Ancient Mysteries - The Men Who Tried to Build Unlimited Energy

Episode Date: July 20, 2026

For generations, inventors have claimed to unlock the secret of unlimited energy.This documentary explores the stories of visionary engineers, controversial inventors, and revolutionary ideas that pro...mised to change the world forever. From ambitious experiments to extraordinary claims, we examine what was attempted, what evidence exists, and why these projects continue to inspire fascination and debate.Could unlimited energy be impossible—or simply beyond our current understanding?💬 Which invention do you think came closest to changing the world?🔔 Subscribe for more documentaries about forgotten inventions, hidden history, and unexplained mysteries.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This episode is brought to you by Activia. You might already be eating yogurt, but not all yogurts are created equal. Activia contains over 1 billion probiotics per serving to survive and reach the gut alive. When it comes to gut health, Activia is the number one family doctor-recommended probiotic yogurt brand. Choose Activia. Feel good from the inside out. Visitactivia.ca for more details. When Westchaffirs took flight in 1996, the vibes were a bit different. People thought denim on denim was peak fashion, inline skates were everywhere,
Starting point is 00:00:35 and two out of three women rocked, the Rachel. While those things stayed in the 90s, one thing that hasn't is that fuzzy feeling you get when WestJet welcomes you on board. Here's to WestJetting since 96. Travel back in time with us and actually travel with us at westjet.com slash 30 years. Hey there, science lovers. Today we're talking about cold fusion. The day two respected chemists went on live TV and told the world they had cracked it.
Starting point is 00:00:59 Unlimited, clean, dirt-cheap energy from a little jar of water on a lab bench. No power plants, no pollution, goodbye oil crisis. Basically, they promised to save the planet. Even better, they dropped this bombshell the same day the Exxon Valdez was busy spilling millions of gallons of oil all over Alaska. You could not script better timing. Overnight, these two are heroes, except the exact same announcement that made them world famous also destroyed them in a matter of weeks. So how do you go from saving the planet to becoming a cautionary tale that was a moment?
Starting point is 00:01:29 fast. That's what we're unpacking today. Smash that like button and drop me a comment. What city are you watching from? Let's get into it. To really understand how this whole thing detonated so spectacularly, we need to rewind the tape and meet the two men standing right at the centre of the crater. And here is the twist you would never guess from the way it ends. These were not reckless cranks chasing attention or basement tinkerers with a wild theory on a website. These were two of the most respected chemists alive. The kind of people other people other than the same. The kind of people other the scientists talked about in hushed reverent tones, the kind whose names showed up in textbooks while they were still teaching. Start with Martin Fleischman. If electrochemistry had a hall of fame,
Starting point is 00:02:11 his statue would be right by the front entrance with the good lighting. He was a fellow of the Royal Society, which for anyone who has never brushed up against the British science world is basically the most exclusive academic club in the English-speaking universe, a membership role that stretches all the way back to Isaac Newton and Michael Faraday. So no pressure, Martin, you're just casually sharing a guest list with the man who invented calculus and the man who cracked electromagnetism, and he had earned every bit of it. Fleshman invented an ultra-precise calerimeter, a device for measuring tiny amounts of heat with almost obsessive accuracy, which is going to matter enormously later, so tuck that away. His colleagues did not just call him good. They described him as more
Starting point is 00:02:54 inventive than any other electrochemist on the planet. When the people who study heat and electricity for a living unanimously agree that you are the single most creative mind in the entire field, that is not a participation ribbon. That is the real thing. He also had the personality to match the resume, which is rarer than you would think in a world stuffed with brilliant people who cannot hold a conversation. Fleischman was charming, quick with a joke. The guy who lit up a dinner party and could explain a mind-bendingly complex idea while simultaneously refilling your glass and making you feel like the smartest person in the room. Born in Czechoslovakia, his family fled to England to escape the rising nightmare of the 1930s, and he grew into the absolute
Starting point is 00:03:36 picture of the twinkly-eyed genius professor. In the partnership we're about to unpack, he was the ideas man. He was the dreamer who would stare at something the entire scientific establishment had filed under, obviously impossible and quietly ask, yeah, but what if it is not? Then there is his partner, Stanley Ponce, who was almost his exact opposite, and not in the cute Hollywood buddy cop way where they bicker on the way to solving the case.
Starting point is 00:04:02 Pons was American, raised in a small town in North Carolina, and his road into science was anything but a straight gleaming highway. Before he ever became a professor, he spent years working in the family business, which is a very normal, very grounded thing to do, and a very unusual origin story for a man who would one day claim to have bottled the power of the sun. He did not even finish his doctorate until relatively late in life, finally earning it at the University of Southampton in England,
Starting point is 00:04:29 and guess who was there mentoring him? Martin Fleischman. This is the quiet little seed from which the entire saga grows, a student and a teacher meeting over lab benches and shared coffee and just clicking, the way certain people do. Now if Fleischman was the charismatic idea guy, Ponce was the machine, and I mean that as the highest possible compliment. The man was a workaholic of almost alarming intensity.
Starting point is 00:04:53 In the single year of 1988, he published 36 scientific papers. Let that number sink in. Most serious academics are genuinely delighted to publish a small handful of papers in a strong year, and here is Pons treating research output like a competitive eating contest, just shoveling breakthroughs onto the plate. That relentless internal engine carried him all the way up to become the head of the chemistry department at the University of Utah, which is a seriously prestigious gig, the kind that comes with respect, a budget, grad students who fetch things, and an office with an actual door. But dragponds in front of a microphone and a crowd, and the machine sputtered and stalled.
Starting point is 00:05:35 He was shy, reserved, visibly uncomfortable in the spotlight, the textbook brilliant scientist who would happily spend 12 hours alone with his equipment, rather than five minutes on a stage under hot lights. Keep that detail close, because the universe has a genuinely twisted sense of humour, and this deeply private man was about to get shoved onto the biggest stage on Earth, with the whole world staring back at him. Together, the two of them were what you might affectionately call the odd couple of chemistry. Fleischman dreamed it up.
Starting point is 00:06:05 Ponce built it and tested it with his own hands, and the whole thing purred along because their strength slotted together so perfectly it was almost annoying. And here is the part that gives the ending its real sting. This was not some cold, transactional lab arrangement, where two men tolerated each other for the sake of a grant. These two were real, honest to goodness friends. They went skiing together. They cooked together.
Starting point is 00:06:28 They went hiking and threw parties and hung out like people who actually, unironically enjoyed each other's company. Picture two internationally acclaimed scientists, cheerfully arguing about the correct way to grill something, while a chairlift hauls them up a snowy mountain, and you are not far off. That friendship is the beating heart of this story, which is exactly why watching it get fed into a wood chipper later is going to hurt. Brilliant scientists and a beautiful friendship, though, are only half the recipe for a catastrophe of this magnitude. For a reaction this violent to go critical, you need the right environment, a place hungry enough, proud enough,
Starting point is 00:07:04 and just a little insecure enough to throw caution straight out the window. Which brings us to the second main character in this drama, and it is not a person. It is an entire state. Enter Utah. Utah is a place with a truly fascinating chip on its shoulder. It was founded by Mormon pioneers who hauled themselves across half a brutal continent to build a home in the desert precisely so nobody would bother them, and over the generations that grew into a deep, almost aching hunger to finally be respected by the of the country. There has always been this anxious little hum running underneath the surface, a quiet worry that the coastal elites and the fancy old universities are looking down their noses,
Starting point is 00:07:44 that at any given moment the rest of America might point and start laughing, and when a place carries that specific flavour of insecurity, it tends to reach very hard for greatness, sometimes a little harder than is entirely wise. Utah was rich, fertile soil for big dreams, bold claims, and the occasional full-blown miracle, exactly the kind of place where a legend could sprout overnight and grow ten feet tall before breakfast. Nowhere was that hunger more concentrated than at the University of Utah, and specifically inside the office of its president, a man named Chase Peterson. Peterson was a Mormon with a glittering Harvard pedigree, a smooth, polished administrator who knew precisely how to charm important people and rooms full of donors. He was also, unfortunately,
Starting point is 00:08:31 a man staring down an absolutely brutal spreadsheet. His university had been forced to slash its budget eight years in a row. Eight. If you have ever worked somewhere that trimmed the budget even once, you know exactly how the mood curdles in the hallways. Now stretch that misery across the better part of a decade, the lab slowly getting shabbier, the best talent quietly drifting off to richer schools,
Starting point is 00:08:55 the prestige leaking out like air from an increasingly sad balloon. Peterson was desperate, And here is the thing about desperate university presidents. They do not dream about modest incremental progress. They dream about a miracle. They dream about the phone ringing with a discovery so enormous it tortures the entire funding conversation and rewrites it from scratch.
Starting point is 00:09:17 And naturally, Utah had already done this exact dance before and gotten its foot stomped. Scientists actually coined a slightly mocking nickname for the pattern, the Utah effect, born from a 1972 episode when researchers as there triumphantly announced a breakthrough X-ray laser that set the whole field buzzing with excitement, only for everyone else on earth to try reproducing it and get precisely resoundingly nothing. Big splash, no fish. The phrase became lab shorthand for a result that sounds absolutely
Starting point is 00:09:46 spectacular, right up until literally anyone else attempts to repeat it, which mild spoiler for the rest of this video is going to land with a painfully familiar thud. But Utah had also tasted the sweet, intoxicating drug that is genuine national attention, and it happened in 1982 with something legitimately historic. Doctors at the University of Utah implanted an artificial heart, the Javik 7, into a retired dentist named Barney Clark, making him one of the first human beings to live with a permanent mechanical heart, quietly ticking away inside his chest. The cameras descended, the whole world leaned in and watched, and who stepped confidently up to be the calm, reassuring voice explaining it all to the press pack, Chase Peterson.
Starting point is 00:10:33 And he was fantastic at it, measured and warm and endlessly quotable, the ideal narrator for a real-life medical thriller. The uncomfortable fact that Barney Clark ultimately passed away after 112 grueling days did not undo the lesson Peterson had absorbed deep into his bones. He had learned that a big Utah story could seize the attention of the entire planet, and, just as importantly, that he personally was very, very good at telling it. He had felt the warm glow of that spotlight, and like anyone who has felt it, he wanted it back. So step back and look at the whole board now.
Starting point is 00:11:08 All the pieces finally in position. You have got two world-class chemists, one a dreaming showman with a Newton-tier resume, the other a shy tireless powerhouse, who cannot love a crowd but can outwork any lab on the continent, and the two of them are welded together by a real and rare friendship. You have got a proud, insecure state that is quietly aching, to prove once and for all that it belongs at the grown-ups table, and you have got a prestigious university slowly bleeding money, run by a president who has already tasted the global limelight once, and would very much like a second helping. Every single ingredient for a spectacular, world-shaking, and completely unhinged announcement is now sitting on the counter, measured out and ready to go. The only thing missing was the idea itself. the one dangerous spark that would light the whole thing up,
Starting point is 00:11:57 and that spark, as it turns out, was about to arrive in the most fitting way imaginable, over a glass of whiskey. So here is how the legend goes, and I want to lean hard on the word legend, because like every great origin story this one has been retold and polished so many times it has taken on the smooth, suspicious shine of myth. The setting is the Utah wilderness, a hike through the pine and red rock of Mill Creek Canyon, exactly the kind of outdoorsy afternoon these two lived for.
Starting point is 00:12:25 And later, back inside with a bottle of Jack Daniels doing an increasing share of the intellectual heavy lifting, the conversation wandered somewhere it arguably should not have gone. They started scribbling calculations on whatever was handy, the idea's getting braver as the bottle got emptier, until one of them looked at the other and said, in effect. The odds of this actually working are maybe one in a billion, so obviously we have to try it, which is unfortunately the precise energy that has launched roughly half of all human progress and the other half of all human catastrophe. And the cruel part is that nobody can tell in advance which line they are standing in.
Starting point is 00:13:01 The star of their whiskey-fueled scheming was a metal, and not a flashy one. It was palladium, a quiet, silvery cousin of platinum that most people have never heard of and will never think about again after this video. But palladium has a genuinely bizarre superpower that chemists find delightful, and that is central to everything that follows. It drinks hydrogen, and not politely, not a modest sip. A single chunk of palladium can absorb hundreds of times its own volume in hydrogen gas, cramming those tiny atoms into the spaces in its crystal structure,
Starting point is 00:13:33 like the world's most aggressive game of clown car parking. The Hulu original series Furious is coming to Disney Plus, starring Emmy Rossum. Furious follows FBI Agent Alice Black on the hunt for a mysterious and calculating serial killer. Both walk their own paths toward justice, and as their lives start to intertwine, the line between right and wrong begins to blur.
Starting point is 00:13:58 Don't miss the three-episode premiere of the Hulu original series Furious on July 27th, only on Hulu on Disney Plus. Your summer travels deserve an upgrade. With select Chevrolet, Buick, GMC, and Cadillac vehicles connected by OnStar, you can stream, game, and more on the go. Whether you're headed to a music festival or a cottage getaway,
Starting point is 00:14:20 you can access hundreds of apps on Google Play right from your center display. Explore OnStar Tech today at OnStar.ca and discover how to take your summer to the next level. OnStar. Better never stops. Picture a sponge, except instead of soaking up water, it inhales gas, and instead of gently holding it, it packs the stuff in under staggering internal pressure. That pressure was the whole tantalizing point. If you could jam hydrogen into that metal lattice tightly enough, the reasoning went, maybe, just maybe, you could squeeze the atoms close enough to do something no chemistry textbook would allow.
Starting point is 00:14:58 Now, this was not a brand-new fever dream conjured entirely out of Tennessee's sour mash. Fleischman, being the walking encyclopedia he was, knew about an old, faintly embarrassing footnote from the 1920s, the kind of story that gets quietly left out of the polished lectures. Back then, German scientists announced that they had used palladium and hydrogen to create helium, effectively claiming they had transmuted one element into another, which is the sort of thing that gets you either a Nobel Prize or a stern talking to. The scientific world buzzed, and then came the deflating part, the part that should have been a flashing neon warning sign visible from space.
Starting point is 00:15:35 The whole result fell apart when they realised the helium had not been created by any grand reaction at all. It had simply leaked in from the surrounding air. The Helium was essentially an uninvited guest who wandered in through the window, and everyone had mistaken it for the guest of honour. The claim was retracted, the excitement evaporated, and the episode became a cautionary tale that Fleischman apparently filed under interesting rather than under Please Do Not Repeat this exact mistake. Because here is Fleischman's twist, the mental leap that turned an old dud into a new obsession.
Starting point is 00:16:08 Instead of ordinary hydrogen, he wanted to use due to tuesday. Deuterium. Deuterium is heavy hydrogen, a slightly chunkier version of the same atom carrying a little extra weight in its nucleus, and it is the key ingredient in what gets called heavy water. His dream was to load a lump of palladium with deuterium instead, pack those heavier atoms in under monstrous pressure, and coax them into fusing together, releasing energy at nothing hotter than room temperature. No stars required, no bombs required, just a metal, some heavy water and a very optimistic bet. It is a beautiful, elegant, deeply seductive idea. It is also the point where every physicist watching this video just quietly put their head in their hands.
Starting point is 00:16:50 To understand exactly why, we need to talk about what Fusion actually is, and why trying to do it on a lab bench in Utah was, on paper, about as reasonable as trying to bottle a lightning bolt in a mason jar. There are two ways to squeeze energy out of an atom and people constantly mix them up. Fission is the one we already tamed. Fission splits big, heavy atom. apart and it is what hums away inside nuclear power plants and less pleasantly what level cities. Fusion is the opposite move. Fusion smashes tiny light atoms together so hard they
Starting point is 00:17:21 merge into a bigger one, and in the process it releases a truly obscene amount of energy. It is the engine that powers every star in the sky, including our very own sun, which has been running this reaction non-stop for billions of years without a single maintenance call. So on the scale of tempting energy sources, fusion is the ultimate jackpot. The problem is the doorman. That doorman is called the Kulam barrier, and he does not want to let you in. The trouble is that atomic nuclei carry a positive electric charge, and if you remember anything from a middle school science class you fell asleep in, you know that like charges repel each other. The closer you try to shove two positively charged nuclei together, the more ferociously they push back,
Starting point is 00:18:03 exactly like trying to force the identical poles of two magnets to kiss. The whole universe is essentially screaming no at you, and it screams louder the closer you get. Only if you can somehow bully the nuclei past that furious repulsion, down to an almost unimaginably tiny distance, does a different force finally show up to the party. It is called the strong nuclear force, and it is a bruiser, immensely powerful but hilariously short-ranged,
Starting point is 00:18:30 useless until the very last microscopic moment, at which point it grabs the nuclei and snaps them together with a burst of energy. The catch is that getting them that close normally demands heat and pressure on a scale that does not exist in polite society. We are talking millions of degrees, which is why, up to this point in history, genuine self-sustaining fusion had been reliably observed in exactly two places, and neither of them is somewhere you want to be standing. One is the crushing core of the sun, the other is the inside of a hydrogen bomb. That is the guest list. That is the entire club. So when two chemists strolled up and suggested they could get the same reaction, going in a glorified fish tank at room temperature,
Starting point is 00:19:16 physicists reacted about the way you would expect a Michelin-starred chef to react, if you told them you had recreated their signature dish in a microwave using gas station ingredients. To them, cold fusion was not a bold hypothesis. it was heresy dressed up as science, the kind of claim that sits comfortably in the same drawer as perpetual motion machines and directions to Atlantis. And yet the actual apparatus at the heart of all this was almost insultingly humble, which is a huge part of why the story captured the world's imagination later. There was no giant reactor, no facility the size of a shopping mall,
Starting point is 00:19:50 no team of a thousand engineers. The setup was small enough to sit on a countertop, which is why people fondly started calling it the kitchen experiment. At its core it was a jar, a bath of that heavy water we mentioned, with a pinch of lithium dissolved in to help conduct electricity. Suspended in the liquid were two electrodes, one made of platinum and one made of the precious palladium, wired up to a power source. Flip it on, and electricity flows through the liquid in a process called electrolysis, which relentlessly drives the deuterium out of the water and crams it into the waiting palladium,
Starting point is 00:20:23 loading that metal sponge tighter and tighter, day after day after day, that is the entire contraption. It looks less like the future of energy, and more like a slightly menacing high school science fair project. But a jar bubbling away on a bench does not prove anything on its own, so the obvious question is, how would they even know if it worked? How do you tell whether the impossible is quietly happening inside your fish tank? And this is where the whole plan hinged on one deceptively simple measurement, excess heat. The logic runs like this. You know exactly how much electrical energy you're pouring into the cell, because you can measure that with total confidence. So you sit back and you carefully measure how much energy comes back out as heat. If the numbers match, boring, nothing to see here,
Starting point is 00:21:11 that is just ordinary chemistry and physics behaving themselves. But if more energy comes out than you ever put in, if the jar is somehow producing extra heat with no visible source, then you have a genuine mystery on your hands. Because that surplus energy has to be coming from somewhere, and once you have ruled out the ordinary suspects, the only candidate powerful enough to explain it is something nuclear. Extra heat, in other words, was going to be the smoking gun, the fingerprint of a reaction that supposedly could not happen. And here is the detail that makes this both perfect and, in hindsight, faintly terrifying. Measuring heat with fanatical precision was not some skill Fleischman had to go learn. It was his entire life's work, the reason he was so admired in the first place,
Starting point is 00:21:55 the man who built the ultra-accurate heat measuring instrument we mentioned earlier. Detecting a tiny surplus of warmth in a bubbling cell was, on paper, exactly the game he had spent decades mastering. So when these two looked at their humble little jar and became convinced they were seeing more heat coming out than going in, they were not too random dreamers guessing. They were, by any reasonable measure the perfect people to make this claim, which is precisely what made it so believable, so intoxicating, and, as the entire rest of this story is about to prove, so dangerous. They had the dream, they had the metal, they had the apparatus, and they had convinced themselves the numbers were on their side. The only thing left to decide was whether to keep it quiet a little longer
Starting point is 00:22:39 or to tell the world. And the way they made that choice is where everything starts to go gloriously catastrophically wrong. Before we get to the fateful decision to go public, we have to talk about the single event that supposedly flipped this whole thing from a hopeful hunch into a rock-solid certainty the moment the University of Utah stopped politely humouring two chemists and started genuinely believing them. It has a suitably dramatic name, the meltdown, and it is the absolute cornerstone myth of the entire saga. And I keep using that loaded word, myth, for a very good reason, because this is a story that quietly changes shape, depending on who is telling it, and how many years have rolled by since. The legend goes like this. One of their
Starting point is 00:23:24 humble little jars have been quietly charging away for about seven months, patiently force-feeding deuterium into a small cube of palladium, when Ponce's teenage son, Joey, who was pitching in around the lab, adjusted the electrical current, and then, allegedly, all sorts of drama broke loose. The cube of palladium, a metal that flatly refuses to melt until you get it screaming past roughly 1,500 degrees Celsius, did not merely get toasty. It reportedly melted itself into oblivion, vaporized a chunk of its own substance, and burned straight down through the lab bench and into the concrete floor beneath, leaving behind a hole about four inches across. And let me just point out for perspective that a four-inch scorched crater punched into solid concrete is not the sort of thing
Starting point is 00:24:09 you patch up with a little spackle and a positive attitude. Something inside that jar had unleashed a genuinely frightening amount of energy, wildly more than the polite trickle of electricity feeding it could ever explain. To Pons and Fleischman, this was not a catastrophe or a safety incident. This was the smoking gun they had been fantasising about, made real, dramatic, and now permanently embedded in the floor of their lab. Here is where the myth part really flexes its muscles, though, because the details of this legendary event flatly refused to hold still. Depending on which retelling you happened to stumble into, the current was cranked up, or wait, maybe it was actually turned down.
Starting point is 00:24:51 There was a small explosion, or possibly there was not. It happened in the dead of night, or perhaps in broad daylight, on this date, no, that date. The story shapeshifts like a fisherman's tale that mysteriously gains a few inches of triumph every single time it gets retold at the bar. And the single most inconvenient detail of the whole affair is this. There is no official university record of the incident, none whatsoever, for an event supposedly so earth-shaking that it convinced an entire respected institution to bet its reputation on the physically impossible. The paper trail is remarkably, almost comically empty. It is a bit like being told about the most important fire in the building's history,
Starting point is 00:25:33 and then discovering the fire department was never once called. That said, this was not conjured entirely out of thin air. A graduate student named Kevin Ashley independently confirmed that, yes, there really was a hole in the floor, so something clearly happened in that room. As for why an event this spectacular somehow never graduated into a formal incident report, Fleischman later offered an explanation that is either perfectly reasonable or gloriously convenient, depending entirely on what mood you're in. He claimed they deliberately kept the whole thing hush-hush, because if word ever got out that their laboratory had developed a hobby of melting through its own floor,
Starting point is 00:26:11 the university would have swooped in and shut the place down as a fire hazard, which, to be completely fair, is an extremely sane reaction to a room that occasionally tries to reinvent itself as an active volcano. So the single most explosive piece of evidence in the entire history of Cold Fusion was, by the man's own account, quietly swept under a rug that presumably had a friend, fresh scorch mark on it, and it was this half-documented, floor-melting, no-paperwork mystery that, more than any careful measurement, convinced the University of Utah that they were sitting on top of the discovery of the century. Nothing says rigorous science quite like a legend nobody wrote down.
Starting point is 00:26:51 With the university now thoroughly convinced it was clutching a golden ticket, the whole affair abruptly shifted into a full cloak-and-dagger operation, the kind of thing that would feel right at home in a spy thriller, assuming spy thrillers were ever secretly about patent law. Hushed meetings began among the university's trustees, tense conversations behind firmly closed doors, and because these were serious people, absolutely terrified of leaks and lawsuits, they could not even bring themselves to say the actual word fusion out loud in case somebody overheard. So they gave it a codename. They called it, and I truly wish I were inventing this, the F word.
Starting point is 00:27:28 Picture some of the most educated minds in the state, plus a whole table of administrators, tiptoeing around a single scientific term, as though merely pronouncing it might trip a silent alarm, it is the exact flavour of overwrought secrecy that only starts to make sense when there are millions of dollars and a Nobel Prize theoretically glittering on the table. Then the calendar started moving fast. On the 13th of March, they filed their very first patent application, jamming a legal flag into the ground to guarantee that if this thing turned out to be real, they and the university would own the future of energy itself. Three days later, on the 16th of March, came an emergency
Starting point is 00:28:09 meeting where the pressure got so heavy it began visibly bending people out of shape. The lawyers and administrators, petrified of losing the rights to what they believed was the discovery of the millennium, leaned hard on the scientist to move fast, faster immediately, and the atmosphere in that room reportedly grew so tense that one of the people, present was nearly reduced to tears. And this is simply not how great science is supposed to be born. A real breakthrough is meant to marinate for months, get poked and prodded and viciously double-checked by sceptics until it either survives or dies. Instead, this one was being shoved toward the exit like a product with a coupon about to expire at midnight, and rushed it absolutely was.
Starting point is 00:28:52 The original sensible plan had been to stay quiet, gather more data, and publish the results properly somewhere around 18 months down the line, but then arrived the classic villain of so many carefully laid schemes. A leak. Word was starting to seep out, and worse still, they knew perfectly well they were not the only researchers circling this same tempting idea, which raised the truly nightmarish prospect of someone else planting their flag first and walking off with all the glory. In science, being second is roughly equivalent to being nobody, and that gnawing fear of losing priority is one of the most powerful drugs known to the academic mind. So the careful year-and-a-half timeline simply evaporated and the decision was made to skip straight to the finale and tell the
Starting point is 00:29:36 entire planet at once. Hear that? It's your money calling. It wants a promotion. Elevate your savings with the Scotia high interest savings account. Always earn high regular interest rates that grow the more you save and invest. Conditions apply. Visit Scotiabank.com H-I-S-A to learn more. Scotia Bank, you're richer than you think. This episode is brought to you by L'Oreal Group. Beauty is a powerful force that moves us. That's why L'Oreal Group has built a business that is inclusive at its heart
Starting point is 00:30:14 with 100% of its brands, championing diversity. With 25,000 professional opportunities for people under 30 worldwide and 54% of leading positions held by women, diversity is a strength that helps L'Oréal Group create the best beauty products for all people. Visit laurel.com to learn more. The chosen date was the 23rd of March, 1989. They called a press conference, and what actually unfolded was less a sober scientific briefing and more a full-blown coronation. President Peterson kicked things off by lovingly wrapping the whole announcement in a glowing tribute to the
Starting point is 00:30:51 University of Utah. Because naturally, if you're going to inform the world that your institution just casually solved the planet's energy crisis, you may as well seize the branding opportunity with both hands and squeeze. Then the two scientists took their turn, and the contrast in their personalities played out live and unfiltered under the harsh lights. The shy, private ponds, hauled onto precisely the sort of stage he had spent his whole life avoiding, stumbled and fumbled through a halting description of a self-sustaining reaction, looking every inch a man who would rather be anywhere else on Earth. Fleischman, the born showman, then swept in and delivered the goods with total swagger,
Starting point is 00:31:28 serenely assuring the world that their little jar was pumping out four units of energy for every single unit they fed into it. And then he tacked on the phrase destined to haunt him for the rest of his life, calmly describing one of the most outrageous claims in the history of sciences, and I want you to really savour this, very simple, very simple. He talked about maybe rewriting the laws of physics with the same breezy confidence you would use to explain how to operate a toaster. To put the perfect mythic bow on the whole spectacle, Utah's Mormon governor chimed in from afar with a line lifted from Brigham Young, the pioneer leader who, upon first laying eyes on the Salt Lake Valley, had famously declared that this was the place, a proud, long-overlooked state announcing to the world that destiny had finally, gloriously arrived on its doorstep,
Starting point is 00:32:16 and then, quite simply, the world detonated. There was not a television channel on the planet that did not scramble to run the story. Cold fusion was suddenly everywhere at once, splashed across every front page dropping from the lips of every anchor and dinner party guest alike. Reporters who could not tell a proton from a pretzel were breathlessly explaining nuclear physics to the nation, and a scientific claim that had been made barely hours earlier was already being treated as settled, world-changing fact. And remember that eerie stroke of timing we opened this whole tale with, the oil disaster fouling the Alaskan coast at the very same moment. That grim coincidence poured
Starting point is 00:32:56 rocket fuel on the frenzy, transforming two chemists from Utah into something that felt far less like careful scientists and far more like profits who had shown up at the exact instant the planet was begging to be saved. For one shining, deliriously chaotic week, Ponce and Fleischman were the most important human beings alive, which, as we're about to discover, is a spectacularly dangerous thing to become right when dozens of rival laboratories around the globe are rolling up their sleeves to try your very simple experiment for themselves, and roll up their sleeves they did. Within days of that triumphant press conference, laboratories all across the world dropped whatever unglomerous project they had been slaving over and scrambled to recreate the miracle for themselves,
Starting point is 00:33:40 and to be clear, this is exactly how science is so. supposed to work. A claim only actually counts once other people, ideally deeply skeptical people, who would love nothing more than to catch you in an error, can follow your recipe and get the same result. That is the whole game. So more than 60 laboratories, ranging from the fanciest best-funded institutions on the planet, down to caffeinated grad students in cramped university basements, all lined up to take their swing at infinite energy. And almost immediately they went face-first into a wall so hard you could practically hear the collective thud. Because when these scientists sat down to actually follow the recipe, they made a horrifying discovery. There barely was one.
Starting point is 00:34:22 Recall that Fleischman had breezily assured the entire world that this whole thing was very simple. Well, in practice it turned out to be simple in the exact way a magic trick is simple, effortless, and obvious, once somebody shows you precisely how it is done, and completely maddening when they refuse to. The critical details, the make-or-break specifics that actually determine whether your jar performs a miracle, or just sits there bubbling away like a depressed aquarium were mysteriously frustratingly absent. How big exactly were the palladium rod supposed to be? Nobody could say for sure. How much electrical current should you push through? And just as crucially, how are you meant to raise or lower it over the days and weeks of the experiment? Total fog! How long were you
Starting point is 00:35:07 supposed to spend stuffing the deuterium into the metal before anything interesting was even theoretically supposed to happen. A few days, a few weeks, several agonizing months. Fantastic question, and one the paper conveniently forgot to answer. Were you meant to stir the solution? And if so, how vigorously and how often? Your guess was as good as anybody else is, which is to say, useless. It was like being handed the recipe for the greatest cake ever baked, and finding the entire ingredient list reads flour, some other stuff. Apply heat and best of luck to you. And there was a genuinely poisonous reason for all this vagueness, one that traces straight back to the frantic patent grab from before. The University of Utah and its scientists believed they were sitting
Starting point is 00:35:52 on a discovery worth untold billions, and you do not hand a rival the complete detailed blueprint to your billion-dollar invention out of pure academic generosity. So even as they were begging the world to believe them. They had every legal and financial incentive to keep the juiciest specifics locked in a drawer. It is a spectacular contradiction, essentially standing on a rooftop shouting, we have changed the world, please take our word for it, while quietly refusing to show anyone the actual homework. Science demands total transparency, patent law demands total secrecy. And these two men were desperately trying to sprint in both directions at the same time, which, unsurprisingly, works about as well as it sounds.
Starting point is 00:36:35 To make matters even more gloriously chaotic, the primary way this precious, half-complete information got flung around the globe was through the absolute cutting-edge technology of the era, the humble fax machine. An eight-page pre-print of their paper started rocketing from lab to lab across continents, and because everybody involved was equal parts desperate and paranoid,
Starting point is 00:36:57 it was frequently stamped with the word confidential, which is a genuinely hilarious label to slap on a document you are simultaneously beaming to every research group on earth. That is not confidential. That is a group chat. And here comes the truly absurd part. A fax is already a grainy, smeared, low-resolution mess on its best day. And what was flying around was a fax of a fax of a fax, each new copy a little muddier and more ghostly than the one before it, until scientists across the world were hunched over pages that looked like they had been printed by a machine, actively suffering an emotional breakdown, trying to reverse engineer the discovery of the century out of what was functionally a smudge with delusions of grandeur.
Starting point is 00:37:41 And even in the rare cases where you could actually make out the text, the hard numerical data, the real measurements you would need to have any hope of reproducing the work, remained painfully, suspiciously, thin, which brings us to the part that made serious sober scientists start slowly narrowing their eyes and pouring a stiff drink. How on earth had this thing gotten published so blindingly fast in the first place? Normally, before any big claim gets to appear in a respected journal, it must survive peer review, a process where a panel of independent experts tear the work apart, demand more evidence, question every assumption, and generally behave like the essential, deeply annoying bouncers of the scientific world. Their entire job is to
Starting point is 00:38:23 stop nonsense from getting in the door. The cold fusion paper found its home in the journal of electro-analytical chemistry, and let us just diplomatically say that the bouncer working that particular door was not especially thorough. The paper was essentially waved straight through by a single, friendly reviewer who also happened to be an editor, a cozy arrangement that is roughly the equivalent of grading your own homework and then warmly congratulating yourself on the flawless A. Now contrast that with nature, one of the most prestigious and ruthless science scientific journals on the entire planet, which took a single hard look at the submission, and effectively said, this is fascinating, thrilling even, now kindly go away and actually prove it,
Starting point is 00:39:04 refusing to print a word without serious grinding scrutiny. And here is the thing about that split. When the fanciest, most respected journal in the room politely but firmly shows you the exit, while a friendlier, less demanding one happily lets you cut the line, that is almost never the glowing sign of confidence people want it to be. But honestly, the missing measurements and the questionable paperwork were downright charming compared to what started happening inside the labs that took the biggest boldest swings. As we touched on earlier, Palladium has that peculiar talent for gulping down hydrogen and its heavier sibling, and running powerful electric currents through a setup absolutely stuffed with the stuff is, it turns out, a genuinely hazardous hobby if you are not
Starting point is 00:39:46 obsessively careful, because hydrogen has a long, proud, well-documented reputation for exploding at the slightest provocation. And explode it did. At Lawrence Livermore, one of the most serious and heavily funded research institutions in the entire United States, an attempt to replicate the humble little experiment went off with a bang. Over at North Carolina State University, another hydrogen explosion rattled the walls and rearranged some furniture, so the grand global quest for gentle, infinite, planet-saving, clean energy, was, in several highly respected laboratories, mostly manufacturing loud noises, singed eyebrows, shattered glassware, and a truly impressive stack of extremely awkward incident reports. The soothing dream of a quiet room-temperature reaction
Starting point is 00:40:33 humming peacefully on a kitchen counter was, in cold, hard reality, occasionally attempting to relocate the ceiling. And all of this was unfolding under a spotlight, because the press had not gone home after the announcement. Reporters were now practically camped outside laboratory doors, treating each attempt to reproduce the experiment like a live sporting event, breathlessly reporting every rumour of success and every muffled bang, which meant these scientists were being asked to perform delicate, unprecedented physics at record speed, with cameras pointed at them. Not exactly the calm, methodical conditions great science tends to prefer. And to pour a little more salt in the wound, the few labs that did think they saw something,
Starting point is 00:41:15 could not get anyone to agree on what that something even was. A handful of groups reported catching a whiff of that mysterious excess heat and got briefly, giddily excited. Plenty of others ran the experiment as faithfully as they could and got absolutely, resoundingly nothing, which naturally nudged their suspicion needle deep into the red. A convenient explanation started floating around to patch over the disaster, the idea that maybe it only worked with certain special batches of palladium,
Starting point is 00:41:43 that the metal itself had to be just right, which is a wonderfully slippery excuse because it means every single failure can be blamed on the metal rather than the theory. Cannot reproduce our miracle? Ah, well, you simply had the wrong palladium better luck next time. It is the scientific equivalent
Starting point is 00:42:00 of my incredible invention works perfectly. It just refuses to work whenever anyone else is watching. So this is the precise moment the whole affair earned its brutal, sticky nickname. The world had been solemnly promised fusion. capital F, the salvation of a planet drowning in its own oil crisis. What the world actually received, lab after lab after lab, was confusion. Sixty-some laboratories, all following the same blurry recipe, somehow managed to produce 60-some different outcomes, ranging from mild excitement
Starting point is 00:42:31 to total nothingness, to actual small explosions, and in science that is not the shimmering signature of a genuine discovery. That is the unmistakable fingerprint of a mess. And a mess this loud, this public, this expensive, and this globally embarrassing was never going to be allowed to quietly fizzle out on its own, because the physicists, the very people who had been grumbling the word heresy since the instant this all began, the ones who had spent their careers knowing exactly how hard the universe fights against squeezing atoms together were now rolling up their own sleeves, except they were not reaching for beakers and palladium. They were sharpening their knives and they were about to get their turn to speak. The physicists had their
Starting point is 00:43:13 knives out, sure. But here is the thing about a hype train barreling down the tracks at full throttle, with the entire world cheering it on. The brakes do not work instantly, and for a glorious little while the passengers have absolutely zero interest in stopping. Before the reckoning could arrive, cold fusion was about to roar up to the single most triumphant, chaotic and frankly unhinged peak of its whole brief life, and it happened, of all places, in a basketball arena in Dallas. In April of 1989, the American Chemical Society held its big annual meeting, and roughly 7,000 people crammed into the arena to be part of the moment. The atmosphere in that building was less stuffy academic conference and a lot more sold-out stadium concert, which is exactly
Starting point is 00:43:57 why the whole thing got fondly christened the woodstock of chemistry. And I need you to appreciate how deeply strange that is, because chemistry conferences are not, as a rule, famous for their electric screaming fan energy. On a typical day, the wildest thing happening at one is a mildly tense disagreement over the correct way to label a diagram. But this was something else entirely. Stanley Ponce, the shy, private man who would have happily traded a kidney to avoid a stage, walked out to a hero's welcome and got received like a genuine, bona fide rock star. Chemists were on their feet, roaring, and a huge slice of that roar electricity was something far more primal than scientific curiosity. It was sweet, delicious, tribal revenge. Because for as long
Starting point is 00:44:42 as anyone could remember, the physicists had sat comfortably at the top of the science pecking order, quietly regarding the chemists as the well-meaning folks who mix colourful liquids in beakers and occasionally make something fizz. And now here were the chemists, having apparently cracked nuclear fusion, the ultimate physics prize, while the mighty physics establishment stood around sputtering in furious disbelief. It was the greatest underdog victory imaginable, the kids who always got picked last suddenly running the entire playground. The theatrics only escalated from there. Right in the middle of the celebration, someone read out a breaking bulletin fresh off the wire from Moscow, announcing that Soviet scientists had confirmed the experiment. The crowd
Starting point is 00:45:25 absolutely lost it. International validation, live and in real time. Nobody in that ecstatic arena paused to ask the boring but rather important questions like how rigorous that confirmation actually was, or whether a dramatic announcement hollered to a cheering mob is quite the same thing as careful, verified, peer-reviewed science. In the moment, none of that mattered. The party was in full swing, and nobody wants to be the killjoy squinting at the fine print during the encore. Meanwhile, out in the cold light of the real world, the money had caught the fever even faster than the crowd. Palladium, that obscure little metal almost nobody outside a chemistry lab had ever spared a thought for, abruptly became one of the hottest commodities on the planet.
Starting point is 00:46:11 Prices rocketed upward as investors, speculators and researchers alike scrambled to hoard the magic ingredient of infinite energy. And this is precisely where capitalism did what capitalism always does, which is catch the faintest whiff of opportunity and sprint toward it, with the shame receptors fully switched off. At least one supplier started marketing its palladium as fusion grade, slapping a shiny premium label on the exact same metal it had been quietly selling the week before at a fraction of the price. Because nothing screams trust me, this is rigorous cutting-edge science quite like the aggressive branding instincts of a late-night infomercial. Fusion-grade palladium, now with 50% more destiny, operators are standing by. And the state of Utah, that proud, respect-hungry place we met earlier,
Starting point is 00:46:59 simply could not help itself. Swept up in a wave of patriotic local fervor, its legislature voted by the lopsided margin of 97 to 3 to hand over $5 million to support the research. And here is the single detail that tells you everything about where this circus was truly heading. Of that 5 million, half a million, a full tenth of the entire pot, was immediately funneled straight into the pockets of an army of patent lawyers. Not toward better beakers. Not toward more precise instruments. or independent verification, toward lawyers, so that Utah could make absolutely legally certain it owned the glorious future before a single soul had confirmed that future actually existed, and out of all this fevered excitement rose a grand new institution with an equally grand name,
Starting point is 00:47:46 the National Cold Fusion Institute, an organization solemnly dedicated to harnessing an energy source that would, in the giddy phrasing of the day, be so ludicrously cheap it would not even be worth the bother of measuring how much you burned through. endless near-free power for all of humanity. What, one wonders, could possibly go wrong. And the sheer, breathtaking speed of it all is what makes this moment so surreal in hindsight. An entire institute, millions of dollars, a stampede of lawyers, and a global commodity boom had all sprung up in a matter of weeks,
Starting point is 00:48:21 built on top of an experiment that, as we just saw, dozens of the world's best laboratories still could not reliably make work. The financial world and the political world had sprinted miles ahead of the actual science, which was still standing back at the starting line, sheepishly checking its notes. While all this rock concert euphoria was thundering along, the story was simultaneously climbing to an even loftier and more rarefied altitude, sailing straight into the marble corridors of power in Washington. Because when two people casually announced that they have solved the entire planet's energy crisis,
Starting point is 00:48:54 the government tends to want a word, and the first serious grown-up to get involved was a man perfectly qualified to have one. His name was Glenn Seaborg, and he was a genuine titan of nuclear science, a Nobel laureate who had literally helped discover brand new elements and understood the inner life of an atom about as well as any human being who's ever lived. Before the next track starts, have you ever wondered, who are the people in my old family photos? Or what brought them to Canada?
Starting point is 00:49:22 With ancestry, you can start finding answers. Start with a name and we'll guide you from there. For just 499, try our new 30-day beginners pass and uncover generations of family stories. No experience necessary. You've got questions? We've got ancestors. Offer ends July 22nd, 2026. Visit Ancestry.ca slash beginners for details.
Starting point is 00:49:43 Terms apply. Seabor went to see President George H.W. Bush, and to his lasting credit, he delivered an absolute masterclass in careful, responsible honesty, the kind that had been in treasurer. tragically short supply for the previous chaotic month. He did not march in and declare cold fusion a glorious triumph. But crucially, he also refused to slam the door and branded an outright fraud. His message boiled down to something wonderfully sober. There is no convincing evidence that any of this is real, but it would be reckless and premature to publicly call it a lie just yet. So what this country needs is a calm, thorough, unhurried expert report before anybody
Starting point is 00:50:23 in power says something they can never take back. In a saga defined by people sprinting when they should have been walking, Seaborg was the rare voice quietly suggesting everyone sit down and actually think. The government machinery duly cranked into gear. The Secretary of Energy mobilized roughly a dozen national laboratories to seriously investigate the claim, unleashing some of the sharpest, best-equipped scientific minds in the nation on the mystery of the bubbling jar. This was no longer two friends and a promising hunch. This was rapidly swelling into a full-blown national research effort, with the weight of the federal government behind it. Then came the main event, a marathon congressional hearing on the 26th of April
Starting point is 00:51:04 that dragged on for something like five solid hours, which is roughly four hours and 55 minutes longer than most people can stay awake in a government hearing. And here, the charm offensive paid off beautifully. Pons and Fleischmann, with the full backing of their university, thoroughly charmed the committee, painting a dazzling, irresistible picture of a clean, cheap, revolutionary energy future, sitting right there within America's grasp,
Starting point is 00:51:30 if only the nation was bold enough to reach out and grab it. But the real theatrical masterstroke of the day did not come from the scientists at all. It came from a lobbyist named Ira Magizena, who walked in and reached straight for the single most effective button you could possibly mash in a room full of 1980s American politicians, the fear of Japan. He gravely warned the assembled lawmakers that if America hesitated, If it dithered and dragged its feet, Japan would come swooping in and steal cold fusion right out from under them, exactly the way it had supposedly stolen the electronics industry
Starting point is 00:52:04 and the automobile industry before it. And in an era when American anxiety about Japanese economic dominance was practically a national hobby, this was pure rhetorical dynamite. Suddenly this was not merely about clean energy anymore. It was about national pride, economic survival and beating arrival to the finish line, and nothing on this earth loosens a government's purse strings faster than the gnawing terror of losing a race to a competitor. Peterson, ever the polished and ambitious salesman, recognized a golden moment when it landed in his lap.
Starting point is 00:52:36 He arrived in Washington asking for federal funding somewhere in the neighborhood of $25 to $125 million, which is a gloriously enormous range, the fiscal equivalent of shrugging and saying, oh, somewhere between a nice new car and a private jet, honestly whatever you happen to have lying around. And to really get the defence hawks leaning eagerly forward in their chairs, he gently dangled the military implications, quietly noting that the reaction might be capable of producing tritium, a key ingredient in nuclear weapons. And just like that, the humble little countertop experiment had inflated into a matter of national security. What had begun as two friends scribbling long-shot calculations after a hike in the mountains, was now being seriously
Starting point is 00:53:19 pitched as a project worthy of the full might, prestige and bottomless treasury of the United States government. The stakes had climbed about as high as stakes can physically go, which naturally is exactly why the fall, when it finally came for them, was going to be such a very, very long way down. But not every single person who showed up to those grand Washington hearings was there to cheer and hand out suitcases of federal money. Amid all the soaring promises and the manufactured terror of Japan, one quiet, mild-mannered man stood up to deliver a message that could not possibly have been more different from the hype,
Starting point is 00:53:55 and memorably he brought a plant. His name was Stephen Jones, and he was a physicist from Brigham Young University, which for a little context is another major Utah institution and a longtime local rival of the University of Utah. So right away, there is a deliciously petty, layer of in-state academic feuding baked into this. Jones was soft-spoken, careful, and pretty much the exact opposite of a showman,
Starting point is 00:54:19 and rather than vowing to save the planet by Tuesday, he offered the committee a gentle little parable. He held up a young seedling, a small green sprout, and told the assembled lawmakers in effect that this was a tender young thing, and nobody yet knew whether it would grow into a beautiful rose or a mighty tree. So please, he urged, do not go dumping an entire mountain of fertilizer on it in a frantic panic. Give it time, let it grow and quietly reveal what it truly is before you bet the whole farm on it. In a room absolutely stuffed with people demanding tens of millions of dollars this very instant, this was a stunningly modest, sane, and refreshingly adult thing to say. It was also, spoiler alert, almost completely ignored,
Starting point is 00:55:02 because nobody funds a documentary about a man who calmly recommended patients. But here is the part that quietly recontextualizes this entire saga, and it is a genuinely juicy one. Stephen Jones was not just some random skeptic who wandered in off the street clutching a house plant. He was, in a very real sense, the reason this entire runaway train had ever left the station in the first place, because Jones had been steadily, unglamorously working on his own closely related research, investigating whether you could detect tiny faint numbers of neutrons emerging from deuterium crammed into metal. And I know that sounds almost suspiciously similar to what our two famous chemists were up to, and that similarity is precisely the problem. The crucial difference is that
Starting point is 00:55:46 Jones was chasing a much smaller, much more modest effect, and he was doing it as a cautious physicist rather than a headline-hungry dreamer promising to power the world, but the ideas overlapped closely enough that when the Pons and Fleischman bombshell detonated, Jones felt with a fair amount of justification that they had basically run off with his general idea, inflated it into something enormous, and grabbed all the glory before he could blink, and this is where we finally loop all the way back to the very opening of our story, to that lonely young man left standing in the FedEx office at the Salt Lake City Airport. Because the two rival camps, keenly aware they were treading on each other's toes, had reportedly struck a gentleman's agreement to play fair. The plan was
Starting point is 00:56:30 elegantly simple. Both groups would submit their competing scientific papers to a journal on the exact same day, so that neither side could sneak ahead and claim sole credit for the discovery. That poor graduate student we met at the beginning, Marvin Hawkins, was the one sent to physically ship the papers off, waiting for his counterpart so the two envelopes could be mailed together as promised, and he waited, and he waited some more, and nobody ever came, because the pact had quietly, unceremoniously been broken. One side had already made. its move to lockdown priority, leaving the other clutching an envelope in a fresh, steaming pile of betrayal. Hawkins, the completely innocent errand-runner caught in the crossfire, would go on to
Starting point is 00:57:10 lose his job just weeks before finishing his own doctorate, a small, very human casualty flattened beneath the wheels of two ambitions racing for immortality. Not exactly the noble, high-minded, gentlemanly pursuit of pure truth they sell you in school. So as the hearings and the frenzy churned on, the entire affair now dangled from one enormous unanswered question. Were Ponce and Fleischmann a pair of modern-day Prometheus figures, bold heroes who had stolen fire from the gods to gift humanity limitless clean energy? Or had they flung open a Pandora's box, unleashing chaos and forces nobody could control? Or, the third and most humiliating possibility of all, was this whole spectacle the scientific equivalent of Piltdown Man, that notorious fake fossil
Starting point is 00:57:55 that hoodwinked the world's experts for decades, a magnificent blunder dressed up as the discovery of the age, heroism, curse, or grand delusion. At that precise moment, the world honestly did not know which. But it was about to find out, and the answer would be delivered with roughly the tenderness of a firing squad. The answer arrived just a few weeks later, and it did not come from a jubilant arena packed with adoring chemists.
Starting point is 00:58:19 It came from a room crammed with physicists in Baltimore, and it dropped like a guillotine blade. This was the May meeting of the American Physical Society, and it is remembered to this day as the evening cold fusion was publicly, methodically, and rather mercilessly executed in front of its peers. The first blow came from a chemist named Nathan Lewis of Caltech, who had done the one unglamorous thing the true believers had mostly skipped in their excitement. He had painstakingly, obsessively tried to reproduce the experiment
Starting point is 00:58:49 while hunting down every conceivable source of error like a detective who refuses to go home. And what he uncovered was devastating precisely because it was so mundane. Remember that all-important excess heat, the supposed smoking gun, the mysterious extra warmth that could only be explained by something nuclear stirring inside the jar. Lewis argued it was nothing of the kind. It was, he demonstrated, most likely an artifact, a simple, measurement blunder born from a cell that nobody had bothered to stir properly. When the liquid inside the jar was not thoroughly mixed, warm and cool pockets formed throughout it, and if your thermometer happened to be sitting in a toasty spot,
Starting point is 00:59:31 you could very easily trick yourself into believing the whole contraption was churning out far more heat than it truly was. In other words, the miracle energy of the century may well have been a mirage conjured up by sloppy stirring and a thermometer parked in the wrong corner. The single greatest breakthrough in the history of the human race, potentially demolished by the scientific equivalent of complaining, your drink tastes weird because you never stirred in the sugar sitting at the bottom. Then came the knockout line of the entire night,
Starting point is 01:00:00 delivered by a theoretical physicist named Stephen Coonin. In front of the packed and increasingly gleeful crowd, Coonin did not waste time on diplomatic hedging or polite academic cushioning. He essentially declared that the whole cold fusion claim could be neatly explained by the incompetence and delusion of Pons and Fleishman, and the room, brimming with physicists who had just spent weeks feeling personally insulted by a couple of chemists strolling in and claiming to have casually cracked their hardest problem over the weekend, erupted into applause. It was a savage, career-flattening sentence, cheerfully delivered to an audience that could not have been more thrilled to double as the jury. But the physicist did not lean on insults alone, satisfying as those clearly were.
Starting point is 01:00:44 They had a genuinely lethal scientific argument in their back pocket, and it is honest. my favourite part of this entire take-down because it is so grimly beautifully logical, if real nuclear fusion had truly been happening inside that humble jar at anything remotely close to the rate needed to generate the heat the two men were boasting about, then that reaction would have been furiously spraying out a storm of neutrons and radiation as an unavoidable byproduct. And that is not some minor footnote. That level of neutron flux would have been intensely, catastrophically radioactive. To put it as plainly as well, possible, if their experiment had actually been doing what they claimed it was doing, the radiation
Starting point is 01:01:24 pouring out of it would have killed them both stone dead. Pons and Fleischman would not have been out giving triumphant press conferences and charming congressional committees. They would have been in the ground. The simple, stubborn fact that both men were standing there in glowing good health was, all on its own, powerful evidence that no meaningful fusion was occurring anywhere near that jar. You cannot claim to be running a miniature star on your kitchen counter. and also be perfectly fine, because miniature stars are not exactly famous for their gentle, considerate bedside manner. And there was still more. Among the evidence the two chemists had offered up as proof of a nuclear reaction was a telltale spike in gamma radiation they said they had
Starting point is 01:02:05 detected. But when the physicists put that spike under the microscope, they found something fatal. The peak was sitting at the wrong energy, popping up in a spot that simply did not match what genuine fusion would actually produce. It was a little like proudly presenting a photograph as iron-clad proof of a lion prowling your backyard, only to have everyone gently point out that the beast in the picture is unmistakably a golden retriever wearing a hopeful expression. The signature did not fit the crime, and the case fell apart, and with that, it was finished. In the span of a single evening in Baltimore, the two men who mere weeks earlier had been hailed as the saviors of a struggling planet, welcomed like rock stars, courted by the United States Congress,
Starting point is 01:02:50 and celebrated by an entire proud and hopeful state, were transformed into something else entirely. They became a cautionary tale, a permanent warning label, the very name scientists would forever reach for when they needed to describe how even brilliant, sincere, well-intentioned experts can spectacularly fool themselves and then accidentally fool the entire world along with them. The long fall we kept promising had finally, completely arrived all the way to the bottom. But a crash this loud and this public is never quite the end of the story, because now these two men actually had to go home and figure out how to live inside the smoking
Starting point is 01:03:27 wreckage of the miracle they had promised everyone. And living in the wreckage turned out to be every bit as grim as it sounds, because the slow, grinding machinery of government was about to finish the job the physicists in Baltimore had so gleefully started. In the autumn of 1989, a federal panel of experts operating under the wonderfully dull bureaucratic banner of the Energy Research Advisory Board, or ERAB, sat down to soberly review the entire mess and hand down an official verdict, and their conclusion was polite, measured, and utterly devastating. There was, they found, no convincing evidence whatsoever that Cold Fusion was real, and therefore there was absolutely no need to create any special program to pour money into it. In plain, unvarnished English, the government had popped the hood, peered inside, found a whole lot of nothing,
Starting point is 01:04:17 and quietly rolled the garage door back down. Those glittering dreams of up to 125 million federal dollars simply evaporated into the dry Utah air, leaving behind only the faint smell of embarrassment. The grand institution born at the very peak of the frenzy did not hang on much longer either. That proud National Cold Fusion Institute, which had been conjured into existence
Starting point is 01:04:39 in a blaze of legislative optimism and local pride, limped along for a little while on fumes and hope, but by 1991 it shut its doors for good. Its fatal flaw was that it had never managed to produce the one and only thing it desperately needed. The thing this whole video has circled again and again, reliable, repeatable results, that some other lab somewhere could actually confirm,
Starting point is 01:05:02 an entire research institute millions of dollars and an absolute mountain of good intentions, all quietly folded. up and boxed away because the miracle it was purpose-built to study simply kept failing to clock in for its shift. There is something almost poetically lonely about it, an institution dedicated to boundless, infinite energy running completely out of the one resource it could never seem to generate, which was proof. And the media, the very same media that had breathlessly crowned these two as profits, and plastered them across every front page on earth, performed a whiplash-inducing about face
Starting point is 01:05:38 with truly impressive speed. The same reporters who had struggled to explain nuclear physics to their viewers now had a far juicier and easier story to tell, the story of the fall, the fiasco, the great scientific embarrassment. Fame in the press is a fickle, hungry beast, and it turns out that building someone up into a hero is only ever the setup for the far more entertaining sequel, which is watching them tumble back down.
Starting point is 01:06:04 In the span of a single season, Pons and Fleishman went from the headline, wanted to the punchline everyone repeated. As for our two chemists, Utah had rapidly transformed from a hero's welcome into an awkward place to be recognised at the grocery store. The very state that had crowned them as saviors now mostly wanted to quietly pretend the whole humiliating chapter had never happened, and the wider scientific community had efficiently converted their names into punchlines. So Ponce and Fleischman did what plenty of people do when home becomes unbearable. They packed their bags and left.
Starting point is 01:06:39 They relocated all the way to France, of all places, where they carried on their experiments at a laboratory called I.M. Arich, which was being generously bankrolled by none other than the automobile giant Toyota. And take a moment to truly savour that, because it is one of the great ironic twists of the entire saga. Recall that the specter of Japan swooping in to steal the technology had been used to frighten the United States Congress into a frenzy. And now here was Japan,
Starting point is 01:07:06 through one of its biggest and most famous corporations, cheerfully footing the bill to keep the whole dream on life support. The irony is thick enough to spread on toast and serve at breakfast. But even with a deep-pocketed patron, a fresh start, and some very nice French scenery, the results still stubbornly refused to appear. The extra heat would not reliably show up, the nuclear signatures would not cooperate,
Starting point is 01:07:30 and no matter how the two men tweaked and adjusted, the miracle stayed just out of reach, forever shimmering on the horizon like a mirage that retreats every time you step toward it. And so, by the end of the 1990s, that French laboratory quietly closed its doors as well, adding yet another shuttered building to this story's steadily growing real estate portfolio of dashed hopes. At some point you have to wonder how many buildings one failed idea can politely empty out. The later chapters of the two men's lives took different but equally poignant paths. Stanley Ponce, so deeply wounded by the way his own country had turned on him almost overnight,
Starting point is 01:08:07 went so far as to renounce his American citizenship entirely, choosing to remain in Europe and effectively slamming the door on the nation that had briefly worshipped him, and then just as quickly tossed him aside. Martin Fleischman eventually made his way back home to England, where he lived out his remaining years and passed away in 2012, a man whose brilliant, celebrated career, the one that had once put him in the same conversation as the greatest scientific minds in history,
Starting point is 01:08:34 would forever carry this enormous, unavoidable asterisk, and here is the single detail I find genuinely touching, in a tale otherwise stuffed to the brim with ego, money, and chaos. Through absolutely all of it, through the global humiliation, the closed institutes, and the years of exile, the one thing that appears to have survived intact was the friendship we opened this whole story with.
Starting point is 01:08:58 These two did not turn on each other, they did not spend the aftermath pointing fingers and hurling blame across a courtroom, the way so many partners do the incident a shared dream detonates. They stuck together. They kept working side by side. They rode the entire catastrophe out as a team right to the end. The world had decided they were wrong, but neither of them ever seems to have decided the other guy was the one to blame.
Starting point is 01:09:21 In a story, this cynical, that stubborn and glamorous loyalty is quietly, unexpectedly beautiful. Visit BetMGM Casino and check out the newest exclusive. The Price is Right Fortune Pick. BetMDM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly. 19 plus to wager. Ontario only. Please play responsibly.
Starting point is 01:09:42 If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, please contact Connects Ontario at 1-866-531-2,600 to speak to an advisor. Free of charge. BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with Eye Gaming Ontario. When you're a mid-sized business, You need every competitive advantage you can get. Like an AI solution that works for you, not against you. SAP Grow is built with AI embedded at its core, working across every system.
Starting point is 01:10:13 And it's ready to go from day one so you can hit the ground running. Bring it with SAP Grow, AI Cloud ERP for any size business. For the broader world of science, though, the wreckage left behind both a permanent scar and a permanent lesson. The very phrase, cold fusion, underwent a complete personality transplant, mutating from the two most thrilling words on the planet into something closer to a polite scientific insult. It became the go-to textbook example of what researchers grimly refer to as pathological science, which is a marvellously damning label for the specific phenomenon where sincere, intelligent, highly credentialed experts gradually managed to fool themselves into believing in an effect that is simply not there,
Starting point is 01:10:57 clinging desperately to faint signals and wishful measurements, while cheerfully explaining away every single inconvenient failure. And this is the crucial, uncomfortable part. It is not fraud. Nobody serious believes Ponce and Fleischman were mustache twirling con artists cackling over a fake experiment. In a strange way, it is sadder and more unsettling than fraud, because it is what happens when genuinely brilliant people
Starting point is 01:11:22 want something to be true so badly, so achingly, that they accidentally trick their own. own eyes and their own instruments into agreeing with them. Cold fusion became the cautionary bedtime story whispered to every young scientist ever since. Check your work, stir your solution, invite the skeptics in early, and whatever you do, never, ever call the press conference before you're absolutely certain. And yet, and this is what keeps the tale from ending on a simple tombstone, the story does not fully die. Because a small, stubborn, endearingly persistent band of researchers never entirely let go of the dream.
Starting point is 01:12:00 Even today, quietly and very far from the roaring headlines of 1989, a handful of scientists continue to gently poke and prod at these strange low-energy nuclear reactions, though they now almost always operate under a newer, less-humiliated, rebranded name, L-E-N-R. That fresh label conveniently allows them to study the lingering mystery without instantly triggering everyone in the room to roll their eyes at the cursed words cold fusion. They chip away in relative obscurity,
Starting point is 01:12:30 occasionally reporting odd little anomalies and unexplained blips, keeping the faintest of flames flickering in a corner of a field that firmly moved on decades ago. Maybe there really is some tiny elusive kernel of something real buried down in there. Maybe there is absolutely nothing at all just noise and hope. The jury, all these years later, has technically never fully left the building, though it has clearly stopped paying attention,
Starting point is 01:12:54 and wandered off to get coffee. But that grand, intoxicating, world-shaking promise, the one made in front of the entire planet on that spring day, the glorious vision of unlimited, clean, dirt-cheap power, bubbling peacefully out of a humble jar of water sitting on a countertop, has to this very day never, ever been delivered. So in the final accounting, what exactly were they? Prometheus, Pandora, or Pilt-down,
Starting point is 01:13:21 hero, harbinger of chaos, or elaborate hoax. The honest answer is probably a heartbreaking little cocktail of all three at once. Two authentically gifted men chasing an authentically gorgeous dream, who moved far too fast, believed far too hard, and allowed ambition, money, patent lawyers, and a proud state's desperate hunger for glory to drag them out onto a stage they were never remotely ready to stand on. They did not save the planet.
Starting point is 01:13:48 The oil kept flowing and the power plants kept humming. But what they did leave behind is one of the greatest, weirdest, and most achingly human stories that science has ever coughed up. A permanent reminder that the razor-thin line separating a world-changing genius from a cautionary tale can sometimes be as flimsy as a poorly stirred jar of water, and that particular lesson, it turns out, is worth an awful lot more than... Hey, y'all's Kelly Clarkson with Wayfair. Ever order furniture online and wonder, what if? Like, what if it doesn't hold up? That sofa was four days old. You should have ordered from Wayfair. With Wayfair, there's know what if. Just style you love and quality
Starting point is 01:14:23 you can trust. Visit wayfair.ca Wayfair, every style, every home. For what?

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.