Who Trolled Amber? - The phone calls | Master Ep 6

Episode Date: September 12, 2024

A fifth woman comes forward with allegations against the author Neil Gaiman.Reporter: Paul Caruana Galizia and Rachel JohnsonProducer: Matt RussellAdditional reporting: Jess SwinburneOriginal music and sound design: Tom KinsellaSeries editor: Matt RussellEditor: Jasper CorbettTo find out more about Tortoise:Download the Tortoise app - for a listening experience curated by our journalistsSubscribe to Tortoise+ on Apple Podcasts for early access and ad-free contentBecome a member and get access to all of Tortoise's premium audio offerings and more Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Before we begin, I should warn you that this is a hard listen at times. This series contains graphic descriptions of sex and allegations of sexual abuse. This episode is intended to be listened to after the first five episodes, and all six are designed to be listened to in their entirety, because this is a story of conflicting accounts. Hey. Okay. You can do it. You got this. This is easy. Claire has been stealing herself for this. Hello. Hey. herself for this. She is speaking with Neil Gaiman. She hasn't

spoken to him in close to a decade, but she had sent him a letter to his house in Woodstock, New York State weeks earlier, as there was unfinished business between them. For her, at least. I don't know. I would have, I definitely would have been reaching out a long time ago. I, you know, I've never sort of viewed with anything other than fondness and a little awkwardness and you know, actually feeling like I got the wrong end of the stick, but I thought you were terrific. And I was heartbroken seeing that I was giving you nightmares It's 1.30pm on the 6th of July 2022 and the two of them are discussing what happened between 9 and 10 years earlier. Claire has been struggling with it ever since.

And it seemed Neil Gaiman had too. In that call to Claire, he accepts that he damaged her, and he apologizes. But Neil Gaiman's account, provided to us now, two years after he spoke to Claire, is that he was surprised to hear that she'd been traumatized, because he thought that all their interactions were consensual, and when he realized they weren't, he stopped. But when he's talking to Claire, back in July 2022, he puts a different spin on things. Claire tells him that she's had a long stretch of therapy, one that's put financial strain on her family, and she expresses concern about how expensive the baby she's expecting is going to be.

Neil Gaiman is quick to offer a solution. Would you like me to send you some money? I, again, the whole, like putting a price tag on... I mean, I'm not trying to put a price tag on it. I'm just trying to... I'm not sure that I'm reading you... I said that very bluntly. It's like, listen, you've got a baby on the way and I appreciate that $500 a month... Yes. The two end the call slightly awkwardly. Five days later, Neil Gaiman calls Claire again. So I have a plan and I wanted to run it by you and see if it's acceptable for you.

I've been doing a lot of thinking and a lot of listening to what you were saying on the last call. So what you said about paying for your therapy. I did the numbers and I went, well, that's 10 years of $500 a month, which I make comes out to about $60,000. So what I would propose is that I will give you $15,000 a year for four years, which is the top level centre where Claire used to work. And that is my plan. That is acceptable to you. That is really generous. And I appreciate your... your appreciation for the...

You know, I did something so much shittier than I ever dreamed that I... I didn't even realise I was doing something shitty. I did something really shitty." Claire tells him that she doesn't want the payments to be spread over four years, as it would prolong her contact with him. Something she wanted to end for good. He accepts that. On the 2nd of August 2022 Neil Gaiman sends Claire $60,000 to cover the cost of her therapy. It's not the first time Neil Gaiman has paid women he was involved with money. Two months earlier he had sent some $13,000 New Zealand dollars, which is nearly 8,000 US dollars, and a non-disclosure agreement to Scarlett, after an allegedly abusive sexual relationship that lasted three weeks.

And around eight months before paying Claire, he had paid 275,000 US dollars, and an NDA, to Caroline Warner, after he allegedly coerced her into providing him with sex under the threat of evicting her and her three daughters from his property. Neil Gaiman, who strenuously denied Scarlett and Caroline's allegations, paid all three women money in the space of just eight months. These payments raise questions. Why was he making what looks like personal injury payments to three women? Is it just because, as his account of Claire says, he could offer help? Why would he promise to donate to a rape crisis centre where Claire once worked, when his

position is a denial of all allegations of non-consensual sex? And why is Claire, like all the women we've spoken to for this story, still struggling to come to terms with her involvement with Neil Gaiman. that this isn't black and white. People will say it was consensual. So what happened to me? This is Claire's real voice, but she's using a pseudonym for this podcast. She's a licensed therapist now and doesn't want her clients to change the way they relate to her

because of her experience with Neil Gaiman. It's a scarring experience that tracks straight back to the theme of abusive behaviour that takes place within some sort of consensual relationship, a pattern we've now heard about from four other women. Neil Gaiman's account strongly denies any non-consensual sex with those women. As with Scarlett, Claire's account comes with detailed receipts, records of interactions that show affection, interest, even love. Neal Gaiman's account insists any suggestion of a pattern of behaviour is confected and

flimsy. But the things the women who have spoken to us say he did to them were similar. The harm they say he caused them was similar. The vulnerable situations these women say they were in were similar. The power dynamic of a famous older man and a much younger female is similar.

And now, as we're hearing from Claire, the pattern looks even less flimsy. Like all the other women, Claire thought she was the only one. That's what Neil Gaiman led her to believe on their call in July 2022, and because the $60,000 he paid her didn't come with an NDA. And I saw that as a sign of integrity, and it reassured me that he'd never done this before, because surely somebody who was good at this would send an NDA. Another thing Neal Gaiman didn't do is make a hefty donation to the Rape Crisis Centre where Claire used to work, either directly or through his bookkeeper or business manager. But Claire didn't know that,

just like she didn't know that Neil Gaiman had asked two of the women we've spoken to to sign NDAs. Neil Gaiman's account is that he believes he made a donation to the centre. Claire pointed to on their call and later in an email. But the centre's executive director told us in an email We've looked through our records and do not have any record of receiving a donation from any of those three individuals you named. Neil Gaiman might have thought that the promise of a hefty donation and covering the costs of Claire's therapy would be the end of her story. And I want to be clear, I would pay more than $60,000 for this never to have happened to me. But it felt like he was at least trying and he felt remorse.

But what she really wanted to know was whether he'd mistreated women before, and that he wouldn't do so again. She wanted to break the pattern. I'm Rachel Johnson. And I'm Paul Caruana Galizia. This is the Slow Newscast from Tortis. You're listening to Master, the allegations against Neil Gaiman. Episode 6, The Phone Calls. I love you. I love you. It felt like I was in a dream, and I was terrified, but excited. In September 2012, Amanda Palmer, a singer and Neil Gaiman's wife,

was touring her second studio album, Theatre is Evil. On Friday the 14th of September she played the Cat's Cradle venue in Carborough, North Carolina. Claire, who thought Amanda Palmer was kick-ass, was there. After the concert, Claire spoke to her. They were surrounded by other fans. Claire said that she'd be seeing Neil Gaiman at a talk at the Diana Wertham Theatre in Asheville, North Carolina in two days' time. The event was to be hosted by Malaprop's bookshop,

which was organising a book signing. Claire, a lifelong fan of Neil Gaiman's writing, was going to be there. She volunteered to hold books open for him, some 500 of them, so that she could finally meet him. And I asked if she wanted me to pass a message on to him. And so she put her arms around my neck and she whispered, hello Neil, into my ear.

And she said I had permission to nibble his earlobe and that he's British, so he'll act all embarrassed, but he'll secretly like it. And I remember all the other friends going, oh, being so jealous. And I didn't have any intention of nibbling his ear because I was 22 and he was 30 years older than me and I was in a loving committed relationship and I had no sexual or romantic attraction to him and your stuff grosses me out. But I was excited to have another excuse to actually talk to him. On Sunday the 16th of September at Malaprops,

Claire was introduced to Neil Gaiman by the bookshop staff. And I told him that I had a message for him from Amanda, then I asked him to stand up. And I still don't know where I got the courage to do that because I was so terrified. But he stood up and I gave him a big hug. And as I was pulling away, he kissed me on the cheek. Claire says she never nibbled his earlobe as Amanda Palmer suggested she should because she

felt it would be too forward and in any case isn't into ears. We've reached out to Amanda Palmer as we have multiple times before, but received no comment yet. But we have discovered that she and Neil Gaiman, though separated, are still married. Neil Gaiman's account is that he recalls Claire nibbling his ear, which is why his account says he may have responded by kissing her on the cheek. And it was a little awkward, but I figured that was just a British thing. And after the hug, I was taken care of, and I was still really nervous, but it was very unassuming and sweet, and we chatted a bit.

Neil Gaiman carried on signing books and finished up the show. So he took me to the back of the theater and it was really dark, but he had everyone sign a poster that I had. And he told me this really beautiful story about this flash mob wedding that he and Amanda had had. And he ended the story by saying, and then we kissed like this. And he put his hands on my shoulders and he kissed me on the cheek again. It was the second time that night Neil Gaiman had kissed Claire on the cheek, having only met her hours earlier.

It wasn't weird because it couldn't be weird, because it was Neil Gaiman. If I felt weird, then I was the weird one. After it all, he invited her to his next event on the tour, which was in Charlotte, North Carolina, on Tuesday, 18th of September. So I said yes. Of course I said yes. The next morning, one of Claire's friends, who helped organize the book signing, messaged her. The friend told Claire that Neil Gaiman adored her. Flattered by this, Claire was excited to see Neil Gaiman at the event in

Charlotte. She went with her friend and they were both invited to an after party. And I got pretty drunk and I went inside to get some water and I bumped into him and he asked if we could take a picture of us kissing to prove to Amanda that he was coming out of his British shell. Because it drove her crazy, apparently. It drove her crazy. So he took me to the laundry room and he had what he called a pretend kiss. And I found the photo the other day and it's, it does not look pretend. The photo which Claire has shared shows her and Neil Gaiman kissing on the lips. Her eyes are closed as are his.

One of her arms is wrapped around him. The other is resting on his shoulder. But afterwards, they both went back outside. wrapped around him, the other is resting on his shoulder. But afterwards, they both went back outside. Claire told Neil Gaiman she was an advocate at a rape crisis helpline. Neil Gaiman mentioned his friend, the singer Tori Amos, who co-founded RAIN, America's largest anti-sexual assault charity. Neil Gaiman told Claire that he could get her full-time work there.

So at the end of the night, someone offered to drive us back to my car, which was parked downtown, and the car was packed, and I was the last one in, so I sat on a couple different laps, but mostly Neil's lap. And he had an erection, and a few minutes into the drive he started trying to put his hands up my dress. And at that point I was starting to sober up, and it felt gross, but I let him do it. And I didn't help him. The dress was kind of tricky to get into. I didn't help him, so eventually he gave up and just kept his hands on my legs. I was really pliant. Like, I just let it happen. And that was kind of the theme. I was kind of submitted to it. Not because I wanted it, but because it was Neil Gaiman. He was touching me, he

was close to me, I was in his orbit. So we made it to my car and my friend drove him because I was still a little drunk to his hotel. And when we got there, I had to pee. So I went in the lobby and after I was done, he asked for a few minutes alone with me. He asked my friend for a few minutes alone with me. And when we were alone he pressed me up against the wall of the hotel room and he kissed me and I hated it. I hated the feeling of his tongue in my ear and his hands in my hair but I didn't say no. It did not feel like an option. Eventually, Claire and her friend left. And we went to Waffle House.

And I received a long email from him. And he said he had never done this before, but he liked me and he wanted to stay in touch with me. And I remember being really impressed by how long, how quickly he had written such a long email. In his email, which Claire read at 5am on the 19th of September, Neil Gaiman appears bashful. The email is composed as if what happened was an unexpected and lovely one-off, and that she was the first and the only one. He writes,

This is fun and surprising and fun and exciting and really interesting and unexpected. Now I want to take you out for long walks and find out who you are and how you think and what you do. I know you're beautiful and funny and scary smart and I love that you do the flustered and bemused thing to cover both the scary smart and everything else, mostly because that's my default too. I really really liked kissing you." And then he adds in brackets, because you are probably wondering, no, I've really not done this before, although Amanda has wanted me to for ages. You're it, and a nice funny it too.

He signs off his email with, love, slightly nervously, Neil. It's easy to forget that it's an email written by a man about to turn 52 years old. That it's an email from a world famous author to a female fan 30 years younger, rather than the other way around. Claire messaged another friend and told her all about it. She's shared the messages and they read like two excitable teenagers gossip. She keeps asking her friend not to judge her. Claire says he was seriously gentle.

They were both giddy with excitement over what Claire described in the hotel lobby and discussed what her response to his email should be. Claire shares a draft with her friend, who tells her, It's so cute. Claire replies enthusiastically the next day, September 20th, thanking Neil Gaiman for, A really great time, and suggesting lots more things the pair can do together, such as hikes in the gorgeous mountain trails of Asheville.

She closes with, I was also a fan of the kissing. If you don't mind, I'd very much like to kiss you again. In another email that day, Claire writes to him, Your lap is extremely comfortable, especially when your hands are involved. I seriously regret my wardrobe choice, and that I didn't just wrap my arms around you and start making out with you shamelessly in the back of the car. That is also something I regret. Over the next 6-9 months, Claire and Neil Gaiman would email from him or a text. It was similar to the adrenaline of anxiety, but it was also just the adrenaline. It was excitement, but confusion

too, because the only thing we had that came close to a relationship talk was when he sent me a link to an article about his open marriage with Amanda. And he told me at one point that it was an arrangement that he was able to take advantage of more than she was because of how tired she got after concerts, and book tours were not nearly as tiring. But regardless of what we called it, I had his attention, and the possibility of losing that felt devastating. So even when I was uncomfortable, I was willing to be uncomfortable and be pushed out of my comfort zone in ways I never would have with anyone else, because he was my hero and I trusted that he'd never push too far. And I told him that I had a boyfriend and he told me that he was glad and to tell my boyfriend that he wasn't a threat.

Most of the time I felt like the luckiest fan in the world. There were so many other fans who I could think of who would just kill to be on my shoes. Here I was, Skyping Neil Gaiman at 11 o'clock at night and he was showing me around his library and introducing me to his dog. Gradually the exchanges became more explicit. On one call, Neil Gaiman appeared naked. The two would swap photos over email. In one, Neil Gaiman looks directly into the camera, topless and with messy hair, as though he's just come out of the shower or bath.

In another, Claire sends him a photo of her looking sheepishly at the camera. And there's one of her standing in front of a mirror in her bra looking anxious. Neil Gaiman replies to that photo with, you are very beautiful and endearingly terrified. Sometimes though, it would just be platonic, like when Claire had had a tough day at work that call and hit help her through it. There's a lot of groundwork that he was laying, like he was making me feel safe, he was creating call and hit help her through it. Over time, the lines moved and blurred. New Gaiman's position is that he was corresponding with someone he'd kissed and had every reason to believe, enjoyed it, and wished to do it again. But there was one call Claire remembers. It was maybe a few months in and he told me, I don't know what I see in you. I'm an award-winning,

best-selling author and you are... and he never finished the science, but he didn't need to because I know exactly who I was. I was a 22 year old broke, unemployed fan in an infinite line of obsessed fans and I was a nobody and I was replaceable. And that conversation stands out to me back then because of how terrible and small it made me feel, but it stands out to me now because I can see exactly what he was doing. He was doing it to keep me down and to remind me of my place and to remind me of the stakes if I didn't respond to him in the right way. If I wasn't interesting enough or flirty enough. Claire says in their exchanges she was always clear she didn't want sex and that he always

agreed. She says she was in a loving didn't want sex and that he always agreed. She says she was in a loving committed relationship at the time, with the man who's now her husband. In his messages to Claire, he appears to have been skeptical of Neil Gaiman's interest in her. The messages suggest he thought Neil Gaiman wasn't really interested in friendship, but in something else. On the 27th of September 2012, he asks Claire whether she's heard from Neil Gaiman lately. She replies, yes, he does not want sex to happen either. It's all very exciting. She then adds, I never wanted to have sex with him. And, not only

would sex with Neil Gaiman be gross, I'd also be extremely ashamed about it. But still, Claire remained anxious. In December 2012, she emailed him, Neil, I'm nervous and worried. I really really like you, but right now I'm extremely overwhelmed, and I genuinely think that any more flirting will make me explode. My conclusion is that I'm hopelessly out of my depth here, and should probably head to shallower water. She signs off with, nervously, the same way he'd signed off his first email to her back in September. The emails continued and on the 22nd of June 2013, Claire attended one of New Gamers events at a bookshop in Dekatur, Georgia. She stayed near him backstage as he was signing books. His

account is that she wrote to him effusively about the event. And then, about a week later, the tone of their emails and calls shifted. One night I told him I couldn't sleep. Neil Gaiman responded to her email with, You have fingers and an imagination and also my phone number... And we'd had a few late night phone calls at that point where he'd show me around his house and talk with me. And when I called that night, he initiated phone sex with me. And he told me that I didn't need to talk.

So I stayed quiet. So he talked about how he would fuck me until it almost hurt because of how big he was. And he talked about how he would flip me around and fuck me from behind. And through all of that, I did not say a word and it felt deeply, deeply weird. Neil Gaiman's position doesn't accept Claire's description of this phone sex, saying the tone of their correspondence isn't congruent with it. Claire's description of this

phone sex is similar to three other women's accounts of their phone sex with Neil Gaiman. Still, the next day Claire told him in an email, last night was absolutely wonderful and completely unprecedented, haven't ever gotten off with someone on the phone before. And I planned on going to one of his tourist stops in Nashville a couple days later. The event was at Nashville's War Memorial Auditorium on the 10th of July 2013. It was for Neil Gaiman to talk about his book, The Ocean at the End of the Lane. But after that phone call, I didn't want to go to Nashville anymore. It had made me feel extremely uncomfortable and no matter what Neil was saying about it, we didn't want to go to Nashville anymore. It had made me feel extremely

uncomfortable and no matter what Neil was saying about we didn't want to have sex and we were just friends, I was worried that if I went I would be pressured into doing something I didn't want to do. It was definitely a shock. And there was part of me that had been braced for impact for a while. And that was throughout all of this. It was like there was two parts of me, right? There was that kid, that 11 year old starry eyed fan. And then there was that other part, that almost adult, not almost adult, that adult who was like, this is listen to your body girl, you are not safe.

Sometimes the starry-eyed fan one. She suggested, in an email in October 2013, that they could spend one of the nights on his tour together. But sometimes she thought the adult one. After the phone sex, she also reiterated on a Skype call that she had no desire to have intercourse with him. And he told me there was no pressure and I was under no obligation to do anything. But when we got to Nashville, the second we were alone, he started making out with me and he groped my butt and moved his hands, and I tried to keep my lower body away from his lower body. So in Nashville, it was for the ocean at the end of the lane, he was doing readings, and there was a performer in the beginning to open, like an opening act, and so he asked me to come backstage while he was getting ready for the opening act.

And that was when I went backstage. And we were alone. And that's when he started making out with me and he grabbed my butt and I moved his hands. He kept coming back and I kept moving his hands. And I tried to angle my body away from his lower body and then people came in. I was signalling so much discomfort. It was unmistakable what my body language was telling him. There was no reason why he might have misinterpreted that. There were two other women with Claire that night on the 10th of July 2013. And when the reading was over, he told me and my friends to go to the tour bus and wait for him while he signed books.

And I told the other women that I was starting to get scared. And we came up with a hand signal, jazz hands, that I could use if I needed help. And his assistant brought us whiskey while we waited. Black label. I remember that. It was my first time in Nashville, and none of us were sober at that point. Yeah, when he came back, he sat down and he patted his knee to have me sit on his lap, and he had an erection and I started to panic, and I did jazz hands to the other women,

but they didn't do anything, and I still don't know why, I think they may just have not. Maybe they didn't see or they were too drunk. So he took me to the back of the bus, and he got on top of me, and he started kissing me, and groping under my dress, and over my breasts. And he kept saying, kiss me like you mean it, kiss me like you'll never see me again. Because he knew, he knew I didn't mean it, and he knew that the threat of not seeing him again was such a threat to me. He didn't stop, and I felt so trapped under his body, and I knew if I stopped responding

I would never see him again. And in spite of everything, and how disgusted I felt, and how wrong this felt, I thought of never seeing him again. It broke my heart. So yeah, I... My arms felt really heavy, and everything was fog foggy and I must not have been pretending enough because he rolled off of me. And then he said, and this still boggles my mind, this language. He said, I'm a very wealthy man and I'm used to getting what I want.

And I didn't respond because how do you respond to that? So then he said I'm really sad because I think I'm going to have to let you go. And then it was over. Neil Gaiman's account is that he invited Claire onto his tour bus because their correspondents suggested to him that she wanted intimate contact. His account is that he attempted to initiate a kiss with her while they were lying on a bed at the back of the bus talking, but he stopped when it became quickly apparent that she didn't want one. His account denies that he ever said, I'm a very wealthy man and I'm used to getting what I want. And I don't remember leaving the tour bus, I don't remember what that looked like.

I just remember being back in the hotel and just crying and crying and crying. And I messaged my boyfriend and told him I thought I'd been sexually assaulted and I wanted to go home. Claire shared those messages with us. They chart her emotional journey that night. At 7.14pm she writes, I'm having a lot of fun. And I shouldn't have dreaded this so much. At 9.36pm she writes, So out of my comfort zone and there's nothing I can do about it. Less than half an hour later she writes, I'm safe with my friends.

39 minutes later, I need to leave. Frustrated by her boyfriend being non-responsive, she writes sarcastically, wasn't sexually assaulted much, or extremely harassed, or touched too inappropriately. And I'm an idiot for even thinking I could just be friends with Neil Gaiman. She also made a diary entry in her round careful handwriting. 10th July 2013 Everything went to shit. When I hung out with Neil, I was really uncomfortable. When we were in the bus together, he pressured me. I think I was really uncomfortable. When we were in the bus together he pressured me. I think I was sexually assaulted." Sexual assault can cause severe emotional distress,

even if it doesn't involve violence. Which is why its legal definition, in Tennessee and most jurisdictions, doesn't rest on the occurrence of a physical attack. And which is why Claire says she remembers so clearly how she felt that night and how she continued to feel afterwards. I just felt so trapped and I had so many dreams after that. Nightmares of him on top of me and I would wake up crying and screaming and pushing him away and like that. Feeling of being helpless and trapped. After that night, Claire stopped messaging

Neil Gaiman. Some months later, he messaged her to ask if the two were still friends. And he told me that he regretted us making things sexual. And all of this had been nothing more than, he called it an apotheosis, the miscommunication. He said that my indecision had caused everyone stress that night. And I believed him. Like, what else could I do? I was so used to believing his stories and it didn't just feel natural, it felt... It was a relief to believe him because it was so much easier to blame myself than it

was to admit to myself that he had done that to me. In the aftermath of everything I was so confused and lost and so when Neil told me that his version of what had happened his story became my story and it took me years to piece together what had actually happened to me. Over the following years Claire would speak with friends about what had happened in those nine or so months with Neil Gaiman and they would all tell her the same thing. She began googling Neil Gaiman and sexual assault just as years later Scarlet would, but found nothing. And then she began reaching out to journalists at major news organisations. She wanted them to know what Neil Gaiman had done to her, and that she was concerned he'd

done it before and would do it to another woman. She wanted them to know they're not alone if they existed. In 2017 she emailed Jezebel, a news website geared towards women. A journalist there told her what Neil Gaiman did was gross, but that she needed to hear from more women to do the story. In 2018 she emailed Buzzfeed and got no response. In 2019 she emailed a prominent freelance journalist and got no reply. That year she also emailed the Washington Post and was told that no journalist there would follow up on her story. And she emailed The Cut and got no response. In 2020 she emailed Slate and a famous journalist

at the New Yorker. Neither responded. This is all through the rise of Me Too when the allegations against Harvey Weinstein had been front and centre of people's minds. When people began thinking seriously about sexual misconduct in its various forms. People including Neil Gaiman who sent out tweets to his 3 million followers like ''On a day like today, it's worth saying I believe survivors. Men must not close our eyes and minds to what happens to women in this world. And people, including Claire. But then I started to learn new language.

Sexual coercion and grooming and abuse of power and Darvo and unwanted sexual experiences. Darvo stands for deny, attackse Victim and Offender. I felt so much more had in effect told her that her story wasn't a story. Like Scarlett in 2022 and 2023, with the New Zealand police, her experience wasn't enough. But now she was pregnant and began having nightmares about Neil Gaiman.

She wanted to confront them. Claire reached out to Papillon de Beurre, a therapist who hosts a podcast in which they interview survivors of sexual abuse. It's called Am I Broken? Survivor Stories. Papillon wanted to interview Claire, giving her the space to tell her story. But she decided to write to Neil Gaiman directly instead and told Papillon that she'd do the interview if other women came forward about Neil Gaiman and... So I just set up a Google alert for Neil Gaiman sexual assault and I let myself rest.

And then she turned her letter to Neil Gaiman. to Neil Gaiman. In it, Claire describes a recent dream she says she had about him, a dream in which he apologized to her and recognized that, she wrote, the vast power imbalance that existed between us made my consent to any kind of physical or romantic relationship impossible. Neil Gaiman responded to Claire's letter by email, then arranged a phone call with her. That was the call you heard at the beginning of this episode. I'm sorry. Yeah.

I think even my memories of it are obviously wrong. And I think that's really telling, right? Like this is something I've been thinking about for a long time. And this is something that's not... Like there's a lot of dust for you. Because it's not been on your mind in the same way. It hasn't. It's been... And it obviously has been with you.

Yep. Well, enormously on your mind. Yeah, you've taken up a lot of real estate in my brain. Oh, shit. I'm so fucking sorry. I appreciate you saying that and I'm sorry that this is... Well, no, I'm glad you don't remember it in this way because I think that would be even more upsetting if you actually remembered it like that. Um... I don't want you going through the rest of your life, seeing my name on things and feeling sick or feeling angry or feeling triggered or whatever. I just, you know, you're going to be alive a lot longer than I am.

And you will run into bits of me for the rest of your life, whatever happens, because I've been around. She'd expected him to be defensive on the call. Instead, he was contrite, apolog apologetic and looked to make amends. Claire is neurodivergent and because she was pregnant at the time she was unable to take her prescription medicine. In this situation she was worried she'd emotionally detach herself from the conversation, hearing it as one happening between two other people. So she recorded the call. She wanted a recording to be able to return to it

at a later date she never thought she'd use the recording beyond that. But that's not the end. Remember that Google alert Claire had set up? Two years later, when we published our investigation into the first sexual assault allegations against Neil Gaiman, Claire got an alert. And she got back in touch as she said she would with Papillon. Finally she got to tell her story on her terms. It was the moment that his story separated at last from hers. Because she says she saw

what he told her in their last exchange of messages and on their phone calls was untrue. Neil Gaiman's account is that if he'd been contacted in advance of Papillon's podcast, he'd have been able to provide material to show his side of the story. His account points out that Claire is now making further allegations which weren't presented in her interview with Papillon. Claire approached us because she wanted her story to be reported in full and for Neil Gaiman's claims to be investigated. Neil Gaiman had assured to be investigated. Neil Gaiman had assured her that she was an exception.

Because normally I keep all... I keep fans at arm's length. But we have heard sexual assault allegations against him from two former fans, including Kay, that span 2005 to 2007. That is, years before he even met Claire. He told Claire, A few years ago I was informed I was high-functioning autistic, which is an interesting thing to learn about yourself when you're old. That did mean I sort of went, oh, okay, this is why I sort of sometimes find myself tiptoeing through human relations and sometimes getting really wrong. But people with autism are more likely to be victims of sexual abuse than perpetrators. Like anyone else autistic people are capable of learning from

negative experiences and are not simply bound to repeat them and they are usually more concerned about misreading situations and so more cautious. He tried to tell Claire that her memory was faulty. I have a message for you from your wife. Oh, I didn't get it. And then we were alone, and then you smooched me kind of passionately, and that was, I... Yeah, that's... I mean, I would never have made the first move on anybody. I would be terrified of that. Okay.

And I thought that... I... Not what happened there. Because I thought that you liked me and wanted me. And that you liked me and wanted me and that you... I'm sorry. I hear what you're saying. I hear what you're saying and I'm gonna cut you off here

because I don't think this is a super productive way of having this conversation in terms of people. I'm sorry. And no, no, no, and I do wanna say that I didn't kiss you. You didn't? Nope. But it's his memory that appears to be wrong. That he kissed her first is corroborated by contemporaneous chats she had with a friend and one of his own emails.

And that he'd never have made the first move on anybody because he'd be terrified to, is not supported by even his own account of Scarlett, which says that he invited her to take a bath with him the first time they met. Kay says he propositioned her and her friend for sex the first evening they spent with him. Julia Hobsbawm says he aggressively jumped on her unprompted at her London flat in 1986. Caroline Walner says he came on to her first at a sauna on his Woodstock property in 2017.

On the phone, Claire points out the age gap that he is 30 years older than she is and that it was inappropriate. He agrees. And Neil Gaiman also tells Claire, And yet, months earlier, Neil Gaiman had been with Scarlett, who was 40 years younger than him. Over the course of this series we've seen how Neil Gaiman uses his status, his wealth and his fame to seduce, allegedly abuse and then discard women. We have heard the voices of five women. Since we published the first two women's stories in July 2024, Neil Gaiman has not made a public statement of any kind. The movie of his book Coraline was re-released as a 15th anniversary special in late August

and was an unexpected box office smash, grossing more than $20 million in its first weekend alone but he was nowhere to be seen or heard at the premieres. He's been represented by PR advisors and lawyers over the reporting of this story. The account we were given for this episode stated that Neil Gaiman's recollections of his physical interactions with Claire were consensual, that there is contemporaneous material in the form of messages to support this, and that he immediately stopped his physical advances on Claire on that tour bus when he thought they weren't reciprocated. Since April 2024 when we first reach out to Neil Gaiman, he has declined repeated requests

for an interview. But thanks to Claire's recordings, we have heard him, in his own voice, accept responsibility and apologize for his behavior in her case. It's an apparent contrast to the account we were given. The realization for these women that they were a commodity to a man they thought they were in a relationship or a friendship with has taken some of them years to come to terms with. For them, this is not over. This series is reported by me, Rachel Johnson and Paul Caruana Galizia. This episode is produced by Matt Russell.

Sand Design and Original Music is by Tom Kinsella. Additional reporting is by Jess Swinburne. Artwork is by John Hill. The series editor is Matt Russell. The editor is Jasper Corbett. So The End TORTUS