Focus: Adults in the Room - Adults in the Room: Jonathan

Episode Date: March 17, 2026

The Garfield community -- and, it seems, the whole city of Seattle -- mourns Tom Hudson, remembering him as a great man and teacher. One of the students who was closest to him, Jonathan Hill, spends t...he weeks after Hudson's death trying to ensure his reputation and legacy go untarnished by the allegations that led to his suspension in late 1999.  But secretly, Jonathan is still reeling from the weeks before Tom's death. During that time, Hudson repeatedly leaned on Jonathan -- then the president of Post 84, Hudson's outdoors club -- as his personal crisis counselor. Jonathan reveals he’s also wondered if he’s to blame for Hudson’s death. This is the closest Isolde’s ever come to understanding what happened to Hudson in the weeks between his leave of absence and his suicide. If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988 for the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, or contact the Crisis Text Line by texting TALK to 741-741. Please take care while listening.  Get in touch with the team by email at focus@kuow.org. Support KUOW and projects like this by donating at kuow.org/donate/focus. Adults in the Room is part of FOCUS, a dedicated documentary channel from KUOW Puget Sound Public Radio in Seattle, a proud member of the NPR network. It is hosted by Isolde Raftery. Original reporting by Isolde Raftery, Jeannie Yandel, and Will James. Our producers are Will James and Alec Cowan. Our editor is Jeannie Yandel. Music by BC Campbell. Additional music by Alec Cowan. A special thank you to Ella Hushagen.See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:01 Call your friends, your partner, and maybe a babysitter because Seattle Restaurant Week is here. I'm Brandy Fullwood, host of Seattle Eats. And on the latest episode, Seattle writer Harry Cheatel has been doing the math so you don't have to. We'll tell you about the deals, dishes, and drink pairings worth checking out this Seattle Restaurant Week. Listen to Seattle Eats on the KUOW app or wherever you get your podcasts. Focus. in Seattle. This episode includes descriptions of abuse and discussion of suicide.
Starting point is 00:00:44 If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 9-88 for the suicide and crisis lifeline or contact the crisis text line by texting Talk, T-A-L-K to 741-741. Please take care while listening. On February 6, 2000, the Sunday after Garfield High School science teacher, Tom Hudson, died. The Seattle Times published two stories about him. If you opened the paper that morning, you would have read that this celebrated educator, the leader of the school's renowned outdoors club, was suspended after a parent complained about his conduct, that the school district dragged out a month's long investigation into his alleged abuse of boys,
Starting point is 00:01:39 and that Mr. Hudson, who dedicated his whole world to young people, was in agony being isolated from his students. So he took his own life. One of the stories was a fawning portrait, written by a news columnist who clearly believed Mr. Hudson had been wronged. The columnist referenced ancient Greece when a famed philosopher was put on trial for his unorthodox teachings. Like Socrates, she wrote, Hudson walked a line with rulemakers. But it was the last sentence of the column that made me go cold. I ran to my dad holding the newspaper. My dad scanned the piece, his eyes growing wide.
Starting point is 00:02:26 He read the final paragraph aloud, slowly. in disbelief. It may never be known if the allegations were true, only that they likely played a part in killing a teacher, best known for showing his students how to survive.
Starting point is 00:02:47 What those Seattle Times stories didn't say is that the original complaint made against Mr. Hudson came from me, that I urged my mom to call the authorities after Ella Hushagen, my best friend, told me Mr. Hudson,
Starting point is 00:03:03 had pressed. pressured boys to look at porn and shower with him. Ella and I had done what we thought was right. But now one of the city's major daily newspapers had taken angry whispers, printed them, and in so doing, put a target on both our backs. Soon after Mr. Hudson died, the district superintendent ended the investigation,
Starting point is 00:03:29 saying it wouldn't be fair to continue because Mr. Hudson couldn't defend him. So for the last year and a half, I've been trying to complete the investigation that was cut short. It's been like having a 1,000-piece puzzle dumped on the table, but with some pieces missing, and no box cover as a guide. I'd collected records and talked with some former classmates, but to answer the questions I've carried with me for so long, I had to go into Mr. Hudson's inner circle. I reached out to the former president of Post-84. That's when I discovered how little I really knew about those seminal events from my past.
Starting point is 00:04:17 He told me how, at age 17, he was forced into the role of Mr. Hudson's confidant in the final months of his life. How he fought to keep Mr. Hudson alive. And how, like Ella and me, he's carried the world. weight of those tragic days well into adulthood. All this time, our former classmate hadn't thought of us as responsible for Mr. Hudson's death because he's blamed himself. From KOWW Public Radio in Seattle, I'm Isolda Raftery. This is Adults in the Room, Episode 4.
Starting point is 00:05:00 Jonathan. Tom Hudson's memorial service took place in downtown Seattle, in an old church turned performance space. Today it's typically reserved for famous authors passing through the city on book tours. Picture a domed ceiling, stained glass windows, and a sea of long, curving oak pews. A thousand people packed in shoulder to shoulder to honor Mr. Hudson. Kids from post 84 sat on the floor at the front of this grand space, crisscross applesauce, wearing fern crowns. But this wasn't the only service the post-84 students attended for their leader. They had gathered the weekend before in a forest outside Seattle for their own private remembrance.
Starting point is 00:05:52 Under the Evergreens, dripping with lichen, a campfire crackled as the teens. Many in wool pants bought for cheap at the military surplus store downtown shared memories of their beloved instructor. He trusted us to take care of each other but teach each other to give us the skills to be able to deal. My friend Maria sent me a VHS tape from this Woodsy tribute. The video runs for half an hour.
Starting point is 00:06:24 Students reminisced about Mr. Hudson cajoling them to belay off a rock face, delivering snickers bars to hungry campers after a night alone in the soggy woods and handing out a chainsaw like it was no big deal. This guy just gave me a chainsaw. I'm going to kill myself. I'm not going to go home.
Starting point is 00:06:44 My parents are really mad. After watching the eulogies, I noticed a common thread. Many of these kids were nervous, shy even. There's a recurring pattern of Mr. Hudson pulling introverted students out of their shells and into some new, ridiculous scenario they'd never. ever been in before. But he didn't ask kids to do these things.
Starting point is 00:07:09 He made them. That totally freaked me out, and I looked at Tom. As all of you guys know, when you look at Tom, he tells you to do something. I mean, there's nothing you can really do about it. He volunteered me to do the program, a mixture of volunteering me, but telling me I was going to do it. During our senior year, Jonathan Hill was the president of post-84.
Starting point is 00:07:32 Mr. Hudson had recruited him as a freshman. freshman when Jonathan was just a quiet band nerd. When there was a trip coming up, he didn't approach me and say, Jonathan, are you interested in doing this? Jonathan, I signed you up. I can't wait for you to join. And me still as a pretty timid, small guy at the time, and Tom being a very authoritative teacher, you know, charismatic and all that,
Starting point is 00:08:01 it was hard for me to say no. Jonathan said being voluntled was uncomfortable at first. But with each trip, he could feel his confidence and his bond with Mr. Hudson grow. Are you glad that he did that? Yes, yes. Is there two ways to look at it, right? One is like, it's too forceful. Or he saw in you, I've got to push this kid harder.
Starting point is 00:08:28 Yep. I think it was both of those things. Tom took the post in our programs very, very, very seriously. And he recognized that for the program to be successful, he needed talent. And I do think he saw that in me. And I certainly did not see it in myself. I do think another reason he pressured me into joining the post was like he wanted to be around me more. By the time Jonathan was a sophomore, he devoted almost all of his free time to post-84,
Starting point is 00:09:08 which meant he was around Mr. Hudson a lot. So it wasn't surprising when Mr. Hudson invited Jonathan to play racquetball one day after school. You've heard a story like this one a few times already. We played racquetball and it was fine. It was kind of fun. But then in the locker room after needing to change back into clothes, was a shower and he was like, okay, we're going to shower. Again, it wasn't, hey, Jonathan, do you want to take a shower after? It's, we're going to take a shower now. I was just like, yeah, I can just, you know, so I brought up my swimsuit and he said to me, Jonathan, we don't
Starting point is 00:09:46 wear swimsuits in the shower. And that made me so uncomfortable. And I put on my swimsuit anyway, and I was like, okay, we're showering. And, you know, he went into the shower area. And, you know, he went into the shower area naked and I picked the farthest shower away and I went against him, which I'm proud of myself for. Jonathan can't recall if he'd known beforehand that Mr. Hudson would likely pressure him into the shower. Jonathan told me he was risk averse in general, the kind of kid who would bring swim trunks along to a gym, just in case he might need them. Regardless, that shower changed how Jonathan saw his teacher.
Starting point is 00:10:32 He still admired Mr. Hudson as a mentor, and he still loved post-84. But after that day, Jonathan decided he didn't want to spend time with Mr. Hudson alone. He still helped me grow into a confident person. He just was transformationally good for me before and after that racquetball experience. but I, you know, age 16, 17, 17, I was like, okay, Jonathan, here's the plan. You're going to have a business relationship with Tom. And I thought that at the time. That's how I'm going to be safe.
Starting point is 00:11:07 By his junior year, Jonathan had seen Mr. Hudson coax other boys into showering with him naked after post-84 scuba trainings. And he'd heard from friends in the club that Mr. Hudson had slapped boys' butts in the shower. These stories made Jonathan uncomfortable. But instead of blaming Mr. Hudson for that feeling, he believed something was wrong with him. He was an anxious kid, and Mr. Hudson was so confident and all-knowing. Maybe he was the weird one for not being chill enough to take off his swim trunks in the shower. None of the other guys seemed to think Mr. Hudson's behavior was a big deal.
Starting point is 00:11:48 So Jonathan kept to himself, but felt like he was walking a tightrope as he balanced the risks and rewarding. awards of working closely with Mr. Hudson. And, you know, in hindsight, I think I pulled that off pretty well until senior year. Just ahead of senior year, Mr. Hudson told Jonathan that he'd be the new president of post-84. In that moment, neither could have foreseen that Mr. Hudson would soon be placed on leave, that a formal investigation into his behavior would be launched, complicating their relationship even more. And that in the thick of it all, Jonathan would be drawn deeper into Mr. Hudson's orbit with a force that would take him decades to overcome.
Starting point is 00:12:42 Music festivals and fan conventions, art walks, author events, and reading parties. The next few months are amazing for arts and culture in the Seattle area. And every week, KUOW's Arts and Culture podcast, Meet Me Here, will give you the inside scoop. From inspired recommendations to surprising chats with artists, you'll discover what's truly special about Seattle's creative communities. Listen to meet me here on the KUOW app or wherever you get your podcasts. At the start of our senior year at Garfield High School, Post-84 drew more students than ever before. But Jonathan noticed something was off about Mr. Hudson. The daring rescue on Mount Olympus, which I described in episode.
Starting point is 00:13:32 one happened almost exactly one year before. Jonathan had avoided that trip, so he wasn't there to help his friends save Mr. Hudson's life after he fell into a deep crack in the ice. Publicly, Mr. Hudson said the rescue was a success. He touted the survival skills of the students he trained. But behind the scenes, Mr. Hudson seemed deeply shaken by the accident. That event really messed with Tom, messed with his mind and his sense of self. I think he had an invincibility complex
Starting point is 00:14:10 where he thought he could get away with things and that things wouldn't get in his way. He told me that he wasn't going to see his doctor, even though his knee was messed up from the fall. You know, it was telling me it takes 20 ibuprofen's a day. Okay, that's not healthy. Why are you telling me that?
Starting point is 00:14:28 And he became more volatile. Jonathan heard that Mr. Hudson had kicked another club member in anger and saw that Mr. Hudson was now using his personal boat for post-84 activities, which made Jonathan nervous. Kids would be alone with him, isolated on the open water. Jonathan remembers feeling overwhelmed by these changes in Mr. Hudson's behavior and whether it would hurt post-84.
Starting point is 00:14:59 I think I was more just worried about what would happen, either to Tom or the program or to the students or whatever. And I was just like, I don't like this. I don't like things being elevated. I don't like things coming to light. Jonathan didn't share his concerns with anyone. I feel bad saying it, but like, even at the beginning of senior year, I was like, okay, I've eight more months of Tom. I can get through this. I was still very appreciative for him, but already I was like, I'm looking forward to not being around Tom anymore.
Starting point is 00:15:41 Right before Thanksgiving break, Jonathan learned the school district was poised to investigate Mr. Hudson. He doesn't remember who told him about this, or why, but he and fellow post-84 member, Rosie Bancroft, went to Mr. Hudson's classroom. without thinking, I felt that I needed to tell Tom. It was my responsibility to tell him if I have information that affects him or our program. And it wasn't a debate in my mind. In hindsight, it's like, John, why? And I was 17. I was a few months away for my 18th birthday.
Starting point is 00:16:23 I walked into Tom's office. I was like, Tom, I have something to tell you. And he seemed like he was already having, like, a bad day. Like, he was just low energy and lethargic. And we sat down and I said, Tom, I've learned that the school district is starting an investigation. And I think they're going to look into, you know, how you've been interacting with us students. And he looked at me and just some of the color went out of his face. and he slowly closed his eyes
Starting point is 00:16:59 and then he slowly said I want to keep these eyes closed and never opened them again. Sifting through school records from that time, I found a letter from the district to Mr. Hudson dated just before Thanksgiving. It broke the same news that Jonathan felt compelled to share with him.
Starting point is 00:17:24 Mr. Hudson already knew he was in trouble. After Thanksgiving, Mr. Hudson didn't return to school. Jonathan kept thinking about how defeated his teacher seemed when they talked about the investigation a week earlier. So he and a friend from Post-84 went to check on him at the marina in Seattle's Ballard neighborhood, where Mr. Hudson wore at his boat. They saw his truck in the parking lot and headed for the dock. As they climbed on board, they noticed three empty beer kids. cans on a table next to Mr. Hudson. He had another beer open.
Starting point is 00:18:06 Mr. Hudson was married, but it was evident to Jonathan that he'd been living alone on the boat. Without hesitation, he started talking about his previous 24 hours, and he said, you know, last night he was feeling so lost that he was going to kill himself. And now I'm going to speak in the first person as he was saying. saying to us and you know I wanted to make a plan for how to do it and I just thought I'm going to take my boat out on a puttis sound put the gas pedal up to top notch and then put on a scuba diving weight belt that he had on and drink more alcohol and then just fall off the boat and let the boat go keep going until it ends until it sinks until it hits something and then I would
Starting point is 00:19:00 drown, and that would be that. And he said to us, while I was ready to end it, I thought about you, I thought about the other students, I thought about other people in my life, and that you all want me to stay alive. So here I am because of you. Jonathan went to Mr. Hudson's boat, planning to maintain their quote-unquote business relationship. But during the visit, he felt a shift. I felt like I was someone and my friend was someone he was comfortable talking to and he needed to talk to people. And he wanted to share this and we were there for him.
Starting point is 00:19:49 He had been there for us for many years. And this was an opportunity for me to be there for him. After that encounter, Jonathan and the other Post-84 kids closed ranks around Mr. Hudson. They stopped talking to Eddie Hill, Sr., the former cop the district hired to investigate their teacher. And they tried to get others to join their campaign. A former post-84 leader called from college to persuade Rosie to stay quiet. And Jonathan even phoned me one night, asking me to stop talking. about Mr. Hudson.
Starting point is 00:20:30 Mr. Hudson wasn't allowed to speak with students while he was under investigation, but Jonathan went to the marina twice. He has a clear memory of the second visit about two weeks after Mr. Hudson first told him his suicide plan. It was at night, you know, maybe 7 p.m., 8 p.m. And this time, whereas before there was like a six-pack of beer, now there was like a 24-pack of beer.
Starting point is 00:20:56 and he told me that, you know, he can't eat food. He's not hungry, but even when he tries to eat, it won't stay down. The only thing he can consume his beer. Jonathan recalls a bleak scene and more raw honesty from his teacher. Mr. Hudson let down his guard, revealing that in the past, he'd wondered if he was gay. He shared with me that when he was young, he was having confusing feelings towards other boys and men. But, you know, he didn't tell me he was gay,
Starting point is 00:21:33 but he told me that, well, that he questioned back when he was younger and that he tried different things, including joining the Army, but those feelings didn't go away. It was the only time I had ever seen him vulnerable and allowing himself to share his doubts, his insecurities, his hurt. What was going through your head as he was. was telling you all this. I was basically just listening.
Starting point is 00:21:59 Yeah. But I remember feeling connected. I could tell that he felt that he was being heard without judgment, that he was able to do this safely and say things and tell somebody things that he wanted to say out loud for a long time. Jonathan, why does this get you, like this one memory? Oh, I think it's because it was the first and probably the only time, like he was ever his true self around me. It also, I'm feeling a little emotional now because I was able to make him feel okay for just at least a little while. I don't know how long I was there, maybe 30 minutes, maybe an hour, maybe longer, I don't know, but at a certain point I was like, okay, I got to go home, you know, and he just said,
Starting point is 00:23:06 okay, he said thank you for coming. And then we had a spontaneous hug. I don't know if he put his arms out first. I don't know if I put my arms out, but we just had a hug. and it was despite everything how uncomfortable he made me feel in the past it was so authentic and safe and real and then I said bye and he said bye
Starting point is 00:23:34 and that ended up being the last time I ever saw him but that wasn't the last time Jonathan and Mr. Hudson would talk or the last time Mr. Hudson would lean on Jonathan for support Seattle's economy is complicated inflation, tariffs, AI, layoffs. It's a lot to keep track of. That's where we come in. I'm Joshua McNichols.
Starting point is 00:24:01 And I'm Monica Nicholsberg. We host Booming, a podcast about the economic forces shaping our lives here in the Pacific Northwest. Every week, we dig into the big questions about our economy and where you fit in. Find Booming on the KOWW app or wherever you listen to podcasts. A couple of hours after Jonathan got home from visiting Mr. Hudson on his boat, The phone rang. It was Mr. Hudson calling. Their earlier conversation on the boat had felt raw and vulnerable,
Starting point is 00:24:36 but this was different. He was just like a shell of himself. There wasn't inflection in his voice. It's kind of like a dead man walking kind of thing. He said, Jonathan, I'm calling you so you can say bye to me. Unlike before where he was just like, here's my plan to commit suicide, he was using a euphemism. I'm going south.
Starting point is 00:24:58 I'm heading south. I inferred that he was going to kill himself and that he wanted to give me an opportunity to say bye to him and he wanted me to tell these other people who cared about him that he wanted to say bye but couldn't. Jonathan was a lifeguard, trained in emergency search and rescue. He kept a pager by his bed when he slept. He was oriented toward keeping people alive.
Starting point is 00:25:27 It felt like Jonathan was digging into his soul to keep Mr. Hudson from heading south. My reaction to that was, no, I'm not going to say bye to you. No, I'm not going to do these other things for you. I'm not going to say by to other people for you because you're going to call me tomorrow. Because you're not going to do this and you're going to commit to me that you're going to call me tomorrow.
Starting point is 00:25:54 But Mr. Hudson pushed back. he went into like talking about how worthless he was how he doesn't deserve to stay with with all these people how he doesn't deserve to have me in his life and so my kind of assertiveness and directiveness that wasn't working anymore so i you know went from my brain to to my heart and i was like i got emotional i was like no tom you mean so much to me it means so much to everyone else you are a good person, you do matter, you know. And at that point, I think I kind of wore him out. He said, okay, okay, Jonathan, okay, I'll call you tomorrow. I said, okay, bye. When they hung up, Jonathan hyperventilated. It was a panic attack. He'd never had one before.
Starting point is 00:26:45 He didn't want Mr. Hudson to die. And now he felt like he was the only one who could keep that from happening. Jonathan fell asleep that night, not knowing if he'd talked to his teacher ever again. Mr. Hudson didn't call the next day. But at school, Jonathan heard that someone had spoken to him. So Jonathan's gambit on the phone had worked. Mr. Hudson was still alive.
Starting point is 00:27:16 A week or two later, he called Jonathan. It was basically the same talk except this time he was much more stubborn and just you know Jonathan now is the time to say by to me you're not going to see me again I did my same tactics and it just didn't work and the way I describe it is it like
Starting point is 00:27:39 I mean it's this might sound weird but I like my life energy I tried to transfer into him through my words and sentiment and energy to try and you know like resuscitate his soul because that's what it seemed like it wasn't his mind or even his his brain he he had lost just like the grace to live but he wouldn't give up he wouldn't give up and i was just getting physically weaker on this call and i just my mind clicked on and was like jonathan now's your time to say goodbye so i said thank you tom for everything i'm so sad
Starting point is 00:28:22 that you're doing this. And I'm going to really, really miss you. And he said, okay, bye. And I said bye. And I subsequently learned he did not kill himself that night. And then I heard that he didn't even remember calling me because he was so drunk. And how could that be?
Starting point is 00:28:47 Like, how could destroying me not even be a memory for him? Mr. Hudson cast Jonathan, a 17-year-old high school student, into the role of counselor, therapist, and crisis responder. At Garfield, the lines between teachers and students, adults, and children had always been blurry. But for Jonathan, they'd now disappeared completely. Jonathan had two of these heavy phone conversations with Mr. Hudson. He told me he lived with a constant fear that the phone would ring again. or that worse, Mr. Hudson would find him in person. Jonathan, already an apprehensive teen, was wound so tight during this time that he'd erupt in anger over small things.
Starting point is 00:29:36 One day, after an argument with his brother, Jonathan jumped in his car and just kept driving. I just, like, bawled in my car for, like, 20 minutes. I remember I was overlooking Lake Washington on a hill, and I was just, like, I can't. I can't do this anymore. I didn't seek out help. I did talk to a few of my friends, my peers, that was helpful. But, you know, they were 17-year-olds too. They were also children. Yep. Jonathan would call me in just a state of like, what I don't know what to do with this. Rosie Baincraft was one of Jonathan's good friends. She remembers how distraught he was. Now that I know about this, I have to do something. I have no idea what to do. I have no idea if he's really going to do it. I feel like now that I know about it, it's on me. If he killed him. himself. Jonathan was drained. He couldn't take it anymore.
Starting point is 00:30:26 He had to stop talking to Mr. Hudson, regardless of the outcome. I decided, you know, I needed to tell Tom not to contact me again. So I called him one day in the afternoon. He was sober, or at least he sure
Starting point is 00:30:42 sounded. He sounded pretty normal. And, you know, I just said, Tom, I can't be there for you like you want me to be there for you. I can't have you call me anymore. He sounded so sad to hear that and abandoned, but understanding. And he said, okay, okay, Jonathan, I won't call you anymore.
Starting point is 00:31:09 Mr. Hudson kept his word. He stopped calling. After a few weeks, Jonathan felt better. Another teacher and some parents stepped in to help manage post-84, while he Mr. Hudson was suspended. And Jonathan had an epiphany. Maybe Mr. Hudson was a danger to his students,
Starting point is 00:31:33 he thought, and the investigation was the right thing to do. But soon after, during a post-84 meeting, a parent who attended said nobody had seen or heard from Mr. Hudson for a few days. Well aware
Starting point is 00:31:49 of Mr. Hudson's suicidal thoughts, Jonathan wondered if he followed through. He felt a flicker of emotion and then returned to his autopilot state of avoidance. Don't think about Tom. Keep the post afloat.
Starting point is 00:32:05 Graduate. A day or two later, Garfield principal, Cheryl Chow called the post-84 leaders to her office. She told them Mr. Hudson had died by suicide in a motel room north of Seattle.
Starting point is 00:32:21 I don't really remember what the principal said after that. You know, maybe I'm sorry, but I felt like less than a minute later, principal says, so I need your help. I need your help now. And I think she looked at me, maybe it was all of us, and was like, I need to know which students need to be gathered up to be told. And so, you know, I had 30 seconds to process this before this adult needed me.
Starting point is 00:32:54 to step up and get back into management mode. Jonathan and the other core post-84 members walked around the school, telling about 20 students from the program to meet in Garfield's Career Center, a big room with clunky computers. Jonathan had been instructed to wait for a counselor or the principal to join them. The adults would break the news to everyone. They waited and waited some more. clock was taken by, no one was there,
Starting point is 00:33:25 we were just like, there were no adults in the room. And I was like, this is not right. Most of the people in here had not been told formally. So I was like, quote, quote, an adult now. And so I then said everybody, like, as you know, I think some of you already know, Tom committed suicide. And he's gone. After Jonathan shared the news, he watched his classmates deflate.
Starting point is 00:33:53 Some kids went quiet and still. Others started crying. Eventually, a few adults did show up. I told myself, be strong, hold it together. You can feel your feelings when you get home, but be strong for your friends, be strong for your classmates. And I did for a little while, but then I think the principal offered me to call my parents to let them know. And so I was like, yeah, I think I should.
Starting point is 00:34:24 So I called my mom and I told her what happened and then I broke down. Mr. Hudson's death changed everything at Garfield. It ended the district investigation into his behavior with students. And it let loose a flood of vocal support from parents, students, and the outdoor community that revered him. Tom Hudson, the 58-year-old man facing allegations of sexual abuse, had been. died, but Tom Hudson, the legendary teacher, mentor, and leader was reborn. And Jonathan promoted that narrative. Under Jonathan's leadership, Post-84 celebrated Mr. Hudson's legacy. Jonathan wrote an obituary for Mr. Hudson and the messenger. And at the huge public
Starting point is 00:35:27 memorial, at the Hudson family's request, he delivered a eulogy for the man who changed his life. Jonathan didn't mention what he now calls the suicide talks, conversations that have made him feel guilty for a lot of his adult life. All the pain, the confusion, the shame, the hurt, the harm, the trauma that Tom caused in me, I put that into a box deep inside me. Then in my college years and in my 12th, 20s, my priority was to keep all that in that box. So while I say all these emotions, feelings, and confusion were down in the box, I did have a narrative in my mind. And it was a very brief,
Starting point is 00:36:21 concise narrative. And it was, Tom told me he wanted to kill himself and he was going to kill himself. He did not kill himself because I was there for him. I took. I told him. I told him, I couldn't be there for him. He killed himself. A couple of weeks ago, Jonathan called me. He'd just listened to episode two of this podcast. He'd heard our former classmate, Christina Mitchell, tell the story of how Garfield's principal at the time, Al Jones, took advantage of her. And it made him reconsider our earlier conversations. Jonathan said that when we first talked, he didn't tell me the whole story about the shower with Mr. Hudson. He'd been too ashamed to give me all the details.
Starting point is 00:37:14 The truth was, he said, Mr. Hudson was fully erect and staring at him. Jonathan said that was the first time he'd seen a man turned on. He was 15 years old. An alarm sounded in his brain at that moment, telling him he wasn't safe. It's the real, reason why Jonathan kept his distance from Mr. Hudson after that, why he intentionally missed the
Starting point is 00:37:43 Mount Olympus trip, and steered clear of Mr. Hudson's boat. But for all the space he put between them, Mr. Hudson still managed to dig deep into the psyche of this sweet boy, burdening him with the gut-wrenching responsibility of believing he was the only one who could prevent his teacher from killing himself. Today, Jonathan says he feels kinship with Christina. He is healing and thriving. Jonathan wants other survivors of abuse to hear this experience that life can get better. Through therapy, through friends, through family, and work, work and more work,
Starting point is 00:38:25 I've been able to work through a lot of that and understand a lot more about what happened. and that it was a really, really hard situation that I did my best in and that I actually have a lot to be proud of and that it was not my fault. Jonathan never told anyone about the shower with Mr. Hudson. But his story confirmed part of what my best friend Ella and I had heard at the start of the investigation back in 1999
Starting point is 00:39:01 that Mr. Hudson sometimes got aroused in the shower with his teenage students. Ella and I believed then, and now, that Mr. Hudson had been a serial abuser, a predator hiding in plain sight. He hurt Jonathan. How many others were there?
Starting point is 00:39:21 And did any adults try to stop him? That's on the next episode of Adults in the Room. In episode 5 of Adults in the Room, Ella and I had a mission for this podcast to prove the extent of Tom Hudson's abuse. So we found the man who led the school's original investigation to help us finish what he started. I wanted to try to get that out of the way to figure out what his interpretation of what was happening. His answers, as I remember, did not satisfy me.
Starting point is 00:40:08 But after hitting dead ends, we realized that part of the truth had been sitting right in front of us the entire time. This is why I wanted to talk to you. Because Because nobody needs to do this alone. And I have felt so alone in this for so long. That's coming up next. Adults in the Room is part of Focus, a dedicated documentary channel from KUOW Public Radio in Seattle, a proud member of the NPR Network. KUOW podcasts are made possible because of listener support.
Starting point is 00:40:42 If you enjoyed this podcast, please make a donation or become a monthly member at KUOW.org. original reporting for this project was done by me is older raftery ella hushagen genie andel and will james our producers are will james and alec cowen our editor is jeanie andle as always huge thanks to ella husagin music by b c campbell additional music by alec callum logo design by alicia via amelia peacock manages our marketing and promotions k uow w's director of new content is Brendan Sweeney. Our director of marketing is Michaela Giannati Boyle. KUAW's chief content officer is Marshall Island. I'm Azulteri. Thank you so much for listening. Soundside brings you beyond the headlines with news and conversation rooted in the Pacific Northwest. I'm Libby Dankman. Every week I sit down with local journalists for SoundSide's front page, where we give you a shortcut to understanding the latest news and cultural moments and how affect us here in the Puget Sound region. It's all here on Sound Side, on the radio or streaming
Starting point is 00:42:01 Monday through Thursday at noon and 8 p.m. on KUOW, on the KUOW app, or wherever you get your podcasts.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.