Part Of The Problem - Douglas Murray Is Very Wrong

Episode Date: June 20, 2024

Dave Smith and Robbie The Fire Bernstein bring you the latest in politics! On this episode of Part Of The Problem, Dave and Robbie take a look at Douglas Murray in an Oxford style debate accu...sing anyone with sense of being anti-Semitic.Support Our SponsorSheath - https://sheathunderwear.com use promo code PROBLEM20Yo Kratom - https://yokratom.comSmall Batch Cigar - https://www.smallbatchcigar.com/ use promo code problem at checkoutFind Run Your Mouth here:Youtube - https://www.youtube.com/@robbiethefire2577/streamsItunes - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/run-your-mouth-podcast/id1211469807Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/4ka50RAKTxFTxbtyPP8AHmPart Of The Problem is available for early pre release on GaS Digital Network every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. Sign-up with code POTP to get access to the archives, bonus content and more! https://gasdigital.comFollow the show on social media:Twitter: https://twitter.com/ComicDaveSmithhttps://twitter.com/RobbieTheFirehttps://www.instagram.com/bmackayisrightInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/theproblemdavesmith/https://www.instagram.com/robbiethefire/https://www.instagram.com/bmackayisrightSubscribe On YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/user/DSmithcomicSee Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 You're listening to the Gas Digital Network. Look at who we're funding right now. Every single one of these problems are a result of government being way too big. You're listening to Part of the Problem on the Gas Digital Network. Here's your host, Dave Smith. What's up, everybody? Welcome to a brand new episode of Part of the Problem. I am Dave Smith. He is Robbie the Fire Bernstein. How are you, my good friend? I'm doing well. Vegas was a blast. Some fun shows. Got to see Dead & Co. at the Sphere. It was good times. Yeah, you well. Vegas was a blast. Some fun shows. Got to see Dead & Co. at the
Starting point is 00:00:45 Sphere. It's good times. Yeah, you told me it was a great show. Yeah, I usually don't like Dead & Company, but that might be the best concert I've ever seen. Really incredible. Well, that's people are saying it's a cool. I did say when you first said you were going out to that concert, I was like, yeah, that's like at the Sphere. That probably would be pretty cool. I bet they're going to do cool stuff. Can you show me the pictures? They did. I'm a new man with a longer penis, Dave. Really?
Starting point is 00:01:09 That's what it did for me. New confidence. I saw the Lord himself and I feel good about life. For the record, the Sphere does not stand behind these promises, but take anecdotal evidence for what it's worth. Yeah, it was a lot of fun. I've been a bit under the weather. But aside from that, the crowds were really great.
Starting point is 00:01:29 And the Wise Guys out there in Las Vegas is a cool club. If you can deal with Vegas, you'll have fun there. And if people want to capture this new Longer Penis energy, come out to Porch Tour. I'm spending all of July out on the road. I got White Bear Lake minnesota this weekend then bethlehem play at pa pittsburgh pa richmond virginia virginia beach raleigh north carolina really getting into the carolina virginia section for a nice chunk of road that hopefully my car survives for well hell yeah there you go if not we'll get you a new car we'll figure it out um
Starting point is 00:02:00 okay i'm uh the mothership is all sold out guys so i actually just found that out this morning the sunday show is sold as well so hope to see a lot of you guys hopefully a lot of our uh our fans bought tickets before all those other comedy mothership people bought them all up uh but we got nashville uh zany's coming up in july um be back in uh dallas and fort worth uh i'll be at orlando speaking at the young Americans for Liberty Conference. New York Comedy Club in Stanford, Connecticut. That was the one we had to reschedule. We'll be doing that in August.
Starting point is 00:02:33 Bricktown Comedy in Tulsa. Detroit House of Comedy. The Comedy Club of Kansas City. A whole bunch of places. ComicDaveSmith.com for all of those ticket links. Looking forward to, uh, to hitting a lot of these spots. So come see me and Rob in a town near you. Um, all right. So I wanted to start today's show, um, by, okay, so I've had this, this has happened a few times
Starting point is 00:02:59 now. Uh, sure. Rob, you remember back several months ago where we did a segment on the show about Douglas Murray had debated Cenk Uygur on Piers Morgan's show. And I see on social media that a whole bunch of people love, I guess, like shoving it in my face or something like that, where they're like, oh, Douglas Murray just destroyed this guy. And oh, Dave, you know, even though, by the way, I've publicly challenged the guy to debate and I don't know him. So I don't know how to do this other than to just say it into a microphone, which has gotten me some pretty big debates in the past. So, you know, it's not the worst method. But I've said many times I'll happily debate Douglas Murray on the topic of Israel.
Starting point is 00:03:46 Pierce Morgan, I'm on that show regularly now, and maybe they can set it up. But people still, even though I've challenged them on social media and on the podcast and stuff, people still go, oh, this is why you don't want to debate this guy, because he's the guy who destroys all your thing. I guess like, I'm out there winning a lot of these debates on the war in Israel. So then when people find this guy, they're like, ah, this is take this, Dave. Like he's the antidote to all the bullshit you've been saying. So this has happened a few times. I think this is maybe the third time where I've just gotten a lot of people, you know, saying to me, oh, did you see Douglas Murray? Like fuck up your side at this debate the other day.
Starting point is 00:04:21 And then I go and watch it and I'm just totally unimpressed. I was like, how do you guys even think he did anything here? Anyway, for the record, I did not. I just heard about this this morning and I watched about half of it. And evidently it was it was at the monk debates, which is like a pretty famous, like Oxford style debate thing in Canada. And they evidently they won the debate by the Oxford rules of, you know, they the crowd votes beforehand and then votes afterward. And then you see who moved more people. You know, it's not a flawless metric. There's no flawless metric of how to judge debates exactly. But it's you know, it's it's debatably the best. And so he they did win the debate.
Starting point is 00:05:12 And from what I saw, Mendy Hassan, who was the guy who used to be over at MSNBC, who got canned, he did. the guy who used to be over at MSNBC who got canned. He did. He messed up at one point where he just totally got like Lord Balfour quote wrong. And I didn't see what happened in the second half of the debate. So it is possible that like at the sport of debating, those guys lost the debate. I don't know. I'm not really going to take an opinion on it because I haven't seen the whole thing. But just watching Douglas Murray's opening statement and his and his first rebuttal was just like.
Starting point is 00:05:58 I mean, I don't know, almost everything the guy is saying is just so ridiculous. And so I just figured, well, why not go through it on today's show, since this is a new thing that's kind of going viral and we could talk about it now just to set the stage for this here. One of the things that's kind of interesting about this debate, at least to me, is that the topic of the debate was not the history of Israel and Palestine. It wasn't whether Israel is an apartheid state. It wasn't whether Israel is just or unjust in prosecuting this military campaign over the last eight or nine months or whatever it's been. The topic of the debate was, is anti-Zionism anti-Semitic? So it was, is it anti-Semitic to oppose Zionism? Which, I mean, I don't even understand how that is possibly a debatable
Starting point is 00:06:47 topic. Like it's just it's such a ridiculous claim to say that there's a political movement that it is racist to oppose. Like by definition, you should never be allowed to say that. As soon as anyone gets into the realm of politics or a nationalistic movement, you've forfeited the right to say you're a bigot if you're opposed to this. Right. That would just seem so common sense to me. But anyway, how do you possibly treat Jews who are anti-Zionist? Oh, they're people then Jewish anti-Semites. They're anti-Semites. Yes, that's yes. That is the answer. That is. I. That's the, yes, that is the
Starting point is 00:07:25 answer. That is, I haven't watched the full debate, but I've gotten enough. I've gotten enough to hear that from Douglas Murray. Yes. The answer is that me and you are also anti-Semites and every other Jew who's out criticizing Israel, but that's it. If you think that like, whatever, if you think the way Israel treats the Palestinian people is wrong. The only answer is that you hate Barry, the dentist. Like that's the level of argument that you have to deal with to even make it's just, it's too absurd. Anyway, I just, I feel like, and forget even like, I will grant that like Douglas Murray is, he's talented at what he does and he's got verbal abilities and stuff like that. Snooty Brit. Yes, he's got that snooty Brit thing going for him.
Starting point is 00:08:10 But forget even that of who's better at the sport of debate just for the sake of taking these ideas apart and demonstrating how profoundly weak they all are. I figured we'd do that. And also, I do think that, you know, seeing as how it's a very important thing going on in the world right now, it's not just that Israel is involved in this like mass slaughter campaign against the Palestinians. But it's also the fact that I think for anybody being honest with themselves, who is at all educated on the topic, you know, there's, Israel has a very unique relationship with the United States of America, and let's say, has a fair bit of influence over our foreign policy. And so it's kind of important for people like us who, let's say, passionately oppose U.S. foreign policy, particularly over the last 20 plus years, to deal with this issue. All right, guys, let's take a moment and thank our sponsor for today's show, which is Small Batch Cigar. Guys, if you love cigars, you have to go check out Small Batch Cigar.
Starting point is 00:09:24 Simple, fast, small batch. Free shipping on every order. Almost every order arrives in two to three days in the continental United States of America. They have Boveda pouches, 69% humidity packs included with every purchase, so your cigar shows up fresh and ready to be enjoyed. The most thorough packaging in the industry, an amazing selection of rare, limited, and hard-to-find cigars. Plus, you earn 5% reward points instantly. SmallBatchCigar.com. Most people like to get on that site and click new first to shop their newest arrivals. Plus, make sure you use the discount code PROBLEM. That'll get you 10% off plus those 5% reward points. Smallbatchcigar.com
Starting point is 00:10:07 promo code problem for 10% off plus 5% reward points. All right, let's get back into the show. So anyway, we can start it here with, let's start with Douglas Murray's opening statement from the other day at the Monk Debates. Well, thank you very much, Rudyard. It's a great pleasure to be back at the Munk Debates. When I was last here a couple of years ago, I just returned from the front line of the war in Ukraine, where I was with the Ukrainian armed forces. And for most of the last eight months, I've been in Israel and Gaza,
Starting point is 00:10:43 following the war there as closely as I can. And I won't go into all the details now that I could give you of what's happening. But I would just put it in perspective in this way, first of all. What happened on the 7th of October was not just a massive attack on innocent people inside Israel. It was the equivalent to about 6,000 Canadians being massacred and burned in their homes in one day. It's the equivalent of about 1,500 of your fellow Canadians being taken hostage. thousand of your fellow Canadians being taken hostage. You know, you would have thought after an attack like the one that Hamas instigated that started this terrible war, you would have thought that there would be some sympathy for the world, from the world. You might have thought the world would pay attention to the attack and at least pay attention to the people behind it.
Starting point is 00:11:47 You might have expected, like me, that there might have been a worldwide opposition to the terrorists and rapists and the murderers of Hamas. You might have thought there would be hatred around the world erupting, but the government of Qatar and its mouthpiece in Al Jazeera, its funding of Hamas and its hosting of the leadership of Hamas in Qatar, you might have thought there'd have been an outpouring of
Starting point is 00:12:16 rage at the Islamic Revolutionary government in Tehran, but no. There was immediate outpouring of rage against the state that had been attacked. Let's pause it right here. Let's just go through some of this. When does Harry Potter show up?
Starting point is 00:12:34 I mean, he's doing everything he can to summon him. That's for sure. So, look, on the first note that, you know, last time I was here, I had just gotten back from Ukraine. It's like, yeah, that's right. And you got that war completely wrong. Also, you know, he's one of the people who went to Ukraine and then said, look, if we arm them, they can win. I don't know how clear he was on what his definition of winning was, but he was wrong on that one. And he's wrong on this one, too.
Starting point is 00:12:59 And of course, you know, it's it's kind of interesting to start this thing with a big, you know, appeal to emotion, which is reasonable enough that obviously talking about October 7th, a truly horrific event. And so you're going to work up some some sympathy from that. some sympathy from that, understandably. It would make sense if like this debate was happening on like October 25th or even November 10th, maybe even into December. But, you know, like the first thing, at least that just pops out in my mind, is that when you sit here and you go, look how many people were killed on October 7th and think about the proportion of what that would be in Canada. That would be as if, however, many Canadians were killed. Right. Which is, again, I never exactly like the logic of that, like somehow killing. You know, like if there's a family of six next door and there's a family of two here, killing one person in the family of two isn't like way worse than killing one person in the family of six because there's a smaller family. So I don't like the argument that like the proportion somehow indicates something.
Starting point is 00:14:20 I think that's kind of missing the mark. something. I think that's kind of missing the mark. But the thing that jumps out at you right away is that, well, look, the population of Gaza is much smaller than the population of Israel. And by any count, by anyone's count, more innocent civilians have been killed in Gaza by multiple factors. You know what I mean? Like by orders of magnitude, more innocent people have been killed in Gaza than were killed on October 7th in Israel. So it's just a little bit odd to start out with this like, oh, this would be like, you know, even though it was 1200 people killed or 1400 people killed, this would be like, you know, whatever, 50,000 Canadians killed or
Starting point is 00:15:02 something like that. It's like, yeah, well, if you take the war in Gaza, you're going to get to a much higher number than that. So there's that to start. That's doesn't work. Aside from that, this idea of almost like creating this parallel reality where where Douglas Murray is going to say, you know, you'd think, you would think after something like October 7th, the world would condemn Hamas. You would think that would happen, right? At a minimum. And that almost kind of sounds compelling in a way until you like just stop for a second and rub two brain cells together and go, oh, yeah, and they did. They totally did. What world are you living in? What world are you living in where Hamas was not condemned? Now, you could say not every single person in the world condemned Hamas. You could say you can find extremist voices, perhaps, who didn't. But by and large, to sum up the reaction, dude, to this day, we're talking eight, nine months later of this brutal military campaign that's been carried out.
Starting point is 00:16:12 And that, again, has killed far, far more innocent people than were killed on October 7th. Still, the first thing I swear every goddamn show that I'm on, every debate that I've done, every everything you always get asked, do you condemn Hamas? You always, of course, have to first and foremost say, yes, we condemn Hamas. What happened on October 7th was wrong. Now can we get into the thing that we're here to debate? You know, like it's and the fact is that the powerful institutions around the world were unanimous on condemning October 7th and condemning Hamas. So that one is just, again, it's like one of those things where it's like you're entitled to your own opinion, but you're not entitled to your own facts. It's just factually not true that there was an absence of a condemnation of Hamas. That's just not true. He then immediately pivots to why there wasn't a
Starting point is 00:17:08 condemnation of of Qatar. Again, I think that there certainly was condemnation of Hamas. Much of Hamas's political leadership lives in Qatar. So, OK. But, you know, it does kind of raise an interesting question there. You know, Qatar is an ally of the United States of America and maybe not technically an ally of Israel, but wink, wink, nod, nod, totally an ally of Israel. And this is why Benjamin Netanyahu can send the head of Mossad two weeks before October 7th to Qatar, Qatar, to make sure that the funds keep going to Hamas, because that was the plan to prop up Hamas. So you never have to give the Palestinians their own state. So it just seems like by the same logic he's using here, like if we do want to condemn Qatar, shouldn't we also kind of look at the fact that this is a country that
Starting point is 00:18:07 has a, let's say, a working relationship with the United States of America and Israel? And not only was there not, let's say, pre-October 7th, not only was there not pressure on Qatar to stop funding Hamas, as has been reported in the New York Times and many newspapers in Israel, there was actually pressure on them to continue. So I'm just saying that you might ask yourself those questions also just following this same line of logic. Then he throws in condemning Iran, which is kind of like, OK, but it's never been. Perhaps the reason for that is that there's never been any evidence that demonstrates that Iran was connected or involved with October 7th specifically. what the reaction that he's talking about to October 7th is, is that, you know, October 7th didn't happen in a vacuum. And it's almost like all of these guys try. It's like their entire case rests on acting like this was Canada and the United States of America or something like that.
Starting point is 00:19:20 You know, these were just two sovereign nations who happened to be living next to each other. And then a bunch of people. Yeah. What's your cameras acting weird there? All right. Whatever. Let's keep going. They act as if these were two sovereign nations living next to each other. And then one day, for no reason, these savages just attacked from from this neighboring country like everything was cool until then or something. But of course, anyone who knows anything about this is just knows that's not the case. And the reality is that it's look, these things are never perfect. And I know everyone tries to jump on these examples and, you know, say, well, that's not exactly literally true. know, say, well, that's not exactly literally true. But if what is conjured up in your mind is like two sovereign states living side by side, and then one just decided to attack the other
Starting point is 00:20:11 group because they just hate those people so much. They're so barbaric and so backward and so primitive and so evil. And they just hate those people for being those people, their immutable characteristics or the religion that they practice or their genetic heritage or something like that. So they attacked and killed them. But a much closer analogy would be like a bunch of people in the toughest gang in a prison broke out of that prison and went on a killing rampage and took a bunch of hostages. Now, again, people will say like, well, Gaza is not a literal prison and there's differences between a prison. That is OK. The people in Gaza have been dominated by the Israelis for longer than the Soviet Union occupied Eastern Europe. It's there are there's over a million people who were born into that.
Starting point is 00:21:26 Substantially more than that, probably, but certainly the million people who are 18 and under in Gaza, refugee problem that drove so many people into Gaza. They won a war against Egypt and Jordan in 1967 and occupied the Palestinian territory ever since. Now, they will say that they pulled out in 2005. And you can go read some Dove Weiss glass quotes to see what that was really all about. As as Sharon's top advisor put it, it was to put the peace process in formaldehyde. But even after what they called the disengagement, even after 2005, Israel since then has maintained complete control over Gaza. I mean, down to like whether they're allowed to come and go, whether they're allowed to have an airport, which they're not, whether they're allowed to have a seaport, how far they can fish off the coast, how much they can trade with the world, whether they're allowed to have potato chips or cookies or all types of stuff,
Starting point is 00:22:21 every detail. Their tax revenue is collected by Israel. Like Israel rules the Gaza Strip and has since 1967. And the thing about people is that they don't much like being ruled by foreign militaries. And so, yes, this is a dynamic. It's not as if one group of people or even as people like Douglas Murray won't exactly say, but will seem to imply that it's kind of the same as the Nazis attacking the Jews. Like as if there's a parallel between the ruling government attacking a helpless people and a helpless people lashing out at the people of a ruling government. Not saying either is OK, but they're definitely different. That might be part of why the world reacted the way it did. Anything you want to add, Rob, or you want to keep playing? I agree with everything you said. And he's playing a real dirty trick when he goes,
Starting point is 00:23:18 the entire world didn't condemn this because we did until Israel took it as an opportunity to kill innocent civilians. And then as that continues to happen, everyone went, hey, you can't do that. So to pretend like people weren't outraged over what happened or even us at the time going, hey, you had an opportunity here where the world was on your side and now you're blowing it by killing innocent civilians and destroying their homes. So, yeah, we would all just be talking about how outrageous what Hamas did to this very day if Israel did not take it as, oh, look, this is our ticket to kill innocent civilians. Yeah, that's right. Well, look, even just to make your point
Starting point is 00:23:57 and just like a little bit stronger, even than that, think about the circles that I run in as somebody who's pretty critical of Israel and particularly of this, the war over the last eight months. Hortons and Connor Freemans and, you know, Kyle Anzalove and Dave DeCamp and like all the anti-war libertarian institute guys who are like known for talking about this issue a lot. All great, by the way, go give those guys a follow if you don't already. Um, you think about Daryl Cooper, um, the other people who I've been kind of like on the debate circuit with, like I did a two on two debate with Cenk Uygur. Um, I, I've been on a breaking points been on Breaking Points with Sager and Crystal. I don't know, I'm missing out on it. But people like Brianna Joy Gray, who just got canned from Rising at the Hill. Just all these people. Every one of them condemns Hamas. Every one of them condemns October 7th. Even in my world of critics of Israel, it's unanimous to a person. We all condemn Hamas.
Starting point is 00:25:10 We all condemn October 7th. So the idea that the greater world didn't condemn them, it's just in no meaningful way is that true or accurate. It's just a false reality. It is not the case. it's just a false reality that is not the case this role also couldn't have uh done more to ruin the sympathy that they were given by people by displaying ads on uh kids networks on youtube um which was very strange and then i guess to this day i'm still okay because off of your recommendation i've been reading uh the and the Unnecessary War book, Pappy Cannon's book, and they talk about, I think it was World War I,
Starting point is 00:25:49 people getting suckered into it because of false claims of extreme violence. To this day, I still am unclear to what extent, I guess, rape and baby killing actually took place. I'm unclear. I can't say as a definite either way, um i'm unclear i haven't i can't say fat like as a definite either way uh but it sure seemed like israel was running with some very extreme questionable stories right at the top it was like guys what happened was atrocious why do you gotta why do you gotta play this up and why do you gotta do ads on kid shows like and they start yeah and it's almost like a game that they're playing where they wildly exaggerate some of the atrocities that happened. And then if you point out, you go like, oh, this is completely unsubstantiated. They go, so you're downplaying
Starting point is 00:26:30 October 7th. And it's like, no, I'm saying like, let's tell the truth. And so not only that, but it, one of the things that's amazing that the pro-Israeli side gets away with doing is like arguing that nobody condemned Hamas and nobody supports Israel while we're literally funding the war. Well, while we're arming and funding the war and passing all types of legislation in states in America about what you can and can't say, like whether you can criticize the war or not, what counts as anti-Semitic or not, like all this crazy, and that's federal legislation, you know? So it's like, wait a minute, how do you get both of those? Either you're in a world where nobody condemns Hamas
Starting point is 00:27:14 and nobody supports Israel, or the most powerful governments in the world are all funding Israel's war. You can't have both of those. All right, let's keep playing. Bring back our girls. We had 10 years ago in the war in northern Nigeria, which I also covered. Bring back our girls. No international campaign saying bring back our Jewish children. Believe all women, we've been told for years. But turns out, not if the raped women are Jews. Israel is the only country in the world which, when it's attacked, gets attacked more. You know, the interesting thing about anti-Semitism is, as my late friend Jonathan Sachs said, it's a shape-shifting virus. It moves across the centuries. When you could hate
Starting point is 00:27:59 people for their religion, the Jews were hated for their religion. Then you couldn't hate people for that anymore. So people hated the Jews for their race and then after the 20th century people realized that wasn't such a great idea either now the Jews are hated not for their religion or their race but for having a state people around the world hate them so much for it. That Israelis are attacked when they have hostages taken. And this is to remember the 100 hostages still in captivity in Gaza, who if they were given back by Hamas today, the war would be over. And they're also attacked when they rescue their hostages. All right.
Starting point is 00:28:38 So let's pause it right there. Listen, I do understand, I guess, if you're already pro-Israel and you just want someone to confirm your bias, how like Douglas Murray does have a way with words and has this kind of charismatic, you know, quality to him. But like what he's saying here is just such bullshit. It's just like, oh, it's all so ridiculous that there's no merit to the argument whatsoever. First of all, to go through this thing of like anti-Semitism is a shape-shifting virus and blah, blah, blah. And throughout history, there was all this sort of,
Starting point is 00:29:11 and this is, and so this is just another form of that. It's just another form of that same thing. I mean, just think about how ridiculous this would be if applied to anything else. Like if I were to be, if, if I were to be critical of, say, black people in America today. OK, but let's say I was criticizing the black community and I said, look, there are these problems, the kind of violence, worshiping culture amongst kids, you know, loving things like gangster rap, you know, like high crime rates in your communities, your family is not sticking together high, much higher than average illegitimacy rates, things like this. You could agree or disagree with that. OK, you could. I'm not even saying that. Right. You could. There's lots of different ways you could attack that. If you disagreed with the argument, you could say, let's say you could say, well, actually, the crime rates are higher and I have some data to indicate that they're not higher than that. Or you could
Starting point is 00:30:08 say, well, there are these policies that lead to these higher crime rates. Or you could write like you could have an argument about that. But if your response to that was hating black people is a shape shifting virus. And a thousand years ago, when people hated black people, they did it for all these messed up reasons. And you're just now the latest version of that. You'd recognize that's not a counter to the argument that you've in no way dealt with the argument that someone's making or the criticism that someone's making. And this is not criticizing a group of people like black people. This is criticizing a government, a governmental policy. And I'm sorry, you don't get to just say it's shape-shifting.
Starting point is 00:30:58 So if there were criticisms of Jews in the past that were bullshit, that means you can't ever criticize Israel or it's just a shape-shifting virus. That's ridiculous. And to say Israel is criticized for having a state is not in good faith dealing with what the actual criticism is. It's not that they're criticized for having a state. They're criticized for their treatment of the Palestinian people, what their government does to the Palestinian people, whose territory they have controlled since 1967. That's the criticism. The criticism is not of Israel getting its hostages back. That's ridiculous. This is like, I mean, it's on the level of when, like, if there's like a thug, you know, who's like, I don't know, whatever, shouting obscenities and threatening people. And then they get tased by the cops and you go, oh, they tased him because he was black.
Starting point is 00:31:55 Like basically what he's saying is you're only criticizing them because they're Jewish. Oh, Rob, they're criticizing them for getting their hostages back. Is that really what they're getting criticized for? I thought it was the babies they killed. Like that was the criticism. The criticism wasn't that they got hostages back. Israel said, Israel said a hundred people got killed in that mission. And then the health ministry in Gaza said like 280 people got killed. So I'll say right now, I don't know. I don't know what the answer is. But like, even if it's Israel's numbers, which I doubt, you know, like, let's get real.
Starting point is 00:32:37 The number is probably higher than what Israel is admitting. But even if it's Israel's numbers, OK, so they killed 100 people to get four back. OK, let's say 50 of those people were Hamas militants or people who were firing at them or housing the hostages or something like that, which is I'm being very generous in these estimates. OK, let's say it's Israel's number and let's say 50 of the dead people. OK, you still killed 50 innocent people to retrieve four. That's the criticism, not retrieving your hostages. Sorry, that's just not that. That's such bad faith argumentation. You're not actually grappling with what anybody is saying. It's just that this was nuts to me is where I see people send me this video. Oh, Douglas Murray just tore these
Starting point is 00:33:16 guys apart. You're like, what? What do you think this is? This is nothing. All right. Any comment, Robert? Should I keep playing? No, well said. I think it's like with this logic, what action could the Israeli government take that you would be allowed to criticize? I mean, at the moment they're killing civilians, but I'm saying like, what action could they take where I could go, hey, they shouldn't be doing that, where the response wouldn't be, well, that's just because it's really your deep rooted anti-Semitism. And if you could hate Jews for being Jewish, you would do that. But since that's not culturally appropriate, you're only you're just criticizing these people for baby murder because you really hate Jews.
Starting point is 00:33:54 Yeah. Well, you know, someone I got into this back and forth on Twitter the other day, which pissed a lot of these guys off. But I think also a lot of people didn't follow exactly what I was saying, which maybe is on me. Maybe I could have been a little more clear about it. But I think also a lot of people didn't follow exactly what I was saying, which maybe is on me. Maybe I could have been a little more clear about it. But there is this argument that so basically when you're dealing with this, when you're dealing with the pro Israeli side, and I've done a lot of these debates at this point, so I'm kind of used to it. There's it's always one of two arguments. Both are equally absurd or maybe one's a little more absurd than the other. But one is that there are no innocent Palestinians like that was that was the Laura Loomer position that when we debated.
Starting point is 00:34:36 I mean, I'm not exaggerating. That was her position. There are no innocent Palestinians. They're they're Muslims and all the Muslims are bad and they voted for Hamas. So and they haven't overthrown them yet. So they now that are that argument is just. Well, that's pro-Geminicide towards all Muslims. Yes. Core. It's a it's a what are you calling for?
Starting point is 00:34:56 It's a genocidal argument, which whose logic is identical to Osama bin Laden's. Literally the exact same argument Osama bin Laden made, that the U.S. citizens are fair targets because we have elections, and so we're complicit in the crimes of our government. It was bullshit when he made it, and it's bullshit when the Zionists make it. But of course, I mean, it's just the argument falls apart immediately under any scrutiny, because, like, I don't know, there's a million kids in Gaza. So first off, a five year old in Gaza didn't vote for anything. They weren't even alive the last time there were elections. And even if they did vote for anything, doesn't matter. They're five.
Starting point is 00:35:35 You know what I mean? They're just not you are innocent by definition at that age. So and that's just dealing with five year olds. There's lots of other adults who are also innocent civilians. Anyway, the other argument that you'll get is like there are innocent civilians and it's terrible they're dying, but it's all Hamas' fault. None of it is Israel's fault. And that argument almost leads you to reducto absurdum as you just were. Like, okay, so Israel could just do whatever they want? You know, and like I said this to someone.
Starting point is 00:36:04 Someone said to me on Twitter recently and they go, if you take hostages and people school blow up the school because we got to get the bad guy. So he blows up the school and kills all the kids. Are you telling me there's no responsibility on your police department there? Their hands are completely clean. They could just say, well, there was a bad guy. We were targeting him. We have, yeah, sure. It was the bomb that we dropped that blew up the school, but it was the bad guy who did. It's like, just take this thing to its logical conclusion. Obviously the argument that you have zero responsibility for the babies that the bombs you're dropping kill is so ludicrous. You can't even believe grown
Starting point is 00:37:07 adults make it. You can't even believe with a straight face that anyone would make that argument. It's like, yeah, OK, that's a bad guy in there. There's still a responsibility on you to do absolutely everything you can to make sure you don't kill babies. That's civilization 101. All right, guys, let's take a moment and thank our sponsor for today's show, which is Yo Kratom, home of the $60 kilo, longtime sponsor of this podcast and this podcast network. If you are over the age of 21 and you enjoy Kratom, make sure to get your Kratom at YoKratom.com. It's all lab tested. It's quality stuff. It's delivered right to your door and it's the best price you will find anywhere. Sixty dollars for
Starting point is 00:37:48 a kilo at YoCratom dot com. All right, let's get back into the show. All right, let's keep playing. You know, the interesting thing about anti-Semitism is the Jews can never win because historically they've been hated for being rich and
Starting point is 00:38:04 for being poor. They've been hated for being rich and for being poor. They've been hated for integrating and for not integrating. They were hated for being stateless. Remember, rootless cosmopolitans, the far right used to say. Now they're hated for having a state. Today, the only really acceptable form of antismitism aside from the sewers of the far right the only real tolerated form of anti-semitism is anti-zionism zionism as we just heard is simply the right of the jews to self-determination in their historic homeland that's all all. Anti-Semitism, as we've also just heard, is double standards
Starting point is 00:38:47 against Jewish people or cruel and unfair treatment of people because they're Jews. This isn't very far away from home here. If this isn't anti-Semitism, can the audience here tell me why the following things have happened since October the 7th. Why in a Montreal suburb a synagogue should be firebombed, as happened in November. Why there should have been gunshots against the yeshiva. Why in Toronto a bookstore owned by a Jew should be attacked. Why a Molotov cocktail was thrown to a Jewish community center in Montreal, why a Toronto Jewish deli in North York was firebombed, why in Toronto the Orthodox synagogue was vandalized. Okay, let's stop it here.
Starting point is 00:39:31 Two men on fire. So first of all, listen, man, I don't know the details on all of these claims, what happened in Canada. I do know this is all completely irrelevant to the debate topic. This is just pure theater with no substance whatsoever. But a couple of those claims there was like a bookstore whose owner was Jewish was attacked. And you're like, I can't get the details of that story. Are you just saying because the owner was Jewish?
Starting point is 00:39:59 Like, was it done because the owner was Jewish? But let's just assume it was for the sake of argument. Do you guys get why I say that all these right wingers who are are like pro Israel just become the woke? Isn't this just like the most woke argument ever? Like if you were to say like there isn't a real problem with systemic racism in America. And then they just listed off like 12 things that happened to black people that are crimes. And you'd be like, okay, so like, were the police called? Because we got laws on the books against that. And yeah, you should call the cops and those people should be prosecuted. Okay. What the hell does that have to do with whether
Starting point is 00:40:42 you can oppose Zionism and not hate Jewish people? What? I mean, even as he laid it out there, which is all kind of lame, like, you know, when you say, oh, if you oppose Zionism is simply the belief that Jewish people ought to have self-determination in their historic homeland. Well, OK, but like that's not exactly what anyone really objects to. And if you're talking about Zionism as actually exists, like actually existing Zionism in real life also involved the ethnic cleansing of the local population out of that area and has since 1967 involved the occupation of the people who were cleansed out of that area. That's what people are objecting to. But this just listing off, there were some things that happened to Jewish people. Look, when you're talking about a country like the United States of
Starting point is 00:41:38 America, just hundreds of millions of people, or even a country like Canada, which is many tens of millions of people. These are big countries. And to rattle off 12 examples of something bad, it doesn't prove anything. I mean, yes, it proves those things were wrong and they should be reported. Again, much like with the woke left, so many of these stories end up being hoaxes or exaggerated or things like that, that it actually does make you want to go through them one by one before you just accept them. But seeing as how this is Canada and I don't pay that much attention to like random, you know, local crimes in the country of Canada, I'll just take him at his word, which I shouldn't, but I'll take him at his word that all these things happened and happened the way he said that. But that doesn't describe anything, right? And every everyone who doesn't isn't like a full blown pink haired college 20 year old leftist should recognize this cheap
Starting point is 00:42:37 tactic for what it is. It's like that's not how you measure whether a society is is racist. That's not how you measure if a society is prejudiced against a group. Listen, Jewish people in the United States of America and in Canada are a tiny percentage of the population, and they are overwhelmingly successful. Now, as Douglas Murray pointed out there, there are some far fringes of the right that might demonize that. But to the rest of us, that's just like, no, they're a successful group of people. That's OK. That's fine. I don't think you should be demonized for their success. But let's not pretend they're not successful.
Starting point is 00:43:20 Let's not pretend that Jews in these societies are being held back. let's not pretend that jews in these societies are being held back they live you know it's the stuff we talked about with that that woman in florida grilling uh desantis on how uh you know how terrifying it is to be a jew in florida like give me a break dude this is just again it's like saying no one condemned tamas this is so removed from reality i don't even know what world you're fucking talking about dude what world are you talking about? I'm, I'm Jewish. I'm a public figure. I talk about being Jewish fairly often. It's known that I'm Jewish. I travel the country without security. You know what I mean? Like I'm not at that level of fame. I don't have you. I'm very touchable. You know what I mean? I meet fans after shows. I hang out with people.
Starting point is 00:44:06 So weird. Just never experienced any of it. Never. Just not a problem whatsoever for me or anyone I know. This is all just nonsense. And this proves nothing. And again, just to be clear here, because sometimes with these debate tactics, you do almost have to explain the debate tactic to people before they can see it. I think most of the people
Starting point is 00:44:25 who listen to this show are probably wise enough to see this already, but if it needs to be explained, what he's doing is appealing to emotion strictly to get you to stop using the logical part of your brain and start using the emotional part of your brain. Think about how terrible October 7th was. Think about how terrible this bookstore that got vandalized was. Are you on the side of that? No? Then support me. But there's just no connection. There's no connection between October 7th, these random attacks in Canada, and whether or not you can oppose the Zionist agenda without hating Jewish people. Zero connection to any of it. Yeah, the eight minutes of the frankly, I'm just disgusted tonality gets a little bit old. Speaking to what you were saying, though, his definition of Zionism, which was what it was self just self-governance and determination in their historic homeland.
Starting point is 00:45:22 So I guess, though, by that definition, so it can include genocide. but that's just the way that they want to exercise their self-determination. And how dare you oppose someone's self-determination in their ancient homeland, even if they had to come back and forcibly take some of it. But that doesn't matter. It's just the self-determination. It's a nice little title that I guess once you grant someone, they have a right to self-determination. So I guess they can engage in any sort of violence in any capacity because you gave them, you know, the right to self-determination. And that's the higher principle and the higher cause. Yeah. Well, for people, if you've done like more like deep reading on on the history of Israel, too, it is very similar to how. to. It is very similar to how. OK, so they'll be like. So Benny Morris is like one of the most,
Starting point is 00:46:12 if not the most prominent Israeli historian. He was kind of the most famous of the new historians. Elon Pape was another Israeli new historian. And Pape is much more critical of Israel. And Benny Morris has in later years become a total apologist for the Israeli government. But the argument when you get down into really reading their works and listening to their interviews and their back and forths with each other is like Benny Morris, the guy who's apologizing for Israel, he has admitted in the past, I think he admitted that the Palestinians were ethnically cleansed and then kind of walked that back years ago, I think he admitted that the Palestinians were ethnically cleansed and then kind of walked that back years ago. I think once he even said something like, it's a shame they didn't ethnically cleanse all of them because the rest of the history
Starting point is 00:46:53 wouldn't have been so contentious if they had, whatever, however you feel about that. But his argument is essentially that like, yes, aestinians got kicked out in 1948 forcibly um many others fled so like they weren't all kicked out um but this happened under the fog of war and it wasn't really like a centralized plan and it wasn't like executed from the top down and this wasn't the goal of israel so it's like it's almost like that's where you're left with the debate it's like oh okay actually by the way that's seemingly worse at least like you can point at the nazis and go they were very successful at genocide but it's because they removed a lot of people from the process and kind of kept it on a wrap right
Starting point is 00:47:40 putting people on train i was just doing this i was just doing this and so individually not everyone was evil in the culture they weren't aware of it to say that it's not systematic or from the top then you're saying that there's actually such a flaw in the jews living in israel that they all spontaneously have decided yeah you're alone to engage in violence and genocide what are you telling me you're telling me a good old-fashioned grassroots ethnic cleansing isn't any better than a top down authoritarian, a totally decentralized grassroots ethnic cleansing is what we're dealing with here. But again, the thing that look, there's a few things that totally destroy Benny Morris's like laughable case on this is number one, the distinction that like not all of them were forcibly removed, but some of them were.
Starting point is 00:48:27 So like he'll admit that like at Dyer, Dyer, you sound there was like like atrocities committed, like children killed and women raped and stuff like that. And they were forced to leave. But then he's like, oh, but in all these other areas, they just fled. Like the war broke out and they just fled. And you're like, yeah, that's what ethnic cleansing is. There's never been an example of ethnic cleansing ever where every single member of the group was individually had a gun put to their head and then you intentionally spread the word about it. And then word gets out and everybody else figures out the deal. And they go, we got to get the hell out of here. So it's just totally ridiculous to even like start slicing and dicing the percentages. Like once, once enough people are violently evicted, then the whole group was in effect violently evicted. And then the other thing that really just tears down his logic is even if there were people and there were some who were just fleeing from the war, well, they weren't allowed to come back to their homes. And there's no rule that says if you flee your home, you therefore forfeit your property rights.
Starting point is 00:49:41 You know what I mean? Like, it's not like if I hear gunshots outside and I grab my family and get in the car and get the hell out of here, I still own my house. You still come back to it when the dust settles. Anyway, this is a similar type of argument that it's just like, oh, well, we just believe in self-determination for the Jews in Palestine. It's like, okay, but the objection is people who also believe in self-determination for the Jews in Palestine. It's like, okay, but the objection is people who also believe in self-determination for the Palestinians in Palestine. That seems reasonable. All right, let's keep going. I had the other week on a Jewish girls school. If it isn't antisemitism, tell me why just a week ago, pro Hamasammaz protesters tried to go through Jewish areas
Starting point is 00:50:26 in this city shouting, not just ala akba, but, and I quote, sorry for the language, fucking filthy fucking Zionist pigs, dirty Zionist rats. Not an easy chant. Have you heard that language before?
Starting point is 00:50:42 The Jews have. Now look, if you are interested in this motion, just bear this in mind. It's not about Netanyahu. It's not about this war. It's about double standards. And one question hovers over it above all. The question of who would protect the Jews. Who would you trust to protect them? The Europeans? The Arab world? No. History shows only one people protect the Jewish people. The Jewish people.
Starting point is 00:51:18 That's what Zionism is. Thank you. All right. So I guess that last line there is like what people were like, oh, you don't want to deal with this Douglas Murray guy. He's got some arguments. I mean, it's just unfortunately it's just empty nothingness. It's meaningless.
Starting point is 00:51:37 It's nothing. First of all, history doesn't show that only the Jews can protect the Jews. History shows that the Jews weren't so good at protecting themselves. Right. Like, I don't exactly know what point that is. It's also strange to me, particularly if you know anything about who Douglas Murray is, that he takes this shot at Europeans. This is very strange how this happens to be linked in with like being like radically pro-Israel is like, who's going to do it? The Europeans. Yeah. You know, those garbage people who let the Holocaust happened as if it's like all of Europe's fault or something like that. But like, I don't know. I mean, yeah, for the most part, I don't think Europeans would allow
Starting point is 00:52:23 a Holocaust to happen right now. I know we're never supposed to say that. But again, he can sit there and say it's not about the war. It's not about this. It's about whether the Jews are allowed to protect themselves. Again, though, what's the issue with that? That's a total obvious straw man. Nobody, even in my camp, in my circles, nobody is arguing against Jewish people protecting
Starting point is 00:52:49 themselves. Who would, obviously me and you both support that. We are Jewish people. Yes, we believe Jewish people should be allowed to protect themselves. Self-defense is the, probably the most important, the most basic natural right. That's not what the question is. The question is, do Jewish people have the right to indiscriminately slaughter innocent Palestinians? And then do they also have the right to dominate them and to occupy them for decade after decade after decade?
Starting point is 00:53:21 That's what the argument's about. And it's very convenient that nobody on the pro-Israeli side actually wants to have that argument. You never want to talk about that. That's, listen, I'm not saying you can't find some people, you know, sometimes you'll use the term, nobody's saying this. Okay. That's not literally true. I know there's, with social media today, you could find anybody who's saying any crazy thing. But in general, even amongst the people who are like critical of Israel, that is like a crazy fringe position that nobody else is really taking. That's not that's not what anyone's saying. So his whole thing, his whole opening statement here came down to October 7th was bad.
Starting point is 00:54:07 Lots of people hate Jews. Jews have a right to protect themselves. Okay. You're just arguing with yourself and maybe three crazy people. I don't know. I'm totally unimpressed. Let's, so that, that was his opening statement. Let's play a little bit of his rebuttal, too, and we can also respond to that. And then I guess we'll call that an episode. Lots to talk about on the next one. Quite a lot to reply to there. Let me first say, Gideon, you started with a peroration about me
Starting point is 00:54:43 not mentioning the Palestinian casualties. That's because I started by mentioning the war. And there is no law of war that says you're allowed to start a war and then complain when you lose it. Okay, let's pause it right there. This is another thing that comes up constantly in these debates, right? It's like, yeah, you lost. All right, loser. You don't get to complain when you're losing a war like, oh, OK. Yeah, I don't I don't think anybody's really arguing that the Palestinians aren't the losers in the conflict with the Israelis. the Israelis. Like, you think that's a point in your favor? Fine. But, um, there's, I don't know. Yeah. They didn't even lose the war in 1967. By the way, the Palestinians didn't, didn't start it. Egypt amassed some troops. Israel launched a preemptive attack. Jordan got involved and then Israel responded by, by attacking Jordan. Then the Palestinians get dominated forever because Israel won the war.
Starting point is 00:55:49 It's okay. Is that what Western civilization is? Is that, is that the height of like modern morality that if you lose a war, all of your people are, are just doomed to subjugation forever. All right. Doesn't seem right to me and and insert him saying there's no law that says if you start a war you get to complain about losing it it goes well there are lots of laws around war and collective punishment is illegal under international law so yeah there
Starting point is 00:56:19 are those laws the international court of Justice has deemed this a plausible genocide. The International Criminal Court has issued warrants for Bibi Netanyahu. But yeah, there actually are laws about how you fight wars, if that's your argument and appeal to the law. But forget that. It's like, look, people are typically very collectivist when it comes to war you know like people like douglas murray who i'm sure have cheer led for every disastrous war over the last 20 years you know if saddam hussein does something then they go iraq did it that's not really true right first of all iraq was a majority uh shiite country ruled by a minority Sunni populations dictator. OK, and the boys fighting in Saddam Hussein's army were conscripted.
Starting point is 00:57:13 They were forced. But this isn't even that. This isn't even a government. This is Hamas, a gang, you know, a gang who won a plurality of an election once as they. But so what? All the people because of October 7th, essentially, what is the argument here? Because of October 7th, no Palestinians have any rights whatsoever. They're all just evaporated. OK, if that's your logic, fine. But then also apply that logic to Israel, to the United States of America, right?
Starting point is 00:57:46 How much of it, how about the wars America's embarked in, which I'm sure Douglas Murray supported over the last 20 years? Do we all just lose our rights? Are we fair game to be killed because of that? Or is it only, it's only when like a guerrilla terrorist organization does it, but not when a well-trained, well-armed, well-financed military does it. Then somehow it's different in moral character or something like that. Again, just ridiculous arguments. All right, guys, let's take a moment and thank our sponsor for today's show, which is sheathunderwear.com, the underwear of legends, the most incredible, most comfortable pair of boxer briefs you will ever
Starting point is 00:58:25 own. The only underwear that I ever put on my body is sheath underwear. And not only because it's the most comfortable pair of boxer briefs I've ever owned, but also because they are a longtime loyal sponsor of this show and the company is run by great people. So I highly recommend it. Support our sponsor. And at the same time, get the most comfortable pair of boxer briefs you will ever put on your body. Do that by going to sheathunderwear.com and use the promo code problem20. You're also going to get 20% off your next order. Sheathunderwear.com, promo code problem20 for 20% off your next order. All right, let's get back into the show. Let's keep playing. And if maybe cares about the Palestinian casualties, as I'm sure he does, then tell your bosses in Qatar to tell their friends
Starting point is 00:59:12 in Gaza to stop the war and give back the hostages. All right, let's pause it again, because it's just every goddamn sentence is more bullshit than the last sentence so i just sorry it's hard to get through this um this line that's come out that i've heard this a lot of uh people the lady i was arguing with on pierce morgan the other day used this one it was just stop the war by giving back the hostages that's it just which is like first of all i don't even know where to start first. Okay, I guess first I'd say even Benjamin Netanyahu is not saying that. He's not saying if you just return the hostages, we'll end the war. That's not the deal.
Starting point is 00:59:56 That deal hasn't been offered at all. He said the full eradication of Hamas. That's different than just giving the hostages back, right? full eradication of Hamas. That's different than just giving the hostages back, right? That would require like a full surrender of all of Hamas. And then, of course, Israel could just say, that's not all of Hamas. We have to continue this. So it's, at best, it's not at all a guarantee that just releasing the hostages would end the war. And more reasonably, it almost certainly wouldn't end the war, but also, and then what? And then what? Does Gaza get self-determination as you define Zionism? Do they get self-determination after that? Do they get to
Starting point is 01:00:42 form a state after that? No, of course not. So just surrender and then you can be subjugated for eternity. That's the role you're supposed to play. Why do you think that might not be acceptable to a group of people? Oh yeah, because that wouldn't be acceptable to any group of people. No group of people would ever accept that and not keep fighting back. That's just a fact. A fact of human nature. Gideon says nothing. Israel needs nothing more than criticism.
Starting point is 01:01:23 If Israel doesn't get criticism, wow, he doesn't even read his own country's press um uh by the way you said the other day in an interview gideon i couldn't care less about the jewish state so we know very well where you're coming from um let me just say a couple of things about the about that i didn't get to in my opening remarks but are important you know if you didn't throng the streets of this city or any other for the actual genocide going on in Sudan, not the one that Mehdi and Gideon pretend is happening, but the actual genocide going on
Starting point is 01:01:53 in Sudan, if you didn't spend weekend after weekend doing that, but you did come out for the post October the 7th protests, you're an anti-Semite. If if October the 7th protests, you're an anti-Semite. If like maybe you once sent a tweet condemning that, it doesn't give you quite enough smoke cover. You know, if you protested not a bit, didn't set up a tent when Bashar al-Assad was killing six times the number of people in a decade that Israel and all of its enemies have lost in 75 years of war.
Starting point is 01:02:30 You are an anti-Semite. And I would just add one other thing. I know that the media has tried to reframe the motion. I'm not going to allow it either. You know, maybe there is somebody in the world, Pakistan was invented, created as a state around the same time as Israel. I reckon that if this debate tonight was about Pakistan, Pakistan started a lot of wars, it suffered a lot of wars, it suffered a lot of casualties, caused a lot of casualties. But you know what, if somebody said, I don't, I think Pakistan should be abolished.
Starting point is 01:03:01 They just don't have the right to a state. And although they had one set up for them many decades ago, we should abolish it. I think people would say, hmm. And then if the person said, oh, by the way, although I want to abolish that state, I have no problem with the Pakistani people. Please, please, of course you would. All right, so let's stop there and just end this nonsense. Okay, so we could wrap it up. Let me just tear apart these last couple points, I guess you could say it. Okay, so yeah, if that's what they said, maybe you'd be like, I wonder if these guys hate Pakistan or whatever, Pakistani people.
Starting point is 01:03:41 But what if instead of saying we should abolish the state of Pakistan, which neither of his debate opponents are saying, and almost nobody on the other side is actually saying, but let's just say you said, hey, I don't think Pakistan should be allowed to occupy India. And I don't think Pakistan should be allowed to slaughter innocent women and children in India. That wouldn't sound like you hate the people of Pakistan that much, would it? That would sound just like a very reasonable position. And that's what the critics of Israel are saying. I'll go a step further with that. Imagine you created a state of Pakistan. And within the state of Pakistan, you had a whole bunch of people that
Starting point is 01:04:19 said, Hey, I don't really like this new government. And then that new government treated those groups of people terribly. And they said, Hey, I don't like this Pakistani government. And then he said, Oh, you must be anti Pakistani. You're like, Well, what am I I live in Pakistan. I'm part of the power. I'm part of these Pakistani group. And I'm telling you that this government that you just said can own my land is being real mean to me. Oh, you're an you're an anti Pakistani. So I hate myself. Yeah, it's it's totally ridiculous. And look, his thing about saying if you're not protesting the genocide in Sudan, but you are protesting the genocide in Palestine, then you're an anti-Semite. If you weren't out in the streets over Bashar al-Assad killing people, but you are about this, then you're an anti-Semite. I come on. This is just the stupidest fucking argument. I mean, like,
Starting point is 01:05:13 look, first of all, um, that, that just doesn't follow. That does not logically follow. Like if I'm, if I was, uh, came out at, let's say there was a black guy who murdered someone and I was like, he should be brought to justice. And someone went, well, you didn't say anything. When a white guy killed someone, it doesn't prove that I'm a racist. It's like, I don't know. It could just be, I happen to read about this one. I didn't read about that one. Am I right or am I wrong? Should the murderer be held to justice or not? Right. The question is whether you're right or wrong. The question is not, have you consistently applied this to every single area in life? It's like if so, like Michael Malice, my good friend, Michael Malice wrote a great book about North Korea. He went to North Korea. He studied North Korea and he wrote a book about North Korea.
Starting point is 01:05:56 It's a really interesting book. I highly recommend people read it. It's called Dear Reader. If you were to go to him, how come you're not writing a book about every other authoritarian regime? You must just hate the people of North Korea. You get how that's stupid, right? That doesn't make any fucking sense. That happened to be the one he got interested in. He happened to go there. He happened to research the history of the country. People are allowed to pick areas that they care about. And that doesn't, you can't deduce from that, that there's some like horrible ulterior motive. And in fact, you would only even go down this ridiculous line of thinking if you knew you couldn't actually defend the policy. You know, you couldn't actually
Starting point is 01:06:35 defend North Korea's government. And so you have to change the subject to something else. By the way, as somebody who has been quite outspoken about the disastrous war in Syria, it was actually started by the Americans in 2012. And there were plans to overthrow Bashar al-Assad for many years before that. And, yeah, he didn't just start killing his own people. It's that Obama decided to start funding all of the anti-Assad moderate rebels. Remember them, Robbie? Those real moderate members of ISIS? Yeah, so there's a bit more to that story.
Starting point is 01:07:10 But the idea that like, oh, if you didn't protest that one and you protest this one, we can deduce from that that you're a horrible person that just hates these guys is just stupid. I don't know what else to say. Anyway, happy to debate Douglas Murray anytime and to all you people on social media. He's giving the blueprints, so it should be easy. Yeah, there you go.
Starting point is 01:07:30 You have my arguments here. I've done a whole bunch of these debates. You can basically figure out everything I got to say on the subject. Anyway, all you people on social media sending me this stuff, as I said before, to quote George St. Pierre, I am not impressed with your performance. All right, we'll wrap up on that. Peace. as I said before, to quote George St. Pierre, I'm not impressed with your performance. All right, we'll wrap up on that.
Starting point is 01:07:47 Peace.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.