Where Should We Begin? with Esther Perel - Leaving the Shame Behind

Episode Date: March 10, 2025

This is a classic session of Where Should We Begin? A young couple has endured a series of crises early in their marriage, from a benign brain tumor to a serious car crash to the husband’s near-fatal heart attack. Following his recovery, he’s adapting to new physical limitations, while she says the children bear the brunt of his frustrations. Esther coaches them through an honest conversation on anger, parenthood and the power of apology.      Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Everything has changed. I went from just on the verge of finally having everything to having nothing. What you are about to hear is a classic session of Where Should We Begin with Esther Perel. None of the voices in this series are ongoing patients of Esther Perel's, and each episode is a one-time counseling session. For the purposes of maintaining confidentiality, names and some identifiable characteristics have been removed, but their voices and their stories are real. We just got married like three and a half years ago, but I feel like we've been married 40 years, you know,

just with the number of things that have happened to us. This couple is in their early 30s, and yet they have already experienced so much. They've been hit with a car accident on his side, a benign brain tumor on her side. And then he had massive heart failure and he died. He ended up being in a coma for eight weeks. One of the consequences is that it has left him

with a slurred speech and a limited mobility. You know, I can't walk to the park without getting winded and I just feel less useful than I used to be, you know. I can't do what I used to do. And in addition to the many health crises that they have undergone, they also are weathering the vicissitudes of the everyday life, raising their two-year-old child, as well as her two children from a previous relationship.

He being unemployed and she being a mother. their two-year-old child as well as her two children from a previous relationship. He being unemployed and she being over-functioning. Now she's out working all the time and I'm the one taking care of the two-year-old at home. I've never been the most patient father in the world. He's just looking for someone to blame. And I think a lot of the times that I'm the one who gets the brunt of that. As much as we fight sometimes, like,

she's just too smart and good and I do just love her too much. I don't know. I love him so much, but he's got some good weapons in his arsenal when it comes to emotional hurt. This is Where Should We Begin with Astair Perel. Listen, we all love a good hustle. We all love a rise and grind mentality. But let's be real, you could do all that and still be super comfy, right?

Right. Nothing says comfort quite like a pair of Crocs. Since 2002, they've been disrupting the footwear industry with their iconic clogged silhouette. And now you can choose from more than 800 styles to find the pair of Crocs that is perfect for you. Like the Echo Way, with a sculptural boundary pushing design that was crafted with the urban explorer in mind.

Whatever your style, buy yours at Crocs.com. Your Crocs. Your story. Your world. Support for this show comes from Indeed. Indeed sponsored jobs can help you stand out and hire fast. Your post even jumps to the top of the page for relevant candidates to make sure you're getting seen.

There's no need to wait any longer. Speed up your hiring right now with Indeed. And listeners of this show will get a $100 sponsored job credit to get your jobs more visibility at indeed.com slash voxca. Just go to indeed.com slash Vox CA right now and support the show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com slash Vox CA.

Terms and conditions apply. Hiring Indeed is all you need. Give me the loop in your head. When you start bitching at life. When you feel like life gave you a raw deal. I don't know, it's mostly just like no one's listening to me. Like nothing's working out the way I planned, you know. Everything's been messed up, you know. Say more.

Sometimes I just... There's too many bad things that have happened in a row and I just can't... ...seem to forget about them sometimes. What do you focus on? Oh, just how crappy I feel. How much it hurts to do lots of things. Just how different I feel just as a person from when this happened. Because you feel more vulnerable? Because you feel more fragile, or because you physically hurt as well.

Actually all of those, really. I used to always say I was invincible, and at the same time I saw that I'm not completely invincible. So it's kind of one of those weird things. And you say what? Life is over? You say nothing means anything? You say I'm worthless? You say what? Yeah, those are, yeah, a lot of those things.

I seem to be worthless. I'm not doing anything like I wanted to do. Okay. Where are your friends? I don't have any. Where have your friends? I don't have any. Where have they gone? Moved far away or just don't exist anymore. And you? Oh, I have...

You have friends? Yeah, I mean, I have friends, yeah. It was kind of odd, like, when we met, I didn't really have a lot of friends, and he had a friend group from high school. And most of that friend group has disseminated, and they moved away, and we just don't really talk to them very much anymore.

It's just recently, like in the past couple years, that I've made more friends and felt more comfortable in my own skin, I think. A lot of these people I didn't even meet until after he was sick. And I think... Did you meet people through this whole ordeal? No, not really.

It's kind of odd because he's so young. There is a community of people who have gone through heart issues and things, but they're also very much older than us. But it doesn't have to be the same condition. It just has to be... There are a lot of young people who are hit with a major health crisis.

In all these situations, their life has changed overnight. He's never really been open to therapy or group kind of things. But I wasn't even thinking just therapeutically. I'm thinking you are isolated, and that is compounding everything else. Oh yeah. You're isolated, and you know, you need people.

So I'm asking about friends. I also want to ask about family. Where is the family? Is there other people around you? Oh yeah, my parents, you know, my parents live close to us. And how are they involved? Oh, they help with the kids and they come over and help me all the time. They invite us over for dinner and they're very involved.

In a good way? Yes. I love them very much. In fact, my mom's watching the kids right now. Right now. And my aunt. Are there people your age in your family? Back there, my mom's watching the kids right now. Right now. So am I not? Are there people you rage in your family? I'm completely different from any of those people, you know, and it's just like I'm the

only one that's married and a homeowner and has kids that they even know. Like literally, it's just I'm very different from the rest of my family. They... I don't think you need to disparage them that way, but they are a lot younger than him and not in the same place in life, I wouldn't say. Where is your family? Oh gosh. My parents got divorced when I was an adult, so, and then my dad remarried to the woman that he was having an affair with,

so it was very complicated situation there. And then my middle brother's a heroin addict that my mother enables quite a bit, and it's been a very problematic situation for us to overcome. So I don't really have a lot of contact with any of my family members. My defense mechanism is I just don't invest.

So, but there's not any support there. Not really. You have siblings? Yes. He has a brother. I've got one brother. And where is he? In Atlanta.

They're not close. They haven't been close since. His brother moved out of the state as soon as he graduated from high school and hasn't returned. So they've not had a... And your dad drinks? No.

No, his dad's been sober for what, like 40 years or something? Yeah. A ridiculously long time. Yeah, something like that. And you? For 40 years. Oh yeah, I still drink. Yeah, too much.

Says who? Me. It says her. It says me. Well, I think, I don't know. I think anyone... Let me check, let me check. Sometimes.

Tell her how much you really drink, be honest. Be honest. Well, I don't drink like I used to, that's for sure. Yeah, but you still. I still drink four times, four or five times a week, you know. How much? Three to four drinks. Four or five times a week, three or four drinks.

I think that's too much. It's just I want to relax and, you know, feel like I'm young again, you know. What other things do you do to feel young still? I don't know. You play video games. That's about it. Yeah, I play video games. Yeah. That's about it.

Wait, wait, let me ask him. Sorry. It's okay. I shouldn't answer. I do that a lot. Yes, you do. I'm sorry. There's nothing to apologize.

That's about all I do nowadays. I pretty much play video games and that's about it. One of the things that I notice at this moment is that for all the months that he was in the coma and completely incapacitated, she had to take over so much that at this point, even when he's perfectly capable of answering a question by himself, she still feels that he needs her help. And one of the things that needs to happen is for her to know where her over-functioning is needed and where it no longer is necessary.

And so I will try to help her step back in the areas where at least he can step forward. And what else? What did you used to do? I used to finish an eight hour day on my feet and then go play 18 holes. And then come home and make dinner. And that was like a Wednesday for me. And now it's like I've pretty much just chase around the kid and you know, I don't really do that much. You know, walk the kid to the park, that's about all I really do. And is she in nursery school?

No. And why not? Because I do it and it's just, it's too expensive right now. We don't have any money for it, so. With my younger children, they went to daycare by her age because we were at work. And so they got that exposure that they needed to the schooling and things.

And she hasn't had that. So that was one of the things that he knows I really feel strongly that it's almost time to get her into a class a few times a week at least. One minute we're dealing with basic everyday life, parenting issues, discipline issues, money issues. And then the next minute we've just gone through brain tumors and heart attacks and comas and death and resurrections, resuscitations, whichever

way you want to call it. And this is not a normal situation, but it is a situation where two people are trying to normalize and to resume life with a sense of future and a sense of hope and a different awareness, definitely a different awareness. And that awareness can either become the source of great zeal, life is short, I don't know what can happen tomorrow, I am going to take it with full force, or I don't know what's going to happen so what's the point. I sense that you go back and forth between two extremes.

One minute you think I can do everything I used to do, which is not true, and the next minute you think there is nothing more you can do, and that's not true either. Yeah, that's the way I see it. So we need to think about how you create something that is more real, but also more hopeful. You were two people who felt very early on

that you were gonna do better than the people around you. Yep, that was the plan. And there is no reason that that can't be there right now. Yeah. You may not do what you used to do, but you will do other things. Being torted on your course happens to a lot of people, you know, people who play their instrument their whole life and suddenly they can't play, or people who danced and suddenly they can't dance. You actually could cook. It's not like you can't

cook. You can't be a chef in a very intense stressful situation, but your craft you can still apply. Maybe you can't build homes, because I think you probably wear a very good handyman too. Yeah? But there are plenty of talents you may not even know that you have. Because you're a talented guy. Yeah. Do you know that? Sometimes I forget about it.

That's right. That's right. You don't feel any of it enough at this moment. But in part because you're not doing enough. You understand? The world you live in is too small for you. Yeah, I definitely agree with that. So, give me a sense of what are the things around you that you could do tomorrow morning.

They don't only have to do with work, by the way. Yeah. But. Well, tomorrow I just wanna hang out with my daughter and take her to do whatever she wants. But the thing is, that is part of the narrow world. Yep. Because now your daughter becomes your entire source of pride and identity.

Yeah. She's only two. Oh, she's perfect though. I know. I'm sure she'll stay that way forever. No. It's a burden on her shoulders. Yeah, she doesn't need to be.

To make her father's life worthy. To make him feel that he still is useful. It's a big burden on your daughter. Yeah. So, we need to add something. You need other interests. Drinking, gaming and childcare. Not enough. Well. Not enough.

Well, no. Not enough. So, you telling him all the time that is only gonna become an argument where he can say no to you, because that now becomes a source of some power and some say and some autonomy. So resisting you becomes your new force.

That sucks. Yeah, for both of us. For both of you. I'm glad you know that. Yeah. Opposition becomes autonomy. Yeah. It's very important when you are in front of someone who is facing so much loss, loss

of their, what they had envisioned for themselves, loss of their capacity physically and mentally to not become the generator who is constantly trying to ignite him and push him, but just give him enough so that he can begin to push himself. It's like a car that you try to first put in neutral, take off the brakes, and then push it just enough and hopefully down a hill so that it can catch some speed and then begin to ride back on its own. And that's where I'm trying to position myself in relation to him at this moment.

And we're gonna have to write a new story. Yeah. With new things you want to do. If it's immediately not the way I used to, then you're basically giving me a story of mourning. Yeah. The man I thought I was, the man I knew, the man who is no more. And we're going to need to mourn pieces of him and welcome a new guy, because there's somebody here that's in front of me that's quite alive. Yeah, I think.

Yeah? All right. Is he around? We got him? There he is. Sometimes. Are you willing to welcome the new guy? Or do you want to new me?

I already have a new you. I mean, you think you're not the same person? No, I'm not. I'm not either. I'm completely different. How could we be after that? That's the thing. I think you are dwelling so much on what you wanted to be.

You're not thinking about what you can be or what you should be now. Yeah. Are we willing to welcome these new people? I mean, I've had a hard time with it because I, sometimes I just feel like I'm right back at the beginning of it, you know, like something will happen that will make me

regress back to being so scared and that, you know, I always was anxious. I had anxiety before this happened and it was like the worst possible thing to have happen that this thing that you shouldn't really have to worry I had anxiety before this happened and it was like the worst possible thing to have happen that This thing that you shouldn't really have to worry about that really, you know Anytime I had those kind of crazy thought processes I would try to rein them back in and be like that's not likely that's something that we need to not worry about and then actually

Happens to you. It makes it a lot harder to tell yourself That's you know, not gonna happen because it already did happen it has been difficult and so I I Don't like the person that I am now sometimes because I feel the weight of that It is totally understandable but What you do with that will make all the difference You can say I Learn learned something about the fragility,

and therefore I'm much more caring, careful, attentive, grateful. There's lots of good things that come out of that as well. I'm not trying to make it rosy, you know? But it's a different awareness of life and of us as human beings. Or you can go into the poor me. People are continuously having to choose when things hit us.

We can't choose what will hit us, but we will choose what we do with it and the meaning that we give to it. Yeah. And you may not be able to do all of it alone. You need help, you know, and it can't all be her because she has her own. And you're going to go to places that give you free help

or very low-pay help. Get the support you need. Yeah. Because you're going to go to places that give you free help or very low-pay help. Get the support you need. Because you're not continuing as is. I'm not sure if therapy is where he will go, but I wanted him to know that therapy is available for him, should he want to go and that there is very good treatment out there that doesn't cost much or even anything. But in addition what I really wanted to emphasize to him is what my friend Susanna Fox has often

called just-in-time someone like me. That there is nothing that can replace the support of others who have gone or are going through some of what we are struggling with at this time. Social isolation compounds all his physical or mental limitations more than any other factor. more than any other factor. We'll be back with a session right after this. And while we love our sponsors, if you want to listen to this session ad-free, click the Try Free button to subscribe to Astaire's office hours on Apple Podcasts. podcasts. Support for the show comes from Robinhood.

With Robinhood Gold, you can now enjoy the VIP treatment, receiving a 3% IRA match on retirement contributions. The privileges of the very privileged are no longer exclusive. With Robinhood Gold, your annual IRA contributions are boosted by 3%. Plus, you also get 4% APY on your cash and non-retirement accounts. That's over 8 times the national savings average. The perks of the high net worth are now available for any net worth. The new gold standard is here with Robinhood Gold. To receive your 3% boost on annual IRA contributions, sign up at robinhood.com slash

gold. Investing involves risk, rate subject to change. 3% match requires Robinhood Gold at $5 per month for one year from first match. Must keep funds in IRA for five years. Go to robinhood.com slash boost. Over eight times the national average savings account interest rate claim is based on data from the FDIC as of November 18th, 2024. Robinhood Financial LLC member SIPC. Gold membership is offered by Robin Hood Gold LLC.

Fox Creative. This is advertiser content brought to you by the all new Nissan Murano. Okay, that email is done. Next on my to-do list, pick up dress for Friday's fundraiser. All right, okay, all right, where are my keys? In my pocket, let's go. First, pick up dress, then prepare for that big presentation.

Walk dog, then... Okay. Inhale. One, two, three, four. Exhale. One, two, three, four. Ooh, who knew a driver's seat could give such a good massage? Wow, this is so nice. Oops, that was my exit.

Oh well, that's fine. I've got time. After the meeting, I gotta remember to schedule flights for our girls' trip, but that's for later. Sun on my skin, wind in my hair, I feel good. Turn the music up. Your all-new Nissan Murano is more than just a tool to get you where you're going. It's a refuge from life's hustle and bustle.

It's a place to relax, to reset, in the spaces between items on your to-do lists. Oh wait, I got a message. Could you pick up wine for dinner tonight? Yep, I'm on it. I mean, that's totally fine by me. Play Celebrity Memoir Book Club. I'm Claire Parker. And I'm Ashley Hamilton. And this is Celebrity Memoir Book Club. I'm Claire Parker and I'm Ashley Hamilton and this is Celebrity Memoir Book Club.

Support for Where Should We Begin comes from Quince. Every now and then you deserve a taste of the good life. If you're looking to make your wardrobe a little more luxurious but without the high costs, you might want to consider Quince. Quince offers high-quality, long-lasting essentials at affordable prices, like 100% Mongolian cashmere sweaters from $50, washable silk tops and dresses, organic cotton sweaters, and even 14-carat gold jewelry. All winter long, I've actually been loving my sheepskin slippers from Queen's. No matter what you're looking for, Queen's says that all of their items are priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands.

You can give yourselves the luxury you deserve with Queen's. You can go to queens.com slash begin for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. That's q u i n c e dot com slash begin to get free shipping and 365 day returns. queens dot com slash begin. It feels like you've given up a little bit. Yeah, well I have. You don't have to, that's the whole point. You can't because you're too young.

That's not a reason. That's not a reason. That's not a good motivator. No, he's got too much talent. And you have so many people that love you. That's another great one. Yeah. The boys and me, they love you. They look up to you.

Yeah. Yeah. I know, but a lot of the time they're... I think you take your frustration and you turn it into finding things that they've done wrong. And they look up to you. They love you so much. And you...I don't think you realize that it hurts them. into finding things that they've done wrong. And they look up to you. They love you so much. And you, I don't think you realize that it hurts them. Like I can take it because I'm an adult, you know?

Yeah. But they're little. They need you to be giving to them, not, you know. Yeah. When you say, yeah, it means I hear you, I agree with you, or just keep on talking. Oh, I agree with her. Really? Yeah.

Really, really though? Yeah, really. I didn't think that you even knew how cruel you've been, you know? Or how much you've let it... You've let your frustration leech onto them. What do you know? Yeah, sometimes they're catching up on my frustration. You're letting it out on them. Do you apologize afterwards?

No. No. No. How come? Because I feel embarrassed. I don't want to lose my authority. I don't want to feel like I make any mistakes. Even if I do. If you explode and you tell them, I'm sorry, that was not about you, you don't lose your

authority, you don't appear weak, you teach your boys self-awareness, you teach them a sense of responsibility about how they affect others. You teach them humility. You teach them that true strength is the ability to say, I'm sorry. And you're not weaker because of it. That makes sense. There may be a much better way of dealing with it. Do you understand? And I think you have it in you, by the way.

The idea that it would show me as weak because I'm too embarrassed, because I'm actually feeling ashamed, turn the shame into guilt. Guilt is conscience. Shame is hiding. Kids, that wasn't about you. I'm sorry. I could have done this better. And your boys will melt in your hands. And they'll look up to you. And you will look up to you and you will feel better. That's a thing for tomorrow morning.

Yeah. Can you hear yourself say it? Yeah. Show me. Oh my gosh. It's like, shut the door, kids. Wait, I'm sorry. You know, I'm just having a rough morning. You kids have a good day at school.

Mm-hmm. That might actually be a prediction of exactly the way it happens. Mm-hmm. And you could even go a step further. It might actually be a prediction of exactly what the way it happens. And you could even go a step further. Some days I feel very frustrated. It's been hard for me and I know that I take it out on you. And I want you to know that I know. Yeah. Can you imagine that one? Yeah.

They need to hear that, you know. Yeah. But I am looking at him because if you're going to tell him, then he's going to feel undermined again. So you can't go home and say, Esther's sad. I know. Simon's sad. Can I get that in writing?

Yes. Yes. But yours need to be in writing too. Yeah. So tell her what you're prepared to put in writing. And then she'll put hers in writing. And then she'll put hers in writing. I'm sorry honey. You know there's been terrible times since I got sick and I've just been so angry at everything. Angry at the fact I can't talk, angry at the fact I can't talk, angry at the fact I can't move.

Angry at everything. You've been the one person there for me and I'm sorry I've taken all that anger out on you. Because I shouldn't have been the one person that's been there for me constantly. And I love you. It's not about you, okay? Maybe there's nothing to do with you, okay? It has to do with me, okay? I'm sorry, I love you.

You know I do. I know you do. You know I do. I know you do. Too much. Ha ha. Ha ha. There's no such thing as too much loving your wife though. Wow.

Wow, that's debatable. I... And now bring the boys in there. And it's just, you guys know it's been rough. It's been... I do, but... Terrible. It's been hard for you, it's been hard for me, and you know what?

I'm sorry I've taken a lot of it out on you. You know, I love you. You know, I want things to be great. So let's try to make things great. Can I tweak a bit? Yeah. It's great what you're I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much.

I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much.

I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much.

I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you very much. I love you you the way I do you probably don't feel anything Love from me Because at some point you will have convinced them that you don't love them If you keep doing what you do and then they will become defined and then they will talk back to you and then you will feel more humiliated and Then you will feel more humiliated. And then you will act worse. And then you will hide it more, because you will feel even more embarrassed

about being in a way that has nothing to do with who you are. Yeah. So you tell them, I would like to change this. I'm going to work on this. I'm making a commitment. I know that it's not going to change necessarily overnight, but I'm going to make a real attempt at changing this. You don't deserve this, and neither do I.

I see you try. I see how you can be with them sometimes. They love you when you're like that. They want your love so much. I see you try. I see how you can be with them sometimes. They love you when you're like that. They want your love so much. You can give it to them and they'll take it. It's definitely not too late. Yeah.

You know, that's the whole thing I really wanted to come here for. Because I've thought about leaving because I can't keep watching you do what you do to them. For me, I would never leave because I love you so much. But the thing that I struggle with is I love them too. Am I being a good parent if I let it go on? And I know that the answer is I'm not, that I need to.

So I just desperately want you to work hard, Rocket. And they want it too. We all want it. We all wanna be happy. Yeah. And we all are trying our best for you and for ourselves and... How bad does it get? Hmm?

How bad does it get? Really bad. I would say really bad. You can be really mean. You can say really terrible, terrible things to them and to me when you're angry. Yeah. They believe that you think they're stupid and that you think they're dumb and lazy.

They believe that because that's what they hear from you when you're mad. And even when you're not that angry, just when you want them to comply, you pull those weapons out, sometimes really prematurely. And this is different from before? I would say it is a lot more frequent now, a lot more.

We know that people who feel disempowered in the world outside often will take their repressed anger and act it out at home. But I also know that for him it isn't just a response to the disempowerment that he has felt post illness. I also think that this is something that has a longer history and that doesn't relate to the immediate crisis that just occurred. There's a bigger legacy that is at the heart of the way that he explodes with his children. We are in the midst of our session and there is still so much to talk about. We need to take a brief break. So stay with us. Support for this show comes from Indeed. You just realized your business needed to hire somebody yesterday.

How can you find amazing candidates fast? Easy. Just use Indeed. With Indeed-sponsored Jobs, your post jumps to the top of the page for relevant candidates and you're able to reach the people you want faster. And it makes a huge difference. According to Indeed data worldwide, sponsored jobs posted directly on Indeed have 45% more applications than non-sponsored jobs. Plus with Indeed Sponsored Jobs, there are no monthly subscriptions, no long-term contracts, and you only pay for results. There's no need to wait any longer.

Speed up your hiring right now with Indeed. And listeners to this show will get a $100 sponsored job credit to get your job's more visibility at indeed.com slash voxca. Just go to indeed.com slash voxca right now and support this show by saying you heard about indeed on this podcast. Indeed dot com slash vox ca.

Terms and conditions apply. Hiring indeed is all you need. Thumbtack presents the ins and outs of caring for your home. Out, uncertainty, self-doubt, stressing about not knowing where to start. In, plans and guides that make it easy to get home projects done. Out, word art, sorry, live laugh lovers. In, knowing what to do, when to do it, and who to hire. Start caring for your home with confidence.

Download Thumbtack today. Listen, we all love a good hustle. We all love a rise and grind mentality. But let's be real, you could do all that and still be super comfy, right? Right. Nothing says comfort quite like a pair of Crocs. Since 2002, they've been disrupting the footwear industry

with their iconic clogged silhouette. And now you can choose from more than 800 styles to find the pair of Crocs that is perfect for you, like the Echo Wave, with a sculptural boundary pushing design that was crafted with the urban explorer in mind. Whatever your style, buy yours at crocs.com. Your Crocs, your story, your world.

Where did you learn this? I don't know. I do. And who did this to you? Nobody, really. Really? Really? Yeah. You really, your dad did?

I mean, your dad did. It didn't do me and my dad. Your dad did. He does, he is the same kind of way. He's got a short fuse and he can say crazy things when he's mad too. Not as crazy as you, but... And what was that like when you were the child? Oh, not fun. Meaning?

But I also wanted to not mess up. It was my... You wanted his approval? I wanted to be better at everything. I don't know. Really? Yeah. I think we both agree that by the time you were a teenager,

you were rebelling pretty hard. Yeah? Yeah. I think we both agree that by the time you were a teenager, you were rebelling pretty hard. Yeah? Yeah. So I don't think that it made you want to be better. I'm truth checking you a little bit on that. Because. And now that she did a bit of a corrective, why don't you tell me? What was it like to have him shame you, humiliate you, and confuse your behavior

with your personality and character assassinate you? I mean, he was harsh, he was strict, he was mad, but it's not. You thought you deserved it? Well, especially now that I'm older, I realize I probably did deserve it, because I was being a little shit sometimes. You know, sneaking out of the house, there's a lot of things that I did

that I look back on and go, God, I was a terrible little kid. But when she says, But when she says, this will be a deal breaker for me, what happens to you? Well, I don't want to think about that, because it's... She knows that I try, you know. No, but no, she won't know that you tried, because you've just told her that you actually think

it's the right way to be. Yeah. Yeah. They're just, they don't deserve it. And not because I am being too lenient. And I have agreed with you that I will pay more attention. And I've been trying to do that. Or that there's no punishment and we just let it go.

Well, the problem is we don't agree on what requires punishment and what just needs redirection. I redirect them to get back on task, but he wants to punish them for not doing the task. Or something like that, don't you think? Or talking back to you. to get back on task, but he wants to punish them for not doing the task. Or something like that, don't you think? Or talking back to you. If you call them names, you're teaching them to talk back. Yeah.

It's not your intention, but they're learning from you, like you learn from your dad. Yeah. And then you may have one kid who does what you did, which was, I'll outdo you so that you can never have a bad word to say about me. I'll become perfect. I'll become stronger, better, smarter.

I'll show you. Yeah. That was you. And then you have another sibling who basically gets the hell out of there as fast as possible. Mm-hmm. Yeah. And probably barely comes back.

And she doesn't want that for her two boys. Yeah. I've made that exact same statement when you tell me that you turned out okay, I see. You turned out okay because you were pushed by the anger toward your dad. As in, I'll show you. But not before self-destructing pretty good first, too. I don't know. I did drugs when I was younger and things.

Did nothing for a couple of years when I was like 18, 19. And then I quit doing all that stuff and then went back to normal work and stuff like that. That's about it. So you have the experience of turning things around? Yeah. Yes. You've done it already once. Yep.

Good. And what did you do? One day you just said enough of this shit? Yeah. It was basically it. I felt like shit. I looked like shit. Mm-hmm. I was tired of, you know, feeling terrible. Like now? Yeah. Like now? Okay. Very similar, actually.

Mm-hmm. More similar than I'd probably like to admit. Yep. Did it ever occur to you that this is so similar? No. Did it ever occur to you that this is so similar? No. One was self-induced and one is not self-induced. The accident is not self-induced. But the state that you're in right now is,

I don't know that I would call it self-induced, but it is self-generated. Yes. That's very interesting, because you actually have a real precedent. I know how to do this. Yeah? So how bad do I have to feel? Pretty bad.

Or do you need to really feel like she's at the door? I hope not. Do you know that she is? Did you hear her say it just now? Yeah. That was the first time? No. No.

But generally she says it in the middle of a fit. Yeah. And now she said it to you very calmly, very caringly. Yeah. I don't want to leave you. That's not what I want. That's why we're here. That's why I'm still here.

Yeah. But I don't want what's going on in our house to continue either. No? And I think a lot of the time you say things like, whose side are you on? And you try to pit it like it's you versus the kids and whose side are you on? And I don't want to be on any side.

I want to be together and do it together. But we've talked about so many times there are certain behaviors that you do that I can't get behind. And then we're stuck. You feel like I'm not supporting you and I feel like you are doing something so terrible to the children that I can't support it. Yeah. Sometimes I ask for help and I don't feel like I get it. I ask for what do you want to do? What do you think we should do different? And it's often times like, well, let's just let it go.

It's just very direct. And it's like, well, this is the tenth time this has been a problem. Like, we can't just keep it all we need. Your problem is not the discipline issue. Your issue is to be more loving to those kids. Yeah. There's a lack of care, and so you're trying to compensate with control.

Yeah. Do you really mean yeah? I guess is my question. No, no, no, I understand that. Do you? Yeah. Look, this is a very common problem. Yes. And a piece of this is unrelated to what happened to you.

It's just that you feel worse about yourself, so you're dumb more. But the method was in place before because the method is the one that you grew up with. Any boy who was put down and shamed by his dad and who then used it as a source of defiant energy, I'll show you, has this weird belief that it actually was the right tactic. It strengthened me. It made me a man. You actually think that it's the way to go. And it's a way with some known outcomes, with a classic debate between the partners, with which one becomes the overindulgent

and one becomes the over-controlling. And every time you become over-controlling, she will be in your mind overindulgent because she will think that she has to soften the blows and Every time you will become more tough than you actually are because you think that she's turning them into mush Yeah, and you are gonna toughen them up and make a man and she's just like sissying him up and the whole thing is one big gender mindfuck Yeah So you can reverse roles for a while and the whole thing is one big gender mind fuck. Yeah.

So you can reverse roles for a while. You're gonna take the responsibility of limit setting. And you're gonna take the responsibility of showing love. Alright. But you will not look at how well she's setting the limits. You will look at how well you are expressing your love. Your joy for them, your fondness for them, your appreciation for them in your life, your belief in them, your trust in them. That's going to be your focus and only that because you are totally skewed to the other side.

Each of you has taken on one side. You both need both, but that matter. The fact is, your system doesn't work. The system that doesn't work is the system in which parents become polarized, each one thinking that they need to do what they do in order to compensate for what's missing in the other person's approach. But also the system that doesn't work is his hoping to gain control by losing control. That is always an ineffective system. But what I'm also doing more importantly is I'm grounding them into something that can happen and change tomorrow morning.

That is back into the everyday and for which he can do something right away, both of them. And that is a very big shift away from the self absorption around his change and his losses and his mornings into the who can you be right now. You're going to slip and you're going to go back on track. You just remember I'm on a different path here. My goal at this point, I've done a few years of just discipline.

At this point, I'm turning into brats, and the more bratty they become, and the more I'm gonna wanna squish them, and the more I'm gonna squish them, and the more they're gonna resist me, and it's not gonna be good, because I actually would like to connect with these kids, and I'm gonna end up not.

But before that all happens, she'll be gone. Because she has a great pride in who she is as a mother. You know? Yes. And that will come before you. That self-love is gonna be more important than how much she loves you. That she's very clear on, and I respect that a great deal.

Yeah? So, to apologize, there's nothing weak about it. Whoever apologizes first is always the stronger one. A few weeks later, we received a letter from the woman that there had been another major incident and that this time she knew she had reached the limit. She was clear, she was grounded. She loved this man, but she was not going to put her children at risk. Within 15 minutes, she packed up the stuff. She left him.

She went with the children to a hotel and sought a safe haven. But while it took her only 15 minutes to take her children and leave the house, it will take much longer for the remnants of abuse to heal. You just heard a classic session of Where Should We Begin with Esther Perel. We are part of the Vox Media Podcast Network in partnership with New York Magazine and The Cut. To apply with your partner for a session on the podcast, for the transcripts or show notes on each episode, or to sign up for Astaire's monthly newsletter,

go to astaireparell.com. Astaire Perel is the author of Mating in Captivity in the State of Affairs. She also created a game of stories called Where Should We Begin? For details, go to her website, astaireparel.com.