Fantasy Baseball Today - 04/04: "Are They Good?"; Trade Talk; Regulators (Fantasy Baseball Podcast)
Episode Date: April 4, 2019Beginning with big news on Jeremy Jeffress, Francisco Lindor and potential opportunities for Jose Martinez and Christian Walker. Then we ask "Are They Good?" for surprising studs at second base (7:23)..., shortstop (10:00), starting pitcher (11:24) and first base/outfield (18:45). We discuss Kike Hernandez, Yoan Moncada, Matt Boyd, Matt Shoemaker, Trey Mancini and so many more ... Bullpen news (25:00)! What's going on in the BOS, STL, PHI and MIN bullpens? Then it's time for Buy Low (31:55), Sell High (37:34) and players we're actually concerned about (41:30) ... Dropometer (50:00) for SPs like Nathan Eovaldi, Jon Lester and Robbie Ray and then the Fantasy Regulators are back (56:50)! ... Your emails at fantasybaseball@cbsi.com To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Welcome to the Fantasy Baseball Today podcast from CBS Sports.
Got a fantasy question?
Email Fantasy Baseball at CBSI.com.
Get ready to win your league.
Now here's Adam, Scott Heath and Chris.
Well, so far the early goings of the 2019 baseball and fantasy baseball season,
we've got a lot of great performances to players that we did not necessarily expect it from.
And that needs us to ask, are they good?
We will be answering those questions about several players today,
including top three second basemen in fantasy baseball so far.
They are not Jose Altovae or with Maryfield or Ozzy Albees or anyone like that.
Welcome to the Thursday show.
It is April 4th.
I am Adam Azer.
Scott White and Heath Cummings are here.
Good morning.
Scott White.
Good morning, Adam.
Good morning, Heath Cummings.
Adam, how are you doing?
Frasal.
Like, frazzled.
Kind of a hectic.
Yeah, I can tell.
Yeah.
I didn't have my coffee this morning,
and I don't like to talk to anybody when I don't have my coffee, you know?
I can relate to that completely.
Heath hasn't had his coffee, so he might be a little ornery today.
Scott and I don't drink coffee.
Way to steal his material out of it.
Good going.
Just trying to, you know, just try to poke the bear a little bit.
Okay, so before we get into Are They Good,
we got some big news.
First of all, if you're playing in Daily leagues or DFS or whatever,
San Diego, St. Louis, and Seattle, Chicago have been postponed.
Meanwhile, Jeremy Jeffers will begin a rehab assignment tomorrow,
so we will see what happens when he gets back.
Francisco Lindor is going to miss at least two more weeks with a sprained ankle.
Apparently his calf is fine, but two more weeks with a sprained ankle.
Heath, reaction on Francisco Lindor?
This is nothing new.
We thought, I think we heard earlier this week or last week, it was going to be three weeks.
So he's seemingly progressing fine.
It's nice to hear that at least the Indians don't think the ankle was related to the calf.
Hopefully it was not, and hopefully he's back in two weeks and fine.
Okay, we've got some injuries potentially opening up some opportunities for first baseman here.
Scott, Marcelo Ozuna will have an MRI on his side.
That's never good.
And Jake Lamb left with a quad strain, and he's going to have an MRI.
So Jose Martinez could play more.
Obviously, Christian Walker could play more.
What are your thoughts on those guys?
I'm moderately excited about Christian Walker,
who has put up big numbers in the miners the past few years.
He's 28 years old and has waited a long time for an opportunity
that he finally seems to have and seems to be seizing here in the early going.
I think a natural comparison is Jesus Aguilar,
who nobody was really putting much fantasy stock into at the start of last year,
and then an opportunity suddenly opened up for him,
and he becomes a must-start high in first baseman.
I don't, you know, it's too early to say Walker's going to become that,
but I would put him about on the Tyler White level of first baseman that need to be owned
and potentially somebody who's going to...
You know what it is.
What is that UFO in the background?
Is that your phone?
I haven't heard your phone at a while, so I got the...
vibrate.
Just put it up.
This is my sister.
This is my sister's texting style.
She doesn't, like, write a long text.
She'll send, like, rapid-fire text
before she gets to the end of a complete thought.
You have a vibrate mode on your phone, right?
Well, I just turn the volume down.
No, vibrate, not down.
Like, vibrate off.
Boop, boop, bo, bo, bo, bo.
Well, I wouldn't hear it if it was just vibrating.
You don't have to hear it.
The point.
I know.
I just turned it down, and you guys are saying that's not good enough.
Okay, so Christian Walker.
Well, who would you rather have, Walker or Jose Martinez?
I would rather have Walker because there's also Tyler O'Neill who figures to factor into the Cardinals' outfield mix.
And so, yeah, I don't, I don't think it's as likely Jose Martinez would be playing every day if this ends up being a big deal for Ozuna, which we don't even necessarily know that it is.
or Jake Lamb, I guess, for that matter.
Yeah, he's going on to the deal.
I think that's pretty safe to say in Lamscape.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, I guess so.
Or I.L., excuse me.
The I.L.
Okay, so would you guys, Heath, would you rather have,
or would either of you drop Ryan McMahon for Christian Walker?
I would not.
No.
Okay.
All right.
And then moving on, we have Williams All-Studio,
starting to play a little bit more maybe.
He's only started two of five games.
But he started at third base yesterday.
He's 63% owned.
Williams Astuio is catcher eligible.
63% on, as I mentioned.
He's six for nine.
No walks, no strikeouts.
No.
I guess, like, we'll just use Francisco Mejia.
That's the one that people keep...
Should I drop Francisco Mejia?
Would you drop him for Astudio?
Ah, I mean, they've started the same number of games so far, right?
I feel like Mejia is the higher upside play there.
And I mean, even the starting guy yesterday was at third base,
which eventually won't be an option for him when Miguel Sineau returns.
They're both guys who we want to see play more, right?
I think I'd rather have me here.
I think I'm going to go with us to do you.
Yeah.
I'm not sure that we've fully recognized what his upside is.
Or that we fully know what is up.
Yeah, what is it?
I mean, I know he's really interesting.
He never strikes out.
Pretty much never.
But how good of a hitter is he's kind of a singles hitter, isn't he?
I think he could be a doubles hitter for sure.
He may not have a ton of upside in Roto other than the fact that he might hit 3.30.
Right.
Which would be a pretty big boost from your catcher.
Yes, sir.
All right.
Thank you very much for your thoughts on the big news.
Also, one other news item.
I have 15 points in a 12-team Roto League.
15.
That's really bad.
Like 12's the minimum, right?
Yeah.
Second place has 49 points.
First place has 103 points.
I have 15 points.
That means I'm in last in almost every single category.
I feel better now.
Thank you.
That was like my coffee.
Unbelievable.
Every reliever I throw out there.
Just garbage.
Steve Sechek, three walks, three earned runs yesterday.
Mike Trout.
Can you hit a home run, Mike Trout?
Jose Altoe.
Can you hit more?
Alex Bregman, can you do something?
With terrible team.
Terrible team.
Can't do auctions on the air.
Those are good players, you name.
Yeah, I know, right?
I think things are looking out.
Already.
They're not going to be looking down.
I will finish with more than 15 fantasy points, I guarantee, or points rather, in that Roto League.
All right, here we go, guys.
Are they good?
Also, later in the show, Bilo, sell high, and players were actually worried about just one week into the season.
Are they good, the second base edition?
The top three second baseman right now in fantasy are Colton Wong won, Enrique Hernandez,
Kike Hernandez, two.
and Yoamonkata 3.
So are Colton Wong, Kike Hernandez, and Yoan Moncada good, Heath?
I don't believe Colton Wong is good.
He's had 2,300 plate appearances to show if he was good,
and so it's going to take more than 24 for me to believe that something's changed.
I think Enrique Hernandez is sneaky good.
He's not like top 12 second baseman good,
but I do think that he is sneaky good
and somebody that I want to start in a roto league.
for sure.
And then,
Yon Moncada
is probably
the one
that I'm most
excited about
just because
he has the best
pedigree.
He has the most
upside,
and he has been
just,
he ripped the cover
off the baseball
yesterday.
Not literally.
Yeah, and all year.
And Moncada
has not faced
lefties yet.
The White Sox
have the
second few
is the bats against
lefties.
He's one for one
with a home run
against lefties,
but that has been,
something that's held Moncada back, a 611 OPS in his career against Southpaws.
But so far, he's batting 4.50 with two home runs, three walks, three strikeouts.
That's great.
Kike Hernandez is batting 435 with three home runs, four walks, three strikeouts.
And Colton Wong, you know, a listener pointed out via email, I did not see this,
that after the All Star break, Scott, Colton Wong batted 317.
They only hit two home runs, but 13 walks, 17 strikeouts.
It wasn't playing every day.
but you know he's carrying that over.
So anyway, what do you think about these second basemen?
Are they good?
No, I mean, I need to see a lot more from Wong.
If we find out he did something, like you joined the Flyball Revolution,
which I haven't seen anything along those lines,
then obviously it opens the door for him to maybe add some power
that we thought was going to be there at the start of things
and just has never showed up.
But Moncada is the one who's showing the most.
You mentioned only three strikeouts and 20 bats.
He struck out in 25.
percent of his plate appearances this spring.
And that was kind of the range we always set
for him. With his batted ball profile,
if you could get that strikeout rate down to 25%,
that could be the precursor
to a breakout.
Still a small sample size, even if you include
spring training, but it's very
encouraging to see for a guy who
flashes when he makes contact,
high end ability.
Are you more likely to buy, sell, or hold,
Yoamonkata right now?
I would agree with that, yes.
Okay, let's do Are They Good?
The Shortstop Edition, Dansby Swanson and Marcus Simeon.
Swanson is only 26% owned.
He has two home runs and a double three walks, four strikeouts in five games.
Marcus Simeon, 62% own.
Right now he has a 932 OPS, and two previous seasons it was below 730.
So he's sitting up, but five walks, five strikeouts for Marcus Simeon so far this
season are Swanson and Simian good
Heath
Is Swanson okay? He got hurt last night right?
He didn't end up leaving the game
but his surgically repaired wrist he was
favoring it after a play on defense
said it felt fine in his last two of bat
I am a little bit excited
about both of these guys but it's only
relative to where we drafted them
or possibly picking them up to be a middle
infielder I don't think either of them is going to be
an actual difference maker
Who would you rather have Swanson or Simian?
Simian.
Scott, are you seeing anything from these two short stops that make you think, I don't know, they could have new seasons?
Not anything new.
They're both guys who you're looking at if you lost Trey Turner right now, probably.
And I would trust with the one who's shown the most, which is Marcus Simeon, but that's not an especially high ceiling.
Okay, here's the starting pitcher edition of Are They Good?
Freddie Peralta, eight scoreless innings, 11 strikeouts.
He did not record one ground ball out in this game.
It was all strikeouts and flyouts.
Freddie Peralta, Carlos Rodon, and then the Mats, Matt Boyd and Matt Shoemaker.
All of these guys were just awesome yesterday.
There you see, if you're watching on video.
Hey, by the way, watch on video.
Paralta, Rodon, Boyd, and Shoemaker, Skoumaker.
got, are they good?
The one who has changed my opinion the most is the first of those two mats, Matt Boyd,
who seems to be taking the Robbie Ray route to success this year, where his best pitch
the slider, he's throwing it a ton, actually threw it nearly as often as his fastball in
this game.
26 swinging strikes.
I think that's the biggest number we've seen this year, just off going off memory, I feel
like it is in this outing.
That half of the slider was
responsible for half of them.
And this was against the Yankees. The first
was against the Blue Jays, okay.
Maybe it's hard to believe. But even
in their injury depleted state,
the Yankees have a lot of good hitters in that lineup.
I think, boy, this is must-own
and I wouldn't be looking to move him.
Shoemaker's shown a lot in the first
couple outings, too, but his second,
his first was against the Tigers, his second
against the Orioles. There's still that hanging over it.
and then who's the third one?
Oh, Peralta.
Paralta and Carlos Rodon.
And you said Boyd is the one who's changed your mind the most,
but does that mean you actually like him the most of this group?
Paralta Rodon.
Yeah, he's must own, and I wouldn't be looking to move him if I owned him.
I wouldn't be looking to sell high on Boyd.
I think he could be one of this year's biggest breakouts.
After two starts, that's my takeaway there.
Wow.
Okay.
I think I've added one or more of these pitchers in almost every league that I'm in.
I'm interested in all of them.
I don't disagree with anything.
anything Scott said about Matt Boyd
except for the Yankees having a lot of good
hitters in their lineup.
Aaron Judge?
There's one.
Robert Torres.
Luke Voight.
Gary Sanchez.
Gary Sanchez and Aaron Judge are definitely good hitters.
Okay, but here's the thing.
I knew this would come up.
And if you think about it, you got,
LeMayhew is a respectable hitter.
You know, it puts the bat on the ball.
You got Glaber Torres, Gary Sanchez,
Aaron, Judge, Luke Voight.
It may not be that great of a lineup,
but how many lineups in the American
League are actually better than that.
And how many lineups in the American League Central are better than that?
I would say maybe the Twins and that is it.
So it might not have been a great lineup, but the fact is, like, in the American League,
he's going to face a lot of bad lineups.
I do have to point one thing about Matt Boyd.
This is not just my opinion.
This was said over and over again in the quotes, in the postgame quotes, even the
managers were saying, the shadows were brutal yesterday.
And even his own manager, Ron Gardenhier said the shadows made it very easy, or
very difficult for hitters, especially with the slider.
So, but...
Yeah, with a slider, because it breaks about the point the slider comes through.
The one guy I'll say Carlos Rodon,
just because I can never quit Carlos Rodon,
and he's the guy I had ranked the highest of this group
at the start of the season.
He would still be the guy that I would have ranked the highest.
Two very encouraging starts against two very bad offenses.
He's got to hope he can keep it going.
It's Tampa Bay next week, Carlos Rodon.
Matt Boyd gets Cleveland next week.
So even if you just are thinking, I'll stream him for one start.
Cleveland next week,
for Boyd could be great.
And I think what's interesting is that we haven't really said
Freddie Peralta, and he's the most owned by far
on this list at 81%.
Yeah.
He's just weird. He's probably
the weird, well, maybe aside from Chris Sale,
he's probably the weirdest pitcher to assess right now
because he throws 80% fastballs.
And apparently it's a really good fastball.
He's had multiple starts like this already
in his major league career,
but there seems to be a lot of volatility there.
where when maybe it's not in peak form, there just isn't enough to fall back on.
That's kind of my, that's kind of how I'm assessing Peralta right now.
It's just a little too, a little too volatile for me.
Sure.
I mean, last year, Peralta, in his first four starts, he had a 159 ERA.
Three of those four starts, he allowed three or fewer hits and nowhere runs.
So he looked unbelievable.
And then his last 10 starts, he had a 565 ERA.
So that is part of Peralta's history.
It's a tough group here.
I guess, yeah.
How would you compare them to Trevor Richards,
who's also like 67% owned?
And he pitched a pretty well yesterday.
I might be ready to sneak void ahead of Richards.
I don't know.
I probably would put him behind the Marlins'
right now.
Yeah, Richards would be ahead of all these guys for me,
but he's the only Marlins pitcher who's ahead of all these guys.
Okay.
All of them?
You have all of them ahead of them?
No, I'm saying he's ahead of them.
No, I'm saying he's the only one that would be at the top of this list.
So you take Richards one and then like Rodon, two, Heath?
Yes.
And then who, Boyd or Shoemaker or Peralta?
So it sounds like you're higher on all of these guys than I am then.
Well, I think I'm probably lower on the Marlins, air quotes, stallions than every one of the podcast.
By the way, I'm not including Irania, to be clear.
I'm not including Irania, and I'm not really.
including Sandy Alcantara,
who is probably the one I like the second most.
Okay.
Would you guys rather have Lucas Gialito or Matt?
All of these guys.
Over Gialito?
And every Marlins pitcher and the rest of the Brewers pitchers.
How about Jordan Zimmerman?
Most of the White Sox pictures.
I would take Gialito over Shoemaker and Rodon.
So clearly, because he loves Rodon most of this group.
Clearly, it's a tangled mess here.
They're trying.
Exactly.
sort through.
It really is.
So as I'm looking at the most added list,
I think Eric Lauer
is one that if you own,
you can drop him for some of these more exciting
guys. He's 71% owned.
All of them.
Yep.
Domingo Armand?
57% owned?
No.
Keep him?
Boyd is kind of in the same range,
but otherwise, Hermon would top the group for me.
I think I have,
I haven't moved Boyd up yet enough,
But I'd rather have Boyd, I'd rather have Rodon.
I think I'd rather have Peralta than Hermon.
How about Corbyn Burns?
Burns tops all of them.
Yeah, I know I have Burns ahead of Peralta.
I'm not sure if I had a redone or not.
I know that we are talking about the same guys basically every show.
But I think it's the most important thing right now.
I think trying to figure out who the best of the bunch is
with these waiver-wire starting pitchers.
and I imagine that as we
a month, like three weeks a month from now,
the list will be different.
It's just guessing at this point.
But hopefully we'll be pretty accurate.
But I think that's the most important thing right now.
In fact, based on my inbox, based on my tweets,
that's what most people are asking right now.
So that was your starting pitcher edition of Are They Good?
Here's your first base slash outfield edition of Are They Good.
Ryan O'Hern is 88% owned quietly off to a nice start,
batting 333 with one home run.
They've only faced one lefty starter, and he did sit.
That was opening day.
Ryan O'Hern.
Trey Mancini, batting 417 with three home runs.
Randall Gritchick, 75% own.
Two ding-dongs yesterday for Randall Gritchick after he signed his overpay contract.
And Brandon Nimmo, 80% owned, he's off to a terrible start.
He's batting 100 with four walks, which is good, but 13 strikeouts, which is bad.
Are they good?
Ryan O'Hern, Trey Mancini, Rand.
Gritchick, Brandon Nimmo.
This is first base slash outfield.
Yes.
I take it.
Yes.
Okay.
I think the one, well, I think Nemo and Gritchick are the two that are the most relevant
in mixed leagues, which would have been my opinion coming in, too.
O'Hern's going to have playing time issues, but there's definitely power there, and I just
don't think Mancini's ceilings high enough, especially in that lineup, to factor outside
of.
Rotel leagues where you just have a ton of lineup spots you have to fill.
And Randall Gritchick's well worth his contract.
Well, he really isn't because he signed for more than like Severino.
He signed for more.
Who was the other guy who signed the same day?
Well, I think he's, it's a different situation because I think he may be a free agent after this year.
Okay.
Severino was under cheap control next year.
Because Grichick at his best has been like a two-win player and how valuable or how much do
those guys really make on the open market when they're basically corner outfielders.
It doesn't seem like much. So I wonder what kind of assumption the Blue Jays are making in terms of
salary escalation there. So Armand Marquez, the most surprising of the extension Paloosa guys
was actually yesterday, though, David Bodie. Yeah. Cubs signed a five-year deal.
Right. But Armand-Marquez, five years, 43 million for Marquez. Five-year-old.
is $52 million for Gritchick.
I mean, which contract do you like better?
It's an easy one.
Well, it's, they're, like Keith was saying, I mean,
I think in Marquez's case, they bought out some pre-arbitration years, so,
and obviously the early, like the first arbitration year, a guy doesn't make much money either.
Gritchick is just further along the service time ladder, so,
but I would expect them to be a little closer, I guess, than Grichick having that much of a,
advantage over
Marquez.
I'm getting close to dropping
branded Nimmo
but I don't really want to
it's just like
there are exciting players out there
should we be patient with Nimmo
or
or cut them loose?
Has he played against the left of yet?
I'm not sure that they faced one.
They faced at least one
because Ahmed Rosario let off
and he didn't,
Nimmo didn't start.
Oh okay well Nimmo also was a little
banged up for one game
and that may have been it.
This is actually something I wrote about yesterday.
I think it depends entirely on format.
If it's a three outfielder points league
and you're trying to stockpile your bench with starting pitcher
and there's so many options emerging right now
that you're having to make these really tough calls.
I mean, Nimmo, you drafted to be your third outfielder probably, right?
If you feel like there's a guy you can trust more
in that third outfield spot better,
you don't need to stick Brandon Nimmo on your bench.
mention the hopes that he becomes a better third outfielder at some point. There's always going to
be outfielders available in that format. I would say the same for Jesse Winkert, too, by the way.
As much as I like him, as much as I still think at some point this season, he could take off
and become a must-start player. I don't know when. My bench base is too precious right now to
devote a spot to him in that format. And deeper formats where the caliber of player you're looking at
on the waiver wire is much lower than fine. Dash the upside play. But I think,
particularly in points leagues where you're having,
there's just too many starting pitchers to roster.
You don't need a backup infielder on your bench who, you know,
you wouldn't feel comfortable starting at this point.
Right, but the problem with dropping Nimmo in a points league is that he does lead off,
and he's let off five out of six games, including they face two lefties.
I know he was hurt for one of the games.
I don't know if that's why he sat against one of the lefties,
but you're right, Heath Rosario led off in that game.
In the other lefty, the game against Patrick Corbyn, Nimmo let off.
He is such a good on-base guy, and he leads off.
He's actually tailor-made for points leads.
But look, he's the kind of guy that you drop now,
and if he's not like he's going to win the MVP.
So, you know, if he has a good season, whatever, I'm sure you can replace him.
But I want to be a little bit patient with him.
It's only one week.
It's only five games for him.
He's batting 100.
He does have four walks.
All right, we've got a lot more to get to.
Corey Kluber struggled.
Miles Michaelist struggled.
Buy low, sell high.
Players were concerned about.
Some more news and notes, by the way, Jesse Winker, Scott Shebler, and Matt Kemp.
They are one for 42 so far this season for the Cincinnati Reds.
That is not very good.
Let's take a quick break.
When we come back, we'll look at the bullpen, interesting bullpen developments in yesterday's game.
Ryan Brazier!
Hey, team name Tuesday on a Thursday, Ryan Brazier Crane.
Brazier Crane?
Like Frazier?
Okay.
Yeah, all right.
Yeah, I got a save.
I hated that show.
Really?
Yeah.
Drink some coffee, Heath.
It's a good show.
Brazier got a save.
Matt Barnes got Chris Davis out in the seventh and then pitched the eighth, and then Brasier came out of the ninth.
David Robertson struggled again.
People are freaking out about David Robertson.
The, looks like Alex Reyes got a save opportunity yesterday, and he coughed it up.
Blake Parker got a one-out save as Trevor May pitched five outs.
And I just want to talk about Jose Alvarado when we get a chance, because he came into the,
but my God, he's filthy.
So Heath, let's talk about actually David Robertson.
I think we should start with him.
What would you tell the David Robertson owner right now?
He's off to a very bad start.
Well, the good thing for him is Anthony Dominguez was bad as well.
I do not have any David Robertson this year, and it wasn't because I was afraid he was
going to be bad.
It was because of Gabe Kepler and how they were going to use their relievers.
And this makes me even more concerned about the way Robertson has started this season,
Because you've already have a manager that's prone to using his relievers in a variety of different ways.
And then Robertson's not asserting himself as the best reliever.
It could get really scary.
You're not dropping him, though, are you?
Not in a Roto league, for sure.
In a points league?
Are you picking up anybody else?
How about that?
In the Phillies bullpen?
I'm not picking up anybody else in the Phillies bullpen.
I would drop Robertson for one of the young exciting sports.
Okay, Scott, what is your take on the Red Sox and Cardinals bullpins?
Yeah, so I was under the assumption, I think, most of us were, that Matt Barnes was the closer after he got to save on the second day of the season.
He hadn't worked since.
That was his only appearance, which says something about the way the Red Sox season is gone.
But I think it was a tie game he entered.
So, like, the next time there was a high leverage situation.
they wanted to get him some work and he got four outs in this one.
I still think he's the preferred option here, but clearly,
Fraser's like a 1A for Alex Cora, and it may be,
it may end up being a split kind of like David Robertson and Sir Anthony Dominguez have,
which, you know, could be anywhere from like 75, 25, 25 to 6040, I think.
I'm a little concerned today as the barns owner, yes.
Okay, yeah, as I mentioned, I mean, he came in to get Chris Davis.
the clearly best hitter in the seventh.
Right.
But he didn't get saved.
Brazier did.
So I don't know that Jordan Hicks was available, Scott.
I didn't read that he wasn't.
But he pitched Sunday, and then he threw 32 pitches over two innings on Monday.
So do you think it was just another day off for Hicks?
Yeah, I think so.
I don't, I mean, because his last outing was great.
Two of his three outings have been great.
I don't know why they wouldn't have used him otherwise.
the guy who got the save here Dakota Hudson, obviously in the rotation right now.
So that was, I assume off days allowed for him to come into the bullpen in that scenario.
Yes.
But Alex Reyes is a threat to Jordan Hicks.
I mean, Jordan Hicks not only isn't a proven closer, he's not even really a proven high-end reliever.
So there are going to be times when his role is called into question.
And Alex Reyes could be one of those guys that calls it into question, Carlos Martinez, when he returns from the I.L.
well.
So there's, he's not a sure thing, Hicks.
Alex Reyes is 52% own.
He's not off to the best start.
I'm going to look up Carlos Martinez's ownership percentage.
76% own.
So that is someone that you could stash.
Another guy you could stash is Brandon Morrow.
He could be back in early May.
He's 54% own.
And nobody in the Cubs bullpen is doing anything to hold down that job.
Now we have like a month before Morrow is back.
Seish is a better picture than what he showed yesterday.
Strope is a better picture.
than what he's been showing.
But right now, the Cubs bullpen is an absolute mess,
and that's a good development for tomorrow.
Meanwhile, Blake Parker got a save.
He got a one-out save.
Trevor May got five outs.
He pitched the eighth, two outs in the ninth,
and then Blake Parker came in and got his second save of the season at Kansas City.
I did pick up Blake Parker.
I dropped Steve Seashek.
That was an easy call for me.
Would you guys drop David Robertson for Blake Parker?
No, and I'm still not certain.
I know that Parker has two saves now,
and Parker was the guy that I wanted the most of at the beginning of the year.
But this was a pretty clear situation of Blake Parker came in
because Alex Gordon was up with one out left.
I mean, he just came in to get the lefty.
And Taylor Rogers was unavailable,
who probably would have gotten the lefty if he was.
They feel comfortable if they have three relievers they can use in the ninth inning.
I don't believe they have a set closer.
They might at some point.
But they're all going to kind of take turns.
The only guy that really hasn't got to finish it yet, I guess, is Trevor Murray.
Yeah.
And then Jose Alvarado pitched in a tie game in the eighth inning at home,
whereas Diego Castilla pitched in the ninth.
But I just don't know that I realized how good Jose Alvarado is.
He threw a 99-mile-per-hour fastball that moved so much to Charlie Blackman.
He struck out the side, and he had a great year last year.
Guys really a – I mean, am I wrong?
Jose Alvarado is a stud.
I don't know that he's going to get every save.
He's good.
He's good, but the usage during this Rocky's series has been concerning
because there's two appearances in a row where he's worked the eighth
and Diego Castillo's worked the ninth.
Castillo didn't get a save in either of those chances,
but he did get a save earlier.
And it may be a lefty-righty-play-the-match-up scenario between those two.
I would still favor Alvarado because I think he's better,
but Castillo's pretty good himself.
He is.
Yeah, he is.
That's a good team, the very good bullpen.
And Castillo's only 15% own.
So Castillo or Parker, guys, real quick, we'll wrap up bullpen.
Castillo or Parker?
I would go Castillo.
It seems like there's fewer competitors there.
But in both bullpen situations, I would take the lefty.
Like, I would rank between those two bullpins.
I would rank them, Alvarado, Rogers.
Taylor Rogers.
Then Diego Castillo and Blake Parker.
Yeah, I think I'd take Parker over Castillo.
They'd have Alarado over all of them.
Okay.
All right, guys.
Let's talk trade here.
Bilo, sell high, and who are we concerned about after just one week?
Heath, I'm going to let you kick it off.
Who is your Bilo candidate for Thursday, April 4th, early in the season?
I'm going to go with Eddie Rosario, and it took me a long time to actually believe that Eddie Rosario was good.
Not great, but good.
And I think it took a lot of other people, not very long at all,
to decide he may not be good again.
So you look at his production earlier in the early in the year.
Yeah, he struck out too much, but it's a very small sample size.
He's walked a ton more than he normally does, too.
His bab-ip is just absolutely awful.
I think Rosario is going to be a fine third or fourth outfielder,
and I think you can almost get him for free right now.
Eddie Rosario, last year, oh, how come I, oh, because he missed some time.
He was 30th and I was going to say,
how come I don't have where he finished among outfielders?
He only played 138 games,
but the year before, 30th and points 23rd in Roto.
Scott, do you have a buy low candidate?
Yeah, I mean, the hard part about buying low this time of year
is having someone actually believe it's low.
It's a guy's expected outcome has actually changed.
And so I'm going to go with Miles Michaelis here.
who had another not-so-great start yesterday.
And because strikeouts aren't a big part of his repertoire,
when he's bad, it doesn't look like there's much that's redeemable there.
So the first start was awful.
The second start not-so-great with only two strikeouts.
I think there's a possibility maybe the Michaelis owner is thinking he purchased some fools gold here.
And you can try to make a play for him.
He still should pitch a lot of innings, be good at run prevention for a team that
is going to be in the playoff picture.
Yeah, so I think I might be one of those Michaelis owners,
and I don't own him.
But I might be one that you're talking about.
That would be a little concern that I purchased some fools gold.
If he doesn't strike out more batters,
I just don't see how he could repeat what he did last year.
And so far, he's got five strikeouts in 10 innings.
So that's...
I mean, there are three legs to that fifth triangle, right?
which helps estimate what an ERA could be.
Strikeouts gets the most attention,
and it contributes something in its own right in fantasy.
But the other two, limiting home runs, limiting walks.
Michaelis was elite at both last year.
So that's how it could happen,
and that's how I expect it to happen still.
But what was his FIP?
A couple not-so-great start.
His FIP?
It was, what, 328?
3-28.
Pretty good.
It's 283.
Yeah, it's very good.
All right. I don't know.
Just...
Okay. All right.
Hey, you know what's interesting?
The top three most traded players in CBS Sports Leagues are Chris Sale, Corey Klober, and Zach Granky.
So I don't know what the trades were.
Maybe they weren't really by lows.
But people are making trades involving Chris Sale, Corey Klober, and Zach Granky.
And you as an owner have to decide, are these good bylows or are these guys that are not going to have such a great season?
What are you willing to pay for them?
I have a feeling
Corey Klooper's start yesterday was just nothing.
He said his mechanics were off.
He was fine last time out,
but, you know, kind of a,
I'm guessing, a low strikeout rate.
He only struck out five and seven innings
in his first appearance.
Yeah, anyway, between Sale Kluber and Granky,
you know, do you think that they're all worth offering right now,
making offers four right now?
Okay, so Sail is pretty much the only ace level pitcher who has two bad starts now.
I mean, I guess we could argue whether yesterday's was really bad, but it's the first time he ever had one strikeout in four innings or more, and it was, you know, six inning.
So that's, it was bad.
It was bad.
Granky's had one good start.
Uber has.
I would definitely buy low on them.
Sale is a player you have to be concerned about.
I would be more likely to sell sale if I got another ace caliber pitcher in return.
I've dropped them to ninth in my rankings.
So that kind of shows you the range where I'm looking where, okay, yeah, sales upside may be higher,
but just to rid myself of the headache, if I'm still getting an ace in return, I'm willing to dump that off.
But, you know, somebody offered us Jamison Tyone straight up for Chris Sale on the podcast for the People League last year.
and that's, I mean, yesterday.
And that's, uh, that's too low.
I'm talking, you know, if I can get Trevor Bauer, Garrett Cole,
uh, Corey Klobber, somebody like that, then yes, I would be willing to move on from sale.
How about Kershaw?
How about Kersh.
How about Kersh.
How about who?
Kershaw?
No.
No.
He's got his own issues.
Heath, you want to weigh in quickly on sale Kluber, Granky?
Uh, yeah, I'd be trying to make an offer for all of them.
I think there, I don't think sales going to be a top two.
starting pitcher or maybe even a top five starting pitcher, but I think eventually he's
going to be very good again. I think Grinky's fine, and I don't really have any concerns over
Kluber's most recent start. So if you can get somebody to dump an ace like that for less than
ace value, do it. All right then, let's go to our sell high guys. Scott, who are we selling high on
this early in the season? I'm selling high on Josh Hater, again with the idea that you've got to
convince somebody he's really this good. We know Josh Hader's good. I mean, he was an outlaw.
among middle relievers last year.
He was drafted pretty much everywhere,
despite nobody having much hope for him to be a full-time closer,
when now there's hope for him to be a full-time closer.
All four of the Brewers save opportunities he's gotten,
and he's converted the last three in a traditional one-out, one-inning sense.
But Craig Counsel was so steadfast last year
in terms of having to keep Hader in that flexible,
multi-inning role that I still think that's what he wants.
And if Jeremy Jeffress, who's now beginning,
beginning a rehab assignment should be back soon.
If he's back to full health, I think counsel would be happy to move Hater back to the role
where we're used to seeing him, and Jeffers becomes the main closer.
So just because he's among the saves leaders now, there's a good chance a lot of people
are believing that Hater is just the guy, and if he is just the guy, they might pay top
two, three, closer value for him.
All right, Josh Hater.
Josh Hader has a zero ERA.
Can you guess what his FIPP is?
Zero.
Negative.4-7.
Well, it's not fair because FIP doesn't factor in balls that were actually hit out of the park
but saved by Lorenzo Cain.
Because he should have a run.
That's true.
So Scott is selling Josh Hater, and Heath, who's your sell high?
I'm going to go with Madison Bumgarner.
I've not seen enough from him yet to really.
believe that he's back. I know he has changed a little bit.
I just don't know that the approach he's changed to is going to be good enough once everybody else catches up.
And he's got that nice, sparkling, low ERA because of his stupid error and his Grand Slam not counting.
So if I can get top 25 starting pitcher value for Bumgarner, I'm gladly taking it.
Would you give him up for Zach Granky?
I would be thrilled to turn Madison Bumgarner into Zat Granky.
Okay. Madison Bumgarner.
Rilled.
Yeah, so far, Sparkling 1380 RA.
What's his FIP?
His FIP is, I would guess it's around 4.
And now that I've guessed, I can tell you, it is 3.62.
Very good, good job.
Real quick, Jeremy Jeffers is owned in 34% of leagues to follow up on what Scott was saying.
That is a guy that you should be stashing, and you should stash it before Brandon Morrow, for sure.
before Carlos Martinez probably
because Jeffers
could be coming back very soon.
We've got to take another quick break, our last
break of the show. Stick around when we
come back. We will talk about players we are actually
concerned about. Be right back.
Players were actually concerned about. Here we go.
I have a list. I didn't do any by-lows or sell highs, but I do
have a list of three guys that I am legitimately concerned
about, and then one guy that I'm going to ask you about.
But, you know, concerned at this point is like
I was concerned coming into the year, and they're off to bad starts, right?
Brian Dozier, two for 18, one walk, seven strikeouts.
Now it is important to note that he batted second yesterday with Trey Turner on the IL,
so that's nice for Dozier.
Jerks and ProFar is 5 for 36, and I was concerned about ProFar because he did so much of his damage
at home last year.
He had a 511 slugging percentage at home, 405 on the road,
and obviously the ballpark change is dramatic for him in a bad way.
And Miguel Cabrera is 3 for 25.
with three walks and nine strikeouts.
I'm wondering when fantasy owners are going to drop all three of these guys,
Brian Dozier, Jerks, and ProFar, and Miguel Cabrera.
Fellows, what do you think?
I'll start with you, Heath.
I would assume shortly we'll start seeing those ownership percentages go down.
Dozier is a hard one because he was so, so bad last year at the end
that he couldn't even play.
But he's also been really, really bad.
at the start of a season before and then turned back into a borderline star.
So, and second base is a terrible position.
If there's someone that you're excited about starting a second base, I have no problem
dropping him.
And then pro far is the other one that's really interesting because he has so much eligibility
at different positions.
But I don't, I don't see the enormous upside with him, so I don't really feel bad about
dropping him either.
There's no qualms about dropping McGee.
Biggie, okay.
Scott, you want to defend your man, Jirks and Provar?
Well, not exactly.
I mean, all three of these guys, you know, I'm not putting much stock into any performances right now.
Guys, I'm worried about it's not because of performance.
For the most part, I think if you're going to worry about performances, you pick three good candidates for it.
But I would definitely prefer to hold on to these three.
But at the same time, I think they're also perfect examples of in a shallower league
where you're looking to maximize two start options on your bench.
So obviously like a shallow head-to-head league,
if you have somebody else you're comfortable starting at the positions they're filling,
they might be your ticket to free up another roster spot with the kind of starts they're off to
and the level of concern surrounding each of them coming in.
ProFAR, I think, is the easiest to hold on to, especially if it's like a daily league
where you can take advantage of his quadruple eligibility,
but he's not in those shallower league.
He's not beyond dropping.
And I want to stress shallower league,
because obviously I would prefer to hang on to all of these players.
I would prefer to have a 60-man roster and have everybody I have, you know,
some kind of inkling about.
But obviously you can't do that.
The three guys we're talking about are Dozier, ProFar, and Miguel Cabrera.
The one I want to ask you about is Charlie Blackman.
Are you concerned about Charlie Blackman?
He hasn't played a home game yet, but he's batting 233.
I don't know if he has an extra base hit.
Let's say, yeah, he must.
Thanks for the graphics guys.
He's got the slugging percentage of 300.
So he probably has a double.
But the walk-to-strikeout ratio, I mean, no walk-seven strikeouts.
For a guy who, you know, getting older, get moved off of center field, you know,
are we worried about Charlie.
Yeah, this is one I'm not.
This is one I'm not worrying about.
Not even a little bit.
Okay, so Heath, who are we worried about right now?
I think somebody has to say Jesse Winker,
partially because he has done absolutely,
almost quite literally nothing so far this baseball season.
He certainly hasn't got a hit.
I think he has one walk, maybe two.
He's got three times as many strikeouts,
and the most important thing is not about the performance,
but the fact that he's already set out two games.
If he'd only set out one, I wouldn't feel that bad about it.
But it could be,
perfectly fine. He could still break out.
I'm not saying that there's not upside still left
there, but I'm certainly concerned.
All right, Jesse Winker. Scott,
how about you? Anyone that's concerning to you?
I think helping Winker's case
is that all Reds
outfielder's been terrible, so it's not like
he's really fallen behind in the pecking order.
But, yeah,
it's also a playing time case for me.
Somebody I'd be less comfortable
dropping than Winker actually in the
shallow league scenario. And that's
Max Muncie, who has
sat three games, I believe, for the Dodgers.
Yes, three.
And all but one left.
They face four lefties so far.
He sat against the other three.
So it looks like they're going strict lefty, righty with him,
despite hopes that maybe with fewer possibilities there,
they'd look at last year split and say,
okay, this guy needs to play every day.
So far, that's not happening.
And while I think his bat is impactful.
enough in like a roto lineup with the corner infield spot, all the extra hitter spots to fill.
I wouldn't really be anywhere close to dropping them there.
But it's at least starting to enter my mind in a head-to-head lineup context where you don't
have the corner infield spot.
And again, bench space is so critical.
Yeah, just to go back to the Reds real quick, Nick Senzel, boy, they must be so excited
for him to get healthy and come back because they could really use second base and outfield help for sure.
So I'm sorry, you were saying with Muncie, you would or you would not drop him?
But that would be a...
I wouldn't drop him anywhere yet.
No.
The upside, I think, is too high.
But if he is truly a platoon player all season long, he's going to have trouble factoring,
particularly in like a points league.
But the Roto League, I don't think there's ever a scenario where I'm going to be dropping them this year.
And in head-to-head categories league with the smaller lineups, probably not either.
But it's at least entering the thought because it doesn't look like he's an everyday player.
All right, guys, we're making some good progress today.
We have to get to the fantasy regulators a little bit later.
We have some regulating to do.
Your emails at Fantasy Baseball at CBSI.com.
Some more news and notes.
Troy Toulowitzky is likely head.
to the DL with a calf strain.
That is very surprising.
They lasted a week.
Tyler Wade replaced him in the Yankees lineup.
They called up or reportedly are calling up Thiro Estrada.
But I guess if you're in an AOL-only league,
Tyler Wade might play pretty regularly for them.
He's not very good.
DJ LeMay, who could battle higher in the order.
That would be nice.
Corey Dickerson has shoulder soreness.
AJ Minter's coming off the DL today.
Mike Voltenevich is making a rehab start today.
Steve Pierce is likely coming off the IL for the Red Sox, probably to start, I would assume, just against lefties for Pierce.
Is that right?
No platoon with Moreland?
Presumably.
Okay.
Let's see.
The Cubs signed David Bodie to a five-year $15 million deal.
Clayton Kershaw expected to make a rehab start today and then another next week, so he'll have two rehab starts before coming back.
Ben Zobris is 35 percent owned.
He's been leading off against right.
that might be relevant for some of you out there.
Byron Buxton did not start.
He pinched ran, though, and stole his first base of the season.
Jason Kipnis will begin a rehab assignment tomorrow.
And I read a crazy story about Ryan Brazier.
Maybe you knew about it.
It was published like over a week ago.
I was just looking into, you know, Red Soxclosure situation.
Google Ryan Brazier's name.
So there was a USA Today story.
He was, after the World Series, I don't know when, but he received a court order because his son,
his eight-year-old son had missed 21 days of school.
And he had to appear in court because of this.
Because during the playoffs and the World Series run,
he wanted his family to be there.
So his son missed all this school.
And I don't know if the school, the school board, whoever it was,
they got really pissed and they were threatening to expel Ryan Brazier's son.
So he had to appear in court.
That's a lot of days.
21 days in school.
But at the same time, like winning the World Series.
Sounds like they're going to look into homeschooling.
I think it's been resolved, but I thought that was such a crazy story.
That's weird.
Fun fact.
I miss so many days of school as a senior in high school that somebody said,
you better start showing up or you're not going to graduate.
So I started showing up.
Okay, let's talk about some players we might be ready to drop.
They're all owned in a ton of leagues, 84% or more.
In fact, three of them are owned in 95% or more?
Are you ready to drop them?
Nate Avaldi, Heath, go ahead and say yes.
On the dropometer, I would say he is at a 9.5,
but Scott is probably a better person to ask about this player than I am
because he actually wanted to draft him.
Okay, Nate Avaldi, Scott, you ready to drop him?
I mean, I might make it like a 6.5.
Basically, all of the pitchers we were talking about in the Are They Good segment
are ones I'd be willing to drop for him.
I'm not saying I absolutely would in the cases.
of like Carlos Rodan or Prudy Peralta, some of those I had on the lower end of that group.
But he's Avaldi's in that mix.
I mean, I feel like the ceiling's lower than basically all of those guys.
So I think, Scott, just to clarify what you said, you said those starting pitchers, are they good,
that you'd be willing to drop for Evaldi?
But I think you meant to say you'd drop Avaldi for them in most cases.
Yeah.
Yeah, you know, you get me out.
I got you.
I got you.
I got you.
All right, so you know what, let's just turn this into the dropometer.
Our second picture on the dropleter is Robert Ray.
Wild as always.
Five walks yesterday.
Five walks in his first start.
Robbie Ray Heath's dropometer.
Zero.
Ten.
We don't even need to discuss it.
Zero.
Ten.
Wow.
Geez.
No, like a six.
I come down closer to Heathside on this.
Oh, my God.
Robbie Ray, he's not even good.
What is with you guys?
You know that in his last 11 starts?
last year, Robbie Ray had a 265 ERA,
and he made three quality starts
because the guy can't throw six innings
because he throws 100 pitches in five innings.
No, I get it. I get what you're saying.
I have serious doubts he's going to be somebody
we're comfortable using on an every-star basis this year,
and yet I also recognize there's a possibility.
He cuts down on those walks just a little,
and he's a guy who's basically
like a poor man's Blake Snell
striking out a dozen every time out
and able to go those six innings
that are so valuable
in the fantasy baseball world.
But he doesn't go six innings.
He doesn't. He goes five.
I know he doesn't.
I know he doesn't,
but it wouldn't take much to get him there,
I'm saying.
And I feel like you can't pass up that upside
after two discouraging starts, you know?
And he also didn't go six innings
very many times in 2017
when he was like a top of,
15 starting pitcher.
And you would say he was like the luckiest pitcher that year.
No.
I think I did call him a bust going into the next year,
but that didn't mean he was anywhere.
All those are they good guys have been definitely better than Robbie Ray,
and they may be a little bit safer on a start-to-start basis.
None of them can touch Robbie Ray's upside.
If you're going to have pitchers on your bench hoping to get upside,
this is the pitcher you have on your bench.
John Lester, 97% owned, off to an okay start,
and was a top 30 starting pitcher last year.
Dropometer for Lester.
Two?
I'll say four.
If there's a month of starts like this,
then I think we can feel pretty comfortable.
He's not going to have this Cole Hamels-like resurgence
where the strikeout rate jumps back up,
and he ends up having a pretty good season.
He's looking more like Jake Garietta last year than Cole Hamels last year, I would say.
And in the end, Jake Garietta was a guy who was getting dropped in a lot of lead.
I mean, he was good against the Braves, right?
Yeah, it was a good.
Obviously, the outcome was good.
Ten swinging strikes, I think,
get as a better indication of what the stuff was than the seven strikeouts and six innings.
Yeah, I mean, Lester at this point might be kind of boring.
but boring's not always bad
so he's not a 10 on the dropometer
I think Keith said zero or two
I think he said two and Scott said four
and finally all right Heath
break the break the dropometer for Julio Taran
84%
I don't believe anyone actually owns him
84% of leagues have
have Julio Taran owed
I said that very well
10
Ted
Scott
I mean six I'm not
he's not somebody I'm protecting if something interesting is emerging on the waiver wire.
But I don't think there's a huge difference between him and Lester in terms of expected outcome.
Somewhat running out of time here, so I will sum up the rest of the show and save time for regulators.
Jacob de Grom is the most amazing person in baseball.
He also had 26 swinging strikes yesterday, and he homered.
Luis Castillo, for some reason the walks are up, seven walks and two starts.
that's unusual for him, but he had another very good start.
I still think he's a two-pitch guy.
I'd like to see him get that third one going there.
Joey Lucasey.
So we want to know going into this year,
can Joey Locacy Lucchese pitch six innings?
And you may have seen the line last night.
Lucasey pitched five innings,
scoreless with six strikeouts against Arizona.
He only threw 83 pitches.
The reason he did not pitch the sixth,
he was lifted for a pinch hitter with two on and two outs in the fifth inning.
So I do believe that was the reason why they ended up winning the game.
because of it, Mahia came in and got the base hit and scored a run.
So I think that you could be not as concerned about Lucchasey yet, not pitching deep into games.
What?
That's legit.
That's what happened.
That's what happened.
Okay.
Okay.
But would it have been like his previous start where as soon as he put a runner on in the sixth,
they take him out?
I think probably.
Maybe.
He still looks like a two-pitch pitcher, and that made him terrible the third time through
the lineup last year.
I'm not saying he's a bad option, but it's going to be hard for him to take him.
a big step forward if he remains just a two-pitch guy.
Would you rather have Lucchasey or Robbie Ray?
Robbie Ray.
Right.
Okay.
And the only pitcher that was great yesterday that we didn't talk about was Mike Minor,
43% owed, seven scoreless, seven strikeouts against Houston.
His first start was terrible.
He is at Arizona next week.
Do you have any interest in Mike Minor?
He's 43% own.
Minor, interest.
Yeah, that, that,
ownership sounds about right.
Okay, fine.
We have to acknowledge that joke.
No.
He's pretty good at it.
He's very quick.
Very quick.
Okay, guys, we have some league disputes.
Let's regulate.
Send in your league disputes with a fantasy regulators subject line to fantasy baseball at cbsi.com.
Don't do it, Heath.
John from Los Angeles has our first regulators.
Okay.
I offered a trade.
for Trey Turner, giving up Jose Ramirez before the injury.
So he offered up Ramirez to get Trey Turner.
The GM did not reject or accept.
Then the Trey Turner injury happens,
and I quickly go to my computer to cancel my trade offer,
only to see that a few minutes before the Trey Turner owner accepted,
and he got my Jose Ramirez for his Trey Turner.
Our league policy is no veto unless collusion.
Am I screwed?
What should the rule be regarding this?
Oh, you shouldn't play with such jerks, John.
Yeah.
No, that is the answer.
I mean, a reasonable person would ask, well, he would assume you wouldn't want to make the deal, but he would at least ask before pulling the trigger when the circumstances change like that.
And, you know, if this guy, at the very least, you boycott this guy from trades in the future.
You don't need to trade with him anymore.
He's a jerk.
Yeah, I would say also, because this is something I could 100% see myself doing to one of you,
just to get you all riled up and throwing a fit before I gave the player back.
So I would just make sure that's not what this is.
Because it's hard to believe someone's a big enough jerk to do this and actually mean it.
What's a bigger jerk thing to do?
To do it and mean it or to do it just to fire up media and or Scott?
Like, they're both pretty bad.
Listen, if I were the commissioner, I would 100% overturn this trade.
This is where vetoes do come in.
This doesn't have to be collusion.
A trade like this should never go through.
I'd overturn it.
I don't think I'd overturn the trade, but I might penalize the owner who did it future draft pick.
You can't just do that.
That's not in the bylaws.
You can't do that.
You can't do that.
You're not Roger Goodell.
I'm the commissioner.
You can't tell me what to do.
All right.
Tim from Olympia.
I'm in a pretty old, relatively serious 14-team family points league.
Most of the owners have been in it for 10-plus years.
In the last couple of years, the commissioner has made some rule changes without running them by the league.
This year after the draft, he changed the league so that...
Okay, this year after the draft, he changed the league so that all unroastered players were on full waivers all the time.
So you couldn't just do add drops.
Everybody's on waivers.
was done to limit two-starred streamers.
But the biggest problem with this change is that the commission didn't tell anyone we were switching to full waivers
until the second week of the season.
So a fellow owner drafted his team with weak pitching, planning to be able to stream those two-star guys.
How do I handle this with the commissioner?
Should I ignore it since it doesn't affect my team much?
Should I ask him to switch back to last year's rules and wait until next season to make the full waivers change?
What should we do if he refuses?
He's also my stepdad.
Well, the first thing I would do is scream in his face, you're not my real dad.
Oh, my God.
Pete, get drink some coffee.
Wow.
Okay.
What else would you do?
Maybe throwing a, you're not the boss of me?
That's better.
Okay.
I would just maybe do a very public posting on the message board, suggesting that we not have any more rules changes without.
league vote
I wouldn't go that far
I'm okay with commissioners
making unilateral changes
but there does have to be
forewarning
you know you can't have it
after the season's already started
which is the case
when you talk about a draft
I don't even
I don't even necessarily mind
throwing it out there
hey guys do you mind if we make this change
even though we've already drafted them
as long as there's not too much
objection to it going ahead
and making the change
but from the perspective of making changes in a general sense,
if everybody has enough warning that they can adjust to it,
I think it's fine.
If they have that big of a problem with it,
they'll say, I don't want to play in the league anymore.
But as the commissioner, you're doing the legwork,
and I think you get to set the rules because of it.
I don't know.
It's just, like, think about this.
If you're the owner that drafted based on last year's rules,
and now all of a sudden in week two you find out those rules have changed,
you're going to be rightfully very angry.
What are you going to do?
No, I started off angry.
I said he shouldn't have made this change.
He shouldn't have, but the question is not.
But we're not the fantasy, you know, judgmental.
Like, we're not going to just judge it.
We have to do something about it.
Like, what do you do?
You know, like, what do you do if you're Tim,
who is not the commissioner?
He's this commissioner's stepson.
You know, do you demand?
I think sending a passive aggressive note to the whole league,
like he mentioned, is one.
There's a fine way to do it
trying to convince the commissioner
one-on-one that this is a bad idea
as another fine way to do it. If you can't convince them,
your choices are to either live with it or quit
the league. I say you
tell the commissioner say,
Dad, can I call you dad?
I think you should go back
to last year's rules and implement
the full waivers rules next year.
And that would be a beautiful
father-step-son moment.
And thank you for listening to the
fantasy regulators and to
the rest of the show. Friday, our show on Friday, we always preview the week ahead,
so we'll look at two-star pitchers, maybe give you some hitting advice as well.
Please send your emails to Fantasy Baseball at Cbsi.com.
I'm Adam Azer for Scott White and Heath Cummings.
We'll talk to you tomorrow on Fantasy Baseball today.
