Classic Audiobook Collection - The Circular Study by Anna Katharine Green ~ Full Audiobook [mystery]

Episode Date: December 12, 2022

The Circular Study by Anna Katharine Green audiobook. Genre: mystery In this well-plotted, character-driven mystery, Detective Gryce receives a cryptic message calling him to the scene of a “strange” crime. He soon finds that the adjective is correct, for in a quiet brownstone house in a respectable New York City neighborhood, he finds the body of a man brutally stabbed to death, yet lovingly laid out on the floor of his study. The only apparent witnesses are a deaf and dumb butler driven mad by the event, and a caged bird that sings out a vital but puzzling clue. Before he solves the crime, with the help of the redoubtable Miss Amelia Butterworth, Gryce must uncover a motive that spans generations and the passions that have kept it alive. Anna Katharine Green was a pioneering writer of detective fiction in the United States. Her first such novel, The Leavenworth Case, was published in 1878. She is credited with changing the genre by making her stories legally accurate. She invented the 'girl detective.' But her works remained popular because of their lively, twisting plots and the strong characters she developed. For ad-free listening try our premium subscription Chapters (Approximate) (00:00:00) Chapter 01 (00:11:46) Chapter 02 (00:29:17) Chapter 03 (00:39:25) Chapter 04 (00:54:47) Chapter 05 (01:21:50) Chapter 06 (01:49:32) Chapter 07 (02:09:58) Chapter 08 (02:30:36) Chapter 09 (02:40:57) Chapter 10 (03:07:38) Chapter 11 (03:27:24) Chapter 12 (03:35:40) Chapter 13 (03:48:20) Chapter 14 (03:54:33) Chapter 15 (04:15:38) Chapter 16 (04:30:15) Chapter 17 (04:45:42) Chapter 18 (05:08:11) Chapter 19 (05:23:46) Chapter 20 (05:32:47) Chapter 21 (06:01:36) Chapter 22 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

the circular study by anna catherine green book one a strange crime chapter one red light mr gryce was melancholy he had attained that period in life when the spirit's flag and enthusiasm needs a constant spur and of late there had been a lack of special excitement and he felt dull and superannuated he was even contemplating resigning his position on the force and retiring to the little farm he had bought for himself in westchester and this in itself did not tend to cheerfulness for he was one to whom action was a necessity and the exercise of his mental faculties more inspiring than any possible advantage which might accrue to him from their use but he was not destined to carry out this impulse yet for for just at the height of his secret dissatisfaction there came a telephone message to headquarters which roused the old man to something like his former vigor and gave to the close of this grayfall day an interest he had not expected to feel again in this or any other kind of day it was sent from carter's well-known drug store and was to the effect that a lady had just sent a boy in from the street to say that a strange crime had been committed in blank's mansion round the corner the boy did not know the lady and was shy about showing the story the boy did not know the lady and was shy about showing the money she had given him, but that he had money was very evident, also that he was frightened

enough for his story to be true. If the police wished to communicate with him he could be found at Carter's, where he would be detained till an order for his release should be received. A strange crime. That word strange struck Mr. Grice and made him forget his years in wondering what it meant. Meanwhile, the men about him exchanged remarks upon the house brought thus unexpectedly to their notice. As it was one of the few remaining landmarks of the preceding century, and had been made conspicuous, moreover, by the shops, clubhouses and restaurants pressing against it on either side, it had been a marked spot for years, even to those who knew nothing of its history or traditions. and now a crime had taken place in it mr gryce in whose ears that word strange rang with quiet insistence had but to catch the eye of the inspector in charge to receive an order to investigate the affair

he started at once and proceeded first to the drug store there he found the boy whom he took along with him to the house indicated in the message on the way he made him talk but there was nothing the poor waif could add to the story already sent over the telephone he persisted in saying that a lady he did not say woman had come up to him while he was looking at some toys in a window and giving him a piece of money had drawn him along the street as far as the drug store here she showed him another coin promising to add it to the one he had already pocketed if he would run into the telephone clerk with a message for the police he wanted the money and when he grabbed at it she said that all he had to do was to tell the clerk that a strange crime had been committed in the old house on Blank Street. This scared him, and he was sliding off, when she caught him again and shook him until his wits came back, after which he ran into the store and delivered the message.

There was candor in the boy's tone, and Mr. Grice was disposed to believe him, but when he was asked to describe the lady, he showed that his powers of observation were no better than those of most of his class. All he could say was that she was a stunner and wore shiny clothes and jewels, and Mr. Grice, recognizing the lad's limitations at the very moment he found himself in view of the house he was making for, ceased to question him and directed all his attention to the building he was approaching. Nothing in the exterior bespoke crime or even disturbance. A shut door, a clean

stoop, heavily curtained windows, some of which were further shielded by closely drawn shades, were eloquent of inner quiet and domestic respectability, while its calm front of brick with brownstone trimmings offered a pleasing contrast to the adjoining buildings jutting out on either side, alive with signs and humming with business. Some mistake, muttered Grice to himself, as the perfect calm reigning over the whole establishment struck him anew. But before he had decided that he had been made the victim of a hoax, a movement took place in the area under the stoop, and an officer stepped out,

with a countenance expressive of sufficient perplexity for Mr. Grice to motion him back with the hurried inquiry. Anything wrong? Any bloodshed? All seems quiet here. The officer, recognizing the old detective, touched his hat. Can't get in, said he, have rung all the bells. Would think the house empty if I had not seen something like a stir in one of the windows overhead. Shall I try to make my way into the rear yard through one of the lower windows of Nappen Company's store next door? Yes, and take this boy with you.

Lock him up in some one of their offices and then break your way into this. house by some means it ought to be easy enough from the back yard the officer nodded took the boy by the arm and in a trice had disappeared with him into the adjoining store mr gryce remained in the area where he was presently besieged by a crowd of passers-by eager to add their curiosity to the trouble they had so quickly scented the opening of the door from the inside speedily put an end to importunities for for which he had as yet no reply, and he was enabled to slip within, where he found himself in a place of almost absolute quiet. Before him lay a basement hall leading to a kitchen, which even at that moment he noticed to be in trimmer condition than as usual where much housework is done, but he saw nothing that bespoke tragedy, or even a break in the ordinary routine of life, as observed in houses of like size and pretension.

Satisfied that what he sought was not to be found here, he followed the officer upstairs. As they emerged upon the parlor floor, the latter dropped the following information. Mr. Raffner of the firm next door says that the man who lives here is an odd sort of person whom nobody knows. A bookworm, I think they call him. He is occupancy. He is occupied. the house six months yet they have never seen anyone about the premise but himself and a strange old servant as peculiar and uncommunicative as his master i know muttered gryce he did know everybody knew that this house once the seat of one of new york's most aristocratic families was inhabited at present by a mr adams noted alike for his more than common personal attractions his wealth and the uncongenial nature of his temperament, which precluded all association with his kind. It was this knowledge which had given zest to this investigation. To enter the house of such a man

was an event in itself, to enter it on an errand of life and death, well, it is under the inspiration of such opportunities that life is reawakened in old veins, especially when those veins connect the heart and brain of a sagacious if octogenarian detective the hall in which they now found themselves was wide old-fashioned and sparsely furnished in the ancient manner to be observed in such time-honored structures two doors led into this hall both of which now stood open taking advantage of this fact they entered the nearest which was nearly opposite the top of the steepest which was nearly opposite the top of the staircase they had just ascended, and found themselves in a room barren as a doctor's outer office. There was nothing here worth their attention, and they would have left the place as unceremoniously as they had entered it if they had not caught glimpses of richness which promised an interior of uncommon elegance behind the half-drawn folds of a portier at the

further end of the room. advancing through the doorway thus indicated they took one look about them and stood appalled nothing in their experience and they had both experienced much had prepared them for the thrilling the solemn nature of what they were here called upon to contemplate shall i attempt its description a room small and of circular shape hung with strange tapestries relieved his and there by priceless curios, and lit, although it was still daylight, by a jet of rose-colored light, concentrated, not on the rows and rows of books around the lower portion of the room, or on the one great picture which at another time might have drawn the eye and held the attention, but on the upturned face of a man lying on a bare-skin rug with a dagger in his heart, and on his breast a cross whose golden lines sharply outlined against his long dark swathing garment gave him the appearance of a saint prepared in some holy place for burial save that the dagger spoke of violent death

and his face of an anguish for which mr gryce notwithstanding his lifelong experience found no name so little did it answer to a sensation of fear pain or surprise or any of the emotions usually visible on the countenances of such as have fallen under the unexpected stroke of an assassin end of book one chapter one book one chapter two of The Circular Study. This is a Librivox recording. All Librivox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librivox.org. The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green, Chapter 2. Mysteries. A moment of indecision, of awe even, elapsed before Mr. Grice recovered himself.

the dim light, the awesome silence, the unexpected surroundings recalling a romantic age, the motionless figure of him who so lately had been the master of the house, lying outstretched as for the tomb, with a sacred symbol on his breast offering such violent contradiction to the earthly passions which had driven the dagger home, were enough to move even the tired spirit of this old officer of the law, infuse a mind which, in the years of his long connection with the force, had had many serious problems to work upon, but never one just like this. It was only for a moment, though, before the man behind him had given utterance to his own bewilderment and surprise, Mr. Grice

had passed in and taken his stand by the prostrate figure. That it was that of a man who had long since ceased to breathe, he could not for a moment doubt. Yet his first act was to make sure of the fact by laying his hand on the pulse and examining the eyes, whose expression of reproach was such that he had to call up all his professional sang-froix to meet them. He found the body still warm, but dead beyond all question, and once convinced of this he forbore to draw the dagger from the wound, though he did not fail to give it the the most careful attention before turning his eyes elsewhere. It was no ordinary weapon. It was a curio from some oriental shop. This in itself seemed to point to suicide, but the direction in which the

blade had entered the body and the position of the wound were not such as would be looked for in a case of self-murder. The other clues were few. Though the scene had been one of bloodshed and death, the undoubted result of a sudden and fierce attack, there were no signs of struggle to be found in the well-ordered apartment. Beyond a few rose-leaves scattered on the floor, the room was a scene of peace and quiet luxury. Even the large table which occupied the center of the room and near which the master of the house had been standing when struck,

gave no token of the tragedy which had been enacted at its side. that is not at first glance for though its large top was covered with articles of use and ornament they all stood undisturbed and presumably in place as if the shock which had laid their owner low had failed to be communicated to his belongings the contents of the table were various only a man of complex tastes and attainments could have collected and arranged in one small compass pipes pens portraits weights measures roman lamps venetian glass rare porcelains metals rough metalwork manuscript a scroll of music a pot of growing flowers and-and this seemed oddest of all a row of electric buttons which mr gryce no sooner touched than the light which had been burning redly in the cage of fretted ironwork overhead changed in a twinkling to a greenish glare filling the room with such ghastly tints that mr gryce sought in haste another button and pressing it was glad to see a mild white radiance take the place of the sickly hue which had added its only one of its own little button and pressing it was glad to see a mild white radiance take the place of the sickly hue which had added its only horror to the already solemn terrors of the spot. Childish tricks for a man of his age and position, ruminated Mr. Grice, but after catching another

glimpse of the face lying upturned at his feet, he was conscious of a doubt as to whether the owner of that countenance could have possessed an instinct which was in any wise childish, so strong and purposeful were his sharply cut features. Indeed, the face was one to make an impression under any circumstances. In the present instance, and with such an expression stamped upon it, it exerted a fascination which disturbed the current of the detective's thoughts, whenever by any chance he allowed it to get between him and his duty. To attribute folly to a man with such a mouth and such a chin was to own oneself a poor judge of human nature. Therefore, the lamp overhead, with its electric,

connection and changing slides had a meaning which at present could be sought for only in the evidences of scientific research observable in the books and apparatus everywhere surrounding him. Letting the white light burn on, Mr. Grice, by a characteristic effort, shifted his attention to the walls, covered as I have said with tapestries and curios. There was nothing on them calculated to aid him in his research into the secret of this crime unless yes there was something a bent down nail wrenched from its place the nail on which the cross had hung which now lay upon the dead man's heart the cord by which it had been suspended still clung to the cross and mingled its red threads with that other scarlet thread which had gone to meet it from the victim's wounded breast who had torn down that cross not the victim himself with such a wound any such movement would have been impossible besides the nail and the empty place on the wall were as far removed from where he lay as was possible in the somewhat circumscribed area of this circular apartment another's hand then had pulled down this symbol of peace and pardon and placed it where the dying man's fleeting breath would play across it

a peculiar exhibition of religious hope or mad remorse to the significance of which mr gryce could not devote more than a passing thought so golden were the moments in which he found himself alone upon this scene of crime behind the table and half-way up the wall was a picture the only large picture in the room it was the portrait of a young girl of an extremely interesting and pathetic beauty from her garb and the arrangement of her hair it had evidently been painted about the end of our civil war in it was to be observed the same haunting quality of intellectual charm visible in the man lying prone upon the floor and though she was fair and he dark there was sufficient likeness between the two to argue some sort of relationship between them below this picture were fastened a sword a pair of epaulets and a medal such as was awarded for valor in the civil war mementos which may help us in our task mused the detective passing on he came unexpectedly upon a narrow curtain so dark of hue and so akin in pattern to the draperies on the adjoining walls that it had up to this time escaped his attention it was not that of a window for such windows as were to be seen in this unique apartment were high upon the wall indeed almost under the ceiling it must therefore drape the opening into still another communicating room and such he found to be the case pushing this curtain aside he entered a narrow closet containing a bed, a dresser, and a small table. The bed was the narrow cot of a

bachelor, and the dresser that of a man of luxurious tastes and the utmost nicety of habit. Both the bed and dresser were in perfect order, save for a silver-backed comb which had been taken from the latter, and which he presently found lying on the floor at the other end of the room this and the presence of a pearl-handled parasol on a small stand near the door proclaimed that a woman had been there within a short space of time the identity of this woman was soon established in his eyes by a small but unmistakable token connecting her with the one who had been the means of sending in the alarm to the police the token of which i speak was a little black spangle called by miller and manchua makers a sequin which lay on the threshold separating this room from the study and as mr gryce attracted by its sparkle stooped to examine it his eye caught sight of a similar one on the floor beyond and of still another a few steps farther on the last one lay close to the large centre table before which he had just been standing the dainty trail formed by these bright sparkling drops seemed to affect him oddly he knew minute observer that he was that in the manufacture of this garniture the spangles are strung on a thread which if once broken allows them to drop away one by one till you can almost follow a woman so arrayed by the sequins

that fall from her. Perhaps it was the delicate nature of the clue thus offered that pleased him. Perhaps it was a recognition of the irony of fate in thus making a trap for unwary mortals out of their vanities. Whatever it was, the smile with which he turned his eye upon the table toward which he had thus been led, was very eloquent. But before examining this article of furniture more closely, he attempted to find out where the thread had become loosened which had let the spangles fall. Had it caught on any projection in doorway or furniture? He saw none. All the chairs were cushioned and—' But wait, there was the cross. That had a fretwork of gold at its base. Might not this filigree have caught in her dress as she was tearing down the cross

from the wall, and so have started the thread which had given him this exquisite clue. Hastening to the spot where the cross had hung, he searched the floor at his feet, but found nothing to confirm his conjecture until he had reached the rug upon which the prostrate man lay. There amid the long hairs of the bearskin he came upon one other spangle and knew that the woman in the shiny clothes had stooped there before him. satisfied on this point he returned to the table and this time subjected it to a thorough and minute examination that the result was not entirely unsatisfactory was evident from the smile with which he eyed his finger after having drawn it across a certain spot near the inkstand and also from the care with which he lifted that inkstand and replaced it in precisely the same spot from which he had taken it up Had he expected to find something concealed under it?

Who can tell? A detective's face seldom yields up its secrets. He was musing quite intently before this table when a quick step behind him made him turn. Stiles, the officer, having now been over the house, had returned and was standing before him in the attitude of one who has something to say. What is it? asked Mr. Grice with a quick movement in his direction.

for answer the officer pointed to the staircase visible through the antechamber door go up was indicated by his gesture mr gryce demurred casting a glance around the room which at that moment interested him so deeply at this the man showed some excitement and breaking silence said come i have lighted on the guilty party he is in a room upstairs he mr gryce was evidently surprised at the pronoun yes there can be no doubt about it when you see him but what is that is he coming down i'm sure there's nobody else in the house don't you hear footsteps sir mr gryce nodded some one was certainly descending the stairs let us retreat suggested styles not because the man is dangerous but because it is very necessary you should see him before he he sees you he's a very strange acting man sir and if he comes in here we'll be sure to do something to incriminate himself where can we hide mr gryce remembered the little room he had just left and drew the officer toward it once installed inside he let the curtain drop till only a small loophole remained the steps which had been gradually growing louder kept advancing and presently they could hear the intruder's breathing which was both quick and labored. Does he know that anyone has entered the house?

Did he see you when you came upon him upstairs? whispered Mr. Grice into the ear of the man beside him. Stiles shook his head and pointed eagerly toward the opposite door. The man for whose appearance they waited had just lifted the portierre and in another moment stood in full view just inside the threshold. Mr. Grice and his attendant colleague, both stared. Was this the murderer, this pale, lean servitor with a tray in his hand on which rested a single glass of water? Mr. Grice was so astonished that he looked at Stiles for explanation. But that officer, hiding his own surprise, for he had not expected this peaceful figure,

urged him in a whisper to have patience, and both, turning toward the man again, beheld him advance. stop cast one look at the figure lying on the floor and then let slip the glass with a low cry that at once changed to something like a howl look at him look at him urged styles in hurried whisper watch what he will do now you will see a murderer at work and sure enough in another instant this strange being losing all semblance to his former self entered upon a series of pantomimic actions which to the two men who watched him seemed both to explain and illustrate the crime which had just been enacted there with every appearance of passion he stood contemplating the empty air before him and then with one hand held stretched out behind him in a peculiarly cramped position he plunged with the other toward a table from which he made a faint of snatching something which he no sooner closed his hand upon than he gave a quick side-thrust still at the empty air which seemed to quiver in return so vigorous was his action and so evident his intent. The reaction following this thrust, the slow unclosing of his hand from an imaginary dagger, the tottering of his body backward, then the moment when, with wide-open eyes he seemed to contemplate in horror the result of his own deed, these needed no explanation beyond what

was given by his writhing features and trembling body, gradually succumbing to the remorse or terror of his own crime, he sank lower and lower, until, though with that one arm still stretched out, he lay in an inert heap on the floor. "'It is what I saw him do upstairs,' murmured Stiles into the ear of the amazed detective. He has evidently been driven insane by his own act.' Mr. Grice made no answer. "'Here was a problem for the solution of which he found no precedent.' in all his past experience.

End of Book 1, Chapter 2. Book 1, Chapter 3 of The Circular Study. This is a Librevox recording. All Librevox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librevox.org. The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green. Book 1, Chapter 7.5.

the mute servitor meanwhile the man who to all appearance had just reenacted before them the tragedy which had so lately taken place in this room rose to his feet and with a dazed air as unlike his former violent expression as possible stooped for the glass he had let fall and was carrying it out when mr gryce called to him wait man you needn't take that glass away we first want to hear how your master comes to be lying here dead it was a demand calculated to startle any man but this one showed himself totally unmoved by it and was passing on when stiles laid a detaining hand on his shoulder. Stop, said he, what do you mean by sliding off like this? Don't you hear the gentleman speaking to you? This time the appeal told. The glass fell again from the man's hand, mingling its clink,

for it struck the floor this time and broke, with a cry he gave, which was not exactly a cry either, but an odd sound between a moan and a shriek. He had caught sight of the men, who were seeking to detain him, and his haggard look and cringing form, showed that he realized at last the terrors of his position. Next minute he sought to escape, but Stiles, gripping him more firmly, dragged him back to where Mr. Grice stood beside the bare-skin rug, on which lay the form of his dead master. Instantly at the sight of this recumbent figure, another

change took place in the entrapped butler. joy, that most hellish of passions in the presence of violence and death, illumined his wandering eye and distorted his mouth, and, seeking no disguise for the satisfaction he felt, he uttered a low but thrilling laugh which rang in unholy echo through the room. Mr. Grice, moved in spite of himself by an abhorrence which the irresponsible condition of this man seemed only to emphasize, waited till the last faint sounds of this diabolical mirth had died away in the high recesses of the space above. Then fixing the glittering eye of this strange creature with his own, which, as we know, so seldom dwelt upon that of his fellow-beings, he sternly said,

"'There now, speak! Who killed this man? You were in the house with him and should know.' the butler's lips opened and a string of strange guttural sounds poured forth while with his one disengaged hand for the other was held to his side by stiles he touched his ears and his lips and violently shook his head there was but one interpretation to be given to this the man was deaf and dumb the shock of this discovery was too much for styles his hand fell from the other's arms and the man finding himself free withdrew to his former place in the room where he proceeded to enact again and with increased vivacity first the killing of and then the mourning for his master which but a few moments before had made so suggestive an impression upon them this done he stood waiting but this time with that gleam of infernal joy in the depths of his quick restless eyes which made his very presence in this room of death seem a sacrilege and horror stiles could not stand it can't you speak he shouted can't you hear the man only smiled an evil and gloating smile which mr gryce thought it his duty to cut short take him away he cried examine him carefully for blood marks i am going up to the room where you saw him first he is too nearly linked to this crime not to carry some trace of it away with him but for once even this time-tried detective found himself at fault no marks were found on the old servant nor could they discover in the rooms above any signs by which this one remaining

occupant of the house, could be directly associated with the crime which had taken place within it. Thereupon Mr. Grice grew very thoughtful and entered upon another examination of the two rooms, which to his mind held all the clues that would ever be given to this strange crime. The result was meager, and he was just losing himself again in contemplation of the upturned face, whose fixed mouth and haunting expression told such a story of suffering and determination, when there came from the dim recesses above his head a cry, which, forming itself into two words, rang down with startling clearness in this most unexpected of appeals. Remember Evelyn!

Remember Evelyn? Who was Evelyn? And to whom did this voice belong in a house which had already been mentioned? ransacked in vain for other occupants. It seemed to come from the roof, and, sure enough, when Mr. Grice looked up, he saw, swinging in a cage strung up nearly to the top of one of the windows I have mentioned, an English starling, which in seeming recognition of the attention it had drawn upon itself, craned its neck as Mr. Grice looked up and shrieked again with fiercer insistence than before. Remember Evelyn! It was the last uncanny touch in a series of uncanny experiences. With an odd sense of nightmare upon him, Mr. Grice leaned forward on the study table

in his effort to obtain a better view of this bird, when, without warning, the white light, which since his last contact with the electrical apparatus had spread itself through the room, changed again to green, and he realized that he had unintentionally pressed a button and thus brought into action another slide in the curious lamp over his head. An annoyed, for these changing hues, offered a problem he was as yet too absorbed in other matters to make any attempt to solve, he left the vicinity of the table and was about to leave the room when he heard Stiles's voice rise from the adjoining antechamber where Stiles was keeping guard over the old butler. Shall I let him go, Mr. Grice? He seems very uneasy. Not dangerous, you know, but anxious,

as if he had forgotten something or recalled some unfulfilled duty. Yes, let him go, was the detective's quick reply, only watch and follow him. Every movement he makes is of interest. unconsciously he may be giving us invaluable clues and he approached the door to note for himself what the man might do remember evelyn rang out the startling cry from above as the detective passed between the curtains irresistibly he looked back and up to whom was this appeal from a bird's throat so imperatively addressed to him or to the man on the floor beneath whose ears were forever closed. It might be a matter of little consequence, and it might be one involving the very secret of this tragedy. But whether important or not he could pay no heed to it at this juncture, for the old butler, coming from the front hall whither he had hurried on being released by Stiles, was at that moment approaching him, carrying in one hand his master's hat

and in the other his master's umbrella. Not knowing what he was. Not knowing what he was, he was going to be aftain't what this new movement might mean, Mr. Grice paused where he was and waited for the man to advance. Seeing this, the mute, to whose face and bearing had returned the respectful immobility of the trained servant, handed over the articles he had brought, and then noiselessly and with the air of one who had performed an expected service, retreated to his old place in the ante-chamber, where he sat down again and fell almost immediately into his former dazed condition. Humph, mind quite lost, memory uncertain, testimony valueless, were the dissatisfied reflections of the disappointed detective,

as he replaced Mr. Adams' hat and umbrella on the hall rack. Has he been brought to this date by the tragedy which has just taken place here? Or is his present insane condition its precursor and cause? mr gryce might have found some answer to this question in his own mind if at that moment the fitful clanging of the front door-bell which had hitherto testified to the impatience of the curious crowd outside had not been broken into by an authoritative knock which at once put an end to all self-communing the coroner or some equally important person was at hand and the detective's golden hour was over End of Book 1, Chapter 3. Book 1, Chapter 4 of The Circular Study. This is a Librivox recording.

All Libravox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librivox.org. The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green. Book 1, Chapter 4. A new experience for Mr. Grice. Mr. Grice felt himself at a greater disadvantage in his attempt to solve the mystery of this affair than in any other which he had entered upon in years. First, the victim had been a solitary man with no household save his man of all work, the mute. Secondly, he had lived in a portion of the city where no neighbors were possible, and he had even lacked, as it now seemed, any very active friends. though some hours had elapsed since his death had been noised abroad no one had appeared at the door with inquiries or information this seemed odd considering that he had been for some months a marked figure in this quarter of the town but then everything about this man was odd nor would it have been in keeping with his surroundings and peculiar manner of living for him to have had the ordinary associations of men of his class

the absence of the usual means of eliciting knowledge from the surrounding people added to rather than detracted from the interest which mr gryce was bound to feel in the case and it was with a feeling of relief that a little before midnight he saw the army of reporters medical men officials and such others as had followed in the coroner's wake file out of the front door and leave him again for a few hours at least, master of the situation. For there were yet two points which he desired to settle before he took his own much-needed rest. The first occupied his immediate attention. Passing before a chair in the hall on which a small boy sat dozing, he roused him with the remark. Come, Jake, it's time to look lively. I want you to go with me to the exact place where that lady ran across you today. The boy, half dead with sleep, looked around him for his hat. I'd like to see my mother first, he pleaded.

She must be done up about me. I never stayed away so long before. Your mother knows where you are. I sent a message to her hours ago. She gave a very good report of you, Jake, says you're an obedient lad and that you've never told her a falsehood. She's a good mother, the boy warmly declared. I'd be as bad as bad as my father was if I did not treat her well.

Here his hand fell on his cap, which he put on his head. I'm ready, said he. Mr. Grice at once led the way into the street. The hour was late, and only certain portions of the city showed any real activity. Into one of these thoroughfares they presently came, and before the darkened window of one of the lesser sharp, paused while jake pointed out the two stuffed frogs engaged with miniature swords in mortal combat at which he had been looking when the lady came up and spoke to him mr gryce eyed the boy rather than the frogs though probably the former would have sworn that his attention had never left that miniature conflict was she a pretty lady he asked the boy scratched his head in some perplexity she made me a good woman

good deal afraid of her, he said. She had very splendid clothes. Oh, gorgeous, he cried, as if on this question there could be no doubt. And she was young and carried a bunch of flowers and seemed troubled? What, not young, and carried no flowers, and wasn't even anxious and trembling? The boy who had been shaking his head looked nonplussed. I think as she was what you might call troubled, but she wasn't crying, and when she spoke to me she put more feeling into her grip than into her voice. She just dragged me to the drug-store, sir. If she hadn't given me money first, I should have wriggled away in spite of her. But I likes money, sir. I don't get too much of it. Mr. Grice by this time was moving on. Not young, he repeated to himself.

Some old flame then of Mr. Adams. They're apt to be dangerous, very dangerous, more dangerous than the young ones. In front of the drug store he paused. Show me where she stood while you went in. The boy pointed out the identical spot. He seemed as eager as the detective. And was she standing there when you came out? Oh no, sir, she went away while I was inside. Did you see her go? Can you tell me whether she went up street or down? I had one eye on her, sir. I was afraid she was coming into the shop after me, and my arm was too sore for me to want her to clinch hold on it again,

so when she started to go I took a step nearer and saw her move toward the curbstone and hold up her hand, but it wasn't a car she was after, for none came by for several minutes. The fold between Mr. Grice's eyes perceptibly smoothed out. Then it was some cabman or hat-driver she had, Were there any empty coaches about that you saw? The boy had not noticed.

He had reached the limit of his observations, and no amount of further questioning could elicit anything more from him. This Mr. Grice soon saw, and, giving him into the charge of one of his assistants who was on duty at this place, he proceeded back to the ill-omened house, where the tragedy itself had occurred. Anyone waiting for me, he inquired of Stiles, who came to the door? Yes, sir, a young man, name Hines, says he's an electrician. That's the man I want. Where is he? In the parlour, sir. Good, I'll see him, but don't let anyone else in. Anybody

upstairs? No, sir, all gone. Shall I go up or stay here? You'd better go up. I'll look after the door. Stiles nodded and went toward the stairs, up which he presently disappeared. Mr. Grice proceeded to the parlor. dapper young man with an intelligent eye rose to meet him. You sent for me, said he. The detective nodded, asked a few questions, and, seeming satisfied with the replies he received, led the way into Mr. Adams' study from which the body had been removed to an upper room.

As they entered, a mild light greeted them from a candle which by Mr. Grice's orders had been placed on a small side table near the door. but once in mr gryce approached the larger table in the centre of the room and placing his hand on one of the buttons before him asked his companion to be kind enough to blow out the candle this he did leaving the room for a moment in total darkness then with a sudden burst of illumination a marvellous glow of a deep violet colour shot over the whole room and the two men turned and faced each other both of a sudden burst of illumination a marvellous glow of a deep violet colour shot over the whole room and the two men turned and faced each other both with inquiry in their looks, so unexpected was this theatrical effect to the one, and so inexplicable its cause and purpose to the other. That is but one slide, remarked Mr. Gryce. Now I will press another button, and the color changes to pink, as you see. This one produces green, this one white, and this abelius yellow, which is not becoming to either of us, I am sure.

now will you examine the connection and see if there is anything peculiar about it mr hines at once set to work but beyond the fact that the whole contrivance was the work of an amateur hand he found nothing strange about it except the fact that it worked so well mr gryce showed disappointment he made it then himself he asked undoubtedly or someone else equally unacquainted with the latest method of wiring will you look at these books over here and see if sufficient knowledge can be got from them to enable an amateur to rig up such an arrangement as this mr hines glanced at the shelf which mr gryce had pointed out and without taking out the books answered briefly a man with a deft hand and a scientific turn of mind might by the aid of these do all you see here and more the aptitude is all then i'm afraid mr adams had the aptitude was the dry response there was disappointment in the tone why his next words served to show a man with a turn for mechanical contrivances often wastes much time and money on useless toys only fit for children to play with look at that bird-cage now perched at a height totally beyond the reach of any one without a ladder it must owe its very evident useless for you see it holds a rather lively occupant to some contrivance by which it can be raised and lowered at will where is that contrivance can you find it the expert thought he could and sure enough after some ineffectual searching he came upon another button well hid amid the tapestry on the wall which when pressed caused something to be disengaged which gradually lowered the cage within reach of mr

his hand we will not send this poor bird aloft again said he detaching the cage and holding it for a moment in his hand an english starling is none too common in this country hark he is going to speak but the sharp-eyed bird warned perhaps by the emphatic gesture of the detective that silence would be more in order at this moment than his usual appeal to remember evelyn whisked about in his cage for an instant and then subsided into a doze, which may have been real and may have been assumed under the fascinating eye of the old gentleman who held him. Mr. Grice placed the cage on the floor, and idly, or because the play pleased him, old and stayed as he was, pressed another button on the table, a button he had hitherto neglected touching, and glanced around to see what color the light would now assume. but the yellow glare remained. The investigation which the apparatus had gone through

had probably disarranged the wires. With a shrug he was moving off when he suddenly made a hurried gesture directing the attention of the expert to a fact for which neither of them was prepared. The opening which led into the ante-chamber and which was the sole means of communication with the rest of the house

was slowly closing. From a yard's breath it became a foot. From a foot it became an inch. From an inch... Well, that is certainly the contrivance of a lazy man, laughed the expert. Seated in his chair, here he can close the door at will. No shouting for a deaf servant, no awkward stumbling over rugs to shut it himself. I don't know, but I approve of this contrivance, only...

Here he caught a rather serious expression on Mr. Grice's face. The slide seems to be of a somewhat curious construction. It is not made of wood as any sensible door ought to be, but of— Steel, finished Mr. Grice in an odd tone. This is the strangest thing yet. It begins to look as if Mr. Adams was daft on electrical contrivances. And as if we were prisoners here, supplemented the other. I do not see any means for drawing this slide back.

Oh, there's another. button for that, of course, Mr. Grice carelessly remarked. But they failed to find one. If you don't object, observed Mr. Grice after five minutes of useless search, I will turn a more cheerful light upon the scene. Yellow does not seem to fit the occasion. Give us rows, for unless you have someone on the other side of this steel plate we seem likely to remain here till morning. There is a man upstairs whom we may perhaps make here, but what does this contrivance pretend it has a serious look to me when you consider that every window in these two rooms has been built up almost under the roof yes a very strange look but before engaging in its consideration i should like a breath of fresh air i cannot do anything while in confinement my brain won't work meanwhile mr gryce was engaged in examining the huge plate of steel which served as a barrier to their egress

He found that it had been made, certainly at great expense, to fit the curve of the walls through which it passed. This was a discovery of some consequence, causing Mr. Grice to grow still more thoughtful and to eye the smooth steel plate under his hand with an air of marked distrust. Mr. Adams carried his taste for the mechanical to great extremes, he remarked to the slightly uneasy man beside him, this slide is very carefully fitted and if i am not mistaken it will stand some battering before we are released i wish that his interest in electricity had led him to attach such a simple thing as a bell true we have come across no bell it would have smacked too much of the ordinary to please him besides his only servant was deaf try the effect of a blow a quick blow with this silver-mounted alpenstock someone should hear and come to our assistance. I will try my whistle first. It will be better understood. But though Mr. Grice both whistled and struck many a resounding knock upon the barrier before them,

it was an hour before he could draw the attention of Stiles, and five hours before an opening could be effected in the wall large enough to admit of their escape, so firmly was this barrier of steel fixed across the sole outlet from the same. this remarkable room. End of Book 1, Chapter 4. Book 1, Chapter 5 of The Circular Study. This is a Librevox recording. All Librevox recordings are in the public domain.

For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librivox.org. The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green, Chapter 5, 5, 5 Small Small bangles such an experience could not fail to emphasize mr gryce's interest in the case and heighten the determination he had formed to probe its secrets and explain all its extraordinary features arrived at headquarters where his presence was doubtless awaited with some anxiety by those who knew nothing of the cause of his long detention his first act was to inquire if bartow the butler had come to his senses during the night The answer was disappointing. Not only was there no change in his condition, but the expert in lunacy who had been called in to pass upon his case had expressed an opinion unfavorable to his immediate recovery.

Mr. Grice looked sober, and summoning the officer who had managed Bartow's arrest, he asked how the mute had acted when he found himself detained. The answer was curt, but very much to the point. surprised sir shook his head and made some queer gestures then went through his pantomime it's quite a spectacle sir poor fool he keeps holding his hand back so mr gryce noted the gesture it was the same which bartow had made when he first realized that he had spectators its meaning was not wholly apparent he had made it with his right hand there was no evidence that the mute was left-handed and he continued to make it as if with this movement he expected to call attention to some fact that would relieve him from custody does he mope is his expression one of fear or anger it varies sir one minute he looks like a man on the point of falling asleep the next he starts up in fury shaking his head and pounding the walls it's not a comfortable sight sir he will have to be watched night and day let him be and note every change in him his testimony may not be valid but there is suggestion in every movement he makes to-morrow i will visit him myself

the officer went out and mr gryce sat for a few moments communing with himself during which he took out a little package from his pocket and emptying out on his desk the five little spangles it contained regarded them intently he had always been for a little package from his pocket and emptying out on his desk the five little spangles it contained regarded them intently he had always been fond of looking at some small and seemingly insignificant object while thinking. It served to concentrate his thoughts, no doubt. At all events, some such result appeared to follow the contemplation of these five sequins, for after shaking his head doubtfully over them for a time, he made a sudden move, and sweeping them into the envelope from which he had taken them, he gave a glance at his watch and passed quickly into the outer office, where he paused before a line of waiting men. Beckoning to one who had followed his movements with an interest which had not escaped the eye of this old reader of human nature, he led the way back to his own room.

"'You want a hand in this matter?' he said interrogatively as the door closed behind them and they found themselves alone. Oh, sir, began the young man in a glow which made his more than plain feature, is interesting to contemplate. I do not presume. Enough, interposed the other. You have been here now for six months and have had no opportunity as yet for showing any special adaptability.

Now I propose to test your powers with something really difficult. Are you up to it, Sweetwater? Do you know the city well enough to attempt to find a needle in this very big haystack? I should at least like to try, was the eager response.

If I succeed, it will be be a bigger feather in my cap than if I had always lived in New York. I have been spoiling for some such opportunity. See if I don't make the effort judiciously, if only out of gratitude. Well, we shall see, remarked the old detective. If it's difficulty you long to encounter, you will be likely to have all you want of it. Indeed, it is the impossible, I ask. A woman is to be found, of whom we know nothing, save that she wore when last seen, a dress, heavily be spangled with black, and that she carried in her visit to Mr. Adams at the time of or before the murder, a parasol, of which I can procure you a glimpse before you start out. She came from, I don't know where, and she went, but that is what you are to find out. You are not the only man who is to be put on the job, which as you see is next door to a hopeless one, unless the woman comes forward and proclaims herself.

indeed i should despair utterly of your success if it were not for one small fact which i will now proceed to give you as my special and confidential agent in this matter when this woman was about to disappear from the one eye that was watching her she approached the curbstone in front of hudson's fruit store on fourteenth street and lifted up her right hand so it is not much of a clue but it is all i have at my disposal except these five spangles dropped from her dress, and my conviction that she is not to be found among the questionable women of the town, but among those who seldom or never come under the eye of the police. Yet don't let this conviction hamper you. Convictions as a rule are bad things and act as a hindrance rather than an inspiration. Sweetwater, to whom the song of the sirens would have sounded less sweet, listened with delight and responded with a frank smile and a gay. I'll do my best, sir, but don't show me the parasol,

only describe it. I wouldn't like the fellows to chaff me if I fail. I'd rather go quietly to work and raise no foolish expectations. Well, then, it is one of those dainty, nonsensical things made of gray chiffon with pearl handle and bows of pink ribbon. I don't believe it was ever used before, and from the value women usually place on such falderals, could only have been left behind under the stress of extraordinary emotion or fear. The name of the owner was not on it. Nor that of the maker? Mr. Grice had expected this question and was glad not to be disappointed. No, that would have helped us too much. And the hour at which this lady was seen on the curbstone at Hudson's? Half past four, the moment at which the telephone message arrived.

Very good, sir. It is the hardest task I have ever undertaken, but that's not against it. When shall I see you again? When you have something to impart, ah, wait a minute, I have my suspicion that this woman's first name is Evelyn, but mind it is only a suspicion. All right, sir, and with an air of some confidence the young man does. disappeared. Mr. Grice did not look as if he shared young Sweetwater's cheerfulness. The mist surrounding this affair was as yet impenetrable to him. But then he was not twenty-three with only triumphant memories behind him. His next hope lay in the information likely to accrue from the published accounts of this crime, now spread broadcast over the country. A man of Mr. Adams's

wealth and culture must necessarily have possessed many acquaintances, whom the surprising news of his sudden death would naturally bring to light, especially as no secret was made of his means and many valuable effects. But as if this affair, destined to be one of the last to engage the powers of this sagacious old man, refused on this very account to yield any immediate results to his investigation, day passed by without the appearance of any claimant for Mr. Adams's fortune, or the arrival on the scene of any friend capable of lifting the veil which shrouded the life of this strange being. To be sure his banker and his lawyer came forward during the day, but they had a little to reveal beyond the fact that his pecuniary affairs were in good shape, and that so far as

they knew, he was without family or kin. Even his landlord could add little to the general knowledge. He had first heard of Mr. Adams through a Philadelphia lawyer, since dead, who had assured him of his client's respectability and undoubted ability to pay his rent. When they came together and Mr. Adams was introduced to him, he had been struck first by the ascetic appearance of his prospective tenant, and secondly by his reserved manners and quiet intelligence. but admirable as he had found him he had never succeeded in making his acquaintance the rent had been uniformly paid with great exactitude on the very day it was due but his own visits had never been encouraged or his advances met by anything but the cold politeness of a polished and totally indifferent man indeed he had always looked upon his tenant as a bookworm absorbed in study and such scientific experience as could be carried on with no other assistance than that of his deaf and dumb servant.

Asked if he knew anything about this servant, he answered that his acquaintance with him was limited to the two occasions on which he had been ushered by him into his master's presence, that he knew nothing of his character and general disposition, and could not say whether his attitude toward his master had been one of allegiance or antagonism. and so the way was blocked in this direction. Taken into the room where Mr. Adams had died, he surveyed in amazement the huge steel plate which still blocked the doorway, and the high windows through which only a few straggling sunbeams could find their way.

Pointing to the windows, he remarked, these were filled in at Mr. Adams' request. Originally they extended down to the wainscoting. He was shown where Lath and Quarckon. plaster had been introduced, and also how the plate had been prepared and arranged as a barrier, but he could give no explanation of it or divine the purpose for which it had been placed there at so great an expense. The lamp was another curiosity, and its varying lights the cause of increased astonishment. Indeed, he had known nothing of these arrangements, having been

received in the parlour when he visited the house, where there was nothing to attract his attention or emphasized the well-known oddities of his tenant. He was not shown the starling. That loquacious bird had been removed to police headquarters for the special deletation of Mr. Grice. Other inquiries failed also. No clue to the owner of the insignia found on the wall could be gained at the pension office or at any of the GAR posts inside the city. Nor was the name of the artist who had painted the portrait which adorned so large a portion of the wall, a recognized one in New York City. Otherwise, a clue might have been obtained through him to Mr. Adams' antecedents.

All the drawers and receptacles in Mr. Adams' study had been searched, but no will had been found nor any business documents. It was as if the strange man had sought to suppress his identity, or rather as if he had outgrown all interest in his kind. or in anything beyond the walls within which he had amured himself late in the afternoon reports began to come in from the various tradesmen with whom mr adams had done business they all had something to say as to the peculiarity of his habits and the freaks of his mute servant they were both described as hermits differing from the rest of their kind only in that they denied themselves no reasonable luxury and seemed to have adopted a shut-in life from a pure love of seclusion the master was never seen at the stores it was the servant who made the purchases and this by means of gestures which were often strangely significant indeed he seemed to have a great power of expressing himself by looks and actions and rarely caused a mistake or made one he would not endure cheating and always bought the best of his sanity up to the day of his master's death there was no question

but more than one man with whom he had had dealings was ready to testify that there had been a change in his manner for the past few weeks a sort of subdued excitement quite unlike his former methodical bearing he had shown an inclination to testiness and was less eased pleased than formerly to one clerk he had shown a nasty spirit under very slight provocation and was only endured in the store on account of his master who was too good a customer for them to offend mr kelly a grocer went so far as to say he acted like a man with a grievance who burned to vent his spite on some one but held himself in forcible restraint perhaps if no tragedy had taken place in the house on blank street these various persons would not have been so ready to interpret thus unfavourably a nervousness excusable enough in one so cut off from all communication with his kind but with the violent end of his master in view and his own unexplained connection with it who could help recalling that his glance had frequently shown malevolence but this was not the evidence of the decided character required by the law and mr gryce was about to regard the day as a lost one when sweetwater made his reappearance at headquarters the expression of his face put new life into mr gryce what he cried you have not found her sweetwater smiled don't ask me sir not yet i've come to see if there's any reason why i should not be given the loan of that parasol for about an hour i'll bring it back i only want to make a certain test with it what test my boy may i ask what test please to excuse me sir i have only a short time in which to act before respectable business houses shut up for the night and the test i speak of has to be made in a respectable house

then you shall not be hindered wait here and i will bring you the parasol there bring it back soon my boy i have not the patience i used to have An hour, sir. Give me an hour, and then? The shutting of the door behind his flying figure cut short his sentence. That was a long hour to Mr. Grice, or would have been, if it had not mercifully been cut short by the return of Sweetwater in an even more excited state of mind than he had been before. He held the parasol in his hand. "'My test failed,' said he,

but the parasol has brought me luck notwithstanding i have found the lady sir and he had to draw a long breath before proceeding and she is what i said began the detective a respectable person in a respectable house yes sir very respectable more respectable than i expected to see quite a lady sir not young but-her name boy is it evelyn sweetwater shook his head with a look at as naive in its way as the old detective's question i cannot say sir indeed i had not the courage to ask she is here here mr gryce took one hurried step toward the door then came gravely back i can restrain myself he said if she is here she will not go till i have seen her are you sure you have made no mistake that she is the woman we are after the woman who is in mr adams's house and sent us the warning. "'Will you hear my story, sir? It will only take a moment. Then you can judge for yourself.'

"'Your story? It must be a pretty one. How came you to light on this woman so soon? By using the clue I gave you?' Again Sweetwater's expression took on a touch of naivete. "'I'm sorry, sir, but I was egotistical enough to follow my own idea.

It would have taken too much time to hunt up all the drivers of hacks in the city, and I could not even be sure she had made use of a public conveyance. No, sir, I bethought me of another way by which I might reach this woman. You had shown me those spangles. They were portions of a very rich trimming, a trimming which has only lately come into vogue, and which is so expensive that it is worn chiefly by women of means, and sold only in shops where elaborate garnitures are to be found. I have seen and noticed dresses thus trimmed in certain windows and on certain ladies, and before you showed me the spangles you picked up in Mr. Adams's study, could have told you just how I had seen them arranged. They are sewed on black net in figures, sir, in scrolls or wreaths or whatever you choose to call them, and so conspicuous are these wreaths or figures owing to the brilliance of the spangles composing them, that any break in their continuity is plainly apparent, especially if the net be worn over a color, as is frequently the case.

Remembering this and recalling the fact that these spangles doubtless fell from one of the front breaths, where their loss would attract not only the attention of others but that of the wearer, I said to myself, what will she be likely to do when she finds her dress thus disfigured? And the answer at once came. If she is the lady Mr. Grice considers her, she will seek to restore these missing spangles, especially if they were lost on a scene of crime. But where can she get them to sew on, from an extra piece of net of the same style? But she will not be apt to have an extra piece of net. She will therefore find herself obliged to buy it,

and since only a few spangles are lacking, she will buy the various strip. Here then was my clue, or at least my ground for action. the rounds of the few leading stores on broadway twenty-third street and sixth avenue i succeeded in getting certain clerks interested in my efforts so that i speedily became assured that if a lady came into these stores for a very small portion of this bespangled net they would note her person and if possible procure some clue to her address then i took up my stand at arnold's emporium why arnold's i do not know perhaps my good genius meant me to be successful in this quest but whether through luck or what not i was successful for before the afternoon was half over i encountered a meaning glance from one of the men behind the counter and advancing toward him saw him rolling a small package which he handed over to a very pretty and rosy young girl who at once walked away with it for one of our leading customers he whispered as i drew nearer i don't think she is the person you want but i would take no chances i followed the young girl who had carried away the parcel and by this means came to a fine brownstone front in one of our most retired and aristocratic quarters when i had seen her go in at the basement door i rang the bell above and then well i just bit my lips to keep down my growing excitement

for such an effort as this might well end in disappointment and i knew if i were disappointed now but no such trial awaited me the maid who came to the door proved to be the same merry-eyed lass i had seen leave the store indeed she had the identical parcel in her hand which was the connecting link between the imposing house at whose door i stood and the strange murder in blank street but i did not allow my interest in this parcel to become apparent and by the time i addressed her i had so mastered myself as to arouse no suspicion of the importance of my errand you of course foresee the question i put to the young girl has your mistress lost a parasol one has been found i did not finish the sentence for i perceived by her look that her mistress had met with such a loss and as this was all i wanted to know just then i cried out i will bring it if it is hers all right and bound it down the steps my intention was to inform you of what i had done and ask your advice but my egotism got the better of me i felt that i ought to make sure that i was not the victim of a coincidence such a respectable house such a respectable maid-servant should she recognize the parasol as belonging to her mistress then indeed i might boast of my success so praying you for a loan of this article i went back and rang the bell again the same girl came to the door i think fortune favored me to-day here is the parasol said i but before the words were out of my mouth i saw that the girl had taken the alarm or that some girl had taken the alarm or that some of the parasol said i but before the words were out of my mouth i saw that the girl had taken the alarm or that some some grievous mistake had been made that is not the one my mistress lost said she she never carries anything but black and the door was about to close between us when i heard a voice from within call out peremptorily

let me see that parasol hold it up young man there at the foot of the stairs ah if ever an exclamation was eloquent that simple ah was i could not see the speaker but i knew she was was leaning over the banisters from the landing above. I listened to hear her glide away, but she did not move. She was evidently collecting herself for the emergency of the moment. Presently she spoke again, and I was astonished at her tone. You have come from police headquarters, was the remark with which she hailed me. I lowered the parasol. I did not think it necessary to say yes. From a man there, called. called grice she went on still in that strange tone i can hardly describe sir since you ask me i now replied i acknowledge that it is through his instructions i am here he was anxious to restore to you your lost property is not this parasol yours shall i not leave it with this young girl the answer was dry almost rasping

mr gryce has made a mistake the parasol is not mine yet he certainly deserves credit for the use he has made of it in this search i should like to tell him so is he at his office and do you think i would be received he would be delighted i returned not imagining she was in earnest but she was sir in less time than you would believe i perceived a very stately almost severe lady descend to the stairs she was dressed for the street and spoke to me with quite an air of command have you a cab she asked no said i then get one here was a dilemma should i leave her and thus give her an opportunity to escape or should i trust to her integrity and the honesty of her look which was no common one sir and obey her as every one about her was evidently accustomed to do i concluded to trust to her integrity and went for the cab but it was a risk sir which i promised not to repeat in the future she was awaiting me on the stoop when i got back and at once entered the hack with a command to drive immediately to police headquarters i saw her as i came in just now sitting in the outer office waiting for you are you ready to say i have done well mr gryce with an indescribable look of mingled envy and indulgence pressed the hand held out to him and passed out his curiosity could be restrained no longer, and he went at once to where this mysterious woman was awaiting him. Did he think it odd that she knew him, that she sought him?

If so, he did not betray this in his manner, which was one of great respect. But that manner suddenly changed as he came face to face with the lady in question. Not that it lost its respect, but that it betrayed an astonishment of a more pronounced character than was usually indulged in by this experienced detective. The lady before him was one well known to him, in fact almost an associate of his in certain bygone matters, in other words, none other than that most reputable of ladies, Miss Amelia Butterworth of Gramercy Park. End of Book 1, Chapter 5.

Book 1 Chapter 6 of The Circular Study. This is a Librivox recording. All Librevox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librevox.org. The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green Chapter 6. Suggestions from an Old Friend The look with which this amiable spinster met his eye was one which a stranger would have found it hard to understand he found it hard to understand himself perhaps because he had never before seen this lady when she was laboring under an opinion of herself that was not one of perfect complacency miss butterworth what does this mean have you there the word

came with some sharpness you have detected me at my old tricks and i am correspondingly ashamed and you triumphant the gray parasol you have have been good enough to send to my house is not mine but i was in the room where you picked it up as you have so cleverly concluded and as it is useless for me to evade your perspicacity i have come here to confess ah the detective was profoundly interested at once he drew a chair up to miss butterworth's side and sat down you were there he repeated and when i do not presume to ask for what purpose But I shall have to explain my purpose not to find myself at too great a disadvantage, she replied with grim decision. Not that I like to display my own weakness, but that I recognize the exigencies of the occasion and fully appreciate your surprise at finding that I, a stranger to Mr. Adams,

and without the excuse which led to my former interference in police matters, should have so far forgotten myself as to be in my present position. before you this was no affair of my immediate neighbor nor did it seek me i sought it sir and in this way i wish i had gone to jericho first it might have meant longer travel and much more expense but it would have involved me in less humiliation and possible publicity mr gryce i never meant to be mixed up with another murder case i have shown my aptitude for detective work and received ere now certain marks of your approval but my head was not turned by them at least i thought not and i was tolerably sincere in my determination to keep to my own metier in future and not suffer myself to be allured by any inducements you might offer into the exercise of gifts which may have brought me praise in the the past, but certainly have not brought me happiness. But the temptation came, not through you, or I might have resisted it, but through a combination of circumstances which found me weak and in a measure unprepared. In other words, I was surprised into taking an interest in this

affair. Oh, I am ashamed of it, so ashamed that I have made the greatest endeavor to hide my participation in the matter, and thinking I had succeeded in doing so, was congratulating myself upon my precautions when I found that parasol thrust in my face and realized that you, if no one else, knew that Amelia Butterworth had been in Mr. Adams' room of death prior to yourself. Yet I thought I had left no traces behind me. Could you have seen? Miss Butterworth, you dropped five small spangles from your own. your robe. You wore a dress spangled with black sequins, did you not? Besides, you moved to the inkstand and, well, I will never put faith in circumstantial evidence again. I saw these tokens of a woman's

presence, heard what the boy had to say of the well-dressed lady who had sent him into the drugstore with a message to the police, and drew the conclusion, I may admit it to you, that it was this woman who had wielded the assassin's dagger, and not the deaf and dumb butler, who until now has borne the blame of it. Therefore I was anxious to find her, little realizing what would be the result of my efforts, or that I should have to proffer her my most humble apologies. Do not apologize to me. I had no business to be there, or at least to leave the five spangles you speak of behind me on Mr. Adams's miserable floor. i was simply passing by the house and had i been the woman i once was that is a woman who had never dipped into a mystery i should have continued on my way instead of turning aside sir it's a curious sensation to find yourself however innocent

regarded by a whole city full of people as the cause or motive of a terrible murder especially when you have spent some time as i have in the study of crime and the pursuit of criminals i own i don't enjoy the experience but i have brought it on myself if i had not been so curious but it was not curiosity i felt i will never own that i am subject to mere curiosity it was the look on the young man's face but i forget myself i am rambling in all directions when i ought to be telling a consecutive tale not my usual habit sir this you know but i am not quite myself at this moment i declare i am not quite myself at this moment i declare i am more upset by this discovery of my indiscretion than I was by Mr. Trom's declaration of affection in lost man's lane. Give me time, Mr. Grice, in a few minutes I will be more coherent. I am giving you time, he returned with one of his lowest bows. The half-dozen questions I long to ask have not yet left my lips, and I sit here as you must yourself acknowledge a monument of patience.

So you thought this deed perpetrated by an outsider, she suddenly broke in. Most of the journals, I read them very carefully this morning, ascribed the crime to the man you have mentioned. And there seems to be good reason for doing so. The case is not a simple one, Mr. Grice.

It has complications. I recognized that at once, and that is why. But I won't waste another moment in apology. You have a right to any little fact I may have picked up in my unfortunate visit, and there is one which I failed to find included in any account of the murder. Mr. Adams had other visitors besides myself in those few fatal minutes preceding his death. A young man and woman were with him. I saw them come out of the house.

It was at the moment I was passing. Tell your story more simply, Miss Butterworth. What first drew your answer? attention to the house. There, that is the second time you have had to remind me to be more direct. You will not have to do so again, Mr. Christ. To begin, then, I notice the house because I always notice it. I never pass it without giving a thought to its ancient history and indulging in more or less speculation as to its present inmates. When, therefore, I found myself in front of it yesterday afternoon on my way to the art exhibition, I naturally looked up, and, whether by an act of

providence or not, I cannot say, it was precisely at that instant the inner door of the vestibule burst open, and a young man appeared in the hall, carrying a young woman in his arms. He seemed to be in a state of intense excitement, and she in a dead faint. But before they had attracted the attention of the crowd, he had placed her on her feet, and taking her on his arm dragged her down the stoop and into the crowd of passers-by, among whom they presently disappeared. I, as you may believe, stood rooted to the ground in my astonishment, and not only endeavored to see in what direction they went,

but lingered long enough to take a peep into the time-honored interior of this old house, which had been left open to view by the young man's forgetting to close the front door behind him. as I did so I heard a cry from within. It was muffled and remote, but unmistakably one of terror and anguish, and led by an impulse I may live to regret, as it seems likely to plunge me into much unpleasantness, I rushed up the stoop and went in, shutting the door behind me, lest others should be induced to follow. So far I had acted solely from instinct, but once in that semi-dark hall I paused. and asked what business i had there and what excuse i should give for my intrusion if i encountered one or more of the occupants of the house but a repetition of the cry coming as i am ready to swear from the farthest room on the parlor floor

together with a sharp remembrance of the wandering eye and drawn countenance of the young man whom i had seen stagger hence a moment before with an almost fainting woman in his arms drew me on in spite of my feminine instincts, and before I knew it I was in the circular study and before the prostrate form of a seemingly dying man. He was lying, as you probably found him a little later, with a cross on his breast and a dagger in his heart, but his right hand was trembling, and when I stooped to lift his head, he gave a shudder and then settled into eternal stillness. I, a stranger from the street, had witnessed his last breath, while the young man who had gone out. Can you describe him? Did you encounter him close enough for recognition? Yes, I think I would know him again. I can at least describe his appearance.

He wore a checked suit, very natty, and was more than usually tall and fine looking. But his chief peculiarity lay in his expression. I never saw on any face, no not on the stage at the climax of the most heart-rending tragedy, a greater accumulation of mortal passion struggling with the imperative necessity for restraint. The young girl whose blonde head lay on his shoulder looked like a saint in the clutch of a demon. She had seen death, but he—but I prefer not to be the interpreter of that expressive countenance. It was lost to my view almost immediately, and probably calmed itself in the face of the throng he entered, or we would be hearing about him today. The girl seemed to be devoid of almost all feeling.

I should not remember her. And was that all? Did you just look at that recumbent man and vanish? Didn't you encounter the butler? Haven't you some definite knowledge to impart in his regard which will settle his innocence or fix his guilt? I know no more about him than you do, sir, except that he was was not in the room by the time I reached it, and did not come into it during my presence there. Yet it was his cry that led me to the spot, or do you think it was that of the bird I afterward

heard shouting and screaming in the cage over the dead man's head? It might have been the bird, admitted Mr. Grice, its call is very clear, and it seems strangely intelligent. What was it saying while you stood there? "'Something about Eva. "'Lovely Eva, maddening Eva. "'I love Eva, Eva, Eva, Eva! "'Eva? Wasn't it Evelyn? Poor Evelyn?' "'No, it was Eva.

"'I thought he might mean the girl I had just seen carried out. "'It was an unpleasant experience, hearing this bird shriek out these cries "'in the face of the man lying dead at my feet. "'Miss Butterworth, you didn't simply stand over it. that man you knelt down and looked in his face i acknowledge it and caught my dress in the filigree of the cross naturally i would not stand stock still with a man drawing his last breath under my eye and what else did you do you went to the table yes i went to the table and moved the inkstand yes i moved the inkstand but very carefully sir very carefully not so carefully but that i could see where it had been sitting before you took it up the square made by its base in the dust of the table did not coincide with the place afterwards occupied by it ah that comes from your having on your glasses and i not i endeavoured to set it down in the precise place from which i lifted it why did you take it up at all what were you looking for

for clues mr gryce you must forgive me but i was seeking for clues i moved several things i was hunting for the line of writing which ought to explain this murder the line of writing yes i have not told you what the young girl said as she slipped with her companion into the crowd no you have spoken of no words have you any such clue as that miss butterworth you are fortunate very fortunate mr gryce's look and gesture were eloquent but miss butterworth with an access of dignity quietly remarked i was not to blame for being in the way when they passed nor could i help hearing what she said and what was it madam did she mention a paper yes she cried in what i now remember to have been a tone of a fright you have left that line of writing behind i did not attach much importance to these words then but when i came upon the dying man so evidently the victim of murder i recalled what his late visitor had said and looked about for this piece of writing and did you find it miss butterworth i am ready as you see for any revelation you may now make for one which would reflect dishonour on me if i had found any paper explaining this tragedy i should have felt that you would reflect dishonour on me if i had found any paper explaining this tragedy i should have felt that bound to have called the attention of the police to it. I did notify them of the crime itself. Yes, madam, and we are obliged to you. But how about your silence in regard to the fact of two

persons having left that house immediately upon, or just preceding, the death of its master? I reserved that bit of information. I waited to see if the police would not get wind of these people without my help. I sincerely wish to keep my name out of this inquiry. Yet I feel a decided relief now that I have made my confession I never could have rested properly after seeing so much and, well, thinking my own thoughts in regard to what I saw, if I had felt myself compelled to bridle my tongue while false sense were being followed and delicate clues overlooked or discarded without proper attention i regard this murder as offering the most difficult problem that has ever come in my way and therefore yes madam i cannot but wonder if an opportunity has been afforded me for retrieving myself in your eyes i do not care for the opinion of any one else as to my ability or discretion but i should like to make you forget my last despicable failure in lost man's lane it is a sore remembrance to me mr gryce which nothing but a fresh success can make me forget

madam i understand you you have formulated some theory you consider the young man with the tell-tale face guilty of mr adams's death well it is very possible i never thought the butler was rehearsing a crime he had committed himself do you know who the young man is i saw leaving that house so hurriedly not the least in the world you are the first to bring him to my attention and the young girl with a blonde hair it is the first i have heard of her too i did not scatter the rose leaves that were found on that floor no it was she she probably wore a bouquet in her belt nor was that frippery parasol mine though i did lose a good stout serviceable one somewhere that day it was hers i have no doubt of it left by her in the little room where she was whiling away the time during which the gentleman conversed together possibly about that bit of writing she afterward alluded to certainly her mind was not expectant of evil for she was smoothing her hair when the shop came yes madam i follow you and had to be carried out of the place after what she had placed that cross on mr adams's breast that was a woman's act mr gryce i'm glad to hear you say so the placing of that cross on a layman's breast was a mystery to me, and is still I must own. Great remorse or great fright only can account for it. You will find many mysteries in this case, Mr. Grice.

As great a number as I ever encountered. I have to add one. Another? It concerns the old butler. I thought you did not see him. I did not see him in the room where Mr. Adams lay. Ah, where then? Upstairs. My interest was not confined to the scene of the murder. Wishing to spread the alarm and not being able to rouse anyone below, I crept upstairs, and so came upon this poor wretch, going through the significant pantomime that has been so vividly described in the papers. Ah, unpleasant for you very. I imagine you did not stop to talk to him. No, I fled. I was extremely shaken up by this time and knew only one thing to do, and that was to escape. But I carried one as yet unsolved enigma with me. How came I to hear this man's

cries in Mr. Adams's study, and yet find him on the second floor when I came to search the house? He had not time to mount the stairs while I was passing down the hall. It is a case of mistaken an impression. Your ears played you false. The cries came from above, not from Mr. Adams's study. My ears are not accustomed to play me tricks. You must seek another explanation. I have ransacked the house. There are no back stairs. If there were, the study does not communicate with them. And you heard his voice in the study? Plainly. Well, you have given me a poser, madam. and i will give you another if he was the perpetrator of this crime how comes it that he was not detected and denounced by the young people i saw going out

if on the contrary he was simply the witness of another man's blow a blow which horrified him so much that it unseated his reason how comes it that he was able to slide away from the door where he must have stood without attracting the attention and bringing down upon himself the vengeance of the guilty murderer. He may be one of the noiseless kind, or rather may have been such before this shock unsettled his mind. True, but he would have been seen. Recall the position of the doorway. If Mr. Adams fell where he was struck, the assailant must have had that door directly before him. He could not have helped seeing anyone standing in it. That is true. Your observations are quite correct, but those young people were in a disorrent. state of mind the condition in which they issued from the house proves this they probably did not trouble themselves about this man escape was all they sought and you see they did escape but you will find them a man who can locate a woman in this great city of ours with no other clue than five spangles dropped from her gown will certainly make this parasol tell the name of its owner ah madam the credit of this feat is now

not due to me. It was the initial stroke of a young man I proposed to adopt into my home and heart, the same who brought you here tonight. Not much to look at, madam, but promising, very promising. But I doubt if even he can discover the young lady you mean with no other aid than is given by this parasol. New York is a big place, ma'am, a big place. Do you know how sweetwater came to find you? Through your virtues, ma'am, through your neat and methodical habits had you been of a careless turn of mind and not given to mending your dresses when you tore them he might have worn his heart out in a vain search for the lady who had dropped the five spangles in mr adams's study now luck or rather your own commendable habit was in his favour this time but in the prospective search you mentioned he will probably have no such assistance nor will he need it i have unbounded faith in your genius which after all is back of the skilfulness of this new pupil of yours you will discover by some means the lady of the dove-coloured plumes and through her the young gentleman who accompanied her

we shall at least put our energies to work in that direction sweetwater may have an idea and i may have one you yes i indulged in but little sleep last night that dreadful room with its unsolved mystery was ever before me thoughts would come possibilities would suggest themselves i imagined myself probing its secrets to the bottom and wait madam how many of its so-called secrets do you know you said nothing about the lantern it was burning with a red light when i entered you did not touch the buttons arranged along the table-top no if there is one thing i do not touch it is anything which suggests an electrical contrivance i am intending to touch it is anything which suggests an electrical contrivance i am intending intensely feminines, sir, in all my instincts, and mechanisms of any kind alarm me. To all such things I give a wide birth. I have not even a telephone in my house. Some allowance must be made for the natural timidity of woman. Mr. Grice suppressed a smile. It is a pity, he remarked. Had you brought another light upon the scene, you might have been blessed with an idea on a subject that is as puzzling as any connected. with the whole affair.

You have not heard what I have to say on a still more important matter, said she. When we have exhausted the one topic we may both feel like turning on the fresh lights you speak of. Mr. Grice, on what does this mystery hinge? On the bit of writing which these young people were so alarmed at having left behind them? Ah, it is from that you would work. Well, it is a good point to start from, but we have found no such bit of writing. have you searched for it you did not know till now that any importance might be attached to a morsel of paper with some half-dozen words written on it true but a detective searches just the same we ransacked that room as few rooms have been ransacked in years not for a known clue but for an unknown one it seemed necessary in the first place to learn who this man was his papers were consequently examined but they told nothing but they told nothing but they told nothing but-theirmed it seemed necessary in the first place to learn who this man was his papers were consequently examined but they told nothing

if there had been a scrap of writing within view or in his desk it was not on his person you had his pocket searched his clothes a man who has died from violence is always searched madam i leave no stone unturned in a mysterious case like this miss butterworth's face assumed an indefinable expression of satisfaction which did not escape mr gryce's eye though that member was for fixed, according to his old habit, on the miniature of her father which she wore in defiance of fashion at her throat. "'I wonder,' said she, an amusing tone, if I imagined or really saw on Mr. Adams's face a most extraordinary expression, something more than the surprise or anguish following a mortal blow, a look of determination, arguing some superhuman resolve taken at the most moment of death, or, can you read that face for me? Or did you fail to perceive ought of what I say?

It would really be an aid to me at this moment to know. I noted that look. It was not a common one, but I cannot read it for you. I wonder if the young man you call Sweetwater can. I certainly think it has a decided bearing on this mystery, such a fold to the lips, such a look of mingled grief and—what was that, you said? Sweetwater has not been admitted to the room of death? Well, well, I shall have to make my own suggestion then. I shall have to part with an idea that may be totally valueless, but which has impressed me so that it must out if I am to have any peace to-night. Mr. Grice, allow me to whisper in your ear. Some things lose force when spoken aloud and leaning forward she breathed a short sentence into his ear which made him start and regard her with an amazement which rapidly grew into admiration

madam he cried rising up that he might the better honour her with one of his low bows your idea whether valueless or not is one which is worthy of the acute lady who proffers it we will act upon it ma'am at once wait till i have given my orders i will not not keep you long. And with another bow he left the room. End of Book 1, Chapter 6. Book 1, Chapter 7 of The Circular Study. This is a Librivox recording. All Librevox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librevox.org. The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green Chapter 7

Amos's son Miss Butterworth had been brought up in a strict school of manners When she sat, she sat still, when she moved, she moved quickly, firmly, but with no unnecessary disturbance. Fidgets were unknown to her, yet when she found herself alone after this interview, it was with difficulty she could restrain herself from indulging in some of those outward manifestations of uneasiness, which she had all her life reprobated in the more nervous members of her own sex. She was anxious and she showed it like the sensible woman she was,

and was glad enough when Mr. Grice finally returned, and, accosting her with a smile, said almost gaily, well that is seen too and all we have to do now is to await the result madam have you any further ideas if so i should be glad to have the benefit of them her self-possession was at once restored you would she repeated eyeing him somewhat doubtfully i should like to be assured of the value of the one i have already advanced before i venture upon another let us enter into a conference instead compare note tell for instance why neither of us look on Bartow as the guilty man i thought we had exhausted that topic your suspicions were aroused by the young couple you saw leaving the house while mine well madam to you at least i may admit that there is something in the mute's gestures and general manner which conveys to my mind the impression that he is engaged in rehearsing something he has seen rather than something he has done and as yet i have seen no reason for doubting the truth of this impression i was affected in the same way and would have been even if i had not already had my suspicions turned in another direction besides it is more natural for a man to be driven insane by another's act than by his own yes if he loved the victim and did not bartow he does not mourn mr adams but he is no longer master of his image emotions. Very true, but if we take any of his actions as a clue to the situation, we must take all. We believe from his gestures that he is giving us a literal copy of acts he has seen

performed. Then why pass over the gleam of infernal joy that lights his face after the whole is over? It is as if he rejoiced over the deed, or at least found immeasurable satisfaction in it. perhaps it is still a copy of what he saw the murderer may have rejoiced but no there was no joy in the face of the young man i saw rushing away from this scene of violence quite the contrary mr gryce we are in deep waters i feel myself well-nigh submerged by them hold up your head madam every flood has its ebb if you allow yourself to go under what will become of me you are disposed to humour mr gryce it is a good sign you are never humorous when perplexed somewhere you must see daylight let us proceed with our argument illumination frequently comes from the most unexpected quarter very well then let us put the old man's joy down as one of the mysteries to be explained later have you thought of him as a possible accomplice certainly but this supposition is open to the same objection as that which made him the motive power in this murder one is not driven insane by an expected horror it takes shock to unsettle the brain he was not looking for the death of his master true we may consider that matter as settled bartow was an innocent witness of this crime and having nothing to fear may be trusted to reproduce in his pantomimic action its exact features

very good continue madam nothing but profit is likely to follow an argument presented by miss butterworth the old detective's tone was serious his manner perfect but miss Butterworth ever on the lookout for sarcasm from his lips bridled a little, though in no other way did she show her displeasure. Let us then recall his precise gestures, remembering that he must have surprised the assailant from the study doorway, and so have seen the assault from over his master's shoulder. In other words, directly in front of him. Now what was his first move? His first move as, as a now seen is to raise his right arm and stretch it behind him while he leans forward for the imaginary dagger. What does that mean? I should find it hard to say, but I did not see him do that. When I came upon him he was thrusting with his left hand across his own body, a vicious

thrust and with his left hand. That is a point, Mr. Grice. Yes, especially as the doctors agree that Mr. Adams was killed by a left-handed blow. You don't say, don't you see the difficulty then? The difficulty, madam? Bartow was standing face to face with the assailant. In imitating him, especially in his unreasoning state of mind, he would lift the arm opposite to the one whose action he mimics, which in this case would be the assailant's right.

try for the moment to mimic my actions see i lift this hand and instinctively nay i detected the movement sir quickly as you remembered yourself you raise the one directly opposite to it it is like seeing yourself in a mirror you turn your head to the right but your image turns to the left mr gryce's laugh rang out in spite of himself he was not often caught napping but this woman exercised a species of fascination upon him at times, and it rather amused than offended him when he was obliged to acknowledge himself defeated. Very good, you have proved your point quite satisfactorily, but what conclusions are to be drawn from it, that the man was not left-handed, or that he was not standing in the place you have assigned to him? Shall we go against the doctors?

They say that the blow was a left-handed one. mr gryce i would give anything for an hour spent with you in mr adams's study with bartow free to move about at his will i think we should learn more by watching him for a short space of time than in talking as we are doing for an hour it was said tentatively almost timidly miss butterworth had some sense of the temerity involved in this suggestion even if according to her own declaration she had had some sense of the temerity involved in this suggestion even if according to her own declaration she had had had some sense of the temerity involved in this suggestion even if according to her own declaration she had no curiosity i don't want to be disagreeable she smiled she was so far from being so that mr gryce was taken unawares and for once in his life became impulsive i think it can be managed madam that is after the funeral there are too many officials now in the house and of course of course she exceeded i should not think of obtruding myself at present but the case is so interesting and my connection with it so peculiar that i sometimes forget myself do you think here she became quite nervous for one of her marked self-control that i have laid myself open to a summons from the coroner mr gryce grew thoughtful i'd the good lady or rather her folded hands with an air of some compassion and finally replied the facts regarding this affair come in so slowly that i doubt if the inquest is held for several days meanwhile we may light on those two young people ourselves if so the coroner may overlook your share in bringing them to our notice

there was a sly emphasis on the word and a subtle humour in his look that showed the old detective at his worst but miss butterworth did not resent it she was too full of a fresh confession she had to make ah said she if they had been the only persons i encountered there but they were not another person entered the house before i left it and i may be obliged to speak of him of him really madam you are a mind of intelligence yes sir was the meek reply meek when you consider from whose lips it came i ought to have spoken of him before but i never liked to mix matters and this old gentleman old gentleman yes sir very old and very much of a gentleman did not appear to have any connection with the crime beyond knowing the murdered man ah but that's a big connection ma'am to find some one who knew mr adams really madam patience has its limits and i must press you to speak oh i will speak the time has come for it besides i am quite ready to discuss this new theme it is very interesting suppose we begin then by a detailed account of your adventures in this house of death drily suggested the detective your full adventures with your full adventures madam with your full adventures with your adam with nothing left out i appreciate the sarcasm but nothing has been left out except what i am about to relate to you it happened just as i was leaving the house what did i hate to ask you to be more explicit but in the interests of justice you are quite right as i was going out then i encountered an elderly gentleman coming in his hand had just touched the bell-handle you will acknowledge that it was a perplexing moment for me

his face which was well preserved for his years wore an air of expectation that was almost gay he glanced in astonishment at mine which whatever its usual serenity certainly must have borne marks of deep emotion neither of us spoke at last he inquired politely if he might enter and said something about having an appointment with some one in the study at which i stepped briskly enough aside i assure you for this might mean what did you say did i closed the door i assuredly did was i to let the whole of blank street into the horrors of this house at a moment when a poor old man no i didn't go out myself why should i was i was i to let the whole of blank street into the horrors of this house at a moment when a poor old man no i didn't go out myself why should i was i was i was i was i to leave a man on the verge of eighty excuse me not every man of eighty is so hale and vigorous as yourself to enter such a scene alone besides i had not warned him of the condition of the only other living occupant of the house discreet very quite what was to be expected of you miss butterworth more than that you followed him no doubt with careful supervision down the hall most certainly what would you have thought of me if i had not he was in a strange house there was no servant to guide him he wanted to know the way to the study and i politely showed him there kind of you madam very it must have been an interesting moment to you very interesting too interesting i own that i am not made entirely of steel sir and the shock he received at finding a dead man awaiting him rather than a live one was more or less communicated to me yet i stood my ground admirable i could have done no better myself and so this man who had an appointment with mr adams was shocked really shocked at finding him lying there under a cross dead

Yes, there was no doubting that. Shocked, surprised, terrified, and something more. It is that something more which has proved my perplexity. I cannot make it out, not even in thinking it over. Was it the fascination which all horrible sights exert on the morbid, or was it a sudden realization of some danger he had escaped or of some difficulty yet awaiting him? Hard to say, Mr. Grice, hard to say,

but you may take my word for it that there was more to him in this meeting than an unexpected stumbling upon a dead man where he expected to find a live one yet he made no sound after that first cry and hardly any movement he just stared at the figure on the floor than at his face which he seemed to devour at first with curiosity then with hate then with terror and lastly how can i express myself with a sort of hellish humour that in another moment might have broken into something like a laugh if the bird which i had failed to observe up to this moment had not waked in its high cage and thrusting its beak between the bars shrilled out in the most alarming of tones remember evelyn that startled the old man even more than the sight on the floor had done he turned round and i saw it his fist rise as if against some menacing intruder, but it quickly fell again as his eyes encountered the picture which hung before him, and with a cringe painful to see in one of his years, he sidled back till he reached the doorway. Here he paused a minute to give another look at the man outstretched at his feet, and I heard him say, It is Amos's son, not Amos. Is it fatality, or did he

plan this meeting, thinking. But here he caught sight of my figure in the antechamber beyond, and resuming in an instant his former debonair manner, he bowed very low and opened his lips as if about to ask a question. But he evidently thought better of it, for he strode by me and made his way to the front door without a word. Being an intruder myself I did not like to stop him, but I am sorry now for the consideration I showed him, for just before he stepped out, his emotion, the special character of which I own to you I find impossible to understand, culminated in a burst of raucous laughter, which added the final horror to this amazing adventure. Then he went out, and in the last glimpse I had of him before the door shut,

he wore the same look of easy self-satisfaction with which he had entered this place of death some fifteen minutes before remarkable some secret history there that man must be found he can throw light upon mr adams's past amos's son he called him who is amos mr adams's name was felix felix the son of amos perhaps this connection of names may lead to something it is not a common one and if given to the papers may result in our receiving a clue to a mystery which seems impenetrable your stay in mr adams's house was quite productive ma'am did you prolong it after the departure of this old man no sir i had had my fill of the mysterious and left immediately after him ashamed of the spirit of investigation which had led me to enter the house i made a street boy the medium of my communication to the police and would have been glad if i could have so escaped all responsibility in the matter but the irony of fate follows me as it does others a clue was left of my presence which involves me in this affair whether i will or no was the hand of providence in this perhaps the future will tell and now mr gryce since my budget is quite empty and the hour late i will take my leave if you hear from that bit of paper if i hear from it in the way you suggest i will let you know it will be the least i can do for a lady who has done so much for me now you flatter me proof positive that i have stayed a minute longer than was judicious good evening Mr. Grice. What, I have not stayed too long? You have something else to ask? Yes, and this time it is

concerning a matter personal to yourself. May I inquire if you wore the same bonnet yesterday that you do today? No, sir. I know you have a good reason for this question and so will not express my surprise. Yesterday I was in reception costume and my bonnet was a jet one. With long strings, tied under the chin? No, sir, short strings. Long strings are no longer the fashion. But you wore something which fell from your neck? Yes, a boa, a feather boa. How came you to know it, sir? Did I leave my image in one of the mirrors? Hardly. If so I should not have expected it to speak. You merely wrote the fact on the study tabletop, or so I have dared to think. you or the young lady did she wear ribbons or streamers too that i cannot say her face was all i saw and the skirt of a dove-coloured silk dress

then you must settle the question for me in this way if on the tips of that boa of yours you find the faintest evidence of its having been dipped in blood i shall know that the streaks found on the top of the table i speak of were evidences of your presence there. But if your boa is clean or was not long enough to touch that dying man as you leaned over him, then we have proof that the young lady with the dove-colored plumes fingered that table also instead of falling at once into the condition in which you saw her carried out. I fear that it is my boa which will tell the tale another proof of the fallibility of man or rather woman, in secret search for clues I left behind me traces of my own presence. I feel really mortified, sir, and you have quite the advantage of me. And with this show of humility, which may not have been entirely sincere, this estimable lady took her departure. Did Mr. Grice suffer from any qualms of

conscience at having elicited so much and imparted so little? i doubt it mr gryce's conscience was quite seared in certain places end of book one chapter seven book one chapter eight of the circular study this is a librivox recording all librivox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit librivox dot org the circular study by anna catherine green chapter eight in the round of the staircase the next morning mr gryce received a small communication from miss butterworth at or near the very time she received one from him hers ran you were quite correct so far as appears i was the only person to lean over mr adams's study-table after his unfortunate death i have had to clip the end of the end of my own person to lean over mr adams's study-table after his unfortunate death i have had to clip the ends of my boa his was equally laconic my compliments madam mr adams's jaws have been forced apart a small piece of paper was found clinched between his teeth this paper has been recovered and will be read at the inquest perhaps a few favoured persons may be granted the opportunity of reading it before then notably yourself of the two letters the latter naturally occasioned the greater excitement in the recipient the complacency of miss butterworth was superb and being the result of something that could not be communicated to those about her occasioned in the household much speculation as to its cause

at police headquarters more than one man was kept busy listening to the idle tales of a crowd of would-be informers the result which had failed to fall to fall to followers the result which had failed to fall to fall the first day's publication of the crime came rapidly in during the second there were innumerable persons of all ages and conditions who were ready to tell how they had seen this and that one issue from mr adams's house on the afternoon of his death but when asked to give a description of these persons lost themselves in generalities as tedious as they were unprofitable one garrulous old woman had observed a lady of genteel appearance appearance, open the door to an elderly gentleman in a great-coat, and a fashionably dressed young woman came in all breathless to relate how a young man with a very pale young lady on his arm ran against her as she was going by this house, at the very hour Mr. Adams was said to have been murdered. She could not be sure of knowing the young man again, and could not say if the young lady was blonde or brunette, only that she was awfully pale and had to be sure of knowing the young man again, and could not say if the young lady was blonde or brunette, only that she was awfully pale and

had a beautiful gray feather in her hat others were ready with similar stories which confirmed without adding to the facts already known and night came on without much progress having been made toward the unraveling of this formidable mystery on the next day mr adams's funeral took place no relatives or intimate friends having come forward his landlord attended to these rights and his banker acted the part of chief mourner. As his body was carried out of the house, a half-dozen detectives mingled with the crowd blocking the thoroughfare in front, but nothing came of their surveillance here or at the cemetery to which the remains were speedily carried. The problem which had been presented to the police had to be worked out from such material as had already come to hand, and in forcible recognition of this fact, Mr. Grice excused himself one evening at headquarters and proceeded quite alone and on foot to the dark and apparently closed house in which the tragedy had occurred.

He entered with a key, and once inside proceeded to light up the whole house. This done he took a look at the study, saw that the cross had been replaced on the wall, the bird cage re-hung on its hook under the ceiling, and everything put in its wonted order, with the exception of the broken casings which still yawned in a state of disrepair on either side of the doorway leading into the study. The steel plate had been shoved back into the place prepared for it by Mr. Adams, but the glimpses still to be seen of its blue surface through the hole made in the wall of the ante-chamber formed anything but an attractive feature in the scene, and Mr. Grice, with something of the instinct

and much of the deftness of a housewife, proceeded to pull a couple of rugs from the parlor floor and string them over these openings. Then he consulted his watch, and finding that it was within an hour of nine o'clock, took up his stand behind the curtains of the parlor window. Soon, for the person expected was as prompt as he, himself he saw a carriage stop and a lady alight and he hastened to the front door to receive her it was miss butterworth madam your punctuality is equal to my own said he have you ordered your coachman to drive away

only as far as the corner she returned as she followed him down the hall there he will await the call of your whistle nothing could be better are you afraid to remain for a moment alone while i watch from the window the window the arrival of the other persons we expect? At present there is no one in the house but ourselves. If I was subject to fear in a matter of this kind, I should not be here at all. Besides, the house is very cheerfully lighted. I see you have chosen a crimson light for illuminating the study. Because a crimson light was burning when Mr. Adams died. Remember Evelyn, called out a voice. Oh, you have brought back the bird, exclaiming. named Miss Butterworth. That is not the cry with which it greeted me before. It was Eva, lovely Eva. Do you suppose Eva and Evelyn are the same?

Madam, we have so many riddles before us that we will let this one go for the present. I expect Mr. Adams's valet here in a moment. Sir, you relieve me of an immense weight. I was afraid that the privilege of being present at the test you proposed to make was not to be accorded me miss butterworth you have earned a seat at this experiment bartow has been given a key and will enter as of old in entire freedom to do as he wills we have simply to watch his movements in this room sir i do not think i shall like that i had rather not meet this madman face to face you will not be called upon to do so we do not wish him to be startled by encounter any watchful eye, irresponsible as he is, he must be allowed to move about without anything to distract his attention. Nothing must stand in the way of his following those impulses, which may yield us a clue to his habits and the ways of this peculiar household. I propose to place you where the chances are least in favour of you being seen by him.

In this parlour, madam, which we have every reason to believe was seldom open during Mr. adams's lifetime you must put out the gas then or the unaccustomed light will attract his attention i will not only put out the gas but i will draw the portier's close making this little hole for your eye and this one for mine a common expedient madam but serviceable madam serviceable the snort which miss butterworth gave as she thus found herself drawn up in darkness before a curtain in company with this plausible old man, but feebly conveyed her sensations which were naturally complex and a little puzzling to herself. Had she been the possessor of a lively curiosity, but we know from her own lips that she was not, she might have found some enjoyment in the situation, but being where she was solely from a sense of duty, she probably blushed behind her screen at the position in which she found herself in the cause of truth and justice, or would have

done so if the opening of the front door at that moment had not told her that the critical moment had arrived and that the deaf and dumb valet had just been introduced into the house. The faintest hush from Mr. Grice warned her that her surmise was correct, and bending her every energy to listen, she watched for the expected appearance of this man in the antechamber of Mr. Adams's former study. He came even sooner than she was prepared to see him, and, laying down his hat on a table near the doorway, advanced with a busy air toward the portire he had doubtless been in the habit of lifting twenty times a day. But he barely touched it this time. Something seen or unseen prevented him from entering. Was it the memory

of what he had last beheld there? Or had he noticed that? Or had he noticed that? He didn't. He was the rugs hanging in an unaccustomed way on either side of the damaged casings neither apparently for he simply turned away with a meek look wholly mechanical and taking up his hat again left the ante-chamber and proceeded softly upstairs i will follow him whispered mr gryce don't be afraid ma'am this whistle will bring a man in from the street at once i am not afraid i would be ashamed but it was useless for her to finish this disclaimer mr gryce was already in the hall he returned speedily and saying that the experiment was likely to be a failure as the old man had gone to his own room and was preparing himself for bed he led the way into the study and with purpose or without a purpose who knows idly touched a button on the table-top thus throwing a new light on the scene it was miss butterworth's first experience of this change of light and she was observing the effect made by the violet glow now thrown over the picture and the other rich articles in the room when her admiration was cut short and mr gryce's half-uttered remark also by the faint sound of the valet's descending steps. Indeed, they had barely time to regain their old position behind the parlor portiers when Bartow was seen hurrying in from the hall with his former busy air, which this

time remained unchecked. Crossing to his master's study, he paused for an infinitesimal length of time on the threshold, as if conscious of something being amiss, then went into the room beyond, and without a glance in the direction of the rug, which had been carefully relayed on the spot where his master had fallen, began to make such arrangements for the night as he was in the habit of making at this hour. He brought a bottle of wine from the cupboard and set it on the table, and then a glass, which he first wiped scrupulously clean. Then he took out his master's dressing-gown and slippers, and placing them to hand, went into the bedroom. By this time, the two watchers had crept from their concealment near enough to note what he was doing in the bedroom.

He was stooping over the comb which Mr. Grice had left lying on the floor. The small object in such a place seemed to surprise him. He took it up, shook his head, and put it back on the dresser. Then he turned down his master's bed. Poor fool, murmured Miss Butterworth, as she and her companion crept back to their old place behind the parlor curtains he has forgotten everything but his old routine duties we shall get nothing from this man but she stopped suddenly they both stopped bartow was in the middle of the study with his eyes fixed on his master's empty chair in an inquiring way that spoke volumes then he turned and gazed earnestly at the rug where he had last seen that master lying outstretched and breathless and and awakening to a realization of what had happened fell into his most violent self and proceeded to go through the series of actions which they were now bound to consider a reproduction of what he had previously seen take place there

then he went softly out and crept away upstairs mr gryce and miss butterworth stepped at once into the light and surveyed each other with a look of marked discouragement then the latter with a sudden gleam of enthusiasm cried quickly turn on another color and let us see what will happen i have an idea it will fetch the old man down again mr gryce's brows went up do you think he can see through the floor but he touched a button and a rich blue took the place of the violet nothing happened miss butterworth looked disturbed i have confidence in your theories began mr gryce but when they imply the possibility of this man seeing through blank walls and obeying signals which can have no significance to any one on the floor above hark she cried holding up one finger with a triumphant air the old man's steps could be heard descending this time he approached with considerable feebleness passed slowly into the study advanced to the table and reached out his hands as if to lift something which he expected to find there seeing nothing he glanced in astonishment up at the bookshelves and then back to the table shook his head and suddenly collapsing sank in a doze on the nearest chair miss butterworth drew a long breath eyed mr gryce with some curiosity and then triumphantly exclaimed can you read the meaning of all the last breath-eyed mr gryce with some curiosity and then triumphantly exclaimed Can you read the meaning of all that?

I think I can. Don't you see that he came expecting to find a pile of books on the table, which it was probably his business to restore to their shelves? But how can he know what light is burning here? You can see for yourself that there is no possible communication between this room and the one in which he has always been found by any one going above. Miss Butterworth's manner showed a hesitation that was almost naive. she smiled and there was apology in her smile though none in her voice as she remarked with odd breaks when i was upstairs you know i went upstairs when i was here before i saw a little thing a very little thing

which you doubtless observed yourself and which may explain though i do not know how why bartow can perceive these lights from the floor above i shall be very glad to hear about it madam i thought i had thoroughly searched those rooms and the halls and the halls and that nothing in them could have escaped my eyes but if you have a more patient vision than myself or make it my business to look lower how to look lower to look on the floor say on the floor the floor sometimes reveals much shows where a person steps the oftenest and therefore where he has the most business you must have noticed how marred the woodwork is at the edge of the carpeting on that little landing above in the round of the staircase yes mr gryce did not think it worth his while to answer perhaps he had not time for leaving the valet where he was and miss butterworth where she was only she would not be left but followed him he made his way upstairs and paused at the place she had mentioned with a curious look at the floor you see it has been much troddened here she said at which gentle reminder of her presence he gave a start. Possibly he had not heard her behind him, and after sixty years of hard service, even a detective may be excused a slight nervousness. Now, why should it be

trodden here? There is no apparent reason why anyone should shuffle to and fro in this corner. The stair is wide, especially here, and there is no window. Mr. Grice, whose eye had been traveling over the wall, reached over her shoulder to one of the dozen pictures hanging at intervals from the bottom to the top of the staircase, and pulling it away from the wall, on which it hung decidedly askew, revealed a round opening through which poured a ray of blue light which could only proceed from the vault of the adjoining study. No window, he repeated, no, but an opening into the study wall which answers the same purpose. Miss Butterworth, your eye is to be trusted every time. I only wonder you did not pull this picture aside yourself. It was not hanging crooked then.

Besides, I was in a hurry. I had just come from my encounter with this demented man. I had noticed the marks on the landing and the worn edges of the carpet on my way upstairs. I was in no condition to observe them on my way down. I see. Miss Butterworth ran her foot to and fro over the flooring they were examining. Bartow was evidently in the habit of coming here constantly, said she, probably to learn whether his master had need of him. Ingenious in Mr. Adams to contrive signals for communication with this man, he certainly had great use for his deaf and dumb servant, so one mystery is solved. and if I am not mistaken we can by a glance through this loophole obtain the answer to another you are wondering I believe how Bartow if he followed the movements of the assailant from the doorway came to thrust with his left hand instead of his right

now if he saw the tragedy from this point he saw it over the assailant's shoulder instead of face to face what follows he would imitate literally the movements of the man he he saw turn in the same direction and strike with the same hand mr gryce we are beginning to untangle the threads that looked so complicated ah what is that why it's that bird his cage must be very nearly under this hole a little to one side madam but near enough to give you a start what was it he cried then oh those sympathetic words about eva poor eva well give a glance to bartow you can see him very well from here miss butterworth put her eye again to the opening and gave a grunt a very decided grunt with her a grunt was significant of surprise he is shaking his fist he is all alive with passion he looks as if he would like to kill the bird perhaps that is why the creature was strung up so high you may be sure mr adams had some basis for his idiosyncrasies i begin to think so i don't know that i care to go back where that man is he has a very murderous look and a very feeble arm miss butterworth you are safe under my protection my arm my arm is not feeble. End of Book 1, Chapter 8.

Book 1, Chapter 9 of The Circular Study. This is a Librivox recording. All Libravox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librivox.org. The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green. Chapter 9, High and Low. At the foot of the stairs, Mr. Grice excused himself, and, calling in two or three men whom he had left outside, had the valet removed before taking Miss Butterworth back into the study. When all was quiet again and they found an opportunity to speak, Mr. Grice remarked,

one very important thing has been settled by the experiment we have just made. Bartow is acquitted of participation in this crime. Then we can give our full-efficient. attention to the young people. You have heard nothing from them, I suppose. No. Nor from the old man who laughed? No. Miss Butterworth looked disappointed. I thought, it seemed very probable, that the scrap of writing you found would inform you who these were. If it was important enough for the dying man to try to swallow it, it certainly should give some clue to his assailant. "'Unfortunately it does not do so. "'It was a veritable scrawl, madam, running something like this. "'I return your daughter to you. "'She is here.

"'Neither she nor you will ever see me again. "'Remember Evelyn,' and signed, Amos's son. "'Aimus's son? "'That is Mr. Adams himself. "'So we have every reason to believe.' "'Strange, unaccountable. "'And the paper in the same.' inscribed with these words was found clinched between his teeth. Was the handwriting recognized?

Yes, as his own, if we can judge from the specimens we have seen of his signature on the fly-leaves of his books. Well, mysteries deepened, and the retaining of this paper was so important to him that even in his death-throw, he thrust it in this strangest of all hiding-places, as being the only one that could be considered safe from search. and the girl her first words on coming to herself were you have left that line of writing behind mr gryce those words few and inexplicable as they are contain the key to the whole situation will you repeat them again if you please sentence by sentence with pleasure madam i've said them often enough to myself first then i return your daughter to you so mr adams had some one's daughter in charge whom he returns whose daughter not that young man's daughter certainly for that would necessitate her being a small child besides if these words had been meant for his assailant why make so remarkable an effort to hide them from him very true i have said the same thing myself yet if not for him for whom then for the old gentleman who came in later it is possible since hearing of him i have allowed myself to regard this as among the possibilities especially as the next words of this strange communication are she is here

now the only woman who was there a few minutes previous to this old gentleman's visit was the light-haired girl whom you saw carried out very true but why do you reason as if this paper had just been written it might have been an old scrap referring to past sorrow or secrets these words were written that afternoon the paper on which they were scrawled was torn from a sheet of letter-paper lying on the desk and the pen with which they were inscribed you must have noticed where it lay quite out of its natural place on the extreme edge of the table certainly sir but i had little idea of the significance we might come to attach to it these words are connected then with the girl i saw and she is is not evelyn or he would not have repeated in this note the bird's catch word remember evelyn i wonder if she is evelyn proceeded miss butterworth pointing to the one large picture which adorned the wall we may call her so for the nonce so melancholy a face may well suggest some painful family secret but how explain the violent part played by the young man who is not mentioned in these abrupt and hastily penned sentences. It is all a mystery, madam, a mystery which we are wasting time to attempt to solve. Yet I hate to give it up without an effort. Those words now, there were some other words you have not repeated to me. They came before that injunction, remember Evelyn. They bespoke a resolve.

Neither she nor you will ever see me again. Ah, but these few words are very significant, Mr. Grice. could he have dealt that blow himself may he have been a suicide after all madam you have the right to inquire but from bartow's pantomime you must have perceived it is not a self-inflicted blow he mimics but a maddened thrust from an outraged hand let us keep to our first conclusions only to be fair to every possibility the condition of mr adams's affairs and the absence of all family papers and such documents as may usually be found in a wealthy man's desk prove that he had made some preparation for possible death it may have come sooner than he expected and in another way but it was a thought he had indulged in and madam i have a confession to make also i have not been quite fair to my most valued colleague the study that most remarkable of rooms contains a secret which has not been imparted to you a very peculiar one madam which was revealed to me in a rather startling manner this room can be or rather could be cut off entirely from the rest of the house made a death-trap of or rather a tomb in which this incomprehensible man may have intended to die look at this plate of steel it is worked by a mechanism which forces it across this open doorway i was behind that plate of steel the other night and these holes had to be made to let me out ha you detectives have your experiences i should not have enjoyed spending that a special evening with you but what an old-world tragedy we are unearthing here i declare

and the good lady actually rubbed her eyes i feel as if transported back to medieval days who says we are living in new york with the sound of the cable car and the singing of the telegraph wire some men are perfectly capable of bringing the medieval into wall street i think mr adams was one of those men romanticism tinged all his acts even the death he died nor did it cease with his death it followed him to the tomb witness the cross we found lying on his bosom that was the act of another's hand the result of another's superstition that shows the presence of a priest or a woman at the moment he died yet proceeded mr gryce with a somewhat wondering air he must have had a grain of hard sense in his make-up all his contrivances worked he was a mechanical genius as well as a lover of mystery an odd combination strange that we do not feel his spirit infecting the very air of this study i could almost wish it did we might then be led to grasp the key to this mystery that remarked mr gryce can be done in only one way you have already pointed it out we must trace the young couple who were present at his death struggle if they cannot be found the case is hopeless and so said she we come round to the point from which we started proof positive that we are lost in the woods and miss butterworth rose she felt that for the time being she at least had come to the end of her resources mr gryce did not seek to detain her indeed he appeared to be anxious to leave the place himself they however stopped long enough to cast one final look around them as they did so miss butterworth's finger slowly rose

see said she you can hardly perceive from this side of the wall the opening made by the removal of that picture on the stair landing wouldn't you say that it was in the midst of those folds of dark colored tapestry up there? Yes, I had already located that spot as the one. With a picture hung up on the other side, it would be quite invisible. One needs to keep one's eyes moving in a case like this. That picture must have been drawn aside several times while we were in this room, yet we failed to notice it. That was from not looking high enough. High and low, Mr. Grice. What goes on at the level of the eye is apparent to everyone. the smile with which he acknowledged this parting shot and prepared to escort her to the door had less of irony than sadness in it was he beginning to realize that years tell even on the most sagacious and that neither high places nor low would have escaped his attention a dozen years before end of book one chapter nine book one chapter ten of the circuit ten of the circuit

study this is a librivox recording all librivox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit librivox dot org the circular study by anna catherine green chapter ten bride roses a blonde you say sir yes sweetwater not of the usual type but one of those frail ethereal creatures whom we find it so hard to associate with crime. He, on the contrary, according to Miss Butterworth's description, and her descriptions may be relied upon, is one of those gentlemanly athletes whose towering heads and powerful figures attract universal attention. Seen together you would be apt to know them, but what reason have we for thinking they will be found together? How are they dressed? Like people of fashion and respectability. He wore a brown-checked suit apparently fresh from the tailor, she, a dove-colored dress with white trimmings. The parasol shows the color of her hat and plumes.

Both were young, and, still according to Miss Butterworth, of sensitive temperament and unused to crime, for she was in a fainting condition when carried from the house, and he, with every inducement to self-restraint, showed himself the victim of such powerful emotion that, he would have been immediately surrounded and questioned if he had not set his burdened down in the vestibule and at once plunged with the girl into the passing crowd do you think you can find them sweetwater have you no clues to their identity beyond this parasol none sweetwater if you accept these few faded rose-leaves picked up from the floor of mr adams's study then you have given me a problem mr gryce remarked the young detective dubiously as he eyed the parasol held out to him and let the rose-leaves drop carelessly through his fingers somehow i do not feel the same assurances of success that i did before perhaps i more fully realize the difficulties of any such quest now that i see how much rests upon chance in these matters if miss butterworth had not been a precise woman i should have failed in my former attempt as i am likely to fail in this one but i will make another effort to locate the owner of this parasol if only to learn my business by failure and now sir where do you think i am going first to a florist's with these faded rose-leaves just because every other young fellow on the force would make a start from the parasol i'm going to try and effect one from these rose-leaves i may be an egotist but i cannot help that i can do nothing with the parasol

and what do you hope to do with the rose-leaves how can a florist help you in finding this young woman by means of them he may be able to say from what kind of a florist's to say from what kind of a florist's a florist's woman by means of them he may be able to say from what kind of a rose they fell, and once I know that, I may succeed in discovering the particular store from which the bouquet was sold to this more or less conspicuous couple. You may. I am not the man to throw cold water on anyone's schemes. Every man has his own methods, and till they are proved valueless, I say nothing. Young Sweetwater, who was now all nerve enthusiasm and hope, bowed he was satisfied to be allowed to work in his own way i may be back in an hour and you may not see me for a week he remarked on leaving luck to your search was the short reply this ended the interview in a few minutes more sweetwater was off the hour passed he did not come back the day and still no sweetwater another day went by and livened only by an interchangeable of notes between Mr. Grice and Miss Butterworth. Hers was read by the old detective with a smile,

perhaps because it was so terse, perhaps because it was so characteristic. Dear Mr. Grice, I do not presume to dictate or even to offer a suggestion to the New York police, but have you inquired of the postman in a certain district whether he can recall the postmark on any of the letters he delivered to Mr. Adams? A. B. his on the contrary was perused with a frown by his exacting colleague in grammarcy park the reason is obvious dear miss butterworth suggestions are always in order and even dictation can be endured from you the postman delivers too many letters on that block to concern himself with postmarks sorry to close another thoroughfare e g meanwhile the anxiety of both was great that of mr gryce excessive he was consequently much relieved when on the third morning he found sweetwater awaiting him at the office with a satisfied smile lighting up his plain features he had reserved his story for his special patron and as soon as they were closeted together he turned with beaming eyes toward the old detective crying news sir good news i have found them

I have found them both, and by such a happy stroke. It was a blind trail, but when the florists said that those petals might have fallen from a bride-rose—well, sir, I know that any woman can carry bride-roses, but when I remembered that the clothes of her companion looked as though they had just come from the tailors and that she wore grey and white, Wyatt gave me an idea, and I began my search after this unknown pair at the Bureau of Vital Statistics. "'Brillient,' ejaculated the old detective. "'That is, if the thing worked.' "'And it did, sir, it did. "'I may have been born under a lucky star, probably was, "'but once started on this line of search,

"'I went straight to the end. "'Shall I tell you how? "'Hunting through the list of persons "'as had been married within the city limits "'during the last two weeks, "'I came upon the name of one Eva Poindexter. "'Iva, that was a name well-known, in the house on blank street, I decided to follow up this Eva.

A wise conclusion, and how did you set about it? Why, I went directly to the clergyman who had performed the ceremony. He was a kind and affable domine, sir, and I had no trouble in talking to him. And you described the bride? No, I led the conversation so that he described her. Good, and what kind of a woman did he make her out to be? delicate pale sir he had not read the service for so lovely a bride in years very slight almost fragile but beautiful and with a delicate bloom which showed her to be in better health than one would judge from her dainty figure it was a private wedding sir celebrated in a hotel parlor but her father was with her her father mr gryce's theory received its first shock

then the old man who had laughed on leaving mr adams's house was not the father to whom those few lines in mr adams's handwriting were addressed or this young woman was not the person referred to in those lines is there anything wrong about that inquired sweetwater mr gryce became impassive again no i had not expected his attendance at the wedding that is all sorry sir but there is no doubt about his having been there the bridegroom yes tell me about the bridegroom was the very man you described to me as leaving mr adams's house with her tall finely developed with a grand air and gentlemanly manners even his clothes correspond with what you told me to expect a checked suit brown in color and of the latest cut oh he is the man mr gryce with a suddenly developed interest in the lid of his inkstand recalled the lines which mr adams had written immediately before his death and found himself wholly at sea how reconcile fact so diametrically opposed what allusion could there be in these lines to the new-made bride of another man they read rather as if she were his own bride as witness i return your daughter to you she is here neither she nor you will ever see me again remember evelyn amos's son there must be something wrong sweetwater must have been led astray by a series of extraordinary coincidences dropping the lid of the inkstand in a way to make the young man smile he looked up i'm afraid it's been a fool chase sweetwater the facts you relate in regard to this couple the fact of their having been married at all tally so little with what we have been led to expect from certain other evidences which have come in

pardon me sir but will you hear me out at the imperial where they were married i learned that the father and daughter had registered as coming from a small place in pennsylvania but i could learn nothing in regard to the bridegroom he had not appeared on the scene till the time for the ceremony and after the marriage was seen to take his bride away in one carriage while the old gentleman departed in another the latter concerned me little it was the young couple i had been detailed to find employing the usual means of search i tracked them to the waldorf where i learned what makes it certain that i have been following the right couple on the afternoon of the very day of mr adams's death this young husband and wife left the hotel on foot and did not come back their clothes which had all been left behind were taken away two days later by an elderly gentleman who said he was her father and whose appearance coincides with that of the person registering as such at the imperial all of which looks favourable to my theory does it not especially when you remember that the bridegroom's name you have not told it is adams thomas adams same family as the murdered man you see at least he has the same name mr gryce surveyed the young man with admiration but was not yet disposed to yield him entire credence humph i do not wonder you thought it worth your while to follow up the pair if one of them is named adams and the other eva but sweetwater the longer you serve on the force the more you will learn that coincidences as strange and unexpected as these do occur at times and must be taken into account in the elucidation of a difficult problem much as i may regret to throw cold water on your hopes there are reasons for believing that the young man and woman whom we are seeking are not the ones you have busied yourself about for the last two days

certain facts which have come to light would seem to show that if she had a husband at all his name would not be thomas adams but felix and as the facts i have to bring forward are most most most direct and unimpeachable, I fear you will have to start again and on a new tack. But Sweetwater remained unshaken and eyed his superior with a vague smile playing about his lips. You have not asked me, sir, where I spent all the time which has elapsed since I saw you last. The investigations I have mentioned did not absorb more than a day. Very true. Where have you been, Sweetwater? to Montgomery, sir, to that small town in Pennsylvania from which Mr. Poindexter and his daughter registered. Ah, I see, and what did you learn there? Something directly to the point?

I learned this, that John Poindexter, father of Eva, had for a friend in early life one Amos Cadwallader. Amos? repeated Mr. Grice with an odd look. Yes, and that this Amos had a son. son, Felix. Ah, you see, sir, we must be on the right track. Coincidences cannot extend through half a dozen names. You are right, it is I who have made a mistake in drawing my conclusions too readily. Let us hear about this Amos, you gathered something of his history, no doubt. All that was possible, sir, it is closely woven in with that of Poindexter and presents one feature which may occasion you no surprise, but which I own came near non-plusing me.

Though the father of Felix his name was not Adams, I say was not, for he has been dead six months. It was Cadwallader, and Felix went by the name of Cadwallader, too, in the early days of which I have to tell, he and a sister whose name, well, was Evelyn. Sweetwater, you are an admirable fellow, so the mystery as ours. The history, not the mystery, that still holds. Shall I relate what I know of those two families? At once, I am as anxious as if I were again twenty-three and had been in your shoes instead of my own for the last three days. Very well, sir. John Poindexter and Amoskadar were in their early life bosom friends. They had come from Scotland together and settled in Montgomery in the 30s. Both married there, but john poindexter was a prosperous man from the first while cadwallader had little ability to support a family and was on the verge of bankruptcy when the war of the rebellion broke out and he enlisted as a soldier

poindexter remained at home caring for his own family and for the two children of cadwallader whom he took into his own house i say his own family but he had no family save a wife up to the spring of eighty then a daughter was born to him the eva who has just married thomas adams cadwallader who was fitted for army life rose to be a captain but he was unfortunately taken prisoner at one of the late battles and confined in liby prison where he suffered the tortures of the damned till he was released in eighteen sixty five by a forced exchange of prisoners broken old and crushed he returned home and no one living in the town at that time will ever forget the day he alighted from the cars and took his way up the main street for not having been fortunate enough or unfortunate enough perhaps to receive any communication from home he advanced with a cheerful haste not knowing that his only daughter then lay dead in his friend's house and that it was for her funeral that the people were collecting in the green square at the end of the street he was so pale broken and decrepit that few knew him but there was one old neighbor who recognized him and was kind enough to lead him into a quiet place and there tell him that he had arrived just too late to see his darling daughter alive the shock instead of prostrating the old soldier seemed to nerve him afresh and put new vigor into his life limbs. He proceeded almost on a run to Poindexter's house, and arrived just as the funeral cortege was issuing from the door. And now happened a strange thing. The young girl had been

laid on an open beer, and was being carried by six sturdy lads to her resting place. As her father's eye fell on her young body under its black pall, a cry of mortal anguish escaped him, and he sank on his knees right in the line of the procession. At the same minute another cry went up, this time from behind the beer, and John Poindexter could be seen reeling at the side of Felix Cadwallader, who alone of all present, though he was the youngest and the least, seemed to retain his self-possession at this painful moment. Meanwhile, the bereaved father, throwing himself at the side of the beer, began tearing away at the pall in his desire to look upon the face of her he had left in such rosy health four years before. But he was stopped, not by Poindexter who had vanished from the scene, but by Felix, the cold, severe-looking boy who stood like a guard behind his sister. Reaching out a hand so white it was in itself a shock, he laid it in a certain prohibitory way on the Paul as if saying no.

and when his father would have continued the struggle it was felix who controlled him and gradually drew him into the place at his own side where a minute before the imposing figure of poindexter had stood after which the bearers took up their burden again and moved on but the dramatic scene was not over as they neared the churchyard another procession similar in appearance to their own issued from an adjoining street and evelyn's young lover, who had died almost simultaneously with herself, was brought in and laid at her side. But not in the same grave. This was noticed by all, though most eyes and hearts were fixed upon Cadwallader, who had escaped his loathsome prison and returned to the place of his affections for this. Whether he grasped then and there the full meaning of this double burial, young Kissam had shot himself upon hearing of Evelyn's death, or whether all explanations were deferred till he and Felix walked away together from the grave has never transpired.

From that minute till they both left town on the following day, no one had any word with him, save Poindexter, whom he went once to see, and Young Kissam's mother who came once to see him. Like a phantom he had risen upon the sight of the good people of Montgomery, and like like a phantom he disappeared, never to be seen by any of them again, unless, as many doubt, the story is true which was told some twenty years ago by one of the little village lads. He says, it was six years after the tragic scene I have just related, that one evening as he was hurrying by the churchyard, in great anxiety to reach home before it was too dark, he came upon the figure of a man standing beside a grave with a little child,

in his arms. This man was tall, long-bearded, and terrifying. His attitude, as the lad describes, it was one of defiance, if not of cursing. High in his right hand he held the child, almost as if he would hurl him at the village which lies under the hill on which the churchyard is perched. And though the moment passed quickly, the boy, now a man, never has forgotten the picture thus presented, or admitted that it was anything but a real thing. one as the description he gave of this man answered to the appearance of amos cadwallader and as the shoe of a little child was found next morning on the grave of cadwallader's daughter evelyn it has been thought by many that the boy really beheld this old soldier who for some mysterious reason had chosen nightfall for this fleeting visit to his daughter's resting-place but to others it was only a freak of the lad's imagination which had been much influenced by the reading of romances for as these latter reason had it really been cadwallader why did he not show himself at john poindexter's house that old friend who now had a little daughter and no wife and who could have made him so comfortable among these was poindexter himself though some thought he looked oddly while making this remark as if he spoke more from custom than from the heart indeed since the unfortunate

at death of Evelyn in his house, he had never shown the same interest in the Cadwalladers. But then he was a man much occupied with great affairs, while the Cadwalladers, except for their many griefs and misfortunes, were regarded as comparatively insignificant people, unless we accept Felix, who from his earliest childhood had made himself feared even by grown people, though he never showed a harsh spirit or exceeded the bounds of decorum in speech or gesture. A year ago news came to Montgomery of Amos Catwallader's death, but no particulars concerning his family or burial place, and that is all I have been able to glean concerning the Cadwalladers. Mr. Grice had again become thoughtful. Have you any reason to believe that Evelyn's death was not a

natural one? No, sir. I interviewed the old mother of the young man who shot himself out of grief at Evelyn's approaching death, and if any doubt had existed concerning a matter which had driven her son to a violent end, she could not have concealed it from me. But there seemed to have been none. Evelyn Cat Wallader was always of delicate health, and when a quick consumption carried her off, no one marvelled. Her lover, who adored her, simply could not live without her. But her, and she did not live without her, so he shot himself. There was no mystery about the tragic occurrence, except that it seemed to sever an old friendship that once was firm as a rock. I allude to that between the Poindexters and Cadwalladers. Yet in this tragedy which has just occurred

in Blank Street we see them brought together again. Thomas Adams marries Eva Poindexter. But who is Thomas Adams? You have not mentioned him in this history. not unless he was the child who was held aloft over evelyn's grave humph that seems rather far-fetched what did you learn about him in montgomery is he known there as well as any stranger can be who spends his time in courting a young girl he came to montgomery a few months ago from some foreign city paris i think and being gifted with every personal charm calculated to please a cultivated young woman speedily won the affections of evauburned poindexter and also the esteem of her father but their favorable opinion is not shared by everyone in the town there are those who have a good deal to say about his anxious and unsettled eye naturally he could not marry all their daughters but this history you have given me it is meager sweetwater and while it hints at something deeply tragic does not supply the key we want a girl who died some thirty years ago a father who disappeared appeared a brother who from being a cadwallader has become an adams an eva whose name as well as that of the long-buried evelyn was to be heard in constant repetition in the place where the murdered felix lay with those inscrutable lines in his own writing clinched between his teeth it is a snarl a perfect snarl of which we have as yet failed to pull the right thread but we'll get hold of it yet i'm not going to be baffled in my old age by difficulties i would have laughed at a dozen years ago

but this right thread how shall we know it among the fifty i see entangled in this matter first find the whereabouts of this young couple but didn't you tell me you had done so that you know where they are yes i learned from the postmaster in montgomery that a letter addressed to mrs thomas adams had been sent from his post-office to belleville long island ah i know that place and wishing to be assured that the letter was not a pretence i sent a telegram to the postmaster at belleville here is his answer it is unequivocal mr poindexter of montgomery pennsylvania mr thomas adams and mrs adams of the same place have been at the bedel-house in this place five days very good then we have them be ready to start for belleville by one o'clock sharp and mind sweetwater keep your wits alert and your tongue still remember that as yet we are feeling our way blindfold and must continue to do so till some kind hand tears away the bandage from our eyes go i have a letter to write for which you may send in a boy at the end of five minutes this letter was for miss butterworth and created a half-hour later quite a stir in the fine old mansion in grammarsie park it ran thus have you sufficient interest in the outcome of a certain matter to take a short journey into the country i leave town at one p m for belleville long island if you choose to do the same you will find me at the bedel-house in that town early in the afternoon if you enjoy novels take one with you and let me see you

reading it on the Hotel Piazza at five o'clock I may be reading too if so and my choice is a book all is well and you may devour your story in peace but if I lay aside my book and take up a paper devote but one eye to your story and turn the other on the people who are passing you If after you have done so you leave your book open, I shall understand that you fail to recognize these persons. But if you shut the volume, you may expect to see me also fold up my newspaper, for by doing so you will have signalled me that you have identified the young man and woman you saw leaving Mr. Adams' house on the fatal afternoon of your first entrance. E. G.

End of Book 1, Chapter 10. 1 chapter 11 of the circular study this is a librivox recording all librivox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit librivox dot org the circular study by anna catherine green chapter 11 misery it is to be hoped that the well-dressed lady of uncertain age who was to be seen late that afternoon in a remote corner of the Hotel Piazza at Belleville, had not chosen a tale requiring great concentration of mind, for her eyes, rather fine ones in their way, showing both keenness and good nature, seemed to find more to interest them in the scene before her than in the pages she so industriously turned over. The scene was one calculated to interest in idle mind, no doubt.

first there was the sea, a wide expanse of blue dotted by numerous sails. Then the beach, enlivened by groups of young people dressed like popin-jays in every color, then the village street, and lastly a lawn over which their now and then strayed young couples with tennis rackets in their hands or golf sticks under their arms. Children too, but children did not seem to interest this amiable spin-scentred. there could be no doubt about her being a spinster she scarcely glanced at them twice while a young married pair or even an old gentleman if he were only tall and imperious looking invariably caused her eyes to wander from her book which by the way she held too near foreseeing or such might have been the criticism of a wary observer this criticism if criticism it would be called could not have been made of the spruce but rather feeble octogenarian at the other end of the piazza. He was evidently absorbed in the novel he held so conspicuously open, and which, from the smiles now and then disturbing the usual

placidity of his benevolent features, we can take for granted was sufficiently amusing. Yet right in the midst of it, and certainly before he had finished his chapter, he closed his book and took out a newspaper, which he opened to its full width before sitting down to peruse its columns. At the same moment the lady at the other end of the piazza could be seen looking over her spectacles at two gentlemen who just at that moment issued from the great door opening between her and the elderly person just alluded to. Did she know them or was it only her curiosity that was aroused. From the way she banged together her book and rose, it looked as if she had detected old acquaintances in the distinguished-looking pair who were now advancing slowly toward her.

But if so, she could not have been overjoyed to see them, for after the first hint of their approach in her direction she turned, with an aspect of some embarrassment, and made her way out upon the lawn, where she stood with her back to these people, caressing a small dog in a way that betrayed her total lack of sympathy with these animals, which were evidently her terror when she was sufficiently herself to be swayed by her natural impulses. The two gentlemen, on the contrary, with an air of total indifference to her proximity, continued their walk until they reached the end of the piazza, and then turned and proceeded mechanically to retribly. trace their steps. Their faces now being brought within view of the elderly person who was so absorbed

in his newspaper, the latter shifted that sheet the merest trifle, possibly because the sun struck his eyes too directly, possibly because he wished to catch sight of two very remarkable men. If so, the opportunity was good as they stopped within a few feet of his chair. One of them was elderly, as old as, if not older, than the man watching him. But he was of that famous Scotch-stock, whose members are tough and hail at eighty. This toughness he showed not only in his figure, which was both upright and graceful, but in the glance of his calm, cold eye which fell upon everybody and everything unmoved, while that of his young but equally stalwart companion seemed to shrink with the most acute sensitiveness from every person he met save the very mild old reader of news near whom they now paused for a half-dozen words of conversation

i don't think it does me any good was the young man's gloomy remark i am wretched when with her and doubly wretched when i try to forget myself for a moment out of her sight i think we had better go back i had rather sit where she can see me than have her wonder oh i will be careful but you must remember how unnerving is the very silence i am obliged to keep about what is destroying us all i am nearly as ill as she here they drew off and their apparently disinterested hearer turned the page of his paper it was five minutes before they came back this time it was the old gentleman who was speaking and as he was more discreet than his companion or less under the influence of his feelings, his voice was lower and his words less easy to be distinguished. Escape? South Coast. She will forget to watch you for— A clinging nature.

Impetuous but foolishly affectionate. You know that— No danger. Found out. Time. A cheerful home. Courage. Happiness.

All forgotten. a gesture from the young man as he moved away showed that he did not share these hopes meanwhile miss butterworth you surely have recognized miss butterworth had her opportunities too she was still stooping over the dog which wriggled under her hand yet did not offer to run away fascinated perhaps by that hesitating touch which he may or may not have known had never inflicted itself upon a dog before but her ears and attention were turned toward two girls chatting on a bench near her as freely as if they were quite alone on the lawn they were gossiping about a fellow-inmate of the big hotel and miss butterworth listened intently after hearing them mention the name adams these are some of the words she caught but she is i tell you she is sick enough to have a nurse and a doctor i caught a glimpse of her as i was going by her room yesterday, and I never saw two such big eyes or such pale cheeks. Then look at him. He must just adore her, for he won't speak to another woman, and just moves about in that small hot room all day. I wonder if they're bride and groom.

They are young enough, and if you have noticed her clothes. Oh, don't talk about clothes. I saw her the first day she came, and was the victim of despair until she suddenly. got sick, and so couldn't wear those wonderful waists and jackets. I felt like a doughty when I saw that pale blue. Oh, well, blue becomes blondes. You would look a fright in it. I don't care about her clothes, but I did feel that it was all up with us if she chose to talk or even to smile upon the few men that are good enough to stay out a week in this place.

Yet she isn't a beauty. She has not a good nose nor a handsome eye, nor even an irreproachable complexion. It must be her mouth, which is lovely, or her walk. Did you notice her walk? It was just as if she were floating. That is, before she fell down in a faint. I wonder why she fainted.

Nobody was doing anything, not even her husband. But perhaps that was what troubled her. I noticed that for some cause he was looking very serious, and when she tried to attract his attention two or three times, and failed, she just fell from her chair to the floor. That roused him. He has hardly left her since. I don't think they look very happy, do you, for so rich and handsome a couple? Perhaps he is dissipated. I have noticed that the old gentleman never leaves them. Well, well, he may be dissipated. Hansome men are very apt to be, but I wouldn't care if.

Here the dog gave a yelp and bowl. Miss Butterworth had unconsciously pinched him in her indignation possibly at the turn these rattlepated young ladies' conversation was taking. This made a diversion and the young girls moved off, leaving Miss Butterworth without occupation. But a young man who at that moment crossed her path gave her enough to think about, you recognize them there is no mistake he whispered none the one this way is the young man i saw leave mr adams's house and the other is the old gentleman who came in afterward mr gryce advises you to return home he is going to arrest the young man and sweetwater passed on miss butterworth strolled to a seat and sank down she felt weak she seemed to see that young one sick overwhelmed struggling with her great fear sink under this crushing blow with no woman near her capable of affording the least sympathy the father did not impress her as being the man to hold up her fainting head or ease her bruised heart he had an icy look under his polished exterior which repelled this keen-eyed spinster and as she remembered the coldness of his ways she felt herself seized by her an irresistible impulse to be near this young creature when the blow fell if only to ease the tension of her own heart-strings which at that moment ached keenly over the part she had felt herself obliged to play in this matter but when she rose to look for mr gryce she found him gone and upon searching the piazza for the other two gentlemen she saw them just vanishing round the corner in the direction of a small smoking-room

as she could not follow them she went upstairs and meeting a maid in the upper hall asked for mrs adams she was told that mrs adams was sick but was shown the door of her room which was at the end of a long hall as all the halls terminated in a window under which a sofa was to be found she felt that circumstances were in her favor and took her seat upon the sofa before her in a state of great complacency instantly a sweet voice was heard through the open transom of the door behind which her thoughts were already concentrated where is tom oh where is tom why does he leave me i'm afraid of what he may be tempted to do or say down on those great piazzas alone "'Mr. Poindexter is with him,' answered a voice, measured, but kind. Mr. Adams was getting very tired, and your father persuaded him to go down and have a smoke. "'I must get up. Indeed, I must get up. Oh, the camphor—the—' There was a bustle. This poor young wife had evidently fainted again. Miss Butterworth cast very miserable glances at the door.

Meanwhile, in that small and retired smoking-room, a terrible scene was in progress. The two gentlemen had lit their cigars and were sitting in certain forced attitudes that evinced their non-enjoyment of the weed each had taken out of complacence to the other, when an old man, strangely serious, strangely at home, yet as strangely a guest of the house like themselves, came in and shut the door behind him gentlemen he at once announced i am detective gryce of the new york police and i am here but i see that one of you at least knows why i am here one both of them this was evident in a moment no denial no subterfuge was possible at the first word uttered in the strange authoritative tone which old detectives acquire after years of such experiences, the young man sank down in sudden collapse, while his companion, without yielding so entirely to his emotions, showed that he was not insensible to the blow which,

in one moment had brought destruction to all their hopes. When Mr. Gry saw himself so completely understood he no longer hesitated over his duty, directing his full attention to Mr. Adams, he said, this time with some feeling, for the misery of this young man had impressed him, You are wanted in New York by Coroner D, whose business it is to hold an inquest over the remains of Mr. Felix Adams, of whose astonishing death you are undoubtedly informed. As you and your wife were seen leaving that gentleman's house a few minutes before he expired, you are naturally regarded as valuable witnesses in determining whether his death was one of suicide or murder. It was an accusation, or so nearly one, that Mr. Grice was not at all surprised

to behold the dark flush of shame displaced the livid terror which but an instant before had made the man before him look like one of those lost spirits we sometimes imagine as flitting across the open mouth of hell. But he said nothing, seemingly had no power to do so, and his father-in-law was about to make some effort to turn aside this blow, when a voice in the hall outside was heard inquiring for mr adams saying that his wife had fainted again and required his help the young husband started cast a look full of despair at mr poindexter and thrusting his hand against the door as if to hold it shut sank on his knees before mr gryce saying She knows, she suspects, her nature is so sensitive. This he managed to utter in gasps as the detective bent compassionately over him. Don't, don't disturb her, she is an angel, a saint from heaven, let me bear the blame.

He was my brother, let me go with you, but leave her in ignorance. Mr. Grice, with a vivid sense of justice, laid his hand on the young man's arm. say nothing he enjoined my memory is good and i would rather hear nothing from your lips as for your wife my warrant does in no way include her and if you promise to come with me quietly i will even let you bid her adieu so that you do it in my presence the change which passed over the young man's face at these significant words was of a nature to surprise mr gryce rising slowly he took his stephen by Mr. Poindexter, who, true to his inflexible nature, had scarcely moved in limb and feature since Mr. Grice came in. What have you against me, he demanded, and there was a surprising ring to his voice, as if courage had come with a necessity of the moment. Of what am I accused? I want you to tell me. I had rather you tell me in so many words. I cannot leave in peace until you do. Mr. Poindexter made a movement at this and cast a half-suspicious, half-warning glance at his son-in-law,

but the young man took no notice of his interference. He kept his eye on the detective, who quietly took out his warrant. At this instant the door shook. Locket, was the hoarse command of the accused man. Don't let anyone pass that door, even if it is to bring the tidings of my wife's death. mr gryce reached out his hand and turned the key in the lock young adams opened the paper which he had taken from the detective's hand and while his bloodshot eyes vainly sought to master the few lines there written mr poindexter attracted the attention of mr gryce and fixing him with his eye formed his lips with three soundless words for murder him him the detective's bow and a very long-drawn sigh from his son-in-law answered him simultaneously with a curious lift of his upper lip which showed his teeth somewhat unpleasantly for a moment he drew back a step and sank into his previous immobility i am indebted to you declared the young man now i know where i stand i am quite ready to go with you and stand trial if such be deemed necessary by the official's in New York. You, he cried, turning with almost an air of command to the old gentleman beside him,

will watch over Eva. Not like a father, sir, but like a mother. You will be at her side when she wakes, and, if possible, leave her only when she sleeps. Do not let her suffer, not too much, no newspapers, no gossiping women. Watch, watch as I would watch, and when I come back, for I will come back, will I not? He appealed to. to Mr. Grice. My prayers will bless you, and a sob stuck in his throat, and he turned for a minute aside. Then he took the detective's arm quite calmly and remarked, I do not want to say good-bye to my wife. I cannot bear it. I had rather go straight from here without another glance at her unconscious face. When I have told my story, for I shall tell it

to the first man who asks me, I may find courage to write her. Meanwhile, get me a away as quickly as you can time enough for the world to know my shame to-morrow mr gryce tapped on the window overlooking the piazza a young man stepped in here is a gentleman he cried who finds himself forced to return in great haste to new york see that he gets to the train in time without fuss and without raising the least comment i will follow with his portmanteau mr poindexter you are now at liberty to attend your suffering daughter. And with a turn of the key he unlocked the door, and one of the most painful scenes of his long life was over. End of Book 1, Chapter 11. Book 1, Chapter 12 of The Circular Study. This is a Librivox recording. All Librevox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librevox.org. Study by Anna Catherine Green. Chapter 12 Thomas Explains

Mr. Grice was not above him floying a little finesse. He had expressed his intention of following Mr. Adams, and he did follow him, but so immediately that he not only took the same train, but sat in the same car. He wished to note at his leisure the bearing of this young man, who interested him in quite a different way from what he had anticipated, a way that vaguely touched his own conscience and made him feel his years as he had no right to feel them when he had just brought to an end an intricate and difficult pursuit seated at a distance he watched with increasing interest the changes which passed over his prisoner's handsome countenance he noted the calmness which now marked the features he had so lately seen writhing in deepest agony and wondered from what source the strength came which enabled this young man to sit so stoically under the eyes of people from whose regard an hour before he had shrunk with such apparent suffering was it that courage comes with despair or was he too absorbed in his own misery to note the shadow it cast about him his brooding brow and vacant eye spoke of a mind withdrawn from present surroundings

into what depths of remorse who could say certainly not this old detective seasoned though he was by life-long contact with criminals some of them of the same social standing and cultured aspect as this young man at the station in brooklyn he rejoined his prisoner who scarcely looked up as he approached in another hour they were at police headquarters and the serious questioning of mr adams had begun he did not attempt to shirk it indeed he seemed anxious to talk he had a burden on his mind and longed to throw it off but the burden was not of the exact nature anticipated by the police he did not acknowledge having killed his brother but confessed to having been the incidental cause of that brother's death the story he told was this my name is catwallader not adams my father a scotchman by birth was a naturalized citizen of Pennsylvania, having settled in a place called Montgomery when a young married man. He had two children then, one of whom died in early life. The other was my brother Felix, whose violent death under the name of Adams you have called me here to explain. I am the fruit of a later marriage entered into by my father some years after leaving Montgomery.

when I was born he was living in Harrisburg but as he left there shortly after I reached my third year I have no remembrances connected with that city indeed my recollections are all of very different scenes than this country affords my mother having died while I was still an infant I was sent very early in life to the old world from which my father had originally come when I returned which was not till this very year I found my father dying and my brother a grown man with money a great deal of money which i had been led to think he was ready to share with me but after my father was laid away felix with what effort he uttered that name felix came to new york and i was left to wander about without settled hopes or any definite promise of means upon which to base a future or start a career while wandering i came upon the town where my father had lived in early youth and hunting up his old friends i met in the house of one who had come over from scotland with my father a young lady how his voice shook and with what a poignant accent he uttered that beloved name in whom i speedily became interested to the point of wishing to marry her but i had no money no business no home to care give her, and, as I was fain to acknowledge, no prospects. Still, I could not give up the hope of making her my wife. So I wrote to my brother Felix Cadwallader, or rather Felix Adams, as he preferred to be

called in later years, for family reasons entirely disconnected with the matter of his sudden demise, and telling him I had become interested in a young girl of good family and some wealth, asked him to settle upon me a certain sum which would enable me to marry her with some feeling of self-respect. My only answer was a repetition of the vague promise he had thrown out before. But youth is hopeful, even to daring, and I decided to make her mind without further parley, in the hope that her beauty and endearing qualities would win from him at first view, the definite concession he had so persistently denied me. This I did, and the fault with which I have most to reproach myself, is that I entered into this alliance without taking her or her father

into my confidence. They thought me well off, possibly rich, and while Mr. Poindexter is a man of means, I am sure if he had known I had nothing but the clothes I wore and the merest trifle in the way of pocket money, he would have cried halt to the marriage, for he is a very ambitious man, and considers his daughter well worth a millionaire's devotion, as she is. Felix, you must pardon me if I show no affection for my brother, he was a very strange man, was notified of my marriage, but did not choose to witness it. Neither did he choose to prohibit it. So it was conducted quietly with strangers for witnesses in a hotel parlor. Then, with vague hopes, as well as certain vague fears,

I prepared to take my young bride into the presence of my brother, who, hardened as he was by years of bachelorhood, could not be so entirely impervious to feminine charms as not to recognize my wife as a woman deserving of every consideration. But I had counted without my host, when two days after the ceremony which had made us one, I took her to the house which has since become so unhappily notorious. I found that my brother had but shown me one facet, and that the least obdurate, of his many-sided nature. Brilliant as steel,

he was as hard, and not only professed himself unmoved by my wife's many charms, but also as totally out of sympathy with such follies as love and marriage, which were, he said, the fruit of unoccupied minds, and a pastime wholly unworthy of men boasting such talents and attainments as ourselves. Then he turned his back upon us, and I, moved by an anger little short of frenzy, began an abuse for which he was so little prepared that he crouched like a man under blows, and losing minute by minute his self-control, finally caught up a dagger lying close at hand and crying, You want my money? Well then take it. stabbed himself to the heart with one desperate blow.

I fear I shall not be believed, but that is the story of this crime, gentlemen. End of Book 1, Chapter 12. Book 1, Chapter 13 of the Circular Study. This is a Librevox recording. All Librevox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librevox.orgs.

The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green Chapter 13 Despair Was it? Tragedies as unpremeditated as this had doubtless occurred, and inconsistencies in character shown themselves in similar impetuosities from the beginning of time up till now. Yet there was not a man present with or without the memory of Bartow's pantomime, which, as you will recall did not tally at all with this account of mr adams's violent end who did not show in a greater or less degree his distrust and evident disbelief in this tale poured out with such volubility before them the young man gifted as he was with the keenest susceptibilities perceived this and his head drooped i shall add nothing to and take nothing from what i have said was his dogged remark make of it what you will

the inspector who was conducting the inquiry glanced dubiously at mr gryce as these words left thomas adams's lips whereupon the detectives said we are sorry you have taken such a resolution there are many things yet left to be explained mr adams for instance why if your brother slew himself in this unforeseen manner you left the house so precipitately without giving an alarm or even proclaiming your relationship to him you need not answer you know the inspector's voice broke in no man is called upon to incriminate himself in this free and independent country a smile the saddest ever seen wandered for a minute over the prisoner's pallid lips then he lifted his head and replied with a certain air of desperation incrimination is not what i fear now from the way you all look at me i perceive that i am lost for i have no means of proving my story this acknowledgment which might pass for the despairing cry of an innocent man made his interrogator stare you forget suggested that gentleman that you had your wife with you she can corroborate your words and will prove herself no doubt an invaluable witness in your favor my wife he repeated choking so that his words could be barely understood must she be dragged into this so sick so weak a woman it would kill her sir she loves me she was she with you in mr adams's study did she see him lift the dagger against his own breast no and with this denial the young man seemed to take new courage she had fainted several moments previously while the altercation between my breast brother and myself was at its height. She did not see the final act, and, gentlemen, I might as well

speak the truth. I have nothing to gain by silence. She finds it as difficult as you do to believe that Mr. Adams struck himself. I have tried with all my arts to impress the truth upon her, but, oh, what can I hope from the world when the wife of my bosom, an angel, too, who loves me? Oh, sir, she can never be a witness for me. She is too conscientious, too true to her own I should lose. She would die. Mr. Grice tried to stop him. He would not be stopped. Spare me, sir, spare my wife, write me down guilty, anything you please rather than force that young creature to speak. Here the inspector cut short these appeals which were rending every heart present. Have you read the newspapers for the last few days, he asked?

I? Yes, yes, sir. How could I help it? blood is blood the man was my brother i had left him dying i was naturally anxious naturally saw my own danger and i read them of course then you know he was found with a large cross on his breast a cross which was once on the wall how came it to be torn down who put it on his bosom i sir i am not a catholic but felix was and seeing him dying without absolution without extramunction without exdermunction i thought of the holy cross and tore down the only one i saw and placed it in his arms a pious act did he recognize it i cannot say i had my fainting wife to look after she occupied all my thoughts i see and you carried her out and were so absorbed in caring for her that you did not observe mr adams's valet he's innocent sir whatever people may think he had nothing to do with this crime you did not observe him i say standing in the doorway and watching you now the inspector knew that bartow had not been standing there but at the loop-hole above but the opportunity for entrapping the witness was too good to lose mr adams was caught in the trap or so one might judge from the beads of perspiration which at that moment showed themselves on his pale forehead but he struggled to maintain the stand he had taken crying hotly but the but that man is crazy and deaf and dumb besides or so the papers give out surely his testimony is valueless you would not confront me with him we confront you with no one we only asked you a question you did not observe the valet then

no sir or understand the mystery of the coloured lights no sir or of the plate of steel and the other contrivances with which your brother enlivened his solitude I do not follow you, sir, but there was a change in his tone. I see, said the inspector, that the complications which have disturbed us and made necessary this long delay in the collection of testimony have not entered into the crime as described by you. Now this is possible, but there is still a circumstance requiring explanation, a little circumstance which is nevertheless one of importance, since, you. your wife mentioned it to you as soon as she became conscious. I allude to the half-dozen

or more words which were written by your brother immediately preceding his death. The paper on which they were written has been found, and that it was a factor in your quarrel as evidence since she regretted that it had been left behind you, and he—' Do you know where we found this paper? The eyes which young Adams raised at this interrogatory had no intelligence in them. the sight of this morsel of paper seemed to have deprived him in an instant of all the faculties with which he had been carrying on this unequal struggle he shook his head tried to reach out his hand but failed to grasp the scrap of paper which the inspector held out then he burst into a loud cry enough i cannot hold out with no other support than a wicked lie i killed my brother for reasons good as any man ever had for killing another but i shall not impart them i would rather be tried for murder and hanged it was a complete breakdown pitiful in its contrast with the man's herculean physique and fine if contracted features if the end it was a sad end and mr gryce whose forehead had taken on a deep line between the eyebrows slowly rose and took his stand by the young man who looked ready to fall

the inspector on the contrary did not move he had begun a tattoo with his fingers on the table and seemed bound to beat it out when another sudden cry broke from the young man's lips what is that he demanded with his eyes fixed on the door and his whole frame shaking violently nothing began the inspector when the door suddenly opened and the figure of a woman white as a wraith and wonderful with a sort of holy passion darted from the grasp of a man who sought to detain her and stood before them palpitating with a protest which for a moment she seemed powerless to utter it was adams's young invalid wife whom he had left three hours before at belleville she was so frail of form so exquisite a feature that she would have seemed some unearthly visitant but for the human anguish which pervaded her look and soon found vent in this touching cry what is he saying oh i know well what he is saying he is saying that he killed his brother that he held the dagger which rid the world of a monster of whose wickedness none new. But you must not heed him. Indeed, you must not heed him. He is innocent. I, his wife, have come twenty miles from a bed of weakness and suffering to tell you so. He—' But here a hand was laid gently but firmly on her mouth. She looked up, met her husband's eyes, filled with almost frantic appeal, and, giving him a look in return that sank into the heart of every

man who beheld it, laid her own hand on his, and drew it softly away. It is too late, Tom, I must speak. My father, my own weakness, or your own peremptory commands, could not keep me at Belleville when I knew you had been brought here. And shall I stop now in the presence of these men who have heard your words and may believe them? No, that would be a cowardice unworthy of our love and the true lives we hope to lead together. sirs and each man there held his breath to catch the words which came in faint and fainter intonation from her lips i know my husband to be innocent because the hand that held the dagger was mine i killed felix cadwallader

the horror of such a moment is never fully realized till afterward not a man there moved not even her husband yet on every cheek a slow pallor was formed but on every cheek a slow pallor was formed which testified to the effect of such words from lips made for smiles and showing in every curve the habit of gentle thought and the loftiest instincts not till some one cried out from the doorway catch her she is falling did any one stir or release the pent-up breath which awe and astonishment had hitherto held back on every lip then he in whose evident despair all could read the real cause of the great dread which had drawn him into a false confession sprang forward and with renewed life showing itself in every feature caught her in his arms as he staggered with her to a sofa and laid her softly down he seemed another man in look and bearing and mr gryce who had been watching the whole wonderful event with the strongest interest understood at once the meaning of the change which had come over his prisoner at that point in his memorable arrest when he first realized that it was for himself they had come and not for the really guilty person the idolized object of his affections meanwhile he was facing them all with one hand laid tenderly on that unconscious head do not think he cried that because this young girl has steeped her hand in blood she is a wicked woman there is no purer heart on earth than hers and none more worthy of the worship of a true man see she killed my brother son of my father beloved by my mother yet i can kiss her hand kiss her forehead her eyes her feet not because i hate him but because i worship her the purest the best

he left her and came and stood before those astonished men sirs he cried i must ask you to listen to a strange a terrible tale Book 1, Chapter 14 of The Circular Study This is a Librivox recording. All Librevox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librevox.org. The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green. Chapter 14 Memoranda It is like and unlike what I have just related to you began young

Adams, in my previous confession I mixed truth and falsehood, and to explain myself fully and to help you to a right understanding of my wife's act, I shall have to start afresh and speak as if I had already told you nothing. Wait, cried Mr. Gryce in an authoritative manner, we will listen to you presently. And leaning over the inspector he whispered a few words, after which he took out a pencil and jotted down certain sentences which he handed over to this gentleman. As they had the appearance of a memorandum, and as the inspector glanced more than once at them while Mr. Adams, or Cadwallader, as he should now rightfully be called, was proceeding with his story, I would present them to you as written. Points to be made clear by Mr. Adams in his account of this crime. One, why a woman who was calm enough to stop and arrange her hair during the beginning of an interview should be wrought up to such a pitch of frenzy and exasperation before it was over as to kill with her own hand a man against whom she evidently had no

previous grudge remember the comb found on the floor of mr adams's bedroom two what was the meaning of the following words written just previous to this interview by the man thus killed i return you your daughter neither you nor she shall ever see me again remember evelyn three why was the pronoun i used in this communication what position did mr felix adams hold toward this young girl qualifying him to make use of such language after her marriage to his brother four and having used it why did he upon being attacked by her attempt to swallow the patient upon which he had written these words actually dying with it clinched between his teeth five if he was killed in anger and died as monsters do her own word why did his face show sorrow rather than hate and a determination as far as possible removed from the rush of overwhelming emotions likely to follow the reception of a mortal blow from the hand of an unexpected antagonist six why if he had strength to seize the above-mentioned paper and convey it to his lips did he not use that strength in turning on a light calculated to bring him assistance instead of leaving blazing the crimson glow which according to the code of signals as now understood by us means nothing more required just now keep away seven what was the meaning of the huge steel plate found between the casings of the doorway and why did it remain at rest within its socket at this the culminating moment of his life eight an explanation of how old poindexter came to appear on the scene so soon after the event

his words as overheard were it is amos's son not amos did he not know whom he was to meet in this house was the condition of the man lying before him with a cross on his bosom and a dagger in his heart, less of a surprise to him than the personality of the victim? 9. Remember the conclusions we have drawn from Bartow's pantomime? Mr. Adams was killed by a left-handed thrust. Watch for an acknowledgement that the young woman is left-handed, and do not forget that an explanation is due, why for so long a time she held her other arm stretched out behind her. 10. Why did the bird whose chief cry is, remember Evelyn, sometimes vary it with

poor Eva, lovely Eva, who would strike Eva? The story of this tragedy, to be true, must show that Mr. Adams knew his brother's bride both long and well. 11. If Bartow is, as we think, innocent of all connection with this crime save as witness, why does he show such joy at its result this may not reasonably be expected to fall within the scope of thomas adams's confession but it should not be ignored by us this deaf and dumb servitor was driven mad by a fact which caused him joy why twelve notice the following schedule it has been drawn up after repeated experiments with bartow and the various slides of the strange lamp which caused so many different lights to shine out in mr adams's study white light water wanted green light overcoat and hat to be brought blue light put back books on shelves violet light arrange study for the night yellow light watch for next light red light nothing wanted stay away the last was on at the final scene note if this fact can be explained by mr adams's account of the same with these points in our mind let us peruse the history of this crime and of the remote and possibly complicated causes which led to it end of book one chapter fourteen book two

Chapter 1, Part 1 of The Circular Study. This is a Librevox recording. All Librevox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librevox.org. The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green. Book 2, Remember Evelyn. Chapter 1 The Secret of the Cadwallators, Part 1. Cadwallader suggested rather than told his story. We dare not imitate him in this, nor would it be just to your interest to relate these facts with all the baldness and lack of detail imposed upon this unhappy man by the hurry and anxiety of the occasion.

Remarkable tragedies have their birth in remarkable facts, and as such facts are but the outcome of human passions, we must enter into those passions if we would understand either the facts or their appalling consequences. In this case, the first link of the chain which led to Felix Adams' violent death was forged before the birth of the woman who struck him. We must begin then with almost forgotten days and tell this story, as her pleader did, from the standpoint of Felix and Thomas Cadwallader. Thomas Cadwallader, now called Adams,

never knew his mother. She died in his early infancy. Nor could he be said to have known his father, having been brought up in France by an old Scotch lawyer, who, being related to his mother, sometimes spoke of her, but never of his father till Thomas had reached his 15th year. Then he put certain books into his hands with this remarkable injunction. Here are romances, Thomas. Read them, but remember that, none of them no matter how thrilling in matter or effect will ever equal the story of your father's bitterly wronged and suffering life my father he cried tell me about him i have never heard but his guardian satisfied with an illusion which he knew must bear fruit in the extremely susceptible nature of this isolated boy said no more that day and thomas turned to the books but nothing after that could ever take his mind away from his father. He had scarcely thought of him for years,

but now that that father had been placed before him in the light of a wronged man, he found himself continually hunting back in the deepest recesses of his memory for some long-forgotten recollection of that father's features calculated to restore his image to his eyes. Sometimes he succeeded in this or thought he did, but this image, if image it was, was was so speedily lost in a sensation of something strange and awe-compelling enveloping it that he found himself more absorbed by the intangible impressions associated with this memory than by the memory itself what were these impressions and in what had they originated in vain he tried to determine they were as vague as they were persistent a stretch of darkness two bars of orange light all washington shining always the same, black lines against these bars like the tops of distant gables, an inner thrill, a vague a fright, a rush about him as of a swooping wind,

all this came with his father's image, only to fade away with it, leaving him troubled, uneasy and perplexed. Finding these impressions persistent, and receiving no explanation of them in his own mind, he finally asked his guardian what they meant. But that guardian was as ignorant as himself on this topic, and satisfied with having roused the boy's imagination, confined himself to hints, dropped now and then with a judiciousness which proved the existence of a deliberate purpose, of some duty which awaited him on the other side of the water, a duty which would explain his long exile from his only parent, and for which he must fit himself, by study and the acquirement

of such accomplishments as render a young man a positive power in society, whether that society be of the old world or the new. He showed his shrewdness in thus dealing with this pliable and deeply affectionate nature. From this time forth Thomas felt himself leading a life of mystery and interest. To feel himself appointed for a work whose unknown character only heightened its importance, gave point to every effort

now made by this young man, and led to his studies that vague touch of romance which made them a delight, and him an adept in many things he might otherwise have cared little about. At 18 he was a graduate from the Sorbonne and a musical virtuoso as well.

He could fend, ride, and carry off the prize in games requiring physical prowess as well as mental fitness. He was in fact a prodigy in many ways and was so considered by his fellow students. He, however, was not perfect. He lacked social charm and insofar failed of being the complete gentleman. This he was made to realize in the following way. One morning his guardian came to him with a letter. from his father in which together with some words of commendation for his present attainments that father expressed a certain dissatisfaction with his general manner as being too abrupt and self-satisfied with those of his own sex and much too timid and deprecatory with those of the other thomas felt the criticism and recognized its justice but how had his father proved by this letter to be no longer a myth

become acquainted with defects which thomas instinctively felt could never have attracted the attention of his far-from polished guardian his questions on this point elicited a response that confounded him he was not the only son of his father he had a brother living and this brother older than himself by some twenty years or more had just been in paris where in all probability he had met him talked with him and-and this brother older than himself by some twenty years or more had just been in paris where in all probability he had met him talked with him and perhaps pressed his hand. It was a discovery calculated to deepen the impression already made upon Thomas's mind. Only a purpose of the greatest importance could account for so much mystery. What could it be? What was he destined to do or say or be? He was not told, but while awaiting enlightenment he was resolved not to be a disappointment to the two anxious souls who watched his career so eagerly and extracted from him such perfection. He consequently moderated his manner, and during the following year, acquired by constant association with the gilded youth about him,

that indescribable charm of the perfect gentleman which he was led to believe would alone meet with the approval of those he now felt bound to please. At the end of the year he found himself a finished man of the world. How truly so he began to realize when he noted the blush with which his presence was hailed by women and the respect shown him by men of his own stamp. In the midst of the satisfaction thus experienced, his guardian paid him a final visit. You are now ready, said he, for your father's summons. It will come in a few weeks. Be careful then. Form no ties. you cannot readily break for once recalled from france you are not likely to return here what your father's purpose concerning you may be i do not know but it is no ordinary one you will have money a well-appointed home family affection all that you have hitherto craved in vain and in return you will carry solace to a heart which has awaited your healing touch for twenty years so much i am ordered to see say, the rest you will hear from your father's own lips. Aroused, encouraged, animated by the wildest hopes the most extravagant anticipations,

Thomas awaited his father's call with feverish impatience, and when it came, hastened to respond to it by an immediate voyage to America. This was some six months previous to the tragedy in Blank Street. On his arrival at the wharf in New York, he was a man. He said, he was, he was, he was met not by his brother, as he had every reason to expect, but by a messenger in whose face evil tidings were apparent before he spoke. Thomas was soon made acquainted with them. His father, who he now learned was called Cadwallader, he himself had always been called Adams, was ill, possibly dying. He must therefore hasten, and being provided with minute instructions as to his way, took the train at once for a small village in northern Pennsylvania.

All that followed was a dream to him. He was hurried through the night with the motion of the ship still in his blood to meet what? He dared not think. He swam in a veritable nightmare. Then came a stop, a hurrying from the train, a halt on a platform reeking with rain, for the night was stormy, a call from some one to hurry the sight of a panting horse steaming under a lamp whose blowing flame he often woke in after nights to see a push from a persuasive hand then a ride over a country road the darkness of which seemed impenetrable and finally the startling vision of an open door with a meg merrily's of a woman standing in it holding a flaming candle in her hand the candle went out while the candle went out while he was a meg marilies of a woman standing in her hand the candle went out while he looked at it and left only a voice to guide him a voice which in tones shaken by chill or feeling he could not tell which cried eagerly is that you laddie come away in come away in dinna heed the rain the maister's been crying on you all day i'm glad you're no o'er late he got down followed the voice and stumbling up a step or two entered a narrow door, which was with difficulty held open behind him, and which swung to with a loud noise

the minute he crossed the threshold. This or the dreariness of the place in which he found himself disturbed him greatly. Bare floors, stained walls, meager doorways, and a common pine staircase, lighted only by the miserable candle which the old woman had relit. Were these the appointments of the palatial home he had been led to expect? these the surroundings this the abode of him who had exacted such perfection on his part and to satisfy whose standard he had devoted years of hourly daily effort in every department of art and science a sickening revolt seized him aggravated by the smiles of the old woman who dipped and courtesied before him in senile delight she may have divined his feelings for drawing him in a side she relieved him of his overcoat crying all the while with an extravagant welcome more repulsive than all the rest oh the fine laddie would your poor mother could see you the no bonnie and clever know your father's bernival all mother laddie all mother the room was no better than the hall where is my father he asked authoritatively striving to keep down his strong

pugnance didn't ye hear him he's crying on ye poor man he's wearyin to see ye hear him he could scarcely hear her the driving reigned the swish of some great boughs against the house the rattling of casements and doors and the shrieking of the wind in the chimney made all other sounds well-nigh inaudible yet as he listened he seemed to catch the accents of a far-off voice calling now wistfully now imperatively thomas thomas and thrilled with an emotion almost superstitious in its intensity he moved hastily toward the staircase but the old woman was there before him nay nay she cried come in by and eat something first but thomas shook his head it seemed to him at that moment as if he never could eat or sleep again the disillusion was surrogens but thomas shook his head it seemed to him at that moment as if he never could eat or sleep again the disillusion was surre bitter his disappointment so keen you will nay then haste ye haste ye but it's a pity you wouldn't hae eaten something ye'll need it laddie you'll need it thomas thomas wailed the voice he tore himself away he forced himself to go upstairs following the cry which at every moment grew louder at the top he cast a final glance below the old woman's stood at the stair-foot, shading the candle from the draught, with a hand that shook with something more than age. She was gazing after him in vague affright, and with the shadow of this fear darkening her weazen face, formed a picture from which he was glad to escape. Plunging on, he found himself before a window whose small panes dripped and groaned under

a rain that was fast becoming a torrent. Chilled by the sight, he turned toward the door, door faintly outlined beside it, and in the semi-darkness seized an old-fashioned latch rattling in the wind that permeated every passageway and softly raised it. Instantly the door fell back and two eyes blazing with fever and that fire of the soul of which fever is the mere physical symbol greeted him from the midst of a huge bed drawn up against the opposite wall. Then two arms rose and the moaning cry of Thomas, Thomas, changed to a shout, and he knew himself to be in the presence of his father. Falling on his knees in speechless emotion, he grasped the wasted hands held out to him.

Such a face, rugged though it was, and far from fulfilling the promise held out to him in his dreams, could not but move any man. As he gazed into it and pressed the hands in which the lifeblood only seemed to linger for this last, this only embrace. All his filial instincts were aroused, and he forgot the common surroundings, the depressing rain, his own fatigue and bitter disappointment in his lifelong craving for love and family recognition. But the old man on whose breast he fell showed other emotions than those by which he was himself actuated. It was not an embrace he craved but an opportunity to satisfy an almost frenzied curiosity as to the appearance and attributes of the sun who had grown to manhood under other eyes pushing him gently back he bade him stand in the light of the lamp burning on a small pine table and surveyed him as it were from the verge of his own fast-failing life with moans of mingled pain and weariness

amid which thomas thought he heard the accents of a supreme satisfaction meanwhile in thomas himself as he stood there the sense of complete desolation filled his breast almost to bursting, to have come home for this, to find a father, only to be weighed in the scales of that father's judgment, to be admired instead of loved. As he realized his position and listened to the shrieking of the wind and rain, he felt that the wail of the elements but echoed the cry of his own affections thus strangled in their birth. Indeed the sensations of that moment made so deep an impression upon him that he was never afterward able to hear a furious gust of wind or rain

without the picture rising up before him of this great hollow room with the trembling figure of his father struggling in the grasp of death and holding it at bay while he gaged with worldly wisdom the physical mental and moral advantages of the sun so long banished

and so lately restored to his arms A rush of impetuous words, followed by the collapse of his father's form upon the pillow, showed that the examination was over. Rushing forward he grasped again that father's hands, but soon shrank back, stunned by what he heard and the prospect it opened before him. A few of his father's words will interpret the rest. They came in a flood, and among others Thomas caught these. "'The grace of God be thanked. Our efforts have not failed. Handsome, strong, noble in look and character. We could ask nothing more, hope for nothing more. My revenge will succeed. John Poindexter will find that he has a heart and that that heart can be wrung. I do not need to live to see it. For me it exists now. It exists here. And he struck his breast with hands that

seemed to have reserved their last strength for this supreme gesture john poindexter who was he it was a new name to thomas venturing to say so he reeled under the look he received from his father's eyes you do not know who john poindexter is and what he has done to me and mine they have kept their promise well too well but god will accord me strength to tell you what has done to me and mine they have kept their promise well but god will accord me strength to tell you what has done to tell you what has done to me has been left unsaid by them. He would not bring me up to this hour to let me perish before you have heard the story destined to make you the avenger of innocence upon that enemy of your race. Listen, Thomas, with a hand of death encircling my heart I speak, and if the story find you cold, but it will not. Your name is Cadwallader, and it will not. constrained by passions such as he had never imagined even in dreams Thomas fell upon his knees. He could not listen otherwise.

His father, gasping for breath, fixed him with his hollow eyes, in which the last flickering flames of life flared up in fitful brightness. Thomas, the pause was brief, you are not my only child. I know it fell from Thomas. promises white lips i have a brother his name is felix the father shook his head with a look suggestive of impatience not him not him he cried a sister a sister who died before you were born beautiful good with a voice like an angel's and a heart she should be standing by my side to-day and she would have been if if he but none of that i have no breath to waste facts facts just facts afterward may come emotions hatred denunciation not now this is my story thomas end of book two chapter one part one book two chapter one part two of the circular study this is a librivox recording all librivox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit librivox dot o

the circular study by anna catherine green chapter one the secret of the cadwalladers part two john poindexter and i were friends from boyhood we shared each other's bed food and pleasures and when he came to seek his fortune in america i accompanied him he was an able man but cold i was of an affectionate nature but without any business capacity as proved of this, in fifteen years he was rich, esteemed, the master of a fine house, and the owner of half a dozen horses, while I was the same nobody I had been at first, or would have been, had not Providence given me two beautiful children, and blessed or rather cursed me with the friendship of this prosperous man. When Felix was fourteen and Evelyn three years older, their mother died. soon after the little money I had vanished in an unfortunate enterprise and life began to promise ill both for myself and for my growing children John Poindexter who was honest enough then or let me hope so and who had no children of his own though he had been long married offered to take one of mine to educate but I did not consent to this till the war of the rebellion broke out then I sent him both son and daughter and went in to the army. For four years I fought for the flag, suffering all that a man can suffer and live,

and being at last released from Libby Prison, came home with a heart full of gratitude and with every affection keyed up by a long series of unspeakable experiences, to greet my son and clasp once more within my wasted arms the idolized form of my deeply loved daughter. What did I find? A few in the street hers and felix your brother walking like a guard between her speechless corpse and the man under whose protection i had placed her youth and innocence betrayed shrieked the now frenzied parent rising on his pillow her innocence her sweetness and he cold as the stone we laid upon her grave had seen her perish with the anguish and shame of it without a sign of grief or a word of contrition oh god burst from the lips the old man was watching with frenzied cunning ay god repeated the father shaking his head as if in defiance before he fell back on his pillow he allowed it and i but this does not tell the story i must keep to facts as felix did felix who was but fifteen years old and yet found himself the only confident and solace of this young girl betrayed by her protector it was after her burial cease cried a voice smooth fresh and yet strangely commanding from over thomas's shoulder let me tell the rest no man can tell the rest as i can

felix ejaculated amos cadwallader below his breath felix repeated thomas shaken to his very heart by this new presence but when he sought to rise to turn he felt the pressure of a hand on his shoulder and his shoulder and heard that voice again, saying softly but peremptorily, Wait, wait till you hear what I have to say. Think not of me, think only of her. It is she who are called upon to avenge, your sister Evelyn. Thomas yielded to him as he had to his father. He sank down beneath that insistent hand, and his brother took up the tale.

Evelyn had a voice like a bird. in those days before father's return she used to fill old john poindexter's house with melody i who as a boy was studious rather than artistic thought she sang too much for a girl whose father was rotting away in a southern prison but when about to rebuke her i remembered edward kissum and was silent for it was his love which made her glad and to him i wished every happiness for he was good and honest and kind to me She was eighteen then and beautiful, or so I was bound to believe, since every man looked at her, even old John Poyne, Dexter, though he never looked at any other woman, not even his own wife. And she was good, too, and pure, I swear, for her blue eyes never faltered in looking into mine, until one day when, my God, how well I remember it, they not only faltered but shrank before me in such terror that, boy, though I was, I knew that something terrible, something unprecedented, had happened.

And, thinking my one thought, I asked if she had received bad news from Father. Her answer was a horrified moan, but it might have been a shriek. Our Father, pray God, we may never see him or hear from him again. If you love him, if you love me, pray he may die in prison rather than return here to see me as I am now. I thought she had gone mad, and perhaps she had for a moment, for at my look of startled distress, a change took place in her. She remembered my youth, and laughing or trying to laugh away her frenzy uttered some hurried words I failed to understand, and then, sinking at my knee, laid her head against my side, crying that she was not well, that she had experienced for a long time

secret pains and great inward distress, and that she sometimes feared she was not going to live long, for all her songs and merry ways and seeming health and spirits. Not live, Evelyn? It was an inconceivable thought to me, a boy. I looked at her and seeing how pale, how incomprehensibly pale she was, my heart failed me, for nothing but mortal sickness could make such a change in anyone in a week, in a day. Yet how could death reach her, loved as she was by Edward, by her father, and by me? Thinking to rouse her I spoke the former's name, but it was the last word I should have uttered. Crouching as if I had given her a blow, she put her two hands out, shrieking faintly.

Not that, never that. Do not speak his name. Let me never hear of him or see him again. I am dead. Do you not understand me? Dead to all the world from this day, except to you. she suddenly sobbed, except to you. And still I did not comprehend her. But when I understood, as I soon did, that no mention was to be made of her illness, that her door was to be shut and no one allowed to enter, not even Mrs. Poindexter or her guardian,

least of all her guardian, I began to catch the first intimation of that horror which was to end my youth and fill my whole afterlife with but one thought, revenge. But I said nothing, only watched and waited. Seeing that she was really ill, I constituted myself her nurse, and sat by her night and day, till her symptoms became so alarming that the whole household was aroused, and we could no longer keep the doctor from her. Then I sat at her door, and with one ear turned to catch her lightest moan, listened for the step she most dreaded,

but which, though it sometimes approached, never passed the opening of the hall leading to her chamber. For one whole week I sat there, watching her life go slowly out like a flame with nothing to feed it. Then as the great shadow fell, and life seemed breaking up within me, I dashed from the place, and confronting him where I found him walking, pale and disturbed in his own hall, told him that my father was coming, that I had had a dream, and in that dream I had seen my father with his face turn toward this place. Was he prepared to meet him? Had he an answer ready when Amos Cadwallader should ask him what had become of his child?

I had meant to shock the truth from this man, and I did so. As I mentioned my father's name, Poindexter blanched, and my fears became certainty. Dropping my youthful manner, for I was a boy no longer, I flung his crime in his face, and begged him to deny it if he could. He could not, but he did what neither he nor any other man could do in my presence now and live. He smiled.

Then when he saw me crouching for a spring, for young as I was I knew but one impulse and that was to fly at his throat, he put out his powerful hand and, pinning me to the ground, uttered a few short sentences in my ear. They were terrible ones. They made me see,

that nothing I might then do could obliterate the fact that she was lost if the world knew what I knew, or even so much as suspected it, that any betrayal on my part or act of contrition on his would only pile the earth on her innocent breast and sink her deeper and deeper into the grave she was then digging for herself, that all dreams were falsities, that southern prisons seldom gave up their victims alive, and that if my father should escape, the jaws of Libby and return, it was for me to be glad if he found a quiet grave instead of a dishonored daughter. Further, that if I crossed him, who was power itself, by any boyish exhibition of hate, I would find that any odium I might invoke would fall on her and not on him, making me

an abhorrence, not only to the world at large, but to the very father in whose interest I might pretend to act. I was young and without worldly experience. I yielded to these arguments, but I cursed him where he stood. With his hand pressing heavily upon me, I cursed him to his face. Then I went back to my sister. Had she by some supernatural power listened to our talk, or had she really been visited by some dream that she looked so changed? There was a feverish light in her eye and something like the shadow of a smile on her lips mrs poindexter was with her mrs poindexter whose face was a mask we never tried to penetrate but when she had left us alone again then evelyn spoke and i saw what her dream had been felix she cried as i approached her trembling with my own emotions and half afraid of hers there is still one hope for me it has come to me while you have been away edward he loves me did perhaps he would forgive if he would take me into his protection i see you know it all felix then i might grow happy again well strong good

do you think oh you are a child what do you know but-but before i turn my face forever to the wall try if he will see me try try with your boy's wit your clever schemes to get him here unknown to-to the one i fear i hate and then then if he bids me live i will live and if he bids me die i will die and all will be ended i was an ignorant boy i knew men no more than i knew women and yielding to her importunities i promised to see edward and plan for an interview without her guardian's knowledge i was as evelyn had said keen in those days and full of resources and i easily managed it edward who had watched from the garden as i had from the door was easily persuaded to climb her lattice in search of what he had every reason to believe would be his last earthly interview with his darling as his eager form bounded into the room i tottered forth carrying with me a vision of her face as she rose to meet what i dared not think or attempt to foresee falling on my knees i waited the issue alas it was a speedy one a stifled moan from her the sound of a hoarse farewell from him told me that his love had failed her and that her doom was sealed creeping back to her side as quickly as my failing courage admitted i found her face turned to the wall from which it never again looked back while presently before the hour was passed shouts ringing through the town proclaimed that young kissom had shot himself she heard and died that night in her last hours she had fancies she thought she saw her father and her prayers for mercy were heart-rending then she thought she saw him that demon her executioner and cringed and moaned against the wall but enough of this two days after i walked between him and her silent figure outstretched for burial

i had promised that no eye but mine should look upon her no other hand touch her and i kept my word even when the impossible happened and her father rose up in the street before us quietly and in honor she was carried to her grave and then then in the solitude of the retreat i had found for him i told our father all and why i had denied him the only comfort which seemed left to him a last look at his darling daughter's face end of book two chapter one book two chapter two of the circular study this is a little bit of the circular study this is a little bit of a little bit of the circular study this is a librivox recording all librivox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit librivox dot org the circular study by anna catherine green chapter two the oath a sigh from the panting breast of amos cadwallader followed these words plainer than speech it told of a grief still fresh and an agony still unappeased, though thirty years had passed away since the unhappy hour of which Felix spoke. Felix, echoing it went quickly on. It was dusk when I told my story, and from dark to dawn we sat with eyes fixed on each other's face, without sleep and without rest. Then we sought John Poindexter.

Had he shunned us we might have had mercy, but he met us openly, quietly. and with all the indifference of one who cannot measure feeling because he is incapable of experiencing it himself. His first sentence evinced this. Spare yourself, spare me all useless recriminations. The girl is dead, I cannot call her back again. Enjoy your life, your eating and your drinking, your getting and your spending. It is but for a few more years at best. Why harp on old griefs?

His last word was a triumph. When a man cares for nothing or nobody, it is useless to curse him. Ah, that was it. That was the secret of his power. He cared for nothing and for no one, not even for himself. We felt the blow and bent under it. But before leaving him in the town, we swore your father and I that we would yet make that cold heart feel,

that someday in some way we would cause that impassive nature to suffer as he had made us suffer, however happy he might seem, or however closely his prosperity might cling to him. That was thirty years ago, and that oath has not yet been fulfilled. Felix paused. Thomas lifted his head, but the old man would not let him speak. There are men who forget in a month, others who forget in a year. I have never forgotten, nor has Felix here. When you were born, I had married again in the hope of renewed joy,

I felt, I know not why, that Evelyn's Avenger was come. And when, a year or so after this event, we heard that God had forgotten John Poindexter's sins, or perhaps remembered them, and that a child was given him also after 18 years of marriage, life, I looked upon your bonny face and saw, or thought I saw, a possible means of bringing about the vengeance to which Felix and I had dedicated our lives. You grew, your ardent nature, generous temper and facile mind, promised an abundant manhood, and when your mother died,

leaving me for a second time a widower, I no longer hesitated to devote you to the purpose. for which you seemed born. Thomas, do you remember the beginning of that journey which finally led you far from me? How I bore you on my shoulder along a dusty road, till arrived within sight of his home, I raised you from among the tombs, and showing you those distant gables looming black

against the twilight's gold, dedicated you to the destruction of whatever happiness might hereafter develop under his infant's smile. you do i did not think you could forget and now that the time has come for the promise of that hour to be fulfilled i call on you again thomas avenge our griefs avenge your sister john poindexter's girl has grown to womanhood at the suggestion conveyed in these words thomas recoiled in horror but the old man failed to read his emotion rightly clutching his arm he proceeded passionately. Woo her! Win her! They do not know you.

You will be Thomas Adams to them, not Thomas Cadwallader. Gather this budding flower into your bosom, and then... Oh, he must love his child. Through her we have our hand on his heart. Make her suffer. She's but a country girl,

and you have lived in Paris. Make her suffer. And if in doing so you cause him to blench, then believe i am looking upon you from the grave i go to and be happy for you will not have lived nor will i have died in vain he paused to catch his failing breath but his indomitable will triumphed over death and held thomas under a spell that confounded his instincts and made him the puppet of feelings which had accumulated their force to fill him in one hour with a hate which it had taken his father and brother a quarter of a century to bring to the point of active vengeance i shall die i am dying now the old man panted on I shall never live to see your triumph. I shall never behold John Poindexter's eye

glaze with those sufferings which rend the entrails and make a man question if there is a God in heaven. But I shall know it where I am. No mound at earth can keep my spirit down when John Poindexter feels his doom. I shall be conscious of his anguish and shall rejoice. And when in the depths of darkness, to which I go, he comes faltering along my way.

Boy, boy, you have been reared for this. God made you handsome. Man has made you strong. You have made yourself intelligent and accomplished. You have only to show yourself to this country girl to become the master of her will and affection, and these once yours, Remember me, remember Evelyn!

Never had Thomas been witness to such a person. passion it swept him along in a burning stream against which he sought to contend and could not raising his hand in what he meant as a response to that appeal he endeavored to speak but failed his father misinterpreted his silence and bitterly cried you are dumb you do not like the task are virtuous perhaps you who have lived for years alone and unhampered in paris or you have instincts of honor habits of generosity that blind you to wrongs that for a longer space than your lifetime have cried aloud to heaven for vengeance thomas thomas if you should fail me now he will not fail you broke in the voice of felix calm suave and insinuating i have watched him i know him he will not fail you thomas shuddered he had forgotten felix but as he heard these words he could no longer delay looking at the man who had offered to stand his surety for the performance of the unholy deeds his father exacted from him turning he saw a man who in any place and under any roof would attract attention awake admiration and yes fear he was not a large man not so large as himself but the will that expressed its in frenzy on his father's lips, showed quiet and inflexible in the gray eye resting upon his own

with a power he could never hope to evade. As he looked and comprehended, a steel band seemed to compress his heart, yet he was conscious at the same time that the personality before which he thus succumbed was as elegant as his own and as perfectly trained in all the ways of men and of life. even the air of poverty which had shocked him in his father's person and surroundings was not visible here felix was both well and handsomely clad and could hold his own as the elder brother in every respect most insisted upon by the parisian gentleman the long and to thomas mysterious curtain of dark-green surge which stretched behind him from floor to ceiling threw out his pale features with a remarkable distinctness, and for an instant Thomas wondered if it had been hung there for the purpose of producing this effect. But the demand in his brother's face drew his attention, and bowing his head he stammered, I am at your command, Felix, I am at your command, father, I cannot say more,

only remember that I never saw Evelyn, that she died before I was born, and that I— But here Felix's voice. voice broke in kind but measured perhaps there is some obstacle we have not reckoned upon you may already love some woman and desire to marry her if so it need be no impediment but here thomas's indignation found voice no said he i am heart-whole save for a few lingering fancies which are fast becoming vanishing dreams he seemed to have lived years since entering the this room. Your heart will not be disturbed now, commented Felix. I have seen the girl. I went there on purpose a year ago. She's as pale as a snowdrop and as listless. You will not be obliged to recall to mind the gay smiles of Parisian ladies to be proof against her charms. Thomas shrugged his shoulders. She must be made to know the full intoxication of hope, Felix

proceeded in his clear and cutting voice. To realize despair, she must first experience every delight that comes with satisfied love. Have you the skill as well as heart to play to the end, a role which will take patience as well as dissimulation, courage as well as subtlety, and that union of will will and implacability which finds its food in tears, and is strengthened rather than lessened by the suffering of its victim? I have the skill, murmured Thomas, but— You lack the incentive, finished Felix. Well, well, we must have patience with your doubts and hesitations.

Our hate has been fostered by memories of her whom, as you say, you have never seen. look then Thomas look at your sister as she was as she is for us look at her and think of her as despoiled killed forgotten by poindexter have you ever gazed upon a more moving countenance or one in which beauty contends with a keener prophecy of woe not knowing what to expect anticipating almost to be met by her shade Thomas followed the direction of his brother's lifted hand and beheld where but a minute before that dismal curtain had hung a blaze of light in the midst of which he saw a charming but tragic figure such as no gallery in all europe had ever shown him possibly because no other limned face or form had ever appealed to his heart it did not seem a picture it seemed her very self a gentle loving self that breathed forth all the tenderness he had vainly sought for in his living relatives and falling at her feet he cried out do not look at me so reproachfully sweet evelyn i was born to avenge you and i will john poindexter shall never go down in peace to his tomb. A sigh of utter contentment came from the direction of the bed. Swear it, cried his father, holding out his arms before him in the form of a cross.

Yes, swear it, repeated Felix, laying his own hand on those crossed arms. Thomas drew near and laid his hand beside that of Felix. I swear he began, raising his voice above the tempest which poured gust after gust against the house i swear to win the affections of eva poindexter and then when her heart is all mine to cast her back in anguish and contumely on the breast of john poindexter good came from what seemed to him an immeasurable distance then the darkness which since the taking of this oath had settled over his senses fell and he saw sank insensible at the feet of his dying father. Amos Cadwallader died that night, but not without one awful scene more. About midnight he roused from the sleep which had followed the exciting incidents I have just related,

and, glancing from Thomas to Felix, sitting on either side of the bed, fixed his eyes with a strange gleam upon the door. Ah, he ejaculated a visitor, John Poindexter. He comes to ask my forgiveness before I set out on my dismal journey. The sarcasm of his tone, the courtesy of his manner, caused the hair to stir on the heads of his two sons, that he saw his enemy as plainly as he saw them, neither could doubt. Does he dread my meeting with Evelyn? Does he wish to placate me before I am joined to that pathetic shade? He shall not be disappointed.

I forgive you, John Poindexter. I forgive you my daughter's shame, my blighted life. I am dying, but I leave one behind who will not forgive you. I have a son, an avenger of the dead, who yet lives to—to— He fell back, with these words which seemed to seal Thomas to— his task, Amos Cadwallader died. End of Book 2, Chapter 2. Book 2, Chapter 3, Part 1 of The Circular Study.

This is a Librevox recording. All Librevox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librevox.org. The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green. Chapter 3 Eva Part 1 Felix had not inherited his father's incapacity for making money. In the 20 years that had passed since Thomas had been abroad he had built up a fortune

which he could not induce his father to share but which that father was perfectly willing to see devoted to their mutual revenge. There was meaning, therefore, in the injunction Felix gave his brother on his departure for Montgomery. i have money spend it spend what you will and when your task is completed there will still be some left for your amusement thomas bowed the labourer is worthy of his hire was his thought and you he asked looking about at the scanty walls which seemed to have lost their very excuse for being now that his father had died will you remain here felix's answer was abrupt but positive No, I go to New York tomorrow. I have rented a house there which you may one day wish to

share. The name under which I have leased it is Adams, Felix Adams. As such, you will address me. Cadwallader is a name that must not leave your lips in Montgomery, nor must you forget that my person is known there. Otherwise,

we might not have been dependent on you for the success of our revenge. And he smiled, fully conscious of being the handsomer man of the two. And now, how about those introductions we enjoined you to bring from Paris? The history of the next few weeks can best be understood by reading certain letters sent by Thomas to Felix by examining a diary drawn up by the same writer

for his own relief and satisfaction. The letters will be found on the left and the diary on the right of the double columns hereby submitted. The former are a summary of facts. The latter is a summary of feelings. Both are necessary to a right comprehension of the situation. First letter, dear Felix, I am here, I have seen her. She is, as you have said, a pale blonde. To-morrow I present my credentials to John Poindexter. From what I have already experienced, I anticipate a favorable reception. Yours affectionately, Thomas First entry

I could not write Felix the true story of this day. Why, and why must I write it here, to turn my mind from dwelling on it? Perhaps I do not seem to understand my own feelings or why I begin to dread my task while ardently pressing forward to accomplish it. I have seen her, this much I wrote to Felix, but I did not say where our meeting took place, or how?

How could I? Would he understand how one of Poindexter's blood could be employed in a gracious act, or how I, filled with a purpose that has made my heart dark as hell ever since I embraced it, could find that heart swell and that purpose sink, at my first glimpse of the face whose beauty I have sworn to devote to agony and tears? Surely, surely Felix would have been stronger, and yet? I went from the cars to the cemetery. Before entering the town or seeing to my own comfort,

I sought Evelyn's grave, there to renew my oath in the place where, 19 years ago, my father held me up, a four-year-old child, in threat toward John Poindexter's home. I had succeeded in finding the old and neglected steep. stone which marked her resting place, and was bending in the sunset light to examine it, when the rustle of a woman's skirts attracted my attention, and I perceived advancing toward me a young girl in a nimbus of rosy light which seemed to lift her from the ground, and give to her delicate figure and strangely illumined head an ethereal aspect which her pure features and tender bearing did not belie.

In her arm she carried a huge cluster of snow-white lilies, and when I observed that her eyes were directed not on me, but on the grave beside which I stood, I moved aside into the shadow of some bushes, and watched her while she strewed these flowers, emblems of innocence, over the grave I had just left. What did it mean? and who was this young girl who honored with such gracious memorials,

the grave of my long-buried sister? As she rose from her task I could no longer restrain either my emotion or the curiosity with which her act had inspired me. Advancing, I greeted her with all the respect her appearance called for, and noting that her face was even more beautiful when lifted in speech than when bent in gravity over her flowers, i asked her in the indifferent tone of a stranger who was buried in this spot and why she a mere girl dropped flowers upon a grave the mosses of whose stone proved it to have been dug long before she was born her answer caused me a shock full as my life has lately been of startling experiences i strew flowers here said she because the girl who lies buried under this stone had the same birthday as my life has lately been of startling experiences i strew flowers here said she because the girl who lies buried under this stone had the same birthday as

myself i never saw her it's true but she died in my father's house when she was no older than i am to-day and since i have become a woman and realize what loss there is in dying young i have made it accustomed to share with her my birthday flowers she was a lily they say in appearance and character and so i bring her lilies it was eva poindexter the girl i and she was strewing flowers on evelyn's grave letter two dear felix i have touched the hand of john poindexter in order to win a place in the good graces of the daughter i must please the father or at least attract his favourable notice i have reason to think i have done this very truly thomas entry two i no longer feel myself a true man john poignant Dexter is cold in appearance, hard in manner, and inflexible in opinion, but he does not inspire the abhorrence I anticipated, nor awaken in me the one thought due to the memory of my sister. Is it because he is Eva's father? Has the loveliness of the daughter cast a halo about the parent? If so, Felix has a right to execrate me and my father to...

Letter three dear felix the introductions furnished me have made me received everywhere there is considerable wealth here and many fine houses consequently i find myself in congenial society of which she is the star did i say that he was as of old the chief man of the town yours truly thomas entry three she is beautiful she has the daintiness of the lily and the flogethy she has the daintiness of the lily and the of the rose. But it is not her beauty that moves me. It is the strange sweetness of her nature, which nevertheless has no weakness in it. On the contrary, it possesses peculiar strength, which becomes instantly apparent at the call of duty. Could Felix have imagined such a poindexter? I cannot contemplate such loveliness and associate it with the excreble sin which calls down vengeance upon this house. I cannot even dwell upon my past life. All that is dark, threatening,

secret and revengeful slips from me under her eye, and I dream of what is pure, true, satisfying, and ennobling. And this by the influence of her smile, rather than of her words, have I been given an angel to degrade, or am I so blind as to behold a saint where others, Felix, let us say, would see only a pretty woman with unexpected attractions. Letter four, dear Felix, rides, dances, games, nonsense generally. My interest in this young girl is beginning to be publicly recognized. She alone seems ignorant of it. I wonder if our scheme will fail through her impassibility and more than conventional innocence.

I am sometimes afraid she will never love me, yet I have exerted myself to please her. Indeed, I could not have exerted myself more. Today I went twenty-five miles on horseback to procure her a trifle she fancied. Yours affectionately, Thomas. Entry four All will not go as easily as Felix imagines. Eva Poindexter may be a country girl, but she has her standards, too, and mere grace and attainment are not sufficient to win her.

Have I the other qualities she demands? That remains to be seen. I have one she never dreams of. Will it shadow so overwhelm the rest that her naturally pure spirit will shrink from me just at the moment when I think her mind? I cannot tell, and the doubt creates a hell within me. Something deeper, stronger, more imperious than my revenge,

makes the winning of this girl's heart a necessity to me i have forgotten my purpose in this desire i have forgotten everything except that she is the one woman of my life and that i can never rest till her heart is wholly mine good god have i become a slave where i hoped to be master have i thomas cadwallader given my soul into the keeping of this innocent girl i do not even stop to inquire to win her-her That is all for which I now live. Letter 5. Dear Felix, she may not care for me, but she is interested in no one else. Of this I am assured by John Poindexter, who seems very desirous of aiding me in my attempt to win his daughter's heart. Hard one, close bound. If she ever comes to love me, it will be with the force of a very strong nature.

The pale blonde has a heart. Yours affectionately, Thomas Entry 5 If it were passion only that I feel I might have some hope of restraining it But it is something more, something deeper, Something which constrains me to look with her eyes, Hear with her ears, and throb with her heart.

My soul rather than my senses is enthralled. I want to win her, not for my own satisfaction, but to make her happy. I want to prove to her that goodness exists in this world. I who came here to corrode and destroy, I who am still pledged to do so. Ah, Felix, Felix, you should have chosen an older man for your purpose, or remembered that he who could be influenced as I was by family affections possesses a heart too soft for such infamy. Entry 6. The name of Evelyn is never mentioned in this house sometimes I think that he has forgotten her and find in this thought the one remaining spur to my revenge forgotten her strange that his child

born long after his victim's death should remember this poor girl and he forget yet on the daughter the blow is planned to fall if it does fall should I not pray that it never may that she should loathe instead of love me trust instead of confide in my honour and affection? But who can pray against himself? Eva Poindexter must love me, even if I am driven to self-destruction by my own remorse after she has confided her heart to my keeping. Letter 6. Dear Felix, will you send me a few exquisite articles from Tiffany's? I see that her father expects me to give her presence. I think she will accept them.

If she does, we may both rest easy as to the state of her affections. Very truly, Thomas. Entry seven. I cannot bring myself to pass a whole day away from her side. If Felix were here and could witness my assiduity, he would commend me in his cold and inflexible heart for the singleness with which I pursue my purpose. He would say to me in the language of one of his letters,

you are not disappointing us us as if our father still hovered near sharing our purposes and hope alas if he does he must penetrate more deeply than felix into the heart of this matter must see that with every day's advantage and now i think each day brings its advantage i shrink further and further from the end they planned for me the end which can alone justify my advance in her affections I am a traitor to my oath, for now I know I shall never disappoint Eva's faith in me. I could not. Rather would I meet my father's accusing eyes on the verge of that strange world to which he has gone, or Felix's recriminations here, or my own contempt for the weakness which has made it possible for me to draw back from the brink of this wicked revenge to which I have devoted myself. Letter 7

dear felix this morning i passed under the window you have described to me as evelyn's i did it with a purpose i wanted to test my own emotions and to see how much feeling it would arouse in me enough eva accepted the brooch it was the simplest thing you sent affectionately thomas entry eight i hate john poindexter yes i hate him but i can never hear his daughter only Felix could so confound the father with a child as to visit his anger upon this gentle embodiment of all that is gracious all that is trustworthy all that is fascinating in woman but am I called upon to hate her am I not in a way required to love her I will ask Felix no I cannot ask Felix he would never comprehend her charm or its influence over me he would have doubts and come at once to Montgomery. Good God, am I proving such a traitor to my own flesh and blood that I cannot bear to think of Felix contemplating even in secret the unsuspicious form of his enemy's daughter? Letter 8. Dear Felix, a picnic on the mountains. It fell to me to escort Miss Poindexter down a dangerous slope, though no words of affection passed between us. She is not yet ready

for them. I feel that I have made a decided advance in her good graces. Yours, Thomas. Entry nine. I have touched her hand. I have felt her sweet form thrilling against mine as we descended the mountain ledges together. No man was near, no eye. There were moments in which we were as much alone in the wide paradise of these wooded slopes as if the world held no other breathing soul. Yet I no more dared to press her hand or pour forth the mad worship of my heart into her innocent ears than if the eyes of all Paris had been upon us. How I love her, how far off and faint seem the years of that dead crime my brother would invoke for the punishment of this sweet soul. Yes, and how remote that awful hour in which I knelt beneath the hand of my dying father and swore,

Ah, that oath, that oath! Entry ten. The thing I dreaded, the thing I might have foreseen, has occurred. Felix has made his appearance in Montgomery. I received a communication to that effect from him today, a communication in which he commands me to meet him tonight at Evelyn's grave at the witching hour of twelve. I do not enjoy the summons.

I have a dread of Felix, and beckoned. to think he calculates upon stage devices to control me. But the day is passed for that. I will show him that I can be no more influenced in that place and at that hour than I could be in this hotel room with a sight of her little glove. Is there sin in such thefts, lying on the table before us? Evelyn, she is a sacred memory,

but the dead must not interfere with the living. Eva shall never be sacrificed to Evelyn. manes, not if John Poindexter lives out his life to his last hour in peace, not if Felix, well, I need to play the man. Felix is a formidable antagonist to meet alone in a spot of such rancorous memories at an hour when spirits, if there be spirits, haunt the precincts of the tomb. Entry 11 I should not have known Felix had I met him in the street. How much of a stranger he appeared then in the faint moonlight which poured upon that shaded spot.

His very voice seemed altered, and in his manner I remarked a hesitation I had not supposed him capable of showing under any circumstances. Nor were his words such as I expected. The questions I dreaded most he did not ask, the recriminations I looked for he did not utter. He only told me coldly that my courtship must be short. that the end for which we were both prepared must be hastened, and gave me two weeks in which to bring matters to a climax. Then he turned to Evelyn's grave, and, bending down, tried to read her name on the mossy stone. He was so long in doing this that I leaned down beside him and

laid my hand on his shoulder. He was trembling, and his body was as cold as the stone he threw himself against. Was it the memory of her whom that stone covered which had aroused this emotion? If so it was but natural. To all appearance he has never in all his life loved anyone as he did this unhappy sister, and struck with a respect for the grief which has outlived many a man's lifetime, I was shrinking back when he caught my hand and with a convulsive strain contrasting strongly with his tone, which was strangely measured, he crouched. He crowsing, cried, Do not forget the end. Do not forget John Poindexter, his sin, his indifference to my father's grief, the accumulated sufferings of years which made Amos Cadwallader a hermit amongst men. I have seen the girl. She has changed. Women do change at her age. And some men, I do not say you, but some men might think her beautiful. But beauty, if she has it, must not blind your eyes, which are fixed upon another goal overlook it overlook her you have done so have you not pale beauties cannot move one who has sat at the feet of the most dazzling of parisian women keep your eyes on john poindexter the debt he owes us and the suffering we have promised him

that she is sweet gentle different from all we have thought her only makes the chances of reaching his heart the greater the worthier she may be of affections not in did to that hard soul the surer will be our grip upon his nature and the heavier his downfall the old spell was upon me i could neither answer nor assert myself letting go my hand he rose and with his back to the village i noticed he had not turned his face to it since coming to this spot he said i shall return to new york to-morrow in two weeks you will telegraph your readiness to take up your abode with me i have a home that will satisfy you and it will soon be all your own here he gripped his heart and dark as it was i detected a strange convulsion cross his features as he turned into the moonlight but it was gone before we could descend you may hear from me again he remarked somewhat faintly as he grasped my hand and turned away in his own direction i had not spoken a word during the whole interview end of book two chapter three part one Book 2, Chapter 3, Part 2 of The Circular Study. This is a Librevox recording.

All Librevox recordings are in the public domain. For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librevox.org. The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green. Chapter 3, Eva, Part 2. Letter 9 Dear Felix, I do not hear from you. Are you well, or did your journey affect your health? I have no especial advance to report. John Poindexter seems greatly interested in my courtship. Sometimes he gives me very good advice. How does that strike you, Felix?

Affectionately, Thomas Entry 12 I shall never understand Felix. He has not left the town but is staying here in high. watching me no doubt to see if the signs of weakening he doubtless suspects in me have a significance deep enough to overthrow his planned revenge i know this because i have seen him more than once during the last week when he thought himself completely invisible i have caught sight of him in mr poindexter's grounds when eva and i stood talking together in the window i even saw him once in church in a dark corner to be sure but where he could keep his eye upon us sitting together in mr poindexter's pew he seemed to me thin that day the suspense he is under is wearing upon him is it my duty to cut it short by proclaiming my infidelity to my oath and my determination to marry the girl who has made me forget it? Letter ten.

Dear Felix, Miss Poindexter has told me unreservedly that she cares for me. Are you satisfied with me now? In haste, Thomas. Entry 13. She loves me. Oh, ecstasy of life, Eva Poindexter loves me!

I forced it from her lips today, with my arms around her and her head on my shoulder, I urged her to confession, and it came. Now let Felix do what he will. What is old John Poindexter to me? Her father? What are Amos Cadwalliter's hatred and the mortal wrong that called so loudly for revenge? Dead issues, long-buried sorrows, which God may remember, but which men are bound to forget? Life, life with her. That is the future toward which I look. That is the only vengeance I will take, the only vengeance Evelyn can demand if she is the angel we believe her. I will write to Felix tomorrow.

Entry 14. I have not written, Felix. I had not the courage. Entry 15. I have had a dream. I thought I saw the meeting of my father with the white shade of Evelyn in the unimaginable recesses of that world to which both have gone. strange horrors stranger glories met as their separate paths crossed and when the two forms had greeted and parted a line of light followed the footsteps of the one and a trail of gloom those of the other as their ways divided i heard my father cry there is no spot on your garments evelyn can it be that the wrongs of earth are forgotten here that mortals remember what the angels forget and that our revenge is late for one so blessed? I did not hear the answer, for I woke,

but the echo of those words has rung in my ears all day. Is our revenge late for one so blessed? Entry 16. I have summoned up courage. Felix has been here again, and the truth has at last been spoken between us. I had been pressing Eva to name our wedding day, and we were all standing, that is, John.

on poindexter my dear girl and myself in the glare of the drawing-room lights when i heard a groan too faint for other ears to catch followed by a light fall from the window overlooking the garden it was felix he had been watching us had seen my love heard me talk of marriage and must now be in the grounds in open frenzy or secret satisfaction it is hard to tell which determined to know determined to speak i excused my myself on some hurried plea, and searched the paths he knew as well as I. At last I came upon him. He was standing near an old dial where he had more than once seen Eva and me together. He was very pale, deathly pale it seemed to me, in the faint starlight shining upon that open place. But he greeted me as usual very quietly and with no surprise, almost in fact as if he knew I would recognize his presence and follow him. you are playing your role well said he too well what was that i heard about your marrying the time had come i was determined to meet it with a man's courage but i found it hard

felix is no easy man to cross even in small things and this thing is his life nay more his past present and future existence i do not know who spoke first there was some stammering a few broken words then i heard myself saying distinctly and with a certain hard emphasis born of the restraint i put upon myself i love her i want to marry her you must allow this then i could not proceed i felt the shock he had received almost as if it had been communicated to me by contact something that was not of the earth seemed to pass between us and i remember raising my hand as if to shield my face and then whether it was the blowing aside of some branches which kept the moonlight from us or because my eyesight was made clearer by my emotion i caught one glimpse of his face and became conscious of a great suffering which at first seemed the wrenching of my own heart but in another moment impressed itself upon me as that of his felix's i stood appalled my weakness had uprooted the one hope of his life or so i thought and that he expressed this by silence made my heart yearn toward him for the first time since i recognized him as my brother i tried to stammer some excuse i was glad when the darkness fell again for the sight of his bowed head and set features was insupportable to me. It seemed to make it easier for me to talk, for me to dilate upon the purity, the goodness which had robbed me of my heart in spite of myself. My heart, it seemed a strange

word to pass between us two in reference to a poindexter, but it was the only one capable of expressing the feeling I had for this young girl. At last, driven to frenzy by his continued silence which had something strangely moving in it, I cried. You have never loved a woman, Felix. You do not know what the passion is when it seizes upon a man, jaded with the hollow pleasures of an irresponsible life. You cannot judge, therefore you cannot excuse. You are made of iron.

Hush! It was the first word he had spoken since I had opened my heart to him. You do not know what you are saying, Thomas. Like all egotists you think yourself. alone in experience and suffering will you think so when i tell you that there was a time in my life when i did not sleep for weeks when the earth the air yes and the heavens were full of nothing but her name her face her voice when to have held her in my arms to have breathed into her ear one word of love to have felt her cheek fall against mine in confidence in passion in hope would have been to me the heaven which would have driven the dead devils from my soul forever? Thomas, will you believe I do not know the uttermost of all you are experiencing, when I here declare to you that there has been an hour in my life when, if I had felt

she could have brought love to me, I would have sacrificed Evelyn, my own soul, our father's hope, John Poindexter's punishment, and become the weak thing you are today and gloried in it? I, Felix Cadwallader, the man of iron, who has never been known. to falter? But Thomas I overcame that feeling. I crushed down that love, and I call upon you to do the same. You may marry her, but—' What stopped him? His own heart or my own impetuosity? Both, perhaps, for at that moment I fell at his feet, and, seizing his hand, kissed it as I might a woman's. He seemed to grow cold and stiff under this embrace, which showed both the delirium I was laboring under,

and the relief I had gotten from his words. When he withdrew his hand, I felt that my doom was about to be spoken, and I was not wrong. It came in these words. Thomas, I have yielded to your importunity and granted you the satisfaction which under the same circumstances I would have denied myself. But it has not made me less hard toward you. Indeed, the steel with which you say my heart is bound seems tightening about it, as if the momentary weakness in which I have indulged called for revenge. Thomas go on your way, make the girl your wife.

I had rather you would, since she is, what she is. But after she has taken your name, after she believes herself secure in her honorable position and your love, then you are to remember our compact and your oath. Back upon John Poindexter's care she is to be thrown, shortly, without explanation or excuse. and if it costs you your life you are to stand firm in this attitude using but one weapon in the struggle which may open between you and her father and that is your name of cadwallader you will not need any other thomas do you swear to this or must i direct my own power against eva poindexter and by telling her your motive in courting her make her hate you forever

i will swear i cried overpowered by the alternative with which he threatened me give me the bliss of calling her mine and i will follow your wishes in all that concerns us thereafter you will there was a sinister tone in this ejaculation that gave a shock to my momentary complacency but we are so made that an anticipated evil affects us less than an immediate one and remembering that weeks must yet elapse during which he or John Poindexter or even myself might die, I said nothing, and he went isily on. I give you two months, alone and untrammeled, then you are to bring your bride to my house, there to hear my final decision. There is to be no departure from this course. I shall expect you, Thomas, you and her. You can say that you're going to make her acquainted with your brother. I will be there, I murmured, feeling a greater oppression than when I took the oath at my father's deathbed. I will be there. There was no answer. While I was repeating

those four words, Felix vanished. Letter 11. Dear Felix, have a fresh draft made. I need cigars, clothes, and a wedding ring. But no, let me stop short there. We will be married without one unless you force it upon us. Eva's color is blue. Very truly, Thomas. entry seventeen to-day i wrote again to felix he is at home must be for i have neither seen nor felt his presence since that fateful night what did i write i don't remember i seem to be living in a dream everything is confused about me but eva's face eva's smile they are blissfully clear sometimes i wish they were not were they confused amid these shadows i might have stronger hope of keeping my word to felix now i shall never keep it eva once my wife separation between us will become impossible john poindexter is ill letter twelve dear felix congratulations visits from my neighbors all the accla we could wish or a true lover hate the ring you sent fits as if made for her i am called in all directions by a thousand duties i am on exhibition and every one's curiosity must be satisfied in haste thomas entry eighteen

the wedding is postponed john poindexter is very ill pray god felix hears nothing of this he would come here he would confront his enemy on his bed of sickness he would denounce him and eva would be lost to me letter thirteen dear felix eva is not pleased with the arrangements which have been made for our wedding john poindexter likes show she does not which will carry the day yours affectionately thomas entry nineteen mr poindexter is better but our plans will have to be altered we now think we will be married quietly possibly in new york letter fourteen dear felix a compromise has been affected the wedding will be a quiet one but not celebrated here as you cannot wish to attend it i will not mention the place or hour of my marriage only say that on september twenty seventh at four 4 p.m. You may expect my wife and myself at your house, affectionately Thomas. Entry 20. We have decided to be married in New York. Mr. Poindexter needs the change, and Eva and I are delighted at the prospect of a private wedding. Then we will be near Felix, but not to subject ourselves to his will. Oh, no. Entry 21. Married. She is mine. And now to confront Felix with my determination to hold on to my happiness. How I love her and how I pity him.

John Poindexter's wickedness is forgotten, evil in but a fading memory. The whole world seems to hold but three persons, Eva, Felix, and myself. How will it end? We meet at his home tomorrow. End of Book 2, Chapter 3, Part 2. Book 2, Chapter 4 of The Circular Study. This is a Librevox recording. All Libravox recordings are in the public domain. For more information, or to volunteer, please visit Librevox.org. The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green, Chapter 4, Felix.

Meanwhile, there was another secret struggle going on in the depth of a nature from which all sympathy was excluded, both by the temperament of the person concerned and the circumstances surrounding him. I can but hint at it. Some tragedies lie beyond the ken of men, and this one we can but gather from stray scraps of torn-up letters addressed to no one, and betraying their authorship only through the writer's hand. they were found long after the mystery of felix catwallader's death had been fully accounted for tucked away under the flooring of bartow's room where or how procured by him who can tell madness i have seen eva poindexter again and heaven and hell have contended for me ever since eva eva the girl i thought of only as our prey the girl i have given to my brother she is too lovely for him she is too lovely for any man unless it be one who has never before thrilled to any woman's voice or seen a face that could move his passions or awaken his affection

is it love i feel can i felix who have had but one thought known but one enthusiasm retain in this breast of iron a spot however secret however small which any woman least of all his daughter could reach never i am the prey of frenzy or the butt of devils yet only the inhabitants of a more celestial sphere brighten around me when i think of those half-raised eyes those delicately parted lips so devoid of guile that innocent bearing and the divine tenderness mingled with strength by which she commands admiration and awakens love i must fly i must never see her again thomas's purpose is steady he must never see that mine rocks like an idol smitten by a thunderbolt if thomas had not been reared in paris he too but i am the only weak one curses on my did i say i would fly i cannot not yet one more glimpse of her face if only to satisfy myself that i have reason for this method madness. Perhaps I was but startled yesterday to find a celestial loveliness where I expected to encounter pallid inanity. If my emotion is due to my own weakness rather than to her superiority, I had better recognized my folly before it proves my destruction. I will stay and Thomas will not, shall not, Dexter's daughter, hate, hate for Tomp!

my self-esteem is restored i have seen her again him they were together there was true love in his eye how could i expect him not to love her and i was able to hide my anguish and impose his duty on him she loves him or he thinks so and the work goes on but i will not stay to watch its accomplishment no no i told him my story to-night under the guise of a past experience oh the devils must laugh at us men they have reason to sometimes i wonder if my father in the clearness of his new vision does not join them in their mirth home with my unhappy secret home where nothing comes to distract me from my gnawing griefs and almost intolerable thoughts i walk the floors i cry aloud her name i cry it even under the portrait of evelyn there are moments when i am tempted to write to thomas to forbid him eva eva eva every fibre in my miserable body utters the one word but no man shall bea ever know Thomas shall never know how the thought of her fills my days and nights making my life a torment and the future I wait for his letters scanty they are and cold as the doomed criminal awaits his executioner does she really love him or will that exquisite that soulful nature call for a stronger mate a more concentrated temperament a i thought i saw in one of my dark hours my father rising up from his grave to curse me oh he might curse on if what have i said about no man knowing bartow knows in his dumbness his deafness he has surprised my secret and shows that he has done so by his peering looks his dissatisfied ways

and a jealousy at which i could shout aloud in mirth if i were not more tempted to shriek aloud in torment a dumb serving man picked up i have almost forgotten where jealous of my weakness for john poindexter's daughter he was never jealous of my feeling for evelyn yet till the day i dared fate by seeking out and looking for the second time upon the woman whose charms i had scorned her name often resounded through these rooms and my eyes dwelt upon but one spot and that was where her picture hangs in the woeful beauty which has become my reproach i have had a great surprise the starling which was a-ixture has been taught to murmur evelyn's name to-day shrieked out eva eva my first impulse was to wring its neck my next to take it from its cage and hide it in my bosom but i did neither i am still a man barcho will ring that bird's neck if i do not this morning i caught him with his hand on the cage and a murderous light in his eye which i had no difficulty in understanding yet he cannot hear the word the wretched starling murmurs he only knows it is a word a name and he is determined to suppress it shall i string the cage up out of this old fellow's reach his deafness his inability to communicate with others the exactness with which he obeys my commands as given him by my coloured slides his attention to my every wish consequent upon his almost animal love for my person are necessary to me now while the bird ah there it goes again eva eva is it hate or love i feel abhorrence or passion

love would seek to save but i have no thought of saving her since she has acknowledged her love for thomas and since he oh it is not now for evelyn's sake i plan revenge but for my own these nights and days of torture the revelation i have had of my own nature the consent i was forced to give to a marriage which means bliss to them and anguish beyond measure to me all this calls for vengeance and they will not escape these two i have laid my plans deep i have provided for every contingency it has taken time thought money but the result is good if they cross the threshold of my circular study they must consent to my will or perish here and I with them. Oh, they shall never live and be happy. Thomas need not think it. John Poindexter need not think it. I might have forgotten the oath made on my father's crossed arms, but I will never forget the immeasurable griefs of these past months or the humiliation they have brought me. My own weakness is to be avenged, my unheard of, my intolerable weakness. remember evelyn remember felix ah again eva eva eva

eva end of book two chapter four book two chapter five of the circular study this is a librivox recording all librivox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit librivox dot org the circular study by Anna Catherine Green Chapter 5 Why the Iron Slide Remained Stationary The rest must be told in Thomas's own words as it forms the chief part of the confession

he made before the detectives According to my promise I took my young wife to Felix's house On the day and at the hour proposed We went on foot for it was not far from the hotel Where we were then staying and were received at the door by an old servant who I had been warned could neither speak nor hear. At sight of him and the dim old-fashioned hall stretching out in aristocratic gloom before us,

Eva turned pale and cast me an inquiring look. But I reassured her with a smile that most certainly contradicted my own secret dread of the interview before us, and, taking her on my arm, followed the old man down the hall, past the old man, open drawing-room door, where I certainly thought we should pause, into a room whose plain appearance made me frown, till Bartow, as I have since heard him called, threw aside the portier at one end and introduced us into my brother's study, which at that moment looked like a fairyland, or would have if Felix, who was its sole occupant, had not immediately drawn our attention to himself by the remarkable force of his personality, never so impressive as at that moment.

Eva, to whom I had said little of this brother, certainly nothing which would lead her to anticipate seeing either so handsome a man or one of such mental poise and imposing character, looked frightened and a trifle awe-struck. But she advanced quite bravely toward him, and at my introductions smiled with such an inviting grace, that I secretly expected to see him more or less disarmed by it. And perhaps he was, for his already pale features turned waxy in the yellow glare cast by the odd lantern over our heads, and the hand he had raised in mechanical greeting fell heavily, and he could barely stammer out some words of welcome.

These would have seemed quite inadequate to the occasion if his eyes which were fixed on her face, had not betrayed the fact that he was not without feeling, though she little realized the nature of that feeling, or how her very life, for happiness is life, was trembling in the balance under that indomitable will. I who did know, or thought I did, cast him an imploring glance, and saying that I had some explanations to make, asked if Mrs. Adams might not rest here while we had a few words apart. He answered me with a strange look. Did he feel the revolt in my tone

and understand then as well as afterward what the nature of my compliance had been? I shall never know. I only know that he stopped fumbling with some small object on the table before him, and bowing with a sarcastic grace that made me for the first time in my intercourse with him, feel myself his inferior, even in size,

led the way to a small door i had failed to notice up to this moment your wife will find it more comfortable here he observed with slow pauses in his speech that showed great but repressed excitement and he opened the door into what had the appearance of a small but elegant sleeping apartment what we have to say cannot take long mrs adams will not find the weight tedious no she smiled with a natural laugh born as i dare hope of her perfect happiness yet she could not but have considered the proceeding strange and my manner as well as his scarcely what might be expected from a bridegroom introducing his bride to his only relative i will call you i began but the vision of her dimpled face above the great cluster of roses she carried made me forget to complete my sentence and the door closed and i found out of her dimpled face above the great cluster of roses she carried made me forget to complete my sentence and the door closed and i found myself face to face with felix he was breathing easier and his manner seemed more natural now that we were alone yet he did not speak but cast a strange if not inquiring glance about the room the weirdest of apartments as you all well know and seeming satisfied with what he saw why i could not tell led the way up to the large table which from the first had appeared to exert a sort of uncanny magnetism upon him saying come further away i need air breathing place in this close room and so must you besides why should she hear what we have to say she will know the worst soon enough she seems a gentle-hearted woman an angel i began but he stopped me with an imperious gesture. We will not discuss your wife, Mrs. Adams, he protested.

Where is John Poindexter? At the hotel I rejoined, or possibly he has returned home, I no longer take account of his existence. Felix, I shall never leave my wife. I had rather prove recreant to the oath I took before I realized the worth of the woman whose happiness I vowed to destroy. This is what I have come to tell you. Make it easy, for me, Felix. You are a man who has loved and suffered. Let us bury the past. Let us— Had I hoped I could move him? Perhaps some such child's notion had influenced me up to this moment. But as these words left my lips—nay, before I had stumbled through them, I perceived by the set look of his features, which were as if cast in bronze, that I might falter, but that he was

as firm as ever—fermer it seemed to me, and less even. easy to be entreated yet what of that at the worst what had i to fear a struggle which might involve eva in bitter unpleasantness and me in the loss of a fortune i had come to regard almost as my own but these were petty considerations eva must know sooner or later my real name and the story of her father's guilt why not now and if we must start life poor it was yet life while a separation from her Meanwhile Felix had spoken, and in language I was least prepared to hear. I anticipated this. From the moment you pleaded with me for the privilege of marrying her, I have looked forward to this outcome and provided against it. Weakness on the part of her bridegroom was to be expected. I have therefore steeled myself to meet the emergency, for your oath must be kept.

crushed by the tone in which these words were uttered a tone that evinced power against which any ordinary struggle would end in failure, I cast my eyes about the room in imitation of what I had seen him do a few minutes before. There was nothing within sight calculated to awaken distrust, and yet a feeling of distrust, the first I had really felt, had come with the look he had thrown above and around the mosque-like interior. of the room he called his study. Was it the calm confidence he showed, or the weirdness of finding myself amid oriental splendors, and under the influence of night effects in high day and within sound of the clanging streetcars

and all the accompanying bustle of everyday traffic? It is hard to say, but from this moment on I found myself affected by a vague affright, not on my own account, but on hers whose voice, we could plainly hear humming a gay tune in the adjoining apartment. But I was resolved to suppress all betrayal of uneasiness.

I even smiled, though I felt the eyes of Evelyn's pictured countenance upon me, Evelyn's whose portrait I had never lost sight of from the moment of entering the room, though I had not given it a direct look and now stood with my back to it. Felix, who faced it, but who did not raise his eyes to it, waited a moment for my response, and finding that my words halted, said again, That oath must be kept. This time I found words with which to answer, Impossible I burst out, flinging, doubt, fear, hesitancy,

everything I had hitherto trembled at to the winds. It was in my nature to take it, worked upon as I was by family affection, the awfulness of our father's approaching death and a thousand uncanny influences all carefully measured and prepared for this end. But it is not in my nature to keep it after four months of natural living in the companionship of a man thirty years removed from his guilt and of his guileless and wholly innocent daughter. And you cannot drive me to it, Felix. No man can force another to abandon his own wife because of a wicked oath taken long before he knew her. "'If you think your money—'

"'Money,' he cried, with a contempt that did justice to my disinterestedness as well as his own. "'I had forgotten I had it. "'No, Thomas, I should never weigh money against the happiness of living with such a woman as your wife appears to be. "'But her life, I might. "'Carry out your threat. "'Forget to pay John Poynexter the debt we owe him, "'and the matter will assume a seriousness for which you are doubtless poorly prepared. A daughter dead in her honeymoon

Will be almost as great a grief to him As a dishonored one And either dead or dishonored He must find her When he comes here in search of the child He cannot long forget Which shall it be? Speak

Was I dreaming? Was this Felix? Was this myself? And was it in my ears These words were poured? With a spring I reached his side Where he stood close against the table and groaned rather than shrieked the words.

You would not kill her. You do not meditate a crime of blood. Here on her, the innocent, the good. No, he said, it will be you who will do that. You who will not wish to see her languish, suffer, go mad. Thomas, I am not the raving being you take me for. I am merely a keeper of oaths. Nay, I am more.

I have talents, skill, the house in which you find you, yourself is proof of this. This room, see it has no outlet save those windows, scarcely if at all, perceptible to you, above our heads, and that opening shielded now by a simple curtain, but which in an instant, without my moving from this place, I can so her medically seal that no man, save he be armed with crowbar and pickax, could enter here. Even if man could know of our imprisonment in a house soon to be closed from top to bottom by my departing's servant. May God protect us, fell from my lips, as stiff with horror I let my eyes travel from his determined face, first to the windows high over my head, and then to the opening of the door,

which, though but a few steps from where I stood, was as far as possible from the room into which my darling had been induced to enter. Felix, watching me, uttered his explanations as calmly as if the matter were one of everyday significance. You are looking for the windows, he remarked. There behind those goblin faces you see outlined on the tapestries under the ceiling. As for the door, if you had looked to the left when you entered, you would have detected the edge of a huge steel plate hanging flush with the casing. This plate can be made to slide across that opening in an instant, just by the touch of my hand on this button. This done, no power save such as I have mentioned can move it back again, not even my own. I have forces at my

command for sending it forward, but none for returning it to its place. Do you doubt my mechanical skill or the perfection of the electrical apparatus I have caused to be placed here? You need not, Thomas, nor need you doubt the will that has only to exert itself for an instant to. Shall I press the button, brother? No, no, I shouted in a frenzy, caused rather by my knowledge of the nature of this man than any especial threat apparent in his voice or gesture let me think let me know more fully what your requirements are what she must suffer if i consent and what i he let his hand slip back that smooth white hand which i had more than once surveyed in admiration then he smiled i knew you would not be foolish he said life has its charms even for hermits like me and for a beau-garsons such as you are hush i interposed maddened into daring his full anger it is not my life i am buying but hers possibly yours for it seems you have planned to perish with us is it not so certainly was his cold reply am i an assassin would you expect me to live knowing you to be perishing i stared aghast such resolve such sacrifice of self-touching

to an idea was beyond my comprehension. Why? What? I stammered. Why kill us? Why kill yourself? The answer overwhelmed me. Remember Evelyn?

Shrilled a voice, and I paused, struck dumb with a superstitious horror I had never believed myself capable of experiencing, for it was not Felix who spoke. Neither was at any utterance of my own aroused conscience. muffled strange and startling it came from above from the hollow spaces of that high vault lit with the golden glow that henceforth can have but one meaning for me death what is it i asked another of your mechanical contrivances He smiled. I had rather he had frowned. Not exactly. A favorite bird, a starling. Alas, he but repeats what he has heard echoed through the solitude of these rooms. I thought I had smothered him up sufficiently to ensure his silence during this interview, but he is a self-willed bird and seems disposed to defy the wrappings I have bound around him. which fact warns me to be speedy and hasten our explanations.

Thomas, this is what I require. John Poindexter, you do not know where he is at this hour, but I do, received a telegram but now, which, if he is a man at all, will bring him to this house in a half hour or so from the present moment. It was sent in your name, and in it you informed him that matters had arisen, which demanded his immediate attention, that you were on your way to your brothers, giving him this address, where, if you found entrance, you would await his presence in a room called the study.

But that, and here you will see how his coming will not aid us if that steel plate is once started on its course, if the possible should occur and your brother should be absent from home, then he was to await a message from you at the plaza. The appearance of the house would inform him whether he would find you and Eva within, or so i telegraphed him in your name thomas if bartow fulfils my instructions and i have never known him to fail me he will pass down these stairs and out of this house in just five minutes as he is bound on a long-promised journey and as he expects me to leave the house immediately after him he has drawn every shade and fastened every lock consequently on his exit the house will become a tomb to which just two weeks from today,

John Poindexter will be called again, and in words which will lead to a demolition which will disclose, what? Let us not forestall the future, our horrible future, by inquiring. But Thomas, shall Bartow go?

Shall I not by signs he comprehends more readily than other men comprehend speech, indicate to him on his downward passage to the street, that I wish him to wait and open the door to the man whom we have promised to overwhelm in his hour of satisfaction and pride? You have only to write a line. See, I have made a copy of the words you must use, lest your self-command should be too severely taxed. These words left on this table for his inspection, for you must go and Eva remain, will tell him all he needs to know from you.

The rest can come from my lips after he has read the signature, which in its will confound him and prepare the way for what i have to add have you anything to say against this plan anything i mean beyond what you have hitherto urged anything that i will consider or which will prevent my finger from pressing the button on which it rests i took up the paper it was lying on the table where it had evidently been inscribed simultaneously with or just before our entrance into the house and slowly read the few lines I saw written upon it. You know them, but they will acquire a new significance from your present understanding of their purpose and intent. I return you back your daughter. Neither she nor you will ever see me again. Remember Evelyn, Amos's son. You wish me to sign these words, to put them into my own handwriting, and so to make them mine? Mine? I repeated. Yes, and to leave them here on this table for him to see when he enters. He might not believe any mere statement

from me in regard to your intentions. I was filled with horror. Love, life, human hopes, the world's friendships, all the possibilities of existence swept in one concentrated flood of thought and feeling through my outraged consciousness, and I knew I could never put my name to such a blasphemy of all that was sacred to man's soul. Tossing the paper in his face, I cried, You have gone too far. Better her death, better mine, better the destruction of us all than such dishonor to the purest thing heaven ever made. I refuse, Felix, I refuse, and may God have mercy on us all. The moment was ghastly. I saw his face change, his finger tremble where it hovered above the fatal button, saw, though only in imagination as yet, the steely edge of that deadly

plate of steel advancing beyond the lintel, and was about to dare all in a sudden grapple with this man when a sound from another direction caught my ear, and looking around in terror of the only intrusion we could fear, beheld Eva advancing from the room in which we had placed her. That moment a blood-red glow took the place of the sick. thickly yellow which had hitherto filled every recess of this weird apartment but i scarcely noticed the change save as it affected her pallor and gave to her cheeks the colour that was lacking in the roses at her belt fearless and sweet as in the hour when she first told me that she loved me she approached and stood before us what is this she cried i have heard words that sound more like the utterances of some horrid dream than the talk of men and brothers. What does it mean, Thomas? What does it mean, Mr. Cadwallader, announced Felix, dropping his eyes from her face, but changing not a wit his

features or posture. Catwallader? The name was not to her what it was to her father. Cadwallader? I have heard that name in my father's house. It was Evelyn's name, the Evelyn who—' Whom you see painted there over your head, finished Felix. my sister thomas's sister the girl whom your father but i spare you child though you be of a man who spared nothing from your husband you may learn why a cadwallader can never find his happiness with a poindexter why thirty or more years after that young girl's death you who were not then born are given at this hour the choice between death and dishonour i allow you just five minutes in which to listen after that you will let me know your joint decision, only you must take your talk where you stand, a step taken by either of you to right or left, and Thomas knows what will follow. Five minutes with such a justification to make and such a decision to arrive at.

I felt my heads swim, my tongue refuse its office, and stood dumb and helpless before her, till the sight of her dear eyes, raised in speechless trust to mine, flooded me with a sense of triumph amid all the ghastly terrors of the moment, and I broke out in a tumult of speech, in excuses, explanations, all that comes to one in a more than mortal crisis. She listened, catching my meaning rather from my looks than my words. Then as the minutes fled and my brother raised a warning hand, she turned toward him and said, You are in earnest, we must separate in shame or perish in this prison-house with you? His answer was mere repetition, mechanical, but firm.

You have said it. You have but one minute more, madam. She shrank, and all her powers seemed leaving her. Then a reaction came, and a flaming angel stood where but a moment before the most delicate of women weakly faltered, and giving me a look to see if I had the courage or the will to lift my hand against my own flesh and blood, alas for us both I did not understand her caught up an old Turkish dagger lying only too ready to her hand and plunged it with one sideways thrust into his side crying we cannot part we cannot die we are too young too happy it was sudden the birth of purpose in her so unexpected and so rapid that felix the ready who was prepared for all contingencies for the least movement or suggestion

of escape, faltered and pressed, not the fatal button, but his heart. One impulsive act on the part of a woman had overthrown all the fine-spun plans of the subtlest spirit that had ever attempted to work its will in the face of God and man. But I did not think of this then. I did not even bestow a thought upon the narrowness of our escape, or the price which the darling of my heart might be called upon to pay for this supreme act of self-defense. My mind, my heart, my interest were with Felix, in whom the nearness of death had called up all that was strongest and most commanding in his strong and commanding spirit. Though struck to the heart he had not fallen, it was as if the will which had sustained him

through thirty years of mental torture held him erect still that he might give her, Eva, one look, the like of which I had never seen on mortal face, and which will never leave my heart or hers until we die. Then as he saw her sink shudderingly down, and the delicate woman reappear in her pallid and shrunken figure, he turned his eyes on me, and I saw, good God, a tear well up from those orbs of stone, and fall slowly down his cheek, fast-growing hollow under the stroke of death. Eva! Eva! I love Eva! Shrilled the voice which once before had startled me from the hollow vault above.

Felix heard, and a smile faint as the failing rush of blood through his veins moved his lips and brought a revelation to my soul. He too loved Eva. When he saw I knew, the will will be able to my soul. I saw I knew, the will which had kept him on his feet gave way, and he sank to the floor, murmuring, take her away, I forgive, save, save, she did not know I loved her. Eva, aghast, staring with set eyes at her work, had not moved from her crouching posture. But when she saw that speaking head fall back, the fine limbs settle into the repose of death,

A shock went through her, which I thought would never leave her reason unimpaired. I've killed him, she murmured, I've killed him! And looking wildly about, her eyes fell on the cross that hung behind us on the wall. It seemed to remind her that Felix was a Catholic. Bring it, she gasped. Let him feel it on his breast. It may bring him peace, hope. As I rushed to do her bidding, she fell in a heap on the floor.

save, came again from the lips we thought closed forever in death, and realizing at the words both her danger and the necessity of her not opening her eyes again upon this scene, I laid the cross in his arms, and, catching her up from the floor, ran with her out of the house, but no sooner had I caught sight of the busy street and the stream of humanity passing before us, then I awoke to an instant recognition of our peril. Setting my wife down, I commanded life back into her limbs by the force of my own energy, and then dragging her down the steps, mingled with the crowd, encouraging her, breathing for her, living in her till I got her into a carriage and we drove away. For the silence we have maintained from that time to this

you must not blame Mrs. Adams. When she came to herself, which was not for days, she manifested the greatest desire to proclaim her act and assume its responsibility. but i would not have it i loved her too dearly to see her name bandied about in the papers and when her father was taken into our confidence he was equally peremptory in enjoining silence and shared with me the watch i now felt bound to keep over her movements but alas his was the peremptoriness of pride rather than love john poindexter has no more heart for his daughter than he had for his wife or that long-forgotten child from whose grave this tragedy has sprung had felix triumphed he would never have wrung the heart of this man as he once said when a man cares for nothing and nobody not even for himself it is useless to curse him as for felix judge him not when you realize as you now must that his last conscious act was to reach for and put in his mouth the paper which connected eva with his death at the moment of death his thought was to save not to avenge and this after her hand had struck him end of book two chapter five book two chapter six and seven of the circuit study. This is a Librivox recording. All Librevox recordings are in the public domain.

For more information or to volunteer, please visit Librevox.org. The Circular Study by Anna Catherine Green. Chapter 6. Answered A silence, more or less surcharged with emotion, followed this final appeal. Then, while the various auditors of this remarkable history whispered together and thomas adams turned in love and anxiety toward his wife the inspector handed back to mr gryce the memorandum he had received from him it presented the following appearance answered one why a woman who was calm enough to stop and arrange her hair during the beginning of an interview should be wrought up to such a pitch of frenzy and exasperation before it was over as to kill with her own hand a man she evidently had no previous grudge against remember the comb found on the floor of mr adams's bedroom answered two what was the meaning of the following words written just previous to this by the man thus killed i return you your daughter neither you nor she shall ever see me again remember evelyn answered three why was the pronoun i used in this communication what position did mr felix adams hold toward this young girl qualifying him to make use of such language after her marriage to his brother answered four and having used it

why did he upon being attacked by her attempt to swallow the paper upon which he had written these words actually dying with it clinched between his teeth answered five if he was killed in anger and died as monsters do her own word why did his face show sorrow rather than hate and a determination as far as possible removed from the rush of overwhelming emotions likely to follow the reception of a mortal blow from the hand of an unexpected antagonist. Answered. 6. Why, if he had strength to seize the above-mentioned paper and convey it to his lips, did he not use that strength in turning on a light calculated to bring him assistance, instead of leaving blazing the crimson glow, which, according to the code of signals,

as now understood by us, means nothing more required just now, keep away answered seven what was the meaning of the huge steel plate found between the casings of the doorway and why did it remain at rest within its socket at this the culminating moment of his life answered eight an explanation of how old poindexter came to appear on the scene so soon after the event his words as overheard were it is amos's son not amos did he not know whom he was to meet in this house was the condition of the man lying before him with a cross on his bosom and a dagger in his heart less of a surprise to him than the personality of the victim not answered nine remember the conclusions we have drawn from bartow's pantomime mr adams was killed by a left-handed thrusts watch for an acknowledgment that the young woman is left-handed and do not forget that an explanation is due why for so long a time she held her other arms stretched out behind her answered ten why did the bird whose chief cry is remember evelyn sometimes vary it with poor eva lovely eva who would strike eva the story of this tragedy to be true must show that Mr. Adams knew his brother's bride both long and well. Answered.

11. If Bartow is, as we think, innocent of all connection with this crime, save as witness, why does he show such joy at its result? This may not reasonably be expected to fall within the scope of Thomas Adams' confession, but it should not be ignored by us.

This deaf and dumb servitor was driven mad by a fact which caused him joy. Why? Footnote 2. It must be remembered that the scraps of writing in Felix's hand had not yet been found by the police. The allusions in them to Bartow show him to have been possessed by a jealousy which probably turned to delight when he saw his master smitten down by the object of that master's love and his own hatred. how he came to recognize in the bride of another man the owner of the name he so often saw hovering on the lips of his master is a question to be answered by more astute students of the laws of perception than myself

probably he spent much of his time at the loophole on the stairway studying his master till he understood his every gesture and expression answered twelve notice the following sketch it has been drawn up after repeated experiments with bartow and the various slides of the strange lamp which caused so many different lights to shine out in mr adams's study white light water wanted green light overcoat and hat to be brought blue light put back books on shelves violet light arrange study for the night yellow light watch for next light red light nothing wanted stay away the last was on at the final scene note if this fact can be explained by mr adams's account of the same two paragraphs alone lacked complete explanation the first number nine was important the description of the stroke dealt by mr adams's wife did not account for this peculiar feature in bartow's pantomime consulting with the inspector mr Mr. Grice finally approached Mr. Adams and inquired if he had strength to enact before them the blow as he had seen it dealt by his wife. The startled young man looked the question he dared not ask. In common with others he knew that Bartow had made some characteristic gestures in endeavoring to describe this crime,

but he did not know what they were, as this especial bit of information had been carefully held back by the police. he therefore did not respond hastily to the suggestion made him but thought intently for a moment before he thrust out his left hand and caught up some article or other from the inspector's table and made a lunge with it across his body into an imaginary victim at his right then he consulted the faces about him with inexpressible anxiety he found little encouragement in their aspect you would make your wife out left-handed suggested mr gryce now i have been watching her ever since she came into this place and i have seen no evidence of this she is not left-handed but she thrust with her left hand because her right was held fast in mine i had seized her instinctively as she bounded forward for the weapon and the convulsive clutch of our two hands was not loosed till the horror of her act made her faint and she fell away from her from me to the floor, crying, "'Tare down the cross and lay it on your brother's breast. I would at least see him die the death of a Christian.'

Mr. Grice glanced at the inspector with an air of great relief. The mystery of the constrained attitude of the right hand, which made Bartow's pantomime so remarkable, was now naturally explained, and taking up the blue pencil which the inspector had laid down, he wrote with a smile a very decided answered across paragraph number nine end of book two chapter six book two chapter seven of the circular study this librivox recording is in the public domain the circular study by anna catherine green chapter seven last words a few minutes later mr gryce was to be seen in the outer room, gazing curiously at the various persons there collected. He was seeking an answer to a question that was still disturbing his mind and hoped to find it

there. He was not disappointed, for in a quiet corner he encountered the amiable form of Miss Butterworth, calmly awaiting the result of an interference which she in all probability had been an active agent in bringing about. He approached and smilingly accused her of this, but she disclaimed the fact with some heat. I was simply there, she explained. When the crisis came, when this young creature learned that her husband had left suddenly for New York in the company of two men,

then— Why, then it became apparent to everyone that a woman should be at her side who understood her case and the extreme. in which she found herself and i was that woman you are always that woman he gallantly replied if by the phrase you mean being in the right place at the right time so you are already acquainted with mrs adams's story yes the ravings of a moment told me she was the one who had handled the dagger that slew mr adams afterwards she was able to explain the cause of what has seemed to us such a whole horrible crime when i heard her story mr gryce i no longer hesitated either as to her duty or mine do you think she will be called upon to answer for this blow will she be tried convicted madam there are not twelve men in the city so devoid of intelligence as to apply the name of crime to enact which was so evidently one of self-defence no true bill will be found against young mrs adams rest easy the look of gloom disappeared from miss butterworth's eyes then i may return home in peace she cried it has been a desperate five hours for me and i feel well shaken up will you escort me to my carriage

miss butterworth did not look shaken up indeed in mr gryce's judgment she had never appeared more serene or more comfortable but she was certainly the best judge of her own condition and after satisfying herself that the object of her care was reviving under the solicitous ministrations of her husband, she took the arm which Mr. Grice held out to her and proceeded to her carriage. As he assisted her in, he asked a few questions about Mr. Poindexter. Why is not Mrs. Adams' father here? Did he allow his daughter to leave him on such an errand as this without offering to accompany her? the answer was curtness itself mr poindexter is a man without heart he came with us to new york but refused to follow us to police headquarters sir you will find that the united passions of three burning souls and a revenge the most deeply cherished of any i ever knew or heard of have been thrown away on a man who is positively unable to suffer do not mention old john poindexter to me and now if you will be so good tell the coachman to drive me to my home in grammarcy park i have put my finger in the police pie for the last time mr gryce positively for the last time

and she sank back on the carriage cushions with an inexorable look which nevertheless did not quite conceal a quiet complacency which argued that she was not altogether dissatisfied with herself or the result of her interference in matters usually considered at variance with a refined woman's natural instincts mr gryce in repressing a smile bowed lower even than his wont and under the shadow of this bow the carriage drove off as he walked slowly back he sighed was he wondering if a case of similar interest would ever bring them together again in consultation end of book two chapter seven end of the circular study by anna catherine green