Murder, Mystery & Makeup - Runaway Sugar Baby or MURDER Cover-Up? This Case has tons of WTF Moments

Episode Date: September 20, 2022

Hi friends, how are you today? I hope you are having a wonderful day so far! I have really been enjoying these stories from long ago, the women sure were a little cray, to say the least. But I must sa...y, there were a lot of strange coincidences going on around Louise's life, wasn't there? She was the definition of suspish to say the least. Thank you for tuning into Murder, Mystery & Makeup. I love and appreciate you so much, and I hope to be seeing you very soon. xo Bailey Sarian Watch the original video here and make sure you subscribe to my YouTube @BaileySarian!

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Hi friends, how are you today? I hope you're having a wonderful day so far. And if you're not having a wonderful day, don't worry. It's gonna get better. I'm rooting for you. My name is Bailey Sarian, and today is Monday, which means it's murder, mystery, and makeup Monday. Shana-shay, shana-shay, shana-shay-shay-shay-shay-shay. If you are new here, hello, how are you?
Starting point is 00:00:25 My name is Bailey Sarian, and on Mondays I sit down and I talk about a true crime story that's been heavy on my noggin, and I do my makeup at the same time. If you're interested in true crime and you like makeup, I would highly suggest you hit that subscribe button because I'm here for you on Mondays. But other than that, I will stop yip yapping
Starting point is 00:00:46 and let's talk about Louise. Okay, Louise, she was born September 30th, 1880. But the crazy ones were in like the 1800s, early 1900s. I don't know what it was. Something was in the water. She was born in Bienville, Louisiana. Did I say that right? I probably was born in Bienville, Louisiana. Did I say that right? I probably did not.
Starting point is 00:01:07 Bienville, Louisiana, okay? And her father was super wealthy. Oh yes, very wealthy man. He ran a newspaper company. And honestly, it was very clear to Louise that she came from a very privileged life. At the age of 15, she would go on to attend a private school in New Orleans, New Orleans, do you remember?
Starting point is 00:01:31 Couple of videos ago, I said New Orleans. I got roasted in the comments. I get it. So she goes to a private school, New Orleans, but she wouldn't last there too long because she was expelled. She got caught stealing from her classmates. And then the final nail in the coffin
Starting point is 00:01:49 was when she was caught engaging in some sexual behavior with other boys in the school, you know? So she got kicked the heck out. There was really not much information about her upbringing. Like I was trying to figure out where her mom was at and stuff and again, cause it's such an old story. It's like, good luck. So some of the details are missing, but you'll get it.
Starting point is 00:02:11 It's still a very interesting one. So she grows up very privileged family, wealthy, great. And then in 1903, Louise, she marries her husband, her first husband, and his name is Henry Bosley. And he worked as a traveling salesman. Louise seemed to like the fact that Henry was away all the time, you know, because he's a traveling salesman, so he's like not home,
Starting point is 00:02:36 and Louise liked that, because while he was away, Louise did indeed play, if you know what I mean. She was having many affairs. It's not very nice, Louise. Anyways, so after four years of marriage, Henry comes home one day from working,
Starting point is 00:02:54 comes home early. He opens up the door and what does he find? Louise is inside with another man. He's absolutely devastated. Like he's heartbroken over this. And because he walked in on Louise, the love of his life cheating on him, he fell into like a really deep depression, okay?
Starting point is 00:03:14 And then soon after he ended up committing suicide. Yes, it's rough in the first five minutes, I know. After her husband's death, Louise decides to move to Shrevenport, Louisiana, another part of Louisiana. So she moves and she's in need of a job, right? She's got bills to pay. She's new in town. Great.
Starting point is 00:03:35 So she starts looking around for a job and Louise figured the easiest job for her, I'm not saying this is an easy job, she felt like it was an easy job for her, I'm not saying this is an easy job, she felt like it was an easy job for her, was to become like a high class sex worker, but she could make even more money, extra money on top of that, by simply stealing some money from her clients
Starting point is 00:03:57 when they weren't looking. So she would, you know, when they weren't, when they were like doing something else, she was sneaking off and like taking some money from them. And Louise, she pulled these tricks for about two years, but decided she was over it. And then in 1911, Louise moved to Boston, where she wanted to change her name for some reason.
Starting point is 00:04:18 She needed to rebrand. And she changed her name to Louise M. Gold. Louise, when she's in Boston, she gets a new scam going and she starts telling people that she's a 19 year old heiress from Dallas, Texas, who has been confined to a convent by her family and she had run away, she had escaped. I mean, there's no internet back then or anything, right?
Starting point is 00:04:40 So it's like, yeah, sure, you are, whoa, you know? I know we don't know too much about her upbringing, but we know that wasn't true. It was fake, that was a lie. So Louise is kind of spinning this web of lies while mixing and mingling with the wealthier families of Boston. Now it's said that Louise was a very beautiful woman
Starting point is 00:05:01 and she was very charming. It's not long before she manages to convince one of these wealthy families to take her in, like almost adult adopting her. Very bizarre, but okay. But it's also not long before Louise is up to her old tricks again, okay? She decided she was gonna start to scam the family.
Starting point is 00:05:20 She would run up large bills at some of the most expensive stores in Boston. And she was also stealing money, not only from the family she was staying with, but also their friends and their employees. This is like the olden days where you could be like, put it on the card, put it on the Johnson account. You know, and it's like, you could just pay later
Starting point is 00:05:41 or something, no one would let you do that now. But at this time, that was a thing. So she was doing that, like put it on the tub. And yeah, she was running up a big bill, not having to pay anything. Now it's not clear how, but someone catches onto her lies and like what she's really been up to, okay? So they tell the family that she's been staying with,
Starting point is 00:06:04 hey, she's lying to you. She doesn't come from a wealthy family. She's been stealing money and she's been running up a bill. I don't know, but I'm assuming it was something like that. Well, again, this is the olden days, 1911 at the time, and the wealthy family she was staying with was super embarrassed that they were duped in the first place.
Starting point is 00:06:26 Their first thought was if anybody finds out, they would suffer greatly from public embarrassment. Okay, and that's like the most important thing, public embarrassment. So they don't want that, okay? So the family's like, we're not gonna press charges, but they tell Louise, if you go away, okay, if you promise to leave town, we won't press any charges.
Starting point is 00:06:52 And she's like, okay, promise? I mean, what a deal. No lessons to be learned there. Sounds great. So Louise goes to Waco, Texas, where she meets right away a wealthy oil boss named Joe Apple. Now Joe loves diamonds, oh yes.
Starting point is 00:07:12 He has diamonds on everything, rings, belt buckles, even the buttons on his shirt had diamonds on them. And he loved to flaunt his wealth to the peasants with their basic belts and shirts, you know? So he's just a douche, a rich douche. Well, Louise sees the diamonds and she's like, "'Hell yeah, sign me up." She goes straight to him, beeline for that guy.
Starting point is 00:07:37 And I don't know, I don't know what her deal is, but she's able to get a man very easily. And things between Joe and Louise, they get pretty hot and heavy pretty damn quickly okay um but the relationship itself is pretty short-lived. One week after they met Joe was found dead. His cause of death he was shot but not only that all of his diamond jewelry was missing. Now, many had seen Joe and Louise together. So naturally, Louise was arrested. She was arrested for the crime and she went all the way to trial for the crime
Starting point is 00:08:15 because it was believed she was the murderer. But again, people just really seemed to enjoy, just like Louise, I don't fricking know, man. She sat on the stand and told the jury that Joe had tried to rape her. So she killed him in self-defense. She had no diamonds in her possession. So the jury, they side with her, self-defense,
Starting point is 00:08:38 and they find her not guilty and she's released. Now that's all fine and dandy, you know, because like that does happen and self-defense is important. But as we go on in this story, you also have to question if that's true or not, you know? So Louise decides that was a pretty close call. I mean, she went all the way to court. She almost got in trouble for murder.
Starting point is 00:08:59 She needs to move again and rebrand herself because now people know her in town as, you know, this questionable woman. So in 1913, she picks up and she moves again. This time she goes to Dallas, Texas. Look, I don't know how she did it, but she did. She would find a rich guy on day one. It was literally weeks after being there,
Starting point is 00:09:22 she meets and marries a man also named Henry. No, no, no, no, his name's Harry. Sorry, his name's Harry. He works as a night clerk at a hotel called St. George. In the 1930s, St. George would get like a $100,000 makeover. It was a really big deal. And the hotel would be renamed as Hotel Whitmore. One night, Harry is working his night shift at the hotel would be renamed as Hotel Whitmore. One night Harry is working his night shift at the hotel
Starting point is 00:09:48 when a robbery happened. There was $20,000 worth of jewels stolen out of the hotel's safe. He tells Louise like there's been a robbery, like all these jewels are missing. And Louise is like, oh my God, that's crazy. And so he calls up the police And Louise is like, oh my God, that's crazy. You know? And so he calls up the police and police come
Starting point is 00:10:10 and they interrogate Harry, but he's eventually cleared of any involvement with the missing jewelry because he doesn't have them. Investigators then look into Louise, right? Cause she's been hanging with Henry. Like maybe something's up with her. So they look into her thinking maybe she did it. But at the end of the day,
Starting point is 00:10:29 there was zero evidence linking her to the crime and none of them had the jewels in their possession. So it couldn't have been them. Now, sadly, even though they had both been cleared by police, Harry allegedly wasn't able to like really move past the embarrassment of being accused of stealing from the hotel. And it was said he fell into a major deep depression,
Starting point is 00:10:54 leading him to commit suicide. There's a lot of speculation that Harry did not actually commit suicide. Rumors were going around that Louise actually was the one who pulled the trigger. But again, there was no evidence to actually prove that this was true. So it was just all speculation and rumors. But ain't that a little fishy? That's three boyfriends who are dead.
Starting point is 00:11:16 Hmm. So now Louise is done with Texas and she decides that she's gonna move to Denver, Colorado in 1915. And this, once again, she meets and marries a salesman. His name is Richard Peet. So they get married, these two, they get married and they go on and they have a daughter named Frances Ann.
Starting point is 00:11:43 They call her Betty for short. And this happens about a year after they meet. So like clockwork Louise, she seems to struggle with married life, which leads to the couple to be constantly fighting, disagreeing about stuff. And then four years later in 1920, the two decide it's best to separate. So they do.
Starting point is 00:12:05 Louise seems to only have about a four year threshold of people and places because she then leaves her husband and daughter and then she moves to Los Angeles, California. I don't know how she's doing it, I really don't. Okay, great, so she moves to Los Angeles, wow. And guess what? You probably guessed right. She meets a guy named Jacob Denton,
Starting point is 00:12:29 who was like a recent widower, and he had a teenage daughter. Leaving her own daughter to be a mother to someone else's child, it didn't seem to be Louise's cup of tea, you know? She's like, damn it, no. But it turns out Jacob is also a mining engineer who made millions before he retired.
Starting point is 00:12:51 So she's like, meh, I'll give it a whirl. You know, she's like, whatever. She just sees dollar signs. Their meet cute love story starts when Louise inquires about a 14 room mansion she is hoping to rent. And what she wants a 14-room mansion for, we may never know. But she does. And Jacob, the guy, he's the one who's renting it. And he's asking $350 a month to rent his 14-bedroom mansion.
Starting point is 00:13:22 And Louise is able to sweet talk him all the way down to $75 a month. First of all, $350 a month for a 14 room mansion in Los Angeles, a tragedy on its own. What the hell? Cannot even come close to relating Louise. $350 for a 14 room mansion? I know that was a lot to them back then, but still.
Starting point is 00:13:49 Anyways, so Louise sweet talks him, she gets him down to $75, great. Louise moves in on May 26th, and then she and Jacob start hooking up. It wasn't long until Louise, she proposes marriage to Jacob, but he turns her down saying that he was going out of town for a month and like it just wasn't gonna work out, wasn't in his schedule. And when Louise hears this, she is quite upset. I mean she always gets her way. I mean nobody has told her no so far, you know?
Starting point is 00:14:27 So she's just really unsure what to do with these new emotions. No? Huh? You know? So now during this time rumors are circulating around town as to what role Louise plays in Jacob's life. Is she really his live-in girlfriend like Louise claims she is? Is she the housekeeper. Is she really his live-in girlfriend, like Louise claims she is? Is she the housekeeper? Is she the tenant? She never signed a lease, so who is she? You know, people are just talking, gossiping,
Starting point is 00:14:54 trying to figure out who this lady was living in this big old mansion and where she came from. Well, a couple of days after Louise's proposal, Jacob just poof, vanishes, disappears, gone. Now he was supposed to go out of town for a month, but no one can confirm if he did indeed actually go. So Louise tells the neighbors that, "'Oh yeah, he went away for the month.
Starting point is 00:15:19 "'Yes, yes, I saw him off. "'Don't worry, like he's just gone for business. "'Calm down, girl.' "'And like, don't worry about it he's just gone for business, calm down girl. And like don't worry about it because they were kind of asking like where is he? It's been a while. And then some time goes on, things carry on, but you know people deep down are having that funny feeling that something's not right with Luis. So a few days later, Luis hires a gardener to come out to the house and spruce it up, spruce it up a bit, you know?
Starting point is 00:15:53 So she brings a gardener in and she's like, hey, can you come into the house and unload a bunch of dirt into the basement of the house? Now the gardener is like, that's a very odd request. What exactly is the dirt for in the basement, you know? And Louise tells him that she's planning on growing Jacob's favorite kind of mushrooms down there as a surprise, so when he comes home, he's gonna be like, oh my God, mushrooms my house, just what I always wanted, you know? Super strange, but she has money and these gardeners are here to work,
Starting point is 00:16:18 so it's like, meh, sure, we'll do it, makes enough sense. So they load in a bunch of dirt into the basement. And she's gonna grow some mushrooms, I guess. Then on June 5th, Louise shows up to the local bank with a permission slip from Jacob to withdraw $300 from his bank account, and it's also giving her access to his safety deposit box. Now the bank teller noticed that Jacob's signature it looked a little suspicious. It didn't look so right, you know?
Starting point is 00:16:47 So she's kind of like, oh, this is off. Let me say something. So she points it out to Louise, like, you know the signature doesn't, girl it's fake, you know? And Louise is, she just gives the teller some crazy story about how she had to help Jacob write his signature with his left hand because his right arm had to be amputated after he got in an argument with a mysterious
Starting point is 00:17:10 and very angry quote, Spanish looking woman who shot him. Super believable, super believable. She's like, yeah, that's what happened. This is a real story. That's what's even better about this whole nonsense. And the teller, I don't know, I guess she's like, oh wow, that must have, like that does happen, I hear. And she gives Louise access to the money
Starting point is 00:17:33 and the safety deposit box. She gets away with everything. But Louise seems to be having a hard time keeping her story straight. Maybe she just doesn't give a rat's ass, I don't really know. But she retells the story again when she comes back to the bank at a later time, but this time saying that the woman cut off his arm
Starting point is 00:17:52 and his leg, but this time with a sword. Very dramatic situation. She then said that Jacob was so embarrassed by his amputated arm, not the leg though, but just the arm, that he had locked himself up in the house and will only speak to her and her only. So as the weeks go by, Jacob's friends, neighbors, and business associates, they start worrying
Starting point is 00:18:14 and they're questioning Louise a bit. They're pushing a little bit harder. They're like, where's Jacob? We haven't seen him. Meow, meow, meow. And Louise, she just always had an answer. She would tell him like, oh, his business trip got extended. I'm sure he'll be back soon.
Starting point is 00:18:26 Like, don't worry about him. He's totally okay. Depending on who was asking, her story would change. Sometimes he lost an arm, sometimes he didn't. It just, whatever, you know? She's free balling it. I think I'm using that term correctly, free balling it. Anyway, while Jacob was out of town, air quotes,
Starting point is 00:18:41 Louise seemed to be quite happy running the show. She was spending his money, driving his Cadillac, renting out the rooms in his mansion, and just in turn, she was pocketing the rent money. Smart, I'll give her that. She bought two very expensive dresses at a local high-end department store under Jacob's name while claiming to be his wife.
Starting point is 00:19:03 She also pawned a bunch of his jewelry and more valuable possessions. I mean, she is doing the most. And she wasn't worried about a damn thing. She was like doing it so confidently and very openly. There was no secret, you know? This girl's bold. I think because she knows she could just pick up
Starting point is 00:19:20 and leave again, she's not worried about it. Louise found out that Jacob had some rental properties out in Phoenix, Arizona, and she's able to contact the tenants and she convinces them to start making their rent checks out to her instead of Jacob. Wow, you know, she was really doing it. She was, she was professional scammer.
Starting point is 00:19:41 Okay, so you know how I mentioned earlier that Jacob had a teenage daughter? Okay, well, if you don't remember, earlier that Jacob had a teenage daughter? Okay, well, if you don't remember, look, he had a teenage daughter. And while all of this was happening, Louise running around, stealing money and just being a shitty person, Jacob's daughter knows something is up
Starting point is 00:19:56 with this shady woman. Now Jacob's daughter, she was living with Louise in the house, but my guess is that it's a 14-bedroom mansion. So like you probably really don't have to interact with one another if your house is that big. That's what I'm imagining, right? She's probably like on the left wing
Starting point is 00:20:13 and you're on the right wing and you never really see each other unless you have to. So that's why I'm thinking she wasn't like so concerned with the daughter. I don't know. I'm really guessing. But eventually the daughter really starts to question Louise.
Starting point is 00:20:25 I mean, her father has been missing or gone for far too long by this point. So she's like, you know what? I'm not getting any straight answers from this Louise woman. Let me hire a lawyer in hopes to help find my father. So a lawyer comes out and questions Louise, like, you know, where's Jacob? And she just kind of blows him off saying
Starting point is 00:20:44 that she really just doesn't know, he's on a business trip, but whatever. But she does agree to give the lawyer Jacob's financial and business documents as soon as she can. It might be a few days until she can gather that information, but she'll hand that over to make sure
Starting point is 00:20:59 there wasn't any unusual activity going on, you know? Hopefully track where he's at. She's like, yeah, I'll get that right over. At this point, Louise had rented out every room in the mansion and she decides this is her cue to go, okay? She's like, well, my time has expired here. And she packs up her stuff and she ends up going back to Denver, Colorado.
Starting point is 00:21:19 What Louise does is she goes crying back to her ex-husband, Richard, the one that's taking care of the baby. Yeah, she goes crying back to her ex-husband, Richard, the one that's taking care of the baby. Yeah, she goes crying back to him, like, "'Take me back, I wanna be a family again. "'I miss you,' which is so messed up." And Richard is like, "'Dude, I've just been taking care of our daughter
Starting point is 00:21:36 "'for the last four months and trying to figure it out, "'and now you just wanna come waltzing right back in?' "'Okay.' So, you know, she's a good talker or something and she's like, okay, let's, you can come back, you know, let's be a family again. She wants to be a wife now. But back at the Los Angeles mansion,
Starting point is 00:21:54 now that Louise is gone, Jacob's daughter, she decides that she is going to search the house up and down and search for any type of clues, just anything, okay, evidence, something that will help her figure out what the heck just happened. So the daughter is searching the house and on September 23rd, 1920,
Starting point is 00:22:14 she finds Jacob's or her father's decomposing body. He's tied up in like a number of cords. He's wrapped up in blankets and he's buried in the basement. Mm-hmm. But he's buried like in the basement under some stairs. I couldn't figure out if he was like in the dirt. Maybe the dirt was preventing people from going down there.
Starting point is 00:22:35 Cause he wasn't necessarily in the dirt. He was under the stairs, from my understanding. Either way, he was dead. Okay, so the autopsy report determined that Jacob was shot in the head and strangled. So Louise is obviously their number one suspect. So the police try and track her down. They go out to Denver to question her.
Starting point is 00:22:56 So they knock knock on Louise's door and they're asking her, "'Hey, did you have anything to do with Jacob's death?' And she has a number of theories as what might have happened to him. One of them involved a mysterious Spanish woman who shot Jacob, causing his arm to be amputated. It must have been her.
Starting point is 00:23:14 But no one was buying that theory anymore because Jacob's body still had his arms and his legs attached, so no. And then Louise tries to change her story again. This time claiming that Jacob isn't dead at all. That the body they found inside the mansion, oh nay, nay, that was not him. That was a double who Jacob had killed himself.
Starting point is 00:23:37 She's like playing Clue or something, I don't know. She thinks this is a murder mystery dinner. Now at first when I was researching this, I was like, let me guess, they believed her, right? Because like everyone seems to believe her. Anyway, so police are like, what do you mean double? Like, what do you mean? Does he have a twin or a lookalike or something?
Starting point is 00:23:54 And Louise, she had no answer for that specific question of theirs. So with that being said, they placed her under arrest for first degree murder and dragged her ass back to LA. Now here's where you probably think that the story is gonna end. No, it does not. It goes on and on and on. It goes on and on and on.
Starting point is 00:24:14 But okay, so Louise, she does get arrested and she does get put on trial for the murder of Jacob Denton, which starts in January of 1921. And it was the hot gossip at the time. There was thousands of people lining up on the daily to watch Louise walk into the courthouse and like see what she looked like
Starting point is 00:24:31 and what she was wearing and stuff. Cause they were interested. They were super interested. Newspapers were reporting on this trial and they were selling like crazy. So the media was loving it cause it was selling newspapers. There was just something about Louise
Starting point is 00:24:44 that had many people captivated. Anyhow, so the trial, it would only last for a few weeks. And then in February of 1921, Louise, she was convicted of first degree murder and she was sentenced to life in prison. Now, great, beautiful, we love that. She deserves it, but there's more to the story, okay? So during her trial and her first two years
Starting point is 00:25:03 of her life sentence, Louise's husband, remember him, Richard? He stayed super loyal and supportive. He pretty much was the only one who believed that she was innocent. I mean, she wasn't, but she believed that she was. Louise, she told him straight up, "'Listen, you should move on, okay?
Starting point is 00:25:20 "'I've been convicted of murder. "'You can be free to divorce me and remarry. "'Like, find yourself a nice woman. You deserve it. This is what she's telling Richard. And now this was heartbreaking to him, but he agreed and he was like, fine, I'll get a divorce. But he tells Louise that he was gonna wait forever for her.
Starting point is 00:25:38 Cause he knew one day she's probably gonna get released and then they could be together again. There was just no other woman out there for him. And Louise is like, yeah, yeah, yeah. We're gonna lose it, bud. Now something super strange happens, let me tell you. Because as soon as the two of them divorced, Louise, she stopped answering Richard's letters
Starting point is 00:25:55 and she refused to see him when he came to visit her at prison. Well, first of all, Louise claimed that poor Richard felt so guilty over her conviction and the fact that they're not together, that he committed suicide. I was trying to figure this one out because we know that Luis didn't do it because she was in jail.
Starting point is 00:26:12 Great, right? So my thought was like, maybe she put someone up to it, but like, why would she, you know? I was like, well, maybe he did commit suicide, but what are the odds that every fricking ex of yours commits suicide? Like, what is this? You know, this lady is deadly.
Starting point is 00:26:30 They are dropping. I don't get it. I just, I don't know, but maybe he did. And then I feel bad because I'm like, eh. Okay, so Louise, she's using this to her advantage. She's telling others in jail that no man can resist her charm. And she's just kind of using this to brag about it.
Starting point is 00:26:45 All of the husband's deaths, I guess. I guess maybe people are impressed by it. I don't really know. Well, get this. So Louise started her sentence at San Quentin State Prison before being transferred to like a women's institution. In California, it wasn't far. But she was there for a while
Starting point is 00:27:00 and she plays the role of like this perfect prisoner. She's like, oh my God, hi, I'm so happy to be here. Like using her southern charm to make those around her just think she's such a splendid little lady. She maintained the prison's flower garden, she worked as a dental assistant, and even wrote for the prison newspaper. Now she would end up serving 18 years before Louise was paroled for good behavior in 1939. Yeah, she's paroled for good behavior at the age of 59. So she gets out, okay?
Starting point is 00:27:29 So there was this woman named Jessie Marcy. She was like lobbying for Louise's release. When Louise was released, well, she would go into Jessie's custody. But the deal was that Louise was going to be Jessie's live-in housekeeper, okay? I don't know the connection between the two, but it doesn't matter because get this,
Starting point is 00:27:50 it's like a sweet deal, but Jessie ends up dying of natural causes, like not even a week after Luis is released. I think she's aqua to fauna-ing everyone's ass. She has to be, how is she doing this? Natural causes? Where? Either she is killing them
Starting point is 00:28:07 or people just are dropping like flies around her. I mean, that's not a coincidence. Come on. Louise then she moves in with her probation officer. Her name is Emily. So Emily takes her in and Louise was like, I'll work as your housekeeper and also as your nurse and take care of her because she's a little bit older.
Starting point is 00:28:26 So this arrangement, it didn't last long because Emily died of a fricking heart attack in 1943. I mean, come on, why is everyone who comes in contact with this woman just dropping dead? It's so bizarre. For some reason, police never looked further into these deaths, like since they died of natural causes, there wasn't much to look into.
Starting point is 00:28:43 But it's also because, this is the thought here, that the local police, they didn't look into Louise's past or Louise at all, because they had no idea that she was on parole in the first place, because when she was released from prison, Louise changed her name to Anna Lee. Yeah, she changed her name to Anna Lee. Lordy, lordy, lordy. Louise just has everything all figured out.
Starting point is 00:29:08 She's one step ahead. So after Emily died, Louise found another living arrangement for herself. This time it was with an old prison friend named Margaret and her husband, Arthur Logan. Now Margaret and Louise were good friends and she always thought Louise was innocent in the first place, Margaret did.
Starting point is 00:29:27 She thought Louise was innocent, just the sweetest little lady. So when she heard that she was in trouble, she wanted to help her out. So she invites Louise to come live with her. She was like, hey, if you move in with me, can you be my live-in housekeeper in trade, you know? But also if she could be a nurse to Arthur
Starting point is 00:29:42 who was suffering from dementia. So she's like, can he be his nurse? I'm sure you can imagine where this is gonna go. But as we have learned, something is off with this woman, and Louise starts telling neighbors these rumors. She's like, hey, Arthur, yeah, he goes into terrible fits of rage, and he beats his wife Margaret every night.
Starting point is 00:30:02 She's telling everyone this, and she's telling them this rumor, and I don't know why, well, it'll make sense later night. She's telling everyone this and she's telling them this rumor. And I don't know why, well, it'll make sense later, but she's telling everyone this and they're like, oh my God, like that sounds so awful. And Luis is telling the neighbors, like don't mention it to them or Margaret because like it'll just really upset them.
Starting point is 00:30:19 So they're believing it. They're like, oh my gosh, poor Margaret is just in an abusive relationship. Okay, so once again, in June of 1944, Margaret disappears. Nobody has seen her. Nobody has any clue where she went, nothing. Three days after Margaret goes missing, Louise decides to put Arthur in a state hospital.
Starting point is 00:30:40 Oh yeah, she wheels him right off to the state hospital. I think this woman is the actual devil. Louise moves herself full-time into the house. My house now. I cannot believe her. So of course the neighbors are asking what happened to Margaret and Arthur and Louise is telling them like, oh my god you guys, Arthur attacked Margaret, bit off her nose,
Starting point is 00:30:59 and she's so disfigured that she's like too embarrassed to come outside. That's what she tells them. The cycle continues, but okay, look, right before Margaret went missing, Louise had met a new guy. He's a banker, his name was Lee, and she met him and they went on to get married. You know how she does it.
Starting point is 00:31:18 So she left out that tiny detail about being in jail for murder though. So he really had no idea. Plus he thought her name was Anna. So they've been dating, Margaret goes missing. And Lee had met Margaret once before. And he's asking Louise like, what happened to Margaret?
Starting point is 00:31:34 Like it's been a while, where's she been? You know, just asking, just genuinely asking. So Louise repeats the same story that she's been feeding to the neighbors, but adds that after the attack, Margaret went into isolation in preparation for plastic surgery on her nose. Now it's weird because Lee and Louise
Starting point is 00:31:51 are actually living inside of Margaret and Arthur's home for about six months, and he doesn't further wonder like what the hell is going on, where is Margaret? Like he doesn't know or question or I don't. Now it's believed that he didn't question anything like what was going on because Louise was forging checks and spending Margaret and Arthur's money on herself
Starting point is 00:32:13 and her new hubby Lee. Like you want anything, I'll buy it for you. So maybe that's why he didn't care too much and didn't keep asking. I don't know, but that's what it's believed to be true. So the spending spree is cut short when Arthur dies in December of 1944. And the bank notices that there are still checks
Starting point is 00:32:34 being cashed with his forged signature. And that doesn't make sense because Arthur passed away. So how is a dead guy signing checks, right? So the bank teller calls up the police who naturally head over to where Margaret and Arthur's house where Louise and Lee are living. And they're investigating, they're just doing their questioning. They're like, hey, you know, we got a call,
Starting point is 00:32:53 you're forging some checks, whatever. And they're just getting a funny feeling about the couple, but no arrest was made. I think Louise was telling the police it must be Margaret, but Margaret's out of town. So the police was like, okay, we'll come back in a couple of weeks when Margaret is back. And think Louise was telling the police, it must be Margaret, but Margaret's out of town. So the police was like, okay, we'll come back
Starting point is 00:33:07 in a couple of weeks when Margaret is back and we'll talk to her. So the police come back a couple of weeks later to further ask questions and maybe even speak to Margaret at this point. But Margaret's been missing for six months. So they ask Louise like, okay, you know what? Can we just look around the house?
Starting point is 00:33:23 You know, this is just weird. Like what is really going on here? So they're looking around the house and in the backyard, they discover a shallow grave. It's under an avocado tree, and in the shallow grave is Margaret's decomposing body. Louise is immediately arrested, this time only taking a couple of hours for Louise to be charged with murder again. So the autopsy report determined that Margaret had been shot in the back of the neck,
Starting point is 00:33:41 and she also had a fractured skull. So the autopsy report determined that Margaret had been shot in the back of the neck and she also had a fractured skull. So during questioning, Louise tells police that Margaret was actually attacked and shot to death by her husband, Arthur, during one of his anger fits of rage and that she had been telling the neighbors about it.
Starting point is 00:34:04 And if they didn't believe her, they should go ask the neighbors because they knew all about Arthur's abuse. Honestly, I'll give her a point there because that's kind of smart. That's kind of smart. I'll give her that. She's literally thinking ahead.
Starting point is 00:34:17 You don't see that too often with most killers, like this much, you know? So Louise admits to police that in a panic, she had buried Margaret and didn't report the incident because she was afraid that they would charge her with murder because of her previous convictions. Or you know, because maybe she murdered her. But she insisted she was innocent.
Starting point is 00:34:37 She did not kill her. So Louise's husband, Lee, he was also arrested and charged with murder. And like his wife, he also insisted that he was innocent. The murder charge against him was dropped because there wasn't enough evidence. So Lee was released, but his freedom was short-lived because guess what happens the very next day?
Starting point is 00:34:56 Lee jumps to his death off the ninth floor of an office building in Los Angeles. You guys, this is too strange because I don't know, I don't know if people are just offing themselves. I'm not trying to be funny, but if that's the case, or if they are being killed by Luis. But Luis seemed to be in police custody, so maybe he did, I don't know.
Starting point is 00:35:17 I just don't understand how this is happening, I really don't. Like, are they killing themselves, or are they being killed? I wanna say that they're being killed, but I don't know. Anyway, so for the first time, Louise actually shows some emotion when she learns about her new husband's death
Starting point is 00:35:32 and she openly cries and she tells reporters, media, that she felt she was the one to blame for Lee's death. That's because you are. I wonder if there's like some life insurance she's collecting on these guys or what the deal really was, because again, this is just bizarre. So Louise's third and final murder trial begins on April 23rd, 1945.
Starting point is 00:35:53 It gets some media attention, but nobody really cares as much as they did as like the first time. So the prosecution believed that Louise killed Margaret in order to gain control over the Logan family finances, which makes the most sense. The prosecution thought that Louise got in an argument. There must've been an argument between her and Margaret
Starting point is 00:36:10 after she discovered a check that Louise had forged, which then led to her killing Margaret. That's what they believe happened. And it must've been a very compelling argument because on May 31st, the jury found Louise guilty of first degree murder, again. But this time Louise received the death penalty, okay? Not life in prison.
Starting point is 00:36:33 This time she was gonna be put down. No more of her shenanigans. Now it was said during her sentencing, Louise sat calmly reading a book of Chinese philosophy called The Importance of Living. And she only looked up once to make some kind of mocking facial expression before going back to her cell.
Starting point is 00:36:51 So over the next several years, Louise attempted to appeal several times. She maintained that she was innocent, but each appeal failed. Her day of execution finally arrived, April 11th, 1948, exactly eight years after she walked out from the women's prison the first time. This lady has way too many coincidences
Starting point is 00:37:10 going on in her life, huh? Anyways, Louise tells her friends in the jail or whatever that she's ready, she's ready to go, and she calmly walks from her cell to the gas chamber. And it was said she was smiling, and she's like, yeah, I don't know, yay. And everyone's just watching her as she's entering the room. Now she had a really big crowd of people watching her.
Starting point is 00:37:30 Like one of the most ever, I forget how many it was, like 80, I wanna say 80 people were watching her be put down, which is very unusual. As the guards left the chamber, one of them offered a final farewell saying, goodbye, good luck, breathe deep, and don't fight the gas, thanks. And at 10.03 a.m., the deadly gas pellets dropped
Starting point is 00:37:51 and 10 minutes later, Louise was declared dead. She was the second woman in the state of California to be executed. Honestly, good. She caused way too much chaos, my God. Oh my God. And that, my friends, is the story of Louise. I don't even know what her name is because she changed it.
Starting point is 00:38:08 What was her name? Louise P. I don't even know. Louise P. Great. So this story, it totally sounds fake. It totally does, but it's a real story. She was, I don't want to call her crazy, but she was crazy.
Starting point is 00:38:20 Something was off. I don't even have any words because it was like, good. There's no place for her. I'm sorry, girl. Like you had many chances. Oh, a lot of chances. And you chose violence over and over and over again. Goodbye. I'm not a big fan of the death penalty, but in cases like this, it totally makes sense.
Starting point is 00:38:35 You know, like she literally proved that she doesn't want change. Women back then seemed to be real different, real unique. Passionate, passionate killers, I must say. Anyways, thank you guys so much for hanging out with me today. I hope you have a wonderful rest of your day. I appreciate you so much for hanging out with me here
Starting point is 00:38:58 and you know, just being a friend. I really appreciate you. I hope you have a good rest of your week. You make good choices. Please be safe out there. Love you guys. And I'll be seeing you later. Bye.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.