Ancient Mysteries - The Prophecy of the Popes: Why Everyone Is Looking at 2027

Episode Date: September 9, 2026

For centuries, one mysterious document has claimed to predict the future of the papacy — and its final interpretation points to 2027.Known as the Prophecy of the Popes, the text traditionally attrib...uted to Saint Malachy contains a sequence of cryptic Latin mottos supposedly describing generations of popes.Some of the matches seem remarkably specific. Others appear vague enough to fit almost anyone. And historians have uncovered evidence suggesting the document may have appeared centuries after Malachy actually lived.So why has this prophecy survived for so long?In this documentary, we trace the extraordinary history of the Prophecy of Saint Malachy — from medieval Ireland and the Vatican to papal elections, disputed predictions, historical coincidences, and the controversial interpretation that has renewed attention around the year 2027.Was it really a medieval prophecy?Was it an elaborate political forgery?Why did so many of its early predictions appear to match?And what does its mysterious ending actually say about the future of the papacy?The deeper we investigate, the stranger the story becomes.This video examines the historical claims and competing interpretations surrounding the prophecy. It does not present predictions of future events as established fact.Subscribe for more documentaries exploring religious history, ancient texts, historical mysteries, forgotten documents, and the stories behind some of history’s most fascinating claims.#ProphecyOfThePopes #SaintMalachy #Vatican #Pope #CatholicHistory #HistoryDocumentary

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Where some see heroes and others see egos. Bloomberg sees the era of billionaire athletes. While others follow the noise, we follow the money. Learn more at Bloomberg.com. Visit BetMGM Casino and check out the newest exclusive. The Price is Right Fortune Pick. BetMDM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly. 19 plus to wager.
Starting point is 00:00:26 Ontario only. Please play responsibly. If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, please contact connects Ontario at 1-866-531-2,600 to speak to an advisor, free of charge. BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with Eye Gaming Ontario. Hey there, history buffs. May 8, 2025, white smoke over the Sistine Chapel, and outwalks a guy from Chicago, Robert Prevost, Leo 14, first American Pope ever,
Starting point is 00:00:55 and according to the most famous prophecy in church history, this man should not exist. The list ended with his predecessor. After the last pope, Rome burns and the world ends. Rome is fine. The world is annoyingly still here. Case closed, right? Except researchers went back to the original Latin and found a printing error from the 1600s. One mistake that glued two separate sentences into one and made four centuries of readers misread the ending. Fix it, and the prophecy stops counting popes. It starts counting years, and it lands on 2027.
Starting point is 00:01:29 Hit that like button if this is your kind of rabbit hole, and drop a comment telling me what city you're watching from. Let's roll. To understand how a printing error ended up holding the fate of the world hostage, you have to meet the man whose name got stapled to the whole thing, and he was not a mystic in a cave. He was a church administrator with a hostile takeover on his hands. Ireland in the early 1100s was Christian, technically.
Starting point is 00:01:53 It had been Christian for 600 years. What it did not have was anything the rest of Europe would recognise as a church. There were no real dioceses, barely any parishes, and the bishops mostly floated around without territory, which is a bit like having managers with no departments and no employees, just impressive business cards. Real power sat with the monasteries, and the monasteries were run by abbots,
Starting point is 00:02:16 and the abbots were increasingly not monks. They were local strongmen who had inherited the job the way you inherit a farm. The abbey owned land. Land meant rent. Rent meant power. And once a family got their hands on a good abbey, they were not letting go of it for something as flimsy as canon law. The crown jewel of this system was Armagh, the highest church office in Ireland, the seat founded by Patrick himself, the closest thing the island had to a papacy. And for roughly 200 years, Armaz had been the private property of one family, the clan Sainais. Fifteen generations of them give or take. Eight of those holders were married men.
Starting point is 00:02:55 Several of them had never been ordained at all. They were not priests, they were not bishops. They did not perform sacraments, and they had no interest in learning. They were landlords with a very good title. Imagine if the Vatican had spent two centuries being run by a family who had never actually been to seminary and mainly showed up to collect rent, and you have roughly the right picture.
Starting point is 00:03:16 Naturally, nobody in Ireland thought this was strange, because it had been going on longer than anyone could remember, and there is no argument more powerful in human history than we have always done it this way. Into this mess, around the year 1094, a boy was born in Armagh named male Medocua Morgia. Latin turned him into Malachius, English turned him into Malachi. His father taught in the cathedral school, which put the family firmly in the educated professional class and firmly outside the ruling clan, and both of his parents were dead before he finished growing up. He did the medieval equivalent of dropping out of the family career tracts,
Starting point is 00:03:52 and went to study under a hermit named Imar, who lived in a cell beside the church and had opinions about how much comfort a human being actually needs. The answer was less. Maliki took to it immediately, which tells you something unsettling about his personality. Other teenagers rebel by acquiring bad habits. This one rebelled by acquiring fewer. He was ordained a priest around the age of 25 by Kellach, the Archbishop of Armagh, who happened to be from the ruling clan, but was also, remarkably, an actual reformer, who wanted the whole hereditary arrangement dismantled. Even that ordination broke the rules,
Starting point is 00:04:27 since the legal age was 30, and Chelech shrugged and did it anyway. Then he sent Maliki South to Lismore to learn how Christianity was practiced in the rest of Europe, because at this point Irish liturgy had drifted so far from Rome that visiting clergy kept discovering local customs the way you discover a new species. Marriage laws were essentially freelance.
Starting point is 00:04:47 Confession had quietly stopped happening in whole regions. Tithes were a rumour. Maliki studied under a bishop named Malchus who had trained in England, came back armed with the standard Roman playbook, and started applying it to people who had never asked for it. His first real project was Bangor, an abbey on the coast that had once been one of the great learning centres of northern Europe, and was now a ruin with a story attached.
Starting point is 00:05:10 Vikings had hit it repeatedly in the 9th century, and the local memory insisted that hundreds of monks had been killed in a single raid. The site had been sitting mostly abandoned for generations, technically owned by Maliki's own uncle, who handed over the land but kept the revenue, because family is family but money is money. Maliki showed up with ten companions and rebuilt the place out of wood in about a week and a half, not stone, wood. When people objected that this was a bit modest for a site of such historic importance,
Starting point is 00:05:40 he pointed out that Irish monks had always built in wood and he was not going to bankrupt a starving district for architecture. Unfortunately for that philosophy, he would later get very interested in stone-building, and the resulting culture clash produced one of the best arguments of his life, but we will get there. In 1124, at around 30, he was made Bishop of Connor, and Connor is where his reputation as an administrator got tested by reality. According to the biography written later by his closest friend, his new flock were Christians in name and pagans in practice. They did not pay tithes, did not go to confession, did not bother with church weddings, and in some places had not had a functioning priest
Starting point is 00:06:20 within living memory. He went house to house. He preached in the open air when nobody came to church. He reintroduced the sacraments to a population that regarded them as a foreign import, which they arguably were. It went about as well as you would expect for a man walking into a district, and informing everyone that their entire family arrangement is now technically invalid. Then, in 1127, the whole thing was erased. A regional king came through, the territory got taken apart, and Connor stopped being a functioning diocese. Maliki fled seven. with about 120 followers and was taken in by Cormac McCarthy, King of Munster, who gave him land to start over. So by his mid-30s he had rebuilt one ruined abbey, run one diocese into
Starting point is 00:07:02 the ground through no fault of his own, and was now starting a monastery in exile in someone else's kingdom. Not a resume that screams future prophet of the end times, and then Chelleh died, and the fight began. On his deathbed in 1129, the Archbishop of Armagh did something that should have been unremarkable and was in fact nearly suicidal. He named his own successor, and he named an outsider. Maliki, a man with no clan claim, no family right, no inherited stake in the property. Chellach sent his pastoral staff to him as the symbol of the appointment and then died, having lit the fuse and left the building in the most literal way available. The clan did what the clan had done for two centuries. They ignored it. They installed one of their
Starting point is 00:07:45 own, a man named Murschatach, and when he died a few years later they installed another one Neil, and both of them held something more important than legal title. They held the relics, specifically they held the Book of Armagh and the staff known as the Staff of Jesus, an object Irish tradition claimed had belonged to Patrick himself. In a country where most people could not read a legal document, but everyone knew what those objects looked like, whoever physically carried the relics was the Archbishop full stop. Possession was not nine-tenths of the law. Possession was the entire law, and the other tenth was how many armed relatives you could bring with you. Maliki did not move for two years. He had been legally appointed to the
Starting point is 00:08:25 highest office in the Irish Church, and he simply refused to take it, because taking it meant war, and he knew exactly what that war would cost. It took a papal legate and a group of bishops and kings collectively cornering him and telling him he had no choice before he agreed, and even then he agreed on one condition, which is the detail that makes him interesting. He said he would take our mar, and the moment the office was free of the clan, he would resign it and hand it to someone else. He negotiated his own exit before he had walked in the door. Nobody does that. People do not fight their way to the top of an institution while contractually promising to leave. What followed was roughly five years of low-grade civil war conducted with
Starting point is 00:09:05 the tools of the period, which is to say ambushes, seizures, standoffs, and at least one attempt to poison him at a peace meeting, where the wine was reportedly prepared with a additional ingredients. He was cornered in the open by armed men more than once. Both sides eventually had their own archbishop, their own supporters, and their own opinions about which one of them was the real one, and the whole conflict was fought largely over custody of two objects. In 1137, the last rival gave up, and the relics changed hands, and Maliki became the undisputed archbishop of Armagh, in full possession of the most powerful office in the country, with his rivals broken and his authority absolute. He resigned within the year. He kept the promise. He split the
Starting point is 00:09:48 enormous old diocesan two, handed Armour over to a bishop named Gelassius, and took down for himself, which was smaller, poorer, and a substantial demotion by any measure you like. He went back to living in a monastic community and rebuilding churches. It is genuinely difficult to find a comparable move in medieval history, an era in which men routinely blinded their own brothers over inheritance and considered it Tuesday. He won the war for the throne and then gave the throne away because winning it had never been the point, and that is the man who, in 1139, packed a bag and set off for Rome. The trip had a bureaucratic purpose, which is the least mystical sentence available. Ireland needed the pallium, the woolen band a pope gives to an archbishop that formally confirms
Starting point is 00:10:32 his rank, and Maliki wanted two of them, for Arma and for Cashel. Without them, the Irish Church remained an oddity on the edge of the map. So he crossed to Scotland. Scotland, went down through England, and here he ran into his first problem, because the Archbishop of York was under instructions from the King of England to let nobody through to Rome without royal permission, and Maliki did not have royal permission. He kept moving anyway. He got across the channel, went south through France, and stopped at a place he had heard about but never seen. Clairvo. Clervo was an abbey in a valley and champagne, and it had been open for less than 20 years, and it was already one of the most influential addresses in Europe because of the man running it.
Starting point is 00:11:13 Bernard of Claervaux was in his late 40s, physically wrecked from decades of fasting, and functionally the most powerful voice on the continent. He had joined the Cistercian Order when it was on the verge of collapse, brought 30 relatives and friends with him, and turned it into an expansion machine that would plant hundreds of monasteries across Europe within a generation. He wrote the founding rule that turned the Knights Templar from a small band of unemployed knight in Jerusalem, into a recognised order, and then wrote a whole treatise arguing that they were a new species of warrior, holy rather than vain, which was extremely effective marketing and got them
Starting point is 00:11:48 donations from every noble family that could afford one. Kings wrote to him, popes wrote to him. He would later preach the Second Crusade to an enormous crowd in Vesolay and personally trigger a continental military mobilisation, and when that crusade collapsed into a disaster, he would write an apology that basically said the fault was everyone's sins, which is the medieval equivalent of blaming the market conditions. Maliki walked into that abbey and he did not want an audience or a favour. He wanted to stay. He asked Berner if he could quit everything, resign his bishopric entirely, and live at Claervo as an ordinary monk. The two of them became close almost immediately, which surprised people, since Bernard's usual mode of interacting with bishops was to write them a devastating letter
Starting point is 00:12:32 about their moral failings. Maliki continued to Rome, met the Pope, and got a mixed result. He was made papal legate for all of Ireland, which was real authority. He was refused the palliour, on the grounds that Ireland had to hold a proper national council, and request them formally, which is the 12th century version of being told to submit the correct form. He also asked again, to be released from office so he could become a monk, and was told no, twice. In terms that made clear the answer was permanent. So he went home the long way, back through Clervaux, and here he did the thing that actually changed Irish history. He left four of his companions behind to be trained as Cistercians. A few years later they came back with a group of French monks and founded
Starting point is 00:13:16 Mellifont, the first Cistercian Abbey in Ireland, built in stone, in the international style, laid out the same plan used across Europe. Some of the French monks took one look at Irish conditions and went home, and some of the Irish took one look at the French building methods and objected loudly that this was not how they did things, and Maliki had to stand in the middle of that argument and explain to both sides that a wall is a wall. The order took root anyway and spread across the country within decades. Nine years later, he set out for Rome a second time to finally collect those palliour, and he never arrived. He fell ill on the road and reached Claervaux in October of 1148 and got no further. And here is the detail that
Starting point is 00:13:57 everything else in this story hangs from, because before he ever left Ireland, monks had asked him where he thought he would die. He gave them an answer, not a vague one. He said he would die at Claervo, and he said he would die on the Feast of All Souls. He died at Clairvaux on the 2nd of November 1148, which is the Feast of All Souls with Bernard beside him. He was 54. Bernard buried him, wore his tunic and wrote his biography, and that biography is essentially the only detailed source we have for his entire life. It is a warm, admiring, thoroughly biased document written by a man who loved him, and it is packed with miracles, healings and predictions, including several other occasions on which Maliki correctly called a death before it happened. He became the first
Starting point is 00:14:41 Irishman formerly canonised by a Pope in 1190. And that is the reputation, the one thing everyone in Europe eventually knew about the Irish Archbishop, the man who scheduled his own death and hit the date, which is exactly the kind of reputation you want attached to a document if you're ever going to convince people it can see the future. Now rewind nine years to that first trip and to the version of the story that the biography somehow forgets to mention. Where some see heroes and others see egos, Bloomberg sees the era of billionaire athletes.
Starting point is 00:15:16 While others follow the noise, we follow the money. Learn more at Bloomberg.com. Visit BetMGM Casino and check out the newest exclusive. The Price is Right Fortune Pick. BetMGM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly. 19 plus to wager. Ontario only. Please play responsibly.
Starting point is 00:15:37 If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, please contact Connects Ontario at 1-866-531-2,600 to speak to an advisor. Free of charge. BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with Eye Gaming Ontario. was not a city that had just settled a leadership dispute. It was a city that had barely survived one. In 1130 the previous Pope had died, and what happened next was less an election than a heist. A faction of cardinals worried about losing control, moved the dying man to a fortified monastery, waited for him to expire, buried him immediately an unconsecrated ground so there could be no delay,
Starting point is 00:16:18 and held a rushed vote before dawn with a minority of the college present. Their candidate walked out as innocent too. Within hours the rest of the Cardinals, who had reasonable objections to being locked out of the most important vote in Christendom, held their own election, and produced Pietro Pierleone, who took the name Anacletus II. Two popes, both with a legal argument, both consecrated. And this was not a technicality that would sort itself out in a fortnight, because the two men had entirely different power bases. Anacletus came from one of the wealthiest families in Rome, a banking dynasty descended from Jewish converts, and his father. family owned large chunks of the city, including its fortifications. Innocent had the better reputation and almost no muscle. Within weeks, Anaclitus held Rome, held the churches, held the money, and Innocent held a boat out of town. He fled to France, and that is where the whole thing turned, because the
Starting point is 00:17:13 decision about who was really Pope was not made in Rome by canon lawyers. It was made in France by an abbot. Burner of Claervo backed Innocent, argued for him at a council, and then spent years touring Europe convincing kings one by one. France came over, England came over, the German emperor came over. Anaclitus, meanwhile, held the actual city and bought himself an ally by handing Roger two of Sicily a royal crown, which is how Sicily became a kingdom, a decision that outlasted everyone involved by about 700 years. The result was eight years of schism that dragged half of Europe into it. The emperor marched on Rome twice. Innocent was installed in part of the city, while his rival held the rest, which meant Rome briefly ran a two-poppe system with a front line
Starting point is 00:18:00 through the middle of it, and pilgrims arriving to see the heart of Christendom had to pick a side before choosing a church. Bishops were appointed twice over, whole regions had duplicate clergy, and it only ended when Anaclitus died in early 1138, and his supporters elected a replacement, Victor IV, who lasted about two months before Bernard talked him into resigning, which has to be the single most efficient piece of persuasion of the century. Innocent then held a council at the Lateran in the spring of 1139 to clean up, and he cleaned up with enthusiasm. Everything his rival had done was annulled,
Starting point is 00:18:35 every ordination, every appointment, every consecration. Bishops who had spent eight years running dioceses discovered they had never legally been bishops at all. Cardinals were stripped in front of the assembly. It was lesser reconciliation than a public demolition, and the message was simple. There had never been two popes. There had only ever been one, and everyone who thought otherwise was now unemployed.
Starting point is 00:18:58 That is the Rome Maliki arrived in a few months later. Not a serene eternal institution, but a bruised one that had just watched itself split down the middle and nearly not come back. Everyone in that building understood, in a way their successors would spend centuries trying to forget, that the papacy could actually end. Not through a prophecy.
Starting point is 00:19:18 Through paperwork, family, and a bad night in a locked chapel. And this is where the legend takes over from the record. The story goes that Maliki in Rome went down to pray at the tomb of Peter beneath the basilica. The old basilica, the one built by Constantine, dark and cluttered and 800 years old, nothing like the building that stands there now. He knelt there through the night. And instead of the quiet he'd come for, he got something else. He did not see names. That is the part everyone gets wrong and it is the part that makes the whole thing work. There was no scroll unrolling with a list of future popes and their dates of birth.
Starting point is 00:19:54 What he saw, according to the tradition, were images, one after another in sequence, a castle standing above a river, an eagle with its talons spread, a crescent moon, a rose, a swan, a wolf. Objects, animals, heraldry, landscapes, arriving in order, each one standing for one man who would sit on the throne of Peter, from the next pope all the way to the last one, and he wrote them down as short latin. phrases, not sentences, two, three, four words at most the length of a caption, 112 of them. Some are places, some are family emblems. Some are jokes so specific you have to know a man's coat of arms to get them. Read cold, without knowing who they refer to,
Starting point is 00:20:37 they are close to meaningless, a list of scenery with no explanation attached, which is either the signature of a genuine vision or the signature of something else entirely, and that argument is going to occupy us for a while. The last vision was different. The last one was not a symbol. It was a city on seven hills burning, and a judge, terrible and final, sitting in judgment over his people. Then the text stops. No motto follows it. No hundred and thirteenth image. The list does not conclude, it terminates, and Maliki, the story says, handed it to Innocent 2 as a consolation. Sit with that word for a second. Consolation. This is a pope who has just spent eight years fighting another man for his own chair, who has been chased out of his own city, who has watched
Starting point is 00:21:22 the office nearly get torn in half, and a visiting Irish bishop hands him a document and says, Here, this will make you feel better. And the document contains a complete inventory of every man who will ever hold his job, and then it ends with Rome in flames and the last judgment. That is not consolation. That is an actuarial table with an expiry date on it. That is somebody handing you a calendar where the final page is on fire. You can construct a reading where it is comforting if you squint. The message would be that the institution survives, that after everything, there are still 111 more popes to come, that the office he nearly lost has a long future ahead of it. Fine. But the human brain does not work that way. Nobody reads a list of their successes
Starting point is 00:22:08 and feels reassured about the continuity of the organisation. They count how many names are left and they notice the number is finite, and once you know the number is finite you are no longer looking at a prophecy, you are looking at a countdown, which, according to the legend, is exactly what Innocent concluded, because he did not publish it, circulate it, or read it aloud to the Cardinals. He put it in the archive and shut the door on it, and this is the only genuinely defensible decision anyone makes in this entire story. He had spent almost a decade proving that his office was permanent, indivisible, and divinely guaranteed, and the last thing he needed on his desk was a piece of paper politely disagreeing. So into the vault it went, and there it sat,
Starting point is 00:22:52 unmentioned, uncopied, and unquoted by anybody at all for 450 years. Nobody cites it. Not the popes who supposedly appear in it, not the chroniclers who wrote down every relic, rumor and two-headed calf-sighting in medieval Europe. Not the man who wrote Maliki's biography, and never missed a chance to record one of his predictions, four and a half centuries of total uninterrupted silence from an institution that could not go a decade without writing something down. And then, in the autumn of 1590, at the worst possible moment during one of the strangest papal elections ever held,
Starting point is 00:23:28 it walks out of the archive and into the light. The timing could not have been better if somebody had planned it, which is a sentence worth remembering for later. Rome in the autumn of 1590 was having what you, you might charitably call a rough patch. Sixthus the 5th had died in August after a rain spent aggressively rebuilding the city, fixing the finances and executing bandits at a rate that made travel noticeably safer and family reunions noticeably smaller. The Cardinals filed into the conclave, argued for a couple of weeks under heavy pressure from Philip II of Spain, who had helpfully
Starting point is 00:24:01 sent along a list of candidates he would accept and a shorter list of candidates he would veto, and eventually settled on Giovanni Battista Castagna, a widely respected diplomat with a reputation for being kind to the poor. He took the name Urban Seven. Everyone exhaled. The system had worked. He died 12 days later. Malaria got him before he could even be crowned. Twelve days. That is the shortest papacy in the entire history of the office, a reign so brief that his main documented achievement was banning smoking in and around churches, which makes him either a pioneer of public health policy or the world's least popular boss, depending on your point of view.
Starting point is 00:24:41 The Cardinals, who had just gone home, turned around and came straight back to Rome, and if you have ever had to redo a two-week project because of something entirely outside your control, you have some sense of the mood in that building, and it got worse. The conclave that followed took two months of brutal deadlock before producing Gregory the 14th, who lasted 10 months. His successor, Innocent the 9th, lasted two. In the space of about 15 months, the Catholic Church went through four popes, in a city that was simultaneously dealing with plague, food shortages,
Starting point is 00:25:11 and a general sense that God might be trying to communicate something through the medium of extremely short employment contracts. Rome was not a stable institution at that moment. It was a revolving door with incense. That is the exact moment a manuscript surfaced saying none of it mattered. The document showed up during the scramble after Urban 7 died, circulating among Cardinals in the middle of an election, and its claim was breathtakingly rude when you look at what an election actually is. Because a conclave is supposed to be
Starting point is 00:25:40 the Holy Spirit working through the free choice of the College of Cardinals, that is the theology. Men pray, men vote, God guides. What the manuscript proposed instead was that the entire sequence of popes had been fixed 450 years earlier, written down in a locked room in the 12th century, and that everyone shuffling around the Sistine Chapel casting ballots was essentially reading lines off a script written before their great-great-grandparents were born, turn up, vote, agonise, whatever you like. The next name was already on the list. Naturally, this made the manuscript extremely popular.
Starting point is 00:26:16 Now, an anonymous document making enormous claims and arriving at a suspiciously convenient moment is not exactly a novel phenomenon, and the church of the late 1500s was not staffed by idiots. They wanted it checked, and the man the job landed on was about as qualified as anyone alive. Alfonso Chacon, known in Latin as Diacognos, was a Spanish Dominican living in Rome, and he was the leading authority on papal history in Europe. His major work was a set of biographies covering every pope and every cardinal,
Starting point is 00:26:46 a project of genuinely obsessive scale, cross-referencing coats of arms, family names, birthplaces, tomb inscriptions and career paths for people who'd been dead for centuries. If you wanted someone who could tell you what a 13th century bishop's family crest looked like off the top of his head on a Tuesday, this was your guy. He was, effectively, the search engine for the entire institution before search engines existed, and unfortunately for the skeptics, he did not come back saying the document was nonsense. He came back with a decoding. Roughly 74 mottoes, running from the 12th century right up to the Pope who had just died, each one matched to a specific man, and the matches were not vague. They were tight enough to be uncomfortable. The first
Starting point is 00:27:32 motto in the list is ex-Castro Tiberis, from a castle on the Tiber. That points to Celestine the Second, elected in 1143, whose name before the throne was Guido, and who was born in a town called Chita di Castello, which literally means city of the castle, and which sits on the river Tyber. Not a metaphor, not a stretch. Just his hometown, translated. The second is inimicus expulsus, the enemy expelled. That lands on Lucius 2, born Girado-Cacianemici, and if your Italian is rusty, that surname breaks down into Caccia, to chase or drive out, and nemesy, enemies. His actual family name means expel the enemy. It also happens to describe how his reign ended, since he personally led an armed assault on the capital, to put down a rebel.
Starting point is 00:28:19 bellious commune that had decided Rome should be a republic again, and got hit in the head by a throne stone during the attack and died shortly after, which is a reminder that being Pope in the 12th century was not a desk job, no matter how much everyone would have preferred it to be. Then there is Seuss in Cribro, a pig and a sieve, which sounds like an insult until you look up Urban 3. His family name was Crivelli. Crivello is the Italian word for sieve, and the Crivelli coat of arms features, alongside the sieve you would expect from that name, a pig. So the motto is not poetic at all. It is somebody reading a shield and writing down what is on it,
Starting point is 00:28:56 in the least imaginative way possible. That pattern repeats over and over through the medieval section. Fridius Abbas, the Cold Abbot, for Benedict 12, who before his election was the abbot of a monastery called Fontfouad, which means cold spring. De Parvo Hominey from a small man, for Pius III, whose family was a family. name was Piccolomini from Piccolo Womo small man. Boss Albanus in Portu, the bull of Alba in the
Starting point is 00:29:23 harbour, for Paul II, whose family arms carried a bull, and who served as Cardinal Bishop First of Albano, and then of Porto, which is the word for harbour. And the last one Chacon decoded, DeRour Cailly, from the Jew of Heaven, for that unfortunate 12-day Pope Urban 7, who had spent years as Archbishop of Rosano in Calabria, a district known for harvesting manor, the sweet residue that collects on ash trees and which everybody in the period cheerfully described as dew from the sky. Read that run of hits and you can see exactly why nobody in 1590 laughed it out of the room. These are not horoscopes. These are not phrases loose enough to fit anybody. They are surnames, hometowns, heraldic animals and job titles, converted into three words of Latin with the precision of a man filling in a form.
Starting point is 00:30:11 Chacon worked through the whole medieval sequence and the matches held, decade after decade family after family. The commentary and the list together got printed in 1595 in a book by a Benedictine monk named Arnold De Wyan, published in Venice, and it was not even a book about prophecy. It was a sprawling history of the Benedictine order, a promotional volume designed to remind Europe how many important people had come out of Benedictine monasteries, and the prophecy of the popes appears inside it as a supporting exhibit, because Maliki, conveniently, could be claimed as one of theirs. Wyon explained that the text had been sitting forgotten in the Roman archive, unseen and unread by anyone until now, which is a claim we're going to come back to with a magnifying
Starting point is 00:30:54 glass and printed all 111 motos plus the closing passage, and that publication is the moment the thing stops being a curiosity and becomes a machine, because up to 1595 every match was made looking backwards into a past everybody could already read. From 1595 onward, the remember remaining mottoes was sitting in print, in public, unassigned, waiting. The list was now making predictions, and it was about to get a run of results that turned it into the most famous prophecy in the history of the Catholic Church. The first genuinely spectacular hit came almost two centuries later, and it is spectacular because it does something the earlier entries never did. It stops describing the Pope. The motto in position for the man elected in 1775 is Peregrinus Apostolicus,
Starting point is 00:31:43 the Apostolic Pilgrim or the Apostolic Wanderer. The man who drew it was Giovanni Angelo Braski, Pius the Sixth, and when he was elected that phrase must have looked like standard-issue flattery. Pilgrim. Sure. Popes are shepherds, pilgrims, travellers, fishers of men, whatever noun you like. It is the kind of word that fits absolutely anyone in a white robe, and if the list had a weakness, this looked like it.
Starting point is 00:32:08 Then history took the word literally in the ugliest possible way. Pius the Sixth reigned for over 24 years, at the time the longest papacy anyone could point to, and he spent most of it watching the ground disappear underneath him. The French Revolution dismantled the church in France, seized its property, and demanded the clergy swear loyalty to the state. He condemned it. France responded by annexing papal territory, and in 1798 a French army under General Bertier walked into Rome, declared a Roman Republic and informed the 79-year-old Pope that he was no longer ahead of state and should hand over his ring. He refused. They took it anyway, then they took him. An old man with a body that had largely stopped working was loaded onto a carriage and moved from town to town across
Starting point is 00:32:55 the Alps and through France, shuffled between locations by nervous officials who could not decide where to keep him and were not thrilled about the optics of a dead Pope in custody. He was carried up mountain passes on a stretcher. He never went home. He died in 1799 in Valance, in the south of France, a prisoner, having been dragged across a continent against his will. The apostolic pilgrim, wandering right to the end, on a route he did not choose, and then the list did the strangest thing it had done yet. The next motto is Aquila Rapax, the rapacious eagle. The man it belongs to is Pius VIII, Barnabarimonti, elected in 1800 in a conclave held in Venice, because Rome was too dangerous to meet in.
Starting point is 00:33:40 And nothing about Chiaramonte is eagle-like. He was a mild, scholarly Benedictine, who once preached that democracy was not necessarily incompatible with the gospel, which was a radical enough take at the time to get him nicknamed the Citizen Cardinal. Gentleman, bookish. Absolutely not a bird of prey. The eagle, the defenders of the prophecy say, is not him. it is the man standing over him. Because Pius Seven spent his entire reign locked in the orbit of Napoleon Bonaparte, whose armies marched under bronze eagles mounted on their standards in deliberate imitation of imperial Rome, and whose personal emblem was, unsurprisingly, an eagle.
Starting point is 00:34:20 And the relationship between those two men is one of the great slow-motion collisions of European history. It opens with a wedding, which is not where you expect this story to go. In 1804, Napoleon wanted the Pope physically present at a time. his coronation in Notre Dame, because a self-proclaimed emperor with no dynasty and no bloodline needed the oldest institution in Europe to stand there and make it look inevitable. Pius agreed to travel to Paris, and then, days before the ceremony, Josephine quietly informed the Pope that she and Napoleon had only ever been married in a civil ceremony, which by church law meant they were not married at all, which meant the Pope was about to crown a man living in what canon
Starting point is 00:34:57 law would call an irregular situation, in a cathedral, on camera, in front of everybody. Josephine, it should be said, knew exactly what she was doing, since a religious marriage is considerably harder to walk away from than a civil one, and she had reason to think about her long-term job security. Napoleon was furious and completely trapped, so on the night before the coronation, in a private chapel, his own uncle performed a hasty religious wedding with almost nobody present, purely to keep the ceremony legal. The most powerful man in Europe was strong-armed into remarrying his own wife, at short notice by a bishop from Ireland's least likely rival in the field of quiet leverage. The next day came the part everyone knows. During the ceremony Napoleon took
Starting point is 00:35:42 the crowned the crowned Josephine himself. The pope sat there and watched. It was a public statement that this power came from Napoleon and no one else, and the pontiff had been flown in as scenery. It went downhill from there. Napoleon demanded the papal states close their ports to British trade. Pius refused, on the grounds that he was the spiritual father of everybody, including the British, which is theologically sound and strategically suicidal. In 1809, Napoleon annexed the papal states outright. Pius responded with the only weapon he had left and excommunicated him. Napoleon's reaction was to send soldiers to the Quirinal Palace in the middle of the night. They put up ladders, broke in through the windows, and arrested the Pope, who was hauled out
Starting point is 00:36:29 of his own residence and driven north under guard. He spent the next five years in captivity, first at Savona, then at Fontainebleau, isolated from his advisers, worn down by pressure to sign away his authority, occasionally so ill that people expected him to die. He got home in 1814 only because the empire collapsed around him, and in one of the better endings in this whole story, after Waterloo, Pius VIII, the seventh, offered refuge in Rome to Napoleon's mother and family, and asked for the deposed emperor to be treated with mercy, which is either an extraordinary act of Christian forgiveness, or the single most devastating way to win an argument ever recorded. So the rapacious eagle motto, sitting on a mild, bookish Benedictine, ends up describing his reign perfectly, provided you accept, that the list is describing what happens to a Pope rather than who he is. And that flexibility, the way the mottoes can swap from describing a man to describing his era to describing his enemies whenever it becomes convenient is either evidence of a subtle prophecy or evidence of an interpretation method with no rules at all.
Starting point is 00:37:33 Hold that thought. Two positions further down comes another one that lands hard. Crux-de-Cruce, a cross from a cross, assigned to Pius 9, elected in 1846, whose race of 31 years remains the longest in history, and who therefore had ample time to accumulate crosses. The reading everyone points to is heraldic. The House of Savoy, the royal family driving the unification of Italy, carried a white cross on a red field, and it was Savoy that took the papal states apart piece by piece, and finally, in 1870, marched into Rome itself and ended more than a thousand years of the Pope ruling central Italy as a temporal monarch. Pius XIII refused to accept it, shut himself inside the Vatican, and declared himself a prisoner, a protest that his
Starting point is 00:38:19 successors would maintain for nearly 60 years. A cross delivered by a cross, from a family whose emblem was a cross, ending an institution his predecessors had spent a millennium building. That one does not require much squinting, and then Lumen in Kylo, a light in the sky, for Leo 13, elected in 1878. Here the mechanism goes back to pure heraldry. His family name was Petchy, and the Petchy coat of arms carries a comet crossing the field. That is the whole match. Somebody looked at a shield, saw a streak of light against a blue background, and wrote down light in the sky. It is exactly the same trick as the pig and the sieve, 300 years later still working, which is precisely why this stretch of the list is so persuasive and so infuriating at the same
Starting point is 00:39:07 time. When the motto's hit heraldry, they hit with the precision of a barcode scanner. When they do not, the interpreters just widen the target until they do, and the eagle that means an emperor rather than a pope, is the moment where you can watch the rules being renegotiated in real time. But nobody in the 19th century was interested in that objection, because the list was on a winning streak, and winning streaks are immune to criticism. It had a run of results, it was in print in every language that mattered, and educated Catholics who would have laughed at a fortune teller in the street, were quietly counting how many entries were left, and there were not many. The next one due up would land in the middle of the worst thing to happen to Europe in 600 years,
Starting point is 00:39:48 and its two Latin words were about to look less like a prediction, and more like a weather report. Religio de populata. Religion laid waste. Religion depopulated. Two words, and unlike the eagle, there is no coat of arms to hide behind, no hometown, no family pun. This one is not describing a man at all. It is describing damage. The Pope it landed on was Jacomo delisie. ESA, elected on the 3rd of September 1914, which is a date worth sitting with for a moment. The Austrian ultimatum to Serbia had gone out in July. Germany had invaded Belgium in August. The Battle of the Marn was happening literally that week, close enough that the Cardinals voting in Rome
Starting point is 00:40:29 were choosing a new pope, while the largest army movements in human history were underway a few hundred miles north. He took the name Benedict 15 and inherited a job that had just changed definition overnight. And here is what makes his motto genuinely disturbing rather than merely well-timed. The First World War was not a war between Christianity and something else. It was Catholic France against Catholic Austria, Catholic Belgium against Catholic Bavaria, Irish Catholics in British uniforms shooting at Bavarian Catholics in German uniforms, both sides going to mass beforehand, both sides being told by their own bishops that God was
Starting point is 00:41:05 firmly on their team. Chaplains on opposing sides were praying to the same saints for opposite out. comes, which raises some genuinely awkward logistical questions about how that inbox gets sorted. Cathedrals across northern France were shelled into skeletons. The cathedral at Reyes, where French kings had been crowned for a thousand years, burned with its scaffolding on fire, and monasteries and seminaries all over Europe were converted into military hospitals, which is a noble use for a building, but does mean the trainee priests were now either in a ward or in a trench. That last part is the one people forget. France had passed laws separating church,
Starting point is 00:41:40 and state a decade earlier and had no interest in exempting clergy from conscription, so tens of thousands of French priests, monks and seminarians were called up as ordinary soldiers and stretcher-bearers. Thousands of them died. An entire generation of the French clergy was thinned out in the mud of the Western Front, and the seminaries that were supposed to replace them were being used as recovery wards for men with gas burns. Whatever you think of prophecy, the phrase religion laid waste is a fairly economical description of that situation. Benedict 15 spent the entire war trying to stop it and being ignored with remarkable consistency by everyone. He refused to condemn either side, which was theologically correct and politically catastrophic,
Starting point is 00:42:22 because both sides immediately decided that a Pope who would not denounce their enemy must secretly be working for their enemy. The French called him the German Pope. The Germans called him the French Pope. Nobody split the difference and called him neutral, because neutrality in 1916 was treated roughly the way it is treated on the internet today, which is to say as cowardice with better vocabulary. In 1917 he published a seven-point peace plan proposing no annexations, no reparations, disarmament,
Starting point is 00:42:52 arbitration of disputes and freedom of the seas, which reads today like a reasonable outline of the post-war order everybody wished they had built. At the time it was rejected by every single belligerent government, some of them politely and some of them not. He was then formally locked out of the peace conference that ended the war, thanks. to a clause in a secret treaty Italy had signed specifically to keep the Vatican out of any post-war settlement. So the head of the largest religious institution in Europe watched the continent get redrawn from the sidelines, with a written guarantee that his opinion would not be required. What he did instead was spend money. He poured Vatican funds into locating missing soldiers, exchanging lists of prisoners,
Starting point is 00:43:33 arranging for the seriously wounded to be repatriated, and getting information to families who had heard nothing for two years. Where some see heroes and others see egos. Bloomberg sees the era of billionaire athletes. A fad to some, the future of money to others. We see crypto's trillion-dollar swings. The end of jobs or the end of human struggle. We see the endless funds fueling the AI hype. While others follow the noise, we follow the money.
Starting point is 00:44:07 Learn more at Bloomberg.com. Visit BetMGM Casino and check out the newest exclusive. The Price is Right Fortune Pick. BetMDM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly. 19 plus to wager. Ontario only. Please play responsibly. If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you,
Starting point is 00:44:27 please contact connects Ontario at 1-866-531-2,600 to speak to an advisor, free of charge. BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with Eye Gaming Ontario. The office he set up handled hundreds of thousands of inquiries. By the end of it, the Vatican was so close to broke that when he died in 1922, it reportedly could not afford much of a funeral and had to borrow to fund the conclave that replaced him. He is one of the very few popes in history who effectively bankrupted the papacy on postal services and humanitarian aid, which is an unusual way to go out and, unsurprisingly, not one anybody has repeated. And while all this was happening in the West, the phrase was being fulfilled in a much more literal way in the East. The revolution in Russia in 1917 produced a state that did not simply reduce the influence of religion. It set out to remove it as a category. Church property was nationalised within a couple of months.
Starting point is 00:45:25 Religious instruction to anyone under 18 was banned. Monastries were closed and repurposed as barracks, warehouses and prisons. A campaign to seize church valuables during the famine of the early 1920s turned into open confrontation, and clergy who resisted were arrested, tried in public show trials, and shot. Over the following two decades, the numbers become genuinely hard to process. Tens of thousands of churches closed. Bishops, priests, monks and nuns, executed or sent to camps in numbers that ran into the tens of thousands. By the late 1930s, the Orthodox Church in the Soviet Union had gone from more than 50,000 functioning parishes to a few hundred, and a state
Starting point is 00:46:09 sponsored League of Militant Atheists was running a public campaign with the announced goal of eliminating religious belief entirely by the end of the second five-year plan. Depopulated is not a poetic flourish for that. It is an accounting term. So you can see why the motto did some heavy lifting for the believers. There is no shield to point at, no clever wordplay, nothing that reads as a lucky match with a surname. Two Latin words assigned centuries earlier to whoever happened to occupy position 109, and the man in position 109 turned out to be the Pope of the war that broke Europe, and the revolution that tried to abolish God on a schedule. But here is the thing that gets lost in the excitement, and it matters for everything that comes after. Relidio di Populata
Starting point is 00:46:54 was not the only text circulating in that era predicting the destruction of the church. It was not even the most alarming one. The early 20th century was absolutely saturated with visions of a pope fleeing a burning city, and once you notice how many of them there were, the whole picture starts to look different. Take the one attached to Pius X, the Pope elected in 1903, a man from a poor family in the Venetot who reportedly kept the porn tickets from his student days as a reminder. The story, which comes down through his associates rather than any document he wrote, places him in 1909 during an audience with a group of Franciscans. He is said to have gone quiet, sunk into what looked like a faint, and then come out of it with the colour gone from his face,
Starting point is 00:47:38 describing what he had just seen, a Pope. Not himself, he was careful to say, but one of his successors, leaving the Vatican in flight, and to get out this future Pope had to walk over the bodies of his own priests dead in his path. There is a second version of the same story from 1914, told shortly before his death that August, where he supposedly saw the same thing again and added a detail about the Pope having to leave Rome in disguise. Pius X died on the 20th of August 1914. Weeks into the war he had watched arriving and had failed to prevent, and the traditional account says the war itself is what killed him, which is not medically precise but is emotionally accurate enough that nobody has ever bothered to correct it. Whether he ever said any of it is a
Starting point is 00:48:22 genuinely open question. The account only really circulates in print decades later, in a period when this kind of material was in enormous demand, and the pattern where a private vision surfaces years after the visionary can be asked about it should be setting off a small alarm by now given everything else in this story. And then there is the one that is not a rumor at all because the document exists is in the Vatican and was published with the Pope's approval.
Starting point is 00:48:48 In 1917, while Benedict 15 was writing peace proposals nobody would read, three shepherd children in a field outside a village in central Portugal called Fatima reported seeing a woman in white above a small oak tree. The apparitions ran monthly from May to October. The crowds grew from a handful of relatives to tens of thousands of people standing in the rain in a field, and the whole thing culminated in October, with a mass event that the witnesses described
Starting point is 00:49:14 as the sun appearing to move erratically in the sky, an occurrence that was reported by secular newspaper journalists present, who had turned up specifically to mock the whole affair and came away noticeably less witty than they arrived. the children reported receiving three secrets. The first two were made public in the 1940s, and they were the sort of thing that got attention immediately, a vision of hell and a warning that a worse war would follow
Starting point is 00:49:39 if the world continued as it was, arriving under a light in the night sky, along with a statement about Russia specifically that people in 1917 found so bizarre they had a check that Russia was a country and not a woman's name. The third secret was written down in 1944 by the last surviving visionary, and none by then, sealed in an envelope with instructions that it should not be opened before 1960. And that is where it turned into one of the great
Starting point is 00:50:06 open sores of 20th century Catholicism, because 1960 came, the envelope was reportedly read by the Pope of the day, and nothing was released. No explanation, just silence, which unsurprisingly produced four decades of feverish speculation in which the third secret was variously claimed to predict nuclear war, the collapse of the church, the end of the world, and a conspiracy at the highest levels of the Vatican, with the intensity of the theory increasing in exact proportion to the absence of any information to test it against. It was finally published in the year 2000, and what was actually in the envelope was not a paragraph of doom. It was a picture. The text describes an angel with a flaming sword standing over the earth, the flames extinguished by a light, then a bishop dressed in
Starting point is 00:50:54 White, who the visionary says they had the impression was the Holy Father, walking through a half-ruined city, trembling, halting, praying for the souls of the dead he passes on the way. He climbs a steep mountain to a large rough cross at the top, and there, at the foot of the cross, soldiers fire, bullets and arrows at him, and he falls. And after him, in the same way, die the bishops, priests, monks and nuns who had climbed the mountain behind him, and other people of every rank and station, one after another until nobody is left. The official interpretation released alongside it connected the vision to the assassination attempt
Starting point is 00:51:31 on John Paul II in 1981, which happened on the 13th of May, the anniversary of the first apparition, and after which he had the bullet placed in the crown of the statue at Fatima, where it remains. The reading is that the prophecy showed a possible future, that the sword was averted, that the bishop in white fell but did not die.
Starting point is 00:51:51 Not everyone accepted that. A significant chunk of traditional Catholic opinion argued and still argues that the published text does not match the fevered anticipation, that the vision has no accompanying words from the Virgin when the first two secrets had plenty and that something was withheld. That argument is not settled and it is not going to be settled here. What matters for our purposes is much simpler and it is the pattern rather than the content. Line these things up. A motto from a medievalist saying religion is laid waste. a Pope collapsing in an audience and seeing his successor stepping over dead priests, three children in a Portuguese field watching a man in white walk through a dead city to be shot at the foot of a cross. Different sources, different centuries, different mechanisms of transmission, and the same image over and over again, the church destroyed, the Pope fleeing or falling, the city in ruins.
Starting point is 00:52:45 You can read that convergence two ways, and both are worth taking seriously. The first is that multiple independent channels, were picking up the same event, which is exactly the kind of corroboration that makes a prophecy look real. The second is that Europe between 1900 and 1950 was a place where the destruction of Christian civilization did not require any supernatural insight whatsoever. It was the obvious guess. The single, most reasonable prediction available. Empires that had defined themselves as Catholic for a thousand years were dissolving. Governments were seizing church property from Lisbon to Moscow. Anyone with a functioning pair of eyes could see the trajectory, and describing a pope walking
Starting point is 00:53:27 through a ruined city was less a vision of the future than a moderately observant summary of the present. Portugal itself had just been through a revolution that overthrew the monarchy, and launched an aggressively anti-clerical campaign, which meant that three children in 1917 lived in a country where priests being driven out was a current event, not a mystery. predicting catastrophe during a catastrophe is not clairvoyance. It is pattern recognition with better lighting, and that distinction is about to become the whole ballgame because the list did not just sit there being interpreted after the fact. Somewhere along the way, people started reading it before the fact, and then acting on it, and then trying to make it come true, which is where this stops being a story
Starting point is 00:54:09 about prophecy, and starts being a story about how prophecy gets used. You would expect the obvious institutional response here, a church with a functioning bureaucracy and a healthy suspicion of unauthorized mysticism, presented with an anonymous document claiming the papacy runs on a fixed timetable, should have investigated it, condemned it, and dropped it down the deepest whole available. That is what happened to a great many other pieces of freelance prophecy in that period, usually along with the person holding them. Instead, the Pope started wearing it. beginning in the 1600s and running through the 1700s, it became fashionable for a new Pope to have his motto from the list turned into decoration. Coronation medals were struck referencing the phrase.
Starting point is 00:54:53 Family coats of arms got quietly adjusted so the heraldry lined up more neatly with the words. Court poets wrote verses playing on it. If your motto mentioned mountains and stars, and your family arms happened to include hills and a star, you made absolutely sure that everybody noticed, and if the fit needed a little help, Well, heraldry has always had a generous amount of give in it. Take Alexander the 7th, elected in 1655, whose motto in the sequence is guardian of the mountains. His family the Chigi carried six small hills topped with a star on their shield, which they had been using long before anyone in the family was elected Pope. The alignment was free. He put that shield on everything he could reach
Starting point is 00:55:33 in Rome, and since he was the Pope who commissioned Beninini to build the great colonnade around the square in front of St. Peter's, that turned out to be a lot of surfaces. Walk around central Rome today, and you're essentially touring one man's very enthusiastic reaction to a Latin caption. Others were less lucky with their heraldry and improvised. A Pope drawing a motto about flowers might commission a medal featuring a garland. A Pope drawing something about a river might find that his birthplace had a river in it, which given the geography of Italy, is not a difficult condition to satisfy. The prophecy was supposed to be describing popes. Now the popes were reading it before the ceremony and dressing to match, which introduces a small logical problem. Once the target starts
Starting point is 00:56:16 helping the arrow, you can no longer tell how good the archer was. And nobody involved seemed remotely bothered by this, because the prophecy had stopped being a threat and become a compliment. Getting a motto meant you were on the list. Being on the list meant you were part of a divine sequence stretching back to the 12th century. It was flattering, it was decorative, and it cost nothing, right up until the moment it started influencing who got the job at all. Which brings us to the single, funniest thing that ever happened in a papal election, and it involves an American, a rented boat, and livestock. In October 1958, Pius X12th died after a 19-year reign covering the Second World War and its aftermath, and the Cardinals gathered in Rome to replace him.
Starting point is 00:57:01 Anyone with a copy of the list could see what was coming up next in the sequence, and this one was unusually easy to read. Pastor Etnauta, Shepard and Sailor. Enter Cardinal Francis Spelman, Archbishop of New York, a man of extraordinary energy and political skill who had built the American church into a financial powerhouse, was on first-name terms with presidents, and was widely understood to have views about his own suitability for higher office. He looked at that motto and made a decision that has entertained church historians ever since. He hired a boat, he loaded it with sheep, and he sailed up and down the tiber with them, just to be clear about what is happening here. A cardinal of the Roman Catholic Church, one of the most powerful clergymen in the world,
Starting point is 00:57:45 arranged for actual sheep to be transported onto an actual vessel and floated past the actual city of Rome, in the days before a conclave, so that a 900-year-old Latin phrase would have something to point at. This is the ecclesiastical equivalent of showing up to a job interview holding a prop because you heard the boss likes people who are good with their hands. It is a campaign advertisement and the target audience is a prophecy. It did not work. The Cardinals shut themselves in and, after 11 ballots, elected Angelo Roncali, the patriarch of Venice. And that is the joke, because Venice is a city built entirely on water
Starting point is 00:58:22 where the standard method of getting to work involves a boat and its patriarch had spoken. spent years being ferried around a lagoon as a matter of routine. Roncalli had also come from farming stock in Lombardy, one of 13 children in a family of sharecroppers. He took the name John 23 and immediately started talking about the church as a shepherd rather than a fortress, calling for it to be pastoral, to open the windows and let some air in, and then stunned everyone by summoning the council that reshaped Catholic life for the next century.
Starting point is 00:58:51 Shepherd and Sailor, delivered without a single sheep being rented. Now, defenders of the prophecy point at this and say, look, it worked. Skeptics point at exactly the same event and say, look, it worked on anybody, and the skeptics have the better of it, because think about what would have happened if Spelman had won. New York is a port. The Archbishop of a city with that harbour, who had crossed the Atlantic more times than most, who had spent the war visiting troops on ships across multiple oceans, and whose entire office is described in scripture using shepherd imagery,
Starting point is 00:59:23 would have been declared a flawless fulfilment within about ten minutes. Both candidates fit. Every candidate fits. Shepherd applies to every bishop who has ever lived, since it is the literal job description, and sailor applies to anyone who has ever been near water, which in a Mediterranean institution is all of them. That elasticity runs right through the modern entries, and once you see it, you cannot unsee it.
Starting point is 00:59:48 Paul Six draws flower of flowers, and his family arms carry three fleur-de-li, So the match is instant and clean. Fine. His successor draws from the half-moon and the interpreters go to work. John Paul I was born in the province of Belluno, which they cheerfully split into Bella Luna, beautiful moon. He was elected in late August 1978, when the moon happened to be in its first quarter. He died 33 days later, which they point out is roughly the span from one half-moon to the next. Three completely different mechanisms of interpretation, deployed simultaneously for one motto, geography, calendar, and duration.
Starting point is 01:00:28 If the target moves that freely you are not testing a prediction, you are curve-fitting. Then comes from the labour of the sun for John Paul II, and this one is genuinely the most impressive of the lot, so it deserves a fair hearing. He was born on the 18th of May, 1920, and there was a partial solar eclipse that day. His funeral, on the 8th of April 2005, coincided with an annular eclipse visible over parts of the Americas. two eclipses bracketing one life and a motto about the working of the sun. That is a hell of a coincidence, and it is the strongest single card the believers hold in the modern era. It is also worth knowing that solar eclipses happen between two and five times a year somewhere on Earth,
Starting point is 01:01:09 that partial ones are visible across enormous stretches of the planet, and that if you get to choose freely between the birth date, the election date, the death date, and the funeral date, you have four separate shots at hitting a window that opens several times annually. Impressive is not the same as impossible, and the honest position is that this one lands somewhere between striking coincidence and statistics doing what statistics do. So we have a document that generates hits when nobody is trying, generates hits when people are actively trying, and cannot be made to miss because the interpreters get to pick the meaning after the results are in, at which point the responsible question is not whether the motto's
Starting point is 01:01:46 fit. It is where this thing actually came from, and the answer is that scholars worked that out a very long time ago, and the evidence is not subtle. Start with a backstory, because the backstory is the part that unravels fastest. The dramatic version everybody knows, the night at the tomb, the images arriving one by one, the manuscript handed over and sealed in the archive, does not appear in the 1595 publication. One printed the list and said it had been lying unknown in the archive. That is roughly it. The full cinematic account of the vision assembles gradually over the following centuries, with the most familiar version taking its finished shape only in the 1800s, which means the origin's story of the prophecy is younger than the printing press by a comfortable
Starting point is 01:02:33 margin and younger than the United States. Worse, the one person on earth who should have mentioned it did not. As covered earlier, Bernard of Claervo wrote the biography of his friend, and it is not a modest document. It records healings. It records a man raised from the dead. It records Maliki correctly predicting deaths, including his own, in detail, with dates. Bernard is not shy about miracles. He is practically running a promotional campaign, and in a text specifically designed to demonstrate that this Irishman had genuine prophetic gifts, there is not one word about a vision containing the complete sequence of every future Pope through to the end of the world, that is not an argument from silence. That is an argument from a man who wrote down everything else, was physically present
Starting point is 01:03:18 for the years in question, and would have led with it. If your friend correctly predicted his own death, and you thought that was the headline, and he had actually also mapped out 900 years of church leadership, you did not simply forget to mention it, nor did anyone else. Not the papal chroniclers who logged every relic and rumour in Europe. Not the people. canonization documents when Maliki was declared a saint. Not one manuscript copy of the list has ever been produced from before 1590. Not a fragment, not a citation, not a marginal note. Four and a half centuries of nothing, and then the complete text, fully formed in the middle of a conclave. Second problem. The quality of the matches falls off a cliff at a very specific point,
Starting point is 01:04:02 and it is the same point where the document enters public circulation. Everything before 1590 is surgical. Names, hometowns, family emblems, cardinal titles, converted into Latin with almost mechanical literalism. Everything after 1590 goes soft, insatiable beast, dog and serpent, delight of the cross, rake in the door, these not descriptions of anything. They are the sort of phrases that could be attached to any human being who ever lived, and they arrive in the sequence at exactly the moment the compiler's knowledge of history stopped, because his knowledge of history stopped. Because his knowledge of history stopped at the present day, which for him was the 1590s. A genuine vision has no reason to be crisp for 400 years and then get vague for the next 400. A forger has every reason, because a
Starting point is 01:04:50 forger can only research the past. The precision curve of this document is a perfect fingerprint of the year it was written, and then there is the third piece of evidence, which is the one that closes the case, because it is not about vagueness or silence. It is about a mistake. In 1556, an Augustinian scholar named Onofrio Panvino published a compact history of the popes, a reference work summarizing lives, families, origins and reins. It was widely used and widely copied, and like every reference work ever compiled by a human being on a deadline, it contained errors, not many, a handful, but specific, identifiable, traceable errors that belong to Panvino and to nobody else.
Starting point is 01:05:34 One of them concerns John II, the Pope who ran the first. the church from Avignon in the 14th century. Panvino recorded that his father was a shoemaker. The man's family was in fact prosperous and connected to banking and commerce in Cahors, and calling him the son of a cobbler was simply wrong, an error of the kind that creeps into a summary when someone is condensing a lot of material quickly. The prophecy assigns John II the motto about a cobbler. Not a similar theme, not a metaphor about humble origins. It reproduces Panvino's specific factual mistake, and it does the same. thing at several other points, following the same book's errors and the same book's editorial
Starting point is 01:06:12 choices. It also includes anti-papal claimants in exactly the way Panvino's edition handled them, which is a decision no 12th century Irish bishop would have any reason to replicate, and which no divine vision has any business getting wrong. Put simply, the prophecy is not describing history, it is describing one printed book about history, including that book's typos, which means the earliest it could possibly have been written is 1557, and given that it's surfaced in the autumn of 1590 with the mottoes running out at precisely the Pope who had just died, the window narrows to roughly the width of a doorway. So who did it, and why? The most persuasive answer points straight at that chaotic election. Look at what comes next in the sequence,
Starting point is 01:06:55 right after the 12-day Pope, ex-antiquitate urbis, from the antiquity of the city, or read slightly differently from the old city. Now consider that one of the candidates in that conclave was Cardinal Girolamo Simoncelli, who had been governor and effectively the leading figure of a town in Umbria called Orvieto, and Orvieto derives its name from the Latin Urbs Vetus, Old City. That is not a nickname or a poetic association. It is the town's actual etymology, known to every educated person in Italy. So the document lands in the middle of a leaderless conclave,
Starting point is 01:07:29 carrying 450 years of flawless verified accuracy, and then points, with its very first unfulfilled prediction at one specific living man in the room. It is the most sophisticated campaign advertisement of the 16th century. It does not say vote for Simmicelli. It says the Holy Spirit filed this paperwork in 1139, and you are simply here to counter-sign it. The likely mechanics are grubby and completely ordinary. Somebody in his circle, or somebody hired by somebody in his circle, took a copy of Panvino, worked backwards through the popes assigning each one a short Latin tag drawn from his arms or his birthplace, added a plausible number of future entries running forward to an apocalyptic conclusion, so the thing would look like a complete revelation
Starting point is 01:08:13 rather than a targeted advert, and let it circulate at the right moment. Then, presumably, went to bed feeling extremely clever, and it failed, completely. Simoncelli did not get elected, in that conclave or the several that followed in quick succession, and he died a few years later having never worn the ring. The forgery was a total operational flop. The interpreters naturally did not let a small thing like that stand in the way. Gregory 14, who actually won, was declared to fit from the antiquity of the city
Starting point is 01:08:44 on the basis that his father had been a senator of ancient Rome, which is a stretch you could use to tow a truck since Rome had senators in the 16th century, and the word ancient is doing the work of an entire legal team in that sentence. The church itself, once the excitement died down, mostly agreed with the skeptics. A French Jesuit named Claude Francois Ministriere published a thorough demolition in 1689 that laid out most of the argument you have just heard, and the prophecy has been treated as apocryphal by serious Catholic scholarship ever since. It has never been formally endorsed,
Starting point is 01:09:20 it has never been formally condemned either, mainly because condemning it would be free publicity, and the Vatican learned a long time ago that the fastest way to make people read something is to tell them not to. So that ought to be the end of it. A 16th century election stunt exposed within a century, historically documented down to the source book
Starting point is 01:09:38 and the beneficiary, still floating around because a good story has better survival characteristics than a good refutation. Except, the mottoes kept landing, and in 2013, the list ran out. On the morning of the 11th of, February 2013, Benedict XVI sat in front of a small gathering of cardinals to handle three routine
Starting point is 01:10:01 canonisation decrees, which is the papal equivalent of approving the minutes of the last meeting. Then he kept talking, in Latin, and the room did not react, because most of the people in it were not following closely, and Latin at speed after a long agenda is a challenge for anybody. One person in the building understood immediately. An Italian news agency reporter named Giovanna Chiri was watching, the feed, had studied Latin properly, and heard the Pope calmly announced that his strength had deteriorated and that he was renouncing the office. She sat there for several minutes doing the single most terrifying calculation in journalism, which is deciding whether you have just heard
Starting point is 01:10:39 the biggest story of your life or completely misunderstood a grammar construction and are about to end your career. She checked with a Vatican official, got a confirmation that amounted to a stunned yes, and filed. Within minutes, the entire plan of the a planet knew that the Pope had quit. Popes do not quit. That is essentially the defining feature of the job. The last one to resign under anything like normal conditions had done it in 1294, and he was promptly locked up by his successor for the remainder of his life
Starting point is 01:11:10 to prevent anyone getting ideas. There had been a technical resignation in 1415, but that was to end a mess in which three men were simultaneously claiming to be Pope, and it was lesser resignation than a negotiated clean-up. So for practical purposes this had not happened in 600 years, and every living Catholic had grown up with the assumption never really examined that this was a lifetime appointment enforced by biology. That evening a thunderstorm rolled over Rome and lightning struck the dome of St Peter's, twice. A photographer working for a news agency had gone up to a rooftop with a tripod specifically, because he thought a storm over the basilica would make a nice picture on a big newsday, waited about two hours in the rain, and caught the strike. The image went around the world within hours and has never really left, because it is a genuinely
Starting point is 01:11:59 spectacular photograph, and because it looks exactly like the kind of thing a screenwriter would be told to cut for being too on the nose. Meteorologically, it is unremarkable. The dome is the highest point in the area, it has been hit many times, and if you leave a camera pointed at the tallest object in a thunderstorm, you will eventually get your shot. Symbolically it was a gift, and the internet unwrapped it with both hands. officially emptied at 8 in the evening on the 28th of February, a date chosen for administrative where some see heroes and others see egos. Bloomberg sees the era of billionaire athletes. A fad to some, the future of money to others. We see crypto's trillion-dollar swings. The end of jobs
Starting point is 01:12:45 or the end of human struggle. We see the endless funds fueling the AI hype. While others follow the noise. We follow the money. Learn more at Bloomberg.com. Visit betmgmgm casino and check out the newest exclusive. The price is right fortune pick.
Starting point is 01:13:06 BetMGM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly. 19 plus to wager. Ontario only. Please play responsibly. If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, please contact Connects Ontario at 1866-531-2,600 to speak to an advisor.
Starting point is 01:13:22 charge. That MDM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with Eye Gaming, Ontario. Convenience, which happens to fall on the feast day of St. Romanus. And that detail matters for what everyone was about to start doing, because a great many people were now sitting with the same document open in front of them, counting. Benedict's motto in the sequence was Glory of the Olive, which had been read as a nod to the Benedictine tradition and its Olive Branch symbolism, or as a reference to peace. or as anything else you needed it to be. And after that motto, there is no hundred and thirteenth entry. What there is instead is a closing paragraph, and the closing paragraph is the reason we are all here. It says that in the final persecution of the Holy Roman Church there will sit Peter the Roman,
Starting point is 01:14:08 who will pasture his sheep amid many tribulations, and when these are finished, the city of seven hills will be destroyed, and the fearsome judge will judge his people, the end. That is it. That is the entire remaining runway. One more man, described as Peter and described as Roman, a period of suffering, and then Rome is finished and the accounting begins. So in early March 2013, the world's press did something it had never done before and has not really done since. It handicapped a papal election using a medieval prophecy. Bookmakers were taking money. The clear favourite in the prophecy market was Cardinal Peter Turkson of Ghana, who was a genuine contender on the actual merits, who ran a major and who had the enormous advantage of being named Peter. Cardinal Peter Erdo of Hungary got
Starting point is 01:14:56 attention for identical reasons. Half the coverage of the most secretive election on earth had quietly turned into a name check. And on the 13th of March, the balcony doors opened and outcame Jorge Mario Bagolio of Buenos Aires, the first Jesuit, the first Pope from the Americas, the first from the southern hemisphere in more than a thousand years, and he took the name Francis. No Peter, anywhere. Not in his birth name, not in his chosen name, not in his father's name, not in his diocese. You would think that would settle it. The list had made exactly one specific, checkable, falsifiable claim about the future, which is the last one it would ever get to make, and it named a man called Peter, and the man who walked out was called Francis and was from a country roughly
Starting point is 01:15:43 7,000 miles from Rome. The reaction took approximately four hours. The argument assembled in real time, and it went like this. The saint he named himself after, Francis of Assisi, was baptized Giovanni, and it was his father who called him Francesco, and that father's name was Pietro di Bernardone, Peter. So the new Pope is Peter by inheritance from the saint he chose, which is a chain of custody with more links than a bicycle. And for the Roman half, Bogleio's parents were Italian immigrants from Piedmont,
Starting point is 01:16:14 his father having sailed to Argentina in the late 1920s, which makes him Italian by blood, which makes him Roman, in the sense that Italy contains Rome. So the prediction of a Roman named Peter was fulfilled by an Argentine named Francis on the grounds that a different man from the 13th century had a dad with the right name and that his own grandparents came from a country the prophecy did not mention. If you had proposed that reading in advance, in writing before the conclave, you would have been laughed out of the room. Proposed afterwards, it was accepted almost instantly by a very very very very,
Starting point is 01:16:47 large number of people, and that is the entire history of this document in a single afternoon. To be fair to the believers, the tribulations part did not require any creative accounting at all. In March 2020, a virus shut down the planet and Catholic churches closed on a scale that had not happened in the entire history of the institution. Not during plague, not during war, not during revolution. Mass was suspended across whole countries. Easter was celebrated to empty buildings. Priests gave absolution through car windows and administered last rights in protective suits, and in some places the dying were anointed with a cotton bud on the end of a stick, which is either a beautiful adaptation of ancient practice to modern hazard, or the single,
Starting point is 01:17:31 strangest sentence in 2000 years of sacramental theology, depending on your mood. And on the 27th of March 2020, the image everybody remembers, St. Peter's Square, completely empty, in the rain, at night, wet stone reflecting the lights, and one elderly man in white walking alone across it with a limp, up the steps, to pray in front of an empty piazza and a global television audience of tens of millions. He gave the blessing normally reserved for Christmas and Easter to nobody physically present. If you had spent the previous seven years arguing that the closing paragraph described a pope, pasturing his sheep amid many tribulations, that broadcast did not require any interpretation whatsoever. It just needed a screenshot. Then came the rest of it. A full-scale war
Starting point is 01:18:19 returned to Europe in 2022, with two nations of overwhelmingly Christian populations shelling each other, and a Pope spending three years making appeals that the belligerents received with the same enthusiasm his predecessors had enjoyed in 1917. Church attacks and killings escalated sharply across parts of Africa and Asia, with Nigeria in particular seeing congregations attacked, and buildings burned in numbers that most Western coverage never really got around to. The abuse crisis kept unfolding, country by country, with national inquiries producing reports whose numbers were somehow always worse than the previous report. And inside the Vatican itself, the finances detonated. A London property deal went spectacularly
Starting point is 01:19:02 wrong, hundreds of millions of church money evaporated, and the resulting investigation ended with a cardinal standing trial in a Vatican criminal court, the first time. that had ever happened. He was convicted in late 2023 and sentenced to prison. The trial ran for over two years, involved allegations of everything from embezzlement to money being wired, to a self-described security consultant for a hostage rescue that seems to have generated a great many luxury purchases and no hostage, and the whole affair read less like a church scandal than like a script somebody rejected for being implausible. Many tribulations indeed, Whether that is prophecy or simply what a 13-year period looks like when you write down
Starting point is 01:19:44 everything bad that happened in it is a question we will get to because it is the question. Francis appeared in public for the last time on Easter Sunday 2025, frail, barely able to speak, having survived a long hospitalisation earlier that year that at one point genuinely looked like it would be the end. He went out onto the balcony, gave the blessing, and rode through the square in the open vehicle to greet the crowd, which is doctors. had almost certainly not recommended. He died the next morning, the 21st of April 2025 at the age of 88. And then he did one last thing that broke a pattern, which by then was his established practice.
Starting point is 01:20:22 Popes get buried in the Vatican, underneath the basilica, in the grottos, near the tomb where this entire story allegedly began. That has been the default for well over a century and the overwhelming norm for far longer. Francis had left instructions that he was to be buried instead at Santa Maria Maggiore, one of the great basilicas of Rome but nowhere near Vatican territory, in a simple tomb of undecorated stone with nothing on it but his name in Latin. He wanted it there because of an icon of the Virgin kept in that church, in front of which he had prayed before and after every single foreign trip of his papacy, more than a hundred visits in 12 years. No Pope had been buried outside the Vatican in over a hundred years, so the last man on the list,
Starting point is 01:21:06 the one whose reign was supposed to end with the seven hills in flames, was carried across Rome and laid to rest in a church he had chosen personally, in a plain tomb, in a building that already contained somebody else, because Santa Maria Maggiore is also where they buried Sixtus the Fifth. The Pope who rebuilt Rome, whose death set off that whole cascade of 12-day-and-10-month papacies, and whose motto sits in the middle of the list carrying a phrase that nobody paid much attention to for 400 years, an axle in the middle of the sign. Two popes under one roof, four centuries apart, and one of them is holding the countdown. Which brings us back to the balcony, and to the man who was not supposed to be standing on it. The conclave that followed lasted barely
Starting point is 01:21:49 a day and a half. Four ballots, 133 cardinals, the largest and most international electorate in history, thanks to 12 years of appointments that had deliberately scattered red hats to places that had never seen one. Most of these men had never met each other before the meetings that preceded the vote, which in any other organisation would guarantee a deadlock lasting until the catering ran out. They were done by Thursday evening. Robert Francis Prevost was born in Chicago in 1955, grew up in a suburb on the south side, and by his own account was serving at the altar before he was old enough to be much use at it. He joined the Order of St. Augustine, studied mathematics as an undergraduate, then canon law in Rome, and in 1985 went to
Starting point is 01:22:32 to Peru, which is where the actual shape of his life happened. He spent most of the next two decades there, running a seminary, teaching canon law, working as a judge in a regional church court, and serving in parishes in the north of the country during a period when the region was dealing with an insurgency and the routine hazards of the terrain. He became a Peruvian citizen. He was elected head of the entire Augustinian order worldwide and spent 12 years in that job, which mostly consists of flying to places where your monks are having a difficult time and finding out why. In 2015 he was made Bishop of Chiclayo, a hot, dusty, unglamorous diocese on the Peruvian coast. He was there through floods, through the pandemic, through a stretch when the local
Starting point is 01:23:15 health system essentially collapsed and he was helping organise oxygen supplies, which is not typically covered in the Bishop training manual. Only in 2023 was he brought to Rome to run the office that vets and appoints bishops for the entire world, which is one of the most quietly powerful positions in the church because it decides who gets promoted everywhere. So the first pope from the United States is a man who spent almost his entire working life outside the United States. In a country most Americans would struggle to place within 500 miles on a map, doing exactly the kind of unfotogenic parish work that does not make you famous. Whatever else the Cardinals were doing in that conclave, they did not pick a celebrity. He explained his chosen name himself, and the explanation is
Starting point is 01:23:59 refreshingly boring. He pointed to Leo 13, the comet on the shield from earlier in this story, whose great achievement was a document written in 1891, addressing what industrialization had done to working people, wages, hours, unions, and the dignity of labor. That document is generally treated as the foundation of modern Catholic social teaching. And the new Pope said, in effect, that another industrial revolution is happening right now, driven by artificial intelligence, and that the church needs to have something to say about what it does to human work and human worth before it is finished happening rather than 50 years afterwards. Perfectly coherent, entirely defensible and a real signal about his priorities. Nobody in the prophecy community cared about
Starting point is 01:24:45 a single word of that, obviously, because they were busy with his family tree. The genealogist went to work within hours, which is now a standard feature of any papal election, and the results were a mess in the best possible way. His mother's side traced back to New Orleans, to Creole families of mixed heritage documented in Louisiana records going back generations, a finding that surprised his own relatives and produced a genuinely lovely piece of American social history entirely by accident. His father's side ran to French and Italian roots, and then came the claim that lit up the corners of the internet where this sort of thing lives, which is that his paternal grandfather had come from Sicily, from a town on the north coast.
Starting point is 01:25:26 and had changed the family surname on arriving in America, the way an enormous number of immigrants did for reasons ranging from clerical convenience at the port to a reasonable desire to be hired. That claim rests on family research and record-digging rather than anything official, and immigration documents from that era are notoriously slippery, so treat it as reported rather than established. But you can see immediately why it detonated, because the closing paragraph promises a Roman, and here, for the second election running was a pope from the far side of the world with Italian blood one or two generations back and a surname that may not even be the original one. The Francis reading needed a saint's father
Starting point is 01:26:06 from the 13th century to make the connection. This one just needs a passenger manifest. By the standards of this document that counts as a dramatic improvement in evidentiary quality. But the genealogy is a sideshow, and honestly it is the least interesting thing that came out of 2025, because somewhere in the middle of all this, people went back and looked at the actual Latin. Not the translation everybody quotes. The text as it was printed in 1595, and the closing passage does not say what everyone thinks it says. The way it is universally read and the way I laid it out earlier is one continuous sentence. In the final persecution of the Holy Roman Church there will sit Peter the Roman, who will pasture his sheep amid many tribulations, one Pope named Peter.
Starting point is 01:26:51 sitting during the final persecution. That is the version in every book, every documentary, every thumbnail. In the earliest printing, there is a full stop after the verb. The sentence ends at there will sit. Then Peter the Roman begins a new sentence, and in the layout of the original it begins a new block of text entirely. Read it that way, and the whole thing comes apart in the most interesting possible manner. The first sentence says that during the final persecution of the church someone will sit on the throne. It does not name him. It does not say how long. long he sits, and it does not say he is alone. Then, separately the text says that Peter the Roman will pasture his sheep amid many tribulations, and after those tribulations the city of seven hills
Starting point is 01:27:33 will fall. Two statements, not one. And crucially, nothing at all in the text says they happen at the same time or that the same man is the subject of both. The fusion of those two passages into a single sentence is generally traced to a 1624 edition, published in Paris by an Irish priest named Thomas Messingham, who was running the Irish college there and put together a large collection of the lives of Irish saints. Maliki was Irish, so in he went, prophecy and all. Somewhere in the process of setting that text, the paragraph break disappeared and the punctuation shifted, and every subsequent edition copied the new version, because that is how printing worked. You did not go back to a manuscript in an archive that you had never seen. You reset the
Starting point is 01:28:15 last printed edition and fixed the obvious typos, and an invisible missing-fitting-fixing. And an invisible missing full stop is not an obvious typo. So a compositor in Paris 400 years ago, working with hot metal type and a deadline, may have accidentally welded together two separate predictions and created the doomsday countdown that has terrified people ever since, which, if true, is the single greatest editorial error in the history of publishing and comfortably beats every misprinted Bible ever produced, and there have been some spectacular ones. The consequences of unwelting it are enormous. If the last motto on the list marks the beginning of the final persecution, rather than the arrival of the final pope, then the list has not run out. It has reached the start of a period,
Starting point is 01:28:58 and that period can contain as many popes as it likes, because the text never specifies a number. There could be one more, there could be 20. Peter the Roman arrives whenever he arrives, and the mottoes simply stop being issued before he does. And once you accept that, a second problem surfaces that has been sitting there the whole time in plain sight. The list was never numbered. That famous count, 112, is not in the document. The motos were printed as a continuous sequence with commentary, and the numbering was added later by editors who wanted to make the thing readable in exactly the way modern editions add verse numbers to texts that never had them. So the number everyone treats as sacred, the number that makes the countdown feel mathematically inevitable,
Starting point is 01:29:43 is an editorial convenience from a printing house. Worse, the sequence includes anti-papal claimants. It has to, because the source it was assembled from, included them, and the compiler was working from a printed history rather than any official register. So the list contains men who, in the church's own reckoning, were never popes at all, but who each got a motto because they were in the book, which means the alignment between motto number and pope number was never reliable in the first place. It has been drifting since 1595 and nobody a judge.
Starting point is 01:30:13 adjusted for it, because for four centuries the drift did not matter. It only starts mattering when you get near the end, and the exact position becomes the whole argument. Where some see heroes and others see egos. Bloomberg sees the era of billionaire athletes. A fad to some, the future of money to others. We see crypto's trillion-dollar swings. The end of jobs, or the end of human struggle. We see the endless funds fueling the AI hype. While others follow the noise, we follow the money. Learn more at Bloomberg.com. Visit BetMGM Casino and check out the newest exclusive. The Price is Right Fortune Pick.
Starting point is 01:30:59 BetMDM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly. 19 plus to wager. Ontario only. Please play responsibly. If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, Peace contact connects Ontario at 1-866-531-2600 to speak to an advisor. Free of charge. BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with Eye Gaming Ontario. In 2021, a German historian went through the sequence and did the recount, stripping out claimants who were not legitimate popes and realigning the mottoes accordingly. The conclusion that came out the other end is that the list does not end where everyone thought.
Starting point is 01:31:38 On that reading, after the current pope, there are still two more. to come, two more popes, which is either a genuine correction of a 400-year-old bookkeeping error, or the most convenient piece of arithmetic imaginable, arriving at precisely the moment when the alternative would be admitting the prophecy failed. And this is where I have to be straight with you, because it is the crux of everything. Every single one of these fixes solves a problem, and every single one of them makes the prophecy weaker, not stronger, weaker. Look at what has actually happened over four centuries. The mottoes are precise and the Forger's knowledge runs out, then they go vague.
Starting point is 01:32:13 When a motto fails to describe a Pope, the interpreters make it describe his enemy instead. When the list runs out and Rome does not burn, the punctuation gets revised so the deadline moves. When the count comes up wrong, the count is corrected. When the promised Peter does not appear, the family tree gets searched until a Peter is located somewhere in the branches. That is not a prediction being refined.
Starting point is 01:32:37 That is a prediction being immunized. A claim that can absorb any outcome without ever being wrong is not telling you anything about the future, because a statement that forbids nothing predicts nothing. If the list had ended and Rome had burned, that would have been proof. It ended. Rome did not burn, and that is also proof because of a comma. There is no result this document could have produced that would have caused its supporters to put it down, and yet. The punctuation thing is real.
Starting point is 01:33:06 That full stop is genuinely there in the case. the earliest printing, and the fusion genuinely does appear to be a later editorial artifact, and that is a legitimate textual observation that would be interesting even if nobody believed a word of the prophecy. It is a real discovery about a fake document, which is a strange category of fact and one I am rather fond of. More to the point, the split reading does something the traditional reading never could. It frees the prophecy from having to be about counting popes at all, and the moment you stop counting popes, somebody is going to start counting something else. somebody did, and what they found sitting in the middle of the list is not a name,
Starting point is 01:33:43 or a shield, or a hometown. It is a mechanical part, a heraldic lion, and a number that lands about 18 months from now. The motto that started all of this sits at position 73, roughly two-thirds of the way down the page, and for 400 years absolutely nobody looked at it twice. Axis in Mediaticigne, an axle in the middle of the sign. It belongs to Felice Peretti, elected in 1585 as 6thus the 5th, and by the standards of this list it is a completely unremarkable entry. He was a swineherd son from the marches who became a Franciscan, then an inquisitor, then a cardinal, and then, in five ferocious years as Pope, did more to the physical city of Rome than anyone since the emperors. He drove new streets straight through the medieval tangle, so pilgrims could get between the major basilicas
Starting point is 01:34:32 without needing a guide and a weapon. He put an ancient Egyptian obelisk in the square in front of of St. Peter's, an engineering operation involving hundreds of men, dozens of horses and an enormous winch system, during which he reportedly ordered total silence from the crowd under pain of death, so the engineer could hear his own instructions. He finished the dome, he rebuilt the aqueduct. He also executed bandits with such enthusiasm that contemporaries claimed there were more heads on spikes along the bridges than melons in the market, which is a comparison that tells you a great deal about both the crime rate and the produce section. His family shield carries a lion, holding a branch of pears, because his surname is Peretti, and Italian heraldry
Starting point is 01:35:14 has never seen a pun it would not commit to permanently. And running across that shield is a band, a diagonal stripe, cutting the field in half. In Latin, a beam or a plank or an axle is an axis. In heraldry, the shield is the sign. So the motto is, once again, somebody reading a coat of arms and writing down what is on it, a bar across the middle of the shield, that is the traditional reading it fits the pattern of the entire medieval section, and it is almost certainly what the compiler meant, almost certainly is doing some work in that sentence, which is why we are here. Because if you refuse to read it as heraldry, and read it instead as an instruction, the word in the middle stops describing a shield and starts describing a position in time.
Starting point is 01:35:59 And if this motto is the midpoint of something, then you can measure from it in both directions. so people did. The first entry on the list, as covered, points to a Pope elected in 1143. 6th the 5th was elected in 1585. Subtract one from the other and you get 442 years. Take that same span and lay it forward from 1585 and you land on 2027. That is the whole calculation. There is no hidden step, no numerology, no geometria, no converting letters into numbers and dividing by the height of a It is one subtraction and one addition, and it produces a year that is not centuries away or safely abstract, but close enough that you could book a flight for it. And in a genre normally cluttered with elaborate arithmetic designed to hit a predetermined answer, the simplicity is genuinely
Starting point is 01:36:49 what makes it persuasive. It looks less like a calculation, and more like reading a measurement off a ruler. Then the supporting evidence started arriving, and this is where it gets uncomfortable, the lion, sitting on the shield of the man whose motto anchors the midpoint is a lion, and in 2025, for the first time in more than a century, the church elected a pope who took the name Leo, not chosen for that reason, chosen, as he explained, for reasons involving labour and technology, and a document from 1891. But the coincidence sits there regardless, and the people who assemble these patterns did not have to work hard to spot it. An axle across a lion in the middle of the list, and a Leo arriving at the moment the countdown is supposed to be running,
Starting point is 01:37:33 and then there is the sky. On the 2nd of August 2027, there will be a total solar eclipse, and it is not an ordinary one. Astronomers have been circling this date for decades because the duration is extraordinary. Totality will last up to six minutes and 23 seconds, which is close to the theoretical maximum, and it is the longest totality visible from land anywhere on Earth between 1991 and 2114. Most total eclipses give you two or three minutes if you are lucky and standing in exactly the right field. This one gives you more than six, and it does it over a path where the weather in early August is about as reliably cloudless as anywhere on the planet. The reason it lasts so long is genuinely elegant physics rather than anything mystical. The moon will be near its
Starting point is 01:38:20 closest approach to Earth, so it appears larger. The Earth will be near its farthest point from the sun, so the sun appears smaller, and the shadow will be crossing near the equator, in the same direction the earth is rotating, so the ground is effectively running alongside the shadow rather than through it, stretching the whole thing out. Big moon, small sun, and the planet politely keeping pace. The path of that shadow is the part that made everyone lose their minds. It comes in across the Atlantic, crosses southern Spain, passes over the strait, sweeps along the North African coast through Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia and Libya. then straight across Egypt, over Luxor and the Valley of the Kings, before continuing into the
Starting point is 01:39:01 Red Sea and beyond. Look at that route on a map and you're looking at a tour of the Roman Mediterranean, the Spanish provinces that produced emperors, the African coast where Carthage stood, Egypt, the grain supply that fed the city for centuries. The shadow of the moon will spend six minutes crossing the exact territory that made Rome a superpower, on a date that a piece of medieval arithmetic points at in the reign of a pope named after a lion. If you wanted a scene for the opening of a film, you could not order a better one. So let us take it apart because it does not survive contact. Start with the middle, since the entire calculation depends on it. The claim is that 6-5 marks the midpoint of the list. He does not. He's number 73 out of 112. The middle of 112 item
Starting point is 01:39:45 list is position 56, which falls in the middle of the 15th century, 130 years earlier, and a completely different Pope. Seventy-three out of 112 is not a midpoint, it is not close to a mid-point, and no arrangement of the numbers makes it one. You are two-thirds of the way through the list, standing in a spot with no structural significance whatsoever, declaring at the centre. And it is worse than that, because as established, the numbering is not part of the original document. So the entire theory rests on treating an editor's numbering as divinely authoritative in order to identify a midpoint, while simultaneously relying on arguments elsewhere that the numbering is unreliable and should be recounted. You cannot have both. Either the count is meaningful,
Starting point is 01:40:32 in which case the list ended and Rome should have burned in 2013, or the count is an artifact, in which case there is no midpoint to find. Next, the word itself. The Latin term in that motto for the middle turns up elsewhere in this same document, in the entry about the half-moon, where it unambiguous, means a physical half of a visible object and has nothing to do with chronology at all. When a text uses a word one way in one place, and you need it to mean something entirely different in another place to make your theory work, that is not interpretation. That is a hostage situation. And the heraldry explanation for this motto is not merely available. It is the boring, obvious, consistent one that fits every neighbouring entry in the sequence.
Starting point is 01:41:16 The compiler was going through a reference book converting shields into three-word Latin captions. That is what he did to the sieve, to the comet, to the bull, to the mountains. There is no reason to believe he suddenly stopped doing that for one entry, encoded a chronological cipher pointing 442 years into his own future, and then went straight back to describing shields for the next 39 popes. Nobody hides one riddle in the middle of a filing job. The lion does not help either, once you look at it. at how the numbers actually work.
Starting point is 01:41:48 Leo is one of the most used papal names in history, with 14 holders. Lions appear on an enormous proportion of European coats of arms, to the point where finding a noble family without one is more remarkable than finding one with. Given a list of 112 mottoes drawn from Italian heraldry, the odds of at least one of them containing a lion approach certainty, and the odds of the church eventually producing another Leo were always high. Pointing at the intersection of two extremely common things and calling it a signal is like noticing that a man named Smith once worked with metal.
Starting point is 01:42:21 As for the eclipse, here is the thing nobody mentions. There are between two and five solar eclipses every single year. Total ones happen somewhere on Earth roughly every 18 months. And the Roman world, the target the shadow supposedly confirms, covered the entire Mediterranean basin, all of North Africa, Spain, France, Britain, the Balkans, Turkey and the Levant. That is a target area of several million square kilometres spanning three continents. Any eclipse track that crosses anything between Scotland and Sudan can be described as passing over the old empire.
Starting point is 01:42:54 It would be genuinely more difficult to find an eclipse that misses. The 2007 eclipse is a magnificent event and if you can get to that path you absolutely should, because six minutes of totality is a once-in-several lifetimes experience and people who have seen one tend to reorganise their holidays around chasing the next. But it was scheduled by orbital mechanics roughly four and a half billion years ago, and it will happen with the same indifference whether Rome stands, falls, or opens a branch office. So the countdown does not work. The midpoint is not a midpoint.
Starting point is 01:43:26 The word does not mean what it needs to mean. The shield explains the motto perfectly well without any help. The lion is heraldic wallpaper and the eclipse is a Tuesday. Which leaves the question that has been sitting underneath this entire story since a manuscript conveniently appeared in a locked conclave 435 years ago. Why do we want the date so badly? Because we do. That is the consistent finding across the whole history of this thing.
Starting point is 01:43:52 Every generation that has picked up this list has gone looking for the end in its own lifetime, and every generation has found it, and every generation has been wrong. People expected the world to close out at the year 1000. They expected it in 1666 because of the number and because London was on fire. Thousands of Americans sold their farms and waited on hillsides for a date in 1844 that came and went with nothing but a sunset. People stockpiled water for the year 2000. People bought books about a Mayan calendar in 2012 that turned out to work approximately like an odometer. Not one of these was a fringe phenomenon. Each one was mainstream, each one had respectable people involved, and each one dissolved the morning after and was replaced within a decade. The pattern is too consistent to be about evidence.
Starting point is 01:44:41 It is about what a deadline does to us. An announced ending makes life legible. It converts an incomprehensible, open-ended statistically in different universe into a story with an act structure, which is a format the human brain finds enormously easier to hold. It says the mess means something, that we are living in the important part, that the confusion and noise of our particular decade
Starting point is 01:45:03 is not just confusion and noise, but the run-up to something. Being alive at the end is, in a strange way, deeply flattering. It means you are not born into the boring middle, and it removes the hardest thing about being a person, which is not knowing. A specified date is frightening, but it is finite, and human beings will take a terrifying certainty over an open question almost every time. Ask anyone who has ever preferred bad news to waiting for results.
Starting point is 01:45:32 What is genuinely striking is that the most convincing figure in this entire story wanted none of that. The Irish Archbishop, whose name got stapled to this document, almost certainly never saw a single one of these motos. What he actually did was spent his life on unglomerous work in a difficult country, fight a war he never wanted for an office he gave away the moment he won it, and then walk away to rebuild churches in a small poor diocese where nobody would write about him. He predicted exactly one date, his own, and used it to plan a journey rather than to frighten anybody. Then he died on schedule in a friend's abbey
Starting point is 01:46:08 and let somebody else worry about the future. The document that carries his name was probably assembled by an anonymous operator with a copy of a history book, a decent grasp of heraldry and a candidate to promote. It failed at the one job it was built to do, and it has now outlived its own author,
Starting point is 01:46:25 its intended beneficiary, its debunkers, and every deadline anyone has ever assigned to it, because a story that offers people a date will always travel further than a footnote explaining there is not one. Rome is still standing. The seven hills are covered in traffic and scaffolding and tourists, who are mildly disappointed by the Trevi Fountain crowds.
Starting point is 01:46:46 In August 2027, the moon will pass in front of the sun. The temperature will drop a few degrees over southern Spain. The birds will go quiet for six minutes, and then it will get light again, and everyone standing in that field will go home and post about it. The interesting question was never when it ends, It is what you do with the part you have got, given that nobody, in 900 years of trying, has ever managed to find out how long that is.
Starting point is 01:47:11 So tell me where you land on this one. Textual accident, 16th century con job, or something that has been quietly keeping time for nine centuries. Comments are open, and I read them.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.