranding. We're
going to change it all up
so
not too much though
no no
we'll keep the core of it
we'll keep the core of it
it's not going to become
a completely different show
yeah
I mean in a sense it will
because it'll be organised
and that is completely different
it should become a better show
yes
but thank you
for the emails
Matthew and Chrissy
anyone who wants to send anything in
the email address is
info at warwithamate.co.uk
the website is
warwithamate.co.uk
and the Instagram is
just warwithamate
we'll take messages
from any of those
and we'll read everything out at some point we've got 50 years to do the damn thing
and we also have fun reminder our first live show which is at the uk games expo in birmingham
30th of may half four if you've got tickets to the games expo it's free please come
we we've had emails coming we've had a few people yeah people have mentioned that they are coming
if anyone else is coming along get in touch with us let us know we're going to see what we can
about having a bit of a brucey bonus for those that are coming along who are already aware of
the show so if you let us know in advance we can have said brucey bonus ready for you and also
we'll look at doing a bit of a you know meet and greet conversation bit afterwards if you want to
have a chin wag with us let us know because we are just going to be at the expo it looks like
like the friday saturday we'll be there friday saturday so if you if you're around for the
weekend let us know and we'd love to have a chat with some of you guys um learn a bit more about
the board games going on we're kind of fixed in the one thing that is something i'm excited about
is like there's this whole world of board games that way on the fringe i know monopoly and dnd
and then the campaign for north africa and nothing in between like the mainstream and the
The total outlier.
So, yeah, we'd love to just chat with a few of you guys
and find out what's going on.
So let us know, or maybe we'll see you there.
That is it for the listener mail.
Yes.
The mail bag is done for today,
but it's stocked up quite nicely at the moment.
We'll get around to everything,
but you guys are firing in some great stuff,
so thank you for that.
So if we're moving away from the here and now,
We have to go to the there and then.
Yes.
That's the past.
We're going back.
And that's your domain, Andy.
So take us away.
The men of the long-range desert patrols
were quite a sight on their return to Cairo
from a most trip to Libya.
The contrast between the east and west of the Nile
is very marked.
In the east, the country...
At this point, I gave little thought to my past
but had always been interested in boats in the sea.
I am more or less in a position
of a campus surprise where I had a telegram
which is on the point of sinking
because errors are present
we are absolutely not qualified to share views on history
when and where are you taking us to
I'm taking you
back to Libya
that's where I just was
a bit of Italy
that's further away
so the Italian government
therefore finding itself forced to safeguard
its dignity and its interests has decided to proceed to the military occupation of tripoli
and serenica this solution is the only one which italy can accept that's from giovanni giolotti
italian prime minister at the time second longest running prime minister italy ever had okay so this
guy is uh he's really had a seat for a long time yeah it's something like 1890 to 19 like late 90s
to mid 20s it's like 25 years wow good span then yeah but the only other guy who's had more is
mussolini oh yeah wasn't yeah that's not put him in there as an actual elected official yeah so
we've had a brief run through victor emmanuel the third and also the altmans which brings us to the
italo-turkish war italian politicians had been talking up and proposing the war since 1908
as a likely option this kicked into a higher gear in march of 1911 the papers talked of a land rich
with minerals and water likely defended by 4 000 ottoman troops claiming it would be a quote
military walk just like yeah they also spoke of having to protect the small italian population
emigrated there from the locals this is about a thousand italians living in a land with 1.5 to 2.5
million inhabitants that's the ratio on that's an interesting one yeah they also believed for some
reason that the local population was desperate to rise up against the ottomans and would warmly
welcome them and fight with them cool so they're deluded yeah they had a proper
ganda initiative spinning libya as a paradise that rightfully belonged to the italians well
yeah they had a lot of propaganda and this is one of the weirder ones yeah it's also pushing that
roman argument that mussolini will rely on more later where it's like they're they kind of go
we're claiming the heritage of the romans and the romans owned all this but also libya was the only
country in the region owned by the romans at this time that wasn't owned by a western power or the
it's the only easy target yeah they're not going for the the risky ones yeah they're not conquering
britain and gaul and stuff there is also strong opposition inside italy as well though
in particularly from socialists such as the rising fire brand benito mussolini oh there he is who
said the following quotes about this war i just find this fascinating from where he says here
to what he will become in like less than 20 years oh don't tell me he's a hypocrite
he might be a hypocrite uh for us the national flag is a rag to be planted on a dunghill there
are only two fatherlands in the world that of the exploited and that of the exploiters
militarism here is the monstrous leech that is incessantly sucking the blood of the people
the army is now a highly organized school of crime and exists only to protect bourgeois capital and
profits and let a single cry rise from the multitudes of the proletariat and let it be
repeated in squares and streets of italy down with war which i just think are very interesting
things for him to be like writing and saying incredibly andy wall sentiments for a guy who
will launch a war this war actually um has a lot of i personally thought it had a lot of similarities
to ethiopia in some ways which is the italians are fighting an ambitious colonial war
that will be one of the building blocks leading up to this leads up to world war one ethiopia led
up to world war two so and they're at like similar points and they're like this is 1911
and then the ethiopia was like also just before he's like a really shit silver surfer where he's
a herald of great destruction yeah but it's it it's italy in a way it's like if italy ever get
any colonial ambitions the world war is coming okay i'll keep an eye on the news for that
yeah Mussolini also organized a general strike and protest to stop uh trains leaving for really
uh where he lived uh for uh the war with supplies so he's like actively organizing against it
and for this he's charged with sedition and inciting rebellion and sentenced to a year in
prison uh which really boss bolsters his reputation with italian socialists and when he gets out he's
given the appointed as editor for the officialist so official socialist newspaper avanti which also
makes him a national celebrity yeah his like celebrity i think a lot of the celebrity statuses
amongst the war have really confused my perception of what the war looked like across the globe yeah
i think it's mussolini is maybe a proto-influencer like yeah well it's sort of you know it's in a way
kind of trump vibes where you've got this figure who is a celebrity who goes into politics celebrity
politician is something that seemed so new when it started to happen over the last 15 or so years
but it's not new no it's not it's just trans it's finally translated to the social media age
yeah but it was definitely a thing oh yeah i think it was sort of a bell curve
probably you had that well i guess reverse bell curve where you had these celebrity politicians
you've got these figures in history and then you had this sort of boring period
but then you have even in the uk you've got figures like you know thatcher
where you've got these yeah huge landmark figures and politicians and and and culture
yeah and now it's swung around to the the extreme again where it's like this person is
not only a powerful figure but it's all anyone talks about yeah just an interesting thing with
mussolini we'll get to him he's gonna have his own series but it's gonna be a probably a long
in-depth one because he is a he is an interesting character from history i'm interested for the
lusolini series yeah but despite the socialists protesting uh the war would go on the italians
sent a message to the ottomans demanding an answer in 24 hours and the letter was basically
you have 24 hours to cede libya to us and the ottomans replied they received the letter on
the 28th of september and replied like basically immediately saying they're open to negotiating
but are not immediately accepting the terms italy declares war in response of course despite
initiating the war the italian army is characteristically unready having only been
told about the invasion in late september it starts in september so they have like 10 days
notice at most the maps they have are going some of them are relying on roman sources
like from like caesar and like when they owned that region and so they're like two thousand year
old using a two thousand year old map and like accounts from roman generals about the terrain
and stuff i know i know time has changed more rapidly in the last hundred or so years yeah but
the idea of using the campaign for north africa map to plan a trip in egypt in the year four
in the year 4000 well i'm talking about now yeah now it would be insane yeah in the year 4000 and
again i know things will evolve more rapidly now yeah but no no it's stupid it's so dumb
they also receive orders to integrate planes into the army on the 28th of september okay so
so they got a day to figure that leaving that real last minute and this is we'll get to it but
This is an insanely short turnaround for something that is very new.
But they arrive off the coast on the 3rd of October
and start bombarding Tripoli with their ships for two days
before moving in on the 5th,
where 1,500 soldiers disembark and take Tripoli.
The Ottomans don't have an answer for these naval guns,
so they've just retreated in good order inland
to fight the war from better terrain.
But the Italians take this as, like, there's no resistance here.
this is a great victory for us
the rest of this is going to be easy
and so their army starts
disembarking on the 10th of October
with no
training for amphibious landing
so it's just a fucking mess
and it's also one of the first
and they're just like
figuring it out on the fly with no training
they believed a force of 20,000
would be able to take over Libya
as they believed the locals would be on their side
and there were only 4,000 Ottomans
instead the 8 000 ottoman regulars allied with 20 000 local troops mainly from the sensu order
who were familiar with the desert and had been fighting tribal uh wars for basically their whole
lives so it's not 4 000 guys it's 28 000 guys who know the terrain and are hardened soldiers
which historically does not go down well no go to an environment where the native people
know the environment a lot better you send in people naively yeah to the terrain they are
butchered yeah especially when it's a desert there's an extra element here yeah the environment
alone can kill you yeah so despite this the italian forces managed to capture triply tabruk
dirna benghazi and homs between the 3rd and 21st of october 1911 but they're confined very closely
to the coast and like a narrow strip like they would basically be on the road and no further
south to give a sense of they have not conquered libya no no they haven't no but we'll get to the
rest of that campaign uh but we're going to step away for a minute because this is an interesting
war because it uh includes a lot of thirsts uh in particular thirsts in relation to flight
something to keep in mind here i think is um the first flight of the wright brothers
was made only eight years before this and it lasted 12 seconds and it only went 120 meters
and that was eight years before that that's december 1903 wow that is
yeah i'm trying to think of other industries where you go eight years down the line and then
stop relying on it for like warfare yeah i mean look at ai if you were to take ai moves at a
different pace but if you took that from its sort of inception as what ai is currently known as
yeah from whatever that start point was to 80 years later implementing that into something so
vital as warfare yeah that's so risky the straight the rate of change as well it's crazy
yeah like that's why it's so mad they gave them a day to integrate their air force because on the
23rd of october 1911 ricardo moise took the first ever strategic reconnaissance flight that's such
a new concept to introduce yeah and it was actually quite successful he flew along the coast
and found and followed a group of 2 000 ottomans who i imagine were like what the fuck just looking
up in the sky like what is going on i guess you do have the element of surprise yeah i guess you
might they might be like i've heard of these planes is that like they're not common it's such
a new thing to introduce and to to then see it in action yeah yeah he also managed to discover that
the town of azizia was 60 kilometers from tripoli their maps claimed it was eight just to give you
a sense of how bad their geographical information oh my god no that's 52 kilometers through desert
that they wouldn't have accounted for if they were trying to go to that town like that's dangerous
yeah that's insane yeah ricardo also has another i guess more dubious first as on a later flight
he had mechanical failures and went down behind enemy lines becoming the first airman ever to
become a pow oh wow yeah so yeah this this guy is a very unique he's got two firsts in the history
of war which is pretty yeah this guy's ticking off all the boxes he can his bingo cards looking
pretty full at this point and there's another first year um after the first reconnaissance
flight uh by about a week that will change the nature of war forever uh so let's read some of
Lieutenant Giulio Gaviotti's mail.
This is a letter he wrote to his father,
some snippets from it.
Feels bad reading his mail.
Yeah, I think it's fine.
He's probably been dead for a while.
Oh, I see, that's the rule.
Today I have decided to try to throw bombs from the aeroplane.
It is the first time that we will try this,
and if I succeed, I will be really pleased
to be the first person to do it.
there's something so so quaint about that yeah he's so proud about his little experiment
little does he know what would come of this yeah uh today two full boxes of bombs arrived
we were expected to throw them from our planes it is very strange that none of us have been told
about this.
So they were given no warning?
And that we haven't received
any instructions from our superiors.
We're taking the bombs on board
with great precaution.
It will be interesting to try them on the Turks.
This guy's been thrown
completely in the deep end.
Yeah.
As soon as the weather is clear, I head to the camp
to take my plane out.
Near the seat, I have fixed a little leather case
with padding inside i have laid the bombs in it very carefully they're small round bombs weighing
about a kilo and a half each i put three in the case and i put the other one in the front pocket
of my jacket he's giving such detail yeah there's a little excursion oh i i thought this is a great
layer after a while i noticed dark shape or the dark shape of the oasis with one hand i hold the
steering wheel with the other i take out one of the bombs and put it in my lap i'm ready the oasis
is about a kilometer away i can see the arab tents very well i take the bomb with my right hand
pull out the security tag which he did with his mouth uh it doesn't mention in the letter but yeah
and throw the bomb out avoiding the wing so he's leaning out of his plane with a bomb in his hand
He's doing a drive-by.
Driving with one hand and trying to miss the wing
as he, like, skips a bomb.
In the 80s and 90s, he's holding a Mac-11 in one hand.
I can see it falling through the sky for a couple of seconds
and then it disappears, and after a while,
I can see a small dark cloud in the middle of the encampment.
I have hit the target!
As if he's bloody hit as well.
I then send two other bombs with less success.
i still have one left which i decide to launch later on an oasis close to tripoli i come back
really pleased with the result i go to a straight to report to the general everyone is satisfied
and that is the first aerial bombing from a heavier than air aircraft in history wow and
it's so well documented yeah we do a bit of charm like a bit of like almost innocence that is a
weird thing it it does like track as if it is like it's like you know people who have labrador
energy yes it is and then i did this and then and then this is what i did and we were happy
i hoped it would be good and i did it oh the guy did it he pulled it off yeah and what a what a
door he opened oh yeah well after this and further missions the ottoman empire issues a protest
the droppings of bomb from balloons had been outlawed by the hay convention of 1899
but it really argued that the ban didn't extend to heavier than air aircraft which i also think
is an interesting like if that had gone another way and people have gotten bored with it like how
much damage bombing has done yeah in the century since if like if that had gone into the geneva
convention how different would war look well i mean if you think about the the long-lasting
effect of that if it was the case that aerial bombardment had been outlawed then you'd be
looking at no yeah no airstrikes no no napalm no drones agent orange no no nukes yeah yeah yeah
that's that's an insane change to warfare and i think just the world landscape as we know it
i think if it was stuck with you know boots on the ground man to man yeah artillery it would be
yeah completely different world but this this guy has opened up the door to something completely
different yeah it is a sort of remarkable like he's the first guy through this door but this is
like probably comfortably over a million people have died since then from aerial and what year
was this oh three 1911 this was 11 yeah 1911 yeah and it's the plane was invented in 1903 yes yes
that's what i'm thinking of yeah so 1911 and then you've got a a short you know skipping a jump
of 30-odd years
and then a nuclear weapon
is dropped from a plane.
Yeah, I think it's 42 years.
42?
It was dropped in 45?
That would take me to 50, yeah.
Yeah, so 11, so 34.
Oh, sorry, you're saying from 11.
Yeah.
Oh, sorry, I was going from 03, but yeah.
From the first bomb being dropped from a plane.
To a nuke being dropped.
34 years from a little handheld bomb
being dropped from a plane
while he's driving with the other hand
to a device that
flattens most of a city
yeah
that is a
that's a scary jump when you bear in mind how much
time has passed from that nuke
being dropped to now
we're nearing
100 years realistically
yeah so
one more first for this war
no sorry one more first for him
because as well as doing the first bombing
mission ever he also
performs the first ever night mission with a heavier than air aircraft so he's got the first
bombing right on the first night mission that night mission must have been nightmare fuel
yeah because again it's like you're the first like there's no like well at least i know a
couple of people like it's dangerous but people have come back from this yeah you don't know how
viable this is yeah this could be a completely undoable thing yeah it could be the case that
flying a plane at night doesn't work you can't navigate you will fly into the med or the great
desert like because also flying in libya you've got not a lot of you've got mediterranean about
10 kilometers of like civilization near the road and then the desert and there's like people living
there but the chances of like you fall into like the great sand sea and you hope someone comes
across you and in 1911 i don't know what the light pollution was like to be able to determine where a
civilization is and
landing the plane
and you
can't exactly whip out your star
charts like you're on a boat
going three miles an hour
you're bombing it through the sky
and if you're
trying to navigate you just have to do it
on vibes and you're like oh
is that an air
is that an airstrip they've lit up to either side
so I know where to come in or like
a residential street with streetlights
Are we in Zimbabwe and there's an election on?
Like, it's hard to say.
Yeah, and also in this war,
the Italians will have the honour
of having the first ever aircraft shot down.
Oh, brilliant.
Yes.
Also, that's interesting.
What the fuck are they shooting them down with?
Rifles.
I think in particular, Mausers.
Oh.
Flimsy plane, then.
Yeah.
Well, yeah.
They're made of wood and cloth.
because this is all biplanes well yeah yeah these aren't like you know spitfires um so yeah we'll do
more of the tallow turkish war next time but i thought let's do some of the firsts wow in terms
of firsts that is some groundbreaking stuff yeah it's also that's not how i thought that would have
went but also what did i think it would have went like i do know what you mean where it's like
you kind of picture it as like
oh it's going to be this huge
thing but it's like
they don't actually even know if that
bommie fruit caused any casualties
or just like hit a
guy's tent but he was like not at the
tent. The confusion on their part
because you're not going to have like loud
turbines from that plane
No, they fly
fairly low like 600 metres
you might get a bit but also
like five years later
not five years later
20 odd years later when they're fighting the war
here like we've watched
like SAS Rogue Heroes they're like
they know the from of an engine
yeah they hear it
and they immediately like go
because they've been conditioned
but at that point
it's such a new concept
and it's the first bomb ever to be
dropped from a plane yeah you might know what a plane
is you might be like oh there's a plane but
you're not expecting anything to come out of it
yeah it's like oh they're flying around maybe they're gonna land here yeah and then an explosion
blows up beside you yeah and it's like well the plane went over us that has to be the plane surely
yeah well it's just the weirdest coincidence ever and it's like well how did they do that
little do they know it's a guy one hand on the wheel yeah on the other one he's like
stumbling about he's got it in his lap pulls it out throws it over the side
trying not to hit the wing as he said
yeah but it's also just like
the they didn't tell us
about this we didn't train with it
they just sent bombs
to our airfield and I guess we're hoping
maybe one of them will try
do you want to throw one out the plane
I guess
mid air
there's also the thing of he has three and they fit in the pouch
just take three
why put the one in your shirt
you got the extra one
yeah what do you want to make sure you want to have the extra one there yeah but by the sounds
of it it was wasteful because the other ones didn't land on the target but the first one did
yeah he's a he's a pioneer of warfare yeah he is you know that scene in oppenheimer at the end
where he talks about having set off this chain reaction to destroy the world
the prequel will be this guy well it's not the same because like it would have just happened
if this someone would have done it first but no no well this guy like legacy of this guy is more
deaths than the legacy of yeah if you go back to the but i guess if that's the case you go back to
the wright brothers yeah those those dastardly they land the plane after those first 12 or so
seconds and they just have that same moment of i think we've started a chain reaction that will
destroy the world but it cuts to nuclear warheads yeah it cuts to easy jet making a cheap book
drones it's all downhill from that you get you get auditors on like industrial sites in the uk
audit youtubers oh yeah but they're flying their drones over areas and having arguments
for security i think you'll find i'm allowed to fly my drone
i think we've caused a chain reaction that will destroy social media and give wasteful people
something to do with their time what a journey he went on what a journey we went on yeah
that's a trip to the past that i won't forget that first bombing run i feel like i was there
such a descriptive nature within those little parables that he put together yeah that was also
i don't think i mentioned it that is a letter to his dad yeah yeah you said at the start that's
it's a fun thing from that's a fun bit of mail to receive
hello dad what the fuck what's he doing what's a plane how do i conceptualize any of this
you've killed someone from a distance that's never been done before
i think in terms of like range is that the furthest kill that would have happened no it
was only like 600 meters they didn't have that much altitude so like naval guns were like a
couple of k at that point that's a good point yeah you've got artillery yeah i think it takes
a while before planes outdo artillery yeah but even then yeah yeah you're looking yeah
at least he's not got that yeah at least he can sleep easy
fucking 50 or so years ago when he died yeah i don't know i you didn't have anything else
notable other than, well,
the first, I didn't have
anything else notable other than two
firsts in the history of war.
Well, Andy, we're going to have a first.
Yeah? Finish in the game.
Yeah, we'll get into that.
I wonder what our weird second one
will be. No, we'll just do
one. We'll do one first.
But both those guys did two.
Well, if we're ever going
to get to this first first,
we need to actually
stick it out the whole hog yes and to stick it out the whole hog we're going to have to both be in
the room together for the rest of this play time and not dying is problem one because it's a long
time and we're not really healthy people no and problem two is how do we not kill each other
before that that's the more immediate problem well it's the problem i'm going to do things about
and to do something about that we have a solution we do as patchwork as it may be
And that is Common Ground.
And now for something nicer.
A little oasis in the war.
It's time for some Common Ground.
I'm trying the intro for Common Ground.
I'm recording it.
Maybe.
Yeah.
So, Andy, let me hear
what your idea is for us to come together this week
what will we agree on they need to stop having software just help you based on like assumptions
you know where it's like we think you mean this so we'll just do it and it's like i actually didn't
so you're not a fan of clippy i actually this is gonna sound weird clippy is actually a better
implementation because it asks you questions and that's what you want to do it was like a
too early on like an ai helper i'm talking about like like you know if you're in like say excel
and like you try to drag columns down and it'll just randomly guess i wrote this before today
yeah that's yeah you say that i gave you a look there because there was a moment earlier about it
earlier today yeah we had a moment earlier where you were trying to shift some of your was it your
aircraft yeah and it auto filled only part of what you were trying to auto fill it filled in the part
you weren't trying to do i dragged like the row i just wanted it to copy the row but it iterate
because it was the mark one of a plane it did made it like mark two three four five but then
also didn't iterate the numbers in the column i was like what was going on here like and that's a
i guess that's a slightly because excel the thing is with excel it's sort of a case of what you put
into it you'll get where it's designed it's formulated it's designed to act on input but
you sometimes have to like be like no i don't want you to like oh we think this column is like
a currency and it's like no it's not it's just like decimal numbers or something i i agree on
that um i'm gonna ask some probing mainly on excel but it's other times as well where it's like
oh we're just gonna like do something because we think it'll help you and it just doesn't
i'll i'll probe a bit then so how do you feel and this is sort of taking it very much back
to basics how do you feel about copy and paste good so when it comes to copy and paste you know
you've got the the typical copy and paste yeah why you just you hit the shortcut whack out your
old control v or you right click and go for paste without formatting yes are you fine with it pasting
with formatting as the the general rule yes my issue is i think i'm like explaining this badly
my issue is there's like it feels like this software where it'll go like we're gonna try
and figure out whether you want it formatted or not formatted
and do it for you immediately.
I don't want to do something and then have it have different results
based on what the software thinks I want.
So if it's copy and paste and it just copies formatted every time,
then you can do the unformatted.
That's good.
Yeah.
I don't want it to try and guess.
Okay.
i want to always have i want it to be like deterministic i don't want i don't want that
to be like a probability net on like basic commands and shit because they also don't
get it right often enough and if it's not going to be right 100 i just rather it wasn't there
this sounds a bit like you hate sales people um i mean
a bit but not i don't know where you've got that from this i hate sales people okay so you know
when you've got like a you know you you've got a day in the week just a normal day and someone
tries to sell you something and this can be you're in a shop you're i've never had a cold call i've
never had a cold call of someone trying to sell me something like you know cold calling i don't
think i'm important enough to have a cold call sales code i've had emails like the scam ones
but yeah if anything i'd feel quite honored to have a cold call yeah a bit of a tangent but i'd
love that if someone called me up and they said i know they just gave my full name um i'll give my
address next uh you know if someone calls up hello james of war with a mate i'd love to i'd love to
you know chat to you about this thing yeah i'd feel quite honored okay but i imagine there's
also a point where that is uh a frustration yeah it's too much because it's you know it's going to
be for the most part drivel yeah they're selling you something it's probably not going to benefit
you i think it falls into that same almost instinct at this point it's not quite evolved
but it is very clearly learned it's in the zeitgeist it's in the the osmosis of the world
we live in now where you just pick up on you know something's off yes and i think that's where it
started if we're going back to the origin of this as a problem that's where it began it's like a
sales thing it began with that i it began with that and now it's become because what you've got
now is you've got technology that is doing this but it's it's the next layer of it because they've
sold the technology but the technology is doing that for them i agree it's a sales problem but
i think it's a different from what you're saying it it's in at least my take on what it is like
why sales causes what i'm talking about potentially okay is they need something new to sell
which means they need to add new features to stuff constantly i think that's whereas it's
almost like i feel like a lot of this stuff like excel word google drops like you know those like
sort of mainstay kind of applications yes they're just fine but they need to similar to like a fifa
almost they need to be like we have new features so they bloat it with like bullshit basically that
you don't want where the like core lean thing would have just done night what you wanted for
99 of people yeah they like ruin it to accommodate like very niche things which is i think what
they've done they sell the product with the expectation or the promise that this will
fulfill your customers buy this from us and you will fulfill your customers and it's also like
and then the end product new features yeah and it's like the fact that new features is more
important than what the features are yeah the end product is oh this feature will help people
and then it gets to the consumer yourself in this case and it's a case of well no it's not helping
me this is a problem but you can't feed that back to the salesperson no you can feed it back to the
company and at that point they've bought it so they will peddle it oh i see what you mean and
they will tell you no this is a feature this will work because if it doesn't work then we've bought
something that's a bum product yeah so not sales and like it's like purchasing yes it started as
that and i think it's it's devolved and now you're getting the second hand result of that yeah they've
sold it but now they can distribute that on a different level because of the way technology
works the technology can be sold they don't have to do the cold call to you you don't have to be
the guy taking the call to buy the bullshit yeah the company did that for them and now you have to
suffer it because of automation so with that automation comes well this is a cool feature
and it's it's not because how much of this is developed in-house on mass i imagine not a lot
of it i imagine a lot of the stuff you run into has been developed mostly elsewhere oh it's all
like the things i have issues with are like the third like not third party but like
yeah like software you've got no control over but like you have to use and it makes you wonder at
what point they've decided to implement this yeah what who called for this who demanded it yeah i
guess it's it's not necessarily just the i don't want the software to try and help me i don't want
you to do anything that's not i never want to put a command in and not be sure of the result
what like what examples do you have that really stand out because with with my common ground i
find that there's usually a single personal anecdote that really fucks me off is there
anything that stands out for you with this or is this is something that you've you've struggled
with for a longer period
I think it's a general annoyance
but it's all
like AI is a good example of it and the fact
of like you can ask AI the same question
like an AI chatbot the same question
twice in a row and you will get different
and you will get different answers and like
I
I don't
I don't like
that there's
seemingly as we've made
things more advanced we've added more
chance
yes that's weird like yeah do you know do you kind of get what i mean now like i phrased it
through the like helping thing because it tends to be how it's framed but it's like
if i drag this column down it's going to do two different things two different times
depending on the data in it or like which cells i like i don't mind if it's if it's the same issue
that i can kind of navigate around and it becomes a workaround yeah that's fine because you just
build it into your well that's why i went with the copy and paste situation where if you're if
you're aware of it and you know this is the way you can do it or you've got the alternative you
can you can control v or you can paste without formatting yeah and that's okay but if it's if
it's a chance if it's this sounds like maybe an ai thing then but it feels like something that
has come in and not like wanting to help it's coming in with ai and it also feels like something
that's going to get bigger and bigger oh it will where we've talked like i've seen people talking
about like oh um you can have like probabilistic rendering on games using ai but then the problem
is oh so the game's going to render that same scene differently every time someone like goes
to it yeah that's actually a really bad thing sometimes you don't need the advanced shit in
there because with that you've got there's two sides to it and i see both but one of them is
executed too badly for it to work yeah where the idea of variability a unique experience each time
is cool on paper the idea of going through an experience and it being different each time
like uh like replayability in a video game if you're taking that as an example and i'm going
through if if we did campaign for north africa and each time it would you know let's say we can
play it more than once yeah each time we go through and it generates different terrain
a new unit appear that is an interesting replay feature if it can still be if it doesn't right
somehow historically accurate i picked the wrong game for this yeah but in the majority of times
if it's like you say a cut scene if you're playing a game uh you know or just a story driven thing
where it's like oh like there's been some like artistry on the like building even if it's just
like a narrow fairly short single player game yeah but like people have put effort into that
well that's it that's that's the other side of it where you've got a unique replayability is cool
but the other side of it is there was something designed here yeah what are you stripping away
from that if it is just kind of multiplayer slosh and you're playing something that you're
going to play every day and it's just the same environment it's like a roguelike or like
buying like a game where you know it's randomized yeah like a lot of roguelikes as an example because
you like are meant to die and replay where it'll like regenerate that's fine but i wouldn't want
to play like cyberpunk and then like open a door and it's a different corridor than it was on my
like last well yeah some games are more fun when you replay them over and over and it's the same
environment and you learn from the environment and you can adjust to it a lot of rpgs morrowind
is a great game great example of that as well that is a very stylized game and part of the fun of
that game is because you don't get it's you compare that to the later elder scrolls games
and a lot of the fun in that is you learn the environments through repetition yeah and having
to walk to places go through the same area over and over when i've played that the fun in that is
becoming familiar with the environment through a sort of learned experience and you also start
to be like okay you do the first town and then you go then you go north and then right and the
guy falls out the sky yes and then you three scrolls of icari flight love that guy and then
you use them in you use one of them in the dungeon that's further along the road to like bypass
something and get like a bunch of high level you know the dungeon i'm talking about yes i do yeah
but like that's awesome because it rewards
like exploration that's what you want from that kind of game i also love that we've we've both
never talked to each other about Morrowind before
Not really, I think we both said we enjoy it
but we've not gone deep on Morrowind
But we both have the same play style
You walked that route I just mentioned
Yes, we have the same start point for the game
You spawn, you do that same thing
So
That's the familiarity point
But yeah, I just
It's the inconsistency
It's not inconsistency
because
someone's fucked up or it's like a bug
That's kind of fine
well it's because you've added inconsistency in an attempt to mind read me and you're just not
gonna do it like not mind read but you know like you're trying to anticipate my well it's it's a
bit like predictive text or actually you a good example of this actually is um if you buy like a
one-off thing on amazon oh yes and it goes i'm gonna try and help you by sending i recently
brought this tv stand uh i don't know why i tapped it like the listeners because i recently brought a
tv stand so i literally every one or two days for the last like three weeks it's been like
looks like you're onto something how about another tv stand how many do you think i fucking want
do that like and it just feels that's a good example of like none of these algorithms are
helpful so let's maybe not use them so much yeah and i don't know if i'm if i'm just cynical or
set in my ways or if i'm just like adverse to like because i don't like when people approach
me in a shop and ask if i want any help i because that's why i hate being going to america like to
i've got family in america you go visit them you're just trying to like look around the store
and you feel like you're trying to at least to me it feels like they're trying to move you on
because like can we help you and if someone was doing that in britain i'd be like oh so they're
like the thing i'm shoplifting yeah they need they want me out the shop the thing i'm trying
here to steal shit in the uk if someone comes over to you and it's just like in a in like in
like a a typical supermarket you don't get people in the uk at least any experience i've had where
someone comes over and sort of prompts for help i guess yeah well why don't preemptively help me
if i need help and i ask for it please help me but don't come in and like yeah don't don't jump
in on me yeah because i don't like the idea of of you being sort of accosted and that's what i feel
like and to go back to that point i i don't know if it's my i get confused by it and i think maybe
this is part of where you're coming from if i've ordered something recently we ordered a camera for
yeah for our project overall we've got some stuff that involves a camera coming up
and i bought a camera and now i'm getting suggestions i get an amazon notification
every few days that says we think you'd like a new camera and it makes me think well what the
fuck's wrong with the last one you sold me but it also makes me go surely the surely the the thing
you would do is go he's bought a camera the next things you go are do you want a tripod
do you want a lens do you want to learn when you're buying it they're like people buy these
together yes why aren't they doing that why is that not the suggestion yeah like that yeah instead
of the saying we think you'd like a new camera and it makes me the first reaction is have you
sold me a bum camera it is a sort of like oh do you want to replace that like yeah i'm like do
you think i've realized this one's bad because i bought the last one from you why would i trust
this one and i've never and this is not hyperbolic i've never once had a suggestion come up from an
advert or from a uh a pop-up suggestion or never bought anything from a notification on amazon
that is said anything an advert anything like that i can't remember a time where i've been
suggested by an advert or technology in general where it said would you like to buy this and i
went that's a fucking great idea i'm gonna buy that right now or in the future i've never had
a moment that i can recall where i've done that certainly not if there's like suggestions on
amazon i'm sure there are adverts that i've like gradually taken in subconscious maybe but yeah
and it's like that's the algorithm the largest e-commerce thing ever one of the largest companies
ever that's the best they could do is the like this is the software to like help you make
purchasing decisions yes so anyone downstream of that you don't try and make it help which is what
confuses me because how is advertising so big but so pointless when i can't think of a single time
that advertising has got me and again that might be you know me being quite arrogant thinking i've
never i think there's two kinds of advertising in that sense of there's the brand building
advertise like you know when like a coke or a mcdonald's ad advertises where it's like they
know everyone knows about them what they're doing is sort of building themselves into your
subconscious they're keeping up appearances yeah but that like targeted we're selling a single
thing i i'm quite i don't think about it ever no that just that gets on my wick so if we if we try
to boil this back down to your original point which is something trying to help you when it
when it is that prompt i think i feel the same way yeah i think now that i've disseminated it
into the areas that it actually appears in my life when it's you know something popping up and
going would you like this i'm like well no why did you think i would what information have you
extrapolated this from is it a search that i've made because the scary thing is there's like the
you hear the stories of like oh the woman like found out she was pregnant from like the walmart
search algorithm or whatever the fuck um i don't think i know that oh no i'm remembering she didn't
find out she was pregnant they sent a bunch of stuff to her she was like a young girl they sent
a bunch of stuff to her house like as advertising based on her searches and it like outed her being
pregnant to her family oh wow yeah which is also like don't that's fuck yeah but they're just awful
like but also like they work that out but then they can't work it's i don't know it's just a
bizarre thing but i think it's don't help me when i don't ask for it with tech and what certainly
don't do is like remove functionality or like impinge on my life to help me yeah when i don't
want just leave it like yeah i think that's i think we're quite similar in that regard we like
to do stuff at our own pace and do it in our own way and if something is just enforced upon us
as help we we don't like that i certainly don't like that it actually makes me like push against
it a bit that's it i think now when i get those notifications i immediately disregard them
because it's been wrong so many times and maybe the algorithm's changed but the fact that recently
i bought a camera and now i'm being suggested would you like to buy a camera i'm thinking well
no this algorithm is still not working well i bought that boot case and this tv stand if i
bought everything that came on the following suggestions this room would be a library in
terms of bootcases with like five tv stands in the middle of the room you yeah you would have
thought maybe it's like oh would you like a reading light do you want some books like the
thing is i'm i'm able to think of these things i don't know why that's difficult like i because
this has been a problem for so long surely someone can go if they bought the product
don't sell them that exact category yeah there's certain things that you repeat by it's like you
bought toilet paper would you like quilted toilet paper but instead it's would you you bought a
one-time thing that should last you five to ten years would you like to buy another one right now
they need to have a tag for like one time yes they need if i guess this common ground has changed
into we hate the amazon suggestions which i'm happy with because i think i didn't explain it
particularly well but you got me to a point where it makes sense yeah i try to understand it and i
do completely understand this yeah the idea of things just kind of being thrown out there just
shit in the air yeah hoping something will stick but it's never stuck for me and that again that's
amazon the most resourced company in the world so if you're designing anything please keep in mind
the biggest company in the world couldn't figure it out so just have every button do what the
button should do don't do any of the other shit don't put a hat on a hat yeah if you've got
suggested stuff when you're buying something fair enough if you've got a new idea then fair enough
and if anybody listening has bought something from an advert that you can think of that was a good
purchase or i guess more interestingly that was a bad purchase where you've you've been coaxed by
an advert or cold call anything at all if anyone's ever got in touch with you technology or person
and you've purchased something let us know because i'm really interested to know if i'm being overly
cynical or if genuinely nobody adheres to this pattern yeah if anyone can think of a time that
they've done that get in touch with us which i guess brings us to the wrap-up yeah which is that
we found the common ground i think we're definitely one of our stronger agreements in a while yeah
we're definitely on board with this one
and if you want to let us know about these
anecdotes you've got about buying something from an advert
the email address
is info at warwithamate.co.uk
the website is warwithamate.co.uk
and the Instagram is just
warwithamate. Let us know that
let us know anything else
let us know if you come to the live show
30th of May, Birmingham
Games Expo
and from me James
me Andy
stay so humble and brave
In the deserts of your minds, with no further suggestions.
That's it. Good night and farewell.
Thanks for listening.
Bye!
We'll be right back.
