What A Day - How States Can Fight Trump feat. NY Gov. Kathy Hochul

Episode Date: March 7, 2025

Dozens of Democratic governors across the country are facing a nearly impossible task: Manage the day-to-day operations of their state while also playing wack-a-mole with the waves of awful federal policies coming out of Washington right now. From tariffs to mass government layoffs to threats to shutter the Department of Education, it's a lot! New York Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul talks about how she's navigating Trump 2.0 and the ways she's taking 'the gloves off' with the administration.And in headlines: Trump considers revoking deportation protections from nearly a quarter million Ukrainians, the president puts a pin in tariffs on a wide range of products from Mexico and Canada, and California Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom says it's 'unfair' to let trans athletes play women's sports.Show Notes:Subscribe to the What A Day Newsletter – https://tinyurl.com/3kk4nyz8Support victims of the fire – votesaveamerica.com/reliefWhat A Day – YouTube – https://www.youtube.com/@whatadaypodcastFollow us on Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/crookedmedia/For a transcript of this episode, please visit crooked.com/whataday

It's Friday, March 7th. I'm Jane Coaston, and this is What a Day, the show that does not really know what to say about this comment from President Donald Trump in reference to two American astronauts stuck in space for nearly nine months. They've been, maybe they'll love each other, I don't know. But they've been left up there, think of it. And I see the woman with the wild hair, good solid hair she's got. There's no kidding.

There's no games with her hair. I am so sorry. Record breaking astronaut and icon, Sonny Williams. On today's show, President Trump continues to toy with tariffs and Governor Gavin Newsom launches his new podcast and some unpopular opinions. But let's start with the states. You know, where you might live. Or maybe not, if you're an international listener, in which case thanks for listening

and also we're working on it. Anyway, there are 23 states with Democratic governors, and under the Trump administration, they have been tasked with what feels like an almost impossible challenge. Manage the day-to-day operations of a state that might contain millions of people while recognizing that currently the federal government is run by this. There'll always be a little short-term interruption. I don't think it's going to be big but the countries and companies that have been ripping us aren't particularly happy with what I'm doing. But the United States will be very happy and you know, our farmers are going to be very happy and again, there'll be disruption."

That's President Trump discussing tariffs against Mexico and Canada. Tariffs, which he simultaneously believes are wonderful and perfect, and also a terrible thing he can use as a weapon to get Mexico and Canada to do things. On Thursday, he issued exemptions to tariffs he announced two days before. We'll get into that later in the show. And this administration thinks this whole thing is fun. As one senior official told Politico anonymously on Wednesday, quote, it's the greatest show on earth. We'll put tariffs on tonight, but tomorrow we'll tell you we may negotiate and take them off. But

stay tuned because you never know what tomorrow's going to bring. Thanks. I hate it. This whipsaw back and forth stemming from Donald Trump and the Trump administration isn't just on tariffs. It's on everything. It's firing thousands of federal employees and then trying to hire some of them back. It's making policy through daily press conferences, not through Congress. Remember Congress?

And it's enough to make any governor pretty exhausted. So to find out how the governor of one of our most populous states, and one Trump has a very keen interest in, is handling our bat-shit era, I spoke with New York Governor Kathy Hochul. Governor Hochul, welcome to What a Day! Thank you, great to be here today. So we're just a little more than a month into Trump's second term. After Trump won in November, you said you were ready to work with the president where possible. How have your feelings changed since inauguration? Well, I said I'd work together where possible, meaning if you want to help us with

infrastructure projects, let's do Penn Station, let's build more subways, let's invest in infrastructure projects that are all over the state. I'll work even on that. But I also said very clearly, and I also told the president this personally, but if you challenge any of our policies or our values in the state of New York, I'm going to have to stand up and fight you. So we're in that place. I hoped the honeymoon would go a little bit longer, and we're just working together, and clearly it didn't.

So this is where we are, and I have a responsibility as the leader of this state to fight back when I feel we're under attack and we are under attack. Yeah, and I think one of the examples I keep thinking about is his efforts to block congestion pricing in Manhattan during peak traffic hours. You've since spoken with Trump about it, but it speaks to a bigger issue to me with Trump, which is that he will insert himself anywhere where he sees a political opportunity, even when it's like, this isn't your job. So how do you work with an administration like that as a governor?

I'm trying, but here's what we are. Something like congestion pricing. I think about the fact that, you know, the Trump administration believes that you be up to the states to determine whether women can control their own bodies, right, when it comes to reproductive rights. But they're telling me as a state that I can't control my own damn traffic. So they are so wildly inconsistent. I feel like this is a whiplash administration.

Call the medics. We're all getting whiplash because we're going back and forth. There's tariffs on, there's tariffs off, there are firings on, there are firings off. It's almost incomprehensible, but I think that's part of the strategy. So we cannot be sucked into this moment by moment reaction, because the one I think will lose our credibility

with the voters that were just reacting all the time, we have to have a consistent message and pick our fights. This is important. So my fights have been defined. You're coming after congestion pricing, you've got to fight. You're coming after Medicaid, I'll take that fight out. And tariffs. My God, I just had a round table with farmers

from all over New York, and they cannot believe what is happening to them. And now Education Department, it's unrelenting. So I'm not going to hit on every single thing, but my God, there's a lot to deal with it. Right. And Trump campaigned on some of the very issues you're talking about, tariffs ending the Education Department, and people voted for that, even if I don't know if they really thought it would actually happen. I still think people think that Trump is always in negotiation mode.

But does there come a point where you say the gloves are off, there is no real upside to working with this administration? Where do you draw the line? I will still hold out hope that there's some areas that can be common ground. Again, infrastructure is really important to us. I need to protect the Chips and Science Act because I have a whole semiconductor manufacturing industry in New York and innovation that I want to continue to harness and and create the thousands of jobs that are coming. So those are areas where I have to be persuasive and say, can we just leave

this alone because these are your voters. I mean you kill offshore wind, guess what? That's thousands of jobs on Long Island and they voted for you. These farmers were your voters. So it's my job to remind everybody, like maybe you didn't think it would be this bad, but it really is. And how we deal with this? Go to your Republican members of Congress offices. Flood the zone yourself. Bring parents and kids and teachers on something like the education cuts. This is how we start really letting people know how disappointed we are, those who may have voted for them. But also, we saw this coming, and I have to let the consequences be felt, or else people

won't be changing their behavior in 26 and again in 28. I think we've been talking about that flooding the zone concept a little bit. And Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy posted a video on Twitter last week that featured five men bashing congestion pricing. And I know lots of New Yorkers, including a lot of New Yorkers I know, support congestion pricing. My question for you is the Trump administration is very skillful at using the media and social media to project the narrative they want on issues like this.

And it feels like Democrats don't really have a way to meaningfully counter it, besides like fact checking. Is that a problem that you see? And what do you think Democrats can do better to counter the way the administration floods the information space? No, you just have to take the gloves off and jump in the arena. If you look at a press conference we did as soon as Donald Trump literally tweeted that I've just killed congestion pricing, long live the king.

I went into the subway, put on my subway jacket, and I said, we have not labored under a king in this country in 250 years, and we're not about to start. And I referenced something that you may or may not be familiar with, the old Rambo movies. You talk about first blood. I wasn't fighting until you drew first blood. And now I have to give a response back. And it's going to be tough. We're not going to sit on the sidelines. We cannot. We must engage in this fight. And the voters need to see that we're standing up issue by issue where it affects us directly. And you talk about

things like affordability, my God, he promised that the prices would go down on inauguration day. I have an apartment in New York City. I go to the store, toothpaste is $12 for a little tube. The eggs are now $11 in New York City. They didn't go down, they went up 20% since inauguration day.

So I'm working on affordability. I have found a path to put up to $5,000 back in New Yorkers' pockets in my budget, $1,000 tax credit for little kids, a middle-class tax cut, making sure we can give an inflation rebate because we collected a lot of money in sales tax. I'm giving it back to New Yorkers. This is the message that Democrats have to use all across this country We have to use our personal stories connect with people and then have the policies that'll show the contrast between what we're doing in our states versus the

Catastrophic damage that they're wreaking on the American people out of Washington Yeah And it's been interesting because I think Trump believes that there will be no consequences and you see this on tariffs where he thinks going back and forth and back and forth and back and forth is just fun entertainment. But what does it mean for a state like New York, for New York farmers to have the White House going back and forth on huge trade issues like this? It's maddening, not just for the farmers. I did a roundtable in Buffalo, my hometown, right on the border with Ontario.

And there's so much commerce that crosses our borders in the North country of New York. There's a French Canadian company that manufactures our subway cars. They're gonna be using steel and aluminum. The energy cost, the costs of that are gonna go up. And also I got a letter from the Ontario Premier, said, sorry, but our energy costs are going

to go up 25%. We get electricity from Canada. Our costs just went up 25%. Or they say they may end it all together. So the scale of the pain we're going to feel because of these policies from the Trump administration are hopefully going to get people to start changing how they behave, how they act, who they vote for. But again, this ping-ponging back and forth and the whiplash we're getting,

it is damaging to our economy. I don't know who benefits from this. I still don't know. I also don't know. But you mentioned a couple of times that people need to understand the consequences of what they voted for. But also, for many people, especially people who didn't vote for this, this is their livelihoods. This could be the difference for getting food on the table for

some people. So what can the state of New York do to provide some sort of stability? No, that's exactly what I'm doing. That's why I invested $7 billion in child care and these additional tax credit for families with little kids. I'm trying to find ways to put money from the state back in their pockets so they can pay that utility bill without stressing out, or their student loan payment, or their rent or mortgage payment. I'm laser focused on this, and I didn't need an election in November to tell me that people are feeling a lot of pain.

But it is heartbreaking to see that despite what we're doing, so much is gonna be counteracted by the Trump administration. That's the message we have to get out loud and clear. Don't blame the Democratic governors. We're in the fight. We need Washington, though. I get $96 billion from the federal government every year through many, many programs.

I cannot make that up. I cannot compensate for that loss. We need a federal government that stops hurting its people, starts realizing your responsibility to help people. I want to ask a little bit about what Democrats can do about it because it feels like Democrats' current reliance on the federal court system to try and limit Trump's agenda is risky. I know there aren't a ton of options, but the fact of the matter is that the big cases

will make their way to a Supreme Court with a conservative supermajority that seems ready to grant Trump extraordinary power. So how else can Democrats at the state level push back on Trump outside of the courts? Prove that Democrats know how to govern at every level of government. Have people start to rely on us, look to us for leadership, and we can show an incredible contrast. Yes, we'll use the courts, we're using the courts already. That is one option, but I don't know if I can always count on that. Again, focus on elections as well to convince people that we're the ones that help you.

But I think we've seen a bunch of polls recently that people have a dim view of democratic governance right now. They're not feeling great about the Democratic Party. How do you counter that? With success, with accomplishments, and better messaging, no doubt about it. Stop explaining everything. Stop talking down to people. When I come from Buffalo, a blue collar town, my parents used to live in a trailer park. I can communicate with people. I'm happiest in a diner any day of the week. We have to get off this pedestal that we think we're

better than everybody else and start connecting and looking human. You know, throw on a denim jacket and walk around with a pair of sneakers. Be real, be human. And don't be so detached from everybody. I think we can make that connection. I really do. I'm not giving up on the Democrats.

I'm not giving up on the people of this country. I will always have faith in them. Governor Hockel, thank you so much for joining me. Thank you. That was my conversation with New York Governor Kathy Hockel. We'll get to more of the news in a moment, but if you like the show, make sure to subscribe, leave a five-star review on Apple Podcasts, watch us on YouTube, and share with your friends. More to come after some ads. Today's episode is sponsored by Acorns.

Acorns is a financial wellness app that helps you take control of your money with simple tools that make it easy to start saving and investing for your future. You don't need to be an expert. Acorns will recommend a diversified portfolio that matches you and your money goals. And you don't need to be an expert. Acorns will recommend a diversified portfolio that matches you and your money goals. And you don't need to be rich. Acorns lets you get started with the spare money you've got right now, even if all you've got is spare change. Basically, Acorns does the hard part so you can give your money a chance to grow.

Ready to take control of your money? Sign up now and join the over 14 million all-time customers who have already saved and invested over $25 billion with Acorns. Head to acorns.com slash wad or download the Acorns app to get started. Paid non-client endorsement. Compensation provides incentive to positively promote Acorns. Tier 1 compensation provided. Investing involves risk. Acorns Advisor LLC and SEC Registered Investment Advisor. View important disclosures at acorn.com slash wad. Here's what else we're following today. We want them to keep the good people.

And so we're going to be watching them and Elon and the group are going to be watching them and if they can cut, it's better. And if they don't cut, then Elon will do the cutting. President Trump is putting Elon Musk in his place. Well, maybe, sort of. Politico reported that Trump held a cabinet meeting Thursday to tell members of his administration Musk can make recommendations to the departments, but not issue unilateral decisions on staffing

and policy. That's according to two administration officials. Musk was reportedly in the room when Trump clarified the Department of Government Efficiency Leader-Non-Leaders role. Trump followed it up by posting on Truth Social, quote, I have instructed the Secretaries in Leadership to work with Doge on cost-cutting measures and staffing. As the Secretaries learn about and understand the people working for the various departments,

they can be very precise as to who will remain and who will go. Musk didn't seem opposed. He posted on Twitter, quote, very productive meeting. Remember, according to the Department of Justice, he doesn't even run Doge. Trump is walking back his beautiful 25% tariffs on Mexico and Canada. Again. You know, the tariffs that were supposed to go into effect last month, but were delayed until this past Tuesday, when they actually did go into effect for two whole days.

The president signed an executive order Thursday to exempt goods that fall under the USMCA, the big free trade agreement Trump negotiated with Mexico and Canada during his first term. That accounts for about half of all Mexican imports and around 40% of Canadian imports. The order follows the White House's decision Wednesday to also exempt auto imports from Mexico and Canada from tariffs. However, Trump has kept in place an additional 10% tariff on Chinese goods that also went into effect Tuesday.

This chaotic week for U.S. trade policy has driven major swings in the stock markets. Trump claimed that the drop in stock prices has nothing to do with his backpedaling, even though the stock market seems to be the one thing Trump actually cares about. He told reporters in the Oval Office that people are just jealous of the U.S. I think it's globalists that see how rich our country is going to be and they don't like it. You know, big market out there. Right. It couldn't possibly be that nearly every economist told you tariffs are a bad idea.

Definitely not that. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said Thursday that the new tariff pause will last until April 2nd. The same day Trump plans to impose reciprocal tariffs on countries that tax imported goods from the US. Trump says he may end immigration protections for hundreds of thousands of Ukrainians who fled the war in their home country. Because it isn't bad enough that Trump has put a pause on all military aid to Ukraine. It's not enough that Trump ridiculed Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyi

when he came to the White House and pleaded for support amid Russia's violent three-year long invasion of his country. Now, Trump has to punish people who fled the war-torn country, too. Trump told reporters he's weighing his options during an Oval Office gaggle Thursday. Well, we're not looking to hurt anybody. We're certainly not looking to hurt them. And I'm looking at that.

And there were some people that think that's appropriate and some people don't. And I'll be making a decision pretty soon. There are around a quarter million Ukrainians living in the U.S. with what's called temporary protected status or TPS. Revoking that status would put some of them at risk for deportation. Trump didn't seem to know what TPS was though, when reporters asked him about it. Why would we be talking about GPS? Trump's comments undermined his own administration's claims earlier in the day. Reuters was the first to break the story Thursday, citing a senior White House official and three

other anonymous sources. White House Press Secretary Caroline Levitt had earlier tweeted that senior officials who spoke to Reuters, quote, have no idea what they're talking about. California Democratic Governor Gavin Newsom used the debut episode of his podcast, This Is Gavin Newsom, to speak with right-wing influencer Charlie Kirk. An interesting use of time. Kirk is a conservative political activist and founder of Turning Point USA, a pro-Trump organization active on college campuses.

He's been a vocal opponent of transgender athletes in women's sports, and Newsom said he feels similarly. Would you say no men in female sports? Well, I think it's an issue of fairness. I completely agree with you on that. Choice words coming from someone who has backed LGBTQ causes for decades. It was also a major policy break from his fellow Democrats and a noteworthy one because Newsom is widely rumored to be eyeing a White House run in 2028. In the interview with Kirk, Newsom tried to temper his criticisms. There's also a humility and grace that these poor people are more likely to commit suicide,

have anxiety and depression. And the way that people talk down to vulnerable communities is an issue that I have a hard time with. Speaking of talking down to vulnerable communities, Newsom's remarks were met with backlash from some LGBTQ advocates. California Assemblyman Chris Ward and state Senator Caroline Menjivar, who lead the state's LGBTQ caucus, said,

"'We woke up profoundly sickened and frustrated by these remarks.'" It's the latest slate in an otherwise very difficult month for trans Americans. Since taking office, President Trump has issued directives targeting trans people who serve in the military, play school sports, and among other things are just trying to live their lives. And that's the news. One more thing.

Former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo is running to be mayor of New York City. On Saturday, he made the announcement in a 17-minute video, which is about 16 minutes too long for an election announcement video. I believe I can help, and that is why I announced my candidacy today for Mayor of New York City. I am a lifelong New Yorker, and I love New York. He's running against a host of Democrats, including the current mayor of New York City, Eric Adams. But due to a host of tiny little controversies, you might remember something about the DOJ dropping charges to maybe pressure him on immigration,

Eric Adams currently has the popularity of stomach flu, and a majority of New Yorkers want him to resign. In February, Governor Kathy Hokel put limits on his power as mayor. We spoke to her earlier in the show. And right now, Cuomo is leading the pack. According to a Quinnipiac poll released on Wednesday, 31% of voters support his candidacy, the most of any of the candidates listed. But for the life of me, I cannot understand why.

Okay, like, I do get it. Andrew Cuomo is a known quantity in New York and nationally. Remember those daily COVID press conferences? I like to start with just the facts. Just give me the facts. And that's what we do in this presentation. Here are the facts. No opinion. He was governor of New York for a decade. His dad was governor of New York for more than a decade. And in comparison with Eric Adams, Cuomo might seem almost normal. But let's talk about why Andrew Cuomo should absolutely not be the next mayor of New York City.

But let's talk about why Andrew Cuomo should absolutely not be the next mayor of New York City. First, let's remember why he stopped being governor. Because he was credibly accused of sexual harassment in a massive investigation launched by New York Attorney General Letitia James. The damning report, 165 pages long, including the testimony of 179 witnesses documenting a pattern of behavior from 2013 until at least 2020. According to the report, the allegations of sexual harassment against at least 11 women included unwanted touching, groping, and sexual comments. Cuomo even retaliated against one of the women he harassed, feeding damaging information about her to reporters. Cuomo maintained his innocence, but most Democrats, including President Joe Biden, said it was time for him to go.

— I stand by that statement. — Are you now calling on him to resign? — Yes. — And if he doesn't resign, do you believe he should be impeached and removed from office? — Let's take one thing at a time here. I think he should resign. — Cuomo resigned on August 23rd, 2021. But the story doesn't end there.

Because of a state law, the taxpayers of the state of New York have been on the hook for the cost of his efforts to defend himself, to the tune of $28 million. And those efforts have been, as a U.S. district court judge described them, scorched earth. One accuser dropped her federal lawsuit against Cuomo. Her lawyer said he, quote, "'Used every opportunity to harass our client with an astonishing number of invasive discovery requests and outrageous statements in pleadings

to embarrass and humiliate her.' Those requests even included gynecological records." But if you're thinking, okay, so Andrew Cuomo was credibly accused of sexual harassment in a massive investigation that led to his resignation, but that should be it, right? Oh no, definitely not. A second investigation by Attorney General James found that Cuomo undercounted the number of COVID-19 deaths in 2020 in New York nursing homes and tried to keep that information from

state lawmakers for fear that President Trump would use it as a political cudgel. His team even rewrote reports to hide the death toll. Cuomo had become known nationally for those daily press conferences during the peak of COVID, but he downplayed nursing home deaths in those press conferences throughout 2020 and 2021. So here's where we are. We have a candidate for New York City mayor who was forced out of office because of allegations of repeated acts of sexual harassment. That same candidate also allegedly tried to hide deaths of the elderly and disabled during a pandemic. One of his accusers,

Lindsay Boylan, told the Associated Press on Wednesday that her fight now was to keep him from ever becoming mayor. I wake up every day hoping that he'll find some ethics and some moral compass and decide that this is not the right thing for him to do. But I have very little hope of that. And so what I do every day after I wake up in this nightmare is I think, how am I going to spend every moment of this day preventing this monster from becoming the mayor of my city,

the city that my daughter lives in? She shouldn't have to do this. There is no rule in New York state law that the weirdest and worst New Yorker gets to be mayor. New York, you are a very cool place. You contain millions of people who have not been incredibly accused of sexual harassment or covering up the deaths of some of the most vulnerable. You absolutely do not have to elect Andrew Cuomo mayor.

Before we go, Trump's address to Congress was the longest in history because of course it was. But beneath the 100 minute spectacle was the same dangerous rhetoric on immigration, crime, and transgender rights. So now what? On the latest episode of Assembly Required, Stacey Abrams is joined by Jen Psaki, host of MSNBC's Inside with Jen Psaki and the Blueprint, to break it all down, strategize how Democrats and all of us can push back and prepare for the chaos ahead. Listen to Assembly Required now.

New episodes drop every Thursday, wherever you get your podcasts, or on YouTube. That's all for today. If you like the show, make sure you subscribe, leave a review, recognize that it is okay to have zero opinions about Meghan Markle, and tell your friends to listen. And if you are into reading, and not just about how really, it's fine. You can just feel totally neutral about Meghan Markle or the Oscars or a movie or a show or a song, it's okay. You're allowed to be whelmed, like me. What A Day is also a nightly newsletter. Check it out and subscribe at crickit.com slash subscribe.

I'm Jane Costin and you are permitted to not care about things too. What A Day is a production of Cricket Media. It's recorded and mixed by Desmond Taylor. Our associate producers are Raven Yamamoto and Emily Four. Our producer is Michelle Alloy. We had production help today from Johanna Case, Joseph Dutra, Greg Walters, and Julia Claire.

Our senior producer is Erica Morrison, and our executive producer is Adrian Hill. Our theme music is by Colin Gillyard and Kashaka. Our production staff is proudly unionized with the Writers Guild of America East.