Feel Better, Live More with Dr Rangan Chatterjee - The New Science of Awe & How It Improves Your Physical & Mental Wellbeing with Dr Dacher Keltner #340

Episode Date: March 1, 2023

When was the last time you felt awe? Perhaps it’s an emotion you notice often, evoked by the trees, clouds, or people around you. Or maybe it’s something you associate with more dramatic, less fre...quent experiences. Dr Dacher Keltner, has written a sublime book on the subject of awe. It’s called Awe: The New Science of Everyday Wonder and How It Can Transform Your Life and in it he proposes that awe is an emotion that’s all around us, waiting to be discovered – and in doing so, we can transform our health and lives for the better. Dacher is one of the world’s foremost emotion scientists and Professor of Psychology at the University of California. He’s also Director of the Greater Good Science Center, which studies the psychology, sociology, and neuroscience of happiness and wellbeing. He has spent decades studying the science of happiness and believes that across the world, we are collectively having a moment of reflection and looking for more meaning. In this conversation, Dacher defines awe as our response to powerful things that are obscure, vast, and mysterious. They’re beyond our frame of reference, making us feel small and filling us with wonder. But you don’t have to go to the Grand Canyon or see the Northern Lights to find them. Having studied people’s understanding and experience of awe in 26 different countries, he’s found eight types that are common and easily available to us all. They include nature, music, moral beauty (noticing others’ kindness), birth and death, and my favourite ‘collective effervescence’. This is that feeling of coming together with others, moving as one, and sharing the same consciousness – you may have experienced it in a sports stadium, at a music concert, on a dancefloor, in worship, in a choir, or even at parkrun. We spoke in depth about how birth and death are strong triggers for awe, sharing our own painful yet precious experiences of watching close relatives die. We also considered how awe reduces the ego and makes you humble. And how having a regular practice of contemplation, like meditation or breathwork, can open us up to easily noticing and benefitting from everyday awe. I truly believe that Dacher’s work can help all of us find greater meaning and greater health. He’s done a fantastic job of finding the science to support his words, but I think we also know intuitively that what he says makes perfect sense. This was a wonderful and deeply profound conversation that contains science, storytelling, raw emotion and so much more. Support the podcast and enjoy Ad-Free episodes. Try FREE for 7 days on Apple Podcasts https://apple.co/feelbetterlivemore. For other podcast platforms go to https://fblm.supercast.com. Thanks to our sponsors: https://www.athleticgreens.com/livemore https://www.vivobarefoot.com/livemore Show notes https://drchatterjee.com/340 DISCLAIMER: The content in the podcast and on this webpage is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your doctor or qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have heard on the podcast or on my website.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 A lot of the health challenges come out of this internal individual focus that has just blown up today. And awe moves us outside of ourselves. Finding some sense of what is beyond transactional values and money and the like matters for your life expectancy. Hey guys, how you doing? Hope you're having a good week so far. My name is Dr. Rangan Chatterjee and this is my podcast, Feel Better, Live More. When was the last time you felt awe? Perhaps it's an emotion you notice often, evoked by the trees, clouds, or people around you. Or maybe it's something you associate with more dramatic, less frequent experiences. Well, my guest today,
Starting point is 00:00:46 Dr. Daka Keltner, has just published a sublime book on the subject. It's called Awe, The New Science of Everyday Wonder and How It Can Transform Your Life. And in it, he proposes that awe is an emotion that's all around us, waiting to be discovered, and that in doing so so we can transform our health and our lives for the better. Now Dacca is one of the world's foremost emotion scientists and professor of psychology at the University of California. He's also director of the Greater Good Science Center which studies the psychology, sociology and neuroscience of well-being, he has spent decades researching the science of happiness and believes that across the
Starting point is 00:01:32 world we are collectively having a moment of reflection and looking for more meaning. Now in our conversation, DACA defines awe as our response to powerful things that are obscure, vast and mysterious. They're beyond our frame of reference, making us feel small and filling us with wonder. But you don't have to go to the Grand Canyon or see the Northern Lights to find them. Having studied people's understanding and experience of awe in 26 different countries, people's understanding and experience of all in 26 different countries. He's found eight types, which are common and easily available to us all. They, of course, include nature, but also music, moral beauty, birth and death, and one of my favorites, collective effervescence, that feeling of coming together with others, moving as one, and sharing
Starting point is 00:02:25 the same consciousness as you may have experienced in a sports stadium, at a music concert, on a dance floor, in a choir, or even at parkrun. As to the benefits of all, from calming inflammation to activating the vagus nerve, deactivating our brain's stress center to reducing our perception of pain. These awe experiences are buffers for many modern health conditions that we simply cannot afford to miss. We also spoke in depth about how birth and death are strong triggers for awe, sharing our own painful yet precious experiences of watching close relatives die. We also discussed how awe reduces the ego and makes us more humble and how having a regular practice of contemplation like meditation or breath work can open us up to easily noticing
Starting point is 00:03:20 and benefiting from everyday awe. I truly believe that Dacca's work can help us all find greater meaning and greater health. He's done a fantastic job of finding the science to support his words, but I think we all know intuitively that what he's saying makes perfect sense. This really was a wonderful and deeply profound conversation. It contains science, storytelling, raw emotion, and so much more. I hope you enjoy listening. And now, me in conversation with Dr. Daka Keltner. you have been researching lecturing teaching happiness for many many years now as things stand in 2023 how do you think about happiness
Starting point is 00:04:16 that's a terrific question you know um people have been thinking about happiness for millennia and since we started thinking about the human condition, one of the first questions that always arises is, what's the point of this? Why am I happy? What makes me happy? And I started teaching it 25 years ago at UC Berkeley and then online and tens of thousands of people.
Starting point is 00:04:38 And I think that at the time, we were in the middle of this era that is really an era of, you know, economic expansion and weren't really aware of the climate crises. And happiness was really about individual purpose, individual pleasure. How do I experience pleasure dining out or gardening and so forth? And I think right now, Rangan, to answer your question, I think given the times, people are looking for new ideas about happiness. And as a result, you know, people think about happiness in terms of emotions like gratitude, social connections, pleasures. And now there's this new concept of meaning right like do i understand the purpose of my life and how do i enact it so i think about happiness right now as the quest for meaning
Starting point is 00:05:34 this idea that this quest for meaning i went to india in december and I hadn't been back for quite a long time. And as a kid, because my parents are Indian immigrants to the UK, we used to go every other summer for six weeks and play with our family and our cousins. And they were happy times, but I haven't been for a number of years now. And I went in December. And a couple of things you just said there really speaks to me, Daka, which is, you mentioned economics and how does that play a role in happiness. But you mentioned also meaning, and I'm drawn to the story of the doorman at my auntie's place. I remember when the taxi from the airport pulled up and I smiled and said hi, and he directed me and I would chat to him for the next few days whenever I was going for a walk.
Starting point is 00:06:30 And he's someone who doesn't have that much economically, certainly when you compare it to the West, but he had a job. He seemed to enjoy his job. He knew what his role was, where he fit in. And I got to know him over those few days. And then occasionally he'd be at the tea stall opposite the gate, which is, you know, these are very, it's a rich part of the kind of experience in the city called Kolkata, used to be called Calcutta. And, you know, every now and again, he'd be there with these little clay teapots. He would just be chewing the fat with his buddies and smiling. And there was real simplicity. And I don't want to speak for him in terms of how happy he really was.
Starting point is 00:07:18 But he certainly struck me as someone who was happy. So we didn't have much materialistically. Yeah. Right. But I think meaning, I think he knew what his meaning was. Does anything in that speak to you? Oh, that's 20 years of, I believe, to be the most important discoveries in the science of happiness, which is, you know, early on, we started to ask questions like, how much does money really matter?
Starting point is 00:07:41 And, you know, 20 years ago, 30 years ago, you ask somebody in the UK or the United States and they're like, the point of life is to make money and to expand my wealth. And it turns out, as your doorman reveals, the money matters a little, it matters for really poor people, but not that much. It's not as big a contributor to, well, happiness as you might imagine, as we think.
Starting point is 00:08:05 What matters is social connections being embedded in a culture or a community that you feel part of, like your doorman and your example illustrates. And, you know, one of my favorite findings in the happiness literature is that social connectedness gives you 10 years of life expectancy. It just is good for your body, right? And as a result of these discoveries of like money doesn't matter as much, the more I commute, the less happy I get, right? I buy the nicer home and now I'm commuting 40 minutes each way like a lot of people do. It undermines my happiness. like a lot of people do, undermines my happiness. The pressure on high school students or teenagers to find materialism doesn't bring them happiness. It undermines their happiness. And so as a result, we're looking to other examples, like your doorman's example of like, what is it about
Starting point is 00:09:02 his sense of his place in the world, his interactions on a daily basis that gives him happiness? And I think that's a future of the field. Do you think the commonest misconception then about happiness is money, economics, that we need more money to be happier? And I'm very conscious, Daka, as we discuss this, across the world, many people are feeling the pinch. I know, I know. There's a cost of living crisis. You know, we're coming in the UK, we're still in winter,
Starting point is 00:09:35 we're coming out of winter. There's certainly the early sense that spring's on its way, right? But people have struggled. Yeah, no, I know. So if anyone's pushing back and going, yeah, easy for you to say. No, I know. Right? Absolutely. But I'm struggling to pay my bills. How do you approach that with them?
Starting point is 00:09:53 Well, I always say, and this is in the empirical literature, that money matters a lot if you don't have it. And if you get an extra hundred pounds a month, it means paying food bills feels different. It means giving your kids some new, you know, football shoes is different. So money matters if you're poor. And in the United States, one in six people are below poverty and money matters enormously. And when, you know, policies in Biden's administration led to more money for the poor recently, their life expectancy was boosted, right? And immediately things were changed. So money matters for the poor, but for a lot of people, it doesn't matter as much as they think, right?
Starting point is 00:10:34 Life expectancy has come up a couple of times. You mentioned the relationship between loneliness and life expectancy. You just mentioned now how economics can play a role in life expectancy. And I know from some recent data that it does appear that in the US and maybe in some other countries, life expectancy is starting to go down. It's mind-blowing. So what's the relationship between happiness,
Starting point is 00:11:00 the things that we could do to create more happiness, the things we're not doing, right? Which is why many of us I feel don't feel happy and content these days. What's the relationship between that and our lifespan, would you say? Yeah, Rangan, I have been privileged to teach this science of happiness,
Starting point is 00:11:18 of gratitude and compassion and forgiveness and laughter and pleasures and meditation to really skeptical audiences, including one you're familiar with, medical doctors. 25 years ago, and they'd look at me and like, who's this long-haired guy from Berkeley? I don't believe this. And I always led with life expectancy findings.
Starting point is 00:11:37 And there are two lessons there. One is practicing gratitude, getting outdoors for a walk, giving, serving, giving to charity, matters for your life expectancy. The big reviews suggest the more happiness you cultivate, it's about 200 studies, you get about seven or eight years of additional life expectancy, social connection 10 years.
Starting point is 00:12:02 That is comparable to smoking, drinking vodka, and eating red meat, right? And a lot of people ask me, well, if I get happy when I smoke and drink vodka and eat red meat, does it wash out? But it's really important. And then the second thing that's really exciting for me as a scientist is we're starting to understand the neurophysiological pathways of that, right? So, you know, if I feel awe, for example, it activates the vagus nerve, it calms inflammation, it helps my heart, it deactivates stress regions of the brain, the amygdala. So we're starting to get a picture, really clear picture of how finding happiness is good for your body.
Starting point is 00:12:47 And I'm really excited about, that's why Vivek Murthy, our Surgeon General, he's the first Surgeon General, most important medical doctor in the United States to say, this has to be our new set of initiatives. Yeah, I spoke to Vivek a couple of years ago when his book came out on this podcast and it was a really quite profound conversation with him. You, of course, are in
Starting point is 00:13:09 the UK. You're in my studio at the moment to promote your brand new book, Or the Transformative Power of Everyday Wonder. Now, first of all, it's a sublime book. Thank you. It's really got me reflecting about life, the point of life, where I fit into the web of life. Wow, well put. And I think connecting happiness and the things we've just been talking about to the topic of awe, I've got a line, I've got lots of scribbles in the book, which is a sign that I like a book, right? And I want to read this to you. You wrote, awe occurs in a realm separate from the mundane world of materialism, money, acquisition, and status signaling, a realm beyond the profane that many call the sacred yeah
Starting point is 00:14:06 it kind of relates to what we've just been talking about that happiness or what does not make us happy yeah yeah you know um a lot of attention in the field of happiness was interested in this transactional world right how do i do better at work? Or how does money influence my wellbeing? How do I enjoy a good wine, et cetera? Although that can be sublime. But there is this space that scientists had been hesitant to study of, and even to use the words like sacred, sublime,
Starting point is 00:14:40 spirit even, where this is a world where we feel connected to, as you nicely put it, Rangan, you know, the web of life, the larger systems we're part of. And that's what awe is about. It's about sort of pointing us to these big areas of meaning like tending to people who are suffering or redressing injustice or finding beauty or finding my point in life
Starting point is 00:15:08 and finding some sense of what is beyond transactional values and money and the like of the sacred. And so I used, I'm glad you brought up that language because I was trying to stir our culture to think like, we're in this moment of reflection worldwide with climate crises and democracy and, you know, the pinch that a lot of people are feeling, falling life expectancies in the United States. So let's get back to what really matters and what you intuitively would say, that's sacred. For me, it really calls to mind like backpacking with my daughters, getting out in the woods and having those conversations with friends
Starting point is 00:15:53 that your doorman has that you can't put a price to. Yeah. How do you define awe? Yeah, that was hard. And there are centuries of efforts to define awe. But I really was inspired by this great Irish philosopher, Edmund Burke, who wrote a revolutionary book when he was 27. And he said, awe is about powerful things that are obscure, that you can't make out, right? And I then relied on contemporary psychological science to say, just intuitively, awe is vast.
Starting point is 00:16:32 It's like you encounter something that's beyond your frame of reference and mysterious. I love the word mystery in the definition. Like, I can't figure out why a young student would give away all their money to help an unhoused person eat, which I just saw a few days ago in Berkeley, California. So it's encounters with vast mystery. And it's an emotion we feel in the moment.
Starting point is 00:16:55 Aw. Descartes felt it was a basic state of mind that then unleashes wonder and generosity and curiosity. You say it's an emotion. When your book first arrived, I sat with this idea. I thought, do I think awe is an emotion or would I have initially thought it was an experience? Yeah, yeah. And then I thought, is it even important?
Starting point is 00:17:24 Does it even matter whether we call it an experience or an emotion? So why do you say the awe is an emotion? Yeah, I say it's an emotion because there's this great tradition that continues to this day of, you know, the philosopher David Hume and Adam Smith and some of the East Asian traditions, the Hinduism and Tibetan Buddhism, who really feel, and contemporary studies of consciousness like Mark Solms, that the mind and how we experience the world, when you move through the day and you're like, what does the world mean to me? The meaning is found in our emotions or subjective feelings, like you said, Rangan. Like I feel awe about this,
Starting point is 00:18:05 or I feel anger or fear. Those are basic states of the mind in our relation to the world. And we have a rich scientific tradition beginning with Darwin to understand the emotions with lots of tools of science that are in the book. Nervous system and expression and the like. with lots of tools of science that are in the book. Nervous system and expression and the like. I mean, we'll get to some of those scientific benefits or scientific discoveries that you found when trying to study this. But one idea that I've really enjoyed reading about,
Starting point is 00:18:36 I've heard some of your other interviews. Yeah. But also something I'm thinking deeply about and writing about at the moment is, like, are we as a society getting bogged down too much with what does the science say here? Right. And I love the fact that it's quite hard to define awe, that we can't give it a precise definition. I kind of love that because I think, would it not be boring if everything full of wonder in life, we can clearly articulate this is what is going on. Do you know what I mean?
Starting point is 00:19:13 Fundamental. Yeah. And I think, as I say, I love the fact that we can't define it. Yeah. And I have to tell you, Rangan, I mean, when I started writing this book, we had tons of data and great papers, building on this definition of Oz, of vast mystery. And I, like you, I was like, it's still, it doesn't capture the essence of this experience, which I believe, like Einstein, is the fundamental experience. And so, frankly, what I had to do, which was unusual for me as a lab scientist, is go gather stories, you know, and go to prisons and talk to ministers. I'm not a religious person. I'm like, oh my God, you know, and talk to, you know, activists and environmentalists
Starting point is 00:20:00 and veterans, just like, and also gather stories from 26 countries like write about it and i think i think with the stories in the book we get a little closer yeah but but we're still not it's always a mystery and i think we should embrace that yes i think we should embrace that you know one thing like i'm a medical doctor right and for well since 2008 I was practicing general practice. And one of the big differences between general practice and specialism, for me at least, was that we as GPs have to get really good at sitting with uncertainty, right? You know, a lot of time we have a small amount of time. We don't have access to all the
Starting point is 00:20:46 tests that maybe the hospital colleagues have. And so we have to manage uncertainty. And I thought this is a fundamental difference because in the hospital, you might be able to investigate, do this test, have a lot more certainty. And I think, of course, humans like certainty, but I think there's something about being able to sit with uncertainty. I mean, one of the eye-opening things to me when reading your book was you've really broadened out my definition or my perception of what awe is. Honestly, like if someone had said to me before reading your book, when do you experience awe?
Starting point is 00:21:24 I probably would have said in nature. Yeah, yeah. Right? And I don't know what your experience has been going around the world talking about this, but you show that yes, nature is one way to experience awe, but there's eight ways that you've defined. So I came to the conclusion that, oh wow, awe is around me every single day and possibly every single interaction if I can train myself to see it.
Starting point is 00:21:51 Yeah, yeah. Yeah, you know, thank you for bringing into focus. I think the two biggest surprises that blew my mind, you know, we, I too, like, awe is nature, you know, we're Western European. Then I thought, ah, I know the spiritual traditions, awe is spirituality and mysticism. And so we gather these stories from 26 countries, from Mexico to India, to the UK, to Poland, et cetera, all over the world. And awe comes to us through eight paths, which I call the eight wonders. And I'll just quickly, the moral beauty of people, their kindness and courage.
Starting point is 00:22:31 I teach medical doctors. And once they think about this, they think, wow, I just gave a patient a terminal diagnosis. And they held my hand and said, thank you for what you do. That's moral courage and beauty. Nature, collective movement. And what I love about this is like sports fans, like Arsenal fans, they're like, I love sports are almost spiritual and that's because of awe. And then you get to the culture ones, which are music, visual design, and spirituality. And then the two, Rangan, that really caught me off guard, And the two, Rangan, that really caught me off guard,
Starting point is 00:23:07 epiphanies, big ideas, like, you know, wow, the web of life, your phrase, that's the central idea in evolution, right? That Darwin was blown off the map by. We're all part of this, what he called a tangled bank of life. We're all interacting different species. And then the final one, life and death. Rangan, when I started
Starting point is 00:23:27 teaching awe eight, 10 years ago to audiences with people over the age of 55, there would always be a hand that would raise and the person would say, I felt awe holding my sister's hand when she died. And just looking at that mystery, feeling it. And so lo and behold around the world, we really get into a state of awe thinking about life and death. If someone's listening to this at the moment, Daka or watching it, this conversation we're having,
Starting point is 00:24:03 I think this is all really interesting. Sure. You know, it's interesting for me to learn about all, but I'm busy. I got stuff going on in my life. Why does all matter to me? How do you respond? Yeah. You know, I, teaching happiness for 30 years to every imaginable audience, that's often the question, right? Rightfully so. And it gets more poignant. You know, every time I teach a large group of people about happiness, I'll have a mom come to me, especially post-pandemic. And they're like, you know, my 17 year old son is in real deep distress. And what do I do? And I turn to the science of happiness and I say,
Starting point is 00:24:51 man, find some social connections, get them outdoors, you know, give them a way to find meaning or reflect on life. And now awe, you know, the science that I, the health science and the, you know, awe helps your immune system reducing inflammation, helps your cardiovascular system, activates vagal tone, reduces activation in the amygdala, a threat-related region in the brain, helps you think more clearly and more creatively, makes you feel like you have less stress in life. For 75 years old and older, it makes you feel less physical pain, right? I could go on. I mean, these are all studies where five minutes of awe, and I love your phrase of like, hey, wait a minute, maybe it's around me a lot. Five minutes gives you that suite of benefits
Starting point is 00:25:41 that I think are comparable to anything you can do. No kidding. And we didn't know that. And now it's starting to spread, right? Just to be thinking about where are those five minutes of awe? Yeah. I love that answer. Well, you're a medical doctor. Yeah. And that's what matters, you know? I'm a medical doctor, but I'd also describe myself as a curious human, which doesn't always fit with medicine sometimes, particularly with the way we're often encouraged to practice it these days. And if I think about the common problems that exist medically, a lot of them are related to inflammation, the immune system, stress,
Starting point is 00:26:28 the amygdala, the threat response part of the brain being overactive. And you have just explained that awe can buffer us against those, can be an antidote to many of the problems and things that we're suffering from in the modern world. So I agree with you. Awe is critical. And as I say, and this is something I hope we get to more and more throughout this conversation, it reminds me a little bit of gratitude, not in terms of awe being the same as gratitude, although I'm interested in your thoughts on that or what the crossover is. More that if you don't practice it, you don't see where it is. You can go through opportunities.
Starting point is 00:27:11 You can go through situations in life and not see the gratitude. And one of the questions I had around awe, Daka, is let's say the Grand Canyon, right? You could put 10 people, 10 different people in the Grand Canyon, right? You could put 10 people, 10 different people in the Grand Canyon, right? And yes, you would hope that everyone would feel awe, but some people possibly wouldn't, right? So it's not the environment that is creating the awe, it's our approach to the environment, right?
Starting point is 00:27:45 Yeah, that's so important, Rangan, to bring this into our focus here. And I think there are wonderful insights to be gleaned from those eight wonders of life we talked about. You know, we started to find, if you ask people like, where do you tear up and get the goosebumps
Starting point is 00:28:03 and cry and feel awe and wonder and and humans are remarkably varying it's just a fundamental truth about who we are and for some people it's busy cities in the stream of pedestrians and other people it is sitting by trees by themselves in the quiet and for for some people, it's classical music. And for other people, Michael Pollan just, you know, when he interviewed me, he's like, I was just at a Pussy Riot show and I felt awe, you know, punk rock.
Starting point is 00:28:33 For some people, it's wild art. For other people, it's still lives, right? We're all varying. And that's one of the mysteries to me of awe is we find it in such unique ways, but also universal ways, right? And music's a great case study of that. And I think our audience should be asking this question of themselves, which is, think of a time when you last got goosebumps and teared up at a piece of music. And most people have had that kind of experience, right? Have you had one?
Starting point is 00:29:11 I have on many occasions in my life. You know, music's a huge part of me. It always has been. And there's this, well, I was listening to it this morning actually there's a there's a song by the augustana singer dan leis called uh call me when you get there i think it's one of the most beautiful songs i've ever heard yeah it's absolutely gorgeous and this idea you know call me when you get there he goes through various verses once it's about you know him as a dad you get there. He goes through various verses. Once it's about
Starting point is 00:29:45 him as a dad and his daughter leaving when she gets to 18. Then it's like him speaking to his partner, maybe when they're 70, 80. It's every time I hear it, I almost feel it. I have cried before listening to it. It makes me think, I can't even imagine my daughter at 18 leaving home. Do you know what I mean? So yeah, I was actually listening to that song this morning. So do I experience it? Yeah, but what's really interesting again is that we may not perceive that as awe.
Starting point is 00:30:19 But now you're saying it, it's like, yes, that is awe. Because what you just portrayed, and this is a story of awe, is the vastness of music, how it projects you across time. It leads you to think about what it's like to be 80. Think about your daughter being an 18-year-old. So that's vast.
Starting point is 00:30:36 It's mysterious how the mind derives meaning in this way from patterns of sound waves. But the striking thing is that's awe for Rangan, right? I haven't even heard that song, but I understand you. And in fact, when you told the story, I got kind of teary thinking about it because stories of awe reveal, to your point, we all have our pathways to awe. And I think the eight wonders are useful useful and we can all understand other people's pathways when cast within this broader framework of what humans find in awe right that i have songs like that that like do the same thing for me in the chapter on music yeah
Starting point is 00:31:18 there was a kind of line that i, really paused on and thought about. Music locates individuals within broader cultural identities. I'd never really thought of music in that way before. But what exactly did you mean by that? God, you know, you're doing a very deep and careful reading, Rangan. That's a hard question, right? So let's take a couple of ideas out there in this new study of music. And the one really comes from this philosopher, Susan Langer, who said that art and music somehow express life patterns, right? So you hear music and you say, this is about beauty or love or courage or failure or justice. You hear Bob Dylan
Starting point is 00:32:19 or hip hop and it's like, that's about justice, right? So the life patterns are contained within music in ways we're just beginning to understand, how they sound and the lyrics and the acoustic structure of the song. And we hear that. And we as individuals, and this is back to meaning, right? We as individuals care about certain things. We care about beauty or justice or transcendent knowledge, whatever it is. And it's contained within music. And then suddenly we hear a song and it moves us and we can't explain why. And we become part of a community, right? That's oriented around those meanings.
Starting point is 00:33:01 When I first went to college, you know, and I grew up for part of my high school years, teenage years in the United States in a really poor rural town near the mountains. And all it was, was like headbanging rock and roll. And I first heard Brian Eno's ambient music and it was slow, quiet. I was like, I had profound awe because it taught me like, there's this meditative, reflective world that this music contains that I could be part of. So it connects us to communities of meaning. I mean, in terms of take-homes for the audience, these are not just theoretical ideas. These are ideas that we can practice and take part in immediately because I cannot believe that there's anyone listening right now who has not connected with music at some point in their life. full of stress. Maybe they're low mood. Maybe they're rushing around the entire time. They don't feel they have any time for themselves. But what if that part of our conversation
Starting point is 00:34:10 encourages someone to go, you know what? I've not heard that album in a while. I've not heard that song that I heard when I was 16 and it really made me feel like this. If they then go and download that song or, you know, if you're a bit old school like me take the cd out or whatever and re-listen yeah that's all that can have all kinds of benefits can't it just that connection again to that visceral emotion and thank you for reminding us of how accessible and powerful music is and and its revelation of awe um During the pandemic, 30% rise in depression and anxiety worldwide. I got called by Spotify. And they were like, oh, there's this awe scientist at Berkeley.
Starting point is 00:34:54 And they said, you know, it's interesting. We're studying people's listening patterns during this really hard, isolated time. And people were listening to music. Like you're saying, Rangan, like what's the music that makes me tear up and makes me feel like this is why I'm here? And they were listening for that, for awe in the music. You know, I recently went through a really hard time in life with my brother passing. And one of the things I did is exactly what you suggested. You know, I was stressed and not sleeping and in grief thinking about my brother I was close to
Starting point is 00:35:31 and I was like, I got 10 minutes a day. I'm gonna find the music that just sustains me, you know? And it was certain songs by the Beatles and Sufjan Stevens, who's got this kind of spirituality to his music and Brian Eno's Ambient, you know, and whatever offshoots. And I would encourage our listeners, you know, awe sounds sublime and ineffable or hard to find. It's very easy to find. Listen to music for awe. What gives you rushes of goosebumps? And that will bring you benefits.
Starting point is 00:36:08 gives you rushes of goosebumps and that will bring you benefits. The goosebumps don't have to be just positive and happy, do they? No, no. You can even listen to someone in pain and misery. Yeah. You know, what do they say? Sadness can often breed the sweetest songs. Yeah. We can listen to that and connect to a pain, but it still has benefits, right? Totally. And this was, you know, thank you for bringing this up, Prangan. Awe is a complicated emotion. It's a mysterious emotion. It's hard to define. And one of the, you know, when I gathered these stories of awe in the book, so many of them were about struggle and suffering and pain, you. So, Lewis Scott, a prisoner who's a friend, I used to visit him, still visit him, trying to figure out how do you
Starting point is 00:36:51 bring beauty into a prison? Stacey Bear, a veteran, finding awe out of the trauma of combat. And then a lot of people who watch other people pass away or get sick or medical care providers are like, there is wonder and awe in tending to suffering, right? Yeah. And that astounds me about awe is it emerges out of grappling with hardship very often and inspires the mind to be like, how can I make things a little better, right? What can I do to build community here? The chapter you wrote on life and death really was very moving. I was reading it in bed last night
Starting point is 00:37:36 and I thought we could probably do the whole two hour conversation just on death. It was that powerful. I definitely wanna come to that shortly just to sort of maybe tie up music. Again, that's a powerful chapter just on music. But one of my favorite chapters was the one a little bit earlier on collective effervescence. One of my favorite terms, I discovered it a couple of years ago. There's a New York Times article
Starting point is 00:38:03 on collective effervescence. Yeah, that's a foot and I shared it a couple of years ago. There's a New York Times article on collective effervescence. Really? Cool. Yeah. And I shared it on my newsletter and I thought, wow, what a cool term. I'd never heard of that before. And then when I open up your book and it's like, oh, you've written a chapter on this. So perhaps you could explain what that is. It's one of those categories of awe. What is it? How can people experience it? And why is it so beneficial? Just taking a quick break to give a shout out to AG1, one of the sponsors of today's show.
Starting point is 00:38:43 Now, if you're looking for something at this time of year to kickstart your health, I'd highly recommend that you consider AG1. AG1 has been in my own life for over five years now. It's a science-driven daily health drink with over 70 essential nutrients to support your overall health. It contains vitamin C and zinc, which helps support a healthy immune system, something that is really important, especially at this time of year. It also contains prebiotics and digestive enzymes that help support your gut health. All of this goodness comes in one convenient daily serving that makes it really easy to fit into your life, no matter how busy you feel. It's also really, really tasty.
Starting point is 00:39:34 The scientific team behind AG1 includes experts from a broad range of fields, including longevity, preventive medicine, genetics, and biochemistry. I talk to them regularly, and I'm really impressed with their commitment to making a top quality product. Until the end of January, AG1 are giving a limited time offer. Usually, they offer my listeners a one-year supply of vitamin D and K2, and five free travel packs with their first order. But until the end of January, they are doubling the five free travel packs to 10.
Starting point is 00:40:12 And these packs are perfect for keeping in your backpack, office, or car. If you want to take advantage of this limited time offer, all you have to do is go to drinkag1.com forward slash live more. That's drinkag1.com forward slash live more. Thank you for calling attention to that. It was something that emerged in our studies, very hard to study scientifically, collective effervescence, but it emerged as just a surprising way to find awe.
Starting point is 00:40:55 That is a term that the French sociologist Emile Durkheim coined when he was trying to figure out, like William James did and others, what is the core subjective feeling of religion? And he called it collective effervescence. And it's when you start moving in unison or you're synchronizing your movements. Think of a ritual in a church, clapping, cheering at a football game, dancing together, doing rituals before a basketball game, collective movement. Then you start to realize collective movement
Starting point is 00:41:32 makes you have a shared consciousness. So you're all thinking about the same thing. The religious figure leading the ritual, the soccer, the football players on the pitch, the movements at a concert, the band singing and you're all cheering, a political speech, right? And then emotion starts taking over where, you know, and the feeling, I'm going to ask you in a second, Rangan, tell us about a collective effervescence experience, because it's profound where people are like, I got this rush of chills. I was crying. I was
Starting point is 00:42:07 almost ecstatic. I was feeling like I was one with everybody around me. And that's collective effervescence, which is movement, attention, shared attention, and then this electric feeling that moves over you that makes you feel like you're united. So tell me, do you have a collective effervescence? Yeah, I do. But I'm also realizing in my life currently that I don't really engage in collective effervescence in the way that I used to. Yeah. Right? So that was one of the powerful things to me about your book is it really made me reflect on, wow, I used to go to, I've probably been to thousands of gigs in my life. Seriously?
Starting point is 00:42:54 Yeah. I'm a musician. I have always sung, played multiple instruments. I was so into rock as a teenager. Yeah. I've been to so many concerts and the first image that comes up is being at a big stadium rock concert and the drums start playing and everyone's clapping. But it doesn't matter who the people around you are. It doesn't matter their political persuasion.
Starting point is 00:43:20 It doesn't matter what they're tweeting about, frankly. Social media didn't exist back then, thankfully. And you all come together. You're all there and having a shared experience. It's astonishing. Yeah. So concert, you know, I used to, again, be very much into football or soccer. I'm not anymore, actually. I've fallen out of love with it for a variety of reasons. But I used to be obsessive. and I was at the Champions League final in 2005 where Liverpool came back from 3-0 down to win the Champions League on penalty shootout for the first time.
Starting point is 00:43:54 And I remember the feeling in the stadium, the feeling in the plane on the way home. We all felt as though we were floating on air from being part of that communal experience. So, I mean, those are two things that come to mind, but I would definitely say that there's a deficiency of collective effervescence in my life at the moment. Yeah. Well, parenting and, you know, as you head into the middle of life can do that to you. And collective effervescence is really for the young people
Starting point is 00:44:20 finding their place in culture. But to your question, you know, one of the amazing things about thinking about these as contexts of awe, which they are, is this allows us to find the deeper meaning in these wonderful venues. Like people, there are studies that suggest like, you know, your football team is almost on par with a church. It gives you that much meaning and sense of community and sense of history, right?
Starting point is 00:44:49 Following music and going to musical venues. I love the work in spontaneous forms of collective effervescence that people observe, like pedestrians moving through streets and being at festivals or farmer's markets, right? You start to sense like, wow. I was just with my daughter, Natalie, at a farmer's market, what we call a farmer's market in the United States. It was on this really wonderful area in this wonderful area in London.
Starting point is 00:45:20 And it felt there was collective effervescence. We were all moving together, getting the street Indian food, sharing it in a park, right? That was awesome. And so this framework of awe starts to allow us to see the richness of these common venues of awe that we can enjoy. Have you heard of Park Run? No. Park Run, while you're in the UK, I'd encourage you to look it up and check it out. Maybe even participate in one. It's a phenomenal movement that is transforming lives. Nice. I don't know how many,
Starting point is 00:45:54 there's probably hundreds and thousands now in the UK and around the world. It's basically every Saturday morning, local to you in a park, there is a five kilometer, it's not a race, It's a 5k event. And people come together in communities and they complete 5k, right? Some people are running it. They're trying to run really fast. Other people are walking it at the back and they have a philosophy. You know, no one comes last. There's always a tail walker and people can come and volunteer. And I've had patients in the past who just the
Starting point is 00:46:31 volunteering helped them massively reduce their depression. Sometimes completely get rid of it. Incredible. So I think I never really thought about park run through the lens of collective effervescence, but it is, right? Yeah. I mean, you know, the Greek Olympics began with like parkruns where people ran together. It's about moving in unison together. So why is it awe? So why does going to a parkrun for many people give them a sense of awe? Terrific question. And that's, you know, we've mulled over that for 15 years, right? And it won't give everybody awe, but for the person who realizes this is striking, think about this movement of parkrun and how many people are involved in it and how we move together. And suddenly you have the sense of how mysterious it is that this brings me this kind of joy, how vast it is and the people involved, right?
Starting point is 00:47:27 And that's very typical of collective effervescence. A couple of examples that have come to me in doing this work, one is singing together. There are all these singing groups out there. And when I give talks on all, someone always comes up with tears in their eyes, like, you've gotta study choirs because it's all collective effervescence, right? And, you know, a lot of the, it's interesting, a lot of the informal sort of help your body movements like yoga.
Starting point is 00:47:58 20 million people practice yoga in the United States. And a lot of it's collective effervescence. You're doing motions together. Your attention is shared. And you start to feel this joy. Yeah. I really appreciate you sharing that. One of the things that I've been, I guess, concerned with a little bit for a while, and I've just come back from the Middle East where I was giving a few talks and, you know, a lot of people are struggling to find that sense of community and one of the things i said literally a few days ago at one of my talks was look what do you like doing okay someone said yoga i said okay you like yoga one of the big problems
Starting point is 00:48:38 over the last years is that because of some of the restrictions yeah restrictions that have taken place over the past few years, a lot of this stuff has gone online. So sure, let's take yoga as an example. For many people, a phenomenal practice that helps them physically, mentally, emotionally, for sure. And a lot of people now in our bid to save time and be more efficient, right? We go on the Zoom class. We do a 10, 15 minute YouTube video. And again, that can have a role. But I say, listen, if that's you, sign up for a class as well. Do 10 minutes a day on YouTube. Sure. That's great. But make sure once a week you sign up and you go to the class because you're going to meet other like-minded people. That's going to help. You know, that's one of the tips I give people that are struggling with loneliness is what are you,
Starting point is 00:49:33 you know, what hobby do you have? What passion do you like? Is there a local class? Go there, you'll meet other people like you. Right. So what is your view on that? You know, in respect to what we've been talking about so far, loneliness, we're struggling to be happy. on that, you know, in respect to what we've been talking about so far, loneliness, we're struggling to be happy. We, you know, or it's a very clear message throughout your book that one of the powerful qualities of awe is that it takes us outside of ourselves to something much bigger and greater. Right. And, you know, if you're depressed, that's what you need. You're stuck inside yourself thinking, again, I say that with compassion. I'm definitely not being critical. I'm saying we need to help people get outside themselves. Yeah. Wow. What a profound observation. And
Starting point is 00:50:18 you've just spoken to a very important empirical question. Does solitary activity on Zoom compare to collective activity of the same thing? We know in the education world, it does not. And Zoom classrooms for most people are a disaster. You need the collective mind and so forth. Yeah, I love your recommendation, Rangan. I mean, Jane Goodall, awe, she thought in chimpanzees.
Starting point is 00:50:47 It is the beginning of our sense of spirit because it allows us to be amazed at things outside of ourself. And the central challenge of the mental health crises of today is too much self-focus. Yeah. And we're not gonna find awe with Zoom and smartphones where we're, you know, we got to get with other people. You know, I was with a minister a couple of weeks ago who's in the book, Malcolm Clemens Young, a remarkable mind. And he said, you know,
Starting point is 00:51:19 and I suspect this is true of a lot of the domains that you refer to, you can pray by yourself, but there's something about praying with people who are praying with you together. He said, and there's a lot of spiritual traditions around that, meditating together, playing ping pong with other groups of people, doing dance together, doing yoga together. There is no substitute. And the answer for that is awe, that it makes you realize your collective, like Jane Goodall said, and you said, I'm amazed at things outside of myself.
Starting point is 00:51:54 Another story comes to mind for me as you say that. On the plane home a few days ago, I watched a documentary. I don't know if you've heard of the British band Oasis. Of course. Yeah. So there was a documentary on their kind of iconic concerts in 1996. They played somewhere called Nebworth and, you know, very few bands had ever played there. I think Led Zeppelin had, maybe the Rolling Stones had, but very few bands could pull off playing at such a large venue. And they played for two nights. There were 125,000 people each night, so a quarter of a million people. But what was profound about the documentary was, I think two and a half percent of the UK population tried to get tickets.
Starting point is 00:52:45 two and a half percent of the UK population tried to get tickets. Something happened. There was something going on in the 90s, this sort of hope. You know, they sort of paint the picture in the documentary of what else was going on in culture. And Oasis really seemed to ride on that wave. Two and a half percent of the population tried to get tickets. But what was really interesting is they were showing beautifully how this was pre-internet, right? This was pre-mobile phone. So they had images of people on their landlines, teenagers sitting on the stairs on their landlines, pressing the orange redial button, mates trying to get together saying, look, you're going to try and call there, you're going to try and call there, people queuing overnight at the ticket sellers to get their tickets.
Starting point is 00:53:26 And for me, because that was kind of, you know, the sweet spot of where I was into music. And I remember those days with all kinds of bands like queuing for Bruce Springsteen tickets and all this kind of stuff. But what was really powerful was later on, I think Noel Gallagher, the guitar player and songwriter in Oasis said, today, you just wouldn't get that. Today, you'd look out and everyone would be on their phones, trying to capture it, trying to text someone else saying, hey, look, are you here? Trying to show people that I'm here. And he said, it was amazing. And they were interviewing people who were there saying everyone was focused on the same thing. They were all there to see this band at the peak of their powers. No one was distracted. It was just quite incredible.
Starting point is 00:54:12 And it was funny because I was reading your book on the plane preparing for this conversation. And then I watched that documentary. I thought, wow, this is collective effervescence. Yes. Right? This was collective effervescence at a time in the 1990s. And therefore, in relation to what we just said about yoga classes on Zoom, education being done on Zoom, and now the way we experience life with our phones, how problematic is it potentially that we are no longer fully present for moments of awe because we're kind of distracted away from them? Yeah. I think that could be a show and a book, right? And I think
Starting point is 00:54:54 you've just identified one of the critical problems that the new technologies introduce to our lives is they interfere with collective effervescence. I'll give you just a couple of examples. our lives as they interfere with collective effervescence. I'll give you just a couple of examples. Parents go to watch their children sing and perform and dance, and they pop out their cell phones and are filming it. So now your awareness is not collectively on the children, it's distributed across these phones. I was recently at a dance party, you know, really interesting society, and they had a dance party where everybody danced to their own music. And we were in different rhythms, banging into each other. It was ridiculous. And you could go on. And so this sense of shared collective mind so vital to the human
Starting point is 00:55:41 prospect, I think, is imperiled by these kinds of technological quote innovations. But what I will take note of, you know, Rangan, is a lot of our 20-year-olds and 25-year-olds and 30-year-olds feel that viscerally, right? And a lot of collective things are starting to emerge again. And game nights are really popular where you play with actual games with people physically present. Listening to vinyl albums, right, where you get back to that ritual of listening to music together. So it's too strong to take out of our experience, and I think it's coming back.
Starting point is 00:56:20 But critical for us to think about. Given that all that is subjective and we're all going to experience it in different ways and in different environments, let's just stay on technology for a minute. So we've explained that one potential downside of technology in group settings is that it can take us away from experiencing collective effervescence. Yeah. Okay. I think we'd all kind of recognize that. Yes. I'm sure all of us have been to an event at some point where you go, wow, this is quite different from how it used to be. Yeah. But can one experience awe through these smartphones?
Starting point is 00:57:03 Yeah. Well, yeah. By the way, I just have to cite one other experience. I went to go see the Mona Lisa recently, and it used to be where you'd be with a big group of people looking at the painting. And now it's mobs of people taking selfies in front of the Mona Lisa. It's preposterous.
Starting point is 00:57:19 Yeah, I really think, and I don't think, I think it's going to be really hard when you think about those eight wonders to really find awe directly from your smartphone. It's too small. It doesn't have the vastness just visually. What if you were to see an image of the Grand Canyon? Okay, so let's just, we mentioned the Grand Canyon a couple of times, right? So what if on your latest fancy smartphone with whatever high definition technology you're being sold on the latest advert. So in really
Starting point is 00:57:53 sharp focus, you can see everything, right? Why is that not the same kind of awe as if you were there? Because you need, you know, awe, but there's an important optimistic note here. For the full experience of awe, you need the vastness. You know, it just traces back to Edmund Burke, power, bigness, vastness. Think about, you need vastness that, like your example of music, moves you across time. Wow, I remember what it's like to be a child or an adult or holding my mom's hand etc and space and the smartphone can't deliver that like you know just like the difference between being there seeing oasis versus watching the same show on a smartphone but what it can do
Starting point is 00:58:39 for you and i think there's a lot of really interesting work in this is a lot of awe, and this is very encouraging, comes from remembering things, from stories about that experience that we would share. And there's a lot of work on the power of those stories. It's why your story got me tearing up a little. And that the smartphone can do. It can be like, hey, here's a piece of music that brought you off two years ago.
Starting point is 00:59:05 Listen to it in a quiet place. Here's a visual design of a building, Sagrada Familia, that makes you feel awe. And I think good work will happen in that realm. Yeah, because it's not the device itself. It's what you're consuming on it and how you're consuming it. Because as you're saying that, I would like to think, and I'd welcome your perspective on this, that this podcast that many people listen to each week when they're out for walks or they're in their car driving. And I hope that consistently
Starting point is 00:59:36 we have thought-provoking conversations that help people think about their life, their health, their happiness, their place in the world. If someone is consuming that through a smartphone whilst they're walking, I think we can make a case that that could be inspiring all. Totally. And in point of fact, like when you talk to people who love podcasts, like my younger daughter, Serafina, she's like, oh, I listen to it when I'm walking or when I'm out in the woods, right? So you're giving the context of awe. But one of the really exciting things about awe is it's easy to practice. It may not sound like it, but it is. So when I teach healthcare providers, which I do a lot of, one of the things they do is they say, I only have 20 minutes for lunch because as you know,
Starting point is 01:00:27 they work very hard and they're busy, but I'll go sit in the garden. I'll go on a walk with my colleagues when I have this next conversation, or we will share awe stories in a huddle. And you can do this anywhere, right? These are little three to five minute shifts in how we do things, be it eating or sharing a nice quote or an awe story from work that are easy to do and bring us some of the benefits of awe. You've done some studies, I think, on something called an awe walk. Yeah. So tell us about that. And there are thousands of people leading awe walks around the world right now, which makes me really grateful. And there are thousands of people leading awe walks around the world right now, which makes me really grateful.
Starting point is 01:01:12 Yeah, you know, that study begins actually with the great British tradition of walking. And the Brits walk in spectacular ways, you know. And then Rebecca Solnit, a brilliant writer, did this book on wandering and just how much we derive meaning from walking. And she called it, she really talked about it in terms of all, like when you walk, your body is moving through space, but you feel like you're part of the environment, a path, et cetera, and a tradition. And so in our study, we had people who are 75 years old or older, which is an age in the United States where people start to feel more anxious and depressed because people are dying around them.
Starting point is 01:01:49 And so we just, once a week, they went out and did an all walk. And I love this because it's really simple. Go to someplace that's a little mysterious and look at small things like this rock on your table and vast things like your whole studio, right? That's all they did. And they did it once a week for eight weeks we had a nice control condition a vigorous walk condition and our 75 years old participants in the all walk felt less distress they felt more awe over time and we had them take selfies out on the walk and their selfies, the self gets smaller
Starting point is 01:02:26 and starts to fade off to the side and they're taking in more of the environment. So they're just aware of what's, they're amazed at things outside of themselves. And so, you know, you put that together with a lot of the data on just walking outside to find awe is so good for you. And it's easy to do anywhere yeah there's other studies you write about on all kinds of things i think there was one study in the book about how even a very brief experience of awe yeah can make us less narcissistic yeah you know i encourage our audience to do this you know in this study young people a little bit too self-focused this generation of 20 year olds um they're feeling the pain of that narcissism we just have them go out uh in this experiment and
Starting point is 01:03:14 stand up and look at these beautiful trees for one to two minutes one to two minutes one to two minutes got it look at the leaves look at the. Look at how it fades into the sky. And we compared it to a control condition, and they were less narcissistic, less entitled. They needed less money, and they were more altruistic. They helped a stranger nearby. One to two minutes, you know. And what I do, just thinking practically, is like take one minute to look at a sunset. You know, there's a whole cloud society in the UK.
Starting point is 01:03:50 I didn't know about that. Oh yeah, it's a big phenomenon. And it's a wonderful book on cloud spotting. Go look at a cloud for 45 seconds and study its movements. And suddenly you're like, wow, I didn't know they were so dynamic. A little bit of awe and it's easy to get. Well, a couple of things there.
Starting point is 01:04:06 In my second book, which is called The Stress Elysian, I wrote about nature and fractals. And I remember there's a subheading in that chat, where I think I called it staring at a tree. And I basically encouraged- And they didn't laugh at you? I don't think they did. I think I justified it in the book. but I wrote that a few years ago. But
Starting point is 01:04:27 as you're saying that, it reminds me that one of my recommendations was, don't worry if you can't get out in the wild, you can't get out into what you consider nature, just get outside and stare at a tree for a few minutes. And it sounds as though what you're speaking to is saying, yes, you do that and you're going to get all kinds of benefits. Totally. And then awe starts to surface when you're like, like the trees I look at in California, Redwoods, five times as old as I'll ever live.
Starting point is 01:04:54 They have these amazing root systems. They're a family. They're a plant in circles. So this is interesting for me, right? So you can look at the tree. Yeah. You're just looking at it. Maybe you're not thinking about how old it is. That has some benefits. So this is interesting for me, right? So you can look at the tree. You're just looking at it. Maybe
Starting point is 01:05:05 you're not thinking about how old it is. That has some benefits. But what about what you just said, which is if you look at that tree and go, wow, this oak tree has been here for 300 years. Wow. My parents probably saw this. My grandparents, my great grandparents lived through this. It again speaks to this kind of through line, which is it takes us outside of ourselves. It connects us to something much greater than our individualistic, potentially ego-driven existence. So, you know, is it just looking at the tree that's enough or thinking about that tree or do we not know yet? or thinking about that tree or do we not know yet?
Starting point is 01:05:51 Before we get back to this week's episode, I just wanted to let you know that I am doing my very first National UK Theatre Tour. I am planning a really special evening where I share how you can break free from the habits that are holding you back and make meaningful changes in your life that truly last. It is called the Thrive Tour. Be the architect of your health and happiness. So many people tell me that health feels really complicated,
Starting point is 01:06:16 but it really doesn't need to be. In my live event, I'm going to simplify health, and together we're going to learn the skill of happiness, the secrets to optimal health, how to break free from the habits that are holding you back in your life. And I'm going to teach you how to make changes that actually last. Sound good? All you have to do is go to drchatterjee.com forward slash tour. And I can't wait to see you there. This episode is also brought to you by the Three Question Journal, the journal that I designed and created in partnership with Intelligent Change. Now, journaling is something that I've been recommending to my patients for years. It can help improve
Starting point is 01:06:58 sleep, lead to better decision-making, and reduce symptoms of anxiety and depression. better decision making and reduce symptoms of anxiety and depression. It's also been shown to decrease emotional stress, make it easier to turn new behaviours into long-term habits and improve our relationships. There are of course many different ways to journal and as with most things it's important that you find the method that works best for you. One method that you may want to consider is the one that I outline in the three question journal. In it, you will find a really simple and structured way of answering the three most impactful questions I believe that we can all ask ourselves every morning and every evening. Answering these questions will take you less than five minutes, but the practice of
Starting point is 01:07:45 answering them regularly will be transformative. Since the journal was published in January, I have received hundreds of messages from people telling me how much it has helped them and how much more in control of their lives they now feel. Now, if you already have a journal or you don't actually want to buy a journal that is completely fine i go through in detail all of the questions within the three question journal completely free on episode 413 of this podcast but if you are keen to check it out all you have to do is go to drchatterjee.com forward slash journal or click on the link in your podcast app we we know a little and what a spectacular analysis wrong like when you if you just think
Starting point is 01:08:38 about time and then have some guidance like you nicely guided us. And by the way, in a lot of contemplative traditions, I was just up in the Himalayas, they do engage in these multi-generational reflections of what would your grandparent have thought about this tree or the great grandparent. That becomes a source of awe. Like, oh, I am part of a family tradition, a cultural tradition.
Starting point is 01:09:04 What war did this tree, was it born in, right? And what will the world be like when it dies? So yeah, we're starting to sense that, you know, and that was part of our awwak condition or instructions is to get from the small, what does this tree look like to the vast, right? Whoa, how did this grow to be like this? And that kind of reflective exercise is of going from the small to vast physically or temporally is starting to show some of the benefits
Starting point is 01:09:38 that we're interested in. Loved your analysis too. Like in our Western world, we think too much about the individual we forget the systems of people we're part of the family yeah the culture and it's awe-inspiring to reflect on that it really is and of course nature is a is a really good way to access that um there was another study i think you wrote about i I can't quite place it now, I think it was about how experiencing awe makes you more humble. Was this the one at Berkeley where one group was looking at the tall trees, one group was looking at the science building,
Starting point is 01:10:17 and then I think it was this one where the stranger then dropped some pens. And if you had looked at the tree as opposed to the science building, you were statistically more likely to go and help that stranger pick up pens. Have I got that right? Yeah, nailed it. And it's the wonderful work of Paul Piff. And it speaks to the science of awe and the challenges of this mysterious emotion, right? How do you get awe in a lab?
Starting point is 01:10:44 So we started doing a lot of stuff out in the world. We've studied all Yosemite and the Great Wall of China and other people studied it in mosh pits and musical venues and the like. And we have a couple of studies on humility. Humility is when you have a realistic assessment of who you are and you are open to the strengths of other
Starting point is 01:11:05 people right so if i'm humble about my scientific or right author accomplishments and i appreciate what a brilliant writer steve pinker is or an andrea wolf right that's humility some people feel we need more of it today when you think anyway anyway, I won't comment on the ex-president of the United States. But, you know, but so first study, the trees, look up into these vast trees and suddenly yourself gets smaller. You feel humble. Yeah. We got people at Yosemite, travelers from 42 countries looking at Yosemite. They drew really small selves as a characterization of who they are.
Starting point is 01:11:45 We took other people up into this clock tower on the Berkeley campus. They looked out at the view. And this is a classic source of awe. It's like, wow, I see the view of the world. And they not only were more small in themselves, but they felt really good about the strengths of people around them, you know, as opposed to envious or the like. All seems to be the perfect antidote to everything we're struggling with today. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:12:10 Which a lot of it is simply inward focus. Me, me, me. This social media post, how many likes has it got? You know, even take this even further, right? This is something I've, I think one of the downsides of technology for me is that we can customize everything for ourselves. So think about it. 20 years ago, let's say you're in a family or you have a partner, for example. You don't really have the option in the evening to individualize and customize your life. Yeah, sure. You could have both read different books, but let's say you'd put the television on. There's probably one telly and you have to agree which channel are we going to watch. You don't have to do that
Starting point is 01:12:58 anymore. You can both be sitting there on the same sofa with your device in your own customized world, the same sofa with your device in your own customized world. Yeah. Right. Consuming your curated content. Great. But again, it's more me, me, me. It's taken us away from us, us, us. So I think that's interesting to reflect on. Huge. But this thing about humility. Yeah. I'd wonder about your perspective on this, Daphne. Yeah. I'm very fortunate to speak to some incredible people like yourself each week on this show. Yeah. And two people I've had on in the past who, you know, are widely regarded as the best in their field. Yeah. Right. Were the athletes, Elliot Kipchoge, the Kenyan marathon runner. Yeah. And the mountain runner, Kylian Jornet.
Starting point is 01:13:47 Okay, now I've spoken to both of them and they're still considered, one's the greatest road marathon runner, possibly of all time. One's the greatest mountain runner of all time. Now, speaking to awe and the content in your book, because I've been pondering this for a good few weeks to months. I pondered why are those two guests,
Starting point is 01:14:11 I would consider two of the humblest guests, the two of the most modest people I've ever spoken to on the show. It doesn't mean by the guests weren't, but for me, I've been really trying to crack this. What is it about those two when they, you wouldn't be surprised if they had ego, given how good they are
Starting point is 01:14:31 and how celebrated they are around the world. Whereas if you think of a top footballer or a top basketball player, again, it's not everyone, but you would probably think about a bit of ego that comes along with that. And so I'm thinking, well, is it because these are long distances, so they bash the ego out of them? At some point, they have to confront themselves and go beyond.
Starting point is 01:14:54 Or is it the fact that these guys are out there in nature? They're distance runners. Killian in the mountains. Elliot runs in the Rift Valley in Kenya with his running crew. Like, I've been, I've literally, this keeps me up at some times. I think, why are those two so lacking in ego? And I think some of the concepts in your book kind of might help me explain that. Yeah, that's a spectacular observation, Rangan. You know, might help me explain that.
Starting point is 01:15:23 Yeah, that's a spectacular observation, Rangan. You know, when you find people who have been extraordinarily successful, you know, and one of the things, and your question really raises this, I think, timely and really sort of underappreciated possibility that humility is really the pathway to enduring success. And people write about it in the ethics literature, but your examples really bring it to
Starting point is 01:15:52 life. I think the runners, you know, and I think what they, how they find humility setting world records when the self is on the victory stand, right, is almost what I encountered when I interviewed Steve Kerr. And Steve Kerr is a basketball coach in the United States. He set a couple of records. He probably will go down as having won more championships, both as a player and a coach, than any player in history, any person in history. He's at, I think, 10 now or 11.
Starting point is 01:16:26 He's regarded as one of the greatest coaches. He'll be Hall of Fame. And when I talked to him about being this athlete, Olympics, NBA champion, et cetera, he's one of the most humble people you'll know. And what he talked about is what we've been talking about throughout this conversation, which is he is amazed that he plays a sport that puts him into contact with thousands of people and they're inspired when he when he his team start to really play well i asked him like how do you know you're really successful and he said and i was expecting some you know coaching wisdom and he said i look around me and the people are dancing, you know, and it's just joy. And so when you are a runner, like these great runners, and you're part of a history of the sport, that's all. You do it outdoors, that's all. And then you see the people who are moved by
Starting point is 01:17:18 you, that's all, right? And suddenly it's like, oh, this is a privilege to be a runner like this. I wish I could. It's a great idea. And I hope your next book is about that. It's a really interesting idea. Yeah. Thank you for sharing your perspective on that. It's just, yeah, as I say, it's just something I've been thinking about.
Starting point is 01:17:37 And it kind of lit up in my brain when I was reading your book. And I thought, oh, maybe a part of this is that they're spending a lot of time in nature. If you think about Kylian Jornet, he's going to be in mountains all the time. I mean, what teaches you how small you really are than being around these big, vast mountains? That definition, you know, what is it? The definition you put in the book was, or is the feeling of being in the presence of something vast that transcends your current understanding of the world. Yeah, yeah. And that's the challenge of our individualistic times that the athletes find in nature. And we can find it in many different ways. When I interviewed Yumi Kendall, who's one of the great cellists in the United
Starting point is 01:18:19 States, and I asked her, like, how do you find awe? You know, and she plays the cello. It's an awe-inspiring music and she's full of awe. And she said, you know, when I play awe, I am not, I am part of this orchestra. I'm part of the audience. I'm part of humans making music for tens of thousands of years. And the notes are just part of life
Starting point is 01:18:42 and our history together, right? And suddenly she gets really humble and awe-inspired. And I think that's what odd points us to is like, this is what I'm part of that is way bigger than the self. Talking about things greater than the self, very few things teach us that than life and death. Yeah. And this chapter really did have a big impact on me. I thought it was beautifully written. Thank you. With some phenomenal ideas in there. Let's start with life. I think it's easy for us to understand when we think about it, that the birth of a child is an awe-inspiring event. It is. Yeah. And, you know, when we did that study, stories of awe from 26 countries,
Starting point is 01:19:30 everywhere in the world, people, parents, relatives, grandparents. I remember this story from a grandmother in France who's like, when my granddaughter came in, I just felt like hugging everybody and my life was anew, you know. Yeah, you know, and very simply, this is, you know, it's awe-inspiring visually and, you know, it's got a lot of, as you know, fluids and so forth. But out comes the face and you look at the face as I did with my daughter Natalie.
Starting point is 01:20:01 And I was like, I saw all the generations that she was part of genetically and historically. I was blown away by the beauty of her face. I still get goosebumps thinking about it now. And time, like you're listening to the music and thinking about your daughter, like, wow, this is the beginning of a cycle, right? And then a lot of people, I remember a mom from Japan writing about like, oh my God,
Starting point is 01:20:27 I am different. I now am responsible. I have to take care of somebody for 60 years. So transformative. Yeah. There's nothing like becoming a parent to take you outside of yourself, you know, and your own, and well, what am I going to do? And your worries is suddenly, suddenly everything changes. Everything. You know? Yeah. own, and well, what am I going to do? And your worries is suddenly everything changes. Everything. You know? Yeah. I still remember at Edinburgh Medical School,
Starting point is 01:20:50 when I was on my obstetrics and gynecology placement, and I can't remember what year, maybe third year, fourth year as a med student. Yeah. I went in to observe a cesarean section. Wow. And I remember putting, you know, scrubbing up and going in. And I just remember being literally amazed that within minutes, I basically cut open someone, pulled out a baby.
Starting point is 01:21:18 And I just remember at that time going, I've never seen anything like that before. That is just ridiculous. Do you know what I mean? I mean, when you go from no baby to baby out of the body, you're like, it's- Yeah, it was one of those. It was one of those things.
Starting point is 01:21:33 But interestingly enough, one of the things I found fascinating as you were writing about life was, you were talking about this lady who started off the natural childbirth movement because there was a concern that births are becoming over-medicalized. I thought that was fascinating. Yeah, Nancy Bardicke, it's a radical cultural shift, right? We started to, women would be in general anesthesia and they wouldn't recognize their child and just presumably for safety reasons. And we've moved
Starting point is 01:22:00 away from that. And Nancy Bardicke leads this whole like awe-based approach to giving birth to children. Like, you know, be aware of it, understand the vastness and it's to good effect. Yeah. Let's talk about death. Death is a topic that I think we don't talk about enough. Certainly in the West. Yeah. It's something that is hidden away. Even the way we use language, we often don't say that that person died. We say, oh, I lost that person. We try and soften it in so many ways, whereas there's many cultures where death is right there in your face. Yeah, absolutely. And if I reflect on my own life,
Starting point is 01:22:49 one of the transformative experiences was when my dad died. Sorry. Yeah, it's almost 10 years now, which is mad for me to even think that this march will be 10 years. And this whole idea that it takes you outside of yourself that's what awe is you know you think about the vastness until i read that chapter i don't think i look back on dad's death and i never would have thought about the emotion or yeah yeah but actually i think you're bang on it was was awe-inspiring. I would have thought that awe is
Starting point is 01:23:27 a positive emotion. It's love. But of course, that is love. It's losing love. That's one way you could describe it. But I thought, yeah, that was the first time in my life after dad died that I started to ask big existential questions. Who am I? Yeah. Whose life am I leading? What am I going to do? Yeah. Right. So talk to me about death and why that made the book. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:23:52 Under this sort of umbrella of all. Yeah. Thank you. And I could not agree more about our Western European view of death. In working with medical doctors during the pandemic and they watched a million people in the United States die by themselves, right, in a hospital bed often. Tough stuff. We don't confront it like a lot of other cultures. Yeah, it made the book for a couple of reasons. And, you know, one was our data from 26 countries and people talked a lot about dying you know watching i remember
Starting point is 01:24:27 this young guy from indonesia just watching his mom die and he's just like wow what was my mother and what was her life and you know what is my life without her and as you nicely illustrated and argued, you know, Rangan, it's a huge mystery. Like, what is it? Where do they go? And then the other thing, and I really, this led me to write the book was my brother's death,
Starting point is 01:24:56 my brother Rolf. And as I was thinking about awe, you know, I was lucky, he's my younger brother red hair you know we had a awe-filled childhood of you know we were one year apart we my parents were kind of counterculture grew up in the Laurel Canyon in the 60s and then in the country and we backpacked and run ran it jumped in rivers and you know it was just full of awe and then he got colon cancer um and you know it's important to say at the outset like dying is horrifying you know it was brutal that's a brutal cancer it was just like chaos and then
Starting point is 01:25:41 um i he the cancer returned after chemotherapy, hit his gut. And you know this, carcinoma peritoneus. Yeah. And it just lights out. And so the day that he died, we all rushed up to his home. And I was sitting there and I knew this was coming for years. And I was sitting there and I knew this was coming, you know, for years and holding, you know, touching his body and seeing that he was in this state. And, you know, it was like it was a transcendent visual experience where it was like I saw patterns of light vibrating. I felt like there was a soul there you know like his soul uniting us
Starting point is 01:26:27 and then like you you know when he passed my mind was flooded with the big questions like what is life you know what um what was his life why why did he die you know what is death Why did he die? What is death? And I went in search. That is part of the book. I mean, sorry to hear about you brother. Thank you for sharing that story. Your brother plays quite a key role in this book.
Starting point is 01:26:57 He teaches heavily at various times. There was something in the chapter on death about these three practices towards the end of life. I think it was Roshi, Joan, Halifax. That really made me stop and reflect. I wonder if you could talk us through them. Yeah. Thank you, Rangan. You know, when my brother struggled with colon cancer, I'd visit him almost every week. And, you know, you would be able to make sense of it. I couldn't.
Starting point is 01:27:37 You know, it was just like, what's going on with the body? And like a lot of people who are really with illness and confronting the death of a deeply loved person, I tried to control things, I tried to fix things. I thought I had solutions. I was reading journals and bringing foods and so forth. And I was not doing well and I wasn't helping. And then, I read Roshi Joan Halifax,
Starting point is 01:28:07 who started a lot of the hospice work in the United States with AIDS patients. Seen thousands of people die. She's a friend. I love her. And she comes at dying out of a Buddhist contemplative tradition. And it has these three principles, which is accept uncertainty, mystery, and not knowing. You don't know. You don't know how long, you don't know where the body goes. And when I was near my brother, I was like, okay, I'm going to shift to like, I don't know. I will never know. The second is witness, you know, just like,
Starting point is 01:28:51 just observe instead of direct or control or label, like be there and witness the process. And it was interesting, you know, and a lot of people talk about this, who are around death a lot, that people who are dying kind of know the vast thing they're heading into. They're like, wow, this is a mystery. And my brother started to lead me there.
Starting point is 01:29:07 I remember one moment where he's like, you know, I was like, how are you doing? He's like, well, I'm thinking about the big D. And I was like, what is that? Death. I was like, what? You know, it's like, yeah, I'm so curious about what is it, you know? And I was like, oh, I got to witness that. What is it?
Starting point is 01:29:21 You know? And I was like, oh, I got to witness that. And then compassionate action is don't control or mislead, but just, you know, be kind. And man, thank you for reminding me of those, Rangan. Like, once I read that and I got those and embodied those, the whole thing changed. You know, my whole experience of his dying opened me up to awe, frankly. Yeah. We're talking about the benefits of awe, the benefits of us experiencing more awe in our lives.
Starting point is 01:29:56 How does that relate to death? Because death is seen as something negative often. Yeah, yeah. And there'll be many people listening who are either going through it or recently been through it. Someone close to them has died. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:30:11 How do you put that together with this idea that all has incredible benefits for us? Yeah. Do you know what I mean? Like, help us sort of understand that. Right. It's a next movement that's already starting to happen in facing the end of life and then grieving, right?
Starting point is 01:30:33 So facing the end of life. So for as an empirical illustration, we know psychedelics actually benefit people with terminal diseases. And the thinking now that we've written about and others, and I write about in this book, is psychedelics help us feel awe. And so if you're given a terminal disease
Starting point is 01:30:52 and you feel awe about it, and now there's work that's not psychedelic related with children facing terminal diseases, you're doing exactly what you did in your examples, Rangan, which you're like, well, I'm really part of a family and I'm part of a broader human experience. And maybe I believe in a soul
Starting point is 01:31:12 and my consciousness stays in some fashion. We don't know, you know? And that helps people facing dying. That helps ordinary people not facing dying just to reflect on that. And there's studies showing it's good for you. And then with grief, grief has a lot of awe in it. It's horrible, it's panicky, it's anxious, but there are all these mysteries that we have to head into. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:31:38 Awe guides us to. There are two more things in that chapter that really moved me one was how you ended it and i'm just going to read some of your words okay i'm glad you're reminding me and that the people we love remain with us in even more mysterious ways after they leave yeah Yeah. That is just so profound. Yeah. Like there's so many ways to interpret that. I certainly have been thinking a lot about my dad and how I now feel I still have a relationship with him. It's just changed. Like I can't talk to him. I can't ask him things and get a response, but I still have a relationship with him. It's just a different one. And so that line really spoke to me.
Starting point is 01:32:28 Thank you. You know, when my brother died, I went on a kind of a 18 month odyssey to just figure out the mysteries of life. And it's interesting, Rangan, and I haven't really thought about this, but when I write about it, he kept coming to me in when i was out in nature because he and i did a lot of outdoors time you
Starting point is 01:32:50 know growing up in the country and then backpacking and i would i'd feel his voice in the sky here's voice in the wind or i'd feel his eyesight in the sky i'd see him in trees, literally. And he is with me in consciousness in ways that science will never understand. And I feel to be true. And that I learned by following the awe of dying and grief. Yeah. Death can really teach us so much about what it means to be alive the the other section
Starting point is 01:33:26 in that chapter i wanted to talk to you about was this japanese principle of is it wabi-sabi yeah yeah i hadn't come across that yeah but this idea that the evolution of all forms from the natural to the man-made follow a cycle of creation, birth, growth, decay, and death. Again, we read things and they land with us at different parts of our life. So I've had an incredibly challenging six weeks, two months. You know, just after Christmas, me and my brother thought mum was dying. And I went through a sort of grief type process thinking that's it, I'm never going to be able to talk to mum again. And she has survived. And she's come home. But she's not the person she was before. And there's a lot of care in place. She hasn't got the vibrancy that she had before. But that section on Wabi Sabi has been incredibly comforting because
Starting point is 01:34:41 and I think it speaks to awe yeah it speaks to this idea that there is a natural yeah cycle and instead of trying to fight this and control it creation birth growth decay death i thought mom's probably in that fourth stage she's probably in that fourth stage. She's probably in decay now. And instead of resisting it, maybe it's a case of embracing it and going, yeah, mom's had a good life. This is now her journey on the evolution of life. Yeah, sorry about your mom. Yeah, that was a central insight
Starting point is 01:35:26 in grappling with my brother's death. I'm a scientist, I believe in evolution, I love molecules and nervous systems. And I watched him go and I watched that process of, I thought about his creation and then his growth, which I shared almost everything with growth. Then I watched his body decay brutally and go. And my mind at that moment was, that's it.
Starting point is 01:35:53 And then the experience of awe opened me up to like rebirth of Rolf is here in other ways. He's creating new things in this show. He's spreading these ideas, right? It gives me goosebumps thinking about it today. And that notion really confounded me of the cycle. And I was like, I don't quite understand this. So I started reading Wabi Sabi, the idea in Japanese design of everything goes through this cycle.
Starting point is 01:36:24 Charles Darwin in evolution, everything goes through that cycle. I talked to Reverend Jen Bailey and I was like, what's the secret to spirituality and awe? She said, it's always composting. It goes through a cycle of, you know, birth, growth, decay, and starting over. And I was like, oh my God, you know, this is one of the things that awe teaches us is that cycle. It's incredible. One might think that talking about these topics
Starting point is 01:36:57 is dark and somber, but I don't think it is. I think it actually really helps us connect with life, connect with something bigger, you know, remind us of our insignificance, really, in this kind of ego-focused world where there appears to be more and more people exhibiting narcissistic traits. This is the power of awe, wherever you experience it, isn't it? That actually it takes you out of yourself. You realize that, you know what?
Starting point is 01:37:32 It's all been, it's all happened before. It's all, it's all done. Let's just play our part in the kind of, I guess, the normal evolution of life. Yeah. You know, thank you for that summary, Rangan. One of the things you can take from this book is there are these eight wonders that hint to us that there are big things to be part of,
Starting point is 01:37:54 music and life and death and moral beauty, collective effervescence we've talked about. And just, you know, when you feel awe, just ask yourself that question, like, what am I part of here? You know, and it usually points you towards, it makes you realize, like, I'm just a small thing that actually is okay. That's actually true. But I'm part of something really large, like fellow humans, you know, an ecosystem or something about culture.
Starting point is 01:38:19 And we need that today. And we need that today. You know, like you said earlier, a lot of the health challenges come out of this internal individual focus that has just blown up today. And awe moves us towards the things that are amazing outside of ourselves. It's interesting that you pose the idea in the book that the English language doesn't really have good words like other languages might do about experiencing things outside of ourselves. Yeah. Can you speak to that a little bit?
Starting point is 01:38:52 Yeah, I mean, it's striking. You know, there is a term in Japanese, I think it's called jibun, which is shared life space, which is kind of like their sense of self. It's not like Dacker with all my traits and characteristics. It's like shared life space. I just encountered this other concept in Javanese. I think it's called perna, which is home, which is like, what is meaning? It's my sense of home, which you can find anywhere, like, what is meaning? It's my sense of home, which you can find anywhere. But it really is about a collective experience of this is we, right? And the English language, you try to find
Starting point is 01:39:34 words to describe that and it just doesn't hit, right? We think of the self and the ego and it has these connotations of like bounded self so hopefully this book opens people's minds to a little bit of the collective imagination it's that classic um tussle between east and west as in terms of philosophies and that you feel it yeah it's it's incredible to it's incredible to think how much the language we have access to influences our experience of the world. Because that's how many of us, we see it, don't we? You know, if we don't have the words to, you know, if your culture has these collective words within it and you're using them,
Starting point is 01:40:19 of course, you're going to see these things more easily. You know, it's not going to be quite as a struggle. Even this concept of, oh, this is what we were getting to at the start, that you may go to some cultures and go, yeah, we kind of know this. We're connected to our ancestors. We're connected to the land. We're connected to our communities. I really feel that there's this thing now in the West where we have to prove everything. Prove to me what you already know is intuitively true. And look, you've done a great job at supporting these ideas with science, to be clear. You've done a brilliant job at putting it all together. But I do question some of the stuff, like experiencing awe is an innate human quality
Starting point is 01:41:04 that humans 200,000 years ago were doing before a scientific study said to them, you know, you must, awe is good for you. Yeah. Do you know what I mean? Yeah, no, but, but, you know, that's, that's what science, you know, as, as my advisor Lee Ross said, you know, is in, in some sense, it's about knowledge for kindness, you know, it's sense, it's about knowledge for kindness. You know, it's for learning things that make us a little bit better as a community. And I think if you look at the broad trends that we've been noting in our largely globalized Western European cultures and now increasingly throughout the world, it's self-focused. It's individualistic.
Starting point is 01:41:39 It's more materialistic. And we've forgotten, you know. And you're absolutely right. unrealistic, and we've forgotten, you know. And you're absolutely right. For the interested reader, like the indigenous traditions that Dr. Yuria Salidwin, whom I interviewed for the book, represents, they have so much awe in their general cultural tendencies. And we just need to remind ourselves of that, you know, that we need this. People who are religious have a lot of awe, don't they? Yeah. Yeah. And you know, one of the interesting things about awe is it helps us understand why certain things are
Starting point is 01:42:11 beneficial. People who are religious tend to feel less depression, benefits for life expectancy. And one of the hypotheses is, and I write about this, is that religions are just containers for awe. You know, you go and you do your rituals and you sing together. You look up at the beautiful stained glass and you're in a cathedral that looks like a forest and you're hugging people. That's all awe, you know? And so we, when my brother died, I'm not a religious person, but like a lot of secular people facing such stress, I was like, how do I kind of build a sense of of that of like moving with people and my rituals and my sacred texts um so uh religion is a master it's a technology of all yeah it really is as we as we speak my uh wife's parents are in kenya at the moment. And they have a lot of family there. They used to live there.
Starting point is 01:43:06 And I've only visited once. And my father-in-law is part of the Jain community. And there's something in Nairobi called the Oshawa Center. And I have this vivid memory. I spoke about this once on the podcast when chatting to Shane O'Mara, the neuroscientist from Ireland, who wrote a brilliant book on walking and about what happens when you walk together with other people. And you, of course, touched on that in your book. And I don't know if he's done this yet or not, but at the Oshawa Center, the Jain community or certain elements of the Jain community would come together every evening at dusk. And it's the most beautiful sight. They walk together around this track. They just go around talking. So they're getting physical activity. They're getting community. They're getting connection. They're getting the mood lifting benefits of all of those things.
Starting point is 01:44:04 They're getting the mood lifting benefits of all of those things. But it's built in to the fabric of the community, of the structure. And I think that's what, as we become more secular, this is a massive thing we've lost. Of course, there are some negatives of religions. I'm not trying to paint a picture that everything's fantastic. But we really have lost some of this cohesion and this ritual that used to exist. I, you know, and I love one of our, the people I interviewed is Diana Gameroz, who's this great musician. And she did the Awok that we talked about, but in a Mexico Zocalo.
Starting point is 01:44:37 And Mexico Zocalos are, they're like churches. They're like genius locations for a lot of, you know, sharing music and culture and the like. Yeah. You know, we have one of the things that's been really surprising and exhilarating about writing this book. And then in the conversations is I think it gives us a new way to talk about religion and spirit and sacred. You know, we started with a quote about the sacred and even the divine that, you know, let's put aside dogma and definitions and so forth and just ask humans as William James did, like, what brings you a sense of the sacred? What would you give your life for, right?
Starting point is 01:45:32 Where do you find a sense of your soul? That which is primary and good and it's mysterious, right? And lo and behold, a lot of it's about awe. And so 81% of Americans believe in spirit and half of those people find it in nature. And they go out there and they're like, this is beyond my words and understanding. It's awe and it gives me a sense of soul. Yeah.
Starting point is 01:45:56 I chatted to my wife this morning and I said, I'm talking to you about awe. And I asked her about how often she experiences awe. She said all the time. And the thing she said to me was, when I'm meditating regularly, I experience awe everywhere all the time. I found that interesting. So that practice of solitude and the way she meditates and what she taps into allows her then to go out into the non-meditative world, i.e. when the parts of her life where she's not meditating and she's starting to see the wonder of life everywhere.
Starting point is 01:46:32 So I wonder your perspective on that, but I also wonder, like my last book, Daka, was on happiness, right? And I said happiness is a trainable skill. Yeah. And I believe it to be, and you have a lot more experience talking about happiness than I do. But I can't shake that thought,
Starting point is 01:46:52 like with happiness, like with gratitude, and now with awe, that the ability to experience or see or find awe is something you can get better at once you start looking for it. Yeah, yeah. Your wife is onto something really profound that I think we'll learn more about,
Starting point is 01:47:15 which is when you find your, what you might call your contemplative practice, and it might be listening to music, it might be walking in the woods, reading the Upanishads for me believe it or not I was playing pickup basketball for decades just like this I'm in a reflective moment about my life you often feel extensive awe about almost everything in life you know and in some sense that's what you find in the spiritual
Starting point is 01:47:45 journalings of and you know the great revelations of in the bhagavad-gita or other texts is like wow there's so much that's incredible here it's so much wonder and the science and scholarship around awe says as as i show like this is a basic state of mind and it's not you don't need to be on a plane and going to the barrier reef it's just a basic thing about reality to wonder about it that it's mysterious and it is to your to your question you can cultivate it you know and when you read the book and you think about you like you said earlier listening to music for awe or going for an awe walk or reading a poem that really moved you, watching children grow. If you just do that. I do that every day when I walk to work. I walk by a little preschool and I just stop for about 30 seconds and look, oh,
Starting point is 01:48:38 they're playing, you know, they have this weird, you know, Game of Thrones game going on. Kids are amazing. It's a mind blowing. So you listen to them speak language, whatever it is. So there's so much awe. And your wife is in some sense, the kind of the spirit of the book that I was trying to say, encourage, which is like,
Starting point is 01:48:58 there's everyday awe and wonder. Just go get it, you know? Yeah. Well, let's close this conversation down, Daka. It's, you know, been so expanding this conversation. For me too. I think I've experienced awe on several occasions throughout. I think the book is wonderful.
Starting point is 01:49:17 I think it's such a deep dive. We haven't even covered a fraction of what's in it in terms of the things i think people can learn about themselves about the world about their history about their ancestors i think it really is quite profound um this podcast is called feel better live more when we feel better in ourselves we get more out of our lives and i would like to finish off with a question to my guest around this idea. If you look around in the world today, people are sick. There's a lot of sickness, a lot of struggle. There's a lot of discontentment. So for that person who's
Starting point is 01:50:00 listening right now, who feels like that that through the lens of this new book, through the lens of awe, have you got any final words of advice or some practical wisdom for them? Yeah. Thank you. That's one of the reasons I wrote this book. You know, I felt it in grief, like I'm sick. I saw it in the broad patterns of data. And then I hear from those parents that are like, man, my son is really struggling like a lot of teens are. And I say, find awe. And those eight wonders are really useful. So just a few of them. One of them is moral beauty. Can you just sort of top line what is moral beauty? Moral beauty is when we're astonished by the kindness and courage of other people.
Starting point is 01:50:47 And one exercise I have people do is just think about a mentor whose courage or kindness changed your life and how it's with you today. Wow. And when they do that, they're like, oh, my God, my math teacher, Mr. McAuliffe, he told me I was good in math. I didn't know. And now I'm X or Y. And we're, we forget that in our individualistic mindset, you know, get outside and do an all walk, find some form of collective movement, you know, or, or singing, listen to music for all right. Find, you know, it's, I mean, the, this is where the where the, you know, our internet and the smartphones are great.
Starting point is 01:51:26 Like, man, look at awe videos. There are tons of awe videos. One of my favorite, Babies in Tunnels is a whole series of babies coming out of tunnels. Like, ah, you know, so much awe out there. And then, you know, I'll avoid spirituality. That's up to people to form their own spirituality. But, you know, think about the ideas that matter to you. And when my brother died, I was like, God, I know I have this cocktail of ideas that I'm part of.
Starting point is 01:51:55 And I started reading Walt Whitman and Virginia Woolf and so forth. And then, you know, I am grateful, Rangan, that you've brought into focus death. Like there are now exercises of imagine the full life of somebody you really care about from their birth to their death. The Bhutanese do this as a regular practice. School kids do this. We never do it. Oh, don't think about dying. But, you know, you think about like, wow, this is – I think about my mom, you know, 85, inspiration for me.
Starting point is 01:52:22 Like that's what she was like as a little girl. And I follow the trajectory of her life and then appreciate it will end. And suddenly you come out of that as study show, like we all have this part of our life, right? And it's has all in it. Daka, I appreciate the work you've done. I appreciate the book you've written
Starting point is 01:52:42 and I really appreciate the conversation that's coming up to the studio. Yeah, thank you Ragan. This I really appreciate the conversation. That's coming up to the studio. Yeah. Thank you, Ragan. This has been an incredible conversation. So thank you. Thank you. Really hope you enjoyed that conversation.
Starting point is 01:53:00 As always, do think about one thing that you can take away and start applying into your own life. Now, before you go, just wanted to let you know about Friday Five. It's my free weekly email containing five simple ideas to improve your health and happiness. In that email, I share exclusive insights that I do not share anywhere else, including health advice, how to manage your time better, interesting articles or videos that I've been consuming and quotes that have caused me to stop and reflect and I have to say in a world of endless emails it
Starting point is 01:53:30 really is delightful that many of you tell me it is one of the only weekly emails that you actively look forward to receiving so if that sounds like something you would like to receive each and every Friday you can sign up for free at drchatterjee.com forward slash Friday Five. Now, if you are new to my podcast, you may be interested to know that I have written five books that have been bestsellers all over the world, covering all kinds of different topics, happiness, food, stress, sleep, behavior change, and movement, weight loss, and so much more. So please do take a moment to check them out. They are all available as paperbacks, eBooks, and as audio books, which
Starting point is 01:54:13 I am narrating. If you enjoyed today's episode, it is always appreciated if you can take a moment to share the podcast with your friends and family, or leave a review on Apple Podcasts. Thank you so much for listening. Have a wonderful week. And always remember, you are the architect of your own health. Making lifestyle changes always worth it. Because when you feel better, you live more.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.