48 Hours - Everything to Lose

Episode Date: January 4, 2024

Dana Clair Edwards was found dead in her home in San Antonio, Texas on January 2, 2009. She was last seen alive leaving a New Year’s Eve party just after midnight. Police interviewed friends and acquaintances, including Dana’s ex-boyfriend, John Thomas Ford. Prosecutors soon believed that he was their main suspect, but the investigation dragged on and Ford remained a free man. Dana’s mother, Deborah Edwards believed Jon Thomas Ford was the alleged killer and tormented him with notes and emails marking anniversaries, birthdays and holidays; each note including a reference to her daughter. Finally, a year after the murder, there was a break in the case. “48 Hours" correspondent Richard Schlesinger reports. This classic "48 Hours" episode last aired on 8/17/2013. Watch all-new episodes of “48 Hours” on Saturdays, and stream on demand on Paramount+.See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Wondery Plus subscribers can listen to this podcast ad-free right now. Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app today. Even if you love the thrill of true crime stories as much as I do, there are times when you want to mix it up. And that's where Audible comes in, with all the genres you love and new ones to discover. Explore thousands of audiobooks, podcasts, and originals, with more added all the time. thousands of audiobooks, podcasts, and originals, with more added all the time. Listening to Audible can lead to positive change in your mood, your habits,

and even your overall well-being. And you can enjoy Audible anytime, while doing household chores, exercising, commuting, you name it. There's more to imagine when you listen. Sign up for a free 30-day Audible trial and your first audio book is free. Visit audible.ca. I'm Erin Moriarty of 48 Hours and of all the cases I've covered, this is the one that troubles me most. Listen to Murder in the Orange Grove, The Trouble Case Against Crosley Green,

wherever you get your podcasts. He was upset. I think he was angry. He parks around the corner because he doesn't want to be seen. He walks in. He waits. And he's watching. He waits over an hour.

He waits for the lights to go off. And I don't think she had a fighting chance. The nature of this crime was a very personal crime. Did he pop her in the mouth first and then the head blow? There was no other motivation for this murder but to kill Dana Claire Edwards. It just was hard not to like her. Everybody liked her. Well, Dana was my little sister. She was so full of energy from such a young age

through her entire life. She had beautiful green eyes. And when she smiled, her eyes smiled. She loved people. She was happy. And then it was cut off. It was stopped. She was laying face down on the floor. I just wanted to see her green eyes. The pieces didn't fit for me.

A strangulation just seemed so deep and so personal. It had to have been someone who knew her very well. The first people you go to in a murder are friends and acquaintances and lovers. A wonderful girl, full of energy, full of life. Thomas Ford was Dana Clare's boyfriend for a number of years. Thomas Ford became a suspect very early on. Sorry I had to ask you these hard questions. When she was dating Thomas, after they'd gotten serious,

she really had thought that they would get married and have a family. Dana Claire Edwards and Thomas Ford broke up in the fall of 2008. Common sense says Thomas Ford was the most logical suspect because he had just broken up with Dana Claire. But common sense isn't evidence. Evidence was lost. The fingernail clippings of the right hand.

Lost underwear. Lost underwear. If they're that sloppy about what they lose, how sloppy are they about what they bring to the jury? From the beginning of working on this case, I did not doubt that John Thomas Ford was guilty. Thomas Ford did not kill Dana Clare Edwards and does not know who did. There's nothing more frustrating as a prosecutor than to think that he might get away with this.

I'm Richard Schlesinger. Tonight on 48 Hours, everything to lose. in 2014 laura hevlin was in her home in tennessee when she received a call from california her daughter erin corwin was missing the young wife of a Marine had moved to the California desert to a remote base near Joshua Tree National Park. They have to alert the military and when they do, the NCIS gets involved. From CBS Studios and CBS News, this is 48 Hours NCIS. Listen to 48 Hours NCIS ad-free starting October 29th on Amazon Music. Hot shot Australian attorney Nicola Gaba was born into legal royalty. Her specialty? Representing some of the city's most infamous gangland criminals. However, while Nicola held the underworld's darkest secrets,

the most dangerous secret was her own. She's going to all the major groups within Melbourne's underworld, and she's informing on them all. I'm Marsha Clark, host of the new podcast, Informants Lawyer X. In my long career in criminal justice as a prosecutor and defence attorney, I've seen some crazy cases, and this one belongs right at the top of the list. She was addicted to the game she had created. She just didn't know how to stop.

Now, through dramatic interviews and access, I'll reveal the truth behind one of the world's most shocking legal scandals. She just didn't know how to stop. Early and ad-free right now. It's a place where I come to decompress. I can relax out here, be away from everything, spend the night in the country, get up in the country. It takes a lot to get defense attorney Dick DeGaran away from his cattle and into a courtroom. He's one of the most famous defense lawyers in Texas. He can pick and choose his cases, and he's chosen the case of Thomas Ford. Look very carefully at the evidence. You will find that Thomas Ford is not guilty. Thomas Ford is 43 years old, from one of the best families in one of the best neighborhoods of San Antonio. He's charged with killing his former girlfriend, Dana Claire Edwards.

I'm worried that an innocent man could be convicted. DeGaran will do battle with three of San Antonio's top prosecutors, led by Catherine Babbitt. And you guys are going against Dick DeGaran? Her co-counsel, Kirsta Melton. I am rock solid in the truth. And Kathy Cunningham knew well what they were up against. The Fords had everything they could want. We object to it and she continued. The best attorney, a lot of money. So we were behind the eight ball and even if we lost it,

we were going to fight as hard as we could for Dana and for the Edwards. Edwards. January 2nd, 2009, Dana Clare's body was found face down in her condo. You try to think, well, what could have happened? You can never imagine that someone would murder your child. You can never imagine that someone would murder your child. We thought Dinah was in the safest place in the world. Deborah and Daryl Edwards raised Dinah Clare in the Tony San Antonio neighborhood called Alamo Heights. Dinah didn't look down on anyone, whether it was the poorest person or the richest person. We were in cheerleading together. We really bonded over that. Dana Clare's close friend, Cornelia Sawatsky. And I just, I miss her, miss her a lot. She was a positive energy and a positive spirit. I mean, she was just always full of life and love.

Dana's older brother, DJ. The ultimate, you know, American girl. She loved horses, and she loved dogs. Dogs, cats, ducks, anything that walked. She was constantly bringing them home. But it was Grit, a Jack Russell Terrier, mostly, who was her favorite. She rescued him, and he became her constant companion. Grit was always kind of her main little baby, and he's a special little critter. Dana went to medical school but had to drop out after seriously injuring her back in a car accident.

She worked in the family construction business near her childhood home in Alamo Heights. When Dana Clare was murdered, of course Thomas Ford, her ex-boyfriend, was a logical suspect. But most people say he's not an obvious suspect. What kind of guy is he? He's a really decent, nice guy. He had a great upbringing. Popular in high school. Had a lot of friends.

Dana Clare and Thomas began dating in 2006. It seemed like a healthy, you know, kind of solid relationship. We did like Thomas very much. Daryl and Deborah Edwards treated Thomas like family. Fun person to be with. He was at our ranch a lot of times. He was at our ranch a lot of times. Like Dana Clare, Thomas Ford worked for his family's company, also in construction. From the beginning, I didn't see it as a match, as a good match. But DJ and his girlfriend, Tammy Trasher, thought that even though Dana and Thomas had some things in common,

they were still an odd couple. They seemed too different. She wanted to settle down. He was more in the single mindset. In October of 2008, after a two-and-a-half-year relationship, Dana Clare broke up with Thomas. But the two moved in the same social circles and remained friends. Then, just before Christmas, Thomas asked Dana Claire over to his house. Her mother says he told Dana he was having a hard time with the breakup. She told me that it had been a really hard meeting,

but he was going on and on and crying and she was worried. And she said, finally, I just had to leave mother. If Dana Claire was worried about Thomas, she was looking forward to her own future. She got ready for New Year's Eve in Alamo Heights and said goodbye to her parents who were going to the family ranch. I went in and told her, I said, we're going to go to the ranch a day early. And she said, let me walk you to your car, Mom. Gave me a big hug and a kiss, stood at the car door and said, y'all have fun, I'll call you. Dana Clare rang in 2009 at this party.

Thomas was also there. She went home shortly after midnight. Happy New Year. The next day, New Year's Day, her parents expected to hear from Dana. The Edwards called their daughter dozens of times But of course, she never answered Have you ever wondered who created that bottle of sriracha that's living in your fridge? Or why nearly every house in America has at least one game of Monopoly?

Introducing The Best Idea Yet, a brand new podcast from Wondery and T-Boy about the surprising origin stories of the products you're obsessed with and the bold risk-takers who brought them to life. Like, did you know that Super Mario, the best-selling video game character of all time, only exists because Nintendo couldn't get the rights to Popeye? Or Jack, that the idea for the McDonald's Happy Meal first came from a mom in Guatemala? From Pez dispensers to Levi's 501s to Air Jordans,

discover the surprising stories of the most viral products. Plus, we guarantee that after listening, you're going to dominate your next dinner party. So follow The Best Idea Yet on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to The Best Idea Yet early and ad-free right now by joining Wondery Plus. It's just the best idea yet. As a kid growing up in Chicago, there was one horror movie I was too scared to watch. It was called Candyman. But did you know that the movie Candyman was partly inspired by an actual murder? Listen to Candyman, the true story behind the bathroom mirror murder, wherever you get your podcasts.

Hadn't gotten a call from Dinah on New Year's Day. We looked at each other and just said, we got to go. Daryl and Deborah Edwards drove to their daughter's apartment as fast as they could. I opened the door and I yelled for Dana and there was no sound back and no dogs. The apartment was pitch black as they went inside. And how long were you in the house before you found her? Less than five minutes. She was lying on the bathroom floor in a big pool of blood,

and I felt her leg, and it was cold. Dana Clare's face was covered with a towel. It was very hard. And I kneeled on the floor next to her and pushed the towel off of her head and looked at her beautiful green eyes. and looked at her beautiful green eyes. I have no idea how long I was there.

It was until the police made me get up and leave. At 2.30 a.m. on January 2, 2009, the police arrived and began videotaping the scene. Evidence item one, blood. Despite blood droplets, rolled up carpet, and a room in disarray, police chief William McManus says at first, police thought Dana Clare had fallen

and hit her head on the sink. The case was considered an accidental death. I believe that they felt there was something suspicious about it, but they believed that it was not a homicide. But there were a lot of questions. What happened to Dana Clare? Where was Grit? Dana Clare was almost never without her dog, and he was nowhere to be found. Hours later, on January 2nd, police called with the results of Dana Clare's autopsy. They said homicide and ligature strangulation.

She'd been strangled? Yes. The autopsy also revealed Dana Clare was hit in the head repeatedly. But whatever happened here, it did not look like a robbery. There was no sign of forced entry and nothing was taken. When I heard, I just knew it had been deeply personal just because the way the killing was perpetrated. The news that Dana Clare had been murdered came as friends had gathered to comfort the Edwards family. And one of the people who came to the Edwards house was Thomas Ford.

He gave me a hug and then he kind of stood around and talked to a few people. He wouldn't look at me. He wouldn't look me in the eyes. But if Ford was avoiding Mrs. Edwards' eyes, he was not avoiding the police. Thanks for coming in. Appreciate that. Oh, absolutely. He agreed to be interviewed by detectives the next day without a lawyer. It's been a death. Sure. Do you have any idea why somebody would have wanted to hurt her? No, I have no idea. And the detective questioned Ford about this New Year's party. He and Dana both attended just hours before she was killed. Ford said he left the party before midnight and went to sleep shortly after that.

You go home, change, and within a few minutes, you're out. Watched a little TV and went to bed. And within a few minutes, you're out. Watched a little TV and went to bed. But within a few days, police found evidence that made them doubt Ford's story. This dark and grainy surveillance tape from a camera across the street from Dana Clare's condo complex. What do you think you can tell from that tape? You could at least tell that it was a white SUV, the type that Thomas was driving. That white SUV entered and left the complex twice, between 11.20 and midnight.

Then, a few minutes later, someone is seen walking into the complex. Police thought that figure was Thomas Ford, wearing the same clothes he wore to the party. Do you remember what you were wearing tonight? Jeans, a red shirt, and a tan vest. Investigators asked Ford for those clothes in the weeks after the murder, but he refused to turn them over and then promptly hired a lawyer. Two weeks into the investigation, the battered remains of Dana Clare's dog, Grit, were found near the Olmos Dam, almost two miles from her house.

And that dog was Dana's dog. That was her baby. Prosecutor Kathy Cunningham believes that Grit was murdered, and the only person who could have killed him was Thomas Ford. Killing the dog, he did not like that dog, because that dog was probably more important to her than he ever would be. But as the murder investigation dragged on for most of 2009, Thomas Ford remained a free man. I wanted him to know I was thinking about him and that he needed to think about me. And that he needed to think about me.

So she began writing Thomas Ford on February 14, 2009, Valentine's Day. You sent Thomas Ford a valentine? Mm-hmm. He said, I'm thinking of you. She sent notes for months. One read, Mother's Day, never the same. Another one sent from Dana Clare's own email account said, How long were you planning this murder? It's an unusual move, don't you think? I don't know. What does a mother do when she's seen her daughter lying in a pool of blood?

Nearly one year after the murder, police finally got their break. DNA that analysts called consistent with Thomas Ford's was found on the towel that covered Dana Clare's face. Police arrested Ford and charged him with murder. From the beginning, I did not doubt that John Thomas Ford was guilty. But when Katherine Babbitt got the case, she and her two colleagues knew proving Ford guilty would be difficult, to put it mildly. Every aspect of our case, we had a problem. The biggest problem? Lost evidence, and plenty of it.

Investigators lost fingernail clippings taken from Dana Clare. They lost the underwear she was wearing when she was killed. The question has to be to an outsider, how does that happen? I mean, you can understand one mistake, but not this many. It was troubling. Anytime you lose a piece of evidence that should be produced at trial, it's always going to be an issue. And it didn't stop there. Prosecutors were counting on much clearer footage from a second surveillance camera. That was until that footage was also lost. And now they are stuck with this.

Couldn't tell you male, female. Couldn't tell you type and make of car. To be honest with you, there were points in the case that we were despairing, that we were depressed. Tears. Tears. Seriously? Yes, absolutely, because we know we did it. Even though they were facing a bungled investigation and a high-powered defense attorney, Can you say that? I do. Even though they were facing a bungled investigation and a high-powered defense attorney, prosecutors were ready to go.

My biggest fear was that justice might not be done here. In the Pacific Ocean, halfway between Peru and New Zealand, lies a tiny volcanic island. It's a little-known British territory called Pitcairn, and it harboured a deep, dark scandal. There wouldn't be a girl on Pitcairn once they reached the age of 10 that would still have heard it. It just happens to all of them. I'm journalist Luke Jones Jones and for almost two years I've been investigating a shocking story that has left deep scars on generations of women and girls

from Pitcairn. When there's nobody watching, nobody going to report it, people will get away with what they can get away with. In the Pitcairn trials I'll be uncovering a story of abuse and the fight for justice that has brought a unique, lonely Pacific island to the brink of extinction. Listen to the Pitcairn Trials exclusively on Wondery+. Join Wondery in the Wondery app, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. It took more than one year to arrest Thomas Ford for killing Dana Claire Edwards and her dog, Grit. Took two more years to get the case to trial. What we know about the rumor mill is that it started almost immediately.

When the trial finally began, on the streets of Alamo Heights, neighbors had already reached their verdict. Thomas Ford, the ex-boyfriend, it must be him. You going to talk for Thomas? Thomas. Thomas. Okay. From the day he was interviewed, shortly after the murder, Ford has denied having

anything to do with it. But his videotaped interview with police was the first thing prosecutors showed to the jurors. There's a calculated move on our part to start with that statement. It's like been deaf. They know they are taking a risk. What made me nervous about that is that he looked like the guy next door, he acted like the guy next door, and he teared up at the appropriate times. But it was part of their strategy. I mean, we needed to start with him a liar, and we built from there. Ford says he was home by midnight. Once you get home from the party, you went straight home. Yeah. But two prosecution witnesses cast doubt on that. Dana Clare's close friend, Melissa Fedderspill, and Alan Tarver, Thomas Ford's lifelong friend.

So I've known him, I think it's probably second grade. On New Year's Eve 2008, Melissa and Alan were with Ford at that party where Dana Clare was last seen alive. I'm the one eating. where Dana Clare was last seen alive. I'm the one eating. They were playing a game called Apples to Apples. It's for ages 6 to 12. It's a word association game that involves a lot of what is supposed to be good natured teasing.

The game turned to the word marriage, and Melissa made some jokes at Ford's expense. He had only recently split up with Dana Clare and Melissa says he got upset. He turned to me and said he didn't think that was funny at all. But defense attorney Dick DeGaran is quick to point out that detail was not in Melissa's account to police just days after the murder. But what you told Detective Carrion about the party was that everything was fine. Wasn't that the perfect opportunity? DeGaran wants jurors to believe Melissa is lying. I'm not trying to leave a false impression of what I felt. You need an objective of non-responsiveness.

Am I being too rough on you? Objective. When the game ended, Ford got up and left before midnight. Remember, he told police he went straight home. No, I just went straight to my house. But prosecutors think they can prove that is a lie. Shortly after midnight, the party broke up. Dana Clare went home, and so did Alan and Melissa.

But minutes later, Alan and Melissa drove past Ford's house to return a beer cooler he had left behind. We drove by Thomas' house. But they did not see his Chevy Tahoe in the driveway where he usually parked. And they also didn't see it in the church parking lot, where Ford would sometimes park. He looks to the right in the parking lot, drives through the parking lot, and there's no Tahoe there. Tarver asked Ford about that after Ford became a suspect.

He told me that he couldn't really remember where he parked. He thought he parked in back somewhere. I just thought sort of, well, you know, that's not what I saw. me that he couldn't really remember where he parked. He thought he parked him back somewhere. I just thought sort of, well, you know, that's not what I saw. Did you ever talk to him again? I do not believe so. You didn't look all through that parking lot, did you? In this dark corner, late at night, shaded by trees, the Tahoe very well could have been there, couldn't it?

After a day and a half, Okay, yes. Alan got so confused, I think he questioned himself. And so what started out as a fairly solid witness is now saying, well, maybe I did miss it. It's one thing to attack Alan Tarver, but now de Guerin has to somehow cast doubt on a grieving mother's story. She was laying face down on the floor. You could hear a pin drop when Deborah Edwards described sitting on the floor next to her daughter's body.

So I pushed the towel back some and just looked at my baby. DeGaran keeps Mrs. Edwards on the stand for almost two days. When did you start the campaign of harassment? Asking her about every one of those messages she sent to Ford and his family. The tile is so cold. Happy anniversary. Did you send that? Yes, I did. The evil in your soul sustained you. Yes, I did send him that. It's true.

15, 16, 17, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 27, 28, 29, 30. Was it hard to keep your composure, though? I had prayed for grace when I prayed for justice. But the cross-examination is tough. Remember how you ended her life with a photograph of Dana Clare saying, happy new year, Dana Clare as a child. You did that? Yes, I did that. saying, Happy New Year, Dana Clare as a child. You did that?

Yes, I did that. As tough as he's been, DeGaran has yet to put on the heart of his case. It is the police investigation and all the mistakes, starting with the first mistake, calling Dana Clare's death accidental. Wasn't it apparent to you that this was something more than just somebody keeling over and dying? At the time, no, sir. And he goes through every single piece of mishandled evidence,

the lost fingernail clippings, the lost surveillance tape, the lost underwear, and that towel with Thomas's DNA on it, police left it at the crime scene for roughly one week. How do you trust evidence that's gathered by these bumbling crime scene people that lose evidence? Investigators did find that DNA on the towel, but DeGaran says it proves nothing because Ford spent plenty of time in that apartment. He was in the condo shedding his DNA all over the place just 10 days before she was found. DeGaran is having a field day. Prosecutors are worried. We knew that Dick DeGaran would come in and try to confuse the issue. Krista Milton should know.

When she was in law school, one of her professors was Dick DeGaran. I took advanced criminal defense. Did you do well in class? I got the highest grade in the class when I took it. I mean, was that strange for you to be up against one of your former students? No, it was kind of flattering, frankly. But DeGaran now has to consider... The real defense in this case is alibi.

Did he teach her too well? And prosecutors are about to reveal their most damning piece of evidence. They say it's more powerful than the DNA, more important than the surveillance video. It's more powerful than the DNA, more important than the surveillance video. They say they can put Thomas Ford at the scene of the murder. We realized, oh my gosh, we know that I will do everything to help out. Okay. Thomas Ford, who didn't say a word during his trial,

was about to learn why suspects get the warning. Anybody else use your phone that night? No, that would have been impossible. Anything you say can and will be used against you in court. Once you get home from the party, you went straight home? Yeah. Prosecutors used almost everything he told police against him. I go straight home.

They argue the interrogation locks Ford into a story that is a lie. I was home. I was asleep. I didn't leave the bed until 7 a.m. the next day. They say these surveillance images prove he wasn't sleeping. He was driving his SUV to Dana Clare's house. If you just looked at that tape, not knowing anything, and you saw a white SUV come in, two minutes later come out, head south, come back, come in, come out, head north. Your first thought is, what's that guy doing? I mean, are they casing the joint? What's going on here? When you put that with the time he says he left the party, that's when you sort of start to build that timeline.

It's a very common vehicle. But Ford's attorney, Dick DeGaran, says as blurry as these pictures are, nobody can tell anything about that car. You know, you cannot identify this as being Thomas Ford's car. Prosecutors knew they needed more than that surveillance tape to make their case, and they think they found it just before trial in a pile of Ford's cell phone records, which police subpoenaed but never fully analyzed. When we did that, I still have chills thinking about it. Kathy Cunningham realized what she was looking at could change everything. Cell records have the latitude and longitude for the towers the phone is using. Prosecutors used Google Maps to locate the towers and believed they could now say where Ford went and when. They called an AT&T engineer named Ken Dahl.

If you tell somebody that you were home all night long and you really weren't, then if you took your cell phone with you, we're liable to find that out. Dahl created this map showing the towers that picked up Ford's cell phone signals throughout the night. We tracked the defendants' activities from 8.30 that evening until 9 a. We tracked the defendant's activities from 8 30 that evening until 9 a.m. the next morning. Remember, Ford told police he went home from the party, was in bed before midnight, and turned his phone off. But the records seem to tell a different story. At 11 45, he received a call that went straight to voicemail. Prosecutors say the signal should have bounced off this tower that serves Ford's home. But it didn't.

According to prosecutors, it bounced off this tower that serves Dana Clare's apartment in Gallery Court. It showed that his phone was near her apartment. Correct. That 1145 call is key to this case because minutes before that call, the white SUV entered, then left the condo complex, and then this blurry figure is seen walking in. Prosecutors believe Ford parked nearby and entered the complex to lay in wait. nearby and entered the complex to lay in wait. So you now know that the person that is walking into gallery court is John Thomas Ford. One hour later, Dana Claire's car arrives.

And then a half hour after that, a text goes to Thomas Ford's phone. Once again, say prosecutors, the signal bounces off the cell tower that serves Dana Clare's condo. That means, they say, Ford's own cell phone records place him near Dana Clare's condo for 90 minutes. How long do you think it took to kill her? I think it took 15 to 20 minutes. Prosecutors say the cell phone records even provide evidence about what happened to Dana Clare's dog, Grit. At 1.32 a.m., Ford's phone

is registering with this tower. It serves the area where Grit's body was found, the dam near Dana Clare's condo. What would be the only reason it's pinging near the Olmos Dam? That device would have had to have been near the Olmos Dam. Prosecutors believe it was Ford who brought Grit there. But how did he get there? Yet there, the same camera that showed a figure walking into the condo complex shows no one walking out before that 132 call. Prosecutors have a theory. They say Ford did not walk out the entrance, that he came out of the condo and jumped over this wall carrying Grit's body.

Then they think he drove to the dam, disposed of Grit, and returned here, jumping back over the wall. And think about how ridiculous that is. Thomas weighed 250 pounds at least when this happened. Even someone in good physical condition would have a tough time getting over that high wall. Maybe he wasn't at the Olmos Dam. Well, his phone sure was. Historical cell phone tower usage is voodoo. It's junk science. Voodoo? Yes. The defense has found experts who insist it is not possible to pinpoint a phone's location based on what tower it used. But DeGaran has to get Ken Dahl to concede that the cell phone records can be unreliable. You cannot say to a certainty that it was actually in that sector, can you?

I think you have a very extremely high degree of accuracy on that. We make multi-billion dollar decisions based on what this tool tells us. Sure. Prosecutors argue jurors can believe Thomas Ford or they can believe the cell phone records, but they cannot believe both. He had an alibi. The cell phone records pierced that alibi. It's been a tough four weeks of trial. DeGaran's last word to the jury? The state has not proved. The evidence leaves much more than just reasonable doubt. But Catherine Babbitt tells jurors that Ford snapped after being rejected by Dana Clare. Well, I'm going to tell you, there's someone else in here that has some right. And asked them to focus on the lives that were ended that night.

And how did he describe her? Full of life. Full of energy, full of life. Full of energy, full of joy. And if that ain't the picture of that, I don't know what is. And so is this little guy. And how dare he? Lawyers have done what they can do.

The jury, it's time for you to begin your deliberations. It's all in the jury's hands now. For all sides in any trial, this is the hardest part. Waiting while a jury deliberates. I really felt that they would look at it and make a good decision but the Edwards family was not waiting alone they're the only ones who knew it but in his backpack mr. Edwards carried the ashes of Dana Claire and her dog grit toit, to court throughout the trial. You bring them to court every day with you?

Every day. Why did you do that? A quest for justice for my daughter. We owed this to her, to find justice. And if you have unanswered questions, that's a reasonable... Prosecutors in the Thomas Ford case were worried that Dick DeGaran had swayed some jurors. The FBI can't tell what kind of car... Because all it takes for Dick is to confuse one juror.

We have to convince all 12. I was optimistic going into it, and I believe that there were jurors who were on the fence. According to the jurors, DeGaran was right. I just wasn't convinced that he was guilty. Some jurors went into the jury room unconvinced. You were one of the not-guilties, and you were one of the not-guilties. Just couldn't say that he was guilty beyond reasonable doubt at that point. I needed to sleep on it.

The jurors were at an impasse and were dismissed for the night. When they came back the next morning, they sent out a note asking to review the cell phone evidence. Is that a good thing for you or bad thing? Our first thought was, they're right where they need to be. Now just stay there. It's what we said to each other. Shortly after that request, the jurors took a vote. After eight hours of deliberating,

it wasn't easy, but they had a verdict. Is it a unanimous verdict? Yes, ma'am, it is. Mr. Ford, would you please stand? We, the jury, find the defendant, John Thomas Ford, guilty of murder as charged in the indictment. Ford is convicted. It's what Dana Clare's family and the prosecutors have spent more than three years fighting for. And now that we gave each one of the prosecutors a kiss. Thank you so much.

And I meant plans better. He said, thank you for giving me back my life. And so when you talk about doing this kind of job, that's really what it boils down to, is you're giving that family back, hopefully, some peace and some peace of mind. But it wasn't completely over.

Later that day, the jury had to recommend Thomas Ford's sentence. Think about the pressure she felt around her neck as the ligature began to tighten. Prosecutor Kirsten Melton reminds the jurors of why they just convicted Ford. Honor your verdict. Stand for what is right. I understand that you all have reached a verdict. The jury didn't take long to decide on a sentence. We assess his punishment at confinement for a term of 40 years, and we assess no fine. Forty years.

If he lives long enough, Ford could be in his 80s by the time he gets out. The outcome of this trial was an especially sweet victory for the three prosecutors who took a case that had so many problems, at times they weren't sure it would even get to court. When you are fighting for what you know to be right, that when God brings justice through that jury, it breaks your heart with gratitude and thankfulness for seeing the truth prevail. It breaks her heart with gratitude and thankfulness for seeing the truth prevail. It's been more than three years since Dana Clare was murdered. For the Edwards, time and justice have helped ease their pain.

I guess what was a little bit of amazing was I could feel all my daughter's good memories come back to me without Thomas and all of that. I felt like I had her back. It's hard to remember Dana Clare without remembering grit. And following their deaths, Dana Clare's brother DJ found a way to memorialize them both. I didn't want it to be down. I didn't want it to be depressing. And then he said, you said puppies. Puppies? Puppies. You said puppies. Puppies from the local animal shelter were available for adoption at Dana Clare's memorial. There were all these sweet little homeless, helpless pets. She would have loved it. Almost 500 people walked past these puppies. Everybody's playing, handing them off.

And every one of them had been adopted. That was important to give them what Dana would have wanted to give them. Love and life and homes. Just what Dana Clare had done years earlier when she found grit. I know that she was happy when she was looking down on us and seeing those sweet little animals being offered a second chance. It was very special. So Dana. If you like this podcast, you can listen ad-free right now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app. Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a quick survey at wondery.com slash survey. Experience amazing now at Dawn Valley North Lexus. Right now, lease the 2024 IS300 Premium Package from just $518 per month for 28 months at 2.9 percent or choose from canada's

largest selection of lexus demonstrators with offers you won't want to miss now is the time and dawn valley north lexus is the place see website for details expect excellence a proud member of wayne's auto group