What A Day - Netanyahu Threatens to Escalate War In Gaza

Episode Date: May 6, 2025

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Monday that Israel was 'on the eve of a forceful entry to Gaza.' His announcement came just hours after his security cabinet approved a plan to seize and occupy the Gaza Strip indefinitely and move hundreds of thousands of Palestinians to Gaza's southern region. It also came less than two weeks before President Donald Trump is scheduled to head to the Middle East for talks with Arab leaders. Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib, a resident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council where he heads the 'Realign For Palestine' project, talks about what Israel's threats of escalation mean for the people living in Gaza.And in headlines: The White House said it wants to pay undocumented migrants $1,000 to voluntarily self-deport, Trump said he wants to make Hollywood great again by levying tariffs on films produced outside the U.S., and nearly two dozen states sued the administration over its cuts to the Department of Health and Human Services.Show Notes:Check out Ahmed's work – www.atlanticcouncil.org/expert/ahmed-alkhatib/Subscribe to the What A Day Newsletter – https://tinyurl.com/3kk4nyz8What A Day – YouTube – https://www.youtube.com/@whatadaypodcastFollow us on Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/crookedmedia/For a transcript of this episode, please visit crooked.com/whataday

It's Tuesday, May 6th. I'm Josie Duffy Rice in for Jane Costin and this is What A Day, the show that is obsessed with all the looks from the Met Gala last night. The theme was super fine, tailoring black style. Debbie Allen, Colman Domingo. You're perfect. Never change. On today's show, the White House wants to pay undocumented migrants $1,000 to voluntarily self-deport.

And President Trump wants to extend his love of tariffs to Hollywood. But let's start with Israel's war in Gaza. On Monday, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced that Israel was, quote, on the eve of a forceful entry to Gaza. His announcement came just hours after his security cabinet approved a plan to seize the Gaza Strip and occupy the territory indefinitely. Netanyahu made the announcement in a video posted to social media. Here he is, interpreted by Sky News.

We decided to take intensified action in Gaza. That was the chief of staff's recommendation, to move, as he said, toward the defeat of Hamas. He believes this will also help us rescue the hostages, and I agree with him. We are not letting up on this effort, and we will not give up on anyone. Not at all sure how Occupying Gaza Gaza indefinitely is helping the hostages. The Israeli plan also calls for moving hundreds of thousands of Palestinians to Gaza's southern region. The Israel Defense Forces, or IDF, is also calling up tens of thousands of reserve soldiers. This attempt to, quote, conquer Gaza, Netanyahu's words, not mine, would be a massive escalation

in a war that has already caused enormous destruction and death and displaced more than 90% of Gaza's population. Currently, Israel has blocked all humanitarian aid from entering Gaza, and aid organizations have warned that the area is on the verge of widespread famine. So for more on Israel's escalation in Gaza and what it means, I spoke with Ahmed Fuad Al-Khatib. He's a resident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, where he heads the Realign for Palestine project.

He's also originally from Gaza. He joined us Tuesday from the airport in Los Angeles. Ahmed, welcome to What A Day. Thanks for having me. So Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Monday that Israel was, quote, on the eve of a forceful entry to Gaza. And his security cabinet also okayed a plan to take and hold the entire Gaza Strip

for an unspecified amount of time. The army has also called up tens of thousands of reservist troops. What does this mean for the people living in Gaza? What has this changed about, you know, the war thus far? Well, I think there are two ways to read into this. The first is potentially a message, as a pressure tactic, if you will. We know that President Trump of the United States is going to visit the region on May 13th, and that will entail speaking with moderate

Arab Sunni states, including Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates. And so perhaps this is an attempt to pressure the Arab states into avoiding a scenario of full reoccupation of the Gaza Strip, pressuring Hamas itself into understanding that Israel means business and that this is the final opportunity to reach a ceasefire that entails the release of the hostages, the terror group stepping down from ruling the Gaza Strip, and the beginning of some sort of an alternative governing structure. On the other hand, this very much so could be a serious plan in which the Israeli government is truly intending to reoccupy the Gaza Strip with all the challenges that that presents.

You have how many troops are you going to need to actually be able to hold entire chunks of the coastal enclave. We know that there are Israeli reservists who haven't been really reporting for duty. There are folks who are frustrated by the government and Mr. Netanyahu. We know that there's concern about the fate of the remaining hostages, at least the 24 who are believed to still be alive. So those are questions that are going to come up as we explore the two possibilities of is this a negotiation tactic or is this a real operational plan with all the strategic, tactical,

and geopolitical implications that it entails? How would an occupation be an escalation of what we've seen since October of 2023? You know, I think from afar, it already sort of seems like we've been seeing an Israeli occupation of Gaza for months. Well, this, if the Israeli military and government were to proceed with this operation, this would be a massive escalation and a game-changer really, currently as is. And I've, my brother runs a major medical, international medical NGO in the Gaza Strip. I have other folks on the ground, some of my surviving family and several contacts. There are parts of Gaza that are not directly occupied by Israeli ground troops. There are parts of Gaza where

the Palestinian people are able to move relatively freely. And so all of that would fundamentally change if you have a direct thrust by the Israeli military. So that would entail the relocation of large numbers, millions of people potentially. And even those in the South, they would be concentrated in an area that the IDF is trying to establish as a humanitarian bubble, is the term they're labeling. This would also potentially entail, as what we've heard from the IDF chief of staff, the complete destruction of everything above ground, all infrastructure above ground, per his own words. So it would be a significant escalation.

Now the Israeli military currently does control roughly a quarter to a third of Gaza's territory, but most of these are stationed around Gaza's borders with Israel, with a couple of corridors that bisect the strip into three areas. You mentioned this plan to move tens of thousands of Palestinians to the south in this humanitarian bubble. What infrastructure is even left in the south of Gaza to house and care for people in this, quote unquote, humanitarian bubble?

Does that infrastructure still exist? And what would it be like for people in this quote unquote humanitarian bubble. Does that infrastructure still exist and what would it be like for people who are in this southern area of Gaza? Well, this is precisely what's most concerning about this development is that thus far all that has been presented remains very nebulous, very theoretical frameworks for how this would work. It has not been well articulated as to specifics. We've seen the IDF raise entire neighborhoods of what was once the city of Rafa that has been entirely destroyed.

And now you have these areas that are entirely cleared. And I think we're talking about potentially setting up everything from scratch in the form of tents, in the form of distribution centers, but still you have nothing on the ground right now per available satellite imagery. And so that's going to be a difficult challenge to tackle. How are you going to get this infrastructure ready in time? President Trump is supposed to be in the Middle East on May 13th. His visit is

expected to last a few days, and the Israeli government has announced that it will begin this expanded military operation after he leaves. So we're talking about less than two weeks, potentially, to get this infrastructure in place, something that is highly unlikely. Meanwhile, we already have a horrendous situation where outright famine-like conditions have set in parts of Gaza. There's an unequal distribution of what little food that remains there, giving rise to criminal gangs, to looting by remnants of Hamas. We've seen the complete collapse of law and order. I don't think the people of Gaza have two weeks left to really weather what has been the most horrendous chapter

since October 7 in terms of the humanitarian suffering. Hmm. I'd like to just talk about that a little bit more briefly because I think this, the fact that Israel has barred humanitarian aid into Gaza, how are people surviving? What is going on in Gaza right now given that there's no aid able to come in? So the complete blockade and siege has effectively amounted to a policy of collective punishment, unfortunately, whereby, yes, it is pressuring Hamas, but it's also pressuring

the people of Gaza who are stuck paying for a sin that they did not commit and a war that they are powerless to stop. So it's an untenable situation. I met personally with senior Israeli current and former military officials and government officials and I received repeated assurances that we understand it would be a war crime and an unethical decision to allow famine to set in. But we believe, and this was as of two weeks ago, what I was told is we believe that Gaza has one month before actual famine sets in. And I argued with some and said, I don't believe those assessments are correct.

But there's a recognition that this is, in fact, a strategy to pressure Hamas, while also acknowledging that they're going to squeeze to the very last minute before mass widespread hunger spreads. And then they're going to allow the spigot to be reopened. Something that I have called out as being really inconsistent with international humanitarian law that prohibits the use of starvation as a weapon of war. Right. I wonder in this moment where things are with the ceasefire.

Can you tell us a little bit about where those talks are and why they stalled, if you can remind us why they stalled? Well, the very accepted explanation is that the Israeli government chose not to proceed to the second phase of the ceasefire. However, where things stand right now and where I think there's a misalignment is that the Israeli government wants to ensure that the terror

group can no longer rearm, reestablish itself to pose a threat to Israel, reassert control over Gaza, remain in charge of governance. On the other hand, Hamas sees the remaining hostages and the ceasefire as the only mechanism through which it can ensure its own survival as a governance body in the Gaza Strip. Hamas has said that it would potentially let go of direct governance and allow a technocratic committee. Those amount to nothing more than empty declarations that would create a Hezbollah-like model in Lebanon, whereby Hezbollah reigned, but it didn't govern directly. So it's a really tragic situation in which, once again, the innocent, uninvolved people of Gaza who

are the majority of what remains, the women, the children, are paying the ultimate price for a sin they didn't commit? You mentioned how Netanyahu and his government have not really shown interest in trying to stop this conflict, right? And Trump has mostly allowed Netanyahu to conduct the war as he wants. Is there any reason to think that this administration would try to prevent a full-scale capture and occupation of the strip by Israeli power? Initially, I did believe, and I still have reason to believe,

that the Trump administration is indeed interested in calming things down in the Middle East for the sake of pursuing the ultimate deal, which is Saudi-Israeli normalization, not just because Mr. Trump sees himself as wanting to be a peacemaker, but because such a deal is going to generate immense economic potential for American enterprise, American capitalism, and all sorts of international interests. So I hope that President Trump is going to pressure both moderate Arab countries into taking a stance against Hamas and saying, you have got to go. There is no future for Gaza and Palestine with you in

charge. Similarly, that he would do something similar with Mr. Netanyahu and the Israeli government, which relies on US support to say, enough, we cannot go on. We cannot go on with perpetual conflict and simply managing the conflict. The Palestinian people deserve a state and dignity and freedom, even as Israel has every right to exist in safety, security, and to be a safe home and a safe place for the Jewish people. The two things can exist concurrently. They do not have to be in perpetual opposition to one another.

Ahmed, thank you so much for joining us. Thank you for having me. That was my conversation with Ahmed Fuad Al-Khatib, a resident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, where he heads the Realign for Palestine project. We'll get to more of the news in a moment, but if you like the show, make sure to subscribe, leave a five-star review on Apple Podcasts, watch us on YouTube, and share with your friends. More to come after some ads. What a day is brought to you by one skin. Moms know the hustle is real.

With work, kids, errands, and everything in between, there's rarely time to slow down, let alone figure out a 10-step skincare routine. But no matter how busy life gets, your skin still deserves more than just the basics. That's why I love today's sponsor, OneSkin. Their products are two multitaskers. They hydrate, protect,

and support your skin's long-term health. And it's all thanks to their OS1 peptide. It targets the cells that accelerate the visible signs of aging, like wrinkles, thinning skin, and a dry, dull complexion. OneSkin supports the skin at a deeper level, so even if I'm running on fumes, at least my skin gets what it needs. Try their cleanser, moisturizers, sunscreens, or their new peptide scalp serum, because, you know, scalp health is skin health, and get 15% off with code WOD at Oneskin.co. For moms who do it all, now there's a skin routine that does it all too. I do not leave the house

without putting sunscreen on my face and I have been militant about this for 15 years. And as a result, I feel good about my face now at my age, even with kids and very little sleep. And Oneskin is great in supporting that as I continue to march into my 40s. OneSkin was founded in 2016 by an all-woman team of scientists with PhDs in skin regeneration, stem cell biology, immunology, and bioinformatics. After testing the efficacy of more than 900 so-called anti-aging peptides, they developed the OS-1 peptide, the first ingredient to reverse skin's biological age by reducing the accumulation of senescent cells, a key driver of skin aging. OS1 works at the cellular level to improve key aging biomarkers while reducing the visible signs of aging, including fine lines, wrinkles, and sagging skin.

One skin's entire R&D process is run in-house, strictly adhering to the rigor of the scientific process from start to finish. OneSkin's entire R&D process is run in-house, strictly adhering to the rigor of the scientific process from start to finish. Every claim is based on lab or clinical studies and documented on its website. OneSkin believes the purpose of skincare is not just to improve how you look, but to optimize your skin's biology at the cellular level

so it's more resilient to the aging process. OneSkin is the world's first skin longevity company. By focusing on the cellular aspects of aging, OneSkin keeps your skin looking and acting younger for longer. For a limited time, you can try OneSkin is the world's first skin longevity company. By focusing on the cellular aspects of aging, OneSkin keeps your skin looking and acting younger for longer. For a limited time, you can try OneSkin with 15% off using code WOD at oneskin.co. That's 15% off oneskin.co with code WOD. After you purchase, they'll ask you where you heard about them.

Please support our show and tell them that we sent you. Give your skin the scientifically proven gentle care it deserves with one skin. Here's what else we're following today. Headlines. What we thought we'd do is a self-deport where we're gonna pay each one a certain amount of money and we're gonna get them a beautiful flight back to where they came from.

In the Oval Office on Monday, the President spoke to the press about his administration's offer to give undocumented immigrants in the US $1,000 in assist with travel costs if they voluntarily self-deport. The Department of Homeland Security announced the program in a statement on Monday

directing migrants to use the Custom and Border Protections app, CBP Home, to submit their intent to depart to the government. The government says those who do so will be, quote, deprioritized for detention and removal by immigration authorities, and the $1,000 stipend will be paid out once they return to their home country. Even though the government would essentially be paying migrants to leave, DHS says the new program is expected to lower the cost of individual deportations.

The department says it costs over $17,000 on average to arrest, detain, and remove someone without legal status. DHS said one migrant has already used the new program to secure a flight from Chicago to Honduras, and that more plane tickets have been booked for this week and next. This is not how government is supposed to work. These actions are dangerous, cruel, and illegal. A coalition of 19 states and the District of Columbia sued the Trump administration Monday over its gutting of the Department of Health and Human Services. New York Attorney General Letitia James is leading the lawsuit.

Since taking office, this administration has fired scientists, closed labs, shuttered life-saving programs without rhyme, reason, or any legal authority. Nothing but devastating consequences for millions of Americans. This is not government reform. HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced a major restructuring of the department earlier this year to quote, make America healthy again. The department said it would cut around 20,000 jobs and shut down entire agencies as part of that initiative. The lawsuit alleges that the cuts have led to the shuttering of key disease testing labs and made it harder for states to access grants for crucial public programs.

James and her fellow plaintiffs are asking a federal judge to reverse the department's mass layoffs and block Kennedy's restructuring of HHS. An HHS spokesperson responded to the lawsuit in a statement Monday, saying that the department quote, remains confident that the process will withstand legal scrutiny and looks forward to a resolution that reflects the facts and the law. I'm not just blaming other nations, but other nations, a lot of them, have stolen our movie industry. And I'm saying if they're not willing to make a movie inside the United States, then we should have a tariff

on movies that come in. Hollywood is being destroyed. That's a direct quote from President Donald Trump elaborating on the White House lawn about his plan to tariff movies produced outside the U.S. You're probably wondering how we got here. On Sunday, Trump said in a Truth Social post the U.S. film industry is dying because of incentives that draw filmmakers abroad. He said he's authorizing, quote, the Department of Commerce

and the United States Trade Representative to immediately begin the process of instituting a 100% tariff on any and all movies coming into our country that are produced in foreign lands. You're hearing it, you're not seeing it, so you can't see all the random capitalization that happened in his Truth Social post, but believe me, it's

there. If you're wondering how this will work, the White House does not appear to have a plan yet. In an email statement on Monday, a spokesperson said they're quote, exploring all options to deliver on President Trump's directive to safeguard our country's national and economic security while making Hollywood great again. Trump told reporters in the Oval Office Monday he just wants to help the industry. So we're going to meet with the industry.

I want to make sure they're happy with it because we're all about jobs. That's all what I'm... You know, it's very important. It's a big industry, but it's an industry now that's... it's really left... it's abandoned the USA where it started.

And we'll get it back. Maybe Trump will get it back with the help of his dream team, Sylvester Stallone, John Voight and Mel Gibson. Trump appointed the actors earlier this year as special ambassadors to bring Hollywood quote, back, bigger, better and stronger than ever before. And the tense town halls continue. New York Republican Representative Mike Lawler faced a rowdy crowd at his town hall on Sunday night. Voters from Lawler's swing district questioned him about Trump administration policies as chants and boos erupted and multiple people in the crowd were removed by law enforcement.

Lawler's town hall comes at a time of heightened tension between Republicans and the constituents they have to answer to about things like Doge, tariffs, and Ukraine. Despite a registration requirement and a long list of guidelines, at one point during the event when Lawler was discussing tariffs, law enforcement surrounded a woman in the crowd. In a video shared by ABC News, you can hear people chanting, let her stay. Let her stay!

Let her stay! You're gonna have to kick out everybody. The officers eventually picked the woman up and carried her out of the auditorium. She held up peace signs as they removed her. But that was just another raucous night for Lawler. Last month, he held a town hall where he was also heckled by constituents.

And that's the news. Before we go, trans people are under attack by weirdos who think trans people shouldn't exist and billionaire sex pests should. Stand up for the trans community and a trans people have always existed t-shirt or tote at the Crooked Store. Show your defiance with a statement that isn't actually radical at all. Head to crooked.com slash store to shop. That is all for today. If you liked the show, make sure you subscribe, leave a review, heckle your nearest Republican member

of Congress at a town hall, and tell your friends to listen. And if you were into reading, and not just the paltry list of Republicans actually brave enough to even hold a town hall, like me, what a day is also a nightly newsletter so check it out and subscribe at cricket.com slash subscribe I'm Josie Duffy Rice and it's fun to boo people What a Day is a production of Crooked Media.

It's recorded in a mix by Desmond Taylor. Our associate producers are Raven Yamamoto and Emily For. Our producer is Michelle Alloy. We had production help today from Johanna Case, Joseph Dutra, Greg Walters, and Julia Claire. Our senior producer is Erica Morrison, and our executive producer is Adrian Hill. Our theme music is by Colin Gileard and Kashaka. Our production staff is proudly unionized

with the Writers Guild of America East.