Murder, Mystery & Makeup - NFL superstar to cold blooded KILLER - the downfall of Aaron Hernandez

Episode Date: August 5, 2025

Hi friends, happy Tuesday! Okay... so... Aaron Hernandez has been all over the place recently because a new TV show came out about him. And I remember hearing about this guy in the news... but I neve...r really knew all the details. Until now... Friends... the Aaron Hernandez is a ride. His story goes from the highest of highs - playing in the fricken Super Bowl - to the lowest of lows - locked up for a horrible a crime. From fame and fortune, to murder in cold blood - this story is unforgettable. Also, let me know who you want me to talk about next time. Hope you have a great rest of your week, make good choices and I'll be seeing you very soon xo Bailey Sarian I sometimes talk about my Good Reads in show. So here's the link if you want to check it out. IDK. lol: https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/139701263-bailey ________ FOLLOW ME AROUND Tik Tok: https://bit.ly/3e3jL9v Instagram: http://bit.ly/2nbO4PR Facebook: http://bit.ly/2mdZtK6 Twitter: http://bit.ly/2yT4BLV Pinterest: http://bit.ly/2mVpXnY Youtube: http://bit.ly/1HGw3Og Snapchat: https://bit.ly/3cC0V9d Discord: https://discord.gg/BaileySarian RECOMMEND A STORY HERE: cases4bailey@gmail.com Business Related Emails: bailey@underscoretalent.com Business Related Mail: Bailey Sarian 4400 W. Riverside Dr., Ste 110-300 Burbank, CA 91505 ________ Cancel your unwanted subscriptions and reach your financial goals faster with Rocket Money. Go to https://www.rocketmoney.com/makeup today.  The best way to cook just got better. Go to https://www.hellofresh.com/makeup10fm now to Get 10 Free Meals + a Free Item for Life! One per box with active subscription. Free meals applied as discount on first box, new subscribers only, varies by plan.  Get the right life insurance for YOU, for LESS, and save more than fifty percent at https://www.selectquote.com/makeup. 

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Hi, friends. How are you today? My name is Bailey Sarian, and today is Monday, which means it's Murder Mystery Makeup Monday. If you're new here, hi, my name is Bailey Sarian, and on Mondays, I sit down, I talk about a true crime story that's been heavy on my noggin, and I do my makeup at the same time. If you're interested in true crime and you like makeup, I would say subscribe because I'm here for you on Mondays. So, have you ever heard the saying, not everything that glitters is gold? Well, let me tell you there's no truer example of that than the story of Aaron Hernandez. Now, this man who seemed to like have it all, he had it all. Booming NFL career, loving fiancé, beautiful daughter, a lifestyle that most people would like dream of.
Starting point is 00:00:49 But behind like all that glitz, all of that, there was a darkness. A darkness so deep entangled that even those closest to him could not see it coming. Mm-mm. So buckle up, baby, because today we are diving headfirst into one of the most shocking and downright twisted stories in NFL history. Oh, yes. That was a good intro. Aaron Hernandez went from the top of the sports world to frickin' rock bottom, and the fall was
Starting point is 00:01:18 violent, it was fast, and it was full of secrets. Aaron Hernandez, his brother actually wrote a book about his brother, Aaron. So I read his brother's book, and that's where, like, a lot of, I got a lot of information from it. Gave a lot of context, too. But let me just get into it. So Aaron, Michael Hernandez, he was born in Bristol, Connecticut, on November 6th, 1989. He was the second son to his parents, Dennis Hernandez, and Terry Valentine Hernandez.
Starting point is 00:01:53 I know a Valentine, cute last name. But according to Aaron, he said, Look, growing up in the home, there was, like, constant fighting going on. It was toxic. Aaron's dad, his name was Dennis. He actually had, like, a nickname in the city of Bristol. Everyone kind of called him the king because Dennis, he was regarded as, like, a local success story. It was said, Dennis, that he grew up as a, quote, like, scrappy kid who grew up in a family with Puerto Rican roots.
Starting point is 00:02:24 And as he was growing up, he had a lot of run-ins with the law, but he was able to, to like pull himself together as a teenager and become a Bristol Central High Football Star and had a football scholarship to the University of Connecticut. Connecticut. Thank you. And again, this was Aaron's dad. But you know, like those dreams didn't last forever when he was done playing football. He didn't go like pro or anything. And he ended up becoming a high school janitor. and Aaron's mom, she was working as a school secretary, which isn't bad. It's just, you know, he wanted more. So usually when a parent has big dreams, what happens? They push that onto their children and it definitely seemed like this was the case. It was said that both of the parents,
Starting point is 00:03:17 they were pretty rough in like their own ways. And both of them would be arrested and involved in crime during their lives. When Aaron was three years old, his father, Dennis, he was arrested and charged with like trying to buy cocaine from an undercover cop. He had a bit of a drug problem. Not great, right? And then when Aaron was eight, his father, he got into a fight with one of the school of football coaches and ended up punching him in the face, which led to his arrest.
Starting point is 00:03:53 He was one of those parents. You know what I'm saying? And then when Aaron was 11, his mom got arrested for being part of an underground sports gambling bookie operation that was working out of the family home. So what I'm getting at is there was a lot going on. There was a lot going on. It was said that Aaron's father was pretty hardcore.
Starting point is 00:04:18 Like he would often beat and belittle the kids. like nothing they did was good enough. And if their father was drinking, it seemed to be worse. But usually he would tell the kids, like, you're not working hard enough. They were just never doing like the right thing, you know? And as a kid, what I read in the book was that they still love their dad. I mean, as a kid, you just want your parents' approval. So it's like they were just going above and beyond trying to prove to their father that they were good enough.
Starting point is 00:04:49 It was said that like Aaron and his brother, they lived in constant. of like their father's beatings, which were so bad that, like, at times they would threaten their dad that they were going to call the police and in hopes that he would stop. But the dad would be like, go ahead, call them and, like, hand the kids the phone. Like, go ahead. Do it. And then he would tell the kids, like, if you call the police, I'm just going to beat you even harder.
Starting point is 00:05:14 So go ahead. You know, and as a child, I'm sure that's not ideal. You know, sucks. He just seemed really mean. Aaron would say that he remembered his mother, like, throwing his father out of the house on multiple occasions, but she would always end up, like, letting him back in. Aaron's family, they would all get together from time to time, you know, and that's when he saw that his cousins were into cheerleading. And to him, it seemed really fun. And his cousins were, like, really good at it.
Starting point is 00:05:48 They're doing flips. They're cheerleading, you know? And Aaron said that he wanted to be a cheerleader because his cousins, his cousins were good at it and he wanted to do it too. So I guess he told his parents that he wanted to do cheerleading. And let me tell you, that did not go well. Aaron's dad was just straight up like homophobic. He would call Aaron and his brother like just awful slurs, the bad ones, all the time. And even in the book, it was saying that Aaron's dad used to.
Starting point is 00:06:22 say that the way Aaron, like, stood or like had his hands on his hips and stuff, he would call him, he would just say, like, don't stand like that. You look like a F word, you know? And it was a lot of that. So him wanting to be a cheerleader was just, oh, hell no. Okay, he was not going to be a cheerleader, and it was not acceptable to his father. So instead, you know, they're dead. really focused on putting the kids into sports, you know, and they would play sports any chance they could. So they would play basketball. They would play football. And it seemed like their father just wanted, like, the boys to focus on football and be famous football players, really, you know, and just be like the best at it. Well, of course, Aaron played football, you know, and he was
Starting point is 00:07:18 really good at it. He was really good at it. He attended. Bristol Central High School, where he was named High School All-American after catching 24 touchdowns. When he was in elementary school and middle school, it was said that Aaron was like really skinny and just kind of like lanky, you know, but then when he reached high school, he went through like a growth spurt where he reached six foot two and he got all muscular and like he was practicing harder at football than anyone else. And he would tell his brother, like, dude, I'm going to be the best. I'm going to be the best.
Starting point is 00:07:56 And he was, like, just determined to be a star. It's such a shame because, like, I don't really understand the football lingo a lot. But based off what I was reading, I mean, like, he was really, really good and really something special. And it's just a shame. Thank you for coming to my TED Talk. So he's determined to be a star. And things were, like, really working out for him. During his junior year, he had captured the attention of college recruiters across the country.
Starting point is 00:08:22 He was getting calls from places like the University of Michigan, Notre Dame, Boston College, and the University of Florida. So it's like, he's got options. Okay, look, this is a side note because, like, I left it out of the script. Technically, like, he was supposed to go to the University of Connecticut and kind of, like, made a deal with the football coach there that he was going to go there. But then after realizing he had other options, he decided he wanted to go somewhere else. And there was some kind of, like, drama with that. But I'm breezing past it because it doesn't, it doesn't matter. Just saying that, because if you're an Aaron Hernandez fan, you're probably like, why aren't you mentioning that?
Starting point is 00:09:04 There you go. Okay. Great. So then Aaron's junior year of high school, 2006, Aaron's father, Dennis, he would go in, he was having stomach problems. So he went in for a hernia surgery. You know, it's a routine surgery, removing the hernia, whatever. After the surgery, like, he's healing fine. And then all of a sudden, just, like, things started to go downhill.
Starting point is 00:09:29 And they went downhill quick. And Dennis, his dad, ended up passing away at the age of 49. It said he got toxic shock. And then he died. So, again, it was just supposed to be a simple surgery, right? And, like, none of it made sense. And this was a huge loss to the family. and this is really when things just start going downhill.
Starting point is 00:09:56 So the other night I'm sitting there scrolling on my phone and I see this random charge pop up and I'm like, it finally happened. I've been hacked. Well, it turns out the hacker was me. I had a subscription still charging me from like two years ago for a streaming service that I forgot about. Completely, yeah.
Starting point is 00:10:16 Whoopsie. That's when I realized I needed help, keeping track of my stuff. And that's why I started using Rocket Money. Rocket Money is a personal finance app that helps find and cancel your unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending, and helps lower your bills so you can grow your savings. Yeah, I love it because it puts everything in one place, my bills, my subscriptions, even my paydays. Plus, you can set up custom budgets based on your past spending. Oh, yeah. Listen, it was kind of shocking to see how much I was actually spending on food delivery. Oh, God, I'm ashamed. And here's the best part. Rocket Money's
Starting point is 00:10:55 5 million members have saved a total of 500 million and canceled subscriptions, with members saving up to $740 a year when they use all the app's premium features. So if you're ready to stop throwing money into the void, check out Rocket Money today. Cancel your unwanted subscriptions and reach your financial goals faster with Rocket Money. Go to RocketMoney.com slash makeup today. That's rocketmoney.com slash makeup. Rocketmoney.com slash makeup. After his father's death, it was said that Aaron started dabbling with drugs.
Starting point is 00:11:37 A friend and like a teammate of his, his name was also Dennis. He recalled like smoking a lot of weed with Aaron. before school, before practice, and even, like, after the game, after football games and stuff. I guess they were high, like, all the time in high school. Then things got messy. So some of, like, Aaron's relatives, they also lived in Bristol and they, you know, they were close. He had one cousin. Her name was Tanya, and she was about, like, 14 years older than he was.
Starting point is 00:12:09 So she was, like, an older sister to him, some, an older sister he never had, you know, someone he could totally trust. But after his father died, he learned that his mother was having a romantic relationship with Tanya's husband. So obviously, major shock to Tanya, right? What? Huh? Yes. And also to Aaron. When Aaron found out about his mom having the relationship, whatever, it made him and Tanya grow closer in the relationship. And also, Aaron, like, really started to despise his mom, like, really did not like her. So Tanya would end up divorcing her husband, and it wouldn't take long for Tanya's ex-husband to, like, move in with Aaron's mom. So it was just, like, it was a lot, right? Like, your dad just died. Now your mom's with your
Starting point is 00:13:01 cousin's husband. Like, it was just a lot for him. So Aaron would spend a lot of his time at his cousin Tanya's house after learning about the affair. Like, he didn't want to be home anymore. And her house was across the street from the fields where Aaron used to play youth football. So it was like, it was just a second home to him. It was said at Tanya's house, that's where he like first really got introduced to weed and to like a lot of questionable people. It was said this is where at Tanya's house, it's where he acquired his streetwise mentality. So Aaron's transition from high school to the union. University of Florida was in January of 2007. It was marked by both anticipation and
Starting point is 00:13:50 controversy. He was pushed by the Florida Gators head coach, Urban Meyer, who was keen on recruiting young talent, and he wanted Aaron to graduate high school early to join the college football ranks. Now, Aaron, again, was really great athletically, but he wasn't like fully academically ready for college. It was said that he scored a 420 on his SAT, which was below the minimum requirement at Florida, where most of the freshmen scored 600 or above. So technically, he shouldn't have been allowed in, but it didn't matter, though, because he was great on the field, and the coach was like, you know, just he wanted him, right? And it's like, oh, he can focus on reading and writing in college. Like, it's fine. Just ignore it. Everything's fine. So they just really ignored
Starting point is 00:14:45 his low scores. So at just 17 Aaron's encounter with adulthood and its freedoms was off to a rocky start. There was an early incident at a Gainesville bar called The Swamp. And here's what happened. So that night, Aaron goes out to this bar with another college football star and teammate, Tim Tebow. First of all, Aaron was just 17 years old, so he shouldn't even have been at the bar drinking in the first place. But it said that like college football players kind of get treated like rock stars there. So the whole age thing didn't matter. So they go out. Aaron has like a couple of drinks at the bar and then was given the bill because you got to pay, right? Well, Aaron allegedly didn't think such a big football star like himself should have to pay for the drinks.
Starting point is 00:15:41 So an argument happened. And we don't really know what was said, but what we do know happened was that Aaron ended up punching the bar manager in the head. And the manager, he, like, suffered from a ruptured eardrum. Now, Aaron could have easily been charged with a felony over this. but again the college football stars they get treated differently so Aaron like called the coach his coach in the middle of the night gave him the details and the Gator's unofficial defense lawyer intervene soon afterwards the bar manager told the police that he was going to request
Starting point is 00:16:22 that the charges be dropped because he had been contacted by legal staff and coaches with the university and that they were just going to work on some kind of agreement. I know, must be nice. Well, is it? No. There's no consequences with these boys. In the end, Aaron never faced any charges. But this was like, red flag number one.
Starting point is 00:16:47 Aaron's teammates in Florida considered Aaron to be like a big-hearted clown. They gave him the nickname Chico and he like embraced it. His teammates would say that he always trying to be the life of the party. And like people either loved him or they just couldn't stand the guy. During his time at Florida, he was recognized as one of the top players in the nation. Like he was a key player on the 2008 BCS National Championship team. That's like speaking a different language. I don't know what that means, but like, yes, he was a very talented player.
Starting point is 00:17:24 but even with his fun personality, Aaron was facing some serious issues. He wasn't doing great in his classes, if he was even going. And he even got like mixed up in a scary situation involving a shooting in Gainesville that left two wounded. I tried to find more information about this because I was like, what? He wasn't part of this shooting. It was more of him being at the wrong. place at the wrong time. That's like all the information I could find. I think after the fact, people now think he probably was involved in some kind of way with whatever went down. Yeah, I don't even know if it was worth mentioning, but like I mentioned it. So, because I don't really know what, I don't know what the situation was. So despite all these problems, Aaron was still an amazing football player, he ended up receiving the John Mackie Award as the nation's best college tight end for his junior season at Florida in 2009, which is pretty huge. I feel so dumb. This is not my world. But I guess I looked it up. And the John Mackey Award is like presented
Starting point is 00:18:40 annually to the most outstanding college tight end in the United States. So that's very impressive, right? So Aaron, he had his eyeset on joining the NFL, which, you know, the real deal. But there were some more problems. Aaron was failing drug tests while he was at the University of Florida. And Scouts, I learned that football scouts, they do some serious digging. They hire private investigators to look into everyone's backgrounds to know like what they're investing in, which is good. But at the same time, how come they always overlook domestic abuse? I don't know.
Starting point is 00:19:23 But so scouts were looking into Aaron because he's amazing, right? But they didn't really like him and they were describing him as like a social misfit who had like a serious weed habit. So on top of that when they were looking into, you know, his past, they were concerns about his possible ties to like some kind of criminal behavior in his hometown of Bristol. He didn't technically have any charges on his record. But like there were some, there was some questions. He just, they weren't sure. Sure. So like a lot of recruits didn't want to touch him. But things were going to be all right for him because in 2010, Aaron was drafted by the New England Patriots in the fourth round of the NFL draft. Now this was major, right? Huge. Could you imagine? Major. So this was like his chance to like get things together, right? He's playing with the big boys now. And he showed up during his rookie year, Aaron had scored six touchdowns on five. 563 receiving yards, question mark, I don't know what that means, alongside quarterback Tom Brady.
Starting point is 00:20:30 Maybe you know what that means. Okay, so he's doing great. And in his second season, he helped the Patriots, you know, get all the way up to the Super Bowl. They ended up losing to the New York Giants 21 to 17, but I'm sure, like, this was quite the rush for him. I'm sure his dad, as mean as he was, I'm sure his dad would have been very proud. We're not. I'm not sure. But either way.
Starting point is 00:21:00 So as his fame and workload were growing, Aaron decided to hire like two friends to work as like his assistants. Now one of them, his name was Alexander Bradley, who technically was a drug dealer that Aaron met back in college. And I guess he was now working as his personal assistant. And it seems like mainly his weed supplier. And Alexander, like his job wasn't, I guess, just about getting drugs. He was also there to calm Aaron down whenever he would get angry or paranoid, just do things for Aaron. So at one point, Aaron had asked Alexander to buy him a $375 silver revolver for him. I don't know. He just wanted some guns. And the Patriots, the team, they kind of like turned a blind eye to Aaron's shenanigans. Like they knew he was up to no good. And they knew that he was smoking weed, allegedly. But again, he was such a good player. And they like, he was such an asset to the team. So they were just kind of like, you know, just looking the other way. And because Aaron did so well on his like rookie year,
Starting point is 00:22:16 year or whatever, the Patriots, the team, they went ahead and signed Aaron to a five-year $40 million contract extension with the Patriots. And this happened in August of 2012. Now, at this time, Aaron is 23 years old. I don't know about you, but I could not imagine being 23 years old with a $40 million contract. I'm sure if you don't have the right people around, it could easily destroy you right be stupid with the money buying stupid crap just being stupid it was said that Aaron often carried a gun around and some people that were around him thought that he was like a respectful nice guy especially for being a celebrity athlete but they would say like the friends that he was hanging around were just a bad influence
Starting point is 00:23:12 One friend who hung around, like, his circle, said that Aaron was very gullible and he was willing to just do whatever to, like, prove that he was badass or something. It was like he didn't realize that he was getting himself into a lot of trouble by hanging out with the wrong people. And a lot of people said that he was just a follower. So the Patriots, teammates described Aaron as an attention seeker who at times seemed unhinged. They would go on to say that he would have like these major mood swings where he would be like the most hyper, masculine, aggressive individual in the room and like was ready to fight anybody, you know, during like fits of rage. And then there would be other times where he would be like the most sensitive person in the room. And he would be talking about like cuddling with his mom or he would go up to other players asking like if he was good enough to play. He just seemed deeply insecure.
Starting point is 00:24:08 I guess there would be beef at times with their legendary team leader, Tom Brady, who would become enraged by Aaron's erratic behavior. It's like one minute Aaron would be like childlike, laughing and disruptive. And then the next, he would kind of storm off in a fit of rage. And then there was Aaron's lover, Shiana Jenkins. The two of them, they met when they were kids growing up in the same neighborhood in Bristol. They attended the same elementary and high school. school, which meant that they knew each other just from a very young age. Their families were
Starting point is 00:24:43 familiar with each other and they, you know, were childhood friends for like many years. As they grew older, their friendship eventually turned into a romantic relationship in high school. They broke up for a little bit when Aaron went to the University of Florida, but they still like stayed in touch. And then when he went into the NFL, I guess that's when they like decided to pick back up their relationship. Shiana eventually moved in with Aaron after he started playing for the New England Patriots, and then the couple ended up getting engaged in 2012. On November 6, 2012, Shiana gave birth to their daughter. You would hope this would make him grow up a little bit, you know, grow up. You have a family now, but nay, nay, of course not.
Starting point is 00:25:36 Do you ever have that moment where you, like, open the fridge and you're just standing there staring and realizing that the only thing looking back at you was a bottle of ketchup that expired in 2021? Yeah. Maybe that was too real. Maybe that's me. Maybe I'm looking in a mirror. I don't know. Anyways, you're standing there like, damn, I'm hungry.
Starting point is 00:25:56 And honestly, that ketchup, it has calories. I wouldn't mind. Well, guess what? Listen, it doesn't have to be like that. Because there's Hello Fresh. HelloFresh is a meal kit delivery service that sends chef-crafted recipes and fresh pre-portioned ingredients right to your door. And this summer, HelloFresh made their biggest menu upgrade yet. They doubled their menu so you can choose from 100 options every week.
Starting point is 00:26:23 And if you're like me and love variety, you can get steak and seafood recipes every single week at like no extra cost. You'll also get bigger portions that actually keep you full and satisfied. Hello Fresh brings me meals that I'm actually excited to cook. I know. I made these like cute. Yeah, they were cute. Pork fajita lettuce wraps. Yeah, that's how cute.
Starting point is 00:26:47 Wow. They were easy and delicious. And nine out of ten people say dinner is more delicious with Hello Fresh. And I completely understand why. Because let's be honest, no one should ever have to like make a meal out of ketchup. and um and ketchup the best way to cook just got better go to hellofresh.com slash makeup 10 fm now to get 10 free meals plus a free item for life oh yeah one per box with active subscription free meals applied as discount on first box new subscribers only and it varies by plan that's hellofresh dot com slash makeup 10
Starting point is 00:27:30 M to get 10 free meals plus a free item for life. In July of 2012, Aaron was at the Cure Lounge one evening. He's partying and he was hanging out with his friend, Alexander. It was said at around 12.30 a.m. inside of the club, a guy named Daniel Diabro, bumped into Aaron, causing him to like spill his drink on himself. That was it. Okay? And I guess that was enough to set Aaron off.
Starting point is 00:28:09 Alexander said that Aaron was getting all riled up and that it was best if they just left the club. So the two of them leave the club and they're like outside and Aaron is fuming. Like he can't freaking let it go. Then Aaron noticed that that guy Daniel who ran into him and his friend Seferro were leaving the club. So I guess Aaron like turns to Alexander and he tells him like, let's let's go. Let's go. Let's like follow them. So it's around 2.30 a.m.
Starting point is 00:28:38 Aaron and his friend Alexander, they hop into their car. It's a silver SUV and they hit the road. And they catch up to the car that Daniel and Seferro were in. And they like pull up next to them. So I got a red light. Witnesses later testified. that someone in Aaron's car had shouted at the other men saying like, what's up now? Just like shouting at them and then screaming like some racist stuff before firing five shots
Starting point is 00:29:13 into the vehicle, which ended up killing both of the men. So the SUV with Aaron and his friend, they, you know, they take off and they end up taking the SUV to Aaron's cousin's garage, Tanya, to keep it hidden for a while because they just freaking killed someone so they're like, we need to hide the car. So naturally, police come out to the scene and investigate, figure out what the frick happened. And they were looking into surveillance footage from the club that night to determine, like, who killed these men, right? And on the footage, they actually saw Aaron, Aaron Hernandez, on the footage. And at first, like, the police even said they just thought, like, oh, what a coincidence.
Starting point is 00:30:00 You know, like, he's a big football star and he was at the club. That's funny. Like, they didn't think he was a part of it. The only thing they had to go off of the police was, like, finding that SUV that was involved in the attack. But they were having no luck locating the vehicle. So the police, they said that they had, like, they had no luck. leads. They had no leads because both Daniel and Seferro had no criminal history. They had no enemies. They worked cleaning buildings at night and were just like good, honest people. And the
Starting point is 00:30:35 killing made no sense. Now the police, again, they were not looking into Aaron at this time because technically Aaron did not have a criminal record himself. Like yes, he had those involvements earlier, but there was never any, like, police reports made, so there was nothing on his record. And again, the police were like, he's a big football star. Like, what would he have to do with this crime? You know? The case kind of goes cold because they don't even know who they're looking for. It was really sad for the family, like, these men that got killed.
Starting point is 00:31:05 They just seemed like they're, it was just like so, so sad. Like, they just seemed like really good people. And they got killed for literally no freaking reason. And the families, you know, they were preparing to bear. Daniel and Seferro side by side, like in a Boston cemetery. And meanwhile, Aaron was off partying, like nothing happened. He was spotted within like days of the murders, riding jet skis with a bunch of his like Bristol friends in a fancy harbor town of Newport Road Island.
Starting point is 00:31:44 He literally just killed two people, you know? It's like pretty wild. So at this point, like, Aaron is getting away with his crimes over and over again. And I think it was just like proving to himself that he was untouchable. It seemed like he could get away with anything at this point. Aaron would literally go on to play a full season of football after killing two people. Like, nothing happened. And he did a really great job.
Starting point is 00:32:15 Like, it's just wild. So then in February of 2013, Aaron and his friend, Alexander, they flew down to Miami, Florida. And they were there because they wanted to party with one of Aaron's old teammates from the Florida gators. His name was Deontay Thompson. So they go down there and they started like their party in Deontay's hometown, Belle Glade. And then they headed to a Miami strip club called Tootsies. And I guess like the first night that they were there, Aaron had spent like $10,000 that first night. So while they were there partying in the VIP section, it was said that Aaron started to act all paranoid because he thought that the two older men that were sitting by them, he swore that they were cops from Boston.
Starting point is 00:33:07 Now there was no proof to even believe that these guys were cops. But Aaron was telling his friend Alexander like, those are fucking cops. and being just paranoid, truly paranoid. And then on the second night at Tootsies, because they go again, things got tense between Aaron and Alexander. It was said that they got into a fight over the bar bill. And then Alexander, like, forgot his phone in the club. And this seemed to just really annoy Aaron, like, he was raging.
Starting point is 00:33:42 So he's in a bad mood and he tells everyone, like, let's go. were leaving, right? So the whole group, they all leave. They get into the car and they drove like north on Interstate 95. Alexander was in the back seat and he fell asleep. Alexander later testified that he woke up to Aaron holding a gun pointed right between his eyebrows. He has no idea like what is going on. And that's the last thing he remembers. Now the next morning as the sun came up, Police found Alexander lying in a parking lot bleeding from a bullet wound between his eyes. Aaron, nowhere to be found. At this point, he had already flown out of Florida thinking like he was done with Alexander for good.
Starting point is 00:34:30 Now, surprise, surprise. Luckily, like Alexander survived. Now, he ended up losing his right eye and needed like several surgeries. So despite everything, Alexander, he refused to. cooperate with the police, so they, the police, couldn't like prove or even link Aaron to the crime. Alexander, he would later testify in court that he didn't want to involve the police and he wanted to like handle it on his own and he wanted revenge. In my personal opinion, I think he wanted to get money from Aaron and you'll see. So if he involved the police,
Starting point is 00:35:10 he wouldn't be able to like blackmail him. You know, Alexander, he ends up living. Now, Aaron doesn't know this. And the next day, Alexander, he ends up calling up Aaron. And he's like, guess who? And Aaron, like, played dumb acting like he didn't know who it was. He's like, what, who's this? Who's this? I don't know.
Starting point is 00:35:28 But once the conversation ended, text messages from Alexander just start rolling in. In one of the texts, he said, like, you left me with one eye and a lot of head trauma. You owe for what you did. And then Aaron wrote back, like, if you ever got me. me in trouble or ruin my life for something I didn't do, you will pay. Just going back and forth, back and forth. And Alexander, like, he wasn't scared because he knew the truth, right? And he was telling Aaron, like, you don't scare me. You know, I have tons of guns. And I'm going to do something about it, essentially. Brian Murphy, who was Aaron's agent, found out about the shooting.
Starting point is 00:36:09 Aaron had told his agent that this Alexander guy was like threatening to either get money from him or kill him. So Brian Murphy, he reached out to Alexander's lawyer to try and like settle things quietly, but like that didn't work. There were no charges were ever filed against him for the shooting and nobody like informed the Patriots coach about the situation. So it just kind of was going under the radar. And again, mind you. Aaron is still playing football. He's doing really great and buying a big old mansion. Everything is just like fine and dandy.
Starting point is 00:36:47 But, you know, things are growing in Aaron's mind. Like his paranoia was hitting a new level. So he ended up hiring another friend from his hometown. His name was Ernest. He went by Beau. Wallace is his last name. And he hired this guy to be like his bodyguard around the clock. And just like with like Aaron's other friends,
Starting point is 00:37:09 Ernest also had a criminal record, but Aaron, you know, he trusted him to have his back. Aaron's really paranoid. So he ends up like in early April. Aaron had sent $15,000 to a friend. His name was Oscar Hernandez, no relation. And he was using this money to buy a used Toyota with two 22 caliber handguns and two rifles inside. And I guess in this car, they like made specific compartments where the guns would be hiding. Aaron would occasionally check in with this guy, Oscar, asking if like everything was going smoothly. And Oscar was like, hell yeah, you know, I almost got everything. But Aaron didn't, he didn't stop there.
Starting point is 00:37:55 He also spent over $110,000 on an armored 2013 Chevrolet, Suburban. that had been outfitted as an armored car. It was like a mini war wagon. For him, it was to feel safer. You know, he was paranoid that someone was going to come after him for what he had done. Meanwhile, Alexander, he's still around like he's texting Aaron, pushing Aaron for money. He's texting Aaron, like, you can't go through life consequence free when you do certain shit, you know? And a confrontation seemed to be getting closer and closer.
Starting point is 00:38:36 Then on June 3rd, Alexander texted Aaron saying that he would be near the Patriots Stadium waiting there, like after practice, armed with a semi-automatic handgun, and he would be wearing a bulletproof vest. That day, the two of them exchanged like a staggering 125 text messages just full of insults, accusations, threats. It was all talk because like nothing. ended up happening. But Alexander had warned Aaron that he was going to go public with a lawsuit if Aaron did not pay up. The next day after all of the threatening text messages, Alexander had
Starting point is 00:39:15 like texted Aaron demanding $5 million from him. It's like $5 million and this will all go away, you know? Aaron came back and offered him $1.5 million. And then Alexander came back saying, I'll accept $2.5 million. It was just kind of messy and sloppy. And, like, Like, they just kept going back and forth because then Alexander filed a federal suit against Aaron, and then he withdrew it like four days later before the news media caught wind of it. So I don't really know what happened there, you know, because then Aaron's agent had texted Aaron saying, like, they withdrew the lawsuit so we can engage in settlement talks without like the media getting involved and that this was a huge win for us. So that's cool, I guess. But despite the win, the situation was just one part of like the trouble that was brewing in Aaron's life. And it wouldn't be long before things got even worse.
Starting point is 00:40:19 Have you ever heard of the Slayer's statute? Their actual laws that stop someone from inheriting money if they murder the person they're supposed to inherit. it from. Yep, learning something new every day, huh? Listen, it exists. I'm sure you know why, because people really have tried to cash in on someone else's life insurance policy. Yep, but it does make you realize just how valuable life insurance actually is. And that's why so many people turn to Select Quote. Select Quote is one of the most trusted life insurance brokers in the country. For over 40 years, they've helped more than two million Americans secure over $700 billion in coverage. Unlike one-size-fits-all companies, select quotes agents actually work
Starting point is 00:41:03 for you. Not the insurance carriers. In as little as 15 minutes, they'll compare policies from top-rated carriers to find the best fit for your health and your budget, and they do this for free. For me, knowing my family's covered and that nobody can pull a real-life true crime plot twist on my policy can give me, it gives me a lot of peace of mind. Honestly, life insurance is is never cheaper than it is today. So don't wait, go to SelectQuote. They shop, you save. Get the right life insurance for you for less
Starting point is 00:41:36 and save more than 50% at selectquote.com slash makeup. Save more than 50% on term life insurance at SelectQuote.com slash makeup today to get started. That's selectcote.com slash makeup. So that brings us to Odin Lloyd. Now, Odin, he was born in November of 1985 and it was said that he grew up in a tough neighborhood, you know, and Odin saw football as like his way out and a chance at a better life for himself. By the time he was 27, Odin was playing semi-pro football for the Boston bandits and had become good friends with Aaron. Now, they became close partly because Odin was dating Shania Jenkins, who happened to be the sister of Aaron's fiancé, Shiana Jenkins.
Starting point is 00:42:33 That's how they like got to know each other. But you know, as they're spending time together, Aaron and Odin, they found out that they had a lot in common. Like, they both obviously enjoyed playing football. They both enjoyed smoking weed, playing video games, and like going out to nightclubs. So they started hanging out like a lot. On the night of June 15, 2013, Odin bought Aaron a drink at a Boston club called Rumor. And it seemed like an ordinary night. But according to prosecutors, something that Odin said or did that evening upset Aaron.
Starting point is 00:43:09 What was said has never been clearly proven. And it remains like one of the biggest mysteries of this case. Nobody knows exactly what happened. but after this, Odin was on Aaron's shit list pretty much. And then two days later, on June 17th, Aaron had been drinking with friends at his cousin Tanya's house. So they're all hanging out at Tanya's house and they texted Odin asking him to hang out. Around 2.33 a.m., Aaron and his friends Ernest Wallace and this guy Carlos Ortiz picked up
Starting point is 00:43:48 Odin from his house. I know. I was like 233 a.m. Like, who is up? They were. At that moment, Odin started to feel like something was off. Like, he sat in the car, right? And when he's in the car, Odin is texting his sister. And it's like three in the morning. And he texts his sister saying, like, did you see who I'm with? And I guess she didn't answer right away. Like a few minutes had passed. And then he texted her again saying like, hello. And then his sister responded. saying like who. And Odin replied saying NFL, referring to Aaron Hernandez. Odin's last message was sent at 3.23 a.m. to his sister saying just so you know. So many speculate that he felt like something was up and he was letting his sister know like who he was with. Now literally
Starting point is 00:44:40 everything that happened in between big mystery. What we do know was that Odin was shot six times and left to die in an industrial park near Aaron's home, which was in North Attleboro, Massachusetts. The next morning, there was a jogger out minding his own freaking business, and that's when he came across Odin's body. And, you know, it was confirmed that he had been killed just a short distance from Aaron's mansion. So the police quickly come out and start investigating, and I was watching, like, interviews from what the police who were at the scene, and they were. were like, this was a sloppy job. The killer did a very sloppy job. Because nearby there was a white towel found. There were shoe prints and tire prints in the mud. This was like a muddy area.
Starting point is 00:45:33 There was a half-smoked blunt lying nearby. And the only tie Odin had to this neighborhood was Aaron Hernandez. So police searched phone records and saw that Aaron's phone was hitting cell towers that lined up with the crime. They also matched Aaron's shoe prints to those found in the mud. They matched the car tire marks to the ones in the mud with Aaron. They got surveillance footage from Aaron's house the night of the murder. And on the footage, there was like after the murder, they saw Aaron holding what looked like a gun.
Starting point is 00:46:16 Again, there were those text messages from Odin to his sister saying like who he was with. Everything was pointing to Aaron. The police ended up searching Aaron's mansion June 18th, 2013, and then again, June 22nd, 2013. Listen, the media got a hold of this story, right? And it was wild. It was all over the place. You couldn't avoid it. Aaron was being followed everywhere he's.
Starting point is 00:46:46 went, being questioned, there was this one shot of, there was like a helicopter following Aaron and he's driving on the freeway on his way to practice. He was either on his way to practice or he was meeting up with his coach or whatever. But it was on like every news media outlet. And of course, all of them were comparing it to OJ and his Bronco. Like it was definitely giving that same feeling. So on June 26, 2013, Aaron, Hernandez was arrested at his home and charged with first degree murder of Odin Lloyd, along with five firearm violations. There was a Globe sports writer who was, his name's Greg Bedard. He was outside of like Aaron's house that morning. He remembered the scene. He said that there must have been like
Starting point is 00:47:36 six or seven cop cars that drove in. And then not long after that, Aaron came out in cuffs wearing a white t-shirt and then he said like at that moment he realized this is not going to end well for Aaron Hernandez and maybe you remember I don't know why but like that is burdened to my memory of Aaron coming out with the white t-shirt on do you remember that that scene and like he didn't have his arms in the holes it was just over I don't know I just remember it so well thank you so much less than two hours after his arrest the Patriots obviously they released him from the team. Everyone wanted a statement from them. So like the Patriots owner, Robert Kraft, told the media that he felt he and the organization had been duped by Aaron.
Starting point is 00:48:23 And then Coach Belichick, he was a little bit more reserved in his response. He kind of kept things vague. He gave like a seven-minute statement, barely mentioning Aaron's name. One of the things he said was that like overall he was proud of the hundreds of players that had come through the program, but that personally, in that moment, he was disappointed and hurt. But like, never really mentioned Aaron's name. The investigation quickly spread to Aaron's friends and family, and on August 1st, 2013, Aaron's cousin, remember, Tanya? She was sent to jail because she refused to testify before the grand jury about what she knew. Plus, the police had found the the SUV that they were hiding from that first shooting in her garage.
Starting point is 00:49:19 And she didn't want to say anything. She kept her mouth shut. She was loyal to Aaron. So she got in trouble. And then Aaron's legal troubles just like kept piling up. So Ernest Wallace bled not guilty to being an accessory after the murder on September 19th, 2013. and then Aaron himself pled not guilty to Odin's murder on September 6th. Carlos Ortiz was charged with being an accessory to Odin's murder on September 27th,
Starting point is 00:49:51 and he also pled not guilty. Aaron's fiance, Cheyana Jenkins, she was also pulled into the investigation. This happened on October 16th, 2013, and she pled like not guilty to perjury charges. she was accused of lying to the grand jury about helping Aaron get rid of a box that was believed to have contained the murder weapon. Because they couldn't find the murder weapon. It disappeared. These charges were eventually dropped. Meanwhile, Alexander, the friend who said Aaron had shot him in the face in Miami, he filed a lawsuit against him. And it just wasn't looking good. Aaron's lawyer stated that Aaron would be in. invoking his Fifth Amendment rights in this case, meaning that he would not be answering any
Starting point is 00:50:39 questions about the whole shooting with Alexander. Now, at first, when he was arrested, he was held at the Bristol jail in a section for like mentally ill or violent inmates, but he was still like a football star and it seemed like he got some privileges. So guards, they would let him do like pull-ups on the stairs outside of his cell and exercise in like a small cement courtyard instead of like locking him up in one of the cells like everybody else. In the summer of 2014, Aaron was moved to the Suffolk County Jail in Boston while awaiting trial. It was said he played a lot of card games. He asked his fiance to bring him more Harry Potter
Starting point is 00:51:22 books. I guess he really liked the Harry Potter books. And during his time in jail, Aaron just like really clung to the people who would still like take his calls like his fiancee his mom some of his old friends his fiance would like call him they would talk on the phone like twice daily she seemed really frustrated with him to be fair she had a good reason to be frustrated with him i mean he ruined everything on may 15 2014 things got even more serious when erin was indicted on two counts of for a serene murder for the 2012 shootings of those two men, Daniel and Safiro, the one that happened outside the club. Yeah. So that now was added to his list of charges. Aaron, he pled not guilty. And then he was indicted for witness intimidation related to the 2013 shooting of
Starting point is 00:52:17 Alexander. So listen, it was just a whole mess and everything was coming up, just come back up. You can't run from it. Karma. Is that karma? Consequences for his actions. So the trial for the murder of Odin Lloyd had started on January 29th, 2015, and it lasted about three months. Prosecutors showed the jury video footage that they said proved Aaron had picked up Odin Lloyd
Starting point is 00:52:47 in his car. They then showed footage taken later at Aaron's house where Odin was like no longer in the car. They also presented an image of Aaron's home surveillance system that showed him standing outside his basement, holding what the district attorney said looked like a gun. Now, Aaron's defense team argued that being there wasn't enough to prove he was guilty. They were trying to say, like, that the other two guys that were there with Aaron that night, they were actually the ones that killed Odin and that Aaron was scared that they were going to do something to him. him if he said anything so he didn't say anything and that him and Odin were really good friends and he would never do this to a good friend. Like that's what they were saying. The prosecution believed that Odin was killed with a 45 caliber glock pistol, which uses a magazine or like a clip to load
Starting point is 00:53:46 bullets. And then in court, they showed text messages that Aaron had sent to his friend Ernest just a week before Odin's murder where Aaron was mentioning clips for the gun. Prosecutors also pointed out that like many text messages had been deleted from Aaron's phone and like the other two guys, which suspicious, you know? Well, listen, on October 15, 2015, after six days of discussing the evidence, The jury ended up finding Aaron Hernandez guilty of Odin Lloyd's murder. Everyone in the courtroom was very emotional. Like, yeah, I mean, for a good reason, you know?
Starting point is 00:54:36 But like, Aaron showed no emotion. Like, nothing. He was sentenced to life in prison without, like, any chance of getting out. Okay? You think, I don't know, he would show some kind of emotion. The other two guys, Aaron's friends, Carlos and Ernest, They were like tried separately and were found guilty of being accessories to the murder. They were each sentenced to like four to seven years in prison.
Starting point is 00:55:00 Aaron was sent to like a high security prison about 40 miles outside of Boston. And while Aaron was in prison, he opened up to his mother in ways that he hadn't before. Now him and his mom had a pretty like rocky relationship. He was telling her on the phone like that she never really, she never really knew. knew him and that he couldn't trust her. And then eventually he opened up and told her like two painful secrets. He ended up telling her that he was gay and that he had been molested as a child. Let me put this wig on.
Starting point is 00:55:41 Aaron's lawyer, his name is George, he thought like admitting this to his mom like helped him Aaron like deal with his feelings of self-hatred because he seemed to really not like himself. So Aaron hired a new defense lawyer, Jose Baez, for his second murder trial that started in March of 2017. Jose is considered to be like a celebrity lawyer because you know who he represented previously? You'll never guess. Casey Anthony. Oh yeah. Look, if someone's going to get you out of being super guilty, I think it'd be this guy. Don't you feel like if you hire like a lawyer who's represented someone who is super guilty, that just kind of makes you look super guilty too?
Starting point is 00:56:31 Or is that just me? It's like, oh, you must be super guilty if you're hiring Casey Anthony's front of lawyer. So this second trial was about the 2012 shooting of Daniel and Seferro. And Aaron and his old friend Alexander, remember, they were the ones being accused. of these murders. Now, this time, Alexander actually testified against Aaron to avoid facing murder charges himself. The two had become enemies after Aaron shot him in the face in Florida. I mean, understandable. But, you know, Aaron had hired this guy who just, like, knew what he was doing. And on April 14, 2017, the jury decided that Aaron was not guilty of the murders. They didn't
Starting point is 00:57:18 believe Aaron was the one who fired the gun. Plus, they really pointed the finger at Alexander because Alexander had like a lengthy track record. So they're like, it was that guy. It wasn't good. Now, this was the first time you actually saw some emotion from Aaron. Like when they read the verdict, Aaron cried. And I guess like this win gave him hope that his lawyer might be able to challenge the conviction for Odin Lloyd's murder next. Like they were going to try and prove, that Aaron was not the one who shot the gun. On April 18th, 2017, Aaron Hernandez ended up taking his own life. It was really like dramatic. So that night, the door to a cell opened and he stepped out like it was any other day. But instead of going to the gym, he ended up like turning
Starting point is 00:58:09 back around and going back into his cell. And like another inmate snuck into Aaron's cell and like hid under the bed. Aaron wasn't planning to work out. Instead, he and this other inmate, they smoked a drug called K2. It looks like weed, but I guess it's like way more dangerous. So the two of them, I guess, talked about life, God, and death. And then two hours later, the other inmate left. Prison officials didn't seem to notice any of this, none of it. And then Aaron, he made his usual phone calls, the last one being with his fiance. She said that their conversation was completely normal. Everything seemed fine. He returned to his cell just before 8 p.m. Aaron chatted with like other inmates through his door. A guard passed by his cell like several times during the
Starting point is 00:59:03 night. But around 3 a.m., the guard noticed a sheet hanging over Aaron's cell door. So he called out to Aaron and was getting like no response. So he he actually opened up the door and that's when he found Aaron hanging from the window bars with a bed sheet around his neck. Also there were shampoo spread all over the floor so it would be like really slippery and Aaron had written John 316 on his forehead in blood. Yeah. Bible verse about God. God's love and eternal life. And then he also drew a series of like symbols and references, including what looked like an unfinished pyramid and an all-seeing eye, which, you know, commonly associated
Starting point is 00:59:58 with Masonic or Luminati imagery. All of this just added mystery, what, what, right, like bizarre, what? But very confusing. So the guards, they finally freed him, they cut him down. They took turns doing chest compressions until the paramedics arrived, but it was too late. At 407 a.m., Aaron Hernandez was declared dead. Okay, look, there's a theory that Aaron Hernandez might have taken his own life in attempt to secure financial benefits for his fiancé and their daughter.
Starting point is 01:00:36 The idea is based on a legal concept known as abatement. ab initio i know i was like what listen's real thing the first person who did this was like a catholic priest who did some shit and got away with it which that should be another murder mystery but listen here's how it works and why people believe this is this might have been his motive so the abatement whatever rule in massachusetts at the time of aaron's death the legal principle of abatement Avenicio meant that if a person died while their criminal case was still under appeal, their conviction would be vacated. Essentially, it would be as if they were never convicted of the crime. So since Aaron Hernandez had appealed his 2015 conviction for the murder of
Starting point is 01:01:27 Odin Lloyd, his death on April 19, 2017 triggered this legal rule, resulting in his conviction being temporarily vacated. Now, by having his murder conviction vacated, Aaron might have believed it would allow his family to pursue any remaining salary or bonuses owed to him from his NFL contract with the Patriots. Also, it could have prevented wrongful death lawsuits filed by Odin Lloyd's family from moving forward against his estate. If Aaron's conviction was erased, the Patriots in the NFL might have been legally obligated to pay out his contract, potentially providing financial support to his fiancee and his daughter. Also, Aaron left three suicide notes before his death, one for his fiance, one for his
Starting point is 01:02:27 daughter, and one for his lawyer, Jose Baez. The content of these letters hasn't been fully disclosed, but reports suggest that they contained messages of love and hinted that he might have been thinking about this strategy. Jose, the lawyer, later confirmed that Aaron was aware of this, this rule. You know what I'm saying? So a lot of people think that's what he was trying to do. After Aaron's autopsy, his brain was sent to a neuropathologist. Her name is Dr. Anne McKee. It was sent to her research lab at Boston University. And Dr. Anne McKee is one of the leading experts in the world studying the long-term effects of brain injuries, especially in athletes, military veterans, and like others who have experienced repeated concussions and like head
Starting point is 01:03:27 impacts, you know? So she's like the one who's like studying this. She's the shit. Dr. McKee announced that Aaron had the worst case of CTE that she had ever seen in someone so young. What CTE? Well, maybe you've heard of it. But CTE is a brain disease caused by repeated head injuries, which is like really common among football players, you know? They're constantly, she studied Aaron's brains. And like part of his brain had shrunk while others had become unusually large.
Starting point is 01:04:03 There were microbleeds and a protein called tau, which usually is found in Alzheimer's patients' brains, yes. But it was all over his brain. She said on a scale from one to four, four being like the worst, Aaron's CDE was rated as stage three. I was watching this interview with her and she showed a picture of like a normal brain at his age and then his brain. and his brain full on holes just missing parts. It was wild. Like his head was fucked up. So Dr. McKee explained that people with severe CTE often have trouble controlling like
Starting point is 01:04:43 their impulses making decisions and usually they have a really hard time managing their anger. Now is this an excuse? No. You know, it's not an excuse. He still did what he did. But it gives us some like answers and insight as to why he was so paranoid, just psychotic, really, you know? Well, finally, on March 13, 2019, the Massachusetts Supreme Court changed its mind and decided that Aaron's conviction should not have been erased, making him officially guilty of Odin Lloyd's murder once again. So that meant his conviction was reinstated, which would stop any potential financial benefits
Starting point is 01:05:30 his family might have received from his suicide. It's not proven that Aaron killed himself solely for financial reasons. There's evidence suggesting that he was aware of this potential legal loophole and may have hoped his death would benefit his family financially. But listen, like his plan ultimately didn't work. out, you know, it didn't work out the way he might have intended. That was a lot. And that is everything I learned about the Aaron Hernandez case, my friends.
Starting point is 01:06:10 Look, at the end of the day, it's a shame because he was really talented. I don't watch football or anything like that. I know, I'm sorry, whatever. But like I was watching clips of him and like he was so good and it's such a shame, huh? I don't know. Sports, huh? Yeah. You know what's funny, actually.
Starting point is 01:06:28 It's not funny. But when you think about, like, crazy sports person who's crazy, I, like, I always think OJ, OJ, right? OJ. It's always OJ, OJ. But Aaron, Aaron, he's kind of like, he did worse. I don't know. I guess it isn't a competition of who's worse. I think maybe they're both bad, Bailey.
Starting point is 01:06:56 Two things can be right at the same time. Anyways, I hope you have a good rest of your day. You make good choices. You be safe out there, please. And I'll be seeing you guys later. Goodbye. Bye. Thank you.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.