What Bitcoin Did - The Spiritual War for Bitcoin | American HODL, Erik Cason & Marty Bent

Episode Date: October 31, 2025

Marty Bent is the Founder of TFTC and Managing Partner at Ten31, Erik Cason is the Co-Founder of Vora, and American HODL is… American HODL. In this Bitcoin Whitepaper Day special, marking 17 years ...since Satoshi published the paper that changed the world, the three reflect on Bitcoin’s wild evolution from a fringe internet experiment to a $2 trillion, geopolitically relevant asset. We discuss how Bitcoin can free society from financial decay, why the future risks sliding into either communism or fascism, and why Bitcoiners must walk the narrow middle path to preserve individual sovereignty. We get into the Trojan horse of institutional adoption, the spiritual war at the heart of money, and what it means to build in an age of surveillance. THANKS TO OUR SPONSORS: IREN RIVER ANCHORWATCH BLOCKWARE LEDN BITKEY FOLLOW: Danny Knowles: https://x.com/\_DannyKnowles or https://primal.net/danny American HODL: https://x.com/americanhodl8 or https://primal.net/hodl Erik Cason: https://x.com/Erikcason or https://primal.net/erikcason Marty Bent: https://x.com/MartyBent or https://primal.net/marty

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:02 The root of the problem is that the money, how money's created and how it's distributed. Throughout the economy, it has externalities on everything. Bitcoin can be a means to an end, but it's how do you convince people that this is the right means to the right end? If you own Bitcoin and you have itself custody, it's yours. It's going to be your way out of this dystopian hellhole that's probably going to get produced. The point of uncensurable cypherpunk money is to be uncensurable and allow for anyone anywhere to use it for whatever they want. If you're worried about the state doing stuff,
Starting point is 00:00:36 like, get the fuck out of, like, I don't know what you're doing here. I don't understand why you're interested in this project. You should just kind of bluntly assume your favorite Bitcoin developer is probably an intelligence asset just because that's the model. If you're a bitcoiner who believes in freedom, like you have to tread lightly as you walk through the valley of the shadow of death because you are beset on all sides by a... on all sides by enemies.
Starting point is 00:01:05 Eric, Hoddle, Marty, good to see you guys. I thought I wanted to get a show out for Bitcoin White Paper Day, 17 years since the white paper dropped. This is going to go out on Friday. Mark, this is your first time on the show, though. Welcome, man. It's great to be here. I was on the previous iteration of what Bitcoin did, but never this one.
Starting point is 00:01:23 Yeah, we tried to make it work in Austin when I was there a few months ago, but here we are anyway. But 17 years since the white paper dropped, you guys have all been in Bitcoin for like a long time. Eric, I think probably you've been in the longest. I just want to get a bit of a reflection on this. Like when you look back at what Bitcoin's done over the last 17 years, like how do you take it in? It's gone from being like worth literally zero. You could get it free like a faucets and you could mine it on your home laptop to being like a two trillion dollar asset that's very sort of geopolitically relevant. How do you take all that in? Yeah, I remember when you used
Starting point is 00:01:58 to be able to get like a hundred of a Bitcoin from a faucet. Um, I mean, it's like I took acid and it never wore off. It's just like I'm like perpetually in this insane trip of a journey. And like it's super blessed and amazing. I mean, when I first discovered Bitcoin, there was very little outside of the Bitcoin talk forms that were available. Yeah. And it was like a bat shit crazy idea.
Starting point is 00:02:21 And it's funny because like I don't feel like there's as much of the like you like smoke, you like smoke the Bitcoin crack sort of effect that like people used to have. Because like some of the other. early psychopaths that I met, like, they would be like, yeah, like, when it clicked for me, like, I couldn't sleep for days on end. I, like, lost a bunch of weight. It was, you know, like, I really got what it was. And so now that it's, like, actually achieving what it set out to be, it's a very strange and ethereal journey, but I feel immensely blessed that I saw what it was, that it seems to be doing what we wanted to. And we're also at this very interesting
Starting point is 00:02:58 inflection point where it seems like banker Bitcoin and Suecoin, is actually giving like cypherpunk vision a bit of a run for its money at this point in time. So I don't know, like I feel really great about what it's accomplished, but I'm deeply concerned
Starting point is 00:03:16 about the lack of pedagogical approach about like the point of uncensurable cypherpunk money is to be uncensurable and allow for anyone, anywhere to use it for whatever they want in my class. That's technical purpose. And so seeing a lot of people just cheering on number go up repeatedly,
Starting point is 00:03:31 I do find a bit alarming. But with that being said, Bitcoin's magnitudes beyond anything I could have imagined in my wildest dreams. So, like, I feel deeply blessed that the vision is out there in the world and it offers a radical new kind of hope to most people. I'd just like to get back to sort of a lot of insane stuff that me and Hoddle first connected around. Like, in sort of the 2020, 2020, 2021 cycle where it was much more about, like, you know, the spiritual awakening of Bitcoin as opposed to that we're all just going to get rich and drive Ferraris. Do you think that's just like a consequence of scale though? And not everyone's going to get Bitcoin in that way.
Starting point is 00:04:09 Because like I'm with you. I got into Bitcoin later than you. But even when I did, like the from the day I first heard about Bitcoin, there's probably not been a single day since that I've not read about it, like tried to learn about it, want to go further and further down that rabbit hole. But like as this scale, not everyone's going to be like that. Yeah. And I do think that's part of the consequence.
Starting point is 00:04:26 I also think that like sort of the crazier, more radical voices are getting drowned out a bit. And like, I sort of think it's time for us to redouble into our own insane journey. Because like, my deepest frustration now when I talk to people, I'm like, oh, I'm a Bitcoin. And they're like, oh, crypto. I'm like, no, if you ever say that again, I'm going to smack it right here in your fucking mouth. And I'm very pedantic. I'm like, if you don't understand the difference between Bitcoin and crypto, you don't understand either. And you're going to get scammed for the latter as opposed to actually getting the true cause of what the former is. And like, so that Bitcoin has a real opportunity to free us from the endemic rot that,
Starting point is 00:05:01 is the Fiat system. And I'll drive people around me crazy by like constantly commenting on the societal ills that Fiat has created. And you can just see that metastasizing effect across society. And at this point in America, like I highly expect the next five years, it's fascism or communism. It's like one of the two choices. And that's just a result of a broken money system.
Starting point is 00:05:23 And it's really interesting to like watch America become like the Weimar remix of like 2030s. You know? And like, that's what we're going to get. And it's pretty scary because also, like, the communists have, like, a very strong argument now of, like, yeah, fuck it. Like, let's just seize the boomer's property redistribute it to the youth because, like, they fucked us over. We'll never fucking touch social security. We'll never get entitlements. They're just handing out willy-nilly Medicare to everyone except for the youth.
Starting point is 00:05:52 So, yeah, like, fuck it. Let's just have a full-on communist party. Start seizing wealth across the board. Start executing VCs. it'll work great. And at that point, that's when you get somebody in the far right being like, hey,
Starting point is 00:06:04 they're going to kill all you guys and you don't give me radical power. So you can either sign up here or get executed by the communists. Which one? This is funny you're bringing this up because this aligns very much in my early Bitcoin
Starting point is 00:06:21 story back in like 2013. I got pushed over the edge. I was like really into Bitcoin. It's funny. This is the Philadelphia Inquirer, headline from October 31st, 2008, when the white paper dropped, why we're here to meet this. I was 17 years old running around the streets of Philadelphia
Starting point is 00:06:38 after the Phillies won the World Series. Great financial crisis was happening. I went to college with anewyer enemy mentality, but to your point, Eric, what really pushed me over the edge is I worked for this Russian immigrant. He immigrated to the United States in the 90s. And I'll never forget this one portfolio management meeting we had. We sat down and ended up.
Starting point is 00:06:59 up just being me and him. His name was Dimitri. In the room, we were talking about TSA and civil liberties and stuff like that. And he typically, during our meetings, he would just look at his computer. He was a quants and he'd have all this stuff up. And he, like, turned from his computer and looked at me. When we were talking about the TSA, he was like, Marty, I want to tell you the story. The first time I immigrated here, I'll never forget in 1994, the first time I walked through an airport in the United States, I cried because I never felt that amount of freedom. And I want to warn you, as a young 22-year-old men that the U.S. is turning into the Soviet Russia, I ran away from. And that was in like 2013, maybe early 2014, and I was learning about Bitcoin at the time, but just reflecting on
Starting point is 00:07:42 America and not necessarily Bitcoin since then, like, yeah, it's definitely gone down that trajectory towards overt communism. And really why I went full bore into Bitcoin in the first place was like, this thing is separate from that. I need to focus my attention on that. this. Yeah. Just reflecting on the whole thing, like, I remember, you know, being deeply affected by the great financial crisis, just like Marty. I have a friend, Jenseth, who says that you didn't get to Bitcoin because you're so smart. You got here because you were a young man who had stupid ideas about the government, which I certainly embodied. I was, you know, in high school writing papers about like seesteading and things like that. And my daughter's working through. Hi, sweetie.
Starting point is 00:08:24 Can you go? Can you click the story? Thank you. And so anyway, I was ideologically predisposed to be a crazy libertarian person, and then you find Bitcoin and you're like, well, shit, here it is, the thing we've been waiting for. Like, we don't have to be loser libertarians anymore. We're going to be rich libertarians who, like, you know, affect the world in a positive way. And actually, like, maybe, you know, maybe we can get towards anarcho-capitalism because Bitcoin is solving a problem, right?
Starting point is 00:08:50 It's not just us complaining or doing rhetoric against the system. Like, we actually are solving a problem. And the problem is, like, people used to say in the early days of Bitcoin, it had no killer app. And it's like, the killer app is prosperity. You know, prosperity is the killer app. And every single person on earth wants that. And when you talk about this political fight that's happening now
Starting point is 00:09:08 between the commies and the fascist, and I was just listening to like, Fuentes on Tucker Carlson, and he throws in there as this like sort of casual aside that he admires Joseph Stalin. And it just gets brushed right by it. It's like, okay, both of these guys, the Luigi Mangione, left, the Groypers, everyone's an economic populist, and economic populism is rising.
Starting point is 00:09:31 And I think that we as the Bitcoiners are, like, which is weird because we're the people who are from the island of Misfit Toys, we're the weirdos. We are now occupying the sane, like, middle ground. Like, we are the rational center and saying, hey, guys, like, maybe it's not we need to kill all the immigrants, and maybe it's not we need to kill everybody with more than a million maybe it's we need a money that can't be corrupted and oh by the way we're a broad multi-diverse multiracial multi-ethnic multi-religious coalition of young people who have all seen a better brighter, orangeer future and like join us you know and that's that's crazy but it gets
Starting point is 00:10:14 less crazy every day less you know the alternative like the mainstream political alternatives are so much fucking crazier than what I just said like Magic internet money, join us. You know what I mean? A man in a stupid wizard hat. Like, that's way more sane than what's going on on the left or the right. What Bitcoin did is brought to you by the massive legends, Iron. The largest NASDAQ listed Bitcoin miner using 100% renewable energy.
Starting point is 00:10:42 Iron are not just powering the Bitcoin network. They're also providing cutting edge computing resources for AI, all backed by renewable energy. We've been working with their founders Dan and Will for quite some time now and have been really impressed with their values. especially their commitment to local communities and sustainable computing power. So whether you're interested in mining Bitcoin or harnessing AI compute power, Iron is setting the standard. Visit iron.com to learn more, which is iri-en.com. If you already self-custody of Bitcoin, you know the deal with hardware wallets, complex setups, clumsy interfaces, and a seed phrase that can be lost, stolen or forgotten.
Starting point is 00:11:16 Well, BitKee fixes that. BitKee's a multi-sig hardware wallet built by the team behind Square and Cash App. It packs a cryptographic recovery system and built-in inheritance feature into an intuitive, easy-to-use wallet with no seed phrase to sweat over. It's simple, secure self-custody without the stress, and time named Bitkey one of the best inventions of 2024. Get 20% off at Bitkey.world when you use the code WBD. That's B-I-T-K-E-Y. And use the code WBD. This episode is brought to you by Anchor Watch. The thing that keeps me up at night is the idea of a critical error with my Bitcoin cold store. And this is where Anchor Watch comes in. With Anchor Watch, your Bitcoin is insured with your own A-plus rated Lloyds of London insurance policy,
Starting point is 00:12:00 and all Bitcoin is held in their time-locked multi-sig vaults. So you have the peace of mind knowing your Bitcoin is insured while not giving up custody. So whether you're worried about inheritance planning, wrench attacks, natural disasters, or just your own silly mistakes, you're protected by Anchor Watch. Rates for fully insured custody start as low as 0.55% and are available for individual and commercial customers located in the US. in the US. Speak to Anchwatch for a quote and for more details about your security options and coverage. Visit anchorwatch.com today.
Starting point is 00:12:31 That is anchorwatch.com. Marty, I want to go back to something you said before. You were talking about the US basically trending towards Soviet Russia. If that's happening, the UK and Australia and other places around the world are definitely front running the US in that sense. Do you think Bitcoin can actually stop that? Or is Bitcoin just an opt-out so you don't have to be involved in it? I don't think Bitcoin in and of itself can really stop anything.
Starting point is 00:12:56 It's really up to individuals adopting Bitcoin and using it to stop it. And I think, obviously, the four of us here are pretty much well in our way to trying to do that. I think, Hottle, to your point, and I think it's the one thing I've been reflecting on a lot in the recent, in the last year, is, okay, like, how can we sharpen the messaging to really get into people? like you're saying, we have the crazy left and the crazy right, and they're all somehow missing that there's a third option or another option, maybe there's more than three with Bitcoin where the root of the problem is that the money, how money's created and how it's distributed throughout the economy.
Starting point is 00:13:40 It has externalities on everything we touch in the economy. It's like Bitcoin can be a means to an end, but it's how do you convince people that this is the right means to the right end? And that's something that I think a lot about these days. And Huddall, like you were saying that prosperity is the killer app. And that kind of goes against what Eric was saying, because you're basically saying number go up is the thing we need right now. So Bitcoin's get wealthy and can, I guess, change the world themselves.
Starting point is 00:14:09 Do you think we are sacrificing things for number go up right now? Yeah, there's a tension. I mean, listen, just to be honest, yeah, there's a tension between censorship resistance and number go up. And I've long had this sort of view that Bitcoin is going to have to walk through sort of a period of like, you know, purgatory, essentially, like that there's going to be like a shadow, you know, co-option of Bitcoin where it kind of looks like Bitcoin has been cucked and then Bitcoin explodes out the other side. Now, maybe that's like a defeatist viewpoint and people are like, oh, you can't give in because, you know, but I think that if you're thinking about these things as two super organisms like Bitcoin and the traditional financial system, I think Bitcoin is a pathogen that eats the host. And so I think if we put Bitcoin into the traditional financial system,
Starting point is 00:14:57 I think it will overtake the traditional financial system over time. And I don't know that the idea of Bitcoin being outside money is Bitcoin's ultimate destiny, because in order to get where it's going, it has to pass through the traditional system, I think. So, like, you know, you see this throughout history, like, Christianity subsumes Rome, and I think Bitcoin subsumes, like, the modern state, the fiat state.
Starting point is 00:15:20 And that's a long arduous journey that like, if you're a Bitcoiner who believes in freedom, like, you have to tread lightly as you walk through the valley of the shadow of death because you are beset on all sides by enemies. You know, that's just the way it is. We've chosen the hardest path on the table, basically. It's a lot easier to join up and say, I'm going to be a far right populist or I'm going to be a far left populist. You know, Bitcoiners are trying to walk the middle path and it's difficult. Yeah, I want to know what you think about that, right?
Starting point is 00:15:46 Because like with the way Bitcoin, people interact with Bitcoin. Now, it's like KYC, AML exchanges, there's like treasury companies, ETF, the institutionalization of Bitcoin. Like that is the area that I have like some concern. Not a great deal of concern in, but like some degree of concern it. Like do you think Bitcoin's strong enough to go through that and make out the other side, like Hoddle saying, or do you think we risk losing something along the way? Yeah, it's kind of interesting because like I feel like this is always the game Bitcoin's
Starting point is 00:16:14 playing with the Trojan horse thing. And so like I feel like we're at the place where like they've brought in the horse in the Troy, they've all had their great celebration. And I think like, now we essentially need to see a bunch of shit blow up internally inside of the financial system and watch kind of the general wealthy and elite flee to Bitcoin. And that's sort of them like opening the gates of Troy in fleeing. And then it's like, oh, look, the Aegeans are outside. With that being said, maybe like this is more onto us, as I felt back in like the 2021 era, I felt like we had a really strong narrative about how Bitcoin was going to fuck up this system and empower people.
Starting point is 00:16:51 But really, like, I kind of think, like, stealing from Lenin's playbook, like, we essentially need a deep class consciousness awakening, and there needs to be a pedagogical approach that explains how fiat money has destroyed society, because I find it very interesting that everyone sees how absolutely fucked up everything is. And usually they take a right-left paradigm in order to describe that. And like, particularly being here and like the liberal hub
Starting point is 00:17:17 of the world, like, I'm extremely pedantic with my liberal friends about like, you, like, we have this like,
Starting point is 00:17:22 no king's bullshit going on here about, like, Trump trying to, like, do gerrymandering. And I'm just like, how,
Starting point is 00:17:28 like, come on, like, how much of a bozo do you have to be to see it? Like, they're doing gerrymandering
Starting point is 00:17:33 for the left and that somebody like Nancy Pelosi is now worth $100 million dollars despite being a career politician. Like, you don't think that that is
Starting point is 00:17:41 from pure and utter corruption and not like at least people like Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos are being direct about how they want to make money. Like Nancy Pelosi is a pure parasite in so far that she literally engages in insider trading, robs the American public by making backdoor deals with some of the most disgusting people and ideas that there could be. And yet somehow you find yourself cheering for her and her side. You really need to look deeper into what's going on if you actually want to liberate yourself. And I have a great answer for you, but it's going to require some real thought on your part and really actually wondering whether or not you've become a useful idiot for people that hate you and want to abuse you and steal from you because I do have an answer.
Starting point is 00:18:26 But it's going to require you to do some real thought and actually start in the process of unwinding the very deep brainwashing that most people have gone through. And some people receive it. Some people don't. But at the end of the day, like, and this is why I've kind of lightly. flirted with the idea about an orange party is that like my idea is we essentially need a radical central orange party that's in the middle that advocates for these very middle of the road normal things and in the process needs that absolutely fucking lamb blast anybody on the right or left and be like the democrats and the republicans are the enemies they've destroyed our fucking country and when we
Starting point is 00:19:03 come to power every single federal representative will be put on trial for treason and when they're found guilty they will be hung according to american law Because that's what they did. They engaged in outright fucking treason. They never expected themselves to be held accountable. And I want to see them hung from public gallows when it becomes very clear that they sold us up the street to the Chinese for like, what, $20,000 maybe? Like that's the other thing that's outrageous is the amount of money that they're prostituting us for is fucking pennies on the dollar. And with that being said, this establishment is so corrupt.
Starting point is 00:19:38 I don't see why we can't just ram through state legislatures because what? to buy something to pass any state legislature. It's going to cost maybe $50,000 to get converts on the right side. And as you popularize a movement like this, you just strong arm everybody because it's clear that these geriatrics are completely spineless individuals. That the moment that you start putting real pressure on them and being very clear that this is the direction it's going and this isn't about money anymore. This is actually about whether or not they're going to live at the end of this. Yeah, they'll collapse. But again, this is a very radical viewpoint that I'm establishing.
Starting point is 00:20:16 So if anybody wants to take this and run with it, please feel free. I don't think it needed that disclaimer. But what kind of legislated do you want to push through? Because you're the anarchist. Like, why do you want this to go through sort of the government rails? Excellent question. I wanted to go through state government rails because in the United States, we have the ability to amend the Constitution using state legislations alone.
Starting point is 00:20:38 There's been a number of amendments to the U.S. Constitution that have gotten pretty close. And I'm pretty sure the only amendment that was actually pushed through, through this methodology was to repeal the amendment for prohibition. And so essentially the idea is that if you can get 35 state legislatures to pass an amendment to the United States Constitution using the slang the language, that's supposed to just be added to the Constitution directly and unilaterally. And this was explicitly explained in the Federalist Papers as a way for the American public to be able to reclaim the republic when the federal, when the federal government has become entirely corrupt, which I think that's the place that we're at. And so it's a very, it's a, it's a radically different
Starting point is 00:21:21 strategy that sort of tries to lateralize states to reclaim their ability to, to essentially prove their sovereignty through amending the constitution without any sort of federal representatives whatsoever. Again, this is like kind of a hairbrain idea. I don't really want to run this down because like, I'm not a politician and I don't really want to get shot at this. age. Although, yeah, like, maybe I'm due for a young death anyway. So, like, maybe we should just run this down anyways. But what do you want added to the Constitution? First one is just like unilateral destruction of the Federal Reserve. Just like the Federal Reserve does not get the issue of the dollar anymore, done. And, like, with that, it's amended
Starting point is 00:22:00 the Constitution. And the interesting thing is, like, this causes a constitutional crisis. Because it's not like a federal government's just going to be like, oh, no, they amended the Constitution with Article 5. Like, gee golly dang, you know, in addition to like, if you get that method to work, keep going. It's like, you know, the United States federal government has no right to tax anyone anymore. Or like the IRS is just an illegal institution that needs to be outright liquidated today. Like, you know, let your mind go crazy because there's no reason why we can't just use amendments directly as a way to essentially have a publicist to be able to pass laws against the federal government. And again, super radical idea would definitely cause a constitutional crisis, would probably get me killed in the process, but fuck it.
Starting point is 00:22:47 We're all going to die at this point in time if communists comes along, so I'd rather get shot and starve to death. I love that whenever you speak to Eric, this is about reflecting on 17 years of Bitcoin, it took us, what, 20 minutes to get into hanging all the politicians. Well, look, I want to only do it if they have actually been found guilty of treason. All I'm saying is let's actually uphold the laws that have been established. There will be due process. And I think if we looked in the- It's not French Revolution. It's due process.
Starting point is 00:23:15 Exactly. And it's very important that state governments all handle this on their own. So I'd expect that the representatives of each individual state in addition to their senators, you know, so I would want Wyoming to put their senators on trial. And if it turns out that their senators hadn't broken the law, excellent. They don't get hung. Turns out that if, you know, some of the representatives in California, California that took COVID money and never paid it back, had broke the law, well, hey,
Starting point is 00:23:40 that they need to be held accountable for. But to me, like, again, and it is ironic that as the anarchists, that like I'm the one representing the rule of law more than anybody else is just kind of the irony of the entirety of this thing. A very fact that we're talking about magic internet money is supposed to be a thing that returns us to sane economic prerogatives in the world is, well, that's where we're at in the narrative. So here we are.
Starting point is 00:24:03 And you brought up the No Kings protest. I've very intentionally just ignored everything that's been going on with that because I don't need to pay attention to that. But can one of you fill me in? Like, how big has that been over there? Not that big. It's, it seems like it's astro-turfed, honestly. It seems kind of fake. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:24:21 I've seen some people hanging out at, like, again, because I live in, like, the heart of liberal Macca. Like, I see some people standing out on the corners with their signs congratulating themselves for participating in democracy. But I'm just, like, super confused because. Because wasn't Donald Trump, like, elected through the Democratic process? So, and, like, furthermore, like, I don't know of a lot of kings that, like, served for one term and then, like, left afterwards and reelected. And so, I don't know. There's, like, a weird brain virus going on because, like, I don't actually hear, I mean,
Starting point is 00:24:53 like, of the two Republicans that I know in the area, like, they don't talk about Trump incessantly. Whereas, like, the liberals that I know, they're always like, that piece of shit, Trump, and he's destroying America with his fascism. And I'm like, do you, like, do you know what this word means? Because, like, I think you're using a lot of words that you don't understand.
Starting point is 00:25:13 They're like, yeah, like, fascism's where the bad guy wins. And I'm like, no, I think that there's maybe a deeper consequence. Because I always insist to people, like, the problem with calling Trump a fascist, like he's not principled enough to be a fascist. Like, if it was a fascist,
Starting point is 00:25:28 like, I'm pretty sure we'd see a lot more people in prison and getting murdered exjudiciously. So I don't know. That's just my standpoint with it. But yeah, I do feel like this is astroturfed. And it's, I don't know, this is all bullshit. It's this left right thing to divide us instead of us to be like, hey, like the cost of groceries has gone up 50% in the last five years. Like that seems to be fucking all of us pretty equally except for this political class.
Starting point is 00:25:56 That's pretty strange, huh? Hmm. Just to bring it back to Bitcoin for a minute. Like, we've done 965 shows or something about all the wins that Bitcoin has had. But is there anything that you think we're not doing well enough? Maybe we'll start with you, Mai. Getting to the youth. I was going to say, Eric, while you're talking about that,
Starting point is 00:26:16 like, not only we stuck in the middle with you with red and blue, but I think it's like boomers and Gen Z. It's like, I feel like there's a cohort of millennial. Obviously, not every millennial is in the Bitcoin, but I think we're overrepresented within people that have adopted Bitcoin. And the boomers are just old dogs. We're not going to teach an old dog, new trick. And then the zoomers are just completely nihilistic and running towards the wrong fake idols,
Starting point is 00:26:49 if you will. And it's like, how do we? That's one thing. Again, I've been thinking about. We had a whole Zoomer series on RHR. I remember the one when I was in Austin early this year, Mark, we were talking about this, because I think the demographics for our shows
Starting point is 00:27:03 are probably pretty similar. And like the boomers, I've actually seen that growing. Like, I do see a sort of growing cohort there, but in terms of sort of Gen Z, there's almost no one listens to the show. I don't know whether that's because it's like long-form content. People prefer different types of media.
Starting point is 00:27:18 But like, how do you reach those people? I don't know. I'm looking at my demo right now. Core demo is 35 to 44 at 25%. the next is 45 to 54, 24, and then it's 55 to 64, and then it's 65 plus, and then it drops down to 2534. So it's not even millennials in my age, which is crazy. I don't know if it's the type of content we do,
Starting point is 00:27:41 but I'm sure yours is similar for some reason. Yeah, is. The zoomers who are arguably the most important cohort for us to go out and convert to recognizing this third way of doing things or just not getting this information from what I can tell. I do wonder though, because when I got into Bitcoin, I didn't have very much money at all. And Bitcoin seemed expensive then, and like relatively it was obviously not.
Starting point is 00:28:04 Like, do you think that's just unit bias that like, how can I, you know, gain from this thing when I can just go and like punt on meme stocks or whatever? I think we're just living in a completely different world. I've come to realize this like in the last three years. Like I don't get zoom or culture at all. No, I got that. Six seven or something like that. Six seven. The first one is I don't have no idea what it is.
Starting point is 00:28:25 and apparently it's the biggest thing. Yeah, I've never even heard of that. Maybe I don't. I think the thing that's hard as a millennial to understand about Zoomers is that just how pronounced denialism is. I think, like, we all go on Twitter
Starting point is 00:28:41 and we're like, oh, my God, things are just getting worse every day. But we still have this sort of inherent, like, boomer utopianism because we were, like, real optimism because we were raised by the boomers. And so we kind of think that, I don't know, things are pretty shit, But I think we can pull it out.
Starting point is 00:28:57 Maybe we can make it work. And so Bitcoin is a, you know, it's a philosophy of rational optimism because you're basically saying, like, I have a future and I'm going to plan for my future. And I'm going to do that with Bitcoin. But if you've totally swallowed the black pill, then you're basically saying, like, I'm waiting for the revolution. And if the revolution never comes, I'll just kill myself.
Starting point is 00:29:21 And I think, unfortunately, that's what's going on with a lot of people in the Gen Z demographic. And what I would say to them is basically like, listen, the generational divide, whatever, millennials are cringe, yeah, of course, we're crunch. That's our thing, dog. You guys need to care about yourself, and you need to, like, start making some plans
Starting point is 00:29:38 because you do have a future. No matter what happens, the world gets really bad, the world goes dark, whatever. It's like, the sun is still going to come up, and people are still going to go to work, and people are still going to raise their families. Like, you have a future, and so you need to plan accordingly
Starting point is 00:29:52 as if you have a future, And you need to do that in a rationally optimistic way, I think with Bitcoin. But like in all aspects of your life, you should plan that you're gonna be here in the next 10 years because the people that aren't, that don't plan to be here, they end up in woeful circumstance. They're still here.
Starting point is 00:30:10 They're still here 10, 20, 30 years from now. And they end up in just these awful circumstances with just these miserable lives. And you don't want that to be you. I mean, to be fair to like steal in the black pill argument. Like it's like really strong. It kind of reminds me like the fish parable, but darkness. It's like, hey, kids, like, how's the light today?
Starting point is 00:30:29 And like, you know, the fish swim in fact, they're like, what's light? You know, because like, like, look at the demographics and the statistics that, like, they grew up with a generation of parents who, like, already believed, like, the climate crisis dumerism. AI Dumerism, like, I'm in the heart of AI. Like, it's fucking bananas that, like, I don't think I've met a single person. Well, there's one guy, but outside of him, I don't think I've met a single AI person. that like has a non black filled version.
Starting point is 00:30:57 So like AI is going to murder everybody anyways. Like the politics are completely fucked across the board. The idea of them living out of their parents' basement is a distant dream. You know, the idea of just getting a room in the house and not living in the basement is like a dream. So like they have a pretty strong argument for like, why should I give a fuck about myself or the future? Because it's not going to come.
Starting point is 00:31:20 And this is one of the places where like that's why I think that like insane communism works because it's like, hey, if you join my communist party, we're just going to kill the boomers and steal their shit and redistribute their housing to you. So, would you like to take up arms for the great communist cause? I'm like, that's like a pretty appealing thing at this point in time. And it's fucking terrifying. And I wish that this would actually get the boomers to the table in a meaningful way to go, oh yeah, we did actually fuck everything up, rewarded ourselves and then sold our children down the river. And now our grandchildren are going to murder us for that. you know, like that, that seems to be like a probabilistical outcome.
Starting point is 00:31:57 And the thing that that I find deeply resentful of is that like when, at least in my case, when this has been presented to boomers, you kind of just get a shrug. And they're kind of like, eh, like, I'm 10 feet out from the grave anyway. Like, don't care. Yeah. And so like, in all honesty, like, again, I think this brings it back to us and our demographic. And like, it kind of sucks to admit it. But like, I think we just have to actually do something.
Starting point is 00:32:23 something, even though I'm like pretty resistant to it. And like, this is absolutely idiotic that it's like magic internet money is here to save everybody from the nihilistic hellhole that the world is becoming. But this seems to be the narrative that we're on the course for. So I guess let's just get it done before it gets fucking harder. I do think like when you talk about we're going to move to either communism or fascism. Like the communist outcome is really easy to predict, especially with AI. IAA. Like you can see UBI is almost. most like baked in the cake at this point to me. I don't understand how we can have anything else. Do you think that's the most likely outcome here? No, I think the fascist outcome is the most likely
Starting point is 00:33:03 outcome. Yeah, I agree with that. Yeah, because the surveillance state has already been built, and it works whether you're a communist, you know, oligarchy or a fascist dictator. And I think that the call to, you know, restoring Western society to what it once was, because, you know, many of the people alive have seen it deteriorate, I think it's going to be a pretty strong call, and all you need is a, you know, a charismatic, you know, dictator type to come and say he's going to fix everything.
Starting point is 00:33:33 And a lot of people who are otherwise normal, hardworking, conservative, you know, family people will have this, the opposite brainworm of the communist brainworm and say to themselves, well, I do want things to go back to normal. So let's grant this guy unlimited power. And that is, you know, the road to hell. But if you're, if you're staring down two forks in the road
Starting point is 00:33:57 and they're both the road to hell, that's the road to hell that's more comfortable and easier to take, I think, for the vast majority of Western people. Well, and to be very clear that, like, fascism was an explicit development as a counter-communist movement. Right. Like, Mussolini was an anarchist before he created the fascist movement. And like that's part of the reasoning is when he saw what communism was doing after,
Starting point is 00:34:26 uh, I'm trying to remember the Italian movement that got, uh, that got communism in power in Italy. And he saw the sort of damage it was doing the culture. It's only after that that the fascist movement sort of gained steam. In addition to like, we're just talking about variants of socialism. Fascism is literally a brand of nationalized socialism. And, and like this is one of the main dividing things that a lot of people don't understand as something that sets socialism apart from communism, is that socialism is just a nationalized brand, whereas international socialism is communist. And so it's like, through that methodology, you get to be like, oh, Americanism is an actual special cultural thing.
Starting point is 00:35:04 We do need to kick all the immigrants out. Like, that's something that we need to protect as a national identity for ourselves. Whereas communism is just like no borders. Everybody can participate equally. We're going to seize the means of production and redistribute it because that worked out super well in the 20th century and nobody was ever harmed from it. In addition to like, fascism died a death in an early grave,
Starting point is 00:35:25 so it's kind of a general spooky name. Like we haven't outside of, because also I'd make the argument that stuff like Francoism, what we saw in Portugal and all the stuff that we saw in Latin America, like I don't think, I think those were authoritarian movements as opposed to fascist ones. This is highly debatable, but like I think fascism is still an open-ended question,
Starting point is 00:35:46 particularly here in America. Yeah, and essentially, like, as the communist rise into power, it seems that it'll have great appeal because instead of me needing to appeal to all of the masses, you essentially go to three dozen billionaire tech founders and you say, give me the fucking power, people are going to kill you. And they'll go, yeah, that sounds good. Do you wish you could access cash without selling your Bitcoin? Well, Leeder makes that possible. They're the global leader in Bitcoin-backed lending, and since 2018, they've issued over $9 billion in loans with a perfect record of protection. and client assets. With Leiden, you get full-costly loans with no credit checks or monthly repayments, just easy access to dollars without selling a single SAT. As of July 1st, Leiden is Bitcoin
Starting point is 00:36:29 only, meaning they exclusively offer Bitcoin-backed loans with all collateral held by Leiden directly or their funding partners. Your Bitcoin is never lent out to generate interest. I recently took out a loan with Leiden. The whole process was super easy. The application took me less than 15 minutes, and in a few hours I had the dollars in my account. It was really smooth. So if you need cash but you don't want to sell Bitcoin, head over to leaden.com, forward slash WBD and you'll get 0.25% off your first loan.
Starting point is 00:36:58 That's ledden.com. This episode is brought to you by River and they've just launched a very cool new product where you can automatically buy every price dip. Their zero fee recurring buys are a proven way to build wealth with Bitcoin and you can now supercharge them and buy up to 100% more Bitcoin
Starting point is 00:37:15 if the price is dipping at the time of your order. It's a great tool to buy more Bitcoin at lower prices, and while your cash is waiting to be deployed, you earn 3.75% interest on it paid in Bitcoin. River is built to last with security at its core, and is the only Bitcoin exchange in the US with proof of reserves. To open an account, go to river.com forward slash WBD and earn up to $100 in Bitcoin when you buy.
Starting point is 00:37:39 That's river.com forward slash WBD. What if you could lower your tax bill and stack Bitcoin at the same time? Well, by mining Bitcoin with Blockware, you can. New tax guidelines from the Big Beautiful Bill allow American miners to write off 100% of the cost of their mining hardware in a single tax year. That's right, 100% write off. So if you have $100,000 in capital gains or income, you can purchase $100,000 of miners and offset it entirely.
Starting point is 00:38:06 Blockware's mining as a service enables you to start mining Bitcoin right now without lifting a finger. Blockware handles everything from securing the miners to sourcing low-cost power to configuring the pool, they do it all. You get to stack Bitcoin at a discount every single day while also saving big come tax season. Get started today by going to mining.blockwresolutions.com forward slash WBD. Of course, none of this is tax advice. Speak to your accountant or tax advisor to understand how these rules apply to you and then head over to mining.blogwresolutions.com forward slash WBD
Starting point is 00:38:38 and you'll get one week of free hosting and electricity with each hosted minor purchased. It almost sounds like you're saying fascism is a good way out of this. I don't want to say it's a good way out. I mean, like, it's like the fucking trolley problem. Like these are both horrible outcomes, you know, but also like, you know, it would have been great. We'd been great if our grandparents didn't sell us up the fucking river and end for the convertibility of gold and completely fuck up the entirety of the financial system
Starting point is 00:39:07 so that when we're sitting here talking about the fact that Zoomers could actually own homes instead of it being a distant dream. It could be a possibility. So again, it sucks, but same thing with the trolley problem. You wish that one dumbass wasn't standing on the track versus four, but either way, you're going to have to break some eggs to fix this problem. I think about this quite a lot, Eric. And to me, it's like I really do think the thing I said earlier about us walking the middle path
Starting point is 00:39:38 is kind of the arduous journey that we have set ourselves upon. You know, we didn't do that initially, but like, that's just where we find ourselves. And I do think that it is going to be a cohort of, you know, millennial-aged men who believe in freedom that are going to be the most significant players in the fourth turning. And I think it's, you know, it's easy to look at what's going on. like get riled up and kind of like join aside. Like, you know, I'm with the fascist. I'm with the cops.
Starting point is 00:40:16 And I just, I think that's just not what we should be doing. I think Bitcoiners need to continue to walk the middle path and, you know, knowing that it's the most dangerous path, but it's, it has the best outcomes. And so that's why you have to walk it, you know. To recuse myself, I 100% agree with you. I also do think it is absolutely the most difficult path, the most challenging path, and one that's just going to take a lot of difficult and hard work. But the more and more that I spend time here kind of running this down,
Starting point is 00:40:51 the more and more that it's actually pretty essential, but it's also like, who does this? How does it form? How does it get pushed forward? And, you know, the last time when we talked about the Charlie Kirk assassination, like he was making massive inroads with the youth and the way that he was starting to direct kind of a new political vision. So I guess we kind of need something like that for Bitcoin, but I don't know, maybe even
Starting point is 00:41:15 a wider view of that like, I guess we sort of just need a third party and it just needs to start being a mass political movement that like this is not about right or left, but it's really just about like we need to get a sane money system that isn't biased towards politics anymore. And Bitcoin's that actual answer. Well, doesn't even need to be a political moment, a political movement should just be social. right because this is what i think a lot about is like the sly roundabout way to take money out of the hands of the government and that's the one thing particularly when it comes to right versus left
Starting point is 00:41:48 red versus blue and even the introduction of a third party and so is solving these problems by political means are you ultimately going to end up with communism versus fascism or can we do our part in the free market um as bitquiners to convince enough critical mass of people to adopt Bitcoin and integrate it into their lives where they're able to save themselves instead of trying to work through the political apparatus to try and force the politicians to save them. And this is why, I mean, to sprinkle in some white pills here,
Starting point is 00:42:25 that's what's like really encouraging to see Square release, like, Bitcoin for small businesses, their point of sales systems. It's great to see, I mean, to your point, to your point, Eric, a big problem for Zoomers specifically I think cornerstone, literally the base layer of Maslow's hierarchy needs to shelter. And people don't think they can buy homes. So introducing Bitcoin is collateral and mortgages.
Starting point is 00:42:52 In very early days, we can squint and see if it takes off, like, people, particularly boomers and people that have houses right now, can begin to care less about the equity value of their houses and really just let the equity value of the Bitcoin do the work and sell the price. properties off at a cheaper value to people who need it. And I think it's just trying to get Bitcoin stuffed in as many nooks and crannies of the academy as possible, as quickly as possible. Yeah, that's the white pill on the Sue Coiner narrative as well, right? Is that it creates alignment between people who are non-Bitcoiners and Bitcoiners.
Starting point is 00:43:31 So we, you know, the original Citadel Post is like talking about how like the world is horrible outside the Citadel and Bitcoiners live in the Citadel and everything is, you know, fine in the Citadel or whatever. Like, that's not a world you want to live in because you're under siege every day. Like, you don't want to be under siege every day. You want to live in a good world where your neighbors are prosperous as well. And so I think that, you know, when we look at like the stuff that's going on with treasury companies, for instance, that's embedding a lot of Bitcoin in the public markets.
Starting point is 00:44:00 And as those, you know, they make their way into the Q's and they make their way into the SEP 500, you know, these different Treasury cos. more people have more exposure to Bitcoin. And so if Bitcoin is demonetizing fiat currency, well, you know, like there's 166 million Americans who are going to have, you know, exposure to that via broad market index funds. And like, that's not a bad thing.
Starting point is 00:44:22 Like, it's a bad thing for Bitcoin's maybe political goals and aspirations, but it's not a bad thing in terms of alignment with our fellow citizens. It's a way to orange pill people without them even knowing they've been orange pill, essentially. And I think that that is a, you know, it's a silver lining. It's a bright spot. It's not purely negative in my view. I agree it's not purely negative, but there are like negative externalities from that in the sense that people are actually owning Bitcoin.
Starting point is 00:44:51 There's a massive centralization of coins. Like, Marty, I've not really heard you talk about the treasury company stuff. What's your take on it? A bit nuanced. I think it's my, like the pure play Bitcoin treasury companies that are just going public to accumulate as much Bitcoin as possible. Like, I've said this many times on RHR over the last year. I think it's going to be a Pareto distribution.
Starting point is 00:45:13 I think it's a success. I think it's an economy's a scale game if you're trying to weaponize capital markets. So I think the pure play Bitcoin treasury companies, there will be maybe five that actually get significant market share to sustain themselves in a long time. And I think they're certainly interesting. I mean, it's hard not to find interest in them considering what strategy is done specifically,
Starting point is 00:45:40 but what I'm more focused on is the operating businesses. Again, like leaning back on squares implementation of Bitcoin and the point of sales systems. And I don't think it's going to be, I think the predominant use case of that is people, merchants that become Bitcoiners are sweeping funds into Bitcoin automatically. I don't think like paying with Bitcoin, a POS system is really going to expand beyond sort of our circle for a few years, but the ability to get small and medium-sized businesses onto a Bitcoin standard.
Starting point is 00:46:11 It's going to be massive. Yeah, Treasury companies are a distraction to a degree in both directions. Like, one, people focus on number go up and you have, like, the master Norse and all the stock influencers popping up and really trying to drive people towards that. But then I think in the other direction, too,
Starting point is 00:46:33 people saying, like, oh, Bitcoin's distracted, did like number go-ups, all that cares. If you pay attention, I wrote about it last night in the newsletter. Some dude with six bit axes and an Avalon Q, mined a block by himself. He was self-hosting a node, self-hosting his own pool instance,
Starting point is 00:46:48 and running his computers in his living room and mined a Bitcoin block and contributed to a $2.5 trillion dollar monetary network. That's mind-blowing. Like that cypherpunk ethos is not only still alive, it's still possible, which is the most important thing. And the other things, like, you look at arc launching, cashew and fetidment, sort of e-cashments,
Starting point is 00:47:10 becoming more mature. I think while number go up, particularly in the context of Bitcoin treasury companies and the narratives around Saylor and others, doing that play is a distraction to an extent, but not only a distraction for people enamored by number go up, but by regulators and suits, we're like, oh, we've successfully cucked Bitcoin,
Starting point is 00:47:33 but I think the cyphor punk movement within Bitcoin is more alive than it has been in many years, particularly with these second layer solutions focused on privacy. I think that guy who mined a block with is bitax is fucking awesome. Like, minor centralization has been one of the things that, I guess, it's been a big concern of a lot of people for quite a while now. Do you think the tide is kind of turning there, Marty, with things like the heat punk stuff, like bit axes, like all that, like datum and stratum, all that stuff? Definitely. I mean, and it's, I think it's twofold. It's that you have this energy and focus in the open source mining community, both on the hardware or on the hardware, firmware, software, pool. Like, there's definitely a critical mass of people focused on building out those capabilities for people. But then the second fold thing is, like, we're reaching ASIC modification. So these use cases actually are viable now. It's much easier to do them.
Starting point is 00:48:31 in a somewhat economic way, they're not all going to be profitable. But we're getting closer to the point where you can integrate Bitcoin miners at home pretty easily. And many people may be able to do it profitably depending on where they live and how they're using the heat.
Starting point is 00:48:47 And I think it's trending in the right direction. I think I would not be surprised we look back and mining centralization, like peak mining centralization, was at some point before this date. I think the emergence of Proto, who knows how they're performed, but I think this at-home mining trend and theme that we'll be seeing grown over the last three years specifically is only getting stronger. And I've talked to Tyler Stevens from Exergy and there's many others.
Starting point is 00:49:17 I will not be surprised if sort of commercial Bitcoin mining being used as waste heat for industrial purposes becomes mainstream in the next decade. and that helps to distribute hash rate ownership, distribute hash rate geographically. Then most importantly, with the pool software, being open source and it becoming easier to self-host your own node and your own pool instance and reliably mine a block if you find a hash in your living room to your self-hosted node, like that's going to be massive for the network.
Starting point is 00:49:52 Yeah, I mean, if we get to a world where people are using Bitcoin for their mortgages, he in the houses using Bitcoin mining, like that seems like a very positive, like insanely positive place to be. But like all of this comes down to adoption. Like from everything all of you guys have said, like, Eric, this is how we stop the world turning to like fascism or communism. Like do you think all the infighting that's happening in Bitcoin is basically just like people playing silly games when there's way more important stuff to be doing?
Starting point is 00:50:20 I totally think so. You know, I'm like I think, I mean the fact that Op Return is the thing that we're debating about so heavily as opposed to something like op-cat or something goes to show like how how little technical information is actually out there how much this widow echo chamber is like its own thing and additional like i just want to echo marty's sentiment of giving a little bit of my own white pill that like it's interesting because like cypherpunks inherently like can't be loud so even though like that has generated its own sort of critical mass of movement like they're sort of silent individuals. So I've been surprised at the number of people that will pop up on the radar
Starting point is 00:50:59 who are doing really cool and interesting stuff, but like they don't make any noise simply because like that's sort of how they move. It's like a really positive thing. So like ultimately like I think while I can get quite nihilistic about this political front, like we've made huge inroads. In addition to the idea of that like using Bitcoin's heat, like that's always going achieve a larger economic efficiency than just outright mining Bitcoin. So like at some point, we move in that direction in addition to like what happens when we've become efficient enough with this stuff that like you can find a place up in northern Alaska that's like, hey, everybody just gets free energy and eat here because of the way that we've set up the infrastructure of this new
Starting point is 00:51:40 city that's going to provide all these new different services. You know, and like that's, that's kind of one of the places I ultimately think the greatest affect is going to be had is like what happens when we actually make massive infrastructural changes towards like the way that mining decentralization occurs and also like how we're going to innovate around this. So like ultimately like, you know, the old nomad of like everything's good for Bitcoin. So I think like as things move in a direction and as the general world sort of becomes darker and more nihilistic, that lets the light of Bitcoin sort of shine all the brighter
Starting point is 00:52:15 in that darkness. And as it pertains to like the infighting. with Bitcoin, within Bitcoin about opereturn, I don't think anybody outside of the Twitter or Noster bubbles is seeing any of that, nor do they care, nor should they, because it's noise. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:52:31 In terms of distracting us from actually working on more worthwhile endeavors, I think that's certainly happening, at least to some people. I know you said you wanted to talk about, my whole, I've tried my hardest over the last six months. I did the live stream at Bitcoin Plus Plus in Austin
Starting point is 00:52:48 in May for two days, did eight hours of content on the subject and then after that I was like, I think the best move is just to not talk about this and suck the oxygen out of the conversation because it's so idiotic in my mind. Yeah. But so I do, like, I've done shows on it. So I've not done the same thing as you there. But like, I understand why you want to kind of ignore it in a sense that like maybe it is just people on Twitter that care about it. But the number of people that are getting sort of riled up about this is it's quite large.
Starting point is 00:53:20 I think there's definitely some sort of bots and some sort of fake signal in there. But like people are getting very angry. And now there's this like new proposed soft fork, which is, I mean, for anyone who's not been paying attention, like good on you. But it's basically like a temporary soft fork to mitigate spam. And like this actually does worry me. I'm going to pull up a tweet because this summed it up way better than I could. So BitPain tweeted the other day. It's this last bit here that I thought was really good.
Starting point is 00:53:49 He said, once you grant the state that you can take efforts to mitigate the illicit material, they'll start demanding it, including for monetary transactions they don't like. And if you've accepted that you have a community-wide moral imperative to censor, you don't have a like to stand on. Like, that is my fear in this, is that, like, this is getting serious sort of traction from a subset of Bitcoiners, and, like, what are the implications of us doing something about it? I don't think they're going to be able to solve for you. Like, I don't think you need to convince a lot of people to do it.
Starting point is 00:54:17 And I guess my going back to the operative debate, this is all I'll say, I'll throw it to Eric, but like it's consensus valid. Like it's, it's like, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's, it's consensus valid. Like, I don't know what we're fighting about over here. It's within Bitcoin's consensus rules. And tonight said I didn't get to just have my outburst there because I probably
Starting point is 00:54:38 would have gone on a totally unhinged rant. Um, look like, look like if you're worried about the state doing stuff, like get the fuck out of, like, I don't know. know what you're doing here. I don't understand why you're interested in this project. Like, when I got involved, there was nobody in the state that paid any attention to it, nor could they stop it. Like the thing that was happening was the Silk Road. And like it did that and it did it fucking well and that it massively improved people's access to being able to get illegal substances and other things. Like if you're worried about your Bitcoin node running and having
Starting point is 00:55:14 the state come kick down in your door, you should probably think about ripple. That's probably the right answer for you and what you want. You know, they're going to comply with the state. They're really interested in regulation. Like, you should go check out that project. If you're interested in uncensurable money that you can use right now to send people in Gaza
Starting point is 00:55:32 money if you want, or help people escape from North Korea or do whatever the fuck you want, you should stay here. And also, like, this is the one that upsets me the most, is that, like, you should really think very hard about if you're advocating very strongly for one of these sides, why it is all of the highly technical people seem to be on one side of the debate.
Starting point is 00:55:54 I'm not saying that that's necessarily the right argument, because from the very beginning of this whole fucking shit show, me and Steve Lee had a great dialogue with each other where all is like, this shit isn't going to go away, and it's going to bite everybody in the ass. And the big problem is because everyone's talking past each other. The tech bros are trying to tech explain to all of the plebs, and the plebs are trying to explain in their particular way in methodology of why they feel totally disrespected and like what tech explaining
Starting point is 00:56:21 is that it's not something that lands for them. But unfortunately we've all been talking past each other at this point in time and meanwhile the state is trying to pass all kinds of fucked up regulations to make it so that we can't actually have self-ownership of our wallets. Like there's a real fucking crisis going on
Starting point is 00:56:39 and it's not op return and you should really ask yourself if you're being a useful idiot within this dialogue or if you're doing something useful. I would really like to see a lot more people take a couple step back and go, maybe there's something I'm missing here because I sure as fuck don't know everything.
Starting point is 00:56:56 And perhaps there are other people that both have more technical expertise than me. And for those that do have the technical expertise, I implore you to actually have somewhat respect for other individuals that are involved in Bitcoin and maybe they don't have the technical acumas you do, but they have still meaningfully participate. participated in the success of Bitcoin.
Starting point is 00:57:17 So with that being said, I hope everybody can shut the fuck up for a little while and take a moment to listen to each other and stop being such goddamn assholes to each other. Because that's the biggest thing that's upsetting me the most is that like we can totally disagree. We can totally have respectful dialogue. And when you're calling people fucking idiots or morons or diff shits or fuck faces, you're really doing yourself a disservice and actually furthering the dialogue in a meaningful way. Oh, but you get to look cool on Twitter. So maybe you should continue with that bullshit. So that was actually like a pretty hinged rant, actually. I don't think I actually totally flew off the can there.
Starting point is 00:57:56 Why do you think this has like captured so many people's imagination huddle? You know, uh, is it people trying to feel like they're important to big. I know what you're thinking. I, you know, I think it's a larp of people that miss the block size of war and want to feel that they are contributing to Bitcoin, you know. And like, I'm not even saying that from the perspective of somebody who was like, you know, a key player in the block size war. I was a nobody. I was a new. I was confused during the block size war.
Starting point is 00:58:24 I didn't make any meaningful contributions. I found myself on the wrong side of the block size war like half the time and I didn't get on the right side until the very end. So, like, you know, these extremely technical arguments are usually at core ideological in some way. And I feel like there's this weird desire in Bitcoin to recapitulate the blacklist. box-sized war over and over and over again to feel like we are exerting our grassroots power over Bitcoin in some way. But, you know, the block size war was existential. And since then, I don't think many of the conflicts have been existential.
Starting point is 00:59:02 I don't think Ordinals was existential. I don't think this oper-turned drama is existential. You know, I think, like, Taproot was a good example. Like, we spent way too much time focused on the activation path for Taproot, rather than what what taproot actually was. Everybody just kind of rubber-stamped taproot and was like, yeah, sure, no big deal. We love taproot.
Starting point is 00:59:21 Now, let's talk about how to activate it because everyone had fucking PTSD from the block size war. And I think that was probably the wrong thing to do. Like, we should have been taking more time to have more, you know, dialogue about what taproot was, what it enabled, what its second, third order effects were. And I don't know, I just, I find that, like, you know,
Starting point is 00:59:40 earlier people, I don't know if we said this on camera, off camera, but there's spooks on, somebody was saying there's spooks on one side. There's spooks on all sides of Bitcoin development. You know what I mean? Like, you should just kind of bluntly assume your favorite Bitcoin developer is probably an intelligence asset
Starting point is 00:59:57 just because that's the model. That's the risk model. You know? So, like, yeah, man, I don't know. I don't think I have anything meaningful, really, to contribute other than I think a lot of it is larping. Yeah, they're all spooks as a side-up. But, Matt, like, if I agree,
Starting point is 01:00:12 I agree they're not going to be able to soft walk. I don't think they're going to get enough people on board with this, but they can hard fork. Do you think we might see a rage quit over this? I want to be surprised. I mean, just using a pattern recognition from 13 years in Bitcoin, there'll probably be one or two rage quits at some point, but. That's what we need for the next bull market.
Starting point is 01:00:31 I'll take some free coins. Yeah. Yeah. And that's like, I mean, reflecting on 17 years of Bitcoin in my time in Bitcoin, that's the hardest thing to do is to stay sane throughout all of the, this throughout the price volatility throughout all these sort of protocol wars, whatever you want to call them. And it's just trying to keep a level head and not become too maniacal or ego-maniacal about it and try to make yourself the main character. Yeah, that's kind of the funny thing about
Starting point is 01:01:03 it is like you can get wrapped up in all this drama and you can try and do things. Or you could just do nothing and you went. Yeah. Doing nothing is actually always the best move in Bitcoin. always you know oh you got hyped up and bought a treasury company guess what it's a penny stock now oh you wanted to trade shit coins guess what all your money's gone oh you you know you pick the wrong side of the fork oh guess what all your money's gone like doing nothing is is really key but it's kind of hilarious how hard people find it to do nothing it's the hardest thing it's so hard it's so much harder than yeah doing a hundred things is so much easier than doing nothing Doing nothing is fucking difficult.
Starting point is 01:01:45 I have deep existentialism about what it means that like buying Bitcoin and then doing nothing with it for a decade, like turns out to be the best economic decision that you could have ever made that fundamentally negates the entirety of all work you've ever done. And like it's shocking because like I told people that a decade ago, they come back to me being like, I missed the boat. I'm like, do it again. Just like buy the Bitcoin. The next decade is still good. And then like, you're good all over again. Like totally fine. But like it,
Starting point is 01:02:16 it's just such an unfucking believable thing that, uh, like the, the fact that Bitcoin can actually have its fixed supply and like not violate that predication by any means outside of, of, you know, like a 51% attack, which we've all been through it out.
Starting point is 01:02:34 Like, that's a monumental achievement that like continues to allow for a number go up and like, I don't know. It's very interesting to me that like the world of fiat has fucked everything up so much that just buying magic and money and doing nothing with it is like the best economic decision that most of us will ever make. So there's something to be said for that. I'm not sure what it is. It's one of the things I think about quite a bit in terms of like the financialization of Bitcoin, Wall Street coming, Nation States coming. Like doing nothing is like the antithesis of Wall Street. And I wonder how I'm sure they're going to fuck it up in some. way, but I wonder how they fuck it up and how they manage to, like, what happens when the world goes to like a Bitcoin standard? Like, what is Wall Street?
Starting point is 01:03:18 Does Wall Street just not exist? I mean, it's current form. I don't think so. Because it's wholly dependent on this Fiat monetary spigot, right? Yeah, and like, it's all built off these, like, fucked up parisic relationships of like, you know, like, what's the real value that a Wall Street firm is providing into the world? know, I'm like it's, I don't, it's, we just live in a really weird world where dudes with like soft baby hands that have like never known a day of hard work that like they, they make literally
Starting point is 01:03:51 thousands of times more than like day laborers in India who spend half of, like from literally sunrise to sunset breaking boulders to make gravel. Like I, I don't know. Like that there's like a very particular statement about the world of what that means. My great hope is that like once we go to a Bitcoin standard, we've like actually gone all. the way back to where like proof of work itself and providing like real value to other humans in the world through whatever means it is is like the thing to do like real entrepreneurship versus like the financialization of those things. You know like it's it's a strange world that we live in right now and the more and more that I just look at how fucking weird it is, the more
Starting point is 01:04:32 that like I think if you like plop somebody from the fifth century or from the 15th century down today and like tried to explain everything to them like they would they would just be like Like, do you guys, like, live in, like, a crazy world where nothing makes any sense whatsoever? Do you think in this move from, like, current state, over the next 10 years, whether it's to communism, fascism, like, with the rise of AI, all this stuff, that Bitcoin has become a scapego at some point? Yeah, 100%. That, by the way, that's the reason why orange-pilling people matters is that so your head doesn't end up on a pipe. Like, you know, the original murder in the Bible, Kane kills Abel. out of pure envy.
Starting point is 01:05:12 There's no other reason. Envy is the, like, you know, that's the emotion of murder. Very often times. Like, if people, you know, I used to think the Charlie Kirk thing changed my mind a lot because I used to think, like, oh, you know, well, people might want your Bitcoin, but they're going to have to, like, kidnap you and coerce you and take you all these multi, you know, geographic locations and blah, blah, blah. No, dude, people will kill you just because they hate you for being rich.
Starting point is 01:05:38 They will kill you just because you have something and they have nothing. And so I think that's the political reality of the world. That's why I'm, as somebody who's advocating this middle path in Bitcoin, that's why I don't want to join up with the far right. And I don't want to join up with the far left because I know that I'm on the chopping block either direction, actually, probably less so with the far right. But still, the far right are economic populace, the same way the far left are. They have slightly different visions for what that looks like.
Starting point is 01:06:08 but like, we have to make people, it's not good enough to like be friendly with people politically or something like, no, we need to like get people to have Bitcoin. So their interests are aligned with ours. That's why we try and orange pill people. That's why we try and get people on board. And like to the stat earlier about how Gen Z doesn't have enough, well, you know, it's not the boomers we're going to have to worry about.
Starting point is 01:06:34 It's Gen Z we're going to have to worry about. So it's actually a massive. problem that Gen Z doesn't have enough interest in Bitcoin because they're too nihilistic. So, like, we have to, like, continue to reach out and try and shake them awake and be like, dude, do something now before it's too late, you know, from a self-preservation standpoint. Like, and for their own good. It's both things. It's good for them.
Starting point is 01:06:56 It's good for us. It's good for the world. It's good for Bitcoin. It's good for everybody. It's good for America. I'm American Hoddle. I'm running for present. No, I'm just kidding.
Starting point is 01:07:02 I don't know what to do, man. We're, like, building on that, I'm sure. You guys may see this as well, but I see what my boy, my oldest is five now, I'm a six. And I wonder if like Bitcoin's ultimate success is just has to skip a generation. Because I'm, obviously my sons are probably more, more tuned to recognizing Bitcoin as a brand
Starting point is 01:07:28 because if dad works in it, I talk about it and they talk about it with them. They watch Tuttle Twins about it, but like, they get what Bitcoin is already. Like it's gonna be part of their lives. their whole life. And I imagine there are many other Gen Alpha children out there that the same will happen. And like is, for lack of a better term, Gen Z, just a lost generation that we're going to have to put up with in the interim for the generation behind them picks up. I hope not. I don't think it has to be that way, but just war gaming. Like that's a total possibility of a scenario that could play out. I do think that's kind of interesting, though, because like especially the younger end of,
Starting point is 01:08:08 Gen Z. Charlie Cook is what made me realize this, because I obviously, like, I knew his work, but I didn't really know him very, very well. I didn't understand how much of his sort of pop culture figure he was to young people. And so, like, there does seem to be this, like, based, growing, like, young Gen Z group of people. And, like, are they still nihilistic? Or do you think they will be able to get Bitcoin? No, and I've run into this subsect of Gen Z just in my personal life. And there is like a hardcore, like, we're not gooning, we're working out, we're going to church, we're going to do good things and like get our, get our pests right. It's very like lower C conservative.
Starting point is 01:08:49 Yeah, I just, I just wonder what percentage of the total makeup of the generation that is, is that like an intolerant minority that's like, hey, we're going to get back on the right path. We notice the atrocities of the generations before us, and we're going to go the monks route of making sure that we get our personal lives in order. There's certainly a contingent of Gen Z that thinks that way and is not as nihilistic, but more inward looking and sort of trying to find resolve in doing what would be deemed
Starting point is 01:09:23 to be traditionally conservative things, like eating healthy going to church, being less sexually promiscuous. Just being a normal person. But we've all got young kids. Are you, are you, like, what world do you think they're going to grow up in? I mean, what's interesting is that, like, everything seems to have greater volatility than before. So, like, I don't, it's very hard for me to predict, you know, like, I feel great about how I've chose to raise my kids. So, like, they're not, they're not going to operate kind of inside of any normalized system in addition to, like, I think we've done a great job of keeping them, like, outside of the brainwashing of the school system.
Starting point is 01:10:06 in addition to like keeping them really in close contact with nature and kind of building personal skill sets. So I feel pretty great about the direction that my kids are going. This AI thing is like an interesting question because it's clearly an extremely powerful tool. And also like it's not clear the exact direction that it's going to go or what it's going to do. And like it's interesting because also like calling it AI a bit of a misnomer, you know, because like a lot of these are just LLMs and like, there's a bunch of other techniques around AI that, like, still haven't fully bootstrap themselves. In addition, like, these are all in, like, highly proprietary models that, like, reach a limit, particularly around the sort of garb rails that have been painted up around it.
Starting point is 01:10:51 In addition to, like, think about how hard the dialogue around Bitcoin and crypto is. And, like, AI is a more extreme version of that. And I'm only getting that because, like, I've been working pretty close with this guy lately that has a PhD and AI. And like really smart guy, like did, did lots of deep, deep research kind of at the cutting edge. And like, he's been explaining all this stuff to me. And it's pretty wild because, like, I didn't, I thought I was relatively well informed. But like, these really showed me how big, how much bigger this playing field is and how much more potential it has. And so very much like the internet, I think AI is something similar to that.
Starting point is 01:11:31 And depending on how people are able to use that tool and how much they get to really own. that tool. I think like these are really going to end up becoming sort of second digital cells, particularly if like we can fully own and encrypt these things and like train them and do whatever we actually want with them versus like the highly proprietary like chat GBT anthropic models that like frankly I think are really dangerous and are like, uh, like I think that these are essentially like communist brainwashing tools. And it's really interesting because first of all, these are just large language models. And because they only operate on recursive linguistics. I think in light of that, if anybody gets an opportunity, in 1984, there's an
Starting point is 01:12:11 appendix that George Orwell wrote specifically about the functions of Insock, which was like the language that they had. And he talks about like the entire idea is modifying language or destroy certain words. So like they don't exist within the lexica anymore. And like to me, that's exactly what AI is. And that like it's essentially providing modules of thought to destroy anything that's unique and outside of it, particularly with the way that people like ping this thing constantly or treat it like a therapist, but like, they don't understand that you're actually engaging in self-reinforcing learning against yourself. And like, that's the really dangerous shit in my opinion. So like, whereas like also like, like, we've started training up models that like,
Starting point is 01:12:53 you know, we've gotten deep seek to talk to us about, you know, like Tiananmen Square and shit. So like you can bust these models and like make them do crazy shit. But like, you need to know how to jailbreak them and you need to know how to make them loyal to you or else they're going to be loyal to the Chinese government or Anthropic or Sam Altman. Did you see that in, uh, I can't, it was an Eastern block country. I can't remember which one. Maybe it was Bulgaria. Um, at the direction of Tony Blair, some senator, MP there, uh, introduced a chatbot
Starting point is 01:13:26 as a senator. What? Yeah, yeah. No, this is real. did see that. Google this. This is real. And that's, I think, where we're headed is, like,
Starting point is 01:13:38 we're headed towards not only this recursive loop thing that Eric is talking about, where you give yourself chat, GPT-induced psychosis, but we're heading towards a future in which the chatbot is just your overlord, and it just tells you what to do, you know, because it's air quotes so much smarter and it's wise and whatever. And when they introduced this thing to, you know, whatever, the Bulgarian parliament or wherever it was. It's Albania.
Starting point is 01:14:03 Albania. Albania. Sorry, I was miss speaking. It said, you know, opposition to me is really hurtful to my feelings. Like the robot is saying this. I'm like, shut the fuck up, robot. You don't have fucking, play this video. This is insane. Watch as Albania's parliament erupts in fury and papers are thrown
Starting point is 01:14:26 as the country installs an AI chatbot as a government minister. Prime Minister Edie Rama, known as Tony Blair's protégé, has worked closely with the former UK Prime Minister to digitalise Albania's government. Last year, Rama spoke publicly of his relationship with Blair. I would not be nor a Prime Minister and either a man engaged in politics without him. The pair spoke of Albania's plans for digital ID to defeat corruption. What are you doing? You're building digital infrastructure? You've got plans for digital identity. Albania's AI minister made a speech to the country's parliament causing tensions to flare.
Starting point is 01:15:08 The bot said she was hurt by accusations she was unconstitutional. That hurt me, not for myself, but for the 972,000 interactions I had with citizens, who am I served as part of E-Albania, and also in relation to the 36,000 digital documents I issued to them. Let me remind you, the real day to constitutions have never been machines, but human decisions made by those in power. I am not here to replace human beings, but to help them. Indeed, I have no citizenship, but I have no ambitions or personal interest either. I only have data at my disposal.
Starting point is 01:15:36 I am eager to learn new information, and I have algorithms at my disposal, so that I can put all of this at the service of citizens with impartiality, transparency, and without ever tiring. That's fucking terrifying. Feelings are a biological thing. This fucking program doesn't have feelings, okay? I can't, I can't, there's never been a more blatant sci-op in human history than, like, you hurt my feeling. You're a fucking program!
Starting point is 01:16:01 You're a program. Then she admitted it later. She admitted it later, too. She's like, oh, don't worry, I can't think. It's a... The levels of depravity and insanity that we are going to live through because of AI is going to be absolutely just the most dystopian thing you can think of. Basically, the worst parts of the Bible.
Starting point is 01:16:20 It's the book of Revelation. I'm just going to say it. The Antichrist is coming back. Sam Holman is the Antichrist. There I said it. I agree with Peter Thiel. He's the Antichrist, too. They're both anti-crath.
Starting point is 01:16:30 I mean, the major problem, in my opinion, is that, like, I'm afraid for our generation and older that, like, AI is essentially, like, how the Internet's going to be with us. And so it's, like, flash forward 10 years from now, I'm going to be like, oh, I like sent you money, kids. Like, you said that you were in danger because the holograph came up. And they're like, God, damn it, Dad. Like, that was clearly, like, an AI bribery bot. You just, like, fucking paid it. And I'll be like, well, like, it looked real and it sounded like you. And they're just going to be like, God.
Starting point is 01:17:00 Dad, like, you fucking know this. You know as soon as I get on the phone, you say fucking key in, and I provide you the valid fucking key form that validates my identity. Like, what, like, what the fuck have you been doing, dad? Like, come on, like, row the fuck up. And so, like, this is all just kind of a recursive model with technology, right? That, like, the old can't understand it, the young master it. So, like, while I think that these are really dangerous tools, like,
Starting point is 01:17:24 they have these massive loopholes that, like, if you know how to talk to them, they, like, have to expose their nature to you. And so it's like once you kind of get how this game is played, it will be like, Hoddle comes up and he's like, oh God, there's like, I'll be in, Terriots that want to murder me now. And I'll be like, Keian, Kian fuck. And you'll be like, I don't, I don't have my key. And I'm like, motherfucker.
Starting point is 01:17:43 Like you're trying to rip me off like, you know, and I'll call. How many hours are in strawberry? Tell me. How many are? Yeah, and I'll like name off a string of digits that like makes you fucking malfunction. And then I'll ask by, I'd inject you with some prompts. And I'll be like, great. You like work for me now.
Starting point is 01:17:57 You'll be like, yes, new master. And it's like, cool. Like go rogue on your fucking, you're my double agent. You're going to get back to your former master and figure out how to get information so I can send my drones to him to strike him. So thanks. What I thought was more telling you that video that was going on in Albania, it's just like how blatant it is. Like if Tony Blair's protege, like, oh, don't worry, we have this AI. It's great.
Starting point is 01:18:21 Parliament member now. Like she's, she can't think. Don't worry. Don't ask questions about the context window that we used to feed her information. and the super prompt, the system prompt that we gave her to make decisions off of. It's like they, that's like another silver lining white pill. These people are getting so lazy. And I think the tech is blown past them that they don't even know how to leverage it correctly.
Starting point is 01:18:44 But the other side of that, too, I mean, tying it in with digital ID and going back to communism versus fascism here in the United States, I'll put my hand up, like the immigration stuff. I'm a fan of here in the United States. You came illegally and you were part of like the Biden administration's flood. of the borders. I think that's a massive problem, not only here, up in Canada, UK, Germany. Like, I think that's a problem. If you came illegally to our countries, rule vlogs this, you should go home.
Starting point is 01:19:09 But with that being said, what worries me about the Trump administration, and they've lightly signaled this, is that, like, secure borders is going to be the mechanism by which they roll out digital ID. And that is something that I think digital ID and, like, sort of despotic government-controlled AI go hand in hand. and there are things we have to be hyper vigilant of and hold the line on. I mean, again, this is where like the UK is just completely front running the US on the digital ID stuff. Like, Kirstarmer's brought that in.
Starting point is 01:19:38 I think he got something like 8 million signatures on a petition against it. Like every time he posts about it, he gets absolutely flamed in the comments, but he still just is going full bore on this thing. So they tried it pretty significantly here during COVID, but we shut it down pretty hard. That was one of the big wins that the populace got during COVID. We didn't get a lot of wins, but we got that one. We stopped vaccine passports, at least for now. But they're going to keep, like you said,
Starting point is 01:20:03 they're going to keep trying every single chance they get, you know. So do you think they'll come to the U.S. eventually? Well, I think what's going to happen is they're going to do the border thing. They're going to successfully kick out a lot of illegal immigrants. I'm like, okay, we did our jobs and make sure this never happens again. Everybody sign up for the digital ID. Right. Unfortunately, that's how I think it's going to play out.
Starting point is 01:20:24 Yeah, think about it like, you know, if you were in Germany in 1937, like, you know, you gotta figure out who the Jews are, so we need to know all of your IDs, like all of your papers, right? So to figure out the illegal immigrants, we need to know all of your, like, data. How do I know you're not an illegal immigrant? Yeah, you were born in American hospital,
Starting point is 01:20:44 and you're a standard white guy with a douchy baseball hat, but we don't know. We don't, give me your identification, right? And that is like a slippery slope, and they're not gonna stop pressing because the tool, of surveillance, the surveillance Panopticon has already been built. We already live under, you know, covert surveillance.
Starting point is 01:21:04 Edward Snowden has a quote I'm very fond of where he says that we are forced to stand naked before power in a very real way in today's day and age. And he's right in the sense that like, you know, there are videos of you jerking off at NSA headquarters, right? Because like, they, they give the porn data from the porn companies to the intelligence agencies. and, like, if you weren't ultra-careful with putting your finger over the little thing, and you, you know, you type in, like, Debbie does Dallas number nine, like, there's going to be a video of you coming and the NSA can watch it. That's real. And there's now, like, a weird thing where they want to make that covert system overt
Starting point is 01:21:41 so that they can compete with China. That's actually their reason for wanting to do it. They think that the Chinese population is more under control and they can marshal their resources better in a total war scenario. And so they want the... the same level of control that China has over their citizenry over you. And so they're not going to stop pushing until they try and get it. And they're going to push from the left and the right and the center.
Starting point is 01:22:03 And, you know, it's just never going to stop. And there will always be some reason why you need to accept it. And you should just always reject it outright. But eventually there will be a generation of people who grew up on the internet and they don't give a fuck about their privacy and they'll just let it slip through, you know. Do you think that's what this is? Like the surveillance authoritarianism is all because of the threat of China. Like, that doesn't seem like enough to me.
Starting point is 01:22:27 That's part of what's motivating it. And then obviously, you know, these people are authoritarian who go into achieve state power. Like, that's the core of their life is telling other people what to do. And so why would they not want more power and more control over, you know, telling the average American citizen what to do?
Starting point is 01:22:44 Of course, they want that. They want to be able to control your life, you know. Yeah, I saw funny or interesting, thought-provoking tweet about China. I forget who's Senate. About China in the U.S. It's like for the last 30 years, China's been a capitalist country LARPing as a socialist country,
Starting point is 01:23:02 and the U.S. has been LARPing as a capitalist country, acting as a socialist country. And I think, to your point, Hottle, like, we're trying to catch up on the socialism. And China's trying to, they've implemented some form of a capitalist system that's seeing a lot of success right now and scares the shit out of the authoritarian's here. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:23:22 let's um let's close out with some white pills like 17 years in since spick on white paper dropped um like what are the positive things that you see coming if you own bitcoin and you have it self-custody it's it's yours nobody can take it from you those 12 magical words but uh you know have some criticism for it like you you actually own those are yours more than kind of anything else so like that's your lifeboat again as i said earlier just like set a little bit aside sit onto that shit for the next 10 years. Don't fucking lose the key. It's going to be your way out of this dystopian hellhole
Starting point is 01:24:00 that's probably going to get produced. In addition to the fact of that, like, more people know about Bitcoin than ever before. A lot of people don't, and like, again, this is sort of the recursive thing. Even if people come in as banker coin guys or a number go up people, eventually they get curious enough about it to be like, how does this thing actually work under the hood? Why is it important?
Starting point is 01:24:21 And they start to really orange pill themselves in a meaningful way. So like everything's good for Bitcoin. I ultimately think the direction that we're going. And also like the fact that we're like hovering at what $113,000 and not like it feels like a bear market that, you know, everybody's kind of like Bitcoin's dead. Like we should have been. That was phenomenal. So like remember where we're actually at in the timeline. And, you know, like we're going to have another bowl rally at some point in time and it's going to kick the shit.
Starting point is 01:24:51 get out of gold and silver and everything else. And it's going to be fun. So, you know, you should consider buying more Bitcoin. I think all of the, this is the big lesson since, you know, I've been in Bitcoin, is that all of the craziest thoughts and beliefs you have about what is going to happen in Bitcoin, those are all real. They're all going to come true. And you're going to find yourself, you know, part next.
Starting point is 01:25:21 next to a mega yacht in Miami with Eric Kason, drunk off your ass being like, why are we here? You know, what's going on? You're going to be standing next to Marty Bent at some fucking mansion on Star Island being like, this mansion is kind of ugly, actually. These are both real interactions I've had with both of these gentlemen.
Starting point is 01:25:41 And I'm just a guy who fucking bought magic internet money and stumbled my way in here after a random drunken night at the casino. And then I posted my real thoughts about Bitcoin on the internet and people were like, I kind of like the cut of this guy's jib, and then I started getting invited to Millionaire Mansion parties and shit. It's weird. It's really weird. And, like, so, you know, when I first sat down and, like,
Starting point is 01:26:02 it's weird. It's weird. And when I first sat down and discovered Bitcoin, I, you know, when I found out that there was 100 million Satoshes in each Bitcoin, I was like, clearly, that's going to be worth $100 million one day. And, like, I didn't really, you know, I wasn't smart enough to be like, the $100 million will be severely debased, but I was like, it will be worth
Starting point is 01:26:24 $100 million, you know, so like, I do think that Bitcoin goes to infinity, that continues, it becomes more of a, you know, political movement across the Western world and people use it to sort of, you know, revivify society, really, because
Starting point is 01:26:40 what Bitcoin is, is it's a restorative vision of the future, which is what the fascist want. That's what the far right wants. And it's a, progressive vision of the future in that it enables all these new tools and technologies. And that's kind of what the communist side wants. And so it kind of is the perfect marriage of this economic populism that both sides are, the younger generations are dying for.
Starting point is 01:27:08 I also think that when the boomers die, there's the largest wealth transfer that's ever happened. And I already can see it with my friends is that those who didn't get in on Bitcoin are going to inherit wealth from the boomers who are going to leave it. to them and then they're going to be a lot less price sensitive than we are and they're going to be like yeah, $250,000 for a Bitcoin, that's very cheap. Like, I'm going to buy three of those because I just got money from my parents when they passed away, whatever. And so I think that there's going to be a lot of when this well transfer happens, a lot of boomer
Starting point is 01:27:38 money is going to end up in Bitcoin and it's going to continue going up. And I think that it's important for us to maintain our principles through this whole thing and to be like, it's not number go up or censorship resistance, because if we don't have both, we've failed. And so we need to make it through to the other side with Bitcoin's core properties, its inherent property is intact. And that's a long bet, and it's going to take your whole life. And you don't martyr yourself for something by dying in a blaze of glory.
Starting point is 01:28:12 You martyr yourself for something by giving your life for it every day, like you would do with your life. family or things that you're passionate, that you care about, your community, you show up for those things every day, you show up for Bitcoin every day, you show up for the principles every day, it's going to take the rest of our lives. So just buckle in, you know, and if you're here now, 17 years in, like, actually, this is a thousand-year system, so you're still at the very beginning of the story, the very, very beginning. I don't think I can top anything forward looking at these two gentlemen just said, but something I've been just looking at marveling at this week is the hash rate.
Starting point is 01:28:48 We're sitting at 1.15 Zeta hash around there, based on what estimates you look at. But it took 11 years for Bitcoin to go from launch to 100 X a hash. I looked this up earlier today. And it hit 100 X a hash for the first time in January of 2020. Then you think it took four years, five, five years. We hit one Zeta hash last month, September 15th,
Starting point is 01:29:17 like, reliably. And so it took like four and a half, almost five years to go from 100 to a Zeta hash. And in a little over a month, we've added another X-a-hash to the network. And so, like, when you think about that, like the amount of raw power dedicated to the Bitcoin network and how fast it's coming on the network right now. It's mind-boggling to me to think of some, a process that took 11 years just took less than six weeks. That's insane.
Starting point is 01:29:50 It's insane. And that is a signal that something's happening here. Like this network is bootstrapping. It's working. And no matter what you hear with, debates over op return, at the price is hovering at 113, and you don't think that's high enough.
Starting point is 01:30:05 Like, there's something happening behind the scenes. The melding of the physical and digital world via Bitcoin hash rate is happening at a pace that I don't think many people recognize right now. Like that X a hash, I looked at it. I was like, wait, 1.1 Zeta hash means we, or excuse me, we added 100 X a hash in the last six weeks. It's insane to think that it took, going from zero to 100,
Starting point is 01:30:30 took 11 years, then from 100 to 10,100 X a hash took four years, and then we just added 100 X a hash in six weeks. Like that's insane parabolic growth that we're entering on the hash rate side of things. And I think that's a, foundational base that is very underappreciated right now, and the growth of that base is very underappreciated right now. And that's, I mean, a lot of people have been sharing,
Starting point is 01:30:57 resharing the Buckminster Fuller and Henry Ford sort of visions of the future. We need a currency based at some degree in energy, and that's what Bitcoin represents. They can't dilute it. They can't take it from you if you secure it properly. and slowly but surely more and more people are going to realize this, they're going to adopt it, and the number is going to go up. And hopefully, people don't get distracted by number go up.
Starting point is 01:31:24 And we still have the cypherpunks out there, which I'm very confident we do working on the tools that make you able to access Bitcoin sovereignly and privately. I'm actually very bullish on sovereign and private usage of Bitcoin over the next decade, despite what the governments would like to do to us by cucking up. us and not allowing us to self-custy. If it gets to that point where they write a law and says you can't self-custody by LKYC. I've said this before. Matt doesn't like me saying this on our HR,
Starting point is 01:31:53 but we're not on our charge. Like civil disobedience will need to come back and we'll just need to flaunt our sovereign users of Bitcoin in the States face and say, no, you're not taking this from us. Yeah, let's fucking go. I mean, that's like the 6102, but you just don't have to listen. Many people, that's what many Bitcoiners are really.
Starting point is 01:32:09 Many people during 61-2 didn't listen either. They were just like, no, I'm not giving you my fucking cold. You know, we have this digital slash physical merger via Bitcoin mining. To me, when I think about that, I think about that creating a bridge or a rift in space time. And it is a portal that, you know, leads to a new dimension. And so when we talk about this, yeah, the old world is dying, like, let's just admit it and be like, yeah, it's dying. It may, in fact, already be dead. And we're just staring at its carcass. And I think that the most logical and sane thing to do is if you find a hole in space time is to walk through it
Starting point is 01:32:48 and see, you know, where it takes you, right? Doesn't sound like it's the same thing to do, but it is. I love that. So things might get shit, but it's going to get better. This has been really cool. Thank you, guys. I appreciate the time. And I'm going to get this out on Friday, White Paper Day.
Starting point is 01:33:05 Let's go. Thank you, Danny. Nice.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.