Fantasy Baseball Today - Top 100 Prospects! Jackson Holliday Up On Opening Day?? (1/15 Fantasy Baseball Podcast)
Episode Date: January 15, 2024Scott White just released his Top 100 prospects for 2024! Will Jackson Holliday break camp with the Orioles (3:45)? ... Jackson Chourio should get a legit shot after signing his extension (12:02). ...... Could Wyatt Langford be the Rangers' DH (18:15)? ... Will Junior Caminero really get a shot early on (25:44)? ... News (32:53): the Giants signed Jordan Hicks to be a starter? ... How aggressive will the Pirates be with Paul Skenes (41:32)? ... Is there a spot for Jordan Lawlar to play (44:47)? ... Kyle Manzardo has an opportunity with the Guardians if he can seize it (48:25). ... Heston Kjerstad seems ready but the Orioles have so many young players (51:07). ... We wrap up with Pete Crow-Armstrong and Tyler Black (55:03). To display your continued support of the show, please vote Fantasy Baseball Today in the Sports Podcast Awards in the "Best Baseball Podcast" Category https://www.sportspodcastgroup.com/sports_category/best-baseball-podcast/ Fantasy Baseball Today is available for free on the Audacy app as well as Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Podcasts, Stitcher and wherever else you listen to podcasts. Subscribe to our YouTube channel: youtube.com/FantasyBaseballToday Get awesome Fantasy Baseball Today merch here: http://bit.ly/3y8dUqi Follow FBT on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@fbtpod?_t=8WyMkPdKOJ1&_r=1 Follow our FBT team on Twitter: @FBTPod, @CTowersCBS, @CBSScottWhite, @Roto_Frank Join our Facebook group at https://www.facebook.com/groups/fantasybaseballtoday Sign up for the FBT Newsletter at https://www.cbssports.com/newsletters/fantasy-baseball-today/ For more fantasy baseball coverage from CBS Sports, visit https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/ To hear more from the CBS Sports Podcast Network, visit https://www.cbssports.com/podcasts/ You can listen to Fantasy Baseball Today on your smart speakers! Simply say "Alexa, play the latest episode of the Fantasy Baseball Today podcast" or "Hey Google, play the latest episode of the Fantasy Baseball Today podcast." To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Welcome to the Fantasy Baseball Today podcast from CBS Sports.
Got a fantasy question?
Email Fantasy Baseball at CBSI.com.
Get ready to win your lead.
Now here's Frank Scott and Chris.
Will the two Jackson Prospects, Holiday and Chorio, be up on opening day?
We shall discuss.
Welcome in to Fantasy Baseball today.
Frank Scott and Chris all here on Monday, January 15th, Martin Luther King Jr.
day. Today on the show, Scott's top 100 prospects are out on the site. They are live. We're taking
a look at the names who will be fighting for a job this spring. Will they be up on opening day?
I've got 10 names picked out that we will talk about. Just 10? Yeah. I thought we're going to go through
all 100, Frank. I was I was loaded up here, man. Scott's been dunking back Peep's Pepsi in preparation.
Like people kept offering to send me this peeps Pepsi or peepsy.
It's got to be peepsie, yeah.
They kept urging me to try it because of my reputation with peeps.
That isn't entirely earned.
So I tried it finally.
And you know what?
I mean, it's just sugar.
It doesn't, it doesn't take, like, part of my defense of peeps is their sugar-covered marshmallows and what could possibly be wrong with that.
But they do have, like, their own unique taste.
I know what a peep taste like.
And when I drink this peep's Pepsi, it doesn't remind me of a peep.
It's like marshmallow flavored soda, basically.
Like if you told me it was toasted marshmallow Pepsi, I'd totally buy that.
But what could be wrong with that?
It's good.
I would drink it again.
10 out of 10 would drink again.
I can't imagine soda being any sweeter, but when you said marshmallow flavored Pepsi, my gosh.
Well, that's what Pete, you're not the first person who told me that.
It's the same sugar.
content.
Like soda is just super sweet on its own.
True.
If it's flavored like something, that doesn't really change it.
That's true.
Today on the show.
That's my take on Pepsi or Pepsi.
Peefcy.
It's a great name.
Great name.
Mentioned what we're going to be talking about today.
We've got the top prospects, those fighting for a job this spring.
Plus, kind of odd, maybe.
We'll get your thoughts.
Jordan Hicks signed a four-year deal with the Giants to be a starter question mark.
So we will talk about that as well.
So let's get into the prospects.
As I mentioned, Scott's Top 100 Prospects are live on the site.
You can check it out.
You can follow along.
Again, we'll be talking about the ones that they are fighting for a chance to be on the opening day roster.
On the Top 100 Prospects article, there is a, it's, it's my fantasy impact rating for, for 2024.
And there is a firmer one than fighting this spring.
It is Pencilham in.
but those are generally guys who we talk a lot about in other contexts
and are already pretty familiar to fantasy baseballers.
So these are more the prospects who will likely have an impact in 2024,
but won't for sure be on the opening day roster
for their fighting this spring for that chance.
Yes.
And most of them have not debuted yet.
There's a few on the list.
Junior Caminero obviously was up for like seven games.
Jordan Lawler, not so much.
Heston Kirstad. But for the most part, I think the majority of these names have not debuted yet.
Let's start with your number one overall prospect, Scott. That is Jackson Holiday, the shortstop
with the Baltimore's, the number one overall pick in the 2022 draft, son of former major
leaguer Matt Holiday, and all Jackson Holiday did last year was Match across four different levels.
He hit 323, 12 homers, 24 steals, a 941 OPS, 1001,1, 1,1.1.1.1.1.1.
walks to 118 strikeouts.
That plate discipline is something that should definitely play up in a points league.
During the winter meetings, Orioles GM Mike Elias said that it's, quote, definitely a very
strong possibility.
Holiday could make the club's opening day roster.
Scott, talk to me about your expectations for Jackson Holiday.
My expectation is he will make the opening day roster.
They've pretty much left the spot open for him unless they're going to go with a lot of
Ramona Reyes again.
or Jorge Mateo, neither of whom deserves to be starting for a first division,
neither of whom deserves to be starting for a contender like the Orioles.
Well, I'll get into this other thing in a second.
But for Jackson Holiday specifically, what stands out most is the plate discipline,
the fact he walked 101 times in his first, like, extended look in the minors,
as somebody who was drafted out of high school, the power is not all the way there yet.
He's only going to be 20 this year.
But it's something that could come along very quickly.
And I expect that in the majors as a rookie, he'll exceed the 12 home runs he hit in the minors last year by a healthy margin.
He can also run.
He really does everything well.
He's just an all-around great player.
And somebody who obviously grew up around the game as the son of Matt Holliday,
seven-time All-Star, and not just.
just, okay, he was the son of Matt Holiday,
but Matt Holiday now is kind of a hitting guru.
Like, people go to him from around the game
and work out and improve their swings.
Like, he's beyond just being the father,
like Jackson Holiday, it's beyond just the fact
that his father is a great hitter.
He actually can teach hitting too.
So you see it in how polished he is
at such a young age.
And yeah, like I said, I expect him to be
the Orioles opening day shortstop
since all the incentives,
with the CBA that took effect a couple years ago
seemed to favor high-end prospects being on the opening day roster.
And when we, I had the Welshon recently,
I know he has some contacts within the Rangers organization.
We will talk about Wyatt Langford in just a little bit.
He asked his contact,
how much do teams actually care about the draft pick compensation?
And he said, and his contact said,
they care about it, but even more so is
they get additional pool money to spend,
I believe during the draft.
So that is like another added incentive.
And I think almost the most important part of what these teams can earn by having a
prospect on their opening day roster and then that prospect going on to finish whatever
it is, like top three in rookie of the year voting or top five in MVP, whatever it might.
And it lasts a few years.
It's not just they have to finish high in awards voting their rookie season.
It's a really complicated breakdown of how it works.
I won't bore you with the details,
but if they place high enough in awards voting for certain awards
over the first several years of their career,
they get a draft pick in relation to that.
It's not always a draft pick at the end of the first round.
It just depends.
It just depends on what exactly the player goes on to win.
But the point is, it's only an option if they're on the Major League roster
for their entire rookie season.
And that's why the first, I imagine the first four names we're going to talk about,
the top four in my top 100.
I expect them all to be on the major league roster.
And one of them is just guaranteed, I think.
One of them signed a long-term extension that will,
it would be wild.
Jackson Trio, he's the only one who has a long-term deal
to where the service time stuff doesn't really matter for him.
Right.
Yeah, and we'll talk about Jackson Trio in just a second.
Again, Chris, everything is lining up here for Jackson Holiday
between just the players,
the Orioles have available, the quotes that we've heard.
The ADP over the past month over at the NFBC,
again, these are the only data sources we have right now in terms of drafts.
So, you know, take it with a grain of salt.
But 210.7 is the ADP for Holiday as the 21st shortstop off the board.
Worth noting a lot of the drafts being done right now are deeper leagues
where I think people value playing time and higher floors.
And maybe Jackson Holiday doesn't necessarily fit into, you know, both of those.
but what do you think the highest is that he can get in terms of ADP, right?
If we get any kind of confirmation throughout spring training,
where do you see Jackson Holiday potentially like settling in an ADP?
I would think 150-ish, maybe higher.
I mean, that's probably where we saw like,
like Anthony Volpe is 133 right now.
He's right at like Tyro Estrada, Tommy Edmund, Trevor Storia,
right behind him.
I think in that Dansby Swan,
and Anthony Volpe range.
So right around the 11th round
would probably be,
I feel like Jackson Cheerio's
probably going to be a little more enticing
for people in fantasy drafts.
I think he's likelyer to be drafted higher
if we, you know,
all else being equal.
But I think that's probably the range.
Probably not top 100,
but very, very high.
You know what I see with,
can we just name the top four
because we keep making reference?
Sure.
We'll talk about them in.
So the top four, who I think will all be on the opening day roster, or at least their teams want them to be on the opening day roster.
I suppose they could just look overmatched in spring training and it won't happen.
But I think the idea is for all of Jackson Chorio, Brewer's outfielder, Wyatt Langford, Rangers outfielder, and Junior Commonero raised third baseman to make the opening day roster for the reasons we already broke down.
they are all, according to their early ADP on NFBC, going way too low, considering.
And, you know, it could be just given that those are deeper leagues and the consequences for missing or higher,
it could just be that they're playing it safe for now in these early drafts.
And when these guys start to gain momentum in spring training, they'll surge up draft boards,
like we saw with Anthony Volpe and Jordan Walker over the course of last spring.
Not that it worked out so great for either of them.
But of course, it worked out great for the people who drafted Corbyn Carroll and Gunner Henderson last year.
It worked out great for the people who drafted Julio Rodriguez and Bobby Whit the year before.
Like, high-end prospects are still worth gambling on.
But the place these four are going right now, it doesn't even feel like any sort of gamble.
It just feels like a no-brainer.
Yeah, I think it's exactly the reason you mentioned, Scott.
I think people are kind of playing it safe right now.
Again, deeper leagues, I mentioned it.
I think players are kind of valuing fantasy.
players are valuing played appearances and I guess more so assurances, things that
players we know that are going to play for sure at this point in the offseason. But you're
right. Like once we get to spring training Jackson Holiday pops a few homers. Boom,
that's gone. He's, you know, inside the top 150. Let's talk about-
Sleepers 1.0 will be out Tuesday. All four of them are on it. They're all lumped together in one
category because it seemed kind of cheap to just spend four spots on those four guys.
I can see it. I can see it already. Scott.
last year drafted a bunch of young prospects.
And I can just see, Scott,
you're going to be drafted a bunch of dynasty redraft teams again this year.
Well, like I said,
I think by the time we get to drafting real teams
that we're actually going to play with,
the price for these four will be a lot higher.
And to the point,
I probably won't be able to get away with calling of sleepers anymore.
Right.
But certainly here in January,
with the information we have available,
yeah, give me all the Jackson Holiday, Jackson Chorio,
Wyatt Langford and Junior Common Arrow, you can throw at me.
All right, let's talk about Jackson Churio.
Outfielder with the Brewers, Scott's number two overall prospect,
signed the largest extension for a player yet to debut earlier this offseason.
Eight years, $82 million, with incentives that could max out at $140 million over 10 years for Jackson Churio this past season.
As a 19-year-old, he hit 282 with 22 home runs, 44 steals from one year to the next,
lowered his strikeout rate dramatically. Chris, you already kind of alluded to this,
but Brewer's GM, Matt Arnold, said after the extension that Trio will have a chance to make the
team's opening day roster and given that extension, I think it's a little bit more likely than
these other names we're going to talk about. But what are your expectations for Jackson
Shrio here in 2024? Sky high upside, but I think this is a much more high variance profile than
Jackson Holidays where you've got, I think, high.
upside because you've got, I think, more of an in, more in-game power and speed right now,
44, 43 steals last season, 22 home runs, sorry, 44 steals.
The plate discipline doesn't seem quite as, as well developed.
That's not to say Jackson Truro strikes out a ton because he doesn't.
His strikeout rate was 18.4% in AA.
He only played six games at AAA, but, you know, he makes a lot of contact.
It's just he doesn't walk a lot.
And so that's the kind of profile where you worry,
is he too overly aggressive?
What happens when he sees major league sliders for the first time?
He's basically never played above AAA.
He has six games at AAA.
He's played in the Venezuelan Winter League this year
and actually has been quite good from what I've seen,
which is another positive sign.
Yeah, eight strikeouts in 75 plate appearances,
984 OPS.
I think there's more risk with Jackson Turyo.
He also just wasn't as good.
as Jackson Holiday overall, 803 OPS last season at AA.
Jackson Holiday was 980 something OPS overall.
So I think, you know, while Jackson Churio's profile is probably a little more fantasy friendly,
I think Jackson Holiday is the better bet to be productive right away.
Yeah, I would say Jackson Chorio of those four we're talking about,
including Jackson Holiday, who I rank ahead.
Jackson Chorio has the best chance of becoming a.
perennial first rounder type in fantasy because he has that profile that could turn him into a 30 homer,
I mean, yeah, a 30 homer 50 steel guy, Julio Rodriguez type profile here.
And okay, I mean, I don't think part of the reason I rank Jackson Holiday ahead is because I don't
think prospects get much safer than him with that well-developed plate discipline at such a young age.
It's hard to say exactly what Jackson Holiday's upside is.
because we are still waiting on the power development.
But, like, I don't know, Jackson Holiday could be Corey Seeger-like, but with speed.
That's kind of him maxing out his power projection.
It'll probably fall a little short of Corey Segar power.
But that's the kind of profile we're talking about with Jackson Holiday.
Jackson Shorio, like I said, Julio Rodriguez like.
You mentioned the strikeout rate.
I was encouraged last year that it improved by so much because in the lower miners,
And Jackson Chorio, he was already getting plenty of prospect height.
Even before, you know, as an 18-year-old, people were wowed by how hard he hit the ball and his athleticism and all of that.
He was still like a top five prospect everywhere.
But he struck out 26.9% of the time in the lower miners in 2022.
And then last year, moving to the upper miners for the first time facing much tougher pitching, Jackson Chorio dropped that rate to 17.8%.
26.9 to 17.8.
Huge improvement in one year from, again,
a very young player with great tools.
And I'll also point out that his numbers were dragged down in the first half
because he was playing in the Southern League
where they were working with that tacky baseball
and pitchers were able to spin it so much better.
And they changed that out at the All-Star.
At the halfway point, yeah.
And his numbers surged after that.
So I don't have the exact breakdown.
But, you know, the fact he hit 283 with 22 homers and 44 steals
while facing cartoonish pitching in the first half
and still struck out less than 18% of the time for the year.
It's very impressive what Jackson Shoria did.
You can understand why the Brewers wanted to lock them up long term already.
Yes. So with Jackson Sharia, I wanted to quickly just touch on the outfield situation
and what they kind of have lined up for now.
Rasta Resource has Trujillo starting in center field with South Freelick and right,
Garrett Mitchell and left, Christian Yelich at DH and Joey Weimer on the bench.
I think that's entirely possible.
I also think there's still a chance Yelich could play left field and maybe someone like
Garrett Mitchell doesn't get as much playing time early on.
But given this extension and given the prospect pedigree,
I think Turyo will get a shot at the center field job on opening day.
His ADP over the past month is 140 as he.
30th outfielder off the board.
That's after the extension has happened.
So this is just kind of where it's
settling in for now. And even
there, I get it's like a big price tag.
Like top 150 for a player who hasn't
done, yeah, hasn't played a single game yet.
I kind of like it. I kind of like it.
Oh, I have Churio,
I think in Roto leagues, which obviously is what we're talking about
with NFBC ADP.
I'm 21st in the outfield.
Do you say he's about 40th by ADP?
30th, 30th.
Pretty. Okay. So not, I'm not that as far out on a limb then, but still, pretty big difference there. And part of it's just the outfield. Like there's so little upside to be found after the top 20, 25 that it's easier to take a shot on a Churio. But yeah, I still think that that early ADP is discounting, is safeguarding against the possibility. Churio proves he's not quite ready this spring.
Well, if you're looking for upside at the outfield position, another name, Wyatt Langford has a,
ton of it. Scott's number three overall prospect was just drafted last year, fourth overall by
the Texas Rangers turned 22 years old in November, and it sure looks like a team who just
won the World Series is about to get even better because this guy crushed it. A very small
sample size, 44 games in the minors, Wyatt Langford, hit 360 with 10 homers, 12 steals, and 1157
OPS, more walks than strikeouts, and he did that across four different levels.
Started at rookie ball, got up to five games in AAA.
Again, it's a really, really small sample size.
I found this quote from Bruce Bochy this offseason.
Quote, this Langford kid, I've already had the chance to see him.
He's special.
Every step of the way, he just kept putting up those numbers.
He'll come into spring training.
We're going to stay open-minded.
It's going to be competitive.
He'll have a chance to make the club.
It's all performance-based.
I don't care how old they are.
GM, Chris Young doesn't care.
If we think they are ready, then they're,
They'll be on the team.
Scott,
sounds like there's a legit chance here for one,
Wyatt Langford.
I mean, yeah, he's older,
a couple years older than the first two guys we talked about.
And in a span of a couple months,
he just shredded the entire minor leagues,
reaching AAA by the end.
It's one of those situations where it all happens so fast
that it's hard for me to kind of take stock of,
Wyatt Langford and what exactly he is.
Okay, so I mean, basically the scouting reports say he's good at everything offensively.
Defense is, you know, nothing that special, but should hit for average, should hit for power,
really good plate discipline.
And certainly it showed up in the minors.
Nobody could slow him down.
It feels a little too good to be true, but, you know, I think about another player who just sped through the miners,
played only 122 games there.
So a little bit more than Langford, but not even like a full major league season worth of games.
Juan Soto, he was, he just killed it at every level with terrific plate discipline like
Wyatt Langford has.
And obviously the rest is history.
I mean, you just look at Langford at college first.
And then you look at what he did as a professional.
Keep in mind, what he did last season is impressive enough getting to AAA two months after
he got drafted or whatever.
He has never played a season this long before.
This was the first time he's ever played 100 games in his life.
That's also another impressive thing is that he did that while.
He put up an 1157 OPS after a full college season when a lot of guys don't even play
full, full season ball after getting drafted.
I will say on the topic of him making the opening day roster,
the Rangers haven't left as wide of an opening for Wyatt Langford
as the Brewers have for Jackson Churio and the Orioles for Jackson Holiday.
They have a full outfield as it is.
Their DH spot roster resource shows Ezekiel Duran there currently.
I mean, he doesn't need to start.
So maybe they use that to rotate all of their outfielders through.
Wyatt Langford makes opening day roster.
I still think he will and that's probably the direction they go.
But if they wanted to slow play it, they could.
It's just, I mean, the higher end the prospect,
the more likely he's going to place high in rookie of the year voting.
And so if you think he's going to be up in the first half at all,
the incentives now are really to have him there from the beginning
so that he has a chance of scoring you all those extra goodies.
And the Rangers could give themselves two shots at those awards
and those incentives by having both,
Kevin Carter and Wyatt Langford on their opening day roster.
So I think it's a real chance.
Again, DH is pretty much open there.
We'll have to see what Wyatt Langford does this spring.
His ADP over the past month over at the NFBC 161.7,
38th outfielder off the board.
Chris, what do you think about that price tag?
Just inside the top 40 outfielders.
I can't really argue against it given the profile,
given the fact that there's plenty of speed in his profile.
You know, you read the sky.
Scouting reports, and it's one where he's a big dude.
You know, he's buff, he's built 225 pounds.
What he's listed at at 6-1, but runs well.
21 steals between college and the pros, including 12 and 44 games as a professional.
I think that price is pretty reasonable.
And obviously, I'm not as well-versed on the prospects, but I don't see a ton of reason to rank him far below Jackson Churio.
given that the profile feels a little safer.
There's plenty of speed in the profile as well.
Maybe Jackson Churio's highest percentile outcome is a little higher,
but Wye-Langford looks pretty legit to me.
I got them right next to each other.
I said I had Churio 21.
I have Y. Langford 22,
and I believe they're flipped in my Points League's ranking,
since there is that difference in plate discipline between the two of them.
All right, let's take our first break.
When we return, we'll get to the last of the big four up at the top.
Junior Caminero, we'll do that right after this.
Welcome back.
Before we get to Junior Caminero, just a quick reminder that FBT is a finalist
for the best baseball podcast category in the sports podcast awards.
Thanks to all of our listeners, we actually won the award last year.
Now we're looking to go back to back.
To help us bring home the hardware, you can find the link in the podcast and YouTube
descriptions or scan the QR code in the top right of the screen.
the whole process should take you less than a minute,
and we would really appreciate it.
Thank you for your continued support.
And speaking of support,
make sure to sign up for the FBT newsletter.
It is free.
Chris, what are the details on the FBT newsletter?
I know you do a great job with it.
Well, I'm not doing a great job with it yet.
Let's not get ahead of ourselves.
The first edition of the new CBS Sports Fantasy Baseball Today newsletter
will go out probably Tuesday.
Tuesday is when our rankings are going live,
sleepers break on some bus.
Big death.
Introducing myself to the audience,
make sure you go to CBSSports.com
slash newsletters to check it out.
But yeah, the goal is to have that be everything you need to win.
We're going to have all the content that the three of us create throughout the season.
We're going to break down news analysis.
It's going to all be from my unique perspective,
whether that's a selling point to you or not,
is up to you to do.
determine, but I think it's going to be pretty good. That's going to be my primary focus this
coming season. I think it's going to be a pretty good product. If you, if you subscribe to the
FFT newsletter, you should know what to expect. It's going to be a lot of information in your inbox
five days a week. It's going to be awesome. And it's free. So why not? You don't have to do anything.
It literally goes straight to your email inbox. So again, CBS.Sports.com slash newsletters,
you punch in your email and boom, you sign up for free. Let's talk about Junior Camerero,
who is Scott's number four overall prospect.
He is a third base prospect,
but Tampa Bay has played a little bit at shortstop as well.
He went bonkers in the minors last year,
hit 324 with 31 homers and a 975 OPS
across high A and double A.
He actually got promoted to Tampa Bay for the final, you know,
towards the end of the season,
he got seven games in.
He only hit 2.35 with one homer.
But, man, this is a fun prospect.
Not sure that there's any speed here really at all,
but we're talking about a potential four category contributor
with big batting average and power.
He's crushing the Dominican Winter League right now
for whatever that's worth.
It's got the only thing that worries me,
and I saw this quote in an article written by Mark Topkin
of the Tampa Bay Times.
He wrote,
It's most likely that Camerro,
who has played just 290 pro games,
81 above Class A before his promotion,
is headed back to the miners as,
one of the game's top prospects.
That's just a beatwriter writing that.
I don't know if he heard that within the organization,
or he's just kind of speculating on his part.
But of these four names,
that's the only one where I've actually read something
that put a little bit more doubt
on that player being up on opening day.
Yeah, I have the most doubt for Common Arrow of these four,
which is interesting because he's the one who actually got called up last year.
And normally, as we saw with Corbynoburnal,
Robin Carroll and Gunner Henderson,
they were seeing higher-end prospects get called up in September
to sort of get their feet wet so that when opening day comes the next year,
it's not this daunting thing.
It's kind of a chance without exhausting their rookie eligibility
to give them some major league exposure so that they're prepared to win an opening day job the next year.
And so that seemed like the plan the race were following with Junior Cominero.
But what makes me skeptical, apart from that report, is, you know, I look at the roster and there doesn't seem to be an opening for Cominero.
Primarily a third baseman, as you say, Issoc Peretti's had a good year, currently slotted there.
Okay, he could slide over to first base, but you got Yanti Diaz there.
So, you know, D.H is open and the Rays like to mix it up.
You wouldn't think they'd want a dedicated D.H.
And so maybe that's Junior Commonero's in.
It's not really the Rays M.O.
to call up a guy in his age 19 season as they did with Common Arrow next year.
So the fact they took that leap with him, the rays of all organizations tell me that they really believe he's ready.
So I still suspect he'll make the opening day roster,
but it feels less,
I'm less confident in a common arrow for the other three.
And this is a raise organization that I,
I don't know if you want to say they,
they've left their guys down in the minors to overproof.
But they,
they want,
they tend to want guys to prove it at AAA first,
you know,
and that's something that we've dealt with when,
when waiting for them to call,
top prospects up and guys who, you know, to our eyes, seem ready, still end up going.
And we've seen it, you know, with a lot of lower end prospects, Vidal Bruhan, Jonathan
Rondo over the past couple of seasons have gotten called up for like a week.
And we're like, all right, they're here to stay.
And in Vidal Bruhan's kid, you remember his rookie season, he got called up for 10 games and had like
one hit.
He played regularly, but was just awful.
So they sent him back down.
So that might not be the same thing.
it's just to point out that the raise developmental process,
in all ways,
the race kind of marched to the beat of their own drum.
Teams might call up precocious 19 or 20-year-olds
who dominated AA,
the raise might be willing to let them prove it at AAA for a month or two
or calling them up.
And that's my concern with,
and I think there are,
at least in my less,
learned viewpoint.
I think there are,
I would put him like a half tier behind the three guys ahead of him,
mostly because he doesn't bring any speed to the team.
Yeah, he doesn't.
He does hit the ball hard,
like about as hard as any minor leaguer,
which is especially impressive given that,
like I said,
he was a teenager for most of last year.
And he does it without striking out much either.
So it's,
I know these are some very lofty comps I'm throwing out of it out there,
but like he reminds me of like an Adrian Beltray type hitter.
And obviously Belcher wasn't a big speed guy either.
But yeah, I mean, certainly in leagues, the scoring formats like rotisserie where speed is essential.
Common Arrow has to rank behind those other three just because he's not going to be a contributor of it.
I do want to go back a second to the prospect of Common Arrow making the rays because I mentioned D.H is open.
it became open because remember the race traded Luke Rayleigh to the Mariners.
And at the time, I said, oh, there's great news for Jonathan Aranda, unless they decide to go with Curtis Mead there instead.
And I didn't even bring up Commonero, I don't think.
They got a lot of moving pieces.
A lot of directions the race could go.
And, you know, I think Aranda's an incredible hitter and he's already 26, I believe.
So, like, in a way, it would be a shame for Commonero to pass him over.
And I do kind of wonder, since they haven't solved their shortstop issue, the raise,
they did acquire Jose Caballero in that Luke Rayleigh deal,
but it's not like he's a, it's not like he's to be playing every day.
I do wonder if they want to mix Common Arrow in it shortstop.
That has been discussed.
I don't think he would play the position full time.
But as much as the race like to mix it up, there may be a way to fit two or three of those guys.
meaning Commonero or Ronda and Mead on the roster.
We'll just have to see how it all plays out.
And you haven't even mentioned Richie Palacios yet, Scott.
How dare you?
I think he's in a different category, but they did acquire him.
He's played like one inning at shortstop, I think.
Not at shortstop, but for DH.
Jose Cabriero, by the way, great defender and Tampa Bay does value defense.
According to Stackass, at least, his outs above average ranked in the 94th percentile last year.
And he's pretty fast, too, 90th percentile sprint speed.
So I think there's a chance that they acquired Caballero,
just kind of knowing what their situation is right now,
and they needed a shortstop.
But yeah, we should learn more in spring training, hopefully.
Let's quickly talk about some news and notes from the weekend.
Jordan Hicks signed a four-year, $44 million deal with the San Francisco Giants,
and apparently they plan to use him as a starter.
In eight career starts, Jordan Hicks has a 547 ERA,
and a 156 whip.
All eight of those starts came in 2022.
And in 204 career relief appearances,
Hicks has a much more admirable 365 ERA, 127 whip.
So not sure how long this experiment is going to last,
but that's what we're being told as of now.
Jordan Hicks signed as a starter.
And the Giants rotation as of now includes Logan Webb,
Kyle Harrison, Ross Stripling, Jordan Hicks,
and Keaton win.
Chris, do you have any enthusiasm for Jordan Hicks, the starter?
I don't want to say it's impossible,
but there is some additional context
in addition to those eight starts he made in 2022,
which is that he made eight starts
at the beginning of the 2022 season,
and then went right on the IL
with right forearm flexor strain.
He missed about a month and a half,
return to the bullpen.
I think Jordan Hicks is a super fun player.
He reminds me a lot of like Dustin May as a starter where, you know,
I don't know if the strikeout numbers will be what we want,
but he's going to be so hard to hit that he could be good.
I just this feels like it ends with a trip to the I.L.
At some point, I, I just, he hasn't shown he can stay healthy even in a reliever's workload.
He throws so hard.
He's such a high effort pitcher that I think it's very unlikely.
he gets through a full season as a starter.
Over the past month,
Jordan Hicks's ADP is 315.
I guess something from a points league, Scott,
if it does work out as a starter
for some crazy reason,
he will be a spark.
So I guess something to consider there.
Well, part of it with me is he's just,
he's inefficient.
I mean, Chris pointed to the effort,
but he walks a lot of guys too.
Oh, yeah.
And I just don't see how it's
supposed to work, that he would go the distance we need for him to be useful in fantasy.
And knowing the Giants, what is starting pitcher even me?
I mean, they had Sean Mania going three and a third to four and two-thirds
innings every time out.
It's worth mentioning they have a new coach now in Bob Melvin.
So Gabe Kapler was obviously very, you know, that's true.
Kind of his own type of manager and, you know, did things in his own way.
But you got to feel like.
the front office had a hand in that too, given the way modern organizations are run,
and that remains the same.
I think if you're going to invest in a converted reliever late in a points league and the hope
you get a great spark out of it, I would prefer Reynaldo Lopez with the Braves.
Not that it's, it's not as certain he wins a rotation spot for them,
but I think there's a better chance he's successful with it.
Yeah, and with Reinaldo Lopez currently,
apparently competing for the fifth starter job in the Braves rotation with Bryce Elder and A.J. Smith,
Chauvers. So that will be something to watch in spring training as well.
And if it doesn't work out as a starter for Jordan Hicks, four years, 44 million for potentially a really good setup, man.
That's not a bad deal. So I think either way, it could work out for the Giants. We'll see.
The Cubs president of baseball operations, Jed Hoyer said Saturday that Michael Bush's ultimate position will be up to Craig Cous.
counsel, but he expects Michael Bush to play first base, which Scott, every time we've had the
opportunity to ask the Welsh about Matt Mervis' offseason, we tried. But hearing this,
reading this, and the ties to Reese Hoskins is offseason two, it just, it kind of feels
like it might be over for Matt Mervis. Look, it's a net win. I think Michael Bush is better than
Matt Mervis. But yeah, I think, I think the book is closed on.
Matt Mervis is a fantasy asset.
He's already old, and the Cubs show no interest in clearing a spot for him.
And there aren't that many teams that could use them, even if you're thinking trade.
Like, he's a true first baseman.
I was trying to think through, like, what team could make this investment and maybe turn him into something?
Well, certainly the A's could, but, you know, what are the odds of that happening?
Yeah, I do not plan on keeping him for $5 in the sky.
White Dynasty League, a 24 team head-to-head points league.
Very interesting.
Ray's president of baseball operations,
Eric Neander told reporters that Taylor Walls is, quote,
unlikely to be ready for opening day following off-season hip surgery,
which again would explain why the team went out and acquired Jose Caballero last week.
I mentioned he's fast.
He had 26 steals across 104 games, 90th percentile sprint speed.
I think in very deep leagues, if you are desperate for speed,
he's just a name to know if he gets
every day playing time again. That's Jose Caballero.
White Sox GM Chris Gets
revealed that Garrett Crochet is preparing
to be a starting pitcher in
2024. He has pitched
73 innings
in his major league career, 271, ERA,
a 133 whip. He's a
6 foot 6 left. He averaged 97
miles per hour on the fastball.
He's got a great slider when he's on.
This is a former first overall pick
back in 2020.
Again, Chris, I'm not sure
how it's going to work out.
Is he going to be stretched out enough?
Is he going to be a traditional starter?
Does he go maybe three or four innings?
And then they bring in like a bulk reliever.
But he's a pretty interesting name.
He was a very high draft pick.
So it's at least on my radar as something to watch
Garrett Crochet as a potential starter.
I mean,
an incredibly talented pitcher for sure,
based on what we've seen at the Major League level.
It's just he's started one game since 2019.
2020 was the COVID shortened season.
He started one game at the University of Tennessee.
He hasn't started at all as a professional.
It seems unlikely that this is going to work out well.
But yeah, keep an eye on him.
If he looks good in spring training, let's take a look.
He should be on a late round deep sleeper radar.
Some huge news.
The Yankee signed good old Luke Weaver to a one-year, $2 million deal for some
Deweaver.
Somebody had to do it.
I'm happy you did it because I was not going to do it.
I actually texted the former host of this podcast, Adam Azer.
I let him know, hey, the Yankee signed Luke Weaver.
I thought you'd be happy to know that.
He said, I know, I love it.
Yankees suck.
That was the end of the conversation.
That's what he said.
You, you, you, you, you, you, queued him up, had it on a tea for him, and he whiffed.
Yeah, I was, you know, sending it to him in, like, celebratory fashion.
Like, hey, Luke Weaver, I know you love that guy.
And I think he liked that part of it, but I guess,
the rest of the Yankees all season.
Adam Azor is not a fan.
Oh, trading for Juan Soto wasn't enough for him?
Poor guy.
I wasn't going to bring it up to him, but I'm sure he's aware.
The deadline for arbitration eligible players was Thursday night.
Juan Soto, that's right, the name we just mentioned,
Juan Succo, set the new record by getting $31 million from the Yankees for the
2024 season.
Some of the bigger names who did not come to an agreement and are headed for an arbitration
hearing include Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Adolius Garcia, Luis Arise,
among others.
The latest rumors,
the Blue Jays are reportedly monitoring
Blake Snell's market.
They already have a pretty damn good pitching staff,
but you can never have enough pitching,
the old saying goes.
The Yankees and Rangers have emerged as frontrunners
for reliever Hector Nerris,
and he was actually pretty awesome last year.
He does have closing experience.
If he lands with either of those teams,
the Yankees or Rangers,
there is a non-zero chance
that Hector Neris could work his way into the back end,
saving games for either of those teams.
So we shall see.
And the Orioles have expressed interest in James Paxton.
Let's take our final break.
When we return, we've got six prospects to talk about in 20 minutes.
Will we do it?
Probably not, but we will try here on Fantasy Baseball today.
Welcome back in. Reminder, Scott's Top 100 Prospects,
currently live on the site, CBSports.com slash fantasy slash baseball.
And today we are talking about the top names on that list that are competing for a job
with their respective teams for opening day.
And we get to Paul Skeens,
who is a starting pitcher prospect
with the Pittsburgh Pirates,
the number eight overall prospect.
And he was the first overall pick
in last year's draft.
21 years old, big dude,
6 foot 6.
He features a huge fastball,
which averaged 98 miles per hour in college.
He has a plus slider.
Crazy numbers at LSU.
He led Division 1 baseball in strikeouts,
K-per-9.
Whip, did make five starts towards the end of the season.
The Pirates rotation, as of now, Mitch Keller,
Martin Perez, Marco Gonzalez, Luis Ortiz, and Bailey Falter.
Yikes.
So it's Mitch Keller.
Yeah.
If they want to get Paul Skeens in the rotation,
they very clearly could, Scott.
It's just, what is there,
what is the likelihood that happens,
considering the pirates are not really competing in 2024?
That's the question.
Yeah, and they're the pirates.
and I'm less hopeful it happens in this case,
but there is some smoke there that makes me think it could happen.
Also, the fact he's a pitcher and, you know, having him on the roster for the beginning,
what do you do when the innings start to pile up?
It's a little more complicated with pitchers.
But Paul Skeens is, as pitching prospects go, he seems to be very safe.
If he's already proven himself in the, you know, in the college ranks, he was the most impressive pitcher in the college ranks last year.
Throws a fastball very hard, has a great slider.
There is some hand-wringing in analyst circles about the shape of Paul Skeen's fastball.
It seems so missing the forest for the trees.
It does.
Like, I get when you're dealing.
dealing with this level of prospect, you're always like, you know, micro slicing for, for flaws, but.
Yeah.
And I think the fact he was the first overall pick.
And instead of Wyatt Langford and a guy we're not going to talk about Dylan Cruz.
Dylan Cruz.
Yeah, the national.
Yeah.
The SEC was pretty bonkers last year.
Like those, I think those outfielders were so impressive as draft picks at the first.
fact the Pirates one Paul Skeens instead, then it makes, it kind of begs for more questioning.
But yeah, I mean, okay, so vertical approach angle rising fastball, that's very much in right now.
And Paul Skeens doesn't have that.
But yes, he throws 100.
And the slider so good that his fastball doesn't need to be a huge bat misser anyway.
And he's capable of taking on big workload.
And he'll probably be good, if not great.
And whether it's on opening day or not,
it'll probably begin at some point in 2024.
Again, this was a huge prospect coming out of college,
not just size-wise,
but we're talking about comparisons to the best pitching prospects
since Steven Schrosberg, right?
So keep that in mind again.
I probably shouldn't overthink it from like a dynasty perspective.
My guess is he will be up at some point in 2024 on opening day.
There are some questions.
Let's move on to Jordan Lawler.
Chris, you'll get the first word here.
Scott's number 12 overall prospect with the Arizona Diamondbacks
First round pick back in 2021, drafted sixth overall.
This season in the minors hit 278, I guess last season,
278 with 20 homers, 36 steals in 874 OPS.
He did get 14 games in with the D-BACs towards the end of the season,
where he hit 129 with a 32% strikeout rate.
D-backs made it all the way to the World Series.
Seemingly did not use Jordan Lawler at all throughout that run.
In the postseason, in the World Series,
there are issues with strikeouts.
And even more than that, Chris, there might be a log jam here too
because the debacks have Geraldo Perdomo,
penciled in at shortstop.
They signed Eugenio Suarez or traded for to play third base.
They have Loris Guerrille as their DH right now too.
So there's a chance for opening day,
but I think Jordan Loller probably will have to have a really,
really big spring training for that to happen.
Yeah, it's hard to see exactly where he fits right now,
although Eugenio Suarez and Geraldo Perdomo
both feel like the kind of guys who could have a really bad April and just become completely irrelevant.
So if it's not opening day, it shouldn't be too much longer for Jordan Lawler.
I think there's obviously the 12th prospect and the rest of those guys were top five.
I think there's a clear step down here.
And I think the biggest carrying tool from fantasy perspective, at least, appears to be speed.
You know, 33 steals and 89 games last season at AA.
24 and 44 at A last or the year before.
So it seems like it's more of a good hitter with very,
very good speed rather than, you know,
someone who's right away and impact bad.
He's still very young.
He was very young at every level last season being 20 at double A and triple A.
So definitely don't want to write off the potential for more improvement.
But it doesn't seem like the,
the hit tool is as progressed in a way that,
that makes him likely to be a difference maker for fantasy right away.
It reminds me a lot of Anthony Volpe, to be perfectly honest,
which I guess is more of a cautionary tale if Jordan Lawler does start gaining traction this spring.
You know, obviously not encouraging that he went four for 31 in his first stint in the big leagues,
though he wasn't given the most consistent playing time on the eventual NL champion Diamondbacks.
He could easily make the roster, but it's, he just doesn't impact the ball the way most high-end prospects do.
And I think, as Chris said, the speed might be enough to make up for that.
But it could be a struggle to get the hitting up to the level we want, or it could not.
I mean, he could be Marcus Simeon.
It's, you know, hard to say.
I just think there are more downside concerns with Jordan Lawler than the prospects we've talked about so far.
far. The ADP over the past month for Jordan Lawler is 297.9 as the 27 shortstop off the board.
He's going about 30 picks after Zach Netto and JP Crawford. What do you guys think about that
price tag for Jordan Lawler? That's about where I have him. I might prefer him to Netto.
I mean, obviously you'd have to win a job for that to be the case. But I would definitely
take Crawford over both of them.
All right, let's move on to Kyle Manzardo.
A little bit further down the top 100 list.
Scott's number 26 overall prospect,
a first basement in the Guardians organization,
23 years old, came over from Tampa Bay
in the Aaron Savali trade last year,
and did have a down year after a breakout 2022,
where Manzardo hit 236, 17 homers, and 801 OPS.
Turns out he was dealing with some injuries.
He had some personal stuff going on off the field,
which obviously he's human,
could have affected the numbers.
Did bounce back in the Arizona Fall League for whatever that's worth.
272 batting average there, six homers, OPS over 900.
I saw him when I was out there for first pitch Arizona.
I saw him crush a home run to right field in the AFL Fall Stars game.
So we know the power is legit, makes good contact, batting average should be there as well.
And Scott, if we're looking just at the Guardian situation right now,
they have Josh Naylor, who probably profiles better as like a DH anyway.
then there's not really much else.
So the opportunity looks like it should be there for Kyle Manzardo.
Yeah, I feel pretty good about this one,
about Manzardo's chances of making the opening day roster.
It seemed like that was being talked up the moment
the guardians acquired him from the raise for Aaron Savali last year.
And, you know, you might get some people sleeping on him
just because the minor league production was underwhelming last year.
But the exit velocity readings were great.
The plate discipline was great,
whether you're talking about just barely walks to strikeouts
or zone contact rate was over 85%.
Everything under the hood looked good for Monsardo,
which, you know, you might still be skeptical of it,
even knowing that, except for the fact that he was as good as he was in 2022,
327 batting average in a 1043 OPS in a year.
much of the time was spent at double A.
So at this point, last year,
Manzardo seemed like a perfect hitting prospect
and then had his struggles this past year.
But I still think there's a lot to like here,
and I still think, you know,
I'm happy to mostly tune out what he did in the minors last year
and treat him as kind of a Vinny Pasquantino type going forward.
The ADP for Kyle Manzardo over the past month, 3.30.7,
the 30th first basement off the board going just after Thai France.
So it seems pretty late.
I think there's probably a little bit more upside than someone like Thai France.
My guess is that will probably creep up as we get closer to spring training as well.
Let's move down to Heston Kirstad, who is Scott's number 33 overall prospect,
who is a first base corner outfielder, DH type for the Baltimore Orioles,
former first round pick back in 2020.
went second overall in that draft,
dealt with a bunch of issues from myocarditis
to a nasty hamstring injury,
which knocked him out for nearly an entire season.
But he just played his first full minor league season,
and he was awesome.
Heston Kirstad hit 303, 21 homers,
a 904 OPS.
Does have a big leg kick,
but also comes with big power.
Got 13 games in with the Orioles.
Towards the end of the season, hit two homers.
Flash some of that exit velocity,
92.3 miles per hour.
But Chris, you know,
not to the same extent as like Jackson Holiday
because it seems like there's like
a pretty clear opening for him.
It's a little bit tougher here
for Heston Kirstad and a bunch of the other names, right?
Like there's Kobe Mayo on that team
and there's Connor Norby.
There's just kind of a log jam
to have Ryan Mountcastle, Ryan O'Hern,
Alston Hayes, Anthony Santander,
taking up like first base DH and corner outfield spots.
So I just don't see a spot right now
for Hess and Kirstad, what do you think?
Yeah, and Kirstad's the kind of player
where you look at the profile.
And he was weirdly controversial.
When he got called up last year,
there was a lot of debating in fantasy baseball circles
about what to make of his prospect profile,
given his age, given his lack of experience.
I think a lot of those discussions were frankly a little unfair
for a guy who missed so much time,
not because of injuries,
but mostly because of non-baseball-related health.
health scares. But the profile, it makes me think, you know, there's big power there. There's
some swing and miss potential there. There's not much speed. And so you look at it and you take it all
together. And it's, it's the kind of profile where this is not the guy I think you're drafting
before he has a job locked up. You know, especially if you play in in what most leagues are,
which is what, 276 players drafted or maybe 350 if you go through the bench spot. And
in the 12-team Roto League, like probably not someone I think you need to draft and stash there.
But if we get to early March and he's playing with the first team and he's heating up and it looks
like he's got a spot, then we start to have those discussions.
But I think in most 12-team leagues, Heston-Kirstad is not necessarily someone you need to be drafting
the stash right now.
I do want to point out with Heston Kirstad, who at times I'm tempted to call Kestan-Hirstad.
But no, it's Heston Kyrstad.
I always think of Kestan Hiro when I see his name.
Right.
Right.
That's probably why I do it too.
Put that together yet, but that's probably why.
So, yeah, he does have this reputation as a power first bat who might swing and miss a lot.
His own contact rate last year was 88%.
It was elite.
Like, when he swung at a ball, when he swung at an actual strike, he did not miss at a rate you rarely see among minor league.
hitters. And so, I don't know, that might be, that might be overstated his, his swing and miss
potential. But I do have just concerns how he's going to find his way into the Orioles lineup,
because he is not a great defender, pretty much just left field, first base, maybe right field.
And they're kind of full in all of those spots. I mean, Ryan O'Hern is currently occupying
first base. Maybe he's nothing, but he did have a good year. He probably deserves a
chance to do it again. So I'm not super confident that Heston Kirstadt is going to make the roster.
And that's part of the reason why he's only 33rd in my top 100.
All right, Scott. Let's bring it home here. The final two names on the list, I'm going to pair them up
together. We've got Pete Crow, Armstrong, and outfielder with the Cubs, your number 41 overall
prospect. And Tyler Black, who is a, I would call a utility player for the Brewers. He can play
anywhere and that's not a knock on him.
I think it's actually better for his value
because there are multiple avenues
for him to get into the lineup.
He is your number 42 overall prospect.
Pete Kerr Armstrong does come with some power,
really good speed.
There are some questions there on the hit.
Superb defense.
So once he's there and he's in center field,
I don't know that they're going to take him out of the lineup
because that defense is going to be so valuable
for the Cubs. It's just how much of an
offensive impact is he going to make?
And then Tyler Black,
this breakout prospect from last season,
a little bit older at 23 years old,
but he hit 284, 18 homers, 55 steals,
and he is on a Brewer's team
that looks like they could use him, right?
They have Jake Bowers, penciled in at first base,
Andrew Monasterio at third,
Bryce Tarang at second.
You know, he's a young player
that'll probably give him a shot,
but first and third,
both seem like possibilities for Tyler Black.
So what do you have here on Pete Kronstrom
and Tyler Black?
Well, I rank Pete Crow Armstrong 41.
I rank Tyler Black 42.
I am much more.
So clearly you love Pete Crowe Armstrong way more.
I'm more excited about Tyler Black than I am about Pete Crowe Armstrong.
I'm trying to make a statement by ranking Crow Armstrong only 41st.
This is about as low as you'll see him on any list.
And I think he's, I think his fantasy stock has been involved.
inflated for a couple reasons.
One, he shows up so high on real life list because he is a defense standout in
center field, and that's hard to find.
Two, he had a great year in the miners last year.
He had 283 with 20 homers, 37 steals.
Who wouldn't love that from Pete Crowe Armstrong?
You dig a little deeper.
The exit velocities are terrible.
The zone contact rate is terrible.
There's a lot of terrible there in his hitting profile, and I'm not confident he's going
to be even a.
decent major league hitter. It'll probably start because the defense is so good, but I'm skeptical. I'm
skeptical that Pete Crowe Armstrong is going to be what we need him to be with the bat. So I'm trying
to fade him a little bit. It's hard for me to justify lowering him beyond 41. But that's my
take removing it, you know, just that's my take in a vacuum on Pete Crow Armstrong, who I will
point out is the real life son from the mom in the movie Little Big League. So that's that's, that's
really cool. Nobody can take that away from Pete Crow Armstrong. Yeah, Tyler Black, man,
he walked 88 times he stole 55 bases. Like, how can you not get excited about that? And it's not like
he was a zero for power. His power is not, it's probably not going to be a big part of his
major league output. But 18 homers and 40, 450 a bat. He's going to be playing in a great
hitters park.
in Milwaukee
and seems like
you know
a lot of people are kind of penciling them in there
at third base for the brewers to open the year
if that happens
you know
I I struggle with
what kind of comp would work here for Tyler Black
it's a weird profile
I kind of want to say Alex Breggman
but Alex Breggman
doesn't run like this and
am I overestimating the power well it's not like
Alex Breggman's power's amazing
He's, you know, 20-25 homer guy.
Could Tyler Black be that?
Sure, he could be that.
So, I don't know.
I mean, it seems like too lofty of a comparison.
Alex Bregman, but with a ton of steals.
I don't know.
I think Tyler Black could be that.
What about Whitmeryfield with walks?
Does that work?
Wooden-Maryfield's better power seasons, yeah.
Yeah.
You know, wouldn't Maryfield approach 20 homers a couple times, right?
Yeah.
I was thinking someone that can, you know,
like 15 homerers, 30 steals, if everything works out, right?
Again, these are lofty projections, but 15 homers, 30 steals with a solid batting average and
good OBP? Sure. That's, that's, yeah, I mean, the one thing I might quibble on when you look
into the profile is just a lot of infield fly balls. And it seems like there's not very much
raw power here. So that there's good contact profile, great plate discipline, you know, you read the
scouting reports. That all shows up, but it might be a case where in order to maximize the
endgame power, and it might be worth the tradeoff, he's got to, you know, swing from the hips
and get under the ball in a way that might make it more difficult for him to be more than like a
265 hitter at the major league level. But if he could hit 265 and he could hit 15 homers and
neither of those is, I think, a ceiling outcome for him, although, right, you know, I think
25 is probably asking an awful lot from this profile,
but like 15-ish,
if he can do that and steal 30 bases,
that gets to be a pretty intriguing skill set.
You know what Alex Bregman's batting averages
over the last four years?
It's like 260ish, yeah.
Yeah, 261.
I really don't think it's a crazy comparison.
Yeah, I mean, honestly.
You're comparing him to Alex Bregman who hit 41 home runs,
then yeah, but Bregman hasn't been that in a long time.
Anthony Volpe might not be a bad comp with more speed, maybe less power, but more speed.
Yeah, that might be like the higher probability outcome.
You're hoping for more than a 209 average.
Yeah, again, that's Tyler Black that we're talking about.
He has played first base, second base, third base center field in the minor leagues.
If we're just talking about eligibility, has third base on CBS.
Yes. Obviously he can gain more.
People seem to be excited.
If you look at the ADP over the past month,
3.45 for Tyler Black.
He's going just ahead of names like Brett Beatty and Colt Keith.
So that's not nothing.
I think people are pretty excited about him.
And one other, I guess, feather in the cap for the power of Tyler Black
is that Milwaukee, now American Family Field,
Miller Park was cooler.
They rank 8th over the past three years in home run park factors.
So it's a pretty good ballpark for power as well.
I see people in the comments in the chat
asking about other prospects.
Mason Wynn, Thomas Sejisi,
Colt Keith.
All of those prospects are also on Scott's top 100 prospects list.
So again, I highly recommend checking it out
and reading what Scott has to say about those players
and a potential timeline of when we might see them here in 2024.
We are going to wrap there for Scott and Chris.
I am Frank.
Thanks as always for tuning in to Fentasy Baseball
today. Please make sure to follow and leave a five-star rating on Apple or Spotify, and we'll be back again on
Wednesday.
Bye-bye.
