Ancient Mysteries - The Creatures Science Still Can’t Fully Explain

Episode Date: August 30, 2026

For centuries, people have reported creatures that seem impossible to explain. Some became legends. Some were exposed as elaborate hoaxes. And a surprising few turned out to be real.In this documentar...y, we descend through the cryptid and mythological creature iceberg — from famous legends like Bigfoot and the Loch Ness Monster to Mothman, strange lake creatures, mysterious beings from folklore, and stories buried deep in history.Along the way, we examine eyewitness accounts, famous photographs, scientific investigations, historical records, and the psychology that can transform a single strange encounter into a legend.But there’s a fascinating twist: history contains real animals that scientists once dismissed as rumors — including the okapi, Komodo dragon, mountain gorilla and coelacanth. So where does mythology end and reality begin?💬 Which creature do you think deserves a closer investigation?🔔 Subscribe for more mysteries, strange history, unexplained stories, and deep-dive documentaries.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Two and five Canadians will hear the words you have cancer. That's why every step and dollar raised matters. On September 19th, join thousands in Toronto for the Princess Margaret Cancer Foundation Walk. Challenge yourself, friends, and family to walk 21 kilometers in support of life-saving research. Together, we can carry the fire and help create a world free from the fear of cancer. Register today at pmcf walk.ca.ca. Your playlist might get you through the workday, but have you ever wondered how your ancestors spent theirs?
Starting point is 00:00:36 What work helped them build a life? How did they adapt as the world around them changed? With Ancestry, you can search Select Historical Occupational Records for free for a limited time and discover the stories behind the jobs in your family tree. You've got questions. We've got ancestors. Search free until August 31st. Visit Ancestry.ca for details. Terms apply.
Starting point is 00:00:59 Hey there, Monster Hunters. Cryptozoology is the only field where zero evidence counts as proof of a cover-up. Nobody. Government took it. Today we're going down the crypted iceberg, sorted by fame, not by fear. The top is Bigfoot and Nessie. The bottom is one forum thread with four replies. One question follows us all the way down.
Starting point is 00:01:21 Everybody carries a 4K camera. So why does every monster photo still look like it was shot next to Abraham Lincoln? And the twist that ruins it for the skeptics. Some cryptids turned out to be real. Laughed at then handed a Latin name. Smash that like button and drop a comment telling me what city you're watching from. Let's dive. Before we meet a single monster, you need to understand the assembly line that builds them,
Starting point is 00:01:46 because monsters do not appear in the woods. They appear in newsprint. The recipe never changes. Step one, one person sees something in bad light. Step two, a local paper, with three staff members and a column to fill prints it, because a hardware store fire is not moving copies this week. Step three, panic.
Starting point is 00:02:05 Step four, and this is the part that does the heavy lifting, dozens of other people suddenly remember that they also saw something weird, and now the thing is confirmed by multiple independent witnesses, except none of them are independent, because they all read the same article on the same morning over the same coffee. The gold standard for this process is a small town in Illinois called Enfield, and the spring of 1973. Henry McDaniel came home one night, and his kids told him something had been scratching at the door. He grabbed a flashlight and a pistol, opened the door, and reported
Starting point is 00:02:38 seeing a greyish creature standing there with pinkish glowing eyes, short arms, and three legs. Three, not two, not four, which are the two numbers evolution has more or less settled on for large land animals. McDaniel fired at it several times, said he hit it, said it made a hissing sound, and then covered 50 feet in three enormous hops before disappearing toward a railroad embankment. In fairness to the man, whatever he saw genuinely scared him, and he did the thing most people would do,
Starting point is 00:03:09 which was empty a firearm at his own porch. Here is where the machine kicks in. A radio station picked it up. The wire services picked it up from the radio station, and within days, Enfield, a town of a few hundred people, became a monster tourism destination. Carloads of armed men arrived
Starting point is 00:03:26 from neighbouring states with rifles, spotlights, and the confidence of people who have never tracked anything more dangerous than a parking spot. They wandered around private farmland in the dark, shooting at noises, which is exactly as safe as it sounds. At one point, a group reportedly fired at something that turned out to be, unsurprisingly, other monster hunters. Local law enforcement had to step in and start threatening arrests, and several of the visiting adventurers were in fact cited,
Starting point is 00:03:53 which means the actual body count of the Enfield Monster incident is zero, monsters and several find idiots. The police chief was not chasing a cryptid. He was chasing tourists with guns, which is a much more real and much more annoying problem. McDaniel himself later reported a second sighting, said the thing came back and by then the town had split into two camps. Camp one thought he saw something, camp two thought he saw a kangaroo, and yes, that was an official adjacent theory, because a kangaroo had reportedly escaped in the region, and standing upright on a thick tail can absolutely look like a third leg in a flashlight beam at midnight. So the leading scientific explanation for the terrifying three-legged demon of southern Illinois
Starting point is 00:04:36 is a lost marsupial having the worst week of its life. Now compare that to a case where we know for certain nobody saw anything because the guy who invented the monster wrote it down and signed his name. In 1868, a settler named Joseph C. Rich sent a report to a Utah newspaper describing a creature in Bear Lake up on the Utah and Idaho border. He wrote it with tremendous confidence, mentioned local indigenous accounts to give it depth, and produced a serpent-like beast with a huge body and a head like a walrus that could allegedly out-swim a horse,
Starting point is 00:05:09 which is a strange benchmark to choose, but here we are. The story landed. People started watching the water. More sightings arrived naturally because now everyone knew what shape to see. 26 years later, Rich publicly admitted the whole thing was a piece of newspaper entertainment. He made it up. He said so out loud, in print, in a paper people actually read. And the sightings continued anyway. That is the single, most important fact in this entire chapter. The confession changed nothing. Reports kept coming through the 20th century,
Starting point is 00:05:43 and one of the most publicized modern sightings happened as recently as 2002, when a local boat operator described a serpent surfacing near his craft. Years later he would explain that he had been running a mechanical monster in the lake for the amusement of tourists, which tells you that Bear Lake is now on its second generation of admitted hoax, and the lake still has a monster, a legend, and a healthy summer season. The creature has been dead since 1894 and it is still employed, so we can already extract the three symptoms that show up in every manufactured cryptid, and you should keep them in your pocket for the rest of the same.
Starting point is 00:06:18 this descent. Symptom 1, the photographic evidence is always blurry, always taken at the exact distance where identification becomes impossible, and always by someone who owns a perfectly good camera. Symptom 2. The entire structure rests on a single origin point, one witness or one article, and everything after that is echo rather than evidence. Symptom 3, and this one never misses, somebody made money. A newspaper sold copies, a town sold festival tickets, a boat operator sold rides, an author sold a book. Follow the receipts, and you will usually find the monster standing next to a cash register, which brings us to the most famous cash register in cryptozoology, and the moment where the iceberg stops being about towns and starts being about forests,
Starting point is 00:07:04 because there is one creature that is not local at all. It is everywhere. In the Pacific Northwest, it is Bigfoot or Sasquatch. In the Himalayas, it is the Yeti, which the Western press upgraded to the abominable snowman, a name so aggressively dramatic that it sounds like a wrestling gimmick. In Australia it is the Yowie. In Florida it is the skunk ape. Name for a smell that witnesses describe as something between rotten eggs and a gym bag left in a car in July. Ohio has the grassman, Sumatra has the Orang Pendek, the short person of the forest, different continents, different languages, different climates, and functionally the identical animal. A large hairy biped that walks like a person, hides better than any animal in history, and leaves nothing behind.
Starting point is 00:07:51 That should be your first red flag, and it is a strange one because it cuts both ways. Believers say the global spread proves it, that so many unconnected cultures cannot all invent the same thing. Skeptics point out that humans have exactly one template for a scary humanoid, which is a bigger, hairier version of ourselves, and every culture with forests and imagination arrives there independently. We are not describing an animal. We are describing our own reflection with the resolution turned down. The centrepiece of the whole phenomenon is about 60 seconds of film shot in October 1967 at Bluff Creek in Northern California. Roger Patterson and Bob Gimlin were riding
Starting point is 00:08:29 along a creek bed when their horses reacted to something. Patterson got off, grabbed his camera and shot the most analysed home movie ever made outside of Dallas. The subjects, nicknamed Patty, walks across an open gravel bar, turns to the same. its upper body toward the camera in that famous over-the-shoulder glance and strolls into the tree line without breaking stride. It has been studied frame by frame for over half a century. Some anatomists point to the muscle movement and the compliant gate, a walking style with bent knees that is difficult to fake. Other people point out that Patterson had been writing a book about Bigfoot, had been actively looking for Bigfoot to film, and then found Bigfoot,
Starting point is 00:09:07 which is the luckiest first day at work anyone has ever had. A man named Bob Hieronymus, later claimed he was the one in the suit, and that he never got paid, which is either a confession or the greatest exercise in petty grudge holding in American history. And that luck is the part that deserves more attention than the footage itself. Because if a guy with a rented camera and a rented horse can drive into the woods and capture the creature almost immediately, the search should be over. Instead, we got an entire television industry. A flagship series about hunting this animal ran for the better part of a decade across more than 100 episodes, sending crews into forests all over the country, with thermal imaging, night vision, sound equipment and a budget.
Starting point is 00:09:50 Total confirmed discoveries across that entire run, zero. Not a body, not a bone, not a tooth, not a tuft of hair that survived a lab. They produced a hundred hours of people whispering excitedly at trees. If Patterson managed it on day one with equipment from 1967, either he was extraordinarily, blessed, or the show was hunting something that only exists during sweeps week. To be fair, there is a real scientific hook underneath all this, and it is genuinely interesting. Gigantapithecus was an actual ape, known from fossil teeth and jaw fragments found in southern China, and it was enormous, possibly around 10 feet tall standing up. It existed, it is in museums, and a popular version of the Bigfoot theory says that a population of these giants crossed
Starting point is 00:10:37 the Beringian Land Bridge into North America, along with everything else that made the trip, then survived quietly in dense forest. It is a tidy story, it has a real animal in it, which makes it feel respectable. Then the actual biology arrives and starts breaking furniture. Gigant apis is closely related to modern orangutans, which are not knuckle-dragging forest ninjas, but arboreal apes, and the fossil evidence gives no support for the idea that it walked upright it like a person. It seems to have died out hundreds of thousands of years ago, likely as its forest habitat shifted to grassland and it could not adapt fast enough, which is exactly the kind of climate story that kills big, specialized animals, and there is not a single gigantapithecus
Starting point is 00:11:19 fossil anywhere in the Americas, not one tooth. Two and five Canadians will hear the words, you have cancer. That's why every step and dollar raised matters. On September 19th, joined thousands in Toronto. for the Princess Margaret Cancer Foundation Walk. Challenge yourself, friends, and family to walk 21 kilometers in support of life-saving research. Together, we can carry the fire and help create a world free from the fear of cancer. Register today at pmcfwalk.ca.ca. For an animal that supposedly crossed a continent and then survived here for tens of thousands of years,
Starting point is 00:11:59 the fossil record is a blank page with a coffee stain. The knockout punch came in 2014, when Oxford geneticist Brian Sykes did the thing nobody in the community actually wanted, which was to invite everyone to submit their best physical evidence for real analysis. Hair samples arrived from all over the world, collected by serious researchers who had guarded them for years. The lab results came back, and the answer was a parade of animals you have already met. Bears, repeatedly, horses, cows, raccoon, porcupine, deer, deer. And in a detail that stung the most, dog, somebody had been protecting a sacred Yeti relic that came off a Labrador. Two Himalayan samples produced an unusual bear result that generated
Starting point is 00:12:43 headlines about a mystery bear hybrid, and follow-up work indicated the tidy answer was Himalayan brown bear, which means the abominable snowman is, on the current evidence, a bear having an off day. Here is the thing that should end the argument and never does. In 1967, cameras were rare, film was expensive and the woods were mostly unwatched. Today there are trail cameras strapped to trees across every hunting district in North America, satellites overhead, drones in the air, phones in every pocket, and hikers photographing their own lunch at a rate of millions of images per day. The amount of visual surveillance pointed at the American wilderness has increased by an unimaginable factor, and the quality of Bigfoot evidence has not improved by a single
Starting point is 00:13:27 pixel. Trail cameras have captured mountain lions, wolverines and every stray dog in three states, but the eight-foot ape remains permanently out of focus. As the number of cameras in the forest goes up, Bigfoot gets smaller, further away, and blurrier. That is not how real animals work. That is how a story behaves when the lighting gets better. Move a step down the ice and the humanoid starts changing shape, because if the ape does not convince you, America has a whole belt of creatures that split the difference between man and dog. In southeastern Wisconsin, along a stretch of rural pavement called Bray Road, a run of reports in the late 1980s and early 1990s described a large wolf-like animal that ran on two legs, had glowing eyes, and on one memorable occasion was
Starting point is 00:14:13 allegedly seen sitting upright by the roadside eating roadkill, which is somehow more unsettling than any monster movie has ever managed. A local reporter followed the accounts seriously and gave the thing a name, and once a creature has a name, it stops being a stray animal and becomes a resident. Michigan runs the same species with an older passport. The story goes back to 1887 in the northern part of the state, where a pair of lumberjacks reportedly cornered what they thought was a dog, and the animal stood up on two legs to a height of around seven feet and let out a scream that sounded disturbingly human. Sightings trickled along for decades. And then in 1987, a radio DJ named Steve Cook wrote and recorded a novelty song about the Michigan Dogman as an April Fool's joke.
Starting point is 00:14:59 The song went into heavy rotation, listeners started phoning in with their own encounters, and a regional curiosity turned into a full folk monster, essentially because of a bit. The legend of Northern Michigan has a release date and a songwriter credit. Reports from Minnesota carry the same silhouette, including a widely repeated account from a serviceman on patrol at an airbase, who described something large and upright watching him from the perimeter, which is the kind of witness people find hard to dismiss, since that job involves staring at empty fields professionally. None of this is new, and Europe would like everyone to know it got their first. Between roughly 1450 and 1650, the same courts that were prosecuting witches
Starting point is 00:15:40 were also prosecuting werewolves, with equally rigorous standards, meaning none. In France, in 1573, a hermit named Gilles Garnier was executed after confessing under torture to killing children, while transformed into a wolf. In Germany in 1589, Peter Stump was tried in a case so lurid that the surviving pamphlet reads like early tabloid journalism, and his execution was designed as public theatre. In 1603, a teenage boy named Jean Grenier told authorities he'd been given a wolfskin by a mysterious man in the forest,
Starting point is 00:16:13 and in a rare flash of institutional sanity, the court decided the kid was delusional rather than demonic, and sent him to a monastery instead of a stake. The court was probably looking at a starving child with severe mental illness, and every one of these trials was likely some combination of coerced confession, rabies, wolf attacks in a period with a lot of actual wolves and a legal system that treated confession as the finish line rather than the starting point, which finally brings us to the one monster on this tier that has a birthday,
Starting point is 00:16:43 a crime scene and a movie tie-in. In 1995 in Puerto Rico, farmers began finding dead goats with puncture wounds, and according to the reports drained of blood. The name that Stuck translates roughly as goat-sucker, and the creature became a national obsession within weeks. The first prominent witness described something specific, a bipedal thing around four feet tall, with large dark eyes, thin arms,
Starting point is 00:17:08 and a row of spines running down its back. That description is the interesting part, because it is not a folk monster. It is a design. And a couple of months before that citing, a science fiction horror film called Species had opened in theatres in Puerto Rico, featuring a creature with large dark eyes, a lean upright body and spines down its back. The resemblance is close enough that when researcher Benjamin Radford compared them,
Starting point is 00:17:34 the case for coincidence took heavy damage. The founding image of an international monster panic appears to have walked out of a movie theatre, and the physical evidence has been even less kind. Over the following decades, dozens of alleged chupacabro corpses were recovered in Texas and northern Mexico, and unlike almost everything else in this video, these ones came with bodies. They went to actual labs. Every single tested specimen came back as a known animal, mostly coyotes, along with dogs and raccoons, all suffering from advanced sarcoptic mange. That disease destroys the coat, thickens and wrinkles the skin, and leaves the animal gaunt
Starting point is 00:18:11 and hairless with a pronounced spine and an unnatural gait, because chronic mange is agony. What people were photographing was not a vampire from another world. It was a coyote in the final stages of a horrible parasitic infection, dying slowly in a ditch, and the reason it went after livestock is that a sick animal that cannot run cannot catch anything that runs either. The Monster of the Americas is a public health story with better marketing. Now let us move from the tree line to the water,
Starting point is 00:18:40 because there is a rule in North American geography that nobody voted on, and yet everybody follows. If a lake is deep, cold, and shaped like a long, dark trench, it has a monster. Not maybe. It has one. Scotland has Nessie and Loch Ness. British Columbia has Ogapogo in O'Canagan Lake. Lake Champlain, sitting politely between New York and Vermont, has Champ. Lake Erie has Bessie. Lake Manitoba has Manipogo, which is not so much a separate creature as a Canadian trademark dispute. Arkansas has the White River Monster. Same beast, different accent, and in every case the local tourism board is delighted. The template is remarkably
Starting point is 00:19:21 consistent. Long neck, humps in the water, appears in summer, vanishes when approached, occasionally rocks a boat. The one that broke away from the pack and became global, did so because of a single black and white image taken in 1934 and credited to a respectable London physician, which is the entire trick. A farmer sees a monster, and it is a story. A doctor sees a monster and it is evidence. The photograph shows a slender neck and small head rising from rippled water, and for 60 years it was the closest thing cryptozoology had to a birth certificate. There are two problems with it, and the first one is simply cropping. The version everyone knows is a tight enlargement. The full, uncropped frame shows a very different picture, mainly a lot of water
Starting point is 00:20:08 and a very small object, with wave patterns around it that indicate the thing is roughly the size of a shoebox rather than a bus. It is not a dinosaur photographed from far away. It is a small item photographed from quite close, and the mystery evaporates the moment you see the borders of the image, which is exactly why the borders of the image were not the ones getting printed for six decades. The second problem is that the whole operation was revenge. A filmmaker and big game hunter named Marmaduke Wetherill
Starting point is 00:20:38 had been hired by a London newspaper to find the creature, and he triumphantly produced a set of footprints on the shoreline. The Natural History Museum examined the casts and concluded the prints had been made with a dried hippopotamus foot. The kind sold as an umbrella stand, which was a popular home accessory of the era, and also, apparently, a monster forging tool, Wetherill was publicly humiliated, so he did what any dignified professional would do, which was billed a fake monster out of a toy submarine with a sculpted head attached, floated in the loch, and launder the photograph through a doctor with a spotless reputation,
Starting point is 00:21:12 so the newspaper would print it and look ridiculous forever. It works so well that it outlived him by half a century. In 1993, one of the last surviving participants, his stepson, Christian Spurling, admitted the whole thing at the age of around 90, describing the toy submarine and the modelling putty. The most famous monster photograph on earth was a prank about a hurt ego and an umbrella stand. But forget the photo, because the real argument against every lake monster is not about hoaxes. It is about volume. A lake is a bucket. It has edges, a measurable bottom and a finite amount of food in it. Loch Ness is impressive by British standards and irrelevant by ocean standards, and it has been swept with sonar repeatedly,
Starting point is 00:21:56 including a coordinated operation in the 1980s that lined up a row of boats and walked the entire length of the loch like a police search line, producing a couple of unidentified contacts and no animals. A population of large air-breathing reptiles could not live there quietly, because air-breathing is the giveaway. Whales surface constantly, and we notice them from miles away. A plesiosaur would need to come up for air every few minutes for its whole life, in a narrow lake surrounded by roads, houses, hotels, and thousands of people with cameras pointed at the water full-time. It would not be a mystery. It would be a traffic hazard. There is also the small matter that Loch Ness did not exist as a lake during the age of dinosaurs. That entire region was buried under glacial ice until roughly 10,000 years ago,
Starting point is 00:22:44 which means any surviving population would have needed to wait out the ice age somewhere else, and then move in, presumably with a truck. And a breeding group is not optional. One monster cannot be 1,600 years old. You need dozens of them to avoid inbreeding collapse, which means dozens of enormous animals eating an enormous amount of fish out of a loch that does not have that much fish in it. The math is not close.
Starting point is 00:23:07 The final word came from an unglamorous piece of modern science. In 2018, a team led by geneticist Neil Gemmell from the University of Otago sampled water throughout the lock at multiple depths and ran environmental DNA analysis, which works because every living thing constantly shed skin cells, waste and scales into the water around it. You do not need to see the animal. You just need to catch its litter. They catalogued around 3,000 species. They found fish, mammals, birds, bacteria and every deer and sheep that had ever wandered near the shore. What they did not find was a single trace of reptile DNA. None. Not a molecule. What they did find, in surprising abundance, was eel DNA, present at basically every sampling point in the loch.
Starting point is 00:23:56 That result is more interesting than it sounds, because eels can grow long. They undulate in a way that produces exactly the rolling hump illusion people describe, and they are already there in enormous numbers. Gemmel was careful, noting the data cannot tell you how big any individual eel is, so an unusually large one remains technically possible. And that is where the mystery now lives. Not a surviving marine reptile from the Mesozoic. A fish that would look, at a distance, in poor light, like precisely what people have been reporting for 90 years. Meanwhile, over in Arkansas, the local legislature took its own river creature so seriously in the 1970s that it formally established a protected sanctuary for it, which means Arkansas has a legally recognised monster refuge and no monster.
Starting point is 00:24:42 Best guess for what people actually saw there is a wandering elephant seal, which is objectively hilarious for anyone who has ever seen an elephant seal, an animal that looks like a sofa having a bad reaction to medication, so the lakes are a bust, which makes it deeply inconvenient for the sceptics that the moment we leave freshwater and hit the open ocean, the entire pattern flips and the believers start winning. For centuries Nordic sailors described the Cracken, a creature so vast it could be mistaken for an island, with arms capable of reaching a ship's masts. Serious naturalists filed it under drunk sailor. Then bodies started washing up, and in the modern era we not only confirm the giant squid, we filmed it. Our catuthis is real,
Starting point is 00:25:22 it has eyes the size of dinner plates. The largest reliable measurements run to around 43 feet, including the feeding tentacles, and it lives deep enough that no one had ever seen a living one until Japanese researchers finally photographed one in its own habitat in the mid-2000s, followed by video a few years later. It took submersibles, specialised bait, and years of failure to get pictures of an animal the length of a school bus. Sailors were right, science was late, and everybody had to apologise to some very old Norwegian folklore. The sea serpent got the same treatment.
Starting point is 00:25:56 Reports of an enormous silver ribbon of a creature undulating near the surface were classic tall-tail material, until the oarfish stepped forward and admitted everything. Reglicus Gleson is a genuine bony fish that can reach lengths in the range of 50 feet, has a bright red crest along its head, swims vertically in the water column, and occasionally comes to the surface when it is sick or dying, which is when people see it. It is a real animal that looks fake. Every so often one washes ashore in California, and the photos go viral because it appears to have been designed by someone who had monsters explained to them over the phone.
Starting point is 00:26:31 Not everything survives contact with the data, though. In 1997, underwater microphones originally installed to listen for submarines picked up an extraordinarily loud, low-frequency sound in the South Pacific, so powerful it was detected across thousands of miles. The internet named it the bloop, and immediately decided it belonged to an animal larger than a blue whale, which is a wonderfully unsettling idea and completely wrong. Further monitoring identified the profile as an icequake, the sound of a massive, ice sheet fracturing and carving in Antarctica. The most terrifying noise ever recorded in the ocean was ice-breaking, which is either a relief or a disappointment depending on how your week is going.
Starting point is 00:27:12 Then there is the special category of ocean mystery that arrives with no explanation and no dignity, which is the globster. That is the term for a formless mass of tissue that washes up on a beach looking like nothing that should exist. In 2003, a lump weighing an estimated 14 tonnes landed on the Chilean coast, and briefly convinced the internet that a giant octopus had been confirmed. Tissue analysis identified it as the decomposed blubber of a sperm whale. Whale corpses lose their skin, muscle and skeleton at different rates, and what remains is a shapeless collagen mattress that resembles absolutely nothing familiar. Most historical sea monster carcasses fall into this category, including the one's
Starting point is 00:27:56 19th century newspapers illustrated with tremendous imagination. In 2009, in Panama, a group of teenagers reported killing a strange hairless creature near Cerro Azul claiming it had come at them and they acted in self-defense, which is an interesting legal position to take against something that was, on examination, a decomposing sloth that had likely been dead in water for some time. The internet had a full week with that one. And in 2008, a small waterlogged carcass, with a strange beak-like face and exposed teeth,
Starting point is 00:28:28 washed up at Montauk on Long Island, and became a genuine international news story. Every biologist who looked at the photos, said raccoon, because when soft tissue is destroyed by seawater, the snout takes on that odd exposed appearance, and the front paws of a raccoon look uncomfortably like small human hands. Nature is not designing monsters, mining. Decomposition is, and it is extremely good at it,
Starting point is 00:28:52 which is the perfect setup for the man who figured out that you do not have to wait for the ocean to deliver. Two and five Canadians will hear the words you have cancer. That's why every step and dollar raised matters. On September 19th, join thousands in Toronto for the Princess Margaret Cancer Foundation Walk. Challenge yourself, friends, and family to walk 21 kilometers in support of life-saving research. Together, we can carry the fire and help create a world free from the fear of cancer. Register today at pmcf walk.ca.ca.
Starting point is 00:29:26 Going on vacation? We're here for it. With kids, who turned the backseat into a courtroom drama over whose tablet is louder, whose charger is faster, and while watching the same cartoon for the hundredth time is the human right?
Starting point is 00:29:42 Yep, we totally have vehicles to handle that, because whether it's a road trip or a business trip, where your flight's delayed, your phone's at 2% and your dinner is, whatever is open? Yeah, here for that too. Enterprise, we're here for it. In 1842, showman Pee Barnum exhibited what he presented as a genuine mermaid recovered near the Fiji Islands,
Starting point is 00:30:05 complete with the supporting expert who was actually an associate of his in a costume. Visitors expected something beautiful. What they got was a shrivelled, snarling thing about the size of a house cat built by sewing the upper body of a juvenile monkey onto the tail of a large fish and drawing the whole assembly. It was ugly, obviously artificial and completely irresistible. ticket sales at his museum reportedly tripled. That object is the first commercially successful crypted in history, and it established the business model that runs through everything on this list,
Starting point is 00:30:37 which is that the audience does not require the monster to be real. It only requires the monster to be worth the price of admission. Look up from the water and the pattern repeats in the air, with the added advantage that anything in the sky is hard to measure and easy to exaggerate. Across many indigenous nations of North America, the Thunderbird is not a monster in the crypted sense at all but a powerful supernatural being, a creature whose wing beats produce thunder and whose eyes throw lightning, appearing in carvings, stories and ceremonial art across an enormous geographic range.
Starting point is 00:31:10 Then, 19th century settlers arrived, met the concept, and instead of treating it as sacred narrative, went looking for something to shoot. In 1890, a newspaper in Tombstone, Arizona, ran a report of two cowboys, allegedly killed an enormous flying creature in the desert, describing a wingspan of around 30 feet, a body like a serpent, and no feathers. They supposedly dragged it back and nailed it to a barn. This story is the source of one of the strangest phenomena in the entire subject, which is the thunderbird photograph that thousands of people are certain they have seen, showing men in period clothing standing in front of a barn with an immense winged creature stretched out behind them.
Starting point is 00:31:51 That photo has never been found. Not in an archive. Not in a collection, not in a single verified publication. It is a collective false memory of an image that appears not to exist, which is arguably a better mystery than the bird. Large birds did keep making the news, though, and the most alarming case came from Laundale, Illinois in July 1977, when a 10-year-old boy named Marlon Lowe was reportedly grabbed by a huge dark bird in his own yard while his mother watched. She described it lifting him briefly before dropping him, and the family stuck to the account for decades despite relentless mockery. The most likely candidate is a very large raptor or a wandering vulture and a terrified misjudgment
Starting point is 00:32:31 of scale, and it is worth saying that a bird capable of carrying a child would need a wingspan far beyond anything alive today, because flight is brutally unforgiving about weight. But the family gained nothing, and lost quite a lot by talking, which puts them in a different category from most of the people in this video, then the sky gets stranger. In November 1966, near an abandoned munitions plant outside Point Pleasant West Virginia, two young couples driving through the area reported a tall winged figure with glowing red eyes that allegedly chased their car at highway speed. Within days, more reports came in from around the county. The creature acquired the name mothman, which sounds a lot less frightening than the accounts,
Starting point is 00:33:13 since moths are famously beaten in single combat by porch lights. The most common explanation offered at the time was a sandhill crane, a bird that stands nearly as tall as a person, has a red patch on its head and would have been well outside its normal range. That explanation satisfies almost nobody, largely because it is the least dramatic option available, and because Point Pleasant, as we will see shortly, was about to become the sight of something far worse than a bird.
Starting point is 00:33:42 The wing tear fills out quickly from there. In 1976, in the village of Mornan in Cornwall, children reported a large hovering figure near the church tower, and the resulting Alman case has a heavy fingerprint on it from a local showman with an established history of promoting mysteries, which tends to lower the evidentiary value considerably. Java has the Ahul, described as a bat with a wingspan of 10 feet or more, name for the call it supposedly makes,
Starting point is 00:34:08 and given that Southeast Asia does host genuinely enormous, fruit bats. This one is at least in the neighbourhood of plausible. Papua New Guinea has the Ropen, a glowing nocturnal flyer that certain expedition groups have promoted as a surviving terrosaur, though the glow is far better explained by bioluminescent fungus, marsh gas, or the plain fact that flying foxes are common and the jungle at night is disorienting. And then there is Iowa, 1903, where the town of Van Meter produced a visitor that reads like a fever dream committed to public record. Multiple prominent townspeople,
Starting point is 00:34:43 including a doctor, a banker, and a business owner, reported a large winged creature with a blunt horn on its head that projected a blinding beam of light and claimed to have tracked it to an abandoned coal mine where it appeared with the second one. They fired at it without effect. The reports were unusually specific and unusually well-witnessed by local standards
Starting point is 00:35:01 and the entire thing stopped as abruptly as it started. Whatever it was, the town has since embraced it, because nothing improves a place like a monster with an event calendar. The oldest of the flying set belongs to New Jersey, where the legend holds that in the 1700s a woman remembered as mother Leeds, sometimes given the name Jane, cursed her 13th pregnancy out of exhaustion, and the child was born and immediately transformed into a hooved, winged, horse-headed creature
Starting point is 00:35:29 that flew out through the chimney. Thirteen children is enough to make anyone say something regrettable. The story attached itself to the pine barrens, a genuinely vast and disorienting stretch of forest, and stuck. The most quoted sighting belongs to Joseph Bonaparte, the older brother of Napoleon, who was living in exile in New Jersey, and who allegedly encountered the thing while out hunting. A former King of Spain being startled by a swamp demon in southern New Jersey
Starting point is 00:35:56 is the kind of detail no fiction writer would risk, which brings us to the part that explains why none of these creatures ever quietly disappear. Point Pleasant did not just keep its winged visitor. It built the thing a 12-foot polished metal statue standing in the middle of town, opened a museum devoted to it, and runs an annual festival that draws crowds from all over the country into a small river town that would otherwise have no particular reason to attract them. Local businesses sell themed food, merchandise and tours.
Starting point is 00:36:25 The creature has become the single most reliable economic asset the town has. And that reframes the entire question, because no amount of debunking can compete with that. proving the monster does not exist would cost a real community actual money, and proving it does exist would only mean the merchandise sells faster. The monster is not being defended by believers. It is being employed by a Chamber of Commerce, and it is a model employee. Deeper down the ice, the entities stop behaving like animals altogether. They do not hunt, they do not eat, and they leave no tracks. They show up, they say something unsettling, and then something terrible happens.
Starting point is 00:37:02 This is a completely separate category, and calling it cryptozoology is generous, because these are not creatures. They are omens with legs. The strangest resident of this tier arrived on a lonely road in West Virginia in November 1966, a few weeks after the winged figure had put the region on edge. A sewing machine salesman named Woodrow Derenberger was driving home in the evening when a vehicle cut in front of him and stopped. He described it as dark and shaped unlike any car on the road, and a man stepped out of it. it. The man was wearing what Derenberger called a shiny outfit. He had his hands tucked behind his back, and he was smiling, not politely, continuously. The kind of smile that would make you lock your doors at a gas station. According to Derenberger, the man never opened his mouth.
Starting point is 00:37:50 The conversation happened directly inside his head, which is either the most efficient communication method ever devised, or the single worst thing that can happen to a person on a Wednesday. The visitor introduced himself as Indrid Cold, said he came from a place called La Nuelos, asked about the local area with the mild curiosity of a tourist checking whether anything is open late, and then said they would meet again. Then he got back in the craft and left. What makes this case genuinely interesting is not the story itself, but what Derenberger did next, which was go on local television and lay the whole thing out for the better part of half an hour with an unnervingly calm delivery. He did not act like a man selling anything. He did not embellish for the camera. He described a road, a stranger, and a headache, and stuck to that account for the rest of his life while his neighbours mocked him, his reputation took damage, and his family paid the social bill.
Starting point is 00:38:46 He later wrote a book about further visits, which is exactly where most people stopped taking him seriously, and fairly so. But the first interview has an odd quality to it. Whatever happened on that road, the man reporting it does not look like he's enjoying himself. And then, on the 15th of December, 1967, the region stopped being a curiosity and became a disaster site. The Silver Bridge connected Point Pleasant, West Virginia to Gallipolis, Ohio, across the Ohio River, and it was packed with rush hour traffic and holiday shoppers on a Friday evening when it failed. Not gradually, not with
Starting point is 00:39:21 warning. The entire span went into the river in under a minute with vehicles still on it. Forty-six people died. It remains one of the of the worst bridge failures in American history, and the community that lived through it has spent decades watching the story get repackaged as a monster movie. The actual cause is documented in exhaustive engineering detail, and it is horrifying precisely because it is so mundane. The bridge, opened in 1928, used an ibar chain suspension design, meaning the entire deck hung from linked steel bars connected by pins. It was an efficient design for the traffic of the 1920s, and it had one catastrophic flaw, which is that it had no redundancy whatsoever. Investigators traced
Starting point is 00:40:05 the failure to a single eye bar, number 330, which developed a tiny crack through stress corrosion, growing invisibly inside the steel over roughly 40 years. The crack was reportedly around a tenth of an inch when it finally gave way. That one bar failed, its partner could not carry the load alone, the joint separated and the failure cascaded through the entire structure in seconds. The bridge had also spent four decades carrying vehicles far heavier than anything it was designed for, because 1928 traffic and 1967 traffic are not the same animal. Inspection at the time could not see inside a steel bar. There was no technology that would have caught it. The direct result was the creation of national bridge inspection standards in the United States, which is to say that every bridge you drive
Starting point is 00:40:51 over today is checked because of what happened in Point Pleasant. That is a story about metal fatigue, deferred maintenance and the limits of 1960s engineering. It is not a story about a winged omen. But the legend attached itself anyway, cemented by a best-selling book in the 1970s and then by a major film decades later, and now the dominant global memory of the disaster is that a creature warned the town. That framing has since expanded with tremendous ambition. The same figure has been retroactively credited with appearing before the Chernobyl reactor explosion, where workers allegedly reported a dark-winged shape, and before the attacks of the 11th of September 2001, there is no contemporaneous documentation for either. Both stories surfaced afterward, in retellings,
Starting point is 00:41:39 which is the giveaway. A warning that only becomes known after the event is not a warning. It is a story people tell to make an unbearable thing feel less random. The same logic runs through the rest of this tier. Men in black entered the culture through a strange incident on Puget Sound in 1947, when a harbour patrolman named Harold Dahl claimed he had witnessed something over Mori Island and the following morning was visited by a man in a dark suit who took him out for breakfast, described the details of the sighting backed him with impossible accuracy, and advised him that talking about it would be bad for his family. The case is generally regarded as a hoax, tangled up with an associate of Dahl who was pitching stories to a magazine and who left a long
Starting point is 00:42:22 trail of unreliability behind him. It does not matter. The image was too good. The concept of anonymous authority figures who appear in dark suits to enforce silence has proven so durable that it survived being disproven, being turned into a comedy franchise and being parodied for 30 years. Black-eyed children are much younger and have an unusually clean origin. In the late 1990s, a journalist named Brian Bethel posted an account to an internet mailing list describing two children, who approached his car at night in Texas asking for a ride, and he wrote that he felt an overwhelming, irrational dread, and noticed their eyes were completely black.
Starting point is 00:43:02 He posted it as a personal experience with genuine uncertainty attached. That single post spread across the early internet, and within a few years people were reporting encounters worldwide. This is the folklore assembly line running at modern speed, except instead of a small-town newspaper it is a forum, and instead of 26 years, the escalation takes about 18 months. And the hat man belongs in this category for a completely different reason, because unlike everything else here, he has a firm medical explanation.
Starting point is 00:43:31 A very large number of people across totally unconnected cultures report the same experience of waking up unable to move while sensing a tall, dark figure in the room, often described as wearing a wide-brimmed hat. The neurology behind this is well established. During certain phases of rest, the brain paralyzes the body's voluntary muscles so that you do not physically act out what is happening in your head.
Starting point is 00:43:55 Occasionally the mind becomes alert while that paralysis is still switched on. You're awake, aware, and unable to move a finger, and the threat detection systems of the brain, which are ancient and not remotely subtle, conclude that something is in the room. The mind then does what it always does with insufficient data, which is generate a shape. Newfoundland folklore calls the experience
Starting point is 00:44:18 the old hag, Japanese tradition has its own long-established term for it, and cultures across the world independently produced a nearly identical intruder figure. That is the strongest evidence in this entire chapter, and what it proves is not the existence of a figure. It proves that human brains are running identical hardware and producing identical errors, which is the thread tying all of it together. This tier is not zoology, it is meaning-making. A bridge collapses on a Friday evening and kills 46 people for reasons involving corrosion chemistry, and that is intolerable because it means the universe is not paying attention. A creature that came to warn the town is a worse fact but a better story, because it implies the disaster was noticed by something. People do not
Starting point is 00:45:04 build omens because they are gullible. They build them because randomness is the hardest thing a person is ever asked to accept. That instinct, though, is not just a coping mechanism. Wind it back a few thousand years, and it turns into something genuinely useful, because the oldest monsters on earth were not entertainment. They were operating manuals with teeth. Among the Algonquian-speaking peoples of the northern forests and Great Lakes region, the Wendigues are being associated with insatiable hunger, greed, and the winter, and it is treated as a serious spiritual concept rather than a campfire story. The traditional accounts describe a person who consumes human flesh becoming one and never being satisfied again, growing larger as it eats so that the hunger permanently
Starting point is 00:45:49 outpaces any possible meal. Read that as a practical instruction and it is brutally effective. In a sub-Arctic winter a hunting party cut off from supplies faced a real and specific choice and the survival of the group depended on that choice never being made because a community that permits it once has permanently changed what it is. The taboo is enforced not by law, which requires enforcement, but by horror, which requires nothing. The monster is not a warning about the woods. It is a warning about what a starving person is capable of talking themselves into. There is a medical footnote to this that has aged badly. 19th and early 20th century ethnographers described what they termed Wendigo psychosis,
Starting point is 00:46:32 a supposed culture-bound condition in which a person developed a compulsive craving for human flesh, and it's circulated in psychiatric literature for decades as an exotic curiosity. Modern researchers have taken that apart fairly thoroughly. Two and five Canadians will hear the words, you have cancer. That's why every step and dollar raised matters. On September 19th, join thousands in Toronto for the Princess Margaret Cancer Foundation walk. Challenge yourself, friends, and family to walk 21 kilometers in support of life-saving research. Together, we can carry the fire and help create a world free from the fear of cancer.
Starting point is 00:47:12 Register today at pmcf walk.ca.ca. The 26 Chevrolet Tracks is the stylish SUV for those on the move. And with the standard Chevy safety assist package, you have the backup to handle every turn with confidence. The 26 tracks. Start your build at Chevrolet.ca. The documented cases are extremely thin. Most were recorded second-hand by outsiders working through interpreters. Several appear to involve people who are starving or executed for entirely other reasons,
Starting point is 00:47:43 and the framing tells you far more about colonial era assumptions than about anyone's mental health. It is a diagnosis that mostly diagnose the people writing it down. Japan produced the same category of monster with a completely different personality, and the Kappa is, without competition, the strangest creature on this entire list. It is a river dweller roughly the size of a child with a shell, webbed hands, and a shallow dish of water on top of its head that is the source of its strength. Its main documented crime is dragging people into the water and extracting the Shirikadama, a mythical organ located, and there is no delicate way to phrase this, at the far southern end of the digestive tract. As a message to children, this is devastatingly effective, because you can tell a kid a river is dangerous and they will nod and go swimming, or you can tell them a turretsy. The turtle goblin wants that specific thing, and they will never go near water again.
Starting point is 00:48:37 What makes the Kappa magnificent, though, is everything else in its file. It is obsessed with cucumbers, to the point that Japanese cuisine still names a cucumber roll after it, and there is a traditional practice of throwing one into a river as a toll. It is fanatically devoted to sumo wrestling and will challenge people to matches, which is a hobby, not a threat. And it is compulsively polite, which turns out to be its fatal weakness, because if you bow to a kappa it is obligated to bow back and bowing tips the water off its head, at which point it loses its power and has to go home.
Starting point is 00:49:11 A monster that can be defeated by good manners is the greatest design in world folklore and nothing else comes close. The Japanese coast contributed a second entry with none of the charm. The Umibozu is described as an enormous dark figure with a smooth round head that rises from the sea and crucially it appears when the water is calm. That detail is the whole point. Sudden squalls kill sailors specifically because the conditions before them look safe and a flat, glassy sea in the wrong season is a warning sign, not an invitation. The folklore encodes an actual maritime hazard into a shape a fisherman will remember at 3 in the morning
Starting point is 00:49:49 far better than he would remember a barometric principle. The pattern is global once you start looking. In Islamic tradition, gin are created from smokeless fire and are described as an entire parallel category of being with free will, capable of good, evil and everything in between, with the Ifrit representing the more powerful and hostile end of the range. They are associated with ruins, deserts and abandoned places, all of which are genuinely dangerous locations to wander into alone. Among the Diena, or Navajo, the Skinwalker is a figure so serious that traditionally it is not discussed casually with outsiders at all, which is worth respecting rather than mining for content,
Starting point is 00:50:28 and it functions within a specific moral framework about the deliberate misuse of knowledge rather than as a generic movie monster. The Philippines has the Aswan, a shapeshifting creature that targets the vulnerable and specifically pregnant women, and its later history is remarkable, since there is a well-documented episode in which counter-insurgency operatives deliberately exploited local belief in it as a psychological weapon during a rebellion, which is possibly the only recorded case of a folk monster being formerly weaponised. Australia has the Bunyip, tied to waterholes and billabongs across many Aboriginal nations, sitting exactly where still water hides deep drop-offs and unstable banks.
Starting point is 00:51:08 Slavic tradition has Baba Yaga, who lives in a hut standing on chicken legs at the boundary of the deep forest, and who is not straightforwardly evil, because she will help a properly respectful child and destroy a rude one, teaching manners and forest boundaries in the same transaction. And the Wampanoag describe the Pukwudgi, small beings of the New England woods who are tolerable if left alone and dangerous if provoked or mocked, which is functional instruction for any child living beside a forest. Line them all up and the pattern is impossible to miss. The monster is never in the village square. It is in the deep water, the winter forest, the abandoned ruin, the unfamiliar coast, and the specific stretch of river where the current turns. Every one of these creatures is standing precisely where a child should not go, holding a sign written in the only language that reliably works on human beings, which is fear. The deeper we go, the less the monsters live in the woods, and the more they live in office buildings.
Starting point is 00:52:06 Because somewhere near the bottom of this iceberg, cryptozoology stops being about animals entirely and merges with politics, and the creature you're supposed to be afraid of is no longer hiding in a swamp. It is wearing a suit and giving a speech about infrared. structure. The modern version of this belongs almost entirely to one man. David Icky was a professional footballer whose career was ended by arthritis, then a sports presenter on British television, which is a respectable and completely normal resume right up until the early 1990s, when he announced a spiritual awakening on a primetime talk show and the studio audience laughed at him on live national television. Most people would have relocated to another country. Icky doubled down and built out an
Starting point is 00:52:48 entire cosmology, and by the late 90s he had arrived at the claim that made him famous, which is that a bloodline of shape-shifting reptilian entities, which he calls the Babylonian Brotherhood, occupies the top positions of government, finance and royalty across the world, holding human form through some sort of vibrational trick, and slipping only when photographed at the wrong moment. The standard list of accused shapeshifters is always the same, and it is basically whoever was on the cover of a magazine that decade. President Prime Ministers, Monarchs, Central Bankers, and for some reason a rotating cast of pop musicians, which suggests the interdimensional reptile agenda includes a surprisingly aggressive touring schedule.
Starting point is 00:53:31 It is worth pointing out clearly that historians and researchers who have examined this material closely have noted that the structure of it maps almost perfectly onto much older conspiracy literature, with a secret hereditary bloodline controlling banking and government, and that swapping in lizards does not change the shape of the accusation underneath. That criticism is not a side note. It is the main reason this particular theory gets treated as something more serious than a fun campfire idea. The theory then borrows a foundation from actual antiquity to make itself sound researched, and the load-bearing beam is the Anunaki. These are real, sort of. The Anunaki appear in genuine Sumerian and Acadian texts as a group of deities,
Starting point is 00:54:12 the Divine Assembly of the Pantheon and Mesopotamian religion is a legitimate and deeply studied field. What is not legitimate is the layer added in the 1970s by a writer named Zichoria Sitchin, who produced translations claiming these were flesh and blood extraterrestrials from an undiscovered planet who came to earth to mine gold and genetically engineered humanity as a labour force. Assyrologists, meaning the small number of people on the planet who can actually read cuneiform professionally, have gone through this line by line and found that the translations do not survive contact with the language. Words are given meanings they do not carry, and passages are reassembled to say things the tablets do not say. It is an enormously popular theory built by
Starting point is 00:54:55 someone working around the people who could check it. The biblical layer gets stacked on next. Genesis contains a famously strange passage about the Nephilim, described as being on the earth in those days, associated with the sons of God and the daughters of men, and the text is genuinely cryptic and has been argued over by scholars for 2,000 years. Numbersad's fuel when scouts sent into Canaan come back reporting people of enormous size, the descendants of Anak, and describe themselves as grasshoppers by comparison, which is either a description or the oldest recorded case of a team badly overselling a difficult assignment to management. The Anakim connection is also how Goliath enters the conversation, since the biblical tradition
Starting point is 00:55:36 places surviving Anakim in the very cities Goliath comes from, and here is aenei. and here is a detail that rarely makes it into the documentaries. The height of Goliath is not consistent across the manuscript tradition. The familiar Hebrew text gives six cubits and a span, which works out to well over nine feet, while the Greek Septuagint and the oldest surviving fragments from Cumran give four cubits and a span, which lands closer to six feet nine,
Starting point is 00:56:01 still enormous for the period, still an intimidating opponent, but distinctly within the range of humans who currently play professional basketball. Physical evidence for the giant theory is where things fall apart entirely, and the most cited case is the castanaut bones. In 1890, an anthropologist named George Vaché de la Pouge reported fragments of a humorous, a tibia, and a femur from a burial site in southern France, and suggested they belonged to an individual of extraordinary size, with later retellings
Starting point is 00:56:31 inflating the estimate to around 11 feet. The fragments were partial, the reconstruction was speculative, and the material itself is no longer available for modern examination, which is a spectacular coincidence that happens to almost every giant skeleton ever reported. Meanwhile, there are extremely well-documented cases of humans reaching close to nine feet through pituitary conditions, complete with medical records and photographs, and their skeletons show exactly the pathology you would expect. Real gigantism leaves fingerprints in bone, the mythical kind leaves only a caption, which leads to the theory that ties this whole tier together the idea that ancient monuments were built with outside help.
Starting point is 00:57:13 It went mainstream with a best-selling book in 1968, and the argument is essentially aesthetic. The pyramids at Giza are too precise. Stonehenge is too heavy. The Naska lines in Peru are too large to appreciate from ground level, and are therefore, supposedly, runway markers for someone arriving from above. A carved sarcophagus lid from Palanke gets reinterpreted as a Maya Rueu, operating a rocket, which requires you to ignore the surrounding iconography of maize, the world tree, and the underworld that the rest of the carving is very clearly depicting. Every one of these has an answer, and the answers are more impressive than the theory. The Nazca lines were made by removing a layer of dark, oxidised stone to expose pale ground underneath, which is a technique a person can
Starting point is 00:57:57 perform with a rake, and researchers have reproduced full-sized figures using stakes, cord, and simple scaling from a small drawing. They're also perfectly visible from the surrounding foothills, so the runway argument requires the ancient Peruvians to have been unaware of hills. At Giza, archaeologists excavated the workers' settlement and found bakeries, breweries, housing and cattle bones, along with skeletons showing healed fractures that had been professionally set, meaning the builders received medical care.
Starting point is 00:58:26 Record survive of ration payments in bread and beer. These were organised, fed, housed, paid, crews working in rotation, not slaves, and certainly not passengers, and Stonehenge involved hauling blue stones from Wales across roughly 140 miles, which is astonishing, and which people have since replicated on a small scale using rope, timber and an unreasonable number of volunteers. The core problem with the whole hypothesis is that it only ever gets applied in one direction. Nobody suggests that medieval European cathedrals required alien assistance, and those are structurally terrifying buildings raised by people with no calculus and a lot of confidence. The doubt lands consistently
Starting point is 00:59:07 on the Egyptians, the Maya, the Nazca and the Megalith builders, and archaeologists have been blunt about what that implies. The theory does not add a mystery. It removes a credit line from the people who actually did the work and hands it to an imaginary crew that left no tools, no waste, no writing, and no landfill, which is remarkable, since human beings cannot build a shed without generating archaeological evidence for a thousand years. Down at the muddy floor of this tier sits a creature that has nothing to do with any of that, and yet keeps getting filed alongside it, purely because it is green and has scales. In late June, 1988, a 17-year-old named Christopher Davis was driving home from a night shift near Bishopville, South Carolina, when he got a flat
Starting point is 00:59:52 tire on a road beside a swampy stretch of ground. He pulled over, changed the tire in the dark, and reported that as he was finishing, something came at him across the field. He described it as roughly seven feet tall, green, with red eyes and three fingers on each hand, and said it got onto the roof of his car as he drove away. The car did have damage, including scratches and a bent mirror, which the local sheriff photographed and treated seriously. What followed was the small town monster economy and fast forward. Other residents reported damage to vehicles.
Starting point is 01:00:24 Reporters arrived. a radio station offered a large cash reward for the creature, which is a wonderful way to guarantee the arrival of evidence. Plaster casts of three-toed footprints were produced and later determined to be fabricated. The sheriff's office concluded that the vehicle damage in several cases was consistent with an animal, and canine chewing and clawing on car parts is a real phenomenon that has been documented repeatedly in the year since. Davis, for his part, took a polygraph and did not enjoy the attention, and later reportedly regretted saying anything at all, which is the standard outcome for anyone who reports a monster
Starting point is 01:01:00 and does not immediately open a gift shop. So that is the bottom of the iceberg, reptile bloodlines, mistranslated tablets, lost giants, and a teenager with a flat tire. Which would be a comfortable place to end this, if it were not for the fact that the sceptics have a very serious problem waiting for them at the exit, because the entire sceptical position rests on a simple idea,
Starting point is 01:01:21 which is that if a large unknown animal, existed, we would have found it. That is a reasonable argument. It is also an argument that history has personally embarrassed several times. Start with the Ocarpi. For years, European visitors to the Congo heard consistent accounts from local communities of a forest animal, with the body of a horse and stripes on its legs, and the standard outside response was that the locals were describing something imaginary or garbling a description of a known animal. In 1901, Harry Johnston obtained skin and skulls. And the thing turned out to be entirely real and considerably weirder than advertised because it is not a horse or a zebra at all. It is the only living relative of the
Starting point is 01:02:02 giraffe, a short-necked forest survivor of an ancient lineage, and the reason nobody had photographed one is that it lives in dense rainforest, avoids open ground, and has hearing so acute that it hears people long before people see it. It was not hiding from science, it was avoiding everything, which is its full-time job. Then there is the platypus. which remains the single greatest insult ever delivered to the scientific establishment by an animal. When the first specimen reached Britain at the very end of the 1790s, the assembled experts concluded it was a fraud, specifically that some Asian taxidermist had sown a duck bill onto the pelt of a mole-like mammal
Starting point is 01:02:40 for the amusement of gullible Europeans. One naturalist reportedly went at the join with scissors looking for the stitches. There were no stitches. It was simply a venomous, egg-laying, electro-receptive mammal with a bill because Australia was operating on entirely different design principles. Scientists then spent decades refusing to accept that a mammal could lay eggs, which was not settled until the 1880s, meaning the platypus spent roughly 90 years being treated as a hoax that would not stop being real.
Starting point is 01:03:10 The Komodo dragon was a rumour with the same flavour. Reports circulated of an enormous land crocodile on remote Indonesian islands, and it was treated as sailor exaggeration until a Dutch official collection. specimens in the early 1910s, and the world learned that a genuine 10-foot predatory lizard had been there the whole time, eating deer and occasionally water buffalo, and the modern era keeps producing them. In 2005, an expedition to hydrothermal vents in the South Pacific found a blind crustacean covered in dense pale bristles, and the researchers, having a sense of humour, unofficially named it the Yeti crab. It is now a described genus, Kiwa.
Starting point is 01:03:52 discovered in an environment nobody could reach without a submersible. The best case of the entire category, though, arrived in a fishing net. Two and five Canadians will hear the words, you have cancer. That's why every step and dollar raised matters. On September 19th, join thousands in Toronto for the Princess Margaret Cancer Foundation walk. Challenge yourself, friends, and family to walk 21 kilometers in support of life-saving research. Together, we can carry the fire and help create a world free from the fear of cancer. Register today at pmcf walk.ca.ca.
Starting point is 01:04:30 Across Canada in a Volvo. Destination, Vancouver, turn left to leave. Travel west through. Approaching. Continue toward you've arrived. Adventure in comfort with Volvo. Whether you prefer. For gas, plug-in hybrid or fully electric, there's a Volvo for everyone. Learn more at VolvoCars.ca.
Starting point is 01:04:59 In December 1938, a museum curator named Marjorie Courtney Latimer went down to the docks in East London, South Africa, out of habit, to look through the day's catch for anything unusual. She found a large blue fish with strange, thick, lobed fins that moved like limbs, and she could not identify at all. She fought to preserve it. Taxi drivers refused. to carry it, and by the time an ichthyologists saw it, the internal organs were gone. It did not matter. What she'd recovered was Akela Khanth, a member of a lineage that the fossil record indicated had ended around 66 million years ago, alongside the last of the non-avian dinosaurs. It had never been extinct. It had simply been living in deep water off the coast of Africa
Starting point is 01:05:46 the entire time, wildly uninterested in the fossil record, and local fishermen had been catching them occasionally for generations without knowing anyone cared. Even our closest relatives were on the myth list. Until 1902, European science generally treated accounts of an enormous gorilla living high in the volcanic mountains of Central Africa as hunter's exaggeration, until a German officer shot two of them and the mountain gorilla entered the record permanently. An animal weighing over £400, living in family groups, in specific mountains, was classified as a tall tale within the lifetime of people whose grandchildren are alive today. And there is a genuinely sad flipside to all of this, which is the Saula. It was found in the forests along the border of Vietnam
Starting point is 01:06:30 and Laos in 1992, a slender animal with two long straight parallel horns, so distinct that it required a new genus, and it was hailed as the most significant large mammal discovery in over half a century. Then it more or less vanished again. It has been captured on camera trap only a handful of times, most recently over a decade ago, no scientist has ever reliably observed one in the wild for any length of time, and it may already be functionally gone, killed off largely by snares set for other animals. We found it and lost it inside a single human generation,
Starting point is 01:07:04 which is the actual horror story in this video. Which brings the whole descent to its uncomfortable conclusion. Every animal on that list was at some point exactly what a cryptid is now, meaning a rumor, a local account, a story dismissed by serious people. So the believers are not wrong that the category can graduate, but look carefully at how every single one of them made the trip. Not one was confirmed by an enthusiast with a camcorder and a hunch.
Starting point is 01:07:30 They were confirmed by researchers who went to the place, sat in the mud, worked with the local communities who already knew the animal was there, and came back with a specimen, a skeleton, or a tissue sample that could be handed to a stranger who wanted to prove them wrong. Discovery is not a dramatic moment in a dark forest. It is paperwork, permits, patience and a body. That is the real lesson of the iceberg. The list of confirmed creatures keeps growing and it grows through biology, not through shaky footage. And the reason cryptozoologists will never quit is that they have read the same list we just went through and they have concluded, not unreasonably, that their monster is simply the next one waiting for a Latin name. They might even be right one day. they will just need to bring back something you can hold.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.