Dan Snow's History Hit - The 'Elgin' Marbles

Episode Date: November 29, 2023

The permanent home of the Parthenon Marbles, also known as the 'Elgin' Marbles, has been the subject of a heated, decades-long debate. That debate was reignited this week when Prime Minister Rishi Sun...ak cancelled a meeting with the Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis who had planned to raise the issue of returning the marbles to Greece in it.Currently housed in the British Museum, Greece has been proactively campaigning for their return since the 1980s. But how did this controversy start, why did the marbles end up in London and why are they so important?In this episode, Dan finds answers and solutions from Nick Malkoutzis and Georgia Nakou, two Greek journalists and contributors to the Macropolis.gr who provide the deep history of the marbles and how the two countries might resolve this dispute.Discover the past with exclusive history documentaries and ad-free podcasts presented by world-renowned historians from History Hit. Watch them on your smart TV or on the go with your mobile device. Get 50% off your first 3 months with code DANSNOW sign up now for your 14-day free trial We'd love to hear from you! You can email the podcast at ds.hh@historyhit.com.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Hello everyone, welcome to this emergency episode of Dan Snow's History Hit. Lord Byron, the poet, once wrote, Dull is the eye that will not weep to see, By walls defaced, thy mouldering shrines removed, By British hands, which had best behoved To guard those relics ne'er to be restored. Cursed be the hour from when their isle they roved, and once again thy hapless bosom gored, and snatched thy shrinking gods to northern climes
Starting point is 00:00:34 abhorred. He was talking about the removal of the so-called Elgin Marbles, the frieze, the carved figures that run right along the outside of the Parthenon on the Acropolis in Greece. They were removed by order of the British ambassador to Constantinople, the British ambassador to the Ottoman court, Lord Elgin, right at the beginning of the 19th century. Greece, like much of Southeast Europe, was incorporated into the Ottoman Empire, and so they were the relevant legal authority at the time, and Lord Elgin always claimed and had evidence to show that he had permission to take away the marbles, the Parthenon frieze. However, the Turkish copy of that contract has been lost,
Starting point is 00:01:27 However, the Turkish copy of that contract has been lost, and it does remain a disputed fact. In 2022, the Greek culture minister accused Elgin of a blatant act of serial theft. The Elgin marbles went through quite a lot. First of all, they removed and craned down from the Parthenon. They were transported to ships. One of those ships then sank. The marbles were recovered in a subsea recovery operation, and then the British government bought them from Lord Elgin in 1816 for display in the British Museum. When Greece became independent in 1835, thanks in part to a crushing British and French naval victory over the Turks, the new Greek government asked the UK to return the marbles. And they've gone on repeating that request for decades, joined now by the World Heritage Organization, UNESCO.
Starting point is 00:02:12 This week, we had one of those regular yet somehow always unexpected moments where a historical story blasted into the headlines. It wasn't Napoleon anymore. No, that's yesterday's news. It's now the Parthenon freeze. The British Prime Minister was embroiled in a row with Athens after cancelling a meeting between Prime Minister Rishi Sunak and the Greek Prime Minister. The British claimed that they'd been assured that the Greeks were not going to raise the topic of the Parthenon freeze. The Greeks say they felt at liberty to do so, and the British cancelled the meeting. On Sunday, the Greek leader told the BBC that having some of the treasures in London and others in Athens was like cutting the Mona Lisa in half. The marbles have been controversial
Starting point is 00:02:56 from the moment they were removed by Elgin and brought to Britain. So why did he do it? Did he really have permission? And what are they doing in the British Museum? And ultimately, should the British give them back? Another interesting question is, why is the government weighing in? Who decides whether or not these treasures are sent back to Greece? And of course, there's a wider point here. What should we do with the artistic and cultural treasures that have ended up in British and Western museums, but were created by cultures many, many miles away. Are things like the Parthenon frieze a legacy to all mankind, suitable to be housed in any museum anywhere, or should they maintain their particular connection with a place? In the case of the Parthenon frieze, they were sculpted in the 5th century BC.
Starting point is 00:03:44 The invading Persians after the Battle of Thermopylae had completely destroyed all the religious buildings on top of the Acropolis, and Athens, after their glorious victories over the Persians, rebuilt, re-rendered the temples of the Acropolis in beautiful marble, a sparkling religious site of many temples on its lofty, lofty plateau above Athens. They were created at the height of the Athenian Empire, which was a place bursting with self-confidence, with energy, with wealth, with imperial swagger. And perhaps not uncoincidentally, they were transferred to London at a time when London was hitting the heights of its imperial journey.
Starting point is 00:04:26 For Londoners and Brits in general, I think it was exhilarating to compare themselves with the ancient glories of Greece. Now, to help me understand what on earth is going on here and talk me through what the Greek government has proactively been doing to recover these treasures since at least the 1980s, I'm joined by Nick Malkoutsis and Georgia Narku. They're two journalists that love us a Greek history, and they're both contributors to Macropolis.gr. It's an English language website for everything Greek. Politics, history, culture, the works.
Starting point is 00:05:00 Here, as ever, is Dan Snow's history with all the context you need to navigate your way through the historical culture war du jour. And there'll be plenty more where this came from, folks, so stick with us. Enjoy. T-minus 10. Atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima. God save the king. No black-white unity till there is first and black unity. Never to go to war with one another again.
Starting point is 00:05:23 And liftoff, and the shuttle has cleared the tower. Nick and Georgia, thank you very much for coming on the podcast. Georgia, let's come to you for the deep dive into the history here. Fifth century BC, Athens, the Enlightenment, the great flowering of cultural, architectural, literary, dramatic excellence in Athens at the time. Why was the Parthenon built? Yes, as you say, Parthenon is a monument that belongs to the 5th century BC. It was built in the latter part of the 5th century, which is commonly referred to
Starting point is 00:05:58 as the Golden Age of Athens. And it's the period where democracy came into its own as a system of government. Athens was rich and powerful. It saw the fluorescence of Greek drama, great period for the visual arts and so on. The Parthenon is part of the Acropolis complex. And the Acropolis are on top of a hill that overlooks Athens. Acropolis are on top of a hill that overlooks Athens. And the Athens of the 5th century was around the foothills of the Acropolis. The Parthenon itself is a temple to Athena, and Athena was the patron goddess of Athens.
Starting point is 00:06:41 But to put it into sort of the more proximate historical context, Athens and many of the other Greek city-states had spent the first half of the 5th century battling the Persians, what is known as the Persian Wars. In around 480 BC, the Persians had actually come into Athens. Athens had been evacuated and they razed it to the ground twice in 480-479 BC. They burnt what was then at that time, the old temple of Athena. Nothing was left. And this was a great blow to Athens. Once Athens recovered from that, and the Persians were sort of sent back from whence they came, Athens set about rebuilding the monuments and the Acropolis. And so apart from being sort of a religious monument and what we see now as a temple to democracy, it was very much
Starting point is 00:07:33 a monument to Athenian might. I would compare it in present day terms to the Freedom Tower in New York after 9-11 to bounce back from that blow and show the world that Athens was very much back and bigger and better than ever. Pericles, who was the powerful man at the time, started this building program, which consisted of several buildings on the Acropolis and included the Parthenon. It also, in addition to being a temple, housed the treasury of the Delian League, which was the big coalition of the willing that Athens put together to fight the Persians. So in addition to being a temple and a monument to Athenian might, it was very much to become the seeds of the Athenian Empire.
Starting point is 00:08:23 So you could also look at it as a sort of proto-NATO headquarters. Very much sort of Athens is here, Athens is back, Athens is strong. Maybe a little bit like St. Paul's Cathedral at the end of a troubled 17th century for the English. What about the frieze itself? What's it depict? What can you go and see if you go to the British Museum? Now, first of all, what is a frieze? What bits of the Parthenon have we got here in the UK? The British Museum currently has just over half of the decorative elements of the Parthenon. So the Parthenon is sort of an oblong building with columns, a colonnade surrounding it. And the bits that were the sort of the most interesting sculptural elements were the frieze, the metopes, which are sort of sculpted panels that also go around the top of the columns, and then the pedimental
Starting point is 00:09:13 sculptures. And these are the sculptures that were sort of in the gable end of the temple. And they show a series of mythological scenes which show the foundation myth of Athens, starting in sort of deep myth and progressing to, for example, the pedimental sculptures show a series of mythological battles between different groups of mythical creatures, the centaurs and the lapiths and so on. creatures, the centaurs and the lapiths and so on, they're all allusions to the history, the deep history of Athens and their allegories for the Persian Wars and Athens is sort of leading the Greek world in a victory against the Persians. Thank you for that. You're slightly triggering. I've got traumatic memories of my dad dragging me and my sister around and having long lectures about the various metopes and various things like that. But you did it much better than he did, so thank you.
Starting point is 00:10:07 We would die of old age if we attempted to chart the course of Athenian history from Pericles onwards to say it was war, it was conquest, it was success, it was failure. Can we come up to the point at which the Brits managed to get their hands on it? We're coming right up to the 19th century. Greece is and has for a long time been under Turkish rule. And what happens? Just sort of quick fast forward, as you say, after the decline of the classical world and after the Romans took over the Byzantine rule and so on, the importance of Athens as a centre declined. By the time you get to the 19th century, it really was sort of, as they described it at the time, as a village of a few thousand souls
Starting point is 00:10:52 around the base of the Acropolis. The Acropolis itself being quite prominent had been used at times as a defensive structure and it had fallen into disrepair and it had also suffered a few sort of episodes of destruction, including being shelled by the Venetians, which really took big chunks out of it and killed several hundred people at the time. So it was sort of a shadow of its former self, bits of broken stattery lying around. And also it had been sort of looted by the Venetians as well. So there were bits missing. Bits were being used to build other structures around it. There was a mosque
Starting point is 00:11:32 on the hill during the Ottoman era in the middle of the classical ruins. And into this sort of steps Lord Elgin. So Lord Elgin, his name was Thomas Bruce, and his title was the 7th Earl of Elgin. And he lobbied the crown to become an ambassador to the Ottoman Empire. And he succeeded, and he was appointed, I'm going to read this out, ambassador extraordinary and most of plenipotentiary of his Britannic majesty to the sublime port of Selim III, the Sultan of Turkey. So Elgin was a bit of a fan of classical Greece, which was not quite as widespread at the turn of the sort of 18th and 19th centuries it became afterwards.
Starting point is 00:12:21 He was a bit of a dilettante, a bit of a collector of ancient bits of stone, and he was very much looking forward to going to Greece for that reason. Before setting off, he approached politicians at the time and said, would you be interested if I was to take some artists with me and record these monuments to improve the tastes back home? And they very much said, no, sorry, we're not interested. But he persevered. He got there and he set about doing a bit more than just recording the monuments. Now, there's a lot of debate as to what his motives were. He certainly obviously wasn't acting on behalf of the Crown or the British government. He was very much freelancing. Did he intend to bring the
Starting point is 00:13:02 pieces back to give to the nation? It's not clear. And many people point to the fact that he was in the process of building his country pile in Scotland at the time. So there's some insinuation that he actually just meant to take the stuff back to scatter around the grounds of Broomhall House. house. So he got a form of consent to do this. And when we get to it, there's a lot of the debate around the legality of his actions centers around what exactly the Ottomans gave him permission to do and what he actually did, and whether the permission was strong enough to allow him to take it out of the country. He ended up taking 200 crates full of the nicest bits of the decorative elements of the Parthenon and shipping them to Britain over a course of several years. Just to give you an idea of the magnitude of this hall, he took about 275 feet of frieze, and that's longer than the width of a football pitch. Fifteen of the metopes and 17 of the pedimental sculptures, plus bits of other parts of the Acropolis,
Starting point is 00:14:17 including the caryatid, one of the female maidens, holding up the roof of the Erechtheion Temple, which is another sort of iconic piece of 5th century Greek sculpture. He got this to the UK at his own expense, paying £75,000 at the time, which is several million pounds in today's money. In the course of getting home, His wife had an affair. They had a very sort of tabloid style divorce. And Elgin was virtually bankrupted from the combined expense of bringing the sculptures back with him and his costly divorce. So he was more keen than ever to try and sell the artifacts. He made a first attempt to sell them to the British state that fell flat. This was
Starting point is 00:15:07 around sort of 1801. He kept battling on at it. And eventually, the British Parliament approved the purchase of the sculptures for about half of what he paid to ship them back, and then gave them to the British Museum. Not everyone was enthusiastic about it. Lord Byron was very vocal against it, and so were other travellers who'd been to Greece. But public opinion was fairly split on the matter, and there had to be a parliamentary inquiry to approve the purchase. It wasn't until the sculptures went on display in the British Museum that they actually became wildly popular, even amongst Byron's contemporaries.
Starting point is 00:15:49 And arguably sort of helped raise awareness around the cause of the Greek Revolution, which started in 1821. So that's how they came to be from Athens to London. Well, thanks, Georgia. That was a tour de force. from Athens to London. Well, thanks, Georgia. That was a tour de force. Nick, we've just heard about the Greek revolutions, of the upsurge of nationalism,
Starting point is 00:16:11 which had a huge impact in Greece and its independence, but far beyond Greece as well. When did the Parthenon marbles become an issue, do you think, with the Greek people? Well, the first official request from the fledgling Greek state was made in 1842, the first request for the marbles to return to Greece. And for a long time after that, the issue kind of went on the back burner. Obviously, the Greek state had just been founded and you did a podcast not too long ago on the
Starting point is 00:16:39 Greek War of Independence starting in 1821. It took a while for the war to play out and then for the new state to get founded. And obviously, a new state has all kinds of issues to sort out. But the campaign as we know it today, and perhaps your listeners have seen videos online or posters on the tube or wherever it may be about international campaign to bring them home, bring them back, that really started in 1982. What kicked it off? There were a number of factors. Firstly, at that point, the Parthenon was really suffering, not just from the ravages of time, but also the ravages of pollution in Athens. Obviously, at that time, Athens was very well known for its cloud of pollution,
Starting point is 00:17:24 the nephos, as it was called in Greek, that hung over the city, and it was really eating away at the sculptures that remained. So at that point, this effort began to preserve and protect the Parthenon, the Acropolis in general. And this coincided with a political change in Greece. A new socialist government had just come to power in 1981. The PASOK party won the elections. And this came after a very troubled period in Greek history where we had a seven-year military dictatorship in the late 60s and mid-70s. And this government wanted to represent a newer,
Starting point is 00:18:02 freer, more progressive Greece, but obviously wanted to kind of make this reconnection with the ancient world, which is always a dynamic going on in Greece, in modern Greece, this kind of connection with the past, especially the ancient past. And as we just mentioned, was so instrumental in the support of the international community for the Greek war of independence. But we also had Greece in 1981 joining what was then the European Economic Community, the EC, today the EU. And it was very much about Greece trying to establish its place in the world, in the Western world.
Starting point is 00:18:39 And this idea of bringing the marbles back was really part of this effort to show a new face, to show Greece that had a very bright and illustrious history, but one which had a relevant present and promising future as well. And that's when it all started. And the woman who launched that campaign was Melina Merkouri. She was a culture minister. She had been an actress, and perhaps some of your listeners might know her from what was then a very emblematic film, Never on Sunday. People
Starting point is 00:19:11 may know the tune to that. She acted in that, became an international celebrity, which for Greece at that time, in the late 50s, early 60s, really didn't have a lot of international celebrities. So she was a nationwide figure, popular with Greeks at home, popular with Greeks abroad, but also known to an international audience. And in 82, she went to a UNESCO conference in Mexico and said, look, we're beginning this campaign to get them back. And as she put it, for the marbles to come back under the blue sky of Attica, Attica being the sort of greater Athens region. And she talked about them returning to their natural space and being reunited as part of a unique whole.
Starting point is 00:19:53 And this was really the basis of the campaign was, and it's still relevant today, was that yes, artifacts have been taken for many countries, but we're not talking about a vase that's been taken or a statue. This is a unique sculpture which is broken down into pieces and part of it is in the UK and part of it is here and we want to reunite it. It's not about just bringing something back home. We want to reunite this work of art, essentially. And you asked earlier about what bits are here, what bits are in the UK. You can sum it up by saying the head of Athena is here in the Acropolis Museum and her torso is in the British Museum. And this was very much at the centre of the campaign, let's reunite this. And that was the start of a campaign that's been going on for a number of
Starting point is 00:20:44 years since then and has gone through various ups and downs. Listen to Dan Snow's history. Talk about the Parthenon freeze, the Elgin marbles. More coming up. I'm Matt Lewis. And I'm Dr. Alan Orjanaga. And in Gone Medieval, we get into the greatest mysteries. The gobsmacking details and latest groundbreaking research
Starting point is 00:21:09 from the greatest millennium in human history. We're talking Vikings. Normans. Kings and popes. Who were rarely the best of friends. Murder. Rebellions. And crusades.
Starting point is 00:21:19 Find out who we really were. By subscribing to Gone Medieval from History Hit. Wherever you get your podcasts. What's the current situation? Has there been any movement? I mean, whose decision is it? And what's the mood music been? Is there any smoke coming out of the Vatican chimney? Well, the progress has been limited. Obviously, the marbles are still in the UK. I think there have been various small gains along the way. There was a time when the world would have spoken of the Elgin marbles. Today, it's more likely that we speak of the Parthenon marbles, and that's a result of this campaign of awareness.
Starting point is 00:22:12 When Melina Mercuri began this effort to get the marbles back in 82, it also marked the start of these international committees for the marbles return being formed around the world, including in the UK. And they are really the ones that drive it outside of a sort of government to government discussion. The Greek government at various times has made the argument and it's been pushed back. Initially, the argument was that they're better looked after in the British Museum. Athens is a dirty, polluted city. They're just going to be damaged in the dirty environment there. Then there was the argument that, well, you don't really have a proper museum because at the time, until 2009, Greece didn't have a large, dedicated Acropolis Museum. There was, I wouldn't call it quite a porter cabin,
Starting point is 00:23:05 but there was this very small museum on the actual Acropolis rock. So we had this push just before Athens hosted the Olympics in 2004 to get them back. And that fell flat on its face when the then Greek prime minister, Kostas Simitis, sidled up to the British prime minister, Tony Blair, at the sidelines of a EU summit. And he didn't realize that the microphones were picking up what they were talking about. And he said to Tony Blair, this was in 2003, you know, look, we've got the Olympics coming up next year. But I also have elections, it would be really useful
Starting point is 00:23:42 for me to get the marbles back. And this caused a big furor in Greece. It was a political scandal that we're trying to politicize this issue when it's really a national issue, an issue of national importance. And of course, he didn't get anything out of Tony Blair. But the interesting thing is that Greece has seen Labour leaders, if not necessarily the prime minister in this case, as more receptive to the idea of the conservative leaders of the marbles coming back. So Tony Blair's predecessors, Michael Foote and Neil Kinnock, both publicly came out more or less in favour of returning the marbles. And more recently, Jeremy Corbyn gave an interview to Tanea newspaper and our colleague Yanis Andetropoulos, who's their London correspondent, and said, yes, I'll give them
Starting point is 00:24:29 back if I become prime minister. But of course, it's not as simple as that. They are the property of the British Museum, and it's up to the trustees of the museum to decide this. But even then, as I understand it, it would need a change to the law in the UK, a law in the 1960s. The 1963 British Museum Act, which is intended to preserve the collection for posterity. So there is a political hurdle to overcome. Even if the trustees decided they were keen on repatriating them, the law would have to change to allow them to do that. That's interesting, Georgia. So he has suggested it is the trustees of the British Museum who have the final say, but if it requires an act of parliament as well, then that's not entirely true.
Starting point is 00:25:16 Yes, and this is sort of convenient for both the government and the British Museum because it avoids anyone having to make a tough decision on this front. You know, it's very legalistic. And I think it's interesting that there was a letter made the papers recently from a former UK ambassador to Athens who said that really the UK should avoid or British authorities should avoid falling back on these arguments because they're very transparent and they sort of don't make the UK look as if it's acting in good faith or the BM. Do we know, has anyone done a sort of exciting politics style or England football style breakdown of what all the different trustees think about the issue?
Starting point is 00:25:58 They don't publish their individual views. There's a couple of sort of interesting developments just around this general area. I mean, one is that there is a greater movement generally towards restitution of cultural property. If you look beyond Athens and beyond Greece, there are obviously other countries whose antiquities make up the British Museum's collection. And that is, you know, what is promoted as the great strength of the British Museum, that it holds treasures from around the world. The issue with that is that at the moment, you know, that's come to be seen as a bit of a weakness, because it really exposes the colonial history of Britain, and aspects of the colonial history of Britain and aspects of the colonial history that are less of a cause
Starting point is 00:26:46 for pride, for instance, the slave trade. And just to give you a sort of an example that is completely separate from the marbles, but quite relevant, there's a group of artifacts called the Benin Bronzes that are scattered around the world, several in the BM, the Metropolitan Museum, and so on. They were looted from the Kingdom of Benin, which is now modern day Nigeria. They were looted as part of a sort of destruction of the kingdom to do with retaliation over the slave trade. Because of those associations, there's been a pressure on the institutions that hold them to give them back. Slightly more clear-cut case because of the circumstances of their taking, but several institutions have voluntarily given them back, not for legalistic reasons, but simply because
Starting point is 00:27:36 it's not a good look anymore to show these things away from their context and to potentially sort of hide their context. Because of the way that the argument for the reunification of the Parthenon marbles has been presented in the past, it's exceptional, it's a one of a kind, it's not like any of these other things. They have sort of isolated themselves from this movement. have sort of isolated themselves from this movement, but it is sort of a sign of a turning tide that may eventually help to, you know, lead to their restitution. Okay, folks, I'm going to ask you the big question. I hope you don't mind answering in a personal capacity. Let's start with Georgia. What do you think? What's the answer? What's the way out of this? I think the tide is turning on this,
Starting point is 00:28:22 but I think it's not going to be easy. I mean, any kind of resolution would have to involve a win-win, diplomatically negotiated solution. The British Museum, it's unlikely to just return the sculptures to Athens, because they have long argued that this would open the floodgates to all sorts of requests. I would argue that, you know, slowly the floodgates to all sorts of requests. I would argue that, you know, slowly the floodgates are being prized open, but this would be a big one. I mean, it's an existential threat to the British Museum as it stands currently. And someone really sort of radical would have to come in and reconceive the museum for the modern era. The other thing I'd say is that the current British government
Starting point is 00:29:07 might have to change before any great moves take place. There was some pretty trenchant rhetoric that greeted George Osborne's appointment to chair the board of trustees from groups of Tory backbenchers who basically wrote an open letter calling him not to give in to the so-called woke agenda, which would involve entering into negotiations over things like the Parthenon marbles and even smaller scale restitutions. I don't have a very strong view on what should happen because I think for the purposes of scientific study, they can be anywhere. I think the moral case is to return them to Greece. And I think there are many ways in which you can go about plugging the gap. We have all sorts of technology at our fingertips now. Microsoft just did an augmented reality reconstruction of the whole site at Olympia.
Starting point is 00:30:06 Not a very tasteful one, but that's a matter of taste, not a technological ability. So I think, you know, more and more moving towards these technological solutions that will make it less painful to part with things. And then there are also things like, you know, I think the Greek governments sort of turn more towards offering things in exchange. So permanent, not permanent, but sort of a rolling kind of sequence of loans to museums. So imagine something like the Tutankhamen exhibit, but with Agamemnon's mask and the Mycenae treasures.
Starting point is 00:30:44 You know, there's all sorts of things that can happen if museums can sort of work together that way, make things more interesting for everyone, really. Okay, listen, I think that's well done, Georgia. That's going to be my new opinion. Thank you very much for that. Have I nailed it? That's all sorted. Everyone go home. Nick, what do you think? Look, Dan, speaking as someone who loves the British Museum, and obviously I have a great deal of time for the Acropolis Museum, I want to see them both flourish. And I understand this is a difficult issue in that respect. But also as someone born to Greek parents in the UK and now living in Greece for many years, I've kind of grown a bit tired of this issue always seeming to dominate, at least on the surface, relations between the two countries.
Starting point is 00:31:33 When there's so much that's interesting and diverse and progressive and really fantastic about what's going on. Obviously, this is a story that attracts a lot of media attention. It's sexy. People write about it and going on. Obviously, this is a story that attracts a lot of media attention. It's sexy, people write about it and so on, but it's not anything to do with the current relationship between the two countries and the peoples within the two countries. So I would love to see it resolved. And I would like to go to a quote by the British Museum director, Hartwig Fischer, when he gave an interview to Tanea newspaper, a Greek daily newspaper I mentioned before, in 2019. And he essentially suggested that maybe we should appreciate Lord Elgin's act and his argument. And I quote here, and I'll give my comment on the end,
Starting point is 00:32:17 you could, of course, be saddened by the fact that the original environment has disappeared. When you move a cultural heritage to a museum, you move it outside its original environment. However, he says, this shifting is also a creative act. Now, you can imagine, Dan, how that went down in Greece. Lead balloon would be, to put it mildly. But if he's talking about the creative act, and I won't comment on that, but maybe it's time for another creative act so many years after Lord Elgin's one, if we're going to call it that.
Starting point is 00:32:51 I think there are solutions. And the Greek government, not just this one, but previous ones have tried to be constructive. And I think as time has gone on, perhaps be more constructive in this debate. And they've offered to, in return for getting the marbles back, to send on this sort of rotation, important ancient Greek artefacts to be exhibited at the British Museum. So maybe that's a starting point for a sensible adult discussion about this. You know what? I mean, I like the Parthenon marbles, but I think I'd take rotating greatest hits of ancient Greece every six months. I think that's a good, but I think I'd take rotating greatest hits of ancient Greece every six months. I think that's a good deal. I think the British Museum should go for that deal.
Starting point is 00:33:29 It's pretty sweet. Well, someone made the point of discussing that the BM could actually charge for admission to rotating exhibits, whereas it can't make any revenues off the Parthenon Marbles. Money spinner. Your phone's going to be ringing off the hook after this podcast, let me tell you. You're going to be ringing off the hook after this podcast, let me tell you. You're going to have George Osborne on the old blower. So I was just going to say, Dan, that my son, he's 13 now, but when he was about seven or eight, and obviously they're taught about this in Greek school, that Elgin came along and ripped half the marbles off the Parthenon. He suggested suggested to me we take his grandfather's pickup truck,
Starting point is 00:34:06 drive it to London, break into the museum, steal the marbles and bring them back. Heist movie idea. If they go missing one day, no one heard that from me. Well, listen, more likely that's coming in the next David Williams book, buddy. Watch out, protect your intellectual property on that one as well. Georgia and Nick, thank you so much. That was, I think, a really interesting discussion.
Starting point is 00:34:27 I learned a lot about the history. And there were some solutions there as well. That's very unusual for this podcast. It was practical ideas for a better future. Brilliant. Well done. Thank you, Dan. Pleasure. you

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.