Dissect - 'IGOR' by Tyler The Creator | LAST SONG STANDING (E4)
Episode Date: July 21, 2026The LSS Boyz journey to crown Tyler The Creator's best song ever continues with 2019's IGOR. Cole & Charles revisit its release, quiz each other with album trivia, and nominate its best songs. What...'s your favorite song on IGOR? Sound off in the comments below. 👇 Follow @dissectpodcast on Instagram, TikTok, and Twitter. Hosts: Cole Cuchna & Charles Holmes Producer: Justin Sayles Editor: Iulia Ciobanu Engineer: Sarah Reddy Theme Music: Birocratic Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Welcome everyone to Last Song Standing.
I'm Cole Kushna.
And I'm Charles Holmes.
And in this best season of Last Song Standing, we're working our way through Tyler
the Creator's entire catalog in order to crown his greatest song of all time,
aka Last Song Standing.
Last episode, we revisited Flower Boy.
And today, we are tackling what many believe is Tyler's best album.
Hell yeah.
2019's Igor.
Cole.
Bro.
We're here.
It's been on a journey.
Our friendship has been tested.
It is very funny that I feel like we both love, we both love the opposite Tyler albums.
Thinking back to last episode, I feel like you, this is like the reformed Charles is
really showing itself because I feel like a few years ago you would have came in here just
shitting on Flower Boy.
I know that there's a part of you that wanted to shit on Flower Boy is so bad.
But the new accepting meeting people where they're at Charles is very much showing itself.
And last episode, I'm proud of you.
You showed a lot of.
That was my cherry bomb episode where I'm like, yeah, cherry bomb is great.
And you're like, well, you know, it's no flower.
You're learning from me.
I'm learning from you.
I think I feel like that's that.
That is what friendship is all about.
So before we get into it, do we want to go over where we stand this season with our picks?
I'm feeling good about the picks that we're rounding out until I feel like the prime of Tyler's discography, but let's go over our picks so far.
All right.
So I've got bastard title track.
She, answer, cherry bomb title track, and garden shed.
I've, I'll just say I love garden shed.
I maybe have slight regret not going 911, but I still think garden shed was.
Garden shed is the one, right?
Don't have regrets.
Okay.
You made the right choice.
are you are you are these personal regrets or are these regrets that you feel like the fan base is like i think
that's kind of it no no if you learned anything the fans we love them keep listening they can lead you
astray you know what i'm saying we have to honor the exercise okay if an alien comes to earth
what is the song that best represents tyler yeah all right for my choices dog this list is great
French yonkers Bimmer Buffalo who that boy
Banger banger banger banger banger banger banger
They're all good songs I'll just like we said last episode
It's just a little one note I would love I would like to see some variety out of you today maybe
Do you think that's going to happen hey when Tyler starts showing us some variety I will as well
Got one in there got one in there early I'm sorry
I had to okay so all right before we get it and do we want to walk people through the premise of the
whole show. Yes. So for those who have forgotten, each episode of Last Song Standing covers
one album where we're forced to choose the best song off of that album, aka the Last Song Standing.
In the season finale, we take all the songs that we picked across the entire season into a
royal rumble. They duke it out. They go head to head until we eliminate and agree upon
the single greatest Tyler the creator song of all time. We're going to take a quick break
and then we're going to get into your favorite your favorite tyler album i'm going to have to
talk this through because it might be my favorite tyler album but i haven't convinced myself it's my
favorite and the best so uh after we get uh some ads you know rolling we'll get back i'll drop some
album facts about egor you'll get into the themes and then you know we'll have a little bit of banter
about where eager stands in 2026 this episode is presented by sierra nevada life's about embracing the
What does that mean? Living in the moment.
Seeing where the night takes you.
Being up for the adventure.
And there's no better way to embrace it than with Hazy Little Thing by Sierra Nevada.
Hazy, citrusy, smooth.
Juicy but not sweet.
Hoppy, but not bitter.
America's best-selling Hazy IPA for good reason.
Hazy Little Thing.
Enjoy responsibly.
All right.
We're back with Tyler's sixth studio album, Igor, released on May 17, 2019,
the 12-song project features collaborations with Charlie Wilson, Playboy Cardi, Loseyvert,
Sandy Gold, among others. It spawned one single in Earthquake and debuted at number one with
165,000 copies sold. Become the first time Tyler went number one on the Billboard 200.
And then in a big moment, I remember covering this, Tyler wins best rap album at the 62nd
Grammys. Yeah, this is one thing I wanted to talk to you about because this is
Tyler's sixth album, and it's his biggest, to that point,
debut's number one for the first time, gets his first Grammy.
I was trying to think back, like, I mean, this is just how atypical,
I feel like his career has been in terms of like just this like continual ascension.
Because I think there's a world in which Flower Boy is the album for Tyler.
Yeah.
And that becomes a peak in which he is not able to ever reach again.
We've seen that how many times.
And usually that happens early in someone's career with the debut or the sophomore work.
A lot of times the debut, I think of like a 50 cent who just came out so big and was just never able to sustain that height.
Where Tyler's, you know, if it was charted on a graph, is just up and up and up.
And I feel like the back to back of a flower boy, which I feel like earned him a certain critical acclaim and respect, brought in a new fan base to then just follow it with a.
even better record in an Igor that is even more mature and more refined and more, you know,
um, exact in a vision.
Just really, we talked about Flower Boy changing the trajectory of his career, but I really think
it's the back to back of Flower Boy and then doing it again on an Igor that really just
redefined Tyler as an artist.
This comparison, the fans might kill me, you might kill me, but Tyler would be like,
oh no, that's actually, that might be actually right.
is to me his trajectory reminds me of like a Justin Timberlake.
He loves Signoretti.
He loves Ferrell, the Neptunes, that era of music.
And if you think about it, Tyler for like the first kind of part of his career was in a boy band.
Odd Future in a way was very much that conception of a hip-hop version of music.
Right, right.
I was just saying.
Even though he had solo records, A, you're going to find all of these same collaborations.
is an Earl or Frank or Haji.
And I think the reason why he's had this assent truly is the fact that like once he breaks away from that structure of that family, you get a justified.
And I think this is his future sex love sounds where it's like, oh, who am I when I am not the center of a group?
Who am I when I have to stand on my own two?
And of course, he had been standing on his own two for a while.
But as we talked about last episode, you do see that moment where he doesn't want to be the guy who's being noticed because he's in a ridiculousness episode or he's on Twitter just like shit posting or even all of the adult swim, the adult swim show, Waiter Squad.
This to me is the moment where you're like, oh, okay, artistically, you have finally, finally, finally shed a lot of the baby fat, the baby weight.
And this is like a coming out record as like a fully bloomed artist.
Yeah.
And I think we mentioned it last episode, but I think the work that was done not only
artistically in refining a sound and learning to pick and choose a spots and all that we talked
about.
But I think the emotional work of a flower boy and the things that he confronted about himself
and shared in his music for the first time allowed him to make a project like Igor,
which feels as meaningful and thematically heavy as a flower boy,
but a little more effortlessly.
Yes.
I think Flower Boy is like,
you could tell it was him kind of working out that part of himself artistically.
Like,
I need to make an album that means something.
And you can very much hear or like see the brushstrokes a little bit,
if that makes sense.
Where Igor, after having done all that work,
just feels like this was a situation that happened to him.
him that was kind of effortlessly expressed through music in a way that doesn't feel forced.
Not to say that Flower Boy feels forced, but it would definitely feel, felt more considered,
if that makes sense.
It's a little sweaty.
And I don't mean that in a bad way.
It's like sweaty sometimes can be good because you see how hard he's working.
And I want to bring up this quote because I was like, oh, the things that, you know, I thought
about Flower Boy, Tyler has kind of said it as well where he said an interview with, I believe
this was with Rick Rubin. I think Flower Boy is good and it's my best work thus far just because
it's an easy listen. It's not boring. It's just tamed to me. Of course you're going to like it. It's
nothing too abrasive. It's nothing too weird about it. And he goes on to say in interviews with Rick,
with interviews with Zane Low, where on Flower Boy, he shaves away a lot of the idiosyncratic things
we had known about Tyler, which is like he loves crunchy sounds and distortion.
and these things that have become hallmarks.
And on Igor, he adds that back in to the mix, but it does not take away.
To your point, it is a seamless transition where it's like you think of because of the cover
and a song like Earthquake that Igor is like a very soft record.
But when you go back to, I'm like, there's a brace of moments that like they're very much like
the distortion and the crunching is everything.
I was like, oh, this is playing so well with the high, low, heart.
Well, you see that, that's perfect because you see that even in the album art with soft pink background.
Yeah.
And a black and white really contrast heavy photo of him that is literally cut and jagged, you know, edges,
which I think is a perfect album cover to relay the sound of the record, which is exactly that,
because it starts with that synth.
There's, you know, distorted synth on every single song.
And but yet he's rapping less than he ever has before.
he's singing on most of this record.
There's only less than a handful of moments where you get a traditional rap verse.
I mean, even earthquake, which we'll probably talk about later, doesn't have a verse from Tyler.
It's essentially like two hooks.
And then the verse that comes is a Playbord Cardi verse.
And so we're seeing those moments of him being the producer that he, you know, we talked about
that with like a boredom where he's more of the curator, a la Kanye, putting pieces together.
And so we get the best of that world.
And then Igor, I feel like what makes it special is that juxtaposition of soft and distortion.
It's the high, low, it's the soft and abrasive, perfectly melded together to, you know, I'm always taking it back to the themes of the album, which maybe I can use as a transition into the concept of the record.
But essentially having mixed feelings about this guy in his life that he has feelings for, who he's caught in this.
love triangle with. So it's Tyler liking this guy, this guy being involved with this girl,
also seems to be leading Tyler on. But the irony of the record is that it seems like the guy that
Tyler likes in this story is going through something similar that he went through on Flower Boy,
which it doesn't seem like he is comfortable with that part of his sexuality. Yeah.
There's multiple times on the album where Tyler's saying, I know your secrets, take the mask off,
like, you know, kind of alluding to maybe that part of why this relationship isn't working
is because this person's not yet comfortable with that part of himself. And so the album essentially
it's really clever because it's not heavy-handed, but there is a very clear, linear
progression of emotion where it starts in romantic infatuation on earthquake, moves into like
a longing and obsession on songs like I Think and some of those middle tracks. We get the
rejection. We get anger and new magic wand and resentment. We get indifference and I don't love you
anymore. And then ultimately it ends in acceptance where he's, are we still friends? It's very much him
accepting the fact that this thing we had was beautiful and it's gone and that's okay. And so it's really
this beautiful arc of this unrequited relationship expressed over however many 10, 12 tracks,
very concisely, not heavy handed. There's no really skits aside from like Gerard Carmichael
very brief little moments that kind of anchor the thematic kind of areas of the record.
And then of course, like, I think the most brilliant, or one of more brilliant things about
the Igor character is that he's playing on this idea of like the classic Igor sidekick,
grotesque, you know, infatuated with this master, but seen as a sidekick by the master himself,
playing on the scientist, the classic, you know, I'm talking about the sci-fi trope.
And so he's playing on that, I think, with the Igor character.
And just one last thing.
What's cool about the record, too, is that Igor is this character, but he also has a sound in my mind.
So Igor's theme were presented with a 23-second one synth note introduction of the record,
which that bass synth that we hear at the start of the record is in every single song.
And that, to me, represents the Igor character.
and it really anchors all these songs together
and glues them together sonically in a way
that I think one of the strengths of this album
is that it is very sonically cohesive
despite having a lot of variety in songs types.
It's again, Tyler being such a refined producer
where he knows how to build a world
as articulate and as narrowly focused as ever.
We saw glimpses of that throughout his career,
but I think Igor is where things really come together in terms of like the thing I always say,
I can picture Igor the world of Igor in my mind.
You know, it's that sonically concise.
What I think works also for me about this album so much, going back to like that eager figure
as a character, is that Tyler, when he's talking about this record and he's talking about
how much he, because he's always been like this.
how much he hates his voice, how everybody wants him to rap, and he knows how good his rapping voice is.
But he wishes he had that type of pitched up being able to voice, being able to hit those notes and everything.
And what's so funny is you have him building this character that is playing upon very European beauty standards with the blonde wig.
So it's like, it's so funny how you have this juxtaposition of Igor as this short,
grotesque monster who would probably traditionally have a voice similar to Tyler.
Right.
And that's gruff.
But then the visual, when you see him in the videos or you see him on tour of this like stick thing.
Right.
Pastel suit.
Blonde wig.
It's it is Tyler doing something that he had been doing all of his career, which is embodying
characters to tell a story.
But this is the one where I'm like, okay.
This works on a conceptual level, on a narrative level and on an aesthetic level, where it is just, it's seamless.
Yeah.
Where on a lot of times with his other characters, I'm just like, this is like a funny punchline, but it doesn't always go here.
Yeah.
Yeah.
The piece is all coming together.
Like this is what makes this album so special because it's everything we saw and Tyler and gotten bits and pieces across his career put together in one kind of perfectly constructed package.
Why do you think, before we get to a very contentious segment, why do you think love triangles
reappeared Tyler's catalog so much? Because his characters on Wolf, obviously at the camp,
are in a love triangle. On Igor, they're in a love triangle. And then even on, call me if you get lost,
there's a love triangle. So why do you think that this is something that kind of keeps,
well popping up in like and i'm not talking i don't want to get into like what tyler's love life
is i'm talking more narratively why do you think that that is something that he keeps trying to
interrogate well that's the thing because it is so there's just if you go on like the tyler reddit
it's like there's so many theories about who this you know white guy is that he's infatuated in
there's theories that the same guy on flower boy is the same guy on eager which is the same guy and
call me if you get lost. I do think there's some truth to like this just being inspired by
real events. Um, there's even connections. Some have brought all the way back to like a song like
fucking young. There's just it's so it's, it's when I was doing my season on both these records
is something I had to contend with a lot, which is like I don't like getting into that real world
shit. And so I'm more interested in like narratively to your question, you know, why is it,
um, something he keeps returning to? Like the first thing I would say is like it does seem like,
It does seem like it's inspired by real life events.
But I mean, it is just a kind of classic and interesting narrative framework that has worked across, you know, rom-coms forever.
But I do think there is something interesting thematically about it being the gender fluidity of it all.
And like the needing to accept yourself in order to accept a love that is presented to you.
You know, that was the story of Flower Boy for Tyler personally.
And now Tyler being on the other side of that is dealing with someone that was once like him in the past, what I think is just kind of interesting.
So I don't know if it's anything other than real life events and just a timeless and proven thematic kind of narrative framework, you know.
And I think what's interesting to me as well is like there's a racial component as well because he's always making jokes about this white boy, right?
And then you get a project like Igor where he's wearing the blonde wig.
He's dancing in a certain way.
And then you go to a very braggadocious record, like call me if you get lost, where almost Tyler, I think he's, to your point, he's playing with gender fluidity.
He's playing with just what it means to like be a rap artist at one moment and then want to make rock music or make R&B or make soul.
And that's why this, this era of because his career is so interesting to me because he's getting better at playing with that without being obvious.
That's the thing.
That's why it works so well is because it's not heavy handed at all.
Yeah.
It just feels natural or inorganic, not forced.
It's not him trying to make a serious album.
It's just him expressing what it seems like real life events and real feelings through music, which is what music does at its best is capture emotions.
you know how fucking yeah so should we should we pivot to uh like i said our most contentious segment
quiz me if you get lost trivia used to be the nominations but i feel like the contention is now
in now in the quizby if you get lost section so for those that don't know quiz me if you get loss
is where charles and i attempt to stump each other with little known facts about the album
whoever gets the most questions correct we'll get first pick in the last long standing segment
of the episode, but maybe more importantly, we are keeping a running tally this entire season
and whoever has the most points at the end of the season gets a prize picked out by Justin Sales.
Hell yeah.
Justin, welcome to the episode.
You're a fan of Igor, right?
I love Igor.
Yeah.
I think, you know, last album, Charles asked me what I thought about this in relation to the rest of his discography.
And I'm sure you guys will get into it, but this is probably the pinnacle of it still,
but definitely to this point.
Yeah, I agree.
I just, is it my favorite?
Maybe it's, maybe it's better if I don't pick because I just, I can make a case for
Fireboy, Igor, and Chromacopia.
And I feel like-
It's so funny.
Chromacopia, I can't wait till we get.
That is an album I bounced off so hard.
God damn.
Call me if you get lost.
Yeah, okay.
All right, so running tally so far, you're up by one.
You have five points.
I have four.
Okay.
you want to go first?
I will go first because do you want me to start with...
Don't say fucking softball.
No, because I'm going to start with my most difficult one.
Okay.
Because you did a season on this.
I really had to...
Like, there was a bunch where I was like this.
Too easy, too easy.
So this is going to be difficult.
Okay.
Tyler worked with engineer Vic Weinstein.
Sorry if I pictured that on the album.
And he talks very much about like how exacting Tyler was and especially about 808s.
and how much they needed to work on the 808s to make them knock on this record.
Okay.
So what plug in was their secret sauce to maintaining the fidelity of the 880s?
Dude, okay, this is a really good question.
I don't remember what it is, but I love this question.
I can't wait to be re-remembered what it is.
I'll take the loss right away, but I love this question.
Little Labs, V-O-G.
Okay.
Yeah, I was reading that interview.
Yeah, where did you find that?
Oh, I was just like researching and looking it up. If you look up a Tyler Ego, Igor engineer, he has like an interview where he kind of goes through. Because I believe he had already worked with Tyler on Flower Boy. And he's getting very much into like the nitty gritty of. They worked with another engineer who kind of was like helping them a little bit, showing them like, okay, here's how you work the 80 weights so they can get to where Tyler wanted them to be without losing any of that fidelity.
I was like, oh, that's fucking interesting.
Yeah, it's Little Labs, Voice of God, bass resonance.
It looks like tune low in with confidence.
It's a universal audio plug-in for any audio nerds out there.
It's 50 bucks.
Did the job.
Did the job.
That's cool.
I love that.
You know, I love that kind of shit.
Okay.
This one I picked out just for you.
It might be a softball.
Who knows?
Tyler wrote running out of time during a recording session with what other rapper?
With what rapper?
With what rapper?
He was in a session with this rapper.
and he wrote running out of time.
I can give you a hint for a half point deduction.
I want to say
because he uses the same sample from Bound 2,
which he also worked on a version of Bound that never came out.
It's not Kanye.
No.
Give me a hint.
Okay.
The rapper is from Harlem.
A-Sat-Ferg.
Yep.
Yeah.
A-Sap-Berg.
Okay.
Half-point?
Hell yeah.
Great job.
That's such a rant,
because that song sounds nothing like.
No, I read that.
I was like, why the fuck would Tyler, like, be with ASAP Fur?
But I'm like, oh, no, that makes sense.
Like, he's, he's battling around with the Rocky.
Okay.
This is going to be a softball for you.
When did Tyler have the original idea for Gone Gone?
What year?
2013 Wolf Tour.
Yes.
Damn.
I knew you would get it.
I knew you would get it.
But also, not to spoil, Gone Gone, one of my favorite records on this album.
And to know that Tyler.
even back then on Wolf, like a project that I think we both liked, but we're like,
okay, he's getting there, but it's not perfected.
Yeah.
Him having that insight to be like, let me keep this.
Like, let me keep this idea.
It's not on this.
Because he said, like, there were a couple records where he's like, it's not meant for
this record.
It's not meant for this record.
And then bring it back out.
I was like, oh, yeah.
It's, knowing how good it got, it's like, obviously they made the right decision.
And like, yeah, to have that intuition to be like, this is not right or it's not ready or I'm not
ready to make this song yet and to see what it becomes.
It's like, there's a hundred,
there's like so many radio heads like songs like that that started like 10 years.
They always saved it.
And then when you get the final product 10 years later,
you're just like, oh, okay.
They know they have the instincts to know like,
we're not ready yet or it's not right for this moment or whatever it is.
And like that to that,
to your point,
I don't even know if Tyler was at a place as a producer who could,
yeah,
who could really get that song.
which is such a just like a monument in his career to where it would need to go.
He needed to like,
he needed to level up.
Yeah.
All right.
So I'll throw you a softball.
Okay.
Igor's final song,
Are We Still Friends?
Features a guitar solo from what famous rock musician?
Check white?
Yeah.
That was too easy.
Fuck.
Come on.
That's too easy,
bro.
All right,
this one,
this one is on the easier side,
but we'll see if you get it.
one of Tyler's favorite moments and my favorite moments on Igor is the bridge on I think.
Yeah.
There are a lot of versions of I think as a bridge.
Which number version do we end up here?
I've definitely read this before, but I don't know the exact number.
He tweeted out nine.
So this is like the ninth version of the bridge, which is like, just incredible.
I think starting with Cherry Bomb, but really on Flower Boy and then really on Igor, he just, he loves bridges.
He loves them.
He will talk about his love of Bridges.
But loves them.
Okay.
So last one, I'm going to give you.
Okay, this is an interesting one.
So Tyler said that the minimalistic sound of Igor was inspired by something specific.
Do you know?
So he's talked about like letting the songs breathe, not trying to fill every single
moment with vocals or stacking production.
He's just like, he was inspired by something that was minimalistic.
was like, oh, I need to take this idea into my music.
I believe he went to a friend's house.
And the only thing in the house was like a couch and like this super like amazing artistic sound system.
And I believe he said something to the effect of like we have so much shit in our lives in our house that we don't need.
And I wanted to kind of make a record that was represented.
Damn, Charles.
Damn.
Come on.
I love this record.
Bro.
Come on.
Okay, I have a theory.
He never says who this is, but I think it's pretty clear who it is.
You see, he also said the house is in Malibu.
Rick Rubin?
Rick Rubin.
I think it's right.
And he did that interview with Rick Rubin for Igor.
So I think it's, I think it was Rick Rubin's house, which Rick Rubin coming up two episodes
in a row.
Hey, it's, I will say, my barber did tell me a crazy story about being at Rick Rubin's house.
I will not share it here.
But I was just like, yeah, man.
I'm glad you got like you got your life back.
Like he was like,
he was like,
yeah,
man,
it was crazy.
Like,
Rick was not there.
Okay.
All right.
All right.
So where is that standpoint wise?
I'm fucked.
Uh,
okay.
So you have a seven point,
seven point five.
I have five.
So I got some work to do.
Step it up,
Cole.
Step it up,
Cole.
You,
okay,
but the thing is,
no,
never mind.
You do this every time.
If we're being real,
though,
you're a bigger,
Tyler fan.
I know.
In his later career.
It's a,
it's a thing.
I have a bad memory when it comes to like,
like facts like this.
So do I.
Most of this stuff,
I'm like,
it's funny.
I'm like most of the stuff I've read before.
Right.
Yeah.
I was covering this music still.
And it's not until I read again.
I was like,
oh,
that was in my mind.
Well,
I do so much like this kind of work for dissect.
I think my brain just like retains only what it needs.
Because like I did a season on Igor,
but this was like,
I don't know,
four years ago now.
So I'm just like,
I'll obviously,
read everything about this album, but because then I'd turn around and do the same thing for
another album, right after that, it's just fucking. Okay, that was great. Let's go ahead and get
into our nominations. Yes. All right. So remember the goal of each episode of Last
Song Standing is to determine the single best song Tyler Creator ever made. We're going to select
the songs off of Igor that we think are in contention for Tyler's best. We're going to nominate
three and we'll force to choose one by the end of the episode.
Charles, do you want to go first?
Are you just going to get the one that I know you're going to pick out of the way?
Or where are you going first?
No, no, no, no, no, no, we're going to lead up to that.
I'm going to go to my pick that.
I don't know if it's the best song in this album, but it damn near might be my favorite song in the album, I think.
Can you just before I even start?
Can you just play it?
I just want to play a little bit just to kind of, like, situate myself.
Okay.
I love this song so much.
It's so good.
Let me fast forward a little bit.
What do you think I would love about this record is how understated his vocals are, almost the entire time.
Dog, I was about to talk about that.
Okay.
It is an artist completely in control of their instrument.
Yeah.
Where early in Tyler's career, to me,
a lot of times
his vocal would be the star
which is good in the beginning of your career
but as you grow up
and you listen to more music
there are moments on I think
in the rest of the record where I don't even know
if understated is the right word
but his vocal almost sounds
a little bit like bored
but in a perfectly
in a purposeful way
and it's like there's this
it's this four on the floor beat
there's this groove
it's escalating and it's taking you
want a journey, but it's not in a rush
to get there. This to me
is, I think, but also Igor as a
whole, is a record about subtraction.
Where it's like, even though there are a lot of
maximalist ideas in the
record, there's a lot of different things
he's doing. It's never overpowering.
Like, when we talk about
the bridge,
that's a
moment where I think
in previous records,
Tyler's trying to show off.
He loves bridges and like
to me in 2026
we've just had
so many years
when you want
a rapper or a singer
or a producer
wants to show off
they throw in this bridge
and I'm like no
a bridge has a point
it is there
to transport you
from one place to another
it is not a repository
to show off
to jangle some keys
to put all of the ideas
that did not fit
in the more normal
structure of the song
and to me
why I love I think is I'm like, of course Tyler loves Bridges, but he does it in such an effective
way where it's so understated that every single time I listen to what I hear new things and I'm
amazed by just how like technically brilliant it is. But even the hook, I can, uh, I can't, uh, I can't
I tell you. Not the hook, um, what's we call the refrain afterwards. How can I tell you? Any singing voice
is so much more confident.
He's so much more confident in his instrument.
Do you like this record?
I love this record.
You'll see, I'll do some honorable mentions at the end of the ones that I couldn't pick.
I mean, half this record, I could have, you know, you can make a case for half these songs.
I think is a perfectly valid nomination.
Do you know the backstory of the song is pretty interesting?
Do you know it at all?
Okay, so he was saying that he, you know, his dad's Nigerian and he started to get like,
look up, try to get more, I guess, in touch with his Nigerian side of himself. And he found
Nigerian music specifically from the 70s and 80s and started looking at like photos of like old
clubs people would go to during that time. And he said, I wanted to live in that moment for a day.
So me Solange and Frank Ocean flew to Italy. They didn't end up going to any clubs, but they made,
I think, during the trip. And what's cool about the song is that there's two sample or there's one
sample and one interpolation, both being from Nigerian dance songs from the 80s, from the same
year, actually, 1982. So the drum sample of the song comes from a song from his name, I don't know,
I'm not going to pronounce this right, but Konotellis, Nigerian artist. The song's called Get Down
from 1982. He pulls the drums from here. So, I mean, it's so sick. Okay, so he pulls those drums,
and then he interpolates a song called Special Lady by another Nigerian musician, B.B. Maskell.
And here's what that sounds like.
It's so sick.
So it is because even to that point, and the reason I love the song so much is, you know, I love dancing.
And you have elements on the song where you have the full escape.
Yeah.
Where it does feel like an 80s dance record call and response.
We're all in the dance floor.
there's a DJ and to me for Tyler to get to a moment in his career where he can make a dance record.
Yeah, you can't this is like kind of new territory for him. You can't really think of a song like I think
in his pat in his catalog to this point. No. And it's to me for this to kind of be not the first time,
but like definitely like an early attempt at you trying to like you hear these Nigerian records
because he also talked about listening to a lot of 80s music during the recording of this process.
To be able to synthesize that, it works not only as a dance record, but it works as a Tyler dance record.
If we go back to Cherrybaum, he was trying a lot of rock-infused elements on that.
And that's a perfect example of like when I feel like it wasn't completely there.
He didn't have full mastery of it.
On this record, he's able to, like there's records where he's like, there's records where he's
like sampling or interrelated,
interpolating like Japanese city pop.
Yeah.
But he brings it into his world.
Yeah.
So I think is just,
I was listening to it on the car right here.
I was like,
there's just something about the groove.
Yeah.
So fucking infarction.
And he knows,
yeah,
to your point,
like he's at a point in his career
artistically where he knows,
yeah,
I don't need to do too much on this song.
I can let the groove of it be the star.
And when I come in,
I'm just going to sound smooth and cool.
And there's something,
He does that so many times on the record where the beat is feeling one way, like a new magic one, where it's like, it's so aggressive.
And then he comes in just so opposite of that.
It's again, that contrast of soft and hard.
And he's just working.
He just, it just feels effortless.
I think I'm falling.
Well, what's also?
So on Igor, he does this a lot.
Like, on Twitter, after the album came out, he was really into, like, pointing out specific moments on the record that he loved.
and he seemed like he was very intentionally creating singular moments and songs that were repeated to that point.
What's cool about the choruses of this song, if you listen closely, they're never repeated the exact same and it builds across the entire song.
So I'm going to play all three hooks, sections of all three hooks.
And notice how hook one is very understated.
It's just Tyler kind of almost singing like what feels like a scratch take.
I'll just play it here.
He's like barely audible, you know.
Okay, so we get that more understated version.
Okay.
The second iteration of it, we get Solange more in the foreground
and the vocals are doubled more consistently.
You hear the difference, like dynamically.
Even you hear the screech in the back.
And then now for the third and final iteration at the very end of the song,
even bigger.
So to go from that first chorus where it's very like,
almost inaudible to then now at the very end of the song.
So you're getting this dynamic arc across the entire thing.
This is just like really technically sound,
like big picture thinking about the progression of not just I need to make this part really good.
And then I'll move on to the next part, make that part really.
No, I'm thinking actually across the entire thing dynamically.
And it's just like stuff like that.
There's just little moments and details all throughout this record.
We've talked a lot about this kind of phenomenon and like,
like a Frank Ocean blonde.
There's reasons we keep returning to an Igor more than a wolf because there are
these details.
There are all these little special moments that our brain hasn't like can't predict because
it's always kind of moving.
And there's so much information tastefully kind of planted so that we're just always
entertained, always finding something new.
And what I would also say though is, you know, they say this about movies, which is it's
it's going to be a dumb statement, but like movies are a visual medium.
So if you can show something that's going to do something to the audience more than you just telling them.
Right.
In the same way, music is an auditory experience.
I think in the past, Tyler, if you think about it, I think, and it being about love and obsession and that building that crescendo, normally I feel like Tyler would have said it.
He would have wrapped it.
Right.
There would have been, there would ever been a texture where it's like, okay, he's showing the escalation through his voice.
And to this, to your point, it's like sonically, he's showing you the progression.
So you don't intuitively when it hits your ears and emotionally, you feel it before you do intellectual.
Yeah, yeah.
And that is what makes a great artist where it is like, okay, I do not have to, I can be subtle about this.
I do not have to point to how joke this is.
Yeah.
you understand it before, like, just in your soul before anything.
Yeah, perfect.
I don't bring Justin in here.
Are you fan of I think, because I think, I think this album has like a good chance of
maybe using your coach's challenge later in the episode.
So I'm going to get your take on all these songs.
Okay.
Yeah, I, you know, Charles, you were bringing up like 80s dance songs.
And to me, I was saying this to you yesterday, Cole, this feels like a roller skating
rink jam to me a little bit.
but like kind of like I don't know but with like a melancholy vibe mixed to it it's yeah I I love
this song and yeah I don't know uh it's gonna be hard to not use the coaches challenge on this one
I'm gonna be very strategic this episode I'll just say that because there's so many songs that
need to make it to the finale in my mind so okay so let me go are you is that you good yeah I'm
good who do I want to go first should I just get the big
one out of the way.
I got to go gone, gone.
Thank you.
Okay, so let's, let's partner up on this because this was also.
It was on your list too?
This is a perfect song.
This song, I was reminded, for whatever reason, I've always loved this song, but
for this exercise at this time of my life or whatever it was, it was just like, oh,
this is the song.
Like this is like, fucking a masterpiece.
This is one of his best songs.
this can actually win it all potentially.
So I think, I'm glad it was on your list because I was hoping that,
hopefully it gets into the finale from one of us.
But I have like a thousand things to say about this.
My notes are there's so much.
Let's start with just like gone, gone the first half of the song.
So this is a track 10.
This is the classic two tracks in one.
Tyler does on the track 10 thing.
One thing that I love about this album, specifically this song.
It's a good example of it.
I guess we talked about it with I think.
So GondGon is based around a sample of the song called Hey Girl by Colin Amory.
Let's just play a clip here so we can hear it.
So it's beautiful.
It's a great, you know, it's a great sample selection.
But what he does so often on this record and beautifully on this song is that, you know,
a lot of times in hip-hop, it's like the sample becomes the centerpiece.
You write the drums to it.
Yeah.
And it kind of just loops.
But on Igor, and he's been doing this entire career.
but it really comes to fruition here on Igor.
He builds an entire world around the sample.
You can tell it's all based,
the production is all based on the sample
in the same key and borrowing elements of the sample,
et cetera.
But he creates so much original material around the sample
that he can actually come and go dynamically,
where you're not just looping it.
It just becomes a part of the texture that,
like in this instant,
it just kind of comes in for the chorus.
But then the very,
verses and the bridge and stuff are all independent of the sample. And so he really builds a world
around it and builds the Igor world around it so that to your point earlier, it feels of the world.
It doesn't feel like a sample. It feels like something Tyler could have written. And so just to give you
a taste of that world, he builds around it, there's a section of the song that doesn't use the sample.
And you can hear all the original elements that he composed.
So no sample, but the guitar is playing a line that's similar to the sample.
But this is all original production, right?
And so when the sample comes in and when it leaves, it's seamless and like, it's just,
it's just beautiful production.
This is Tyler at his best production wise.
I think his singing on here is really bad and beautiful, which is like.
I actually think he's singing on here is among his best.
You think so?
Not technically.
Okay, that's what I'm saying.
Emotionally.
I mean it in the most positive.
This is coming from someone that cannot sing.
I have a bass voice like Tyler's.
I wish I can sing high and I can't.
And I really admire the fact that he just fucking goes for it.
And it works.
Like it works beautifully and it feels genuine,
which is the most important part.
Dog.
Keep going.
Bro.
Okay.
Okay.
So this is also something that Tyler just didn't do as well until.
a flower boy and especially Igor,
which is he matches.
I mean, he's done this entire career,
but a song like this where you are,
the production reflects
the theme of the song
so perfectly that it
that it accentuates the emotion
that you're conveying in the lyrics
with the music.
And so the song is all about,
you know, Gone Gone,
his,
it's kind of a double entendre
in terms of like he's saying,
my love is gone, meaning this love of his life has left him for this girl.
And his love for this person is dissipating because the next song is, I don't love you anymore.
So he's kind of setting up this idea of the lover leaving and also his love dissipating.
But it's also him accepting and finding beauty in the fact.
Instead of being resentful on a new magic wand earlier on the album, this is him coming to terms with, okay, this thing is over.
I wanted it to be more than it was, but I'm now accepting the fact that at least I had it.
You know, at least I experienced this really special thing.
I mean, he says it, you know, clearly he says, the bird going to leave the nest.
You're so chromatic.
At least I had it instead of never.
I mean, just that phrasing alone, at least I had it instead of never.
It's just like it speaks to something universal in terms of like beautiful moments of our lives
that are fleeting, that can't be repeated.
and instead of being resentful or bitter
or depressed about it,
you find beauty and acceptance
in the fact that
and just gratitude in it actually happening
instead of never.
I mean,
I even love what he's the,
I know that love is all like that.
That's part is so beautiful.
When did we get that?
I was like,
because I never thought.
I know.
This is the,
like he would have a moment
where I was like,
oh,
that is so beautiful
because it is like so,
tender and so soft.
And it's so funny where when you look at Tyler's clothes and the evolution of where he would go
between just the merch with the fucking cats and the tie-dye to Gulf LaFleur, like I'm like,
he is an artist that visually loves texture.
He loves like the cash beers and the softness.
And this to me is also a reflection of that world of like you can just feel that if like
the physical embodiment of.
of this song would be that like soft cloth.
Like I was dog.
Do you know who sings the chorus?
The weather is rain or shine.
I know I'm fine for now.
Unfortunately,
Celow.
Okay,
but have some respect.
Whoa,
that has less to do with artistic.
Oh,
is there some shit about,
oh,
I missed it then.
We might just want to cut this.
Oh,
really?
It's that bad.
Oh,
it's bad.
It's as bad as it gets.
Okay.
Oh,
damn.
That sucks.
Okay.
That's why I didn't bring him up.
Well, the good thing that, but then, you can't really tell it's him.
No, you can't.
Which is, I guess, a positive thing in this case.
Yes.
But also, there is, I want to bring this up.
A, to me, Tyler's humor is evolving as well because he has a line on this.
Felt like summer to my December.
Was it my August?
Shit, I don't remember.
Oh, right.
Yeah.
When you hear that, it's not supposed to be funny, but it has kind of like that West Anderson
human.
human to me where it's like it's just a little two bars that I'm like it's cute but not too cute
it's saying so much and to me it also loops back to a song like November where to me like
Tyler he has these motifs and to me Tyler does understand so much of his world through the
changing of the seasons yeah temperature whether it's hot whether it's cold whether he's wearing
the Hawaiian shirt like Como it's like I also drawd car
Michael says something that like I've listened to this song a lot but it hit
me differently this week when he says I hate wasted potential that shit crushes
your spirit it really does it crushes your soul to me that could almost be the thesis
statement for not only Tyler creator's career but this era of his career of like
living up to your potential yeah that's just not musical potential and
artistic potential. It is like your potential to be a realized human that is like not going to let
the repression win that wants to fully be yourself. And I was like, oh, man, that is such a perfect way
to send us out. Yeah. On this album. Yeah. And then I just have to point out structurally,
this song potentially could be such a mess because it's doing so it's doing the thing that like
Cherrybaum was trying to do where there's like,
There is a defined verse chorus, but then when we get to the bridge, it's a terminal climax in terms of like, once we get to the bridge, it never returns to the chorus of the verse again. It just ends, or in this case, it segues into another song eventually. But the bridge itself is beautiful. It's like your classic Tyler Bridge. I think he said it was one of his favorite moments he's ever, he's ever written. And it really takes the song takes a turn here.
It's still smooth transition, but he's modulating.
This whole chord sequence is all modulating through different keys.
So to my ear, this is him taking the lessons that he learned in a flower boy where he was studying, you know, a song like God bless his child that he wrote boredom to, which is a class, you know, a jazz standard that modulates, does the same kind of modulation thing.
So in my ears, I'm like, oh, he's taking the, he's not now just like riding over someone else's corporate.
progression, he's actually taking that same idea that he learned in a song like a jazz standard like that and implementing it in a bridge here, totally original. And then the wrapped verse, like, what I love about Igor is like when he does rap, it's perfect. Like, you could tell he saved the rap moments for the exact right times because one of my favorite sections of this entire album is the rap verse. And it is because it is so rare.
It's nothing special, but it's like,
that part.
Just emotionally, you can hear kind of like that little bit of sadness in there,
a little bit of dejection, but like and him coming to terms with this whole,
how it all played out.
But just like him reserving those moments to make them special, the rap moments, you know,
and meeting the moment with a great, with just one single rap verse.
And then my favorite part of this entire song,
and maybe the entire album actually, is this part.
But I finally found peace.
So peace.
Right here.
Let me do it over.
And then it goes into the jar of karma.
So that whole, like, let me do it over.
Obviously, it sounds like he's saying he wants to do his takeover,
but then what everything.
And that just speaks to this entire relationship.
Yep.
Regrets, things I wish I could have done.
And to your point about waste of potential, that segues right into that.
Just, I don't know, there's something about that candid moment that just feels like perfect
in terms of like what it's emotionally expressing.
I mean, he even said it during, in interviews, how he was kind of teaching himself because
obviously Tyler, the creator as Asba, he was teaching himself how to kind of like rewrap again
in terms of just like how to deliver it.
And he was saying he was deliberate about leaving a lot of like the breath work where it's like
if you've ever seen like, if you've ever been like a studio session or seen someone record,
like an engineer traditionally is going to take out breasts and stuff like that.
And there is that adds a level of texture because Tyler's not taking a lot of those moments out.
Right.
So even though Igor is this record that is very, very polished, you have moments like that.
Oh yeah, yeah.
That are so, you're just like, he's also finding beauty in the moments where we're in a studio, we're recording.
Like there's going to be parts instead of taking it out.
If it fits the texture of the song, keep it in.
Yeah.
Then we should just acknowledge, unless you have anything more on like the gone gone.
So then it bridges into thank you.
And this is where I'm saying like the song structure potentially could just feel chaotic.
But this is where he really nails a complex structure that I think when you listen from start to finish to the song, even though it is kind of three songs in one.
if you count the bridge as its own kind of world.
Because when we get to thank you after that transition I just played,
for me it just works somehow,
even though it does it is a totally new song.
I love.
It's,
and again,
it's an interpolation.
I'll play the original source of a 1998 song called Fragile by Tetsuro Yamashita.
This song is incredible.
Thank you for your love.
Thank you for your love.
It's so beautiful.
They'll never be a long and lonely night again.
It's so beautiful, but then to what we already talked about,
the way he brings that into this world and makes it his own.
Maintaining the emotional core of the sample of the interpolation,
singing it through the high-pitched Igor voice,
putting it over distorted, the same harmony, I think, as the original,
but completely distorted.
That fluttering scent in the background.
Yeah.
This song is so good.
It's so good.
Incredible.
Yeah.
Dog, I'm so happy.
We both love this song.
Justin,
where are you at on this song?
Very, very, very high.
Should have brought this up
when you were talking about the sample.
One thing I wanted to shout out.
This is just for the audience
who might not know.
Kona Mori was part of,
a great indie band in the early 2010s called Smith Westerns.
They put out a couple bangers and then disappeared.
They're on subpop, right?
They were.
And then a couple of the members went on to form a band that I think some of the people
in the audience might be familiar with, Whitney.
Oh, okay.
And shout out to Whitney.
Shout out to Mack.
Shout out to Julian.
Cool guys.
I've spent some time.
Oh, sick.
Cool.
So that's all I want to say.
But this great song, great Sam.
I don't know. I think it should and can go very far.
I think so.
All right. So you want to go to a quick break?
And then since we both picked Gone Gone, Gone.
You have one left?
No, you have two left, don't you?
Oh, shit, I do.
Yeah, so why don't we go when we come back?
You'll reveal your second nomination.
All right, let's do it.
This episode is brought to you by Sierra Nevada Hazy Little Thing.
If you saw the band when they played at the bar or stopped mid-festival to look at the stars,
then you're ready to embrace the haze with hazy little thing.
Citricy, smooth and easy to drink,
it pairs with nights that don't need a script.
Brewed with the purest ingredients for finest quality,
there's a reason it's America's best-selling hazy IPA.
Embrace the haze with Sierra Nevada hazy little thing.
Enjoy responsibly.
All right, Cole, what's your second nomination going to be?
All right, I'm going to go, this might be a curveball.
Maybe.
I don't know.
It's actually the third, I was surprised this is the third biggest song
off at Igor if we're just going by Spotify streams, are we still friends?
Are you gonna have to sell me on this one?
Really?
No, I don't dislike it.
It was not even on my short list.
Okay, well, I think this is a song that's really hard to remove from the album.
Yeah.
And so I don't know how far it can go on its own.
But in the context of the album, this song works so fucking well.
Just to get some of the maybe more technical stuff.
the way prominently samples Al Green's song called Dream.
So it's a rare instance where Tyler doesn't do much to the sample.
Like that sounds pretty close to what's on the record, right?
He eventually builds it out.
But for whatever reason, it works in the world at Igor where it doesn't feel like just a
straight one-to-one sample, although at points it definitely is.
But he does build the world around it eventually.
The bridge of the song doesn't feature
the sample at all and it carries on its own. It has a really cool, swingy 6-8 feel, which you don't
really hear in hip-hop too much. And what I love about the song is that one, it's a thing where
he says, I don't need to fill the space of every single part of a song. Yeah.
Where it's like there's half of the song Tyler's not even on. We get a Farel sample or a feature
a little bit later in the song. But, you know, it feels almost.
like a freestyle at times where he's kind of just going off the cuff.
But thematically, I think what resonates for me about the song is where the album ends,
which is, you know, after the acceptance of Gone Gone,
after the kind of shedding the relationship and I don't love you anymore, we get to this place
where a lot of relationships end up, which is like, can we still be friends?
Can something so special in our life, it seems like a tragedy to just have,
have it be all or nothing.
And so there's always the temptation of like, can we be friends?
Can we be in each other's lives?
And it's purely a friendship or is the whatever chemistry between our lives and who
we are as people, is it impossible for us to have that kind of relationship?
Does it have to be all or nothing?
And sometimes that is, it is all or nothing because there's just something between,
it's that weird juxtaposition of where there's, there is chemistry.
but there is also like severe oil and water effect, you know?
And can you still be friends when there's not only been hurt,
but so much of the album is also about Tyler being at a point in his life after a flower boy
that this love interest is not.
So can Tyler be his full self and still be friends with someone who is living,
he's at a different phase, which I've,
on fascinating that once again,
if you go back to Bastard,
it's a weird thing,
but like Bastard and Igor are almost sister albums
where you go from Tyler being the one in therapy
or like at least the one with Dr. T.C.
Almost now he's a doctor T.
It's crazy.
Yeah.
What I love about the song too is like,
the theme is so unique.
Like what other songs.
capture this dynamic, like this question, this dynamic, especially it coming at the end of the
album and having experienced the full trajectory of this relationship, I love songs that are
about something that everyone has experienced, but is rarely articulated in art. Because it's
really hard to articulate this thing. And he's pretty explicit about it. Are We Still Friends?
Makes the theme very clear. But it's like, I can't really think of other songs that are about
exactly this phenomenon, which is very common. You know,
And so it's Tyler kind of capturing something unique there.
But this also does bring me to the most dissectable moment.
Okay.
Oh, shit.
And we have a sponsor.
Oh, yeah.
We got our first segment sponsor on L-D-W-S.
How yeah, yeah.
So this most dissectable moment is brought to you by Sierra Nevada and their hazy little thing,
which is America's best selling hazy IPA all about embracing the haze being present and leaning into the moments that matter.
And what better moment that matters most on Igor is the very last note of the album.
I'm pretty sure I've laid this theme out to you.
And I've definitely laid out this concept.
You know, I think last season on last longstanding and definitely in my season on Igor.
But guess what?
I've had a lot of hazy IPAs.
So it's like, I don't even remember.
So break it down for me.
But it is worth repeating because I think it is very, again, it's the subtle mastery of Tyler the creator at this point in his career.
in making five concept albums before Igor and really understanding how to tell a story through music and through an album is expressed in this single note at the end of the album.
So to set up the single note, I have to tell you a couple of things about the album itself.
So the bass synth that starts Igor is some version of a distorted bass synth appears in every single song.
sometimes in songs that wouldn't you would not think a bass,
a distorted sound like that should be in.
So it seemed very deliberate that he was placing it every song.
And importantly, that same bass synth both opens the album and the 23 second sustained
synth that opens Igor's theme.
And there's a similar synth that closes the album that is also sustained for like 10
or 15 seconds.
And before I make the connection between the beginning and
And just remember track, I think four of this album is just an interlude where Gerard Carmichael says,
exactly what you run from, you end up chasing.
And so over the course of the album, we experienced this a range of emotions about this guy and this
relationship.
Ultimately, Tyler lands on this idea of gratitude, acceptance, and then at the very end,
wanting a friendship or questioning whether he can be friends with this person.
But the final line of the album repeats, can't say goodbye, can't say goodbye, can't say goodbye,
I can't say goodbye.
So he leaves you on this kind of cliffhanger of like, okay, can they still be friends?
And maybe as much as Tyler tried to be accepting and, you know, loving this experience for what it was, he does leave us with this idea of like, I can't say goodbye ultimately.
And so what's really cool about this, keeping in mind exactly what you run from, you end up chasing this idea of can't say goodbye and wanting to be friends.
and this idea of this looping cycle with this relationship,
the final note of the album is this here,
which I'll play for you now,
which sounds a lot like the opening of the album,
which is this here.
And what I love about the contrast between the two synths,
which are similar synths, but with some slight variations,
Igor's seam is more full, more energetic,
where the last note of the album is a little more deflated.
Right. Same synth sound, but there's an emotional contrast. And what's cool about this is that it works, the beginning note and the end note work on a technical music theory level. So the final note is a B flat and the opening note of the album is an E flat. And so what this implies in music theory is the most common cadence in music, which is a 5-1 chord progression, which is a chord of,
extreme tension that is meant to set up a resolution to the home chord of the key.
And so if these were fleshed out more than a single note, it would sound like this.
This is the chords that they are implying.
So it's a classic technically sound cadence, which means that the final note of Igor
is the chord of tension that is resolved by the beginning note.
So what we're hearing is essentially the end and beginning of the album is a technically sound musical loop,
where the end goes into the beginning.
And thematically it works because if Tyler becomes friends with this guy,
exactly what he was trying to run from, he ends up chasing again and the loop starts all over again.
and he's caught in this cycle of falling in love again
and experiencing this same endless cycle over and over again,
which is in my mind fucking so cool.
You know, I love this kind of thing.
But the fact that it works musically,
thematically, and it's not just an arbitrary loop,
it actually fits the theme of the song
and the theme of this idea of like,
if this person is in my life,
it is inevitable that I'm going to go through this cycle,
again. Are you dissected?
Not only am I dissected.
I remember you breaking this down for me before.
So similar to Igor.
Oh yeah.
There's this fucking circle, bro.
I'm still as my mind is blown.
I was like, damn, I remember when he broke this down the first time.
Even the second time, it's still fucking joke as fuck.
Hell yeah.
That's what I think.
I get just as hyped.
This might be like the most high.
I've ever got when I discovered something on an album.
And Tyler liked the tweet when I laid this theory out on Twitter first, and Tyler liked the tweet.
So I think I'm not just making it up.
Hell yeah.
So that was the most dissectable moment brought to your friends, bought to by our friends at Sierra Nevada.
Embrace the moments that matter with hazy little thing by Sierra Nevada.
Hasey, citrusy, smooth, juicy but not sweet, hoppy but not bitter, hazy little thing,
enjoy responsibly.
Are you going to be enjoying, we're recording this on the eve of the 4th of July,
you're going to be enjoying some tasty beverages.
Oh, you already know.
You know how I get down cold.
I also just want to say, bro, I love what Cole getting his corporate bag.
He's like, all right, I'm going to do, he's like, all right, brought to you by Sierra that.
I'm like, damn, you grow shit.
You get that.
A little code switch to the corporate.
Hell yeah.
That is one thing you do learn on podcasting.
we all do have the ad read voice.
All right, brought to you by.
All right.
So where are you going next on your nomin?
Oh, I know you're gone.
There's only one place.
You make my earthquake.
Oh, you make my earthquake.
Oh, this song.
You guys know, I'm a creature of habit.
I'm a basic bitch when it comes to my music fandom.
Is the best pop song in Tyler's catalog?
he finally got one.
Better than see you again?
Yeah.
Because for Tyler to land this plane,
a pop song where he is singing
and trying to hit high notes,
working with Charlie Wilson,
The Legend,
and has Playboy Cardi on one song.
The grand irony of this is that
when Igor was dropping,
I was still working at Rolling Stone,
and I remember document
how Tyler and DJ Khalid were in a battle to see who would go number one.
And what's so funny about Igor is that Tyler's doing the DJ Khalid thing,
where it's like you're taking a bunch of artists and putting them on one song.
But with Tyler, there is artistic intent behind it.
And with DJ Khalid, he's just trying to make the biggest grandiose song possible.
And to me, Earthquake is a perfect existence.
of an artist seeing what makes Charlie Wilson special, seeing what makes Playboy Cardi special, and then seeing what he can add to the mix.
And you get this moment of just pure fucking alchemy. And I know earthquake can feel like the basic pick, but I don't ever want. I always want to reward artists for doing something that seems simple. A good pop song is so good that people think it's easy to make because it has the
that feeling of like a nursery rhyme you've already heard a thousand times before.
And we've heard earthquakes so many times already.
But I still remember going back and listening to it to the first time I was like,
damn, Tyler made this.
Because it's just so, it's structurally, it's perfect.
Obviously, like, he's doing what he did on Flower Boy,
which is employing other more technically gifted singers to help him along.
Yeah.
But Charlie's not doing all of the heavy lifting.
Like Tyler is going for it
And I just also have to say
Playboy Cardi's verse
Is
a top 10 verse of the 21st century
Wait what? Really?
Is this a hot take? Justin, is this a hot take?
Yeah, it's a little bit of a hot take
Wait, really? The 21st century
Yes, we have about heroes
I don't get bovado, get it like
barely saying words
Yeah.
Because here's, all right, can I break it down?
Sure.
Yeah.
Why Playboy Cardi's verse on this is so masterful.
Okay.
Because we get to a point with rap where you feel like you've heard everything.
And what ends up happening is like, hey, you know, the mumble rap, sound cloud generation or whatever.
But what that moniker does is it strips away how genius a verse like this is.
which is it is
incoherent
on purpose
where
it's not about
what Playboy Cardi is saying
it is about how he is saying it
it is just like the most
it's a pure distillation of what
makes hip hop
one of the greatest art forms
of modern music
which is like you are using rhyme
and how it hits your ear
to make you feel something
and because it's like post-lirical,
it is the height of absurdist art to me.
This is the, and I think that's why Tyler
had been wanting to work with Playboy Cardi.
When you hear Playboy Cardi, you were just like,
oh, it sounds so dumb and easy,
but you try to do it.
Right.
You try to rap like this.
And you're going to sound like a fucking idiot.
You're like the squawks and the baby murmurs or whatever.
And it takes away from the gym.
genius of him like, oh, I got body rose is like quite literally one of the most cliche
fucking opening bars out. There are so many rappers who have rapped about Derek Rose before,
but the way he says it and it hits your ear, like, pop, what? It's just, yes, I think this is one of the
greatest verses of the 21st century because it is an artist kind of getting to me what was
like at that point the final frontier of rap. We are so pegged.
lyrics at this point.
I'm just going to make you feel what are essentially like,
there are words of this,
but like,
they're secondary.
They're secondary.
Or maybe third dairy or what about it?
Well, what I love about Earthquake is that it is Tyler's biggest song.
And where like a song like See You Again is huge and it's,
you know,
idiosyncratic like we talked about last episode.
Earthquake is really weird.
So weird.
For a hit song, for a song,
for a song is, I think it has like two billion streams
on Spotify or something.
Like for a song this big,
it's just weird.
Like there's not really,
Tyler doesn't have a rap verse on it.
He's singing in a voice.
I mean,
I think what ends up on the record are his scratch vocals that he was,
he was trying to get Justin Bieber this song.
He was trying to get Rihanna this song.
Yeah.
Both rejected it.
And so what we hear,
I think is what he said is the,
just the rough draft version of him just trying to like get the melody off.
But there's something special about that unrefined, not thinking people will ever hear this.
So it may be something more naturally came out where he wasn't really like trying that hard, quote unquote.
But you can tell that it's also like really good writing for as few lyrics as it does have.
And you can tell he was trying to write a quote unquote pop song because the lyrics are really like tight.
Because you make my earthquake, riding around.
You'll love to be shaking me up.
So earthquake and shaking.
it's making my heartbreak,
also tying this motif
of shaking an earthquake.
And then even the post-chorus
where it's just don't leave,
it's my fault,
fault playing on fault lines.
Where it's like,
it's all very simple,
but you know,
this is what pop music does all the time
where it's like,
the lyrics are usually pretty damn good
in terms of like,
staying consistent with a relatively simple idea,
but just hitting it perfectly and consistently.
But even that,
talking about the fault line,
like,
what is the,
the don't leave is my fall.
Oh yeah, yeah. Oh, yeah.
That just that jagged.
Like when you see an earthquake and it splits the asphalt.
And it just, it's like little stuff like that is just so.
But to make a song called earthquake, but once again, to make it this tender and this
delicate, just shows you just like the high and low, the soft and the heart of the record.
And as someone who's a fan of pop music like Justin Bieber or Rihanna,
The reason why this would not have been a hit if he had given it to someone like Justin Bieber is that Justin Bieber is a great record that he dropped last year.
But Justin Bieber is a very linear artist.
He can be weird.
And he's talented in his own way.
But for Earthquake to work and to be sold as a record, it can't be a linear record.
It can't just be even Tyler singing because it's just like a rough scratch vocal.
Like there are certain songs that sound like the artist is singing a karaoke version of a song that already exists.
Right.
Where it's like they're not hitting every single note.
They're straining a little bit.
But that's that weird texture and that weird part of the song is what makes it scanned out from other pop songs.
If it's just Rihanna or Justin Bieber, because they're better singers than Tyler, they don't have to think about it asshole.
But for this to work, this has to be a world.
This has to be Igor's world.
It has to be Tyler's world.
And the reason like, oh, people are like, of course you're a big earthquake.
But I'm like, don't, just because something is popular does not mean that it's easy.
And this is not an easy record to land.
I wouldn't be surprised if this was one of the more difficult records to fully, fully get to where it is.
Yeah.
I mean, it reminds me of like Nirvana, to be honest, like in terms of like,
To your point, like smells like Teen Spirit, one of the biggest songs ever, is fundamentally a pop song.
Yes.
It's a kind of a set like technically sound pop song, but is a pop song that only Nirvana could have sold.
Yes.
And so if you gave those same elements, the same melodies, like you can recognize the catchiness of smells like teen spirits chorus.
We can all recognize that.
It doesn't sound pop in the same way that earthquake to me doesn't sound.
pop and to your point, like it probably wouldn't have worked.
That's why I wouldn't have worked in a Bieber or Rihanna.
Because it's fundamentally sound, but in a way that is idiosyncratic.
And so, like, if you strip this song to the core, it's still going to work on a piano
and just, you know, plain melody in the same way if you strip smells like Teen Spirit down
to its core.
So why, like, pop songs, the most fundamentally sound pop songs can always be played on
an acoustic guitar and just sung.
Because the structure, the musical structure,
and the underpinning core progression and melody are just sound.
Earthquake has that.
But the production, the vocal timbers, the features, all of these things are what makes it unique.
And so it just strikes that perfect balance of like, we've never heard anything like this before,
but it has enough familiarity in the soundness of it being pop structure that we accept it.
If that makes sense.
It can be accepted by like my mom, you know.
Tyler, I think, described the record at one point as being, like, as influenced by, like, push a T as, like, Stevie Wonder.
And earthquake is, like, a perfect example of that.
People are always surprised that Pusha T wrote the, blah, blah, pa, blah, I'm loving it.
But you're like, there's a reason why Kanye wants to work with Pusha T or Farrell wants to work with Pusha T.
Where even though Pusha T has a distinct rapping voice, when you listen to Clips Records, you're like, no, this is a.
master of song structure.
Yeah.
And,
Earthquake is a moment
where I'm like,
oh, no,
Tyler becomes,
he goes where push it
D doesn't want to go,
where it's like,
oh, no, I'm going to be
Stevie and I'm going to be
pushing Tee.
I have the ability to wrap,
but I don't need to.
I can just show you that I've mastered
song structure.
I know how to make a pop song.
It's also like producer,
him being doing the connoe thing
where it's like,
yeah,
I'm going to grab a Cardi.
I'm the only person in the world
that probably hears Cardi on this,
but it's going to work.
It's going to work.
And it's going to be so,
strange but like beautiful and that's again that's just one of the many things that makes this
song really unique.
They don't let me up.
Justin,
Justin,
are you high on earthquake?
How are we feeling about Earthquake?
Yeah, I look,
you're going to be hard pressed for me to find a,
find a song on this album that I'm,
that I'm pretty high on.
That's actually a good exercise because if we were trying to critique Igor and find its
lowest moments,
where would we go?
Because I only have one song.
that I don't.
I wouldn't say I dislike it,
but it's the one song I'm like,
I kind of don't want to hear this right now.
And that's Puppet,
which I know a lot of people love Puppet,
so I might be alone in this.
But that's the only moment on the album for me personally
that I would ever,
ever even think about reaching for the skip.
I don't,
I'm with you on Puppet.
A Boy is a Gunn is in my favorite record.
Oh, really?
I thought you would like that record.
Because it's more traditional.
No?
Don't make that face.
That is, that, I like Tyler singing on this when he does the,
that when he tries to do the falsetto, I'm like, all right, nigga, call for a.
I'm not doing this.
Justin, do you have any low moments on the album?
Low moments.
You know, to your point, puppet is something that I feel like when I'm not listening to the record.
I'm like, oh, I really like puppet.
And then when it gets there, it's like, it doesn't quite.
live up to what's around it.
Yeah.
I don't know, man.
It's kind of perfect.
This is the rare album where even if you don't like a song,
and this is why short albums are great,
if you can pull them off,
taking a song off this album wouldn't make it better.
You might not like the song.
But it's just like there's certain,
like Tyler records in the past where it's like,
no, you could have taken this off the record and it would have been better.
Like, I'm not going to be an asshole on this album on this episode
because I'm just like, even if a boy is a gun is not my favorite song, if you take it off the
record, it's taking away something.
Yeah.
And that speaks to how well intentioned this is as a project.
Yeah, 12 songs, one of being, so really 11 songs, 39 minutes, 46 seconds, like kind of,
perfect.
We need more albums like this, let me just say.
We need more movies.
We need more TV shows that are like this.
Make your statement.
Get in, get out.
don't be cute about it.
Okay.
And yet Charles famously thinks illmatic is pretty mid.
All right.
Don't do that to me.
It's just not for me.
Elmatic is just not for me.
It's a great record.
It's a classic record.
You can get mad at me.
What do you want?
This is what I love about you because you have the guts to say something like that.
Here's the thing.
And you know,
I'm a serious shit.
Because I got him started, Justin.
I was on the midnight boys, right?
And we're talking about Supergirl flopping.
like Charles, see, you're smiling over there.
Did it all?
Why are you so happy?
Did it all?
And I'm like, y'all don't really want my real opinion.
Because if you want my real opinion, I'm like, dog, I like what I like.
A, I'm not afraid to say it.
B, shit, like Tyler the Creator, be talking shit just because he, Richard got changed.
Y'all let him do it.
I am not rich and I don't got changed.
But shit, shit, too.
All right.
So you're out of nominations.
This is my final, right?
I already know where you're going.
Say it then.
New Magic One.
Yeah.
I don't know.
Passage of your car.
It's going to be dead.
I just got a magic wand.
Tyler, okay, so Tyler did his own album bracket after Igor.
So it doesn't count call me if you get lost or anything after that.
New Magic Wand was his last song standing.
This is a song that I tried this go around.
I'm like, yo, this is a fan favorite, bro.
you're going to listen to this song until you get it till you understand and i'm like couldn't get
there that's okay so this is like really because this would be a song that i think you would like
to me this is in the darker more aggressive minor key crunchy sound that you've traditionally
picked on this exercise so far i don't like what is it about it that doesn't really work for you
if you can explain it it it reminds you it
me of another song that I like more,
uh,
send it up off Yeezus.
Okay.
Where to me,
new magic wand,
like I get what like listening to it this time.
I'm like,
oh no,
no,
no, no.
I get why people love this song.
If you see Tyler Live,
that's the thing.
Molluckers are just going to,
it is,
it is him taking that mosh pit energy that he,
that was very much part of his early career and just perfecting it into pure
pop magic.
Yeah.
I just think that the song doesn't go far enough.
I think like in terms of like that grungy in your fucking face, disgusting feeling.
Like there's something about it where I'm like, oh, this is like the like the palatable version.
Like this is the this is the version of like that crunchy shit where you're just like.
You want so you just wanted to go.
I want to go even harder.
Well, if you saw it live, I'll just say it goes it gets there for sure.
Well, that's one of the interesting things about the song to me.
why I like it is because if you heard this
Sometimes you gotta close the door to open a window.
Like the predictable thing would be to come in super aggressive,
but Tyler doesn't do that.
He does what he does on this album a lot and he comes in so understated.
More melodic than you would ever think.
I will say I love his, this right here.
This part.
Dude.
But even before that,
His delivery, his voice sounds so good on this record.
And what I love about it, because what you don't like about is what kind of why I love it is that he, the song really only reaches its highest high one time and it's at the very end.
And so where you think he would go, there's a spot in the song where you think he would go really high.
And what he does is the opposite.
He does.
He goes lower.
And so structurally, it's really interesting because where it should peak, he drops into this bridge.
and he totally transforms the song
new chord progression
same drum beat
but what this allows him to do
is build the song back up
and so when you get to this moment
this is where the real peak
comes two minutes and 20 seconds
into the song
all those synths in the background
dude
I look I fucking love this song
Here's the thing.
The more we talk about it, the more I am like, damn, this is a banger.
This is a banger.
You need to experience it live.
You will never get me to go to a career concert.
Even if I took you together, that would be so fun.
Oh, if we were going on like, honestly, that sounds like a great comedy.
We should go to Camp Flognaw together.
Hell no.
Hell no, bro.
I'm 33.
I'm 10 years older than you, dude.
No.
Fuck, no.
But honestly, that, that would be.
a great comedy. You would not just spend the whole day together again. Okay, let me just shout
out a couple more things I like about New Magic One. I love the theme. New Magic One being this
play on a Photoshop, make this girl disappear. So this guy, this, this girl that's in the picture
with this other guy is also a gun, which is revealed on the next song, a boy is a gun. So it's
essentially this murder mystery fantasy that Igor is having when he just wants this boy to
himself and wants this girl out of the picture. So structurally, thematically, conceptually,
really works perfectly placed in the track listing. I mean, I just think I just loved the musicality
of it all, like the bridge that we, that please don't leave me. And then it's stacking with like
magic, like magic. And then the woman coming in, you can make me leave. Like all these layers,
like really coming to a head about a minute into the track. I already kind of outline the structure
of it. I just think it's so unique in its catalog. There's not really like a chorus or anything.
It's kind of just one piece that kind of continually evolves, almost like through composed
and ends on a super big climax that I cannot take the live version of it out of my head.
So maybe that's part of the reason why I love this song so much is that when you see that last
climax that I pointed out live, oh my God. There's, I've never, I vividly remember
experiencing that on the
Call Me If You Get Lost
Tour. Because the Igor tour he did
in smaller theater still.
Call Me If You Get Lost was his first arena tour.
Yeah.
And you got that full sound system
for the first time and hearing that outro
on the full sound system.
It was the last song he played too.
And it was just one of the most cathartic,
visceral experiences I've had at a live show.
Is this a Dirty Mac anthem?
I feel like Tyler the creator makes a lot of dirty Mac in anthems.
He always wants somebody else
his partner. Every single time, I'm like,
Nicky, dog, go fight. You're tired of creator. Go find somebody else.
We always raise songs about thirsting after somebody who take him, bro. Like,
dog, we don't do that. I mean, I can't talk. But.
All right. That's another podcast. That's another culture of exchange, I think. Okay.
But that's my last nomination. Let me just shout out some honorable mentions.
Honorable mentions, we already listened like three, fours.
the album.
Igor's theme was really close for me nominate.
What?
In this exercise, it's hard.
That's what I was going to say.
I love it.
It's a perfect album opener, but in this exercise, I don't think it could get far.
I think was on my shortlist.
Earthquick is on my short list.
I love running out of time.
Boy, as a gun was on my short list.
I love what's good.
It's the same kind of energy as New Magic Wand.
Not as popular, but I like what's good more than I like New Magic Wand.
I can see that.
I can see that.
But that's like half the album.
I literally didn't shout out like two songs.
So actually just one song.
This album's perfect.
Okay.
Are we ready for the last song standing?
Yo, let's do it because this is going to be, this is going to be interesting.
We got to be strategic here, I think.
We can't, we can't fuck this up.
So we're going to now select our final song, our last song standing from Igor.
That's going to be advanced to the finale.
In that finale will be a Royal Rumble.
All the songs will duke it out until we've named the last song standing,
Tyler the creator's best song.
You won the quiz so you get first pick.
I don't think we're going.
Well, actually, maybe not assume.
Where are you going?
Do you have an obvious winner here or be strategic.
I'm just telling you, we got to get, we got to get the right songs on the board.
All right.
So it's not going to be, I think.
I think in my heart is what I like just like because I love dancing.
Yeah.
I love that song, but I can't see it getting far.
I can't see it getting far.
So it's between earthquake and gone, gone, thank you.
To me, gone, gone, thank you just needs to be there.
But it was our only song that overlaps.
So are you passionate about earthquake getting far?
Because I'm going to tell you, I'm not picking earthquake.
So what, if we both know that gone, gone, thank you is going, like one of us is going to pick it.
What would you, what would your song that?
Well, this is, this is your bet that you need to make.
because you nominated
So essentially you can force me
into picking Gone Gone Thank you
by picking Earthquake
or you can pick Gon Gonkhan think
New Magic Wan
Are we still friends?
Are we still friends?
I'll just tell you
probably doesn't really have a shot.
So yours is in between
New Magic Wan and
Gone Gone.
And yours is between Earthquake and GoneGone.
So this is where the strategy comes in.
And we also might
think about Justin's. We do have a coach's challenge. There is just in terms of just like,
I'm no longer a music writer because I podcast five times a week. But if you will make a tie of
the creator list, earthquake has to go on. It is just, it's a record where we won't talk about
how competitive. I think it could be very, very competitive. And I think for just the enjoyment of
the season, you got to put earthquake there. So you got an earthquake. And I know,
new magic wand is a fan favorite
but gong
gone
man fuck yeah
I'm a
wait just a kid pick
earthquake
Justin I will
ask me this
because also
music editor
earthquake has to be
like it's like
people aren't going to look at this shit
and be like guys what happened
that's why you got to pick it
but I want gong gone
I can't promise what I'm going to do
uh interesting
I like this.
Yeah, fuck yeah.
I'm picking Gone Gone.
I don't care.
You just nailed your coffin, man.
I'm picking Gone Gone Gone.
Earthquake is on your back.
It's a depending on you.
Here's the thing.
I'm gonna go with my heart.
Like, fuck you.
No, because I see all the songs that I have.
Singles, single, single, singles.
Nah, I got to go with, like, I got to show people that it's like,
this is the moment for me where Tyler, like, before this,
I like Tyler's rapping.
Tyler was it, I didn't need to get.
get to like call me if you get lost and be like oh tyler got bars i'm like motherfucker have y'all
heard french have y'all heard yonkers have you heard like this figure can rap but gone gone thank you to
me is when he finally perfects the thing that i've been waiting for which is this like damn a lot of
your more emotional songs they have that west anderson thing about them yeah they're just too
they're just like it's just like one spoonful too much of sugar and this was the perfect cup of coffee
have to go with con gone thank you.
Yeah.
Okay.
You're,
you're,
I had a strategy and you've ruined my strategy.
I know I did.
I know I did.
Okay.
So it's new magic one or,
or I mean,
I could,
I could pick earthquake,
but I think new magic wand needs to go.
So I'm picking new magic wand.
If I can't pick new magic wand.
And Justin,
this is going to,
now interesting conversation for you.
I feel like.
Ah.
Because I mean, it's, so I guess this calls into question the purpose of the coaches challenge.
Is the coach's challenge to get in a song that I really, like, feel strongly about it to basically be like the referee.
The editorial.
Yeah.
But also, we're not doing a fan vote this year.
So like, you're also part of you is speaking for the fan.
Yeah.
And I kind of feel like my, my hands being forced here a little bit, which I don't feel like as the referee.
that should be the case.
Well, to be fair, I was going to,
if it played out like I was planning,
I was hoping you'd pick Earthquick, I was going to pick
New Magic One, and I think you probably
would have been happy to choose Gone Gone.
I would have been, I mean, Gone, and
thank you, is my
top two, three, Tyler,
the creator song for me, maybe number one.
It's,
to me, that's the song
off the album, this is the one that should go the furthest.
If I were picking from me,
I might go with something else
like I think
or
I really like I think
a couple of other songs
but
staying true to the purpose
of the role being the referee
speaking for the fans
making sure you guys don't fuck up
this is very
befitting of your managerial role
I know I'm going to
use the coaches challenge
today.
We need some sound effect.
But Kevin,
put some sound effect in there
like a coach's whistle or something.
Coach's challenge is going to Earthquake.
Hell yeah.
I think that's the right choice.
Although I'm a little bit bitter
that you got to pick con gone.
No,
because here's a thing.
I was trying to gift it to Justin.
You have been on me, bro.
You were like, look at your list.
It's so basic.
Blah, blah, blah.
And I had to tell you, I'm like, no, dog.
I like other Tyler songs.
It's just this is the moment where he finally.
I'm like, all right, shit, you got one.
bro.
I got to point out, though, I only get one coach's challenge for the season.
Yeah.
Now, I mean, look, if something really gets fucked up, like, we're going to have to sit here
and have a conversation.
Yeah.
But that means that you guys are on your own.
Yeah, that's true.
If you guys do something really silly for the rest of the season, like, I'm not, I can't
clean it up.
I will tell you, when we get to, like, the features and shit, there's one song that he does
that I, that, like, I'm like, bro, I'm trying to get this as far as possible.
there's one song that keeps coming up in the comments of now that we're rolling out the episodes
that is a B-side.
I don't want to say it yet, but it is in serious content.
By just the amount of comments that really surprised me, there is one song that is a B-side
that has maybe more votes than I've seen so far.
It's not on.
Really?
Yeah.
So I think that episode is going to be an important one.
Okay, so next up we got, call me if you get lost.
You like that album?
Yeah.
Okay.
Love that album.
Once again, like, I feel like everybody who's like, yo,
like, here's the thing.
Tyler started to wrap it over other people's beats.
I mean, he had been doing that since on future, but he took a break and then like.
Yeah.
So it took that for people to be like, oh my gosh, Tyler's at the pop out.
I'm like, Tyler's a good rapper.
Tyler knows he's a good rapper.
I like, that was just the record where I was just like, okay, we can finally enjoy this.
Earthquake, that's a good.
Earthquake at the pop out, getting.
Do you remember the response that it got from the crowd?
He got the loudest pop at the pop out with Earthquake, which is reaffirming the coach's challenge in my head because you could tell in that moment how big that song is, how beloved that song is.
I don't think the distance between in terms of popularity, like obviously now it's different.
Kendrick is here.
It's not like Tyler is here.
Yeah.
Tyler is a here of Kendrick.
Yeah.
It is just like, if I'm being honest, Kendrick is more of a traditional archetype of rap where it's.
like the fact that Tyler is almost as popular.
It's pretty, yeah.
Or I'd say this.
I think culturally Tyler might be just as popular if you take in the totality of
odd future, the camp flognaw, the TV shows and everything.
I just think musically,
Kendrick is like a little bit over, but like at the pop out, it was a moment where I was
like.
Well, Kendrick can make a Luther.
And that's the difference.
You know, that's really what it is.
Yes.
But I don't, but here's the thing.
I don't know if like.
I think Tyler wants to make a Luther.
And he can.
He just doesn't want to do it for himself.
Like I think like when he's making a pop song, he just can't help himself.
He'd be like, what if it was just a little weird?
And Kendrick's like, hey, yo, I got kids to feed.
Here's one for y'all.
All right.
We'll see next time.
All right.
All right.
We are back.
Dog, we have been, I would say that L-DLS boys have been.
The Mindful Boys on cultural exchanges.
We're growing, I'm growing up, you know, you're on your own journey.
Yeah.
I, for this, uh, coach's challenge gave you an anime film on Netflix.
100 meters.
Tell me, what'd you think?
You are two for two on the cultural exchange so far.
Really?
Yeah, this was great.
That's so good.
And I love, so this is my first anime I saw that was like an, I guess, adult anime out of
there's categories for these things.
But I've been watching Jibli,
which is more children oriented.
This is very much,
I guess I could show this to my daughters,
but like it's a little more mature
and its themes, I would say.
Yeah.
And so experiencing that side of anime for the first time
was really cool.
Because there's moments of it where you kind of forget
it's an anime in terms of like.
Because they're using an animation technology
called rotoscoping, which I usually don't like.
You can like,
what would you probably seem like rotoscoping
and stuff like a,
scanner darkly if you remember.
Oh, yeah, yeah.
But yeah, for those that don't know, this is basically the story of like two childhood
friends who run track and that basically one of them is kind of born, I would say,
with kind of an innate talent.
Yeah.
And one of them has to struggle.
And it kind of in a very interesting way, you think the story is going.
You think you have where the story is going and it definitely ping pong.
Yeah.
Thematically, it's just like, I think you mentioned it earlier as being a little more,
not something you see in like American culture as much but like I really like the philosophical
kind of underpinning of it where it was like take almost like the privilege of taking a talent
for granted versus someone trying to earn what the other person has and you're really kind
of stuck between yeah what is is it is it less about the the thing itself which in this
case is running really fast or is it about you know the work to get there like what
is the actual, what's the value? Because you have this super talented, naturally born fast runner
who doesn't see the value in his own talent. And then it's juxtaposed with someone that
wants everything that that guy naturally just has. And you don't know which one is like truly
valuable. You know what I mean? So just like, just the premise of it was super interesting.
And then to see it play out. Yeah. And like it taking the narrative twists and I don't know.
There's also an older gentleman who's also who is like, this is going to be one of his last races.
And he's always kind of been like the second or third guy to someone who was just a generational talent.
So you have these different generations who are all basically discussing not only what does it mean because there's an art to running.
So it's like, why do you run?
Why do you compete?
Do you want to compete because you want to be number one?
Do you want to compete because you want to be faster than the next guy?
Do you want to run because you want to beat your own personal goal?
Yeah.
And like that's what I love about it, where to me a lot of sports in the American imagination isn't often as interested in.
I'm like to compete.
Everybody's not competing for the same thing.
If you take basketball, some people do want to win like a finals trophy.
They want to win finals MPP or they want to do this or that.
But some people are just in a competition with themselves.
Right.
Or they're in a competition with a person next.
to them or a competition with someone on the bench.
And it's like...
Or their past.
Or they're past.
What are they running from?
What are they running to?
And to me, that is what's so interesting.
There's another, there's another foundational kind of like sports manga called ping pong.
I've heard about that one.
That is exactly, like has a very, very similar type of trajectory between being born with talent,
taking it for granted and what you need to do to reclaim that.
and someone who was looking at someone born with the talent and is like, I'm going to need to work 10 times harder to get there.
So it's a different level of focus and appreciation, but also what do you lose in having those blinders on?
Yeah.
And like I didn't realize it until talking to you right now, but why I think it's so fitting to put on a Tyler season is to me like Tyler's trajectory as an art.
artist is kind of that where it's like someone slowly but surely running their race.
Yeah.
And there were bigger artists than him at every single turn.
Yeah.
But him just like having this focus of like, all right, Justin Bieber, Rian,
is not going to take my record.
Fine.
I'm going to sing it.
Yeah.
Oh, fine.
You guys don't think I can rap.
All right.
I got DJ drama.
I'm going to show you.
I can do my own ginks of girls and slowly but surely becoming the artist that he wants
to become.
Yeah.
Beautiful.
Okay.
Okay.
So I'm going to do more extra credit though because I'm like,
I'm like fully bought into the anime world.
So I know you're not supposed to give me like a cultural exchange this time.
It's my turn to give you something.
But if you're just,
give me a short list of maybe a couple of films I want to check out from now until the next episode.
Oh, man.
You're putting me.
Do you have a favorite of all time?
Are you going to or.
I do.
Like,
if I was to give you one that is like,
now this one would be wonky.
Because I just watched it this year.
This is like,
to me,
like it's a foundation.
piece and it's short
it's called Angels Egg
not a lot of dialogue
at all. It is pure
just like and it's like not a lot of story
to me it's like it's so I love
me I love films like that so
it's literally like it's like
a yeas where it's like
anime heads love it but if I was to
give it to anormy they would be like what the
fuck? Yeah what the fuck is this
so don't watch it with my daughters
I this is one that will give them right there
like I would not want to
Angel's hands.
Okay.
All right.
So I'm going to, I think this fits the theme of what we've been doing so far.
So I'm going to give you another book that I read multiple times when I was in my 20s.
It is by one of my favorite authors, Cormac McCarthy.
Okay.
It's a, essentially, it's a play, actually.
It's called The Sunset Limited.
It's very short.
You could read it in one or two sittings because it's supposed to be an hour-long play.
And it's just dialogue.
And it takes place in just one room.
So the premise of the story.
is, Justin, are you familiar with the Sunset Limited or Cormac McCarthy at all?
I'm familiar with Cormac McCarthy. I've never read the Sunset Limit.
Okay. So the premise is a white intellectual attempts to kill himself by jumping into an oncoming
subway train, the Sunset Limited. And a black former prisoner saves his life. Yeah.
And the conversation, the play is a conversation between them in this black man's apartment.
And I don't want to tell you anything more than that.
But essentially, let me just leave it there.
Because essentially each of the two characters are representing something that I think.
And the conversation that they had essentially with the black man trying to talk this white man into why life is worth living plays out.
out and ultimately comes to a interesting resolution, quote unquote. So I'll just leave it there.
Have you, have you familiar with this at all? No, but I'm super fucking, I'm super fucking excited.
They did make a, they did make an HBO version of it where Tommy Lee plays the white guy and
Samuel plays the black guy. Should I watch that after I read it? Or will it ruin it?
No, if you read it first, it's fine to watch it. Okay. The book is better. Obviously, obviously.
But it's, I mean, they're both great actors and the text is really rich.
So like, it's an interesting watch.
Oh, fucky year.
Let's fucking go.
All right, y'all.
Late.
